incongruous avatars and hilarious sidekicks: design ... ?· incongruous avatars and hilarious...
Post on 31-Aug-2018
Embed Size (px)
Proceedings of DiGRA 2013 Conference: DeFragging Game Studies.
2013 Authors & Digital Games Research Association DiGRA. Personal and educational classroom use of
this paper is allowed, commercial use requires specific permission from the author.
Incongruous Avatars and Hilarious Sidekicks: Design Patterns for Comical Game Characters
Claire Dormann University of Ottawa
School of Information Studies
55 Laurier E., Ottawa ON K1N 6N5 Canada
Mish Boutet University of Ottawa
School of Information Studies
55 Laurier E., Ottawa ON K1N 6N5 Canada
ABSTRACT Integrating humour in games or designing humorous games can be challenging but
rewarding. Contributing to practical knowledge of these contexts, we examine the role
and value of humour in game character design. We begin with a brief review of main
theories of humour. Next, we outline our methodology, describing steps taken to develop
game design patterns on humour. From our investigation, we present a classification of
comic characters and discuss a sampling of patterns for characters, highlighting design
considerations particular to these. Then we enrich our collection by situating our
character patterns within the comic worlds the characters inhabit. Our intent is to create
tools that game designers can use for laughter-inducing entertainment, to generate new,
amusing gameplay experiences.
Keywords humour, comic, game design patterns, character design
INTRODUCTION A common tendency is to think of humour only as fun. Indeed, fun has value and is an
end in itself. People engage in the exchange of jokes and humorous exploits to provoke
laughter and share pleasurable experiences. However, in addition to providing
entertainment, integrating humour into videogames can serve social, emotional, and
cognitive functions, providing players with benefits beyond laughter. This integration can
be challenging, but the payoffs to well-implemented humour can be tremendous.
A major source of humour can come from games characters. These characters can be
humorous in appearance, speech, action, interactions, or gameplay mechanics.
-- 2 --
For example, you have the risible visual design of the frog-like Globox in 2D platformer
Rayman Origins (Ubisoft 2011).You have the dry wit of Nathan Drake in action-
adventure Uncharted 3 (Naughty Dog 2011). Or, you have the wobbly mechanics of an
octopus disguised as a human in adventure Octodad (DePaul Game Experience 2010).
Humour can also arise from characters juxtapositions in unlikely environments or
situations. Humour, and comic characters in particular, can increase a games appeal and
leave its mark on players. How much are our fond memories of LucasArts adventures
buoyed by their pantheon of compellingly comic characters and their interactions in the
worlds around them?
To gain a better understanding of humour in game and game character design, we begin
with a brief review of humour theories. From a survey of comical characters and analysis
of gameplay examples, we present a classification of comic characters and a sampling of
our game design patterns. Then, we discuss how to expand and enrich our collection of
character patterns by situating them within the comic worlds they inhabit. In this paper,
we highlight the potential of humour for character design and discuss factors affecting its
design. We hope to provide better tools for designers to implement humour in games and
create new comical games.
BACKGROUND ON HUMOUR AND THE COMIC Humour is an essential component of communication and integral to popular culture.
Among other things, it is used to communicate, consolidate, and negotiate differences of
political, cultural, or social status. Its pairing with game design is a match well-made, for
many designers, notwithstanding the desire to make good games, also use games to
communicate, negotiate, or transgress these very differences.
Humour is experienced by all, yet is difficult to capture and define. Humour has been
described as a process, initiated by humorous stimuli and terminating with responses
indicative of pleasure and joy, such as mirth, the most enduring property of humour
(Gruner 1996). Following Martin (2007), humour is conceptualized and used in this paper
as an overarching concept that includes different kinds of comic devices, such as wit,
ridicule, or slapstick.
Three main classical theories of humour are superiority, relief, and incongruity theory
(Meyer 2000). These three are neither incompatible nor exclusive, but highlight different
aspects of humour. Superiority theory relates to social and power relations, while relief
theory mainly addresses emotion, and incongruity theory connects to the cognitive side of
humour (Raskin 1985).
Gruner (2011) views humour as playful aggression, with a winner and loser. Superiority
humour is often connected to malice. People laugh because they feel superior to others.
Think Schadenfreude and the nasty pleasure of balking at those who feature in reality
television series. This kind of humour mocks people, making them appear ridiculous and
refers to genres such as satire, sarcasm, and self-deprecation. In games, this kind of
humour comes into play in first-person shooters and other competitive multiplayer games
as a result of avatar death (Dormann and Biddle 2009). It is why we laugh at the
overconfident Dan Hibiki from fighting game Super Street Fighter IV (Capcom 2010) or,
in part, at the goofy Globox in Rayman Origins.
-- 3 --
According to relief theory, humour results from releasing nervous energy. People
experience humour, then laugh to reduce stress. The pleasurable aspect of humour, with
its liberating effect, is often highlighted here. Relief humour may manifest in different
ways, from dark, gallows humour, to sexual or naughty humour. Leisure Suit Larry in
the Land of the Lounge Lizards (Sierra On-Line 1987) and its sequels, for example,
featuring the misadventures of Larry Laffer, have their humour firmly entrenched within
this theory. Relief theory is notably the most well-known aspect of humour in games,
particularly in association with comic characters. A comic relief character lightens moods
or diffuses tension through humour.
Finally, according to incongruity theory, people laugh at the unexpected or surprising
(Berger 1993). Humour involves imagination and seeing things from unusual
perspectives. This form of humour typically plays with different frames of reference,
multiple meanings, ambiguity, and association. It includes forms of verbal humour, such
as jokes and puns, as well as visual humour, such as sight gags. Some game character
names contains puns, many examples of which are found in tower-defence Plants vs.
Zombies (PopCap Games 2009), such as the peashooter, repeater, and threepeater plants
that fire one, two, or three peas at a time respectively, to fend off zombies. Classic
LucasArts adventures mastered incongruity with their delightful, if fiendishly difficult,
COMIC CHARACTER PATTERNS This paper stems from a broader investigation of humour in videogames and discovery of
tools to assist in its design. We conducted interviews with players, drawing on their
recollections of humorous game experiences. Within these interviews, numerous
statements related to game characters, from their roles as comic relief to characters
snarky comments. As we too could recall comic characters from our play experiences, we
decided to look closer at the design of comic characters and its value. Character design
has been examined by developers and scholars (e.g. Meretzky 2001, Salen and
Zimmerman 2004, Isbister 2006), but little has been written on characters and humour.
There exist numerous YouTube countdowns (of varying quality) and lists on prominent
gaming sites on the best comic characters. We thus conducted an extensive survey
centred on humour in character design, which included reviewing game articles on
humour, and mining reviews and forum discussions for references to humour in game
characters. Listing the types of games and characters, and analyzing the parameters of
humour in their representation gave us insight into dimensions of humour in character
To further analyze humour in context, we examined in-game moments related to humour
in several popular games through inspection and gameplay. We also added examples
derived from affective walkthroughs (a process detailed in Dormann et al., 2011) of
comic LucasArts games conducted for another project. We then consolidated and
conceptualized the knowledge derived from the review and gameplay into emergent
humour patterns. In game design, patterns have been used as a problem-solving method
or a way of codifying design knowledge (Bjrk and Holopainen 2005). Our patterns are
descriptions of recurring aspects of game design concerning humour, with a focus on
intentional, scripted humour, rather than players' emergent humour. We then reviewed
-- 4 --
and refined patterns, adding further exampl