managing overabundant white-tailed deer

Upload: tamu-wildlife-and-fisheries-extension

Post on 06-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    1/18

    M Odt

    Wt-Td D

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    2/18

    Table of Contents

    Managing OverabunDanT WhiTe-TaileD Deer 1

    inTrODucTiOn 1

    History of Deer Abundance 2

    Human Values Placed On Deer 3

    Biological Carrying C apacity 3

    Problems Associated With Deer Overabundance 3

    Ecological Impact of Urban Deer Overabundance 5

    laWs anD regulaTiOns cOncerning urban Deer 6

    Whos In Charge of Managing Urban Deer? 6

    Whos In Charge of Regulating Urban Deer? 6

    Is Fer tility Control a Management Option? 6

    Management Options in Texas 7

    Laws Governing Trap, Transport, and Translocation (TTT) and/or Process (TTP) 9

    Steps for Managing Urban Deer Populations 9

    Step 1: Form a Deer Management Action Committee 10

    Step 2: Determine the scope of the problem 10

    Step 3: Hold a Town Hall Meeting 11

    Step 4: Develop an Urban Deer Management Plan 11

    Step 5: Implement the Plan and Monitor Results 12

    case sTuDies 12

    Need For Educat ional Program Development 13

    Final ThOughTs 13

    appenDices 14

    White-Tailed Deer Biology 14

    by: Matt Cook Photo by: Matt Cook

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    3/18

    White-tailed deer (Odocoileus

    virginianus) are one of the most

    recognizable and charismatic

    species of wildlife, but they are

    the cause of a growing urban

    wildlife management problem

    in many metropolitan areas

    throughout the United States.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    4/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    Introduction

    Wt-td d (Odocoileus virginianus) o

    o t mot oz d mt o

    wd, t ty t o ow

    wd mmt om my mtoot toot t utd stt. a w

    , t t tt qd y my

    wd d, t wt-td d

    to dt to omt d m

    tty. Wt-td d oto ow dy

    t d to t k o t dto, ty

    tt, dt ood o, d d

    o .

    W m d wd o to o

    ot, m-wd ot

    o. ato wt-td d ot wd tty ddto to my

    omow ommt, ty

    om w ty om odt

    d md. Fo xm, wt-td d

    ommt oom o

    to om d d d t,

    d tomo om d- oo.

    a t to y, w dd 204

    odt om stt Dtmt o nt

    ro, t 40 tt d t Dtt

    o com w odtd to t xtt o

    m/wt-td d ot toot t

    utd stt. ety t o t odt

    otd tt om o t ommt t ttw x m/wt-td d ot.

    O t t t y, mot odt (71%)

    otd t m o tz d

    ommty omt o m/wt-

    td d ot. how, t (42%) o

    t odt od dty wo w o

    wt-td d mmt t tt. a

    odt Oo td tt y t

    t tt tt d d m/wt-td d

    ot. a m oto ot to ow d

    ommt xd, tmt ky to xd o t utd stt. T o

    oo om t tdy w tt y

    ommty wt t zooo o wt-

    td d am w, tm, oy

    wt odt d d (Figure 1).

    Dmm otd wt d m

    om t d o dd dt, oty

    ow oto, d ty omt. how,

    w qd wt t oo d toy

    kowd to m t om. T o o t

    Managing OverabundantWhite-Tailed Deer

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    5/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    to to dt d o t ooy d

    ooy o wt-td d d to od

    dmt odto qd to do

    t mmt .

    History of Deer Abundance

    Wt-td d mott o

    to toy. vo d ot odt om

    d odd t, ot, d d y o y am. Wt-td d

    w o otd to t ot w t y

    xt w ttd. i t y 1900, d

    oto w t t owt w odd wt

    y oto wok d t domt o d

    tt td wd mmt oo.

    i Tx, d oto d

    to o o om d-

    o o to t tt d oto

    mmt. Tody mmt ot y

    td od od qty d od o

    m d Tx. M d t

    o jt ow t d oo y ty

    ommo o. boo y ty w

    ty td y d, dto, d ty

    o ood. i , d m md

    y t to mt wt o,

    t o t tk mo dft.

    i ddto to d, Tx o m oto tt dtd to w

    om 23 mo to 33 mo y 2030. coqty,

    o oto ow, tt o wt-td

    d otd, o ot omty to

    zto. Ot, wt-td d tt

    dtty td. Fo t, dmty

    td d k yd tt

    tt o wt-td d d t oto

    ot om qt (Figure 2).

    TX

    NM

    AZ

    CA

    NV

    UT

    CO

    OR

    WA

    ID

    MT

    WY

    ND

    SD

    NE

    KS

    OK

    MN

    IA

    WI

    MO

    ILIN

    MI

    OH

    KY

    AR

    LA

    MSAL

    TN

    GA

    FL

    SC

    NC

    WVVA

    PA

    NY

    ME

    VTNH

    CT

    MA

    RI

    NJ

    DEMD

    Figure 1. Zoogeographic range of white-tailed deer and states reporting white-tailed deer conicts.

    States Reporting White-Tailed Deer Conict

    LEGEND

    States Reporting Conict

    Range

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    6/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    Human Values Placed On Deer

    T my w d m

    dty dd o ty o to. som

    odto d t d ty k, o

    d tmo, o ot m t,

    d oom ot.

    po tt dmty dt moto d

    ytm to wt-td d. som o w

    d ot, t t o t

    tt tt do ot q tto y o.

    Ot w d o oo o

    tt mt mod om t d. bot

    oo to td, yt mt.

    tm tyy od mo tto t wt,

    ty otty ot m o

    m. boo y t o

    od d o t tm w o owt

    (.., wt) w o t t k.

    poto my xd oo y ty,t wt dtmt o t tt. smt

    T t m tt my ommt

    x odt d oto,

    w, d mtd t o. T

    o ot omty t. coqty,om om o d mmt om ot

    qmt, ot oto.

    Biological Carrying Capacity

    boo y ty ot wt

    wd . it dfd t mxmm

    m o dd tt omt

    ot wtot dtmt t. boo

    y ty o d mo tt tt

    t yy d oy. Fo xm, -

    ood ot t y ty o

    . it ow, tfy t oto

    o t t mt o t t tt.i mty d tt, oto

    to ot d t oto owt

    d . T ot o oo y

    ty wdy d o d oto t

    tt; ow, t od otd tt y

    ty mm oo ot.

    a m to o oo y

    ty t t y ty o

    ommty. Cultural carrying capacity t

    mxmm m o d tt oty w t

    wt o my, t m o dtt omty oxt wt t o m

    oto. T t y ty

    xdd wtot xd t oo y

    ty o t , dt ommt

    dt to o d m. i

    mot m-d ot tto ow, ot

    xdd d otd.

    Problems Associated With Deer Overabundance

    Deer-vehicle collisions tdy d o

    not am o t t two dd. stt Fmi tmt tt 2.4 mo d-

    oo od tw Jy 1, 2007 d J

    30, 2009. T m 18.3% om t

    o f y od. T i ittt o

    hwy sty tmt tt d- oo

    mo t 150 tt y, d t

    oty dm ot $3,050. i Tx, d-

    oo jmd 33% t dd d

    Tx d 1 416 kood o od

    wt d o t xt y.

    People attach

    dramatically different

    emotions and value systems

    to white-tailed deer.

    Many urban communities are experiencing overabundant

    deer populations, urban sprawl, and limited natural

    resources.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    7/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    D- oo ot omt

    d od wt dt o d.

    u otd wt d m

    oto owt d od dty

    mo t to d- oo.

    ato tq (to, wt,

    w , d dd d mt)

    td to d d- oo, o

    otty t.

    Disease transmission tw d d m o o my ommt wt odt

    wt-td d oto. Wt-td d

    ot o t k-d tk (Ixodes scapularis d

    Ixodes pacifcus). bk-d tk tmt

    tk-o d. T mot ot, lym

    d, my od t ott d

    ot-t utd stt ddto to om

    wt tt d Tx (Figure 3). T

    y o k-d tk omx; ow, tk

    tyy ott t d w d o

    m, d, o ot m m. a dt, tk

    d t d to w ot w d

    m. D do ot om td wt lym

    d to d m ood o o dt

    tk d d mott tot tk d

    mt tk oto.

    Example of population growth

    Figure 2. A deer population starting with 10 males and 10 females is projected for 10 years, assuming 50% fawn recruitment

    and 50% fawn mortality. Given none leave or others come into the population, a population beginning with 20 individuals will

    grow to 769, degrading and exhausting habitat resources.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    8/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    aod to t Center for Disease Control,

    oxmty 21,000 o lym d

    od o o t t 10 y, towd.

    s td td t mt o d

    dto o tk d. Dt ot

    t o td, dto d y

    oodd wt dto o tk. how, t

    o d dto y to d t k o

    lym d to m ot td.

    Ecological Impact of Urban Deer Overabundance

    rdt o ommt wt d m

    omtm oz t d t d o

    d, owd d omt d.

    Mo ot dt oz t ot dm

    t o t ty do ot oz t mtd

    dm o tm. D tmtd $250

    mo d dm o

    towd. Jt d o dtoy

    omt d, d t mt

    o t tt w t m xd t

    oo y ty.

    by om , tm, ow d t, d

    dty t t owt, odto, d o

    t. D w om d t ft,

    oy t wt wd to domt t

    . Odt d oto om

    qtt o tto; ty t od o ot d d d tto

    yw wt d d (od to 6

    t). s tto tzd y ow o

    y t o t tt ow d. T

    o d m.

    My t t od to o wt

    oy (omto o t o t t)

    to o m to d tox.

    how, t d tyy ot ft

    to t o-o wt odt

    87

    52

    75

    157

    CO

    6

    12

    9

    4

    3

    12

    0

    7

    8

    1

    1,238

    123

    1,814

    10

    149 55

    51

    33

    6

    1

    2

    113

    31

    11

    30

    31

    53

    84959

    3,994

    4,165

    529

    Alaska 10

    Washington DC 116

    Massachusetts 2,988

    Rhode Island 177

    Connecticut 3,085

    Hawaii 0

    New Hampshire 896

    Vermont 138

    Delaware 715

    Maryland 2,576

    New Jersey 3,134

    Figure 3. Number of reported cases of Lyme disease in the United States in 2007. (Data from Center of Disease Control;http://www.cdc.gov).

    Number of Reported Cases of Lyme Disease

    http://www.cdc.gov/http://www.cdc.gov/
  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    9/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    d. Dty o t o t ommty

    dd d to o d t mtd

    d to otd d omto.

    T mt o d o t ommty

    d t o d d ot m

    oto. itt, t, m,d, m d mmm y o d t

    ommt o ood d o, y wt

    to zo y d y o d. roy

    o tt td y d mtd ot jt y

    ot-tm d m, t o y t toy d

    ty o o-ow, o odto, d mt.

    som td dt tt dt dto d

    m tt t o t dty

    o t ot-tm d tto oy my oy

    o to xtdd od o ow d dt.

    Laws and Regulations Concerning

    Urban Deer

    Whos In Charge of Managing Urban Deer?

    rdt o ommt wt d om

    ot k Wo d wt m

    wt-td d? T d tw to

    d mmt om mott t

    do. rto t o o do

    w tt o t w- o m .

    Mmt t mto o tt d

    oto to t t wt

    oytm. roty o mmt

    dt o d oto. T o

    oty o mmt o ot

    t dow w t oty o

    mmt tyy d

    dt, ty of, d tz ozto oty ow oto.

    Overabundant deer populations

    can consume large quantities of

    vegetation; eventually creating a

    void of both preferred and less

    preferred vegetation.

    The negative impact of deer can be seen by browse lines and

    by the presence of plants that show hedging.

    Whos In Charge of Regulating Urban Deer?Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TpWD)

    mdtd y w to ott t tt t o.

    Ty do o y t w d to,

    d y od mt d dto mt

    to t . T t too d

    ommdto t do-mk o.

    it t oty o ommt to tk to

    o mmt do, d y tm ot. T

    t m tty d o d. Tx pk d

    Wd Dtmt ot o o mk

    mmt do o mmt mmttt o wt-td d o t oty.

    Is Fertility Control a Management Option?

    cty, tty oto ot mmt

    oto Tx. Ftty oto ot o

    qt om dt w to m

    odt d d. Ftty oto do

    ot d t m o d oto, d

    t w ot tto w d dy

    ootd. Ftty oto oy d to

    d oto owt t, d tooy ot to mt d oto t

    t t . Ftty oto oto

    d t odto oy; o xm,

    oy od oto wt m m

    o d. aot mtto o tty oto ot

    ( tw $350 d $1,100 ttd m).

    i mot , d mt td to dmt

    t d ty dmty t ot.

    ct t o t m w o oo

    my t dt. som tty oto t

    http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/
  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    10/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    do d tt t y w ot

    q oot ot to m t d

    t q t o dd y.

    T oy o Environmental Protection

    Agency (epa) od mmoott

    (gocoTM

    ) w oy to d dtt wd . it ot od o

    Tx d ot xtd to t o

    mot ommt. Tm, o, d qmt

    otd wt d t mo oty t t

    d ( $1 do). std dt tt to

    mt oto t dd , t t 50% o

    t m mt otd. hd-o dy o

    t d too ot ot. coqty

    dy ytm to mt d mt

    dod, to ty, o oto xt.

    Management Options in Texas

    T ot ot d t oto o

    m d d (T

    1). Nonlethal methods do ot d t d

    oto. Ty mody t o o

    d, tt t momt d to t

    (.., t, k, . od, d), o

    o d to t mmdt . som o

    t ot mtod od oy ot-tm fx

    (t d qky) w ot o-

    tm oto ( t my y) to

    m-d ot. rd, ot mtod

    t tzd ojto wt om

    d mmt om.

    Trap, Transport, and Transplant(TTT)

    odd ot mtod, ow, ow tt om d d om t t. it od

    o otd tt Tx, t tt t

    d o w om td oto.

    Lethal methods dty o dty d t

    d oto o o two wy: (1) t

    d o d, o (2) t o d to

    td t. e mtod dt

    d ddt, t t mott to mm

    tt dto mtod ot q initial

    treatment phase (.., t ooto o d

    mod) oowd yannual maintenance phases(.., ddto d mod). it tyy

    ft to mmt o-tm mmt

    om o wt-td d. Mt

    y q o-tm ot to d

    mt wd mmt o.

    Hunting t mtod o oto

    odt d d odtd

    y t ( o od d, tt d

    t ) o oo oot

    (td mkm). it t tt d t

    Technique Description

    Fencing

    High Fence (8 ft tall)A high fence is an effective method for keeping deer out of protected areas Although

    expensive, high fences can be a long-term solution

    Electric FenceElectric fencing is useful at keeping deer out of protected areas It is less expensive thanother fencing options however; some communities may have ordinances prohibiting

    electrical fencing Effectiveness is dependent upon the size of the area and design of fence

    Habitat Modifcation

    Unpalatable Landscape

    Plants

    Planting undesirable plant species or fake plants will cause deer to seek food elsewhere

    This is an effective method although costs depend on the size of project

    Deterrent Techniques

    Visual

    Scarecrows, shiny pans and other visual devices can be used to provoke caution in deer

    Although inexpensive, overabundant deer quickly habituate to visual deterrent techniques

    and become less scared of them

    AuditoryNoise making devices can also stimulate caution in deer but again deer habituate quickly to

    noises Auditory devices can be a nuisance to neighbors

    Olfactory

    Odors can be used to repel deer Several commercial repellants are available, but their

    efcacy is questionable. Their life span is short, lasting between a few days to 3-4 months

    in dry conditions

    Dogs Dogs are effective, long-term stimuli to keep deer away

    Table 1. Nonlethal techniques used to minimize human-deer conicts.

    http://www.epa.gov/http://www.epa.gov/http://documents/TTT_TTP_Proclamation.pdfhttp://documents/TTT_TTP_Proclamation.pdfhttp://documents/TTT_TTP_Proclamation.pdfhttp://www.epa.gov/http://www.epa.gov/
  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    11/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    to t ommt odtd

    to mxmz m ty, m, dto,

    d fy. ext ty od my ot

    t o fm t y qmt ot

    tt. i otto wt TpWD d

    ot wd oo, ty of t t

    oto d z o ommo , t d

    dod d od t ommty to

    dtm ty y td.

    i ommt w t , t

    od mt ofy tdd td y

    t ommty od to tt. ht

    od o td to dtm tt ty

    o d t. i Tx, t tdd

    Nonlethal methods Pros Cons Cost

    High fence (8 Ft tall) Effective barrier, long-term Relatively expensive Varies by project

    Electric fence Effective barrier, long-term Prohibited in certain areas Varies by project

    Unpalatable landscape

    plants

    Somewhat effective, long-term Large plantings become expensive Varies by project

    Visual deterrents Inexpensive Deer habituate quickly Varies by project

    Auditory deterrents InexpensiveNuisance to humans, deer habituate

    quicklyVaries by project

    Olfactory deterrentsSomewhat effective,

    relatively inexpensiveRelatively short-term Varies by project

    Dogs Effective, long-term Medical and food expense Varies by project

    Trap, Transport, and

    Translocation (capture

    and release)

    More accepted by public

    Can be used in areas where

    rearms are restricted.

    Receiving landowner may be

    willing to pay costs associated withrelocation

    Must nd suitable, approved deer

    habitat Permit required

    Limited number of release sites

    Some mortality due to trapping stress

    Time and labor intensive

    Requires expensive equipmentDisease testing is required

    $150 to 750/deer

    Fertility control Socially attractiveProhibitively expensive, ineffective for

    deterring or reducing deer populations

    $350 to $1100 per

    treated female

    Lethal methods Pros Cons Cost

    Trap, Transport,and

    Process

    Suitable release sites not

    necessary

    Disease testing is not required

    Can be used in areas where

    rearms are restricted.

    Meat is donated to charitable

    organizations to feed the needy

    Lethal means opposed by some

    Time and labor intensive

    Requires expensive equipment

    Permit required

    $175 to $300/deer

    Individual hunting

    Local residents solving local

    problem

    Expensive transporting equipment

    not required

    Disease testing is not required

    Increases outdoor recreation

    Lethal means opposed by someRequires greater coordination among

    community and hunters

    Additional security costs for law

    enforcement personnel

    Requires large number of willing and

    procient hunters.

    No sound suppression on rearms.

    Permit required

    Limited in application

    $85 to $300/deer

    Sharpshooters

    Requires only a few individuals

    Can be done discretelySound suppression on rearms.

    Lethal means opposed by some

    Must hire for this service

    Additional security costs for lawenforcement personnel

    Permit required

    $250+/deer

    Table 2. Comparison of methods to reduce urban white-tailed deer densities.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    12/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    odtd t t ommty . ht zo

    wt t ommty dtfd to mxmz

    m ty d omot t, m, d

    ft d t. D ot td to t

    o od o tm d t t d

    t to oto. Mt om mt dy t t o dotd to dtd t

    ozto. bot t d o-t

    dt mt oz tt d t

    mmt too dd to d t m

    o d, wt od m o mo

    m. T ot toy k t. ht

    Tx do tdto t

    t o to t mt om od y

    TpWD tt ow dd to t mo t

    mt (Managed Lands Deer Permitso

    Landowner Assisted Management Permitting System).

    Laws Governing Trap, Transport, and

    Translocation (TTT) and/or Process (TTP)

    Tx pk d Wd Dtmt td

    o two mmt oto kow

    Trap, Transport, and Transplant(TTT) d Trap,

    Transport, and Process(TTp; Table 2). sf

    o mtod od t Tx

    admtt cod, mo fySection 65.101

    65.119 and TPWD Code Title 5, Subtitle A, Chapter

    43, Subchapter E, Sections 43.061-43.062.

    High fencing can be a long-term solution to human-deer

    conicts

    aot ty o t do y d

    sharpshooters. soot td

    oo to t d. soot td t to ttt d d tk ty ot

    ot (

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    13/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    ommty o-otd wt d. T

    ot ow t t, d o ,

    d o o dtoy t. soooy, d

    o m-d ot wt td o o

    d t d d t, d d

    m/d ot. Domt o

    d mmt o o oto, t

    ot ty.

    Managed booy, d m mo

    d wt tt. soooy,m-d ot dd. T

    ommt tt ttd d

    mmt om y omt t t o

    t dd ow. u d mmt

    oo o w -dtmd m

    o d mod om t ommty o

    .

    T qt t tt d to

    tk to do t d om.

    Timeline M d o d

    tt t o mott. ext t t o to tk o t ty ttd.

    e ommty dt d t o my tk

    mot o y o y to tk. cot

    w to tk wtot t dt

    kowd o t, to t o o

    to oow t dd ow. W ot

    t t mot o ommto o, d

    t k o ommto o odto o

    t ot t t dow o mot d

    ot.

    Step 1: Form a Deer Management Action Committee

    u d mmt omto o m

    ot o d d. T ft om o to od

    t tmt o D Mmt ato

    commtt (DMac). som ommty tty, y

    t ty o, myo of, o oty ow

    oto od o t omto o t

    ommtt, t dt to om mm, d

    ttd ozto mt. T DMac od

    ot o t to dt o t ommtyd t o to xm t t d xtt

    o t d om d ommd oto.

    T ft od o to dtm t o o

    t om.

    Step 2: Determine the scope of the problem

    T ft t dtm t o o t om

    to t tz kowd d oo o wt-

    td d ooy d mmt. it t to

    t t oo t o TpWD wd

    oot, t to oot, d xtowd t. T citizen surveydtm

    ommty dt oo o d m,

    d to mmt mmt oto, d

    t mmt oto, d wo

    o do d mmt d mmt

    . T tz y o dtm t

    o kowd tt dt ot d

    ooy d mmt oto w od

    d t domt o t dto

    mt. it toy td tt ommt

    http://documents/Citizen_Survey.docxhttp://documents/Citizen_Survey.docx
  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    14/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    k ot y oo to d,

    dmt, yz, d ot t t o tz

    y. O t tz y omtd,

    t ommty mo to t td t jtfd.

    Step 3: Hold a Town Hall MeetingT ft odto st 3 to dty t

    t tkod tt mt tt. som

    xm ommty dt, ty d tt

    omt of, oty ow oto,

    w omt, d ot tt mt dtfd

    om t t o t tz y. T od

    odto wo w t mt to od.

    som ommt o t oty

    ow oto, w ot tzd t

    tt o t ty o. Tx pk d

    Wd Dtmt t ow q o d mmt dd o d ty

    od ot t mt. it d t tow

    mt tt t t o t tz y

    w td. addto omto my

    odd y wd oo. ext t ft

    mt to t d otto o

    t ttd o dt wo ky to

    t oot d moto oo o

    d mmt. sqt mt td to

    otto. T wo o o t tow

    mt() to od m t omto o o t tz tt t

    domt o d mmt tt

    t d, mo motty, t.

    Step 4: Develop an Urban Deer Management Plan

    po to do urban deer management plan,

    t tt to dtd to to tt

    ott to d d not am.

    D y dtd to xot t o

    , d y do xot

    owt tt (F 2) o t oowodto:

    1. lk o t , d toy

    otto t t ty omt .

    2. adt tt ood o t om

    o omt , d t, t

    , m t, d mt d.

    3. low d o t dto. l

    dto t ft mtd d

    w.

    4. To o dt d m

    d t tt.

    5. h odto d t o o.

    6. lo t ty w omd to t

    oty.

    i , mmt od od o

    dto d oto o d oto d to

    d td dm. Dt ommt w

    d dt tt t ft xt odto.

    T t d mmt o.

    Management plans

    should be focused on reduction

    and control of deer populations and

    to reduce related damage.

    Approach 1 Planning for Wildlife: T

    ot mmt tty tt o

    domt tt tt t t xd

    t. it o ommty d tt o

    t t tt, t t o

    t o, d ot m oty wt

    t t wod w ty . smt gowt,

    D wt nt, d coto D

    t xm o xt domt

    tt tt od t om o d (wd)od ommt.

    Approach 2 - Getting at the Root Cause: gtt t

    t oot o d od

    q y o to ( t o t o

    6 to) tt omot d ty

    ommty. T mot ommo mmt

    to qd to t t t oot to

    ot omt tt do ot o t

    od o d. T oto o d

    d t to o od. somommt td d o my

    wd oto (to d oo, oyot,

    ox, t), d om jt o wt-td d.

    eomt o t d jt t.

    addtoy, o dt to d

    wt t, d-tt t to t

    dt omt, ow f o t

    om dm, d to t t dty.

    rtodto o dto ot

    , t ty o dto,

    http://documents/Urban_Deer_Management_Plan.docxhttp://documents/Urban_Deer_Management_Plan.docx
  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    15/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    Statements Answer % Correct

    1 The size of urban habitats prevents deer herds from growing too large False 60

    2 Urban deer can carry diseases that affect humans True 59

    3 Urban deer can destroy habitat used by other animals True 52

    4 In order to survive, urban deer rely heavily on supplemental food sources True 36

    5 Urban deer can begin to produce fawns when they are six months old True 17

    6 Twins are a common result from urban deer reproduction True 52

    7 More deer per acre means the deer will be physically larger in size False 86

    8 The most common cause of death in urban deer herds is predators False 75

    9 The least common cause of death in urban deer herds is disease and starvation False 49

    10 Deer are an endangered species in Texas False 91

    11 Deer live in urban areas because they have adapted to living near people True 55

    12 People can help urban deer the most by letting nature take its course False 41

    13 Deer live in urban areas because human development has pushed them out of their natural habitat True 8114 People have done more harm than good for urban deer True 60

    15 People can help urban deer the most by managing them True 69

    16 Fertility control techniques for managing urban deer are cost effective and easy to implement False 10

    Table 3. Survey response by 256 residents of Hollywood Park and Lakeway, TX, concerning urban deer ecology and

    management (2008).

    oyot d ot, xot

    oto owt, o m tto y

    dto ot mttd.

    Approach 3 - Do Nothing: T o o

    tkod tt dot d t (od) o t t tk t o oo o

    mmt d o oto z. adot

    o t d mmt oto w d to

    tm d ot ommty dt

    o d o o tto, d d-

    dt, ott d tto, d qt

    xo o my od, t, m,

    d ot mmm. a do ot o to

    wt-td d mmt ky to o

    om d w ky d to moto d ot

    to o xt om.

    Step 5: Implement the Plan and Monitor Results

    som ommt dotd d

    mmt tt omto o

    dd mmdt om d o

    o-tm mmtto d moto. Ft, t

    DMac od o t omto om tow

    mt d wd oo. T DMac

    mt t om to oto o t ommty.

    T od o o tt ow dt to

    o o/ot, t t d t t DMac

    tt mk t f mmt do d

    oy t oy to t ommty.

    O t mmtd t

    mott to moto t t. T t

    o t mmt my motod tmo dd t dm, d- oo, d

    m-d ot. it my o motod

    t m o d t t ommty. T

    motod wt oto y

    odtd y TpWD o ot wd oo.

    ext ddto to t d d om

    of odto d o mmto.

    T ottom o ommt to t t

    t tt t d mmt w

    oo oto o t d t

    oood. T td tt oow odd o t mmt oto.

    Case Studies

    Two Tx ommt w o to dtm

    wt dt kw ot t ooy d

    mmt o wt-td d. lkwy,

    Tx otd otwt o at, d hoywood

    pk, Tx otd t ot t o

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    16/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    San atoo. bd o t utd stt c b

    2006 tmt, s atoo t 2d t ty

    d at t 4t t ty Tx. bot

    ommt m o, oo, d

    oooom tt, w d:

    1. h dty o wt-td d

    oto.

    2. rty dt d ot z.

    3. pott o wt-td d oto owt.

    s t 1990, d d mtd

    lkwy d hoywood pk to d

    d- oo, dfd ow

    toot t ommty, d t m-d

    ot. Fo xm, t ommt

    D coto commtt tt dd, wt t

    om TpWD, tt o m d

    d. T m o t ommt

    dtmd ot y d ot, t y

    t m o d- oo,

    m-d ot, d od jd o

    dd, d -td dt. ey o, to

    d o oo tw tkod o

    hoywood pk d to mo otto d

    mmt omt t t lkwy.

    bot ommt mmtd om to

    dt o d oto d m.cty od w ot t d o d,

    tt to d oto d

    oto tt, d t o dm o

    dtto o d oto qmt. voto

    d wt c c mdmo

    y f o ot to xd $500, w od y t

    o o dtmt.

    Need For Educational Program Development

    a t ojt d o 16 kowd

    d qto to dtm wt hoywoodpk d lkwy dt kw ot d

    ooy d mmt (Table 3). so d

    om f to t o o 16. T o

    o dt o ot ommt w t ot

    w. T mjoty w w ow

    d d, d, d d, d t oq d

    t o mmt oto. a xt-ot

    xmto do ot od o t omto

    qd o do om dto

    om o d ooy d mmt,

    t t dd d dty domt d o

    dto om o:

    (1) d oto oto mtod,

    (2) d ooy d ooy,

    (3) mmt tt, d

    (4) o-tm tt to o m-d ot.

    Tody, lkwy d wt otoy om t

    dt d d mmt t

    t t 1990 w d mmt ft .

    ato ot t, hoywood pk ot

    to d wt ott dt wo oo d

    mmt. p dto toot t

    ommt oo o. a dt

    mo to ommt wt d mmt

    , ty too w d to dtd ot

    d ooy d mmt t ommty.

    T t d mmt om lkwy

    d hoywood pk m to ty m

    t d oto. lkwy ty t

    TTp mtod d hoywood pk t

    omto o TTT d TTp mtod to m

    d t ommt. i t t, lkwy

    d hoywood pk mod x o

    250 d y od to t ty d

    oto d oytm wt t t.

    Final Thoughts

    Ot, dt do ot oz tt d

    mmt tod, oto wod oo xd

    t oo y ty . rdt wod

    t x mo oom o d d

    d-m ot. it mott o m

    to dtd tt w d wt t ,

    ty o w om dt tkod

    o. it t to dd o mmt

    om mmtd od to d t

    ott ot tw m d dt.

    The current deer management

    programs in Lakeway and

    Hollywood Park seem to beeffectively managing the

    deer population.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    17/18

    MANAGING OVERABUNDANT WHITE-TAILED DEER

    Appendices

    White-Tailed Deer Biology

    g Dto

    Adultcoatcolor:brown(wintercoat),reddish

    (mm ot) Fawncoatcolor:brownwithwhitespots

    Pelage color serves to break-up the bodys outline

    and blend with habitat.

    Bright white hairs under the tail serve as a visual

    alarm to others.

    Size

    Male ~ 150 lbs.

    Female ~100 lbs.

    Fawn 4-8 lbs. at birth

    Distribution

    Found throughout Texas. ScentMarking

    Used or communication.

    Scrapes - shallow depressions dug by the hooves.

    Rubs - shrubs and trees are sometimes damaged

    when removing velvet rom antlers.

    Antlers

    One o the astest growing tissues.

    Only ound in deer amily.

    Found only on males or white-tailed deer.

    Produced and shed annually.

    Growth begins in mid-March. Hardened, polished antlers by September.

    Antlers are weapons used both or oense and

    deense.

    Habitat

    Food

    Require4-6lbsoffoodperday;thatis2,000lbs

    y.

    Ruminants(4-chamberedstomach)requirea

    y tto dt.

    Forbs(weeds),browse(leavesandwoodystems),

    d oy ~10% . Water

    -1.5quartsperday.

    Cover

    Needvegetationofdiverseheights,thickness,

    d to dto, d w, d

    mt ody tmt.

    Space

    Variesdependingonhabitatquality.

    BreedingSeason

    Known as the rut.

    Generally occurs between October and December.

    Males are oten more aggressive. Males movements encompass a larger area.

    Reproduction

    White-tailed deer are highly reproductive.

    Females are reproductively capable at 6-8 months

    old.

    Males are reproductively capable typically at 1.5

    years old.

    Pregnancy lasts 187-222 days.

    Fawning

    Firstattempttypicallyproduces1fawn.

    Thereafter,femalesannuallyproducetwins(tt ).

    Longevity

    10-13 years.

    Mortality

    actors

    Predators(coyotes,bobcats,mountainlions,and

    m)

    Diseasesandparasites

    Automobilecollisions

    Starvation

    Inclementweather Trauma(combat,injuries,infectedwounds)

    Changinglanduses(populationlevel)

    Mortality is highest among awns and it aects age

    classes at dierent rates.

  • 8/3/2019 Managing Overabundant White-Tailed Deer

    18/18

    Authors Contact Information:

    James C. Cathey

    Texas AgriLife Extension Service, Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

    Texas A&M University

    College Station, TX 77843-2258 USA

    Shawn L. Locke

    Texas AgriLife Extension Service, Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

    Texas A&M University

    College Station, TX 77843-2258 USA

    Clark E. Adams

    Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

    Texas A&M University

    College Station, TX 77843-2258 USA

    Sara Ramirez

    Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

    Texas A&M University

    College Station, TX 77843-2258 USA

    Jessica Alderson

    Texas Parks and Wildlife Department

    Austin, TX 78744 USA

    Kevin Schwausch

    Texas Parks and Wildlife DepartmentAustin, TX 78744 USA

    Acknowledgements

    This document represents a partnership between Texas A&M University, Texas AgriLife Extension Service, Texas AgriLife Research

    and Texas Parks and Wildlife Department We thank Texas Parks and Wildlife Department for funding this work We appreciate the

    efforts of Warren Bluntzer (Wildlife Biologist/Consultant) and Richard Heilbrun (Urban Wildlife Biologist) in providing editorial review of

    by: Matt Cook Photo by: Matt Cook Photo by: Matt Cook