nmr, ms services, and pharmaceutical development support - … · 2019. 6. 11. · lc/ms...

1
Rapid and Automated LCMS Characterization of Antibody and Protein Drug-Conjugates Mark E. Hail, Robert J. Schuster, Kevin S. McCarl Novatia, LLC Objective The development of rapid, robust, and automated methods for characterizing antibody and protein-drug- conjugates using LCMS Overview Antibody and protein-drug conjugates (ADCs) are very popular therapeutic modalities that require extensive structural characterization. One of the most important attributes of ADCs is the Drug-Antibody Ratio (DAR), which represents the average drug molecule payload per antibody molecule. The complexity of the raw ESI mass spectra and the processing of these spectra from LCMS data sets to extract meaningful DAR values can be challenging and time consuming without the use of robust analytical methods and automated data processing approaches. In this presentation, the automated LCMS methods and software used in our laboratory to analyze ADCs and other protein-drug conjugates are described. Methods Rapid LC gradients combined with automated ESI charge deconvolution data processing and reporting software enable highly efficient analysis of protein-drug conjugates. Enhancements were made to the ProMass HR deconvolution software to enable protein drug conjugate analysis and automated drug-antibody ratio (DAR) calculation. LC/MS Instrumentation Waters Xevo G2-XS QToF with I-Class UPLC Thermo Scientific LTQ Orbitrap Velos Pro Software: ProMass HR for MassLynx or Xcalibur with new features allowing automatic DAR calculation Chromatographic Conditions Column: Agilent 2.1x50 mm PLRP-s 4000 A, 80C Solvents: A: 0.05% TFA in Water, B: 0.05% TFA in ACN Gradients: 10%B - 70%B over 3 min for intact samples and 10%B - 70%B over 10 min for reduced subunits Test samples included a lysine-conjugated ADC Mimic: Alexafluor 488 (ThermoFisher) conjugated to MSQC4 mAb (Millipore-Sigma) and a cysteine-conjugated ADC Mimic: MSQC8 mAb (Millipore-Sigma). Rapid PNGaseF (New England Biolabs) was used for reduction/deglycosylation. Sample Setup and Data Processing Figure 1. Sample analyis and data processing is initiated from the sample list (MassLynx shown). The user enters parameters for chromatogram peak detection, deconvolution, target masses, drug masses, and number of protein chains. Data processing occurs automatically at the end of each sample acquisition. MS Data of ADC Mimics Intact Lysine-Conjugated ADC Mimic Raw ESI MS Spectrum (QToF) Baseline-Corrected ESI MS Spectrum Showing Charge Series Deconvoluted and Zoomed Deconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectra Zoomed ESI Charge Series Figure 2. The inherent complexity of ESI/MS data of ADCs requires the use of effective baseline removal in order to produce high quality deconvolutions with minimal artifact peaks. Reduced Lysine-Conjugated ADC Mimic Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Light Chain Deconvoluted and Zoomed Deconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectra of Light Chain Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Heavy Chain Deconvoluted and Zoomed Deconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectra of Heavy Chain Figure 3. Proteins may be reduced and/or deglycosylated to reduce complexity of high DAR samples. LCMS TICs of ADC Mimics Cysteine-Conjugate Reduced Cysteine-Conjugate Intact Lysine-Conjugate Reduced Lysine-Conjugate Figure 4. Typical LCMS TIC traces (QToF) for reduced and intact samples. Reduced samples utilize a 10 min LC gradient, while intact ADCs utilize a 3 min gradient. ProMass HR software integrates and deconvolutes the spectra from the LCMS data, grouping the intensities of drug-modified species even if the species elute in multiple unresolved chromatographic peaks. Cysteine-Conjugated ADC Mimic Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Light Chain Deconvoluted Spectrum of Light Chain Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Heavy Chain Figure 5. Multiple partially-reduced forms are observed. Deconvoluted and Zoomed Deconvoluted (inset) Spectra of Heavy Chain Reduced Cysteine-Conjugated ADC Mimic Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Light Chain Deconvoluted Spectrum of Light Chain Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of Heavy Chain Figure 6. Only drug-modified heavy and light chains are observed. Deconvoluted and Zoomed Deconvoluted (inset) Spectra of Heavy Chain DAR Report and Calculations Table 1. ProMass HR Sample Report Including Automatically-calcuated DAR Table 2. DAR Calculation Table Detail The ProMass HR software produces an HTML report of chromatograms, ESI/MS and deconvoluted mass spectra, and tabular summaries of the results. The above data is from the lysine-conjugated ADC mimic shown in Figure 2. The calculated DAR is shown in the ProMass HR HTML report (Table 1), which is hyperlinked to display a more detailed calculation table (Table 2). Orbitrap and QToF DAR Comparison Table 3. Measured DAR for MSQC8 Cysteine-conjugated mAb using both Orbitrap and QToF platforms. The DAR values are highly consistent across instruments for reduced forms. The MSQ8 mAb analyzed without reduction was found to have multiple partially-reduced forms. DAR estimation is not as accurate in these cases. The expected DAR is 4.2 from the MSQC8 certificate of analysis. Therefore, the values observed are in excellent agreement with the expected. For the AF488 lysine conjugate mimic (batch 2 not shown), we observed an average DAR of 6.14 +/- 0.07 when analyzed as our QC sample over the course of a month on the QToF. Results Results are shown for the MSQC8 ADC cysteine- conjugate standard from Sigma as well as an ADC mimic prepared in-house using Sigma MSQC4 labeled with Alexafluor-488, conjugated to lysine. Samples may be analyzed intact or after disulfide bond reduction and/or deglycosylation. Entire LCMS data sets can be processed with automatic identification of all drug-labeled forms and integration of the signal intensities to enable DAR calculation. Both Thermo Xcalibur and Waters MassLynx versions of ProMass HR have been implemented to allow for automated ADC analysis and DAR calculation. The data processing is configured and initiated from the Xcalibur or MassLynx sample list, enabling convenient setup and analysis. DAR results calculated with the new ProMass HR software are shown to be comparable with data acquired on either Waters QToF or Thermo Orbitrap platforms. Conclusions Rapid, robust, and automated methods for were developed for characterizing antibody- or protein-drug conjugates using LCMS. Intact (non-reduced) samples of these kinds can be characterized in as little as ~5 minutes. Output reports include tabular data of masses, retention times and calculated DAR, as well as the associated chromatograms and mass spectra. Results are displayed in an interactive and easy-to-use web- based format that may be viewed by analysts and clients alike with any web browser. One challenge is the complexity of of the raw ESI mass spectra at high DAR, or when highly heterogeneous proteins are analyzed. Another challenge is the accurate estimation of DAR from partially reduced forms, as is the case for the MSQC8 cysteine conjugate. Reduction/deglycosylation steps can be used to address these challenges at the expense of analysis time.

Upload: others

Post on 11-Aug-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NMR, MS Services, and Pharmaceutical Development Support - … · 2019. 6. 11. · LC/MS Instrumentation Waters Xevo G2-XS QToF with I-Class UPLC Thermo Scientific LTQ Orbitrap Velos

Rapid and Automated LCMS Characterization of Antibody and Protein Drug-Conjugates Mark E. Hail, Robert J. Schuster, Kevin S. McCarl

Novatia, LLC

Objective● The development of rapid, robust, and automated

methods for characterizing antibody and protein-drug-conjugates using LCMS

Overview● Antibody and protein-drug conjugates (ADCs) are very

popular therapeutic modalities that require extensivestructural characterization.

● One of the most important attributes of ADCs is theDrug-Antibody Ratio (DAR), which represents theaverage drug molecule payload per antibody molecule.

● The complexity of the raw ESI mass spectra and theprocessing of these spectra from LCMS data sets toextract meaningful DAR values can be challenging andtime consuming without the use of robust analyticalmethods and automated data processing approaches.

● In this presentation, the automated LCMS methods andsoftware used in our laboratory to analyze ADCs andother protein-drug conjugates are described.

MethodsRapid LC gradients combined with automated ESI chargedeconvolution data processing and reporting softwareenable highly efficient analysis of protein-drug conjugates.Enhancements were made to the ProMass HR deconvolutionsoftware to enable protein drug conjugate analysis andautomated drug-antibody ratio (DAR) calculation.

● LC/MS Instrumentation● Waters Xevo G2-XS QToF with I-Class UPLC● Thermo Scientific LTQ Orbitrap Velos Pro● Software: ProMass HR for MassLynx or Xcalibur with

new features allowing automatic DAR calculation● Chromatographic Conditions

● Column: Agilent 2.1x50 mm PLRP-s 4000 A, 80C● Solvents: A: 0.05% TFA in Water, B: 0.05% TFA in ACN● Gradients: 10%B - 70%B over 3 min for intact samples

and 10%B - 70%B over 10 min for reduced subunits● Test samples included a lysine-conjugated ADC Mimic:

Alexafluor 488 (ThermoFisher) conjugated to MSQC4mAb (Millipore-Sigma) and a cysteine-conjugated ADCMimic: MSQC8 mAb (Millipore-Sigma).

● Rapid PNGaseF (New England Biolabs) was used forreduction/deglycosylation.

Sample Setup and Data Processing

Figure 1. Sample analyis and data processing is initiated from the samplelist (MassLynx shown). The user enters parameters for chromatogrampeak detection, deconvolution, target masses, drug masses, and numberof protein chains. Data processing occurs automatically at the end ofeach sample acquisition.

MS Data of ADC Mimics

Intact Lysine-Conjugated ADC Mimic

Raw ESI MS Spectrum (QToF) Baseline-Corrected ESI MSSpectrum Showing Charge Series

Deconvoluted and ZoomedDeconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectra

Zoomed ESI Charge Series

Figure 2. The inherent complexity of ESI/MS data of ADCs requires the use ofeffective baseline removal in order to produce high quality deconvolutionswith minimal artifact peaks.

Reduced Lysine-Conjugated ADC Mimic

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of LightChain

Deconvoluted and ZoomedDeconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectraof Light Chain

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of HeavyChain

Deconvoluted and ZoomedDeconvoluted (inset) Mass Spectraof Heavy Chain

Figure 3. Proteins may be reduced and/or deglycosylated to reducecomplexity of high DAR samples.

LCMS TICs of ADC Mimics

Cysteine-Conjugate Reduced Cysteine-Conjugate

Intact Lysine-Conjugate Reduced Lysine-Conjugate

Figure 4. Typical LCMS TIC traces (QToF) for reduced and intact samples.Reduced samples utilize a 10 min LC gradient, while intact ADCs utilize a 3min gradient. ProMass HR software integrates and deconvolutes the spectrafrom the LCMS data, grouping the intensities of drug-modified species evenif the species elute in multiple unresolved chromatographic peaks.

Cysteine-Conjugated ADC Mimic

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of LightChain

Deconvoluted Spectrum of LightChain

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of HeavyChain

Figure 5. Multiple partially-reducedforms are observed.

Deconvoluted and ZoomedDeconvoluted (inset) Spectra ofHeavy Chain

Reduced Cysteine-Conjugated ADCMimic

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of LightChain

Deconvoluted Spectrum of LightChain

Raw ESI Spectrum (QToF) of HeavyChain

Figure 6. Only drug-modified heavyand light chains are observed.

Deconvoluted and ZoomedDeconvoluted (inset) Spectra ofHeavy Chain

DAR Report and Calculations

Table 1. ProMass HR Sample Report Including Automatically-calcuatedDAR

Table 2. DAR Calculation Table Detail

The ProMass HR software produces an HTML report of chromatograms,ESI/MS and deconvoluted mass spectra, and tabular summaries of theresults. The above data is from the lysine-conjugated ADC mimic shownin Figure 2. The calculated DAR is shown in the ProMass HR HTML report(Table 1), which is hyperlinked to display a more detailed calculationtable (Table 2).

Orbitrap and QToF DAR Comparison

Table 3. Measured DAR for MSQC8 Cysteine-conjugated mAb using bothOrbitrap and QToF platforms. The DAR values are highly consistentacross instruments for reduced forms. The MSQ8 mAb analyzed withoutreduction was found to have multiple partially-reduced forms. DARestimation is not as accurate in these cases. The expected DAR is 4.2from the MSQC8 certificate of analysis. Therefore, the values observedare in excellent agreement with the expected. For the AF488 lysineconjugate mimic (batch 2 not shown), we observed an average DAR of6.14 +/- 0.07 when analyzed as our QC sample over the course of a monthon the QToF.

Results● Results are shown for the MSQC8 ADC cysteine-

conjugate standard from Sigma as well as an ADC mimicprepared in-house using Sigma MSQC4 labeled withAlexafluor-488, conjugated to lysine.

● Samples may be analyzed intact or after disulfide bondreduction and/or deglycosylation.

● Entire LCMS data sets can be processed with automaticidentification of all drug-labeled forms and integrationof the signal intensities to enable DAR calculation.

● Both Thermo Xcalibur and Waters MassLynx versionsof ProMass HR have been implemented to allow forautomated ADC analysis and DAR calculation.

● The data processing is configured and initiatedfrom the Xcalibur or MassLynx sample list, enablingconvenient setup and analysis.

● DAR results calculated with the new ProMass HRsoftware are shown to be comparable with dataacquired on either Waters QToF or Thermo Orbitrapplatforms.

Conclusions● Rapid, robust, and automated methods for were

developed for characterizing antibody- or protein-drugconjugates using LCMS.

● Intact (non-reduced) samples of these kinds can becharacterized in as little as ~5 minutes.

● Output reports include tabular data of masses,retention times and calculated DAR, as well as theassociated chromatograms and mass spectra. Resultsare displayed in an interactive and easy-to-use web-based format that may be viewed by analysts andclients alike with any web browser.

● One challenge is the complexity of of the raw ESI massspectra at high DAR, or when highly heterogeneousproteins are analyzed. Another challenge is theaccurate estimation of DAR from partially reducedforms, as is the case for the MSQC8 cysteine conjugate.Reduction/deglycosylation steps can be used to addressthese challenges at the expense of analysis time.