july 13, 2009 quarterly research conference call
TRANSCRIPT
July 13, 2009
Quarterly Research Conference Call
Jeff MacLeanChief Executive Officer
Eric J Petroff CFA
LOS ANGELES
WURTS & ASSOCIATES
SEATTLE
Eric J. Petroff, CFADirector of Research
LOS ANGELES2321 Rosecrans AvenueSuite 2250El Segundo, California 90245310.297.1777 telephone310.297.0878 facsimile
SEATTLE999 Third AvenueSuite 4200Seattle, Washington 98104206.622.3700 telephone206.622.0548 facsimile
Dialing & Playback Instructions
July 13, 2009 Quarterly Research Conference Call – 10:00 am (Pacific)
Dial In
1 877 641 00931-877-641-0093(please dial in 5-10 minutes early)
Playback888-284-7564R f # 137062Reference #: 137062Available for 90 days
1
Our Goal – Top Down & Holistic Portfolio DesignMosaic and Exhaustive Market Analysis
• Key macroeconomic factors
• Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Treasury Department
• Fiscal & Monetary Policy
• Federal Reserve, Office of Management & Budget, Congressional Budget Office
• Major Asset Class Valuations
• S&P, Shiller, Russell, Barclays, MSCI, , , y ,
• We develop our own informed opinion…We look to capital markets for guidance, not the herd
Strategic Thinking vs. Benchmark Fixation
• Thought process and outlook aligned with goals and needs of our clientele
• Strategically oriented 10 year outlook on capital markets and economic environment
Simplicity & Clarity of Thought
• There is no correlation between investment complexity and investment return
Si l i b tt d th t’ th t!• Simpler is better…and that’s that!
Holistic Portfolio Design
• Assets deployed based on current market conditions, not past returns
• Diversification based on easily understood key risk factors…no reliance on statistical models
2
y y
• Dynamic and responsive to evolving conditions…when markets change, so should your advice!
3
A Reminder…We Look at 10 Year Periods for a Reason
144
180The Basic Relationship Between Time and Forecasting Accuracy
72
108
Fore
cast
ing
Err
or
0
36
0 20 40 60 80 100 120Time
0.74
0.840.91
0.8
1.0
Correlation Between the Barclay's Credit Index Starting Yield and Subsequent Returns (since 1973)
0 56
0.760.75
1.00
Correlation Between Shiller's Earnings & Dividend Yield and Subsequent Returns (since 1948)
0.50
0.3
0.5
0.22
0.37
0.56
0.25
0.50
1
0.0
1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year
Source: Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
0.00
1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year
Source: Ibbotson, Yale/Shiller, Wurts & Associates
4
Can We Be Numerically Correct, No – Directionally Correct, Yes
15%
25%
35%Rolling 3 Year Market Efficiency - Implied vs. Actual Returns
-25%
-15%
-5%
5%
Source: Yale/Schiller, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
25%Rolling 10 Year Market Efficiency - Implied vs. Actual Returns
35%Rolling 5 Year Market Efficiency - Implied vs. Actual Returns
-35%
Implied Difference in Expected Equity & Treasury ReturnsActual Difference in Equity & Treasury Returns Over Rolling 10 Years
15%
25%
15%
25%
35%
-5%
5%
Implied Difference in Expected Equity & Treasury Returns
-15%
-5%
5%
Implied Difference in Expected Equity & Treasury Returns
2
Source: Yale/Shiller, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates Source: Yale/Shiller, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
-15%
p p q y yActual Difference in Equity & Treasury Returns Over Rolling 10 Years-25%
Reaching the Lower Bounds of Economic Activity
2.8 2.5 2.6
6
12 Growth Rates of Key Macroeconomic Factors (Mar. '09)
-0.4
-3.2 -3.4
1.5
-6
0
Last 1 Year
Source: Federal Reserve, BLS, BEA, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
-8.9-12
CPI GDP Aggregate Demand Aggregate Supply
Last 1 Year
Last 20 Years
10Rolling 1 Year GDP Growth (Mar. ‘09)
12Seasonally Adjusted Unemployment Rate (June '09)
5
6
8
10
0
Rolling 1 Year Average GDP Growth Rate Average
2
4
6
Unemployment Rate Average
3
Source: BLS, Wurts & Associates
-50Unemployment Rate Average
Source: BLS, Wurts & Associates
6
Setting the Stage for a Rebound in Household Net Worth
25%27% 27%
40%Major Components of Household Assets/Net Worth (Mar. '09)
13%
6%
15%
11%
6%
15%
9%
5%
18%20%
Last 50 Years
Last 25 Years
Source: Federal Reserve, Wurts & Associates
0%
Real Estate Deposits Fixed Income Equities & Mutual Funds
Last 25 Years
Last 10 Years
5545Returns & Valuations for the S&P 500 Over Time (June '09)
15Rolling 10 Year Change in Household Real Estate Equity (Mar. '09)
3525 10
15
155
Rolling 10 Year Return for S&P 500 Schiller PE Ratio
5
4
Source: Ibbotson, Yale/Schiller Source: Federal Reserve, Wurts & Associates
-5-15oll g 0 ea etu o S& 500 Sc lle at o
0
7
Don’t Misinterpret an Increase in the Savings Rate
8
10
12Household Savings Rate vs. Household Net Worth (Mar. '09)
2
4
6
Rolling 10 Year Average Savings Rate
Source: Federal Reserve, BEA, Wurts & Associates
0
g g g
Rolling 10 Year Change in Household Net Worth
1212Growth in Household Net Worth vs. Personal Consumption (Mar. '09)
12Growth in Consumer Spending vs. Growth in GDP (Mar. '09)
8
10
12
8
10
12
8
10
12
2
4
6
2
4
6
Rolling 10 Year Change in Household Net Worth
4
6
Rolling 10 Year Growth in Personal ConsumptionR lli 10 Y G th i GDP
1
Source: Federal Reserve, BEA, Wurts & Associates Source: Federal Reserve, BEA, Wurts & Associates
00Rolling 10 Year Growth in Personal Consumption
2Rolling 10 Year Growth in GDP
8
Gov’t Spending Should Overcome an Increase in Savings Rate
4.85.1
5.0
6.0CBO's Estimate of Federal Spending ($'s, Trillions)
3.73.6 3.6
3.84.0
4.24.4
4.6
4.0
$2.0
Growth in Savings vs. Gov't Spending Per Capita in Thousands (Assumes 5% Growth in Disp. Income and 7% Savings Rate by 2019)
3.0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
$20
CBO Estimated Federal Spending Per Capita in Thousands (300 million pop. assumed)
Source: CBO, BEA, Wurts & Associates
$0.6$0.7 $0.6
$0.8 $0.7 $0.7
$1.0$1.0
$2.0
$$15.4
$16.1
$17.1 $18
$20
$0.2 $0.2 $0.2 $0.2 $0.2 $0.3 $0.3 $0.3 $0.3 $0.3
-$0.5-$0.4
$0.0$0.0
Estimated Additional Dollars Saved Per CapitaE ti t d Additi l G t S di P C it
$12.3 $11.9 $11.9 $12.5
$13.2 $13.9
$14.7
$13
$15
2
Source: CBO, BEA, Wurts & Associates
$0.5
-$1.0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Estimated Additional Government Spending Per Capita
$10
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Source: CBO, BEA, Wurts & Associates
9
Monetary Policy is Inflationary & Our Creditors are Figuring it Out
90%
95%
100%
15
20
25Market Timing of Foreign Official Holders of US Treasury Debt (Mar. '09)
75%
80%
85%
5
0
5
10
2,500,000 Composition of Federal Reserve Balance Sheet1 500 000
Federal Reserve Asset Purchases: Actual vs. Approved
70%-10
-5
Subsequent 1 Year Return of Barclays US Treasury 7-10 Yr. Index% of Foreign Holdings in T Notes
Source: US Treasury, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
1,500,000
2,000,000
Other Federal Reserve AssetsMaiden Lane LLC I, II, III (Bear Stearns and AIG)Commercial Paper Money Market Funding FacilityOther loansRepos and Term auction credit
1,250,000
800,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
500,000
1,000,000
s
Repos and Term auction creditSecurities held outright (Gov't Securities, Agency Debt, and MBS)Gold stock, treasury currency, and special drawing right acct
158,441 87,824
455,337
25 000
300,000200,000
500,000
llion
sActual Total Purchases as of June '09
Total Approved Purchases
3
Source: Federal Reserve
-
$ M
illio
ns
,25,000
-
US Treasury Securities
Federal Agency Debt Securities
MBS TALF
$ M
il
Source: Federal Reserve
10
Are We Really De-Levering at the Societal Level?
15
20
25
15
25 Growth in Federal Debt vs. Volatility in Treasuries (Mar. '09)
5
10
15
5
Mar. '08 - Mar. '09 Change in Annual Rates ($'s, Trillions) $20Year Over Year Debt Outstanding by Sector ($'s, Trillions)
0-5Rolling 10 Year Nominal Growth in Federal DebtRolling 10 Year Annualized Std Dev IA SBBI US IT Govt
Source: Federal Reserve, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
1.0
0.0
2.0g ($ , )
10.6 10.8
16.4
10.511.2
17.0
$15
$20g y ( )
-0.6
-2.7
-0.8
-2.0
2.6
5.2
2.6
6.7
$5
$10
Mar. '08
Mar. '09
1
-4.0
Total Household Borrowing
Total Domestic Financial Borrowing
Total Business Borrowing (non-
financial)
Total Federal Borrowing
$0
Household Mortgage Household Consumer Credit
Total Business Debt Total Federal Debt Domestic Financial Sector Debt
Source: Federal ReserveSource: Federal Reserve
11
Inflationary Expectations Higher, but Still Somewhat Low
12
16
8
10
12Growth in Monetary Base vs. Inflation (June ‘09)
4
8
2
4
6
R lli 10 Y I fl ti R lli 10 Y G th i M t B
Source: Federal Reserve, BEA, Wurts & Associates
00 Rolling 10 Year Inflation Rolling 10 Year Growth in Monetary Base
2.5Inflation Expectations (Nominal less Real Treasury Yields)
126Societal Arbitrage-Cost of Borrowing vs. Growth in GDP & Household Net Worth
1.31.3
1.7
1.58
10
-2
2
0.7
0.30.5
5 Year Implied Inflation
4
6
-6
-2
10 Year Nominal GDP less 10 Year Nominal Treasury YTM
2
Source: Federal Reserve, Wurts & Associates Source: Federal Reserve; Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
-0.2-0.5
Dec-08 Mar-09 Jun-09
5 Year Implied Inflation
10 Year Implied Inflation 2-10 10 Year Nominal Growth in Household Net Worth
12
How Does Inflation Affect Key Portfolio Risk Factors?
10
12
14
16
lati
on
The Relationship Between Inflation & Shiller PE Ratio (Since 1960)
0
2
4
6
8
Rolli
ng 1
Yea
r In
fl
Source: Yale/Shiller, Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
-4
-2
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Shiller PE Ratio
16The Relationship Between Inflation & Risk Free Interest Rates (Since 1960)
16The Relationship Between Inflation & Credit Spreads (Since 1973)
8
10
12
14
ar In
flat
ion
8
10
12
14
16
r In
flat
ion
2
0
2
4
6
Rolli
ng 1
Yea
2
0
2
4
6
Rolli
ng 1
Yea
r
3
Source: Ibbotson, Wurts & AssociatesSource: Ibbotson, Wurts & Associates
-4
-2
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Ibbotson US LT Yield
-4
-2
-1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7Barclays Credit - Treasury Yield
13
Macroeconomic Factors Provide the Bulk of Diversification
170%
100%
150%
200%One Year Change in Major Risk Factors - Dec. '08
-41% -50% -40%-50%
0%
50%
50Major Risk Factors During a Flight to Safety - 2008
40Major Risk Factors During a Flight to Risk - Recent Returns (2nd QTR ‘09)
Source: Yale, Dept. of Energy, Barclays, Federal Reserve
-100%
Shiller PE Ratio Price of Oil ($'s/barrell)
Credit Spread (OAS) Corp. Credit
10 Year Treasury Rate
-3
34
8
0
25
16
21
12
19
129
20
Equity RiskCommodity Risk
Equity RiskCommodity Risk
Interest Rate/Credit Risk
Interest Rate/Riskless
-37 -40 -36
-46
-10-3
-50
-25
9
-9
10
Interest Rate/Credit Risk
Interest Rate/Riskless
1
-75
S&P 500 MSCI World DJ UBS S&P GSCI Barclays Global Credit
Barclays US Credit
Barclays US Treasury 20+
Barclays US MBS
-20
S&P 500 MSCI World DJ UBS S&P GSCI Barclays Global Credit
Barclays US Credit
Barclays US Treasury 20+
Barclays US MBS
Source: Ibbotson Source: Ibbotson
14
Risk in US Large Caps is Far More Balanced Than a Year Ago
15
20
25
30
40
50History of Normalized PE Ratio & Returns (June '09)
5
0
5
10
15
10
20
30
Effects of Changes in Shiller PE Ratio on S&P 500 Returns (Assumes 5% Growth in Earnings & 3% Dividend) (June '08)
Effects of Changes in Shiller PE Ratio on S&P 500 Returns (Assumes 5% Growth in Earnings & 3% Dividend) (June '09)
-10
-5
010 Yr. Real PE RatioSubsequent Rolling 10 Year Return (S&P 500)
Source: Ibbotson, Yale/Shiller
-3-5-2
47
2 3 6 7
5
30 (Assumes 5% Growth in Earnings & 3% Dividend) (June 08)
12
34
210
14
3 5 9 11
0
30
60(Assumes 5% Growth in Earnings & 3% Dividend) (June 09)
-46
-19
-45
-20
-47
-25
-2
-60
-30
0
1 Year Sensitivity 5 Year Sensitivity 10 Year Sensitivity
2
-61-70
Early '80's: PE =8 3rd Quartile Since 1926: PE =11.5
Average Since 1926: PE=17.5
30 Year Average: PE =21
1 Year Sensitivity 5 Year Sensitivity 10 Year Sensitivity
Source: Yale/Shiller; Wurts & AssociatesSource: Yale/Shiller; Wurts & Associates
-60
Early '80's: PE =8 3rd Quartile Since 1926: PE =11.5
Average Since 1926: PE=17.5
30 Year Average: PE =21
y y y
15
A Practical Examination of Downside Risk (Fixed Income)
19.418.1
15
20
25Nominal Fixed Income Rates (YTM)
1.6
3.6 4.0
6.9
1.8
3.7 4.1
7.1
2.44.3 4.1
5.6
12.8
5
10
15
Dec-08Mar-09Jun-09
25
One Year Sensitivity of Barclays Credit Index to Changes in Interest Rates (Assumes 1% default, 5% coupon, and duration of 5)
One Year Sensitivity of Barclays High Yield to Changes in Interest Rates (Assumes 15% default, 8% coupon, and duration of 5)
0
Barclays Treasury Index
Barclays Agency MBS Index
Barclays Aggregate Index
Barclays Credit Index
Barclays High Yield Index
Source: Barclays
20.9
10.9
5.3
0.7
13.7
3.8
25( )
47.036.5
25.517.123.0
12.51.5
25
75
-12.4
-1.9
-6.5
0
As of March '09
-25.4
-6.9
-49.4
-25
As of March '09
3
Source: Ibbotson, Barclays, Wurts & Associates Source: Ibbotson, Barclays, Wurts & Associates
-19.6-25
20 Year Low = 3.9 20 Year 3rd Quartile = 5.8
20 Year Average = 7.0
20 Year 1st Quartile = 7.9
20 Year High = 10.0
As of June '09-75
20 Year Low = 6.8 20 Year 3rd Quartile = 8.9
20 Year Average = 11.2
20 Year 1st Quartile = 13.0
20 Year High = 21.8
As of June '09
16
The Cycle of Capital Markets – Thinking Ahead
8
10The Potential Effects of Inflation on Allocation Decisions
Effects of High Inflationary Expectations• TIPS & commodities rise sharply
Base Assumptions
• Economy recovers in the face of significantmonetary and fiscal stimulus
Implied Shifts in Allocation• More TIPS & commodities
6
CPI
• PE ratios fall• Interest rates rise
• Inflation likely moves past historic averageas a result…a decision point is reached
• Will inflation remain controlled, buthigher than average temporarily, or will itget out of control (i.e., ’70’s)?
• Reduce equities• Sell long bonds/buy floating rates
2
4 Effects of Normal Inflationary Expectations• TIPS & commodities decline slightly• PE ratios are relatively unaffected• Interest rates decline/stabilize
Implied Shifts in Allocation• Scale back TIPS & commodities• Maintain equities• Maintain fixed income
Flight to SafetyStimulus Enacted
Investors Tip Toe Into
A Flight to Risk Ensues
R l i &
Overvaluations & Overconfidence
The Cycle of Capital Markets
0
Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Jan-15 Jan-16 Jan-17 Jan-18 Jan-19
Fiscal & Monetary Stimulus
Risk Free Asset Bubble
Investors Tip-Toe IntoRisky Assets
High Grade investments Recover First
Real Estate, Equity & Credit Markets Rise
Household Balance Sheets are Repaired
Liquidity Triumphs Over Reason
Downside Risks Abound and are Ignored
4th Qtr 2008 – 1st Qtr 2009 20xx?Beginning to Happen
4
Repeat
17
Concluding ThoughtsKey Top Down Considerations
• Clearly the US economy remains in the throes of a recession, but we are nearing the lower bounds of economic activity.
• Conditions won’t get worse forever.
• Yes, the savings rate is increasing. However, this is very good for the long term health of the US economy.
• We could very well be setting the stage for the next significant period of economic expansion.
Potential Risks & Opportunities
• We continue to be concerned about inflation over the next decade.
• We could be wrong about inflation, though we doubt it, but the risk to real portfolio value is undeniable.
• Credit remains an attractive opportunity, but not as attractive as just a few quarters ago.
• Equities appear fairly valued relative to long term valuation metrics.
Overall Strategic Portfolio Implications
• Don’t let short term pessimism drive long term allocation decisions. Now is the time to embrace risk, not run away from it.
• Markets tend to be short sighted in nature, which only works to the advantage of long term focused investors.
• Simple concepts such as discipline and patience are far more valuable in achieving portfolio goals than market timing acumen.
• And they are much, much easier!
1
Read our full Quarterly Research Report…We just can’t cover everything during this conference call.
18