injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · injury in the aging recovery and...

15
Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation Michael A Horan and John E Clague Department of Geriatric Medicine, Hope Hospital, Salford Royal Hospitals NHS Trust, Salford, UK Interest in how victims of traumatic injuries recover is increasing and a number of observational studies have now been done. There are very few intervention studies aimed at enhancing recovery, but there will be more as our knowledge base grows. Older recipients of traumatic injuries differ from the young in the types of injuries they sustain, in the way they respond to their injuries and in the consequences of even relatively minor injuries on their future independ- ence. In this paper, we summarise our understanding of recovery after injury and consider this in more depth for older people with specific injuries. Correspondence to- Prof. Michael A Horan, Department of Geriatric Medicine, Clinical Sciences Building, Hope Hospital, Salford M6 8HD, UK Why is it important to consider recovery after traumatic injury, particularly in older people? The answer to this question is best considered from the perspective of history. Over the last 50 years or so, the pathophysiology of traumatic injuries has become well understood, and this understanding has been, to a great extent, translated into clinical practice. The resulting improvements in the likelihood of survival of even extremely severely injured people have been nothing short of dramatic. It is one of the great success stories of biomedical research. Distinct phases of research activity can be recognised. First of all, systematic observational studies were needed to determine the biochemical and physiological consequences of traumatic injuries. As our knowledge base expanded, so too did research activity and the phase of hypothesis- driven research began. It was during this phase of research that patho- physiological explanations emerged and possible intervention strategies were explored. An important enabling factor for the progression of this research strategy was the development of scoring systems so that different groups of patients could be compared and intervention strategies could be properly targeted and evaluated. It soon became clear that 'time' was a critical factor for many injured patients who, in order to derive maximum benefit for survival from intervention strategies, needed to receive them as soon as possible after sustaining their injuries. This opened a new dimen- sion in trauma research: how to organise trauma services to optimum effect. Part passu, the importance of injury prevention was appreciated and epidemiological studies have assumed increasing importance. British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 895-909 O The British Council 1999

Upload: others

Post on 24-May-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging:recovery and rehabilitation

Michael A Horan and John E ClagueDepartment of Geriatric Medicine, Hope Hospital, Salford Royal Hospitals NHS Trust, Salford, UK

Interest in how victims of traumatic injuries recover is increasing and a numberof observational studies have now been done. There are very few interventionstudies aimed at enhancing recovery, but there will be more as our knowledgebase grows. Older recipients of traumatic injuries differ from the young in thetypes of injuries they sustain, in the way they respond to their injuries and inthe consequences of even relatively minor injuries on their future independ-ence. In this paper, we summarise our understanding of recovery after injuryand consider this in more depth for older people with specific injuries.

Correspondence to-Prof. Michael A Horan,

Department of GeriatricMedicine, Clinical

Sciences Building, HopeHospital, Salford

M6 8HD, UK

Why is it important to consider recovery after traumatic injury, particularlyin older people? The answer to this question is best considered from theperspective of history. Over the last 50 years or so, the pathophysiology oftraumatic injuries has become well understood, and this understanding hasbeen, to a great extent, translated into clinical practice. The resultingimprovements in the likelihood of survival of even extremely severelyinjured people have been nothing short of dramatic. It is one of the greatsuccess stories of biomedical research.

Distinct phases of research activity can be recognised. First of all,systematic observational studies were needed to determine the biochemicaland physiological consequences of traumatic injuries. As our knowledgebase expanded, so too did research activity and the phase of hypothesis-driven research began. It was during this phase of research that patho-physiological explanations emerged and possible intervention strategieswere explored. An important enabling factor for the progression of thisresearch strategy was the development of scoring systems so that differentgroups of patients could be compared and intervention strategies could beproperly targeted and evaluated. It soon became clear that 'time' was acritical factor for many injured patients who, in order to derive maximumbenefit for survival from intervention strategies, needed to receive them assoon as possible after sustaining their injuries. This opened a new dimen-sion in trauma research: how to organise trauma services to optimumeffect. Part passu, the importance of injury prevention was appreciated andepidemiological studies have assumed increasing importance.

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 895-909 O The British Council 1999

Page 2: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

The burgeoning successes of trauma research and the translation ofresults into clinical practice have posed new problems. Many peoplenow survive who, in previous years, would have died, but at what cost?Many of these survivors of severe injuries have considerable physicaland psychological impairments1, but little research has been done on thequality of their survival and how it may be modified. Even injuries oflesser severity can be associated with significant functional impairmentsfor long periods after the injury. Rehabilitation has not beenincorporated into trauma services as an integral part, even in the US(which has the most sophisticated systems for trauma care in the world).Thus, there are no proper standards or triage guidelines for this aspectof trauma care. This is regrettable, as trauma is the commonest cause ofdisability in the young and is a major cause in all age groups. In a sense,our understanding of recovery after injury is still in the phase ofobservational research and we have only a sketchy view of how it takesplace and what factors might determine functional outcomes.

Functional state of trauma survivors

To study recovery properly, we must be able to measure function,disability, handicap and quality of life, as well as their rates of change. Allof the available scales that have been used so far exhibit 'floor' and/or'ceiling' effects at either end of the functional spectrum and, as the scalesare ordinal in nature, they are poor measures of the rate and/or magnitudeof change, especially when patients start at different baselines. Despitethese difficulties, Mackenzie2, who recruited 479 patients from two NorthAmerican Trauma Centers and followed functional change, found that atone year, 27% had quite marked limitations and 16% had more modestones. Those who survived injuries to the thorax or abdomen generally hada good functional outcome with only 5% still convalescing at one year.Those with minor injuries to the head and spine also had good functionalrecovery, though this is not necessarily true for the old. However,moderate-severe brain, spine and limb injuries were associated withpersistent, often marked, impairments. Even minor injuries to the limbswere associated with substantial morbidity at one year. Another study3,using the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) to evaluate function m a group ofpatients with lower limb fractures reported that about half had somedetectable disability a year later, and about half of these rated thedisability as moderate-severe. Interestingly, the domain most markedlyaffected was 'psycho-social'.

Emhoff et at* have reported the use of the Functional IndependenceMeasure (FIM) to study 109 consecutive trauma patients, all with multipleinjuries and fully independent before injury. They showed that those with

896 British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 3: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation

the most marked impairments on admission were the most likely topresent discharge problems and require rehabilitation. Furthermore,those with the slowest rates of improvement soon after admissionpresented similar discharge problems. Recently, a series of weightingfactors has been described for the FIM which the authors claim totransform the scale to behave as if it were interval in nature and thistransformed scale appears to be robust in practice5. Similarly, therecently described London Handicap Scale is also claimed to behave asan interval measure. Neither of these 'interval' functional scales has beenappropriately applied in the setting of traumatic injury.

The nature of recovery

Recovery from injury has at least three components:

(t) the return to function of injured body parts;

(it) a more generalised process of restoration of the deficits that arisefrom the acute and subacute changes that characterise the well-knownebb and flow phases of the injury response; and

(m) the psychosocial adjustment of the patient.

These components of recovery will be modulated by:

(i) the presence of pre-existing impairments;

(it) co-existing diseases and conditions (e.g. undernutrition);

(m) medication use; and

(iv) the availability of resources and support.

Most accounts of the response to injury detail the ebb and flow phasesand go on to refer to a third phase known variously as the recovery,convalescent or anabolic phase. This phase remains largely unchar-acterised: we do not even know if it occurs simply by resolution of thestimuli that induce the ebb and flow phases, or whether it is driven byspecific signals of its own. Our knowledge of psychosocial adjustment tophysical injuries (other than head injuries) is similarly scant.

The anabolic phase

Much of our limited understanding of recovery comes from studies ofpatients recovering from elective surgical procedures, usually abdominaloperations of moderate severity. Moore6 studied large numbers of suchpatients and concluded that the restoration of lean body mass takes

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 897

Page 4: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

many weeks and is associated with persistent fatigue and weakness. Theresumption of a normal diet has a permissive effect but does not appearto initiate the process. Only after restoration of lean body mass is fatdeposited and usual body weight is not restored for weeks/months.

Apart from a very limited study of glucose and protein kinetics7, theonly aspect of the whole body response to have been studied extensivelybeyond the flow phase is postoperative fatigue: this lasts beyond 2months in about a third of patients8"11. There is some evidence that olderpeople may be more resistant to some sorts of neuromuscular fatiguethan younger ones12. Mild muscle weakness and reduced exercisecapacity have been reported in patients with postoperative fatigue.Although fatigue is related to the magnitude of the surgical procedure,the relative roles of undernutrition, protein catabolism, inactivity andphysiological deconditioning have yet to be resolved. Psychologicalfactors are not thought to play a major role, though they have only beenexamined in a limited fashion13.

Several studies have investigated the acute effects of trauma on cardio-vascular control mechanisms. Trauma leads to changes in 'resting' auto-nomic activity causing a simultaneous elevation of the blood pressureand heart rate, sympatho-excitation and a reduction in the sensitivity ofthe baroreflex14. The controlled trauma of surgery causes reduced heartrate variability, which indicates a reduction in both vagal andsympathetic influences on the sino-atrial node, and the duration of thisreduced heart rate variability seems to be markedly prolonged in theold15, hi other settings, such as after myocardial infarction16 and in thegeneral elderly population17, reduced heart rate variability is independ-ently associated with an increased risk of death.

Psychosocial adjustment

Using a Quality of Well-Being (QWB) scale, functional impairmentshave been shown to persist for at least 18 months, but most of therecovery takes place in the first 6 months1. Interestingly, these patientswith persistent impairments performed well on activities of daily living(ADL) items and psychosocial items accounted for most of theimpairment. These findings are similar to those from a study using theSIP3. This may argue for a disproportionate importance of psychosocialitems, but could also be explained by a deficiency in the measurementscale with the physical items being effectively capped at a fairly basiclevel (ceiling effect). Paradoxically, owing to rather differentexpectations and abilities of old and young people, the scale mayoperate better for older patients.

898 British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 5: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation

Injuries in the aging

The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous population with a highprevalence of pre-existing illness, medication consumption, disability andmalnutrition. At all levels of injury severity (other than the most trivialand most severe), they are more likely to die than are young people withinjuries of similar (or even greater) severity, they have a greaterphysiological response at any given level of the Injury Severity Score(ISS)18 and late deaths are common. In contrast to the heterogeneity ofinjuries in the young, a single type of injury, fractures of the proximalfemur, account for many of the hospital admissions of old people withtraumatic injuries.

The causes of injury in the old

Falls are the major cause of injury-related morbidity in the elderly, and theleading cause of accidental death in those over 75 years of age19. One-third of community-dwelling people aged over 65 years and half ofwomen over 85 years fall each year20. In one recent survey of fallersattending accident and emergency departments, 65% reported a fall m theprevious year21. Typically, only falls leading to injury or loss of functionare reported and many reported figures are probably underestimates.Fractures, soft tissue injury, joint dislocations and mobility impairmentsoccur after 15-20% of falls22. The psychological consequences of falls areequally disabling. Fear of falls is reported to occur m up to 60% offallers23"15 and one-third of such subjects report avoidance of activity as aconsequence23'15. Limiting activity after a fall may lead to physicaldeconditioning, functional deterioration and further increase falls risk.Falls commonly precipitate admissions for continuing care26.

The importance of falls for public health is well recognised. To reducethe death rate from accidents in people 65 years and over has been ahealth target of our previous and present governments. Similar concernshave prompted the US National Institute on Aging and the NationalInstitute for Nursing Research to sponsor the multi-centred study calledFrailty and Injuries: Cooperative Studies of Intervention Techniques(FICSIT) on therapeutic strategies to reduce falls27.

A large number of epidemiological studies have been carried out onfalls and hundreds of risk factors have been identified. Complexinteractions between host-related factors and the environment lead tofalls. The greater the number of risk factors, the greater the likelihoodof falls. This complexity makes intervention studies to reduce fallsdifficult. General interventions will not usually address specific risks andpotentially beneficial interventions might be overlooked if studied in

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 899

Page 6: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

Table 1 Major musculoskeletal injuries in the old

Head and face injuries

Cervical spine injuries

Sternoclavicular subluxation

Clavicle fractures (often near the coracoclavicular ligaments)

Proximal humerus fractures (usually the surgical neck)

Rotator cuff tears

Radial head fractures (not common)

Olecranon fractures (not common)

Distal radius fractures

Fractures around the hip

• Subcapital hip fracture

• Intertrochantenc hip fracture

• Acetabulum fractures

Pubic ramus fractures

Femoral shaft and supracondylar fractures

Meniscus tears

Tibial plateau fractures

Patella fractures

Tibial shaft fractures

Quadriceps and patella tendon ruptures

inappropriate subjects. Despite these limitations, interventions exam-ining exercise, home assessment, education, falls in institutional settingsand interventions to reduce injuries from falls have been performed.Systematic reviews assessing falls interventions have been publishedrecently28.

Reducing fall-related injury

Injuries, especially fractures, are the most serious consequences of falls(Table 1). It is not clear that interventions leading to reduction of fallsnecessarily reduce the incidence rates of major fractures, but thehypothesis that they do is very appealing. Most studies assessing falls'risk intervention have been too small to detect reductions in fracturerates apart from those targeted at osteoporosis and others evaluatingmechanical hip protectors.

Vitamin D levels decline with age and lower levels are seen in thehouse-bound and during winter months. Trials have examined supple-mentation with vitamin D with or without calcium on fracture risk.Chapuy et al found a 20% reduction in fractures over a 3 year period in

900 British Medial Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 7: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging, recovery and rehabilitation

residential home subjects given calcium and vitamin D29. Lips et al foundno benefit from supplementation with vitamin D alone30. The optimumregimen for fracture prevention is yet to be determined28. Observationalstudies suggest reductions in hip fracture risk with hormone replacementtherapy (oestrogens) and the biphosphonates, etidronate and alendronate,but only alendronate has been proven to reduce hip fracture incidence in acontrolled trial31. Mechamcal hip protectors may have a role in those at thegreatest risk of falls. The hip fracture incidence rate was more than halvedin residential home subjects wearing them32*33. However, compliance withthe intervention was problematic in both studies and acceptability is beingassessed in a further FICSIT study34. A recent review by the CochraneCollaboration recommends further trials with economic evaluation beforecommunity fracture prevention programmes are introduced28.

Common traumatic injuries of the old

PresentationMost old people who have sustained traumatic injuries present toaccident and emergency departments. Those with multiple injuries orare otherwise seriously ill, will successfully and speedily engage with theappropriate specialties. Likewise, arrangements for admission of thosewith lower limb fractures will usually be effected, though often withconsiderable delay. Many centres have developed 'fast-track' admissionpolicies for those with hip fractures, thus ensuring patient comfort andminimising the risks of serious complications like pressure ulcers.

Much more problematic are those injuries not requiring operativeintervention and for which enforced 'non-weight bearing' is not needed.Many orthopaedic surgeons may not consider these patients to be appro-priate for admission to their wards. Geriatrics services are generallyamenable to accepting them, but geriatricians are often uneasy aboutmanaging 'orthopaedic problems' such as spinal fractures treated with aplaster jacket (often poorly tolerated by patients) or patients with tibialplateau fractures who are 'non-weight bearing' and are in need ofrepeated reviews. Systems need to be in place to have prompt advice fromorthopaedic surgeons on request.

More minor injuries, with which younger patients may be expected tocope with little problem, may render older patients extremelyvulnerable. Accident and emergency staff are generally ill-equipped todeal with these problems adequately. Even the obvious fart that thepatient will have fallen for some reason may be overlooked. It is notuncommon for geriatricians to encounter patients recently dischargedfrom accident and emergency departments who have been seen therefrequently on account of recurrent falls. No adequate explanation for

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 901

Page 8: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

the falls is recorded and no referral for assessment and investigation hasbeen made. Mechanisms need to be in place to respond to the needs ofthis patient group, particularly because timely interventions may preventnon-injurious falls becoming injurious ones. However, there is no goodevidence to show what an appropriate and cost-effective interventionsystem comprises.

Types of injuriesUpper limb injuries are of special concern because they are common andbecause the upper limb enables us to interact with the world around us.Impairment or loss of upper limb function can be immensely disabling.In fact, upper limb function should be quickly assessed in any old personbeing considered for discharge from an accident and emergencydepartment.

Injuries to the neck and shoulder are very common after falls and theirprecise diagnosis can be challenging. Patients whose shoulder pain centreson the scapula or radiates beyond the elbow need careful assessment of thecervical spine. Tears in the rotator cuff are commonly missed at initialpresentation. They often follow a fall on an outstretched hand (FOOSH)and render the patient unable to raise the arm, despite appropriateanalgesia. Distal radius fractures are the commonest fractures of the upperlimb and usually follow FOOSH. The commonest functional impairmentsthat follow these fractures in the old are shoulder stiffness, finger stiffnessand the carpal tunnel syndrome.

The lower extremity is principally concerned with locomotion and thenegotiation of the immediate environment. Compromise or loss of lowerlimb function can be very disabling and a previously independent personmay be rendered completely unable to manage at home without con-siderable and costly modification of the home environment. Any olderpatient under consideration for discharge from an accident and emergencydepartment should have lower limb function quickly checked. Proximalfemur fractures are the commonest significant injuries to the lower limbs,though acetabulum and pubic ramus fractures often occur after a similartype of fall.

Proximal femur fractures

Most patients with proximal femur fractures are admitted to orthopaedicdepartments where the fractures are stabilised operatively. About 30% ofthese patients will die within 6 months in sharp contrast with the sporadicdeaths in young people with injuries of similar severity (ISS 9). Mostdeaths directly attributable to the fracture occur within the first month.

902 British Medial Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 9: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging- recovery and rehabilitation

Of the survivors, about half will have a slow and complicatedrehabilitation and will have permanent impairments in their ability toundertake activities necessary for independent living (ADL)35. Thefactors that predict survival after hip fracture are not well understoodbut are reported to include prefracture fitness and health36'37, depressionand dementia38. Many people with hip fractures are undernourished39,but the relationship between this and survival is not well established.The old do not die as a result of failing to mount a response to the injury.On the contrary, some aspects of the injury response are known to beunusually prolonged. For example, old women have raised plasmacortisol concentrations for at least 8 weeks after the fracture40, whichcontrasts markedly with what is seen in the young with injuries ofsimilar, and even greater, severity. We have also shown that theconcentrations reached may be sufficient to exert effects peripherally inthat they are associated with impaired glucose transport in circulatingmononuclear leucocytes41.

These and other factors have been reported to be associated with poorfunctional outcomes after hip fractures: pre-fracture fitness and health36,postoperative complications, undernutrition39-42"44, depression anddementia38'45"47 and poor social supports45-48. It has also been suggestedthat acute undiagnosed stroke may be associated with hip fractures49

and they can be difficult to detect in this clinical setting except byimpeding recovery.

Optimising femur fracture outcome

This obviously depends on which outcome is being sought. Mostcommonly, the desired outcome is to discharge from hospital as quickly aspossible rather than to pursue a management strategy to optimise functionand maintain independent living. The former approach has cost-containment as a sub-agendum. Regrettably, health accounting does notyet appear to be up to the task of realistically costing components ofmanagement strategies so that they may be fairly compared over thelonger term. Various systems for hip fracture management exist and havebeen researched, though we know little of how longer term function andquality of life are affected.

Orthogeriatrics unitsProbably the first reported orthopaedics-geriatrics liaison wasestablished in Hastings in 196250. The orthopaedic surgeons selectedpatients for transfer to a dedicated orthogeriatrics ward and sharedresponsibility for them with the geriatricians. Many similar units have

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 903

Page 10: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

been set up with operational policies adapted to local circumstances.Two influential reports have recommended the Hastings system as avaluable model for other units51-52.

Liaison servicesResource implications have probably discouraged the establishment oforthogeriatrics units more widely and some centres have establishedliaison-based systems. In one scheme53, a senior nurse with both ortho-paedic and geriatric experience liased between the two units and was ableto give advice on rehabilitation, common medical problems, and the avail-ability of community care. Geriatricians were available for medical advice,but few patients each month required transfer to the geriatrics unit.

A junior doctor-led service requiring input for around 3 h each weekhas been described54. This service depended on a multidisciphnary wardround at which advice was given on symptoms management, holisticcare, medical investigation, rehabilitation and discharge goal setting.Improved care and fewer patients transferred for rehabilitation wereseen as the main benefits.

The rapid transit systemThis is based on the ideas of Ceder and colleagues55 and was popularisedby Sikorski et al in Australia56. The aim is to minimise the amount of timespent in hospital (as little as 5 days). Only essential investigations aredone, narcotic and sedative drugs are not used and general anaesthesia isavoided. Surgery is done early, often after direct transfer from the accidentand emergency department to the operating theatre. Full weight bearing isencouraged within hours of surgery. Discharge planning starts on the firstpostoperative day and patients are discharged when they can move aboutthe bed, are reasonably safe with transfers and can walk a few steps withor without an aid. High levels of domiciliary support are provided atdischarge, which is reduced over 2-3 weeks towards prefracture levels.

Hospital-at-homeThis was established on an existing general practice-based, communitynursing service in Peterborough. The aim is immediate rehabilitationand discharge planning by a team that oversees both in-hospital andpost-discharge management. Intensive home nursing (24 h/day, ifneeded) is provided plus occupational therapists and physiotherapists. Itis reported that up to 50% of hip fracture patients are suitable for thismanagement57"59.

904 British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 11: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging' recovery and rehabilitation

Consultant geriatricians in the trauma wardsAs little is known about the ideal approach to the management of hipfracture patients (and older people with other traumatic injuries), furtherresearch is needed. Our own approach has been to integrate our clinicalpractice with the trauma service so that we can utilise our clinical practiceas a research tool. A consultant geriatrician visits the trauma wards dailyand sees all new admissions, to advise on fitness for surgery, to provideon-going medical supervision, to select patients most likely to benefit fromtransfer to a dedicated orthogeriatrics rehabilitation unit and to identifythose in need of continuing care. He also supervises the care of thosetransferred to the specialist unit. We also provide a structured assessmentservice to evaluate those factors underlying falls (including dynamiccardiovascular testing, where indicated). Longer term follow-up ismaintained. This approach should improve the quality and consistency ofmedical care, not only by the prompt recognition and treatment of co-existing medical and psychiatric disorders and reducing the risk of furtherfalls, but also by changing the mind-set of the staff in the trauma wardsso that they become more attuned to the particular problems of olderpatients.

Table 2 The rehabilitation approach

Identify and treat co-morbid problems

Clarify present and previous functional abilities

Record usual domicile and support availability

Establish realistic goals

Formulate management plan

Assess progress, modify management plan

Initiate discharge planning early

Plan post-discharge management

The rehabilitation approach

As we have already stated, rehabilitation involves a radically differentapproach from the traditional 'diagnose-treat-cure' model of medicalpractice. It utilises a spectrum of skills from different disciplines to identifyproblems, suggest solutions, set goals and assist the patient to accom-modate to a new set of circumstances that may radically alter theirlifestyle. The ideas and aims that underlie rehabilitation are discussed indetail by Barnes (this issue) and will not be re-iterated here. Table 2summarises our own approach.

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 905

Page 12: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

Hip fractures

Pelvic fractures

Many younger, previously reasonably fit patients will recover quickly andcan be discharged quickly with the remaining problems being addressedon an outpatient basis or by domiciliary therapy services. Others, largelybecause of co-morbidity or pre-existing impairments will be deemedunlikely to recover sufficient function to be sustained independently athome and will require continuing care. The remainder will very likelybenefit from transfer to a dedicated rehabilitation ward or umt. While onthe trauma ward, these patients will be mobilised within 48 h of surgeryand active steps will be taken to prevent complications (contractures,undernutrition, venous thrombosis, disuse, medication side-effects, con-stipation, dislocation of a prosthesis, etc.). If a patient uses a trapeze inbed, they should exhale while usmg it (to prevent a Valsalva manoeuvre).Range of motion and isometric exercises will be done with progression toresistive exercises. These will then be integrated into a programme oftransfer and gait retraining. For patients with hemiarthroplasties,excessive adduction of the hip (risk of dislocation) may be prevented by atriangular foam wedge while in bed. If the surgery was by a posteriorapproach, the knee may occasionally be immobilised in extension toprevent excessive hip flexion. Dislocation is also minimised by using highchairs and raised toilet seats.

Prolonged non-weight-bearing is to be avoided (worsens balance andcauses deconditioning), but partial weight bearing is often impossible toachieve for older people. Virtually all patients undergo full weight-bearingas soon as feasible. The adequacy of analgesia is addressed, medicalproblems are stabilised and depression is actively sought. Leg-lengthdiscrepancy must be detected and corrected as soon as possible. At thisstage, patients must be assessed for factors predisposing to falls whichneed to be corrected, where possible. Gains in strength and range ofmotion will be translated into self-care and independent living.

Case conferences will take place at weekly intervals when progress isevaluated and new goals are set. Home circumstances and availablesupport will determine the timing of discharge home, after which, therapymay need to continue, either at home or on an out-patient basis. We alsoundertake a formal review several weeks after discharge from hospital,principally to address fall-related issues and to assess whether function hasbeen mamtained.

Pubic ramus and undisplaced acetabular fractures are often admitteddirectly to our wards rather than to the trauma wards. They are initially

906 British Medial Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 13: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation

treated by analgesic drugs and bed-rest. Once reasonable analgesia hasbeen achieved, weight-bearing commences, as with hip fractures. Also,underlying factors for falls are sought. Pain can be reduced by the use ofan appropriate walking aid. Undisplaced acetabular fractures are some-times treated with one or more weeks of traction followed by severalweeks of non-weight-bearing activity.

Wrist fractures

Underlying factors for falls should be sought. Range of motion exercisesof the digits, elbow and shoulder commence immediately after theorthopaedic intervention (usually casting). Weight-bearing activities andstrong gripping are avoided. Upon cast removal, wrist range ofmovement exercises begin. The hand should be assessed for mediannerve entrapment. Some patients with wrist fractures may be renderedunable to live at home. These patients do not really need a rehabilitationward until the cast is removed and are better managed in aresidential/convalescent home setting.

Humerus fractures

These are generally managed non-operatively. Underlying factors forfalls are sought. Range of motion exercises commence when the fractureis stable and pain permits. Pendulum exercises then start and weightbearing is avoided. After 2-3 weeks, active range of movement exercisescan usually start, followed by isometric exercise and strengtheningexercise. Persistent range of movement impairment of 25-50% is usualand assistive devices will usually be required for self-care.

References

Holbrook TL, Anderson JP, Sieber WJ, Brouwer D, Hoyt DB. Outcome after ma|or trauma: 12-month and 18-month follow-up results from the trauma recovery project. / Trauma 1999; 46:765-71MacKenzie EJ, Siegel JH, Shapiro S, Moody M, Smith RT Functional recovery and medicalcosts of trauma, an analysis by type and severity of injury / Trauma 1988, 28 281-97Jurkovich G, Mock C, MacKenzie E et al. The sickness impact profile as a tool to evaluatefunctional outcome in trauma patients / Trauma 1995; 39. 625-31Emhoff TA, McCarthy M, Cushman M, Garb JL, Valenziano C Functional scoring of multi-trauma patients: who ends up where? / Trauma 1991; 31: 1227-32Kidd D, Stewart G, Baldry J et al The functional independence measure: a comparative validityand reliability study. Disabil Rehabil 1995; 17. 10-4Moore FD. Bodily changes in surgical convalescence. Ann Surg 1953; 137: 289-314Humberstone DA, Shaw JHF. Isotopic studies during surgical convalescence. Br J Surg 1989;76 154-8

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 907

Page 14: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Trauma

8 Chnstensen T, Kehlet H Postoperative fatigue and changes in nutritional status. Br ] Surg1984; 71- 473-6

9 Chnstensen T, Hougard F, Kehlet H. Influence of pre- and intraoperative factors on theoccurrence of postoperative fatigue. Br ] Surg 1985; 72: 63-5

10 Chnstensen T, Stage JG, Galbo H, Chnstensen J, Kehlet H. Fatigue and cardiac and endoennemetabolic response to exercise after abdominal surgery. Surgery 1989; 105 46-50

11 Chnstensen T, Nygaard E, Stage JG, Kehlet H Skeletal muscle enzyme activities and metabolicsubstrates during exercise in patients with postoperative fatigue Br J Surg 1990; 77: 312-5

12 Nanci MV, Bordini M, Cerretelh P. Effect of aging on human adductor polhcis muscle function.J Appl Physiol 1991; 71: 1277-81

13 Chnstensen P, Rasmussen JW, Hennneberg SW Accuracy of a new bedside method forestimation of circulating blood volume Cnt Care Med 1993; 21: 1535-40

14 Anderson ID, Little RA. Testing artenal baroreflex function in acutely unwell patients. ChnPhysiol 1992; 12: 463-74

15 Marsch SCU, Skarvan K, Schaeffer H-G, Naegeh B, Castelh I, Scheidegger D. Prolonged heartrate vanabihty after elective hip arthroplasty Br J Anaesth 1994, 72 643-9

16 Tuirunga YS, van Veldhuisen DJ, Brouwer ] et al Heart rate vanability in left ventricular dys-function and heart failure: effects and implications of drug treatment. Br Heart] 1994; 72: 509-13

17 Tsuji H, Venditti Jr FJ, Manders ES et al. Reduced heart rate vanabihty and mortality risk inan elderly cohort. The Framingham heart study. Circulation 1994; 90. 878-83

18 Shabot MM, Johnson CL. Outcome from critical care in the 'oldest old' trauma patients. /Trauma 1995; 39: 254-60

19 Lilley JM, Ane T, Chilvers CED. Accidents involving older people: a review of the literatureAge Ageing 1995, 24: 346-65

20 DTI. HASS listings for 1993, for males and females aged SO and above for falls. London:Consumer Unit, DTI, 1993

21 Close J, Ellis M, Hooper R, Glucksman E, Jackson S, Swift C. Prevention of falls in the elderlytrial (PROFET): a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 1999; 353 93-7

22 Tinetti ME, Speechley M. Prevention of falls among the elderly. N Engl J Med 1989, 320.1055-9

23 Tinetti ME, Speechley M, Ginter SF Risk factors for falls among elderly persons in thecommunity N Engl] Med 1988, 319: 1701-7

24 Tinetti ME. Falls efficacy as a measure of fear of falling. / Gerontol 1990, 45 P239-4325 Maki BE, Holhday PJ, Topper AK. Fear of falling and postural performance in the elderly. /

Gerontol 1991; 46: M123-3126 Tinetti ME, Williams CE. Falls, in)unes due to falls, and the risk of admission to a nursing

home. N Engl] Med 1997, 337 1279-8427 Province MA, Hadley EC, Hornbrook MC et al. The effect of exercise on falls in elderly

patients A pre-planned meta-analysis of the FICSIT trials. Frailty and mjunes cooperativestudies of intervention techniques. JAMA 1995; 273: 1341-7

28 Gillespie WJ, Madhok R, Murray GD, Robinson CM, Swiontowski ME Musculoskeletalin/unes module of the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 1st edn. Oxford TheCochrane Collaboration, 1998

29 Chapuy MC, Arlot ME, Duboeuf F et al Vitamin D3 and calcium to prevent hip fractures inelderly women. N Engl] Med 1992; 327: 1637-42

30 Lips P, Grafmans WC, Ooms ME, Bezemer PD, Bouter LM. Vitamin D supplementation andfracture incidence in elderly persons. Ann Intern Med 1996; 124: 400-6

31 Black DM, Cummings SR, Karpf DB et al Randomised trial of effect of alendronate on risk offracture in women with existing vertebral fractures. Lancet 1996; 348: 1535-41

32 Launtzen JB, Petersen MM, Lund B Effects of external hip protectors on hip fractures. Lancet1993, 341: 11-3

33 Ekman A, Mallmin H, Michaelsson K, L|unghall S External hip protectors to preventosteoporotic hip fractures Lancet 1997; 350: 563—4

34 Wallace RB, Ross JE, Huston JC, Kundel C, Woodworth G. Iowa FICSIT trial: the feasibilityof elderly wearing a hip joint protective garment to reduce hip fractures. / Am Geriatr Soc1993, 41: 338^0

908 British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4)

Page 15: Injury in the aging: recovery and rehabilitation · 2017-04-09 · Injury in the aging recovery and rehabilitation Injuries in the aging The old, unlike the young, are a heterogeneous

Injury in the aging, recovery and rehabilitation

35 Greatorex IF Proximal femoral fractures, an assessment of the outcome of health care in elderlypeople. Community Med 1988; 10: 203-10

36 Ions GK, Stevens J. Prediction of survival in patients with femoral neck fractures / Bone JointSurg Br 1987; 69- 384-7

37 Steen Jensen J. Determining factors for the mortality following hip fractures. Injury 1984; 15:

38 Shamash K, O'Connell K, Lowy M, Katona CLE Psychiatric morbidity and outcome in elderlypatients undergoing emergency hip surgery: a one year follow-up study. Int J Gertatr Psychiatry1992; 7 505-9

39 Mansell PI, Rawhngs J, Allison SP et al. Low anthropometnc indices in elderly females withfractured neck of femur. Clin Nutr 1990; 9 190-4

40 Roberts NA, Barton RN, Horan MA, White A. Adrenal function after upper femoral fracturein elderly people: persistence of stimulation and the roles of adrenocortjcotrophic hormone andimmobility. Age Ageing 1990; 19: 304-10

41 van Rijen EAM, Harvey RA, Barton RN, Rose JG, Horan MA. Sensitivity of mononuclearleucocytes to glucocomcoids in elderly hip-fracture patients resistant to suppression of plasmacortisol by dexamethasone. Eur J Endocrmol 1998; 138 659-666

42 Bastow MD, Rawhngs J, Allison SP. Undernutrition, hypothermia, and injury in elderly womenwith fractured femur an injury response to altered metabolism? Lancet 1983; I: 143-6

43 Bastow MD, Rawhngs J, Allison SP Benefits of supplementary tube feeding after fractured neckof femur- a randomised trial. BMJ 1983; 287: 1589-92

44 Farmer ME, Harris T, Madans JH, Wallace RB, Cornoni-Huntley J, White LR Anthropometncindicators and hip fracture: The NHANES I epidemiologic follow-up study. / Am Geriatr Soc1989; 37: 9-16

45 Mossey JM, Mutran E, Knott K, Craik R. Determinants of recovery 12 months after hipfracture: the importance of psychosocial factors. Am J Public Health 1989; 79: 279-86

46 Mossey JM, Knott K, Craik R. The effects of persistent depressive symptoms on hip fracturerecovery. / Gerontol 1990; 45: M163-8

47 Billig N, Ahmed SW, Kenmore P, Amaral D, Shakhashin MZ Assessment of depression andcognitive impairment after hip fracture. / Am Geriatr Soc 1986; 34: 499-503

48 Cummings SR, Phillips SL, Wheat ME et al. Recovery of function after hip fracture: the role ofsocial supports. / Am Gertatr Soc 1988; 36: 801-6

49 McClure J, Goldsborough S. Fractured neck of femur and contralateral intracerebral lesions /Clm Pathol 1986; 39: 920-2

50 Devas MB, Irvine RE. The geriatric orthopaedic unit. / Bone Joint Surg Br 1963; 46: 630—451 Security DHSS Report of a working party. Orthopaedic services: waiting time for out-patient

and in-patient treatment. London HMSO, 198152 London Royal College of Physicians Fractured neck of femur. Prevention and management.

London, 198953 Blacklock C, Woodhouse KW Orthogenatnc liaison Lancet 1988; I: 99954 Harrington MG, Brennant M, Hodkinson HM. The first year of a geriatric-orthopaedic liaison

service an alternative to 'orthogenatric' units5 Age Ageing 1988; 17: 129-3355 Ceder L, Lindberg L, Odberg E. Differentiated care of hip fracture in the elderly. Mean hospital

days and results of rehabilitation. Ada Orthop Scand 1980; 51 157-6256 Sikorski JM, Davis NJ, Senior J. The rapid transit system for patients with fractures of the

proximal femur. BMJ 1985; 290: 439^357 Mowat IG, Morgan RTT. Peterborough hospital at home scheme BMJ 1982; 284: 641-358 Meeds B, Pryor GA. Early home rehabilitation for the elderly patient with hip fracture. The

Peterborough hip fracture scheme. Physiotherapy 1990; 76: 75-759 Pryor GA, Myles JW, Williams DRR, Anand JK. Team management of the elderly patient with

hip fracture Lancet 1988; I: 401-3

British Medical Bulletin 1999, 55 (No 4) 909