jobsoutlook - engage employee · jul–sep 2014 oct–dec 2014 employed self-employed temps in work...
TRANSCRIPT
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress
86% of hirers plan to add permanent headcount over the next quarter, whilst almost eight in ten (79%) plan to do so in the medium term.
95% of employers know that they either have no workforce surplus or that the little capacity they have may be insufficient to accommodate any form of increase in demand.
99% of hirers plan to hold or increase agency worker levels in the medium term, whilst 98% intend to do the same over the next quarter.
In the past year, pay rises were twice as likely in the private (40%) as the public sector (20%), despite staffing increases being broadly similar across the sectors.
Employers anticipate driving and distribution skills to be in short supply to fill both permanent (14%) and temporary (10%) roles over the next year.
Eight in ten (79%) hirers are using agency workers to gain short-term access to key strategic skills.
JobsOutlookAugust 2015
CONTENTS Permanent Recruitment / Temporary Recruitment / Labour Market Dashboard / Employer Dashboard / Agency Dashboard / Sector Prospects / Predictive model
Permanent and agency hiring intentions surge
Key Points from July Survey
Three quarters (74%) of employers believe that economic conditions, domestically, are improving and 45% believe that this more favourable outlook will lead to increased confidence in making hiring and investment decisions by their organisations.
Confidence
Recruitment &Employment
Confederation
1 3 5
4 62
permanent
86%next
quarter
Do you think economic conditions in the country as a whole are getting ...
Do you/does your organisation expect confidence in hiring and investment decisions to get ...
REC-Markit Predictive model
Our current nowcast is for a further modest rise in the labour force survey measure of unemployment of 10 thousand in the three months to July, and for the unemployment rate to hold steady at 5.6%. This latest nowcast points to a slightly slower rise in unemployment than the 25 thousand increase in the three months to June.
More information about the predictive model can be found on page 9 of this report.
5.6%
Expected unemployment rate for March–July 2015
95%no workforce surplus
A lot better A little better No change A little worse A lot worse Don’t know
396 38 11 15
[%]
668 8 9 2 7
[%]
79%medium term
temporary
98%next
quarter
99%medium term permanent
temporary
10%
14%
8 in 10use agencyworkers
40%private sector
20%public sector
pay rises
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 2
OUTLOOK BY EMPLOYER SIZENet balance of short-term expectations by employer size – permanent staff The drive in short-term permanent hiring intention remains evenly spread across all sizes of employer. Small companies (11–50 employees) are, however, evidencing the highest likely demand over the next quarter in July.
NOTE: Figures are based on the % responding increase less the % responding decrease, analysed by size of employer
SKILLS SHORTAGES AND QUALITY OF HIRESWhere do you expect to see a shortage of workers this year?An anticipated shortfall in technically skilled workers for permanent hire claimed two of the three top spots in July, whilst those with logistics skills are also anticipated to be in short supply over the next year.
Microbusiness(1–10 employees)
76
Small(11–50 employees)
Medium(51–200 employees)
Large(200+ employees)
4%82% 7% 7% 0%
1%77% 17%
3%2%
4%82% 7% 7% 0%
1%77% 17%
3%2%
PermanentRecruitment
SHORT-TERM OUTLOOKIn the next 3 months, do you think that your organisation’s permanent workforce will increase or decrease?Short-term permanent hiring intention improved further in July, with the positive balance increasing 7 percentage points to 79%. The proportion of hirers planning to add headcount increased 12 percentage points to 86%. With 7% of employers planning to reduce worker numbers slightly, there is potential that this increased availability will partially satisfy demand.
MEDIUM-TERM OUTLOOKIn the next 4–12 months, do you think that your organisation’s permanent workforce will increase or decrease?July evidenced an 11 percentage point increase in the positive balance of medium term permanent hiring intention. With almost eight in ten hirers (79%) planning to increase numbers (+10 percentage points in the month), the 3 percentage point decrease in the proportion planning to release workers (to just 4%) will intensify competition for skills.
% of respondents
Increase greatly
Increase greatly
Increase slightly
Increase slightly
Stay the same
Stay the same
Decrease slightly
Decrease slightly
Decrease greatly
Decrease greatly
79Monthly change
Net balance
75Monthly change
Net balance
% of respondents
84
7
May–July 2015
Computing, IT, Telecoms
Driving, Distribution
14%15%
12%
12 3
Technical, Engineering
NOTE: Proportion of employers who anticipateskills shortages. Rolling three month average
11
8177
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 3
TemporaryRecruitment
SHORT-TERM OUTLOOKIn the next 3 months, do you think that your organisation’s use of agency workers will increase or decrease?In addition to UK plc’s signal of strengthened permanent hiring intention in July, hirers also highlighted their plans to increase agency worker numbers. The proportion of hirers planning to add agency headcount over the next quarter increased by 13 percentage points (to 44%). The fact that just 2% plan any form of release will add to their challenge.
OUTLOOK BY EMPLOYER SIZENet balance of short-term expectations by employer size – agency staffing Whilst the hiring intentions of microbusinesses largely focus around engaging permanent staff, large employers continue to increase their intended focus on hiring agency workers.
NOTE: Figures are based on the % responding increase less the % responding decrease, analysed by size of employer
MEDIUM-TERM OUTLOOKIn the next 4–12 months, do you think that your organisation’s use of agency workers will increase or decrease? Whilst the proportion of hirers planning to increase agency worker numbers in the medium term increased by 12 percentage points this month (to four in ten), just 1% of organisations signalled any intent to reduce numbers. This results in 99% of hirers planning to hold or increase agency staffing levels.
SKILLS SHORTAGES AND QUALITY OF HIRESWhere do you expect to see a shortage of workers this year?It is amongst technical, managerial/professional and logistics workers that hirers anticipate a shortfall in the availability of agency workers over the next year. With two of the top three categories also being flagged as an issue over the anticipated availability of workers for permanent hire, this points to areas of key skills shortage.
Microbusiness(1–10 employees)
Small(11–50 employees)
Medium(51–200 employees)
Large(200+ employees)
Increase greatly
Increase slightly
Stay the same
Decrease slightly
Decrease greatly
39Monthly change
Net balance
% of respondents% of respondents
Increase greatly
Increase slightly
Stay the same
Decrease slightly
Decrease greatly
42Monthly change
Net balance
NOTE: Proportion of employers who anticipate skills shortages. Rolling three month average
Professional, ManagerialTechnical, Engineering
May–July 2015
16%
10%
Driving, Distribution
3
14%
2 1
16
38 41
55
12
0%1%
1% 2%0%
1%
54%43%
39% 59%
0%1%
1% 2%0%
1%
54%43%
39% 59%
13
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 4
LabourMarketDashboard
LLOYDS BUSINESS BAROMETERAccording to Lloyds, business confidence fell 5 percentage points to a 5-month low in July (50%), fuelled by a decline in sentiment towards the UK’s economic prospects. Firms’ sentiment around their own trading prospects was also marginally lower.
Total employment, employed and self-employed
CONSUMER CONFIDENCE INDEX Following last month’s 6 point increase to +7, noted by GfK as ‘a real post-election bounce’, the Index decreased by three points in July to +4. Three of the measures used to calculate the Index saw decreases this month, one measure saw an increase and one stayed the same. Expectations for the General Economic Situation over the next 12 months decreased five points to -1, some ten points lower than in July 2014.
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT – PERMANENT AND TEMPORARYWhilst the UK’s workforce reduced by 63,000 against the previous quarter, it remained 354,000 higher than in Q2 2014. One notable year-on-year decrease was in self-employed numbers – down by 95,000. Of this figure, 70,000 were full time roles, 59,000 of which were performed by men. 200,000 potentially ‘falsely self-employed’ workers in construction were the government’s key target for new legislation introduced in April 2014.
UNEMPLOYMENT AND CLAIMANT NUMBERSFor the second consecutive month, unemployment was reported as rising against the previous quarter – up by 25,000 in Q2 2015 against Q1. This implied a rate increase from 5.5% to 5.6%. Unemployment remains 221,000 lower than in the same period last year, however, when the rate was 6.3%. The quarterly rise was felt amongst both those unemployed for up to 6 months and those out of work for 6–12 months. Youth unemployment rose slightly from 15.9% to 16.0%, quarter-on-quarter.
% net balance % net balance
Business prospects(LHS)
Economic prospects (RHS)
Long-term average
(both series)
60
0
40
80
20
-20
-60
-40
-80
-100
50
60
70
80
40
30
0
10
20
-10
-20
-30
Jul 07 Jul 08 Jul 09 Jul 10 Jul 11 Jul 12 Jul 13 Jul 14 Jul 15JulJun Jul Sep NovAug DecOct Jan MayFeb Mar JunApr
+7
+1 +1
-2 -2-1
-2-4
+1 +1
+4 +4+4
+1
Source: LBCB, BDRC Continental
Source: Labour Market Statistics, August 2015: unemployment (quarterly) and claimant count (monthly)Source: ONS
Source: GFK
30,680 30,793 30,896 31,098 31,035
25,831 26,027 26,181 26,370 26,316
4,608 4,520 4,501 4,504 4,5121,651 1,701 1,704 1,688 1,644
Total employed
Apr–Jun2015
Apr–Jun2014
Jul–Sep2014
Oct–Dec2014
Employed Self-employed Temps in work
Jan–Mar2015
NOTE: Figures for April and May 2015 have been revised this month
Num
ber
00
0s
Dec
Number of claimants Unemployment
JulMayMar JunAprJun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Jan Feb
730
1,04
0
1,00
5
967
946
922
893
863
826
796
776
764
754
748
2,0741,959 1,862 1,827 1,852
-3
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 5
EmployerDashboard
WORKFORCE CAPACITY How much capacity is there in your business to take on more work?The fact that hiring intention has been increasing over the past three months appears to be being borne out in the additional capacity that this is realising for employers. For the majority, however, this translates into just a little potential spare resource. Based on the surge in hiring intentions in July, it would appear that this small increased capacity is not anticipated to be able to satisfy demand.
Workforce changes made in the last year 3 month rolling average to July 2015
3 month rolling average to July 2015 Recruitment channels used for temporary staffing as at July 2015
WORKFORCE PLANNING BY SECTOR Instances of increased pay/earnings were twice as likely in the private sector (40%) as the public sector (20%) in the year to July 2015, whilst the instances of staffing level increases were broadly similar across the sectors. In a tightening labour market, the ability of private sector employers to respond to demand by offering increased pay/earnings could help them attract staff more effectively.
WORKFORCE PLANNINGWhat changes have you made to your workforce in the past year?Seven in ten employers (69%) either increased pay or headcount over the last year, whilst 22% made no workforce changes whatsoever. This left just 9% making redundancies or cuts to pay/hours.
RECRUITMENT CHANNELS USED OTHER THAN AGENCYThe key channel through which hirers have lost their dependency and/or capability to source temporary workers over the last year is their alumni network. This route was used by just 10% hirers in July compared with 20% in the same month last year. Talent pools/staff banks remain a channel of choice, and are notably more significant to hirers that throughout 2014.
A little – we might take on staff if demand grew this year
None – we would have to take on new staff
A fair amount – we could take on a lot more work now
Considerable – we have a great deal of spare capacity
40%
0% 1%
42%
1% 1%
25% 28%
% responses
Reduced pay Reduced hours Headcount freezeStaffing increased
Redundancies Increased pay/Earnings None
8% 3% 6%4%20%
21%
Privatesector
Publicsector
13%
7%
15%
16%
6%
12%
10%
13%
8%
15%
4%
15%
13%
2%7%
20%
9%
15%
16%
6%
13%
14%
3%
9%
19%
7%
13%
17%
7%
13%
14%
4%
10%
18%
6%
11%
15%
8%
11%
15%
4%
9%
20%
7%
11%
13%
7%
11%
16%
3%
8%
21%
8%
13%
12%
9%
10%
16%
5%
9%
19%
7%
13%
14%
8%
11%
15%
6%
10%
18%
6%
12%
14%
10%
11%
14%
7%
12%
16%
6%
16%
10%
11%
15%
7%
12%
16%
6%
18%
11%
10%
10%
4%
18%
15%
11%
18%
10%
11%
10%
4%
15%
13%
15%
15%
10%
14%
14%
5%
14%
8%
15%
MayApr JunAug JulJul Sep Nov DecOct Jan Feb MarPeople approach us
Job Centre/Universal jobmatch
Internal referrals Online job boards Own web site
Talent pools and staff bank Alumni network
Offline advertising Social media
10% 7% 3% 4% 5%
3%41%
5%
28%22%
1%0%
None
Reduced pay Staffing increased
Redundancies Increased pay/earnings
Headcount freezeReduced hours
3 monthrolling average
0%
Resp
onde
nts
July
201
4Ju
ly 2
015
0%58%
57%
37%
35% 8%
5%
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 6
AgencyDashboard
CRITERIA USED BY EMPLOYERS TO SELECT AGENCIESHow important to you are the following factors when it comes to choosing and using a recruitment agency to cover temporary positions?With the ability to provide management information and an agency’s scale (i.e. its size and/or geographical or skills specialism), fast approaching the level of importance given to overall quality of service, an agency’s own role appears to be becoming as strategically important as the workers it provides. However, costs remain the top concern.
TEMPORARY TO PERMANENT In what proportion of hiring organisations do temporary workers go on to take permanent roles?Whilst the proportion of employers in which at least one temporary worker has transferred to become a permanent employee over the last year is slowly increasing again, at 44% this remains significantly lower than the 90% level at which it sat for many years. With demand for both permanent and agency workers being strong, it is likely to suggest that decisions are being made on a case by case basis, rather than signalling any notable shift in strategic intent.
IMPORTANCE OF AGENCIES TO EMPLOYERS How important would you say that agency workers are for your organisation in terms of the following?The ability to use agency workers to cover others’ leave – the key benefit for nine out of ten hirers two years ago – now ranks 6th in importance. In its place, eight in ten employers now cite the ability to gain short-term access to key strategic skills as being of greatest importance.
EMPLOYER SATISFACTION WITH AGENCIES USED IN LAST 2 YEARS How satisfied are you overall with the agencies you have used in the last 2 years?A net satisfaction rating of 93% in July serves as a useful indication of how well recruitment agencies are faring amid the pressure of heightened demand. This level of satisfaction remains a significant achievement for a service industry.
Scores indicate the % responses stating the factor is quite or very important.Percentage of respondents where at least one temp has become permanent
34%
44%
56%60%
62%59%
52%48%
32%36%
55%
38%
59%
MayApr JunJul Aug JulSep NovOct Dec Jan MarFeb
3% 0%
1%
63%
33%
Very satisfied Fairly satisfied Stay the same
Fairly dissatisfied Very dissatisfiedScores indicate % responses stating the factor is quite or very important
93
Monthly change
Net satisfaction
82%81%
66%
51%
67%50%
34%
59%82%
79%
20%
91%
57%
66% 37%
52% 59% 54%
July 2013
Peaks indemand
Coveringleave
Reducingcosts
Managingchange
Respondingto growth
Providing shortterm access
to key strategic skills
Managinguncertainty
% responses
July 2014 July 2015
58%31%
23%
45%48%
49%
94%100%93%
94%98%
85%
35%
46%
70%
27%23%
57%
68% 75%
July 2013
Agency brand Agency scale Management information
Quality of service
Price/costs of workers
Trade associationmembership
% responses
July 2014 July 2015
14%
-2
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 7
Temporary workers earn less than they would if theywere permanent
Cannot say/Not applicable/Don’t know
Temporary workers earn more than they would if they were permanent
Temporary workers earn about the same as they would if they were permanent
80%
70%
65%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%MayJul 14 Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul 15
65 65 65 6561
56 56
62
32
38
4
61
29 31 29 2932
30
36
50
41
6
35 6 8 63 3 3
1 1 02
42
65
32
30
102
322
5544
01
54
45
AgencyDashboard
SATISFACTION WITH CANDIDATES How satisfied are you with the quality of candidates presented to you by your agencies?89% of hirers are satisfied with the quality of candidates being presented by agencies, despite increasing demand for their services and skills shortages in key areas.
AGENCY WORKER PAY RATESHow do agency pay rates compare to permanent worker pay rates?Almost all hirers (99%) believe that agency worker pay rates translate into the same or higher earnings than that enjoyed by their permanent counterparts.
Very satisfied Fairly satisfied Neither satisfied or dissatisfied Fairly dissatisfied Very dissatisfied
52%
37%
5%6%
0%
3 month rolling average to July 2015
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 8
TECHNOLOGY
OFFICE SALESPROFESSIONAL
HOSPITALITY MEDICAL
SectorProspects
EDUCATION ENGINEERING FINANCE
INDUSTRIAL
TemporaryPermanent
The charts show the month on month increase/decrease in sector prospects using the most recent three months rolling average values, against a zero base set in January 2012.
WHICH SECTORS ARE LIKELY TO SEE THE GREATEST DEMAND FOR AGENCY AND PERMANENT STAFF OVER THE NEXT 3 MONTHS?With the exception of four skills pools where forecast demand over the next quarter remained broadly static, the likely demand for all other categories of workers increased in July.
Skills areas in which forecast demand is near to its all-time peak, since January 2012, include both permanent and temporary construction workers, permanent drivers and engineers and agency technical, professional and office workers.
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
250
200
-150
Jan Mar MayApr JunJul JulSepAug NovOct Dec Feb
Call 0207 009 2100 for more information twitter.com/RECPress 9
UNEMPLOYMENT RATE SET TO REMAIN STABLE AT 5.6%
REC-MarkitPredictive model
Labour Market Tracker (RHS)
Tracker Index
20072006 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 20152014
Three month unemployment change (thousands)
275
225
175
125
75
25
-25
-75
-125
-175
-225
3.75
2.75
1.75
0.75
-0.25
-1.25
-2.25
-3.25
Unemployment change (LHS)
CHART 1: TRACKER MODEL HISTORY
Nowcast Lower
Oct 2013Jul 2013 Jan 2014 Apr 2014 Jul 2014 Jan 2015Oct 2014
100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
-200
ActualUpper
Thousands
Jul 2015Apr 2015
CHART 2: THREE MONTH UNEMPLOYMENT CHANGE
Data sources: Markit, REC, KPMG, ONS, European Commission, Google
The REC and Markit have developed a model to ‘nowcast’ the UK’s headline unemployment rate. The REC and Markit have developed a model to ‘nowcast’ the UK’s headline unemployment rate.
Our current nowcast is for a further modest rise in the Labour Force Survey measure of unemployment of 10 thousand in the three months to July. This would imply the unemployment rate holding steady at 5.6%. The Office for National Statistics (ONS) will publish these statistics on 16 September 2015.
The latest nowcast points to a slightly slower rise in unemployment than the 25 thousand increase in the three months to June, and also the 15 thousand rise in the three months to May. Prior to this, unemployment had fallen continuously for over two years.
The turnaround corresponds with weaker survey evidence such as the Report on Jobs, which is currently signalling the slowest growth of staff appointments in more than two years. The PMI Composite Employment Index is similarly running at its lowest level in 22 months.
As shown in the chart, the model has generally done a good job at pre-empting shifts in the official data over the past 18 months or so.
MethodologyThe model draws on a range of official, survey and internet search data, which are available on a more timely basis than our target variable. This includes:
• REC’s JobsOutlook survey data on employers’ expectations for short-term staffing requirements
• KPMG/REC Report on Jobs survey measures of permanent placements and temporary billings
• Markit PMI data, in the form of the composite employment and output indices covering the manufacturing, services and construction sectors
• Markit’s Household Finance Index measures of workplace activity and job security
• The European Commission consumer survey measure of unemployment expectations
• Google internet search patterns for terms which we believe give useful signals on the health of the labour market
• ONS measures of claimant count joblessness and vacancies
We have created a single-variable model that provides an overview of underlying conditions in the labour market. We used principal component analysis to extract common factors from our dataset, which we could then weight to create what we call our “Labour Market Tracker”. To produce our nowcasts, we combine the Labour Market Tracker with a weighted average of single-variable models to guide our prediction for the three-month change in unemployment.
‘Lower’ and ‘upper’ lines in the chart above represent the bounds of a 70% confidence interval around our nowcasts for unemployment changes since July 2013.