john waihee hoaliku governor state of hawaii i'· state … · the windward o'ahu wells...

1608.77 11 10 o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR STATE OF HAWAII

I'·

HOALIKU L DRAKE CHAIRMAN

HAWAIIAN HOMES COMMISSION

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS

P. O. BOX 1879

HONOLULU, HAWAII 96805

October 14, 1993

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue Chairperson commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Ahue: withdrawal of Objections

1\.:

, ..

,I \.~". 'j:'"

(.,,:; c.. . .) c"" C) .. .. ~ -dJ

. . .. \ ~

. \ '\ 'r" c:ri --, ," '

The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands has been in a;position to raise objections to various applications for water~se permits, particularly in Windward O'ahu, on the basis that water reservations were yet required to meet statutory obligations to Hawaiian home lands.

Please be advised that as the proposed water reservations in O'ahu and Moloka'i water management areas are finalized, our objections for this reason are thereby withdrawn.

HLD:BH:ci/1608L.77

wfZ~t Il~~o~a~ H~ Drake, Hawaiian Homes Co sion

\ ,

r t '-}~ 1639.79 27 8 o 0 c c; {It r} ' ..... r·~1

JOHN WAIHEE GOVERNOR

STATE OF HAWAII

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS

p, O. BOX 1879


August 30, 1993

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Ahue: Water Use Permits

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to these applications for the following water use permits:

O'ahu Malaekahana-Campbell (3957-01 thru 07, 3956-01) Laie-White (3855-05) Laie-BYU (3855-06 thru 08, 3956-03)

Moloka'i

O'ahu

Waikolu-Dept Ag (0855-01 thru 06) Ualapue-County (0449-01)

The Windward O'ahu wells are all pre-existing~ and we ask only that the requested pumpage be compared with existing pumpage to determine whether use is expected to increase. ~

Moloka'i The Waikolu source for the Moloka'i Irrigation System is primarily for service to Hawaiian home lands, and we favor their approval. Three wells are existing, but three are new; the impact of the new wells is not fully understood.

Our primary concern is that the groundwater not be overpumped to the detriment of stream flows. The application indicates that normally low summer flows would be interrupted (the stream would be dewatered during those periods). We support management efforts in conservation, leak prevention, adequate maintenance, and adequate storage of higher winter flows. We

o Water Use Permits 30 August page 2

o

suggest that pumpage and streamflows be carefully monitored for further information and understanding of the aquifer characteristics.

We have no objections to continued County use of the Ualapue Shaft. Homesteaders at Kapaakea and Kamiloloa are served by this system.

Warmest aloha,

~f&A Chairman Hawaiian Homes Commission

1639.79 27 8 o Q

JOHN WAIHEE GOVERNOR

STATE OF HAWAII

HOALIKU L. DRAKE CHAIRMAN .. , . (~L

,~. t. ,.I L I .) HAWAIIAN HOMES COMMISSION

j+\ IJ, .: J STATE OF HAWAII

DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS P.O. BOX 1879


August 30, 1993

i"J', iii, r- . ~ .

.) I /\ I ;,: .. ;

, I (',

:j'.\ \, .• 1: ,) , :. , . i . . , I

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

')}

." ") Dear Mr. Ahue: ,.' .. ,: .. "

i

Water Use Permits \ '\ .: 1

"X' ~o

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to these ap~'li'cati~s ~.,; .. ~I." ••

for the fol~owing water use permits:'! Ii' •. " ......... \

O'ahu \.':"':,\',\\

Malaekahana-Campbell (3957-01 thru 07, 3956-01) Laie-White (3855-05) Lais-BYU (3855-06 thru 08, 3956-03)

Moloka'i

0' ahu

Waikolu-Dept Ag (0855-01 thru 061 Ualapue-County (0449-01)

The Windward O'ahu wells are all pre-existing, and we ask only that the requested pumpage be compared with existing pumpage to determine whether use is expected to increase.

Moloka'i The Waikolu source for the Moloka'i Irrigation System is primarily for service to Hawaiian home lands, and we favor their approval. Three wells are existing, but three are new; the impact of the new wells is not fully understood.

'j

Our primary concern is that the groundwater not be overpumped to the detriment of stream flows. The~npplication indicates that normally low summer flows would be interrupted (the stream would be dewatered during those periods), and we object to this as a matter of policy, preferring to focus on conservation, leak prevention, adequate rnaintenance,';,and adequate storage of higher winter flows. We request that p~rmits be conditioned

.. ::\

Water Use Permits 30 August page 2

o Q

accordingly, and that pumpage and streamflows be carefully monitored for further information and understanding of the aquifer characteristics.

We have no objections to continued County use of the Ualapue Shaft.

Warme t alOh~~

Ho u L. Drake, Cnairman Hawaiian Homes Commission

J

ROLL CALL:

o Q

MINUTES

FOR THE MEETING OF THE COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

DATE: TIME: PLACE:

September 15, 1993 1:30 p.m. Mitchell Pauole Community Center Conference Room Kaunakakai, Molokai, Hawaii

Chairperson Ahue called the meeting of the Comrilission on Water Resource Management to order at 1:47 p.m.

The following were in attendance:

MEMBERS: Mr. Keith Ahue Mr. Richard Cox Mr. Guy Fujimura Dr. John L Lewin Mr. Robert Nakata

EXCUSED: Mr. J. Douglas Ing

STAFF: Ms. Rae Loui Mr. Edwin Sakoda Mr. Roy Hardy Ms. Lyann Mizuno Ms. Lenore Nakama Ms. Sharon Kokubun

COUNSEL: Mr. William Tam

OTHERS:

Dan Kuhn Wilma Grambusch Mike Foulkes Edwin Miranda Paul Matsuo Robert Granger Charley Ice Gene Ferguson Rick Ten Cate Duane Cranney June Kapuni-Dearson Joseph Wampler Daniel Bennet Kelii Mawae Neal Wu

Tom Hill Judy Caparida Ellen Kraftsow Steve Kaiser Wilma Joy Peter Eichhorn Collette Machado Tom Nance Tom DeCourcy Elizabeth Johnson George Denison Pet:!' ThJmpson Kip Dunbar David Martin

All written testimonies submitted at the meeting are filed in the Commission office and are available for review by interested parties. Some items were taken out of sequence to accommodate requests by applicants or interested parties.

ITEM 1 MINUTES OF THE SEPTEMBER 1. 1993 MEETING

Unanimously approved (Cox/Nakata).

ITEM 1

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management July 28, 1993

ITEM 2

ITEM 3

ITEM 4

ITEMS

ITEM 6

ITEM 7

OLD BUSINESS/ANNOUNCEMENTS

Ms. Loui announced the public meeting which would be held that evening at Molokai High School to hear testimony for proposed reservations of water for the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL).

RESUBMITfAL: SEA LIFE PARK HAWAII APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE PERMIT, WELLS I, 2, 3, & A ewELL NOS .1939-01 & 02, 1940-11 & 02>, WAIMANALO GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. OAHlI)

Mr. Steve Kaiser, representing the applicant, stated. that a request was sent to the Department of Land and Natural Resources to determine if a water license is required.

Mr. Martin of Native Hawaiian Advisory Council presented testimony (cop, in Commission files).

Unanimously approved as submitted (Lewin/Cox).

APPOINTMENT OF HEARINGS MASTERS

Unanimously approved (Lewin/Nakata).

HOUSING FINANCE AND DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION APPLICATION FOR A PUMP INSTALLATION PERMIT, WAHIKULI IRRIGATION WELL ewELL NO, 5440-01>. WAHIKULI, MAUl

Mrs. Grambusch asked if any allotment for housing was made for native Hawaiians. Mr. Neal Wu, representing HFDC, had no response. Mrs. Grambusch asked for an allotment for native Hawaiians to go with the permit if water is approved for the project.

Chairperson Ahue stated that the matter was reviewed by OHA. If the project is on ceded lands and there are revenues, OHA would be-entitled to 20% of the revenues.

Unanimously approved ( Cox/Nakata).

KAIAELOA PARTNERS, LoP, AMENDMENT OF A WATER USE PERMIT AND APPLICATION FOR A WELL CONSTRUCfION PERMIT, KAIAELOAWELLS PW-7 TO 9 <WELLS NOS. 180S-10-12l, EWA BEACH, OAHU

Unanimously approved (Nakata/Cox).

HAWAIIAN RESEARCH LTD. APPUCATION FOR A WATER USE PERMIL KAMILOLOA GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. MOWKAJ

Unanimously approved (Nakata/Lewin).

- 2 -

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management July 28, 1993

ITEM 8

ITEM 9

ITEM 10

DAVID W. CURTIS, R,M. GRANGER, KAWELA PLANTATION HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, JOHN UAEA. SR.. AND MAUl DEPARTMENT OF WATER SupPLY APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE PERMITS, KAWErA GROUND WATER MANAGEMEN[ AREA. MOWKAl

Ms. Grambusch objected to the amount of water being requested by the Kawela Plantation from the Kawela Aquifer. She felt the evening meeting on reservation of water should have taken place before the Commission meeting because all the applications being heard are affected by reservation of water.

A Petition to Intervene was filed by Michael Foulkes on behalf of Wilma Kamakana Grambusch, pursuant to the right to a contested case hearing under Section 174C-60 (see Commissio~ files). Mr. Foulkes reviewed the petition asking for deferral of the applications.

Mr. Tam stated that the objector (Mrs. Grambusch) must file an application to be a party in a contested case hearing within ten days detailing the grounds for her objections so a determination on standing can be made. H she has legal standing on all five applications a public hearing will be held.

Unanimously approved for deferral for a public hearing process to possibly be held on November 10, 1993. Existing uses may continue. (Lewin/Cox).

DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS AND MAUl DEPARTMENT OF WATER SupPLY APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE PERMITS, KUALAPUU GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. MOLOKAI

1. DHHL Well Nos. 0801-01 & 02: Mr. Charley Ice, representing the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, stated that the existing amount is acceptable but they would eventually have to come back to the Commission to request additional irrigation and potable water for future developments.

2. DWS Well No. 1059-01: Ms. Ellen Kraftsow of the Maui Department of Water Supply requested an amendment to 36,000 gpd (the amount used to currently serve the customers in Kalae) instead of 25,000 gpd being recommended.

NHAC presented testimony (see Commission files) asking that the Commission records reflect "DHHL's continuing and increasing reliance upon the principle that their right of first call will be effectuated with a sense of immediacy".

1. Unanimously approved (Nakata/Cox). .

2. Unanimously approved with an amended water use of 36,000 gpd (Nakata/Cox).

MOLOKAJ RANCH, LTD. APPLJCATION FOR WATER USE PERMIL MANAWAINUI GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. MOLOKAJ

Mrs. Wilma Grambusch stated her concerns in regards to the wetland areas that may be affected by the applicant's request.

- 3 -

o o

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management July 28, 1993

ITEM 11

Mr. Ice (DHHL) said the first of the four wells appear to be an existing use, therefore they have no objections. The other three wells appear to be new uses and are upgradient of Hawaiian Home lands. Withdrawals could affect salinity for future uses on Hawaiian Home lands. DHHL recommends monitoring the salinity of water and conditioning any future use upon the means of future uses on Hawaiian Homes lands. Ms. Collette Machado asked Molokai Ranch what the plans were for the land because the community has not been kept informed of the development plans. Until plans are made known, their permits should be denied.

The applicant was asked to provide written information on the specific uses for the water use being requested. The following actions were taken on the four recommendations made by staff in regards to the issuance of interim water use permits:

• 1. Unanimously approved to deny without prejudice the issuance of an interim water use permit for 150,000 gpd from the Ooia Dug Well (Cox/Lewin).

2. Unanimously approved the issuance of an interim water use permit for use of 600,000 gpd for the Orca Shaft #1 and Orca #2 Wells (Cox/Lewin)

3. Unanimously approved the issuance of an interim water use permit for use of 40,000 gpd from Orca #3 (Cox/Lewin).

4. Unanimously approved for deferral to the November 10, 1993 meeting on Molokai, the request for 40,000 gpd of water from the Orca #3 Well (Cox/Lewin).

JOHN N. VRAUCHI. ELLEN M. OSBORNE. AND MAUl DEPARTMENT OF WATER SupPLY APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE PERMITS. UALAPUE GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. MOWKAI

1. Mr. Urauchi asked that the acreage of land be corrected to 0.25 acre and not 25 acres.

2. Mrs. Osborne explained the water would be used to irrigate established plantings.

Chairperson Ahue stated that the resolution of the issues raised by the Historic Preservation Division is not determined by the Commission. He asked that Mrs. Osborne work with staff.

Ms. Collette Machado of the Molokai Burial Council asked that the application be denied because of pending charges and fines against Mrs. Osborne for deliberate disturbance of a burial site.

Dr. Lewin asked for AG. opinion in regards to the burial site since the well in question does not affect the site. Mr. Tam stated that the Commission can act independently of any action with the burial council and the Historic Preservation Division.

3. Ms. Ellen Kraftsow of the Maui Department of Water Supply requested that the water use be amended to 185,000 gpd instead of the stated 171,000 gpd.

- 4 -

o o


ITEM 12

ITEM 13

ITEM 14

Ms. Grambusch was concerned that 1) the County of Maui needs to be more precise on the amount of water they need and 2) questioned if the County was conforming to the safe drinking water act.

Dr. Lewin stated that he did check with the Safe Drinking Water Program and since 1992 the County has complied with the Safe Drinking Water Act.

The following actions were taken on the above three applications:

1. Urauchi: defer to the November 10, 1993 meeting. Applicant to submit more detailed information for the proposed water use being requested (Lewin/Cox).

2. Osborne: defer to the November 10, 1993 meeting. Applicant tQ submit written plans for use of the water being requested and to supply information on the source of the existing irrigation system (Lewin/Cox).

3. Maui Department of Water Supply: Unanimously approved for the amended use of 185,000 gpd (Lewin/Nakata).

KAJNALV RANCH APPLICATION FOR A WATER USE PERMIT, WAIALUA GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA, MOLOKAI

Dr. Lewin requested the applicant to submit a written request to continue the permit process for a well construction, pump installation, and water use permits. Recommendation was made to defer action until the next meeting to be held on Molokai.

Unanimously approved for deferral (Lewin/Nakata).

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE APPLICATION FOR A WATER USE PERMIT, WAIKOLU GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. MOWKAI

On the advice of the Attorney General, Chairperson Ahue called for a deferral of this application as recommended by staff due to objections raised and stated that a public hearing would need to be held. A tentative date of November 10, 1993 was set for the public hearing to be held on Molokai. The Department of Agriculture may continue pumpage of the existing source.

Testimonies were presented by parties for as well as against the project. All written testimonies received are on file in the Commission office.

OTHER BUSINESS

1. In regards to the letter from Lanai Company raising questions on the sustainable yield and institutional problems with the Land Use Commission, Mr. Cox felt it should be reviewed with the staff, the Commission, and John Mink.

Ms. Loui said a briefing would be scheduled at a later date.

- 5 -

o o


2. Dr. Lewin asked for the following items to be brought up for future action:

a. The Water Quality Plan - the Code Review Commission and the Commission should meet to review the recommended actions rela.ting to overlapping enforcement and adding additional enforcement to certain areas of the Water Code so water quality work can be carried out more effectively.

b. Issues on the Caprock - a hearing will be held in the near future, suggest staff from the DOH and CWRM attend the hearing and register concerns. Long-term effects of the harbor should be considered in terms of caprock water resources.

ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 5:20 p.m.

APPROVED AS SUBMITIED:

~~ L M. WUI, Deputy Director

Respectfully submitted,

..r-r,,-,,-," L OJ SHARON S. KOKUBUN Secretary

- 6 -

" . ". o o State of Hawaii

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resources

Honolulu, Hawaii

September 15, 1993

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management State of Hawaii Honolulu, Hawaii

Gentlemen:

Applications for wate/~se Permits Ualapue Ground Water Mana&ement Area. Molokai

A""Jicants:

1. (Well No. 0352-12) John N. Urauchi P.O. Box 7 Kaunakakai, HI 96748

2. (Well No. 0448-01) Ellen M. Osborne Star Route 224-A Kaunakakai, HI 96748

3. (Well No. 0449-01) Maui Dept. of Water Supply P.O. Box 1109 Wailuku, HI 96793

Back&round

Landowners:

Same

HSPA P.O. Box 1057 Aiea, HI 96701

County of Maui P.O. Box 1109 Wailuku, HI 96793

Completed water use permit applications were submitted to the Commission as indicated on Exhibit 2. Specific information regarding the sources, uses, notifications, objections, and field investigations are described in Attachment A and the attached exhibits.

Analysis & Issues

Eight (8) applications for water use permits from the Ualapue Aquifer System have been submitted to the Commission to date requesting a total of 1.159 million gallons per day (mgd) of water (see Exhibit 2). Of this total, one request, for an allocation of 0.01 mgd, has already beP.n erqnted (Mahealani Ranch, Well No. 0352-09), and one request was recently withdrawn (Clara Brito Sabas, Well No. 0448-07). Two other applications are incomplete. The fourth application has been accepted as complete; however, action on this application shall be deferred pending publication of the notice of this application and to allow for the time period for filing written objections. Three (3) applications have been accepted as complete and ready for Commission action. Pending allocation requests currently total 1.099 mgd, or about 14~ of the Ualapue Aquifer System's estimated sustainable yield.

1. Urauchi #1 is an existing dug well that is currently unused and has not been in use since 1946. The proposed use of fresh water is for agricultural irrigation on the applicant's 25-acre parcel. Although this request is for a very small quantity of water, 1,000 gallons per day (gpd), the request is for a future, rather than an existing, use of water. Because existing uses in the Ualapue Aquifer System are still in the process of

ITEM ,.

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management September 15, 1993

being established, staff feels that this request should not be granted at this time, unless the applicant can show more definite plans for use within the next four (4) years.

2. Mapulehu Shaft #1 is an existing dug source that has not been in use for a number of years because of large boulders and sediment at the well's bottom. Although the pump is run intermittently to keep the pump and motor in working condition, county water is currently supplying the applicant's domestic and crop irrigation needs. The applicant plans to redevelop this well in order to use fresh, non-potable water to augment the supply of county water for irrigation of 4.5 acres of ginger and heliconia. Because this request is for a future and not an existing use of water, this reques~ should not be granted until existing uses have been established and permitted, unless the applicant can show more definite plans for use within the next four (4) years.

Furthermore, the State Historic Preservation Division has recently lodged a formal complaint against the applicant for a potential violation over the alleged disturbance of a burial site. The case is currently pending in the Attorney General's office, and the Historic Preservation DJvision has recommended that act jon on this submittal be deferred until this issue is resolved.

3. The Maui Department of Water Supply (DWS) is requesting 1.08 mgd of fresh water from an existing shaft source to satisfy municipal needs in the Ualapue water system. Based on the information provided in the application, it appears that the ' cpt"'c requested allocation is based on pump capacity, and therefore represents a maximum-day ".,J.J...~ usage. The application further indicates that actual use is considerably less, about 0.18 ~\.~~~ mgd, on average. This is in agreement with the actual 12-month moving average \-"....)- ~-~J... withdrawal of 0.171 mgd, computed using monthly water use data provided by the ~ applicant. Daily permitted withdrawals are based on the longer term 12-month moving, average withdrawal, rather than on the potential maximum-day usage. The Final Report from the Molokai Working Group indicates that existing ground water use by the Maui DWS in the Ualapue Aquifer System is 0.18 and no increase in municipal needs projected to the year 2010 is expected (see Exhibits 3 and 6). .

Use of this water from the Maui DWS shaft source has been in existence for at least the past thirteen (13) years. Therefore, authorization to continue the existing use should not result in additional adverse impacts on other local wells, streams, and the KHalapw Aquifer System. 0~~v

There is no clear reservation recommendation from the Molokai Working Group for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) for the Ualapue Aquifer System. The Final Report of the Molokai Working Group indicates that there are no existing or major projected increases for DHHL potable needs in the area (see Exhibit 3). However, the non-potable water needs projected to total buildout for homestead lands in the Central Aquifer Sector and small portions of the West and Southeast Aquifer Sectors total 23.5 mgd (see Exhibits 4 and 5). Of this total demand, 5.42 mgd is projected for the next five (5) to ten (10) years. About 5.0 mgd of the demand can be met through the existing Molokai Irrigation System (MIS). Current usage by DHHL from MIS is about 2.3 mgd. Staff feels that since municipal use Qf tht water has been in existence and is of beneficial use to the community, potential DHHL reservation should not prohibit action on the Maui DWS application.

The Molokai Working Group has made three recommendations, regarding the Southeast Aquifer Sector, which encompasses the Ualapue Aquifer System. They are:

1. Limit ground water withdrawal to 50 ~ of its developable yield subject to . verification of existing users and water use permits.

2. Any withdrawals from this Sector should not diminish water supplies and supply availability for traditional uses, including taro patches and fishponds.

2


3. Development of additional water from the Southeast Sector should be reserved first for residences of this Sector who are not yet served.

Staff finds that there is no reason to believe that continuation of the existing municipal use will violate these recommendations made by the Molokai Working Group.

RECOMMEND A TIONS

Attach.

The Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a w~ter use permit to John N. Urauchi to use 1,000 gallons per day of fresh water for use from the Urauchi #1 Well (Well No. 0352-12), unless the applicant can show he has definite plans to use this requested amount within the next four (4) years. If and when granted, that water use permit should be an interim permit and shall be subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule.

The Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a water use permit to Ellen M. Osborne to use 2,600 gallons per day of fresh, non-potable water for use from the Mapulehu Shaft #1 Well (Well No. 0448-01), unless the applicant can show she has definite plans to use this requested amount within the next four (4) years and until the concerns of the State Historic Preservation DivisiQn have been resolved. If and when granted, that water use permit should be an interim permit

~

and shall be subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in' -, I Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is s~t by O1le.------ocr--____

_ ~ 0 ~ ~ 'S~ ?,DO 1-~--The Commission approve the issuance of apjliterim water use permit to the Maui Department of Water Supply to use 171,000 gallons per day of fresh water for use from the Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) for municipal use in the DWS Ualapue system, subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule. Until the reservation issue is resolved, the applicant may continue this existing use of ground water within the limits approved by the Commission.

APPROVED FOR SUBMIT! AL:

3


WATER USE PERMIT DETAILED INFORMATION

1.

2.

3.

Source Information

AQUIFER: Sustainable Yield: Existing Water Use Permits: Available Allocation: Total of other pending allocations:

Ualapue System, Southeast Sector, Molokai 8 mgd

0.01 mgd 7.99 mgd

0.006 mgd

WELL: Location: Year Drilled: Casing Diameter:

Elevations (msl= 0 ft.) Water Level: Ground: Bottom of Solid Casing: Bottom of Perforated: Bottom of Open Hole:

Total Depth: Grouted Annulus Depth:





Elevations (msl = 0 ft.) Water Level: Ground: Bottom of Solid Casing: Bottom of Perforated: Bottom of Open Hole:


Urauchi #1 Well (Well No. 0352-12) Kapualei, Molokai, TMK:5-6-11: 16

NA NA in.

NA ft. NA ft. NA ft. NA ft. NA ft.

NA ft. NA ft.

Mapulehu Shaft #1 (Well No. 0448-01) Star Route 224-A, Molokai, TMK:5-7-8:76

NA NA in.

ATTACHMENT A


50 ft. NA ft.

Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) Ualapue, Molokai, TMK:5-6-6:28

1936 48 in.

NA ft. 40 ft.

NA ft. NA ft.

-3 ft.

43 ft. NA ft.

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management

r-.-~

.. , outedmlis

IV' .. w ... at. tml Tot~ Depth

I..

I I I. SGid casilg

I I I L 'VI' t. JWf. casiIg

r-

Mt

Use InfOrmation

1. Quantity Requested: 1,000 gallons per day. Proposed Type of Water Use: Agricultural irrigation Place of Water Use: Kapualei, Molokai at TMK: 5-6-11:16

Reported Water Usage: Nearby Similar Water Usage:

2. Quantity Requested: 2,600 gallons per day.

September 15, 1993

NAgpd NAgpd

Proposed Type of Water Use: Irrigation of 4.5 acres of ginger and heliconia Place of Water Use: Star Route 224-A at TMK: 5-7-8:76


3. Quantity Requested: 1,080,00 gallons per day.

NA gpd NA gpd

Proposed Type of Water Use: Municipal for the Maui DWS Ualapue system Place of Water Use: Ualapue service area


Total Requested:

Ualapue Aquifer System Current 12-Month Moving Average Withdrawal:

Nearby Surrounding Wells and Other Registered Ground Water Us

171 ,000 gpd NA gpd

174,600 gpd

171 ,000 gpd (2.1 ~ of Sy)

Information from the registration program indicates there are possibly nineteen (19) existing wells in the Ualapue Aquifer System. Several of these wells have been initially field checked but many of the declarants, including possibly large users, have not been completely field verified. Several are not in use or are rights claims. No reliable

A IT ACHMENT A


estimate of existing ground water withdrawals from the Ualapue Aquifer System as of 1990 is provided in the Maui Water Use and Development Plan, Island of Molokai. However, the Final Report from the Molokai Working Group provides an estimate of 0.62 mgd for ground water usage from the Ualapue Aquifer System as of July 1993 (see Exhibit 6). Specific information regarding other existing wells in the proximity of the sources is as follows:

1. There are sixteen (16) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0352-12 (see Exhibit lA). Only two (2) of these wells are currently in use.

2. There are ten (10) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0448-01 (see Exhibit IB). Only two (2) of these wells are currently in use.

3. There are ten (10) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0449-01 (see Exhibit lC). Eight (8), and possibly all ten (10) of these wells are currently in use.

Public Notice

In accordance with HAR §13-171-17, a public notice was published in the StarBulletin as indicated on Exhibit 2, and copies of the notice were sent to the Mayor's office and the Board of Water Supply. Additional notice copies were sent to the County Council and Department of Water Supply. Copies of the completed application were sent to the Department of Health, Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Aquatic Resources & Historic Preservation and other divisions of the Department of Land and Natural Resources, and other interested parties for comments. Written comments and objections to the proposed permit were to be submitted to the Commission as indicated on Exhibit 2.

Objections

The public notice specifies that an objector meet the following requirements: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits, (4) provide a copy of the objection letter(s) to the applicant, and (5) submit objections meeting the previous requirements to the Commission by the date indicated on Exhibit 2.

To the best of staffs knowledge there are no objectors who have property interest within the Ualapue Aquifer System or who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use from Well Nos. 0352-12 & 0449-01. Historic Preservation issued an initial statement of "no effect" to the proposed water use from Well No. 0448-01, although they acknowledged the existence of the burial site in that same document. Subsequently, and past the objection deadline, a formal complaint against that applicant was submitted to the State Attorney General's office and is currently pending (refer to Analysis and Issues section). All other objections and/or comments to the application l're summarized as follows:

Objector

NHAC

A IT ACHMENT A

Objection

General process of water use permit applications. No specific objections to this application.


Briefs in Support

Responses to objections, or briefs in support, regarding the application are required to be filed with the Commission ten (10) days after an objection is filed and, presumably, copies are served to the applicant. No briefs in support were filed with the Commission.

Field InvestiKation

1. The water source and proposed use was investigated on November 6, 1992. The investigation(s) verified the non-use of the source.


3. The water source and proposed use was investigated on February 10, 1993 and February 11, 1993. The investigations verified the applicants request- for a water use permit.

A IT ACHMENT A


STANDARD WATER USE PERMIT CONDITIONS

1. The ground water described in the water use permit may only be taken from the location described, used for the reasonable-beneficial use described, and at the location described above and in the attachments. Reasonable-beneficial use means "the use of water in such a quantity as is necessary for economic and efficient utilization, for a purpose, and in a manner which is not wasteful and is both reasonable and consistent with the state and county land use plans and the public interest." (HAR §13-171-2).

2. The right to use ground water is a shared use right.

3. The water use must at all times meet the requirements set forth in HAR §13-171-13 which means that it:

a. Can be accommodated with the available water source; b. Is a reasonable-beneficial use as defined in section §13-171-2; c. Will not interfere with any existing legal use of water; d. Is consistent with the public interest; e. Is consistent with state and county general plans and land use designations; f. Is consistent with county land use plans and policies; and g. Will not interfere with the rights of the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands as

provided in section 221 of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act.

4. The ground water must not interfere with surface or ground water rights or reservations.

5. The ground water use must not interfere with interim or permanent instream flow standards. If it does, then:

a. A separate water use permit for surface water must be obtained in the case an area is also designated as a surface water management area;

b. The interim or permanent instream flow standard, as applicable, must be amended.

6. The water use permit is subject to the requirements of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act, as amended, if applicable.

7. The water use permit application and staff submittal approved by the Commission at its September 15, 1993 meeting are incorporated into the permit by reference.

8. Any modification of the permit terms, conditions, or uses can only be made with the express written consent of the Commission on Water Resource Management.

9. The water use permit may be modified by the Commission and the amount of water initially granted to the permittee may be reduced if the Commission determines it is necessary to:

a. Protect water sources in quantity, quality, or both; b. Meet other legal obligations includinl other correlative rights; c. Insure adequate conservation measures; d. Require efficiency of water uses; . . e. Reserve water for future uses, provided that all legal existing uses of water as of

June 1987, shall be protected; f. Meet legal obligations to the Department of Hawaiian Homes, if applicable; or g. Carry out such other necessary and proper exercise of the State's and the

Commissions's police powers under law as may be required.

ATTACHMENT B


Prior to any reduction, the Commission shall give notice of its proposed action to the permittee and provide the permittee an opportunity to be heard.

10. If the ground water source is not existing, the development of the new well shall be completed, i.e. able to withdraw water for the proposed use on a regular basis, within twenty-four (24) months from the date the water use permit is approved.

11. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, water-levels, salinity, and temperature must be kept and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis in accordance the Commission's September 16, 1992 action on reporting requirements;

12. The water use permit shall be subject to the Commission's periodic review of the applicable aquifer's sustainable yield. The amount of ground water use authorized by the permit may be reduced by the Commission if the sustainable yield of the Ualapue Aquifer System, or relevant modified aquifer, is reduced;

13. The water use permit may not be transferred or the use rights granted by this. permit sold or in any other way alienated. Pursuant to HAR §13-171-25 and the requirements of Chapter 174C, the Commission has the authority to allow the transfer of the permit and the use rights granted by the permit in a manner consistent with HAR §l3-171-25. Any such transfer shall only occur with the Commission's prior express written approval. Any sale, assignment, lease, alienation, or other transfer of any interest in this permit shall be void.

14. The use(s) authorized by law and by the water use permit do not constitute ownership rights.

15. The permittee shall request modification of the permit when necessary to comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances which will affect the permittee's water use.

16. The permittee shall prepare and submit a water shortage plan within 30 days of issuance of the permit to assist the Commission in fulfilling HAR §13-171-42(c). The permittee's water shortage plan shall identify what the permittee is willing to do should the Commission declare a water shortage in the Ualapue Ground Water Management Area.

17. The water use permit granted shall be an interim water use permit, as allowed under HAR §13-171-21. The final determination of the water use quantity shall be made within five years of the filing of the application to continue the existing use.

18. The water use permit shall be issued only after AG review.

A 11 ACHMENT B

C H

CONTOUR INTERVAL 50 FEET o.ru .. IS "EAN SEA LEVEl

OEPr .. CURVES AND SOU"OINGS IN FEET -OA "J" IS "EA .. LOWER LOW \rIoal\.I"( ''''0.''' -'''a,u"" hill ""~IIt()'I"''''( LINI 0' ." .... "'IG'" ."'(11

'"I MUN IlAfifOl 0' riOI I' ""~tIOIII ..... l''''T , ,,(1'

IAWlIIII - 40l1li

IUALA"", .. 4010l-,

_DlUA - '0101

SALE BY U 5 GEOLOGICAL SURVEY. DENVER. COLORADO 80225. OR

• "",. ~~ ... "O "~'''''''E'X R'j BTf" 1 A ,- ,~. __ .•. J ... -

CAMA....,. .. 40401

WAUCo\'U .. 40403

AUPU .. 40404

rn.,aUNU .. 40405

rAILA ..... 40401

_ ALAWA .. 40401

--

L - ALANe· 4OS01 L .. ILA • 4OJOZ

A"',,_OA . 40101

Al.ILU& .. 40104

'PROJECT AREA Molokai

Hlu

N,

I

, ---"

_I0Il - <QIIIl .. -

\ '.

\ • ... Old Se. W,II ,--,-

KUALA""" - "«nOl

HaaUHU" - <alQl

~'_L-"'.

K'LAU"~ • • 40401

ICAHAHUI • 40401

.AIKQt..U .. 40403

HYDROLOGIC UNITS - ISLAND 0' WOLOKAI

F""" .... AWA - 40407

"AUlA - 4CUO"

Molokal

EXHIBIT 1B

, • or

---.. - ..... _-- .... I

..... --PROJECT AREA .. ...wI-=~1

Malak.1

HYOIIOLOGIC UNITS ·'''LANO 0' MOLOKAI

EXHIBIT 1C

WATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION NOTICE STATUS REPORT

\AJPA PUBLIC 1 NO APPLICANT WElL NO WELL NAME EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKNOWGD ACCEPTED NOTICE -

ISLAND OF MOLOKAI

Aquifer system: UALAPUE TIMOTHY C. MEYER, SR. 07116/93 08112193 / / / / MAHEALANI RANCH 0352-09 KAMAlO Y 01120/93 03129/93 01120/93 05124/93 JOHN N. URAUCHI 0352-12 URAUCHI 111 Y 07116/93 08/30/93 07/16/93 08/23/93 WILMA KAMAKANA GRAMBUSCH 0352-17 KAHANANUI Y 07115/93 09/01/93 08/19/93 09115/93 ELLEN M. OSBORNE 0448-01 MAPUlEHU SHAFTII1 Y 02103/93 03129/93 04/07/93 OS/24/93

0 CLARA BRITO SA BAS 0448-07 MAPULEHU-SABAS Y 07109/93 08/30/93 07/09/93 08/23/93 MAUl OilS 0449-01 UALAPUE SHAFT Y 06/09/93 07/08/93 06/09/93 08/06/93 PEARL FRIEL PETRO 0549-01 MAPULEHU TUNNEl Y 07/15/93 08/30/93 / 1 1 /

o

09/04/93

PUBLIC 2 OBJECTION DAYS NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE LEFT AGENDA

/ / / / 1 1 0 / / 06/07193 06/21/93 04/20/93 196 08/04/93 08/30/93 09/13/93 10/14/93 40 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 11/11/93 74 11/10/93 06/07193 06/21/93 07/06/93 -60 09/15/93 08130/93 09/13/93 10/07193 33 09/15/93 08/13/93 08/27/93 09/07/93 3 09/15/93

1 1 1 1 / / 0 / /

8 Applications Totaling

WPA mgd

0.005 0.010 0.001 0.009 0.003 0.050 1.080 0.001

1.159

C\I

I--m -I X W

,

o o

Molokai WorlGng Group

BREAKDOWN OF 2010 POTABLE WATER USE PROJECTIONS IN MGD

CENTRAL SECfOR Manawainui System

1. Hawaiian Research

Kualapuu System 1. County DWS 2. DHHL 3. Kaluakoi Resort 4. Other State Projects S. Palaau Industrial Park 6. Others (Kualapuu. Kalae. Kipu)

Subtotal

NORTHEAST SECTOR Kahanui System

1. National Park Service

Waikolu System 1. DOA MIS

SOUTHEAST SECfOR Kamiloloa System


Kawela System

0.56

0.94 0.84 2.14 0.11 0.20 0.20 4.43

0.22

2.70

0.26

1. County DWS 0.32 2. Kawela Plantation 0040 ~3.~~K~run~al~o~R~a~n~ch~ __________________________ 0.04

Subtotal 0.76

U alapue System 1. County DWS 2. Kamala Ranch 3. Place. M. J.

Subtotal

Alpha USA

WEST SECTOR

TOTAL

I Water development source unidentifie:d.

EXHIBIT 3

0.18 0.22 0.22 0.62

0.00

11.55

,

o o

Molokai Working Group

NON-POTABLE WATER USE PROJECTIONS IN MGD'"

5 to 2010 to 10 years Total Build out

D1·lIIL Hoolehua 4.00 16.0 Kalamaula

Subtotal DHHL 1.42 7.5

Other MIS users .,- 5.42\ 2.502

Molokai Ranch Agriculture, Dairy, Pastures: 1. Ag. Park - Kualapuu 7.70 2. Coffee - 800 acres 1.50 3. Dairy - 4,000 head 0.70 4. Palm Nursery - brackish 0.30 5. Feedlot 0.20 6. Pastures 0.20 7. Hay ~ assume all irrigated on Homesteads 0.00

Subtotal Agriculture 10.63

Recreation: 1. Maunaloa Links 0.25 2. Ironwoods 0.20 3. Network 0.05

Subtotal Recreation 0.503•4

Kaluakoi Resort Recreation: Golf Course Addition 0.00

(two 36-hole courses)

Alpha USA 1.503

TOTAL 20.52

• Estimates furnished by users and were accepted by working group without challenge.

'From DHHL projections From DOA - MIS average delivery = 7.5 mgd

2/3 x 7.5 mgd = 5.0 mgd preference to DHHL 1/3 x 7.5 mgd = 2.5 mgd for other MIS users Note: deficit from MIS of 0.42 mgd

lAssumes maximum usage of 1/3 of MIS for other'users

3Water development source unidentified

Total

23.53

2.5

10.63

0.53.4

2.83

3.0 3

42.9

4A portion of tills projection will be met by the MIS and a portion from private SOUIces

Note: Non-Potable Water Use Projections are for major agricultural. and recreational uses in Ule ceno-al and western areas of the island. It does not include instIeams uses, fishponds, taro patches, aquacultural projections, etc.

EXHIBIT 4

LEGEIW:

• o

..

,A0lF£1It S!CT~ ~",$TSTf" DWS"""-LS ""VAT( w!U.$ Ol~p.

DWSDlVUC....$lON ptttyAn DtV(ltSK:IN

OWS ~'AIIL!: SEfMCE AReA ~ATE POTUl£ 5C.RYa. AJlEA

OT>EJ! OWS SM.l.~ "NY4TE SHAFT OTlEl! I'EIIOED OAOIHI _ 1\H!!L

DEYRoPIEHT _ mAN$I&$SOrf 1\HE:.

D_I_nlol;- . _i ... _~ IUlamaula ;" - - i

i -I

-·-r: ~ .--.J

MOlOKAI AQUIFER SECTORS WATER SOURCE AND SERVICE AREAS

o ICALI .. KLOIII'18I'S

«at 0 ........

SCALE" JU1

LO

I--m -I >< W

t- ...

o o

Molokai Working Group

BREAKDOWN OF EXlSl1NG GROUNDWATER USAGE IN MGD

CENTRAL SECTOR Manawamui System


Kualapuu System 1. County DWS 2. DHHL 3. Kaluakoi Resort

Subtotal

NORTHEAST SECfOR Kahanui System

1. National Park Service

Waikolu System 1. DOA MIS

SOUTHEAST SECfOR Kamiloloa System


Kawela System 1. County DWS 2. Kawela Plantation 3. Kamalo Ranch

Subtotal

Ualapue System 1. County DWS 2. Kamalo Ranch 3. Place. M. J.

Subtotal

WEST SECfOR

TOTAL

0.56

0.59 0.38 0.82 1.79

0.22

1.13

0.26

0.32 0.16 0.04 0.52

0.18 0.22 0.22 0.62

0.00

5.10

. .1.

o

Williamson B.C. Chang Attorney ac Law

969 Ahuwale Place Honolulu, Hawaii 96821

Tel: Boe-377-120~ Fax: 808~377-5096

o

Counsel for Kalamaula Homestead Association, an Unincorporate~ .~8~ociation, Mrs. Wilma Grambu9ch, PrQQidQnt

September 13, 1993

commission on ~']ater Use Managemer!t Mr:-. Keith Jlhue, Chairperson P.o. BOX 621 Honolulu. Hi ;~8020

Ra~ Matters raised at Meetings on Molokai, September 15th, 1: 30 at l\atChQl Pauol1 Cent~r and at 6: 00 at Molokai High School

J . :Request for Deferral cf Sever<l1 Matters schedul~d for 1 ~ 30 llnJ;.il 2:00

On behalf of the Kalam~ula Hom9~tead Association, I wish to rrequest'-deferr<:~1"""'of~deci8iol'l:::making"on·~it~HT"t.S· 7 ':11' of the agenda for the Meetillg of COWRM Elcheduled for l130 on September 15. U~fortunately, many of the membere of the association, including myself, acting as counsel for the as~ociati9n have work commitments which px-event us from atten1.i:lg the 1: 30 nleeting. We ~equeet that you keep open the x-ecord on these items, deter decision making and allow us to c8scity at the 0:00 meeting. TIle Kalamaula Homestead Association , a3sert5 that it has appropriate standing on all of these issues as its lands are sutriciently proximate co the applicants proposea use SUCh Chat the association has an adequate property int~res~. The Associacion relies on the language or the RHeA, particularly section 221, whiCh strongly states that the waters of Molokai, snall ~e first u;e~ to plaCQ·hOmQ~teadQrs on the l:.lnd.

II. Spg~i!1c Qbj~~tiQns to APplications:

0352,·ID D-\:~I,,·\,,\ O'l:~(..,,"O~~i , .. ) O~\","·lb) DL/~;' t;')l ) ) .

a. Item 8 -- application of 'Curtis, jet al, Kawela Plantation Homeowner3 A::Isociat.ion. The Kalamaulo. Homeowners Associat.ion obj ects to the appl ication 0 f David Curtis et al on numerous g:t"ound~: , .... The applicant I s use will interfere with the 3 (c) [see

1" •• \I.f'\'~:,~'i?'t.'~ .. ":'

o

standard W6\tQr · .. U:Q ~ermit concHt.ions 1 anel 3 (9) "existing legal right" to tho U£:Q of water l:lY mambers of the Kalamaula Homestead / Aeeociat;ion. The rightG ot HomQstQaders are <letlneC1 by both. congre9aional and staLe la~ and the barrier to homesteading has· been the inabil ity to obtain wat~r. The rigl'ltb: ot the association !

extend i~land-wide and tr.us all USQ~ other than those for homeste~ding are 5ubordinate to thQ rights of homesteaders not ab1e to 1 i ve on their landa due to failure to ~upply watQr. The strengt.h of thi.~ right i~ obyiou", since it is repeated a number of t~mes in different parte ot the etandard water use permit conditions, pal.ticularly in 9(g) and eection 6. Any issuance of a water ul~e permie on Molokai !Should be deferred unt.il the public heari~g on the proposed rule. Chronologically, only after the rule reserving waters ;l.s fimllized, including the scope 0.£ aquifers which are affected, can water permits be issued on Molokai.

~. Reque~t for "contested case proce8~1ng: I In the event that the Commission ~ee9 fit to proceed with t.he issuance ot a water permit for the applicants in item 8, the Kalamaula Homesteacl Associations exe~cises ics: r:i.ghts uncj.l;!r Chapt.ar 91 in seeking a contested case proceeding. The request for such a hearing requires the Commission to dQfQr dacision making .

.,.b"':''tr.-rem':9 ]" - D~" \ ~ ~\.. \ 10'\"," 0' . a. Requ~~t of DHF..L for water/use Permits: Kalamaula

Hon:estead Association reli;.l9sts that this matter be£'ConSbl"tdated' IwfEn"'the~ropoifedTrure~cO~· be'""<:'lieard.....-at"76;OO~P':M" The re:gervation of amount sought by DHHL coheres with the amount proposed by the Molokai Workin3" Gl:"OUp. Kal~maula Homestead Association flS3erts t~at the rig~ts to water of Hawaiian Homesteaders is not sutlse:::-vient tc the rUlemaldyut:.horir.y of COWRN and that the v

~{~~~~{~ici~~~~~~~~~*O:~~~@Ni8f}~;:f:~;~eeg~r~~~~~ I\. Kalamaula Hom.estli!~d A£s:ociat:ion protQr.:ts the ~~gements~made!"bli

rDHHL •• ·for,,::~n;i~-~:~g~!itQ~I"~"hll.:1J,~~1?5i~,B~ortW~~:Q;:~;§~p~~C~~~_~e ~omplet..!.L@'!'\!-"£'~;"9"£;f:>,~~p.!:.ac.~aQ' a f:fd~~ary·1·rQprQQQnt_tl.vQ~OU :€be~ni1t:.v"'; ~awal.ian;~.::k:i~nQficia;r,J.QQf. ThQ ll.m~tatl.on s::tab~d on page 3 limiting tr~e i~Sl,la.nCQ of intarim PQrmit~, which is to be temporary unci:4 the reaervQ.tions are set :by ful.e, iG a limitation that should :be placed on all permits on Molokvd. Under t;.ha original versicnot:. the Hawaiian Romee Commission Act I all waters, for dQrneeltiCtt,p»:,agricultural uee, were to be first used for the benefit of HQme5.S~acleX'~. . . ., Q'i... ~'''''''''r'"'1 NOI D2r.1'l.p ~

b. Th" Kblamaula Horr.estead AssociCltion. asserts that COWRM has '.' no legal authority to issu9 interim permit ~ubject to conditions that are based on federal r~strictions.

C. In ad31tlon, the Kalamaula Homestead Associ~tion asserts t.hat tIle supremacy Clause 01: the united. States Con::;titution nullitie.s the rignc ct COflRM to set:. limitations on wate~ U5e of

2

o o

native Haw=iian benefic~arip'8 or the Hawaiian Homes Commi5~ion Act. The Hawaiian Hornes Commission Act at 1920 is still teoeral law.

'l,.:;)~· 0'\.) .ti~ Item 10: Kalamaula Hom~steCld ASsociation, acting on behalt ot Mr., .. . 0\ ,V'I Harry Aki I and ~ther residents Of Mauna Loa town, obj ects co

","oC) appl~cant Mol.;kal. Ranch's request, and r obj ects - ,to t.hQ staff \)1l1)"- [)... recommendation as to nos. :2 and 3, on the grounds that Molokai

Ranch, under equitable doctrines of law, i~ acting with lIunclean bands" in that it has failed to comply with the federal Safe Drinking Water Act in_its. delivery of water to Ma.una Loa Town. Until this - v::'olatio:l of ::ederal standards \ is rectified, the app11c;lnt Shou:.d not. receive furthe~ eource:;, 0\ water

\ ~Itetit""'ll': Kfllamaula Homesteaj A550ciacion 'objects to the applicant,

Maui Oep~rtmant of Water Supply to use 171,000 gallons for . ~ , munic_~~al. \.I.SIi __ =11 !-h~~. gro,?:c:s_ tn~~_.~~e ~~~pa-t~~·rt:~J~t!_a~~~~:uppT}j

)~ r .. ~ ". t> p.as~lIun~l~~~);fn~nd.~Z+n1:t.!1:.lll'Jg!t.~:ntp.6ce "th$ :intJ:mt!..Qfxt~~c~O,I.l.s,,~nu :decre9 [r be t;w~Qn--::'t:.hQ:;sta te ~ aru;\ M010kai Ranch] "'1"aS~l;o,!::r;n.-ua11 tyld"r

~t.:..l;;,tl\ \~ o~

~!),-o-k

?\?b\ - 0\

€~~te7""'d.~1"'i:'7'fred,to.~M,~~~7-:'Loamr.,own"1 Kala:n-u1a HO~Q.s.t:&,a.? Associ_ation J.8 wl.llJ.ng to plton'"evidenc.:1Gl of the ~~J1-Y~.1Dol'and!:M.a~_~~,~Y.I

fto~,mee!;.;"'l;he..,.t.ertnS"""o~th~f';d.;oreCl,..andi'7.the?terms,.o.~l'\HS':~rJ~~j.ng,& '.;w_~cer,~ct"01.'~.(}r~OVer;-Kal;2.ma\.l~a ·Home9~ .. ead._~p~Ociat~on 15§~'hc;.~.~~t.O~h& ri 5 ~uance!oF~~t.e;,b'}~~;:.p'e;;w~~~CQ.~nty::When!there~Q";;,:pr~!~n1;t revl.d~n5.:::s....0k:~~T.t';;..CJ4~~~t~_~,1~\lr.;e;;.",!;.o4~1.,1l':~.C9,\l\p,ly,.with.environmentaJ:i' fl.s.W5.S~iJ!.;!;.,~~of~i':the~p~p~~cJ.~Q~~J\g:: .. QJ.;;.the landfn~7anci""dumpB~t.~J~;1~~" 't:hat ex~sts on Kalamaula,:Home"teadProperty' The County should not be rewa4dcd with permits for mere water when they have failed to meet the quaU:y I'equi:t"emer:ta as to exil5ting U5e5.

Item 13 - '. Kala:1:aula Homestead Association' objects to applicants proposa: an~ agrees witt. cr.e starr 4ecommendation for a deferred public hearing on November 10. Objeccor asserts t.hat. the original purposes amll tQ:nnli: Qf the ''faikolu source have been violated to the benefit or the County ana the detriment or ObjectOr. ObjeCtOr wiah~e to h~VQ th~ ab~lity to prOVQ icg ca~Q at a later date.

~!'tem~~ - - Obj €eto:', Kalamaula Homestead Assoc1.ation, opposes the . ~taff ~ecomwmda_tion on_._t:l2.~g~undQ _ ~~at the .W~.~~s~e,':l~~lP.PJ ~ssU~d~()~y~~ft:at?aII'?'nee~3 .~ .. of· the "I' natl. ve-HawaJ.l.an"'l'benefl.ciarieS" (have be~~tl Moreover, ~t does not mQke .ny s~nSQ to grant such a ~ermit~~;pt"ior to the full hearing and final determination of the rule to be heard on the rel!lervation of homeetead wa.ters.

3

o o

In con'cilu8ion, 'bjector seek:s a cont501idation of the 1: 30 &genda with the 6:00 rule m3king agenda and finds that the attempt t.o proceed wit.h perm1t.ting without a final rule a:s to reaervad waters violata~ t.he intect of the state legislature. Objector thus rQSerVe5 its right to seek juQ1cial review, ~y way of a contested casCO! pro:::ei;;diliS, or :)t:hE!rwi ge as to all permits issued prior to rinali zi!"".cg th~ issu~s :a.G to the rule reserving waters for Homee'::eadero.

CATED; September 13, 1993. Honolulu, Hawaii

'-, .,'

_::.;:.~~ :.'t' ~ .

.. ~'.\~~~~~ 1~~.tf~ :;},.

. ;

Yours,

~c~/·-···

Williamson B.C. Chang Couneel for Objector, Kalamauala HcmesteEld Assn, Pro~eBsor of Law, Universi~y of Hawaii

•

,!

=

~'NWAI"" OoVI~MDR

MlJUJ<AI IRRlGAT leN OFFlCE/D\)::l 001

Stile of HawaII or I'I\Al'MENl OF AGntcuL lURE

UM51011 (If Avrlcilitural A.~nllrCt! Managametlt M(llokal Irrlgltlon 'vslDm

r. O. Bolt 201) 11<ul1"IIUII. III 06 nm·(f?lm

~O

YUKIO '''TI\O'''II'/A I:IIAIRPF.II!\ON. 901\111:\ Of' AaR,,~uL·rvR.

ILIMA A. '1IA~4.1:' DI!.f'UlV TO 1H\.: CI~t~lt,I'ftRSON

r-I\)(: 561·9011l

'1' IME: cf.' fb #1.t

FAX f: S'f"7- ~ ~ / 7 -"" - ....

-------_ .. --.. '-~ -r::-: , L./c; ./n ,~ /.

FROM 1 r LJ?:-;t. ~.~' .Ia, ."._._ FAX .: (808) 561-9014

Mor..OKAl lRJUOA'l'rON gYS'I'!M DEPARTMENT OF AORICUt..TUR!

SUBJBCT; {2/~,i~z;t.~- C'AJ tv"Z:;,£, /t(I(i:::, li&t,-t-fi /:

--~----- ... -.------'--- ----~....-... --,-,-R.!MA~K8: __ , ____ ....... ___ ~ _____ Fo_K __ W_6'L-t0 _______ • __ o¥1~E.L

..... _<, .... --------..-.~---_.---_ ... _ .. '_ ..... "._-----

O?:J5"5 -~l f1? 00

~'1'SJ -Q\

--....... -~---.---..... , .. ~, - -, .... . ... _ .. __ .-... --_. _ .. -..... -- ..... -.. _.,.

-----~,-- .•. -.- ------,_ ... ,-.~-----... ____ ri,·· .. _~··_·._ .. _ ... ~- ~ ...• ". _______ ~.

-~-.. ~----... --.----.-------.. _ ... -._" .... '-- -------------_ .. _. __ ... - - .-

----.~"'-.. "'-- ~-----.--~-., ... -.-.~ /

'J.'Qtal number of pagefl (l.llclud;j,ng t:b1s page) : ___ -.:.l' .... """ .. __ .. ,_,_ ... ,_, •. _

If YOll do not receive the total number of paflell llott;.d abovl:l and/or have problems with our transmission, pleaae oontaot l~e aender at (808) 561-6150.

-1-

_._,--- ~OlO<A I _ I RR I GAT I ON CFF I CE/OC!A

i.;,'

i t , !

I

1993 August 30

o NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY GOUNCIL

.-., .. -.-,.-----,.--~~9!J 1008 14191101) 81f001, Sullo 1201, IlonO/viU. Uawoll 961113

Telopholl8 (808) 523-'''.5 :"'Qc.;;nlin (808) 599.1,,180

state of Hawaii commission Oi'l water Resource Management P.o. Box 621 Honolulu, HI 96809

OBJ'BCTIORS '.to AliTD COMKBN'tS ON WATHR USE PBlUlri APPLICATIOJ~S (PUblic notice of July 27, 1.993/Commellts duo Jmgust 30, 1993)

We reite:a:'at.e our genGral t'Jbjections t.o current COWRM water US'~ permit application procos~ng and decisionmaking praotices as previouflly fJUPlIll.t.t.tJd ~m I! :,I\(,\lI)\!f1 (JU£.liUd.OIlf.l LlO/1?/!)?, lOIZl/~Z, ~~/1/9Z, 6/22/93 I , 7/0/93,.

We also have: specific c·omm,nts on and objections tu seve.ral. of th,. applications li$·t~d in tl- is notice, particularly tnose ot Maul Department of Wat.er SUt'pl~ ( St.ate Department ut hgrlculture, Lall~ water co,. Inc. I and can\pb.ll ~state. In each case NHAC' ~.:'preaem ... :i 'Hater source regi:5t.rantl!;, watt::!r use declarants, water \l,"3C perro:i.·: applioants, and ot.hel."s wi.,ll p-coperty interest in land ~'jtnln th'~ hydrologic unit of the l:H.1U :ca of water supply who would i:)~! direct.!.] and intntediately affected l"t' thQ proposed water use.

Because of the cornple)dty, hnpo;ctanct!!, and late arrival f.lf some or these applications to om officer VlQ are requesting an extendei:]

review period (as previd ':.d on yOUX' nu!~.morandllm) to Septr':nber 3, 1993 t when we will sUbmit.lIl objeotiomt and comments for t",th this set cf appl.1.cations an{ t.hose whOSQ objections due -:late 1!; Sept.ambeX' ·3.

Thank' you for your. con6idc'!ratlon or: this requos-t.

~ aA,~ /. )-i1_d.A.iz~ 7i-~ Davia L. Martin t w~ter Cl~im$ ManagQr

l'o..fJ}<AI IRRlGATICN OFFICE/DOA 003

o NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY COUNCIL

----------------~--------------------~~~~~~~~~~~~=

1993 September 3

1088 BI&hop Street, Su1t81204, Honolulu. HawaII 96813 Telephone (808) "1445 Facsimile (808) 599-4380

Stat4 of Hawaii co~~ission ~n Water ResourQe Managemant P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, HI 96809

08J2CTroSa TO AND CONKZNTB ON WATBR USB PBRK%T A.PLXCA~XOHB (Public no~ice of July 27, 1993/Comments due AU9Ust 30, 1901) (Extangion to September 3, 1993 requested on AU9UDt 30, 1993)

GBMBlUtL OLTBC'lIONS

We rEd tGrate our general :>bj actions to current COWRM water uso permit application process.nq and deciSionmal<:in'iJ pl:"b.ctices as previouf;ly s:ublait:ted on n.llllerous ocoas1ons (10/12/92, 10/21/92, 12/1192, 6/22/e3, fA 7/8/93'.

spaoxP%o OBJ_CW%OKS

NHAC repres9nta; watar sou::-ce t'egistrants,wate:a:: use declarant.s, water use permit applicants~ and others with property 1nte~e5t in land within the hydroloqic 1Jnits of the sources of water supply who WQuld be direotly ana imm. «iiately affected by the p rop 0 sea. water useI'.

1. Ualapue Shaft 0449-0:

14. (C) Hawedian Home Landi'l uses affected

In its {'inal report. dat(t i July 1993, the Holokai Workin<j Group reoommends that II ••• OHHLig gSmoU§trab1A needs which are currently tied to lands at Hoolehua and ltalamaula through 2010, be reserved first."

Since reservations of wat.r to E&waiian Home Lands have not yet been ac.complisnec.'l, thif5; a:>plioa.t.ion should be deferred until that time. Additionally i m6cht.nisma. fo~ bulk -.llooation of water to the. Mau1 Department ot Water supply, similar to those beinq developed ,for O'ahu, should be in:?lgented, rather than processing each individual county sour;.;: under f:eparatA water use permit applications.

14. (d) Tne Molok.-:d Working croup recommends that ItOthar rights which may exist pe;taininq to aawaiians not residing on DaHL lands mo.st also be honor£dtl (Final Report p.l!u;Je 6) • . .. .

b' .. '

,. -., .. '

.' . ; ~

004

o 'l'he proximity of thQ Ual(ipue shaft to shoreline rlshponds and Loipunawai rai.cs qu6stion~ ot its impacts upon 9roundwater flows which nourieh thQs.e rQsour'~es. Penaitted use of the shatt sho1,:l;1.d be restriot.ed t.o aVt:.1id a·~fectj.ng subsurfac& floWS required to mft.intain the p}'."oducti'litj' of nearby fishponds, Lolpunawal, and l\ec.rohore ecosyatama, a~d :0 honor the rights of Native Hawaiiana to utiliz.e these rQli/oourcss for traditional and customary praotices.

2. Wdikolu W'Elll&. 065.15--01 to -06

The combined applicat.ion for existing and proposed !Souroes 1$ oonfu~ing and requir'3lt.: ill",ther exPlanation before objections and Comment.s can be oomplate.d. SpQclfic items requirinq clarificat10n include;

SOURCE LOCAT!ON

Wh1~e wells 01-03 oan j.$ lot:.'!atad usinq existing groundwater indices, new wells O~-06 oannot. be located except within a 270' elevational range. In orier to assess potential restriotions on use, more detailed locations for t:he new wells are required.

at What is the quantity requ -;st.ed f')'.'om Qach individual source'~ From the eXisting sources comllLned? From the new sources combined?

15.(a) l111pact on'3usto.ino.bl.e yiQld

The entry ot "7,488, OOt GPD" on tbi. line re.quires further explanation.

15. (b) Permanent or Interim Instream Flo~ standards affected

Applicant should specit:1 Which souroes aff_Clt which streams. Pend tt.e.d use shOUld. be restricted to end and avoid any such effects.

15. (e)

operation of the Molokai frrigatlon Syst8lU wa. ori9'inal~y int.lIlnded to be solely fot' the banefit. at Molok:ai Uawaiian Ho~a Lands. Subsequent state legisl.ition Which allowed 1/3 of thQ system capaci'ty to be used for other purposes violCltea t.h~ epirit and .intent of the original e:lactinq federal leqialDt.ion. Thus USQ of ex.:tsting and new sources b1 the Department of Aqricul ture affeots Hawaiian Home Lands UEesl' and permitted use should be restrioted to avoid any such effects.

09/10/93 19: 44 r U.OI<AI ----.. ----------------:;;-o~--.-.---v -' -' IRRlGATICN CFFlCE/DOA

C 0 005

15. (d) other oxiatinq leqal uses affected

When instrecun flow standarols are affeoted, other leqal uses of streams are also affeoted. Permitted use should be restr1cted to end and avoid any auch QffQ,~ts.

16. REMARKS, EXPLA!.{ATIONS

Tne MOlolcai working Group ;t"gQommana&:

III. L. • •• all addi tiona::. watQT s;upply should first be sought in the sector tor whioh it shall be ua;ed ..

III.P, ••• new water 8UJplis~ should he souqht first through conservation.

IV.A.l. The development of new wa~~ raaouroes from the undeveloped portion:::> of tie North.ast sector should be held in reserve to ma1ntain the J9 mgd devQlopable yield.

IV .A. 3. Development beycr.d the exilitinq water systems in the Northeast Sector Should not be allowed, unloss.t ass&essments indicate more water can be w1tharawr without further impacts to the natural ecosystems.

NHAC believes that appllcan:::' Ii x-eque.t for }?X'opos.d neW' source does not follow the Molokai lv.rkin9 croup reQommondations and thus should n'Ot be permitted. H'iwever, we defer our objections to those of Molokai Hawaiian Home 1~nds beneficiaries and of ~he Molokai Working Group.

:3. Laie water Co., Inc. }Jella 3855-06 to 08 &: 3956-03 Polynesian cul tl1ral C~nter Lagoon Well 3855-09

NHAC supports the objectio;1S f1led by Hui MalamD. 'Aina 'O'La'io on AUfJUst 30, 1993.

4. Campbell Estate Well 1957-01

3. {a) EXISTING SCURCE NAME AND STATE NUMBBR

The Public Notice only oovers Well 01, whiJ.e the eo.p1ee~d applicat.i.on is for a batte:,y of wells also including Well 02 and 04 ~o 06. It seems that th{ commission must republi5b this notio$ wibh the oomplete infontation and. allow additiona~ t.ime for objection and comm.n~.

8. QUANTITY OF WATfR REQUESTiD 13. TOTAL ACRES PROPOSED FOR !RRIGATION AND TYPE: OF CROP

One million gpo. for 80 acr(-3S of various unspecified crops works out to 12,500 qad. Without greater specification ot the proposed crops, it is impossible to oompare proposed use with Water Plan ,

.~ ''':0'' ...... "-. _~,I •••• -" '.-."!'.,':- ..

. .. \

~.

oi ,

.~

~ " >,

., : ... ~

'. '" , . ..

. , :'

- 09/1121/93 0.9: 45

o 006 1'1L1 .. .(1<A I I RR I GAT I ON CfF I CE/DOA

o qul0ellnes and to determine it the proposed use ia reasonable and beneficial.

Mahala

David L. Martin, water ClaJ.ms Manager

PC: Maui Department of Water supply state Oepart,ment of AJr1cult\lre R.B. White, Jr. Laie water co, Inc. polynesian CUltural Canter Campbell Estate

JOHNWAIHEE GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

Mr. Dave Craddick

o

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURGE MANAGEMENT

P.O. BOX 621


SEP -9 1993

Maui Dept. of Water Supply P.O. Box 1109 Wailuku, HI 96793

Dear Mr. Craddick:

Commission Submittal for your Water ~ Permit Ualapue Ground Water Management Area. Molokai

KEITH W. AHUE CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN, M.D. ROBERT S. NAKATA

J. DOUGLAS lNG, ESQ. RICHARD H. COX, P.E.

GUY K. FUJIMURA

RAE M. LOUI, P.E. DEPUTY

The Commission on Water Resource Management will be acting on your water use permit application for the Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) at its September 15, 1993 meeting at 9:00 a.m. at the Mitchell Pauole Center, Conference Room.

A copy of the submittal for action on your water use application is enclosed for your information and review. You may wish to attend the meeting in case the Commissioners have questions regarding your application. Otherwise, we will notify you of the Commission's decision soon thereafter.

If you have any questions, please contact Roy Hardy at 587-0274 or Lenore Nakama at 587-0218. .

LN:fc Attach.

Sincerely,

Deputy Director

JOHNWAIHEE GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

o o KEITH AHllB. CIIAIllPBRSON

STATE OF HAWAII

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION 33 SOUTH KING STREET. 6TH FLOOR

HONOLULU. HAWAII 96813

August 30, 1993

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource

BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL REBOURCE

DEPUTIES

JOHN P. KEPPELER II DONA L. HANAIKE

AQUACUlTURE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

AQUATIC REBOURCES

CONSERVATION AND

ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS CONSERVATION AND

RESOURCES ENFORCEMENT

CONVEYANCES

FORESTRY AND WILDLIFE HISTORIC PRESERVATION

DIVISION LAND MANAGEMENT STATE PAAKS WATER AND LAND DEVELOPMENT

LOG NO: 9130 DOC NO: 9308AG44

Don Hibbard, Administrator ?gC) t.~ ;,;'~ (~>

Historic Preservation Revi a Water Use j;iiimitqj Application for Ma~~ Depar of Water SU~~~f for Well No .. 0449-01 . .:"~~;;;~ co

U.::TJOt=a=1,,",~ .... p-';,,"--~..lI6"-_-,f .... :,,-1_0=2 .... :_a_i _____ -----------.... iiii~ ... i ,~~~: --: ......... -l~ Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this applfeat:ion.O'J

We believe that this permit application will have no effect on historic sites. This is an existing well facility. Significant historic sites are known to be present in the surrounding vicinity, but no historic sites are located within this parcel.

If you have any questions, please contact Annie Griffin at 587-0013.

AG:III

, t:..-- "-" o

STATE OF HAWAII

OFFICE OF HAWAIIAN AFFAIRS

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue State of Hawaii

711 KAPIOLANI BOULEVARD, SUITE 500

HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813-5249

PHONE (808) 586-3777

FAX (808) 586-3799

September 2, 1993

Department of Land and Natural Resources Commission of Water Resource Management P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809 Attn: Mr. Manabu Tagomori, Deputy

Dear Mr. Ahue:

o

We have received the following water permit applications. Thank you for the opportunity to review these applications:

Water Mgt. Amount Requested Applicant Name Area (gpd)

Est. Campbell Es t. Campbe 11

Est. Campbell Est. Campbell R.E. White, Jr. Laie Water Co.

Maui Dept. Agric. Res.

Koolauloa Koolauloa

Koolauloa Koolauloa Koolauloa Koolauloa Koolauloa Koolauloa Koolauloa

' Molokai Hoolehua

100,000 1 ,00.0,000

100,000 2,000,000

87, 140 357,000 357,000 357,000 390,000

1,080,000 3,360,000

Tax Map

5-2-06:06 5-2-06:18

5-6-01:01 5-5-06:18 5-5-01 : 21 5-5-06:05 5-5-06:32 5-5-06:05 5-5-08:58 Various Various

Well Number

3957-07 3957-01 3957-02 3957-04 3957-06 3956-01 3957-03 3855-05 3855-06 3855-07 3855-08 3956-03 0449-01 0855-01 0855-02 0855-03 0855-04 0855-05 0855-06

o Water Permit Applications Sept. 2, 1993 Page 2

o

Our records indicate that wells Nos. 0449-01 and 0855-01 through 0855-06 are on ceded land. We have no objections in granting water permits to the Maui Department of Water Supply and the Agricultural Resource Management Division providing that: (i) DHHL's priority for water usage is met, and (ii) water needs of Kuleana users are fully guaranteed.

We have continuing concern over the increasing use of the Koolauloa aquifer system to meet increasing demands for water in windward Oahu. We must caution that water is a commodity in short supply and the granting of water permits for large developments may jeopardize current or future water demands of small landholders.

S'ncerely yours, l~

LM:sk

DATE:

TOI

FAX NO.!

FROM;

0EI/30,'-S3 15: 45 o 5994380 001


A Ns/Iff!Of!! ~T1Q!! 1008 BIshop Street, Suiti 1204, Il00l\JIulu. tiilwilil 96813

Telephone (008) 523·144!i r Ilcsimlh. (ROll) r.ffA <1380

FAX TRANSMITTAL

, .. r , C~~R,~A1~ __________ ~ ______________ __

-----------------------------------.,~---------------------------

.SI i.-tJ :t19

E11~abeth Mftrtin navid L. Martin David C. Penn

Er ic yam~=\l'tlt)t.n

Tina

,-------------------------~-.~----

~ o B

PHONE: (808) 523-1445

Description of It~ms FAXED:

FAX NO: (808) 599-4380

Total Number of Pages

__________ ... " .• LI' .... ·' •• _·a.I_ .. ~\·- .. ·..,,_._~ __________ _

----------,~----,~, --.~~~--'-------------

__ ~~ .. ,. ... _.. .. __ ... , ... --~_.__.r, __ .. _ ..... ·~ ___ ---_____ __

-------------- -,,~~".-----'['h .. 1.1.::v •. 1I11tlQU co.,t .. J.n .. " 11, tu. Q(lcc".""IIt'lnq 'Cran •• l".J.on i.1I nr Ill .. " 1.. .. IJl:oter.t:.d br the IItt(ll'n4y-(!llftnt "net/or the IIttCl'bet work l,rOduCt. priv Uot9r. .",1 1» CONf'IOf.NTIII". Ii; ito ir.telldoltl vI,ly Cat til" U&~ or. tI,. illdivlol .... l v •• 1,l;lty 14ant1rlod aMv ... If 1;.1\. l,,, .......... uf ~hi,", ........ " .. in not th .. i.nt .. n ..... d &, .. t,J."L."e. YCl', ....... hareby not leI ... 1 t,h~t any c1iaae .. 1Mt,J ,'" or dictributlon at tho 1'I"'-"'''''."r1n9 l.iv"",w',.I.('Dt-l<;>n 1:1 proh!"Lf.e". NO "ppUcab'o P.;I,vll'l'ye J ..... J.v.~ r>y tn. 1'111 ""y' " .. ndlI'11 the /1rm .... J1 .. nvlnu docu .. "ntC .. ). It ),O!l h.~ .. ~ .. C!.i\l9d to!. co_.1I,1"1I1:.101\ tn orror, pler.,ul nat ity un { ••• di.t •. ty j]r t.h,p"c,"c (coll.,o::l:/ 1I1l'" t'ot"rn tile D~t9'lnlll~ m .. ""nqQ t.,a "!II CIt the .. I .... v ••• "" ••• vi .. th« tI,l':. fluul,.l-Su .. ~~u'.. lIu ... 11 I , .. , .. bur ... YIIIU tar pont".... '1'h~,'k va..:.

I.

/ 08/30/93 15:45 o o

NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY COUNCIL A NgNpfmr CqmtAJQ!

10M BIa"op str-, Suit. 12Oot, HonokIlut H_aI 8&813

Telephone (ace) m..1«f FecalmU. (808) !5914180

1993 Auoust 30

State of Hawaii commission on Water Resource Manaqement P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, HI 96809

OBJECT lOBS TO A»D COMMENTS ON WATER USB PERMIT APPLICATIOH. (Ptililio notice of July 27, 1993/Comments due Auqust 30. 1993)

I

We rQitarata our Ijen8ri'1 objE!ct:.ions to current COWRM tltater USe permit app1ioation p~ce~$in9 and decisionmakin9 practices as previousl.y aul:tmltted on numerous occasions (10/12/92, 10/21/92, 13/1/9~~ :~~2/.j, $ 7/BjQ3).

w. al;.cP "'«lYe ~1~ic: COllUllQntl;;. on and Qbject:.ions to several of thQ applicationa listed in thit.l noti.ce, particlllarly those of Maui Department of water Supply, state t>ep.rtmant of Agriculturlii1, Lalliil Water Co,. InQ., and Campbell Estate. :tn eaoh ease NHAC represents water aouroe ~egiBtrant8, water UG~ deo1arants, water use permit applicants, and others with property lntereet in land within thu hydrologic unit of the source of water supply who would be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water u~e.

»ecause or the ~omplexitYI im~Qrtanc~, ~nd l~te ~rrival of 80me of t.llese applications to our o.t.tice, we are reque~tiny lin extended rev iew per ioll (c:lS prov l.cled on your memorandum) to BepteIUber :) I

1993, wrnen we Wl11 sW:)1ni't all ol)jeccions ana. comments tor both this set. or applications ana those whoae Ob)€!ct1ons (lue (lat.e 1s Soptcl'lber 3.

Thank you for your consideration of this request.

~~ t1.~ /. h74.,-1.:t;v Jp __

David L. Martin, Water Claims Manager

Ma~J. i DOFAbJ

RECEI't'FD D!~'I:~!oN ;)f'

ID:2435006

0-

~ n·w '~I\N'\Cr:!t4tW~ State of Hawaii

RUG 27'93

PlW,ARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES AUG 6 4 02 r!t~MISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii AUG 6 1993

MEMORA@llM

TO:

FROM~

SUBJEG'T;

Aquatic Resources ForestJy and Wildlife

. Histolic Preservation v ...... Land Management ,.. AI J p,'

Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and EUVlr01Unental Affain State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties

I~ )( /" Rae M. Lotti, Deputy J)irecto~VvV" 0

R~que:st for Comments \ Water Use Pen:nit Applfcarion Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

13:59 No.002 P.03

Transmitted· for your review and comment is a copy of a water u~e permit application for Maul. l.)~partme.nt of WOller Supply fcr Well No. 0449-01. Public notice of this applicatkm will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletul issues of August 6, 1993 and Augu. .. t 13, 1993.

We would appreciate yom review of the attached application and please retUlTI tllls fomtEyAugust 20. 129~.

If you have any (l' .. \I~sdon.s regarding tIlls applkiltlon, please conta.ct Roy Hardy ~t 587-0274 or Lenore Nakama <it 587·0218.

LN~ko Attachment (5)

Response: Contact person:

( ) We have no comments (/f .. We have no objecuoJ:ls (;r COll' .. m.ent8 llttnchcd ( ) Additional infonnalion requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Phone:

7#'K. ~-- '-t<:::(~ J~"i''T(P-'W'"tt"'~ "J.oc,,,;

f,I".,)~r ,.", t-"" C,.[ # .;:.",. T4tJlJ.A::. 5/e~.

.. d /.' C/. ~-"'4--Slgne·: '-+- ..e()~-. __ ._. __ _

~.I \G \ '2. \993

MEMORANDUM

o o State of Hawaii

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii

AUG 6 1993

". ~. '

TO: Aquatic Resources ;:; , .~. ~

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Fo.restry and Wildlife '_1 Historic Preservation / Land Management Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Directo~ Request for Comments _ \ Water Use Permit Application Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

...... , .. C:.·" .. ~. " " .,1 t..r,;.

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit application for Maui Department of Water Supply for Well No. 0449-01. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993.

We would appreciate your review of the attached application and please return this form by August 30. 1993.

If you have any questions regarding this application, please contact Roy Hardy at 587-0274 or Lenore Nakama at 587-0218.

LN:ko AttachmentCs)

Response: Contact person: 51t:ue- Tae>Jdt~ J

Phone:

C ) We have no comments C ) We have no objections c0" Comments attached

77te GM':Jec--I well Sllc 1S..td- /ocu.w t(//fo,lh r/k. ~//a~ /).s:/r,'c-/.

C ) Additional information requested C ) Extende . period requested

Signed: -Z:::==::::::~---------

'" ; ,

.... " .. ,. ....•.

. : .. ~\

Maui DOFAW ID:2435006 AUG 26'93

o RECEIVfD

DIVISION ~"it" '. /HI: MM~,\IJ f'~n.1 State of Hawaii

o ,P~r.ARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

AUG 6 4 02 rrtd~MISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Honolulu. Hawaii

AUG 6 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic H.esouI'Ct!s Forestry and Wildlife Historic Pr(!'~rvaLioll

... /i.and Management ... N" k ,.

Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and EuvirolUllental Affairs State Parks Warer and Land Development Other Interested Parties

Rae M. Loui. Deputy Dlrecto~ Request for Conunents _ \ Water Use Pennit Application Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

9:01 No.OOl P.03

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of n Walp.r usc p~nnJ[ opplication for Maui Department of Water Supply for Well No. 0449-01. Public notice of this application will be published ill the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993.

We would appreciah~ your review of the attached application and plealle return ,his Conn by AnAt SO. 1923.

If you have any questions regarding this applicationJ please contact Roy Hardy at SB7~0274 or Lenore Nakama at 587·0218.

LN:ko Attac1unent(s)

Response: Contact person: __________ _

I\~r, I i. \993

( ~ We have no comments ( ') . We have no objections (~ Comments attached ( ) Additional Wonnatioll requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signod: a J~'"'7-~

Phone: ______ _

• 0 Iy~LP .9J4, C~/V~

DEPARTMENT OF ~; ~a~:TURAL RESOURCES 'lie 8 () COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ~ .. 441.

Honolulu, Hawaii '4J/ (.jc- • /,

MEMORANDUM

AUG 6 1993 4vt,

1iJ rM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties





LN:ko Attachment(s)

Gordon Akita

",;'

rl"li 1,::::)' -Signed:-+ __ ~~~~==~~~ __________ __ Date: ---"oir---~---

. . , J

o o

AUG 5 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:


Rae M. Loui, Deputy Direct

Request for Comments Water Use Permit Application Waikolu Ground Water Management Area. Molokai

-_ ... -"--.. -------

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit application for the State Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Resource Management Division for Well Nos. 0855-01 through -06. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993.



LN:ko Attachment(s)


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections O() Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signe~~~ ~

" , .,,, ~ I I

',: ,,,t;:

, . , o

State of Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources

DIVISION OF AQUATIC RESOURCES

August 19, 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource Management

Henry Sakuda, Administrator Division of Aquatic Resources

Comments on water use permit application for the State Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Resource Management Division for Well Nos. 0855-01, 0855-02, 0855-03, 0855-04, and 0855-06 the the Waikolu Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

The application is for three existing wells and three new wells adjacent to the Waikolu Stream on north Molokai within the boundaries of the Kalaup~pa National Historical Site. Approximately 3,360,000 gallons of dike-confined water will be pumped per day and transferred to the Hoolehua area for irrigation use. The application characterizes the water quality as non-potable, but it seems likely that the source is actually potable. It was noted that the wells would reduce stream flows during dry periods.

The Waikolu Stream should rate as among the most pristine in Hawaii. It drains a large native forest watershed and flows through the Kalaupapa National Historical Site. The State of Hawaii has retained water rights to the stream and diverts water to the dry south side of the island for irrigation use. Wells have also been drilled adjacent to the stream below the upper diversion to add ground water to the irrigation distribution system. The combination of diversion and dewatering attributable to ground water pumping has dried the middle reach of the stream, between the upper diversion at approximately 1,100 feet in elevation and a lower diversion at 730 feet.

Waikolu Stream supports large populations of all the native fishes and macroinvertebrates. Prior to the alterations which created the dewatered section of the stream, all of the native inland fish species and macroinvertebrates were abundant to the upper end of the stream. After the alterations, this diversity and abundance stopped at the point of dewatering. Only one of the gobies, Lentipes conc%r, subsequently made it to the higher reaches through the dry section, migrating rapidly during periodic freshets, but its numbers were considerably reduced and its size frequency distribution was compressed towards the larger size range, reflecting diminished recruitment.

Additional pumps will probably worsen the situation. However, the Department of Agriculture recently stated a commitment to restore flows through the dry reach adequate to provide continuous habitat suitable for both occupation and migration by native aquatic species.

o This commitment needs to become a condition of the permit, if the application is approved. Included with the condition should be a plan for defining how this flow restoration can be achieved.

In addition, DLNR's Division of Water and Land Development has completed a plan for modification of the upper diversion weir to improve the chances for successful immigration and emigration of native amphidromous species. At present the weir not only presents a barrier but actually represents a trap for these organisms. Completion of this modification should also be a condition of any approved permit.

We also believe that a long term biological monitoring program should be established for this stream to define the effectiveness of the mitigation measures recommended above and to determine whether additional steps, including modification of the mitigative flow regime, are needed. The Division of Aquatic Resources has data that can be applied to a baseline definition, and the National Park Service is presently engaged in studies of Waikolu Stream that can be applied to design the monitoring program once those studies are complete. It is possible that the Division of Aquatic Resources could conduct the monitoring program with logistic support from the Department of Agriculture.

We would prefer to see all diversions and pumps removed from Waikolu, given the biological value of the area, but recognize that agricultural demands have become dependent on this source of irrigation water. Nevertheless, serious attention should be given to the imposition of mitigation measures that can at least partially assure the perpetuation of the stream's suitability as habitat for native aquatic species.

· I "_, '4-

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:


Rae Mr" Loui, Deputy Directo~ Request for Comments _ \ Water Use Permit Application

/\UG 9 \993

Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai




LN:ko Attachment(s)

Response: Contact person: ___________ _

( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections (y'))' Comments attached ( ') Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signe~ j<t ;:;;LtL

Phone: _________ __

o State of Hawaii

Department of Land and Natural Resources DIVISIOf\I OF AQUATIC RESOURCES

August 12, 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource Management

Henry Sakuda, Administrator <tt3 Division of Aquatic Resources

Comments on water use permit applications for Maui Department of Water Supply for Well No. 0449-01 in the Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

The application is for an existing well near Ualapue between the Kiinohu and Moomuku Gulches. Approximately 1,080,000 gallons of basal water per day is pumped for municipal purposes. The Kiinohu and Moomuku Gulches do not have sustained stream flows or perennial pools. We have no objections from the aquatic biological resource standpoint.

o ~- P-1t: eN N",'-' - (~ ~ PIl ..

State of Hawaii DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii

AUG 6 1993

'J

MEMORANDUM : ' ':H:~T~,TOR :',~:,~ V:~:'i;N.

'::'V BR

EReM:('O(

SUBJECT:



,~C<; UGT RR. i'HOl CONTROL SI.\' REC. PLAN. I' Fl!iCAI. STAFF r.:'·'HN. ftSST M:CHAEOLOGISTS

.. ___ ~ CiPC:l!.ATE/POST __ . __ C'iMENTS & REC. ." ._._._ P:C'ltT REPLY

_.__ i{E __ ._ FOLLOW UP

''.::-') :<:qmUE_~

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit application for Maui Department of Water Supply for Well No. 0449-01. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and

'i() it I '9..1

August 13, 1993. _ I .. ..:;? n tD. ~ (, 3 77

We would ~ppreclate your reVIew of the attached application and ~~.~ rett!¢ this '" form by August 30. 1993. ,. "'::': C ,:.8

r;:i C) I"'II'J ':.-''', ("1'

If you have any questions regarding this application, please contact~6y Har~at ·:11

587-0274 or Lenore Nakama at 587-0218.'" .. - -0;;:2

LN:ko Attachment(s)

::;;;: Nt ('~1 "·"I'~ . ~ • • i:::J ~~:I):~ en

en

Response: Contact person: fZlr(JTT!2-~~hone: S~7 D11f--o ( ~ have no cojents ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additio a information requested ( ) Extend d r :view period requested

Signed: ______ ~~~--~~--------------

,

o State of Hawaii

b6~ f,

t;J ~ ,F~~ tJe,,-- fIt ~t"

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCE~ E C E , V t: 0 COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENt' .... '

Honolulu, Hawaii

AUG 6 1993 '93 AGO -6 P 3 :05

MEMORANDUM FORESTi,Y;~ WiLLLi! r

STATE OF HAilo\il

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Hi'l;toric Preservation Land Management Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties




If you have any questions regarding this application, please contac~;'JWy Har~ at 587-0274 or Lenbre Nakama at 587-0218. ;::::: S:::~ i LN :ko ;!.~:~ f:':~; _

~~~~ ;:i;i;i~; ...... Attachment(s) .' "

:" n1 ::;") ,,'I'~

" . . i"'" .. : .. ! H' .... "', ,. "'<

!,) ';::' e 1"''1''1

Response: Contact person: __________ _ Phone: --"i"~~':'! :"",,,~f-: _-1;""-'-_C) en

( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional information re uested ( ) Ext ed ested

DOFAW HAS NO COMMENTS OR OBJECTIONS TO THE PROPOSED REQUESt

!tJ.,!Y~ I 0 Date: ______ _

.. ;

'-.l " " ,

o o

,

;. I , "

,~ ,.:

..

JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

o o


COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Mr. David Craddick, Director Maui Department of Water Supply P.o. Box 1109 Wailuku, Maui, HI 96793

Dear Mr. Craddick:

P. O. BOX 621


AUG 6 1993


JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. ROBERT S. NAKATA

RICHARD H. COX. P.E. GUY K. FUJIMURA

J. DOUGLAS ING. ESa.

RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY

Enclosed is a copy of the public notice for your water use permit application for Well No. 0449-01 which will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993.

Please be aware that there may be objections to your application. If objections are made, the objector is required to file such objections with the Commission and is also required to send you a copy of the objections.

You, or any other party, may respond to objections by filing a brief in support of your application with the Commission within ten (10) days of the filing of an objection. You, or the other party, must also send a copy of the response to the objector.

If you have any questions, please cont~ct Roy Hardy at 587-0274 or Lenore Nakama at 587-0218.

LN:ko Encl.

Sincerely,

RAE M. LOUI Deputy Director

.... ,. o o State of Hawaii

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii

AUG 6 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:






LN:ko Attachment (s)


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: ________________ _

Phone: ____________ _

Date: _______ _

o o OTHER INTERESTED PARTIES

Mr. David Martin Native Hawaiian Advisory Council 1164 Bishop Street, Suite 1205 Honolulu, HI 96813

Mr. David Craddick, Director Department of Water Supply County of Maui 200 South High Street Wailuku, HI 96793

Mr. Brian Miskae, Director Department of Planning County of Maui 200 South High Street Wailuku, HI 96793

o o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII KEITH W. AHUE CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D.

STATE OF HAWAII ROBERT S. NAKATA

RICHARD H. COX. P.E.

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES


GUY K. FUJIMURA

J. DOUGLAS ING. ESQ.

P. O. BOX 621


RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

REF:WRM-KO

Honorable Linda Crockett Lingle, Mayor County of Maui 200 South High Street Wailuku, HI 96793

Dear Mayor Lingle:

AUG 6 1993

Notice of an Application for a Water Use Permit Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai

In accordance with the Department of Land and Natural Resource Administrative Rules, Section 13-171-17(a), we are sending you a copy of the public notice for the water use permit application for the Maui Department of Water Supply for Well No. 0449-01, which will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin.

In addition, Section 13-171-13(b) of our Administrative Rules states:

'Within sixty days after receipt of notice of a permit application, the county shall inform the commission if the proposed use is inconsistent with the county land use plans and policies."

We have attached a copy of the application for your review and would appreciate receiving your comments, within the next sixty (60) days, on whether this water use is consistent with county plans and policies.

Very truly yours,

Ene.

DEPUTY

JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

REF:WRM-KO

o o



P. O. BOX 621


AUG 6 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO: Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake, Director Department of Hawaiian Home Lands

Dr. John C. Lewin, M.D., Director Department of Health

Mr. Clayton H. W. Hee, C.hairperson Office of Hawaiian Affairs

Mr. Goro Hokama, Chair County Council County of Maui

Mr. Byron S. Walters, Chair Board of Water Supply County of Maui

FROM: ~h W. Ahue, Chairperso o ~~~ssion on Water Reso

SUBJECT: Water Use Permit Applicatio Ualapue Ground Water Management Area, Molokai




J. DOUGLAS ING. ESQ.

RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY




Attachment(s)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- .. _----_._. __ ._._-----------------

-Memorandum to:

Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake Dr. John C. Lewin Mr. Clayton H.W. Hee Mr. Goro Hokama Mr. Byron S. Walters

Page 2

o

Response: Contact person: ____________ _

( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: ________________ _

o

AUG 6 1993

Phone: ________ _

Date: _________ _

-+ - ..

',/ INIT;

G. Matsumoto ~ ][ E. Sakoda

Y. Shiroma E. Hirano

_ '_ D.Higa - / G. Bauer

_2_ ~ R'l~~~

_ R. LOUI S.KOKUBUN M. TAGOMORI L. NANBU

"

ER\RESOURCE MANAGEMi-

?tJ q~ FILE IN: ________ _

_ See Me _ Call _ Review & Comment _ Take Action _ Investigate & Report _ Draft Reply _ Acknowledge Receipt _ Type Draft _ Type Final _ Xerox _ copies

FOR YOUR:

__ Approval __ Signature

Information

1~-~~

Rut ~ WJI~ ~/ ~ '/to- ?~ NIr 'lJ/~ i ~/r~ ~ ~

~/tc, f t/ltt .~/ozh3

~~~'

"- .. ) I

"""~-"---" -"",,-

0

1993 August 30

0

NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY COUNCIL A NoNPAoFrr CofFoR.\TlON

1088 Bishop Street, Suite 1204, Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Telephone (808) 523-1445 Facsimile (808) 599-4380

state of Hawaii Commission on water Resource P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, HI 96809

OBJECTIONS TO AND COMMENTS (Public notice of July 27,

GENERAL OBJECTIONS

We reiterate our general objections to current COWRM water use permit application processing and decisionmaking practices as previously submitted on numerous occasions [10/12/92, 10/21/92, 12/1/92, 6/22/93, & 7/8/93).

We also have specific comments on and objections to several of the applications listed in this notice, particularly those of Maui Department of Water Supply, State Department of Agriculture, Laie Water Co,. Inc., and Campbell Estate. In each case NHAC represents water source registrants, water use declarants, water use permit applicants, and others with property interest in land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply who would be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use.

Because of the complexity, importance, and late arriva~ethese applications to our office, we are request~n~an extenaed~ review period (as provided on your memorandum) to-September 3, 1993, when we will submit all objections and comment~F-b~ 1S set of applications and those whose objections due date is September 3.

Thank you for your consideration of this request.


,. , o o

TRANSMISSION REPORT ] THIS DOCUMENT WAS SENT

(REDUCED SAMPLE ABOVE)

** # COUNT ** 4

lj.:j(lli SEND *** :':"1 REMOTE S TATION 1. D. START

! I 808 5257448 7-27-93 t __

TIME

3:09PM

TOT.4L

DURATION #PAGES -

2'37" 4 -

0:02'37" 4

I I

COMMENT -

-

•• 0-

] J

XEROX TELECOPIER 7020

... o PUBUC NOTICE

Applications for Water Use Pennits Ground Water Management Areas

Applications for the following water ~ pennits have been received and are hereby made public, in accordance with Department of Land and Natural Resources Administrative Rules 13-171, "Designation and Regulation of Water Management Areas".

Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) Applicant: Maui Department of Water Supply

P.O. Box 1109 Wailuk:u, MaW, m 96793

Date Completed Application Received: June 9, 1993 Aquifer: Ualapue System, Southeast Sector, Molokai Well Source: Ualapue Shaft, Well No. 0449-01, at Ualapue, Molokai, Hawaii, Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:28 Quantity Requested: 1,080,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Municipal for Maui Department of Water Supply Ualapue Water System Place of Water Use: Ualapue Water System

Well #4 (Well No. 0855-06) Well #5 (Well No. 0855-05) Well #6 (Well No. 0855-04) Well #22 (Well No. 0855-01) Well #23 (Well No. 0855-02) Well #24 (Well No. 0855-03) Applicant: State Department of Agriculture

Agricultural Resource Management Division P.O. Box 205 Hoolehua, m 96813

Date Completed Application Received: June 8, 1993 Aquifer: Waikolu System, Northeast Sector, Molokai Well Sources: Wells #4, #5, #6, #22, #23, and #24, Well Nos. 0855-06, 05, 04, 01, 02, and 03, at Waikolu Valley, Tax Map Key: 6-1-1:2 Quantity Requested: 3,360,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Agricultural irrigation needs of Molokai lnigation System Place of Water Use: Hoolehua at various Tax Map Keys

White Well (Well No. 3855-05) Applicant: R.E. White Jr.

3665 Tantalus Drive Honolulu, m 96822

Date Completed Application Received: June 28, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Wmdward Sector, Oahu Well Source: White Well, Well No. 3855-05, at 55-202 Kamebameha Hwy., Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-5-1:21 Quantity Requested: 87,140 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Irrigation of 9 acres of banana trees Place of Water Use: Kamebameha Highway at Tax Map Key: 0-0-0:0

(more)

-.

Campus Well (Well No. 3855-06) Ceramics Well (Well No. 3855-07) Library Well (Well No. 3855-08) Temple Well (Well No. 3956-03) Applicant: Laie Water Co., Inc.

55-510 Kamehameba Hwy. Laie, III 96762

Date Completed Applications Received: June 23, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, W"mdward Sector, Oahu

o

Well Sources: Campus Well, Ceramics Well, Library Well and Temple WeD, Well Nos. 3855-06,07,08 and 3956-03, at Brigham Young - UH Campus, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-5-6:various Quantity Requested: 357,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Municipal service for over 635 residential and commercial service meter connections in Laie Place of Water Use: Laie Municipal Water System Service Area at numerous Tax Map Keys

PCC Lagoon Well (Well No. 3855-09) Applicant: Polynesian Cultural Center

55-370 Kamebameba Hwy Laie, III 96762

Date Completed Application Received: June 23, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: PCC Lagoon WeD, Well No. 3855-09, at Polynesian Cultural Center, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-5-6:28 Quantity Requested: 691,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Provides circulation supply for large scale water feature at Polynesian Cultural Center place of Water Use: 55-370 Kamehameha Highway at Tax Map Key: 5-5-6:28

Malaekabana Well (Well No. 3956-01) Applicant: Campbell Estate

828 Fort St., Ste. 500 Honolulu, III 96813

Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Malaekabana Well, Well No. 3956-01, at Malaekahana, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6 Quantity Requested: 100,000 gallons per day. ·Existing Water Use: Domestic service to 31 homes and Malaekabana Park Place of Water Use: Malaekabana Bay at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:1

Pump 3 (Well No. 3957-01, 02 and 04 to 06) Applicant: Campbell Estate

828 Fort St., Ste. 500 Honolulu, III 96813

Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, W"mdward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 3, Well No. 3957-01, at Kahuku, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18 Quantity Requested: 1,000,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 80 acres of various crops Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18

(more)

Pump 3A (Well No. 3957-03) Applicant: Campbell Estate

828 Fort St., Ste. 500 Honolulu, ill 96813

Date Completed Application Received: June 16; 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, W"mdward Sector, Oahu

o

Well Source: Pump 3A, Well No. 3957-03, at Kahuku, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18 Quantity Requested: 2,000,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Aquaculture (60 acres of prawns) Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18

Pump 6 (Well No. 3957-07) Applicant: Campbell Estate

828 Fort St., Ste. 500 Honolulu, ill 96813

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aguifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 6, Well No. 3957-07, at Kahuku, Oahu, Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6 Quantity Requested: 100,000 gallons per day. Existing Water Use: Irrigation for 150 acres of cattle and pasture Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6

Written objections or comments on the applications for water use permits may be filed by any person who has property interest in any land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply, any person who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use, or any other interested person. Written objections shall: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; and (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits. Send written objections by August 30, 1993 to 1) the Commission on Water Resource Management, P.O. Box 621, Honolulu, Hawaii 96809, and 2) a copy of the objection letter(s) to the applicant at the above address.

421. Dated:


ML-.~ KEITH W. AHUE Chairperson

Publish in: Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993

o ,. .. ~

STATE OF HAWAII 1'-'

REQUISITION & P6. ~ICHASE ORDER

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES ORGANIZATION

NOTICE TO VENDORS

CWRM ~x

FUNCTION AND ACTIVITY

Conditions of purchase are listed on the back side of this purchase order. Please read carefully. Payments may be delayed if all steps are not followed.

Hawaii Newspaper Agency Honolulu Star Bulletin P.O. Box 3350 UOHoIHIH, HI 96801 Attn: Legal Ad

The State of Hawaii is an EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY and AFFIRMATIVE ACTION employer. We encourage the participation of women and minorities in all phases of employment.

[~. HASE (",.,it NO. C41289

Date ___ 1_11_'_1_0_7_2_79_3 _____ _ Deliver Before ____________ _

DELlVERY ADDRESS COMMISSI(lf ON WA1ER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of land IIId NIbnI Resoun:es 1151 Punchbowl S1reeI; RaoIII '121 Honolulu, HawaR 96813

BILLING ADDRESS

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, HaWlii 96809

QUAN. UNIT DESCRIPTIO OBJECT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT

PUBLIC NOTICE

Applications for Water Use Permits Ground Water Management Areas

Publish in Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of August 6, 1993 and August 13, 1993

r---VO-U-C-H-E-R--' AUTHENTICATED BY:

NUMBER

A. FURUUCHI

Estimated

$1,000.00

GOODS/SERVICES RECEIVED IN GOOD ORDER AND CONDITION BY DATE AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE

SFX TC F YR APP D OBJECT' CC

XX XXX X xx xxx xx XXXX XXXX 01 621 G '.arr 044 C 4000 0726

ICfd.

FOR DEPARTMENT USE ONLY

PROJ NO. PH ACT ESTIMATED COST

XXXXXX xx xxx XXXXXXXXXXX IXX nnnnnn ' OC :07,) 1 -Dnnl J)()

1 I I I

I I

I

COPY #1 - VENDOR

ACTUAL COST M R OPT DEPT DATA

XXXXXXXXXXXIXXX X XXXXXXXXXXX I I

I I

I

I

I

I

STATE ACCOUNTING FORM C-03 JULY 1, 1983 (REVISED)

-~. ' ..

o

CONDITIONS - READ CAREFULL V

1. Prices include delivery charges unless otherwise stated.

2. Show'"purchase order number, date, appropriation symbol, and discounts allowed . " ol1'~f.i'nvoices.

3. The State reserves the right to reject any items supplied that are not in accordance with specifications even though payment has been made in order to obtain discounts.

4. This is not a purchase order unless assigned a P.O. number and authenticated by authorized signature.

5. Send original and three (3) copies of invoice. (The Original invoice is required under sections 40-56 and 40-57, Hawaii Revised Statutes, before payments can be made.)

6. Vendor and purchaser recognize that in actual economic practice, overcharges resulting from antitrust violations are in fact usually borne by the purchaser. Therefore, vendor hereby assigns to purchaser any and all Claims for sU'ch overcharges as to goods and materials purchased in connection with this order or contract. except as to overcharges which result from antitrust violations commencing after the price is establ ished under th is order or contract and wh ich are not passed on to the purchaser under an escalation clause.

11.

... -\ o o

11., lin I DEPARTMENT OF WATER SUA9L:Vi.. 6 AID :(1)

COUNTY OF MAUl

P.O. BOX 1109 ,,("': ;\:'."""" ,_,. ''-':'~ H-,' WAILUKU, MAUl, HAWAII 99793-7109 L,~::·., ,k·.}' .. :: .'.";", f 1,;(

RE [ r·: \ .. ,\_~:..~jEI~ r

July 15, 1993

I Mrs. Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Stat.e of Hawaii Department of Land & Natural Resources Commission on Water Resource Management P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mrs. Loui:

Re: KAWELA SHAFT (WELL NO. 0457-01) ,U,}D UALAPUE SHAFT (WELL NO. 0449-01)

We are responding to your letter dated July 8, please find ~ original permit applications mentioned wells.

We apologize for any inconvenience.

Sincerely,

C(;J~ David R. Craddick Director

ab Enclosures xc: Planning Division

"n '11lL_ iliA,! <=11 q J /I,'" . r, .. -.JhinQ~ Jin ol..ir.

1993. Enclosed, for the above-

Printed on recycled paper ~

..... -State of Hawaii

o COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resources

APPLICATION FOR WATER USE PERMIT

J Ground Water or a Surface Water In.tNC .... : PIe ... IInnt in inIl II' tvpe .... MM 1IOmII ..... 811l1liaedon wiUI atUC""""". 10 the eo-n;.eian _ Wdel Ae .. _ ""en.e-. P.o. 80.821. Honolulu. H.w" 18801. ... •• liaedon".,. 1M --.. .... !ly • _fund.1e tIIInt f .. of t21.oo '.Y" 10 the o..c. of ......... Noturll "-_... The eommiuion m.., not ecc ... Incom.'" .. tItIe"n.. FM ••• __ • C .. the Reoul.clon lIr_tt • '17'()22S (noietdlor i.' ...... 1·1OC).4~1. PERMITTEE INFORMATION

, . (a) APPLICANT (b) LANDOWNER OF SOURCE

FirmIN.. cov~1'i or MAu I Firm/N.-ne MAli! BWN'N DrMsrmM r 0' W&tISS",q Cont8Ct p.,.onD..,.I) P •• OOICK ph. Z",·7all, Addr ••• ~ ~ I !ft~ i liSd') "8'.\4" '4m

Contul Pereon _________ aPbl;.,· ___ _ A~r .. _________ ~'~· ________ __

SOURCE INFORMATION

2. WATER MANAGEMENT AREA: ~I.oIjSII6A:Ul1, ..... )p~Ol.Lf...,jlM~GLIU6.u=1A1IIlU.' _________ ISLAND: MCll.C?l/lU

3. (a) €ISTING We:90IVERSION NAME AND STATE NUMBER: 0.,"9"01 VALANE SHerr (b) PROPOSED (NEW) WEWDIVERSION NAME: (e) LOCATION: Add,... SIr MAP Tu Map Key ,S .. 4"h: '28 (Att.ch. USGS map. Ie .. 1· .2000'. end. prop.rlY tax map Ihowi", HUrce loo8t60n r.forena_ to •• tIbIlhod properlY bound.ri ••. )

4. SOURCE TYPE (choClk ono.: C Scre... [i{ ..... C Dlk.-nflnod a Perched a Ceprock

5. METHOD OF TAKING WATER (choClk ono.: C Arteer8n CilW ... "'"'" C DIvenId Surf.. a 0thaI (explaiN

USE INFORMATION

6. LOCATION OF PROPOSED WATER USE: (1f ............ on ......... __ 1oodon. Otherwi .... ttlCluimilerm.p.'

(Il Propoeod UN of ._le: Iillxildnt 0 Ne. 0 loth ..... no .... lb' Ta .... Key: MVLDPLb: (If Iooation of .... Ie OWl' ........ TMIC8. ........... Tillie 1 on b_ of applic.tion' leI A~,...: \leL&put. wAns S'tiTfN\ C/o MAIl! CGlNTY PEfAglmfpl Of k901U,S9fPL't '~

td Jldl Curr.nt Und U .. DIetItot Co'" onea: (aM.'< 0 UrNn 0 Agriouhure 0 CoMer..... C Rur. ~ I •• Current County Zoning Code: ~Q ~

UN\CIPAL --.uI.I~---------------:":'::5":"O-5'-,"-?"-M-:,:--::I::-r\~

7. QUANTITY OF WATER REQUESTED: leM tAQb gaUena per day. """b •• uur ""j ""\lP, PRO~t..(..-T$ 2.00:. "",I) fOil. pw~ $,,\"~ ~ \'I\6L.O~' ~~<U' ZO 16 CD~~"l» fJ6 or ""J'\~

8. METHOD OF MEASUREMENT: rZ Aowmoter 0 ~ C Woir C Orifice a 0U10r (.xplain!

9. QUAUTY OF WATER REQUESTED: &iF,.... 0 ........ Os .. o Pebble C Non-flotlOl.

14. APPLICANT MUST BRIER. Y DESCRIBE FOLLOWING POTENTIAL RESTRICTIONS ON WATER USE: (a) Impact on SUltlinabie yield (7): UALA'" A'YlfMSY!TINl HAA 8 ~61) - ~n "~\I.)I\Tt.-.1.l.VELl)

!:: ~:::lE~_W);'tm~'!'fRJi!!t,r~:::zu .. ~r:s (d) Oth •• xi,*" IeOII UII8 afftct8d (7): _-5ISJ~IL!l"!!Mfl.u::::llilLliuQLI ..... ' ... a ..... ---------(.i Om.'~ permiU. E!S. 1tC.)(7): ..llQlL' _______________ _

15. REMARKs.EK~nONs: ______________ ----------------------------

Gf ................................ . .oft: ..... ____ .......... __ ...... ___ • .,.... .... c .. - .......... Q2 ............... _-

...-.._ ............. .- ... _ .......... ___ .......... c ........... .--UlllllIIAR- "'-----_ ....... ___ ...... _ .......... _ ................ c. , ..... -

Undownlld$:l ~ Signature Signaturt...:_~~-~~-,L;;.;.;....;;.;;.------Oat. oatl ___ ..J&!fe:j./~"L~/t.:f1:z.5~ _____ ----

For Offici. U .. Onlv: 0." Aec .. vod _____ _

~." Acc.ptod _____ _ MvdroloVlC UnaC No. __ ---

Oiy.reion Wortl. No. ______ -St.CI WtM No. _____ _

, ."3193 WUPA For

· REMARKS. EXPLANATIONS (cont'd):

TABLE 1, MULnpL.E TMKI TO USE REQUESTED WATER

CURRENT

..::'COUNTV ...

> . :.ZONING :·:TOT AL :TMK ... "···'CODE ..•. ( 'NET ACRES<:"C;POIACRE" . <GPO

() ,

'" OF TOTAL

T08EUSED

.OVERNEXT

4 YEARS

-, ,

• JOHN WAIHEE KEITH W. AIIUE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII



Mr. David Craddick, Director Department of Water Supply County of Maui P.o. Box 1109 Wailuku, Maui, HI 96793

Dear Mr. Craddick:

P. O. BOX 621


JUL 8 1993

Applications for a Water Use Permiy" Kualapuu, Kawela, and Ualapue Ground Water Management Areas,

Island of Molokai

CHAIRPERSON



J. DOUGLAS lNG, ESQ.

RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY

We acknowledge receipt, on June 9, 1993, of your completed water use permit applications for Kawela Shaft and Ualapue Shaft (Well Nos. 0457-01 and 0449-01). Please submit the original permit applications for inclusion in our fIles.

We also acknowledge receipt of your water use permit applications for Kualapuu Manka well and Waikalae Tunnel (Well Nos. 0801-03 and 1059-01). Please note that the landowners' signatures as co-applicant complete the permit applications and allow the applications to be accepted for further processing.

Normally, one can expect their application to be processed within ninety (90) days from the date of receipt. However, a condition imposed by the Commission during designation proceedings is temporarily holding fmal action on all water use permit applications on Molokai until the end of July 1993 pending the final report from the Molokai Task Force. Tlus may cause your application to go beyond the normal action time limit.

We will be sending you a copy of the public notice for your applications and any further information regarding the status of your applications. In addition, we may need to visit and verify your proposed water source and use sites if we have not done so already under our registration program.

Lastly, we are returning your water use permit application for the Halawa Intake. At this time, the use of surface waters in the State of Hawaii does not req~e a permit.

LN:ko Enc.

If you have any questions, please contact Roy Hardy at 587-0274.

~~~~~ RAE M. LOUI Deputy Director

• 0\ State of Hawaii I


APPLICATION FOR WATER USE PERMIT

J Ground Water or C Surface Water In.' ......... : PIe ... ,",,11ft "* or tv ...... ____ ..................... _____ " die CoINNe"" 11ft W_ "-_ ... ~ '0. ".12'. Honolulu. H ...... leeoe .................... M ........... ~ •• _fuM .... f ..... fM of 121.00 ....... " die eo.c. of UM oN N .... ___ ••• Tho Comm ... ion m .. not ecco .. ~.... .......... For ••• iot_o. col die AoeuIMIIIft ..... OC II7'()221 I"....,.. iolond •• 1 ·80C).4~I.

PERMITTEE INFORMATION

1 . (a) APPLICANT (b) LANDOWNER OF SOURCE

FirmIN.,. COvt-J1'\ OF MAYI Firm/Name MAli! lDIW bl'A'I"'" r 0' wmAS"'L'I Contect P.raonD""D c.eaDaCK pb.21:1,.71\1r,

Add, ••• ~ ~~ '!~ C uap." He.M " '4m ContMt P ..... _________ .cPb:r.;.· ___ _ Addna ________ ~'~· ____________ ___

SOURCE INFORMAnON

2. WATER MANAGEMENT AREA: 'StAYP Of MQU)!lA' ISLAND: M<l!.QlA~

3. (a) ~ISTING we:golVERSION NAME AND STATE NUMBER: 0,*"9'01 VALANE SMerT (b) PROPOSED (NEW) WELUDIVERSION NAME: ________________ _

(e) LOCATION: Addte.. SIt: MB P Tax M8p K.V .5 -,. b : 2& IAn.oh. USGS 1MIt ..... 1· .2000'. and. propeny tax IMIt ehowine ...... 1oMt6oft r.t __ 10 .. tabIi.hed .. rotMftV .... no.ri ••• 1

4. SOURCE TYPE CO .... OM.: C StIe... lif'..... C Qb.4on1ned C Pare... C C.,ook

5. METHOD OF TAKING WATER Ccheok .... : C~ i2W ... ,.,... COIwrted Surf... COdw( •• CII8N

USE INFORMATION

6. LOCATION OF PROPOSED WATER USE: (1f1l1.1III1 .................... - ................. o.MrwiM • ..-limiIarm,pll

(e) Propo,. UN 0I._1e: lal'lxiltiftt C New C ............... .... Ib) Ta M-. Kay: MVLDPLe.: (If ....... 01_ Ie OWI' ....... TYee. ................ TIbIe 1 on __ of "-o.oonl (c) Add,...: "ALAB,&, ",AIZS S'6Tf'" C/o MPNr-CGlOllY PiMgImEpl Qf t.9tm&SUffL't

N/AJld' Curr.nt L.8nd U. DIeatat .......... <.~ C U..... C A........ C eo.......... C Rur. I •• Currone Councy z.-. Code: - __ ~~O~!h.M.,lJ ...... _---------------=~ __ --~:'T UN\CIPAL "'0,,'" 'P'''''P s \~

7. QUANTITY OF WATER REQUESTED: '.6\ tMtb gaUonal*' day .""'~ .... WI" * w"o, t>Ro~i.c..·n 2.~ 1\1\,1) folt. pw~ $,,\'Io~ _ NI.OV\\ ~'Qf' ZOIG CDtMAtlb) 160r "''''-;!

8. METHOD OF MEASUREMENT: ra'Flo..,.., COII __ .I Cw., COrifloa CQdwII.plDinl

9. QUAUlY OF WATER REQUESTED: ;(".... C ........ Cs ... C,..... C No~Potabl.

10. PROPOSED USE: a(MurtlIIIIII ......... hoUM. ........ J 0·.,1611 ••• Qenl..... Clrrio.uon 0........... C..... C 0Ctw ( •• plDIN

Forqu..ao .. 12.,3: If,..,....TMCe .. ifMItved ................... T ..... ' ....... 01., ........ A' 0' GtI~I't. ~~: ~~;:~ :~~E~g:::~~:;:: ::~:~~D~:';:TfA\ MDt~ =~,& \~I~~~A ,.... 'c,.... 13. PROPOSED TIME OF WATER WITHDRAWAL OR DIVERSION: 21 He ., 1 1 t 1 I

~ ........ ., .......... un. 0 p.m.

14. APPlICANT MUST BAIER. Y DESeRl. FOLLOWING POTENTIAL RESTRICTIONS ON ~ USE: (a. ImpRC on S .......... viI'd C7': UM.ANt A'YlfMSY31JtO He 8 ~'I> - ~U. PI v,)/\TtlllD'ELZ

(b. Inltream Flow StInd8rda .~jn: "'~' m~'~_I1.~ m IOAOMMlnlrrU:~ (c. H.w.i.:~~~~llt'~ssi.sS'IY\M' OON\£fA'II(4J;iw4,1f , ,us (d' Ott..xidng .... uaa .".. C71: _..-.SJIlI~A!1J1!CH!!!:IiIU'f.UOI.a·IDI,IoIIc:riJ-_--------( •• 01h. «pending 1*ftIitI. EIS. ItC.U7): ...I!"H;QMIII£.E _______________ _

15. AEMA~KS.EX~~~nONS: ___________ ~ ______________________________ _

lil ......... " ••• ............... -Oft; .... __ .... -.._ ........ ___ ......... c __ ........ a ....... ..-.. _--__ ................ __ ... -.-.-............ c - ....... "-~--- .. -.--... ______ ........ _ ........... __ ............ c ---

undO-(1)d2 ~ Sign.NI • ..:_~~-~~----L;;.~.;;...---------0••• 14/-z..lg3

• I I

Signatur._....;;;;;J~rp-~~~ ______ _ Oat. ___ ~+-+-....c. _______ _

For 0",011 u .... Only: O.lI "ecDtved_. _____ _ :lat. AcC.PtM ____ _

Io4vG,cMOQlC UN' No. __ ---Oiv.,..on wo," No. ____ -

Stat. WtJA No. ____ _

. 4113193 WUPA FOI

6. REMARKS. EXPLANATIONS ccont'd):

-fABLE 1, MULTIPLE TMKs TO USE REQUESTED WATER

.... , ..... , ... :.:.::" .. . .:-.;::~:?

):

.. ·CUIUlENT .. :

::? ·':":COUNTY .. ,

"ZONING

~TMK ·:':·::CODE .. ::} WET ACUS::'GPD/AeU"

o

'TOTAL

. <GPO

o

).

'" OF TOTAL

'TOaEUSED

.OVERNEXT .

·4 YEARS

I I

51

_ r"1

ua:"'llnU Fishpond

•

• INT .... 'QR-G&QLOGICAL .OC-11HO

50 Medium-duty

49 ROAD CLASSIFICATION

Light-duty

Unimproved dirt ====~====

2329000n

21 °02 156°49'30"

....

52'

~OLOKAI

I::>~

HAWAIIAN ISLANDS ~

QUADRANGLE LOCATION

10

2329ooom·1

• INTEflilOft-ol!OLOGICAL SURVEY, WASHINGTON, D. C.-1V70 21 °02'4

156°49'30"

Medium-duty

725OOOm.[

ROAD CLASSIFICATION

Light-duty

Unimproved dirt =========

State Route

U,AL/tpua <;Hl\f!T 0'44q·O, Map of the Island of Molokai, scale 1:62500, is available

KAMALO, HAWAII N2102. 75-W15649.5/8.5 X 7.5

1968

1. s rvt'N"1lJ~ set«les ~ I:~OOO

to"'''' -~!) r(l. I9Jt

no. ,u ,~ ,

"'" ':' :h~ ,.:,1 1,) •

.. ! :~~I

. '. £., I.

."- ".'. ',o}

r !t_lI915 ~ f '~;6 .. ~ ,~"

:~

; t;_

2 802 UALAPUE - KAF'UAL~I MOLOKAI.

..,.

."

'>

,r"·,1,.'rr slf·· .. r1 ... i "J ". r I I Cd.' \ Hi.

, ___ ____ _ --,,-__ '''_N~~=-:::;;:::=:::_

I

I I i'

! '" '.:.~ .. :."

p

ISLAND OF MOLOKAI

1.0 M.G. RESERvoJ

4 c I

"

RESERVOIR A~CESS ROAD 8 16" PIPELINE

/

~PROJECT SITE

c '",I.

C .. ;e: ..... ,

PART IT

\.

<1 •

/

(

.. :-:A. r!'1 > '.~.~' ·1 f., ' .. '

GRAY. ~.

HIGHWAY

,', '1'

- All

e···. PLA

RI1Ee·, ANI CONSULTI Ne: " i

t ..I'"

I .

,·bOC. '.' sCAl

~ ~ • • 1"

.'

----~----

------,------~--------------------~~------------------~~~~~--

Q

,.10..'

e'-o'

F'UMF P1F1NG r-LAN 1!SC. H!'. ,'-0'

-<-:;'> ........ ": . ,~,

" .

I

I . ""1 I .. ,', I L--_""::' __ J

l~pall...'-T101-J TUI-JI-J~ l'

,( !!J...- 1!.1! " I

I l ~~~,~ L. _______ ..-J_ eoTTO"'" O~ SU""'J-!e.L...--o.e'

. ==,--,.-, ~\.. 1 11 A. ... "

.- -,.~~.

.... 01 e C:' ....... ~~, 1'-0·"·,,

· .. e ~ c;, .. C;·"S· ~.~.~, e"e·,.

"'5 .,.., Db

...: 0'7

.. e -... " I:

.5

'"1

15

: \~.

'T7

·,e lei -el -.5

DE-TAl' \loTS

\AAL.A pUf.. SHAfT

fROM f\S' BUlL. T

•

/

w.' 0

/ / ~

/

I., e

,. ~

Il

0...

;' / ~ /

I

~/

i~ .Ij :h

h 1.(

I' • , ~ k

i-I .; ,

~k' 'J·tlll Q.~ . ~, ,- (, . :Po '1 ' ~ ~ II

It} l, ~j

I

~ ~

I

----4..--- ---

/'

/

\

\//

.Y. ...... :.''''':.:.Y. C~·=!It! ey~.'f!: :~,.~ ~"" TH!,: ,',?" ,1D.,,1t!'=L.'''-''= S.,-(A~! S!; .= J::"~

e A':"':" eX.'S-;-",o..-S , .. 1!!"C,"-{A-VrCA:" <\.1..'::::e'iJl.//,e.'Y'~.""'~ $,L{/.\LL ,eE ~E,I, .. ·C\'e~ /!!J"':' T,LIE' c::t:'.\/.,....~/.\c~~ • . \ "'.~ ='-,,'.\':''':' ,fG,"to.1tI:'E,"E'}f c t -''-1= "~E.-r c:~ w/.\.,....

3 EX'S-",r:; G" X~.,...!",~ .!./\/~ --=- ,~~ ,;<'.~ A.r:-~ 1C'~C_:'=~- 'e eeV'.1C:E-~-::

~PUf. ~HAfr fR.ot4\ AS' 8 UIL T

A TANK

Gal. Sleel

e)

'<eQwonlll

Fishpond

o

.. ':~: \ ~--""""'.:'",'" \

I ~ , ~ , ~

-'

\ 1 I , I I I I I I

\ \ , J

''''-'"'

UALAPUE TANK

DEPARTMENT OF WATER SUPPLY. COUNTY OF MAUl

WAILUKU, MAUl, HAWAII

FIRE PROTECTION WATER DISTRI BUTION MAP

UALAPUE SYSTEM MOLOKAI DISTRICT

Drawn By: E. S. H. Dale: July 3, 1978

1"=7;11 ~. Scale:

Approved By: I. ...<~-----Director, Dep. of Water Supply

. ' ..

. . .

! /

I

I /

I

\ \ \

,

I I

)

UALAPUE TANK

1.0 M G. Conc. Res.

.'- . ___ .&.."'_' __ -.J..l··~···· '~:~'~;" ... ': 1: :~<: ..

"

"r ..... ,.

4 800' - 6" C. I. f

DEPARTMENT OF WATER SUPPLY, COUNTY OF MAUl

WAILUKU, MAUl, HAWAII

FIRE PROTECTION WATER DISTRI BUTION MAP

UALAPUE SYSTEM MOLOKAI DISTRICT

Drawn By: E. S. H. Dote: July 3, 1978

Scole: IH:~ ~. Approved By: --?1 <"

Director, oep:otWQfer Supply

I

o

. I

I

I

I

: i ",

, ' .. ).~.

c

o DWS WELLS/Molokai - water Levels

~ Ualapue Well No. 0449-01 - 500 gpm pump Elev. +42.42' MSL (top-of-steel plate)

Feet -39.32 (top-of-water) Feet -44.00 (bottom-of-well)

Water Level Above Mean Sea Level 10/15/90 +3.41' 12/06/90 +3.66' 02/05/91 +3.59' 08/13/91 +3.51' 06/05/91 +3.37' 07/26/91 +3.53' 08/26/91 +3.63'

Highest Level Above Mean Sea Level 01/19/50 +6.05'

Lowest Level Below Mean Sea Level 09/16/75 -2.09'

Kawela Well No. 0457-01 - 300 gpm pump Elev. +37.37' MSL (top-of-steel plate)

Feet -35.26 (top-of-water) Feet -38.16 (bottom-of-well)

Water Level Above Mean Sea Level 10/15/90 +2.05' 12/4/90 +2.04' 02/05/91 +2.78' 03/13/91 +1.97' 06/05/91 +1.91' 07/29/91 +1.97' 08/26/91 +2.11'

Highest Level above Mean Sea Level 02/05/91 +2.78'

Lowest Level below Mean Sea Level 06/24/55 -1.47'

Source: DWS Molokai, Supervisor

o o

-WATER USES WITHIN TWO MILES OF UALAPUE (0449-01)

WELL # NAME OWNER DISTANCE DIRECTION 0349-01 Ualapue Dug Isaac laea 600' S 0350-03 Ualapue Dug J. Meyer 3600' SW 0350-04 Manawai Dug J. Meyer 4700' SW 0350-02 West Ohia Dug J. Meyer 5000' SW 0350-01 Keawanui Dug Bishop Estate 1 mile SW 0351-02 Kaamola D. McGuire 1.4 miles SW 0449-02 Kaluaaha Dug Hustace 2800' NE 0449-03 Kaluaaha Dug Hustace 3400' NE 0449-04 Kaluaaha Dug Hawaiian Evangelic 3600' NE 0449-05 Kaluaaha Valdez 4800' NE 0448-01 Mapulehu Shaft 1 HSPA 1.5 miles NE 0448-02 Mapulehu Shaft 2 HSPA 1.7 miles NE 0448-04 Mapulehu Friel, P. 1.7 miles NE 0448-05 Mapulehu Dug HSPA 1.7 miles NE 0448-03 Mapulehu Shaft 3 HSPA 1.8 miles NE

GULCHES Kiinohu Gulch 300' W Moomuku Gulch 400' E Kaluaaha Gulch 1200' E Kahananui Gulch 2400' W

WfLL NLJ

I • .£. f.1 t Gr

LliCI-ll(N

024<,,-(11 LJALAPUl lUG D35('-OI KtAWAI,ul llUG £135('-02 W[!>I (IHIJ ulH, 0350-03 UALAPUE ~UG

STAlL LlF HAWAII O~~ARTMt:NT UF LAND ANDNAIURAL RESOURCES

f}VISIoN OF WATER RESUURCE MANAGEMENT FEB 5, 1991

YEt>I( DF III

GROUND WAIER INDEX - MULOKAI CODE 4

DRILLER CUoRD INt> TE 5 LAI LONG

pAGE

PHYSICAL DATA MAJ RECORDS AVAIL Al USGS OWNLR DR

USER TYPE CSG GRD TOTL CSG USE ------------------,--~L WIR WIR CHEM DRFT

('4 lSI-AC II IAEA I4~4

(14 BI~,HuP f!>IAlE (14 ~H:YEf{ J (:4 ME Y~R J

CONS DIA ELEV DEP DEP

210357 1~~495B DUG 210337 1~6~047 ~UG 210336 1565£145 DUG 210335 1565024 DUG

IN FT FT FT

21 2(l

19 2U 15 Ito

8 11

lRR OCC DOM OCC IRR OCC IRR OCC

lEV HH ANAL

MANAWAl rUG ~ELL (4 M[YER J 210342 1565C43 DUG 23 21 acc Dec PUAAHAL_ l4 L MARlIN 210336 1565158 DUG 16 19 IRR

KAAMloLA (4 0 MCGUIRE: K~MALU-WA~iAiA-----(07i--MAUrnmNiy- a-'\Ll_)U~J0.

210339 1565111 DUG 6 2f0326 i5t:~23l OU(;-------·-- i;2

... _------- .--.~-----__ 6 ___ .. __ nIH

41 UNU Dec HON ff~~1~~!~). 0352-02 KAPULEI UUG 0352-03 KAMALU OtiC W[LL 0352-U4 KAMAUI rue \-JELL 0352-05 KAMALu

0352-06 KAMAKAN~ 0352-07 KAMALu 0352-u8 KAMALO l'lI( wF L L 03~;2-(19 KMIALU

0353-lH NA[HU Due wt LL 0353-02 KAMALU-KlI'APA 0353-03 KAHALO GUG 0354-01 KAMI'lC-[ t>~1 [lUG

0354-(2 KAMALLJ-~h~l 0355-01 MAKOLllAU rUG 0355~b2 MAKOLELAU OUG 035~-U3 MAkOLELtU DUG

(l3~l-(11 ~ltI\.L,LLLj\lJ

04(ll -( 1 KAN 1 U:LLJA C441i-ll ~iAf'llLlHU ~HAFT 1 0448-l2 MAPULEHU SHAFT 2

044l:-C7> ~'II PLLllllJ :.tl/,F 1 3 OL.4C'-l'4 MAHILlhU ~::!5 t·1A!-'UL Ll!1Ll'UG

c... AUSTIN E (4 T INOUYE l4 [DLAHARA

15 20 12

16 16 16

DOM OCC DOH IRR

(4 ~ 1 A H [\[JIU.L[l 1961 PACIfiC ORLG

21030C 1565246 DUG 210312 1565242 DUG 210308 1565240 DUG 210351 1~65259 PER 8 213 240- 240 UNU DCC OCL UCC U(C

(4 SMIBAHON ('4 AUST IN

210314 1565243 DUG 210309 1~65246 DUG 2103r.9 1565246 DUG

,1.14 14 (114 16

0 15 17 l4 IZ.UMIGAWA (... Jl:l H:ICH 1~7S (DNTL DRLG CO 21C340 15~524~ ROT 6 130 103

l it E>l S HfI f' EST A TE l~ BISHOP ESTATE (,4 BISHOP fSIATF (I, m:'YER E

('0 11 ~lfYlR INC (4 rUSTER ESIATE u4 FOSTER ESTATE L4 F051fR ESTATE

210334 1565318 rUG 210331 1565345 DUG 210324 1565317 DUG 210340 l~65435 DUG

lQl~ CON1L [lRLG CO 210340 1~6~432 ROl 210351 1~65559 DUG 210353 1565542 DUG 210349 1565553 DUG

4

«0 ru~.1F k I ~ TAlE 191/. (3 HAWN HlI~'E LAN['

liWNER 21U:S9 1565613 DUG 210458 1570002 DUG 210425 1564838 DUG 210425 1564830 TUN

05 HSPA 05 HSPA

liS HSPA OS FRlf:L P ('5. H~f'~

STATe UF

DUG DUG DUG __ oUi;- - 48

210412 1564931 DUG 210412 1564925 DUG

20 19 19 11

64 8

17 4

20 2

50 19

19 20 21 15

IJ{)

10 18

5

19

50 21

30 38 21 20 ~_ H

40 43

23 23

24 21

DOH DOH OCC OOM OCC

"5 DOM

UTH OCC IRR OCC IRR OCC DOM Dec

75 1 RR OCC DCC IRR Dec OTH OCC OTH Dec

IRR IRR UNU DCC aBS HON MON MDN

IRR Dec DOM IRR oLC HUN HON HUN MUN UCC ANN

IRR OCC DOH acc

\

l'Ltld"IILI~1 I>4U Jo'I>4LJ 1\i~tl_dkL .... t:..:>UUt" ... I:~

r' f f J lIP. CIVISION 'ER R~SCURC~ MANAGEMENT

1" "UN,. ! A lfR ::" ::.: 9~\CL[;KA i COD [;. t. WLLL

NO lWNER

Lk 1I~ ~ 17.

YltR CSG lLEVAIIONS IN FE~T INITIAL lEST PUMPING TEST RESULTS

[qLD VIA GRO eeT BOT SURF OF SOL

0;:49-(,1 l~t/L l ItU IqS" 0350-(1 ll~l,ur' t~·I:'H C,3!:>(1-(12 ~I[ Yl.h J 035CJ-l13 M~Y[,k J

0350-l·4 ~llYlf\ J (1351-('1 L ~1/11'11"

('~51-(2 U t:LlUIF,L 1 ~2::nTtAUrl.CUNj'C----

(1352-l2 AIISTltJ I:: U352-~3 1 INUUYE

IN HOLE eSG

t'l Iq 15

B

1 -1 -1 -3

:: 3 -4 1 b -:;

6 (I

42 1 ---.---,.-~- .,----.-~-.

1!:l -1 20 2 12 -4

eUT PERF (SG

U352-(14 ClLl-tltkf r::IS;-('J ~lI1L lVI\-.'f·Ll 1<; t, 1 [1 ~'13 -n ;<3 -<;7

0352-06 ~fMeA~U~ 0352-01 ',USIIN 0352-U8 IlUMl~AWA

(l3~·2-09 JLi: kf ICI'

0353-Ul 81SHLP ~S1AIF 0353-('2 i: i SHL,f' UTA I E 0?5?-03 Rl~HrF E~T/ITE (;354 -PI MI: YLI. [

1915

0354-L~ 11 Mb¥lR INC 197~

0355-01 HIS II R t. ~ 1 A H 0355-02 ~USTF~ fS1ATF O?55-03 F~SlLk E~TAlE

0356-(11 H::.HI' !:~lATE 1'?7l> 04CO-ll Ht.Ht\ IIUMi: L A~[' 04411-l1 H~PA

0446-02 HSPt

(441)-0:;' IoSH

14 14 15

{, DC

"

LO 19 19 11

1 -1 -2 -4

64 -H R -2

Ii' -1 4 -]

20 1 Z -2

5U 0 19 -2

-8 1

-11

STAT HEAD

FT

5.0

CL

MG/L

70 610

1.5 1:2

~.o

"2.7

4.2

23

34 150

25 19bO

3P

440 £'2

23(1 310

275 ~35 400 420

4!.O 610

67 38

21

PUMP DRAW RATE [JUWN

GPM FT

SPEC CL WTR CAP TEMP

MG/L C

300 .3 1000 150 2:.3

4P 3.3 15

24.4 ,I

3(10

25 .2 125

800 4.5 178 26

PUMP ORFT CAP MGO MGD

.01

PAGE 1

WAHR SUPPLY AQFR

STAT MAX MIN MAJOR HEAD Cl Cl USE,YR

FT HG/L HG/l

IkR.47 QA DUM,47 :dA

32 IRR,47 QA IRR,41 QA

DOM,47 QA DUM,47 QA IRR.47 QA UNU,73 TB

DOM, QA DUM,47 QA DOM,47 QA DOM,7!? Tb

OTH.12 QA IRR.47 QA IRR,47 QA [;UM.47 OA

300 190 IRR,75 QA lRR,47 QA 01H,41 OA OTH,47 _

IPR,76 1A 1.2 lRR.47 QA

67 UNU,1t7 QA 3.8 52 28 08S,12 QA

21 IRR ,41 QA DOM,47 QA O .... U-(\4 rl; ILL F

04~.f.::-l ~ j!:;!''; ~()i;'tq-ll ~,AU 1 Utl"l Y 1'13/:·

::'0 21

5 4;;---40

-6 131 .-3:-------...,.4-.~I-.....:..6;:.;4=--:1c-::0:-:5~C- ---:11500-- -90-20-:5--'" --. .3 4.0 111

_. __ .lRRriL~ 50 MUN,47 ~ 10"

0449-l,Z hUS I t.L t 0449-l'? Hli~ T ~L[ ('4'0'7-(':' lillwt. t vl ~'l ~ Ll C. (l'o .. C-t 5 VI, Lf , •

-1 -4 -:;. -]

1~5 148 122 1t0

IRR,47 QA DOM.41 QA IRR.47 OA JRR,47 OA

..

"--::-- ~ - - -~-- --=-.:=:------~-- ~.::------ .--- -~----- - - - - - - - -• .

o o ,.

UALAPUE

c H A

... ,,' ,' ....... ;. ,..' ;. ,,~. , . '" I.;, II.,

N N E

"

..

L

".

c H A N N E L (~~--~r--t----------------------------------------------1----------AL-----~-------------r------------~~----------------------~~----------------~~~'-----------------II~.'-~_;nw;u.;a;.~.M.;~~~;;~&;~~;;~i;;;;;;;;.c ••. c;·~-~';.;?O;--:l::~~~ '-,. ..

53SCALEl:24000~? ~I ~n ~Q_~

WATER USE PERMIT NO. 221

This report has been prepared in accordance with 13-171-22(b) of the Hawaii Revised Statutes

requiring a 20-year review of issued water use permits to determine permit compliance.

Following is a summary of permit information, site characteristics, methodology, findings, and

recommendations for this State permit file.

Permit Information

Water User:

Landowner of Source:

Permitted Withdrawal Rate:

Water Management Area:

Island:

Aquifer Sector/System:

System Sustainable Yield:

Water Type:

Original CWRM Date:

Standard Conditions:

Special Conditions:

Water Source

State Well Number(s):

Well Name:

Water Source TMK Number(s):

State Land Use Classification(s):

County Zoning Classification(s):

Geographical Coordinates:

End Use

End Use TMK Number(s):

State Land Use Classification(s):

County Zoning Classification(s):

MauiDWS P.O. Box 1109 Wailuku, HI 96793


0.185 mgd (Based upon a 12-month moving average)

Ualapue

Moloka'i

Southeast/Ualapue

8.0mgd

Fresh

November 15, 1993

1-11, 13-14, 16-17,20-23

30

0449-01

U alapue Shaft

2nd Division, 5-6-006:028

N/A

N/A

Latitude 21 0 03' 51.2" North Longitude 1560 49' 48.2" West

2nd Division, Various

Various

Various

1 BROWN AND CALDWELL Summary Report for Water Use Permit No. 221

o Beneficial Use Explanation:

Background Information

o Ualapue Water System - 113 meters, 94 active meters,

91 active residential meters

Consistent water use reporting records are available for at least the past four years. The

permittee's 12-month moving average has exceeded the permitted amount of 0.185 mgd during

this time. Reference the permit file for additional information on reporting history.

Water Use Permit 221 was approved during the September 15, 1993 Commission on Water

Resource Management meeting. Standard conditions 1-11, 13-14, 16-17,20-23 and special

conditions 30 are the governing conditions for this water use permit. A complete list of all

standard and special conditions is given in the permit file.

Field Investigation Information

Contact:

Site Address:

Keola Yasso

P.O. Box 1109

Wailuku, HI 96793

Brown and Caldwell conducted a field investigation on August 14, 2008 from 2:00 p.m. until 3:00

p.m. with Thomas (Maui DWS -Molokai Supervisor). During this time, type of water usage was

verified, GPS coordinates of well head(s) were recorded, flow meter installation and functionality

were documented, and property TMK information was verified. The wellhead, its related

appurtenances, and water usage area were visually inspected to assess compliance with permit

conditions. Visual inspection of water loss/waste was limited to outdoor areas within the usage

boundary. Reference the TMK and GIS maps in the permit file for a visual representation of the

site.


o

Summary of Findings for Water Use Permit No. 221

State Well No. 0449-01 is located on TMK parcel (2) 5-6-006:028 at 21 0 03' 51.2" N, 1560 49'

48.2" W, with a real time accuracy of ± 13 feet. Water is drawn from the well via a vertically

mounted pump motor and is metered at the well site. One large storage tank with approximately

1-million gallons of capacity is located at the well site and is used for residential/general water

storage purposes. A small booster pumping system is used to fill the tank when needed. Total

readings from this well are sent to the Maui BWS central SCADA system for data collection and

analysis. End use areas include most of the Kamalo to Monui service areas, as well as additional

locations across the island. Reference the Appendix for photographs of the previously described

system components.

Based upon visual inspection of the system, all components appear to be in full working order.

The permittee demonstrated functionality of an installed flowmeter and provided access to the

site grounds where no wasting of water or water loss was observed. Visual inspection also

conf11111ed that water use was within the permitted TMK boundaries. Water use is currendy

being reporting on a monthly basis.

After inspections of the monthly water use records on file, it is evident that the permittee is in

violation of exceeding their permitted allocation. The 12-month moving average of water use

from State Well No. 0449-01 has consistendy been well over their permitted amount of 0.185

mgd. At times, average water use ran as high as 0.28 mgd. As such, the permittee is in non

compliance with their water use permit.

Also, the following are a list of standard condition(s) that the permittee is found to be in non

compliance with:

(10) An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, water-levels, salinity, and temperature must be kept and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis in accordance with the Commission's September 16, 1992 action on reporting requirements.

Since no salinity reports are being submitted to the Commission, the permittee is found to

be in violation of Standard Condition (10).

3 BROWN AND CALDWELL Summary Reportfor Water Use Permit No. 221

o Recommendations

• Address the following discrepancies between the Commission's electronic database and

actual field investigation findings:

o

o

Change permittee contact to new Maui BWS director

End use TMK should be Various

o Create memo field entry noting field investigation on 8/14/08

• Address violation of using water in excess of the permitted allocation

• Address violation of Standard Condition (10) regarding non-reporting of salinity levels.


o

20-Year Water Use Permit Review Water Use Pennit No. 221

APPENDIX

Field Investigation Photographs

5 BROWN AND CALDWELL

Summary Report for Water Use Permit No. 221

o

Figure 2 - SCADA Monitoring System


o o

Figure 3 - Ualapue (M:olokai) Maui BWS facility

'4ifIIIr' ... '. ~4:i·

Figure 4 - Water storage tank


JUL-18-2008 14:31 808.4 6701

Water Use Permit Survey (PInst tOmpIeIe Cllte SlIM)' rann Ibr e8c:h wOP)

808 244 6701 P,02

WUP Number: -;-"'/ -,.;.........:.------ Well Number(s):_(!);:....::+4-=""--I.f:.--....::t!J~/:.--________ ~ _____ _

Contlct Information (of tb, ptrson who ,,·m .... pnn.,., lier "'lilt): Name: /<e.eJI-1t YA1/.r" Phone (for phone interview) •.J; Email: Bat time to reach for phone i"tcrvlew:_...:():..t.7.;..··=-/J"IJ.;;.;,(Jt+I~:.---'.:J~t.la:..oz..p,~et~ ___________________ _

Property latormation (of tile Wlter ",,·/n .. l1loratloa):

Address: t21¥ KANM4b''''''' V H(ffleJ~Y (l1ir(,.ltI'''') City: /Vt1{1I1t?!C&M1 Zlp:,_l...9..;;.."..:.."..:..'tfL-_________ _ Well Localion TMK (list _n if Qluhiple well .. present):,_.;;S._p_6:::.---=():;..;O:..:~~/..II!";.J!:1!::.lI'~ _______________ _

Water Use TMK (list all ifused on multiple lOIS): t!t.(L"l/,"t,=

Wiler U.elWelllnforPlltion: Is the water source currently In use? Yes No o Jfno, please explain: __ ---_____________________________ _

Whal are you currently uslnl the wafer for? (rltlMl'lplc: ''Usc ror 45 1ICI'GS or di\'er~ifi.d I.riculture and 3 residcnce"'):, _________ _ HUIoI/fJ/lltf .... - VitIA'''#. .$''IJr(,.H ~ lS,.rrtAltN7?~ ____________________ _

Is a flow Ineter installed and working properly? Yes No o Ifno, please explaln: __________________________________ _

Do you submit monthly water use reports to lhe Sl.ce? Yes No o Ifno, please ex.plain: __________________________________ _

Field Inve,tlptloa.: A representative from Brown and Caldwell will be visiting wells in )'Our 1m over Ihe next IWO months between the fimes of9:00 am and 5:00 pm. Each site investiption will take approximately 1-2 hours, Please indicate up to three potential days oftht week and 'Ylilability limes fOl' an on-site Inspection of the \Veil location and verification of water use compliance, The pen11lt holder must provide Brown and Caldwell wirh at least five (S) working days notice of the need 10 reSChedule.

Option III

Option #2

Option fl3

Date (M.f): _____ _

Date (M·F):, _____ _

DatetM-F): _____ _

TilDe: 9:00 am 0 Time: 9:00 1m 0 Time: 9:00 am 0

12:00pm 0 12:00pm 0 J2:00pm 0

3:00pm 0 3:00 PIll 0 3:00pm 0

Once this survey is remmed. a 8rown and Caldwell represenlatiyt will be contlctins you to conduct a phone interview Ilnd finaliu the exact d.fe and time of your field investigation. Plelse tilxlmaj, completed surveys by July 181

., 2008 and direct any q'lostlons related to Ihis sUI've), to Mr. Milo Smith of Brown Ind Caldwell at: 1099 AI.kel Street, Suite #2400 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel: (808) 203-2661 Fax.: (808) 533-0226 mcslnllb@brwncald,col11

Rtai\'ed: 7 )\$/o~,."._ J!Dr Om~ilJ Ute Only

Information Updated: ~f 2---1/ 0 S PhOlio InlClView Complele: ______ _ NoIesIC'omlOlllll.: _______ ~ __ --~_-_

---------------.,~-- .. -

TOTAL P,02

o Phone Interview

WUP Number:_=2-_2------', ___ _ Well Number(s):_....:..O_1~4_q_-_O_I __________ _

Contact Name:_..:.-~_tlJ_1 a_L{-'--a_~_r_o _____ _ Phone Number: Attempt #1: Date/Time:_·_...,.f-/.=:.'1.....::.'!>-I-/.::.~-"<.... ______ _ Result: I LiJi- ~.V~.-Attempt #2: Date/Time: ___________ _ Result: ________________ _

Well Location TMK(s):_5=-------=.0_-_O_O_{tJ_·_· _O_2-_B _________________ _ Water Use TMK(s): _________________________________ _

Water Source Address: (0« ~/t1tA1 a HAlQ Hvvj - V fA /q pUV') City: ~C{ II t1 at a ral Zip Code:_--,-q_b 1..:....4--'---=-6 _____ _

Currently using water source? I \ Notes/Comments: M-.u·, ~ - L~'C .. :. ~

Yes '~ No o

How often is the water source being u~ed? . l Daily Notes/Comments: I't-l~ W~ s,.,.-.-.

Weekly 0 Monthly o

How long have you been using this water source?:_1 _______________________ _

Has there been any rezoning of the water source/water use properties?

Have you reported the rezoning to the State?

Yes 0 Yes 0

No

No N/A% Ifno,explain: ____________________________________ _

Scheduled field investigation day/time:_..<...A_'1--f---"~.=.....J. __ /....L'f_,.... __ t_f1O_f, __ 2.'__:~----1f__--------___ _

Notes (Special directions, site conditions, potential hazards, general notes, etc. ):_-:--____________ _

.... c.-ll-n..-..~ ~'" .... ,~ ..... \\ -~ "" &'Y-'t-l..

Comments To Make:

• Although we prefer that you do not change your scheduled field investigation time, if you require a reschedule, you must provide Brown and Caldwell with at least five (5) working days notice of the need to reschedule.

• A representative from Brown & Caldwell will be making a reminder phone call to you sometime during the week prior to your scheduled field investigation.

• It is very important that you provide access to the site at the day and time agreed upon. Due to a very tight schedule, if you fail to provide access at the agreed upon time and/or do not reschedule with at least a five (5) working day notice, a makeup date will not be allowed.

• If for some reason you don't know where your well head is located, it would be a good idea to locate it prior to your field investigation to help make the visit go quickly and smoothly.

c;;-Interviewed By:._-',.....'---,'--__________ _ Date: __ ~+t_').e ___ _ jl·'~ Time:_----' ____ _

o o

,'!, ..... • ... ',I

'.

,... .... ,.·t .. ...... •. ~.\.' l'"

\ , .-..•• ~ • ~ «"':. '.

o Field Investigation Checklist

WUP Number: __ J-._2-_\ ___ _ Well NumberCs):_-"-O_4e-4_Q_-_o-'-, __________ _ Water Source Well Location TMKCS):_--"-S_-_CP_-_O_O_(p_:_O_l-_<2> _______________ ----:: __

Longitude 1S("- ~f ~:Z.." :1 \~ Well Head GPS Coordinates: Latitude: 4'- 0 -;' 5"'. t,.. .. Well Type: .J....y w •. /V\

Currently using water source? . Yes 5 No D Notes/Comments: ~.(.~ .,.,,,\,.c.. ..s"l~t- ,-.I,...<t .r-.. "... .. "-"",

Is there a flow meter installed? Is the flow meter operational Notes/Comments: $C.-A~ st,\.c..-..

. Water Use

.-Yes S. Yes ~

No No

D D

Water Use TMKCs): __ ,,'-A._"'_-U_~ ___________________________ _ Wha is the water b~ used for?----:;;:::--_..-----:::_--,--,..---:-_____________________ _

~ > ...,... .4 G..... t. ~ JI{. A/V',

Is the water being used within the permitted boundaries? Yes No D Ifno,explain _____________________________________ _

Is there any observed wasting of water or water loss? Yes D No Ifno,explain _____________________________________ _

Are the permit conditions being complied with? Yes No D Ifno,explain: ___ ~ __________ ~-----------------------

Other

Photographs of: Water Source Water Meter

Usage Area Pump/Motor

General Notes/Comments:_--"'~=~::o.~=~=1.,...,R"'-\.:..-=: •• c:.. .. -.---:-------.---_-,-_______________ _

~ .. '~ .... t....k-, IH4k sr~:C:::

Investigated By:._--"V'-"..-___________ _ Date: '1/0.(/"'1> Time: Z~ ...

o

(" .. '" \

o

-"."'-.:' ~ ... ,. ",..,,.' ... ~ .

. .' . • ·_·"t ..... ·, ..... lt

.." { ,'~ .•. ',.'

: ...

Standard Conditions List

1. The water described in this water use permit may only be taken from the location described and used for the reasonable beneficial use described at the location described above. Reasonable beneficial uses means "the use of water in such a quantity as is necessary for economic and efficient utilization, which is both reasonable and consistent with State and County land use plans and the public interest." (HRS § 174C-3)


3. The water use must at all times meet the requirements set forth in HRS § 174C-49(a), which means that it:

a. Can be accommodated with the available water source; b. Is a reasonable-beneficial use as defined in HRS § 174C-3; c. Will not interfere with any existing legal use of water; d. Is consistent with the public interest; e. Is consistent with State and County general plans and land use designations; f. Is consistent with County land use plans and policies; and g. Will not interfere with the rights of the Department of Hawaiian Home

Lands as provided in Section 221 of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act and HRS § 174C-101(a).

4. The ground-water use here must not interfere with surface or other ground-water rights or reservations.

5. The ground-water use here must not interfere with interim or permanent instream flow standards. If it does, then:



6. The water use authorized here is subject to the requirements of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act, as amended, if applicable.

7. The water use permit application and submittal, as amended, approved by the Commission at its <Insert Date>meeting are incorporated into this permit by refer~nce.

8. Any modification of the permit terms, conditions, or uses may only be made with the express written consent of the Commission.

Variations of Standard Condition (8) are as follows: 1. Modification of any permit condition shall be approved by the Commission.

Modification of any permit condition without notification may result in the revocation of the water use permit.

9. This permit may be modified by the Commission and the amount of water initially granted to the permittee may be reduced if the Commission determines it is necessary to:

a. Protect the water sources (quantity or quality); b. Meet other legal obligations including other correlative rights; c. Insure adequate conservation measures; d. Require efficiency of water uses; e. Reserve water for future uses, provided that all legal existing uses of water as

of June, 1987 shall be protected; f. Meet legal obligations to the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, if

applicable; or g. Carry out such other necessary and proper exercise of the State's and the

Commission's police powers under law as may be required.

Prior to any reduction, the Commission shall give notice of its proposed action to the permittee and provide the permittee an opportunity to be heard

10. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure monthly withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, salinity, temperature, and pumping times must be kept and reported to the Commission on Water Resource Management on forms provided by the Commission on a monthly basis (attached).

Variations of Standard Condition (10) are as follows: 1. The applicant shall keep monthly pump age estimates to be submitted

annually to the Commission. 11. An approved flowmeter(s) need not be installed to measure monthly

withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, salinity, temperature, and pumping times must be kept and reported to the Commission on Water Resource Management on forms provided by the Commission on a yearly basis (attached).

ill. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, water-levels, salinity, and temperature must be kept and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis in accordance with the Commission's September 16, 1992 action on reporting requirements.

1v. Approved flowmeters must be installed to measure monthly withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals must be kept and reported to the Commission on Water Resource Management on a monthly basis.

v. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure monthly withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, salinity, temperature, and pumping times must be kept and reported to the Commission on Water Resource Management on forms provided by the Commission on a quarterly /yearly basis (attached).

Vl. An approved flowmeter shall be installed to measure water withdrawls v11. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals; and a

record of the withdrawals must be kept and reported to the Deparment of

o Land and Natural Resources, Division of Water and Land Development, P.O. Box 373, Honolulu, HI 96809, on a monthly basis.

Vlll. Although not stated as a condition of the permit § 13-168-7 HAR requires you to keep a record of your monthly total pumpage, water level, salinity, and water temperature. This information must be submitted to the Commission on a regular monthly basis using the enclosed water use report form.

lX. An approved flowmeter shall be installed and the withdrawal from Well 1851-73 shall be recorded and reported to DLNR on a monthly basis by the owner and/or operator of the well.

x. The withdrawals from these wells shall be recorded and reported to the DLNR on a monthly basis by the BWS.

Xl. The applicant shall provide and maintain an approved meter or other appropriate device or means for measuring and reporting water usage on a monthly basis.

xu. The applicant shall provide and maintain an approved meter or other appropriate device or means for measuring and reporting total water usage. Water usage shall be measured on a monthly basis and reported to the Commission.

X111. The applicant shall provide and maintain an approved meter or other appropriate device or means for measuring and reporting total water usage. Water usage shall be measured on a monthly basis and reported to the Commission along with water level and salinity measurements.

11. This permit shall be subject to the Commission's periodic review of the <Aquifer> Aquifer System's sustainable yield. The amount of water authorized by this permit may be reduced by the Commission if the sustainable yield of the <Aquifer> Aquifer System, or relevant modified aquiferes), is reduced.

12. A permit may be transferred, in whole or in part, from the permittee to another, if: a. The conditions of use of the permit, including, but not limited to, place,

quantity, and purpose of use, remain the same; and b. The Commission is informed of the transfer within ninety days.

Failure to inform the department of the transfer invalidates the transfer and constitutes a ground for revocation of the permit. A transfer, which involves a change in any condition of the permit, including a change in use covered in HRS § 174C-57, is also invalid and constitutes a ground for revocation.

13. The uses(s) authorized by law and by this permit do not constitute ownership rights.

14. The permittee shall request modification of the permit as necessary to comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances that will affect the permittee's water use.

15. The permittee understands that under HRS § 174C-58(4), that partial or total nonuse, for reasons other than conservations, of the water allowed by this permit for a period of four (4) continuous years or more may result in a permanent revocation as to the amount of water not in use. The Commission and the permittee may enter

o into a written agreement that, for reasons satisfactory to the Commission, any period of nonuse may not apply towards the four-year period. Any period of nonuse which is caused by a declaration of water shortage pursuant to section HRS § 17 4C-62 shall not apply towards the four-year period or forfeiture.

16. The permittee shall prepare and submit a water shortage plan within 30 days of the issuance of this permit as required by HAR § 13-171-42(c). The permittee's water shortage plan shall identify what the permittee is willing to do should the Commission declare a water shortage in the <Aquifer>Ground-Water Management Area.

17. The water use permit shall be subject to the Commission's establishment of instream standards and policies relating to the Stream Protection and Management (SP AM) program, as well as legislative mandates to protect stream resources.

18. The permittee understands that any willful violation of any of the above conditions or any provisions of HRS § 17 4C or HAR § 13-171 may result in the suspension or revocation of this permit.

19. Special conditions in the attached cover transmittal letter or attached exhibits are incorporated herein by reference.

20. If the ground-water source does not presently exist, the new well shall be completed, i.e. able to withdraw water for the proposed use on a regular basis, within twentyfour (24) months from the date the water use permit is approved.

Variations of Standard Condition (20) are as follows: 1. The permit may be revoked if work is not started within six months of the

date of issuance or if work is suspended or abandoned for six months. The work proposed in the permit application shall be completed within two years from the date of permit issuance.

21. This permit may not be transferred or the use rights granted by this permit sold or in any other way alienated. Pursuant to HRS § 174C-59 and the requirements of Chapter 174C, the Commission on Water Resource Management has the authority to allow the transfer of the permit and the use rights granted by this permit in a manner consistent with HRS § 174C-59. Any such transfer shall only occur with the Commission's prior express written approval. Any sale, assignment, lease, alienation, or other transfer of any interest in this permit shall be void.

22. The water use permit granted shall be an interim water use permit, pursuant to HRS § 174C-50. The final determination of the water use quantity shall be made within five (5) years of the filing of the application to continue the existing use.

23. The water use permit shall be issued only after agricultural review.

24. That scheduled adjustments to Oahu Sugar Co. permitted use shall be initiated upon discontinuance of agricultural uses.

o

25. The issuance of this permit was approved by the Commission on Water Resource Management at its meeting on <Insert Date>.

26. The permit shall be subject to the review by the Attorney General.

27. The permit holder may be required to relinquish this permit at any time or specified time after issuance to the Board of Land and Natural Resources in accordance with Chapter 166 of Title 13.

28. The applicant shall obtain the necessary land acquisition documents from the Hawaii Housing Authority.

o

Special Conditions List

1. Should an alternate permanent source of water be found for this use, then the Commission reserves the right to revoke this permit, after a hearing.

2. In the event that the tax map key at the location of the water use is changed, the permittee shall notify the Commission in writing of the tax map key change within thirty (30) days after the permittee receives notice of the tax map key change.

3. The applicant shall contact the Environmental Management Division, State Department of Health, at 586-4304, concerning "GUIDELINES APPLICABLE TO GOLF COURSES IN HAWAII" date <Insert Date & Version #>.

4. Standard Condition 10 is emphasized, to report consumption on a regular basis.

5. The applicant may continue this existing use of ground water within the limits approved by the Commission, and the actual issuance of the interim permit shall not be a reason to interrupt this existing use.

6. This interim water use permit shall cease to become interim and shall be subject to HRS § 174C-55 upon administrative review of the quantity within five (5) years, provided that all conditions of the use (including the review of the quantity which shall not be greater than the amount initially granted) remain the same. Enforcement of the allocation limit shall be stayed pending staffs review and issuance of a permanent water use permit.

7. As-built drawings of the well and pump, and a complete pumping test record shall be submitted within sixty (60) days.

8. In the event the pump tests show that aquifer boundary conditions do not support the requested withdrawals, the Commission reserves the right to amend this permit, after a hearing, to a level that is supported by the pump tests.

9. The existing use may be continued within the levels approved by the Commission, and the actual issuance of the permit document shall not be a reason to interrupt the approved level of use.

10. The filing of an application by Kukui, Inc. for a new or modified water use permit for the Kualapuu Aquifer in excess of 2.0 mgd (total system withdrawal) shall be just cause for re-consideration of this interim permit by the Commission

11. Upon completion of a new transmission line for the transport of water use by Well #17, the permit shall be modified to reduce the allocation amount by the additional 79,220 gallons per day allocated for use of the Molokai Irrigation System.

12. Within six (6) months from the date of approval of a water use permit for the well, the applicant shall conduct a feasibility study and submit a report describing

o alternative sources of nonpotable water for irrigation uses at the resort area. It is suggested that the developer consider use of dual lines in the subdivisions so that effluent may be used in the existing reuse system. Another consideration is the development of brackish water wells in the Kaluakoi Aquifer system for mixing with the effluent generated at the resort.

13. Within six (6) months from the date of approval of a water use permit for the well, the application shall evaluate the filter back discharges into Kakaako Gulch to determine if excessive preventable waste is occurring and identify possible measures to eliminate or reduce such waste. The evaluation shall be conducted in cooperation with the Commission staff and staff of the Department of Health's Safe Drinking Water Branch, which regulates the drinking water system.

14. Within six (6) months from the date of approval of a water use permit for the well, the applicant shall 1) implement a leakage control and detection system and compete repairs to prevent such leakage and 2) implement use of xeriscaping and low-flow fixtures.

15. Action on the future use portion of the water use permit application for Well #17 (Well No. 0901-01) is deferred pending the establishment of existing uses in the aquifer. Kukui Inc.'s application for uses in excess of those uses existing on July 15, 1992 will be considered "new" uses and will be taken up by the Commission as soon as other existing use applications have been decided. In the interim,

a. The Commission shall recognize that there is disagreement between the applicant's staff calculations of reasonable-beneficial existing use

b. The Applicant will have the burden of proof to show within six (6) months reasonable-beneficial existing use calculations that support the applicant's request as opposed to staffs calculations.

c. The Commission's enforcement of the approved existing use allocation will be suspended for six (6) months.

16. The permittee shall submit a notice of intent and written request to continue the use at least ninety (90) days prior to the expiration of the interim five-year permit.

17. The Commission shall delegate to Maui Department of Water Supply the authority to allocate the use of water for municipal purposes, as provided in §174C-48(b).

18. Maui Department of Water Supply shall be exempt from the requirements for permit modifications, as provided in§174C-57(c).

19. The permittee must meter water use and monitor chloride concentrations on a monthly basis and submit monthly reports of water use and chloride concentrations to the Commission.

20. Standard Condition 16 is waived for saltwater wells.

21. The permit will be revoked if (1) stream monitoring shows that pumping the well reduces stream flow, or (2) the electromagnetic resistivity survey indicates that the

well was drilled into a dike compartment, unless the applicant submits a petition for an amendment to the interim instream flow standard with the well completion report. However, no use of the water may be made without a Pump Installation Permit, which cannot be issued during consideration of the amendment of the interim instream flow standard.

22. The applicant shall present the results of the electromagnetic resistivity survey, pump tests, and stream monitoring to a community meeting as well as to the Commission.

23. A final determination of water use quantity shall be made within five (5) years of the filing date of the application «Insert Date» to continue existing use.

24. The applicant shall implement, by December 31, 1995, a biological and hydraulic monitoring program for a minimum 2-year period that: 1) documents the existing operating procedure, 2) seeks to identify the impacts of all operating alternatives on Waikolu Stream, and 3) seeks to identify the effectiveness of weir modifications (Dam No.1). This program shall incorporate the three new wells, Wells #4-6 (Well Nos. 0855-06, -05, &-04, respectively), which may be pumped within the approved limits, for monitoring and testing purposes only. Further, semi-annual reports summarizing data and preliminary findings shall be submitted to the Commission. It is suggested that the Department of Agriculture work with the State Division of Aquatic Resources and other affected agencies to prepare the monitoring program in light of the difficult technical questions raised by this application. A particular concern is the coordination of this monitoring program with the ongoing National Park Service study by Anne Brasher. A draft of this plan shall be submitted to the Commission staff within ninety (90) days for technical review and comment. Results of the monitoring program shall be used to make recommendations to the Commission on any additional use of the wells, and shall be made readily available to all interested parties.

25. That the Commission approves the well construction permit for the KamiloloaWaiola Well (Well No. 0759-01), subject to the standard well construction conditions and the special conditions for the pumping well for the aquifer tests.

26. That the Commission authorizes the Chairperson to approve and issue a pump installation permit upon acceptance of adequate pump test result, subject to the standard pump installation conditions.

27. Should the well be used for back-up domestic supply, applicant is advised to contact DOH or otherwise ensure safe drinking water quality is maintained.

28. The applicant shall follow the agreed monitoring plan.

29. If pesticides used by the applicant are found in ground or surface water and can be traced to the applicant's use, the CWRM may revoke the permit immediately upon such finding.

o 30. Issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for

DHHL is set by rule. Applicant may continue this existing use within the approved limits.

31. The applicant shall submit well modification and pump installation permit applications for administrative approval by chairperson prior to beginning any work required to complete well.

32. Should any stream flow impacts result from use, petition to amend interim instream flow standards shall be submitted.

33. Should any dewatering result from use, pumping shall cease immediately.

34. Shall submit accurate schematic diagram of distribution system for the battery of 5 wells.

35. Shall be subject to a 6-month independent audit & monitoring.

36. Final pump capacity shall be determined from pump test results & approved administratively by signature of chair.

37. The permittee shall seek and submit to the Commission within ninety (90) days written confirmation from the Department of Land Utilization of the nonconforming use.

38. Pumping shall cease immediately if the chloride reports show that the brackish water developed in the well exceeds 1,000 mg/l of chloride, unless a variance from the chloride limit has been granted. The authority to approve future variance requests is delegated to the chairperson.

39. The duration of the interim permit shall be: a. To July 1,2006, or b. Until treated wastewater is available and acceptable for use, or c. Until such time that a significant change in permitted, actual, or projected

uses or water supply occurs.

40. Action on any interim permit may be initiated by the Commission or any permittee upon letter request or pursuant to §174C-57 Haw. Rev. Stat. (Modification of permit terms).

41. This permit is approved under the assumption that wastewater will become available for reuse as an alternative supply source.

42. Require adherence to the chloride sampling protocol and the submittal of weekly chloride data. The authority to approve variances from the weekly reporting requirement is delegated to the Chairperson.

43. Require adherence to the Conservation Conditions.

o

44. In the event a water shortage is declared by the Commission, permittees in the <Insert Aquifer Sytem> shall comply with the <Insert Aquifer System> water shortage plan adopted by the Commission.

45. The permittee shall contact the Department of Health, Clean Water Branch and obtain the necessary discharge permit(s).

46. Permit shall be interim and replaces existing WUP for 2051-07 & 11.

47. Applicant shall submit an acceptable archaeological inventory survey report to DHP. If historic sites affected, a plan to mitigate these affects must be accepted by DHP and completed by applicant.

48. Should the well be used for back-up domestic supply, applicant is advised to contact DOH or otherwise ensure safe drinking water quality is maintained.

49. (The permittee) may report monthly pump age on yearly basis.

50. Prior to issuance of any permits, must submit filing fee for after-the-fact pump installation permit.

51. The term of this permit shall be twenty years from the date of issuance of the permit with a five-year Board review to determine compliance with the provisions of the permit.

52. The amount of water to be withdrawn under this permit shall be 0.19 mgd, averaged annually, for irrigation use. This permitted use of 0.19 mgd when added to a preserved use of 0.27 mgd amounts to a total of 0.46 mgd, averaged annually, which may be withdrawn from well 1646-01.

53. The use authorized by the permit must not interfered substantially and materially with existing individual household uses and existing uses.

54. The use of this well shall be subject to the shortage and emergency powers of the Board of Land and Natural Resources (BLNR).

55. This permit may be suspended or revoked, in accordance with Chapter 166.

56. The permit holder may be required to relinquish this permit to BLNR, in accordance with Chapter 166

57. The withdrawal from Well 1646-10 shall be recorded and reported to DLNR on a monthly basis by the permittee.

58. In the event that emergency water use occurs, the permittee shall notify the Commission in writing within one (1) day of pumping, to in form the Commission as to the nature of the emergency and the expected duration of the emergency. A water

o use report shall also be filed pursuant to Standard Condition 10 and Administrative Rule 13-168-7.

59. Note DOH's requirements related to non-potable water systems (attached to original permit).

60. Standard Condition 16 requiring the submittal of a water shortage plan is waived.

61. All non-potable spigots and piping shall be clearly labeled as "DO NOT DRINK, NON-POTABLE" to prevent direct human consumption.

62. Standard Condition 10 is modified. Due to the inability to take water level measurements, the requirement to measure monthly water levels is waived. In addition, as long as the U.S. Geological Survey is collecting and analyzing the chloride content of the well water, the requirement for the permittee to measure and report chlorides is also waived.

63. Well elevation components must be surveyed by a licensed surveyor and this information must be submitted to commission prior to issuance of permanent permit.

64. The permittee shall obtain approvals from the Department of Health and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency prior to use of the water.

65. This water use permit, WUP No. <Insert #>, shall supersede WUP No. <Insert #>.

66. WUP No. <Insert #> is revoked

67. Standard Condition 17 is waived.

68. Standard Condition 22 for interim water use permits shall not apply.

69. To supplement our records, we request that you provide a map of the Galbraith Est. lands west of Wahiawa (2100 ac+-) and the associated TMK's for use area.

70. Deferred action on portion requested for golf course irrigation pending further refinement of irrigation requirement and a feasibility study for utilization of surface water sources, including Wahiawa Reservoir.

71. Written justification be provided for any 'cushion' of 0.5 mgd.

72. The water use permit shall be an interim permit. The duration of the interim permit shall be until treated wastewater is available and acceptable for use. The permittee shall continue discussions with Honolulu Board of Water Supply regarding the use of reclaimed water.

73. The permittee is put on notice that this is a qualified approval in that this permit may be modified or revoked prior to the expiration of the interim permit if the

o Commission decides that the use of additional basal ground water for dust control and landscape irrigation is not reasonable-beneficial use.

74. The permittee encouraged to use drought-tolerant landscaping to conserve water.

75. Should the applicant provide written evidence that the county DHCD approves a 201E exemption for the elderly affordable housing project then the applicant may modify a corresponding portion of their existing aquacultural use to be used by the exemption approved project within the Commission approved water use permit limits under recommendation 5.

76. The applicant shall obtain a water lease/permit from Land Division prior to actual use of the well water.

77. Require the permittee to sign a contract by May 14, 1998 with the City Department of Wastewater Management to buy and use 0.400 mgd ofR-1 water for a corresponding reduction in allocation for Well Nos. 1900-02, 17 to 20, and 1901-03.

78. Standard Condition 9 is waived.

79. Standard Condition 10 is modified to exempt the permittee from monthly measurements of salinity and temperature.

80. Standard Condition lOis waived.

81. Applicant must seek a determination from BLNR and Land Mgt Divas to whether' water license required. If required, license must be obtained prior to issuance of permit. If not, permit will be issued w / out further action.

82. Commission defers action on use in excess of 452,000 gpd pending additional info from BWS and further staff analysis.

83. The permit shall be subject to the Commission's sustainable yield review by December 1990.

84. The Commission shall delegate to the Honolulu Board of Water Supply the authority to allocate the use of water for municipal purposes, in accordance with §174C-48(b) HRS.

85. Honolulu Board of Water Supply shall be exempt from the requirements of permit modifications as provided in §174C-57.

86. BWS must participate in discussions, to be coordinated by Commission Staff, regarding a monitoring program to address impacts to Kaneohe Bay water quality, prior to any action on applications for future municipal uses.

87. A pump installation permit application must be made and approved prior to the installation of a permanent pump.

o

88. The water withdrawn shall be 0.7 mgd for municipal use.

89. The installed pump capacity of the well shall not be more than 700 gpm or 1.01 mgd.

90. The term of permit shall automatically expire twelve months from the date of Issuance.

91. The Honolulu Board of Water Supply may continue to submit monthly water data on their own form, provided that the data are submitted in a format that is acceptable to the Commission staff.

92. Standard Condition 7 shall not apply.

93. Standard Condition 22 shall not apply.

94. Standard Condition lOis modified to exempt the permittee from monthly measurements of salinity and temperature.

95. This permit shall be subject to conditions providing for stream restoration if the Commission determines that additional water should be returned to the streams.

96. HECO 1 mgd for industrial use

97. Campbell Estate 1 mgd for municipal use through BWS, by separate agreement with HECO

98. BWS 1 mgd for municipal use.

99. The permit shall be subject to the Commission's sustainable yield review by <Insert Date>.

100. The applicant shall obtain the current version of the Department of Health's Guidelines Applicable to Golf Courses in Hawaii. Where relevant and viable, items of the guidelines should be implemented and sustained appropriately. To obtain the current version, contact the Safe Drinking Water Branch, Environmental Management Division at 808-586-4258 (Honolulu).

101. The future use portion of the application shall be deferred until existing uses in the Koolauloa area are established.

102. The water to be withdrawn under this permit shall be a total of 0.03 mgd (0.02 mgd preserved plus an additional 0.01 mgd permitted use), averaged annually, for domestic and irrigation use

103. Existing well 1851-09 shall be properly sealed by a licensed drilling contractor. A well modification permit application, enclosed, shall be submitted to the Department for approval of the well sealing. A filing fee for sealing the well will not be required.

o

104. The permittee is required to test the source using a certified private laboratory and submit the test results to the Commission within three (3) months. The Commission will then forward the results to the Department of Health for their review. The Department of Health recommends that the well be routinely tested for microbiological and chemical parameters thereafter.

105. The permittee is required to submit a completed Registration of Well and Declaration of Water use by <Insert Date>.

106. The permitee shall contact the Department of Health for a written determination on the status of their water system and comply with any Department of Health requirements for monitoring and testing.

107. In the event that the original spring source decontaminates, the new well authorized will be shut down.

108. That within each aquifer the total permitted use shall not exceed the sustainable yield.

109. That any water available for allocation shall be for in-district use.

110. That scheduled reductions to Oahu Sugar Co. permitted use shall be initiated upon final termination of an Osco lease or sub-lease, whichever occurs later.

111. That permits for water use issued in accordance with the proposed schedule shall be interim permits subject to review and adjustment by 1995.

112. That the permit shall be an interim permit for a new use which is afforded to existing users as specified in §13-171-20.

113. That the original allocation of 0.200 mgd shall be taken to hearing for possible revocation at a later date to complete the transfer of the water use permit entirely to Well No. 3407-02. This revocation would reduce the current allocation afforded to the Kunihiro Well (Well No. 3406-06) to zero.

114. This allocation incorporates the unspecified domestic needs of the applicant and therefore necessitates a single meter be installed at the well.

115. Should any impacts to nearby wells or streams be established by the use of this well, the applicant shall address these issues to the satisfaction of the Commission.

116. If an economically feasible nonpotable source is identified, the applicant shall convert to the alternative nonpotable source.

117. The permit shall be subject to the Chairperson's approval of a water use plan recommending possible measures to prevent or minimize saltwater contamination and establish courses of action to follow should the aquifer become to saline to use.

o o

118. Permittee shall provide the necessary end-use information on the 10th residence to allow regulation of the use under Chapter 174C.

119. Standard Conditions 10 & 18 shall not apply.

120. Standard Condition 10 is modified to exempt the permittee from the requirement to install a flowmeter. Salt water withdrawals may instead be estimated based on pumping capacity and run time.

121. The applicant shall review the existing year long period of pump age and stramflow data and provide analysis on ground and surface water interaction. Deadline is January 25, 1994.

122. The water use permit for Well Nos. 2301-27 to -32 for 0.75 mgd (WUP No. 419) shall be revoked upon issuance of a pump installation permit for the well.

123. The permittee shall use mulching to decrease evaporative losses and manage irrigation scheduling to minimize water demand.

124. The permittee shall submit a detailed agricultural plan to support any future water use permit application for increased agricultural use at this parcel.

125. If not already obtained, the permittee shall seek and obtain any necessary permits from the Department of Health for the proposed discharge to Malaekahana Stream.

126. Standard Condition 10 is modified to waive the requirement for installing a water meter on Well Nos. 2358-21, 22, and 29. The permittee shall install a water meter on Well No. 2358-26 to measure total monthly flow through the discharge line. This quantity should then be assumed to be the rate of natural flow from the other three wells for monthly reporting purposes.

127. The permit shall be effective upon submittal of documentation by Navy that it has met the DOH requirements for a public system.

128. This WUP shall be subject to Army's application for a WUP to reduce the permitted use of the Army's Schofield Shaft (2901-02 to 04, 10) by 0.208 mgd to a new total of 5.648 mgd. The Army's application shall be submitted within 60 days after the approval of this WUP or this WUP shall be void. Approval of the modification request shall be obtained from the CWRM prior to use of Well No. 3100-02 and issuance of this WUP.

129. Navy shall submit an after-the-fact PIP A, and approval of the permit shall be obtained prior to use of the well.

130. The well shall not be used for drinking water purposes unless it is properly tested and treated.

o 131. This permit is approved subject to reclaimed water becoming a practical alternative

and provided that the Department of Health approves the reuse application.

132. Should any opae ula be recovered in the well water, the permittee shall notify the Division of Aquatic Resources and provide specimens to the Division of Aquatic Resources for analysis.

133. If a single meter at the well is used, the Commission shall allow an additional 1,000 gallons per day to the water use permit amount for the domestic needs of two residences, although a permit for individual domestic consumption is not required. Otherwise, the applicant must provide a meter to separately measure the irrigation consumption.

134. This permit is approved under the requirement that conversion to either: 1) treated wastewater becoming available for reuse as an alternative supply source, provided that Department of Health concerns over the use of treated effluent over the potable water aquifer have been addressed; and/or 2) other nonpotable source becoming available will occur in a timely manner.

135. These permits shall be subject to a review of actual use within four years for possible modification of the permitted amount.

136. The permit shall be reviewed in two (2) years for possible additional revocation due to nonuse.

137. The allocation is based on the projects listed in Exhibit 5 (ofItem 10 of the May 20, 1998 Staff Submittal), except for the Queen's Beach GC (fMK 139-11-2,3), Lot 9 (TMK 139-17-51), and Varsity Place (TMK 128-24-35).

138. Kamehameha Schools Bishop Estate/Honolulu Board of Water Supply shall transfer the water use permit within ninety (90) days of the effective date of the transfer of the pump station to the Honolulu Board of Water Supply, pursuant to §174C-59 Hawaii Revised Statutes.

139. The permittee shall ensure that the water is recycled by either directing it into the Waiahole Ditch for use by downstream farmers (subject to the approval of the Agribusiness Development Corporation's Board) or into Waikele Farm's existing irrigation system.

140. The permittee shall file a completed application to modify WUP No. 758 to reduce the allocation by 0.100 mgd within 60 days. If a completed water use permit modification application is not received within 60 days from this submittal's date, then the subject water use permit application (WUPA No. 767) shall be deemed denied without prejudice without the need for another hearing.

141. The water withdrawn shall be for municipal use. No improvements to the existing sources are required as the existing source capacities are greater than the increase.

142. Water license must be determined through LM.

143. Proposed other uses will be considered at a later date.

• ___________________________ I'I'H.Wi'tMIiM_. • ~ tt<;"oJ<I11~1,.',.~_

256002020

o , 100 I

200 , 300 I

256006017

256002025

256002017

257011020

257011019 ~

256002034

256002024

257011017

256002036

256002003

257011015

256002032

o

1 ..... 1-··-- . . ---- --- .. ---- -. . -

Q) C) co .. ~ C) C 'S; 0 ::i ~ ... c 0 ::i N ,....

I ,.... N N D. :l 3:

0 0 0 0 0 0 LO 0 ~ C! M N N ,.. ,..

C9W

o

-.. ---

, • .. ,

I I

• • • oJ

---- ... _'"

0 LO ci

.. \ \. ,

• '. • • '"

..

.,I'

I I I I I \ • • • • '.

I " .

80-qa.::l

90-lOQ

D.. ::::)

3: gO-Ae~ I

C\I ,.. > « ::2:

I 0 (!J

Po-uer ::2:

GO-das

•

~O-Jd\f 0 0 ci

F(S 8

t'l', " I ~.1 ~q \

/1,,; I ~ 19sn :J£Cll \~}

.lfIZll'SI

!'.' ~~ '"D." ~\\,

t I~n' ~ 1.!2

~h:~;l , H',',

t" ,',"4 .' , .; : :~'4 __ 1 ~ . ~ ~ f ;ru!9i'S

«if iit~-;; .. 51~r6 . ~ , "', • Z~ lSol

UALAPU£ - KAPU L~1 /t10LOKAf.

~--------------------------------------------------------------------------------~~

J

:" .i ~"'r ,\'/: ," 'r ) L.

6 06

---

PRINTfD _ ___ _

!

I ',,-

o State of Hawaii


Honolulu, Hawaii

September 15, 1993

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management State of Hawaii Honolulu, Hawaii

Gentlemen:

Applications for Water' Use Permits UaJapue Ground Water Mana&ement Area. MoJokai

Applicants:

1. (Well No. 0352-12) John N. Urauchi P.O. Box 7 Kaunakakai, HI 96748

2. (Well No. 0448-01) Ellen M. Osborne Star Route 224-A Kaunakakai, HI 96748

3. (Well No. 0449-01) Maui Dept. of Water Supply P.O. Box 1109 Wailuku, HI 96793

Back&round

Landowners:

Same

HSPA P.O. Box 1057 Aiea, HI 96701


Completed water use permit applications were submitted to the Commission as indicated on Exhibit 2. Specific information regarding the sources, uses, notifications, objections, and field investigations are described in Attachment A and the attached exhibits.

Analysis" Issues

Eight (8) applications for water use permits from the Ualapue Aquifer System have been submitted to the Commission to date requesting a total of 1.159 million gallons per day (mgd) of water (see Exhibit 2). Of tbis total, one request, for an allocation of 0.01 mgd, has already beP.n erllllted (Mahealani Ranch, Well No. 0352-09), and one request was recently withdrawn (Clara Brito Sabas, Well No. 0448-07). Two other applications are incomplete. The fourth application has been ac&pted as complete; however, action on this application shall be deferred pending publication of the notice of this application and to allow for the time period for filing written objections. Three (3) applications have been accepted as complete and ready for Commission action. Pending allocation requests currently total 1.099 mgd, or about 14% of the Ualapue Aquifer System's estimated sustainable yield.

1. Urauchi #1 is an existing dug well that is currently unused and has not been in use since 1946. The proposed use of fresh water is for agricultural irrigation on the . applicant's 25-acre parcel. Although this request is for a very small quantity of water, 1,000 gallons per day (gpd), the request is for a future, rather than an existing, use of water. Because existing uses in the Ualapue Aquifer System are still in the process of

ITEM


being established, staff feels that this request should not be granted at this time, unless the applicant can show more definite plans for use within the next four (4) years.

2. Mapulehu Shaft #1 is an existing dug source that has not been in use for a number of years because of large boulders and sediment at the well's bottom. Although the pump is run intermittently to keep the pump and motor in working condition, county water is currently supplying the applicant's domestic and crop irrigation needs. The applicant plans to redevelop this well in order to use fresh, non-potable water to augment the supply of county water for irrigation of 4.5 acres of ginger and heliconia. Because this request is for a future and not an existing use of water, this request should not be granted until existing uses have been established and permitted, unless the applicant can show more definite plans for use within the next four (4) years.

Furthermore, the State Historic Preservation Division has recently lodged a formal complaint against the applicant for a potential violation over the alleged disturbance of a burial site. The case is currently pending in the Attorney General's office, and the Historic Preservation DJvision has recommended that action on this submittal be deferred until this issue is resolved.

3. The Maui Department of Water Supply (DWS) is requesting 1.08 mgd of fresh water from an existing shaft source to satisfy municipal needs in the Ualapue water system. Based on the information provided in the application, it appears that the ' 9-'"

requested allocation is based on pump capacity, and therefore represents a maximum-day .... .,J>~ usage. The application further indicates that actual use is considerably less, about 0.18 ~\.~~ ~ mgd, on average. This is in agreement with the actual 12-month moving average ~~ "f-~L. withdrawal of 0.171 mgd, computed using monthly water use data provided by the ~ applicant. Daily permitted withdrawals are based on the longer term 12-month moving. average withdrawal, rather than on the potential maximum-day usage. The Final Report from the Molokai Working Group indicates that existing ground water use by the Maui DWS in the Ualapue Aquifer System is 0.18 and no increase in municipal needs projected to the year 2010 is expected (see Exhibits 3 and 6). .

Use of this water from the Maui DWS shaft source has been in existence for at least the past thirteen (13) years. Therefore, authorization to continue the existing use should not result in additional adverse impacts on other local wells, streams, and the K\i&lapw Aquifer System.

\) ~ ~ere is no clear reservation recommendation from the Molokai Working Group for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) for the Ualapue Aquifer System. The Final Report of the Molokai Working Group indicates that there are no existing or major projected increases for DHHL potable needs in the area (see Exhibit 3). However, the non-potable water needs projected to total buildout for homestead lands in the Central Aquifer Sector and small portions of the West and Southeast Aquifer Sectors total 23.5 mgd (see Exhibits 4 and 5). Of this total demand, 5.42 mgd is projected for the next five (5) to ten (10) years. About 5.0 mgd of the demand can be met through the existing Molokai Irrigation System (MIS). Current usage by DHHL from MIS is about 2.3 mgd. Staff feels that since municipal use "f thr- water has been in existence and is of beneficial use to the community, potential DHHL reservation should not prohibit action on the Maui DWS application.

The Molokai Working Group has made three recommendations. regarding the Southeast Aquifer Sector, which encompasses the Ualapue Aquifer System. They are:

1. Limit ground water withdrawal to 50" of its developable yield subject to . verification of existing users and water use permits.

2. Any withdrawals from this Sector should not diminish water supplies and supply availability for traditional uses, including taro patches and fishponds.

2


3. Development of additional water from the Southeast Sector should be reserved first for residences of this Sector who are not yet served.

Staff finds that there is no reason to believe that continuation of the existing municipal use will violate these recommendations made by the Molokai Working Group.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Attach.

The Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a water use permit to John N. Urauchi to use 1,000 gallons per day of fresh water for use from the Urauchi #1 Well (Well No. 0352-12), unless the applicant can show he has definite plans to use this requested amount within the next four (4) years. If and when granted, that water use permit should be an interim permit and shall be subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule.

The Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a water use permit to Ellen M. Osborne to use 2,600 gallons per day of fresh, non-potable water for use from the Mapulehu Shaft #1 Well (Well No. 0448-01), unless the applicant can show she has definite plans to use this requested amount within the next four (4) years and until the concerns of the State Historic Preservation Division have been resolved. If and when granted, that water use permit should be an interim permit . and shall be subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in ' , Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set ,. __ oUe:. __ . -'-cr---",

_ .. ~ C> :. < ('B~I V '00 _'// __ 1be Commission approve the issuance of ~jriterim water use permit to the Maui Department of Water Supply to use 171,000 gallons per day of fresh water for use from the Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) for municipal use in the DWS Ualapue system, subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special condition:

a. The issuance of the interim permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule. Until the reservation issue is resolved, the applicant may continue this existing use of ground water within the limits approved by the Commission.

Respectfully submitted,

APPROVED FOR SUBMITr AL:

3

,'h.<.. ..... ,

o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management September 15, 1993

W ArER USE PERMIT DETAILED INFORMATION

1.

2.

3.

SQ.Urce Information

AQUIFER: Sustainable Yield: Existing Water Use Permits: Available Allocation: Total of other pending allocations:










Ualapue System, Southeast Sector, Molokai 8 mgd

0.01 mgd 7.99 mgd

0.006 mgd

Urauchi #1 Well (Well No. 0352-12) Kapualei, Molokai, TMK:5-6-11: 16

NA NA in.


NA ft. NA ft.

Mapulehu Shaft #1 (Well No. 0448-01) Star Route 224-A, Molokai, TMK:5-7-8:76

NA NA in.


50 ft. NA ft.

Ualapue Shaft (Well No. 0449-01) Ualapue, Molokai, TMK:5-6-6:28

1936 48 in.

NA ft. 40 ft.

NA ft. NA ft.

-3 ft.

43 ft. NA ft.

ATTACHMENT A

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management

- -+--If

.. ,

.. 10 . t. lew. Toh~ Depth

~ I I I I I .hn t. perf. casiIg

r-

.1111

Use Information

1. Quantity Requested: 1,000 gallons per day. Proposed Type of Water Use: Agricultural irrigation Place of Water Use: Kapualei, Molokai at TMK: 5-6-11:16


2. Quantity Requested: 2,600 gallons per day.

September 15, 1993

NAgpd NA gpd

Proposed Type of Water Use: Irrigation of 4.5 acres of ginger and heliconia Place of Water Use: Star Route 224-A at TMK: 5-7-8:76


3. Quantity Requested:. 1,080,00 gallons per day.

NA gpd NA gpd

Proposed Type of Water Use: Municipal for the Maui DWS Ualapue system Place of Water Use: Ualapue service area


Total Requested:

Ualapue Aquifer System Current 12-Month Moving Average Withdrawal:

Nearby Surroundjna Wells and Other Reajstered Ground Water Use

171,000 gpd NA gpd

174,600 gpd

171,000 gpd (2.1 % of Sy)

Information from the registration program indicates there are possibly nineteen (19) existing wells in the Ualapue Aquifer System. Several of these wells have been initially field checked but many of the declarants, including possibly large users, have not been completely field verified. Several are not in use or are rights claims. No reliable

ATTACHMENT A


estimate of existing ground water withdrawals from the Ualapue Aquifer System as of 1990 is provided in the Maui Water Use and Development Plan, Island of Molokai. However, the Final Report from the Molokai Working Group provides an estimate of 0.62 mgd for ground water usage from the Ualapue Aquifer System as of July 1993 (see Exhibit 6). Specific information regarding other existing wells in the proximity of the sources is as follows:

1. There are sixteen (16) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0352-12 (see Exhibit 1A). Only two (2) of these wells are currently in use.

2. There are ten (10) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0448-01 (see Exhibit 1B). Only two (2) of these wells are currently in use.

3. There are ten (10) other wells within a mile of Well No. 0449-01 (see Exhibit 1C). Eight (8), and possibly all ten (10) of these wells are currently in use.

Pub lic Notice

In accordance with HAR §13-171-17, a public notice was published in the StarBulletin as indicated on Exhibit 2, and copies of the notice were sent to the Mayor's office and the Board of Water Supply. Additional notice copies were sent to the County Council and Department of Water Supply. Copies of the completed application were sent to the Department of Health, Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Aquatic Resources & Historic Preservation and other divisions of the Department of Land and Natural Resources, and other interested parties for comments. Written comments and objections to the proposed permit were to be submitted to the Commission as indicated on Exhibit 2.

Objections

The public notice specifies that an objector meet the following requirements: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits, (4) provide a copy of the objection letter(s) to the applicant, and (5) submit objections meeting the previous requirements to the Commission by the date indicated on Exhibit 2.

To the best of staff s knowledge there are no objectors who have property interest within the Ualapue Aquifer System or who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use from Well Nos. 0352-12 & 0449-01. Historic Preservation issued an initial statement of "no effect" to the proposed water use from Well No. 0448-01, although they acknowledged the existence of the burial site in that same document. Subsequently, and past the objection deadline, a formal complaint against that applicant was submitted to the State Attorney General's office and is currently pending (refer to Analysis and Issues section). All other objections andlor comments to the application ~re summarized as follows:

Objector

NHAC

ATTACHMENT A

Objection

General process of water use permit applications. No specific objections to this application.


Briefs in Support

Responses to objections, or briefs in support, regarding the application are required to be filed with the Commission ten (10) days after an objection is filed and, presumably, copies are served to the applicant. No briefs in support were filed with the Commission.

Field Investigation



3. The water source and proposed use was investigated on February 10, 1993 and February 11, 1993. The investigations verified the applicants request- for a water use permit.

A IT ACHMENT A


STANDARD WATER USE PERMIT CQNDITIONS

1. The ground water described in the water use permit may only be taken from the location described, used for the reasonable-beneficial use described, and at the location described above and in the attachments. Reasonable-beneficial use means "the use of water in such a quantity as is necessary for economic and efficient utilization, for a purpose,and in a manner which is not wasteful and is both reasonable and consistent with the state and county land use plans and the public interest." (HAR §13-171-2).


3. The water use must at all times meet the requirements set forth in HAR § 13-171-13 which means that it: '

a. Can be accommodated with the available water source; b. Is a reasonable-beneficial use as defined in section §13-171-2; c. Will not interfere with any existing legal use of water; d. Is consistent with the public interest; e. Is consistent with state and county general plans and land use designations; f. Is consistent with county land use plans and policies; and g. Will not interfere with the rights of the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands as

provided in section 221 of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act.

4. The ground water must not interfere with surface or ground water rights or reservations.

5. The ground water use must not interfere with interim or permanent instream flow standards. If it does, then:



6. The water use permit is subject to the requirements of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act, as amended, if applicable.

7. The water use permit application and staff submittal approved by the Commission at its September 15, 1993 meeting are incorporated into the permit by reference.

8. Any modification of the permit terms, conditions, or uses can only be made with the express written consent of the Commission on Water Resource Management.

9. The water use permit may be modified by the Commission and the amount of water initially granted to the permittee may be reduced if the Commission determines it is necessary to:

a. Protect water sources in quantity, quality, or both; b. Meet other legal obligations including other correlative rights; c. Insure adequate conservation measures; d. Require efficiency of water uses; e. Reserve water for future uses, provided that all legal existing uses of water as of

June 1987, shall be protected; f. Meet legal obligations to the Department of Hawaiian Homes, if applicable; or g. Carry out such other necessary and proper exercise of the State's and the

Commissions's police powers under law as may be required.

ATTACHMENT B

o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management September 15, 1993

Prior to any reduction, the Commission shall give notice of its proposed action to the permittee and provide the permittee an opportunity to be heard.

10. If the ground water source is not existing, the development of the new well shall be completed, i.e. able to withdraw water for the proposed use on a regular basis, within twenty-four (24) months from the date the water use permit is approved.

11. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, water-levels, salinity, and temperature must be kept and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis in accordance the Commission's September 16, 1992 action on reporting requirements;

12. The water use permit shall be subject to the Commission's periodic review of the applicable aquifer's sustainable yield. The amount of ground water use authorized by the permit may be reduced by the Commission if the sustainable yield of the Ualapue Aquifer System, or relevant modified aquifer, is reduced;

13. The water use permit may not be transferred or the use rights granted by this. permit sold or in any other way alienated. Pursuant to HAR §13-171-25 and the requirements of Chapter 174C, the Commission has the authority to allow the transfer of the permit and the use rights granted by the permit in a manner consistent with HAR § 13-171-25. Any such transfer shall only occur with the Commission's prior express written approval. Any sale, assignment, lease, alienation, or other transfer of any interest in this permit shall be void.

14. The use(s) authorized by law and by the water use permit do not constitute ownership rights.

15. The permittee shall request modification of the permit when necessary to comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances which will affect the permittee's water use.

16. The permittee shall prepare and submit a water shortage plan within 30 days of issuance of the permit to assist the Commission in fulfilling HAR §13-171-42(c). The permittee's water shortage plan shall identify what the permittee is willing to do should the Commission declare a water shortage in the Ualapue Ground Water Management Area.

17. The water use permit granted shall be an interim water use permit, as allowed under HAR §13-171-2l. The final determination of the water use quantity shall be made within five years of the filing of the application to continue the existing use.

18. The water use permit shall be issued only after AG review.

ATTACHMENT B

I I I 1

I I

I

I ]

I I I , ]

-I

US GEOLOGICAL SURVE~ WRD Feb 3.94 9:26 No.OOl P.Ol

[*, ObGot:v.aLion well; --, 110 dar-al

\)011 --, "----;I::-\-UJil)J!.t,~..::.: _ ...=-.. ::-- 'Hil,tl~X.1CY.u:::::: .. ::-

l'oriod NWllhl~r Perloo NJ,.w,bcr . f,~~ i~~ c!~,_.: - Nu'lIihe r of of of of of of rucord yc~r~ record ycors

:'~!.~~~.'}r. ~:t-'i~'~~.;.~ -~:'.~"'~:~:'f---·""""~ ...... ifif .... · .... \ ............ <v' j..,...,., • >I", ~ .. ~ " .... "iu·~ '. '. ..' ... " -. ~ ,. " .. ' .

H~Jl\Q.llJ V ,,11 \' ~ Oa!1~-Ol 0855-02 0655-03

Kua1;tp!.l1l arC{I 0700·0111' 0801-01 0601-02 080) -03 0901-0J 0902·01 0905·01*

1961,pl'n,uml 31 1961-pres~I1t :n J961-prcscnl ~H

1961-pl-OS()lIl 31 19B] .prufo!nt 11 1991-preSClnt 1 19S2·prcsent ~O 1950-t,3 13

!ollt:h :r;J:tQ..l:e of F.u t. MO) cW OJ.48-02* 0449·01 1979-present 13 0457-01 19J9-prescnl 13 OSOl·0/,A-0,01-0')* 0601-01"'" Off 03-01*

1912-praR QTll 20

1957.-76 24 ]95J-61 8 1938-1,6 8

1970-puscnt 22 ) 9/'7-pr~.'1cnl 4S 1974.r,rl',s",nc )8 1938- 15 , 7 19'17-!J4 I 19!)4 -r'(!seTlt 38 1967. 7 10

,,-_. ---.

recoro

19'16· prc •• wnl 1953-present. 1979-pn!~Clnl 1991· (l)-Q&l"ut 1952-pr(!~(!nl

19:"1-61 1938- 1,9

19~O-71 1945-p,-a!:cmt 19l.fI-presE!r)r

195{, -pre!OkllIl 1967-7/

Table 3.--PumpiIIR rates of wells In W .... lkolu V811C!y. KlJ$Jilp~;U ~nM Dlld alone r:he SOlJt:/1 S'IQre of J::1l.:Jt Moloka1.

16 39 13

) 40 10 11

1 46 (,6

38 10

('81/~fn. gAl1on& v~r minuls; Meal/d. m~llion g~lJons per dHY; --, no dAtnJ

~'ll"-' --r'UJII~ l.nfrat:e"---· 211 -h r -"jJ\iiiipl ne-'---" J u) y'Tryn . (ell /10 n)cpm) capacity mean PUIlI1'8£,C

(Hgal/d) (Mgdl/d) --.... _._ .. __ ..... ao __ " • .. _-_. --_ . ••• ao __ ..... . _--" H,§Ai~~~lo~alley

1000* 1 .'14 0,1.0** 08;~-O? lOOO* 1.44 0.48'** OB~5·03 1000· .Ll!!! .o...Jil!.**

Tola1 - 4.12 - 1 . III, 1(\1 II 1~ [1 uu til: ~~J''l

OISOl-Ol :;90 o.:;~ 0,18 oe01·011 no 1. 02 0.37 0801-03 875 1. 26 D.G7 0901-01 1.500 tH L~

Tot~l .. = 2 0/ South shore of ~fiH. M 0.1 ~,-b i

OGGQ.'HI - . 1000'" 1 ' '! I, 0.22 0456·06 71:;* 0.11 Oll 56 - oe 75* 0.11 Of, S6" 09 75* 0.11 0It57 ·01 650* H4 Q..Jl

Tot;:!l ... - 0.55

;r lnd'lcQt(\~ r~f.l'ilP'\.iinij'c~I)AcltY: '''-;~Tliia~c4(;e~ valut'-~3dIn4teir-rro'n rateO pump Cti~H1Cll}' and t lC! ntunbc.r of hour .. PVII'!' \J;\lQ in u,,"

25

, '

• IJS GEOLOGICAL SURVEY bJRD Feb 3.94 9:27 No.OOl P.02 n~·.~~:J~·:'·o; (J"nl(' ()! (,jl,· 0 Q

Ui·O~Ol~.d, '(W'17)TTT"TT' , I' , I " , 'TlT'~ I ' , , 1 , I "ANNUAL KUKUI (MQlQKAilINC. -KUALAPUU .~~-•. 1.0

,r. ~ ~ ___ .I\ 1\ .. / 0.0 .' I I I I j I I I I .1._1...L.J-1...J\I~'-4L.l_Llt I 1 .. 1 '.1 J , I 1 I .1 I 1 J I

0.8

1950 1953 1956 1959 1962 1965 HHJa 1971 1974 1877 1860 1983 1986 ,9ae ,992

1.0

O.~ -

0.0 ~.J~':J.:'.:.1~i ... ·.b .i. ... ~b.L. ... _~ ... I_J .l.J-1 __ l._1. J , , 1 , I I I I I j j .l.I.l.1 I i..l.

1950 1953 1966 1969 1962 1965 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 19136 19139 1992

OTo~-J-l'(~\~)' I 1" I" I I 1 , ' 1 1 ' I I 'Tfr-q···', I ~NNUA~ J DHtiL -KUALAPUU 1 1.0

0.& 1-- .- .'- r. •. ---........... -..•. -.- 1 n.o .. ' , I , 1 , I I '.1 In l'1'1-:":1"OT-r:-r·l'.f'-l 1.1-:'. I .1.f.J .. J._L.1...1.~ ... J.....:....J..-:J~~.r::h

1950 1953 1956 1969 1962 '966 1968 1971 1974 1917 18BO 1983 196e leSS 1892

1.r. ,.....,.-,,-..-, "T,-"r-J--r-, -"--'-1 ...,.'~-r-r-,..., I ,

I ' , 1-~'·' '1"' 'T~""AN N':jA~ J 0449-01 (S6) 1.0 MAUl OWS -UAlAPUE

o 6 -I

O.O- ....... J.· ...... ~...L......·I • ...L..............l-.... I,· , -. ,..,.. ....... -.- ........ - .. ... -.~ , • .. ":'V'"

~_..L- ....... L ... _.~.J.-...I..J....I.-' •.• .:.......I-....... J_ . .I_ • .l ... J.

1960 1063 \g66 lOS; tQS2 1906 lOSS 1971 1074 1977 19S0 19S3 lOSS 10SO 1002

1.6 , I ! ' I , " I "( . )-'T- ,.. I . I I , I ' , I ' , ( , , I ' " 1 ' ,., ,', ; " , I ' , I 0457,,01 (S4) ANNUAL

1.0 MAUl OWS -KAWEl.A

0.6 ,1-· -•. -.; ......... 4-.

0,0 .' I. I I. J I.L..J-L-L.i .... .....i-l....J 1 .. 1 I .I .L, ..J_L.l...J._L.J . ...J:1 .J .. J _1. I I !.J J I .1.1 J ,gSo Hlsg IIHiB lQ59 19132 1965 19S8 1971 Hl74 1977 1990 1983 lQQ6 10ag 1992

f'jgure lOa. J\nllufl1 me::m pumpnf,f: from :>clcctccl Wl'lls.

211

I

[

I

I

I

I

Feb 3,94 9:28 Na,OOl P.03 .US GEOLOGICAL SURVEY WRD

" iJl!t\f'J~~:()l ql1()t:n or d t.e 0 I

o

I I

I

I

I

l ,

~ Q

II:

~ en Z 9 ...J ot. (.';I

z. o :; .....

2,' • ii' I ··,-r-I""fT'--r'·"·' "--'--'-1-r-r-"1~--""T""""-"""''''''''-' T--'" ,. , ,. "-rr 0901"01 (W171 ONTfHY MfA ... KUKUI (MOLOKAI) INC. -KUALAPUU

1.'

1.2

(I.' • I~ !'fJ UU I I) • D.D .U .U jJ U.\l~j\., .. I • ~ • ol • _ .. L.l....L.-L., I , I I •. J-

2.. -'-'--r I ·r..,....,-. , r~. ' ,.,-.-,- Ii', -T'"""'T'"" r I r 1''-1-'1 ' -, '.,-.-, I I"','" i

0801-01 (W171 ANNUAL M~AN KUKUl (MOlO"AIIINC. -KUALAPUU

1.a

j"\j---' ::~~~!.\, , .~ ... '-~, ,,~.I~_I ,

1102 lt11t1 i8e1e 18111 19&4 1887 11170 11173 10'6 111711 lU2 1985 leU lUI

1.1

flfi\Jl"I~ lOb. t!or.thly and ;mml.!ll mnAa purnp;.lg~ frohl we.l1 0901-01.

o a • i -----, ---r' i ----

MONTHI.Y MEAN ,·--·I····-~··

0902-01 {W15J WKUI (MOLOICAI) INC. -KUALAPUU

~IiV ~,,'~-

0.2

0.1

0.1l

OJ _--r- -...--,-"" -.,.--

0802-01 (W15i KUKUI (MOlOKAII INC. -IWALAPUU

o t .

0.1

-.. -.-----~--.~. --~.-- ....... /~ -....... ......... /;'""

.--,.J........ • --l._~ _ .... --1---. ..... ' . .. -~.-I--.. . .,-.L..--- 1 ... _---1---~

11';00 181i1 181:12 1863 1115-4 1e66 1958 11157 11168 19611 1otO 111111 lU" n,u U.O

Flgut:~ ] 0(:. MOllthly ilnd dl1l)val mCi'in pumpagc: froln wc:l1 0902 -01.

29

US GEOLOGICAL SURVEY WRD DRAJiT-- Do ,:ot quote! ('f CltO Feb 3,94 9:28 NO.OOl P.04

Q

0.' -.--.--, . I -r-r-"--j-'-'--"-'-'-r-r-r--,---r-,' ·r',"'-'--',r--1·r-'I,r--1'--'I-r, I OB01·01 (W18) MONTHLY Mt:AN DHHL -KUALAPUU

O.t

0.0

d .• r-'I '1 •. ,.--,--,- r .'---.-. .... , ' I ""--'-""-I~T' , t 0801'01 (W18)

I"~ I' '-r-r--I .', ANNUAl. MEAN

r OHHl -ICUAl.APUU

t .• t botj ~

•• ~I.' 1........L •. I .• _~ .. h,.I~ 1U2 ue .. · 1908 '0" 1070 10'2 1411" 11118 1878 1880 1982 1984 18111 1eU 1 .. 0 , .. 2

jo"j.?,ure lOll. Monthly and BnnuaIIllt'flt1 pumpllS" from WE'll OSOI-Ol.

1.2 r tu~

0 ••

D.!)

D.O 1.1

0.'

0.'

o. ~

0.0

'---,-- I --, ...

08C,i\·O~ (W1eB) DHHl ·KUALAPUU

,'.'-.' ',--,-'" .... ,--MCNTHLY MEAN

. VVj A.~tyV\vr-ly·l'~'v-, _I ~.lrJ-_-lr~. ..~ .. ~ .. -.. ~. '._-.1 .. -J. __ ••. I. . .. _1 __

r---..·-···-'"T'"--'·--~--· .... --.... , -.. ' -,---r-. _ ..... ---,--....

0801-02 (W16el OHHL ·kUALAPUU

-------.-.---.- -------~ - --"'------~, .............

__ .I-' • __ ' •• __ -'--__ 1-....._--'--..... J ___ ....

ANNUAL MEAN

'",- .... _.- ---.~.-

""---'--

10111 1 (HI 2 ,aU 1 lIB 4 1986 1988 1961 1888 1808 1880 , .. , 11112

1"j r,ure lOe. Mor.th 1)' tmd (tUtHill 1 lIIt'tlU pumpsgE' frol1l well 0801- 02.

30

~I~LNUTIO"

!& DU~ we ...

Ie I ~!I)T-~'l

':'.J~ QI)~ -. I

i C ! UIl£S .-----.----

J (IL OIo(U';5S .;j

Figuxe 11. ~ater levels :rom selected wells, 1938-92 (refer Co table 3 for well characteristics and da~s].

" m C'

lD

IV 00

Z c

o o .... -,;0

o U1

I

I I I I I I I I I I I I I

II I

'. US GEOLOGICAL SURVEY WRD Feb 3.94 9:29 No.OOl P.06

\lIMFT- -/)0 not quote _LtC o

(D, dUB well: T. tcst hole: S, shel1.tj W, drilled well; 001\, Depatl-IDt\ul. of Agr1 culturt: - DLNP., D('J)lHtm~nL l>f Land and Nat;ur~] Rlu:ourceR: DHHI., DcpBrt:n1cnL. of Hawaiian Home Lands; USGS. U. S. Geologlesl survey)

Well C\1aracle.ri:o;t: i CIS: itl f(:~t nboyt' vr- balow m~M\ I:lC8 lev~l. Water level: in f~Qt: Qbove bloBi'll) ~ca leve1_

--_ ... - ... .. --.,----... .. _-_ . " ___ MO._ .. __ ... __ Well ~1ell c:harel.~\.€.r,:i~t;J~£ tJ<}t:Cl' Dale OWO$r State Local . Top of .so t cOIn level measured

cas1ng of hole -_. --_ ...... .. ---~--- ..... "-'---

\.I;aikolu Vnl1p.~

0655-01 tJ2? 99? 592 989 06-29-61 [lOA 085S-02 W23 904 604 864 Oti -OJ - 61 DOli. 0855·03 W23 965 665 91. 7 07-10-61 DOA

I<u.'~ 1 iln~111 Bre~

0700-01 \0118 982 -101 6.1 (M· 23- 82 Kuy.ui (M()lvktll) 0801·01 W16 100'> -90 10.7 0:>-11·49 DHHL 0801·02 tJ]6B 1011 01)9 7.8 07-23-79 DIUIL 0801-03 10)7 ·99 11.7 07-27-S7 Hfll.d Counly OB07-01 348 -41 3.0 11-03- J) Kukui (Molol<Af) 0901-01 \117 981 ·83 10.4 12-0]·50 Kukui (Mo]okai) 0902-01 W15 888 -78 lO.!1 01.·01-46 K~lk\Ji (Moloksi) 090)-01 Ti 398 -11 5.0 11-1)-38 uses ~<;>~Lh shorc....Q!'J:jl5LHolo~:"'J

0352·01 042 43 3 6..7 03-23-57 Malll County 0352-05 w.11 213 -27 5.0 11-21-61 DUm 0448-07. s8 21 -2 4 . .'5 10-21-91 Pc-arl FriAJ 0449-01 S6 (. ? ·3 3.8 04-17-89 Maul Count.y 0'IS7-01 ~'i 3J -2 1.8 0'1-26-90 limit COUllty 0501-04 Sl 28 1 1.1 05-b-43 Kolokal Rauch 0501-05 T4 16 -6 2.5 11-12- S3 Maul Count.y 0559-0) w19 271 -11. I.E. 07-03-67 DUIR 0600-01 t'? 311. -10 8.9 09·?7 -39 l1al1i County 0601-01 Wl1 )2 -6 2.5 09-08-86 Holoklli RMl\oh 0603-01 D14 18 -1 2./1 01-29-75 Me.lokai Ranch

._---_ .. . __ .. .. __ .... , .. ._--_.

" US GEOLOGICRL SURVEY WRD ~!.-Io-- .__ . Feb 3.94 9:29 NO.OOl P.O?

.0 -~~;;':~;;1"" ",--.--r", ' . I '-"'1" ..... ~., .,

KUKUI (MOLOKAIJ INC. -'WALAPUU

10

o ~ 'f-'-'1"""'T'

MONTHLV

o ~ ..... , , . I L, .... ..l~ .• Ll-L.-L..-J .. ' .I~' , 1 .. 1--->-1-1. , .• _j.~ .......

liD 1 ' • , "-r-r-" 1""·.-,--.-" I ' , 1 -~.~,.........., .• , , ·'···-r" , • ·'· .. r·· ... · .. • 0801-01 cwm ANNUAL MEAN I<UKUI (MOL-OKA!) 'NC. -ICUAlAPUU • COMPl[Tt MONTHLY RCCOIII)

20 t INC~MrlHE MONTHLY RECORD

~ ...... -. ....... .. ~ ..... __ ... ... "r l' -.~... ..'" ...

10

l'l I. I , .• -1.-,_., I 1 ... ..l--L-.." I • , l. "_'. 1 .... -L....... .... I I ... ...1_1 •. 1 I , .. .J--,--,_' • 11162 I96S 11168 1"01 .1964 liC!7 U170 1873 11176 1&78 1982 '86e> lin lUI

Figure 1211, Monthly and anuual lIlean wat.1:!r 1 evel from pumping well 0901· 01.

so -,., "1~T"'1 ' I .j-.....-, "'-l~" I'· ....... • • I '···'-r'" I • ,-,""'"T"""''', ' 0902-01 (Wlij) MONTHLY KUKU' (M OlOI<AU INC. -IWAI.APUU

20

10

c 1!1 .) • I • • I 1 , , • • 1 • , I "'-'-1 ' ' ............... I-~··" I ~"-'-'-''''1 "'-"--r--r-t

ANNUAL M(AN 0902 .. 01 (W161 KUKI,), (MOlOKAJ) INC. -KUALAPUU • COMNETE' MONTHLY RECORD

• INCOMPlEH MONTHLY R[CORD 20

, .. 10 f •

D ;, I L •. I. I , I.L_J_LJ~~L I •• --L....-.. I 1 •• 1 I 1 I .1. I .. L...L-I-l. I. 1 J -L~ .•

11162 1966 1968 196' 19(14 ItI(\7 1870 H173 111711 1978 1982 HI {Iii "'88 I Btl 1

Figure l/.b. MOHr.hly Bnd annUli} moan wtll:"r 1cva1 frorn pumping well 0902·01.

35

-us GEOLOGICAL SURVEY WRD Feb 3,94 9:30 No.OOl P.OS LIl'(lIt'l'--lJo not <jllot~ ()r ci tu 0 o

10 '-'"1"" ,.. --,----, , • '---"---..---..--- I·' ---r--..---..---- ,--'W ,., 0700-01 (WIO) MoNTHLY , IWKUI (MOLOKAI) INC. -(A~AL"HAlE

e 11- ............. _- .... ",,_ • ....... __ ..1"' .. ~ .. - ... __ ... ~/ ........ -_ ....... - ..... --... ... -..,.._ .. r ... --v 'V"" _ -.-. ... --.". _~ .. _

•

I

o • , " .•• .L ._..L._ ..... ' .. _.

1:1 r""O'roO:OI(~W--" ""---,,,.--'" • r KlJKUI (MOLOKAU INC. -KAKALAHAlE

- ....... --~" ...... ', ".,' ANNUAL MJ;AN

• COMPLETE MONTHLY AECOItD • INCOMPLU£ MONTHLY RECORD

• 4

•

. , _-L_~ __ . • ' ...• L ___ ' __ ,. , . '---'--''''. • - & __ .....

Ui'O len 111711 18'8 1100 18111 "'112 11113 IU4 'Uti 19118 1!Hi1 1088108" 1G90 111111 19IJ:t

Figure 12(.'. l'1t:llthly And annual mean water level from observat1on well 0700-01,

I-1&1 11.1 U.

~ ...i UJ > IIJ ..J cr: w t-

~

10

•

0

10

•

•

• 2

"", 1 I' '!··I·--r-r-r'" ~ I' , j",","'I-rrr,-"l " , ' ''''·'-'-r .... 1"""1 r'''I-'-..,-TTI 0900-01 (T1) MONTHLY USOS -MOLOKAI AIRPORT

.,!,: I,~' .. ' ,_, I., I "I_1..._L1-...I .. ', 1 I J J . .L........LL .. I I..~ 1 I. Jj...J~..L._._! -nT""," l'I' .. -.,.,...,-,-"-" .. ,, "1-,-, I I 1 I 1 ,--' 1 • .-, I , I \ I Iii T,"",-'-'I--r-rr1

01106-01 tTl> ANNUAL M£AN USGS -MOLOKAI AIRPORT • COMPl(TE MONTHLY RECORD

• INCOMPLETE MONTULV ACCORD

o .... i.L!....J_.L ...... I, J-L..L...I_J..,-'_Ll. ... J., .• ~.~.~l....&....I.-l.. I 1 1. • ...1 , 1 I L ,_I_I_~.I ... L...l~ .... 1

1930194111144'0471860195"&5$1858 180218Mtge8 19/1 111741977 1~1Q831088 1\l80IOO2

Y " t"'d Mo.l,thly and ~nnusl lOOan ~atcr level from obseTvation well 0905·01 1r.ur~ ". •

36

I I I

I I I I

I)S GEOLOGICAL SURlJEY WRD Feb 3,94 9!30 No.OOl P.09 I) lUll' j'-. •. I/'J IIc'l lJ '.' (, t I.' U I o

w

100 "1" 'r-' , I , , I '-'I~"''''''''-I -r-~,.....,.-r-"',,-, •. ',-.-.--y , , "T"-' ..,--.--" I-~ 0801-01 (W1." MONTHLY

.00

100

o .00

Otll,l -KUAI,APUU

Jr ..... .. . . . _.,.,... .' ... _1 , , I , t_.1 I ..... L , I , .... 1 ....................... ,--.L1 I , I 1 •• ...L.... • I 1 • I _1 .... I •• J

.'" I ' ,ooT-'-'-,"'" , 1 '''r-~-'l'l 0801-01 (WHJ) OttHl -KUALAPUU

, "-T-~-'T', ' 1 I • , r-...,.-,-'-T···-r· ANNUAL MEAN

• COMPLETE MONTHLY HeORD

C 400 • INCOMPLETE MOIHHlY RECORD

II!

g o

100

o 18ISJ

+ •

. . , • ..... "i. 06-

.. 1 1 , J .J_.J....L......._, I , • I .... ...L..L...._) , • I ~-J..L..J .. I • , ! , 1.1...1 .... .1 lit!O 1.1i. 1102 nOll 18U 1171 1$74 1971 1080 ,083 1988 1989 1m

Figure 13e. Monthly sud .annu~l mClnn chloridll:l con~~('Ilt:n:ll:iol~ of IJ.!itt.!t· from

pump1ng weI] 0801-01.

w o ii: o ... !I: V

160

IDD

fiO

o 160

100 .

," ----.,,---, ... "'--,.---",", 0801-02 (WlIlB1 OHHL -';UAlAPUU

. ... ~~.,_ ... _. • ............ ' __ 1 ___ . • .. _..L--.I .. .

... --r-.'_.- "1 "--MONTHLY

....

.. ,_. --A...---_ 1 •• . ..... ~- ... -.." ,... . ...... , --.---...,...._ .. , .---,----., .. -,---,--...... ,._-_. I

0801-02 (W15B) ANNI,JAL MEAN DHHl ·KUAlArUU • COMPLETE MONTHLV RECORD

• IHCOMPlETt MONTIILY RECO'lD

o . L, I .. , - ....... l -_.---'--_L..._ ......... _~ .. 187i 18eo tnl 188% '883 1184 1806 teee lU1 HUla lUll lU~O 10g1 1iH2

Figt.n:\:! 131'. l1<.Il\~:llly and C'lnnu.aI lIIeAIl chloride COllt~entnition of wat(!r from

pwnp i tlg we 11 0801· 02 .

us GrOLOGICAL SURVEY WRD Feb 3.94 9:30No.OOl P.IO DRAJ1"J'~ -Do nOl 'luote or dO o

'00 .• , .... '··.··r , , I ' ··.-... 1..,'.....-'-,1.-0'-...'-,1.-.'-.-....... ' .~ ...... ..,............,.-.--.-·1 .~ ..•

110

100

10

I)

200

n.o

100 •

0901·01 (Wl1) MONTHLY KUKUI tMOlOICA/) INC, .KUALAPUU

.• I J ' "-rr .,. I ' , r-,...,...,··"T· r I ' "-r'" J' I , I . '--r-r--'--r ... ' I " r' ,.-r,-0901-01 (V'Ill) ANNUAL MiAN KUKUI (MCLOKAI) INC. -KUALAPUU • COMPLEtE MOI4THLY IIECORD

• INCOMPLETE UONTHLY RlCOR

+

f + .... • • .. --..-, a • t .-..... .. ...

10 ~_. I ......

I) L.! I , •. L.l.-L. . ..I. J ,.j-,~ ... , • 1 .. ----t..., .• I •• ...L.......... •. I • , I •• I • , I.. J

1962 ,.66 1858 11181 1014 1987 '0'0 1I17j 1978 1978 1962 1US 1111111 lUI

fl£ure 13&. l'luHlhly an<1 ofInnua1 mean chloride COllcelltral.ion of Witt-ElI" hOIll

l'ulJl!,i,\t, wo11 0901-01.

eoo ., ", I' '· .... ··T·"'T· I , ' "',~"" 1 r ! 1-'-'-1'·" • , ' ,._,--.-.- r ' , I ,._...,.,..... .. I ' , r 0907-01 (W1S) MONTHLY KUKUI (MOI.OKAJ) INC .• 1I:t.,IALAPUU

400

20(l

I 1:1 L-' ..•. .l............._I.., • I .• ,......l... •• 1 ... I . ...L.r..->.. J •• 1._...........J... I •..• ~ •.. I , • I ..... L

.00

700

. ,. ,.·......,..........-T I", 1 i r'"'' 1-' i

0902·01 (Vi1SI KliKUI (MOLOKAIi INC. -KUALAPUU

.-... . ...... -..

"'f I .j ,-, .-, I • 1 '...,._, ·,-r ANNUAL MEAN

• COMPLETE MONTHlV RECORD • INCOMPl£H MONTHLY RrCORO

o 1 I I I I I I I I..............L,. l.i • .1 ..... I I I I ' , .1., I I I ' 1.. •. , I I I I , .• 1 , • I. 1&00 lUi:! 1876 1869 111&2 10.6 IOU 11171 107~ 1071 1910 US3 1986 11189 ttl92

ngi.lr~ ) 3h. Mcnlhly and .!H!!Il.Ial Inl:1811 chloride conccnt.·ati on or water from pwoping woll 0902-01,

44

o

1993 September 15


A NoNPRoFrr Caw>oAAllON

1088 Bishop Street, Suite 1204, Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Telephone (BOB) 523-1445 Facsimile (808) 599-4380

TESTIMONY TO THE STATE OF HAWAII COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

ITEM 3 Sea Life Park Wells

Background

The submittal mistakenly states that "no specific objections were filed." In fact, NHAC filed specific written objections to the application on September 3, 1993 (copy attached), focussing on issues of permit consolidation, wastewater, and water licensing.

Analysis & Issues

The submittal again mistakenly states that "no specific objections to this application have been submitted to the Commission."

Recommendation:

No action should be taken until applicant and the Commission respond to the specific objections filed by NHAC.

The recommendation should also include permitting of Well A as a back-up source.

NHAC would like to see the Commission suggest to BLNR and Land Management Division that water licenses are required for the proposed type of water use, since such uses have quantifiable economic value that can be shared with the state.

Public Notice

The submittal mistakenly states that "Written comments. and obj ections to the proposed permit were to be submitted to' the Commission by September 2, 1993." The public notice requires that persons "Send written objections by September 3, 1993 ... "

Objections/Comments

This section of the submittal omits NHAC's specific objections sent to the Commission on September 3, 1993.

o o ITEM 5 Wabikuli Irriqation Well

Well Location

The proposed well seems very close to an unlabelled intermittent stream. Is there any possible connection between streamflow and aquifer dynamics in this area?

Analysis:

In non-designated areas, pump installation permitting is the one of the few controls available to the Commission for preventing harm to the resource from occurring. Issuance of a pump installation permit prior to pump testing seems to be a dangerous precedent which limits the Commission's options for proactive water management.

Water Availability.

What is existing use from the Honokowai system?

RECOMMENDATION:

If the Commission decides to issue the pump installation permit prior to pump testing under the proposed conditions, condition 2. should be amended to require the matter to be brought back to the entire Commission for decisionmaking if the pump test results reveal any potential problems with .the 200 gpm capacity pump that would suggest installation of a smaller pump to better protect the resource.

ITEM 6 Kalaeloa Wells l~o~·\O-'~

Analysis:

The submittal fails to mention if construction of the new wells has been completed and to analyze any pump test results. It seems that in this case the water use permit should not be amended until these activities are completed.

If the three new wells are to " ... take the place of the existing six wells for operational efficiency, II will the old wells be abandoned or maintained for system back-up? If they are not going to be maintained, they should be deleted from the amended water use permit and abandoned in accordance with Water Code requirements.

o o ITEM 7 Hawaiian Research Dug Wells

Analysis & Issues

The submittal states that " .•• additional adverse impacts on other local wells, streams, and the Kamililoa aquifer system are not anticipated." Does this imply that identifiable adverse impacts already exist? If so, what are they? What baseline data exist to support the implication that six years of existing use leads to a conclusion that additio~al adverse impacts are not anticipated?

If " ... data were only provided for the seven-month period from November 30, 1991 through June 30, 1992," does this mean that data were recorded for other periods but were not provided by the applicant? If so, these data should be obtained and incorporated in the analysis before recommendations for decisionmaking are submitted.

RECOMMENDATION

NHAC concurs with the recommendation to defer action until reservation of water for Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule. we also suggest that action be further deferred until bulk allocation to the Maui Department of Water Supply is set by the Commission.

WATER USE PERMIT DETAILED INFORMATION

Nearby Surrounding Wells and Other Registered Ground Water Use

Identification, assessment, and evaluation of nearby surrounding streams, springs, seeps, pond, and other registered surface water use should also be required at this level of review.

ITEM 8 Kawe1a Ground Water Management Area 03'2." 10 1C>~~\.."I1-(o~(..-o'f'"'J o~w"'\"'". c4S1--o,

1. David W. Curtis

The presence of six wells immediately downgradient of the applicant's source which may be' affected and the present lack of objections to the application emphasizes the need for the Commission to provide direct notice of proposed actions in designated water management areas to those who have already declared or are otherwise known to have interests that may be affected. If the Commission can readily identify these six wells, it can certainly mail notice of the permit applications directly to their owners and operators.

3. Kawe1a Plantation

Owners and operators of other downgradient wells should be served direct notice of the permit application and objections filed to date.

o o 4. John Wm. Iaea. Jr.

Owners and operators of the wells immediately downgradient of the applicant's source which may be affected should be served direct notice of the permit application and be afforded additional opportunity to file their objections.

ITEM 9 Kualapuu water Management Area Of 0\-0\, D2,. I \0<)"1.· t:> \

NHAC would like the record to reflect DHHL's continuing and increasing reliance upon the principle that their right of first call will be effectuated with a sense of immediacy. In addition to constitutional and statutory language DHHL's reliance may also rest in large part upon statements of Deputy Attorney General Tam that reflect both recognition of the primacy of DHHL's water rights and the attendant potential state liability to other private parties who may be required to cut back should exercise of DHHL's first call adversely affect them.

ITEM 10 Manawainui Ground water Management Area

Oral testimony may be presented~

OLOll ... t>1-, C>}.C.~-D\ kt>O'3 01-1>1.-07...

ITEM 11 Ualapue Ground water Management Area o';t;"l- -17. o,-\~ -0 \ O't"t~ ... " \ / \

Analysis & Issues

I & 2. The ongoing establishment of existing uses in an aquifer system should not of itself be a deterrent to restoring currently unused water sources to their previous uses. What "more definite plan for use" does the Commission propose beyond the statement that agricultural irrigation will take place? without the permit, the applicant is prevented from showing his ability to implement the proposed plan. Perhaps a better solution is to issue an interim permit pending resolution of other allocations issues and applicant's demonstration of his ability to actually use the requested allocation.

3. The submittal fails to mention the specific objections to this permit application filed by the NHAC. We understand that Maui DWS is currently preparing a response to our objections, and ask that the Commission defer action on this item until both the objections and response are available to the Commissioners.

ITEM 13 Department of Agriculture Waikolu Wells Z>.fc;;~-O\ ,\... C....b

Analysis & Issues

The submittal should also note that specific objections to the application were sent on time by NHAC (copy attached), further

o supporting the staff I s recommendation that public hearings be initiated prior to decisionmaking.

Mahalo,


Att.

o o FIELD MEMORANDUM

DECLARANT (File Reference): MAUl DWS MOL

SITE VISIT DATE: February 10, 1993

PRESENT:

STATUS:

February 11, 1993

February 10, 1993: Mr. Philip Akiona, DWS Mr. Richard Jinnai, DLNR Sterling Chow

February 11, 1993: John and Wilfred, DWS personnel Mr. Richard Jinnai, DLNR Sterling Chow

(1) Dug Well 0449-01 ( Ualapue Shaft) currently in use. Water source for the east Molokai service area.

(2) Dug Well 0457-01 (Kawela Shaft) currently in use. One of two water sources (the other being Kualapuu Mauka, Well 0801-03) for the Kaunakakai service area.

(3) Drilled Well 0801-03 (Kualapuu Mauka) currently in use. One of two sources (the other being Kawela Shaft, Well 0457-01) for the Kaunakakai service area.

(4) Dug Well 1059-01 (Waikalae Tunnel) currently in use. Water source for the Kalae service area.

(5) Stream diversion in Halawa Valley currently in use. Water source for service within Halawa Valley. This diversion will be assigned Stream Diversion number 0945-01 (Makaeleele-DWS).

(6) Declaration filed for use water from the Molokai Irrigation System. This connection is no longer in service. Disconnected September, 1992.

(7) Declaration filed for use of water from the State Department of Hawaiian Home Lands water system. The "Kalae Booster Pump" is currently used to pump water from the DHHL one million gallon tank in Kalae into the Department of Water Supply's 100,000 gallon Kalae tank to maintain fire protection capacity.

1

· ,

! o o

SOURCE(S): (1) Well 0449-01 (Ualapue Shaft). TMK: 5-6-6:28.

USE(S):

USGS Kamalo quad (Mo-4). Ualapue aquifer system.

(2) Well 0457-01 (Kawela Shaft). TMK: 5-4-1:50. USGS Kaunakakai quad (Mo-3). Kawela aquifer system.

(3) Well 0801-03 (Kualapuu Mauka). TMK: 5-2-1:24. USGS Kaunakakai quad (Mo-3). Kualapuu aquifer system.

(4) Well 1059-01 (Waikalae Tunnel). 14:02. USGS Kaunakakai quad (Mo-3). aquifer system.

TMK: 5-2-Kualapuu

(5) TMK: 5-9-6:01. USGS Halawa quad (Mo-5). Halawa aquifer system. Diversion to be assigned number 0945-01 (Makaeleele-DWS).

(6) See File Ref: STATE DOA for the Molokai Irrigation System source information.

(7) See File Ref: STATE DHHL MOL for source information regarding the Kalae one million gallon tank.

(1) Water provided to 281 service connections on the east end of Molokai along Kamehameha V Highway from approximately the 9 mile marker in Kamalo to the 22 mile marker in Moanui.

(2) Well 0457-01 is one of two sources (the other is Kualapuu Mauka, Well 0801-03) that provides water for approximately 1,100 service connections in the Kaunakakai area.

(3) Well 0801-03 is one of two sources (the other is Kawela Shaft, Well 0457-01) that provides water for approximately 1,100 service connections in the Kaunakakai area.

(4) Well 1059-01 provides water to approximately 60 service connection within the Kalae service area.

(5) Diversion 0945-01 provides water to 6 service connections within Halawa Valley.

(6) No longer in use.

2

o o (7) Water from the state Department of Hawaiian Home Lands' one million gallon tank in Kalae is used to fill the Department of Water Supply's 100,000 gallon tank in Kalae to maintain the volume for fire protection. The water is ultimately used by the 60 service connections in the Kalae area.

FIELD NOTES:

(1) Well 0449-01 (Ualapue Shaft):

1. Source: A dug well that has a shaft 40 feet deep and a rectangular cross section 5 feet wide and 7 feet long. According to Mr. Akiona, at the bottom of the shaft a tshaped development tunnel extends mauka for 50 feet and extends east for 70 feet and 80 feet west. Water is withdrawn with a 750 gpm pump with a 50 hp electric motor. There is a second pump for backup. Water from the well is pumped through a 6-inch diameter pipeline into a 16-inch diameter line that feeds into a one million gallon storage tank.

2. Use: The water is used to provide water to 281 county service connections on the east end of Molokai along Kamehameha V Highway from approximately the 9 mile marker in Kamalo to the 22 mile marker in Moanui. The pump is usually run during the evenings to fill the one million gallon tank.

3. Quantity: The quantity used is measured with a flow meter.

4 .

5 .

As stated in the Declaration of Water Use, monthly water use from 1983 to 1987 ranged between 2.5 and 8.8 million gallons per month.

Location: Source, TMK: 5-6-6:28. Using the GPS: latitude = 21 deg 04 min 04 sec N

longitude = 156 deg 49 min 59 sec W

Ownership: Land owned by Maui County.

3

Go"""'~f: l'.fHt.-ll P~lDWIt FIELaSPECTION INFORMATION CHE~ST (Ver.4/3/91)

PART I: USE OF WATER Declarant's File Reference: MIhAl "DW> MPl-. to~ ~~""'~lJ\ 1. Tax Map Key where the water IS used: __ -__ -__ : __ . Does the declarant own

this land?·~ If not, who does? f'.P:l'=!8t-o (Ag MlLe:~):m MO RN..c I ( ...... -z,'}.. MIl£. M~~)

2. What is the water used for? WI S?V/~ Co1J1\:1?!110!:!? 1'b MIJ,v'klYf?1... '?'1S1'l21 n) UiJ)t..Q-pUt!

If for irrigation, how many acres are being irrigated by crop type? A-~

If for livestock, how many and what kind? ___________ _ If for drinking, at how many houses? _'k""'B ........ ' ____ by how many people?

3. Is the quantity of water use being measured? yes If yes, document the location of the measurement point and method of measurement; also get use records if these were nat submined previously.

. 4. If this person takes from a multi-user pipe or ditch system: How is the water taken from the system? _______________ _ What is the capacity for taking (gpm)? ________________ _ How often is it taken (used)? ____________________ _

PART II: WATER SOURCE ,Source #: ·044-'1-0 I

1.

2_

3.

Where does the water come from I what· kind of source is this? J}tf.~u-. ve:-p.."n GI1t, <4-0 ;

sttftPr s: fT ~ ..., FtIJ?b 10 &r '"ta;r. Itt Yob1'i!M 6~ $11&'1' ..,-SHePel? 1f!u/o€\- ~~JI Types of sources~. : "':\ ~f/1}:r ~ WtJ IAJ M~~1t' ""~CIf'terJ •. 1) Wells (drilled, u. nnel)) 2) Diversions (dit ,pipe, pump, or livestock from a stream, spring. swamp, pond) 3) Multi-source systems. (Declared use cannot be traced to a single well or diversion) NOTE: If a multi-user system: take from pipe or ditch (need to determine whether this is a multi-source or single-source system before the data can be input to the computer '"10 fT 60 4) Instream (Le., crops planted along water ~dge) ~~

Show the source location on maps, determine latirude and longirude, and document the narure of source development by measurements, sketches. and photographs. How is the water taken? 6f?: f,.p.1~zt04'Q+"IJ, /..ptJ-IS-"&·1t:t'9t"W What is the capacity for taking (gpm)? lWO sp ttr ~c.. ~ c.¥/7JjD ltP1vt pt.{Mf - oNe.'" ~ wf> How often is it taken (used)? "~fY1 fH' AlI&1tr '& Elick I /.Ill> ~'*

Tax Map K<!y at the source: ~_~ __ b_: '2-B" Determine declarant's relation to source. Does the declarant:

1) Operate and maintain the source? Yer> If nat, who does? ________ _ 2) Own the land at the source? ~ If not. who does? __________ _ 3) Use the water from this source? ~ If not, who does? _________ _ 4) Own the land where the water is being u.sed? ~ 5) None of the above? If so, why did they file? __________ _

4. Does anyone else also use water from this source? AJo· If yes, is their use included in this user's declaration? __ Who are the ather users? Did they file? ____ _

Form 8810-1 0, !

1\ t:. eEl V E 0

STATE OF HAWAII COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

DEPARTMENT OF lAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION OF WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

D/V. OF WATER & LMm Dr.Vi:l()i)MENT

REGISTRATION OF WELL AND

DECLARATION OF WATER USE

INSTRUCTIONS: Please type or print. II information is not available or not appIicabI8. Indicate as NlA. Fill out as completely as possible. sign. and file form with the Division 01 Wilier Resowce Management. P.O. Box 373. Honolulu. Hawaii 9680e. Phone 54&3948 or 54&7543 for 1IIIistance.

BAlTERY OF WELLS: For a battery of wells. on the surface. in a tunnel. or in a shaft. submit a registration form for each well together with a single map or plot plan showing layout of wells.

STATE WELL NO.: 0449-01 ISLAND: Molokai WELL NAME OR DESIGNATION: ____ Ua_l_a..:,.p_u_e_S_h_a_f_t ____________ _

SOURCE OR STATION NA~E (For a battery of well): _______________ _

. A. WELL OPERATOR Firm name: Dept of Water Supply Contact person: _________ _

Address: P. O. Box 1109 Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii

Zip: 96793 Phone: 243-7830

C. WELL LOCATION

B. OWNER OF WELL SITE Arm name: State of Hawaii Contact person: _________ _ Address: ____________ _

Zip: __ -...,._ Phone: _______ _

Tax Map Key: 5-6-06: 28 Town. Place. District: _.J.jU:s.la"",1aaJP~u.ue"--_.....,.-______ _

Attach USGS "Quad" map (scale 1 :24.000). tax map. or other map showing the well location.

D. WELL DATA For DrUIed W~I •• subml .as-buII" drawing, drIIIer's log. and pump teet rasulta. and complete items below.

For Tunnel. and Shafts. submiI CONIIruClion drawingI. plot plan. or slcetch map.

Ground elevation (Mean .......... ): ft. Reference point (Used to II'I88IUAt depth to WIlIer):

Elevation: ft. Description: _________ _

Depth to water (Below reference point): ft. Maximum recorded chloride: 90 ppm Minimum recorded chloride: 57 ppm Maximum chloride in 1987: 75 ppm

E. INSTALLED PUMP DATA Pump type: ~ Vertical shaft 0 Submersible Power: 0 Diesel. __ HP 0 Gas. __ HP Pump capacity: gallons per minute

Year drilled or constructed: ______ _ Well contractor: __________ _

Casing diameter: .,-----' _______ in. Solid casing depth (Below ground): ft. Perforated casing depth (Below ground): . ft. Total depth of well: ft.

Minimum chloride in 1987: _~6~0:...-__ ppm

o Centrifugal 0 Other (specify): _____ _

fJ Electric. Z:5D HP 0 Oth~r (specify): ___ _ ,I

Pump installation contractor: F & M Cons true t ion Friendly Isle Contraetor & Equipment

... (continued over)

For Official Use Only: Date received:''I], JU) ... q, '\ Date accepted: ___ 0; II

Field checked by: ___ Date: Latitude: Itt D4 D'l.. Hydrologic Unit: _-:----".-Comments: Longitude: \'bID' Aq' t::,i/:a" State Well No.: oA-"tq - D ,

R ..... ce.: Hawaii Revised Statutes. Chapter 1704C. Hawaii Administrative Rules. Chapters 13·167 to 13-171.

F. DECLARATION OF WATER USE

NOTE: The purpoae 01 the ~ion 01 Wilier Use II to obIaIn Intormlllion neoessary for the management of the State's water N8OUICIII. The o.c:Iaration doeI not conIer a legal rIg~ to water or Its use.

Water use data are recorded: ~ Daily 0 Weekly 0 Monthly o Other (DMcrIbe): ____________ _

Method of measurement: ~ Flow Meter 0 Orifice

o Other (Oescrbe): ____ ------_----

Ouantity of Use (Report meIerec:I or _tlmated monthly water use from the well described on the reve .... side of this form. for the calendar ~ 1183 ttwough 1887. For a baltery 01 weill which •• not individually metered. but which are connected to a U1g1e meter or other mMIUring device. NpOrt total use from the bIItIery.):

;r WATER USE, IN GALLONS X 1000

1983 .1984 1B8~ 1986 1987 I . kaPU , ....... 4.480 3,746 3,609 4,671 4,203 Fe~:'l.Jarv 5~037 3,969 3,501 4,681 4,168 March 7.257 7,583 4,153 5,761 5,084 ! ADril 6,802 6,060 6,054 4,933 5,430

M~ 5,632 6,051 5,895 5,136 4,219

June 7.500 8,355 7,142 5,108 5,311 July 2 .818 6 433 6.376 5,550 6,380 I

.6.lll'tllct 7.794 8,542 6.377 808 5,558

.... r 4.645 6.175 5,286 5,134 5,811 nt!tnhAr 5 631 7.524 6,760 5,841 5,775 .. 4~619 4,437 2,579 4,201 4,286 ... r n ,,.., 5,460 5 302 4 ,023 4 721 ANNIJAL I 68.352 Z~.JJ~ 6:31 034 55 1847 60 1946

Minimum day's use: _______ gallons Maximum day'S use: ______ gallons Typical times of usage: _________________________ _

Type of Use (Check .. category box_1hat IIPPIY and provide addlionallntcirm.tion .. Indicated.):

CategorY Addttlonal Information

f] Municipal (including NIOI1a. hot ... buIInesMs)

o Domestic (systems MMng 25 people or leas)

o Irrigation

o Industrial

o Military

o Other

Number of service connections: ___ 2_8_1 _____ _

Acres Irr~ed: Crop(s): U Sug-a-r--.... O-P-in-e-app-Ie--------

o Other (specify): Non-Crop: 0 Landscape ----.-O-r--Go-H-,C-o-ur-s-e ----

o Other (s~ify): Method: 0 Drip U Furrow--"'O~S~p-r~in~kl~er----

o Cooling 0 Manufacturing 0 Mill o Other (specify): ____________ _

Specify (lMIsIock. aquaculture. etc.): __________ _

I declare that the contents of the above Declaration of Water Use are, to the best of my knowledge and belief, tru correct, and complete.

Water User's Signatur-.·...",:L~'_'''' _1A_~~.-,~-l-~ _____ ....... __ Printed Name: Vince G

Date:#ff

Firm or Title (Well Operator, etc.): _---=!DFi.;;..;;.;ec;:;.;t:;,:;o;,.::r~.~o;:..f ...;D:;,:;et=-'p;,:;a:.:.r.=;tm;:;e;;.;n;.;t;.....;;o..;;.f_W;;.:a::.:t::;:e:.:r--=-Su;;lp~p;.:1:.1.y __ County of Maui' ,

February 22, 1971

Mr. Carl Kaiama Director Dept. of Water Supply County of Mau! Kahului, Hawaii 96732

Dear Carll

U,lapue Shaft Source. Mplokai

Attached is a memorandum report by Dan Lum on the results of a pumping test conducted on Ualapue Shaft, Molokai, on November 17-20,.1970.

Should you have any further questiona concerning the reaults, please let us know.

J DLzjes Attach.

Very truly yours,

ROBERT '1'. CHUCK Manager-Chief Engineer

£j~v Ittdjl--t tl .. JJ ~'rJ( ; I.. '

Ie ( ,- "- . ',1'J

It IZ - (c 0 n"-€...1'J..vJ /

... o

February 19, 1971

MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD

FROM: Daniel Lum

SUBJECT: Estimate of Safe Yield, Ualapue. Sha~t, Molokai

During early November 1970, I inspected Ualapue Shaft (Molokai) and its tunnels, preliminary to arranging a pumping test to determine the safe yield of this County source. The shaft source consists of a If Til shaped tunnel arrangement with two branch tunnels about 75 feet long each, parallel to the shoreline. Observation was that a major part of the shaft yield originates in the east branch of the tunnel in a clinkery interflow zone. Upon recommendation, rock and miscellaneous debris in the tunnel invert which would tend to impede tunnel flow was removed prior to the pumping test.

On November 17-20, 1970 the Ualapue shaft was pump tested with an auxiliary pump at a constant rate of 1,000+ gpm for 78 hours. During the test period, the existing 100+ gpm pump -operated auto-· matically and intermittently, unrecorded~ Results of the pumping test are shown graphically on the attached drawing.

Salinity, not drawdown, appears to be the limiting factor in the safe yield of Ualapue shaft. Pumping at 1,000~ gpm, the chloride content increased about 40 ppm in the first 20 hours, peaked at 106 ppm and thereafter decreased gradually to 87 ppm. Normally, this result would be interpreted as a stabilization of the salinity and an indicated safe yield of 1,000 gp!'1. However, a "Kona" rainfall climate prevailed the week before and during the pumping test, making possible a period of higher-than-normal recharge to the aquifer and accounting for the gradual leveling

~of chlorides. This possibility harmonizes with the fact ~ th~tAthe observed static water level was 0.2 feet higher at thG c: end of the test period than at the beginning. (Thus, because the

pumping test was conducted unavoidably during a:ty~ical climatic conditions, a safe yield of 1,000 gprn for Ualapue shaft must be viewed with some caution at this time.)

The pumping capacity of Ualapue shaft can definitely be increased beyond its present capacity of several hundred gallons per minute. It is recommended, on the basis of the data available, that two pumps of not more than 700 gpm capacity each, be planned for Ualapue shaft. Higher capacity pumps are not recommended, because a heavy, intermittent pumping pattern will likely increase the salinity of the source. . II,

~LUM

f ." '.

c

c

c

1" () ~1 . ""

r:o'f

1°{ Cf:61

1,'0 y i ( 1-

'1; l"l)

~ f r ..st.J~

1:1' 30/~ f 11

q I Y 5 0

q I ~ ()

? ~o ") .

~f~

7 .1 C

',/ ·1 0

3 ·10

3 -'{ 0

3. 9 0

, ,

October 21, 1970

Mr. Carl Kaiama Director Dept. of \'Jater Supoly County of Haui Kahului, Maui 96732

Dear Carl:

We have tentatively scheduled a four-day pumping test of up to 1,000 gpm for the Ualapue shaft source on ~1olokai, beginning on !!onday, Nove"1her 16, 1970, by Roscoe :1053 Co.

In preparation for the test, Dan Lum, ~~ho inspected the shaft and tunnels, h.as recommended to l~r. Phil A.kiona of your 1"50lokai office that some boulders and other debris in the tunnel invert be removed prior to the test to permit maximum yield of the existing source.

~dh cc: !-1r. Phil Akiona

Mr. James Yoshimoto

ROBERT T. CHUCK Manager-Chief Engineer

o 10

" (\

0 , \/, f\ \

,~ if"' I"

"~ ! V"\ ("

\ \' , \' \'- )<;:: I

7' C'-) ~,--' . .,. .. U) f'j ('fJ ) \!' ,-, ("<0.,1)

:j 0 \,',

"j D \.

" '') ? 0 r t , \ '') ~l-

\~ <:) r >r 'G ~) -'\ '. .. r

0~ ) ~--... . " ') "-..-: -- J' -.. -" -.

o

''\'-- \\ \, ~ 0-- ':'j- > ~.

\' ") ,. )

~'" \ .... , ... ,

,~ \ .. ,) ,1' :'- ~ ~, "'J () ~ _I

~ .. ' ...... ) s- ',~ J .. v -- -

o

'\ro..,. "~ , ~':;""'~ ,..

'""~"

.. ~

' .. 1

:'1 '

.....~<

\ }

\~ \

.\~

\~

"

\

Q

i '''' i

\ \ ---'

"')

\ -::--.;::.... -::::......

" \

1 \ \

l

" I '\ t

i

.-..... "".

c l' 71-/ • 7 )' .:;)

)./5 --- q i../ ( . 1 ~1- - ') (;)

• --) I

,--"J,

/ q ":S3 '~.7 !

"

7jj , ( l> '? '5--) ) t

1> « ", / ;:; . (, 3 --'

1 j Y . ) 0 .;. &~) ," '1 ..

" , j ']

/ .,) . i '~

. - )0 3. , '-»

0 C( 1 .-} ') ... ,P",~/

'l . ) ). -q 1.1 ,) -., 3 ·

)) .... '

1 yO -I ) ? . ~

ri; 'i~-i.4 '~r'2... .:$ d ! ..- I 1 ) I

9 :"/~ 3c) "-:,,}',,.,#~

') ·'-IS ,

~ ".' I \ I.. ") 0 'j . ({ ,:;-

Dowald 8/63

PUMPING TEST RECORD for

____ ~)~A~L~A~e~~~ff4/~--------- Well (name)

Q

(No. )

---,vn'""""-~{; i-:;...;(,~k-_tJ.....:· I~ ____ I s land 5 e G;/L /~. L Project or Job No. H cv (1 19..2.£ Description of Well--I. Elevation: ground surface ____ ft., top of casing ____ ft.,€~ei~~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total depth of well_ft.;·or·~ft. e.~vA~, msl 3. in. solid casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ___ ft. depth 4. Static water level on 19: ft. below

ground surface, top of casing: or--- f~levation, msl measured method

Description of Pump and Pump Setting-- J- 1}L.:'l\fS jl£>{.I Sllplf

5. type pump with _ stage bowl assembly ,j((fLII ... l' 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with ____ horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: ft. below : or ft. elevation,msl 9. Depth of airline bottom~ft. below $P?t/ ;or ___ ft. elevation,msl 10. Center of gage: ft. elevation, msl. . Flow measured with ~;'aI/.I(tUi/ 11. Test conducted by '(2, j (!J1JIl{ ,... -

-., . Date Pwnping Airline arawdewn Chleri.~s Te.uperatur~ Cen •. ,

I & ! rate j

. (qpm) I

(feet) (feet) (prm) (eF) (nunhes,~5eC) Time . ! 0 ~~, . A OJvsf: Pu~f' To 1 ~s'"O ! I

.---.. -~ .... -----.-...... --- ... ---.... _--1--- ......... - .. -- ----l- _ ....... - .. _- .. -, t- - - - -.~ ... -- . - --. -... ~ .. _ ..... " _._._-....... ,

I V y ( D , 0 (0 ~: ).. q~' .75"" 1. I 61- __ L~_Y~ .. ___ ..... ,"'---"-~-~'~.--"'-- .,._-,--- ... _- .. _--_ .. _ .. _---

! _ ... _L.7 --z..

I , . ___ bq G 3. ':t ________ .

.l~ 1

b"t '[ \0 .. -. ~ ... -, 13-0 i • 1"1..- i b'1

! 71/ ,

I . ! l1vf ;;4~O -I E.x'';I! f\J r.. PlVfh P CI/o.J , .i1. '2, "; \

., ,- .. j:j,o I n j

t

/.0 0 ' (.1 1 )1 ~ , -F-)(I,;>-I,IhJ!:'1 Vi/; VIP' o~!'-

__ LCf ..1J...C. ____ g,..,-___ t- .-I

b' ~~ ~)) r' t-.. J.:1 --

.11 6 ell 1.-~ \' I ·11 b V'j Z-!, )-"

-.-.'1 ~~ I IJ,1 23~- -.

\' ' k ; rooD: (0.£.=..0_ ... --1I __ '2...;..'-',Q ..... 3<...-_-+-__

Irc/I{ ,/»)'r)i. :t. Cl\

, l.ftS Vi, J': 1'_ c. :2.L .1 hO I ~x PvV\"c r 01\1 .. ·70

(, a '2-~ (J .AlL..PUI->\O DF'F ...

\ ' J

--: I') !'.~ ! I l\ . -- 0 "'. f c.- ) 11) J ___ ':.L 0

1. O~ -;0 r"l "",e .. ,,-

I E')( PUIV>.P tHoJ j. ';, ') ... -

r,;;..: '~:fl'(;' -' .') :.' .") "r~; ~ + •• / - "" -.

..:" ,,, '. .J I t,

~!~j~OO~:~I~O~~~_=-_~-~)-·_~l ____ _+.~~~~~+_------_+----~--__ +-__ ~~ __ \ '. I J' : )i z.. I) . I 0 I) 0 _ I '-, 'J ~

.1'],. 7{) lZ,S-~. I 7~ , 21..)0 20 ~9'~

.·1~ 10.fO t q ~/O 1, , . j ...

I I 11-- 7~ ,3 b '1 3/0 I 15.g

, b ~ . .;- 3).0

--'1

. -'P-. I i .

'e <3 Or- 6- oJfee.T~ .. ~-~-- " ---------.. -

o o

. .. ' '

."

c

Dowald 8/63

PUMPING TEST RECORD

(for

U., A. f" 4 Well (name) (No. )

---4t1~.;;.. • ...:.( ....... _' __ <"_~_i,--__ ,Island _ ..... ? __ r~C.=,_\ __ "".c:;..JI"'---____ project or Job No. N,,, '" 191 D

Description of Well-- ~ r 1. Elevation: ground surface ____ ft., top of casing ____ ft.,€~Die~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total de&>th of well_ft.; ·or·2.....-ft. eJ~vA.t.J"QP, msl 3. in. solid casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ft. depth 4. static water level on 19: ft. below

ground surface, top of casing; or--- f~leyation, msl measured method

Description of Pump and Pump Setting-- 'l t'\I""\t'S: , B'l, STIN ~ 5. type pump with _ stage bowl assembly 's pee, tieL. 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with ____ horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: ft. below : or ft. elevation,msl 9. Depth of airline bottom~{ ft. below BAle:or ___ ft. elevation,msl 10. center of gage: ft. elevation, msl. Flow measured with pit fil.,',tE 11. Test conducted by __ C~._J~IN~Muh~; __________________________________ __

i O:te; :p~~~~g I~~rline .rawdewn Ch1eri.~~ T@!.f~ra.tur~ Cenil. .J Time. (qpm) ; (feet) (feet) (!}{"m). (·F) f(mmhes,2S·C)·

t~~~~)-rlrr. ~-~i: 500- t~ ~o~~is~;;' ~;~ ~. ", .. ;.,,. -;. ~';f_~~=_ i".JJf{_ ! 3.$"O I ___ ~ . t • I." c ..a )--~--,._-'\00 I I 3.4S: ! D,o~ C I. i I, " ....

I ,: I r : •• ~,~- •. -.

! .. ~.!.l.M,-- I I j" I !~'t~l~O_·~S~~~~~~_: __ -=l~.SL-~i ____ ~D~ __ ~1 ______ ~I __ ----__ ~ __ -------I ..lL$.(;.? , ,I ; "3,~ 0_ i _ I ______ -4-_____ _

,

!-,,~l ?-::..:c~o::::....;,.' S~T.::::(;:"..::::.yt,:...:.i~r...:::vtln::./\ .:...p....:--...:~~,u.~~~.t::v2..:+~:...-::h~:---i/:...::O:::.· -=():..:' O:::.ji:-·s::::6'-lP'::'''''''::l-_-+-_-':'-':'';-·' __ -+ __ ~ __ -___ _ , (203 : 5'10(1 f..;"", P '- -- .-..... --,-_._+--_ .... -----+-------'---; {? \ 0 , ex ( S 'Il N 6 i Pu rn P 0 N ..L,------+------ii-------+------... )1:2(3 :" , 3,4)' ~O\ j ( ;).1 5 , S T(~ 1'2_1 f'u Wl ~ CLrlv n-1 P I { ( () -~~-+~~--~~--~~~~~-~~-~------~--------+-----------.-

: 1'1-').0: II [0 3,00 u O,S.o ?.IO

. t o

~ .~. .~ . '

... ~

c

Dowa1d 8/63


____ ~V~~~LA~~~~w~e~------- Well . (name) (No. )

--""J4~b.lll':.II:D;.:::M::c;:...~1 ___ I s land 6FJ!Et:/ 1& project or Job No. ___ 19_

Description of We11-- ± r 1. Elevation: ground surface ____ ft., top of casing ____ ft.,€Rfiie~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total depth of wel,l_ft. :·or·~ft. e.l~vAj;'.4lP, msl 3. in. solid casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ___ ft. depth 4. Static water level on 19: ft. below

ground surface, top of casing: or--- f~levation, ms1 measured method

Description of Pump and Pump Setting--5. type pump with ~ stage bowl assembly 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with _ horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: .......o-ft. below : or _ft. e1evation,ms1 9. Depth of airline bottom: ____ ft. below :or ___ ft. e1evation,ms1 10. Center of gage: ft. elevation, ms1. Flow measured with ___ _ 11. Test conducted by ____________________ ~ ______________________ ___

; Date Pumping, Airline .rawdewn ! & rate !-------I-

I • I ,. i-:;:--- . '--~-"-

I iYJ_~~. (~ANv. .. ,.jJ i{dJMh--:: 1 ... l3t.S .. ~- ~ i ..3.I.~

L_ /foo Jj I D i 3-,r '2« i #tJS:= 13rO

; ,50 II J () , ...

lif-It; '11/ I 1-.!o~ I I '-f~ ! -;,.. &, 't ,~~ : ..••• -~.-. I

~I? ,C; / 1-f?J() iI/I 0 fv \ I \ 1 ;4.3(: 5'10 jOp~ - elJGINf: 5i~~f!.~ :B~0rr;F

f ' 1 '0

I IJ l i i 1 . ! 76 ! I I I

70 /1\7" \ RUNNIN~ ------

I' j

.~-- ... --- .. ____ .... 1

I

... --... -.-... --. ! -_. . ...1

!

?-sO i i

-I

'2=50 J . f-----~-..

. ...Lfl11: 1 3.4~ . ,(!I ..

! QliO; ~1bfl; I 3.L l(fcC flJmp~ , )FF 1 ./

oFF) 0/17 \,

I i f,(I:;!'~:::? I c) 7 fI I 3.70 . .::::~ Tt;:dt ... 1tt:1Q E f..lG.IN.~ Dr.. ~v..>

.~

\

~

0''';''1 '3,70 0 ,( ,

-I _.

I

./V i 0; 'J') I ;';'. £0 51; ;. "(, .. \ i 'n:TfO evI'Y f

'0<60/ 1 £'OJVY' ~ti PV~IO 1 k> ,/¢.O GPI'Y'I .!

O~II , .0. D JV5'i€t. 'u~"JO 10:20 ~fl<>'\ ! t

iO~I) I I O?-O! . ~i bS b ./ (;~9 ?~ ) r ·'1 ' s i

, ui:o ::C ].:>q' ., 'l ?3( -·1 O~)..{) 1 . "" I(r..\~, () L "1 o <6 ).(: 10 ;l o .. j'" : "'" "&'0 ., n b Col

~ .;-

.' ~ '~'~' . ". '2..:) \ i

o ;i3 0 I +- } ,'1) .~ .Of :j b'l :1.)\ .... '1 101.0 .. _ L._. I

J-j? . ..

Q(r:J ~_ (b'10: 1 I gO I ~ ... ,9 0 &, !

1.-0 of: .J. ,'~:; : -~~ ... ] I 17) •.. i

tJ ~10' ( b 1 ,

bq ; i • V" r ...-! , •.

'."

• oJ

...

..,."

, .

o

Dowald 8/63


__ ();.c..A,I;.lI/-;;,cA*-+-r_.:.U.-:;;;F--:-____ We 11 (name)

MneMI Island 6eeCdAL- project or Job No. 19 Description of Well--I. Elevation: ground surface ____ ft., top of casing ____ ft.,€iei~~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total ~epth o~ well_ft.: 'or··~ft. e.#lVA.t.~, msl 3. 1n. so11d casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ___ ft. depth 4. Static water level on 19: ft. below


Description of Pump and Pump Setting--5. type pump with ___ stage bowl assembly 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at ----gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: ft. below : or ft. elevation,msl 9. Depth of airline bottom~ ft. below ior ---ft. elevation,msl 10. Center of gage: ft. e'leVa'tion, msl. Flow measured with ___ _ II. Test conducted by ____________________________________________ ___

Date pumping; Airline arawdelrm Chleri.~~ Te.r.~ratur1 Cen.. i & rate --.,-----+

,Time m ~ fe~t feet (prrn). (·F) (mmhe:c:; I ~5 ·c)

• ~:i~:·JO~ T;·--~bO--E~~j-;~;;:1t-J-/};· i .H{ ___ '3:t,;~ I 1-----:-L.0...2:2---f_ 2.. .. Q 0 ~l. _ ___ ft_. -l-.. __ . I 68..- _2. .. s:: .---- .. \

~1·~6~OO:·~/9.::)j, o{ ~ '22

1693 £4e.v~~ $2,0 I .. ~~~ f' ~;L·_I ~ !..h...J v as-a _ 0 -.~! n ~ QLUl ",',)', ,) ! tdL ~__ ,,-' 0 ._ .. ..:

\i 2"'l 0' ;i- +- i 7 1 I J: /~. .,..- ? /"./' i .. 1.. TO . La..;> 0 - i 2 ZR f/ I .. ' Off; b d".'::> -.l (;) ~ .

11/18~lo2n() IO"s-o:r I ,;~ 00 fA i It .70 O-r-p! ! 03. (\ 1 ;; fr.:5'. if 00 J i ' Joo " I /) • b-::1O{!, !,' -r I ' 1> ~ / / I'j

1Q_4001 L 01.. e..:::2-+ 3 0 z.. II .- L' J -::.f I ~o ,5 '7,J 0 ! 0' ()" ' 1010 :! I '1 . 5' R tI I I • 7" ').. 0 ;11 1 !:) , t, 68. 5- ~ 3 a _ ! D a 0 t2' I??lo -I .~, I" • 0'::> _ '~ ~.'.:, ~9' ___ 1-.L5 D ___ _ i 0 9Q (); (Q So" i 3, i u",~'iP cf:~ 1,0 .1,,) (:" q t.fff'] 0 ..

'-i42ao; 1015/}-I ! _~. f) ,7:::; '" ) '20 '5'.

~ 'I 0 '), Ifl <; o~· 2 q I , 25 0 I ) .~. J ~ 1 Lf Lf $-- .. -j -' r~":< f'i. ;., 1 !

'L~QQ : I(J<)O : ") '7 \c· !~ 15" . ,.",\') 5:' ~~q t './ "". .:/ 5 /. :,...)

+ Iii tJo; I t)5 0 t :J 7 r r.?(;';;·'l . ., ( '0'. - ~9 'i

'Ol, () c .~ , IO[l

./ 1:1. )

/:;0.0 bY ..

" .t:l~" . I . ., :/ ,-"

-- " i f

4!:Ls- ---~:;i

J7 0 0 ; ! Q (" 0 £ ~. __ -+'. _~. "/~"'I_-+-...t-=...~_-I-_~-'--_-+---'fCfa() I foro :. i ;,t,"1 -.

rrco b c{ 01.:0 .. ,"f ,~() !q t J. ., 'il -1

'-9~1 I iii , . '. ..-

41~ ...

!\.O £1 ~ , 7 ..., ,.

91-.( ,

("( b' 1./ :). \

{ I

c

,'\

\ f'\\ ......

".,

--

.... :"(" . r\ . J

n

Dowald 8/63 o PUMPING TEST RECORD

for __ ~~~A .. LLA~r~H~~~ ________ Well

(name)

o

MOL-OM! Island 6eet::/IAI- project or Job No. 19_

Description of Well--I. Elevation: ground surface ____ ft., top of casing ____ ft.,t~~i~~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total depth of well_ft.: 'or"-' ft. el~vA:t.1.9P' msl 3. in. solid casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ft. depth 4. static water level on 19: ft. below


Des~iption of Pump and Pump Setting--5. type pump with ___ stage bowl assembly 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with ____ horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: ____ ft. below : or ___ ft. elevation,msl 9. Depth of airline bottom: ft. below tor ft. elevation,msl 10. Center of gage: ft. elevation, msl. Flow measured with _______ __ 11. Test conducted by ______________________________________________ __

: Date. Pumping i Airline .rawde\;TIl Chleri.·at; Tt!f~ratur1 Cen.. I ~ Ttrne' (~~;~ !-(feet) (feet) (~J:'I')) (eF) (nunheF;,2S eC) "

e '!a.1~Q~ ... ~Q.JO~_,.~-.--~: 12 ... ~._+__.'.7.1 ... -.J. _1:2.9 ..... , l .. 6'1·---,1-·· .'!.~~L __ " ... , I ~_ o900~J~ ro t _+- __ ~_!_~ __ L _,~2Q..,_,_ .. L. fv-.-t-~.----+-,-~-.~,>::.--... j

If~IO)~}+~:~ -+-~·~ol2- '/2.0 I·-Z~:_·_I· ;gt;=-J 11500 ' '- 0 S1) - I 3, J . fO (/./ ~ ! r~~O'-/ 050 I .s ,,~, ,i 0 .I ! l£m L~!i?:U )2. I I )-

0 I .j..J,L.~--+--=::::oo.?--!'-J1 __ r---r-~c---!~I( -1 / "" I .'::> , f,':l YI'i:'? :(~O-':/':>I~ ) (, S/'O

j?Q A -I 9.' ~ '/ / ~ ~;;.-,,---: -:/ o~~ ye(:J ._,:,-·50 I ._.!C~<t:0 J.___ / ~:.-__ 7%,,(,Jot);/a61J 1;. i 3!L 1 ____ ' {Q_' tr~. 0 J 0

. t7...?oo: [p ~, __ _ilr_ ____ +_--

!Q~()'() , I

:'2.;1?o / :5 (j ·10 00; ..... 0

I ~ ~~!:-+--"-:::...:.....::.----l~----_+-----. t ,- ;

--I .JL~~-t..:....:---i---=~~-___f--.:.C:-~-_!_----+_----_t------. r

3.~·~ ,r)"1 i ~~~-J~~·--+-~~~--+----~~-~------+--------~----------·1

i ..JL....L...L..!Io4---J...lL.-=----+-~-L.:~-_+----'t..-.::oC.~-_l_-----+_----__t------.-:

_...I!!"I.:..C.~)~ . ..l..---I-----!...:::::-4--+-------i------+------.. ,

.tiS

Dowald 8/63

0 0 PUMPING TEST RECORD

for llAL~e/Ae Well

(name) (No. )

JJ1 () l- o)<.A I Island ..!5eec..IAL. Project or Job No. 19 -Description of Well--1. Elevation: ground surface ft., top of casing ____ ft.'t~5i~~ft.,

referenced to benchmark 2. Total depth of well_ft. ; ·or·~ft. e.l~vAJ • .i"QP, msl 3. in. solid casing to ____ ft. depth, perforated to ft. depth 4. Static water level on 19: ft. below

ground surface, top of casing; or--- f~levation, msl measured method

Description of Pump and Pump Setting--5. type pump with ___ stage bowl assembly 6. Gasoline diesel, electric, power with horsepower 7. Shaft speed: rpm at -gpm flow 8. Depth of pump intake: ft. below ; or ft. elevation,msl 9. Depth of airline bottom~ ft. below jor ---ft. elevation,msl 10. Center of gage: ft. eleVation, msl. Flow measured with ______ __ 11. Test conducted by ______________________________________________ __

-Cen.. .1

Date Pumping Airline arawdetm Chl.ri.~f; TeuperaturC!! & ; rate

L __ ,

Time (qpm) ,

(f€~t) (feet) (rtrM ). (eF) (rnmheR/~5·C)

! l?j/+~{~ .. 10_0 __ ._.L.-.-.~., .~r:'. __ +!f! (!y~~ f.q,~d.- ... '1'_(1.. .,. ! 70 t _.' :)..1. .~ ...... '" f ..

I - . .~ .".-~ - .- -I

L)1r~ 100 ;;,. '1~- I I'I( L I ,--- .-- •• - ____ .. __ ••. · ••.• _. ___ L .. ____ .• _ .. _ .... ,' ___ I -_._-- _ ..... _ .... __ ... - ---_ ...

: ,-----'-'. ----4------l-------+-----+------t--.------. , I I ! I t ---!...---!---~-+-----+_' ----1-----+------.

, i ,Ii ----+-1 ------/-.-----...;..' .------+-------1------+------: I 1 -----+------+-----~_4--------~-------+_--------_4---------!

Q ; ! -.-...:..----+-------4--__ 1-------+---1------.

i. ---+----+-------+------+-----+------+-----_._( I I I --4! .. -.----......j,-____ -I-_____ +-____ -+-____ -+ ______ ~. ! I j i

------r-... --.---+! ------- 1 I i

Dewald 8/63 o CHLORIDE TITRATION RECORD

for A'l O&Q 1<61 LlA(...AfLle. Well

(No. )

6J;;J M()J,.~)<AI Island ~,.e.e-/AJ- project or Job No. _____ 19_ Titrations conducted by __ n~.=]~I~~~~~~~( ________________________________ __

o

c

Dowald 8/63 o o CHLORIDE TITRATION RECORD

for ____ ~dLA~L~~~e~U~~~ ___________ wel1

(No. )

MOJ,,€Jtt:.A I Island 6r~C-IA" project or Job No. _____ 19_ Titrations conducted by ______________________ _

I

i=~=--·-·-- . -T==~~~·-+!----+---:~-=-~~-_t_r----------,:----:----::--~---~~--:-=------= ! i

1-----+-1

-----+---+----+---+----+---+----- f----.-.-.f------.

d' \

U. S. DEPAR'IMENT OF THE INTERIOR GEOIOOICAL SURVEY

WATER RESOURCES DIVISION

Analyses by Geological Survey, United States Department of the Interior (milligrams per 1i ter)

~ ~~ ezHAW Laboratory Number •••••••••• _ • • • • • (t,)", I~" '518'~ 1520

Date ot collection ••••••••••••••• 11/20/70 12/5/70

Silica (S1~) •••••••••••••••••••• 43 30

Iron (Fe) •••••••••••••••••••••••• -- --Manganese (Mn) ••••••••••••• ., ••••• -- --

Calcium (Ca) ••••••••••••••••••••• 16 14 Magnesium (Mg) ••••••••••••••••••• 12 6.2 Sodium (Na) •••••••••••••••••••••• 73 7.2 Potassium (K) •••••••••••••••••••• 5.0 0.8

Bicarbonate (HC03) •••••••••••.••• 122 72 Carbonate (C03) •••••••••••••••••• 0 0 SUlfate (S04) •••••••••••••••••• ' •• 18 1.0 Chloride ~Cl) •••••••••••••••••••• 95 12 Fluoride F) ••••••••••••••••••••• 0.1 0.1 Nitrate (N03) · • . · • • · • • • • • • • · · • · • · 4.2 2.4

Dissolved solids Residue on evaporation at 180°C -- --CalcUlated ••••••••••••••••••••• 326 109

Hardness as CaC~ •••••••••••••••• 90 61 Noncarbonate hardness as CaC~ ••• 0 2 Alkalinity as CaC03 •••••••••••••• 100 59 Specific conductance

(micro~hos at 2500) •••••••••••• 531 151 pH ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 7.4 6.5 Color •••••••••••••••••••••••••••• -- --Carbon diox1de (C02)calculated ••• -- --Temperature (00) ••••••••••••••••• -- --

HA1~ 1518 Pump Test, shaft at ~alapua, ~to1okai~ 1130 hrs.

HAW 1520 Spring-fed water system at Ninole, North Hilo Collected by D. Shigeoka at 1130 his.

HAW

john waihee hoaliku governor state of hawaii i'· state … · the windward o'ahu wells...

Documents