i n tr od u c ti on - ce4less · i n tr od u c ti on between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities...

41
1 INTRODUCTION Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation in New Mexico and a group of closely knit Alaska Native villages in western Alaska—experienced clusters of youth suicides. Across these communities, 25 young people, all American Indian or Alaska Native (AI/AN), took their own lives. At least 28 others attempted suicide, 19 of whom were hospitalized, and more than 60 other young people were identified as being suicidal. Many other reservations and tribal villages have experienced, and continue to experience, similar tragedies, including an Alaskan village in the same region, where nine young people attempted suicide in 2013. Researchers note that one of the most distinctive features about suicide clusters is that they occur almost exclusively among teenagers (Gould, 2003; Hazel, 1993). While suicide clusters are relatively rare events, accounting for fewer than 5 percent of all suicides in teenagers and young adults (Gould, Wallenstein, and Kleinman, 1987; Gould, 2003), one study found that the relative risk of suicide following exposure to another individual’s suicide was 2 to 4 times higher among 15- to 19-year-olds than among other age groups (Gould et al., 1990). Similar age-specific patterns have been reported for clusters of attempted suicides (Gould et al., 1994). Some researchers report that, compared to adults, youth are more susceptible to suicide behavior modeling, social norming of suicidal behavior (often described as “contagion”), and imitating suicide methods (Haw et al., 2013). This susceptibility has been described as particularly acute among higher risk subgroups of youth such as AI/AN young people (Brave Heart & DeBruyn, 1998; Bechtold, 1988; Wissow, Walkup, Barlow, Reid, & Kane, 2001), especially those who live in small, intense social networks in remote villages or on rural reservations (Goldston et al., 2008). Researchers found that American Indian youth who spent two-thirds or more of their lives on a reservation were at higher risk for suicidal ideation and suicide attempts compared to American Indian youth who spent the majority of their lives in an urban area (Freedenthal & Stiffman, 2004). While additional research is needed to understand the contributing factors, some research has pointed to considerable exposure that AI/AN youth have to suicide on isolated reservations and in rural villages (Bender, 2006). Within a number of tribal communities experiencing clusters, including some in New Mexico and Alaska, local and regional leaders have declared states of emergency and dispatched crisis response teams to contain and prevent additional suicides. The teams provide support for families and community members as they work toward recovery. Local and regional leaders have also intensified efforts, in partnership with state and federal governments, to direct suicide prevention funding and programming What is a suicide cluster? A suicide cluster “can be defined as a group of suicides or suicide attempts, or both, that occur closer together in time and space than would normally be expected on the basis of statistical prediction or community expectation.(CDC, 1988)

Upload: others

Post on 07-Apr-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

1

INTRODUCTIONBetween2009and2011,twotribalcommunitieslocatedapproximately3,000milesapart—anAmericanIndiantribeonareservationinNewMexicoandagroupofcloselyknitAlaskaNativevillagesinwesternAlaska—experiencedclustersofyouthsuicides.Acrossthesecommunities,25youngpeople,allAmericanIndianorAlaskaNative(AI/AN),tooktheirownlives.Atleast28othersattemptedsuicide,19ofwhomwerehospitalized,andmorethan60otheryoungpeoplewereidentifiedasbeingsuicidal.Manyotherreservationsandtribalvillageshaveexperienced,andcontinuetoexperience,similartragedies,includinganAlaskanvillageinthesameregion,wherenineyoungpeopleattemptedsuicidein2013.

Researchersnotethatoneofthemostdistinctivefeaturesaboutsuicideclustersisthattheyoccuralmostexclusivelyamongteenagers(Gould,2003;Hazel,1993).Whilesuicideclustersarerelativelyrareevents,accountingforfewerthan5percentofallsuicidesinteenagersandyoungadults(Gould,Wallenstein,andKleinman,1987;Gould,2003),onestudyfoundthattherelativeriskofsuicidefollowingexposuretoanotherindividual’ssuicidewas2to4timeshigheramong15-to19-year-oldsthanamongotheragegroups(Gouldetal.,1990).Similarage-specificpatternshavebeenreportedforclustersofattemptedsuicides(Gouldetal.,1994).Someresearchersreportthat,comparedtoadults,youtharemoresusceptibletosuicidebehaviormodeling,socialnormingofsuicidalbehavior(oftendescribedas“contagion”),andimitatingsuicidemethods(Hawetal.,2013).ThissusceptibilityhasbeendescribedasparticularlyacuteamonghigherrisksubgroupsofyouthsuchasAI/ANyoungpeople(BraveHeart&DeBruyn,1998;Bechtold,1988;Wissow,Walkup,Barlow,Reid,&Kane,2001),especiallythosewholiveinsmall,intensesocialnetworksinremotevillagesoronruralreservations(Goldstonetal.,2008).ResearchersfoundthatAmericanIndianyouthwhospenttwo-thirdsormoreoftheirlivesonareservationwereathigherriskforsuicidalideationandsuicideattemptscomparedtoAmericanIndianyouthwhospentthemajorityoftheirlivesinanurbanarea(Freedenthal&Stiffman,2004).Whileadditionalresearchisneededtounderstandthecontributingfactors,someresearchhaspointedtoconsiderableexposurethatAI/ANyouthhavetosuicideonisolatedreservationsandinruralvillages(Bender,2006).

Withinanumberoftribalcommunitiesexperiencingclusters,includingsomeinNewMexicoandAlaska,localandregionalleadershavedeclaredstatesofemergencyanddispatchedcrisisresponseteamstocontainandpreventadditionalsuicides.Theteamsprovidesupportforfamiliesandcommunitymembersastheyworktowardrecovery.Localandregionalleadershavealsointensifiedefforts,inpartnershipwithstateandfederalgovernments,todirectsuicidepreventionfundingandprogramming

What is a suicide cluster?

A suicide cluster “can be defined as a group of suicides or suicide attempts, or both, that occur closer together in time and space than would normally be expected on the basis of statistical prediction or community expectation.” (CDC, 1988)

Page 2: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

2

todisproportionatelyimpactedcommunities,manyofwhicharelocatedinisolated,ruralareaswithlimitedhealthinfrastructureandcrisisresponseresources.

Thepurposeofthisreportistolearnaboutsuicideclustersandresponsesintribalcommunities;identifystrength-basedapproachestoprevention,response,andrecovery;exploreexistingandneededresourcesforprevention,response,andrecovery;andproviderecommendationsfortribalcommunities,andforfederal,state,andpartners.

TheauthorsofthisreportusedaqualitativemethodologytolearnmoreabouttheeventsandresponseswithinthetwotribalcommunitiesinAlaskaandNewMexicothatexperiencedclustersbetween2009and2011.TheprincipalsourcesofinformationwerecommunitymembersidentifiedthroughtheirinvolvementwithSAMHSA-fundedprograms(i.e.,NativeAspirationsorGarrettLeeSmithYouthSuicidePreventionandEarlyInterventionProgram),recommendedbytribal/villageleadership,orboth.Individualschosentobeinterviewedreflectedavarietyofperspectivesandincludedelders;triballeaders;teachersandschoolpersonnel;mentalhealthandotheryouthserviceproviders;youngpeoplewholostpeerstosuicide;andmothers,fathers,grandparents,andothertribalmemberswholostfamilymemberstosuicide.Thecategoriesarenotmutuallyexclusive,withmanyintervieweesprovidingmultipleperspectives.

Thisreportincludes:

� Backgroundinformationbasedonresearchliterature,mediareports,andsurveillancedataregardingsuicideratesintheaffectedcommunities;clustersandcontagion;riskandprotectivefactorsintribalcommunities;andcontextualinformationabouttheregionswheretheclustereventsoccurred.Thisincludesthelocalhealthserviceinfrastructureandaccesstobehavioralhealthresources,aswellastheimpactandresponsetotheclustersineachcommunity;

� Adescriptionofdatasourcesusedforthisreport,includinginterviewsanddocumentreviews;

� Findingsrelatedtotheimpactofclustersonindividualsandcommunities,communityresponseandrecovery,suicidepreventionstrategies,andexistingandneededcommunityresources;and

� AdiscussionofthefindingsastheyrelatetofutureresourcestopreventandrespondtosuicideclustersinAI/ANcommunities.

BACKGROUNDNationalBackdropSuicideisasignificantpublichealthproblemintheUnitedStates,withtheratesofsuicidewithinsomepopulationsbeingparticularlyhigh.Suicideisthesecond-leadingcauseofdeathforAI/ANyouthandyoungadultsaged10–24years(NCHS,

Exhibit1.SuicideRatesamongYouthsAged10to24,byRace/EthnicityandSex,UnitedStates,2005–2011*

Page 3: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

3

2011a).ThesuiciderateforthisgroupistwotofourtimestherateofotherAmericansinthisagegroup(NCHS,2011b;Exhibit1).WhilethesuicideratedecreasedslightlyforAI/ANpeopleintheUnitedStatesbetween2010and2011,thispopulationcontinuestoexperienceoneofthehighestsuicideratesofallracialandethnicgroupstrackedbytheCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(CDC;NCHS,2011b).Withinsomestates,overallsuicideratesaremuchhigherthanthenationalaverage,withthehighestratesoccurringinAlaska,theRockyMountainstates,andintheSouthwestregion,includingNewMexico(NCHS,2011b;AmericanFoundationforSuicidePrevention,2014;Exhibit2).Ingeneral,statesintheWestconsistentlyexperiencehighersuicideratesthanstatesintheNortheast,Southeast,andMidwest.Forexample,between2005and2011,fivewesternstateshadaverageage-adjustedratesthatweremorethan19per100,000:Alaska(21.24),Montana(21.01),Wyoming(20.88),NewMexico(19.40),andNevada(19.06).ThisisnearlydoubletheoverallU.S.age-adjustedrateof11.57per100,000,overthesametimeperiod(Exhibit2).

Exhibit2.NationalSuicideRates

*Age-adjusted suicide rates per 100,000 population by state, 2005-2011 (NCHS, 2011b) InAlaskaandNewMexico,suicideratesamongAI/ANyoutharesignificantlyhigherthanratesamongyouthfromotherculturalorethnicgroups.SuicideiscurrentlytheleadingcauseofdeathforAI/ANyouthaged15–24livinginAlaska(NCHS,2011a),witharatemorethanninetimesthatofallyouthwithinthatagerangeintheUnitedStates(98.88and10.04per100,000,respectively).At152.83per

Page 4: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

4

100,000,thesuiciderateforAI/ANmalesaged15–24yearsinAlaskaisnearlyninetimesthatforallmalesaged15–24intheUnitedStates(16.23per100,000).YoungAI/ANfemalesinAlaskadiebysuicide11timesmoreoftenthanallU.S.femalesinthatagegroup(41.02and3.53,respectively;NCHS,2011b).

WhileyouthsuicideratesarelowerinNewMexicothaninAlaska,NewMexiconeverthelessexhibitsasimilartrend.ThesuiciderateforAI/ANyouthaged15–24yearsismorethanthreetimestherateforallyouthwithinthatagegroupintheUnitedStates(33.03and10.04per100,000,respectively).ForyoungAI/ANmales,therateis49.15per100,000,overthreetimestherateforallmalesthatageintheUnitedStates.ForyoungAI/ANfemales,therateis16.44per100,000,overfourtimestherateforallfemalesthatageintheUnitedStates(NCHS,2011b).

SuicideClustersandContagionAsuicideclustercanbedefinedas“agroupofsuicidesorsuicideattempts,orboth,thatoccurclosertogetherintimeandspacethanwouldnormallybeexpectedonthebasisofstatisticalpredictionorcommunityexpectation”(CDC,1988;Gould,Jamieson&Romer,2003).Therearetwomaintypesofsuicideclusters:pointandmass(Haw,Hawton,Niedzwiedz,&Platt,2013;Joiner,1999;Rezaeian,2012).Pointclustersarecloseinbothlocationandtime,occurinsmallcommunities,andinvolveanincreaseinsuicidesaboveabaselinerateobservedinthecommunityandsurroundingarea(Haw,Hawton,Niedzwiedz,&Platt,2013;Joiner,1999;Rezaeian,2012;Coxetal.,2012).Massclustersinvolveatemporaryincreaseinsuicidesacrossawholepopulation,closeintimebutnotnecessarilylocation.Massclustershavebeendocumentedfollowingsuicidesofhigh-profilecelebritiesorotherswhoreceiveconsiderablemediaattention(Coxetal.,2012;Joiner,1999).

Inherliteraturereviewoftheimpactofmediacoverageonsuicide,Gouldprovidesevidencethatextensivenewspapercoverageofsuicideisassociatedwithasignificantincreaseintherateofsuicide,withthemagnitudeoftheincreaseproportionaltotheamount,duration,andprominenceofmediacoverage(2001).Youngpeopleappeartobeparticularlysusceptibletoheightenedriskbroughtaboutbycertaintypesofmediareportingofsuicide(Gould,Jamieson,&Romer,2003).Aretrospective,case-controlstudyofsuicideclustersinyoungpeopleintheUnitedStatesbetween1988and1996(beforethearrivalofsocialmedia)indicatedanassociationbetweencertainkindsofnewspaperreportsaboutsuicideandthebeginningofclusters(Gouldet.al.,2014).Storycharacteristicsinvolvingfront-pageplacement,headlinescontainingthewordsuicideoradescriptionofthemethodused,anddetaileddescriptionsofthesuicidalpersonappearedmoreoftenforcluster-relatedsuicidesthannon-clustersuicides(Gouldetal.,2014).

Whilethemechanismsunderlyingsuicideclustersareunclear,ithasbeenproposedthatpointclustersmayresultfromaprocessof“contagion,”wherebyoneperson’ssuicidalthoughtsandbehaviorsaretransmittedfromonevictimtoanotherthroughsocialorinterpersonalconnections(Coxetal.,2012;Joiner,1999).Accordingtosomeresearchers,asuicidecontagionissimilartothespreadofinfectiousdisease(Haw,Hawton,Niedzwiedz,&Platt,2013).Justasfluismostlikelytoaffectindividualswithweakenedimmunity,inpoorhealth,andinclosecontactwithsomeonewhoissick,suicideismorelikely

Page 5: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

5

toaffectindividualswithahistoryofmentalillness,whoareclosefriendsorrelativesofthepersonwhodiedbysuicide,andwhoareexperiencingpoormentalhealth(Haw,Hawton,Niedzwiedz,&Platt,2013).Otherresearchershavecautionedthatsuicidecontagionhasyettobeclearlydefined(Joiner,1999).

Thesuicideclustersdiscussedinthisreportarepointclustersthatoccurredintwotightlyknitandgeographicallyisolatedcommunities.TheaffectedAlaskanvillagesarenotontheroadsystemandareaccessibleonlybysmallplane,whichforcesahigherlevelofself-andcommunalreliance.Mostindividualsarerelatedthroughbloodormarriage.InthecaseoftheAlaskacommunity,extendedfamilyandrelationsliveinnearbyvillagesthatessentiallyfunctionasasinglecommunity.Thus,whenasuicideoccursinonevillage,itimmediatelyimpactsresidentsinneighboringcommunities.

RiskandProtectiveFactorsSuicideriskfactorsamongAI/ANyoutharewell-knownandhavebeenwidelyreported.ManyAI/ANyouthfacepoverty,isolation,historicaltrauma,discriminationandracism,disruptedfamilyunits,previoussuicideattempt(s),accesstolethalmeans,exposuretootherswhohavediedbysuicide,physicalorsexualabuse,barrierstocare,highratesofalcoholanddruguse,andinterpersonalviolence(AlakanukCommunityPlanningGroupetal.,2009;BigFoot,2007;Borowsky,Ireland,&Resnick,2001;Borowsky,Resnick,Ireland,&Blum,1999;Christman,2012;Duran&Duran,1995;Yoder,2006).Growingupintwoculturesthathaveverydifferentworldviewscancreatecumulativestressesthatmayincreasesusceptibility(LaFromboise&BigFoot,1988).Moreover,theestimatedprobabilityofattemptingsuicidedramaticallyincreasesasthenumberofriskfactorstowhichyouthareexposedincreases(Borowskyetal.,1999;Borowskyetal.,2001).

Hawandcolleagues(2012)reviewedtheliteratureonsuicideclusterstodescribetheriskfactorsandproposedpsychologicalmechanismsunderlyingpointclusters.Theauthorsidentifiedtwokindsofliterature:(1)papersdescribingindividualsuicideclusters,whichincludedcharacteristicsofclustervictimsandenvironmentalriskfactors;and(2)papershypothesizingthemechanismsunderlyingclusterformationand,whichinafewcasesalsoprovidedempiricaldatatestingaspecifichypothesis.Thereviewfoundthatriskfactorsforsuicideclustersaresimilartoriskfactorsforsuicideingeneral.Theauthorsconcludethatnearlyallclusterstudieswereuncontrolledandinvolvedrelativelysmallnumbersofsuicides,andthatfurtherresearchisneededtoimproveunderstandingofthemechanismsinvolved.

“Circlesofvulnerability”(Exhibit3)isamodelthatmayprovideinsightintomechanismsofsuicideclusters.Developedtoassesscommunitytrauma,themodelconsidersgeographicalproximity,psychosocialproximity,andpopulationatrisk(Lahad&Cohen,2006;Zenere,2008,2009).Geographicalproximityisthephysicaldistancefromtheinitialsuicide;psychosocialproximityistheclosenessoftherelationshipwiththeperson

Exhibit3.CirclesofVulnerability

GeographicProximityto

Suicide

PsychosocialProximityto

PopulationatRiskfor

Suicide Suicide

Page 6: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

6

“Multiple traumas in Indian Country are cumulative and can increase feelings of hopelessness and helplessness that can lead to suicide.”

(BigFoot, 2007)

whodied;andpopulationatriskreferstoanindividual’sriskfactors,suchasmentalillness,historyoftrauma,substancemisuse,andhistoryofsuicidalthoughtsandbehaviors(Zenere,2008,2009).Theintersectionofthethreecirclesreflectsthepointofhighestvulnerability.

Throughthelensofthismodel,theriskprofileofNativeyouthisoftenquitehigh.Communitymemberstypicallyliveincloseproximityandarerelatedtooneanother;adolescentsocialnetworksaresmallandintense(Goldstonetal.,2008);andindividualriskfactors(e.g.,alcoholuse,depression,thedeathoffamilyandfriendsbysuicide)tendtomountandmultiply(BigFoot,2007).Whileyouthconnectednesstofamilyandcommunityisgenerallyaprotectivefactor,itcanalsobecomepartofthecontagionprocessifyoungpeoplebegintoperceivesuicidalbehaviorasnormalamongtheirpeersorpeopletheyadmire(ActionAlliance,2014).

Asocialecologicalmodelisalsousefulforunderstandingriskandprotectivefactorsacrossfourlevels:individual,relationship,community,andsocietal(U.S.HHSandNAASP,2012).Somefactorsareattheindividuallevel,butmanytranscendthepersonandareinfluencesofthelargercommunity.AsGoneandAlcántara(2007)stateinaparaphraseofFelnerandFelner’s(1989)transactionalecologicalframework,the“rootsofpathologycanbeandoftenareoutsideoftheperson.”Categorizingriskandprotectivefactorswithinthemodel’slevelsshowsthefactors’complexity,theinteractionandrelationshipbetweenandacrosssuchlevels,andpossiblestrategiesandentrypointsforpreventionandintervention.

Considerationofcommunity-andsocietal-levelriskfactorsisparticularlyimportantforAI/ANpopulations,as“indigenoussuicideisassociatedwithculturalandcommunitydisruptions,namely,socialdisorganization,cultureloss,andacollectivesuffering”(Wexler&Gone,2012,p.800).AmongtheriskfactorsforsuicideuniquetoAI/ANyouth,thesecommunitiescontinuetobeimpactedbyhistoricaltraumastemmingfromcolonizationandlossofconnectiontospiritualandculturalpractices(BraveHeart,Chase,Elkins,&Altschul,2011).

Historicaltraumaisthe“cumulativeemotionalandpsychologicalwoundingoverthelifespanandacrossgenerations,emanatingfrommassivegrouptraumaexperiences”(BraveHeart,2003).Aprimaryfeatureofhistoricaltraumaisthat“thepsychologicalandemotionalconsequencesofthetraumaexperiencearetransmittedtosubsequentgenerationsthroughphysiological,environmentalandsocialpathwaysresultinginanintergenerationalcycleoftraumaresponse”(Sotero,2006).Suicidalideationandbehavior,substancemisuse,depression,anxiety,lowself-esteem,anger,anddifficultyrecognizingandexpressingemotionshaveallbeenidentifiedascomponentsofthehistoricaltraumaresponse(BraveHeart,2003).

EffortsbytheUnitedStatestoassimilateAmericanIndiansintotheEuropean-Americanmainstreamcultureand“toendthetribeasaseparatepoliticalandculturalunit”(Cohen,1982ed.,p.139)arewell-documentedandincludepolicessuchascriminalizingtraditionaltribalgovernanceandcultural

Page 7: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

CDC Lessons Learned In Responding to Suicide Clusters

Potential opportunities for prevention were often missed during the early stages of the [suicide cluster] response as community leaders searched for information on how best to respond to suicide clusters.… In the early days of an evolving suicide cluster, there has typically been a great deal of confusion. There is often a sense of urgency in the community that something needs to be done to prevent additional suicides, but there has usually been little initial coordination of effort in this regard (CDC, 1988, p.2). 7

practices,suchasfuneralproceduresandspecificdancesandceremonies(Cohen,1982ed.,pp.128-145).EffortstouseboardingschoolstoforceassimilationofNativechildrenspannedfrom1790through1920(Hoxie,1984).Childrenwereremovedfromtraditionalfamilies(includingextendedfamilyandclansystemcultures)andfromothertraditionalformsofsocialorganizationandsourcesforidentitydevelopment,toliveinboardingschools,wheretheywereoftenverbally,physically,andsexuallyabused(Napoleon,1996).BraveHeart(1999)discussestheprocessofboardingschoolsdeprivingfamiliesoftraditionalNativeparentingrolemodels,“impairingtheircapacitytoparentwithinanindigenoushealthculturalmilieu.”Theculturalanchorsthatshouldhaveservedtogroundandenhancehealthydevelopment—fromchildhoodthroughadulthoodandparenthood—weremissing,and,inmanycases,dysfunctionwasleftinitsplace.

AnumberofstudieshavealsolookedatprotectivefactorsamongAmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeyouth.Perceivedconnectednesstofamily;discussingproblemswithfriendsorfamily;consistent,healthyattachmenttofamilyandschool;traditionalculturalvaluesandpractices;emotionalhealthandwell-being;andaccesstomentalhealthserviceshaveallbeenidentifiedasprotectiveagainstsuicideattempts(Borowskyetal.,1999;Borowskyetal.,2001;Kraletal.,2011).Similarly,Wolskoandcolleagues(2009)foundthattribalmemberswhofollowamoretraditionalwayoflifereportedgreaterhappiness,morefrequentuseofreligionandspiritualitytocopewithstress,andlessfrequentuseofdrugsandalcoholtocopewithstress.Garroutteetal.(2003)found“astrongandpersistentprotectiveassociationbetweenculturalspiritualorientationsand[lifetimeself-reported]suicideattempts”(p.1576),evenwhenriskfactorssuchassubstancemisuseandpsychologicaldistressareexperienced.Theydefined“Culturalspiritualorientations”notasbeliefsystems,butas“waysofencounteringandinterpretingself,world,andexperiences….[that]reflectAmericanIndianculturalviewsoftheconnectednessofhumanstoallotherphysicalandtranscendentalentities”(Garroutteetal.,p.1573).Moreover,connectednessisprotectivewhenitoccurswithinandbetweenmultiplelevelsofthesocialecology—betweenindividuals,families,schoolsandotherorganizations,neighborhoods,culturalgroups,andsocietyasawhole(ActionAlliance,2014).

PreventingandRespondingtoSuicideClustersOneofthemostwidelyciteddocumentsaboutpreventingandmanagingsuicideclustersisCDC’s“RecommendationsforaCommunityPlanforthePreventionandContainmentofSuicideClusters”(CDC,1988).Therecommendationsunderscorethecriticalimportanceofdevelopingcommunityplansbeforesuicideclustersoccurandtheyguidecommunityleadersandstakeholdersindevelopingspecificstrategies.Thishelpsacceleratepreventioneffortsandfacilitatesswift,coordinated,andeffectiveresponseintheeventofacluster.Thedocument

Page 8: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

8

suggeststhatsucharesponseplanshouldbeimplementedintwocircumstances:(1)whenasuicideclusteroccursinthecommunityor(2)whenoneormoretraumaticdeaths1occurinthecommunity,especiallyamongadolescentsoryoungadults,whomaybeathigherriskforcontagion.Relatedtothesecondcircumstance,CDCnotesthat“severalclustersofsuicidesorsuicideattempts(havebeen)precededbyoneormoretraumaticdeaths—intentionalorunintentional—amongtheyouthofthecommunity”(CDC,1988,p.5).

CDC’srecommendationsarebasedontheexperts’experiencesandlessonslearnedassistingvariouslocalcommunitiesinaddressingsuicideclusters.Onekeyexampleisthefactthatcommunityleadersrespondingtoanevolvingsuicideclusterfacethesimultaneoustasksofattemptingtopreventtheclusterfromexpanding,whilealsomanagingtheexistingcrisis(Askland,Sonnenfeld&Crosby,2003;OfficeofSafeandDrug-FreeSchools,2007).Toensurethetimeliestreactionpossible,therecommendationsurgethattheresponseplanandrolesofeachparticipantbedeveloped,agreedupon,andunderstoodbyallrelevantparticipantsbeforetheonsetofacrisis.

Therecommendationsemphasizetheneedforincludingallsectorsofthecommunity(e.g.,publichealth,mentalhealth,education,localgovernment,clergy,parentgroups,themedia,communityorganizations)inplanningandtheimplementingthepreventionandresponseeffort.Withthegoalofbuildingacoordinated,collaborativeinitiative,CDCurgesthat“[e]veryeffortshouldbemadetopromoteandimplementtheproposedplanasacommunityendeavor.…Nosingleagency…hastheresourcesorexpertisetoadequatelyrespondtoanevolvingsuicidecluster”(CDC,1988,p.3).Thedocumentstressestheneedtoincluderepresentativesofthelocalmediaindevelopingtheplan,toensurethatthe“legitimateneedforinformation”canbesatisfiedwithoutthekindofsensationalizedreportingthathasbeenshowntocontributetosuicidecontagion.

Overall,thedocumentpresentsasetofbroadprinciplesandsequentiallyorderedstepsthatlocalcommunitiescanundertaketopreventandplanforclustersaspartoftheiroverallsuicidepreventionplanningprocess.Therecommendationsemphasizethatcommunitypreventionandresponseplansmustbeadaptedtotheparticularneeds,resources,andculturalcharacteristicsofthecommunity.

A2012literaturereviewaimedatunderstandingeffectivepreventionand

1Traumaticdeathreferstoanydeathinthecommunitythatisnottheresultofoldageorsickness.

Common Response to Contain a Youth Suicide Cluster

1) Development of a community response plan

2) Educational/psychological debriefings

3) Individual and group counseling for affected peers

4) Screening of high-risk individuals

5) Responsible media reporting of the suicide cluster

6) Promotion of health recovery within the community

(Cox et al., 2012)

Page 9: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

9

postvention2strategiesforsuicideclusters(Coxetal.)foundthatfewstudiesactuallydocumentedresponsestrategiesandonlyoneevaluateditsefforts.However,theauthorsidentifiedanumberofstrategiesthatshowpromise,includingsixcommonapproachestoclustercontainmentfrequentlyadoptedbycommunitiesandschools(seetextbox).

SuicideSettingsofFocus:ClusterLocationsandResponses

TribeinNew Mexico

InNewMexico,thesuicideclusteroccurredonatribalreservation3locatedintheU.S.IndianHealthService’s(IHS’s)AlbuquerqueArea.TheAlbuquerqueArea,whichextendsovermostofNewMexicoandallofColorado,provideshealthservicestoAmericanIndiansinnumeroustribalgroups,eachwiththeirownhistory,language,andculture(IHS,n.d.).IntheNewMexicoportionoftheAlbuquerqueArea(Exhibit4),thetribesservedincludethe19Pueblos,theJicarillaandMescaleroApaches,andtheAlamo,Canoncito,andRamahchaptersoftheNavajoNation.Whilethepreviousgenerationsoftheaffectedtribewerenomadichuntersandgatherers,tribalmembersnowfish,hunt,manageranches,andsupportanactivetouristindustry(IHS,n.d.).

Exhibit4.NewMexicoIHSAlbuquerqueServiceAreaandTribalLands

Inresponsetothesuicidecluster,whichinvolvednotonlymultipledeathsbutmanyattemptsandexpressionsofsuicidalideation(strongthoughtsofengaginginsuicidalbehavior),thecommunityformedacrisisresponseteamtodeterminepriorities,strategies,andstepsforpreventionandcontainment.ConsistentwithCDCrecommendations,theresponsereflectedbroadcollaborationamongtribal,local,county,stateandfederalprogramsandpartneragencies.Examplesofactionsincludedprovidingassessmenttrainingandsupportforemergencymedicalserviceproviders,BureauofIndianAffairslawenforcementofficers,tribalconservationofficers,andmedicalproviders.LawenforcementofficialsagreedtonotifyandinvolvetheIHSwithin24hoursofanysuicideattemptorthreat.Thecrisisresponseteamplannedsuicidepreventionawarenesstrainingsinschoolsandothercommunitysettings.Thecommunityprovidedoutreachtotribalyouthintribalandpublicschools

2Suicidepostventionisdefinedas“Responsetoandcareforindividualsaffectedintheaftermathofasuicideattemptofsuicidedeath”(U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices(HHS)OfficeoftheSurgeonGeneralandNationalActionAllianceforSuicidePrevention,2010,p.141).Thegoalsofpostventionmayinclude(1)supportingthebereavedsurvivors,(2)preventingimitativesuicidesbyidentifyingotherindividualsatriskforself-destructivebehaviorandconnectingthemtointerventionservices,(3)reducingsurvivoridentificationwiththedeceased,and(4)providinglong-termsurveillance(Gould&Kramer,2001).3Thespecificlocationoftheclustersandrelateddetailswillnotbedisclosedinthisdocumenttomaintaintheconfidentialityofinterviewparticipants.

Page 10: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

10

acrossfourcommunities,offeringhealthservices,mentalhealthservices,andsuicidepreventionactivities,includingeveningevents.

Justpriortothecluster,thetribehadbegundevelopingasuicidepreventionteamwithfederalgrantfundingfromtheSubstanceAbuseandMentalHealthServicesAdministration(SAMHSA).Astheclusterevolved,theteamimplementednumeroussuicidepreventionprograms,includingapeer-to-peerprogrammodeledafter“NaturalHelpers,”whichhadbeenpreviouslyusedwithsuccessinatribalcommunity(Mayetal.,2005).SernadescribesNaturalHelpersasa“peer-helpingandleadershipdevelopmentprogrambasedonthepremisethatwithineveryschoolaninformal‘helpingnetwork’existsamongpeers.Studentswithproblemsseekoutotherstudentswhomtheytrust.”(2011)Inadaptingtheprogramtotheircommunity,theNewMexicotribalsuicidepreventionteamsurveyedstudentstounderstandsourcesofdistressintheirlivesandidentified“natural”peersupportersamongstudents.Theteamtaughtthepeershowtomentorstudentswhowerestruggling,encouragethemtotalkwiththeirsupportnetworks,andseekoutadultcounseling.Theteamalsointegratedsocialmediatoreachyouthandidentifystudentsatriskofsuicide.

ThetribefallswithintheIHSAlbuquerqueArea,whichisdividedintotenserviceunits,eachofwhichprovidesservicesatthecommunitylevel(IHS,n.d.).ThelocalIHSServiceUnitincludesinpatientandoutpatientservices,aswellasfieldhealthprograms.Specializedservices(e.g.,surgicalandorthopediccare)arereferredtocontracthospitalsintheregion.Atthetimeofthecluster,theIHSServiceUnitmentalhealthclinicemployedtwoindependentlylicensedcounselors.Othermentalhealthresources,includingclinicalpsychologists,psychiatrists,socialworkers,etc.weremorethan200milesfromthetribalsettingforthiscluster—notanuncommonscenarioforrural,tribalcommunities.Accesstobehavioralhealthserviceswasfurtherlimitedbecauseseveraltribalsubstanceuseproviderpositionswerevacant.

Whentheclusterdeveloped,theIHSdirector,inconcertwiththetribe,requestedandreceiveda90-daydeploymentofUnitedStatesPublicHealthServicementalhealthteamstostabilizeandaddressthehighnumberofattemptedandcompletedsuicides.Theteamsworkedwithfourschooldistrictsandcommunities,providingcounselingservicestostudentsandstaff,andimplementingprocessestotrackandmonitorsuicide-relateddata(e.g.,numbersofsuicideattempts,theageoftheperson,whetherdrugsoralcoholwereinvolved).Additionally,IHSinstitutedatelebehavioralhealthservicetoconnectlocalresidentswithbehavioralhealthstaffinotherareas.

Villagesin Western AlaskaThisreportfocusesonthreeYup’ikorCup’ikcommunitieslocatedontheBeringSeacoast,withpopulationsrangingfrom530to1,100.

Thehighratesofsuicide—beyondwhatwouldbeexpected—acrossmanyvillagesintheYukon-Kuskokwim(YK)TribalHealthRegion(Exhibit5)meanthattherearealmostcontinualsuicideclustersintheregion.OftenreferredtoastheYKDelta,thisareahasoneofthehighestsuiciderates(58.2per100,000)inthestateandthecountry.Therateisnearly3timeshigherthanAlaskaasawhole(21.28)

Page 11: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

11

andmorethan5timeshigherthantheUnitedStates(11.38)(AlaskaBureauofVitalStatistics,2002—2011;NCHS,2011b).

TheYKTribalHealthRegioncoversapproximately58,000squaremilesandishometo58federallyrecognizedYup’ik,Cup’ik,andAthabascantribes(Yukon-KuskokwimHealthCorporation[YKHC],n.d.).Theregion’s25,555residents,82percentofwhomareAlaskaNative,livein50villagesranginginsizefrom6to1,100residents(U.S.CensusBureau,2012;YKHC,2011–2014).Allofthevillageswithintheregionareaccessibleonlybysmallplaneorbysnowmachinetrailsinwinter.ThetownofBethelservesastheregionalhubcommunityandishometo6,080residents(U.S.CensusBureau,2012).Variousairtaxisprovide

Exhibit5.Yukon-KuskokwimTribalHealthRegion

regular,albeitexpensive,servicebetweenBethelandthevillages.Round-tripticketsbetweenBethelandthevillagescostbetween$200and$700,dependingonthedistance(ERAAlaska,2014).

IntheYup’ikorCup’ikcommunitiesimpactedbycontinualsuicideclusters,theregion’smainhealthcareprovider(YKHC)deploysacrisisresponseteamofbehavioralhealthproviders.Theteamprovidesmentalhealthcounseling(includingtalkingcircles4)forfamilieswholoselovedonestosuicide,anddebriefingandpostventionservicesforfirstresponders.YKHCandfederalandstateprograms,includingsuicidepreventionprograms,haveworkedwiththecommunitiestodeveloppreventionplansthatengageyouthandlimithigh-riskbehaviorssuchasalcoholanddruguse.Villageschoolstakeanactiveroleincommunityresponsebyincreasingtheiremphasisonthesocialandemotionalwell-beingofstudents.TheschoolspositivelyacknowledgeyouthandimplementtheNaturalHelperspeer-to-peerprogram.

Villagetribalcouncilsrespondtosuicideclustersbycallingcommunitymeetingstodiscusstheimpactofsuicide,itsrelationtohistoricaltraumaandtodrugandalcoholuse,andcontemporaryandtraditionalwaystoheal.Indirectresponsetothehighnumbersofsuicidethataffectedtheregionin2010,AlaskaSenatorLisaMurkowskiconvenedasummit,ajointeffortinvolvingthegovernor,membersoftheAlaskaSuicidePreventionCouncil,theSAMHSAtribalaffairsadvisor,andmembersoftheU.S.SenateIndianAffairsCommittee.SummitparticipantsdiscussedthehighratesofsuicideinwesternAlaskaandheardfromyoungpeopleaboutwaystobetteraddresstheproblem(DeMarban,2010).

TheYKHC,locatedinthehubcommunityofBethel,istheregionaltribalhealthconsortiumandmainhealthcareproviderforthevillagesintheYKservicearea(Exhibit6),provideshospital,dental,and

4Thetalkingcircleisatraditionalwayfortribalpeopletosolveproblems.Thereisnobeginningnorendinacircle;thus,noonepersonisinapositionofprominence.Thetalkingcirclecreatesanenvironmentwherepeoplecanspeakfreely,airtheirdifferences,andresolveproblems.

Page 12: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

12

behavioralhealthcare;healthpromotionanddiseaseprevention;andenvironmentalhealthservices(YKHC,2014).YKHCalsoprovidesbasichealthserviceswithinthevillages,throughclinicsstaffedbyCommunityHealthAides(CHAs).Theselocalindividualsarethefrontlineofmedicalcareandsupportwithintheirvillages.CHAsarecertifiedattheCHAI,II,IIIandPractitioner(CHAP)levelsandareselectedbytheircommunitiestoreceivetrainingfortheirroles.Foreachlevel,thetraininglastsapproximately3weeks(AlaskaCHAP,n.d.).CHAsoperateinanestablishedreferralrelationshipwithmid-levelproviders,physicians,andtheregionalhospitals(AlaskaCHAP,n.d.).WithintheYKDelta,therearealsofivesubregionalclinics,eachofwhichservesthevillageswithinitssubregion.Subregionalclinicsofferahigher

Exhibit6.Yukon-KuskokwimServiceArea

levelofservicethanthevillageclinicsandincludepreventativeandurgentcare,aswellaslaboratoryandX-rayservices.Thesubregionalclinicsarestaffedwithatleastonemid-levelprovider,typicallyanursepractitionerorphysicianassistant.Subregionalclinicsprovideancillaryservices(e.g.,dental,behavioralhealth),oftenintheformoftravelingcaretothehandfulofvillagesintheirsub-region.Comprehensivementalhealthandsubstanceuseservices(includinginpatientandoutpatientservices)areavailableattheYKHCinBethel.However,accesstocomprehensivebehavioralhealthservicesrequiresleavingthevillageviabushplane.

Toincreaseaccesstomentalhealthservicesinvillages,in2004theAlaskaNativeTribalHealthConsortium(ANTHC)collaboratedwithIHStoinstituteastatewidebehavioralhealthworkforcemodelthatwassimilartotheCHA.By2008,theBehavioralHealthAide(BHA)programhadbeenincorporatedintothefederallyrecognizedCommunityHealthAideProgram.TheexistingCommunityHealthAideCertificationBoardStandardsandProcedureswereamendedtoincludestandardsforBehavioralHealthAides(BHAI,II,IIIandBehavioralHealthPractitioner(BHP)certificationandpractice(ANTHC,2005–2014).LikeCHA/Ps,BHA/Ps’shavealimitedscopeofpracticeandserveashealtheducatorsandadvocateswithintheircommunities(ANTHC,2005–2014;vanHecke,2012).Practicingunderthesupervisionoflicensedcliniciansbasedintheregionalhubs,BHAsI,IIandIIIprovidecasemanagement,referral,communityeducation,andpreventionservices;BHPsalsoprovidetreatmentplanningandcommunityevaluations(vanHecke,2012).

WhileeverywesternAlaskavillagedoesnothaveaBHAprogram,thosethatdoselectresidentsoftheirownvillage,fluentinthecultureofthecommunity,whoisawelcomingandfamiliarface.However,giventheclose-knitnatureofthecommunities,concernsaboutconfidentialityandshameaboutbehavioralhealthmaylimitserviceutilization.Communitymembersareoftenreluctanttoseekcarefromindividualstheyhaveknown,inmanycases,theirentirelives(vanHecke,2012).

Page 13: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

13

Availableinsomevillagesfor10years,telebehavioralhealthisanalternativevenueforreceivingcareandmayhelpallayprivacyconcerns.ButevenwiththeadditionoftheBHAprogramandaccesstotelebehavioralhealth,accesstobehavioralhealthcareisextremelylimitedandsimplyoutofreachformanyAlaskaNatives.

SOURCES OF INFORMATIONSAMHSAandtheauthors(federalcontractors)ofthisreportselectedcommunitiesbasedonclustersreportedwithinthepast5years.Theauthorsthenengagedthecommunitiestodiscussthepurposeofthestudy,answerquestions,anddeterminetheirinterestinparticipating.Whenacommunityexpresseditsinterest,theauthorsmetwiththetribalcouncilorvillageleadershipandsignedaMemorandumofunderstanding(MOUs)betweenthetribe/villageandthefederalcontractor.Thecontractorsoughtandobtainedinstitutionalreviewboardapprovalforallproceduresusedinthisstudy.

Thisreportisinformedbymultiplesources,includingqualitativedatacollection,reviewandanalysisofexistingdata(YRBS,BRFSS,NVDRS),andarchivalrecords.ThecontractorrecruitedninecommunitymembersfromthetribeandAlaskavillagestoparticipateinindividualtelephoneinterviews,securinginformedconsentbeforetheinterviews.InterviewswereconductedbetweenJune2013andFebruary2014,andrecorded,transcribed,andanalyzedusingstatisticalsoftware.Thecontractoralsoreviewedandanalyzedarchivalrecords,includingtestimony;meetingminutesfromcommunityandlegislativemeetings;newspaperandmediasources;andotherdocumentsande-mails.

Whiletheindividualsthatparticipatedintheinterviewsarediverseintermsofage,gender,roleinthecommunity,andlevelofinvolvementinsuicidepreventionworkinthecommunity,thesamplewasnotintendedtoberepresentativeofthevillageortribeperspective.Rather,arangeofinformationwasgatheredtounderstandandinformpreventionandresponsetosuicideclustersfromdirectexperiencesanduniqueculturalandtribal/villagecontexts.Inaddition,thesamplesizesacrossthesettingsarenoteven(i.e.,moreinterviewstookplacewithvillagemembersinAlaskathanwithNewMexicotribalmembers).

FINDINGSBasedontheinterviewsandotherdatasources,thissectionpresentsfindingsrelatedtotheimpactofsuicideclustersonthecommunity,andexistingandneededsuicidepreventionresources(bothcommunity-basedandexternal).Thesummaryincludesrecommendationsfromcommunitymembersonfactorsthathinderedorfacilitatedsuicidepreventionandresponsetosuicideclusters.

EffectofSuicideClustersontheCommunityInboththetribeandvillagesettings,relationshipsinthecommunitiesareclose—individualsknowtheirneighbors,andinmanycasestheyarerelated.Asonerespondentdescribed,“Ourcommunityisonebigfamily.”Thus,theeffectofthesuicideclustersandsuicideattemptswaspervasiveandpersonal.Theimpactwasreflectedinparticipants’stories,intheirreactionstotherepeatedsuicidesandattempts,in

Page 14: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

14

theirdescriptionofthecontagion,andinthewaysthatthecommunityresponsewasremarkablyunifiedandhealing.

Allrespondentsindicatedthatthey,alongwithothersinthecommunity,weredeeplyandpersonallyimpactedbythesuicides,attempts,and“nearmisses”—suicideattemptsandpotentialsuicidesnarrowlyaverted.Inadditiontotherecentclusters,somerecalledearliertimeswhensuicidesoccurredwithshockingfrequency.Onerespondentrecalled,“Backinthe‘90s,IwasaVPSO[firstresponder]inmyvillage,andwehadasuicideaweekforalongtime,overayearorforsomemonths.”5Respondentsalsodescribedtheacuteandcumulativepaincausedbyexperiencingandrespondingtomultiplesuicidesinthecommunityovertheyears.Onerespondentrecalled,

“WeusedtogotoAnchorage…anddouseourselveswithboozeforoneandtryto forget everythingbecausewe’ve handled toomanybodies.We’d cleanandwashofftheblood(accumulated)overtheyears.”

InwesternAlaska,somedescribedarhythmoflifeinterruptedwithregularemergenciesrelatedtoimminentsuicideattempts.Arespondentrecalledoneoccasion:“Ayoungladycalledme,shewasabouttohangherself.SoIrantoherhouseandspokewithheratlength,greatlength.”Hewentontosay,

“Mywifewasrunningsuperfasttowardshersister’shouse,mysister’shouse.AndIcalledmyfolks.Iwaslikewhat’sgoingon?Andoneofmynephewsislockedinhisroomscreaming,screaming,screaming….Icalledmysisterrightawayandtheywerecryingsohard….Ithoughtmynephewwasdead.”

Sincemanycommunitymembershelpothersduringaresponsetosuicideclusters,manyexperience“burnout”andexhaustionfromconstantlybeinginastateofemergency:“Wehadasuicideaweekforalongtime,overayearorforsomemonths….Wedidn’thave[any]debriefing…sometimesIfeellikeIneedalittlebreak,butthenIgoforthagain.”

Respondentsconsistentlydescribedorreferencedthecontagioneffect—thetransmissionofsuicidalthoughtsandbehaviorsfromonevictimtoanother—indescribingthatasuicideinonecommunity

5VPSOistheacronymforVillagePublicSafetyOfficer.VPSOsaretrainedandemployedbytheAlaskaStateTroopers.Theyarelocal,villageresidentswhoserveasfirstresponderstovillagepublicemergenciessuchasfires,searchandrescues,emergencymedicalassistance,basiclawenforcementandcommunitypublicsafetyandcrimeprevention(AlaskaStateTroopers,n.d.).

Community responses reflected the frequency of deaths by suicide, the enduring pain these events have caused, the lack of healing experienced by the community, and the way in which the threat of additional suicides or attempts lingers in the community—injecting into everyday life elements of psychic pain and hyper-vigilance.

Page 15: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

15

seemedtotriggeradditionalsuicideseitherwithinthesamecommunityor,inthecaseofwesternAlaska,inneighboringvillages.Relatedobservationsincluded:

“It’sa small community,everyoneknowseachother.Whensuicidehappens inthecommunity,ithappenssequentially,likeinsequence.(Thesuicide)willmakeotherreallyclosefamilyandfriendsfeelreallydepressedanddown.”

Consistentwiththe“circlesofvulnerability”modeldiscussedintheBackgroundsectionofthisreport,onerespondentillustrateshowdegreeofpsychosocialproximitytosomeonewhohasdiedbysuicidecaninfluencethedegreeofriskforindividualcommunitymembers,contributingtocontagion:

“But,theclosertherelativesorthefriendsoftheindividualsthathavetakentheirownlife….theleveloftheimpactishigherthantheonesthatarenotrelated.So,theriskisthereforthosethatareclosertothefamily,especiallythefriendsoftheyoungperson.”

Communitymembersdescribedbeingimpactedbyandrespondingtosuicideclustersinremarkablysimilarways,moreasaunifiedgroupthanasindividualsorparticularsectorsofthecommunity.Villagersnotedthatthecommunityexperiencesacollectivedepressionwhenitlosesayoungpersontosuicide.Notedonevillagemember,“Sincewearecloseknitted,everyoneisbasicallyrelatedtoeverybodycloselyorrelativesorgoodfriends.Itreallyputsthemoraledownverymuch.”Anothersaid,“Peoplethatare‘suiciding’arepeoplethatwegrewupwith…andwhenthathappens,itreallymakesthewholecommunitylikedarkandlikesad.”Reflectingonthetraumaofpastsuicides,theongoingpainofsuicidesandattempts,andthefeelingofsharedsorrowwithothervillages,onerespondentsaid,

“That’sahardthingtoseewhensomeonelosestheirlovedone,especiallythroughsuicide.Andthatreallyaffectseachcommunitybecausewe’vegonethroughsomuchthesepastyearsanditseemslikeit’sstillgoing.AndthathurtsmewhenIhearothervillagesgoingthroughthesameeffectswehaveinthisvillage.”

Atthesametime,anotablecommunitystrength(describedfurtherinCommunity-BasedResources)isthatcommunitymembers—withinandacrossvillages,inthecaseofwesternAlaska—collaborateinunitytosupportthosewhoareclosesttotheyouthwhodiedbysuicide.Thesupportthatcommunitymembersprovideforoneanother,oftenconnectedbysharedspiritualityandculture,promoteshealing.Onepersondescribedhowcommunitymembersgatherwiththefamilywholostayoungperson,“talkingtooneanother,supportingeachother,comfortingandduringthosegatherings,youhavegospelsingingandsometimesstorieswillcomeupofmemories(of)thatperson.Inmostcases,it’sreallygood…wheneverybodycomestogetherandcomfortsoneanother.”Anotherrespondentdescribedthatvillagesreachoutandsupportothervillages,becausecommunitymembersacrossthesevillagescanrelatetothepainandtraumathatthesuicidescause.

“Whenasuicideoccurs,Iknowthere’slotsofsupportgoingonfromourvillagebecauseweknowhowitfeelswhenthere’seffectivesupportforeachother,like

Page 16: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

16

asupportsystem,whichisgoodtoseebecausethat’swhatwedo,dealwiththefamilysupportandseewhatwecandotohelpandjustbeasupportsystemtothem.”

CommunityPerspectivesonResourcesforSuicideClusterPreventionandCrisisResponseCommunitymembersprovidedtheirperspectivesabouttheresourcescriticalforstrengtheningsuicidepreventionandresponsetosuicideclusters.Theyalsoidentifiedimportantresourcesprovidedfromoutsideoftheircommunity.

Community-Based Resources(CrisisResponse)Community-basedresourcesforcrisisresponserangefromtheformal(e.g.,thetribe,behavioralhealthservices,schoolpolicies,VPSOs)tothesocialorcultural(e.g.,elders,families,naturalhealers,communitymembers),withsimilaritiesanddifferencesacrossthetribeandvillagecommunities.

FormalCommunityStructuresAmongthewesternAlaskacommunities,somehaveoneofthevillageshasasubregionalclinic,whichgivesaccesstoahigherlevelofhealthandbehavioralhealthcareservicesthanareavailableinmostvillagesorcommunityhealthaideclinics.Onerespondentnoted,“There’salotofhelpavailablehereatthevillage.We’reoneoftheluckiervillagesinthataspectofgettinghelp.”Hecontinued,“Wehaveourregionalclinichereandthere’smedicalpersonnel,mentalhealthpersonnel,twoVPSOsandapoliceforceforourvillagethatisopen24/7,365daysayear.AndIknowthat’sabigplusforanyvillage.”ThiscompareswithothervillagesthathaveasingleVPSOandnopolice,andonevillagethatreliessolelyonoutsideresourcesforbehavioralhealthservices.

Schoolsandtribalcouncilstakeanactiveroleintheircommunities,includingintimesofcrisis.Referencingarecentincidentinwhichayoungpersonwroteasuicidenote,onecommunitymemberexplainedhowcoordinationbetweenagenciesoccurs:

“Theschoolwasconcerned,ourtribalcouncilwasconcerned,andtheyactedonitrightaway….Theytalkedwiththeyoungindividual,starteddifferentthingsthathecandohereinthecommunity,talkedwiththeparents,madesure

Community-based Resources

Formal Community Structures

• Tribal council and declarations of emergency

• Schools

• Behavioral health resources

• VPSOs and first responders

Cultural/Social Resources

• Elders, traditional teachings

• Local clergy and faith community

• Community members, particularly from the schools

• Tribal medicine, natural healers

• Community gatherings

Page 17: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

17

everybodywasinvolved,sothat’swhattheydidwiththelastsuicidenote.Andwe’vebeenwatchingtheyoungboyforthepastfewweeksandjustthere’sbeenagoodturnaroundthepastfewweeks.”

Further,tribalcouncilsmayprovideimmediatefinancialsupporttofamiliesintheeventofasuicidetoassistwithpracticalmatters,suchasfuneralexpenses.

“They[thetribalcouncil]providebigsupport,especiallywiththepeople,familymemberswholiveoutoftown;theypaytheirfaresroundtripfromwheretheyare,beitlower48oraroundAnchorageorwhathaveyou,theothersurroundingvillage.Andtheyhelppayforcasketsandgivemoneyforfoodalso.Soit’satremendoussupportfinancially.”

Tribalcourts,withaholisticapproachtoproblemsandemphasisonrestorativejustice6,alsoserveasanindirectformalresourceforsuicidepreventionandresponse.Thecourtshandlecasesdealingwithchildprotection,juveniledelinquency,anddomesticviolence,andarethereforewell-positionedtoworkonrestoringbalanceandharmonywithinfamilyandcommunity.IntervieweesconsideredtribalcourtstobevaluablelocalresourcesinaddressingthesuicidecrisisinAlaska.Acommunitymembernoted,“ThetypeofservicesthatweprovidearethroughourIndianChildWelfareActthroughourtribalcourt.Wehavethreejudgesthatmeetwithfamilymemberandmeetwithdifferentproblemareashereinthecommunity.”

Cultural/SocialResourcesInadditiontotheservicesprovidedbyformalagencies,eachcommunityreliesonawealthofsocialandculturalresourcessuchasguidancefromeldersforculturallyrootedapproachestoaddressinggrief,naturalhealersandtraditionalmedicine,andformalorinformalcommunitygatherings.Atsuchgatherings,communitymemberscongregate,sharestories,singgospelsongs,anddrawonasharedsenseofspiritualityandculturalhistoryinattemptingtoovercomecrisesandimpactofthesuicidesandsuicideclusters.Acommunitymemberexplained,

“Thepurposeoftheeldersistoaddresstothecommunity…becausewhenitcomestoloss,again,someofthefamilywouldnothavetheinterestindoingwhattheyusuallydo.Soit’stoadvisethecommunityaswellasthefamilymembersinthecommunityhowtheyshoulddealwiththeirgriefculturally.”

Eldersarerespectedknowledge-bearersintheircommunities.Askeepersoftheircommunities’longhistory,theyplayasignificantroleinsupportingyouth.Byinteractingwithyouth,theyareabletopass

6Restorativejusticeisanapproachtojusticethatemphasizesrepairofharmdonebyoffendersthroughreconciliationwithvictimsand/orthecommunityatlarge.Thepurposeoftherestorativejusticeapproachistorestorebalanceinindividualsandcommunitiesprimarilyforharmdonethroughdrugandalcoholuseaswellasminorcriminaloffenses(DrugCourtsProgramOffice,1999).

Page 18: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

onwisdomandtraditions—informationthathasallowedthevillagestosurviveandthriveinthefaceofaharshenvironmentandthreatsfromoutsidersofculturalextinctionandassimilation.Forexample,Elders’Councilsservethecommunity,inpartbyestablishingmechanismsandprogramsforculturaltransmission.Recountingtheroleofeldersininformingcommunityprojects,onecommunitymemberexplained,

“Therearesometeachingsthatarebroughtdownorallybytheeldersofhowthecommunitymembersshouldhelpthemselves….They’regiventheprinciplesthatarebroughtdownfromtheeldersfromthepast.Everythingisbroughtdownorallyandtraditional.It’slikeculturalevidence-basedteachingsthatpromotewellnesstothecommunities.”

Theinfluenceofelderscarriesintothecommunitysettingascommunitiesconsciouslyintegratecultureintoeverydayactivities(e.g.,school,work,andplay).Interviewparticipantsdescribetheclose-knitfeeloftheirsmall,ruralcommunitiesaskeycommunityassetsthatincludesinceremutualcareandconcernforothers;sharedpurpose;andanactivespiritofcooperationinaddressingcommoninterestsandhealingthecommunity,particularlyintimesofcrisis.Onerespondentstated,“Ithinkintermsofthesesocialissuesandthewaythatwe’vehandledsuicidesinthepast,communitymembersarealwaysinvolved.”Acrosstheboard,manyrespondentsexpressedsimilarsentiments.Onecommunitymemberdescribed,

“Intheeventofemergencies,ourvillagerisestotheoccasion.Thepeopleherearesostrong,sosupportive.Overtheyearswhenkidscommittedsuicide…thewholecommunityandthepeoplewhoareinneed,theybringfooddayafterdayafterday….Wehaveacustomhereinourvillagetoviewabodyfor3days,andinthemeantimeduringthat3days,peoplefromthewholevillageareconsistentlycontinuouslypresentwiththefamily24hoursadayforthose3daysuntiltheburial.”

Communitymembersalsodescribedthatindividualsskilledintraditionalmedicineandnaturalhealersareanimportantcommunityresourcewhoareoftenactivelyengagedduringasuicidecrisis.Inaddition,priortodeclaringastateofemergencyintheNewMexicotribe,keycommunitymemberswhocoordinatedtoaidthelocalcommunityincludedlocalclergyprovidingcommunityservicesforthoseinneed,andcommunitymembersfromtheschoolstopromotemessageswithasuicidepreventionlens.Forexample,theyattemptedtominimizethecontagionbyexplaininghowinformationaboutthemannerofdeathcouldincreaseriskandcontagion.Faithleadersalsoencouragedcommunitymembers

toreachoutforhelpiftheyneededsupport.

Spiritualityprovidesawaytoprocessandhealfromlife’straumasindividuallyandincommunionwithothers.Oneparticipantexplainedhowspiritualityoftenmanifestsinhiscommunity:“Spiritualityisoneofthethingsthatarevaluedinthevillagesystem.…Everybodyisinvitedtoshareasongandpeoplewithtalentsandtheabilityto

18

Community Perspectives on Community Connectedness “Families look out for one another. People look out for one another. I think we’re a strong people.”

“Our village has been through so much, yet here we are still moving forth.”

Page 19: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

19

playmusicforthepeoplethathavethedesiretosharetheirsongs.Ibelievepeopleexpressingtheirfeelingsthroughsongsissomeofthewayofspiritualhealing.”

Atthesocietallevel,traditionalculturealsoservestogroundindividualsandprovideaframeworktoviewtheirplaceintheworld.Asonecommunitymemberstated,“Youngpeopleneedtoknowwhotheyare,haveaknowledgeofwheretheirancestorscamefrom,tobeproudofwhotheyare.”Communitiesareactivelytakingstepstoconnectyouthtoculturebecausetheyunderstandtheprotectiveeffectsofconnectionthatareenabledbycultureandtraditionalpractice.Onerespondentexplainedhiscommunity’sprocessas“usingevidence-basedinterventions,cultural-basedinterventions,likehavingeldersinvolvedandsharestoriesofhowtheyusedtodealwithcrisissituationsinthepastbeforeourgeneration.”

Community-Based Resources (Prevention)

Communitymembersdiscusseddirectandindirectsuicidepreventionactivities.Preventionactivitiesrangefromthecultural(culturecamps,elder/youthconnections)tocommunityandyouthgatherings,toformalschoolprograms(e.g.,thenationalpeer-to-peerNaturalHelpersprogram)andschool-basedpresentationsonsuicidesignsandriskfactors.Acommonaimacrosstheseresourcesandprogramsistostrengthenprotectivefactorsacrossthesocialecologybyconnectingyouthandcommunity,deepeningyouthknowledgeandpracticeoftraditionalculture,anddevelopingandpromotingprosocialadultandpeermentorsandrolemodels.

InthewesternAlaskacommunity,culturecampsareakeycomponentofeachofthecommunities’suicidepreventionstrategies.Inculturecamps,youthlearntraditionalskillsandinteractintensivelywitheldersandotherknowledge-bearersinordertogroundyouthinthousandsofyearsofplace-basedknowledge.Communitymembersdescribedcampactivitiesthatincludesurvivalcampinginthetundra,beading,harpoonmaking,andnaturewalks.Thecampsaretimedwithseasonalsubsistenceactivities,andforsomeyouth,arethefirstexposureandexperiencewiththeirtraditionallifeways.Asonecommunitymembersaid,“Wehavehadmultipleculturalcampshereinthecommunityattheschoollevel,andalsoatour[tribalcouncil]level.ThelastonethatwedidwaslastyearfalltimeandIthink[had]sixorseven—no,sixoreightyoungindividualswhohadnevergonetoculturalcamp[before]andtheyhadaverygoodtime.”Anothersaid,

“Iguesswhatactuallythecommunityhasbeentryingtodoisreestablishthecommunitybacktotheirtraditionalevidence-basedteachingsandoutreachactivitiesandhavingtheyouthbeconnectedwiththecommunitytribalmembers.”

Amongexistingresourcesforsuicidepreventionarefrequentpresentationsinschoolsonsuicideriskfactorsandwarningsigns,andtheNaturalHelpersprogram.Describinganapproachtopresenting,onerespondentsaid,“Thispastmonth,wemetingroups,abunchof[youth]—Italkedtherapytothemaboutsuicide.Imadealessonplanyesterday,and…ittalksabouttheway[that]there’snosingleproblemintheentireuniverse[thatwarrantsdyingby]suicide.”IntheNewMexicocommunity,sourcesdescribedanincreaseinschoolsurveys,assessments,andscreeningsasaresultoftheNaturalHelpers

Page 20: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

29

program.Inaddition,newschoolpoliciesweredevelopedtoimplementsuicidepreventionandresponseprotocols.

IntheAlaskavillages,communitygatheringsandyouthcenters—whereavailable—provideanothervenueforpositiveyouthconnectionwithcommunityandcaringadults.Describingtheimpactofcommunitygatherings,onerespondentstated“CommunitygatheringiswhatIhavebeenfocusingonbecauseitisalessonthatcanbeusedasatooltoconnectelders,youth,family,leaders[in]thecommunity,resourcememberstogethertoimplementempowermentforthespiritualwellnessofthecommunity.”Youthcentersintwoofthevillagesarevenuesforpositivesocialinteractionandactivitiesforyouth.Onevillagerdescribed,“[The]youthcenterhaspeopleworkingonweekendstotryandmotivatetheyoungpeoplefromgettingintoalcoholanddrugsbygivingthemhealthyactivitiesonFridaysandthosearesomeofthethingsthattheyhavesetupinregardstoprevention.”

AmidstalloftheeffortsofthesecommunitiestopositivelyengageyouthandreconnecttoYuuyaraq,thetraditionalwayoflifeknowninAlaska,participantsunderstandthatsuicidepreventiondoesnothappenovernight.Asonecommunitymembernoted,preventiontakestimeandeffort:“Andittakeseffortforatribetobringback—have[youth]regainbacktheircorevalues.”

IntheNewMexicotribe,sourcesalsosuggestedthatformaltribalactionthatpromotesthedevelopmentofsuicidepreventionresourcesandprogramshasbeenacriticalsupport.Asourcesuggested,“Thetribaladministrationfinallyunderstandsthatourcommunity-basedservicesarenotconnectinginavitalwaytomeetingthechallengesofchildrenandyouthwithseriousmentalhealthneedsandtheirfamilies.”

ExternalResourcesInadditiontothelocalresources,bothcommunitiesreceiveoutsidehelpinrespondingtoandpreventingsuicide.IntheAlaskasetting,thecommunityreceivedhelpfromothervillages,regionalcorporationsbasedinBethel(e.g.,YKHC),andeven,attimes,fromthe“lower48”(thecontiguousUnitedStates,asitisreferredtoinAlaska).Thisoutsidesupportoftentakestheformofagencyprovisionofbehavioralhealthservices,andmissiontripsfromvisitingchurchestoengageyouthor(re)buildlocalinfrastructure.

IntheNewMexicocommunity,aftertheadministrationdeclaredastateofemergency,outsidehelpincludeddeployingmentalhealthserviceprovidersandothercrisisworkersfromIHS.Crisisworkerswereavailableintheschoolandthecommunityatlarge.Inaddition,individualsfromalarge,urbanuniversitycametothecommunitytoprovidecounseling,crisisservices,andpostventionservicesforthecommunityingeneralandforthestudentpopulation.

InwesternAlaska,becausevillagesaresmallandrelativelyclosetogether,theregionitselftakesonacommunityfeel.Thus,whenoneofthevillagesexperiencesacrisis,communitymembersfromothervillagesstepforwardtoassisttheaffectedcommunityandfamily.Onecommunitymemberexplained,“Thevillagesaresosmallthatweknowmostofeachother.Sowhenacommunityisgoingthroughacrisis,theothercommunitieswillcomeoverandjustbeasupportofthatfamily.”

Page 21: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

21

IntheAlaskavillages,theregionalhealthcorporation,YKHC,locatedinBethel,provideson-callcrisissupportintheformofdebriefingteamsthatflyintocommunitiesfollowingaviolentdeathortrauma(e.g.,suicideorhomicide).Whensuchaneventoccurs,thecommunitynotifiestheYKHCBehavioralHealthDepartment,whichmobilizesacrisisresponseteam.Onerespondentnoted,

“[The]debriefingthatYK[HC]provides,thatreallymadeabigdifferencewhenalotofotherpeoplewanttohelptotalstrangers,evenorganizationslikeYK[HC],that’ssuchatremendoussupportforvillagesandforindividualfamiliesorindividuals.”

Inadditiontoprovidingpostventionorinterventionafterasuicide,YKHCsupervisesthelocalBHAsandhasateamofitinerantbehavioralhealthclinicianswhotravelmonthlyorbimonthlytothevillagesfor1–2daysatatime.AstheBHAsarelimitedinscope,theitinerantclinicianshelptoroundoutthebehavioralhealthservicesavailablewithinthevillage.OnerespondentdescribedanincreaseinvillagebehavioralhealthservicesprovisionasaresultofassistancefromtheYKHC:“YKHChasprovidedawholebunchofbehavioralhealthservicesafter,Ithink,2007andthey’regettingmorepeopleinvolvedintryingtogetbehavior-typeissuesunderstood.”

Missiontripsfromvisitingchurchescanalsobeformsofexternalsupport.Missiontripsareregardedasasuicidepreventionresourcebecauseofthepositiveengagementtheyprovide,particularlyforyoungpeople.Oneparticipantcitedanongoingrelationshiphiscommunityhashadwithachurchgroupfrom“thelower48.”Forthepastseveralyears,thechurchsentagroupofmemberstothevillageduringthesummertosupportyouthserviceprojectsandtoprovidepositiveactivitiesandengagementforyouth.Thisparticipantdescribes,“theywerehereworkingwithawholebunchofkids,givingthemawholebunchofactivitiestoworkon.”

Asvaluedasalloftheseexternalresourcesare,severalrespondentsinwesternAlaskavoicedconcernoverthelimitationsandlastingimpactoftemporaryhelpcominginfromtheoutside.Notedonecommunitymember,

“Oncetheyleave,eventhoughtheycame,itneedstobethecommunitythatcanworktogetherasacommunityalone.Becausethey’lljustcomeinandhelpus,butthat’swhereitbeginsthatthecommunityneedstounderstandthattheyneedtoworktogetherasateamtohelpeachotherout.”

BarriersandFacilitatorstoSuicideClusterPreventionandResponseCommunitymembersreflectedonthefactorsthathinderedorfacilitatedsuicideclusterpreventionandresponseeffortsintheirowncommunities.Respondentsreportedleadership,capacity(e.g.,humancapital,funding,andservices),andimplementationchallengesaffectingcommunity-levelpreventionandresponse/recoveryefforts.Respondentsalsoidentifiedshiftsinperceivedself-sufficiencyandsocialnorms(e.g.increasedroleofelders,decreasedindividualcomplacency)toexplainthecommunity’sresponsetosuicide.

Page 22: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

Community Perspectives on Shame and Suicide Prevention “It’s like the word suicide is poisonous or something.”

“Most youth won’t go to the mental health clinic. The stigma and shame keeps people away.”

22

Community-Level Barriers

• Limited human capital, funding, and services

• Need for surveillance

• Lack of coordination

• Lack of an evidence-base for suicide cluster prevention in tribal populations

• Role of the media during a suicide cluster

Barr i ersRespondentsidentifiedthefollowingbarrierstosuicideprevention:

� Lackofastandardizedorcommunity-basedreportingandsurveillancesystem.Suchasystem

isneededtohelpcommunitiesunderstandthenatureofsuicideclustersandhowtobestaddresstheproblem.

� Lackofcoordinationacrossgrantandtribalprograms.Lackofcoordinationresultsinmissedopportunitiestostreamlineandmaximizetheimpactofservices,resourcesandprograms.Onesourcenoted,“Thereweredefinitelyalotofserviceissuesintermsofwhichcommunityprogramswantedtoprovidewhichservicestodifferentpopulations…itseemsliketherewasacompetitivenessintermsofwhowantedtoprovideservicestowhom,andnobodyknewhoweachprogramshouldgoaboutdoingthat.”

� Accesstoappropriateevidence-basedservices.Evidence-basedsuicidepreventionservicesfortribalpopulationsarelimited.Onecommunitymemberexplainedthat,whileadaptationmayoftenbenecessaryacrosstribes,thetendencytoencouragea“tribaladaptation”thatcanbeappliedtoallAI/ANpopulationsisinappropriate.Fidelitytotheevidence-basedprogrammaybelostaseachcommunitymakestheirownadaptations,anda“one-sizefitsall”approachcannotaccountfortheuniquefactorsthatdistinguishonetribalcommunityfromanother(Wexler&Gone,2012).

� Theroleofthemediaandmediamessaging.LackofcoordinationonmediamessagingduringthesuicideclusterintheNewMexicoresultedininaccuratereportingabouttheevent.Inaddition,mediasourcesreleasedgraphicdetailsaboutthedeathsand“werereportingthesenumbersaboutthedevastatinglifeconditionsonthereservation,thenegativelifestylesthatweretakingplace”saidonecommunitymember.Communitymembersbelievedthistobeirresponsible.Eventually,communitymembersreachedouttonewsoutlets(televisionstationsandnewspaper/printjournalists)andinvitedthemintothecommunitytocorrectinaccuratereporting,aswellastodiscussthetypeofinformationthatneededtobewithheldfromthepublic.

� Ongoingshame.Shamearoundseekingbehavioralhealthresources,orevendiscussingsuicideandpreventionapproaches,ispervasiveinthesecommunities.Nearlyeveryrespondentidentifiedongoingembarrassment,fear,andshameasanimpedimenttoaccessingbehavioralhealthresources.Onerespondentnoted,

Page 23: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

Community Perspective on Grants The shelf life for grants are pretty low. You only have a handful of years to make an impactful change. And it’s hard to really do that, especially in communities where maybe their readiness level just are not—they still need to be built up.

23

“Nobodyjustwantstotalkaboutit;theyjustwanttoignoreitandhideitandnottalkaboutit.”Inonecommunity,somesuggestedthatshameisrootedina“cultureofsilence”onthetopicsofdeathanddyingthatultimatelycontributestoliveslost.Onecommunitymembersuggestedthatyouthexperienceacombinedsenseofhopelessnessandshamethatpreventsthemfromseekingbehavioralhealthcare:“theyfeelsohopeless,there’snohope….There’snotomorrows.”Otherrespondentssuggestedthatyouthfeelthat“peoplewilllookdownuponthem”andthatthereisa“myththatpeoplearecrazyiftheyaskforhelp.”

� Lackofexistingbehavioralhealthservicesandfunding.Evenwhenanindividualovercomesshameandself-identifiesas“atrisk,”theavailableservicesinruralcommunitiesareofteninsufficient.Inadequatecapacityintheformoffunding,humancapital,andserviceavailabilityimpedessuicidepreventionandresponse/recoveryefforts.IntheNewMexicocommunity,thereisamentalhealthclinicwithonefull-timepsychologisttoprovidementalhealthservicestothousandsofyouthandadults.Insufficientfundingforserviceswasalsoidentifiedasabarrier.Onecommunitymemberreported,“Toprovideservices,ittakeseithervolunteerworkorsomebodythatwantstohelpthecommunitybuttheywantcompensation.”Evenwhencommunitiesrequestassistancefromoutside,itcoststime,effort,andmoney.Asonevillagerexplained,“Tryingtogetotherstoseewhatthecommunityisgoingthrough,theyhavetogooutandtravel,talkwithothers,providecapacitybuildingtraining.Ifyouwantservicestocomeouthere,youhavetoprovidetravelforthemtocomeout.Youhavetogivethemaplacetostay.”Respondentsreportedalackofbehavioralhealthandlawenforcementpersonneltrainedinsuicidepreventionorasgatekeepers.Oneofthevillagersinacommunitywithoutasubregional-levelclinic,shared,“Wehaven’thadabehavioralhealthworkerforawhile.”

� Lackofsustainedinterestandengagementinsuicidepreventionasapriority.Communitymembersdescribedthatturnoverintriballeadershipoftenmeanttheendofsuicidepreventioneffortsthatwerenolongerconsideredtobeapriority.InwesternAlaska,respondentssawcurrentvillageleadershipasahindrancetoprevention,andresponseandrecoveryefforts.Amemberofonecommunityexplainedthattriballeadershipwastooreactive.Whereasleadersprovidedsupportduringacrisis,theydidnotanticipateneeds,plan,orimplementupstreamapproachestoprevention.Anupstreamapproach,whichtypicallyinvolvescollaborativeassessment,planning,andimplementation,wouldaddresstheunderlyingrootsofproblems,oftenbyprovidingopportunitiesforculturallearningandconnectedness.Somesuggestedthatsomeleadersengagedinself-destructivebehaviorsresultinginhighturnoverinthetribaladministratorposition.Accordingtoonecommunitymember,thelackofleadershiphasbeenaprobleminonecommunityfor,“giveortakeaboutthepast10years.”Indifferenttribalcommunities,lackofleadershipcanbebothliteral(i.e.,vacanciesintribaladministrationduetoturnover)andfigurative(i.e.,lackofgreatercommitmentbytriballeadersrelatedtosuicideasapriority).

Page 24: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

24

Sourcesnotedthatoncefundingforasuicidepreventiongrantends,thepeopleinvolvedinanygivenprogramseekoutnewsourcesofemployment:“[Theythink]‘We’vedoneit,themoneyisgone,let’smoveontosomethingelsethatwecangetemploymentwith.’”Onesourceexplainedthathavingagrantisnoassurancethatatribewillmakesuicidepreventionapriority.Prioritieschangewithtribalelectionsandtheebbandflowofgrants:“Thegrantisgone,thepeoplearegone,thepeoplethatweretrainedaregone,andlet’smoveontosomethingelse.”FowlerandcolleaguesnotedsimilarbarriersintheirepidemiologicalinvestigationofayouthsuicideclusterinDelaware(2013).

Facil i t atorsCommunitymembersidentifiedfactorsthatfacilitatethepreventionofandresponsetosuicideclusters:familiarityandclosenessbetweenfamiliesandvillagesandculturallycongruentandpositivemessaging.Relatedtomessaging,onepersonshared,“Allofourfamilieswanttohearsomethingpositivewhenwe’refeelingdownandoutanddepressed[duringasuicideclusterevent].”

Tofacilitateresponse/recoveryefforts(andechoingCDC’srecommendations),respondentsdescribedtheimportanceofcoordinationamonglocalentities(e.g.,regionalhealthclinics,VPSOs,andcommunitymembers)andhavingsubstanceuseandmentalhealthservicesavailableinthecommunity.Whendescribingthebenefitsofcoordination,onerespondentshared,“YKHChasprovidedbehavioralhealthservicesafter2007andthey’regettingmorepeopleinvolved.”Anotherrespondentdescribedtheadvicehereceived:“Weshouldnotkeepthisbigissuetoourselves,buttrytogetmorepeopleinvolvedattheregionalandstatelevel.”

Respondentsreflectedontheircommunities’growthasaresultofrespondingtoandrecoveringfromsuicides.Indoingso,theyidentifiedspiritualityasakeyassetintherecoveryprocess.Onerespondentdescribedgatheringsafterasuicide:“Theyhavemeetingsattheirpersonalhouse…totrytohelpourcommunityintimesoftragicmoments,likesuicides.Theydoitspirituallybysinging.…Thegroupgetsbiggerandbigger,sothegathering[isaccepted]andIdon’tseeanythingwrongwiththat.”Anotherrespondentdescribed:“I’venoticedourcommunityhasgrownalotmorespiritually.”

Facilitators of Suicide Cluster Prevention and Response/Recovery

• Familiarity and closeness between families and villages

• Culturally congruent and positive messaging

• Coordination between local, regional, and state-based health service providers

• Availability of subregional behavioral and mental health services

• Increased communication about suicide

• Coordination between community-based and external prevention programs

• Availability of cultural activities

• Support from the tribal council

Page 25: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

25

IntheNewMexicocommunity,oneofthemostsignificantfacilitatorsspurringrecoverywasthewillingnessofthetribalcounciltodeclareastateofemergencytosecureneededresourcesforthecommunity.Thetribalcouncilalsosentleaderstoeverydepartmentheadtoensurepresenceandrepresentationattribalmeetingswherethesuicideclusterwasdiscussed.

Respondentsidentified(1)increasedcommunicationaboutsuicideand(2)increasedwillingnesstotalkaboutpersonalproblemsingeneral,ascharacteristicsthatstrengthensuicidepreventionefforts.Onecommunitymemberreflected,“Thebiggesthelpisgettingthemessageout.”Communicationisstillamajorproblem,yetrespondentsnotethattherehavebeeninroads.Onerespondentcommented,“YouthinkEskimosdon’ttalkabouttheirproblemsalot,butinthesefewyearsthingsarestartingtochange,peoplearestartingtotalkmore.”

Respondentsdescribedtheimportanceofintegratingculturalactivitiesintothevillagelifetokeepyouthengagedandtospreadsuicidepreventionmessages.Examplesofsuchactivitiesincludedbeading,makingharpoons,makingparkasandmukluks(furboots),pickingberries,goingoncampingtrips,andtakingnaturewalks.Theseactivitiesservedasanopportunityforcommunitymembersandyouthtotalkaboutsuicideaswellasreestablishtiestoculturaltraditions.Onecommunitymemberreflected,“TherewasasuicideinAugustandthatwasaboutthetimethattheywerehavingtheannualtundrafestival.…Theybroughtupthesubjectofsuicideduringthefestival,whichwasgood.”Communitymembersfromsurroundingvillagesattendedsomeofthelargerevents,therebyincreasingthepotentialtospreadsuicidepreventionmessages.

Withtherecognitionthatschoolsareanidealsettingforreachingyouth,thecommunitieshaveworkedwiththeschoolstoformallyintegrateculturalprogramming,includingNativelanguageclasses,Nativestudies,andtraditionalartsandcrafts,intotheschoolcurriculum.

Onecommunityidentifiedlawenforcementasapotentialresourceandfacilitatorofprevention.Asthefirstresponderstoeveryattemptanddeathbysuicide,officershaveawealthofservice/calldataonfactorsthatcaninformprevention.Onerespondentnoted,“Theyrecordtonsofinformationabouttheactualeventitself.Sotheyhavealotofreallyricheventleveldataintermsofsay,demographicinformation.”Theyaddedthatlawenforcementknowswhetherdrugsoralcoholwereinvolvedandtheycollecthistoricalinformationfromfamilymembers.Thisinformationcouldbeusedtoidentifypatternsinideation,attempts,anddeathsbysuicide,tobetteridentifyat-riskyouthandfamilies.

CommunityRecommendationstoEnhanceSuicideClusterPreventionandResponseRecommendationstoenhancesuicideclusterpreventionandresponsearesummarizedbelow.

PrioritizeCollaborativeandCulturally-basedSui cidePreventionEfforts Prioritizingsuicidepreventionandrelatedactivitieswasastrongthemeacrosscommunities.Communitymemberssuggestedthatprogressrelatedtosuicideprevention—suchasthedegreeof

Page 26: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

26

communityemphasisandawarenessaboutriskfactorsforsuicide—seemedtoebbandflowbasedonthefundingforpreventionprogramsandcurrenttriballeadershippriorities.Whileadvocatingthatsuicidepreventionshouldbeaconsistentprioritywithinthetriballeadership,onesourcenoted,

“Weneedmoreleadershipactivitiestoinspireyouthtochangetheirlifecourse.SometimesIthinkourcommunityforgetsthatatribe’slegacyrestsinitschildrenandnotinhowwelltribalenterprisesoperate.”

Participantssuggestedthatthereisacriticalneedtoeducatecommunitymembersabouttherisksforsuicideandtobuildawarenessofprogramsandresourcesforsuicideprevention.Communitymembersreflectedthateducationandawarenessbuildingareimportanttoaddresstheshamesurroundingsuicidethatpreventshelp-seeking.Onepersonsaid,“It’stimetobreakthesilenceandtotallybustthattaboo.That’smyfirmbelief.Andeducateyoungkids,youth,andyoungadults.”

Communitymembersunderscoredtheimportanceofinvolvingyouthinpreventionefforts.OnecommunitymemberwhoattendedastatewideyouthleadershipsummitinAnchoragewithayoungpersonfromhercommunitysuggestedthatyoungpeopleneedmanymoresuchopportunities,sothattheycould“getideasonhowtousetheirthinkingcaps.”Othersstressedtheimportanceofinvolvingyouthinpreventionplanning.Avillagernoted,“IftheywouldinvolvetheyouthNaturalHelpersandstudentcouncil,iftheywouldinvitethatgrouptothemeeting,Ithinkitwouldbehelpfulbecausethoseyouthwouldhelpbringouttheawarenesstotheotherstudents.”Anotherdescribedthevalueofinvolvingyouth,“[Thisis]thefirsttimethatthecommunityactuallyaskedtheyouth.Ithinkthisisgoingtogoalongway.”Anotherrespondentdescribedanapproachtoconductingsuicidepreventionpresentationsforyouth:

“ItriedtogothrougheveryscenarioIcould[asto]whykidscommittedsuicideovertheyears,theonesthatstoodoutandwhykidsmighthavedonethis…[I]reiteratetothekidsiftheyseetheirfamilyorfriendsinsuicidalmode,nottoleavethemandseekfurtherhelpandnottofeellikeatattletaleaboutaskingformorehelp…Iaskthemtolookoutforoneanotherandnotfeellikeatattletaleiftheirfamilyorfriendisfeelingsuicidal.”

Moregenerally,severalrespondentsvoicedaneedforcommunitymemberstocometogetherandworkcooperativelyforthebenefitoftheyouth.Asonerespondentsaid,“Communityleadersandtheeldersareneededtocometogethertoassistandhelptheyoungpeoplesothatsuicidecanbeprevented.”Forsome,thisinvolvesstrengtheningleadershipandcommunicationchannels.Asonecommunitymembersaid,“Weneedmorerichleadershipinvolvementandcommunications,everybodycommunicatingmore.”Another,too,sawtheneedforleadershiptostepup:“Iguessit’sthepolicymakersthathavetodotheirpartintryingtohelp,alsoassistinsolvingtheproblemsinthecommunity,alongwiththeresourcesthatareavailablethatarewillingtohelpasawhole.”Inpart,thiswasseenasanissueoftribalself-determination:“Thecommunitymustcometogetherandacknowledgetheircapabilitiesandstrengthstosolveproblemsrelatingtosomethingsthatneedtobeaddressed,likeviolence.”Villagerespondentshadclearrecommendationsaboutwhichcommunitymembersshouldcometogetherandbeinvolvedincommunitywideplanningforsuicideclusterpreventionandresponse.Oneperson

Page 27: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

Respondent Recommendations

• Prioritize collaborative, culturally-based suicide prevention

• Improve behavioral health services

• Develop community youth centers

• Improve surveillance

suggested,“Wewouldneedourtribalcouncil,ourschool,publicsafety,andourcommunities,Ithinkthatthat’sallweneedtomakeoursuicidepreventionplan,anditwouldworkfinethatwaywithlotsofcommunicationwitheachother.”

Communitymembersrepeatedlyemphasizedtheimportanceofensuringthatsuicidepreventionprogramsbedevelopedandimplementedwithaclearunderstandingofthespecificculturalcontextofagiventribalcommunity.Forexample,oneparticipantnoted,“Theconstructofdeathanddying[is]reallydifferentinNativecommunitiesversusmainstream.”Anothersourcefromthesamecommunitynotedthathiscommunitydidnotspeakofdeathanddyingand,thus,effortmustbemadetocollaboratewithandengagetriballeadershipandeldersindevelopingsuicidepreventionapproachesthatcouldbesuccessfulinthisculturalcontext.

IncreaseAccesstoBehavioral Healt hServicesCommunitymembersadvocatedforexpandedaccesstobehavioralhealthservices,includingincreasingtheavailabilityofbehavioralhealthworkers,programs,andservices,andbuildingawarenessofsuchprograms.Onerespondentexplained,“Weneedtobeidentifyingwhere[youth]cango,[whoyouth]cantalkto…orjustgotoaplacewhereyoucantalkto[someone]whoyoutrustcanbehelpfulorabenefitforyouforcalmingyourself.”Inthevillages,somesuggestedthatthesolutionmaybetoensurethatthereisaBHAineveryvillage.Overall,participantsprovidedmixedresponsesregardingwhethertheBHAneedstobesomeonewhoisacommunitymember.Whilesomesuggestedthiswasnotnecessary,otherssuggestedthatitiscriticalforbehavioralhealthservicestobeprovidedwithaclearunderstandingofcommunityvaluesandculture;thus,itwouldbeusefulandimportantfortheBHAtocontinuetobesomeoneinthecommunity.Thechallenge,onerespondentsaid,isthatconfidentialitycanbehardtomaintain:

“Itdoesn’thavetobesomeoneweknowbecausesomepeopleare—Idon’tknowhowtocomeupforawordforit,buttheydon’treallytrustthatworkerandtheydon’twanttogoovertothemandtalktothembecausetheyknowthem,youknowwhatImean?”

Inthetribalcommunity,participantssuggestedthathavingmorefull-timebehavioralhealthintheschoolsandcommunitywouldpromotesuicidepreventionasapriority.Onesourcenotedthatgreaterawarenessandcooperationisneeded,andrecommended“helpingthementalhealthclinicbecomefullystaffed,gettingfasterhiringapprovalfortheseclinicians,andensuringfasterMedicaidapprovalforpersonsreferredtoresidentialtreatmentcenters.”

DevelopCommunityYouthCentersInthewesternAlaskacommunityonly,participantsindicatedtheneedforanindoorcentralgatheringspaceorhallwhereyouthandcommunitymemberscouldmeetandholdeventsororganizeactivities.Indoorspaceforsuch

27

Page 28: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

28

activities,especiallyhighlyvaluedduringthelongwintermonths,isseverelylimitedacrosscommunities.Forexample,inonecommunity,youthactivitiesthatarenotschool-relatedareusuallyorganizedinthecommunity’slaundromat,acrampedandcrowdedspaceill-suitedforyouthevents.Onerespondentexplained,

“Ifthecommunityhadacommunityhallwherewecouldholdthesuicidepreventiongatherings,everythingwouldbemuchmoreaccessibleandreasonable,justbecauseespeciallyduringthelongwinterdays…thecommunitytendstogetboredandbecausethere’snotreallyanyotherthingstodo….There’sjustnothingtodoforyouthunlessschoolstartsandyougotoschool.”

Improve SurveillanceSomecommunitymemberssuggestedtheadoptionofmandatorysurveillanceortrackingsystemstohelpthecommunityunderstandthenatureoftheproblemandhowtobestaddresstheproblem.TheWhiteMountainApachesurveillancesystem—anationallyrecognizedsurveillancesystem—wasidentifiedbyaNewMexicotribecommunitymemberasamodeltobeemulated.TheWhiteMountainApacheTribeimplementedacommunity-basedSuicideandSelf-injuryReportingSystem.Thetribemandatesreportingofallknownincidenceofsuicideideationsorattemptsordeathsbysuicideaswellasotherintentionalself-injury(e.g.,cutting)andlife-threateningincidencesinvolvingdrugoralcoholintoxication(IHS,2013).Thiscommunitymemberwentontoexplainthat,whilesomecommunitymembershaveadvocatedforthistypeofsurveillancesystem,noformalsystemhasbeeninstitutedorsupportedbythetribalcouncil.

DISCUSSIONThetragedyofyouthsuicideandyouthsuicideclustersinindigenouscommunitiescontinuestobeacriticalpublichealthissue,addingnewlayersoftraumaincommunitiesalreadylivingwiththeimpactofhistoricaltrauma.Informationgatheredinthisreportshedssomelightonbarriersandfacilitatorstoprevention,neededresources,andstrength-basedapproachestoprevention,response,andrecovery.Basedoninformationguidingthisreport,thekeybarrierstoprogressinthesecommunitiesincludethefollowing.

InsufficientCommunityandClinicalBehavioralHealthResourcesNumeroussuicidepreventionprogramshavebeenimplementedacrosstribalcommunities.InSeptember2012,10of23grantsawardedbytheU.S.FederalGovernmenttopreventyouthsuicideswereawardedtoNA/ANtribesororganizations(Woodward,2012).Suchprogramsreachonlyasmallproportionofthecommunitiesthatcouldbenefitfromtheirassistance.Interviewparticipantsrecognizethattherehavebeeninroadsinaddressingtheproblemofyouthsuicideclustersandmanysuicidepreventionprogramshavebeenusefultocommunities.However,thesestakeholderssuggestthatprogresshasbeeninsufficienttoaddressthemagnitudeandcomplexityoftheproblemoryieldsustainable,lastingchange.Interviewparticipantsnote2–3yearsisnotlongenoughtoestablish

Page 29: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

29

sustainablechange.Examplesoflastingchangemayincludechangeincommunityreadinesstoaddresstheproblemofsuicide;changeincapacityorabilitytoidentifyandreferayouthforsuicide;moreservicesorinfrastructuretorespondtoyouthincrisis;orexpansionoftelebehavioralhealthcapabilities(e.g.,phoneandinternetcapabilities).

Inaddition,manysuggestthatIHSischronicallyunderfunded(Dorgan,2010;USET,2014),resultinginahostofhealthcaredeliveryproblems.Theseincludevacanciesinbehavioralhealthcareproviderpositions;insufficientbehavioralhealthcarespecialists;referralsforservicesgreatdistancesoffreservationsoroutofvillagesthatareoftencostly;andcomplicatedregionalofficeadministrativestructuresthatmayinhibitcreativesolutions(e.g.,Belluck,2009;Dorgan,2010;Young,2010).Somesuggestthatthecombinedeffectis“full-scalerationingofcriticalhealthservices,includingmentalhealthcareservices”(Dorgan,2010,p.215)inAI/ANcommunities.Communitymembersattesttothesignificantissueofaccessandadequacyofhealthcare,particularlyinruralorremotetribalcommunities.Suchcommunitiesareoftenbasedhundredsofmilesfromanurbanarea,makingadequatecareandoutreachtoNativeyouthproblematic.Thesedividescanalsomakeitdifficulttorecruitsufficientbehavioralhealthsupportstaff.Finally,emergencyhealthservices,suchasthoseneededtorespondtosuicideattempts,suicideclusters,orotherviolentdeaths,canbeespeciallydifficult.Transportationtoandfromruralareascanbechallengingbecauseofweatherorterrainandexpensivebecauseofdistance—bothconditionsmakingtimelyemergencyhealthservicesuncertain.

InsufficientCulturalTailoringinSuicidePreventionSomesuggestthatwidelyusedapproachestosuicidepreventionmaynotappropriatelyorsufficientlyreflectanunderstandingthat“suicideinindigenouscommunitiesisfrequentlyidentifiedastheterminaloutcomeofhistoricaloppression,currentinjustice,andongoingsocialsuffering”(Wexler&Gone,2012,p.801).AccordingtoaliteraturereviewbytheResearchPrioritizationTaskForceoftheNationalActionAllianceforSuicidePrevention,modelsofsuicidalbehaviorhaveevolvedoverthepast25years,butmanyarepsychologicallybasedandassumesometypeofcognitivedysfunctioninthesuicidalprocess(ActionAlliance,2014).Sometribalexpertssuggestthattheassumptionofcognitivedysfunctionastheprimarysymptomforsuicidepreventioneffortsisflawed.Theassumptionisculturallyincongruentforindigenouscommunities,inwhichsuicidemaybemoreappropriatelyframedasawayofexpressingsocialdistressanddespair(Wexler&Gone,2012).Inaddition,localizedresponsestoyouthincrisisareneededtoensureculturallycongruentapproachestosupportyoungpeople.Forexample,bestpracticesuggeststhatsuicidepreventionprogramsthatusesuicideriskscreeningsshouldhavecommunity-basedservicestoaddresstheneedsofidentifiedat-riskyouth.However,forruralandremotecommunities,supportforyouthincrisisoftenrequiresthattheyouthleavethevillageortribefortreatment.Thisapproachmayhavedevastatingeffectsattheindividual,family,andcommunitylevels,asyouthareremovedfromsettingsandpeoplethatprovideprotectivesocialrelationships.

Historicaltraumahasbeendescribedasrootedinalongandpresenthistoryinthatthecumulativeculturalstressesareunresolved.Ithasbeensuggestedthat“withoutresolution,indigenouspeoplecanbeseenassometimesmisattributingtheirpresentstrugglestopersonalandcollectivefailingsratherthantooppressivesystemsandstructures...[which]leavessomeAI/ANpeoplewithapervasivesense

Page 30: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

30

There are more than 560 federally recognized AI/AN tribal groups. Of these, 231 are in Alaska. These tribal groups have different social structures, individual and gender expectations, support systems, and conceptualizations of death (Novins, Beals, Roberts & Manson, 1999; Olson & Wahab, 2006). Support provided to AI/AN communities must be guided and informed by each unique cultural and geographic context.

ofhavingnofuture,asentimentthatcanbestronglylinkedtosuicide.”(Wexler&Gone,2012,p.802).Thisviewisconsistentwithonecommunitymember’ssuggestionthathopelessness,incombinationwithshamesurroundingdiscussionofsuicide,preventsNativeyouthfromseekingbehavioralhealthcare:“Theyfeelsohopeless,there’snohope...There’snotomorrows.”Thus,preventionandresponsestohigh-riskyouththatdon’tcontributetoongoingtraumaareessential.

LackofBasicStepsandConsistentSupportTiedtotheissuesnotedabove,theinterviewssuggestedthatlimitedprogresshasbeenmadetoformalizepreventionandresponsetosuicideclusters.Forexample,CDCrecommendsthatasanelementalfirststep,communitiesmustdevelopaplantopreventandcontainsuicideclusters(CDC,1988).Noneoftheclustersettingsinthisreporthadaformalcommunitypreventionorresponseplanpriortotheclusterevents.However,eachofthecommunitiesiscurrentlycollaboratingwithfederalandregionalpartnerstodevelopalocalcommunityplan,whichmayhelptoensureculturallycongruentpreventionandresponse.Lookingforward,otherAI/ANcommunitieswillneedconsistentsupportandpartnershipstodeveloptheirowncommunityplansforsuicideclusterpreventionandresponse.

RECOMMENDATIONSThefollowingrecommendationsareinformedbyinterviewswithAI/ANcommunitymembersaswellasliteratureonbestpracticesforpreventingandrespondingtosuicideclusters,including“CDC’sRecommendationsforaCommunityPlanforthePreventionandContainmentofSuicideClusters”(CDC,1988).Theserecommendationsareintendedprimarilyforlocal,state,andfederalagenciesandorganizationsthatmaycollaboratewithAI/ANcommunitiesindevelopingsuicideclusterpreventionandresponseplans,orassistingduringaclusterevent.Additionalrecommendationsandsupportsfortribalcommunitiesfollow.

� PartnerWithAI/ANCommunitiestoDevelopCulturallySpecificCommunityPlans.Manytribalcommunities,includingthecommunitiesinterviewedforthisreport,mayneedassistanceindevelopingcommunityplansforsuicideclusterpreventionandresponse.Foreffectiveplandevelopmentandimplementation,communitiesneedtechnicalassistancetosupportthefollowingcomponentsofplandevelopment:culturallycompetentneedsandresourceassessment,prioritymapping,coalitiondevelopment,identificationoflocallytailoredstrategies,andintegrationoftheplanwithinthecommunity’scurrentinfrastructure.Assuggestedbyinterviewparticipantsandresearchers(Wexler&Gone,2012)andrecommendedbyCDC(1988),communitypreventionandresponseplansforsuicideclustersmustbeadaptedtotheparticularneeds,resources,

Page 31: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

31

andculturalcharacteristicsofthecommunity.ThisisparticularlyrelevantforAI/ANcommunities,giventheresources,diverseculturalcontextsacrosstribalcommunities,andhistoricaltraumadiscussedabove.Attheinvitationoftribalcommunities,local,state,andfederalpartnerswiththisexpertiseshouldcollaboratewithAI/ANpopulations,andbuildingoncommunitystrengths,providetechnicalassistancetohelpthecommunitydevelopaplanthatreflectsitsowntraditionsandculture.

� SupportResearchtoImproveUnderstandingofSuicideClustersinAI/ANCommunities.ThefindingsinthisreportareconsistentwithrecommendationsfromtheResearchPrioritizationTaskForceoftheNationalActionAllianceforSuicidePrevention.Inparticular,therecommendationscallforresearchthatfocusesonunderstudied,hard-to-reach,and/orhigh-riskcommunitiesandcaresettings,includingAI/ANruralsettings.Additionalrecommendationsincludeafocusonstudiesdesignedtoimproveunderstandingaboutsuicidemitigationstrategiesandhowtosustainprogressthatreducessuiciderisk(ActionAlliance,2014).SincesomeAI/ANcommunitiessufferhighersuicideburdenthanothers—includingfrequentyouthsuicideclusters—researchisneededtounderstandthedifferencesbetweenthesecommunities,especiallystrength-basedfactorsthatmaytranslatetoothercommunities.Thefindingsinthisreportalsosuggesttheneedforresearchexaminingtheparticularmechanismsofsuicideclusters,whicharenotwellunderstoodwithinanypopulation.Suchresearchmayresultinmodelsthatbetterexplaincontagion,resilience,andprotectivesocialconnectionswithinAI/ANcommunities.

� SupporttheDevelopmentandEnhancementofSurveillanceSystems.Communitymembersandothershavepointedtotheneedfordataonthementalhealthoftribalcommunitiesandtheprevalenceofsuicideclustersingeneral,toinformprevention(Dorgan,2010).Thedearthofdatapresentsaseriousbarriertounderstandingthecontextualissuesandkeyvariablesthatmayinfluencesuicideclustersandinformclusterpreventionandresponseplanning.Emergingsurveillancesystems(suchasthosesupportedthroughtheSAMHSA’sNativeConnectionsgrantprogram[SAMHSARequestforApplicationsSM-14-013])maybeusefultolocal,state,andfederalpartnersinimprovingunderstandingaboutAI/ANsubpopulationswithparticularlyhighsuicideratesandrelatedneeds.

� EnsureanInclusiveandCoordinatedPlanningProcessInvolvingMultipleCommunitySectors.Local,state,federalagenciesandothersthatpartnerwithAI/ANcommunitiesshouldconsiderCDC’srecommendationforinclusionacrossallsectorsofthecommunity(e.g.,publichealth,behavioralhealth,education,parents,communitymembers,etc.)inplanningandimplementingsuicideclusterpreventionandresponseefforts(1988).Communitymembersinthisreporthadclearideasaboutwhomshouldbeincluded.Oneintervieweesuggested,“Wewouldneedourtribalcouncil,ourschool,publicsafety,andourcommunities,Ithinkthatthat’sallweneedtomakeoursuicidepreventionplan,anditwouldworkfinethatwaywithlotsofcommunicationwitheachother.”Moreover,CDCguidanceurgesthat“Everyeffortshouldbemadetopromoteandimplementtheproposedplanasacommunityendeavor…nosingleagency…hastheresourcesorexpertisetoadequatelyrespondtoanevolvingsuicidecluster”(CDC,1988,p.3).

Page 32: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

32

Lackofadvancedcoordinationmayresultindelayedelementsoftheresponsemaybedelayedoropportunitiesforpreventionmissed.Thus,itiscriticalforallrelevantlocallybasedparticipants,programs,andexternalpartners(e.g.,local,state,orfederalagencies,organizations,oruniversities)tohaveaclearsenseoftheirrespectiverolesandresponsibilitiesinadvance.Inaddition,regularcommunicationamongpartners(e.g.,thelocalcommunityandoutsidepartners)shouldoccursothatallpartnersarekeptapprisedofthestatusofavailableresources,plans,andprotocols.Effectivesuicidepreventionrequiresasustainedandcoordinatedresponse.Partnersmustcommittoandorganizethemselvesinsuchawaythatensuresongoingcoordinationofeffortsandthatsuicidepreventionremainsapriority.

� PartnerWithAI/ANCommunitiestoImproveYouthScreening.Screeningcanidentifyindividualsearlyinasuicidetrajectory,beforeasuicideattemptorsuicideoccurs.Suicidalthoughtsinyouthdonotincreaseasaresultofsuchscreening(Gouldetal.,2005).Individualsatheightenedriskforsuicideshouldbeidentifiedandscreened,andtheliteratureisclearthatpeoplewhohavepreviouslyattemptedsuicideandthosewhohavelostafamilymemberorfriendtosuicideareatheightenedrisk.Qualifiedbehavioralhealthcareprofessionalsshouldoverseethescreeningprocessandconductinterviewstodeterminelevelofriskforallyouthwhoscreenpositiveontheinitialscreen(SPRC,n.d.).Tribesandvillageswithfewavailableprovidersmayrequiresupportinidentifyingprofessionalstooverseetheprocess.Similarly,beforethescreeningbegins,thecommunityneedstoensure(1)thatresponseprotocolsforyouthincrisisarewellestablishedand(2)thatappropriatelytrainedbehavioralhealthprovidersareavailableforyouthwhoscreenpositiveandrequirefollowup(SPRC,n.d.).Ruralandfrontiertribalcommunitiesmayneedtoreachouttolocal,state,orfederalpartnerstocollaborateinfindingavailableproviders.Coordinatingfollow-upservicesforyouthat-riskorincrisisiscritical.

� PromoteYouthEmploymentandEngagement.Toaddressriskfactorsrelatedtoyouthboredomand“lackofthingstodo,”particularlyaftergraduatinghighschool,programsaimedatpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentshouldincludeopportunitiesforemployment—particularlygivenhighunemploymentratesinruraltribalcommunitiesandtheneedforeconomicdevelopment.Researchersfindthatworkandjobsatisfactionaresecondonlytopersonalrelationshipsindeterminingqualityoflife.Basedonsuchfindings,employmentcancontributetoamorefulfillinglife,particularlygivenitspositiveimpactonidentity,socialsupport,purpose,andchallenge(Linley,2004;Snyderetal.,2011).Foryouthwhoarestillinschool,somecommunitymemberstalkedabouttheneedforacommunity/recreationalcenterasahealthyplacetohangout.Communitymembershavealsostressedtheimportanceofengagingyouthandinvolvingtheminpreventionplanning.Anothercommunitymembernoted,“IftheywouldinvolvetheyouthNaturalHelpersandstudentcouncil,iftheywouldinvitethatgrouptothemeeting,Ithinkitwouldbehelpfulbecausethoseyouthwouldhelpbringouttheawarenesstotheotherstudents.”

� IncreaseAvailabilityofandEnhanceBehavioralHealthServices.Asdescribedinthisreport,theavailabilityofbehavioralhealthcareserviceshasimprovedinruraltribalcommunitiesinthe

Page 33: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

33

lastdecade—particularlyinremoteAlaskanvillages—withtheadventoftheBHAprogram,travelingclinicalcounselors,andtelebehavioralhealthcapabilities.InAlaska,theseadvancesmayhaveresultedinanincreaseintheuseofmentalhealthservices.AccordingtotheStateofAlaska's“CastingtheNet”reportfocusedonsuicideprevention,thenumberofAlaskanswhoreceivedmentalhealthservicesgrew17percentbetweenFiscalYears2009and2011.ThenumberofAlaskanswhoreceivedsubstanceusedisordertreatmentalsogrew5.7percentduringthisperiod.WhiletheincreaseinthenumberofAlaskansseekingtreatmentandrecoveryservicesispromising,theresourcesavailabletothebehavioralhealthsystemareunchanged(CTN,2013).Despiteprogressinsomecommunities,behavioralhealthcareisstilllargelyunavailableorinsufficientformanyruralandfrontiertribalcommunities.

� UpdateNationalRecommendationsfortheDevelopmentofaLocalCommunityPlantoPrevent,Contain,andRespondtoSuicideClusters.WhileCDC’s“RecommendationsforaCommunityPlanforthePreventionandContainmentofSuicideClusters”(1988)isaseminalresource,updatingittoincluderesearchfindingsandlessonslearnedoverthelast25+yearswouldbeofimmensebenefittothefield.Attentionmustbegiventouniquecharacteristicsofsuicideclustersindiversecommunitiesandpopulations,especiallyamongAI/ANyouth.

LookingForwardTribalcommunitiescanbenefitfromdevelopingandimplementingcommunityplanstopreventandrespondtosuicideclusters.However,strongandgenuinebarrierstoplandevelopmentexist,suchasculturaltaboosaroundtalkingaboutdeathorsuicide;shameaboutseekingmentalhealthtreatment;suicideandmentalhealthnotbeingcommunitypriorities;andinadequateformalresources/structuresfordevelopingtheplan(e.g.,vacanciesincrucialtribalagenciessuchaseducation,mentalhealth,localgovernment;orlackofbehavioralhealthandcrisisservices).Throughsupportofferedbyarangeoffederalprograms,includingSAMHSA’sTribalTrainingandTechnicalAssistanceCenterandSuicidePreventionResourceCenter,tribesandvillagescanaccessbestpracticesonplandevelopmentandhowtobuildaninfrastructureforcommunitysuicideprevention.

Inaddition,SAMHSA’sSuicidePreventionBranchoverseestheGarrettLeeSmithYouthSuicidePreventionandEarlyInterventionProgram,a5-yeargrantprogramintendedtosupporttribesandstatesinimplementingcomprehensivesuicidepreventionprogramsgroundedinpublic/privatepartnership.Theprogramsprovidesupporttotribes(andstates)toimplementprogramsthatincludecoordinationacrossyouth-servingorganizationstoexpandthecapacitytoidentify,refer,andserveyouthincrisisandatriskforsuicide.Inpart,thesegrantsareintendedtoensurecontinuityofcareforyouthatriskforsuicide.Inaddition,thesefundscanbeusedtoimplementtrackingsystemstomonitorsuicideattemptsaswellasdeathsbysuicidetoidentifypatternsofriskandprioritizepreventionefforts.

In2014,SAMHSAreleasedanRFAforanewgrantprogram—NativeConnections—designedtosupportAI/ANgranteesintheireffortstoreducetheimpactofsubstancemisuse,mentalillness,andtraumaintheircommunitiesthroughapublichealthapproach.ThepurposeofthisprogramistopreventandreducesuicidalbehaviorandsubstanceabuseandpromotementalhealthamongAI/ANyoungpeople

Page 34: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

34

throughage24.These5-yearcooperativeagreementsaredesignedtoallowfortribalspecific-goalgenerationandplanningbasedonCommunityReadinessAssessments(CRAs)conductedannuallyacrossthelifespanoftheprogram.Tribes,workinginclosecollaborationwithSAMHSAandtheirTribalTrainingandTechnicalAssistanceCentercontractors,willdevelopandimplementplansspecifictotheircommunity’sneedsandreflectiveoftheircommunity’slevelofreadiness.

Thecommunityreadinessmodel(CRM)isanine-stagemodelthatassessesacommunity’slevelofreadinesstodevelopandimplementpreventionprograms.Themodelisaprogressiveassessmentofacommunity’sabilitytoimplementsystematicchangeofkeypublichealthissues.Acommunitycanincreaseanddecreasetheirreadinesslevelforanissuedependingupontheappropriatenessandstrengthoflocalefforts.TheCRMhasfivedimensionsthat,togetherwiththestages,provideacomprehensivecommunityassessmentandservesasaninformationguideastowhattypeoflocaleffortsisneededinwhicharea(Jumper-Thurmanetal.,2003).ThefivedimensionsareCommunityKnowledgeofEfforts,CommunityClimate,CommunityKnowledgeofIssue,Leadership,andResources.Eachdimensionreceivesacommunityreadinessscoreandeachcanbeatadifferentreadinesslevel.Thedimensionsarecorrelatedthereforeoneaspectofcommunityreadinessisnotusuallymorethantwostagesapartfromtheotherdimensions(Jumper-Thurmanetal.,2003).Thedimensionsarenotspecifictoculture;howevertheycanbeinterpretedwithinthecontextofthecultureofeachcommunity(Jumper-Thurmanetal.,2003).

Page 35: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

35

REFERENCESAlaskaBureauofVitalStatistics.(2013,September16).Alaskasuiciderates,2001–2011.Retrievedfromhttp://dhss.alaska.gov/dph/VitalStats/Pages/contacts/default.aspx

AlaskaCommunityHealthAideProgram.(n.d.).AbouttheAlaskaCommunityHealthAideprogram.RetrievedFebruary1,2014,fromhttp://www.akchap.org/html/about-chap.html

AlaskaDepartmentofPublicSafety.(n.d.).DivisionofAlaskastatetroopers.RetrievedFebruary1,2014,fromhttp://www.dps.state.ak.us/ast/

AlaskaNativeTribalHealthConsortium.(2005–2014).BehavioralHealthAide(BHA)program.RetrievedFebruary1,2014,fromhttp://www.anthc.org/chs/behavioral/bha.cfm

AlaskaStatewideSuicidePreventionCouncil(2013).Castingthenetupstream:Promotingwellnesstopreventsuicide,AlaskaStateSuicidePreventionPlan,2012-2017;Annualimplementationreport.Retrievedfromhttp://dhss.alaska.gov/SuicidePrevention/Documents/pdfs/CTN_Implementation_Report_2013.pdf

AlakanukCommunityPlanningGroup,etal.(2009).Qungasviktoolbox:AtoolboxforpromotingyouthsobrietyandreasonsforlivinginYup’ik/Cup’ikcommunities.Fairbanks,AK:UniversityofAlaskaFairbanks,CenterforAlaskaNativeHealthResearch.

AmericanFoundationforSuicidePrevention.(2014).Suicidestatistics.Retrievedfromhttp://afsp.org/about-suicide/suicide-statistics/

Askland,K.D.,Sonnenfeld,N.,Crosby,A.E.(2003).Apublichealthresponsetoaclusterofsuicidalbehaviors:Clinicalpsychiatry,prevention,andcommunityhealth.JournalofPsychiatricPractice,9,219–227.

Baldwin,J.A.,Brown,B.G.,Wayment,H.A.,Nez,R.A.,&Brelsford,K.M.(2011).Cultureandcontext:BufferingtherelationshipbetweenstressfullifeeventsandriskybehaviorsinAmericanIndianyouth.Substanceuse&misuse,46(11),1380–94.

Bechtold,D.(1988).ClustersuicideinAmericanIndianadolescents.AmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeMentalHealthResearch,1,26–35.

Belluck,P.(2009).NewhopesonhealthcareforAmericanIndians.NewYorkTimes.RetrievedMarch1,2014,fromhttp://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/02/health/02indian.html?pagewanted=all

Bender,E.(2006,June16).APA,AACAPsuggestwaystoreducehighsuicideratesinNativeAmericans.PsychiatricNews.Retrievedfromhttp://psychnews.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/pn.41.12.0006a

BigFoot,D.S.(2007).AmericanIndianyouth:Currentandhistoricaltrauma.OklahomaCity,OK:IndianCountryChildTraumaCenter.

Borowsky,I.W.,Ireland,M.,&Resnick,M.D.(2001).Adolescentsuicideattempts:Risksandprotectors.Pediatrics,107,485–93.

Page 36: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

36

Borowsky,I.W.,Resnick,M.D.,Ireland,M.,&Blum,R.W.(1999).SuicideattemptsamongAmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeyouth:Riskandprotectivefactors.ArchivesofPediatricandAdolescentMedicine,153,573–80.

BraveHeart,M.Y.H.(2003).ThehistoricaltraumaresponseamongNativesanditsrelationshiptosubstanceabuse:ALakotaillustration.JournalofPsychoactiveDrugs,35,7–13.doi:10.1080/02791072.2003.10399988

BraveHeart,M.,Chase,J.,Elkins,J.,&Altschul,D.B.(2011).HistoricaltraumaamongindigenouspeoplesoftheAmericas:Concepts,research,andclinicalconsiderations.JournalofPsychoactiveDrugs,43(4),282–290.doi:10.1080/02791072.2011.628913

BraveHeart,M.Y.H.(1999).OyatePtayela:RebuildingtheLakotaNationthroughaddressinghistoricaltraumaamongLakotaparents.JournalofHumanBehaviorandtheSocialEnvironment,2(1):109–126.

BraveHeart,M.Y.,&DeBruyn,L.M.(1998).TheAmericanIndianHolocaust:Healinghistoricalunresolvedgrief.AmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeMentalHealthResearch:JournaloftheNationalCenter,8(2),56–78.

CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(1988,August19).CDCrecommendationsforacommunityplanforthepreventionandcontainmentofsuicideclusters.MorbidityandMortalityWeeklyReport;37(S-6);1–12.

CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2009).Nationalsuicidestatisticsataglance.Atlanta,GA:NationalCenterforInjuryPreventionandControl.RetrievedApril22,2014,http://www.cdc.gov/ViolencePrevention/suicide/statistics/index.html

CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2010).Web-basedInjuryStatisticsQueryandReportingSystem(WISQARS).Fatalinjuryreports.Atlanta,GA:NationalCenterforInjuryPreventionandControl.RetrievedApril22,2014,fromhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.html

CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2010).YouthRiskBehaviorSurveillanceSystem(YRBS).Youthonlineinteractiondatatables.Atlanta,GA:NationalCenterforInjuryPreventionandControl.RetrievedApril22,2014,fromhttp://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/index.htm

Christman,S.K.(2012).AmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeyouthsuicide:Areviewoftheliterature.Unpublishedmaster’sthesis,UniversityofTexasatAustin,Austin,TX.

Cox,G.,Robinson,J.,Williamson,M.,Lockley,A.,Cheung,Y.,&Pirkis,J.(2012).Suicideclustersinyoungpeople:Evidencefortheeffectivenessofpostventionstrategies.Crisis,33(4),208–214.

DeMarban,A.(2010,October9).Alaskateensurgeparentalinvolvementatsuicidesummit.TheNewsMiner,Fairbanks,Alaska.RetrievedMarch1,2014,fromhttp://www.newsminer.com/news/alaska_news/alaska-teens-urge-parental-involvement-at-suicide-summit/article_5e4d5c18-76f7-5003-a286-0bb79779af42.html

DeMarban,A.(2012,May8).TragicwaveofsuicidesbatterremoteAlaskavillages.AlaskaDispatch.http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/tragic-wave-suicides-batter-remote-alaska-villages

Dorgan,B.(2010).ThetragedyofNativeAmericanyouthsuicide.PsychologicalServices,7(3),213–18.RetrievedMarch1,2014,fromhttp://centralsaamontana.org/otherdocuments/NativeYouthSuicide.pdf

Page 37: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

37

DrugCourtsProgramOffice.(1999).Healingtowellnesscourts:Apreliminaryoverviewoftribaldrugcourts.Washington,DC:U.S.DepartmentofJustice.Retrievedfromhttp://www.tribal-institute.org/download/heal.pdf

Duran,E.,&Duran,B.(1995).AmericanIndianpostcolonialpsychology.Albany,NY:StateUniversityofNewYork(SUNY)Press.

ERAAlaska.(2014).RetrievedJuly1,2014,fromhttp://www.flyera.com/

Evans-Campbell,T.,Walters,K.L.,Pearson,C.R.,&Campbell,C.D.(2012,September).Indianboardingschoolexperience,substanceuse,andmentalhealthamongurbantwo-spiritAmericanIndian/AlaskaNatives.AmericanJournalofDrugandAlcoholAbuse,38(5),421–427.doi:10.3109/00952990.2012.701358

FederalIndianLawforAlaskaTribesTerminationEra1950s,P.L.280.RetrievedJune16,2014,fromhttp://tm112.community.uaf.edu/unit-2/termination-era-1950s-public-law-280/

Felner,R.D.&Felner,T.Y.(1989).Primarypreventionprogramsintheeducationalcontext:Atransactional-ecologicalframeworkandanalysis.InL.A.Bond&B.E.Compas(Eds.),Primarypreventionandpromotionintheschools(pp.13–49).NewburyPark,CA:Sage.

FowlerK.A.,CrosbyA.E.,ParksS.E.,IveyA.Z.,SilvermanP.R.(2013).Epidemiologicalinvestigationofayouthsuicidecluster:Delaware.DelawareMedicalJournal,85:15-19.

Freedenthal,S.,&Stiffman,A.R.(2004).SuicidalbehaviorinurbanAmericanIndianadolescents:Acomparisonwithreservationyouthinasouthwesternstate.SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,34(2),160–171.

Evans-Campbell,T.,Walters,K.L.,Pearson,C.R.,&Campbell,C.D.(2012,September).Indianboardingschoolexperience,substanceuse,andmentalhealthamongurbantwo-spiritAmericanIndian/Alaskanatives.AmericanJournalofDrugandAlcoholAbuse,38(5),421-27.doi:10.3109/00952990.2012.701358

Garroutte,E.M.,Goldberg,J.,Beals,J.,Herrell,R.,Manson,S.M.,&theAI-SUPERPFPTeam.(2003).SpiritualityandattemptedsuicideamongAmericanIndians.SocialScience&Medicine,56,1571–79.

Goldston,D.B.,Molock,S.D.,Whitbeck,L.B.,Murakami,J.L.,Zayas,L.H.,&Hall,G.C.N.(2008).Culturalconsiderationsinadolescentsuicidepreventionandpsychosocialtreatment.AmericanPsychologist,63(1),14.

Gone,J.P.,&Alcántara,C.(2007).IdentifyingeffectivementalhealthinterventionsforAmericanIndiansandAlaskaNatives:Areviewoftheliterature.CulturalDiversityandEthnicMinorityPsychology,13(4),356.

Gould,M.S.(1990).Suicideclustersandmediaexposure.InS.J.Blumenthal&D.G.Kupfer(Eds.),Suicideoverthelifecycle:Riskfactors,assessmentandtreatmentofsuicidalpatients(pp.517–532).Washington,DC:AmericanPsychiatricPress.

Gould,M.S.(2001).Suicideandthemedia.InH.Hendin&J.J.Mann(Eds.),Suicideprevention:Clinicalandscientificaspects(AnnalsoftheNewYorkAcademyofSciences,pp.200–24).NewYork,NY:AcademyofSciences.

Page 38: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

38

Gould,M.,Jamieson,P.,&Romer,D.(2003).Mediacontagionandsuicideamongtheyoung.AmericanBehavioralScientist,46(9),1269–84.

Gould,M.S.,Kleinman,M.H.,Lake,A.M.,Forman,J.,&Midle,J.B.(2014).NewspapercoverageofsuicideandinitiationofsuicideclustersinteenagersintheUSA,1988–96:Aretrospective,population-based,case-controlstudy.LancetPsychiatry,7–16.

Gould,M.,&Kramer,R.(2010).Youthsuicideprevention.SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,31(s1),6–31.

Gould,M.S.,Marrocco,F.A.,Kleinman,M.,Thomas,J.G.,Mostkoff,K.,Cote,J.,&Davies,M.(2005).Evaluatingiatronicriskofyouthsuicidescreeningprograms.TheJournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,293(13),1635–1643.doi:10.1001/jama.293.13.1635.

Gould,M.S.,Petrie,K.,Kleinman,M.H.,&Wallenstein,S.(1994).Clusteringofattemptedsuicide:NewZealandnationaldata.InternationalJournalofEpidemiology,23,1185–1189.

Gould,M.S.,Wallenstein,S.,&Kleinman,M.(1987).Astudyoftime-spaceclusteringofsuicide(Finalreport).Atlanta,Georgia:CentersforDiseaseControl.

Hazel,P.(1993).Adolescentsuicideclusters:Evidence,mechanismsandprevention.AustralianandNewZealandJournalofPsychiatry,27,653–665.

Haw,C.,Hawton,K.,Niedzwiedz,C.,&Platt,S.(2013).Suicideclusters:Areviewofriskfactorsandmechanisms.SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,43(1),97–108.

Hopkins,K.(2010,July14).Suicides,attemptsspikeagaininWesternAlaskavillages.AnchorageDailyNews.RetrievedJuly1,2014,fromhttp://www.adn.com/2010/07/14/1367324/suicides-in-y-k-delta-take-toll.html

Hoxie,F.(1984).Afinalpromise:ThecampaigntoassimilatetheIndians,1880–1920.Lincoln:UniversityofNebraskaPress.

IndianCountryTodayMediaNetworkStaff.(2011,May,26).Oprah’sangelsaveslives:JeremiahSimmonsleadssuicidepreventionontheMescaleroApacheIndianReservations.IndianCountryTodayMediaNetwork.RetrievedJuly1,2014,fromhttp://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2011/05/26/oprahs-angel-saves-lives-jeremiah-simmons-leads-suicide-prevention-mescalero-apache

IHSContractor.(n.d.).Albuquerquearea.RetrievedJuly7,2014,fromhttp://www.ihscontractor.com/albuquerque-area.html

IndianHealthService.(n.d.).RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://www.ihs.gov/locations/

IndianHealthServices.(2013).TheWhiteMountainApacheModelforsuicideandself-injurysurveillanceandprevention:Innovationinpublichealth.TheIHSPrimaryCareProvider,38(1),1–17.

Johnson,J.L.,&Cameron,M.C.(2001).BarrierstoprovidingeffectivementalhealthservicestoAmericanIndians.MentalHealthServicesResearch,3(4),215–223.

Joiner,J.E.(1999).Theclusteringandcontagionofsuicide.CurrentDirectionsinPsychologicalScience(Wiley-Blackwell),8(3),89.

Page 39: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

39

Jumper-Thurman,P.,Edwards,R.W.,Plested,B.A.,&Oetting,E.R.(2003).Honoringthedifferences:Usingcommunityreadinesstocreateculturallyvalidcommunityinterventions.InG.Bernal,J.Trimble,K.Burlew,&F.Leong(Eds.),Handbookofracial&ethnicminoritypsychology(pp.591–607).ThousandOaks,CA:SagePublications.

KodiakAreaNativeAssociation(KANA).(n.d.)KANABehavioralHealthDepartment.RetrievedMay5,2014,fromhttp://www.kanaweb.org/html/health-programs/behavioral-health.php#MSPIhttp://www.kanaweb.org/html/health-programs/behavioral-health.php#MSPI

Kral,M.J.,Idlout,L.,Minore,J.B.,Dyck,R.J.,&Kirmayer,L.J.(2011).Unikkaartuit:meaningsofwell-being,unhappiness,health,anccommunitychangeamongInuitinNunavut,Canada.AmericanJournalofCommunityPsychology,48(3-4),426–438

LaFromboise,T.D.&BigFoot,D.S.(1988).CulturalandcognitiveconsiderationsinthepreventionofAmericanIndianadolescentsuicide.JournalofAdolescence,11(2):139–153.

Lahad,M.,&Cohen,A.(2006).Thecommunitystresspreventioncenter—25yearsofcommunitystresspreventionandintervention.KiryatShmona,Israel:TheCommunityStressPreventionCenter.

Linley,P.A.,&Joseph,S.(2004).PositivePsychologyinPractice.Hoboken,NJ:Wiley.

Napoleon,H.(19961).Yuuyaraq:Thewayofthehumanbeing.Fairbanks,Alaska:CenterforCrossCulturalStudiesUniversityofAlaskaFairbanks.

MayP.A.,SernaP.,HurtL.,&DeBruynL.M.(2005).OutcomeevaluationofapublichealthapproachtosuicidepreventioninanAmericanIndiantribalnation.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,95,1238–44.

Napoleon,H.(1961).Yuuyaraq:Thewayofthehumanbeing.Fairbanks,Alaska:CenterforCrossCulturalStudiesUniversityofAlaskaFairbanks.

NationalActionAllianceforSuicidePrevention.(2014).Aprioritizedresearchagendaforsuicideprevention:Anactionplantosavelives.Rockville,MD:NationalInstituteofMentalHealthandtheResearchPrioritizationTaskForce.

NationalCenterforHealthStatistics.(2011a).WISQARSTM:Leadingcausesofdeathreports,nationalandregional,1999-2011.Retrievedfromhttp://webappa.cdc.gov/sasweb/ncipc/leadcaus10_us.html

NationalCenterforHealthStatistics.(2011b).WISQARSTM:Fatalinjuryreports,nationalandregional,1999-2011.Retrievedfromhttp://webappa.cdc.gov/sasweb/ncipc/mortrate10_us.html

Niedzwiedz,C.,Haw,C.,Hawton,K.,&Platt,S.(2014).Thedefinitionandepidemiologyofclustersofsuicidalbehavior:Asystematicreview.SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,44(5),569–581.

Novins,D.K.,Beals,J.,Roberts,R.E.,&Manson,S.M.(1999).FactorsassociatedwithsuicideideationamongAmericanIndianadolescents:Doesculturematter?SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,29(4),332–346.

OfficeofSafeandDrug-FreeSchools.(2007).Practicalinformationoncrisisplanning:Aguideforschoolsandcommunities.Washington,D.C.;U.S.DepartmentofEducation.Fromhttp://www.ed.gov/admins/lead/safety/emergencyplan/crisisplanning.pdf

Olson,L.M.,&Wahab,S.(2006).AmericanIndiansandSuicide:Aneglectedareaofresearch.Trauma,Violence,&Abuse,7(1),19–33.

Page 40: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

40

Rezaeian,M.(2012).Suicideclusters:Introducinganoveltypeofcategorization.Violence&Victims,27(1),125–132.

Serna,P.(2011).AdolescentSuicidePreventionProgramManual.SuicidePreventionResourceCenter,EducationDevelopmentCenter,Inc.,Newton,MA.

Snyder,C.R.,Lopez,S.J.,&Pedrotti,J.T.(2011).PositivePsychology:Thescientificandpracticalexplorationsofhumanstrengths.ThousandOaks,CA:SagePublications.

Sotero,M.M.(2006).Aconceptualmodelofhistoricaltrauma:implicationsforpublichealthpracticeandresearch.JournalofHealthDisparitiesResearchandPractice,1(1),93–108.

Stockel,H.(2011).HistoricaltraumaamongtheApachesatMescalero.JournaloftheWest,50(2),75–82.

SuicidePreventionResourceCenter.(n.d.).Recommendationsforschool-basedsuicidepreventionscreening.Retrievedfromhttp://www.sprc.org/sites/sprc.org/files/library/Recommendations%20for%20School-Based%20Suicide%20Prevention%20Screening.pdf

Trudeau,M.(2009).Mediashouldtreadcarefullyincoveringsuicide.NationalPublicRadio.RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=120755264

U.S.CensusBureau:StateandCountyQuickFacts.(2013)DataderivedfromPopulationEstimates,AmericanCommunitySurvey,CensusofPopulationandHousing,StateandCountyHousingUnitEstimates,CountyBusinessPatterns,NonemployerStatistics,EconomicCensus,SurveyofBusinessOwners,BuildingPermits.RetrievedFebruary13,2014,fromhttp://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/02/02270.htmlandhttp://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/02/02050.html

U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices(HHS)OfficeoftheSurgeonGeneralandNationalActionAllianceforSuicidePrevention.2012NationalStrategyforSuicidePrevention:GoalsandObjectivesforAction.Washington,DC:HHS.

UnitedSouthandEasternTribes,Inc.(2014).TestimonyofUnitedSouthandEasternTribessubmittedtoSenateCommitteeonIndianAffairsregardingS.1570,toauthorizeadvanceappropriationsfortheIndianHealthService.RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://www.usetinc.org/wp-content/uploads/Pdf_Documents/LegPolicy/USET%20Testimony%20to%20SCIA%20on%20Advance%20Appropriations%20for%20IHS%20April%202%202014.pdf

VanHecke,S.(2012).Behavioralhealthaides:Apromisingpracticeforfrontiercommunities.SilverCity,NM:NationalCenterforFrontierCommunities.

Weekley,N.,&Brock,S.E.(2004).Suicide:Postventionstrategiesforschoolpersonnel.NationalAssociationofSchoolPsychologists.RetrievedMay1,2014,fromwww.nasponline.org/resources/intonline/HCHS2_weekley.pdf

Wexler,L.M,&Gone,J.P.(2012).Culturallyresponsivesuicidepreventioninindigenouscommunities:Unexaminedassumptionsandnewpossibilities.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,102(5),800–806.

Wexler,L.,Hill,R.,Bertone-Johnson,E.,&Fenaughty,A.(2008).CorrelatesofAlaskaNativefatalandnonfatalsuicidalbehaviors1990–2001.SuicideandLife-ThreateningBehavior,38(3),311–320.

Page 41: I N TR OD U C TI ON - Ce4less · I N TR OD U C TI ON Between 2009 and 2011, two tribal communities located approximately 3,000 miles apart—an American Indian tribe on a reservation

Wissow,L.,Walkup,J.,Barlow,A.,Reid,R.,&Kane,S.(2001).ClusterandregionalinfluencesonsuicideinaSouthwesternAmericanIndiantribe.SocialScienceandMedicine,53,1115–24.

Wolsko, C.,Mohatt, G. V., Lardon, C., Burket, R. (2009). Smoking, chewing, and culturalidentity:prevalenceandcorrelatesoftobaccouseamongtheYup'ik-TheCenterforAlaskaNativeHealthResearch(CANHR)study.CulturalDiversityandEthnicMinorityPsychology,15(2),165–172.

Woodard,S.(2012).SuicideisanepidemicforAmericanIndianyouth:Whatmorecanbedone?RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://investigations.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/10/14340090-suicide-is-epidemic-for-american-indian-youth-what-more-can-be-done

Yoder,K.A.,Whitbeck,L.B.,Hoyt,D.R.,&LaFromboise,T.(2006).SuicidalideationamongAmericanIndianyouth.ArchivesofSuicideResearch,10(2),177–190.

Young,S.(2010).Indianhealthcare:Historicfailure.LakotaCountryTimes.RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://www.lakotacountrytimes.com/news/2010-01-19/Headlines/Indian_health_care_Historic_failure.html

Yukon-KuskokwimHealthCorporation.(2011–2014).CommunityHealthAideProgram.RetrievedMay1,2014,fromhttp://www.ykhc.org/programs/health-aide-program/

Yukon-KuskokwimHealthCorporation.(2011–2014).Ourregion.RetrievedJanuary2,2014,http://www.ykhc.org/our-region/

Yukon-KuskokwimHealthCorporation.(2011–2014).Services.RetrievedJanuary2,2014,http://www.ykhc.org/services/

Zenere,F.J.(2008).Pathwayofcontagion:Theidentificationofayouthsuicidecluster.Communique(0164775X),37(4),1–7.

Zenere,F.J.(2009).Suicideclustersandcontagion.