memorandum - lausd
TRANSCRIPT
201 Santa Monica Boulevard, Suite 500, Santa Monica, CA 90401 INTERNET www.pcrnet.com TEL 310.451.4488 FAX 310.451.5279
Memorandum TO: Gwenn Godek, Contract Professional/CEQA Advisor, Los
Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) DATE: July 28, 2015
FROM: Margarita Jerabek, Ph.D., Director of Historic Resources, Amanda Kainer, M.S., Senior Architectural Historian, and Virginia Harness, M.A., Architectural Historian Technician
RE: CHARACTER-DEFINING FEATURES MEMORANDUM (CDFM) FOR JOHN BURROUGHS MIDDLE
SCHOOL, 600 SOUTH MCCADDEN PLACE, LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, 90005
INTRODUCTION
PCR Services Corporation (“PCR”) appreciates the opportunity to prepare Character-Defining Features Memorandum (“CDFM”) for John Burroughs Middle School (“Burroughs MS”) located at 600 South McCadden place, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. The period of significance for Burroughs MS is between 1923 and 1935, the period when the school was designed in the Italian Renaissance Revival style to the reconstruction of the main, auditorium and shop buildings following the earthquake; therefore meets the age threshold for consideration as a historical resource under CEQA. The first step in the project planning process involving a historically significant school is the identification of character-defining features that account for its eligibility as a historical resource. The baseline data presented in this CDFM is to be used in conjunction with the LAUSD Guidelines and Treatment Approaches for Historic Schools to ensure future modernization and upgrade projects will avoid significant adverse impacts to the historical significance of Burroughs MS.1 This CDFM includes a discussion of the methodology used, previous evaluations, a brief historic overview, and an analysis of the primary and contributing character-defining landscapes, buildings, and features of the subject school.
METHODOLOGY
The CDFM was conducted by Margarita Jerabek, Ph.D., Director of Historic Resources, Amanda Y. Kainer, M.S., Senior Architectural Historian, and Virginia E. Harness, M.A., Architectural Historian Technician, all of whom meet and exceed the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards in history and architectural history.2
1 SWCA Environmental Consultants, Los Angeles Unified School District Guidelines and Treatment Approaches for
Historic Schools, prepared for Los Angeles Unified School District (January 2015). 2 The Professional Qualification Standards are requirements used by the National Park Service and have been
published in the Code of Federal Regulations (“CFR”), 36 CFR Part 61.
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 2 July 28, 2015
The following tasks were performed by PCR for the study:
Undertook an intensive pedestrian survey and digital photography in May 2015 to document the existing conditions of the subject property. PCR utilized the survey methodology of the State Office of Historic Preservation (“OHP”).
Conducted site‐specific research on the school sites utilizing Sanborn fire insurance maps, historical photographs and plans, historical plans provided by LAUSD, and other published sources.
Reviewed and applied methodology, eligibility standards and integrity considerations presented in the LAUSD Historic Context Statement.3 In addition, utilized the National Park Service’s (“NPS”) guidance provided in Preservation Brief 17, Architectural Character: Identifying the Visual Aspects of Historic Buildings as an Aid to Their Preservation, to identify the visual character of the subject school.
PREVIOUS EVALUATIONS
During the Phase I Getty Survey conducted on March 15, 2002, Burroughs MS was assigned a California Historical Resource Status Codes of “3S” and “3CS,” which means the subject school appears eligible for National Register and California Register through survey evaluation.4 Burroughs MS was noted to be “one of the most intact campuses from the 1920s remaining in the District.”
HISTORIC OVERVIEW
The original plans for John Burroughs MS (formerly Wilshire Junior High School) were drawn up by architect E.H. Cline in 1923. The original school plant was constructed in the northwest corner of the school property, at the corner of Sixth Street and what is now South McCadden Place. The Administration and Auditorium Building (Building 1) fronts McCadden Place and the Shop and Cafeteria Building (demolished) behind to the east.5 By 1925 the school was officially John Burroughs Junior High School. That year architect Francis J. Catton designed a Classroom Building (Building 7), Boy’s Gymnasium (Building 2), and Shop Building (Building 9) for the campus.6 A Glass House (demolished) was erected in 1927.7
3 Sapphos Environmental, Inc., Los Angeles Unified School District: Historic Context Statement, 1870 to 1969 (March
2014). 4 Leslie J. Heumann, SAIC, DPR Primary Record Form for Burroughs Middle School (March 15, 2002). 5 8075.03.000 January 1, 1923, New Plant – Main/Auditorium Building & Cafeteria Building 6 8075.02.001 April 1, 1925 Classroom, Gymnasium & Shop Buildings
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 3 July 28, 2015
Figure 1. Historical Aerial of Burroughs MS, 1926 (LAPL)
Following the Long Beach Earthquake, reconstruction work was completed on the Main
Building & Auditorium (Building 1), as well as the Shop Building (Building 9).8 A Music Bungalow was constructed in 1939, followed by a new Lunch Pavilion (Building 20) in 1940.9 Alterations were made to the Cafeteria (demolished) and Home Economics Building (demolished) in 1949, with further alterations to the Cafeteria (demolished) occurring in 1950 as well.10 In 1952, the Main Building & Auditorium (Building 1) also underwent alterations for the creation of an Arts & Crafts Room.11 The arcade of the school campus connecting Buildings 1 and 7 was enclosed in 1956.12 The Multi-Purpose Building (Building 14) was erected in 1957, the same year that alterations were made to the Boys’ Gymnasium (Building 2).13 Alterations to the Shop Building 7 8075.02.002 March 1, 1927 Glass House 8 8075.07.000 March 1, 1935 Reconstruction of Main/Auditorium & Shop Buildings 9 8075.09.000 November 1, 1939 Music Bungalow (Building AA-84) 8075.02.011 July 1, 1940 Lunch Pavilion 10 8075.02.014 October 1, 1949 Alterations to Cafeteria and Home Economics Building 8075.02.017 July 1, 1950 Alterations to Cafeteria Building 11 8075.02.022 October 1, 1952 Alterations to Main/Auditorium Building for Artcraft Room 12 8075.02.023 September 1, 1956 Arcade Enclosure 13 8075.VG.422 August 1, 1957 All Purpose Building & Additions to Boys Gymnasium Building
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 4 July 28, 2015
(Building 9) occurred in 1960.14 The Classroom Building (Building 7) was structurally strengthened and modernized in 1964.15
Several buildings were demolished and replaced in the latter portion of the 20th century, while other existing buildings were altered to accommodate modern needs. The Girls’ Physical Education Building came down in 1971.16 The Cafeteria and Home Economics Buildings underwent corrective work to strengthen their wood frames in 1971, only to be torn down two years later.17 A new Cafeteria/Classroom Building (Building 20) was designed in 1976, as was a new Girls Locker/Shower Building (Building 17).18 Seismic upgrade of the Main and Auditorium Building (Building 1) was undertaken in 1987, also included as part of this project was a new elevator on the rear elevation and reconfiguration of classrooms.19
CHARACTER‐DEFINING FEATURES ANALYSIS
The character‐defining features analysis presented below is a detailed summary of the visual character of Burroughs MS, including the site plan, landscape, buildings, architectural details, materials, finishes and interior spaces, which contribute to the eligibility of Burroughs MS as a historical resource. According to the NPS, “character refers to all those visual aspects and physical features that comprise the appearance of every historic building. Character‐defining elements include the overall shape of the building, its materials, craftsmanship, decorative details, interior spaces and features, as well as the various aspects of its site and environment.”20 The NPS describes the visual characteristics that generally represent character-defining features: “the major contributors to a building’s overall character and embodied in the general aspects of its setting; the shape of the building; its roof and roof features, such as chimneys or cupolas; the various projections on the building, such as porches or bay windows; the recesses or voids in a building, such as open galleries, arcades, or recessed balconies; the openings for windows and doorways; and finally the various materials that contribute to a buildings character.”21 The approach to identifying visual character involved the examination of the subject school from afar to understand its overall setting and architectural context; then
14 8075.12.000 April 5, 1960 Alterations to Shop Building 15 8075.13.000 July 1, 1964 Structural Strengthening & Modernization of Classroom Building 16 8075.02.028 May 1, 1971 Demolition of Girl’s P.E. Building 17 8075.02.029 July 1, 1971 Corrective Work – Pre 1933 Wood Frame Building (Cafeteria & Home Economics) 8075.02.031 May 1, 1973 Demolition of Cafeteria, Home Economics Buildings & Ground Improvements 18 8075.15.000 October 13, 1976 Cafeteria/Classroom Building & Girls Locker/Shower Building 19 8075.16.000 February 1, 1987 Reconstruction of Main Building 20 Lee H. Nelson, Preservation Brief 17: Architectural Character—Identifying the Visual Aspects of Historic Buildings as
an Aid to Preserving their Character, National Park Service, September 1988, http://www.nps.gov/tps/how-to-preserve/briefs/17-architectural-character.htm, accessed June 4, 2015.
21 Lee H. Nelson, Preservation Brief 17: Architectural Character—Identifying the Visual Aspects of Historic Buildings as an Aid to Preserving their Character, pps 1-2.
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 5 July 28, 2015
moving up closer to investigate its materials and the craftsmanship and surface finishes; and lastly, going into and through the buildings to perceive those spaces, rooms and details that comprise its interior visual character.
The character-defining landscapes and buildings on the Burroughs MS campus are analyzed and classified as significant, contributing, and non‐contributing. These terms are generally interchangeable with “primary” (significant), “secondary” (contributing), and “tertiary” (contributing) character-defining features, which are also commonly used descriptors. Significant character-defining buildings and landscapes determine the eligibility of a historical resource (Burroughs MS) and are the most important features to retain. Alterations to significant buildings and landscapes shall be avoided.22 Contributing character‐defining buildings and landscapes are secondary and tertiary features that taken together with the primary features convey a property’s significance as a historical resource. Compared to primary character-defining buildings and landscapes, these contributing buildings and landscapes are not as visually prominent or retain moderate integrity. Because contributing character-defining buildings and landscapes have a lower level of significance, they shall be preserved to the greatest extent feasible and rehabilitated as appropriate; however, more flexibility is given to these buildings and landscapes and alterations or removal of these contributing features may not adversely impact the subject school’s significance. The greatest flexibility is afforded to non-contributing buildings and landscapes; they do not contribute to the significance of the subject school, therefore, their complete removal does not adversely impact the significance or eligibility of the subject school.
Described below are the significant (primary) and contributing (secondary and tertiary) character-defining buildings and landscapes of Burroughs MS dating from the period of significance that account for its eligibility as a historical resource. The primary period of significance for Burroughs MS is between 1923 and 1935 when the campus was initially designed in the Italian Renaissance Revival style to the reconstruction of several buildings following the Long Beach earthquake. Significant character-defining buildings and landscapes represent the original period of significance, are visually prominent, and retain high integrity. While contributing character-defining buildings and landscapes retain moderate integrity or may fall outside of the primary period of significance. Described underneath each significant or contributing building/landscape is a list of features that contribute to the visual character and architectural significance of the building/landscape from its period of significance. Non-contributing buildings, landscapes, and features were not identified; however, non-contributing alterations located on identified significant or contributing buildings/landscapes are italicized. If a building, landscape, or feature is not listed below as significant or contributing, it can be
22 Should a significant landscape or building require alteration further historic review will be required under CEQA
law.
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 6 July 28, 2015
assumed the building, landscape, or feature is non-contributing. The site plan presented as Figure 2, on the following page, visually depicts the character-defining buildings and landscapes of Burroughs MS.
Significant (Primary) Building
Significant (Primary) Landscape
Contributing (Secondary) Building
Non-Contributing Building and Landscape
FIGURECharacter-Defining Features Analysis
Burroughs Middle SchoolEast Village Mixed Use Project 2
Source: Los Angeles Unified School District, 2002; PCR Services Corpora on, 2015.P C R
0 80 Feet
N
1
2
9
7
1
717
14
7
20
14
1
Auditorium
Mc Cadden Place
6th Street
Wilshire B
oulevard
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 8 Error! Reference source not found.
Significant (Primary): Site Plan and Landscape
Building 1 and Building 7 are set-back from street (Mc Cadden Place and 6th Street) behind an open landscape and expanse of grass
Spatial relationship and siting of Building 1 and Building 7
Aerial Showing Set-back of Building 1 Building 1 (Bing Maps)
Open Landscape and Set-back to the west of Building 1, View Southeast
Open Landscape and Set-back to the north of Building 7, View South
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 9 July 28, 2015
Significant (Primary): Administration and Auditorium Building 1
Exterior Features
Two-stories
Irregular I-shaped plan
Red- tiled hipped and half-hipped roofs, flat roofs
Patterned brick exteriors and cast stone trim
Symmetrical massing
Arched openings
Original paneled and glazed doors
Six-over-six double-hung windows with transoms (Alterations, transoms on rear elevation infilled)
Alterations: windows on south elevation of auditorium wing infilled, second story opening on east elevation of administration wing that once connected to a courtyard building (removed) has been infilled, opening infilled on north elevation of auditorium
Interior Features
Circulation Plan
Administration Wing
o Wood doors some with glazing
o Wood door frames with entablature
o Wide interior corridors with transom windows (alteration: window panes painted over)
o Arches over corridors
o Wood counter desk and built-ins located in main office
o U-shape double staircase with intermediary landing, wood handrails and wood banisters
Auditorium Wing
o Wood paneled doors
o Original stage
o Wood auditorium seats
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 10 July 28, 2015
o Auditorium light fixtures
o Auditorium balcony
o Concrete stairs with wood banisters
o Decorative grilles
o Pendant lights
o Wood trusses
o Red-tile floor in foyer
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Primary
Entrance on West Elevation, View East
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, South of
Primary Entrance, West Elevation, View East
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, North
Elevation, View Southwest
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, North
Elevation, View South
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 11 July 28, 2015
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, West
Elevation of Auditorium, View Southeast
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, West
Elevation of Auditorium, View East
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, South
Elevation of Auditorium, View North
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, East
Elevation of Auditorium, View Northwest
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, East
Elevation, View Northwest
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, East
Elevation, View West
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 12 July 28, 2015
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Rear
Entrance on East Elevation, View West
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, North
Elevation of Auditorium, View South
Administration and Auditorium Building 1,
Adminstration Office, View West
Administration and Auditorium Building 1,
Adminstration Office, View Southwest
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Main
Stairway, View East
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Main
Stairway, View East
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 13 July 28, 2015
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Library,
View North
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Second-
Story Corridor, View North
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Second Story
Corridor, View South
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Second Story
Corridor, View East
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Auditorium
Foyer, View West
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Auditorium,
View East
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 14 July 28, 2015
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Auditorium,
View West to Balcony
Administration and Auditorium Building 1, Auditorium
Balcony, View South
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 15 July 28, 2015
Significant (Primary): Classroom Building 7
Exterior Features
Two-stories
Rectangular plan
Three-over-three wood-framed windows and three-light wood-framed transoms (alteration, some transom windows replaced with out-take vents)
Elaborate Italianate brickwork
Arched openings with decorative cast concrete surrounds
Gable and hipped red tile roofs
Arcade topped by a glazed bridge linking buildings (alteration, bridge enclosed with awning windows, 1st floor arcade structurally retrofit with concrete)
Arched windows over entries
Alteration, entrance on north elevation infilled
Interior Features
Circulation Plan
Arched ceilings in corridors
Classroom Building 7, North Elevation, View South
Classroom Building 7, North Elevation, Former
Entrance Infilled, View South
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 16 July 28, 2015
Bridge Connecting Buildings 1 and 7, View south
Classroom Building 7, West Elevation, View Southeast
Classroom Building 7, West Elevation, View East
Classroom Building 7, South Elevation, View North
Classroom Building 7, East Elevation, View West
Arcade/Bridge Connecting Buildings 1 and 7,
View North, South Elevation
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 17 July 28, 2015
Classroom Building 7, 1st Floor of Arcade/Bridge
Connecting Buildings 1 and 7
Classroom Building 7, 2nd Floor of Arcade/Bridge
Connecting Buildings 1 and 7
Classroom Building 7, Corridor, View East
Classroom Building 7, Stairway
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 18 July 28, 2015
Contributing (Secondary): Building 9
One-story
Low, horizontal massing
Rectangular Plan
Italianate exterior brickwork
Arched openings with decorative cast concrete surrounds
Large, multi-pane windows and transoms (alterations: some windows infilled with AC equipment, some transoms removed, metal security screens)
Alteration: doors replaced
Building 9, West Elevation, View East
Building 9, West Elevation, View East
Building 9, South Elevation, View North
Building 9, North Elevation, View South
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 19 July 28, 2015
Building 9, Rear (East) Elevation, View Southwest
Building 9, South Elevation, View Northeast
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 20 July 28, 2015
Contributing (Secondary): Building 2
Exterior Features
I-Shape Plan (alterations: non-contributing addition on the east elevation added circa 1956 canopy and stairs added onto the north elevation)
Varied roof height, gymnasium taller than two flanking wings
Italianate exterior brickwork
Arched openings (alteration, doors replaced)
Large multi-pane windows (alteration, windows on rear altered with intake vents)
Flat roof
Interior Features
Exposed metal truss roof
Building 2, North Elevation, View Southeast
Building 2, South Elevation, View Northwest
Building 2, East Elevation, View West
Building 2, West Elevation, View Northeast
Memorandum RE: CDFM FOR BURROUGHS MIDDLE SCHOOL
PCR Services Corporation Page 21 July 28, 2015
Building 2, Interior, View East
Building 2, West Elevation, View East