The ChronicleTHE INDEPENDENT DAILY AT DUKE UNIVERSITY

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 ONE HUNDRED AND SEVENTH YEAR, ISSUE 123WWW.DUKECHRONICLE.COM

Duke Lax edges Duke Lax edges past Brown, past Brown, Page 7Page 7

Duke increases Duke increases Internet bandwidth, Internet bandwidth, connection still slow, connection still slow, Page 3Page 3

ONTHERECORD“Why do we accept Katniss so fully, and yet reject Bella so vindictively?”

—Ellie Bullard in “As we know it.” See column page 10

TRACY HUANG/THE CHRONICLE

Members of the Duke and Durham community gathered on the steps of the Duke Chapel Tuesday to hold a vigil in memory of Trayvon Martin. SEE SOUNDOFF PAGE 4

Call to action University streamlines admissions

by Maggie SpiniTHE CHRONICLE

Duke administrators are trying to make Durham a little more like home for some employees.

The University has proposed a partner-ship with the city of Durham to reduce the cost of housing in Durham’s Southside neighborhood for University and Univer-sity Health System employees, said Phail Wynn, vice president for Durham and re-gional affairs. Duke’s new initiative would allow employees to purchase new homes at subsidized costs with no down payment.

“Duke is… the largest employer in the community, and establishing an initial criti-cal mass of home-buyers in this challenged neighborhood will contribute to success and hopefully attract additional home buy-ers,” City Manager Tom Bonfield wrote in an email Tuesday. “By identifying qualified employees and providing assistance for credit counseling and credit repair, Duke would be an invaluable resource.”

Some details of the project have yet to be determined, and the University has not formally announced the initiative, Wynn said, though he has discussed it with city leaders.

“The project that we’re looking at is where the city has placed a priority in some of its inner-city neighborhoods and also some of the neighborhoods that have been impoverished for a long time,” Durham

NATE GLENCER/THE CHRONICLE

Duke and the city of Durham are discussing a project that would result in subsidized housing costs for Duke employees in Durham’s Southside neighborhood.

by Kristie KimTHE CHRONICLE

Due to a massive increase in applica-tions to Duke, the admissions office has expedited the decision-making process for candidates whose applications may not meet the University’s standards.

In this year’s early and regular admis-sions cycles, regional admissions officers, who are in charge of subsets of the ap-plicant pool, are now the first University officials to read a given application and have the ability to recommend a prospec-tive student be rejected without further in-depth review. This replaces a system in which no applications were rejected before they were read by two readers and considered by either a senior officer or an admissions committee.

Admissions made these changes to re-lieve stress on a process that was designed to handle 12,000 applications annually, said Dean of Undergraduate Admissions Christoph Guttentag. This year, Duke re-ceived 31,565 applications, which itself is a 6 percent increase from last year.

Court decision may impact Duke employee health benefits

by Tiffany LieuTHE CHRONICLE

Duke’s health care policies may see changes after the Supreme Court passes jurisdiction on ObamaCare this week.

In hearings taking place between March 26 and 28, the Supreme Court will examine evidence regarding the consti-tutionality of President Barack Obama’s Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, signed into law March 2010. The act, which some call ObamaCare, would require all Americans to purchase health insurance or pay a fine beginning in 2014. But the law can be stopped if the court deems it unconstitutional. The court’s ruling, projected to be released in June, is expected to greatly influence both voters in the presidential elections

this coming November, as well as Duke employees’ health care benefits.

“If deemed unconstitutional, it will be a real blow to the act because the whole notion of [the act] was to increase insur-ance coverage,” said Frank Sloan, J. Al-exander McMahon professor of health policy and management and professor of economics at Duke.

Sloan added that an unconstitutional ruling by the court would be a setback for the country’s goal to provide health in-surance to a wider population of Ameri-cans.

Duke and the communityRegarding Duke’s health care poli-

cies, the University is functioning under the assumption that ObamaCare will be

approved by the justices, said Kyle Ca-vanaugh, vice president for administra-tion. If the act is deemed unconstitution-al, the University will assess and adjust its policies accordingly, he added.

Duke currently spends $200 million on health care coverage for University employees and their dependents, Ca-vanaugh said. If the act is approved by the Supreme Court, state-based health exchanges will be enacted in 2014, which would provide employers the option to offer either private or state insurance for employees. Whether Duke maintains its current private policies or opts into pub-lic state insurance hinges on North Caro-lina’s health policies.

SEE ADMISSIONS ON PAGE 6

SEE SUBSIDIES ON PAGE 12

SEE HEALTH CARE ON PAGE 5

Duke to launch home subsidies for employees

Process adapts to rising number of applicants

2 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

P a u l y D o g s P a u l y D o g s

V EGGIE D OGS (Worthington Vegetarian Leanies)

C HICKEN S AUSAGE (Andouille Gluten-Free)

J UMBO D OG (Gluten-Free All-Beef)

A LL - B EEF S PICY S AUSAGES (Sabrett)

A LL - B EEF H OT D OGS (Sabrett)

P a u l y D o g s P a u l y D o g s

Located on the Bryan Center Plaza Sun-Wed 11:00am to 8:00pm • Thurs-Sat till 4:30am

• A LWAYS F REE T OPPINGS w / D OGS (50+ Toppings) • C HECK P AULY ’ S S PECIAL C REATION (see menu boards)

Mention this ad and get

$ 6 REGULAR HOT DOGS 2

(FREE TOPPINGS)

“”

worldandnation TODAY:

7843

THURSDAY:

77

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Environ-mental Protection Agency will issue the first limits on greenhouse gas emissions from new power plants as early as Tues-day. The move could end the construc-tion of new conventional coal-fired facili-ties in the United States.

HARUYOSHI YAMAGUCHI/THE WASHINGTON POST

Kazuhiko Asakawa, president of AIJ Investment Advisors, spoke at parliament in Tokyo Tuesday. Asakawa admitted for the first time that he ordered the falsification of fund performance reports in hopes AIJ could recoup losses that may be more than $1 billion.

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Syria has accepted the six-point peace plan proposed by joint United Nations-Arab League envoy Kofi Annan, who has been urging President Bashar Assad to imme-diately implement provisions including a cease-fire.

EPA to limit greenhouse gas emissions from power plants

Syria accepts Annan’s UN-backed cease-fire plan

Men who have two drinks a day after surviving a first heart attack have a low-er risk of death from heart disease than non-drinkers, Harvard researchers said, adding to evidence that moderate alco-hol use may be healthy.

Men who survived a heart attack and who drank two alcoholic drinks a day had a 42 percent lower risk of death from cardiovascular disease and 14 percent lower risk of death from any cause dur-ing the study compared with non-drink-ers, according to a study led by Jennifer Pai, an assistant professor of medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Har-vard Medical School. The study followed 1,818 men for as many as 20 years from the time of their first heart attack.

The results, published in the European Heart Journal, add to other studies that have observed the positive effects of moderate drinking. The study was fund-ed by the National Institutes of Health.

Two drinks daily may lower risk for heart attack victims

58

“Austin Rivers, who became the first fresh-man since Johnny Dawkins to lead the Blue Devils in scoring this season, will hire an agent and enter the NBA Draft, Duke confirmed Monday... Rivers recorded 3.4 re-bounds and 2.1 assists per game to go along with his team-high 15.5 points per contest.”

— From The Chronicle’s Sports Blogbluezone.dukechronicle.com

onthe web

Duke MBA 2012 Women’s Leadership Conference

Fuqua School of Business, 9:30 a.m.-4 p.m.

All Duke graduate students are invited to join the yearly conference.

The TribunalLaw School 3041, 12:15-1:15 p.m.

Judge Patrick Robinson will discuss her expe-riences as the president of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia.

Racecraft in AmericaFriedl 225, 4:15-6 p.m.

Karen Fields, a highly respected and influen-tial sociologist, will give a talk on issues re-

lated to African American research.

scheduleat Duke...

The difference between jour-nalism and literature is that

journalism is unreadable and literature is not read.

— Oscar Wilde

TODAY IN HISTORY1939: Spanish Civil War ends.

oono the calendarConstitution Day

Serbia

Christian Feast DayGuntram

Serfs Emancipation DayTibet

Teacher’s DayCzech

Tension & ControversyWomen’s Center, 6:30-7:30 p.m.

Robyn Wiegman, professor in literature and women’s studies, leads a discussion about womenand power in “The Girl with the Drag-

on Tattoo.”

—from calendar.duke.edu

THE CHRONICLE WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 | 3

919.688.8188 2608 Erwin RoadDurham, NC

Monday: 10 - 7Tuesday - Thursday: 10 - 8Friday - Saturday: 9 - 6

Schedule your appointment online

March Madness SpecialGet 16 highlights for $65.

Redeem by March 31st. Please mention this ad when booking.

Condoleezza Rice, former U.S Secretary of State, will deliver the Ambassador Dave and Kay Phillips Fam-ily International Lecture in Page Auditorium April 10.

Rice served as the 66th secretary of state from 2005 to 2009 under the Bush administration. She was the second woman and the first black woman to serve as secretary of state.

The lecture is sponsored by the Duke Program in American Grand Strategy and co-sponsored by the Sanford School of Public Policy, Triangle Institute for Security Stud-ies, the Duke Office of Global Strat-egy and Programs and the Alexander Hamilton Society, the University an-nounced Tuesday.

Peter Feaver, professor of political science and public policy and director of the American Grand Strategy program, said Rice’s many important governmental positions makes her perspective very rel-evant. Feaver, who served as a special adviser on the National Security Council staff under former President George W. Bush, will host the discussion.

“Condoleezza Rice has served at the highest levels of government during some of the most important pe-riods in American foreign policy: the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War, the 9/11 attacks, and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq,” Feaver said in a news release Tuesday.

Rice, who has authored and co-authored many books, currently serves as the Denning professor in Global Busi-ness and the Economy at Stanford University’s Graduate School of Business. She is also a political science pro-fessor and the Thomas and Barbara Stephenson senior fellow on public policy at the Hoover Institution, a con-servative policy analysis group at Stanford.

—from Staff Reports

Rice to deliver speech at Duke

Duke increases bandwidth, students see slower connection

by Madeleine ClarkTHE CHRONICLE

Nobody likes traffic jams, espe-cially with Internet connections.

Duke recently increased the band-width of its wireless network from three gigabytes to 20 gigabytes, but the process of upgrading the system resulted in slower Internet connec-tions for individuals across campus. Cara Bonnett, Office of Information Technology managing editor, wrote in an email Monday that OIT is work-

ing to address the problems, but some students are still expressing concerns about slow-loading Web pages and time-consuming downloads.

“It’s been so slow that my entire connection keeps cutting in and out—so frustrating,” said Gavin For-rest, a junior.

Some students noted that certain sites, such as Netflix, are unable to stream videos, online assignment submissions lag and the occasional image comes in pixilated.

When the University expanded its bandwidth several months ago with the goal of increasing speed, difficul-ties in routing Internet traffic conges-tion on the server led to slowdowns in Internet connection speed, Bonnett said. Rather than converting to the re-cently upgraded Internet connections, some network traffic is being routed back through a smaller circuit.

“The resulting congestion caused

Condoleezza Rice

JISOO YOON/THE CHRONICLE

Students have recently been experiencing slower than usual wireless Internet speeds across campus as a result of the University transitioning to increase its wireless network bandwidth.

SEE INTERNET ON PAGE 12

4 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

The Office of Undergraduate Admissions at Duke University has positions for work study or non work study students

for part-time tour guides from May 7 - August 18, 2012. Also, two full-time internships are available.

Looking for a summer job or extra spending money during

summer school?

The Primary responsibility will be providing walking tours of West Campus to prospective students and their families. Part time guides work a flexible schedule which could include as many as 4 tours per week. This is a perfect opportunity to earn some extra income while attending summer school. Being an active participant in the Duke community is a plus, as is enthusiasm.

Interested individuals should contact Will Niver, Admissions Officer,

at 919 684-0665 or Will.Niver@duke.edu

Cyberattacks ought to require presidential approvalStudents, faculty, staff and members

of the Durham community gathered on the steps in front of Duke Chapel to hold a vigil in memory of Trayvon Martin, a 17-year-old black male who was shot and killed Feb. 26 in Sanford, Fla. The shooter, George Zimmermann, claimed to have seen Martin engaging in suspicious activity and said he shot Martin in self-defense. The event brought up allegations of rac-ism, sparking outrage, protest and dialogue across the country about the role race plays in the American legal system. The vigil was planned by freshmen Adesuwa Giwa-Osagie and Ba’Carri Johnson and featured Mark Neal, professor of African and African American studies, as the keynote speaker. The Chronicle’s Kelly Scurry spoke with attendees at the vigil to hear their thoughts and remembrances of Martin.

“I hope that this makes a strong state-ment. His mom and family just want jus-tice so that [Martin] may rest in peace.”

—freshman Ba’Carri Johnson, who knew Martin in high school

“We are grateful that so many peo-ple are fighting to ensure that [Martin didn’t] die in vain.”

—freshman Adesuwa Giwa-Osagie

“I hate that it had to take a death to mobilize us.... This wasn’t an isolated incident, and this is an issue that affects all marginalized peoples. Hate is hate.”

—junior Jasmine Johnson

“We hope that this vigil shows that people care about this issue and that this still happens around the commu-nity and the world.”

—sophomore Ashley Long

“Our hearts go out to the family of Travyon Martin and we hope this vigil doesn’t end awareness of this issue and that justice is done.”

—sophomore Ciera Price

“I hope that this vigil is a testament to all who knew and loved Travyon Mar-tin. It is to all who have felt threatened because of their identity.”

—freshman Stephanie Ogwo

“It was great to see a group of peo-ple from various ethnicities and back-grounds speak [about this issue]. We had another speaker about discrimina-tion against Muslims and Mark Antho-ny Neal mentioned injustice against the [lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender] community.”

—junior Mea Warren

“It is always really good when people get together for a common cause, but this hasn’t been the first event, and it probably won’t be the last. It is up to us to ensure that justice is served for Tray-von Martin.”

—junior Erica Pinson

“It was great that so many people gathered in memory of [Martin] and I just hope we would have gathered [if it had happened to someone] else.”

—freshman Broderick Turner

“I hope that this just won’t be an-other senseless killing of someone. [The vigil] brought to light that in-justice still happens and affects every-one.”

—freshman Crystal Chukwurah

VigilSoundoff

By Ellen NakashimaTHE WASHINGTON POST

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Cyberattacks on enemy computer systems should re-quire presidential authority—and not be launched at the discretion of individual military commanders—the nation’s top cy-berwarrior told Congress Tuesday.

The comment by Gen. Keith Alexander, the head of U.S. Cyber Command, offered a rare glimpse into a largely classified de-bate over standing rules of engagement for the military in cyberspace. Those rules govern what commanders can and cannot do on their own authority outside of war zones.

“It really comes down to, so what are those reactions that make sense that we can do defensively, analogous to the missile shoot-down?” he told the Senate Armed Services Committee.

“But if you are to go after a computer in foreign space or some other thing, that might be a response option that would now take, I think, the president and the [de-fense] secretary to step in and start making decisions, versus us taking that on,” Alex-ander said. “And I think that’s probably where we’ll end up, and that makes a lot of sense from my perspective.”

Alexander’s remarks came during a hearing that highlighted senators’ con-cerns about the growing threats to U.S. military, civilian and commercial networks dependent on the Internet. The threats are coming from foreign governments, crimi-nals and hackers and may one day also come from terrorists, officials warn.

The rules of engagement were last up-dated in 2005 and are being revised to reflect advances in technology and capa-bilities.

“We are pushing for what we think we need,” Alexander said, noting that his staff is working with the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Joint Staff and the Pen-tagon’s civilian leadership. The draft rules also will be vetted by other agencies and the National Security Council.

“Issues being ironed out are what spe-cific set of authorities we will receive, con-ditions in which we can conduct response actions,” he said, adding that the work is likely to be done “in the next few months.”

The military is not allowed to take ac-tions outside of its computer networks without special permission. Alexander al-luded to a contentious debate that has been going on for years inside the Defense Department and the administration about how and when cyberwarriors might take aim at adversaries beyond their network boundaries.

He said the National Security Agency, which Alexander also heads, once detected in foreign computer networks an adversary trying to steal three gigabytes of data from an American defense contractor. The chal-lenge was in alerting the company so that a response could be taken in time to stop the theft, he said.

Alexander likened it to seeing a cyber-intrusion happen at “network speed” and then “trying to send a regular mail letter to them [saying] that you’re being attacked.... There has got to be a better way to do that.”

Cyber Command was created in 2010 at Fort Meade, next to the operations center for the NSA, the nation’s largest spy agency.

Alexander also said that companies pro-viding essential services such as electricity and water should meet “some set of stan-dards” for network security as well as share data on network attacks with the govern-ment. Pending legislation aims at achiev-ing those goals.

Some Obama administration officials in recent months objected when Alexander said publicly that he wanted greater legal authority to protect the nation’s critical private-sector computer networks against cyberattacks.

On Tuesday, when committee Chairman Carl Levin, D-Mich., asked whether he was seeking additional legal authority, Alexan-der said, “No, chairman.”

Visit www.dukechronicle.com

THE CHRONICLE WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 | 5

Look for it on 9th Street and in Chick-Fil-A on campus!

Menu Sampling Old School Veggie Burrito $2.86 Regular Chicken Burrito $5.65 Cheese Quesadilla $1.41 Chicken Quesadilla $3.59 Veggie Nachos $4.12 Chips & Salsa $2.06

Answer:

If the act is found constitutional, adults will be penalized $95 if uninsured, and they will incur an additional fine for uninsured children. It will also expand Medicaid to an additional 16 million Americans. These measures are projected to help an addition-al 32 million Americans become insured by 2020, though 3 to 4 percent of Americans will remain uninsured, Sloan said.

The act will benefit those who do not have insurance by providing subsidies to help pay for health care, Sloan said. But many Americans already insured are un-happy with the act.

“The advantage is that we improve the health of the population that doesn’t have insurance,” he said. “The disadvantage is that someone has to pay.”

Under the health care reform, indi-viduals are insured under their parents’ plans until age 26. Sloan said if the act is repealed, many college students and other young Americans may not have access to health coverage.

Not having access to health insurance may not affect most young Americans be-cause they are healthy, he noted. Repeal-ing health care reform will have a greater impact on those who suffer from chronic diseases but cannot afford health care and do not qualify for Medicaid.

“Most Americans will just go along their merry way,” he said. “[But] the people who are disadvantaged will become more disad-vantaged.”

Duke collaborated with members of Congress and the White House in the developmental and legislative stages of the act, said Paul Vick, associate vice president for government relations at Duke Medicine. He added that mem-bers of the University involved in the

discussions agreed with lawmakers to cut $155 billion in hospital-based reimburse-ments over a 10-year period to fund the reforms.

Vick said Duke will continue to partici-pate in the health care policy debate re-gardless of the court’s ruling come June.

Lasting implicationsIn considering the act, the Supreme

Court will deliberate several important le-gal questions regarding the constitutional-ity of the legislation.

The justices will review all of the man-dates of the health care reform, but will pay particular attention to the “individual man-date” provision, which requires all Ameri-cans to purchase health insurance before 2015 or pay a fine. Deliberations Monday determined whether the individual man-date falls under the Anti-Injunction Act—a statute established in 1867 stating that tax laws must be enacted before federal courts can determine constitutionality. If the act was deemed applicable, then the court would not be able to issue a ruling on the individual mandate until it took effect in 2014.

Separability—allowing certain provi-sions of a law to still take effect even if other components are deemed unconstitution-al—was also in question.

Neil Siegel, professor of law and political science, emphasized the importance of the questions facing the court, adding that the judges’ decision could set legal precedent for many diverse issues.

“These questions are not just for the present, but for the future,” Siegel said. “Justices will try to discipline themselves to focus on very important legal questions with potential implications way beyond health care reform.”

The Supreme Court’s ruling will influ-ence voter opinion and turnout in the up-

HEALTH CARE from page 1

TORI POWERS/THE CHRONICLE

The Duke University Department of Music hosted a performance featuring mezzo-soprano Jacque-line Horner-Kwiatek in the Nelson Music Room in East Duke Tuesday.

The voice

coming presidential elections, but the ex-act outcomes remain uncertain, said David Rohde, Ernestine Friedl professor of politi-cal science.

Some voters feel the need to vote Re-publican in opposition of the act, Rohde noted. But if the court deems the law un-constitutional, those voters’ sense of ur-gency will be reduced, decreasing Repub-lican support at the polls come November. But an unconstitutional ruling could also increase motivation to vote Republican in order to prevent an alternative policy from

being enacted.For Democrats who support the health

care law, an unconstitutional ruling could motivate voters to reinforce their efforts to win the elections, Rohde said. He added that five of the nine Supreme Court jus-tices were nominated by Republican presi-dents.

“At the very least, Obama and his cam-paign will say, ‘Look at what the Supreme Court did—it shows why it is so important that the Republicans don’t get to select any more Supreme Court justices,’” Rohde said.

6 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

ACIR Open Forum: Investment Responsibility

and Con lict Minerals

We invite you to share your views at an Open Forum on Investment Responsibility and ‘Con lict Minerals.’ The President’s Advisory Committee on Investment Responsibility (ACIR) will hold an open forum to hear views of the Duke community (including students, faculty and staff) regarding the university’s investments with companies who may use con lict minerals. ‘Con lict minerals’ refer to metals that are mined in con lict-torn areas such as parts of Central Africa; these minerals may be incorporated into electronics and other products.

Wednesday, April 4, 20126:00-7:30 PM

Von Canon Room A, Bryan Center

Please visit the ACIR website for more informa on and materials:

h p://spotlight.duke.edu/acirforum/

Or contact Michele Wi man at:

mwi man@duke.edu

“Ideally, we want to give all applicants three chances, but given the sheer vol-ume of applications, we have to be prac-tical,” Guttentag said. “It was time we adopted [a system] which made straight-forward decisions more efficient and fo-cused our attention on those that were complex and nuanced.”

He added that each year there are a portion of applications that clearly indi-cate that the applicant is unfit for the institution. Under the streamlined pro-cess adopted this year, regional admis-sions officers denied admission to about one-third of the applicants after the first read, Guttentag said.

Regular decision applicants will re-ceive their admissions decision Thursday evening. In December, 648 of a record high 2,641 applicants were accepted un-der early decision.

Many of Duke’s peer institutions have experienced similar growth in the vol-ume of applications. The University of Pennsylvania received 31,127 applica-tions this year—the second consecutive year when the count exceeded 30,000. Cornell University received 37,673 ap-plications this year, up about 3.5 percent from last year.

Although no two institutions are the same, Guttentag said, a number of schools similar to Duke have already ad-opted new models to adapt to the high volume of applications. The changes

ADMISSIONS from page 1

AUDREY ADU-APPIAH/THE CHRONICLE

Due to higher volumes of applications each year, the admissions office seeks to relieve stress on this year’s admissions process by allowing applicants to be rejected before being reviewed further.

BYTHENUMBERSBYTHENUMBERS

12,00012,000Number of applications the previous admissions process was designed for

31,56531,565Number of applications for the Class of 2016

1/31/3Fraction of this year’s applications denied after the first read

60 -7060 -70Hours per week regional admis-sions officers spend working during admissions season

Duke made to the admissions process should not compromise its ability to se-lect the best applicants.

“In a way, the method in which colleg-es rate students is not as significant or critical as the quality of the decision of the university,” he said. “As long as you have thoughtful, insightful and hard-working admissions officers and a sense of qualities you are looking for, any ad-missions process will do.”

The new modelThe tweaks will allow admissions of-

ficers to focus on applicants hovering on the borderline of acceptance and rejec-tion, Guttentag said.

The new process benefits applicants because regional admissions officers—experts on specific areas—consider their applications first, he added. Ad-junct admissions staff—trained individu-als who are hired as part-time readers—still review applications to give another perspective, but their input comes later in the process. Outside readers often in-clude former admissions officers from Duke and other institutions and long-time community members. Before, the first person to read an application was the outside reader among the two other guaranteed reads—one by the regional officer and one by either a senior associ-ate director or by the committee.

“We want to make sure that the first person to look at the application has a strong impact on how applications are viewed,” Guttentag said. “This year, the first overall review is conducted by some-one who knows the applicant and his or her context well.”

He noted that the role of the first read, which generally lasts about 30 minutes has remained the same. Region-al admissions officers, who are often in charge of about 1,800 candidates, spend 60 to 70 hours per week working from the end of December through the first couple of weeks of March.

The elimination of a mandatory second read has made the process more efficient.

“Instead of using the time to review applications that we know from the start won’t make it, we instead use the pro-fessional time of the admissions staff to pinpoint and analyze those of more

competitive students,” said Steve Now-icki, dean and vice provost for under-graduate education.

The growth in applications also prompted admissions to hire two more associate officers in time for this cycle, though this expansion does not match the exponential growth of applications of recent years, Guttentag said. There are about 20 associates and senior asso-ciate admissions officers.

Still, both Guttentag and Nowicki said the lack of admissions staff was not the guiding decision behind the change in the review process.

A high standardThe applicant pool has become in-

creasingly competitive, as the Duke’s regular decision acceptance rate fell from just under 22 percent in 2005 to 10.8 percent in 2011.

In addition to the qualitative review of applications, readers still rates appli-cants on a five-point scale in six catego-ries: achievement, academic curriculum, essays, letters of recommendation, extra-curricular activities and personal quali-ties. Although top scores from the rating system—a feature preserved in the up-dated admissions process—do not solely determine the fate of the application, Guttentag noted that such measures help officers magnify what would ordinarily be minute differences among applicants.

“[The rating system] is only one of my guides that help us make our deci-sion,” Guttentag said. “If an applicant has a high rating in the categories, their chances of being admitted are in-creased.”

Guttentag said the bar for acquiring a top score in each of the categories is continually increasing. Seven or eight years ago, five Advancement Placement exams with a score of five would warrant the top score in Duke’s achievement category. Today, about half of the appli-cants meet this standard.

This raises the need for continued questioning of the role of the rating sys-tem in the application process, he added.

“To what degree are the criteria serv-ing our purpose?” Guttentag said. “It’s up to much discussion, but it may be time to evaluate the rating system itself.”

Oriakhi a good fit for Blue Devils

Duke holds on to beat BrownMEN’S LACROSSE

by Lopa RahmanTHE CHRONICLE

The Blue Devils have struggled to close out games. And this matchup against Brown was no exception.

Although the Bears staged a furious fourth-quarter comeback, Duke held on to win 9-8, improving to a per-fect 7-0 at Koskinen Stadium.

Brown staged a 3-0 run in the fourth period to bring the game within one, in similar fashion to Georgetown and Har-vard, who scored five and four unanswered fourth-quarter goals

against the Blue Devils, respectively, in recent games. “We knew the game was going to come down to the

fourth quarter,” head coach John Danowski said. “The fourth quarter has not been a strength of ours in the last several games.... We didn’t help ourselves by turning the ball over offensively. So while we got that lead, we cer-tainly almost gave it away.”

The No. 8 Blue Devils’ (8-3) nine goals were scored by nine different players, including two freshmen. Jake Tripucka led Duke in points with a goal and two assists, followed by Jordan Wolf, who added a goal and an assist.

Brown’s (3-4) John DePeters struck first, but was an-swered by an unassisted goal less than three minutes lat-er from the Blue Devils’ David Lawson. With 2:22 left in the first period, Duke’s Robert Rotanz followed that up with a goal, set up by Tripucka. The Bears did not let the Blue Devils head into the second period with the lead, however, as Nick Piroli tied the game at two with a goal off a Duke turnover. BRITTANY ZULKIEWICZ/THE CHRONICLE

Junior midfielder Jake Tripucka scored a goal and assisted on two others to lead Duke in points Tuesday afternoon.

With the 2011-12 basketball season in the rearview mirror for all but four of the nation’s Divi-sion I programs, it’s never too soon to start talking about next year!

For those of us who like to speculate on how Duke’s roster will look when Countdown to Craziness kicks off in October, the events of the past week have

provided significant fuel for the fire. The formal announce-ment Monday afternoon con-firming that Austin Rivers will be second Blue Devil freshman in two years to hire an agent and enter the NBA Draft means that Duke is already down one major contributor heading into

the summer. If Mason Plumlee is indeed “testing the NBA waters” as former Blue Devil Jay Williams first reported Thursday—or more importantly, if Plumlee decides that the NBA has nice “waters” that he finds more pleasing than the “waters” that Duke and the NCAA have to offer—the Blue Devils could have not one but two major holes to fill before the fall.

It would seem to be no secret that Duke is working hard to fill a void in the post through recruiting, and the Blue Devils do still seem to have a shot at land-ing 270-pound center Tony Parker from Lithonia, Ga. But if Duke misses out on Parker, there may not be another low-post high school senior to go after at this stage in the game.

NATE GLENCER/THE CHRONICLE

If Mason Plumlee leaves for the NBA Draft, Claxton writes, Duke would be left with a major hole in its frontcourt.

Duke 9

Brown 8

SEE M. LACROSSE ON PAGE 8

RyanClaxton

SEE CLAXTON ON PAGE 8

WOMEN’S BASKETBALL

Fourth period woes persist as Bears nearly complete upset

Williams named All-AmericanAdd All-American to the list of Elizabeth Williams’

accolades.The 6-foot-3 center was selected to the Associated

Press All-America third team, becoming the first fresh-man in Blue Devil history to earn All-America honors. She was the only first year to make any of the three All-America squads.

Williams has racked up awards in her first year in Durham, already having won ACC defensive player of the year, ACC freshman of the year and All-ACC first team recognition.

Williams led the team in points, rebounds and blocked shots with 14.0, 7.8 and 3.5 per game, respectively. Her 3.5 blocks per game ranked fifth nationally and her 116 total set an ACC single-season record.

Highlighted by an 18-point, 16-rebound and 12-block performance against Wake Forest, Williams improved dur-ing conference play. In her 16 ACC games, she averaged 15.4 points, 8.4 boards and 4.0 blocks.

Point guard Chelsea Gray, who led Duke in assists, steals and minutes played while notching the second-most points per game at 12.5, did not make any of the All-America teams.

Stanford’s Nnemkadi Ogwumike and Baylor’s Britt-ney Griner were unanimous selections for the first team. They were joined by Notre Dame’s Skylar Dig-gins, Delaware’s Elena Delle Donne and Maryland’s Alyssa Thomas.

—from staff reports

CAROLINE RODRIGUEZ/THE CHRONICLE

Center Elizabeth Williams is the first Duke freshman ever to be named an Associated Press All-American.

SportsThe Chronicle

www.dukechroniclesports.com

WEDNESDAYMarch 28, 2012

>> BLUE ZONE Duke was one of eight ACC athletic departments to turn a profit in 2010-11.

A look at how Austin Rivers fits with some of the NBA teams that may draft him.

8 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

ANNOUNCEMENTS

A LOT OF CARS INC. Most vehicles $595-$795 down $250-$280/month.

250+ Vehicles. Layaway option w/$500. Financing Guaran-teed!

Duke ID $150 discount. 20+ cars between $999-$2995 cash. www.alotofcarsnc.com. Owned by Duke Alumni 919-220-7155

RESEARCH STUDIES

PARTICIPANTS ARE NEED-ED for studies of visual and hearing function using mag-netic resonance imaging (MRI). These studies are conducted at the Brain Imaging and Analysis Center (BIAC) at Duke University Medical Center. Participants should be 18 years or older and should have no history of brain injury or disease. Most studies last between 1-2 hours, and par-ticipants are paid approximately $20/hr. Please contact the BIAC volunteer coordinator at 681-9344 or volunteer@biac.duke.edu for additional information. You can also visit our website at www.biac.duke.edu.

HELP WANTED

THE CHRONICLELooking for student to work in our Business Office for the sum-mer and continue through the school year. Reconciling news-paper, Data entering, deposits, customer service, general office work. Please call: Mary Weaver, 684-0384 or email: mweaver@

duke.edu

EARN $1000-$3200 A MONTH to drive our brand new cars with ads. www.Car-DriveAds.com

BARTENDERS ARE IN DEMAND!

Earn $20-$35/hr. in a recession-proof job. 1 or 2 week classes & weekend classes. 100% job placement assistance. Raleigh’s Bartending School. HAVE FUN! MAKE MONEY! MEET PEOPLE! For a limited time, tuition as low as $299. CALL NOW!!! 919-676-0774, www.cocktailmixer.com/duke.html

WE’RE CURRENTLY LOOKING FOR AN

OUTGOING LEADER as a Dell Campus Representative!

In this part-time paid position, you will be required to utilize your networks to create a dia-logue with consumers, generate buzz and in turn support the sustainable development of our client(s) brand. You will help promote Dell by attending cam-pus events such as orientations, club events, career fairs, and a variety of social functions.

How to apply: please call Rich Johnson at 877-870-4800 ext 4842

ENTERTAINMENT

CORN HOLE TOURNAMENT $300 PAYOUT every Thursday. Bring your own team or LOD - $5 Entry. 7:00pm RallyPoint on Har-rison Ave. www.RallyPointSport-Grill.com. Find on FaceBook

ROCKIN’ BLUES BAND FEATURING DUKE PROFS

Thursday, March 29, 10pm at the Broad Street Cafe, “Mona Lisa’s Highway Blues” is a rocking blues band with influences from Chicago blues to Dylan to alter-native psych rock. The band fea-tures barely recognizable Duke professors from Philosophy, En-gineering, and Law, along with celebrated local musicians.

Email wayne.norman@duke.edu

CLASSIFIEDS

The Chronicle

classified advertising

www.duke-chronicle.com/

classifiedsdeadline

12:00 noon 1 business day prior to publication

Advertise here for the best results

The Blue Devils’ Michael Manley kicked off second-period scoring with a fast break goal less than three min-utes in, followed by an unassisted one from Jordan Wolf 46 seconds later. With 8:20 remaining, Brown’s Sam Hurster scored on an extra-man op-portunity but both teams went score-less for the rest of the period with Duke heading into the locker room with a 4-3 advantage.

The Blue Devils started the second half strong offensively, with tallies from Tripucka and Josh Offit in the first 2:46. The Bears’ Dan O’Brien responded with a goal less than three minutes later. With 14 seconds left in the third period, Eddie Loftus scored off a pass from Tripucka, but once again Brown did not let Duke have the last goal of the period, notching a goal with just one second remaining on the clock.

The final period of the game looked promising for the Blue Devils, who had a 9-5 lead after goals from freshmen Will Haus and Kyle Keenan in the first seven minutes of play. The lead did not last long, though, as the Bears started their rally less than a minute later, as O’Brien, Parker Brown and Piroli found the back of the net to bring the game within one.

Although Duke slid by with a win, a three-quarter effort will not be enough in its next game against No. 14 Syracuse.

“We have to play smarter, we have to execute, and we just have to play overall better,” Tripucka said. “We’re not going to be able to squeak out of these games every week. Syracuse is an unbelievable opponent, tons of athletes. We have our hands full Sunday.”

Luckily, in what may turn out to be the most fortuitous news of the week-end for the Blue Devils, junior forward Alex Oriakhi is leaving Connecticut.

Oriakhi announced his departure Thursday morning, citing the Huskies’ pending ban from postseason play due to the program’s poor academic stand-ing. NCAA rules allow players to trans-fer without sitting out a year—as Seth Curry was forced to do during Duke’s 2010 championship run—if the pro-gram is ineligible for the postseason for a period equal to or greater than the player’s remaining eligibility. Ori-akhi just completed his third season at Connecticut, and thus, the Huskies’ one-year ban would be equal to his re-maining year of eligibility.

Landing Oriakhi would be a major coup for the Blue Devil program in a year when shooting guard Rasheed Su-laimon is Duke’s only signed recruit. Su-laimon won the McDonald’s All-Amer-ican 3-Point Contest Monday evening, and will be another quality guard to bol-ster the Blue Devils’ rotation in Rivers’ absence next season.

But Oriakhi would take this team to another level.

With Mason Plumlee, Oriakhi could provide some needed muscle as the sec-ond half of a terrifyingly athletic duo in the paint for Duke. His presence would allow Ryan Kelly to spend more time on the perimeter, and the Blue Devils would immediately be the favorite to win the ACC with a starting lineup of Plumlee, Oriakhi and three veteran guards.

Without Plumlee, Duke could rely on Oriakhi on the interior night in and night out. He could start at cen-ter and allow Ryan Kelly to start at the valuable “stretch-four” position that the Blue Devils missed during the postseason this year. At the same time, he would dramatically relieve the pres-sure that would be thrust on Marshall Plumlee and Josh Hairston in a “worst-case scenario” for Duke’s big men, should the Blue Devils be forced to use a three-man rotation of Marshall, Hairston, and Kelly inside.

Oriakhi brings championship ex-perience from Connecticut’s 2011 title team, a campaign in which he averaged 9.6 points and 8.7 rebounds per game as a sophomore. That season is already better statistically than any of the four seasons Miles Plumlee produced in Dur-ham, and only narrowly trails Mason’s production of 11.1 points and 9.2 re-bounds from this year.

Granted, Oriakhi would only be in the program for one year. He would fol-

low Irving and Rivers as players who came into the program for the first time in Au-gust and departed less than eight months later. Yes, it is rare for Krzyzewski to bring transfer players into the fold, preferring to groom players into the program and devel-op them over several years.

Yet Oriakhi is a special case. He can help immediately, and he fills a glaring void in Duke’s big man rotation that will grow even larger if Mason Plumlee im-merses himself in the NBA waters. With Mason returning, Oriakhi is a great ad-dition. Without Mason, Oriakhi becomes an essential addition.

The Blue Devils will find out soon if they’ve hit or missed on Tony Parker. But Duke can’t afford to miss out on Alex Oriakhi.

M. LACROSSE from page 7CLAXTON from page 7

THANH HA NGUYEN/THE CHRONICLE

Dan Wigrizer had 10 saves, including four in the final period, to help Duke stave off the Bears.

THE CHRONICLE WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 | 9

Diversions Shoe Chris Cassatt and Gary Brookins

Dilbert Scott Adams

Ink Pen Phil Dunlap

Doonesbury Garry Trudeau

Sudoku Fill in the grid so that every row, every col-umn and every 3x3 box contains the digits 1 through 9. (No number is repeated in any column, row or box.)

A nswer to puzzle

www.sudoku.com

The Chronicle What we would streamline:

production: ............................................................................... katiethe walk to loyo: ............................. nickyle, sanette, lauren, juliancampus drive:........................................................................... ardenmm apps: ...................................................................................scotttravel costs: .......................................................................... ctcusackthe tsa line: ............................................. sophia, jisoo, tori, chelseaposting: .................................................................................... jaemsindesign: ................................................................................ yueranBarb Starbuck takes no shortcuts: ............................................ Barb

Student Advertising Manager: .........................................Amber SuStudent Account Executive: ...................................Michael SullivanAccount Representatives: ............................Cort Ahl, Jen Bahadur,

Courtney Clower, Peter Chapin, Claire Gilhuly, Gini Li,Ina Li, Andy Moore, Allison Rhyne,

Daniel Perlin, Emily Shiau, James SinclairCreative Services Student Manager: .......................... Megan MezaCreative Services: ................Lauren Bledsoe, Danjie Fang, Mao Hu

Caitlin Johnson, Erica Kim, Brianna NofilBusiness Assistant: ........................................................Joslyn Dunn

Need help? Put an ad in

The Chronicle classifieds and

get all the help you need!

www.dukechronicle.com/classifieds

It’s easy to admire strong women and sym-pathize with weak women—but we rarely demand complex women. Why?

I’m not sure how “The Hun-ger Games” or “Twilight” series became such phenomena, but I still found myself immersed for hours in their respective first books. I always get sucked into these things. Once I start a sto-ry, I can’t stop. I can’t help but love the feeling of devouring a book that’s smooth from start to finish. Indeed, I sympathize with “The Hunger Games” tril-ogy’s vast fan base. It’s fun to read these kinds of books. They’re easy and exciting. Sorry, though: they’re not worthy of obsession.

All of this wouldn’t irk me that much if not for the buzz about the main character, Katniss (protagonist name fail). Katniss is the family breadwinner after her dad’s death. This role requires her to hunt for her family, so she is a skilled archer. She’s cunning in survival situ-ations, but dense socially. She’s modest, and cares more than anything for the main peo-ple in her life—her mother, sister and friend Gale. She seems … kind of normal to me. I know plenty of women at Duke who are physi-cally strong and mentally sharp, yet sometimes caring and awkward.

From the way people talk about her, you’d think Katniss was some supernatural babe. Entertainment Weekly calls her “remarkable, kick-a**.” One unfortunate New York Times piece calls Katniss’ character “A brilliant, pos-sibly historic creation—stripped of sentimen-tality and psychosexual ornamentation, armed with Diana’s bow and a ferocious will—Katniss is a new female warrior.” Rolling Stone goes on to say that the film is a “victory” because it presents “a heroine propelled by principle instead of hooking up with the cutest boy.”

Haha. No. Katniss is not a revolution-ary or historic character. We’ll confine this conversation to popular fiction and film, but even within those spheres Katniss is not terribly different from previously conceived characters. The recent films “Hanna” and “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” spring to mind; both feature androgynous female characters who exhibit tough attitudes and physical prowess. (Also: Mulan? Remember her?). “Winter’s Bone,” which incidentally stars the same Jennifer Lawrence (the ac-tress who portrays Katniss) follows Ree, an-

other stalwart breadwinner in dire straits. In the book realm, you’ve got the heroines of basically all of Robyn McKinley’s works,

not to mention Lirael in Garth Nix’s “Old Kingdom” series. The devastatingly clever Lyra in “His Dark Materials” is an easy comparison, as is our beloved Hermione. These are just a few women characters who have captured our imaginations.

Besides the fact that Katniss’ character has been done before, it is also problematic to me that she’s now being juxtaposed with

the infamous Bella of the “Twilight” series. It’s easy to chime in and say that Bella is weak compared to Katniss. Essentially, if the two women were in a cage fight, Bella would defi-nitely lose, and probably die in the process. In the words of Rolling Stone: “Katniss makes Twilight’s Bella Swan look like the wimp she is.” I’ll admit, when I read whatever the se-quel to “Twilight” is called, I too cringed at the book’s catatonic phase, in which when Bella loses Edward. For a long time after-wards, I probably would have agreed that Bel-la deserved to suffer for being so dependent. But recently, I’ve been thinking—no matter how annoying it is, why do we accept Katniss so fully, and yet reject Bella so vindictively?

Debates about “strong female characters” (double puke) need to stop. Praising charac-ters for being militantly physical or condemning them for their lack of power tends to mask what their essence is as human beings. Women and men have endless personalities and minds that can be unbearably complex. Physical and mental “strength” has little to do with the deeper com-plications of being human. Characters in popu-lar fi ction and fi lm—especially the ones that kids and young adults internalize—should refl ect these inevitable and fascinating diversities.

What should be respected in this teen-fic-tion genre is the ability to evoke a truly realis-tic, touchable, vulnerable and relatable char-acter. This should be the goal. Like adults, teen girls should be able to read popular fic-tion without having to learn something about being “strong” or “weak.” Rather, they should be able to relish the joys of character devel-opment. We should be able to devour these books in peace.

Ellie Bullard is a Trinity junior. Her column runs every other Wednesday.

commentaries10 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

The C

hron

icle

The Ind

epen

dent

Dai

ly a

t D

uke

Uni

vers

ity

editorial

Cage fi ght: Katniss vs. Bella

Course registration needs reform

”“ onlinecomment

How healthy can “sense of tolerance” be if it allows ethi-cal violations to go unchecked?

—“John U” commenting on the story “Study identifi es students’ moral compass, integrity.” See more at www.dukechronicle.com.

LETTERS POLICY

The Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identifi cation, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns.

The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

Direct submissions to:

E-mail: chronicleletters@duke.eduEditorial Page DepartmentThe ChronicleBox 90858, Durham, NC 27708Phone: (919) 684-2663Fax: (919) 684-4696

Inc. 1993Est. 1905 The Chronicle

SANETTE TANAKA, EditorNICHOLAS SCHWARTZ, Managing Editor

NICOLE KYLE, News EditorCHRIS CUSACK, Sports Editor

MELISSA YEO, Photography EditorMEREDITH JEWITT, Editorial Page Editor

CORY ADKINS, Editorial Board ChairMELISSA DALIS, Co-Managing Editor for Online

JAMES LEE, Co-Managing Editor for OnlineDEAN CHEN, Director of Online Operations

JONATHAN ANGIER, General ManagerTOM GIERYN, Sports Managing Editor KATIE NI, Design Editor LAUREN CARROLL, University Editor ANNA KOELSCH, University EditorCAROLINE FAIRCHILD, Local & National Editor YESHWANTH KANDIMALLA, Local & National EditorASHLEY MOONEY, Health & Science Editor JULIAN SPECTOR, Health & Science EditorTYLER SEUC, News Photography Editor CHRIS DALL, Sports Photography EditorROSS GREEN, Recess Editor MATT BARNETT, Recess Managing EditorCHELSEA PIERONI, Recess Photography Editor SOPHIA PALENBERG, Online Photo Editor DREW STERNESKY, Editorial Page Managing Editor CHRISTINE CHEN, Wire EditorSAMANTHA BROOKS, Multimedia Editor MOLLY HIMMELSTEIN, Special Projects Editor for VideoCHRISTINA PEÑA, Towerview Editor RACHNA REDDY, Towerview EditorNATHAN GLENCER, Towerview Photography Editor MADDIE LIEBERBERG, Towerview Creative DirectorTAYLOR DOHERTY, Special Projects Editor CHRISTINA PEÑA, Special Projects Editor for OnlineLINDSEY RUPP, Senior Editor TONI WEI, Senior EditorCOURTNEY DOUGLAS, Recruitment Chair CHINMAYI SHARMA, Blog EditorMARY WEAVER, Operations Manager CHRISSY BECK, Advertising/Marketing DirectorBARBARA STARBUCK, Creative Director REBECCA DICKENSON, Chapel Hill Ad Sales Manager

The Chronicle is published by the Duke Student Publishing Company, Inc., a non-profi t corporation indepen-dent of Duke University. The opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of Duke University, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. Unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. Columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors.

To reach the Editorial Offi ce at 301 Flowers Building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. To reach the Business Offi ce at 103 West Union Building, call 684-3811. To reach the Advertising Offi ce at 101 West Union Building call 684-3811 or fax 684-8295. Visit The Chronicle Online at http://www.dukechronicle.com.

© 2010 The Chronicle, Box 90858, Durham, N.C. 27708. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without the prior, written permission of the Business Office. Each individual is entitled to one free copy.

ellie bullardas we know it

Bookbagging season evokes a variety of emotions from students, ranging from excitement to anxiety. Preva-lent among these is frustra-tion with the antiquated ACES system due to prob-lems with its interface and content.

These issues are not debili-tating, but they nonetheless degrade the course registra-tion process for students. Due to the scope of their implica-tions, rather than the severity, the means of course registra-tion still needs reform. An im-proved user experience would encourage excitement about courses and the registration process, thus fostering a more conducive environment for academic enthusiasm.

At present, the content of

ACES often forces students to make uninformed or only partially informed decisions about classes. In the absence of in-depth information about a course, students rely on triv-

ial aspects like course titles or meeting times.

To help students make more informed decisions, each course on ACES should in-clude a substantial synopsis so students know the intellectual questions the course attempts to tackle. Similarly, tentative course syllabuses should ac-company every class.

In 2005, Duke Student Government launched the DSG online syllabus archive, which allowed students to upload and share course syllabuses with each other. However, the site has been

neglected, either due to lack of student interest or a fail-ure to update the site. Either way, the primary responsibil-ity should lie with individual professors to upload their syllabuses to ACES. Such an initiative would benefi t both parties—students could have more and better information about their course options, and professors would be more likely to initially attract genu-inely interested students.

Aside from the content, the ACES interface is similarly problematic. Navigating the site is clumsy, as students lack standard conveniences like an intuitive “back” button from the browser. Links within the system are not intuitive, caus-ing confusion in performing simple tasks. Furthermore, cross-listed courses pose addi-

tional challenges to bookbag-ging because they are labeled independently in each depart-ment, leading to confusion about multiple course num-bering and wait lists.

These interface problems are just several of many. But all dampen a student’s course registration experience, bur-dening it with technological diffi culties rather than illu-minating it with academic excitement.

Kaveh Danesh, DSG vice president for academic affairs, has proposed an event called Bookbag Sunday to increase the excitement surround-ing bookbagging. Bookbag Sunday would be a pre-reg-istration social in the library where deans and professors could chat with students about courses. Such an event would

take place the Sunday preced-ing bookbagging, It would al-low students to better choose their next semester’s courses and get excited about them.

ACES certainly has its prob-lems, but they are not so insur-mountable to merit a new and likely expensive software suite. But when Duke does inevita-bly purchase new course regis-tration software in the future, it should invest in new, top-of-the-line software rather than something already outdated at the time of purchase.

Issues surrounding course registration are not detrimen-tal to the process, but they nonetheless stifl e academic excitement around course selection. Software should not serve as a barrier to a suc-cessful course registration—rather it should facilitate it.

When I fi rst wrote about grading policy last semester, I thought I was delving into a basic grading ineq-

uity between majors at Duke.Turns out grading poli-

cy—by which I mean the fl ex-ibility Duke and other un-dergraduate institutions give various departments and pro-fessors to set their own grad-ing standards—is weakening academic culture at Duke and penalizing talented pro-fessors and students.

Start with the professor evaluations completed by stu-dents at the end of each semester. Teacher evaluations are used as a resource in deter-mining whether or not to award tenure—that is to say, they are pretty important. They are also correlated to the grading dis-tributions used in a given course. A study released last year by former Duke professor Stuart Rojstaczer showed that professors who award higher grades on average tend to receive higher course evaluations from students.

“In my experience as a department chair, looking over the teaching evaluations of my colleagues, there’s a correlation between eval-uations and grades,” said Alex Rosenberg, the chair of Duke’s philosophy department.

Awarding higher grades also keeps stu-dents happy and away from offi ce hours, which increases professors’ down time and leaves them free to do more valuable things, like research. “There are people who think that their livelihood, their continued em-ployment at Duke, and even their level of non-annoyance by students is assured by the current system,” Rosenberg told me in a phone call.

As departments have begun to recognize the grade infl ation that results from these perverse incentives, some have taken uni-lateral action against it. Ken Rogerson, the director of undergraduate studies for public policy, showed me a memo he sends to un-dergraduate professors in his department every year. The document includes the rec-ommended mean grades for sub-100 level, 100-level and 200-level courses. The memo tells professors they are free to “bust the grading curve” when they feel it is necessary, but it also warns that consistent lack of adher-ence to department grading policy is taken into account in faculty career reviews.

“One of the reasons we do this is because of the problems of grade infl ation,” Roger-son told me. “We want to push students to be really good criti-cal thinkers.”

But other departments take a different approach. “There is no grading policy in the philosophy department,” Rosenberg told me. “Every member of the depart-ment is completely autonomous in the grades they give.”

Of course, the fact that dif-ferent majors have different grading policies wouldn’t really matter if students were never compared to their peers in dif-ferent disciplines. But they are. In fact, our University makes this comparison every year when it computes Dean’s List and Latin Honors cut-offs. Even though philosophy and public policy majors are subject to complete-ly different grading standards, their GPAs are mashed up and compared against each other in the University’s recognition of academic excellence.

And employers, graduate schools and other folks who

look at GPAs aren’t given the crucial in-formation that a 3.7 in public policy might means something completely different than a 3.7 in philosophy.

When I was told during job interviews this year that some fi rms use a GPA cut-off of 3.5 for interviews, I real-ized how big the difference between a 3.4 in math and a 3.6 in English can be.

“The ironic thing is that as GPAs have gone up and become less meaningful … students and professional schools have decided to try

to make distinctions between GPAs at a fi ner and fi ner level,” Rojstaczer said in an e-mail.

Unsurprisingly, this trend skews student enrollment toward majors and courses that are graded more leniently. “Grading prac-tices do infl uence student choice,” Rojstac-zer, who has completed decades of research on the subject, told me. Amazingly, a study by former Duke statistics professor Valen Johnson concludes that “American under-graduates take 50 percent fewer courses in the natural sciences and math than they would if grading practices were more eq-uitable.”

The domino effect here should scare any-one who cares about the future of Duke and its peer academic institutions. Professors are rewarded for giving higher grades and depart-ments—through increased enrollment—are incentivized not to do anything about it. In the meantime, students are steered towards classes that give higher grades, rather than the ones that interest them.

This is not an issue of grade infl ation, which is a problem (mostly) unto itself. Instead, it’s an issue of grading disparities. If every Duke professor used the same grading distribution with an average grade of A-, for instance, that would clearly result in grade infl ation. But it wouldn’t skew student enrollment or result in the same confusion for employers.

That this problem has festered for so long at institutions of Duke’s caliber is astonish-ing. While other schools are introducing innovative grading policies, Duke’s adminis-tration has, as ever, remained stagnant. This issue cannot wait any longer: It is too crucial to the future of our institution.

We need to reverse the cycle.

Jeremy Ruch is a Trinity junior. His column runs every other Wednesday.

commentariesTHE CHRONICLE WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 | 11

The insidious grading cycle

jeremy ruchrun and tell that

I thought at fi rst that it would go away. Once the novelty wore off, people would stop. But I was wrong, just like I was wrong about “Call Me Maybe” (seriously, WHAT is appealing about that song? Nothing. Sorry I hate fun). I thought that

the fad would die out. But no. It is here to stay. I am talking, of course, about how everyone here thinks they’re Southern.

For a lot of Dukies, Durham is their fi rst en-counter with the South, so they basically think that they are rogue, nouveau-Southern warriors living out “Deliverance.” Not true. Duke is a veritable castle in the heart of the most urban, un-South-ern part of North Carolina. Sorry, Dukies: Just be-cause it’s normal here to get shuper shwasted and belt a half-slurred “Wagon Wheel” does not mean you’re living the Southern life. I would know. I am what you might call “Southern as f***.” Or, to use an expression that might actu-ally kill neurons: Southern as biscuits. Blech, I think typing that made me develop diabetes.

Recently, some of my friends have asked me to explain what Southern RE-ALLY means. So as your resident GRITS (Google it you ignorant Northeasterner), I’m here to enlighten you. So here’s a snippet from my book, “What Is Southern: Things Dukies Should Know, Volume One.”

Tip One: The South is not a fraternity. I fi gured I’d put this one fi rst because it seems to be Dukies’ biggest misconcep-

tion about the South. Soon after rush, the Duke uniboy emerges: the stereotypi-cal “Southern” frat-rostitute, going to Carolina Cup and wearing boat shoes like normal shoes and whatnot. Now I’m not saying frats are an exclusively Southern thing, but it is the main thing Duke boys love that they seem to think is Southern. Many Duke frats take pride in their “Southernness,” which they express through blaring Taylor Swift songs and recruiting lots of rich white kids. Which brings me to the second item.

Tip Two: Conservatism. We Southern folk cordially invite you to our Tea Party. Admission comes with

a free Bible and your choice of torch or pitchfork, and a guarantee that we won’t picket YOUR funeral.

Tip Three: The use of “Y’all.” Dear God. Please—don’t. “Y’all” said with a Midwestern accent is like someone

with a Jamaican accent talking about shrimp on the barbie and kangaroos (with-out the supermega-awesomeness of that combo).

Tip Four: Bojangles’. Go. Just go. Go and order everything and eat it. You eat it right now.Tip Five: Subtlety. If you want to truly act the Southern part, stop being straightforward. Living in

the South is legit learning to speak in code. No one ever says what they mean ever. To be Southern, be indecipherable literally 100 percent of the time. This subtlety extends into how we insult people. Southerners are the LORDS of passive aggres-sive b****iness. Start making cutting comments that sound like compliments, Re-gina George style. Example: Your friend ordered a Loop burger AND mozzarella sticks AND the calamari. You say, “You must have one fast metabolism!” Meaning: “You’re a fata**. Look at your life. Look at your choices.” The goal is to perpetu-ate a culture where no one trusts anyone and you can never tell if your friends love you or keep you around to mock you. You can also utilize the infamous “bless their heart.” You can pretty much call anyone anything with this one. Even to their face! “Bless your heart you goblin-faced, herpes-harvesting penis-burglar.” Totally acceptable.

Tip Six: Weird hobbies.These can range from mudding, shooting guns at road signs and chivalry, to

mowing lawns, mispronouncing simple words and hearkening back to the good-ole-days.

Hopefully with these six simple tips I’ve made what “Southern” is a little clearer for you. If not, you’ll have to order the whole book, for a low price of $1,197! I never really transitioned back from Confederate currency, so that seems like a reasonable price to me.

Okay, so not to get all deeps**t on you—I don’t think anyone reads my col-umns for the life lessons that I superimpose on them—but I actually have a point with this one. There is widespread disdain for the South, and stereotypes about Southerners, some of which I just enumerated. Southerners in popular culture are often portrayed as über-conservative religious nuts with thick drawls and IQs below 50. In fact, go ahead and imitate a stupid person for me. They had a South-ern accent, right?

I love being Southern. Hell, I love the South. Yet I often feel like that’s a minor-ity viewpoint at Duke. Duke students live in the South for at least four years. But how often do we appreciate the fact that it is the home to an incredibly diverse, unique culture? North Carolina has so much to offer—appreciate it! The South will always be an incredibly important part of my life. I invite y’all to make it a part of yours! And if you don’t, you’re a fi lthy pirate hooker … bless your heart.

Lillie Reed is a Trinity sophomore. Her installation of the weekly Socialites column runs on alternate Wednesdays. Follow Lillie on Twitter @LillieReed

In our minds we’re gone to California

lillie reedwumbology

The Socialites

Mariah Hukins, Trinity ‘13

12 | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012 THE CHRONICLE

VIDEO CONTEST

$500WIN

CATCH SOMEONE IN THE ACT OF DOING SOMETHING GREEN2 CONTEST PERIODS IN FEBRUARY AND MARCH

nicholas.duke.edu/gotchavideos

gotcha!living green

Mayor Bill Bell said. “For the University to… support the housing efforts is very important, even key to revi-talization.”

The project would collaborate with Durham’s cur-rent efforts to redevelop the neighborhood and would initially include 10 University employees and their fam-ilies, Wynn said. After these participants are identified and have qualified for mortgage loans, Duke officials plan to work with the city and developers to construct homes for the participants.

Eligibility criteria for individuals interested in the program include five years of continuous employment at the University and a maximum of $40,000 in income from Duke, Wynn said. All qualifying employees will be eligible to apply for the program, though only 10 will be chosen for the pilot phase, with another 25 or so being placed on a waiting list.

“The benefits and incentives of the program include no down payment on the home, [which will be] pro-vided through a $10,000 loan that will be forgiven after five years of continuous occupancy in the home, a be-low market-rate mortgage loan and the purchase of a new home at two-thirds of the purchase price,” Wynn wrote in an email Monday.

Participants will also be required to enroll in the Center for Community Self-Help’s Fast Track program, a community development program that works with aspiring homeowners and provides them assistance in credit repair, credit building and saving, Wynn added.

Wynn did not comment on the cost of the program or how the University will finance the program.

Bell noted the advantages to Duke’s proposal not only related to housing but also having to do with the city’s ongoing efforts to be environmentally conscious.

“[To make] sure we have a [low] carbon footprint that’s sustainable, we’re looking at transportation is-sues for Duke employees who become homeowners in that area, where they can make the best use of public transportation,” Bell said. “Southside is an accessible area for public transportation to help employees get back and forth between home and job.”

The city of Durham has been working with Self-Help on redevelopment projects in the neighborhood for the past four to five years, Bonfield said. Self-Help plans to sell the 100 Southside properties it has acquired to the city or other nonprofit home builders interested in participating in an overall city rehabilitation strategy.

“The Southside Neighborhood is one of the… more challenging inner-city neighborhoods with low homeownership, high vacancy rates [and] high code enforcement needs,” Bonfield said. “[The] neighbor-hood has been in decline since the Durham Freeway was constructed 40 years ago.”

The city has not yet constructed any new homes—though it has completed rehabilitation on two homes and plans to renovate two others soon—but hopes to construct at least 35 homes in the first phase of the project, Bonfield added. Each home will cost the city about $165,000, and qualified buyers will be able to purchase them with a reduction of about $35,000 to $55,000, plus any Duke-funded subsidy. Officials hope this initial phase will create momentum for more mar-ket-based new construction in the future.

Although the proposed initiative would be novel, it would not mark Duke’s first involvement with the Dur-ham’s Southside rehabilitation project, Bonfield said, noting that Duke has provided Self-Help Credit Union with low-to-no interest loans to acquire the properties for a number of years.

SUBSIDIES from page 1

downloads from external websites to be slower than usu-al,” Bonnett said.

The issue reached its peak in early March, Bonnett explained, adding that some of the problems may be due to issues with one of Duke’s Internet service providers.

Several students reported the problem to OIT, and Bonnett noted that her office tried to resolve problems as quickly as possible, adding that issues were addressed within 24 hours.

Despite these reassurances, the slow Internet contin-ues to cause problems for students.

“I’ve noticed it being slow all the time but especially in my [computer science] lab, which is a huge inconve-nience because it keeps crashing while I’m trying to snarf code,” sophomore Marshall Vingi said.

Vingi added that in computer science classes, students are expected to both download project instructions and submit the final assignment via Internet. Crashing pages creates dif-

ficulties when students try to complete an assignment. “Occasionally my connection to Google Docs has

been slow to save,” senior Shreyan Sen said. “While that hasn’t caused any problems for me yet, you can imagine how a shaky connection could be problematic for heavy cloud users.... A lot of [Google Docs are] used for col-laborative work.”

This expansion of bandwidth comes a year after Duke committed to steadily improve wireless service. Last July, Duke committed to providing high speed Internet service by participating in Gig. U—a collaborative project with dozens of other American universities and communities to promote high speed networks in order to accommodate academic, professional and personal online pursuits.

Duke is also making improvements to provide better re-dundancy for the system, Bonnett noted. Redundancy means that each connection can handle the full usage of Internet traffic in case one of Duke’s two connections goes down. The improvements are also equipped to provide automatic adjust-ments when interference from other devices occurs. OIT is currently upgrading wireless access points and controllers across campus.

INTERNET from page 3

Bored? Visit www.chronicleblogs.com for our news, sports, edito-

rial and recess blogs.