how to retire early your guide to...
TRANSCRIPT
HowToRetireEarly
YourGuidetoGettingRichSlowlyandRetiringonLess
BYROBERT&ROBINCHARLTON
Copyright©2013byRobertCharltonandRobinCharltonAllrightsreservedPrintedintheUnitedStatesofAmericaHowToRetireEarly:YourGuidetoGettingRichSlowlyandRetiringonLess
ISBN:978-1482653724FirstEditionThisbookoranyportionthereofmaynotbereproducedorusedinanyformwithouttheexpresswrittenpermissionoftheauthorexceptfortheuseofbriefquotationsforreviewpurposes.Whileeveryefforthasbeenmadetoprovideaccurate
informationwithregardtopersonalfinancesinthisbook,theauthorisnotengagedinrenderinglegal,accounting,orotherprofessionalservicesbypublishingthisbook.Ifanysuchassistanceisrequired,theservicesofaqualifiedfinancialprofessionalshouldbesought.Theauthorwillnotberesponsibleforanyliability,loss,orriskincurredasaresultoftheuseor
applicationofanyoftheinformationcontainedinthisbook.Authorwebsite:http://www.wherewebe.com
TableofContents
IntroductionChapter1.GettingStartedChapter2.TheSpecifics:HowWeRetiredEarlyChapter3.MoreSpecifics:LifeAfterRetirementChapter4.YourRoadmaptoEarlyRetirement
Chapter5.InvestinYourselfFirstChapter6.GetOutofDebtChapter7.StartSavingEarlyChapter8.DetermineYourRetirementIncomeNeedsChapter9.CalculateYourNestEggChapter10.MakeaLong-TermInvestmentPlanChapter11.InvestRegularly
inIndexFundsChapter12.TakeAdvantageof401(k)sandIRAsChapter13.LiveBelowYourMeansChapter14.KeepHomeandCarExpensesLowChapter15.KeepYourLifePortfolioBalancedChapter16.HealthCareinRetirementChapter17.ExtendedTravel
inRetirementAppendixA.DetailedSalaryandInvestmentInformationAppendixB.CreatingYourOwnInvestmentSpreadsheet
IntroductionAttheageof28mywife
andIhadjust$16.88toourname.IstillhavethecheckbookshowingthatdishearteninglittleentrynexttothedateofAugust15,1991.Weownednohome.WewererentersinanapartmentinBoulder,Coloradoandweweregettingseriouslyworriedbecauseour
monthlyrenthadjustshotupandwehadnoclearwayofpayingit.Iwasunemployedandcouldn’tevenfindtempwork.Wehadcollegeandcarloanstopayoff.MywifeRobinwasworkingasatravelagentforthepainfullylowsumof$14,000peryear.Shewasfrazzledenoughaboutourfinancialsituationthatshewastalkingabouttakingonasecondjobatalocalconveniencestorejust
tomakeendsmeet.Atleastshehadajob.
SincemovingfromBostoninJanuary1990,thebestIhadbeenabletomanagewastempworkasawordprocessormaking$7perhour.Ihadastringoffailedcareerattemptsbehindmeandnoclearcareerpathinsight.Iwassixyearsoutofcollegeandgoingnowherefast.HowhadImanagedtomakesomanywrongturns
sincecollege?WasIevergoingtoturnthingsaround?Sometimesitseemedliketheanswertheuniversewasgivingmewasaresoundingno.
IsRetiringEarlyReallyPossible?
Webeginourbookatthefinanciallowpointofourlivestomakeitclearthatevenfromunpromisingbeginningssuchastheseitispossibletogetbackontrackandretireearly.Notthroughget-rich-quickschemesbutthroughsimplehardworkandconsistentsavings.Nomatter
whatyourstartingpoint,nomatterhowhopelessthingsmaylookrightnow,youcanchangeyourlifearoundandsetyourselfonapathtowardsfinancialindependence.
Anditdoesn’thavetotakeforever.Wediditinjust15years,beginningin1992whenweboughtourfirsthomeandendingin2006whenwewalkedawayfromourfull-timejobsforthelasttime,hardlyabletobelieveit
ourselves.Wewere43yearsoldatthetimeandhadmanagedtoscrimpandsaveourwaytonearlyamilliondollars–enoughtobuyusasimpleearlyretirement.
Frankly,ifwecandoit,socanyou.Thisbookisdesignedtoshowyouhow.Itproposesa“getrichslow”approachtoearlyretirementthathasnothingtodowithmarkettiming,daytrading,options,orhigh-risk
investmentsofanykind.Rather,itprovidespracticaladviceonhowtosetarealisticretirementgoal15or20yearsdownthelineandtakethenecessarystepstoachieveit.
Thesestepsaresurprisinglysimple.Theydon’trequireanadvanceddegreeinbusinessorfinance.Justaboutanyonecandoit,includingyou,aslongasyoutakeaself-disciplined,slow-
and-steadyapproachtoinvesting.
Solet’sgetstartedbyansweringafewquestionsyoumaybewonderingabout.
WhoIsThisBookFor?
Thisbookisprimarilyaimedathopefulearlyretireesintheirtwentiesandthirties.However,anyone–includingthoseintheirfortiesorearlyfiftieswhoarejustgettingstartedsavingforretirementinameaningfulway–canusetheconceptsinthisbooktoretirein15to20
years.Infact,latecomerstothegamemaybeabletoretireinjust10years.Why?Becausetheymayalreadyhaveahighersalary,morehomeequity,andmoremoneysetasidethanyoungerinvestors,givingthemalegup.Emptynestersmayalsohavefewerdistractions,financialandotherwise,allowingthemtofocusinontheirretirementgoalwithgreaterintensity.
Ifyoualreadyhaveahigh-poweredsalaryandareabletoliveverywellinthepresentwhilealsoinvestinglargesumsofmoneyforthefuture,thenyouprobablydon’tneedthisbook.Infactmuchoftheadviceitoffersmaysoundstrangetoyourears.Whybothermakingsacrificesandgettingrichslowlyifyouarealreadyonthefasttracktofinancialfreedom?
Butfortherestofus,it’sgoodtoknowthereisanalternativeapproachtoachievingfinancialindependence.Ittakesaslowertrackbutgetsyouthereallthesame,andwethinkaslowertrackismuchbetterthannotrackatall.
WhyAlltheSpecifics?
Weintendtobeasup-frontandhonestwithyouaspossibleinthisbookandnotsugar-coatthetruth.Welayourownfinancesbare,showingyouhowwegotwherewegotandhowlongittook.Wegiveyouhardnumbersonwhatweearned,howmuchwesavedperyear,
andhowmuchwespendperyearnowthatwe’reretired.We’llsharewithyouthesimpleExcelspreadsheetwesetuptotrackourinvestments.We’lltellyouwherewewentwrongandwhatwewouldhavedonedifferentlyifwehadittodoover.
Ofcoursethespecificsofyourownsituationwilldifferfromours,butourfeelingisthatthemoreconcrete,
quantifiableinformationyouhave,theeasieritwillbeforyoutoplanyourownearlyretirement.Youcanextrapolatefromthespecificsweprovideandapplythatinformationtoyourownsituation.IfyouhappentoliveinaveryexpensivecitylikeNewYorkCityorSanFrancisco,forexample,youmayhavetocompensateforthemuchhighercostoflivingtherebyadjustingourincome
andexpenseinformationupwards.
AreYouFinancialExperts?
Wearen’tfinancialexpertsbutwedoconsiderourselvesfinanciallysavvy.IpassedtheSeries7Examandactuallyworkedabriefstintasalicensedstockbrokerearlyoninmycareerbeforedecidingtotakeadifferent
tack.Butwebothlearnedthemostaboutinvestingsimplybydoingitoverthepasttwodecades:whatworks,whatdoesn’twork,what’sthesimplestapproach,andwhatmaysoundgoodonpaperbutisn’tsogoodinpractice.Wemadeenoughmistakesalongthewaytoserveashumanguineapigsforwhatdoesn’twork,andwesharethosemistakeswithyouinthisbooksoyourownpathcanbe
alittleeasier.Frankly,wethinkwe
havesomethinginterestingtosaynotbecausewe’reexpertsbutbecausewe’renot.We’reordinarypeoplewhosetalong-termfinancialgoalandachievedit.Ifyou’relookingforspecializedadvicefromafinancialguru,wesuggestyoulookelsewhere.Butifyouwantpracticalguidancewithplentyofexamplesonhowtoretireearlyfrom
peoplewhohavebeenwhereyouarenow,youmaywanttoconsiderwhatwehavetosay.We’reprobablynotallthatdifferentfromyou,anditcanhelptogettheperspectiveofothertravelerswhohaveventureddownthesameroadyou’rethinkingoftaking.
DidYouHaveHigh-PoweredJobs?
Iworkedprimarilyasatechnicalwriterandproposalcoordinatorintheaerospaceindustry,andmywifeworkedasatravelagentthenasaregisterednurse.Ourjobsstartedoffpayingpoorlyandgotbetterwithtime,asmost
people’sdo,butneitherwouldbeconsideredhigh-powered.Infactourcombinedgrosssalariesforthe15yearsfrom1992to2006averagedjustover$89,000.
Mostpeopletakecomfortinhearingwewereabletoachieveourearlyretirementdreamswithrelativelynormaljobs.Weprovideourannualsalaryinformationandinvestmentamountsinthis
booksoyoucanjudgeforyourself.
DidYouGetAnyFinancialHelp?
Wehadnofinancialhelpinachievingourearlyretirementgoals.Wedidnotreceiveaninheritance.Wedidnotwinthelottery.Therewasnotrustfundtodrawfrom,nocashsettlement,andnosecretgiftsofmoneyfrom
richparentstoseeusthroughhardtimes.Wehavebeenfinanciallyindependentthroughoutouradultlives,andwelikeitthatway.
Intheinterestsoffulldisclosure,ourparentsdidpayformostofourcollegeeducation(butnotgraduateschoolornursingschool),andtheydidloanus$7,000tohelpwiththedownpaymentonourfirsthomebackin1991–anamountwepaid
backoverthenextthreeyears,with8%interest.Wementionthisupfrontsoyoucandecideforyourselfifweachievedourearlyretirementgoalessentiallyonourown.
DoYouHaveChildren?
Wedon’thavechildren,andthatdidofcoursemakeiteasierforustoretireearly.Whilewehadoriginallyplannedonhavingkids,theuniversehaddifferentideasforus,soearlyretirementbecameourplanB.Givenourmodestsalariesduringmostofourinvestingyears,wecan
saywithsomecertaintywewouldnothavebeenabletoretireatage43withchildren.However,webelievewestillcouldhaveretiredbyage50orearlierwithchildren.
Ifyouhavekidsorplanonhavingthem,youcanstillusetheconceptsinthisbooktoretireearly:yousimplymaywanttogiveyourselfsomeextratimetoachieveyourgoal.Insteadofa15-yearplan,youmaywantto
puttogethera20-yearplan.Thatway,ifyouweretostartinvestingbyage30,youcouldstillretirebeforeage50.Thepowerofcompoundingissuchthatanextrafiveortenyearsofinvesting(andnotdrawingdownonyourinvestments)canmakeahugedifference,eveniftheamountsinvestedperyeararesmallerthantheywouldhavebeenotherwiseduetothemyriadexpenses
associatedwithchildren.
What’sItLikeBeingRetiredEarly?
Earlyretirementisoneofthefewthingsinlifethatreallylivesuptoitsexpectations.It’swortheverypennyyouputintoit.It’sworththeyearsofsacrificetoachieve.Andachievingitonyourownwillgiveyoua
senseofsatisfactionandaccomplishmentinitsownright.
Whilewedon’twanttoboreyouwithendlesstalesofouradventuressinceretiring,wedowanttoinspireyouwithwhat’spossibleonceyourtimeisyourown,sowe’llbrieflymentionourveryfirsttripafterretiringandletthatspeakforalltherest.In2007,celebratingournewfoundfreedom,wewent
onafive-monthtriptoNewZealandandFijiandpushedourpersonallimitswithadventureslikeskydiving,bungeejumping,hanggliding,jetboating,andaerobaticflying.Weswamwithdolphinsandseals,snorkeledwithsharksandmantarays,rompedwithlioncubs,rolleddownhillinaZorb,kayakedinDoubtfulSound,andlogged300milesonNewZealandtrails,
includingsuchGreatWalksastheMilford,Routeburn,Kepler,andAbelTasmantracks.Inshort,wehadablast,andsocanyouonceyouretireearly.Ifyou’dliketoreadmoreabouttheseandotheradventureswe’vehad,youcancheckoutourpersonalwebsiteatwherewebe.com.
We’reataninterestingjunctureinourownlivesrightnow,havinghad15
yearsofexperienceworkingtowardsearlyretirementand6yearsofexperiencebeingretiredandseeingwhatit’slikeontheotherside.(Spoileralert:It’sgreat!)Thatgivesussomeusefulperspectiveonbothsidesofthegreatretirementdivide.Wehopewecananswerafewquestionsyou’vewantedtoaskbuthaven’tbeensurewhotoask.Andmaybewecanevenansweraquestionor
twoyouhaven’tthoughttoaskyet.
Ifwecanempoweryoutostopdreamingandstartplanning,tostopwishingandstartwillingyourearlyretirementintoexistence,we’llhavedonewhatwesetouttodointhisbook.
Chapter1.GettingStarted
Soyou’vedecidedearlyretirementsoundsgoodtoyou.Infactyouthinkitsoundsgreatandwouldsuityoutoatee.Travelingtheworld,rediscoveringleisure
time,turninghappyhoursintohappydays(andweeksandmonthsandyears),followingyourdreamswherevertheymaylead....Yeah,sure,youcouldgetusedtothat.
Soyouknowwhatyouwant,you’rejustnotsurehowtogetthere.Butyou’vestartedaskingquestions:Whatwouldittaketomakeithappen?HowmuchwouldIneedtosaveup?Howmany
yearswouldittake?HowexactlywouldIgetstarted?
Well,inawayyou’vealreadygottenstartedjustbyaskingthosequestions.You’realreadyonthemovementallyandthat’sagoodthing,becausegettingstartedisinmanywaysthehardestpart.
Inertiamakesiteasytokeepdoingthesameoldsameold,especiallywhenmakingachangemeansdoing
somethinghard,likegoingtothegymforthefirsttimeorchangingyourspendinghabitssoyoucanbeginsavingforretirement.Puttingsuchthingsoffmakesperfectsense,doesn’tit?Butyou’vegottotaketheplungeatsomepoint,andthattimemayaswellbenow,sincenoneofusisgettinganyyounger.
Thegoodnewsis,inertiaworksintwoways.It’struethatanobjectatresttendsto
stayatrest,butit’salsotruethatanobjectinmotiontendstostayinmotion.Ifyoucangetyourselfmovingintherightdirection,thenthelikelihoodisyou’llkeepmovinginthatdirection–andmaybeevengainmomentumthroughtheyears–righttowardsfinancialindependenceandearlyretirement.
Ourgoalistogetyoumovinginthatdirection.And
thefirststepdoesn’tevenrequireyoutogetupoffthecouch.
DeclareIndependence
Thefoundingfathersdeclaredindependencebeforetheyactuallyachievedit,andsoshouldyou.Theyknewtheyhadahardfightaheadofthem,butthatdidn’tstopthemfromputtingtheirintentionsdownonpaperanddeclaringtheirlibertytotheworld.ThatwasonJuly4,
1776,sevenyearsbeforetheRevolutionaryWaractuallyendedin1783.
Soit’sreasonabletoask,Whendidtheyactuallybecomefree?Fromacertainstandpointtheybecamefreethemomenttheydeclaredthemselvesindependentandsawthemselvesasfree.Onceyoudeclareyourfinancialindependenceandsetyourwholeheartandsoulonit,you’vechangedyourmental
outlookonlifeandyourexpectationsforthefuture.Atthatpointyou’vealreadywonthefirstbattleinyourcampaignforfinancialfreedom.
Intheearlyyearsofthewar,GeneralWashingtonmarkedIndependenceDay1778withanartillerysaluteandadoublerationofrumforhissoldiers.Werecommendyoudosomethingsimilartocelebrateinthemidstofyour
campaign.Anartillerysalutemightbeabitextreme,butadoublerationofrumorafinebottleofwinemightdothetrick.Whileyou’resavoringit,remindyourselfwhatyou’refightingfor:alifefarremovedfromtheratrace,libertyfromthetyrannyofstressandmoneyworries,andofcoursethepursuitofhappiness.
Sopickaday.Maybeit’syourbirthdayoryour
anniversaryorthelastdayofthecalendaryear.Pickadateandputacirclearoundit.Nowvisualizeretiringonthatdate15to20yearsfromnow–andcelebrateeachyearasyoumoveclosertoyourgoal.
InourcasewechoseDecember20,ourweddinganniversary,asourfinancialindependenceday.WehadextrareasontorejoiceeachyearasDecember20rolledaround.Itmaysoundcorny,
buttrustus,havingadatetocelebratemakesitallseemabitmorereal–andyouneedthatintheearlyyears.Ittakesalotoffaithtobelievethatpunylittleaccountyoujustopenedwithafewhundreddollarsinitcansomedaytransformitselfintotheenginethatwillpoweryourretirement,butitcan,anditwill.
SetYourGoalThisbookwillhelpyou
developadetailedinvestmentplantailoredtoyourownfinancialsituation,butyoucangetstartedrightnowbysettingapreliminarygoal.Wesuggestsettingitforsomethingotherthan40or50yearsinthefuture.That’stoodistant.Youreallymightwanttoretireintheold-
fashionedsenseofthewordandsimplyliedownforagoodlongnapbythatpoint.Wethinkeven30yearsfromnowistoofaroff.No,youneedagoalthatisattainablebutnottooremote.Ifit’stoodistantitwillfeelunreal,likeashimmeringmiragethatnevergetsanycloser.
Wethink15to20yearsisideal,with25yearsbeingtheouterlimitforarealisticearlyretirementgoalyoucanstill
getexcitedabout.Thattimeframewillgiveyouplentyoftimetoachieveyourgoalwithoutbeingsofarremoveditfeelsdreamlike.
Youwantyourgoaltohavesomesoliditytoit,someheft.Youwanttobeabletopickitupinyourhandsandturnitaroundandsay,“Yes,that’swhatIwant.That’swhyI’mwillingtoworkhardrightnow.AndthesoonerIgetstarted,thesoonerI’llget
there.”Specifically,wewould
recommend:–15yearsifyouarehighlyambitious,motivated,andhavenokids(anddon’tplanonhavingthem)–20yearsifyouhavekidsbutareatleastasambitiousandmotivatedasyourdouble-income-no-kids(DINK)andsinglefriends
–25yearsifyouhavekidsandarereasonablymotivatedbutalsowanttolivealittlemorealongthewayNow,these
recommendationsaren’tsetinstone.Ifyouaresuper-earnersorsuper-saversextraordinaire,youmightbeabletodoevenbetterthanthesegoals.Youmightretireinjust10years,say,ifyou
haveahigh-payingjob,saveaggressively,andgetasolidlegupfromthemarkets.Oryoumayalreadyhavealittleretirementmoneysetaside,inwhichcaseyou’realreadyaheadofthegameandmaybeabletoretirealittlesooner.
Norisitimpossibletohavekidsandretirein15years–especiallyifyouhavesalariesthatarewellaboveaverage–butit’scertainly
morechallenging.That’swhy,forsanity’ssakeifnothingelse,wesuggestyoutackonafewextrayearstogiveyourinvestments(andyourkids)moretimetogrow.
Ifyoudon’twanttopushsohardandaren’tchompingatthebittoretireuncommonlyearly,youcansetyourgoalfor25oreven30yearsdowntheroadandallowyourselfabitmorefreedomtoliveinthepresent
whilealsosavingforthefuture.It’suptoyou:aslongasyouhaveagoalyoucangetexcitedabout,that’sthemainthing.
Oneofthefundamentalpurposesofthisbookistohelpyourefineyourpreliminarygoaltomakesureit’sachievable.Howmuchyou’llneedtosaveeachyear,howbigyournesteggneedstobe,wheretoinvestyourmoney,howmuchyoucan
expectthemarketstoreturn,howtotrackyouractualprogressagainstgoals,andhowtofine-tuneyourinvestmentplanarealltopicsattheheartofthisbook.Startingintheverynextchapterwe’llprovideyouwithplentyofconcretedetailsandreal-lifeexamplesfromourownexperiencesoyoucanseehowaplanonpapercanbecomearealityinlife.
WorkWithaPurpose
“RightatthismomentIhatemyjobsomuchIcouldspit.Sittinghereatthisdeskforthenext30yearssoundslikehelltome.”
IwrotethesewordsinajournalIkeptveryearlyoninmycareerwhenIwasfranklymiserable.Ifelttrappedinmyjobasanovicetechnical
writerandIwantedout.Itdidn’thelpthatthefirmIwasworkingforwasbeingboughtoutbyanothercompanyandafulltenthoftheemployeeshadbeenlaidoff.Therewasamalaiseintheairthatmadeithardtobeatworkeachday.
Unfortunatelyalotofpeoplefeelasimilarsenseofdespairatthedrudgeryoftheirjobs.Recentsurveyshavefoundthatnearly60%ofAmericansarenothappyat
theirworkandwouldchooseadifferentcareeriftheycouldoverwhattheydonow.Feelingtrappedandfrustrated,stressedoutandunhappy,istheregrettablefirststagemanyofushavetopassthroughbeforeweformthehardresolveittakestoretireearly.
Ifyoufindyourselfinasimilarsituation,takeheart:thingsdogetbetter.Simplyhavingaplanforearly
retirementcangiveyouarenewedsenseofhope.Fromtheverystartofour15-yearplan,IfeltlikeIcouldseelightattheendofthetunnel,nomatterhowdim.ItmademyjobbetterjustknowingIwasn’tchainedtoitforeverlikeaslavetotheoarsofagalleyship.
Andoncewestartedtakingconcretestepstowardsachievingourgoal–mostimportantlybymaking
regularinvestmentseachmonth–itchangedmyattitudeevenmore.IrecommittedtoworkbecausenowIrealizedIhadastakeinearningabettersalary.Itwasnolongerjustaboutpayingthebillsandgettingby.Weneededtomakeextramoneysowecouldinvest.Wewantedtoachievefinancialindependence,andweweresuddenlyalivetothepossibilitythattheharderwe
worked,thesoonerwecouldgetthere.
Asaresult,weworkedwitharenewedsenseofpurposeandwithamuchbetterattitude.Themoreeffortweputintoourjobs,thebetterwedid,andthateventuallytranslatedintoraisesandpromotions.Speakingformyself,IevencametolikewhatIdidforaliving.Ironically,bythetimeIretired,IfeltlikeIcould
havekeptworkingquitehappily–ifnotforever,atleastforseveralmoreyears.Butbythenwehadsomanyotherthingswewantedtodoinlifethatweknewwe’dbettergetbusy,soattheageof43weleftfull-timeworkbehindandneverlookedback.
Togettothatpointyourself,you’regoingtoneedtoworkharderandwithmorepurposethanyoueverhave
before.Yourlong-termgoalshouldbetosaveupenoughmoneythatyourmoneycanworkforyousoyoudon’thaveto.Ittakestimetobuildupanesteggofsufficientsizetomakethispossible,butonceyoudo,youcangetoffthetreadmillforeverandgetonwiththerestofyourlife.
Havingaclearlydefinedend-dateforyourworkingyearschangesyourperspectiveonthings.Your
careerbecomesjustonephaseofyourlife,aphaseyou’dliketobeabletolookbackonwithacertainamountofprideandfeellikeyouaccomplishedsomethingusefulduringthatperiod.Thischangeinattitudecanturnworkintosomethingmorethanjustachoreandmakeitrewardingandoccasionally(darewesayit?)evenapleasure.
Onceyoudecidetoretire
early,you’reworkingforyourselfasmuchasyou’reworkingforthecompanyyou’reemployedby.Sopreparementallytoworkwithapurposeforasetnumberofyearsandseewhatcomesofit.Takeonthehardassignmentsnooneelsewants.Putsomeenergyintoitandletyourjourneytoearlyretirement–thehardworkyoudotogetthere–becomepartofyoursuccess
story.
BuyTimeWhenyoudecidetoretire
earlyyou’rereallydecidingtobuytime–timewhenyouareonyourownclockandnotsomeoneelse’s.Becauseyourtimeisvaluable,wethinkyoushouldbuyasmuchofitaspossiblebyworkinghardforaconcentratednumberofyearssoyouhavemoretimetospendlateron
howeveryoumaychoose.It’snolongerenoughfor
youtomakeendsmeet–youneedtomakethemexceed.Yourgoalinyourworkingyearsshouldbetocreateseedmoneythatisn’tearmarkedforbills,groceries,mortgagepayments,andalltheothernecessitiesoflife.Thisseedmoneycouldbethrowntothewinds(spentonstuff),oritcouldbeplantedandallowedtogrowintosomethingthat
couldcastawholelotofshadeonyourfuture.Whichdoyouthinkwerecommend?
Ifyoucouldhaveabighouseoranearlyretirementbutnotboth,whichwouldyouchoose?Ifyou’relikeus,you’dchoosetheearlyretirementandtoheckwiththebighouse!“That’sallyourhouseis,”jokesthecomedianGeorgeCarlin,“it’saplacetokeepyourstuffwhileyougooutandget
morestuff.”We’reallguiltyofbuyingmorethanweshouldsometimesandsowelaugh,butit’snotsuchalaughingmatteronceyoumakethedecisiontoretireearly.Buyingstuffandbuyingtimeareindirectcompetitionforyourhard-earnedmoney,andthechoicesyoumakeinthisregardhaveadirectbearingonyourfuture.
Toomanymaterial
possessionscanfranklybeaburden,andtheycertainlysubtractfromhowmuchtimeyoucanbuy.Asyouapproachretirement,there’safairchanceyou’llbetryingtounburdenyourselfofstuffsoyoucandownsizetoasmallerspace,sodoyourselfafavoranddon’toverburdenyourselftobeginwith.Keepyourpacklightasyoutravelthroughlifeandyou’llbeahappiercamper.Livesimply,
staylean,buyonlywhatyouneed,andyou’llmakefasterprogressontheroadtoearlyretirement.
We’renotadvocatingyouputallyoureggsinonebasketandonlyliveforthefuture.Youshouldhavefunandadventuresalongthewayevenwhilesavingupforearlyretirement.Youdon’twanttomissoutonlifetodaybecauseyouweretoobusysavingupfortomorrow.Stay
balancedandrememberit’samarathon,notasprint.Paceyourselfaccordingly.
Yougetrichslowlybyputtinginmanyyearsofconsistenteffort,notbypushingsohardyoumakeyourselforthosearoundyouunhappy.Ifyoufollowthesuggestionsinthisbook,you’llspreadyourinvestmentsoversuchanextendedperiodoftimethattheywon’tcauseundue
stress.You’llkeepyourinvestmentsuncomplicatedsotheywon’toccupyyoureverywakingmoment,andyou’llputthemonautopilotsothey’llessentiallytakecareofthemselvesonceyougetthemupandrunning.
Theideaistohavealifewhilealsoplanningforabetterone.
Whenyoufirststartdownthispath,fewwillbelieveyoucandoit.Peoplewill
smileandnodwhenyoutellthemaboutyourplans,butinsidetheymaybethinkingit’sjusttalk.Doyourselfafavorandprovethemwrong.Makeyourdreamcometruethroughathousandsmallactionsanddecisionsyoutakefromdaytodayoverthecourseofyears,allofwhichadduptobuildingwealthslowly.
Ifyou’reluckyandlivetoaripeoldage,youcould
invest15yearsoftimeandtripleorquadrupleyourinvestmentwith45to60yearsoffinancialfreedom.Nowthat’swhatwewouldcallatimelyinvestment!
DreamBigNearlyeveryweekend
duringourworkingyears,RobinandIwouldtakelongwalksintheColoradomountainsnearwherewelived,andmoreoftenthannottheconversationwouldturnatsomepointtoallthefunthingsweweregoingtodoonceweretired.Whereweweregoingtotravel,where
weweregoingtoliveoverseas,theadventuresweweregoingtohave.Thoseweregoodwalks!Keepingthedreamalive–talkingaboutitandmakingitrealtoeachother–madeallthescrimpingandsavingseemworthwhile.
Anditwasworthwhile.Retiringearlyisnotapipedream:it’sachievable,anditreallydoesgiveyouthefreedomtodowhatyoulove
most.Forusitmeansbeingabletotravelforlongerperiodsoftimethanthetwoorthreeweeksourfull-timejobsusedtoallow.Nowourtripscanlastaslongaswewantthemto;wecanimmerseourselvesinanothercultureandgettoknowitfromtheinsideout.
Earlyretirementalsomeanswecanpursueourowninterestswithoutparticularregardtomoney.Wecan
write,takephotographs,andkeepatravelwebsitesimplybecausewewantto,notbecausewehaveto.Wealsolovethefactthatwhenaperfectlysunnydaycomesalongunexpectedlyinthemiddleofthe“workweek,”wecanabandonwhateverplanswemighthavehadandgoforahikewhentherearevirtuallynopeopleonthetrailsandnatureisatitsbest.
It’sliberatingtobeableto
makedecisionsabouthowtospendyourtimeoncemoneyisnolongertheprimarydriver.Doorsopenonawholenewworldofpossibilities:–Volunteerandcommunityworkthatwouldhavebeenclosedtoyoubeforebecausetheydidn’tpayasalary.–Personalprojectslikewritingorpaintingthat
fulfillaninternaldesiretocreatebutmayneverrewardyoufinancially.–Outdoororculturalpursuitsthatenrichyoursoulbutnotyourpocketbook.Whatmattersmostis
beingabletomakeyourownchoiceeachmorningwhenyouwakeup–tohaveasayinhowyouspendyourday–becausetimereallyisthe
ultimatelimitedresource.Soletyourselfdream
aboutwhatyou’lldoonceyouretireandarestillyoungenoughtopursueyourdreams.Visualizeyourselfretiredearly,thenreadontolearnhowtobuildthefinancialbridgetogetyouthere.
Chapter2.TheSpecifics:HowWe
RetiredEarlyItmayhelptohavea
concreteexampleofwhatwedidduringourinvestingyearsasaguidetowhatyoumay
alsobeabletoaccomplish.Weprovidealotofspecificsinthischaptertoallowyoutomakeareasonablejudgmentastowhatmaybepossibleinyourownlifewhenitcomestoearlyretirement.Youcanextrapolatefromoursituationtoyours,usingthedetailedinformationbelowasakindoffinancialyardstick.
AnnualSalariesLet’sstartwiththischart
summarizingourannualsalaries.AdetailedtableofsalaryinformationisprovidedinAppendixA.
Asthechartsuggests,atfirstweweremakingverylittlemoney–lessthan$25,000combinedin1990and1991.By1992wewereupto$38,000.WehadjustpurchasedourhomeinNovember1991andweren’tevenofficiallysavingforretirementyet.Thebeginningsofameaningfulinvestmentplandidn’toccuruntillate1994.However,
sinceourhomeendeduprepresentingaboutonethirdofournetworthatretirement,wethinkitmakessensetostarttheretirementsavingsclockin1992justafterweboughtit.
Forthefirst8years(from1992to1999)weearnedanaveragecombinedsalaryofjust$55,000gross.Ourafter-taxincomeaveragedaround$40,000.Outofthisamountwehadtopayahome
mortgage($1,050permonth),finishpayingoffcarandcollegeloans,andcoveralltheothertypicalbillsandexpensesthatcomewithdailyliving.Investingontopofallthiswasn’teasybutweatleastmadeabeginning,savinganaverageofabout$8,900peryearduringthisperiod.Wehopeyouwilltakesomeencouragementfromthis.Itdemonstratesyoudon’tneedapowerhouse
salarytobeginsavingforearlyretirement.Youcanmakeasmallstartnow,thenworkpurposefullytoimproveyourfinancialprospectsoverthecourseofyourinvestingyears.
Between1999and2000ourincomejumpeddramaticallyduetoRobin’sretrainingasanurse.Aquickglanceatthechartshowswhatapowerfuldifferenceitcanmakehavingtwogood
salariesworkingforyouinsteadofjustone.Intheend,helpedbyRobin’snewcareerandareasonablystrongfinishinmyown,ourcombinedgrosssalariesaveragedabout$89,000forthe15yearsfrom1992to2006.
Let’slookatonefinalsalarystatistic.Ourcombinedgrosssalariesduringour12primaryinvestingyears(from1995to2006)averagedabout$99,000.Thisisthefinancial
yardstickthatmaybethemostusefultoyou.
Basedonthisinformation,it’sreasonabletoassumeacouplewithnokidswithcombinedsalariesaveraging$100,000grossperyearcouldaccomplishwhatwedidorbetter.Thisshouldholdtrueevenwhentakinginflationintoaccountsinceoursalaryaverageovertheentire15-yearperiodwasactuallyunder$90,000.If
eachofyouearn$50,000,say,thatwoulddothetrick.Thegoodnewsis,youdon’tneedsky-highsalariestomakethiswork,yousimplyneeddecentwages.Salariesinthe$50,000to$60,000rangearecertainlyattainableintheU.S.thesedayswithalittleretrainingifnecessary.Robin’ssecondcareerasanurseisagoodcaseinpoint.
Webelieveasingleindividualsavingforearly
retirementcouldachievesimilarresultswithanaveragesalaryofabout$75,000.
Parentsearning$100,000combinedmightneedtotackonanextra5to10yearstoachievefinancialindependenceduetothehigherexpensesassociatedwithchildren.However,ifyoursalariesaverage$125,000peryearormore,youmightbeableto
accomplishsomethingsimilartowhatwedidevenwithkids.
Inflationtendstoplayhavocwithhardnumbersinbookslikethese,soyoumaywanttoadd3%peryearbasedonthebook’spublicationdatetotranslatethesalaryyardstickslistedaboveintocurrentdollars.
AnnualInvestmentAmounts
Thefollowingchartshowshowmuchweinvestedeachyearfor15years.(ExactamountsareprovidedinAppendixA.)Thisiswhatweinvested,withoutreferencetomarketreturnsorcompounding.
You’llnoticethedollaramountsstartoutsmallandgrowmuchbiggerwithtime.Thearrowhighlightsthebigjumpinyearlysavings(+$14,000)thatoccurredonceRobinbecamearegisterednursein2000.Thatamountjumpedbyanother$14,000in2001onceweweredonepayingoffover$15,000instudentnursingloansandcouldchannel
virtuallyalloftheextramoneyshewasearningstraightintoinvestments.Themoralofthestoryis,investinyourselffirstbeforeinvestingforretirementifyouwanttomaximizeyourresults.
Ifyouaddupthetotalamountweputintoinvestmentsfrom1992to2006,itcomestojustover$342,000.Again,thisistheamountweputin,notcountingmarketreturnsor
compounding.Thataveragesouttoabout$22,800ininvestmentsperyear.
Keepinmindthefirst3yearsofthis15-yearperiodwereinsignificantintermsofinvesting–ourcumulativetotalfrom1991to1994waslessthan$6,600.Atthatpointwewereprimarilyfocusedonbuyingandfurnishingourhome,payingoffloans,andswitchingtoa15-yearmortgage.Duringour12
primaryyearsofinvesting(1995-2006),weaveragedjustover$28,000ininvestmentsperyear.
Let’ssplitthedifferenceandsay$25,000peryearisadecentyardstickforanaverageannualinvestmentamount(plustheequitybuildinginyourhome)ifyouareaimingforearlyretirementin15years.Likeus,though,yourannualsavingsratemaystartout
muchsmallerthanthis.Inourfirst3yearsweonlysavedabout$1,750peryearonaverage,sodon’tbediscouragedif$25,000seemslikeanimpossiblybignumberatthemoment.Witha15-or20-yearplan,youhaveplentyoftimetomakecareerimprovementstosuperchargeyoursavings.
PercentageofNetIncomeInvested
Thenextchartshowsthepercentageofournetincomeinvestedeachyear.Asyoucansee,thepercentagesincreaseddramaticallyastheyearspassed.
Thepercentageofournetincomeinvestedaveragesoutto33%peryearover15years,or40%peryearduringour12primaryinvestingyears(1995-2006).Foryardstickpurposes,ifyou’reinvestingonethirdofyournetincomeeachyear(andyoursalaryisatleastroughlycomparabletoours),it’sreasonabletoassumeyou’reontracktoretireinabout15
years.Overtheyears,wehadto
resistthenaturaltendencytospendmorejustbecauseweweremakingmore.Insteadwedirectedany“bonus”moneyintoinvestments.Bykeepingourexpensesflat,wewereabletosaveincreasinglylargeamounts–especiallyafterRobin’sswitchtoabetter-payingjob.Thistooksomeself-discipline,butitmadeaworldofdifferencein
termsoftheamountswewereabletoinvesteachyear.Bymakingdozensofsmallcost-savingdecisionseachday–alongwithafewbigoneslikenevermovingfromourstarterhomeandkeepingthesamecarsthroughoutourinvestingyears–wewereabletodramaticallyincreasethegapbetweenearningandspendinginthelateryearsofourplan.
Ourinvestmentsasa
percentageofnetincomehitanall-timehighof57%in2001,thentailedoffpercentage-wiseeventhoughthedollaramountsinvestedcontinuedtoaveragearound$40,000peryear.That’sbecausewebeganlivingabitmorefortodayandabitlessfortomorrowatthatpoint.Bythenoursalarieswerehighenoughandourmoneywasworkinghardenoughforusthatwefounditeasierto
reachouryearlygoalswithoutneedingtosacrificesomuch.Webegantravelingmoreafter2001,butwewerestillcarefultopayourselvesfirst,makingcertainwecouldmeetouryearlyinvestinggoalsbeforeventuringoffonthatnextbigtrip.
Taxablevs.Tax-AdvantagedAccounts
Ifyouplantoretireveryearlylikewedid,youneedtosaveatleastsomeofyourmoneyintaxableaccountssincetax-advantagedoneslike401(k)sandIRAspenalizeyouforwithdrawingmoneybeforeage59½.As
thischartindicates,wehadtoplaycatch-upinvestingintaxableaccountswhenwerealizedhalfwaythroughourinvestmentplanwewouldberetiringearlierthanexpectedandwouldneedpenalty-freeaccesstomoreofourmoney.
Atretirementweheldalmost$350,000intaxableinvestmentsand$280,000intax-advantagedinvestments(a55/45split).Includingtheequityfromthesaleofourhome($200,000ofwhichwasinvestedinataxablebondfundatretirement),thesplitwascloserto65/35.
Ifyouplantoretireinyourthirtiesorforties,wethinkagoodyardstickforthe
ratiooftaxabletotax-advantagedsavingsisaround50/50.Ifyouexpecttodownsizelikewedidandputaportionofyourhomeequityintotaxablebonds,thenaimfor60/40inclusiveofthebonds.
Thecloseryougetto59½asyourlikelyretirementage,themoreitmakessensetoputallormostofyoursavingsintotax-advantagedaccounts.Therearewaysto
accessmoneyinyourtax-advantagedaccountswithoutpenaltyevenbeforeage59½(see“AllocatingBetweenTaxableandTax-AdvantagedAccounts”inChapter12).Ifyouplantoretireatage55orover,werecommendyoumaxoutyourtax-advantagedsavingsoptionsfirstbeforeputtinganymoneyintotaxableaccounts.
CumulativeNestEgg
Thischartshowsthecumulativenesteggweaccruedoverthe15-yearperiodfrom1992to2006.Thenesteggshownisforliquidassetsonlyanddoesnotincludeequityinourhomeofabout$300,000.
Ifyouaddupthetotalamountweputintoinvestmentsfrom1992to2006,itcomestojustover$342,000(asdiscussedearlierinthischapterunder“AnnualInvestmentAmounts”).Nowcomparethisamounttothecumulativenesteggshownfor2006of$626,000.Thedifference,whichcomestoabout$284,000,isduetotheeffectsofcompounding.This
isessentiallyyourmoneyworkingforyoutoearnmoremoney,anditdemonstrateswhatapowerfulforcecompoundingcanbe.Considerthatabout45%ofthetotalnesteggshownfor2006istheresultofcompounding.
It’sinstructivetonotethateventhoughwewerechannelinglargeamountsofmoneyintothemarketsfrom2000to2002,ourreturns
wereunimpressivebecausetheeconomyasawholewasinthemidstofasignificantbearmarket.Thedot-combubblehadfinallyburstandtheS&P500wasdown-9%,-12%,and-22%in2000,2001,and2002.However,throughoutthebearmarketwewerebuyingmoreshareswithourmoneyandweknewthatinthelongrunourstrategyofconsistentinvestingwouldpayoff.And
itdid.Wesawbigreturnsinthefollowingfouryears.From2003to2006theS&P500gained29%,11%,5%,and16%,respectively.Ourcumulativenestegggrewrapidlyundertheseconditions.Nowthemarketswereworkingforusevenaswecontinuedchannelingmoremoneyintothem.
Thetakeawaylessonisthis:keepinvesting–orinvestmore–whenthe
marketsaredownandyouwillreapbigrewardslateron.
EventhoughtheS&P500gainedmorepercentage-wisein2003thanitdidin2006(29%vs.16%),ourindividualreturnsweregreaterin2006.Why?Becauseourcapitalbasewasgreater:wehadmoremoneyinvestedinthestockmarketbythen.Thinkofitthisway:Ifyouhave$5,000investedinthestockmarketandthe
markethasabanner20%year,that’sagainof$1,000;butifyouhave$500,000invested,you’vejustmadeyourself$100,000.Yourdollarreturnsaretypicallymuchhigherinthelateryearsofyourinvestmentprogram.That’sthenatureofcompounding,andit’swhyevenafewextrayearsofworkcanmakeabigdifferenceintermsofthesizeofyournestegg.Ifthe
marketscooperate,youcanmakeimpressiveandrapidstridesforward–andiftheydon’tcooperate,atleastanynewmoneyyou’reinvestingcushionsyourportfoliofromgoingdownasmuchasitwouldhaveotherwise.Yournesteggmayevencontinuetoincreaseslightlyduringabearmarket,asoursdidfrom2000to2002.
Despitethecompellingargumentforstayinginthe
workforceafewyearslongerandwatchingyournestegggrowbigger,thesirencallofearlyretirementcansometimesbeimpossibletoresist.Suchwasthecaseforus.Aftercarefulthought,wedecidedtoquitfull-timeworktwoyearsearlierthanplannedandretireatage43insteadof45.Weturnedthepageandstartedanewchapterinourlives.
Wasitagooddecision?
Asyouturnthepageyourself,we’lllookathowthingsturnedoutforusonceweleftfull-timeworkandventuredintothepromisedlandofearlyretirement.
Chapter3.More
Specifics:LifeAfter
RetirementWeretiredearlierthan
originallyplannedbecause
wedidn’twanttoalmostarriveatthepromisedlandbutnotquitegetthere–likeMosesleadinghispeoplethroughthedesertforfortylongyearsbutbeingdeniedentrywithinsightofhisgoal.Robin’sworkasanursehadtaughtherfrompersonalexperiencelifedoesn’talwaysgoasplanned.Thatreinforcedourdeterminationtoretireasearlyaspossiblewhilebothofuswerestill
youngandhealthyenoughtofullyenjoyit.
Sowetooktheplunge.Ithelpedknowingoneorbothofuscouldalwaysgobacktoworkonatemporarybasisifneedbesincebothourjobsweresuitedtoit.Italsohelpedhavingarelativelyhightoleranceforriskandfeelingmoreexcitedthanscaredatthethoughtofventuringintotheunknown.
Then,too,whenwe
lookedatourportfoliobalance,wefeltlikewehadenough.Notapennymore,mindyou,butenough.Onlyyoucandefinewhatenoughisforyou,butinourcasewehadclosetoamilliondollarssavedupaftersellingourhome,whichwasenoughtogenerateabout$40,000inincomeperyear.Thatwasanamountweknewfromexperiencewecouldliveoncomfortably.
Aluxuryretirementhadneverbeenourgoal.Fromthebeginningwewantedtosaveupjustenoughtobeabletotraveltheworldaffordablyandfollowotherpursuitsofourownchoosinglikewritingandphotography.Whatwewantedmorethanmoneywastime.
Somemaybesurprisedweretiredonlessthanamilliondollarsandthinkusfoolhardy.Othersmaythink
weshortchangedourselvesbynotputtinginafewmoreyearsandsavingupforamoredeluxeretirement.Stillothersmaythinkwewaitedtoolongandcouldhavemadethejumpsooner.Allwecansayinresponseisthatdecidingwhentoretireisadeeplypersonalchoice.Whatyoudecidemaydifferfromwhatwedecided,andthat’sfine.Partofthepurposeofthisbookistohelpyoufind
yourrightbalancebetweentimeandmoney,workandplay,presentandfuture.
Didwemaketherightdecision?Didwejumpattherighttime?Forustheanswerisanunqualifiedyes.Evenwith20/20hindsightwewouldmakethesamedecisionagain,andthat’sdespiteretiringrightintothearmsoftheworsteconomiccrisissincetheGreatDepression.We’llprovide
insightsintohowweweatheredthatfinancialstormtowardstheendofthischapter,butfirstlet’stakealookatsomespecificstoseewhatourfinancialpicturelookedlikeatthemomentweretired.
NetAssetsinRetirement
ThefollowingchartpicksupwheretheCumulativeNestEggchartinthepreviouschapterleftoff.Itshowsourtotalnetassetsatretirementandbeyond,includingstocks,bonds,andrealestate.
Whenweretiredattheendof2006,ourstockholdingsstoodatabout$587,000.Theyincreasedby$40,000in2007beforeplummetingdramaticallywiththeGreatRecession.Byyear-end2008theyhaddroppedbynearly40%tojustunder$379,000,butby2010theyhadalreadyrecoveredmostoftheirlostground.
Ourbondholdings
amountedtojustunder$300,000in2007afterwesoldourhomeandinvestedtheentireproceedsinafundmirroringthetotalbondmarket.Abruptlywewentfromhavinganegligiblebondpositiontoamuchlargeronerepresentingnearlyathirdofourportfolio.Thiswasamuchhealthierportfoliobalanceforearlyretireesthana100%stockportfoliowouldhavebeen
andwasalwayspartofourplanforearlyretirement.Asthechartindicates,ourbondfundheldsteadythroughouttheGreatRecession–andinfactgrewsteadily,butwekeptwithdrawingdividendstoliveonsoitstayedflatoverallasaresult.
Ourrealestateholdingsbeganat$300,000,droppedtozerofortwoyears,thenremainedatroughly$100,000after2008.Aftersellingour
homein2007,welivedfortwoyearswithnohomeatall,rentinginsteadaswetraveled.Forthosetwoyearsourassetswereallliquid.In2009,whenrealestatepriceswereneartheirlowestduetothehousingcrisis,weboughtasmallcondoinBoulderforunder$100,000,payingforitincashwithproceedsfromourbondfund.Thecondogivesusasmallplacetocallhomewhenwe’renotonthe
road,plusasmallfootholdintherealestatemarket.
Justaftersellingourhomein2007,ourinvestmentportfoliostoodatitsall-timepeakof$975,000.Atthatpointwehadabout$350,000intaxablestockfunds,$300,000intaxablebondfunds,and$325,000intax-advantagedaccountsthatwouldremainoff-limitsandcontinuetogrowundisturbeduntilwetappedintothem
sometimeafterage59½.Thetax-advantagedaccounts,consistingofmy401(k)planandaRothIRAforeachofus,were100%investedinstockindexfunds.Allofourassetsatthatpointwereliquid,soournesteggstoodtantalizinglyclosetothe$1millionmarkinourfirstyearofretirement.
Fromapurelyfinancialperspective,itmighthavebeenwiserforustoworka
bitlongeruntilourliquidassetswereworth$1millionplusanother$100,000toputtowardssomekindofrealestateinthefuture.Slightlyover$1millionistheyardstickwewouldrecommendtoyouastheminimumamountforyournestegggoingintoretirement.Onemilliondollarsisaniceroundsumofmoney,butitdoesn’tgoasfarasitoncedid,anditwill
goevenlessfarduetotheeffectsofinflationinfutureyears.Thatamountcansafelygenerate$40,000peryear,whichisenoughforacoupletoliveonatpresentifthecoupleisreasonablyfrugalbynature.
Ifyouareveryfrugalorplantoliveoverseasinalessexpensivecountry,youmightbeabletogetbyonevenless.Wethinkwecouldliveon$30,000peryearifwedidn’t
travelsointensivelyorspentmostofourtimelivinginacountrywherethedollarstretchedfurther.Weknowotherretiredcoupleswhogetbyon$30,000orless–withtravelofamoreprudentnatureincluded–whoarequitehappywiththelivestheyareliving.
BillyandAkaishaKaderliareacaseinpoint.Theyretiredatage38andrunthehighlyusefulwebsite
retireearlylifestyle.com.Theyare“perpetualtravelers”whohavelivedonanaverageof$22,295peryear–oranaverageof$61.08perday.Theyknowthisbecausetheyhavecarefullytrackedtheirdailyexpenseseverydaysincetheyretiredin1991.
IfyouvisitBillyandAkaisha’swebsiteyouwillseethey’vehadallsortsofadventuresandhavelivedaveryfulllifeindeedonvery
littlemoney.Theyaregreatexamplesofwhatispossibleforallofusifwecanonlyconquerourfearsandtakeonthechallengeoflivinglifetothefullest.Theirstyleoftravelistobasethemselvesinacost-friendlycountrylikeMexico,Thailand,orGuatemalaandstaylongerthanwetypicallydo–oftenforyearsatatime.Thatapproachmakestheirtravellifestylemoreaffordableand
theirexperiencesallthericher.
Ifyouexpecttosupplementyourretirementincomewithsomekindofpart-timeworkorsemi-retirementoption,thatcanalsoreducethesizeofthenesteggyouneed,asdiscussedtowardstheendofthischapter.
InvestmentMixatRetirement
Thetwopiechartsshowhowourinvestmentswereroughlyallocatedbeforeandafterretirement.
Wewerevirtually100%investedinstockswhilesavingupforretirement,butweshiftedtoamixof70%stocksand30%bondsuponretiringandsellingourhome.Shortlythereafter,wefoundourselvesgratefulforeverypercentwehadinvestedinbonds,becausetheyremainedstableduringtheGreatRecessionevenwhilestocksplummeted.Afterpurchasing
ourcondofor$100,000in2009usingproceedsfromourbondfund,ourportfoliomixshiftedcloserto75%stocksand25%bondsandhasremainedinthe25-30%rangeeversince.
Asayardstickforyouonceyouretire,wewouldrecommendastock-to-bondportfoliomixof:–70/30ifyouareanaggressiveinvestor
–60/40ifyouareamiddle-of-the-roadinvestor–50/50ifyouareaconservativeinvestorAcontinuedstrong
presenceinstocksisimportantbecausestockshavethegreatestpotentialforgrowthoverthelongtermandgiveyouthebestchanceofstayingaheadofinflation.
Wecontinuetobelievean
80%to100%investmentinstocksorstockmutualfundsmakessensewhileyouarefullyemployedandactivelysavingforretirement,butyourneedschangedramaticallyonceyou’reretiredandbegindrawingdownyourinvestmentsonaregularbasis.
Atpresentwefindourselvesreluctanttolessenourpositioninstocksbecausetheyseempoisedtomake
stronggainsastheeconomymendsandmoneyflowsbackintothemarkets.We’dliketoseeournetassetscrossthemillion-dollarthresholdforthefirsttime,andwebelievestocksofferthebestpotentialtogetusthere.Thatsaid,wedoconsiderourselvesslightlyoverweightedinstocksatpresent.Astheycontinuetomovehigher,wehopetograduallyrebalanceourportfoliotoincreaseour
safetynetandmoveclosertothe70/30(orperhapseven60/40)stock-to-bondmixwe’vesuggestedtoyouasbeingidealonceyou’reinretirementmode.
AnnualWithdrawalsSinceRetirement
Sincethisisabookaboutretiringearlyonless,itwon’tsurpriseyouwetrytokeepourexpensesaslowasreasonablypossibleinretirement.Duringoursix
yearsofretirementsofar,wehavelivedon$40,000peryear,oranaverageofabout$3,300permonth.Thatamountincludesalllivingexpenses,travelexpenses,creditcardbills,andsoon.Thefollowingtableshowsourannualwithdrawalssinceretiring,includingthesourceofeachwithdrawal.
Ourtwobiggestrecurringmonthlyexpensesatpresentarecatastrophichealthinsurancepremiums($350totalatage49/50)andourcondoHOAfee($200).Otherrecurringexpenseslikecellphoneservice,basiccableandinternet,andgas/electricaveragelessthan$50eachpermonth.Carinsuranceandpropertytaxesalsoaverageouttolessthan$50per
month.Wekeepasingleprimary
creditcardanduseitforeverythingfromtraveltofuel,groceriestotakeout,andbricks-and-mortarpurchasestoAmazonpurchases.Wedonottrackexpensesorkeepamonthlybudgetperseanymore,althoughwedidsoforaperiodoftimeuntilitbecamesecondnatureforustokeeponeeyeonexpensesatalltimes.Wedobudgeton
ayearlybasis,andwehavebeencarefultostaywithinourself-imposedyearlylimitthusfar.Wehavenotneededtoadjustforinflationsofarbutmayfinditnecessarytodosoeventually.
Ourpreferrednormistowithdraw$10,000perquarter,whichmakesiteasytogaugewhetherwe’reontrackfortheyear.Weusuallywithdrawmoneyfromwhicheverfundisperforming
thebestatthemoment.Wecanrebalanceourportfoliotosomedegreesimplybytakingfromwhateverfundhasperformedbestoflate.Rebalancingataxableaccountalwayshastaxconsequences,sowetrytominimizeourrebalancingeffortstothesetypesofwithdrawals.
Ourprimarysourceofwithdrawalsoverthepastsixyearswasourinvestments:
$165,000total,or$27,500peryearonaverage.Asecondimportantsourcewasashort-termconsultingjobItookduringthedepthsoftheGreatRecession.Iearnedapproximately$65,000netduringasix-monthperiod,whichwasenoughtofund1½years’worthofretirementlivingwithoutourhavingtodrawdownourinvestmentsduringanextremelydifficultperiodinthemarkets.We’ll
talkmoreaboutpart-timeworkandsemi-retirementattheendofthischapter.
Withstocksandstockmutualfunds,itisalwaysourgoaltobuylowandsellhigh,andofcoursethatshouldbeyourgoalaswell.Ifwecan’tsellhigh,thenwerelyinsteadonadifferentstockfundthatisperformingbetter,orelseonthedividendsandinterestfromourbondfund.DuringtheGreatRecession,for
example,thestockofthecompanyforwhichIonceworkedcontinuedtoperformwellenoughthatwewereabletosellsharesofitin2008and2011whenitwasatornearitsall-timehighs.Similarly,wesoldsharesofVanguardTotalInternationalStockFundinJanuary2008whenitwasatornearitsall-timehigh.
Mostinvestmentwithdrawalssinceretirement
havebeenfromourbondfunds,whichhaveservedasourworkhorsesoverthepastsixyears.AtfirstweusedtheVanguardIntermediate-TermBondFund,relyingonitessentiallyasourcashfund.During2006(theyearbeforeweretired),weploughed$30,000intothisfund,knowingwewouldneedaccesstoreadycashoverthecomingyear.
Eventuallyweswitchedto
usingtheVanguardTotalBondMarketIndexFundbothasourprimarybondsavingsvehicleandasour“cashfund.”Wehavekepttheprincipalamountessentiallysteadyandhaveusedthedividendsitgeneratesforlivingexpenses.Thebondfundprovidesmuchbetterratesofreturnthanourbankcheckingaccountwould.Thefund’saverageannualreturnsinceinception
hasbeen6.7%.It’seasytoelectronically
transfermoneyoutoftheVanguardbondfundstoourWellsFargocheckingaccount.Theprocessonlytakestwoorthreebusinessdays,anditissoreliablewenolongerfeeltheneedtokeepaseparateemergencyfundsinceweknowwecanaccessthismoneysoeasilyinapinch.Sincethebondfundgeneratesdividendsona
monthlybasis,ittendstoreplenishitselfinareliablemanner.
Wekeepourbankholdingstoaminimumandhavejustasimplecheckingaccount.Wehavenosavingsaccount,CDs,ormoneymarkets.Bankratesaresolowinthecurrenteconomicclimatethatwefindthemunattractiveforanythingotherthanparkingthecashweanticipateneedingover
thenexttwoorthreemonths.While$40,000isthe
amountwefeelcomfortablelivingoneachyear,itmaynotbetherightamountforyou.Partofthepurposeofthisbookistohelpyoudecidewhatyouryardstickforannualwithdrawalsshouldbe.InChapter8(“DetermineYourRetirementIncomeNeeds”),wewalkyoustepbystepthroughtheprocessofhowtoestimate
youryearlyexpensesinretirementbasedonyourcurrentlivingexpenses,whichinturncanhelpyoudeterminethesizeofthenesteggyou’llneed.
IncomeTaxesinRetirement
Thefollowingtableliststheannualincometaxeswepaidfrom1990to2012,includingallfederal,state,socialsecurity,andMedicaretaxes.You’llnoticethere’squiteadifferenceinthepercentageofincometaxespaidbeforeandafterretirement.Beforeretirement
ouraverageannualincometaxasapercentageofgrosssalarywas25%.Afterretirementwetypicallypaid$0inincometaxes.EvenwhenyouincludethetemporaryconsultingassignmentIworked,theaverageincometaxoversixyearsofretirementstillcomesouttolessthan9%.
Thetableillustrateshowprecipitouslyincometaxescandroponceyouarenolongerearningwages.Forexample,inourfinalworkingyearswewerepayingnearly$40,000peryearinincometaxes–whichisthesameannualamountweareabletoliveoninretirement.In2009and2010weonceagainpaidincometaxesduetothesix-monthconsultingassignment
Itookon,whichjustgoestoshowthatsalaryandtaxestendtogohandinhand.
Itcomesdowntothis:ifyou’replanningasimpleearlyretirement,youstandagoodchanceofpayingmuchlowerincometaxesthanyou’vebecomeaccustomedtoinyourworkingyears.Youmaywanttofactorthatintoyourretirementplanning.Whileyourincometaxmaynotalwaysbezeroin
retirement,itcouldquiteconceivablybe10%orless.
Thisisgoodnewsifyou’rethinkingofretiringearlyonless:notonlydoyougetoutoftheratracesooner,youalsogettoreduceyourincometaxessooner.
DividendIncomeinRetirementLet’stakealookatone
particularyeartogetasense
ofhowincometaxesworkinretirement,especiallywithregardtodividendsandcapitalgains.In2008wehadnoincomefromwages.Insteadourincomewasbasedsolelyonwithdrawalsfromtaxableinvestments:$15,000fromVanguardTotalInternationalStockFund,$15,000fromcompanystock,and$10,000fromVanguardTotalBondMarketFund.
Thebondfundgenerated
about$1,200permonthindividendsin2008,or$14,500peryear.Weinitiallyassumedwewouldtakequiteataxhitfromthat.However,sinceourbondincomewasnolongerbeingaddedontopofearnedincomefromasalary,itnolongerhadthesametaxconsequencesitwouldhavehadduringourworkingyears.
Instead,thisdividendincomewasmorethanoffset
bytheIRS’sstandarddeductionsandexemptionsforamarriedcouplefilingjointly(totaling$17,900in2008).ThustheIRSstandarddeductionsandexemptionscanbeusedasasortofbenchmark:ifyourdividendsstayatorbelowthisbenchmark,thenyoushouldowenotaxesonsuchincome.
CapitalGainsin
RetirementInthatsameyearour
capitalgainstotaled$17,196.However,from2008to2012,qualifieddividendsandlong-termcapitalgainsweretaxedat0%ifyoufellwithinthe15%taxbracketorbelow.Partofthereasonwesoldcompanystockin2008wastotakeadvantageofthis0%ratesinceweknewourcompanystockhad
appreciatedmorethananyotherassetweowned.
It’simportanttorememberthatyouneverowetaxesonthecostbasisofthemoneyyouputintostocks,bonds,andmutualfunds.Sowhenwetook$15,000outofourInternationalStockfund,forexample,wedidn’thave$15,000incapitalgainsbecauseabout$9,800ofthatamountwascostbasis(moneyweputin).Theother
$5,200representedthelong-termcapitalgainswehadrealized,andthatwastheamountwewouldhaveowedtaxesonifourlong-termcapitalgainstaxratehadn’tbeenzero.
Withthecompanystock,onlyabout$3,000ofthe$15,000wascostbasis,sowewouldhaveowedtaxeson$12,000ofcapitalgainsina“non-zero”taxyear.
Withourbondfund,
$9,988ofthe$10,000wewithdrewwascostbasis,soweonlywouldhaveowedtaxesonabout$12ofcapitalgains.Thebondfundhadbarelyappreciatedatallfromacapitalgainsstandpoint,althoughitdidgenerateplentyofdividendsasdiscussedabove.
RetiringIntoRecession
“Ifyoudidn’tlosealotofmoneyduringthePanicof2008,youwereprobablydoingsomethingwrong,”writeBenSteinandPhilipDeMuthinTheLittleBookofBulletproofInvesting.
Well,apparentlyweweren’tdoinganythingwrong.Welostplentyover
theshortterm,andweweren’ttheonlyones.TheFederalReserverecentlyreleasednumbersindicatingthewealthoftheaverageAmericanfamilyplunged40%from2007to2010.
TheGreatRecessioncertainlytestedthetwoofusfinanciallyinwayswenevercouldhaveimaginedheadingintoearlyretirement,butwealsofoundwaystoweatherthestormandevenprosper
overthelongrun.Here’sabriefaccountofhowweretiredintosevererecession.Welearnedsomeimportantlessonsalongthewayandwouldliketosharethemwithyouhere.
WhereWeStoodPre-RecessionDuringourfirstyearof
retirementin2007,justbeforetheGreatRecession,
welivedonjustunder$40,000andsawournetworthholdsteady,evenwiththefive-monthtripwehadtakentoNewZealandandFiji.Wetookthatasagoodsign:ourinvestmentswereearningenoughtokeepupwithourwithdrawals.Weweredoingexactlywhatwehadhopedtodo:livingofftheearningsfromourinvestmentswhiletheunderlyingcapitalremained
intactandevencontinuedtogrow.
OnOctober9,2007,theDowstoodatitsall-timehighatthetimeof14,164.53andourpersonalportfoliostoodatitsall-timehighofjustover$975,000.Wewerestartingtoflirtwiththeideaofcrossingthemilliondollarthresholdforthefirsttimeandnaturallyfeltexcitedaboutit–butitwasn’ttobe.
TheRecessionStrikesDuringtherestof2007
andinto2008themarketsslidslowlybutrelentlesslydownward.TheninSeptember2008thebottomfellout.LehmanBrotherswentbankruptandalltheotherdominoesbegantofall.
Wewatchedindismayas,overthenextseveralmonths,ourportfolioshrankin
spectacularfashion.Ournetworthwentfrom$975,000inOctober2007to$683,000bytheendof2008.Thecarnagecontinuedinto2009whenourportfoliohititslowpointof$592,000onMarch9.MeanwhiletheDowhaddroppedtoanewlowof6,547–53.8%lowerthanitsOctober2007high.
Ourportfoliowasdownnearly$400,000fromitshighpoint.Thatnearly40%loss
wouldhavebeenevenworseifwehadbeen100%investedinthestockmarket,butfortunatelywehadinvestedthe$300,000fromthesaleofourhomeintoabondfundmirroringthetotalbondmarket.Thatfundstayedstableandevenwentupinvalue.Suddenlywefoundourbondholdingsrepresentedmorethan50%ofourportfoliovaluesimplybecauseourstockfund
valuationshadsunksolow.Thebondfundwasour
silverliningduringthatturbulenttime.Itprovideduswithatleastonesourcefromwhichwecouldwithdrawmoneywithoutfeelingdistraught.
PaperLossesAsforourstockfunds,
theywereterriblybeatenup,butweknewaslongaswedidn’tsellsharesofthose
funds,thelosseswereonlypaperlosses.Thatistosay,thelossesweren’tlockedinunlessweactuallysoldsharesofanyofourstockfunds,andweweredeterminednottodothat.
Toputitanotherway,westillhadthesamenumberofsharesinourstockfundsaswehadwhenthemarketswereattheirall-timehighs–it’sjustthateachsharehadlessvalue.Ifwewerepatient
enoughandwaiteduntilsharevaluationsincreasedagain,ourpaperlosseswouldbeerased.
Andindeed,aftertheMarch2009lows,stocksralliedandsharevaluationsincreaseddramaticallyduringtherestoftheyear.By2009ournetworthatyear’sendstoodat$780,000,andby2010westoodat$880,000.Thatwasstill$45,000downfromthe2007year-endclose,
butneverthelessthatwasaheckofalotbetterthanbeing$400,000down.
TreadingWaterThemainreasonour
portfoliorecoveredsowellduringthisperiodwasbecausewewithdrewverylittlemoneyfromit.Itookatemporaryconsultingjobforsixmonths,whichprovideduswithacashcushionthathelpedusrideoutthestorm
untilthemarketsrecovered.Inessencewetreadedwater,makingjustenoughsowedidn’thavetotakefromourinvestmentswhilethemarketswereattheirworst.
Inthenextsectionwetalkinmoredetailaboutpart-timeworkandsemi-retirement,butfornowsufficeittosaythatstayingflexibleandpragmaticinearlyretirementcanbeanimportantattributewhenyou’refacedwiththe
unexpected.
NoBufferforPoorMarketReturnsOneimportantlessonwe
learnedfromtheGreatRecessionwasthatonceyouenterretirementandstartlivingoffyourinvestments,youaremuchmorereliantonmarketperformancethaneverbefore.Youhavenonewmoneygoingintothemarkets
tobuffertheeffectsofpoorreturns.
Youalsolosethepsychologicalbenefitthatcomesfrominvestingnewmoneyintothemarketsduringadownturn.Youcannolongersay,“Well,atleastI’mbuyingnewsharesonsaleatalowprice,”becauseyou’renolongerbuyingnewshares.Ifanything,you’rehavingtosellsharestocoverlivingexpenses.
Technicallyspeaking,youcouldrearrangeyourexistingportfoliotoputmoremoneyintostocks,butit’sawfullyhardtotakemoneyoutofabondfundthat’sprovidingyouwithyoursolereliablesourceofincomeandputitintostocksinthemidstofavolatilemarket.Notonlywouldyoubereducingyourincomestreamatexactlythewrongmoment,butyou’dalsobeincreasingyourrisk.
Evenifyouweretotakeonatemporaryjobtotideyouoveruntilthemarketsrecovered(aswedid),you’dlikelyneedwhatevermoneyyouwereearningjusttoliveonandwouldn’tbeabletoinvestitinthestockmarketnomatterhowgoodtheopportunitiesmightlook.
WhenBadNewsIsGoodNews
Untilweretired,wehadalwayswelcomedbadnewsinthemarkets.Why?Becausebadnewsisactuallygoodnewsforbeginningandmiddle-yearsinvestors.Badnewsspellsopportunity.Thismayseemcounterintuitivebutitmakesperfectsenseonceyouthinkaboutit.IfyouhadboughtstocksinMarch2009,forinstance,whentheDowstoodataround6,500,youwould
havebeenparticipatinginanamazing50%offsale.IfyoucouldbuythelatestiPhoneforhalfoff,wouldn’tyouthinkitwasagreatdealandrushouttobuyit?Andyetwedon’talwaysbringthatsamelogictoourinvestments.
Asabeginninginvestor,yourtimehorizonissolongthatyoushouldbeexcitedaboutbadfinancialnews.Itmeansyougettobuymore
sharesforlessmoney.Ifstockpricesstayeddepressedforanotherdecade,thatwouldbefinefromyourstandpoint.Bearmarketsarelikeextendedsalesatyourfavoritestore:scoopupasmanydealsasyoucanwhilethegettingisgood.
Likewise,whileitmightbepsychologicallychallengingtowatchyourinvestmentssoarandplummetrepeatedly,such
volatilityhasnorealeffectonthebeginningormiddle-yearsinvestor.Allthatreallymattersiswhereyourinvestmentsstandwhenyoucashthemout.Ifthestockmarketgoesonamajorbullruninthelastfiveyearsofyourinvestmentplan,allthosesharesyoupurchasedatlow,lowpricesaresuddenlygoingtobearremarkablefruit.
Soforbeginningand
middle-yearsinvestorsouradviceissimple:keepinvesting.Keeptellingyourselfthemarketshavetogoupeventually.Ifyouhavea15-to20-yeartimehorizon,you’realmostcertaintobeprovenright.
WhenBadNewsReallyIsBadNewsForendgameinvestors
andretirees,badnewsreally
isbadnews.Bothgainsandlossesaremagnified.Ifthemarketssuddenlylose20%andyouhave$500,000investedinthestockmarket,that’sa$100,000lossyouhavetostomach(atleastonpaper).
Nordoyouhavetheluxuryofalongtimehorizoninwhichtorecover.Asanewretireeyouneedaccesstoatleastsomeofyourmoneynow.Ifstocksplunge,you
won’tfeelhappyabouthavingtosellthematadeeplossjusttopaythebills.It’sforthisveryreasonthatabondfundbecomescrucialonceyouretire.
SafeHavensforRetireesIfthere’sonelessonwe
learnedfromtheGreatRecession,it’sthatsavingforretirementandbeingretired
aretwoverydifferentanimals.Whilesavingforretirement,werecommendyouinvestaggressivelyinstockindexfunds.Butasyounearretirement,yourneedschangedramaticallyandyoubecomeatleastasinterestedinprotectingthecapitalyoualreadyhaveasyouareinmakingmoreofit.
Forthisreasonwerecommendyouhaveabondindexfundonceyouretire
thatrepresentsatleast25%ofyourportfolioandpreferablymore.A30%stakewouldbewiser,and40%oreven50%isn’toutofthequestionifyouconsideryourselfamoreconservativeinvestor.
Ifyouarewillingtodownsizeonceyouretire,theequityfromyourhomecanmakeforaperfecttransfusionofcashintoabondfund.Theequityinyourprimaryhomeistax-freeupto$250,000per
individualor$500,000percouple.Takethatmoneyandputitintoabondfundsothecapitalremainssafeandhopefullycontinuestogrow.OurVanguardTotalBondMarketIndexFund,forexample,hasreturned6.7%onaveragesinceinception,whichisn’thalfbadforarelativelysafeinvestment.
TwoothersafehavensworthmentioningareTIPSbondfundsandprecious
metalsfunds.TreasuryInflation-ProtectedSecurities,orTIPS,haveinflationprotectionbuiltintothemandarebackedbythefullfaithandcreditoftheU.S.government.Ifadayevercomeswhenhighinflationrearsitsuglyheadagain,TIPSshouldofferretireesasafeportinthestorm.
Forthesamereason,asmallpositioninapreciousmetalsfund–ifboughtat
reasonablevaluations–isworthconsideringbecausesuchfundstendtoruncountertothemarkets.Theyprovideyouwithasmallpoolfromwhichyoucandrinkuntilthedroughtendsandtherestofyourportfoliohastimetoheal.
Part-TimeWorkandSemi-Retirement
Thereisneveragoodtimeforasevererecession,buttheworsttime,expertssay,isrightafteryouretirebecauseyoucanendupdepletingyourcapitalfasterthanyouexpected.Yournesteggcantakeadramatichit
duringasevereandextendeddownturnintheeconomyandneverfullyrecover.Wecertainlydidn’twantthattohappenafterhavingworkedsohardtoreachthepointwherewecouldretireearly.Instead,wewantedtodoallwecouldtominimizeourwithdrawalsuntilmarketconditionsimproved.
SowhentheGreatRecessionhitandwerealizeditwouldn’tbeendingany
timesoon,webegantoconsiderouroptions.Eitherwecouldtightenourbelts–reallytightenthem–tothepointwhereweweretakingouttheminimumpossibleamounttoliveonuntilthemarketsrecovered,orwecouldearnalittlemoneyonthesidesowedidn’thavetowithdrawfromourportfolioduringatroublingtime.
Thebelt-tighteningoptionhaditsappeal,especiallyif
wecoulddoitinaforeigncountrywhereourdollarwouldstretchfurtherandwecouldenjoynewexperiencesatthesametime.Wewereactivelyconsideringsuchanoptionwhenadifferentkindofopportunitycameknockingatourdoor.
WhenOpportunityKnocksIntheendthedecision
practicallymadeitself.OutoftheblueIwasofferedatemporaryconsultingassignmentatanaerospacefirmwithineasydrivingdistanceofourcondo.Itwasforabigproposaleffortthatwasrightupmyalley.Theassignmentwasonlyexpectedtolastthreemonths,whichwasperfectasfarasIwasconcerned.Itookthejobandconsideredmyselffortunate.
Ofcourse,asoftenhappenswithproposals,theassignmentendeduplastinglongerthanexpected,soinsteadofthreemonthsIwoundupworkingsix(fromSeptember2009toFebruary2010).Butthatsixmonthsprovideduswithenoughcashfornearlytwoyears’worthofretirementliving–includinganexpensivetriptoItalyandSwitzerland(withacruisetoGreeceandTurkeythrownin
forgoodmeasure).Thatsplurgetripwasour25thweddinganniversarygifttoeachother,anditwouldn’thavebeenpossiblewithoutthetemporaryworkIhaddone.
Interestinglyenough,theconsultingassignmentturnedouttobethebestworkexperienceofmylife.Theveryfactthatitwastemporarymadeallthe
difference.IenjoyedgettingtodosomethingIwasgoodatonmyownterms.ForthatshortwindowoftimeIputmywholeheartandsoulintowinningtheproposaleffort(whichwedid,bytheway)–andthenitwasdone.TheverynextdayRobinandIjettedofftoIndiaandNepalforanunforgettablethree-monthtrip.Innotimeatalltheworkassignmentfadedawaylikeapleasantbut
distantdream.Now,wemighthavebeen
abletoliveonminimumwithdrawalsfromourinvestments–say,$25,000peryear–withsomeseriousbelttightening,butwecertainlywouldn’thavebeenabletogoonanextendedtriptoEuropewithoutthehelpofthattemporarysalary.Soyoumaywanttothinktwicebeforedismissingoutofhandthethoughtofalittlepart-
timeworkinretirement.
IntheDriver’sSeatPart-timeworkcangoa
longwaytowardspaddinganesteggthat’snotquiteashealthyasyou’dlike,oritcangiveyousplurgemoneytodosomethingyoumightnotletyourselfdootherwise.Anymoneyyouearngoesstraightintoyourpocketinsteadofbeinginvested,soevenalittlecanmakeabig
difference.Wethinkit’sabettersolutionthanfrettingaboutfinancesorfeelingstrappedforcashunnecessarily.
It’simportanttoremembernooneisholdingaguntoyourheadonceyouretireandsayingyoucan’twork.Thesedaysit’salluptoyouwhatyouwantyourretirementtobe.AsFredBrockwritesinRetireonLessThanYouThink,
“Retirementisbecomingatimenotwhenwestopwork,butwhenweworkatwhatwelove–onourownterms.”
Wecouldn’tagreemore.Financialindependenceputsyouinthedriver’sseatwhenitcomestowork.Youcantakeitorleaveitdependingonhowyoufeel.Speakingformyself,Iremainopentofutureworkassignmentsoftwotothreemonths,althoughsofartheonlynotablework
eitherofushasdoneinsixyearsofretirementhasbeenthatoneproposalassignment.
Takingamoreflexibleapproachtoretirementfranklymakesitlessfrighteningtoretireearly.Insteadofallornothing,thereistheenticingpossibilityofsomethinginbetween.It’snotsoscarytakingtheplungeifyouknowyouhavealifelinewaitingforyoujustincaseyoushould
needit.Certainlywefinditcomfortingknowingthatifthingsgettight,Robincanworkashort-termnursingstintorIcantakeonanothertemporaryproposalassignment.Orwecouldgoinacompletelydifferentdirectionandworkforasmalleramountofmoneyinaforeigncountrybutatsomethingthatwouldbringuspleasureanyway.Justconsiderthefollowingthree
opportunities.
TemptingOverseasAssignmentsWillingWorkersOn
OrganicFarms(WOOFF)offerstemptingworkassignmentsallovertheworldinexchangeforyourpart-timelaborharvestinggrapesorfeedingchickensorlearninghowtomakegoatcheese.Hey,whynot?Ifyou
haveaninterestinorganicfarminganyway,orsimplythinkitsoundscooltotryyourhandatsomethingdifferent,thenyoucouldlearnalotwhilealsohelpingsomeoneelseout.Plusyou’llgettoknowthelocalsinawayyouneverwouldhaveotherwise,whilealsovisitingapartoftheworldyou’recuriousaboutanyway.
TheCaretakerGazette(caretaker.org)offers
caretakingassignmentsallovertheU.S.andtheworld,fromwatchingsomeone’spettotemporarilyrunningaB&Btostraightforwardhousesittingrequests.We’resubscribersandhavetakenonahandfulofcaretakingopportunitiesourselves.We’veseenundemandingopportunitiesonofferinEngland,France,Italy,Australia,theCaribbean,Belize,allfiftyU.S.states,
andmanymoretemptinglocales.Someassignmentsareformoneybutmostareforlodginginexchangeforsimplework.Caretakingcanmakeyourtravelsabroadveryinexpensiveandcanletyoufitinwiththelocalcommunityinawaythetypicaltravelerdoesn’tnormallygettoexperience.
TeachingEnglishabroadhasalreadybecomesomethingofatime-honored
traditionforAmericanswhowanttodomorethanjustvisitacountryforaweek.Ifyoulovethethoughtofteachingkidsoradultssomethingyoualreadyknowbyheartanyway–thatis,yourownnativetongue–whynotconsiderit?Thiscanbeanespeciallygoodoptionincountriesthatotherwisewouldbeexpensivetovisit,suchasJapanorTaiwanorcertaincountriesinthe
MiddleEast.Whereveryoudecidetodoyourteaching,itcanaffordyouadecentsalary(comparedtothelocalcostofliving),freeorinexpensiveaccommodation,andreimbursementforyourplaneticket,nottomentiontheopportunityforculturalimmersionandregion-widetravel.
TheAppealofSemi-
RetirementSemi-retirementisa
particularlycompellingoptionforthosewhoseretirementsavingsaren’tquiteasrobustasthey’dlikethemtobe.We’vemetmanyexpatsinforeigncountrieswhoarerunningtheirownbusinesses–smallcafescateringtoAmericanswhomissburritosandpizza,forexample–tosupplement
meagerretirementsavingsorsocialsecuritychecks.Theyputinafewhoursofworkadayduringthelunchordinnerhourinexchangeforgettingtoliveinaninterestingpartoftheworldwhilealsoparticipatinginlocalcommunitylife.
Youcansemi-retiresoonerthanyoucanfullyretire,whichisanimportantbenefitinitsownright.Yournesteggcanbesmaller
becauseitonlyhastofundaportionofyourretirement.Aminimalamountofworkcanfundtherest.Whetheryouchoosetoworkjustafewhourseachdayorcarveoutafewmonthseachyearandhavetherestoftheyeartoyourselfisuptoyou,buteitherapproachcangetyoutoyourgoalofgreaterfreedominashorteramountoftime.
Semi-retirementalsoappealstothosewhoare
worriedaboutbeingboredorhavingtoomuchtimeontheirhands.“Fully80%ofAmericansbetweentheagesof40and58expecttoworkinretirement,”writesBobClyattinWorkLess,LiveMore.“Whileathirdofthoseexpecttoneedtheincome,two-thirds–orfullyhalfoftheBabyBoomgeneration–saytheyareinterestedinrotatingbetweenleisureandworkduringretirementasa
waytokeepmentallychallengedandactive.”
Workinstantlybecomeslessonerousonceit’smixedinwithbreaks–preferablylongbreaksinouropinion!Workingafewmonthsayearatsomethingyouenjoyanywayishardlyaburden,anditcanbalancenicelywithalifestyleoftravelandculturalexploration.Workinginshortburstscanbeapleasure,andmoreandmore
retireesarethinkingofretirementinjustsuchaway.Ifthisapproachappealstoyou,thenputsemi-retirementonyourradarscreenasapossibilityinyourfuture.
Semi-retirementoffersawaytodipyourtoesintotheretirementwatersandseeiftheyaretoyourliking.Itcanofferanicetransitionintofull-timeretirement,oritcanbecomeyourmodusoperandiforyearstocome.It’syour
choice.
Chapter4.Your
RoadmaptoEarly
RetirementOurgoalinthenextten
chaptersistoprovideyou
withpracticaladviceonhowtogetfromPointAtoPointB–fromfull-timeworktofinancialindependence–intheleastamountoftimeandwithaminimumoffussanddetours.InessenceChapters5to14constitutearoadmaptoearlyretirementthatyoucanfollowstepbysteptogettoyourdestination.
TaketheHighway
Sometimesitjustmakessensetotakethehighwayandavoidallthestoplightsandtrafficonlocalroads.Insimilarfashion,youwanttomakesureyougetontothefinancialhighwayasearlyaspossibleandstaythereuntilyoureachyourexit.Thatmeansinvestingprimarilyin
stocksandstockmutualfunds,notcashorbonds,duringmostofyourinvestingyears.Why?Becausestocksarethehighway:theyofferthefastest,mostdirect,andmostreliablewaytogettoyourgoal.
Youalsowanttomakesureyourvehicle–whichistosayyourcareer–isuptothetaskofgettingyouthere.Don’tgetontothehighwayinaclunkerandfindyoucan’t
keepup–orworseyet,breakdownbythesideoftheroad.Instead,purchaseareliablecar(apracticalcareer)firstandsaveyourselfawholelotoftroubleontheroadahead.
AvoidShortcutsShortcutsmakeforlong
delays,asthesayinggoes.Tryingtotaketoomanyshortcutsontheroadtoearlyretirementcanendupbackfiringonyou.Byshortcutswemeananyhigh-riskinvestmentaimedatgettingrichquickratherthangettingrichslowly.Daytrading,currencytrading,
optionstrading,investinginhedgefunds,investinginriskystocks,goingall-inonthenextbigthing,investinginfinancialproductsyoudon’treallyunderstand,andinvestinginanythingthatseemstoogoodtobetrueallfallunderthecategoryofshortcutstobeavoidedifyou’refollowingagetrichslowlyapproach.
Wedon’tmeantoimplythere’sanythingwrongwith
gettingrichquickifyoucandoitreliably,butit’snotwhatthisbookisabout.Plentyofotherbookscoverthattopic.Gettingrichquickisabitlikebobbingandweavingthroughtraffictogettoyourdestinationjustasfastasyoucan,whereasgettingrichslowlyismorelikedrivingonthehighwaybutstayinginthemiddlelane.Itmaynotbewind-in-your-hairexhilarating,butitoffersa
relativelysafeandpredictablewayofgettingyoutoyourgoal.
MilestonesAlongYourRoute
Hereisapreviewofwhat’scomingdownthepike.Thefirstmilestoneonyourrouteisentitled“InvestinYourselfFirst”(Chapter5),anditcomesfirstforareason.Withoutareliablecareer,everythingelseabout
yourjourneybecomesmoredifficult.
Thenextmilestoneis“GetOutofDebt”(Chapter6),anditcomessecondforareasontoo.We’llexplainwhywerecommendyoupayoffallcreditcards,carloans,andcollegeloansfirstbeforebeginningtoinvestinearnestforretirement.
Thenextsixmilestonesarealldedicatedtothespecificsofhowtoinvest
successfullyforearlyretirement:
–Howtousecompoundingtoyouradvantage(Chapter7)–Howtocalculateyourlikelyincomeneedsinretirement(Chapter8)–Howtodeterminethesizeofthenesteggyou’llneed(Chapter9)–Howtoputtogethera
personalizedinvestmentplan(Chapter10)–Howtoputyourindexfundinvestmentsonauto-pilot(Chapter11)–Howtoallocatebetween401(k),IRA,andtaxableaccounts(Chapter12)Arewethereyet?Not
quite.Therearetwomoremilestonesalongyourroute,bothofthemhavingtodowithhowtokeepyour
expenseslowsoyoucanretiresoonerandstayretiredonless.It’sfranklyhardtofindaretirementbookouttherethatdoesn’thaveachapterdevotedtothesubjectoflivingbelowyourmeans(Chapter13).Why?Becauseit’sprobablythesinglemostimportantthingyoucandotoreachearlyretirementandstayretired.“Livebelowyourmeans”mightseemlikeoverlyobviousadvice,but
obviousdoesn’talwaysequatewitheasytoimplementinreallife.Weprovidepracticalguidanceonhowtoputthisadviceintopractice.Thelastroadmapchapter(Chapter14)providesfurtherdetailsonhowtokeeptwoofyourbiggestexpensesinlife–homeandcars–aslowasreasonablypossible.
Afterthatit’sabouttimeforareststop.“KeepYourLifePortfolioBalanced”
(Chapter15)remindsyoutobalancelivingfortodaywithlivingfortomorrowlestyourunoutofenergyalongtheway.
Thefinaltwochaptersinthebookcoversubjectsofparticularinteresttothosewhohavealreadyreachedtheirdestination.Howtopayforhealthcarehasalwaysbeenaconcernforjustaboutanyonewhohaseverconsideredretiringearly.In
“HealthCareinRetirement”(Chapter16),wesharegoodnewsabouttheAffordableCareActinAmericaandmedicaltourismoverseas,bothofwhichbodewellforearlyretireesonabudget.
Wefinishupwithachapteronextendedtravelinretirement(Chapter17).Hereweoffersuggestionsonhowtokeepyourtravelcostsdownasyouheadoffonjourneysthelikesofwhich
youcouldonlydreamaboutduringyourworkingyears.Sincelong-termtravelisboththemotivationandtherewardformanyearlyretirees,wethinkthismakesforafittingandfunfinalchapter.
Chapter5.Investin
YourselfFirstBytheageof31Robin
andIonlyhadatotalofabout$6,500investedforretirement,andthatwasprimarilyinmy401(k)atwork.Itwasastartbutwe
wantedtodomore–alotmore.Wewantedtoaccelerateoursavings.Buthow?Wehadverylittlefatlefttotrimoutofourbudget.Whatweneededwasn’tawaytocutexpensesmorebutawaytomakemoremoney.
“IshouldprobablyfindoutwhatI'mworthinthebusinessmarketplacenowthatI'vegotthreeyearsofexperienceundermybelt,”Iwroteinmyjournalaround
thatsametime.“Increasingmysalarywouldbethequickestwaytospeedusalongonourfinancialhighway.”
Yes!Nowyou’retalking,youngerme.
Ittookmelongerthanmostpeople,butIwasfinallywakinguptothefactthatIhadtomakestridesinmycareerifIeverwantedmyearlyretirementdreamstobemorethanjustdreams.It
wouldtakeusanotherfiveyearsbeforewerealizedthatRobin,too,neededtoswitchcareersandretrainasanurse.Callusslowlearners,buteventuallywecametotheconclusionthatweareourownbestinvestments.Hopefullyyoucanlearnthislessonsoonerthanwedidandprofitfromit.
WhyMinimumWageWon’tWork
Ifyoufindyou’rebarelyabletomakeendsmeetwiththesalaryyou’recurrentlymaking,weadviseyoutoinvestinyourselffirstbeforedoinganyotherinvesting.Workingalow-wagejobwon’tgetyouwhereyou
wanttogofastenough.Toretireearlyyouhavetolivebelowyourmeanssoyoucaninvestanyextramoneyandstartbuildingupacapitalbase.Howcanyoudothatifittakeseverycentyouhavejusttogetby?
Thefederalminimumwageiscurrently$7.25perhour.Assumingaforty-hourworkweek,that’s$15,000peryear.That’sbarelyenoughformostpeopleto
surviveonintheU.S.thesedays.Itdoesn’tgiveyouthewherewithaltoputsufficientmoneyasidetoallowforanearlyretirement.Youmaybethehardestworkerintheworld,butifyou’reinafieldthatpayslowwages,you’regoingtofindithardgoingatbest.Soinsteadwesuggestyouputyourhardworkethictoworkonyourselffirst.
ChoosingaPracticalCareer
Investinginyourselffirstmeansgettinganeducationinsomethingpracticalthatyouknowaheadoftimewillpaywellonceyougraduate.Theeducationmaybeexpensive,butifyouknowthereareattractivejobsthatpaywellandareinhighdemandontheothersideofthat
education,itwillbewortheverypennyyouspendonitandmoretomakeithappen.
Theeducationwe’retalkingaboutisn’tnecessarilyafour-yeardegreeatacollegeoruniversity.Itcouldbethatifyouhaveaspecificcareerinmindthatexpresslyrequiresit.Butbeforeyougodownsuchalongandfinanciallyarduouspath,makesurethereisastrongdemandforworkersinthat
field,thattheonlyindividualswhocanfillsuchjobsarepeoplewiththeeducationyou’reabouttoget,andthatthejobspayhighlyenoughtojustifysuchaprolongedeffort.
Otherwise,therearemanycareersthatpayreasonablywellbutcallforamorefocusedsetofcoursesthatcanbecompletedinayearortwo.ThinkLPNinthenursingfield(orRNifyou
alreadyhaveacollegedegree);EMTorparamedic;dentalhygienist;loanofficer;paralegal;technicalwriter;executiveassistant;policeofficer;plumberorelectrician;automechanic;realestateagent;customsofficer;securityalarminstaller;HVACtechnician;salesrepresentative;etc.Dosomebrainstormingandwebsurfingtogetideasflowingasyouconsiderawiderangeof
possiblecareerchoices.Don’tbeafraidtothink
outsidethebox.Forinstance,youmightconsiderthepossibilityofgoingtoatradeschool,orstartingyourownbusiness,orrunningafranchise,orbecominganentrepreneur.Youmaywanttofocusyourattentiononfieldsinwhichhumansaren’tlikelytobereplacedbycomputersanytimesoon.Theclassicexampleisnursing.
Youdon’tneedtobecomeadoctororalawyerorearnanoutrageouslyhighsalarytoretireearly,butyoudoneedtohaveadecentjobpayingadecentwage–say,inthe$50,000range.Ifyou’reearning$30,000orlessandhavelittlehopeofmakingmore,youshouldconsideracareerchangebecauseotherwiseyou’remakingitharderonyourselfthanithastobe.
Thecareeryouchoosedoesn’thavetobeyourall-timedreamcareer.Itshouldcertainlybesomethingyoudon’thatedoingbecauseyou’regoingtohavetodoitforawhile–probably15yearsormore.Itwouldbevastlypreferabletolikewhatyoudo,butit’ssomecomforttorememberyouaren’tweddedtoyourjobforlifebutonlyuntilyouretireearly.
BitingtheBulletandRetraining
Robin’sfirstcareerwasasatravelagent.Backthenjustabouteveryonewenttoatravelagenttobooktheirairfare,hotels,cruises,carrentals,andsoforth.TherewasnoExpediaorTravelocityoronlineairfarebooking.Travelagentswerethedefactoexpertsinall
thingstravel.Itwasanenjoyablecareerwithgreattravelperks,butitneverpaidwell.Robin’sstartingsalarywas$14,000grossperyearanditneverwentupmuchfromthere,despitethefactshebecameahighlycompetenttravelagentwithmorethan12yearsofexperienceinthebusiness.
Bythemid-1990sithadbecomepainfullyobviousthatpersonalcomputerswere
makingRobin’sjobobsolete.Moreandmorepeoplewerebookingtheirtravelonline,andwhocouldblamethem?Itwasfast,simple,anddirect.Airlinesandhotelsbegantorealizetheydidn’tneedtravelagentsanymoretorepresenttheirbusinesses.Theynolongerhadtorelyonamiddleman:theycouldselldirecttotheircustomers.Asaresulttheystartedcuttingcommissionstotravelagents.
Robincouldseethewritingonthewall.Beingatravelagentsimplywasnotacompatiblecareerchoicewithwantingtoretireearly.
ReinventingYourselfRobinrealizedsheneeded
toinvestinherselffirstbeforeshecoulddomuchtohelpwithinvestingforourretirement.Bythenitwas1998andwehadbeensavingfor7years.Thatwasnearly
halfofour15-yearplan,andyetwestillonlyhadanesteggsavedupofabout$68,000.
Wefeltproudofthataccomplishmentonapersonallevelbecauseweknewhowhardithadbeentosetasideeventhatmuchmoneywithsalariesaslowasourshadbeen.Butclearlyweweregettingnowherefast.Ineededtorededicatemyselftomakingmoreprogressin
myownfield(Iwasaproposalcoordinatormakingabout$40,000peryear),andRobinneededtochangefieldsaltogether.
Aftermuchsoul-searchingshechoseacareerinnursing.Shelikedtheideaofhelpingpeopleanddoingsomethingmeaningful,and,onthepracticalside,nursingpaidreasonablywellandtherewereopeningsalloverthecountryfortrainednurses.
Therewasjobsecurityinthesensethatnocomputerwasgoingtomakethiscareerobsoletelikeitdidherlast.
Sofor1½yearsRobinwentbacktoschoolagaintoreinventherselfandbecomeanurse.Shepassedherprerequisitesatalocalcommunitycollege,gotacceptedtoarigorousone-yearacceleratednursingprogramatRegisUniversityinDenver,andendedup
graduatingthirdinherclass.Ithelpedthatshewasmotivatedandknewexactlywhatshewanted.ShewastednotimegettinghiredasanursestraightoutofRegisandimmediatelyputhernewfoundknowledgetotheteststartingin2000.
TheCostofRetraining–andtheReward
Theone-yearnursingprogramsetusback$20,000(plusthelostopportunitycostofherbeingunemployedfor1½yearsandnotmakingthe$15,000peryearsheotherwisewouldhavemade).Wehadtoborrow$10,500inStaffordloansandanother$5,000fromthebanktohelpcovertheeducationcosts.
Thinkofit:herewewere,rightinthemidstofourprimaryinvestingyears,and
insteadofearningmoney,Robinwasneedingtospenditonre-educatingherself.Butitwasanecessaryexpenseandwebothknewit.Shehadtoinvestinherselffirst,andwetrustedthatinthelongrunitwouldbetherightdecisionandbearfruit.
Anditdid.Inherfirstyearofnursingshemorethandoubledherprevioussalary.Shewentfrommaking$15,000asatravelagentto
$39,000asanurse.Justsixmonthsafterfinishinghernursingprogram,wehadalreadymanagedtopaybackeverycentoftheloans.
Bythefollowingyearshewasmaking$45,000,andtheyearafterthat$50,000andstillgoingup.Nowshewasearningasalarythatcouldgenuinelyhelpuswithinvestingforearlyretirement.
Canyouseehowimportantitwasforustobite
thebulletandpayforthistrainingfirst?Eventhoughitmeanthavingtospendmoneyovertheshortterm,Robinearnedenoughinherfirstyearofnursingtomorethanpaybackherstudentloans.One-and-a-halfyearsofretrainingsetheronareliableearningspathforlife.
Suddenlyshewaseminentlyemployable.Wecouldliveanywhereinthecountryandknowshecould
findwork.Andifweweretoretireearlyanddiscoverourfinancesweretootight,weknewinapinchshecouldfallbackonhernursingbackgroundandfindtemporaryworktotideusover.
Thisgaveusanewfoundsenseofconfidence.Weendedupbeingabletoretireearlierthanoriginallyplanned,inlargepartbecauseweknewbothourcareers
offeredgoodopportunitiesfortemporaryemploymentshoulditeverbecomenecessary.Youmaywanttoconsiderwhetheryourowncareerskillsareportableandcanbecarriedintoearlyretirementtomakethetransitionalittlelessintimidating.
EarningDoubleImagineforamoment
whatitwouldbeliketohaveasalarydoublewhatyou’reearningnow.It’snotimpossible,especiallyifyourcurrentsalaryisunder$30,000.Justpictureit:ifyouwereearning$50,000or$60,000,thenwithalittleself-disciplineyoucouldcontinuelivingatthesame
(orslightlyhigher)standardoflivingwhileinvestingtheresttowardsrapidlyachievingfinancialindependence.
Investinginyourselffirstwillalmostcertainlybethebestinvestmentyouevermake.Thinkofitthisway:Ifyou’reearning$30,000peryear,it’sgoingtotakealotofscrimpingandsavingtoinvesteven$5,000peryear.Butat$60,000peryearyoucouldeasilyinvest$20,000
andstillhaveasufficientamountleftovertoliveon.That’sfourtimestheamountyoucouldhaveinvestedotherwise.Thestockmarketisn’tgoingtogiveyouthosekindsofreturns.Butforaslongasyoustayemployed,whetheritbefor10yearsor20,youcancountonsimilarlyamazingresultsyearafteryear.Howmanyotherinvestmentscanmakethatclaim?
Retoolingforasuccessfulcareerissoimportantthatwebelieveitistheoneandonlythingforwhichyoushouldtakeoutaloanevenafteryou’vebegunsavingforearlyretirement.Everywhereelseinthisbookwerecommendpayingoffyourdebtsfirst,butifyoufindyourselfinalow-payingordead-endjob,yousimplyhavetoremedythatsituationfirst.Justbesuretochooseapractical
careerpaththatwillrapidlybearfruitafterwards.
DoingYourCareerHomework
Asanexampleofanimpracticalapproachtocareerdevelopment,Iofferupmyowncautionarytale.Iearnedmymaster’sdegreeinEnglishliteraturein1989.AtthetimeIintendedtobecomeacollegeprofessor,which
wasafinegoalinandofitself.FineexceptforthefactthatIhadneverdonealickofteachinginmywholelifeandhadnoideawhetherIwouldlikeitornot.IknewIlikedtheperksofteachingandtheprospectofworkinginanacademicenvironment,butwhataboutthejobitself?IfIhadgivenanythoughttohowIwouldfitintotherole,itmighthavesavedmealotofmisdirectedtimeandenergy.
Asitwas,whenIfinallydidgetupinfrontofmyfirstclassroom,ittookmealloffiveminutestodiscoverIwasn’tatallsuitedtobeingateacher.Iwasn’tcomfortablestandinginfrontofalargegroupofcollegefreshmenandbeingthecenterofsomuchattention.HowcoulditbethatIwasalreadypartwaydowntheroadtowardsgettingmyPh.D.beforediscoveringthis?
Isomehowmadeitthroughthatfirstsemesterofteaching,butInevergrewmorecomfortableintherole.IcouldhavesavedmyselfandmypoorstudentsawholelotoftroubleifIhaddonetheslightestbitofcareerhomeworkfirst.MydegreeinEnglishliteraturewasnotveryusefuloutsidetheacademicworld,soitiswithmyownnaiveapproachtocareerdevelopmentinmind
thatIurgetodoalittleresearchfirstbeforegoingdownaparticularcareerpath.Firstandforemost,makesureit’sajobyoucanstomachdoing!
Robindidhercareerhomeworkbeforeshebecameanurse.Earlyonintheprocesssheshadowedanurseforaday,talkedtootherpeoplewhowereLPNsandRNs,andlearnedfromthemwhichnursingprogramswere
mosthighlyrespected.Duringhereducationshegotplentyofhands-onexperienceinclinicalsettings,soshealreadyknewwhatshewasgettingherselfintobythetimeshegotherdegree.
SuperchargingYourCareer
Mostofuslivelongenoughthesedaystohavemorethanonecareer–sogoahead,reinventyourself.Pickanewcareerpathandmakeithappen.Thetruthis,youneedtoflourishfinanciallyinordertobuildupanestegglargeenoughtoletyouretireearly.Youcan’tjustgetby.
Onceyoumaketheswitchtoabettercareer,allthingsbecomepossible.WithRobinmaking$50,000peryear,wecouldliveonhersalaryaloneandinvestallofmysalary.Suddenlywecouldtakegiantstridesforward.WedidmostofourreallygoodinvestingafterRobin’snursingcareergotunderway–andthatwasn’tuntilmorethanhalfwaythroughour15-yearplan.Atthatpointwe
werehittingonallcylindersandwereabletosockawaysignificantamountsofmoneyinarelativelyshortperiodoftime.
ImagineifRobinhadbegunherretrainingatthebeginningofourretirementplanning.Insteadof7yearsofhigherwages,wemighthavehad14yearsofsolidearningshelpingusalongonourpathtofinancialindependence.
Investinginyourselffirstdoesn’talwaysmeangoingbacktoschoolformoreeducation;itcouldmeansimplyapplyingyourselfmorevigorouslytothejobyoualreadyhave.ThiswasthecaseformeonceIbecameaproposalcoordinator.Ialreadyhadthenecessaryeducationandskillsetformyjob,butwhatIneededwastoapplymyselfwithgreaterenergy.Ihadto
tryharder,sayyesmoreoften,takeontheharderprojectsnooneelsewantedtoundertake,andworkwithincreasedefficiencyandenthusiasm.Ihadtotreateachproposalasifitmatteredtomepersonally.
WhenIdidthat,theresultsspokeforthemselves.Wewonmoreproposals,andovertimeIbecamemorevaluabletomycompanybasedontheskillsIhad
developed.AsIgainedabettersenseofmyworthinthemarketplace,Iwasabletoparlayajobofferfromacompetingfirmintoanincreasedsalaryatmyexistingjob.Ifyouknowyou’redoingmeaningfulworkthataddstothecompany’sbottomline,thenbeingwillingtoaskrespectfullyformorecompensationcanbeanimportantcontributortoyour
careergrowth.Ouroriginalretirement
worksheetswoefullyunderestimatedjusthowmuchoursalarieswouldgrow–andhowmuchextramoneywewouldbeabletoinvestasaresult.Wehadtoreviseouryearlysavingsestimatessignificantlyupwardsinordertoaccountforthenewrealityoftwojobspayingsolidwages.Youmaylikewisefindyourself
pleasantlysurprisedontheupside.Dowhatyoucantosuperchargeyourcareerandyou’llendupsuperchargingyourinvestmentsaswell.
Chapter6.GetOutof
DebtIfyou’renotindebt,
congratulations–youcanskipthischapter!Otherwisewestronglyrecommendyougetoutofdebtfirstbeforeyoustartsavingfor
retirement.Payoffcreditcarddebts,carloans,collegeloans,andanyotherloansyoumighthavesotheonlydebtyouhaveleftisyourhomemortgage.
Whydowemakeanexceptionforhomemortgages?Becausebuyingahomeissoexpensivethatmostpeoplefinditimpossibletoownahomewithoutfirstgettingalong-termloanfromafinancial
institution.Yourhomeisalsoaninvestmentoverthelongterm,sothereisgoodjustificationforowningratherthanrentingforsomanyyears.Butallotherdebtbesidesyourhomemortgageismanageable–andshouldbemanagedaggressively.
Yourfirstpriorityshouldbetoeliminatedebtsoyoucanstartyourinvestmentprogramwithacleanslate.Yoursecondpriorityshould
betobuildupasmallreserveofcashtofallbackonincaseofemergency.Oncethosetwoprioritieshavebeenmet,you’rereadytobegininvestinginearnestforearlyretirement.
WhyYouShouldPayDownDebtBeforeInvesting
Youmaybesayingtoyourself,“ButI’mreallyanxioustostartmakingsomeinvestmentsnow!Whycan’tIpaydownmydebtandbeginmakinginvestmentsatthe
sametime?”Well,inonespecific
instanceyoushould.Ifyouhappentohavea401(k)atwork,wewouldrecommendyouinvesttheminimumamountnecessarytotakeadvantageofthefullcompanymatch,whichisessentiallyfreemoney.Butotherwise,unlessfreemoneyisinvolved,itusuallymakesbettersensetogetoutofdebtfirstbeforebeginningto
invest.Here’swhy.Let’ssayyouget
ambitiousandmanagetopayoffyourcreditcardbalancewiththe17%interestrateawholeyearearlierthanyouwouldhaveotherwise.That’sonewholeyearofnothavingtopay17%interest–andthat’stheequivalentofgettinga17%guaranteedreturnoninvestmentfortheyear.Toputitanotherway,nothavingtopay17%ona
$1,000balanceonyourcreditcardsavesyou$170,justasmaking17%ona$1,000investmentmakesyou$170.Making$170andsaving$170aretwosidesofthesamecoin.
Mostpeoplewouldagree17%isaprettygoodreturnoninvestment.We’dfeelverypleasedindeedifwecouldgetthatkindofreturnonaconsistentbasis.Soitonlymakesfinancialsenseto
payoffthe17%creditcardbalancefirst,beforebeginningtoinvestelsewhereatwhatwillprobablybealowerrateofreturn.Evenifyouhappentohaveloansthatonlychargeyou8%or9%interest,that’sstillaprettydecentrateofguaranteedreturn.Sopaythemofffirstandbedonewiththem.
Beyondtheobviousfinancialrationaleforpayingoffyourdebtearly,there’s
alsothepsychologicalone.Simplyput,itfeelsgoodtobeoutfromunderaloadofdebtandnotoweanyoneanymoney.It’slikeaburdenhasbeenliftedoffyourshoulders.
Anemergencycashreservelightenstheloadevenmorebygivingyouafinancialcushionifyourcarshouldsuddenlybreakdownoryourfurnaceshouldgoonthefritzorsomeotherbigexpenseshouldhit
unexpectedly.Asmallstashofcashisyourgetoutofjailfreecardforwhentheunforeseenhappens–whichitinevitablywill.
WhyYouShouldn’tBorrowFromYourself
AsofJanuary2013,averagecreditcarddebtamonghouseholdscarryingsuchdebtwasawhopping$15,442.Whenyouconsidertheaveragerateofintereston
thatdebtisaround15%,it’snowonderweheartalkofpeople“drowningindebt”orbeing“uptotheireyeballsindebt.”Meanwhile,averagestudentdebtisnearly$35,000,soyoungpeopleinparticulararestrugglingtogetoutfromunderamountainofdebtthatmustoftenfeellikeitiscrushingthem.
IfyouareamongthehalfofAmericanhouseholds
carryinganunpaidcreditcardbalanceoverthepast12months,yourfirstorderofbusinessafterlandingasolidjobshouldbetoaggressivelypaydownthatdebtbeforeitcanbecomeanymoreunmanageable.
PoorFutureYouThesadtruthis,eachtime
youletthebalanceonyourcreditcardsrolloveranothermonth,you’reborrowing
fromyourownfuture.You’reessentiallysubsidizing“currentyou”bytakingfrom“futureyou”andsaying“putitonhistab.”Let’sbehonest:futureyouisn’tgoingtohaveanymoremoneythancurrentyouhasifyoukeepstickinghimwiththebill!
Youpayinabigwaywhenyouborrowfromyourownfuture.Youparticularlypayintheformofexorbitantinterestrateschargedby
creditcardcompanies,whichgooutoftheirwaytomakeitaseasyaspossibleforyoutopaytheminimumbalanceeachmonthandstayunderwaterforanotherday,anothermonth,anotheryear.It’sfranklyintheirownfinancialinteresttokeepyouunderwater.Theyreallydon’tmindseeingyoudrowningindebt(oratleaststrugglingalittle)becauseitmeansmoremoneyforthem.
WhataDeal:19½YearsatTwicethePriceHere’sagoodruletolive
by:nevermakejusttheminimummonthlypaymentonyourcreditcards.Here’swhy.Let’ssayyouhave$4,000onacreditcardwitha20%annualpercentagerateonoutstandingbalances.Andlet’ssayyoucurrentlymake
theminimumpaymentof3%permonth.Nowlet’sfigureouttogetherhowmuchandhowlongitwilltakeyoutopayitback:1.$4,000(creditcardbalance)x3%(minimumpayment)=$120minimumpaymentforthefirstmonth.2.Outofthat$120minimumpayment,$66.66isinterest($4,000x20%annualinterestrate÷12
months=$66.66).3.Theremaining$53.34isprincipal($120–$66.66interest=$53.34principal).4.Attheendofthefirstmonth,yourremainingbalancestandsat$3,946.66($4,000–$53.34principalpayment=$3,946.66).5.Thesamecalculationisperformednextmonth,andthemonthafterthat,andsoon,untilthecreditcarddebt
isfinallypaidoff.Ifyoukeepmakingjusttheminimumpayments,youroriginalcreditcarddebtof$4,000willcostyou$8,741topayback.That’s$4,000tocovertheoriginalprincipalplusanother$4,741ininterest–morethantheoriginalcreditcarddebtitself!6.Itwilltakeyou19½yearstomakethe235minimum
payments!Canyouseehowyouend
upsabotagingyourownfuturewhenyouplaybytherulesofthecreditcardcompanies?Stopplayingbytheirrulesandstartplayingbyyourown.Let’sseewhatspecificstepsyoucantaketostartgettingoutofdebtrightnow.
UsingCreditCardCalculators
Creditcardcalculatorsallowyoutoinstantlycalculatehowlongitwilltakeyoutogetoutofdebtbasedonthemonthlypaymentamountyouenter.Thesefreecalculatorsareusefultoolsthatletyouexperimentwith
differentmonthlyscenarios.Payingeven$50morethantheminimummonthlypaymentamountcanmakeahugedifference,forexample,intermsofthetimeitwilltaketopayoffthebalanceandthetotalinterestyou’llpay.Themoreaggressiveyourpaybackplan,themoreimpressivetheresults.
Weparticularlylikethetoolsofferedatcreditcards.com/calculators.
TheirMinimumPaymentCalculatorinstantlyshowsyouhowpainfullylonganddrawn-outtheloanpaymentprocessisifyouonlymaketheminimummonthlypayments.TheirPayoffCalculatorisevenmorehelpful:itletsyouruntwousefulscenarios.Inthefirst,youenterthe“DesiredMonthstoPayOff”yourdebtandthecalculatorautomaticallydeterminesthe
monthlypaymentyouwouldneedtomaketopayoffyourbalanceinthedesiredtime.Inthesecondscenario,youenteryour“DesiredMonthlyPayment”amountandthecalculatorautomaticallydeterminesthenumberofmonthsitwouldtaketopayoffyourbalance.Calculatorslikethisallowyoutomakeinformedchoicesaboutyourfuturebasedonthespecificsofyourownsituation.
DecidingWhichDebtsToPayOffFirst
Werecommendpayingoffthedebtwiththehighestinterestratefirst,thenmovingontothenext-highestrate,andsoon,inalogicalprogressionuntilallyourdebtsarepaidoff.Ourthinkingis,whygiveaway
anymoreofyourmoneythanyouhaveto?
Butanotherschoolofthoughtsuggestsyoushouldgetsomequickwinsunderyourbeltbypayingoffthesmallestdebtfirst,enablingyoutobuildupmomentumtogetyour“debtsnowball”rolling.Thisapproachhassomevaliditytoo.It’slesslogicalfinanciallybutperhapsmoreagreeablepsychologically.
Whicheverapproachworksforyouisfine,aslongasyou’remakingrealprogresstowardsreducingyouroveralldebt.
SettingMonthlyGoalstoTackleDebt
Thebestwaytotackledebtistosetmonthlygoalsforyourself.Settinggoalsgivesyouagameplanandletsyouknowwhatyou’reaimingfor.It’simportanttobeasrealisticaspossiblewhenmakingyourplan.If
yousetthebartoohigh,you’resettingyourselfupforfailure.Ifyousetittoolow,itwilltakeyoutoolongtoreachyourgoal,andthatcanbediscouraginginitsownright.Youwanttofindabalancepointbetweentimeandmoneythatfeelsrighttoyou.
Let’slookatanexample.Let’ssayyouhave$20,000indebt.Thatincludesallyourdebt–creditcards,thelast
fewpaymentsonacarloan,andacollegeloan.Youwanttopayitoffasquicklyaspossible,soyougotooneofthedebtpaymentcalculatorsonlinetodeterminewhatisfeasible.
Firstyoutrypluggingin12monthsasyourdesiredpayoffdate.Theresultssayitwouldtakenearly$1,800permonthtopayoffthedebtinthatperiodoftime,andyourealizestraightawaythere’s
nowayyoucanaffordthatkindofmonthlypaymentgivenwhatyou’recurrentlyearning.Nextyoutry24monthsand36months,andtheresultscomeinataround$950and$700permonthrespectively,bothofwhichseemfeasible.Last,youtry48monthsanddiscoverthatwouldrunyou$550permonth,whichisn’tthatmuchlessthanpayingitoffin36months.Foranextra$150per
monthyoucouldbedoneinthreeyearsinsteadoffour.Plus,somethinginsideyoujustgroansatthethoughtofstillbeingindebtfouryearsfromnow,soyoudecidetoeliminatethatoption.
Nowyou’vebracketedyoursolution.Youknowyoucan’tpayitoffin12monthsandyouknowyoudon’twanttowaitfouryearstopayitoffifyoucanhelpit.Thatleavesyouwithtwosolutionsinthe
middle:either24monthsor36months.
Whichoftheoptionsyouchooseisuptoyou.Ifyouwanttogetoutofdebtmorethananythingelseintheworld,gowiththetwo-yearplan.Ifyouwanttolivealittlemorecomfortablyinthecomingyears,gowiththethree-yearplan.Eitherway,you’vemadeagoodplan.You’vecomeupwithawaytopayoffyourdebtsintwo
orthreeyears’time,whichfeelsaboutright.Ithitsthatbalancepointbetweentimeandmoney.
Witheitheroftheseplans,youcanmakeadjustmentsasyougo.Ifyouchoosethe36-monthoptionbutyoursalaryjumpssignificantlythefollowingyear,youcanalwaysincreaseyourmonthlypayments.Orifyouchoosethe24-monthoptionbutunanticipatedexpensescrop
up,youcanalwaysdecreaseyourpaymentstobringtheminlinewiththe36-monthplan.
Thegoodnewsis,theself-disciplineittakestosetmonthlygoalsandgetoutofdebtisexactlythesamedisciplineneededtosavelargeamountsofmoneyforearlyretirement.Thinkofgettingoutofdebtasatrialrun.Onceyou’vedonethat,you’rereadyforthemain
event:savingupenoughmoneytobecomefinanciallyindependentforlife.
UsingOnePrimaryCreditCard
Werecommendyouusejustoneprimarycreditcardandpayoffthebalanceinfulleachmonth.Don’tshortchangeyourownfuturebylivingindebtforevenonemonthifyoucanhelpit.
Havingasinglecardyou
activelyusemakesiteasytotrackexactlyhowmuchyouoweeachmonthsotherearenounpleasantsurprises.Webelievekeepingthingssimpleandknowingwhereyoustandeachmonthtrumpsthesmallsavingsyoumightrealizebyusingaslewofdifferentcreditcards,eachspecifictoonestore.Yourwalletandyourfinancialburdenswillbelighterwithjusttheonecreditcard.
Onceyou’recertainyouhavetheself-disciplineittakestouseonlyonecard,youmaywanttoconsiderhavingabackupcreditcardstoredsomewheresafejustincaseyourmaincardislostorstolenorotherwisebecomesinactive.Morethanoncenow,we’vehadourprimarycardstopworkingduetoapotentialsecuritybreachatsomestoreorother.Althoughanewcardwasautomatically
reissuedandmailedtoourhomeaddress,wewereoverseasatthetimeandcouldn’tpickitup.Insuchcircumstancesabackupcreditcardcanbeareallifesaver.
Chapter7.StartSaving
EarlyWesometimeswishwe
couldhaveado-overofourtwentiesfromapersonalfinancesstandpoint.Insteadofmakingfocuseddecisionsthatcouldhaveallowedusto
startsavingforfinancialindependencesooner,wedriftedsidewaysanddidn’tstartsavinginearnestuntilage31.Ifwehadsteppedintogood-payingjobsimmediatelyoutofcollege,whoknowshowearlywemighthaveretired?
Wecertainlyencourageyoungerreaderstobemorepracticalthanwewereintermsofyoureducationalandcareerchoices,becauseifyou
domaketherightdecisionsearlyon,youcouldbefinanciallyindependentbyage35or40.Alternatively,youcouldchoosetokeepworkingfiveortenyearslongerandletthepowerofcompoundingreallyworkitsmagicforyou,givingyouasubstantiallylargernestegg.
ThePowerofCompounding
Theearlieryoucanstartsavingforretirementthebetter,sinceitgivesyourinvestmentsmoretimetocompound.Compounding,simplyput,isearninginterestonyourinterest.Wheninterestisaddedtoyourprincipal,fromthatpointforwardittooearnsinterest.
Compoundingisattheveryheartofagetrichslowlyapproachtoinvesting.
Supposeyouput$10,000inabankcertificateofdepositthatpays5%interestannually.Attheendofoneyearyourbalancewillhavegrownby$500(5%ofyourinitial$10,000)to$10,500.AssumingyouleavetheentireamountintheCD,yourprincipalthenextyearwillstandat$10,500+5%=
$11,025.Overthecourseof25years,here’showyourinitialinvestmentwillgrow:
That’sthepowerofcompoundingforyou.Simplyby“doingnothing”andleavingyourinvestmentinplacetogrow,youcanwatchyourinitialinvestmentdoubleanddoubleagain.Yourmoneystartstomakemoneyforyou,whichinturnmakesyourroadtoretirementthatmucheasierastheyearspass.
Timeisyourfriendwhenitcomestoinvesting.That’swhytheearlieryoucanget
startedthebetter.Ifyouweretostartinvestingatage25,youcouldretireatage50andstillhavea25-yearinvestmenttimehorizon,givingyourmoneyplentyoftimetogrow.Compoundingispowerfulenoughthatitcantakeanaverageinvestorandmakehimintoagreatonesimplybyvirtueofhishavingstartedinvestingatayoungenoughage.
Didyouknowcompound
interestwasonceregardedastheworstformofusuryandwasseverelycondemnedbyRomanlaw?Timescertainlyhavechanged:nowgladiatorialcombatisoutandcompoundingisin.Sincecompoundingisfullylegalnow,wesuggestyoutakefulladvantageofitasyousaveforretirement.
Theeffectsofcompoundingbecomeevenmoreevidentifyour
investmentearnsahigherannualrateofreturn.Intheexampleaboveweassumea5%annualreturn.Butlet’ssayyouputthesame$10,000intoamutualfundearning,onaverage,10%peryear.Here’showyourinvestmentwouldgrow:
Byacceptingmoreriskandinvestinginastockmutualfundinsteadofabank
CD,ourhypotheticalinvestorhasearnedamuchgreaterreturn.Noticehowtheeffectsofcompoundingbecomemorepronouncedinlateryears.Forinstance,thebalancejumpsfromaround$67,000atthe20-yearmarkto$108,000atthe25-yearmark.That’s$41,000earnedinjustfiveyears.Thisremarkablegrowthstemsfromthefactthatthecapitalbaseismuchlargertobegin
withatthe20-yearmark,soa10%averagereturnoverthenextfiveyearshasamuchgreatereffect.
Thisgoestoshowwhyalonginvestmenttimehorizonissoimportant.Thelongeryouwaittotapyourmoney,themoredramaticthereturnscanbecomeinlateryears.(Assuming,ofcourse,thatthemarketscooperateonyourbehalf,whichisn’talwaysthecase.)
Asafinalcomparison,let’ssaythatinsteadoflettingthemoneycompound,yousimplytakethe10%earningsouteachyearanduseitforcash.That’s$1,000peryearinyourpocket,butatquitetheprice.Here’showthetwoscenariosmeasureup:
That’sadifferenceofover$73,000betweenthetwoscenarios.Enoughsaid!
UsingInvestingCalculators
Onlineinvestingcalculatorsmakeiteasytoseehowyourmonthlycontributionscompoundovertime,helpingyoutogetrichslowly.Oneofourfavoritesisatdaveramsey.com(underthe“Tools”tab).Youpluginyour1)startingbalance(ifany),2)estimatedannualrate
ofreturn,3)monthlycontribution,4)numberofyearsyouplantocontribute,and5)totalnumberofyearsyou’llbeallowingthemoneytocompound,thenhitthe“Calculate”keyanduppopsabarchartshowingyoutheresults.
Thechartisintuitivelyeasytounderstand.Foreachscenarioyourun,itinstantlyshowsyouthetotalcontributionsmadebyyou
versusthetotalamountearnedasaresultofcompounding.Italsoshowstheyearinwhichyoucrossthe$1millionmark.It’sagreattoolandfreetouse.
Trypluggingindifferentvaluestoexperimentwithdifferentscenariosuntilyouhituponascenariothatfeelsrighttoyou.Agoodscenarioisonethatbalancestheneedsoftodaywiththeneedsoftomorrow.Youdon’twantto
driveyourselfcrazybysettingthemonthlyinvestmentbartoohigh.Also,keepinmindthatanyscenarioisjustthat:areasonableguessaboutthefuturethatmaynotmatchupallthatcloselywithreality.Butthat’sokay,planscanbeadjusted.Theimportantthingistohaveaplan.
HowCompoundingCanHelpParentsinParticular
Themagicofcompoundingisespeciallyimportantforparentswonderinghowtheycanever
managetosaveupenoughforearlyretirement.Byaddingfiveortenyearstotheiroverallinvestmentplan,parentscanstillreachtheirfinancialgoalswhileprovidingfortheirchildren’sneedsatthesametime.Theycandorightbytheirkidsandbythemselvesbymethodicallyinvestingsmallersumsofmoneybutdoingitoveralongerperiodoftime.Itmaytakethema
fewextrayears,buttheresultisstillanice,tidynestegg–andatanageyoungenoughtoenjoyit.Takealookatthesetwoscenariostoseewhatwemean:
Scenario#1.Couplewithnokidssaves$3,000permonthfor15yearswitha9%annualreturntoaccumulatea$1.1
millionnestegg
Scenario#2.Couplewithkidssaves$1,000permonthfor25yearswitha9%annualreturntoaccumulatea$1.1
millionnesteggIneachcasetheendresult
isroughlythesame,andquiteimpressive:anesteggofover$1.1million(notincludinghomeequity).Thecouplewithnokidshasinvested$3,000permonthfor15yearstoreachtheirgoal.The
parentshaveinvestedsmalleramountsbutoveralongerperiodoftime–$1,000permonthfor25years–toreachtheirgoal.
Takeamomenttocomparethetotalcontributionsandtotalinterestinthetwoscenariosandnotethehugevariationbetweenthem.Thecouplewithnokidshasinvested$540,000oftheirownmoneyandearned$604,000asa
resultofcompounding.Notbad.Buttheparentshaveinvested$300,000oftheirownmoneyandearnednearly$830,000asaresultofcompounding!Theyhavehadtoputinalotlessefforttoachieveasimilarresult,thankstothepowerofcompoundingovertime.
Ifthesefolkshadallstartedinvestingatage30,thecouplewithnokidswouldbe45whentheyretiredand
theparentswouldbe55.Compoundinghelpsinbothcases,butitisespeciallyimportantfortheparentswhohavewiselygiventhemselvesalongertimehorizoninwhichtoinvest.
RidingtheCompoundingTailwindtoRetirement
Webelievethehardestyearsofinvestingbyfararetheearliestonesbecauseyou’regettingsolittletailwindintermsofcompounding.Itfeelslike
you’regoingnowherefast.Forusitseemedtotakeforevertoreachthatfirst$100,000mark.
Thenthingsgoteasier.The$100,000alreadysavedupstartedworkingforus,compounding,givingusthatall-importanttailwindwehadbeenmissingbefore.Itdidn’ttakenearlyaslongorseemnearlysoarduoustogetfrom$100,000to$200,000,andthistrendcontinuedintothe
future.Sobeginninginvestors,
takeheart:itreallydoesgeteasierastheyearsgoby.Youcanthankthepowerofcompoundingforthat.Ifyouhangtoughandkeepinvestingasmuchasyoucaninthoseearlyyears,yourperseverancewillpayoffintheend.Ithelpstorememberthatthemoneyyousaveearlyonisthemoneythatwillcompoundthemostoverthe
years.
Chapter8.DetermineYour
RetirementIncomeNeeds
Figuringouthowmuchmoneyyou’relikelytoneed
onanannualbasisinthesomewhatdistantfutureisnoeasymatter.Butyoucanstartwiththissimplepremise:yourexpenseswillalmostcertainlybelowerthenthantheyarenow.
Why?Well,forstarters,youwon’tbeneedingtoinvestforretirementanymoreonceyou’reretired,obviously,sothose“expenses”willgoaway.Inaddition,youwon’tbe
makingmortgagepaymentsanymore,andanyexpensesassociatedwithraisingchildrenandsendingthemofftocollegewillnolongerapply.Certainwork-relatedexpenseswilldropawayonceyounolongerneedtomakethedailycommute.Significanthomeandyardimprovementsshouldbeathingofthepast.Andyourtaxeswillalmostcertainlygodowncomparedtowhat
you’repayingnow.Ontheotherhand,your
healthcarecostsmayincreasesomewhat,aswellasyourtravelandleisureexpenses.Thenthere’sinflation,whichcontinuallyeatsawayatthevalueofyourdollaryearafteryear.Inflationaddsawholenewdimensiontothediscussion.
We’lltalkabouteachofthesefactorsinamoment,butfirstwe’dliketodiscussthe
strongdifferencesofopinionthatexistabouthowbesttodetermineyourfutureyearlyincomeneeds.
TwoMethodsforCalculatingFutureIncome
Oneapproachtoutedbymanyfinancialandinsurancefirmsistostartwithyourcurrentincomethenmultiplythatincomeby70%or80%todeterminetheamountyou’relikelytoneedinthefuture.Wethinkthismethod
isfundamentallyflawed.Ittendstoresultinanoverestimatethatmakespeoplethinktheyneedtosaveabiggernesteggthantheyreallydo.Itgoeswithoutsayingthisbenefitsthesamefinancialfirmsthatrecommendit,sinceitmeansmoremoneyflowingintotheircoffers.
Becausesalariestendtobeattheirhighesttowardstheendofaperson’scareer,a
catch-22situationcanresultinwhicheverhighersalariesleadtoeverhigherestimatesoffutureneeds,whichinturndrivestheperceivedneedforaneverbiggernestegg.Allofthisleadstothebeliefthatyouneedtokeeponworking,keeponsaving,keeponstriving.Butthetruthis,currentincomehaslittletodowithhowmuchyou’llneedonceyouretire.Let’suseourownexampleasacasein
point.Towardstheendofour
workingyearsweweremakingthemostwehadeverearned,astendstobethecase.Firmsrecommendingtheincomeapproachtocalculatingyourretirementneedstypicallysuggestyoutaketheaverageofyourfinaltenyearsofannualincome.Theytellyoutomultiplythatamountby70%and80%togetarangerepresentingthe
lowendandhighendofwhatyou’relikelytoneedinordertomaintainyourcurrentstandardoflivinginretirement.
Applyingthisformulatoourownsituation,ouraverageannualincomeovertheten-yearperiodpriortoretirementwas$106,885.Multiplyingthisamountby70%and80%givesyouarangeof$74,820to$85,508,withthemedianpointofthe
rangebeing$80,164.Butinactualfactwehave
livedquitecomfortablyon$40,000peryeareachyearsinceretiring.Ourstandardoflivinghasremainedvirtuallythesameasbeforeexceptthatitincludesalotmoretravel.Youcanseefromthisexamplejusthowflawedthe70-80approachcanbe.Anymethodthatmissesthemarkbymorethandoubleshouldbeconsideredsuspect.
Ifyouareaggressivelysavingforearlyretirement,thentheresultsofthe70-80methodtendtobeparticularlyskewed.Alargechunkofyourincomeisgoingtowardsinvestmentsandisthusoffthetableintermsofwhatyou’reactuallylivingonatpresent.Ourinvestments,forinstance,oftenamountedtoover40%ofourincomeduringthelatteryearsofouremployment.Ourtaxeswere
alsoattheirhighestduringthisperiod.Thusanyonepushinghardtoretireearlyislikelytobeledastraybyusingcurrentincomeasthemeansfordetermininghowmuchthey’llneedoncetheyretire.
Insteadwerecommendyoustartwithcurrentexpensestodetermineyourretirementneeds.Actuallivingexpensesinthepresentdaygiveyouabettertakeon
whatyou’llneeddowntheroad,onceyouhavesubtractedouttheonesthatnolongerapplyandhavemadeappropriateadjustmentsforinflation.
It’sparticularlyimportanttogettheyearlyretirementincomenumberrightsinceitfeedsdirectlyintothecalculationofhowbigyournesteggneedstobe.Thedifferencebetweenbeingabletoliveon$40,000peryear
and$80,000peryearisthedifferencebetweenneedingtosaveupanesteggof$1millionand$2million.Thinkofhowmanyextrayearsofworkitwouldtaketoamassanextramilliondollarsinsavings.Thustheyearlyretirementincomeestimatebecomesmagnifiedintermsofitspotentialimpactonyourlifeandthedecisionsyoumakeaboutyourownfuture.
MakinganInitialEstimateBasedonCurrentExpenses
Let’sbeginbytakingalookatyourcurrentlivingexpenses.Let’ssayyouandyourspousecurrentlyhavea
combinedgrossincomeof$100,000,or$75,000netaftertaxes.Now,usingbroadbrushstrokes,let’seliminateafewofthemajorexpensesyouprobablywon’thaveonceyouretire.
Forstarters,themortgagewillbepaidoffbythetimeyouretire,sothat’s,say,$1,250permonthor$15,000peryearyouwon’thavetoworryabout.Perhapsyou’vealsobeenputtingaway
$3,000peryearforyourkids’collegeeducation.Andlet’ssayyou’veidentifiedanother$1,000peryearinadditionalexpensesrelatedtokids,jobs,homerenovation,yardmaintenance,andsoforththatyoufeelfairlycertainwillnolongerapplyonceyou’reretired.
Finally,let’ssayyou’reinyourprimaryinvestingyearsandhavebeensockingaway$20,000peryearintoyour
retirementfunds.Ofcourse,that“expense”willnolongerbethereonceyou’reretired.So:$100,000(combinedgrossincome)-$25,000(taxesat25%)-$15,000(mortgagepayments)-$3,000(kids’collegefund)-$1,000(misc.expensesrelatedtokids,jobs,homeimprovements,etc.)
-$20,000(retirementinvestments)$36,000(adjustednetincome)Thishypotheticalscenario
suggestsyouandyourspousecouldbegettingbyonaslittleas$36,000netperyearifitweren’tformortgagepayments,extraexpensesassociatedwithkidsandjob,andtheneedtosaveforcollegeandretirement.That’s
someprettyfrugallivingyou’redoingwhenyouconsideritthatway.
Butnowthependulumhastoswingtheotherway.You’vedonesomesubtraction,nowyouneedtodosomeaddition.Tomakeanaccurateassessmentofhowmuchyou’llneedonceyouretire,youhavetoaddmoneybackintoaccountforinflation,taxes,andpotentiallyhigherhealthcare
costsinretirement.(Wewon’ttrytoaccountforincreasedtravelexpensesinthisexamplebecausetheycanvarysomuchfromonepersontothenext,butyoumaywanttopadyourestimateslightlyhigherifyouexpecttotravelintensivelyonceretired.SeeChapter17,“ExtendedTravelinRetirement,”foradiscussionofaffordablelong-termtravel.)
AdjustingforInflation
Inflationonanationwidebasisrisesbyanaverageofroughly3%peryearaccordingtotheConsumerPriceIndex,whichmeasuresthecostofabasketofcommongoodsandservicesAmericansbuy(food,clothing,housing,medicalcare,energy,etc.).TheCPIis
anationalaverageofprices,butbasedonourownexperiencewethink3%isabithighforcalculatingyourpersonalinflationrate.Ifyouliveconsciously,youcankeepinflationfromhavingasstrongofanimpactonyourlifeasitmighthaveontheeconomyasawhole.
Forinstance,thepriceofseeingamovieinatheatermayhavegoneupto$12perticket,butthatdoesn’tmean
youcan’tmaketheconsciousdecisiontowaitandseethesamemovieathomeforadollar.Andjustbecausearestaurantraisesitslunchpriceto$20doesn’tmeanyoucan’tmaketheconsciousdecisiontoeatsomewhereelsemoreaffordably.Youmightdotakeoutforhalfthepriceormakelunchathomeforevenless.Sowhilewecan’tignoretheeffectsofinflation,wecanmitigateits
effectstosomedegreebymakingintelligentdecisionsinourpersonallives.
Wethinkapersonalinflationrateof2%isclosertothemarkthan3%,andthat’sthenumberwe’llusehere.Butkeepinmindhighinflationcanrearitsuglyheadatanytimeandposeaseriousproblemforretireesonafixedincome.Keepaneyeonwhat’shappeningintherealworldandadjustyour
calculationsandthoughtprocessesaccordingly.
Basedonapersonalinflationrateof2%,tohavetheequivalentof$36,000intoday’sdollarsyou’dneed$36,000+2%=$36,720nextyear.Theyearafterthatyou’dneed$36,720+2%=$37,454,andsoon.In15years’time,tohavethebuyingpower$36,000givesyoutoday,you’dneed$48,451.Forsimplicity’s
sakelet’sroundthenumberupto$49,000.
AdjustingforTaxesinRetirement
Thenetamountourhypotheticalcouplewillneedinretirementis$49,000.However,whentheywithdrawmoneyfromtheirretirementaccountsthey’lltypicallybewithdrawinggrossproceedsandmayneed
topaysomeamountofincometaxonthatamount.Let’sassume10%taxes,whichmaysoundlow,butinactualfactwe’vehadseveralyearsgobysinceretiringinwhichwe’veowedzerodollarsintaxes(see“IncomeTaxesinRetirement”inChapter3fordetails).
Fornowlet’sassume10%incometaxesandadd$5,444tothe$49,000toarriveatagrossincomeof
$54,444.(Incaseyou’reinterestedindoingthemath,dividethenetamountof$49,000by90%toarriveatthegrossamount.)Forsimplicity’ssakewe’llroundthenumberupto$55,000.
AdjustingforHealthCareinRetirement
Youmayalsowanttoaddsomemoneyinforpotentiallyhigherhealthcarecostsinretirement.Asof2014,theAffordableCareActwillmakehealthcaremuchmoreaffordableforearlyretireesonabudget,aswediscussin
Chapter16(“HealthCareinRetirement”).Theeffectsofthisnewlegislationaresignificantenoughthatwe’reonlygoingtoadd$1,000toourhypotheticalcouple’stotal,andthat’smostlytoaccountforhigherout-of-pocketexpensesassociatedwiththingslikedentalandvisioncarethataren’tnecessarilycoveredunderthenewlaw.
Keepinmindyou’re
probablynotpayingzerodollarsforhealthcarecurrently.Evenifyouremployercoversyou,you’realmostcertainlypayingsomethingintothesystem.AccordingtotheEmployerHealthBenefits2011SurveybytheKaiserFamilyFoundation,forexample,workerswithfamilycoveragecontribute,onaverage,$344permonth($4,129annually)towardstheirhealthinsurance
premiums.The$1,000we’readdingisontopofwhateveramountourhypotheticalcoupleisalreadypayingforhealthanddentalcareduringtheirworkingyears.
If,afterreadingChapter16,youstillexpectyourhealthcarecostsinearlyretirementtobesignificantlyhigher,youcanusewhatevernumberyoufeelmostaccuratelyreflectsyourfuturereality.
CalculationSummary
Ourcouple’sestimatedannualretirementexpensesnowstandat$56,000.Thisestimateoftheirfutureincomeneedsisgroundedintherealityoftheircurrentsituationwhilealsohavingbeenappropriatelyadjustedforinflation.Whileitmaynotbeexact,itletsusproceed
withareasonabledegreeofconfidence.
Sincewe’veprovidedalotofdetailedinformationhereinvolvingafairamountofmath,let’stakeamomenttosumup:
Nowallthatremainsistocalculatethesizeofthenesteggitself–whichisthesubjectofthenextchapter.Wethinkyou’llbegladtodiscoverthere’sverylittlemathinvolvedindoingthat.
Chapter9.CalculateYourNest
EggPerhapsthethoughthas
occurredtoyou,Whatexactlyconstitutesmynestegg?Istheequityinmyhomeapart
ofit?Andwhataboutthemoneyinmy401(k)andIRAthatIdon’tplanontouchinguntilafterI’m59½?DoesthatcounttowardsmynesteggwhenI’mtryingtodeterminehowmuchissafetowithdrawintheinitialyearsofmyearlyretirement?
Thesearefairquestionsandonesweponderedourselvesaswewerenearingearlyretirement.We’lldoourbesttoprovidesome
guidancebasedonourownthinkingabouttheseissuesbothbeforeandafterretiring.
WhatConstitutesYourNestEgg?
Yournesteggshouldconsistonlyofliquidassetssuchasstocks,bonds,andcash,notilliquidassetssuchasrealestate.Realestateishardertosellandmorecumbersometoworkwithifyouwanttogeneratecashfor
currentlivingexpenses.Thatsaid,ifyouplanondownsizingyourhomeonceyouretire,whateveramountyouwon’tbeneedingforhome-buyingpurposesinthefuturecanbeturnedintoliquidassetsthatdocounttowardsyournestegg.
HowMuchofYourHomeCounts?Priortoretirementwe
includedalloftheequityinourhomeaspartofournesteggcalculationsincewedidn’tplanonowningahomeonceweretired.Andindeedwedidsellourhomeafterretiringandlivedfortwoyearsasnomadsbychoice,rentingwhereverourtravelshappenedtotakeus.Forthosetwoyearsourassetswereallliquid.
Butwecametomisshavingahomebase,sowe
endeduppurchasingasmallcondo,whichmeanttaking$100,000offthetableintermsofliquidassetsandputtingitbackintoilliquidrealestate.Ineffectthisamountnolongercountedtowardsourretirementnesteggbecauseitnolongergeneratedfundswecouldusetoliveon(shortofrentingitoutforperiodsoftime,whichwehaveconsidereddoingbuthaven’tdonesofar).The
condostillcountstowardsournetassetsbutnottowardsournestegg.
Inretrospectitwouldhavebeenwiserforustofactorintheneedforadownsizedhomeinretirementasopposedtonohomeatall.Bysubtracting$100,000outofourtotalholdings,wecouldhavemoreaccuratelyassessedtherealsizeofournesteggaswewereplanningforretirement.
Forthisreasonwerecommendyousetasideaportionofyourhome’sequity(say,betweenonequarterandonehalf)forfuturerealestatepurposes.Thisamountcanbeappliedeithertoadownsizedhomeortocoveringrentalcostswhereveryoumayhappentoliveintheworldifyouchoosenottoownahomeforaperiodoftime.Eitherway,you’reaheadofthegameifyoudon’thaveto
subtractthisamountoutofyournesteggonceyouretire.
AreYour401(k)andRothIRAAssetsPartofYourNestEgg?Decidingwhether401(k)
andRothIRAassetsareliquidorilliquidintheyearsbeforeyoucanaccessthemwithoutpenaltyisadmittedlysomethingofagrayarea.Hereareourthoughtsonthe
matter,althoughothersmightreasonablydisagree.
Werecommendyoudoinclude401(k)andRothIRAamountswhencalculatingyournestegg,evenifyouplanonrelyingsolelyonthemoneyinyourtaxableaccountintheyearspriortoturning59½.Thestock,bond,andmutualfundassetsintheseaccountsreallyareliquidandcouldbesoldforcashquicklyifneedbe.Of
courseyourintentionistoleavethemuntouchedforyearstocomesinceyouwouldotherwisehavetopayapenaltytaxforaccessingthemprematurely,buttheyareneverthelessstillliquidinnature.
Justbecauseyouchoose(wisely)torelysolelyonthetaxableportionofyourliquidassetsduringyourearlyretirementyearsdoesn’tmeantheothertax-advantaged
liquidassetsdon’texist.Theydoexistandinfactarelikelytogrowintheyearstocome,providingyouwithasteadystreamofincomewhenthetimeisright.Notfactoringthemintoyournesteggwouldbetoignoreasignificantandever-increasingportionofyourportfolio.
Usingthe4%RuletoCalculateYourNestEgg
Onceyou’vedeterminedyourannualretirementincomeneeds,aswedidinChapter8,thenextstepiseasy.Youcanusewhat’sknownasthe4%ruleto
estimatethenesteggyou’llneedinordertosafelygeneratethatamount.Let’sstartwith$56,000,theannualretirementincomeamountfromourexampleinthepreviouschapter.Usingavariationofthe4%rulecalledthe“Ruleof25,”youcanperformaquickback-of-the-napkinnesteggcalculation.Simplymultiplytheincomeamountby25todeterminethesizeofthenest
eggyou’llneed.Forexample:$56,000(annualretirementincome)x25=$1.4million
nestegg
It’sasstraightforwardasthat.Anesteggof$1.4millionwillgenerateanannualretirementincomeof$56,000forourhypotheticalcouple.Notethatdividingtheincomeamountby4%willgetyouthesameresultasmultiplyingby25.Thetwo
approachesaremathematicallythesameintermsofprovidingyouwithananswerastothesizeofthenesteggyouneed.
Perhapsaneasierwaytovisualizehowthe4%ruleworksistostartwiththenesteggamountitselfandmultiplyby4%todeterminetheyearlyincomeamountitwillsafelygenerate,asfollows:
$500,000nesteggx4%=$20,000incomeperyear$750,000nesteggx4%=$30,000incomeperyear
$1,000,000nesteggx4%=$40,000incomeperyear
$1,250,000nesteggx4%=$50,000incomeperyear
$1,500,000nesteggx4%=$60,000incomeperyear
$1,750,000nesteggx4%=$70,000incomeperyear
$2,000,000nesteggx4%=$80,000incomeperyear
Don’tbesurprisedifthenesteggamountyoucalculateislargerthanyouwereanticipating.Inflationcanhavethateffect.Butkeepinmindyoursalarywillalsobekeepingupwith–andhopefullyoutpacing–inflationoverthecoming15to20years,sowhatmayseemlikeanimpossiblylargenumbernowshouldfeelmoreattainableastheyearspassandyoursalaryincreases.
Compoundingwillalsoassistyouinreachingyourgoal,givingyouatailwindinthelateryearsofyourplan.
WhyIs4%aSafeWithdrawalAmount?
Youmaybewondering,Why4%?Whynotmoreorlessthanthat?Doesn’t4%seemartificiallylow?Couldn’tyoutakeout,say,6%andstillbeokay?Andhowsafeissafewhenpeopletellyou4%isasafeamount
towithdraw?Let’strytoanswerafewofthesequestions.
TheOriginal4%RuleMostfinancialplanners
thesedaysagreeonsomevariationofthe4%rule.AsoriginallyformulatedbyWilliamBengen,acertifiedfinancialplannerintheearly1990s,therulestatesyoucan
safelywithdraw4%ofyournestegginyourfirstyearofretirementandincreasethatamountannuallythereafterforinflationwithouttoomuchriskofdepletingyournesteggover30years.
Let’ssayyouhavea$1millionnestegg.Accordingtothetraditionalapplicationofthe4%rule,yourfirstyearofretirementyoucouldtakeout$1millionx4%=$40,000.Nextyear,adjusting
forinflation(let’ssayit’sat2%),youcouldtakeout$40,000+2%=$40,800.Theyearafterthat,ifinflationwereat3%,youcouldtakeout$40,800+3%=$42,024,andsoon.That’sthe4%ruleatitsmostbasic.
Economistshavedonecarefulhistoricalmodelingandrunextensivealgorithms(calledMonteCarlosimulations)toarriveattheconclusionthat4%isa
reasonablysafeamounttowithdrawfromyourportfolioeachyear.Bengenhimselfconcludedthatdrawingdownjust1%morethanthatperyear–thatis,5%plusinflationadjustments–resultedina30%chanceofaretiree’snesteggbeingdepletedtoosoon.Fortheaverageretireethatissimplytoohigharisk.
AtorNeartheLimit
ofSafetyWhenwewereoriginally
planningforearlyretirement,itseemedtousthe4%rulewasoverlyconservative.Wewonderedwhywecouldn’tsafelywithdraw6%ormoreperyearifourinvestmentswereearning,say,9%.Butwe’vecometorealizethatprolongeddownturnsinthemarketcanwreakhavocwithaninvestmentportfolio,
especiallyintheearlyyearsofone’sretirement,andanygoodruleofthumbhastoaccountforthatpossibility.Afewyearsofnegativereturns,combinedwithhigherthannormalwithdrawals,coulddepleteaportfoliotothepointwhereitcannolongersustainitselfbutinsteadbeginsaslowspiraltowardszero.
Whilethestockmarketmayreturnanaverageof9%
overthelongterm,itcanbealloverthemapintheshortterm,andthe4%ruleisdesignedtocompensateforthat.It’salsohelpfultorememberthatpostedannualreturnsaretypicallypre-taxanddonotaccountforinflation.A9%returnisclosertoa7%realreturnafterfactoringininflation,andit’sevenlowerthanthatafterfactoringintaxes.Whenalloftheseissuesare
takenintoconsideration,4%turnsouttobethepercentagethatisatornearthelimitofsafety.Nearlyalleconomicmodelsagreethatyournesteggisatseriousriskofbeingdepletedtoosoonifyouareconsistentlywithdrawing6%ormore,sokeepyourwithdrawalsinthe4%to5%rangeifyouwanttostandareasonablechanceofseeingyourportfoliolastlongerthanyoudo.
Unfortunatelythereisnosuchthingasironcladsafetywhenitcomestoinvesting,onlyrelativesafety.Underterribleeconomicconditionsitwouldbepossibletodepleteyourportfolioevenifyouonlytookout4%peryear.Butthebestyoucandoiserrontheconservativesidesotheoddsareinyourfavorandrecognizetherearenoguaranteeseitherinlifeorininvesting.
Modifyingthe4%RuletoAddressLimitations
Ofcoursethe4%ruleisonlyaruleofthumbandnotanexactscience,butitservesasagoodfinancialyardstickfordeterminingtheapproximatesizeofthenest
eggyou’llneed.Wethinkitworksbestwhen,likeanyruleofthumb,itisappliedwithastrongdoseofcommonsense.Theruleasoriginallyformulatedhassomeimportantlimitations,sowerecommendyouuseitbutinamodifiedfashionasdescribedbelow.
IsThirtyYearsEnough?
Thechiefproblemwiththe4%ruleasoriginallyarticulatedisthatitwasonlymeanttoapplyto30years’worthofretirementliving.Butwithpeoplelivinglongerandretiringearlier,thisassumptionnolongerholdstrueineverycase.Youmightneedtofund40oreven50years’worthofretirementliving.
Oursolutiontothisproblemistoeffectivelyturn
offtheautomaticinflationadjustmentfeaturebuiltintotheoriginalrule.Ifyoudonotadjustforinflationeveryyearormakeonlyminimaltweaks–especiallyintheearlyyearsofyourretirement–thenyouarehedgingyourbetsinfavorofahealthyinvestmentportfoliothatislikelytooutlastyou.
Inflationhasbeensolowoverthepastfewyearsthatwehavebeenabletogosix
yearssofarwithoutneedingtoadjustourannualwithdrawalamounts.Onlynowarewebeginningtonoticearealdifferenceinourbuyingpower.Byminimizinginflationadjustments,wegiveourportfolioabetterchanceofnotonlysustainingitselfbutgrowingoverthelongterm.Thisincreasestheoddsitwillbetheretosupportus40oreven50yearsdownthelineifnecessary.
Asforinflationinourlateryears,wefeelwecanrelyonfuturesocialsecuritypaymentstohelpwiththat.Infactthatisexactlyhowwethinkofsocialsecurity:asahedgeagainstinflationinthedistantfuture.Wearen’texpectingmuchmorefromitthanthat,especiallysinceourpaymentswillbereducedfromthenormsinceweretiredsoearly.(Socialsecuritypaymentsare
calculatedbasedonyour35highest-earningworkingyears;ifyouworklessyearsthanthat,you’llhavesomeyearswithzeroincomeaveragedin–whichwillloweryourpayout.)
TweakingWithdrawalsBasedonActualConditionsAnotherproblemwiththe
4%ruleastraditionally
formulatedisthatitmakesnoattempttoaccountforchangesinspendingbehaviorduetobig-picturechangesintheeconomy.Theruleisappliedblindly,inessence.Whetheryouareinthedepthsofarecessionorattheheightsofaroaringbullmarket,italwaysrecommendsyouwithdrawexactlythesameamountperyear(otherthancompensatingforinflation).
Thismakesitsimpletoapplybutinflexiblewhenitcomestorollingwiththepunchesthatthefinancialmarketssometimesthrowatyou.
Inresponsetothisconcern,manyeconomistsadvocatestartingwiththe4%rulebuttweakingyourwithdrawalsfromyeartoyearbasedonactualmarketconditions.Thismakesperfectsensetous.Ifthestockmarketisperforming
splendidlyyearafteryear,thenyoushouldn’tfeelobligedtoartificiallylimityourselfto4%plustheinflationrate.Insuchasituationyoumightbewarrantedintakingout6%ofyournestegg(ormore)inagivenyear–aslongasitdoesn’tbecomeyournewnorm.Afteraparticularlygoodstringofyears,youmightsplurgeonthataround-the-worldtripyou’vealways
dreamedofbeforereturningtoamorenormalwithdrawalratethefollowingyear.
Ontheotherhand,iftheeconomyisinadeepandprolongedrecession,thenblindlyapplyingthe4%rule–whichtraditionallywouldcallforyoutoincreaseyourwithdrawalamountsinordertoaccountforinflation–wouldbequestionableatbest.Youmightendupmateriallyweakeningthehealthofyour
portfolioanddecreasingitschancesofsurvivaloverthelongterm.Undersuchconditionsitwouldbewisetowithdrawlessthan4%(oratleastnotadjustforinflation)inordertoprotectyourportfoliofromfurthererosion.Increasingtheflexibilityofthe4%ruleinsuchafashionoffersamorepragmatic,eyes-wide-openapproachtodrawingdownyournestegg.
AchievingaSelf-SustainingPortfolioAself-sustainingportfolio
isyouroverallfinancialgoalonceyouretire.Aportfoliothatisgrowingataslowpaceisaportfoliocapableofkeepingupwithinflationandprovidingyouwithaslightlyhigherannualincomeastheyearspass.Modifyingthe4%ruleby1)turningoffautomaticinflation
adjustmentsinfavorofmanualadjustments,and2)tweakingyourwithdrawalratesbasedonactualmarketconditionsshouldallowyoutoachievethisgoal.
UsingRetirementCalculators
Youcanuseonlineretirementcalculatorsinconjunctionwiththe4%ruletodeterminetheapproximatesizeofthenesteggyou’llneed.InChapter7wementionedoneweparticularlylikeat
daveramsey.com(underthe“Tools”tab).Itcreatesabarchartshowinghowyourmoneycompoundsfromyeartoyearandletsyouplugindifferentvaluestoexperimentwithdifferentscenarios.
AnotherniftyonlinetoolistheRetirementNestEggCalculatoronVanguard’swebsite.(Justtype“Vanguardnesteggcalculator”intoGoogleanditwillprovideyouwiththelink,whichis
ratherlongandcumbersome).Thecalculatorruns5,000independentMonteCarlosimulationswithjusttheclickofabutton.
Slidingbarsletsyouspecifyfourdatapoints:1)howmanyyearsyourportfolioneedstolast,2)yourcurrentportfoliobalance,3)howmuchyouexpecttospendfromyourportfolioeachyear,and4)thepercentageofstocks,bonds,
andcashinyourportfolio.Basedonthisinformationitcalculatestheprobabilityofyourportfoliolastingthenumberofyearsyou’vespecified.Ifyou’renotsatisfiedwiththeresults,youcantweaktheslidingbarstoexploredifferentwhat-ifscenarios.
Chapter10.MakeaLong-
TermInvestment
PlanWhenmakingalong-term
investmentplanithelpstobe
abletoclearlystateyourgoalsothereisnoconfusionaboutwhereyouareheading.Forexample:“Iwanttoretirein15yearsandhaveanesteggof$1.5millioninordertogenerate$60,000inincomeannually.”Tobeabletoputtogetheragoalstatementlikethisyouneedtoworkbackwards,inessence,andcompletethreesteps,twoofwhichyou’vealreadycompletedintheprevious
twochapters:1)Estimateyouryearlyincomeneedsonceyouretire.2)Calculateyournesteggbasedontheseyearlyincomeneeds.3)Puttogetheradetailedplanoutlininghowmanyyearsitwilltaketosaveupyournesteggandhowmuchyou’llneedtoinvesteachyear.
Thischaptertacklestheall-importantthirdstep.Youmayalreadyhaveaninitialsenseofthenumberofyearsuntilyourtargetretirementdate,butcompletingthisstepwillhelpyourefinethatunderstanding.Bytheendofityou’llhaveamuchbettergrasponhowmuchyou’llneedtoinvesteachyearinordertoaccomplishyourgoalinthedesirednumberofyears.
Exercise#1:InvestingtheSameAmountEachYear
Let’sgetstartedbytakingalookatthefollowingcharts,whichshowtheresultsofsteadilyinvesting$15,000,$20,000,$25,000,and$30,000peryearfor15years
and20yearsassumingaconsistent9%annualreturn.
Roundingofftheresultsinthecharts,20years’worthofinvestmentscomesto:–$836,000basedoninvesting$15,000peryear–$1.1millionbasedoninvesting$20,000peryear–$1.4millionbasedoninvesting$25,000peryear–$1.7millionbasedoninvesting$30,000peryearSimplyeliminatethelast
fiveyearsonthechartstoseewhereyournesteggwouldstandafter15yearsofsaving.Inthiscasetherounded-offresultscometo:–$480,000basedoninvesting$15,000peryear–$640,000basedoninvesting$20,000peryear–$800,000basedoninvesting$25,000peryear–$960,000basedoninvesting$30,000peryear
Keepinmindtheseresultsareirrespectiveoftheequitybuildinginyourhome,asizableportionofwhichcanbeaddedtothetotalsshownabove,assumingyouarewillingtodownsizeafterretiring.
Thisshouldbegintogiveyouaroughideaoftheaverageamountyou’llneedtosaveeachyearinordertoreachyourgoal.Ofcoursethisissimplyahypothetical
example.It’shighlyunlikelyyou’llbeabletosaveexactlythesamedollaramountperyearfromthebeginningtotheendofyourworkingcareer,andit’sprettymuchaguaranteethestockmarketwon’tconsistentlyreturnthesamepercentageyearinandyearout.
Farmorelikely,you’llbeginbyinvestingsmallamountsearlyon,thenwatchthoseamountsgrow–
hopefullydramatically–asyoursalarygrows.Thiswasthecaseforus.Meanwhile,thestockmarketwillhavegoodyearsandbad,buthopefullyitwillbalanceoutintheendtosomethingclosetolong-termhistoricalaverages.
Exercise#2:InvestingDifferentAmountsEachYear
Nowlet’sengageinanotherhypotheticalexercise,thisonemixinginacertainamountofreal-worlddata
basedonourownexperience.Inthisexercisewe’lluseactualdollaramountsweinvestedeachyearfor15years,butwe’llplugthemintoaspreadsheetthatassumesaconsistentannualreturnof9%peryear.The“GrandTotal”columninthefollowingchartshowstheresultsbasedonthishypothetical9%return,whilethe“ActualResults”columnnexttoitcomparesreal-world
returnsreceivedduringthissameperiodoftime.
Asyoucanseefromthechart,ouryearlyinvestmentamountsfluctuateddramaticallyfromthebeginningofourinvestmentplantotheend.Theybeganatjustafewhundreddollarsperyear,thenratchetedconsistentlyhigherbeforekickingintooverdrivein2000followingRobin’scareerretraining.Ouraverageyearlyinvestmentoverthe
entire15-yearperiodwasslightlylessthan$23,000peryear.
Weweresurprisedourselveswhenweranthesenumbersforthefirsttimeandsawthatouractualresultshadoutpacedaconsistent9%annualreturn.Infacttheyhadoutpacedaconsistent10%return,whichwouldhaveresultedin$586,890.Aconsistent11%returnwouldhaveresultedin$620,868–
moreorlessinlinewithouractualresultsof$626,219.
Howcanweexplainsucharobustreturn?Wasitsimplytheresultofstrongstockmarketperformanceduringtheyearsinwhichwehappenedtobeinvesting?
Thesimpleanswerisyes.Duringthe15-yearperiodfrom1992to2006,theS&P500returned12.02%basedonsimpleaveragesand10.66%basedoncompound
annualgrowthrates(moreonthatinamoment).Thusourannualizedreturnof11%wasmoreorlessinlinewiththestockmarketasawhole.
Thischartshouldlendsomeconfidencethat,despitefluctuatinginvestmentamountsandwildlyvaryingratesofreturnthroughtheyears,real-worldresultsreallycanmatchorevenoutperformhypotheticalresultsbasedonaconsistent
9%return.Yourinvestmentamounts,
likeours,maystartoutsmallbutbuildovertimeasyoursalarygrows.Wesuggestyouincorporatethislikelydollarprogressionintoyourfinancialplans.Ifyoutakeouradvicetoheart,however,andinvestinyourselffirst,thenyourinvestmentsshouldstartouthigherthanoursdidandremainmoreconsistentthroughtimethanourswere.
Thismoreconsistentapproachhasitsbenefits,chiefamongthemthefactthatmoredollarsarebeinginvestedearlyon,translatingintomoretimeforthosedollarstocompound.Amoreconsistentapproachalsomakesplanningforthefuturethatmucheasier.
Whichleadsustoournexttopicofdiscussion.Whatannualratesofreturnshouldyouassumewhen
puttingtogetheryourfinancialplanforthefuture?
EstimatingFutureStockMarketReturns
Whenwebeganinvestinginthemid-1990s,peoplewerealmostmanicallyupbeataboutthestockmarket.Theideathatwewereinaneweraofinvestingwasverymuchintheair.Wewereinthemidstofmultipleback-to-backyears
of20%+returnsandthereseemedtobenoendinsightastohowhightheS&P500couldgo,letalonetheNASDAQ.Justtakealookattheseannualizedreturnsfrom1995to1999togetanidea:
Don’tweallwishwecouldhavethosefiveyearsofreturnsbackagain!In1999theNASDAQreturnedanastonishing85%–andthat
wasafterfouryearsof20%to40%gains.Nowonderpeoplethoughtwewereinaneweraofinvesting–orelseinthemidstofoneofthebiggestinvestmentbubblesofalltimes.
Irememberreadingarticlesinfinancialmagazinesabout“Dow30,000”and“Dow40,000,”andthearticleswerenotwrittentongueincheek.TothisdayabookisavailableonAmazon.com
calledDow30,000by2008!:WhyIt’sDifferentThisTime.Firstpublishedin2003byacharteredfinancialanalystafterthedot-comboomhadalreadygonebust,itclaimedareturntogoodtimeswasjustaroundthecorner.Weallknowhowthatpredictionturnedout.
IstillhaveanarticlefromKiplinger’sdatedJanuary1995thatclaimsanaverageannualreturnof15%overthe
longrunisareasonableexpectationforindividualswhoinvestregularlyinadiversifiedportfolioofsmall-capgrowthstocks.Backthen,talkof15%averageannualreturnsdidn’tseemsofar-fetched,andwhenyoulookatthereturnsshownaboveyoucanbegintounderstandwhy.Iwentontowriteinmyjournal,“Ifthisisso,mycalculationsmaybeoverlyconservative.I’vebasedmy
expectationsonanaverageannualreturnof9%.”
Becauseofarticleslikethisone,Ibumpedmyestimatesupto10%andstillfeltlikeIwasbeinghopelesslypessimistic.NowadaysifIweretosuggestannualizedreturnsof10%,manywouldsayIwasbeinghopelesslyoptimistic.
WhattheHistorical
RecordShowsYouhavetomake
assumptionswhenplanningforthefuture,there’ssimplynowayaroundit.Aslongasyourassumptionshaveabasisinfact–andnotjustovertheshorttermbutoverthelongterm–you’reonrelativelysolidground.Butitwouldbeamistaketoassume20%annualizedstockmarketreturnsjustbecauseyou’re
luckyenoughtoexperiencea20%returninanygivenyear,oreveninastringofyears.Why?Becausethehistoricalrecordsimplydoesn’tsupportit.
Whatthehistoricalrecorddoessupportistheprobabilityofstockmarketreturnsinthe8%to10%rangeoverthelongterm.Doesthatmeanyou’redefinitelygoingtogetthosereturnsduringtheyearsin
whichyouareactivelyinvesting?No,ofcoursenot.Butyou’vegottostartsomewhere,andasgoodaplacetostartasanyiswiththehistoricalreturnsofthestockmarketoveraverylongperiodoftime–say,frombeforetheGreatDepressionin1929tothepresentday.
Gettinganaccuratereadonhistoricalstockmarketperformanceisasurprisinglytrickythinginitsownright.
You’dthinkeveryonewouldagreeinhindsight,forexample,onwhattheannualizedreturnshavebeenfortheS&P500.Afterall,theS&P500isanindexofthe500biggestandbest-capitalizedcompaniesintheU.S.Nevertheless,differentwebsitespostslightlydifferentannualizedreturnsforthesameyear,althoughmostareinroughagreement.
Werelyondatapostedby
moneychimp.comundertheirhelpfulfeaturecalled“CAGRoftheStockMarket:AnnualizedReturnsoftheS&P500.”CAGRstandsfor“compoundannualgrowthrate”andtheir“CAGR-lator”makesitpossibletoenteranyrangeofyearsduringtheentirehistoryoftheS&P500andinstantlyseetheannualizedgrowthrateforthatperiod.
Accordingtotheir
website,from1871to2012,thelongestpossiblerangetodate,theS&P500’sannualizedreturn(dividendsincluded)hasbeen10.60%basedontakingthesimpleaverage–thatis,addingupeachyear’sannualreturnpercentagethendividingitbythetotalnumberofyears.
TheProblemWithUsingSimple
AveragesUsingthesimpleaverage
seemsstraightforwardenough,doesn’tit?However,itisn’talwaysthebestapproach.Let’slookatanextremeexampletoillustrate.Let’ssayyouhave$10,000investedinaparticularstockandyoumake100%onyourinvestmentinthefirstyear.Thatmeansyoumade$10,000onyourinvestment,
leavingyouwithanewtotalof$20,000.
Nowlet’ssayyoulose50%ofthatinvestmentthenextyear.That’salossof$10,000,puttingyourightbackwhereyoustartedat$10,000.Yourrealannualizedgainiszerosinceyoustartedandendedatthesamedollaramount.However,thesimpleaveragewouldsuggestyourannualreturnwas25%.Why?
Because(100%gain-50%loss)÷2=25%.Weintuitivelyseethisdoesn’tmakepracticalsense–andthat’swherecompoundannualgrowthrates(CAGR)comeinhandy.
WhyCompoundAnnualGrowthRatesAreMoreReliableAcompoundannual
growthrateessentiallyshowstherateatwhichaninvestmentwouldhavegrownifitgrewatasteadyrate.Byusingthegeometricmeanratherthanthearithmeticmeanitprovidesatruerpictureofactualreturns.Unfortunately,calculatingtheCAGRisnoeasymatterunlessyou’reamathwhizorhappentohaveafinancialcalculatoronhand.Ifyouwanttoknowtheequation,
hereitis:
Calculatingafractionalexponentisnotsomethingyoucaneasilydoonanordinarycalculator.However,websiteslikemoneychimp.comandinvestopedia.comnowofferCAGRcalculatorsyoucanuse.Forourpurposes,the
importantthingtounderstandisthatcalculationsbasedonCAGRprovideamoreaccurateassessmentoflong-termannualizedreturns,andthat’swhatourfocusisonhere.
Accordingtomoneychimp.com,theannualizedreturnoftheS&P500from1871to2012basedoncompoundannualgrowthratesis8.92%.TheCAGRisusuallyapercentortwoless
thanthesimpleaverage(whichyoumayrecallwas10.60%).Inflation-adjustedannualizedreturnsoverthissameperiodwere6.71%basedontheCAGR.
WhatAnnualRateofReturnShouldYouUse?TheS&P500isa
reasonableproxyfortheentireU.S.stockmarket,soit
wouldbefairtosaythat,overthelongrun,thestockmarkethashadanannualizedreturnofapproximately9%andaninflation-adjustedreturnofapproximately7%.Ifyouwanttoplanforthefuture,youcoulddoworsethanbasingyourassumptionsonthesepercentages.
Nowifyou’reoptimisticbynature,youcanassumestockmarketreturnsof10%orpossiblyeven11%per
yearandstillbemoreorlessinrangeofwhatthehistoricalrecordsupports.Butgoingmuchhigherthanthatmightstarttolookmorelikewishfulthinkingthanconscientiousplanning.
Whenputtingtogetheryourownfinancialplanforthefuture,wesuggestyouuseapercentagerateofbetween8%and10%peryearifyouareinvestingprimarilyinthestockmarket,
with9%beingtheobviousmiddlegroundassumption.Somewillsaythisistoohigh,otherstoolow,butatleastitisintheballpark.Keepinminda9%returnisbasedoninvestingthebulkofyourmoneyinstocksduringyourprimaryinvestingyears.Ifyouwishtoinvestmoreconservatively,withbondsmakingup25%ormoreofyourportfolio,youmaywanttoassumeaslightlylower
annualrateofreturn.Youmaybewondering
whetheryoushoulduseinflation-adjustedreturnswhenmakingassumptionsaboutfutureinvestmentgrowth.(Inflation-adjustedreturnsareusuallyabouttwopercentagepointslowerthanunadjustedreturns.)Withregardtoyourpersonalinvestmentplanwewouldsayno,andhere’swhy:youalreadyfactoredininflation
(i.e.,byadding2%peryear)whencalculatingyourfutureretirementincomeneeds.Thatmeansyournestegghasalreadybeenadjustedupwardstoaccountforinflation.Adjustingannualreturnsdownwardsaswellwouldbetoaccountforinflationtwice.
Eveniftheassumptionsyoumakeaboutfuturestockmarketreturnsaren’ttotallycorrect(andthere’sagood
chancetheywon’tbe),themerefactthatyouhavemadeaplanandadheredtoitmeansyou’reaheadofthegameandalmostassuredlybetteroffthanyouwouldhavebeenotherwise.
MarketResilienceIt’sacomfortto
rememberthatthestockmarkethassurvivedandthriveddespitesuchcatastrophiceventsasthe
StockMarketCrashof1929,theensuingGreatDepression,andtwoWorldWars.Itputsintoperspectivetheconcernsofourowntimeandmakesusrealizethemarketsaresurprisinglyresilientoverthelongterm.Returnsmaybeflatterthanwewouldlike,orevennegativeforaperiodoftime,butovertheverylongtermthemarketshavealwaysbouncedbackandproventhemselvesquiterobust.
Foranyonejustbeginningtoinvesttoday,it’salsosomethingofacomforttorealizethattheGreatRecessionhaswrungsomeriskoutofthemarkets.Duringthefive-yearperiodfrom2008to2012,theS&P500returnedjust1.63%basedonthecompoundannualgrowthrate(or-0.17%whenadjustedforinflation).Thissuggestsstocksmayofferabettervaluethanthey
didbeforetherecession,whichcouldbodewellforthefuture.Marketsmay(andweemphasizemay)outperformintheyearstocome,bringingannualreturnsmoreinlinewithlong-termhistoricalaverages.
PreparingYourInvestmentSpreadsheet
Nowthatyou’vehadachancetoexaminesomehypotheticalspreadsheetexamplesandconsidertheprobableratesofreturnyoushoulduse,it’stimetoprepareyourowninvestmentspreadsheet.Thisspreadsheet
willserveasyourmasterplangoingforward.Itwilltrackyourtaxable,401(k),andRothIRAinvestmentsandwillincludeaGrandTotalcolumnsoyoucanquicklyseewhereyoustandattheendofeachyear.
Onceyourspreadsheetissetup,allyouhavetodoisrevisititonceayeartoassesshowyou’redoingagainstplan.You’llupdateitatthatpointtoincludeactualresults
insteadofestimatesfortheyearjustpast.Thatwillincreasetheaccuracyandrelevancyofyourplangoingforward.
Weurgeyounottoskipthisstepevenifthewordspreadsheetgivesyouchills.Wepromisetokeepitsimple.Moreimportantly,weofferaspreadsheettemplateonlineifyou’dprefernotbuildthetemplatefromscratch.(Andwhywouldyou?)
Toavailyourselfofthisshortcut,simplyvisitourwebsiteatwherewebe.comanddownloadtheExcelspreadsheettemplateunderthe“EarlyRetirement”tab.It’sthesametemplatewepresenthere,anditalreadyhasallofthecolumnsandformulassetupforyou.There’sevenahelpfulinstructionsheetonaseparatetabwithinthedocument.
You’llstillneedtogointo
thespreadsheetitself,ofcourse,andmanuallyenterthedollaramountsyouexpecttoinvesteachyear,butthisisasimplematterofdataentry.Oncethisisdone,thespreadsheetistailoredtoyoursituationandyoucanbegintweakingittoplaywithdifferentinvestmentscenarios.
AFirstLookatthe
SampleSpreadsheetWecreatedthefollowing
investmentspreadsheettoguideusonourownjourneytoearlyretirement.Becausewefounditgenuinelyuseful,wewantedtoshareitwithyoutoo.
SampleInvestmentSpreadsheet
(9%AnnualReturn)
Asyoucansee,thereare
separatecategoriesfortaxable,401(k),andRothIRAaccounts.We’lltalkmoreabouteachtypeofaccountinChapter12,butfornowsufficeittosaythattherearesignificanttaxadvantagesto401(k)andRothIRAaccountsthatmakethemvaluabletovirtuallyeverypersonplanningforretirement.
Anychangesyoumaketothespreadsheetareinstantlyreflectedinthebottomline.Forinstance,ifyouchangetheannualrateofreturnfrom9%to10%,youcaninstantlywatchyourtotalsincrease.Ifyouadjustyourtaxableinvestmentamountsfrom$5,000to$10,000peryear,youcanseehowyournesteggatthebottomofthespreadsheetimmediatelygrowsbigger.
Don’tfeellimitedbythesamplenumbersincludedinthespreadsheet;theyaresimplyillustrativeandhavenomorebearingonourownrealitythantheydoonyours.Asyoumayrecallfromourearlierhypotheticalexample,ouractualinvestmentsweremuchmoreerratic(toputitmildly)thanthecarefulprogressionofnumbersshownhere.Ourannualinvestmentamountsranged
fromnegligibleatthebeginningofourplantosubstantialattheend,sodon’tartificiallylimitwhatyourowninvestmentpicturehastolooklike.
MakeYourSpreadsheetaLivingDocumentWeencourageyouto
thinkofyourmasterplannotasasingledocumentsetin
stonebutasaflexibledocumentthatcanbealteredandfine-tunedatwill.Theideaistoplaywithdifferentscenariosuntilyouarriveatonethatfeelsrighttoyou.Ifyourmaterialsituationchanges,youcanalterthespreadsheettoreflectyournewreality,thuskeepingitcurrentandrelevanttoyourlife.Earlieriterationsofyourplancanalwaysbesavedfortherecord,butmakesurethis
year’splanisasaccuratetoyourreal-worldsituationaspossible.
Aspreadsheetwithnoapplicabilitytoyourreallifefranklymissesthewholepoint.Ifyouthoughtyoucouldsave$10,000peryearbutitquicklybecomesapparentyoucannot,don’tabandonyourplanaltogether.Instead,simplyalterittomakeitfitwhatyoucando.Tryhalvingyourgoalto
$5,000peryear.Seeifthatworksbetterforyourcurrentsituation.Youcanalwaysraiseyourinvestmentgoalslateron.It’sbettertoaimalittlelower–especiallyearlyonwhenyou’retryingtocreategoodinvestinghabits–thantogetdiscouragedaltogetherandgiveup.
ModifyingYourSpreadsheet
IfyoualreadyhavearudimentaryunderstandingofExcel,thenthepracticaltipsthatfollowshouldbeenoughtoguideyouthroughhowtomodifyandupdatethespreadsheet.Otherwise,detailedinstructionsareprovidedinAppendixB.Thatappendixalsoprovidesinformationonhowtocreateyourownspreadsheetfromscratchshouldyouprefertodoso.
Thedefaultspreadsheetshows20years’worthofdata(plusatoprowforanybeginninginvestmentamounts).Ifyouonlywanta15-yearplan,simplydeletethebottomfiverowsthatyoudon’tneed.Besuretoselecttheentirerowyouwanttodelete(e.g.,byclickingontherownumberatthefarleftthenhittingdelete).
Tocreatea25-yearplan,copythelastfiverows,put
yourcursorontheappropriatecell(e.g.,A30),thenpastetoaddfivemorerowstothebottomofthespreadsheet.Again,besuretoselecttheentirerowsyouwanttocopyandpaste.
Youcanmanuallyupdatetheyearsinthe“Year”columnsimplybyclickingonthecellsyouwanttochange,typinginthecorrectinformation,andhittingenter.
Ifyouhavealreadybegun
savingforretirementbeforereadingthisbook,thenchangethezerosinthetoprowofdatatothecorrectamounts.The“GrandTotal”numberattheendoftherowwillautomaticallyupdate.
Theshaded“AmountInvested”columnsaretheprimarycolumnsyouwillneedtoupdatetomakethespreadsheetyourown.Manuallyentertheamountsyouplantoinvesteachyear
inyourtaxable,401(k),andRothIRAaccounts.Thesecolumnscurrentlycontainsampledataonly,buttheyneedtoreflecthowmuchyouactuallyintendtoinvestfromoneyeartothenext.Plugindifferentamountsandseehowthespreadsheetautomaticallyupdates.Asthenumberschange,sodothetotalsatthebottomofthespreadsheet.
Mostoftheothercolumns
inthespreadsheetupdateautomaticallyanddonotrequireinputsfromyou.However,youcanadjustthe“Annual%Return”columnsinordertotestoutdifferentreturnscenarios.Thesecolumnsareallsettoadefaultof9%,butifyou’dliketousealowerorhigherpercentageyoucaneasilydothat.Double-clickonthecellyouwanttoupdateandsimplychangethenumber–
forexample,fromthedefault0.09(for9%)to0.08(for8%)or0.1(for10%)oranyotherpercentyouwishtoexperimentwith.Afteryou’vedonethisonce,youcancopyandpastethiscellinformationtoalloftheothercellsbelowittoapplythesamepercentageratetothosecells.
Theonlyothercolumnyoumightwishtoupdateisthe“401(k)Match”column.
Thiscolumnautomaticallycalculatesa401(k)matchforyou.Thedefaultissetto50%oftheamountinthecolumnpriortoit.Manyemployersmatchtheiremployees’401(k)contributionsatfiftycentstothedollar,althoughothersaremoregenerousandmatchdollarfordollar.Thepercentagecanbeadjustedtobringitinlinewiththeparticularsofyour401(k)plan.Double-clickonthefirst
cellyouwouldliketoupdateandchangethepercentage–forexample,from“0.5”(50%)to“1.0”(100%).Youcanthencopyandpastethiscelltoallotherapplicablecellsbelowit.
GettingtoYourNestEggAmountYourultimategoalin
usingtheinvestmentspreadsheetistoplugin
numbersuntilyouseethenesteggamountyouarrivedatinChapter9(“CalculateYourNestEgg”)appearintheGrandTotalcolumnacrossfromtheyearinwhichyouideallywishtoretire.Playingwiththenumbersandpercentagescanhelpyoufigureouthowbesttoachievethatgoal.
Ifyourearnenoughtobeabletoinvestsizableamountsofmoneyeachyear,the
processmayberelativelystraightforwardandyoumaybedoneinnotime.Butfortherestofus,itmaytakeabitmoretimeandeffort.
Youmayrealize,forinstance,thatyouhavetosavealotmorethanyouthoughtyoudidinordertoreachyourgoal.Atthatpointyouhavesomeimportantdecisionstomake.Youcaneitherkeepyourambitiousyearlyobjectivesinplaceand
committoworkingevenhardertoachievethem,oryoucanincreaseyourtimehorizon(e.g.,from15to20years)togiveyourselfmoretimetoreachyourgoal,oryoucanreconsideryourannualincomeneedsinretirementandstartthinkingcreativelyabouthowtoretireonless.
Alloptionsareonthetableatthispoint.Don’ttakeitalltooseriously:aplayful
andexperimentalattitudewillhelpyoumorethanastressed-outandfrustratedone.Tryondifferentapproachesliketryingondifferenthatsandseewhichonefitsyoubest.Retiringearlyisnotaone-size-fits-allsolution.Yoursolutionneedstobetailoredtofityourowncircumstancesandneeds.
What-IfScenariosSincenoneofuscanread
thefuture,itmakessensetoexperimentwithdifferentwhat-ifscenariostoseehowtheymightaffectyoudowntheroad.Whatifyourinvestmentsonlyreturn8%insteadof9%?Canyoustillreachyourgoals?Whatiftheyreturn11%or12%instead?Whynottestitoutandsee?Whatifyourjobprospectsimprovedramaticallyandyoustartinvestingdoublewhatyou
thoughtyoucouldhalfwaythroughyourinvestmentyears?Suchwasthecaseforus.Whynotrunawhat-ifscenariothatassumesadoublingofinvestmentamountshalfwaythroughyourplanandseehowitaffectsyourresults?
Afteryou’vereadChapter12,whichdiscussesallocatingmoneybetweentaxable,401(k),andRothIRAaccounts,youmaywant
torevisityourspreadsheetandtryexperimentingwithdifferentallocationstogetabetterhandleonhowbesttoapportionyourmoneyandreachyourgoal.
IsMyGoalAchievable?Onceyou’vepluggedin
numbersthatletyoureachyourgoalinthetimeyou’dlike,thenyouhavetoask
yourselftheall-importantquestion:Isthisreallyachievableformegivenmycurrentsituation?CanIreallysave$10,000nextyear?
Becauseintheendyournumbershavetobegroundedinrealityifthisistobemorethanjustanexerciseinnumbercrunching.Theyhavetojivewithyourreal-worldcircumstances.Sostarttothinkaboutwherethat$10,000isreallygoingto
comefromnextyear.Perhapsyouhavea
401(k)planatworkandyoucanautomaticallydeposit10%ormoreofyourpaycheckdirectlyintothat.AndperhapsyoucansetupautomaticpaymentsfromyourcheckingaccountintoaRothIRAaccounteachmonth.Howmuchcanyoureallyspareeachmonthwithoutpushingthingstoofar?Remember,thisisa
marathon,notasprint,soyoudon’twanttopushsohardyoumakeyourselforyourfamilymiserable.
Ifyoubegintosenseyourpreferredscenario,howeverdelightfulinitsoutcome,isoverambitiousintermsofitsday-to-daydemandsonyouoryourfamily,trybackingoffabit.Loweryourinvestmentamountsintheearlyyearsandseehowthataffectsyouroverall
retirementplan.Maybe15yearsissimply
tooambitiousforthetimebeingandyou’llhavetosettlefor20years–atleastuntilyourmaterialcircumstanceschangeforthebetter.Remember,whateverplanyouarriveat,it’snotsetinstone.Youmayreluctantlydecidetoaimfor20yearsonlytogetanunexpectedpromotionatwork,andsuddenly15yearsisbackon
thetable.That’sthetimetopulloutyourspreadsheetandhaveanotherlook.
Letyouractuallifedictatethenumbersyouplugintoyourspreadsheet,especiallyduringtheearlyyears.Tiethemtoreality.Trytoimaginereallysavingtheamountyouseeonpaperinthecomingyear,andifyoucandothatandfeelgoodaboutit,thenthatisatruenumberthathasrealvalueto
youandyoursituation.If,ontheotherhand,next
year’snumbermakesyoucringe,thenit’sbacktothedrawingboard.Tryasmallernumberuntilyoucanlookatitwithoutfeelingpanicky.Intheendyouwantanumberthatdoesn’tmakeyourpalmssweat!
GettingBuy-InonYourInvestmentPlan
Thisisasgoodatimeasanytomentiontheimportanceofinvolvingyourspouseorsignificantotherintheearlyretirementplanningprocess.It’sawfullyhardtogoitalonewhenitcomestosavingforearlyretirement–
unlessyouhappentobewellandtrulysingle.Ifyou’reacouple,thenthetwoofyoushouldideallybeonthesamepage.
TeamworkandCompromiseWeencourageyoueither
tolookatthespreadsheettogetherandtrydifferentscenariosasateam–orelsesharetheresultsoftwoor
threedifferentscenarioswithyourspouseandgetinputandbuy-inearlyon.Seeifheorsheisonboardwithyourgeneralapproach.Ifyougetthesenseyourplansaretooaggressivefromtheirstandpoint,seewhatyoucandototonethemdownabit.
Hopefullyyourspousewillbeasexcitedasyouareabouttheideaofretiringearly,butifnot,youmayhavetocomeupwitha
compromisesolution.Besuretoletyourspouseknowhowimportanttheideaofearlyretirementistoyou,butalsotrytobeflexibleaboutspecificretirementdatesandyearlyinvestmentamounts.
Ifyourspousegenuinelydoesn’twanttoretireearlylikeyoudo,thatdoesn’tmeanyounecessarilyhavetoabandonyourplansaltogether.Infactitcouldmakeplanningforretirement
easierinsteadofharder.Ifheorshegenuinelypreferstocontinueworkingandisn’tundulyputoutatthethoughtofyourretiringearly,thenyoumayneedtosavelessthanyouotherwisewouldhave.Yourspousewillcontinuetoreceiveasalary,soalessrigorousscheduleofinvestingmaybeneeded–whichcouldbebettersolutionforbothofyou.
EarlyRetirementasaSharedGoalIntheearlydaysofour
retirementplanning,RobinthoughtshewantedtocontinueworkingevenafterIretiredearly.Shesupportedmydesirebecauseshecouldseehowimportantitwastome,andshewasevenwillingtomakesomesacrificessowecouldsavemoreandhelpmakethatdreamcometrue.
SoIpluggednumbersintothefirstiterationofourspreadsheetandbeforelongwewereoffandrunning.Weinvestedsmallamountsatfirst,butatleastitwasabeginning.
Afewyearsintotheplan,Robincametotherealizationshewantedtoretireearlytoo.AtthatpointIpulledthespreadsheetoutagainandlookedatitwithfresheyes.Iexperimentedwithdifferent
scenariosandrejiggeredittoallowforthepossibilityofbothofusretiringearly.
Atfirsttheresultsweren’tpromising.OursalariesweresolowIsimplycouldn’tmakethenumbersaddup.Butwebothkeptthinkingandtalkingaboutituntilwearrivedatasolution.Robinwouldneedtoretrainandgetajobthatpaidmorethanhertravelagentjobcurrentlydid.Herhighersalarywould
allowusbothtoretireatthesametime.MeanwhileIwoulddowhatIcouldtoimprovemyownprospectsatworktogetustoourgoalfaster.
Fromthatdayforwardwebegantalkingandthinkingaboutearlyretirementasasharedgoal,oneforwhichwewerebothwillingtoworkhard.Itmeantbigchangesintermsofourjobsandourspendinghabits,butitalso
gaveussomethingmeaningfultofocusonandgetexcitedaboutinthenot-so-distantfuture.Wewouldgoonhikesonweekendsandtalkexcitedlyaboutthetravelpossibilitiesinourfutureoncejobsnolongertiedustoasingleplace.
Ourinvestmentspreadsheetbecameourroadmaptothefuture.Wecouldlookatitandseeweweremakingrealprogress
fromoneyeartothenext.ThedollaramountsintheGrandTotalcolumnkeptgoingup–andtheyweregoingupfastereachyearasourannualinvestmentamountsincreasedandcompoundingbegantomakearealdifference
AttheendofeachyearIwouldupdatethespreadsheetandwewouldhavealookatittogetherandseewherewestood.Itwasanexcitingtime,
andallthemoresobecauseitwasshared.
UpdatingYourSpreadsheetwithActualResults
Onceyourspreadsheetissetup,allyouhavetodoisrevisititonceayeartoassesshowyou’redoingagainstplan.You’llpluginactualresultsattheendofeachyear
soyoucanplanforfutureyearsusingrealnumbersinsteadofestimates.Eachyearyoudothis,thefuturebecomesalittlelessfuzzybecauseyouhavemorerealdatatoworkwith.Also,thewindowuntilyourtargetretirementdatecontinuestonarrow,sotherearefeweryearsinwhichyouhavetorelyoneducatedguessworktogettoyourgoal.
TakingaYear-EndSnapshotHereistheapproachwe
taketoupdatingthespreadsheetattheendofeachcalendaryear.OnDecember31wetakea“snapshot”ofourinvestmentsatthatmomentintime.Weaddupeachcategoryofinvestmentseparately–taxable,401(k),andRothIRA.Thenweplugthoseamountsintothetop
rowofthespreadsheet,replacingtheestimatedsubtotalswithrealdata.Wedeletealltheformulasandestimatesinthatrowandreplacethemwithasingletyped-innumberinstead–onefortaxable,onefor401(k),andoneforRothIRA.TheGrandTotalnumberupdatesautomatically,butweusuallyreplaceitanywaywithahardnumberinsteadofaformula
togiveitasenseoffinality.
UpdatingtheSpreadsheetAnnually:AnExampleLet’ssayit’sDecember
31,2014andthemarketshavepostedtheirfinalnumbersfortheyear.Atthatpoint2014isnolongeranunknownbutaknown,soyoucanpluginactualresults.On
thatdayyoutakeasnapshotofyourportfolio,addingupthesubtotalsforeachtypeofinvestment,pluggingthemintothetoprowofthespreadsheet,anddeletingalltheextraneousformulasandestimatesintheprocess.Upuntilnowthefirstfiverowsofyourspreadsheethavelookedlikethis(note:wehavedeletedthe401(k)columnsforreadabilitypurposes):
Nowtheylooklikethis:
Noticehowtherowfor2014nowonlyhasafewnumbersonit.Alltheotherdatahasbeendeleted.Thenumbersarehardnumbers
thathavebeentypedinratherthanbeingbasedonformulas,andanydatafrompreviousyearshasbeeneliminatedfromthechart.Theyear2014isnowthebeginningyearonthiscurrentiterationofthespreadsheet.
Notice,too,howallthesubtotaldollaramountsintheyearsbelow2014aredifferentfromwhattheywerebefore.That’sbecausetheactual2014datahasrolled
forwardintotheestimateddataforfutureyears.
Comparingthetwospreadsheets,youcanquicklytellyou’reaheadofplan.That’sgreatnews,ofcourse.Whenyoulookatthebottomlineofyourspreadsheet,youcanseetheGrandTotalnumberstillmeetsorexceedsyourdesirednestegg.
TrackingYourProgress
Trackingyourprogressletsyoufine-tuneyourplanalongthewayandmonitorifyouarestilloncoursetoretirebyyourtargetdate.Weencourageyoutotakeagoodhardlookatyourspreadsheetatleastonceayearinordertocompareactualperformanceagainstplan.Givesome
carefulattentionastohowbesttoproceedbasedontheactualfactsinfrontofyou.
WhatIfYou’reAheadofSchedule?Beingaheadofschedule
isafineproblemtohave:enjoyyourgoodfortune.Ifyourmaterialsituationhaschangedforthebetter–ifyou’vereceivedasubstantialraiseatwork,forexample–
nowmightbeagoodtimetoconsiderraisingyourannualinvestmentamountsfortheyearstocome.Bydoingsoyoumightdiscoveryoucanretireevensoonerthanexpected,orelsethatyou’regoingtohavealargernesteggthanyouthoughtyouwould.Eitherprospectisquitewonderfultoconsider.
WhatIfYou’re
BehindSchedule?Ifyou’rejustalittleoff
courseinanygivenyear,there’snoneedtoworry.Thatmaysimplybetheresultofpoormarketconditionsovertheshortterm,somethingoverwhichyouhavevirtuallynocontrol.Ifyou’reinabearmarket,thenit’shardlysurprisingyouaren’treachingyourexpectedgoalsfortheyear.Butthat’s
allright,youshouldtellyourself,becauseyou’rebuyingmoresharesofstockatalowerpricethanyoucouldhaveotherwise.Inthebullmarketyearsthattypicallyfollowafterabearmarket,yourreturnsarelikelytoexceedexpectations,andinthoseyearsyoushouldbeabletomakeupforlostground.
Ourthoughtprocessduringbearmarketswas
simplytoshrugourshouldersandsay,“Well,wedideverythingweplannedtodofortheyear.Wemetourpersonalgoalsintermsoftheamountsweinvested.Therestisuptothemarkets.”Thekeyasfaraswewereconcernedwasnottogetdiscouragedormakeabruptchangesbecauseofapanickyfeelingweneededtodosomething.Instead,weneededtostaythecourseand
continueinvestingaccordingtoplan.Aslongaswekeptdoingthethingsweknewwererighttodoandthatwereinourcontroltodo,therestwasamatterofhavingfaithinthelong-termtendencyofthemarketstogoupratherthandown.
WhatIfYou’reWayOffTrack?Ifyou’rewayofftrack
andhavesignificantlylesssavedupthanyouthoughtyouwouldbytheendofaparticularyearorstringofyears,thenyouhavesomeseriousthinkingtodo.
First,trytodeterminewhyyoufellshortofyourgoals.Didyouinvestasmuchasyouhadhopedto?Ifnot,perhapsyourgoalsweresimplytooambitious.Youmayneedtobringthemmoreintolinewithwhatyoucan
actuallyaccomplishandadjustyourmasterplanaccordingly.
Ontheotherhand,perhapsthemarketsexperiencedaseveredownturnandthroughnofaultofyourownyouwereblownoffcoursefromwhereyouthoughtyouwouldbebythispoint.Inthatcaseyouryearlyinvestmentgoalsaren’ttheproblem,butyoustillneedtofindawaytogetback
ontrack.It’snogoodwishingthingswerebetter:youhavetomakethemso.Sodecidewhichofthefollowingyouwanttodo:–Investextrainthecomingyearsinordertocatchbackupwithyouroriginalgoals.–Increaseyourtimehorizontogiveyourinvestmentsmoretimetocompoundandgrow.
–Plantomakedowithlessinretirement,whichmeansrethinkingyourspendingandlifestylechoicesasyouheadintothefuture.Ofcourseyoucanalways
hopeagainsthopethemarketsstronglyoutperformintheyearstocomeandfixtheproblemforyou.Butsincethatiscompletelyoutsideyourcontrol,it’sriskytorelyon–especiallyif
you’resignificantlybehindwhereyouthoughtyouwouldbe.Bettertotakemattersintoyourownhandsandreviseyourmasterplantorealignitwithyoursituationasitstandstoday.Otherwiseyouriskfallingfurtherandfurtherbehindonyourgoalsandfeelingmoredisheartenedtothepointwhereyousimplydecidetogiveup–andthatwouldbearealshame.Raiseorloweryourgoalstomake
themjibewithreality,butdon’tgiveupaltogetheroryou’llbedoingyourselfadisserviceinthelongrun.
TrackingYourPortfolioYoucantrackyour
portfolioperformancedirectlyonyourinvestmentfirm’swebsite,ofcourse,butyoumayalsowanttocreateasimpleportfoliotrackeron
Yahoo’sFinancewebpage.Youcanpullitupatamoment’snoticewithouthavingtoenterausernameandpasswordeachtimesincethereisnosensitiveinformationonthesite.Allitconsistsofisthemutualfundsymbolsandthenumberofsharesyouown.Thusitoffersaquickwaytocheckyourtotalsandtrackyourprogressonaregularbasis.Thebottomportionofour
portfoliotracker,showingourtaxableinvestmentsandourgrandtotal,lookslikethis:
Tocreateyourown
portfoliotracker,gotoYahoo’sFinancesite,clickon“MyPortfolios,”andselect“CreatePortfolio.”Giveyournewportfolioaname(wecallours“Total”)andbeginaddingmutualfundsymbolstoit,followedbythenumberofsharesyouownforeach.Hitsaveandyou’regoodtogo.Justclickon“Add/EditHoldings”ifyouwanttochangeorupdateanyinformation.
Theonlydownsidetoportfoliotrackerslikethisisthatyouhavetoperiodicallyupdatetheshareinformationifyouwanttokeepitcurrent.Theshareamountsdon’tautomaticallyupdateastheywillonyourowninvestmentfirm’swebsite.
KeepingaRecordofPerformance
Werecommendyousaveacopyofyourinvestmentspreadsheeteachyearbeforemakinganychangestoit.Thatwayyouhaveabackupincasesomethingshouldgowrong.Italsogivesyouahandyhistoricalrecordifyou
shouldeverwanttocompareyourcurrentspreadsheettoonesfrompreviousyears.Wekeepourspreadsheetsinafinancialfolderonourcomputerandlabeleachonebyyear:spreadsheet_2014,spreadsheet_2015,andsoon.Keepingonespreadsheetforeachyeargivesyouasolidrecordofwhereyou’vebeenandwhereyou’regoing.
TrackingCumulative
Goalsvs.ActualsWhenyoufirstestablish
youryearlygoals,youmaywanttocreateachartthatletsyoucomparecumulativegoalsvs.cumulativeactuals.Ouroriginalchartisshownonthenextpage,followedbythesamechartafterithadbeenfilledinwithactualsyearbyyearuntilweretiredin2006.Totalsincludestocks,bonds,andcashbut
nothomeequity.Thegoalslistedinboth
chartsareidentical,althoughyoumayhavenoticedtheoriginalchartextendsoutto2008andthefinaloneonlyto2006.That’sbecausewewereabletoretiretwoyearsearlierthanoriginallyplannedduetosalariesandinvestmentamountsinthelatterhalfofourplanthatweresignificantlyhigherthananythingwecouldhave
anticipatedbackin1994.Thisjustgoestoshowthatnoplanisperfect.Yourinitialplanrepresentsabeginningonly,sodon’texpectprecisionofitbeyondayearortwointothefuture.
Achartliketheoneabove
isinstructiveinthatitprovidesaseriesofsnapshotsintime,thefirsttakenatthebeginningofyourplan,theresttakenatintervalsoneyearapart.Whileyourspreadsheetisalivingdocument–oneyoushouldmodifytokeeprelevanttoyourlife–thechartaboveissimplyahistoricalrecordofyourprogress.
TrackingAnnualInvestmentAmountsThefinalnumbersyou
maywanttotrackareyourannualinvestmentamounts(goalvs.actual).Asimplechartliketheonebelowshoulddothetrick.Thesearesamplenumbersonly,ofcourse;youshouldenteryourowngoalnumbersfromthespreadsheetyoucreate.
Chapter11.Invest
RegularlyinIndexFundsOnceyouhaveprepared
yourinvestmentspreadsheet,youshouldknowexactlyhowmuchyouneedtoinvestover
thecomingyear.Nowtakethatamountanddividebytwelvetodeterminetheexactamountyouneedtoinvesteachmonthinordertomeetyourannualgoal.Allthatremainsistomakesureyouactuallyinvestthatamounteachmonth,regardlessofhowthemarketisperforming.
Thereshouldbenoquestionfromonemonthtothenextifyouaregoingto
invest:ofcourseyouaregoingtoinvest.Itdoesn’tmatterwhatthemarketsaredoing–whethertheyareup,down,orsideways.Youhavenocontroloverthatsoyoushouldn’tconcernyourselfwithit.Butyoudohavecontrolovermakingyourmonthlyinvestmentsasplanned.Staytruetothosemonthlycommitmentsandyou’llhavetakenyourbiggeststeptowards
achievingyourgoalofearlyretirement.
PutYourInvestmentsonAuto-Pilot
Thesecrettoinvestingregularlyistoputyourinvestmentsonauto-pilot.Ifyouautomatethesavingsprocess,ithappenswithoutyourhavingtothinkaboutit–andthat’sagoodthing,becauseyoumaywellbe
yourownworstenemywhenitcomestoinvestingonaregularschedule.Thingsgetintheway,expensesaddup,money’stight,themarketsaredown,you’refeelingdiscouraged,youdon’twanttowritethecheck,youdon’twanttothinkaboutitrightnow,youdon’thavethetimeortheenergy–theexcusesthehumanmindcancomeupwithnottodosomethingarenothingshortofamazing.
Auto-pilotgetsridofmostofthoseexcuses.
SetItandForgetItThebestplacetostart
automatingyourinvestmentsisatwork.Ifyourcompanyoffersa401(k)planthenyoushouldsignupforautomaticdeductionsfromyourpaycheck.Becausethemoneyistakendirectlyoutofyourpaycheckbeforeyoueverseeit,it’salmostasifitnever
existedinthefirstplace,soyoudon’tmissitsomuch.Youdon’thavetopartwithitbyhand–bywritingacheck,say,andseeingyourcheckbookbalancegetlower.Byautomatingtheprocess,you’veeliminatedthemiddleman–you–fromtheequation.
Youcanalsosetupautomaticmonthlytransfersdirectlyoutofyourcheckingaccountintoyourtaxableand
RothIRAaccounts.Youdecideontheamounteachmonthandwhichdayofthemonththetransferismade.Itwon’tbequiteasinvisibleasthe401(k)processbecauseyou’llseethemoneydisappearoutofyourcheckingaccounteachmonth,butatleastit’shands-offandyouhavelesstothinkabout,whichisyourgoal.“Setitandforgetit”isagoodmottowhenitcomesto
investing.Automatingyour
investmentskeepsyouonthestraightandnarrowtoyourannualinvestmentgoalinawaynothingelsewill.Youronlyresponsibilitythenbecomesmakingsureyouhavesufficientfundsonhandtocovertheautomatictransfers.Thinkofyourmonthlyinvestmentsasyouwouldyourmonthlymortgagepayment.There’s
noquestionyou’regoingtomakethatpayment:it’snotanoption,it’sanecessity.That’sthemindsetyouwanttofoster.
PayYourselfFirstYou’veprobablyheard
theexpression“payyourselffirst,”whichmeansinvestinyourownfuturefirstbeforepayingotherbillsorexpenses.Thatmaysoundalittleextreme,butitgivestop
prioritytoyou.Automatingyourpaymentsmakesitfarmorelikelyyouwon’tskipoutonapaymenttoyourself.Itforcesyourhandinaway,whichisn’tallbadwhenyouconsiderhowmanyotherthingsinlifearecallingoutforyoutospendmoneyonthem.ThesirencallofspendingisalittleeasiertoresistifyoutieyourselftothemastlikeOdysseusandgiveyourselfnootherchoicebut
tostaythecourse.Thatsaid,besuretoleave
yourselfalittlebufferwhenyouselectyourmonthlyinvestmentamountsoyouaren’tpushingrightupagainstthelimitsofwhatyoucanhandlefinancially.Bettertoselectasmalleramountyouknowyoucanmanagemonthinandmonthoutthantopushtoohardandfindyourselfstrappedforcashinanygivenmonth.
Consistencyisyourgoal,notstressandfinancialhardship.Letyourmonthlycontributiontoyourfuturebeapositiveaspectofyourlife,somethingyoucanfeelgoodabout,ratherthananegativeburdenthatputsastrainonyourexistence.
UseDollarCostAveraging
Puttingyourinvestmentsonautopilotletsyoutakeadvantageofatechniquecalleddollarcostaveraging.Withdollarcostaveragingyouinvestanequalamountofmoneyeachmonthinanassetregardlessoftheshareprice,whichmeansyouenduppurchasingmoreshareswhen
pricesarelowandfewershareswhenpricesarehigh.
Thisapproachtendstoreduceyouraveragesharepriceovertime.Alumpsuminvestedallatoncecouldbeinvestedatjustthewrongmomentwhenpricesareespeciallyhigh.Dollarcostaveraginghelpsinsulateyouagainstmarketrisktosomedegreebecauseyouspreadyourpurchasesoutevenlyoveralongperiodoftime
andoverarangeofprices.Let’ssayyoudecideto
purchase$100permonthofaparticularmutualfundforthreemonths.Inthefirstmonththefundisvaluedat$50,soyourfixedmonthlyinvestmentof$100buysyoutwoshares.Nextmonththevaluationis$33soyour$100buysyouthreeshares.Thelastmonthitis$25soyour$100buysyoufourshares.That’sninesharesaltogether
whichyou’veboughtforanaveragepriceofabout$33each($300÷9).Ifyouhadinvestedall$300inalumpsuminthefirstmonth,youwouldhavepaid$50pershareandonlyreceivedsixshares.Bydollarcostaveragingyouhavereducedyouraveragesharepriceandlessenedthemarketriskthatcancomewithinvestingalumpsumallatonce.
Dollarcostaveragingalso
helpsoffsetthenaturalhumantendencytobuyanassetwhenitisperformingwellandnotbuyitwhenitisperformingpoorly.Wealllikeawinner,don’twe?Butbuyinganassetwhenitisflyinghighmeansbuyingitatahighershareprice.Logicallyweshouldwanttobuyitwhenitisunderperformingandwecangetmoresharesforourmoney,butthisisn’talways
howhumannatureworks.Dollarcostaveraginghelpsusdowhatweshoulddoanyway,whichisbuymoresharesofaninvestmentwhenitis“onsale”andlesswhenitisnot.
DecideonanOverallInvestmentMix
Oneofthemostimportantdecisionsyoucanmakeasaninvestorisselectingyouroverallinvestmentmixofstocks,bonds,andcash.Yourindividualinvestmentswithinthatmixareofsecondaryimportancetotheportfolio
allocationitself.Whetheryoubuythisparticularstockorthatparticularstockislessimportantthandecidinghowmuchofyourportfolioshouldconsistofstocksinthefirstplace.
RiskToleranceandTimeHorizonYourinvestmentmix
shouldbeareflectionofyourownrisktoleranceandtime
horizon.Let’ssayyouhavealongtimehorizonandarelativelyhightoleranceforrisk(oratleastyouthinkyoudo;you’llknowforcertainafteryou’veriddenoutyourfirstmajorrecession).Inthatcaseyoumaywanttoinvestheavilyinstocksandhavejustatoeholdinbondsduringyourprimaryinvestingyears,sincestocksofferthegreatestpotentialforlong-termgrowth.
Ontheotherhand,ifyouhavearelativelylowtoleranceforriskandsuspectyouwon’tbeabletosleepatnightiftoomuchofyourmoneyisridingonstocks,thenyou’llwanttokeepamorebalancedportfolioofstocks,bonds,andcashtohelpbufferthevolatilitythatinevitablycomeswithowningjuststocks.
Yourtimehorizontoretirementisparticularly
importanttoconsiderwhendeterminingyourinvestmentmix.Aportfolio80%to100%investedinthestockmarketmightmakesenseinyourbeginningandmiddleinvestingyears,butasyounearretirementyouhavelesstimetorecoverfromseriousdownturnsinthemarket.Certainlyonceyouretireyouneedareliablesourcefromwhichtowithdrawmoneyifthestockmarketshould
nosedive,sohavingasolidpositioninbondsbecomescrucial.Capitalpreservationandincomegenerationbecomeatleastasimportantastheneedforadditionalcapitalappreciationonceyouretire.
Duringourprimaryinvestingyearsweinvested100%(orveryclosetoit)instocksandstockmutualfunds.Ouroverridinggoalduringthoseyearswascapital
appreciation.Weweren’tconcernedaboutmarketvolatilitybecauseourtimehorizonwaslongenoughatthatpointthatweknewwecouldrideoutwhateverstormsmightcome.Infactwevieweddownturnsinthemarketasbuyingopportunities,andwebenefitedfromthemoncethemarketsbouncedbackandstockpricesroseagain.
Wewaitedlongerthan
wasprudent,however,tocarveoutasignificantpositioninbondsasweapproachedretirement.Infactitwasn’tuntilwesoldourhomeinthefirstyearofretirementandputthemoneyintoabondfundthatweestablishedourfirstmeaningfulpositioninbonds.(Althoughwedidhave$30,000savedupinabondfundforuseoverthefirstyearofourretirementasa
partialhedgeagainstrisk.)Luckilyforusthings
workedout,butinhindsightitwouldhavebeenwisertoincrementallyincreaseourbondholdingsoverthelastfiveyearsleadinguptoretirement.Thenwecouldhaveapportionedsomeofthemoneyfromthesaleofourhometostocksandtheresttobondsbasedonourpreferredinvestmentmixasweenteredretirement.
TheCaseforaMoreAggressiveApproachThefollowingtable
makesitclearwhyyoushouldinvestprimarilyinstocksduringyourearlyyearswhenyoustillhavealongtimehorizonuntilretirement.Duringthisperiodyouwanttodoeverythinginyourpowertomaximizegrowth.
Thetableisbasedonhistoricaldatafrom1926to2011.That’s86years’worthofdata.Itillustrateshowyouraverageannualreturngoesupasyourallocationtostocksgoesup–from5.6%withanall-bondsportfolioto9.9%withanall-stocksportfolio.Italsoillustrateshowyourriskgoesupasyourallocationtostocksgoesup.Outof86years,youwouldhavehadto
stomach25yearswithalossifyouhadanall-stocksportfolio,ascomparedto13yearswithanall-bondsportfolio.
Thetablemakesitclearriskandrewardgohandinhand.Themoreriskyouarewillingtotakeon,themorerewardyouarelikelytoget.Afterall,ifitweren’tforthepotentiallyhigherreturnsofferedbystocksoverthelongrun,theneveryone
wouldinvestinbondsorcashbecausethosetendtobethesaferinvestments.
Nowaskyourself,Whenisthebesttimeinmylifetotakeonthemostrisk?Theanswerformostofusis,WhenIamyoung,healthy,andworkingfulltime.Whenbettertoskewyourinvestmentstowardshigher-riskstocksthanwhenyouareintheprimeoflifeandfullycapableoftakingonsuch
risks?Youshouldhaveyearsandyearsaheadofyoubeforeyouneedtotouchthemoneyyou’reinvesting,soyoucanaffordtoleaveitinplaceevenifitgoesdowninvalueforaperiodoftimeastheresultofabearmarket.
Inalllikelihoodyouwillneverbebettersuitedtotakingonmoreriskthanyouarerightnow.
TheCaseforaMore
ConservativeApproachYoumighthavenoticed
fromthetablethatyouonlyhavetosacrificeasmallamountofgrowthifyouhaveaportfolioconsistingof80%stocksand20%bondsascomparedto100%stocks.Thedifferenceintheaverageannualreturnisonly0.5%(9.9%vs.9.4%),whichisn’tmuch,especiallywhenyou
factorintheextrapeaceofmindthosebondsmaygiveyou.Evena70/30stock/bondportfoliooffersaveryrespectableaverageannualreturnof9.0%basedonhistoricalaverages.
Ifyouareaconservative,risk-averseinvestor,youcantakegreatcomfortinthis.Itisstillpossibleforyoutotakeagrowth-orientedstancewhilemitigatingyourrisktosomedegreebyinvesting70%in
stocksand30%inbonds.Thatwouldsatisfytheneedforcapitalappreciationduringyourprimaryinvestingyearswhilestillreducingsomeofthevolatilityalongtheway.
Onecouldarguablydoworsethansettinga70/30portfoliomixfromtheverybeginningandmaintainingthatmixthroughlife.
Ifyouareinvested70%ormoreinstocks,thenyou
standagoodchanceofreachingyourearlyretirementgoals.Muchlessthanthat,however,andyoubegintogetintoagrayareawhereyoucanstillexpecttoreachyourgoaleventually,butperhapsnotasquicklyasyoumighthaveotherwise.
TheRiskofBeingOverlyConservativeAnythinglessthan50%
stocksand50%bonds/cashduringyourprimaryinvestingyearsandyoubegintoenterwhatwewouldthinkofasanoverlyconservativespacewherecapitalappreciationtakesabackseattotheperceptionofsafety.Wesayperceptionofsafetybecauseit’safairquestionwhetheryoureallyaresaferwithanoverlyconservativeportfoliomix.Why?Becausethereismorethanonekindofrisk
whenitcomestoinvesting.Extremelyconservative
investorstendtofocussolelyonmarketrisk,whichistheriskoflosingmoneyfromfluctuationsinstockmarketprices(i.e.,ifstocksgodown,youlosemoney).Alotofpeoplearesoafraidofmarketrisktheywon’tevenconsiderinvestinginstocks.Theywouldratherputalltheirmoneyinabankaccountearning1%interest.They
believethey’replayingitsafethatway.
Butthey’reprobablynotadequatelyawareofinflationrisk,whichistheriskinflationwilleatawayattheirinvestmentsfasterthantheycangrow,makingtheirmoneyworthlessandlessovertime.Ifinflationgrowsat3%peryearandtheirinvestmentsonlyearn1%,theninessencetheyarelosing2%eachandevery
year.Suddenlythatsafebankaccountdoesn’tseemsosafeanymore,atleastwhenitcomestotheirlong-termbuyingpower.
Oncepeoplehaveanunderstandingofinflationrisk,they’regenerallymorewillingtotakeasecondlookatabalancedstockandbondportfolio.Despitetherealitiesofmarketrisk,thestockmarketonaveragereturnsabout9%peryearoverthe
longtermandbondsreturnonaverageabout5%to6%peryear.Thusawell-balancedstockandbondportfolioshouldkeepyouaheadofinflation.You’llgetabetterrealreturnonyourinvestmentthanyouwouldwitha“safe”bankaccount.
ChooseanInvestmentFirm
Whenwefirststartedinvesting,wehadinvestmentsscatteredalloverthemap,withpaperworkandelectroniccommunicationsstreaminginfrommanydifferentdirections.Itwassomethingofarelief,therefore,toswitchtoasimplerapproachandhold
justafewindexfundswithasingleinvestmentfirm.Suddenlywecouldseeallofourinvestmentsinasinglestatementandmanagethemwithmuchmoreease.
TheInvestmentFirmWeChoseAllofourmutualfund
investmentsarecurrentlywithTheVanguardGroupandhavebeensincewell
beforeweretired.Vanguardisgenerallyknownforhavingthelowestexpensesintheindustry.Theiraverageexpenseratioisanextremelylow0.20%(that’sone-fifthofonepercent),whichis82%lessthantheindustryaverageof1.12%.Thatmeansverylittleisgoingoutofyourpocketintothebehind-the-scenesmanagementandoperationofthefunds.
Weparticularlylikethe
factVanguardfundshareholdersownthecompany.Asanot-for-profitcorporation,thefund’sinterestsalignnaturallywiththoseofitsshareholders,whopayonlywhatitcostsVanguardtooperatethefunds.Therearenootherpartiestoanswertoandthusnoconflictingloyalties.Wethinkthisissomethingspecialinthemutualfundindustry.
Vanguard’senormousassetbase–consistingof20millionshareholderaccountswithmorethan$1.7trillioninU.S.mutualfundassetsasoftheendof2011–letsittakeadvantageofhugeeconomiesofscale.Theyareabigplayerinthefinancialinvestmentworldinthebestsenseoftheword.
WereceiveVanguard’semailnewslettersandalwaysfindtheiradvicerefreshingly
straightforward.ThewholeworldmightbeturningupsidedownasfarastheTVfinancialnewschannelsareconcerned,butyoucanalwayscountonVanguardtocounselyoutostaythecourse,keepabalancedportfolio,andtrustinthelong-termperformanceofthemarkets.Theirprudentadviceoftenrunscountertothepanickytoneofthemedia,andthatcanbeacomfort
duringdifficultfinancialtimes.
Justtobeclear,wehavenothingtogainfinanciallyorotherwisebyrecommendingVanguardtoyou.It’ssimplythefirmwehavechosentodoourbusinesswith.Thereareothergreatfirmsoutthere–Fidelity,CharlesSchwab,andT.RowePriceamongthem,tonamejustafew.Ifyouarealreadydoingbusinesswithoneofthesefirms,orwith
anotherofthemanyreputableinvestmentfirmsoutthere,wearen’tsuggestingyougothroughthehassleofswitchingfirmsunlessyouareunhappyinsomerespectwiththeserviceyouarereceivingorthefeesyouarepaying.Butifyouarejuststartingoutandarelookingforagoodinvestmentfirm,wewouldcertainlyrecommendVanguardbasedonourownexperience.
KeepingFundExpensesLowTheaveragemutualfund
companychargesfeessixtimeshigherthanVanguard’s.Thesefeesaddupovertimeandmakeasignificantdifferencetolong-termperformance.
Considerthis:withnofeesatall,a$100,000portfolioearning9%peryearwouldgrowto$560,000in
20years.Witha1%annualfeethefinalvaluewouldbe$458,000–morethan$100,000less.Iftheannualfeewere3%,whichisnotoutofthequestionwithsomemutualfunds,thefinalvaluewouldonlyreach$305,000–morethan$250,000less.YoucanseewhyfeesmatterandwhywemightdecidetogowithaninvestmentfirmlikeVanguardforthisreasonalone.
Thequestionoffeesisevenmoreimportantwhenitcomestobondfunds.Ahighfeecanquicklyoverwhelmabondfund’sperformance.Forexample,ifabondfundreturns4%inagivenyear,thena1%feeisequalto25%ofthatreturn.Ifthesamefundreturns1%inagivenyear,thena1%feeeffectivelytranslatesintoa0%return.Thusalow-returnenvironment,whetherfor
stocksorbonds,onlyincreasestheimportanceofkeepingfeeslow.
Vanguard’sultra-lowexpensesapplytobothstockandbondfunds.Tohighlightjusttwoexamples,theexpenseratiosforitsflagshipIndex500FundanditsTotalBondMarketIndexFundareanastonishinglylow0.05%and0.10%respectively.(ThesearetheexpenseratiosforthepreferredAdmiral
Shares,whichrequireaminimumfundbalanceof$10,000.)It’shardtoexpectmuchbetterthanthat.
Whicheverinvestmentfirmyouendupchoosing,werecommendyoumakesuretheirexpensesarelowerthanthenormandthatyoukeepyourinvestmentswithinthatsinglefirmasmuchaspossibleforsimplicity’ssake.Wealsorecommendyoucomparenotjustthefees
chargedbuttherangeofservicesofferedbydifferentinvestmentfirmsbeforemakingafinaldecisionastowhichoneisrightforyou.Forinstance,ifyouprefertodomostofyourinvestinginindividualstocksratherthanmutualfunds,youmightfindanonlineinvestmentfirmspecializinginlow-coststocktradesthatsuitsyourneedsbetterthanVanguard.
WhyIndexFundsMakeSense
Ifyouthinkofinvestingasprimarilyameanstoanendandnotapassioninandofitself,thenindexfundinvestingmightbetherightanswerforyou.It’sagreatsolutionifyouwanttokeepyourfinanciallifeassimple
andlow-maintenanceaspossible.
Withindexfundsyoustoptryingtobeatthemarketsandinsteadsimplykeepupwiththem.Indexfundsmirrorthemarketstheytrackinsteadoftryingtobeatthem.Theyreplicateascloselyaspossibletheinvestmentweightingandreturnsofthebenchmarkindextheyaredesignedtotrack.
Perhapsthemostfamousindexfundofallisalsothefirstevercreated:theVanguard500IndexFund,whichtrackstheS&P500Index.ItwascreatedbyJohnBogleofTheVanguardGroupin1975.VanguardisnowthelargestmutualfundcompanyintheU.S.,andthefundhasbecomeamainstayofmanyaninvestmentportfolio.
Built-InDiversificationWhenyoubuyanindex
fund,youarebuyingawholeportfolioofstocksinasinglefund,soyourriskislowerifanyoneofthecompaniesinthatfundshouldplummetinvalueorgooutofbusiness.Thediversificationprovidedbyanindexfundmeansyourinvestmentsarespreadoutovermanycompaniesand
usuallyovermanyassetclasses.Thiscanbeacomforttothosewhofeeltheyarenotquiteuptothetaskofaccuratelyevaluatingasinglecompany’shealthandfinancialprospectsbasedonabalancesheetalone.Ratherthenbettingyourfutureononestockorahandfulofstocks,youcanspreadyourriskoverhundredsoreventhousandsofstocksandsleepbetteratnightbecauseofit.
BetterPerformanceBecauseindexfundsare
passivelymanaged,theirfeestendtobeverylow,andbecauseofthattheyactuallytendtoperformbetteroverthelongrunthanmostactivelymanagedmutualfunds.Thiscomesassomethingofasurprisetomostpeoplewhentheyhearitforthefirsttime.Afterall,you’dthinkaninvestment
managerwithallhisaccumulatedknowledgeandexperiencewouldconsistentlybeabletobeatapassivelymanagedindexfund,andyetexceptinrareinstancesthisisnotthecase.
Why?Becausetheactivefundmanagerhastochargehigherfeesthanapassivelymanagedindexfunddoes.Ofcoursetheactivemanagerexpectstobepaidforhisservices,andhealsotendsto
trademorefrequentlythanapassivelymanagedfunddoesandthushastocoverthosehighertradingexpenses.Overtimethosehigherfeesserveasadragonperformance–adragthevastmajorityofactivefundmanagerscan’tovercomeoverthelongterm.Bycomparison,indexfundschargeverylowfeesfortheservicestheyprovideandasaresultofferhard-to-beatvaluetotheindividualinvestor.
Welikethefactindexfundsaren’tatthemercyofanyoneperson,nomatterhowwellintentioned.Evenagoodfundmanagersometimesmakesbadinvestmentchoices.Then,too,activefundmanagerssometimesretireorchangeinvestmentfirmsorarereplaced,andthenextmanagermayfollowaconsiderablydifferentandriskierinvestmentstrategy.
Youdon’thavetoworryaboutthiswithapassivelymanagedindexfund.Wethinkthismakesindexfundsamorereliableinvestmentoverthelongterm.
TaxEfficiencyIndexfundstendtobe
quitetax-efficientbecauseshareturnoverisminimal.CompaniesarerarelyaddedtoorremovedfromtheS&P500,forexample,sofunds
trackingitrarelyneedtobuyorsellshares.Thatmeanstherearefewercapitalgainsdistributionstoworryaboutattaxtime.
Indexfundsarealsosimpletoownattaxseasonbecausethemutualfundcompanyprovidesyouwithalltheinformationyouneedtoreportonyourtaxforms.Comparethistoanindividualstockwhereyouareresponsibleforcalculating
andreportingthecostbasisofthesharesyouhavepurchased,sometimesoveraperiodofmanyyears,oncethesharesaresold.Speakingfrompersonalexperience,wecantellyouthisaddsunwelcomecomplicationsattaxtime.
ASimplerApproachWithindividualstocksit
helpstobeabletoreadandunderstandabalancesheet
andaprofitandlossstatementinordertocorrectlyassessacompany’sfundamentalhealth.Ittakestime,effort,andskilltoaccuratelyassessasinglecompanyanditsstock,decideifthestockpricerepresentsagoodvalue,anddeterminenotonlywhentobuythestockbutalsowhentosellit.Stockindexfundsbycomparisonrequirefewerdecisionsandlessanalysis.
Becausetheyaremadeupofhundreds(orsometimesthousands)ofindividualstocks,stockindexfundsarebuy-and-holdinvestmentsthatbytheirverynaturerequirelittleinthewayofpersonalizedattention.Theycanonlybeassessedintheaggregate.YoumightevaluatetheexpenseratioofanIndex500fund,forexample,anddecidewhetherornotthefundisagoodfit
foryourportfolio,butitwouldmakelittlesensetoanalyzeall500individualcompaniesmakinguptheindexsincetheyarebeingsoldasapackageanyway.Youcouldn’ttakethemapartevenifyouwantedto.
Bythesametoken,bondindexfundsofferamucheasierapproachtoinvestinginbondsthangoingthroughtheheadachesofladderingindividualbonds.Witha
bondfundyougetprofessionalmanagement,broaddiversification,andhighliquidityatverylowcost.Therearenofeesforbuyingorsellingsharesofano-loadbondindexfund,whereasthebid-askspreadtobuyandsellindividualbondscanbequitehigh.Foreaseofuseandlowcost,it’shardtobeatagoodbondindexfund.
Withindexfundsingeneral,yourlifedoesn’t
havetorevolvearoundyourinvestments.Youliveyourlifeasnormalanddothethingsyoulovetodo.Meanwhileyourinvestmentsareworkingforyouinthebackgroundwithoutyourhavingtopaymuchattentiontothem.
Nomoretryingtobeatthemarkets.Nomorespendinghoursreadingfinancialmagazinesandtryingtofigureoutthenexthotstock
orthenexthotmutualfund.Simplyinvestit,forgetit,andbedone.Thisbuy-and-holdstrategymakesyourlife(andyourtaxes)muchsimpler.Insteadofreactingtothelatestmarketnews,youinsulateyourselffromthoseconcernsandfocusonwhatyoucancontrol,whichisyourmonthlycontributionstotheindexfundsyouhavechosen.
EaseofAccessandUsabilityAfinalbenefitofmutual
fundsingeneralisthattheyofferwonderfullyeasyaccesswhenitcomestobuyingandsellingshares,transferringsharesbetweenfunds,andwithdrawingmoney.Thiscanbeanimportantfactorwhendecidingwheretoinvestyourmoney.
Wecontinuetoowna
littlestockinthecompanyforwhichIworked,andeachtimewewithdrawsharesweneedtopayatransactionfeetothebrokerandanotherfeetohavethemoneywiredelectronicallytoourcheckingaccount.Thesefeesapplyeachandeverytimewewithdrawmoney,nomatterhowbigorsmallthetransaction.BycomparisonwecanwithdrawfundsfreeofchargefromVanguard
withnobrokerinvolved,andthemoneyautomaticallyappearsinourcheckingaccountinamatteroftwoorthreebusinessdays.Theirwebsiteiseasytouseandletsuscompleteatransactioninlessthanaminuteortwo,andwecanquicklygetanoverviewofourtotalportfolioholdings.
InvestinYourCoreHoldings
Yourcoreholdingsarethehandfulofinvestmentsthatformthefoundationofyourportfolio.Theyaretheinvestmentsyouholdontoforalifetime.Forthatreasonyouwanttomakesuretheyarehigh-qualityinvestmentswithahistoryofsteadyperformance.
Werecommendyouusebroadlydiversifiedindexfundsasyourcoreholdings.Justthreestockindexfundsareenoughtogiveyouworldwidecoverageforequities.Youreallydon’tneedmorethanthat!TothoseyoushouldaddonemorefundforU.S.bonds.Herearethefourfundtypeswerecommendforyourcoreholdings:
1.S&P500IndexFund.AnindexfundthatmirrorstheS&P500willgiveyoubroadexposuretothetop500large-capcompaniesintheU.S.Large-capstandsforlargecapitalization,andthesearethelargest,mostpowerful,andmostwell-capitalizedcompaniesintheU.S.Togethertheyaccountforaboutthree-fourthsoftheU.S.stock
market’svalue.It’sfairtosaynoU.S.-basedportfolioiscompletewithoutanS&P500indexfund.2.ExtendedMarketIndexFund.AnindexfundthatmirrorstherestoftheU.S.stockmarketgivesyoubroadexposuretoU.S.mid-capandsmall-capstocks.Suchfundstypicallyinvestinabout3,000stocksaccounting
foraboutone-fourthofthemarketcapoftheU.S.stockmarket.Anextendedmarketfund(orS&Pcompletionindex)isconsideredacomplementtoanS&P500indexfund,andtogetherthetwoprovideexposuretotheentireU.S.equitymarket.Mid-andsmall-capmarketstendtobemorevolatilethanthelarge-capmarketbutalsoofferthe
potentialforhigherreturnsoverthelongrun.3.TotalInternationalStockIndexFund.TheworldisbiggerthanjusttheU.S.,soitmakessensetohaveexposuretothebiggest,best,andfastestgrowingequitiesfromothercountriesaroundtheglobe.Lookforanindexfundthatgivesyoubroadexposuretothetotal
internationalstockmarket,includingbothdevelopedandemergingeconomies.Emergingmarketstockscanbemorevolatilethandomesticstocks,andcurrencyriskcanaddevenmorevolatility.Ifthisisaconcernforyou,considerinvestinglessinthisfundthantheothertwoequityfunds.4.TotalBondMarket
IndexFund.AbalancedportfolioshouldincludeacorefundthatmirrorstheoverallU.S.investment-gradebondmarket.Atotalbondmarketfundwilltypicallyinvestaboutone-thirdofitsassetsincorporatebondsandtwo-thirdsinU.S.governmentbondsofvaryingmaturities(short-,intermediate-,andlong-term).Whilebondfunds
tendtobesensitivetoincreasesininterestrates,theiroverallrisksarelowerthanstockfunds.Anymajorinvestment
firmwillofferindexfundsofthesefourtypes,sowhicheverfirmyouchoose,youshouldbeabletofindgoodmatches.
CoreVanguardFundsWe
RecommendSinceourown
investmentsarewithVanguard,weprovideadditionaldetailsaboutthecoreVanguardfundsweownandrecommendinthefollowingtable.Foreachfundlistedtherearetwoversionsbasedontheamountyouhavetoinvest.TheInvestorSharesversionrequiresaminimuminitial
investmentof$3,000,whiletheAdmiralSharesversionrequires$10,000andoffersalowerexpenseratio.ThetypicalinvestorstartsinInvestorSharesthentransferstoAdmiralShareswithafewclicksofthemouseoncehisorherinvestmentcrossesthe$10,000threshold.
Ifyouwanttoownevenfewercorefunds,thereisaneasywaytodoit.InsteadofowninganIndex500FundandanExtendedMarketFund,youcaninvestinsteadinaTotalStockMarketIndexFund,whichessentiallycombinesthetwointoone.WithonefundyougainexposuretotheentireU.S.equitymarket,includingsmall-,mid-,andlarge-capgrowthandvaluestocks.
PercentagetoInvestinEachFundTheapproachwetook
wastoinvestonethirdofourmonthlyinvestmentamountineachofthethreecoreequityfundsdescribedabove:onethirdintheIndex500fund,onethirdintheExtendedMarketfund,andonethirdintheInternationalStockfund.
Atfirstyoumayhaveto
saveupenoughtomeetminimumdepositrequirementsforeachfundbeforemovingontothenext.Butonceallthreefundsareupandrunning,youcaninvestaslittleas$100permonthautomaticallyintoeachfundfromthatpointforward.Thatmakesitpossibletoinvestonamonthlybasisinequalincrements.
Ifyoupreferamorerisk-
averseapproach,youmaywanttoinvestahigherpercentageintheIndex500fundandalowerpercentageintheothertwo.Ofthethreefunds,theInternationalStockfundisprobablythehighestriskbecauseitaddsbothcurrencyriskandemergingmarketriskintotheequation.Letyourpersonalpreferencesguideyouintermsofthespecificpercentagesyouchoosetoinvestineachtype
offund:forexample,50%Index500,30%ExtendedMarket,20%InternationalStock.
Whenyourfinancialsituationallowsforit,youshouldalsomakeaninitialinvestmentinaTotalBondMarketindexfund.Ifyouareallocatingessentially100%tostocksduringtheearlyandmiddleyearsofyourinvestmentprogram,simplykeepthebondfundatthe
minimumlevelforthetimebeing.Then,aboutfiveyearspriortoyourtargetretirementdate,beginaddingmoretoit.
Ifyouprefertomaintaina70/30or80/20mixfromtheverybeginning,thenaddtothebondfundaspartofyourongoinginvestmentallocationthroughoutyourprimaryinvestingyears.Keepinmindifyoudownsizeyourhomeonceyouretire,anyextraequityfromthesalecan
makeforanice“surge”investmentintoyourbondfund.
AvoidChasingReturns
It’stemptingtoshootforbigreturns,especiallyasabeginninginvestor.Youwanttoscorebigandmakealotofmoney,sosometimes,unfortunately,yourfirstinvestmentsturnouttobeamongyourworst.Certainlythatwasthecaseforus.Insteadofbuyingmeat-and-
potatoesindexfunds,whichseemedfranklyboringtousatthetime,wechasedthepotentiallyhigherreturnsofferedbyactivelymanagedandspecialtyfunds.
TheLureofTop100ListsAsnoviceinvestorswe
scouredthefinancialmagazinesforthe“bestofthebest”mutualfunds.Top100
liststhatrankedfundsbasedontheirrecentperformancewereaparticulardraw.Perhapsitisn’ttoosurprisingthereforethatwefoundourselvesavidlytrackingthebestfundsontheselistsandmakingourinitialselectionsfromtheonesatornearthetop.Whateverfundhadperformedthebestoverthepastfiveortenyearswastheonewewantedtoinvestinnext.Well-placedadsforthe
self-samemutualfundstendedtounderscorethewisdomofinvestinginthesefundsaboveallothers.
Theysaypastperformanceisnoguaranteeoffutureresults,anditturnsouttheymeanit.Theproblemwithchasingreturnsisthatyouendupbuyinghighandsellinglow–theexactoppositeofwhatyouwanttodo.Fundswithoutsizedreturnshaveoften
hadtotakeoutsizedrisksinordertogetwheretheyareatthetopoftheleaderboard.Theyrarelystaythereforlong.Thebigbetsthatgotthemthereinthefirstplaceoftensinkthemoncemarketsshiftorinvestorsentimentchanges.Expenseratioscanalsobedramaticallyhigherforthesehigh-flyingfunds,andthattendstopullthembackdowntoearthoverthelongrun.
Ourfirsttaxableinvestmentisagoodcaseinpoint.In1994weput$2,000intoanoverseasemergingmarketsfundrightatthetail-endofanamazingfive-yearrunforemergingmarketsstocks.Itwashardlysurprisingsuchfundswereatthepinnacleofallmutualfundsatthatpoint,rightatthetopoftheTop100lists.Predictablyenough,givenitshighvaluationanditshigh
fees,thefundperformedsubstantiallybelowparafterweboughtit.Weeventuallyhadtosellitforaslightlosssomesixorsevenyearslaterwhenwefinallymadetheswitchtoindexfundinvesting.
Oursecondtaxableinvestmentwasequallyquestionable,amomentumgrowthfundridinghighinthe#1positionontheleaderboardwhenwebought
it.Thefundfullyembracedtheconceptofmomentuminvesting–thatis,buyingagrowthstockwhenitisonatearandridingitupevenhigher.Thiswasaverymid-1990’sinvestmenttomake.Wewererightinthemidstofthedot-comboomanditseemedliketechnologystockscouldnevergodownagain.Thefundreallydidgoonatearatfirst,thenthemomentumfizzledbefore
goingthewrongwayfast.Wegotoutintimetoavoidtheworstofthecarnage,butonceagainwefoundourselvesdisappointedwithafundwehadfeltveryexcitedaboutatfirst.
HighValuations,HighRisks,HighExpensesIttooktwoorthree
setbackslikethisbeforewe
learnedourlessonthehardway.Buyingactivelymanagedfundswithhighvaluations,highrisks,andhighexpensesinthehopesofscoringbigdidnotmakeawholelotofsense.Nordiditmakesenseforusasbeginninginvestorstobebuyingfundswithsuchanarrowfocus–suchasemergingmarketsormomentumgrowthfunds.Insteadweshouldhavebeen
concentratingoureffortsonbuildingahealthycoreportfolio.Inotherwords,weshouldhavebeenbuyinghighlydiversifiedstockindexfundswithlowfees.
Ittookusalongtimetolearnthislesson,andwehopeyoucanlearnfromourmistakesandmakeahealthierstarttoyourinvestingprogramthanwedid.Ifyouwanttobuynichemarketfunds,atleastwaittodoit
untilafteryouhaveahealthycoreportfoliobuiltup.Sectorandspecialtyfundsshouldbeconsidereddessert,notthemaincourse.
Steadilybuyinglow-costindexfundsmaynotbethemostglamorousthingintheworld,butaskyourselfwhyyouareinvestinginthefirstplace.Isitfortherushthatcomesfrommakingabigreturn?Orisitfortherewardofreachingyourretirement
goalsuccessfully?Therushtoscorebighasmoretodowithgamblingthaninvesting,whereasabuy-and-holdapproachtoindexfundinvestingisoneyoucanusethroughoutyourlifeasareliablestrategyforgettingrichslowly.
OtherOptionsBesidesMutualFunds
Mutualfundsaren’ttheonlygameintown:thereareotherviableoptionsforgettingrichslowlythroughaprogramofsteadyinvestments.We’dliketotouchbrieflyonafewofthese.
ExchangeTradedFundsExchangeTradedFunds,
orETFs,areclosecousinsofmutualfunds.Theytendtobelow-costandtax-efficientandtheytradelikeastock.Whereasmutualfundsareboughtorsoldattheendofeachtradingday,ETFstradethroughoutthedayatpricesthatcanbehigherorlowerthantheirnetassetvalue.
ThereisnominimuminvestmentrequirementforETFs–akeybenefittobeginninginvestors–andyoucaninvestasmuchoraslittlemoneyasyouwish.
ETFsalsooffertaxbenefitstoinvestors.Mutualfundsmustdistributecapitalgainstotheirshareholdersonayearlybasis(i.e.,whenevershareshavebeensoldataprofitinordertokeeptheportfolioinlinewiththe
weightedindexbeingtracked).Thesegainsaretaxableevenifyoureinvestthedistributionsinmoresharesofthesamefund.Bycomparison,investorsinETFsgenerallyonlyrealizecapitalgainswhentheysellshares.Thisgivesthemabitmorecontroloverwhentheyrealizecapitalgainsandhavetopaytaxesonthem.
MostETFstrackanindexandarethushighly
diversified.Theycanholdstocks,bonds,andevencommodities.Theirexpenseratiostendtobelowerthanthoseforcomparablemutualfunds.OnereasonforthisisthatanETFdoesnothavetomaintainacashreserveforredemptions.TheVanguardS&P500ETF(VOO),forexample,hasanultra-low0.05%expenseratio.Thatmatchestheexpenseratioforthe“AdmiralShares”version
ofitsIndex500fundandislowerthanthe“InvestorShares”version.
BrokeragecommissionssometimesapplywhenyouarebuyingorsellinganETF.Animportantexceptionistypicallymade,however,whenyouarebuyingorsellingETFsofferedbyyourowninvestmentfirm.Forexample,VanguardETFscanbeboughtandsoldcommission-freethrough
VanguardBrokerageServices.Todiscouragedaytrading,Vanguardallows25freetradesofthesameETFina12-monthperiodbeforerestrictingfurthertradingfor60days.
AdiversifiedETFindexfundheldoverthelongtermcanbeasolidinvestmentchoice,buttheveryabilityofanETFtotradelikeastockcansometimesbeadownsideinthatitincreasesthe
temptationtoengageinmarkettimingorshort-termspeculation.
Still,thereisalottolikeaboutETFsandnotmuchtodislike.Wecancertainlyseethevirtuesofinvestinginthem.Perhapsoutofasenseoffamiliarityifnothingelse,wehaveremaineddedicatedmutualfundinvestors.WebelievemutualfundsandETFsofferroughlycomparableexperiencesas
longasyouarealreadyinvestingwithalow-costinvestmentfirmlikeVanguard.
IndividualValueStocksIndividualstocksoffer
anotherworthyalternativetomutualfundsorETFs.Ifyoudecidetogothisroute,besuretogiveyourselfabasiceducationinfinancialmatters
firstsoyouhavethegroundworkneededtobeanastuteinvestor.WerecommendyoureadabookortwoaboutWarrenBuffett,widelyconsideredthemostsuccessfulinvestorofthe20thcentury,togetanideaofhisvalueapproachtoinvesting.
Buffett’sadviceatitsmostbasicistopurchasebusinessesatalargediscounttotheirintrinsicvalue,which
meansavoidinghigh-flyinggrowthstocksandstickinginsteadtocompaniesthatareundervaluedbythemarketforonereasonoranother.Thesecompaniesmaybetemporarilyontheropesbutarelikelytomakeastrongcomeback.
Ifyoucanlearntobeacontrarianinvestorandbuystockswhenthey’rebeatendownbutfundamentallysound,you’llhavegonea
longwaytowardsbecomingawiseinvestor.It’seasytobeluredbytechcompaniesmakingsexyproducts,butthesesamestocksarefrequentlyoverpricedbecausetoomanyotherpeoplewantthemtoo,andusuallyforthewrongreasons.Bycomparison,whatmightlooklikeaboringoldvaluestockatfirstglancecanpackalotofpunch.Insteadoffocusingonwhatacompanydoes,we
recommendyoufocusonwhatitreturns.Letthatbethedeterminingfactorinwhetheryoudeemacompanytobeexcitingornot.
Bearmarketscanbeasmartinvestor’sbestfriend.Keepaneyeoutforstocksthathavebeenbatteredalongwiththemarketasawholeeventhoughtheirfundamentalsaresound.Youcanalsolookforcompaniesthathavebeenbeatenupin
thenewsrecentlybutareintrinsicallysound.Netflixcomestomindasarecentexample.Aseriesofmanagerialmisstepssentthestocksharplydownward,yettheunderlyingbusinessmodelwassoundandthecompanycontinuedtoearnprofits.Anastuteinvestormighthavesteppedinandpurchasedshareswhentheywereatorneartheirlowsandreapedtherewardslateron.
Sometimesanopportunitycomesalongthatisn’tavailabletothegeneralpublic.Asanemployeeatmyaerospacefirm,forexample,Iwasabletotakeadvantageofmycompany’semployeestockpurchaseplan.Itallowedmetopurchasesharesoftheirstockwhichthecompanymatched20%uptocertainmonthlydollarlimits.That’squiteadealwhenyouthinkaboutit:it’s
likegettinga20%freereturnonyourinvestmenteveniftheunderlyingstockpriceremainsflat.Oncewehadwrappedourmindsaroundthatidea,weboughtafairamountofcompanystockovertheyears.Notsurprisinglyitturnedouttobeoneofourbestinvestments,especiallywhenthestockpriceitselfstartedtoriseappreciably.Keepaneyeoutforsimilaropportunities
inyourownlife,especiallywithregardtothecompanyforwhichyouwork.
Themajordownsidetoinvestinginindividualstocksisthatyourriskishigherbecauseyou’reinvestedinonlyahandfulofstocksatatime.You’remuchlessdiversifiedthanyouwouldbewithanindexfund,andifoneortwoofyourstocksshouldplummet,itcouldhaveabigimpactonyourportfolio.On
theotherhand,ifyou’reashrewdinvestorandyourstocksperformwell,youstandtobenefitinabigway.
Unfortunatelymostofusaren’tasastuteatstockpickingasWarrenBuffett,sounlessyouareparticularlyconfidentofyourabilitiesinthisregard,wewouldrecommendyousticktoindexfundinvestingasthesaferandmorereliableapproach.However,ifwe
weretodoitalloveragain,wewouldatleastconsidervaluestockinvestingasaworthyalternativesolutiontoachievingfinancialindependence.Somecombinationofindexfundinvestingandvaluestockinvestingisalsoworthconsidering.
AnyOtherOptions?We’llbrieflymentiontwo
otheroptionsthatcometo
mindforreachingyourearlyretirementgoals.
Buyingandsellingrealestateoffersafeasibleapproachtoachievingfinancialindependence,providedyouhaveagoodunderstandingofyourlocalrealestatemarketandasharpeyeforvalue.Insomecasesthismightinvolveflippinghomes,whereyouputsweatequityintoafixer-upperthenresellitataprofit,andin
othersitmightinvolveestablishingacollectionofrentalpropertiesinyourlocalareathatyoumanageandrentoutonamonthlybasis.Wedon’tpresumetogiveadviceonthissubjectsinceitwasnottheapproachwetook.Wemerelymentionitbecauseweknowofotherswhohavetakenthistacktocreatingamonthlyincomestreamanditworkedforthem.Wesuspectitwoulddemandmorehands-
oneffort,though,andmightrequireyoutobephysicallypresenttomanagethebusinessafteryouretired.
Anotheroptionworthmentioningisbecominganentrepreneurandstartingyourownbusiness.Ofcoursetheskyisthelimitwiththisapproach:youcouldnotonlygetrichslowlybutgetrichquickifyouhitupontherightbusinessopportunity.Ontheotherhand,theriskofbeing
anentrepreneurcanbequitehighsoittakescouragetochoosethisoption.Ineffectallyoureggsareinonebasket–yourbusiness–soifitfailsyourdreamofearlyretirementcanfailalongwithit,oratleastbesidetrackedforatime.Butifitsucceedsitcouldoffersubstantialfinancialwell-beingandagenuinesenseofaccomplishment.
Notlongagowemeta
couplenamedSteveandLynnMiller(webetripping.com)whosuccessfullytooktheentrepreneurialapproachtofinancialindependence.Theystartedasoftwarebusinessin1998witha$10,000investmentoftheirownmoneyandmaintained100%ownershipofthebusinessuntiltheysolditin2009.Earlyretirementwasapartoftheirplanfromthevery
beginning.Theyachievedtheirgoalandretiredatages50and52–whileraisingtwokidsnoless.Wemetupwiththemjustastheyweredroppingtheirkidsofftocollegeandventuringoffonathree-monthtriptoEcuador,Peru,andtheBahamas.Wewereimpressedbythegutsittookforthemtostarttheirownbusiness,managecashflowissues,worklonghours,andeventuallyselltheir
softwarebusinessforahealthyprofit.
Forthosewhohavetheingenuityandtemperamentforit,theentrepreneurialpathcanbeasatisfyingandrewardingone.Fortherestofus,areliablejobandsomesimpleindexfundinvestingmaybethepreferableroute.Slowandsteadywinstheraceformostofusandofferswhatmaybethesafestpathtoearlyretirement.
Chapter12.Take
Advantageof401(k)sand
IRAsIrememberreadingfor
thefirsttimeasabeginning
investorabouttheadvantagesofinvestingina401(k)planandfeelingenergizedaboutsavingforthefutureinawayIneverhadbefore.Thetriplebenefitofacompanymatch,tax-deferredgrowth,andlowertaxeswassimplytoogoodtopassup.Igotstartedrightawayinvestinginthe401(k)planofferedthroughmycompany.Itfeltlikewewerebeinghandedthekeystoashinynewcarthatcould
speedusfastertowardsourgoal.Notonlydiditletuscutthroughtheheadwindsoftaxeswithlesseffort,italsoincentivizedustodowhatwewantedtodoanyway:saveforthefuture.
Abouthalfwaythroughourinvestingyears,anewkindofindividualretirementaccountbecameavailablecalledaRothIRA,andonceagainitfeltlikewewerebeinghandedasurprisingly
generousgift.Thisoneofferedunlimitedpotentialforearningstocompoundwithoutbeingtaxed–ever!Thatseemedalmosttoomagnanimousonthegovernment’spart–butitdidn’tstopusfromtakingfulladvantageofit.
BenefitsofTax-AdvantagedAccounts
Tax-advantagedaccountsofferacarrotintheformoftaxbreakstothosewhoarewillingtoputasideaportionoftheirmoneytodaytopreparefortheirownfuturetomorrow.Inthischapterwefocusprimarilyontwotypes
oftax-advantagedaccounts,401(k)sandRothIRAs.Bothofferdistinctadvantages,whichiswhywerecommendyoudon’tlimityourselftoonebutinvestinbothtypes.
TaxShelteringShelteringyourretirement
moneyfromtaxesisagenuinecomfortcometaxseason.It’sasifthismoneywereinvisibletotheIRS(butinacompletelylegalway,of
course).Aslongasyoudon’twithdrawitbeforeage59½,youdon’tevenhavetothinkaboutitattaxtime.Butwithtaxableaccountsyoudohavetothinkaboutit,becausecertaininvestments–mutualfundsandbondsamongthem–generatedividendsandcapitalgainsthatyouhavetopaytaxesonevenifthosedividendsandcapitalgainsarereinvested.Taxableaccountsareapay-as-you-go
system,whereastax-advantagedaccountsletyoushelteraportionofyourmoneyfromUncleSamuntilamuchlaterdate,whichisdefinitelytoyouradvantage.
FasterCompoundingYou’lloftenhearitsaid
that401(k)sandtraditionalIRAsletyourinvestmentscompoundfasterthantheywouldinataxableaccount.Thisistrueafterafashionbut
requiressomeexplanation.Ifyouinvestexactlythesamedollaramountsinexactlythesameinvestmentsinataxableandatax-advantagedaccount,theywillcompoundatexactlythesamerate.Butitisusuallyassumedyouarecontributingmoredollarstoatax-advantagedaccountthanyouaretoataxableone.Why?Becauseit’seasiertoinvestpre-taxdollarsthanitistoinvestafter-taxdollars.
Thinkaboutitthisway:investing$10,000pre-taxisroughlytheequivalentofinvesting$7,500after-tax(assumingyouareina25%taxbracket).Ittakesnoextraeffortonyourparttogetthe$2,500“bonus”byinvestingpre-taxdollarsinatax-advantagedaccount.Thusitisfairinasensetocompareinvesting$10,000inpre-taxdollarsto$7,500inafter-taxdollars.Withthisassumption
understood,thenitbecomesclearwhya401(k)oratraditionalIRAcompoundsfasterthanataxableaccount:because$10,000reallydoescompoundfasterthan$7,500.
Ofcoursenotalltax-advantagedaccountsarethesamethesedays.WithaRothIRAyouinvestafter-taxdollars,sothefastercompoundingassumptiondoesn’tapplytoyourcontributionamounts.It
couldbearguedearningscompoundfastersincenotaxesareowedonreinvesteddividendsandcapitalgains,butthisisafairlyhollowdistinction.Why?Becausetaxesareusuallypaidoutofyourcurrentincomestream,notoutofyourinvestmentsthemselves.Thuspayingtaxesonreinvesteddividendsandcapitalgainsinataxableaccountmaymakeyourpocketbooklighter,butit
doesnotgenerallyinhibitthecompoundingoftheinvestmentsthemselves.
EasyRebalancingTax-advantagedaccounts
letyourebalancefundsandtransferassetswithinthesameaccountwithnotaxconsequences.Bycomparison,everytimeyoutransferdollarstorebalanceyourportfolioinataxableaccount,itresultsinataxable
eventfortheyear.Werebalanceourtaxable
portfolioafterafashionbywithdrawingmoneyforlivingexpensesfromwhateverfundhasperformedbestoflate.However,werarelymovemoneyfromonefundtoanotherbecauseofthetaxconsequencesofdoingso.Bycomparison,it’sabreezetomovemoneyaroundinatax-advantagedaccountbecausetherearenotax
consequences.Thisconsiderablyincreasesyourflexibilitytomakeadjustmentsandfine-tuneyourportfoliothroughtheyears.
OneDisadvantage:LimitationsonAccessForearlyretirees,the
biggestchallengeofinvestingintax-advantagedaccountsis
thelimitationonaccessingyourmoneybeforeage59½.Withdrawingmoneybeforethatpointtypicallyresultsinhavingtopayasteep10%penaltytaxontopoftheordinaryincometaxesowed.Thislimitationisespeciallysignificantforthoseretiringextra-earlyintheirthirtiesorforties.Thenextsectiondiscussesstrategiesyoucanemploytoaddresstheseconcerns.
AllocatingBetweenTaxableandTax-AdvantagedAccounts
Thepreferredorderofinvestingforatypicalretirementisusuallysummarizedasfollows:
1.Investenoughinyour401(k)toreceivethemaximumpossiblematch2.InvestthemaximumyearlyamountinyourRothIRA(s)3.Investmoreinyour401(k)uptoyouryearlycontributionlimit4.InvestanyadditionalamountinyourtaxableaccountThisruleofthumbmakes
perfectlygoodsenseifyouplantoretireatage55orolder.However,ifyouplantoretireveryearly–say,inyourthirtiesorforties–thenyouneedtogivethemattersomeadditionalconsideration.You’regoingtorequirefundsyoucanaccesswithoutlimitationorpenaltybeforeage59½.Inasenseyou’regoingtoneedtosavefortworetirements–thenear-termoneandthepost-age-59½
one.Sinceitisn’tthenormto
retireinyourthirtiesorforties,yourarelyseethisissueaddressedinthefinancialmedia.Neverthelessitisaveryrealoneforanyonehopingtoretirewellbeforetheageof59½.
TaxableAccountsandtheUltra-EarlyRetiree
Thesimplestoptionifyouareplanningaveryearlyretirementistoinvestmoreinyourtaxableaccount.Thisgivesyoucompletefreedomtoaccessyourmoneyhoweverandwheneveryoulike.Therearenopenalties,noagelimits,andnoregulatoryorbureaucratichoopstojumpthrough.That’sthebeautyofataxableaccount:themoneyisyoursandyoucandowithitasyou
wish.Themaindownsideof
thisapproachisthattheburdenoftaxescanbeheavyduringyourfinalworkingyearswhenyounotonlyhaveahighsalarybutmayalsohavelargeamountsoftaxableinvestmentsthrowingoffdividendsandcapitalgainsasyouprepareforyourimminentretirement.Youmaywanttovoluntarilyincreaseyourwithholding
amountsduringtheseyearstoaccountforthehighertaxesyou’relikelytoexperience.However,theinstantyouretirefromtheworkforce,thisburdenisliftedandyourtaxesdropdramatically.
Whenwefirststarteddreamingaboutearlyretirement,wecontemplatedleavingtheworkforceatage55.Withthatretirementageinmind,itmadesenseformostofourmoneytobe
investedinmy401(k)planatworkandinourRothIRAs.Wefiguredasmalltaxableaccountwouldbeallwewouldneedtocoverusforthe4½yearsorsountilage59½.However,aswebeganmakingdetailedplans,wekeptpushingourtargetretirementageearlier,firsttoage50,thentoage45,andintheendtoage43.
Abouthalfwaythroughourprimarysavingyears,we
realizedwewerewoefullyunderfundedforthefirst15yearsofourretirementbeforeage59½.Asaresultwedramaticallyincreasedthepercentageofourinvestmentdollarsgoingintoourtaxableaccount,realizingwewouldneedthosedollarstocoverusforalongerperiodoftimethanwehadoriginallyanticipated.
Intheendweovershotabitandsavedmoreinour
taxableaccountthanwedidinourtax-advantagedaccounts.Atretirementweheldalmost$350,000intaxableinvestmentsascomparedto$280,000intax-advantagedinvestments(a55/45split).Wethinka50/50split(notincludingtheequityinourhome)wouldhavebeenclosertoideal.
Ourtotaltaxableaccountatretirementstoodatnearly$550,000.(Thisincludes
$200,000inbondfundsfromthesaleofourhomebutexcludes$100,000setasideforfuturehome-buyingpurposes.)Thisamountgeneratedenoughcapitalgains,interest,anddividendstoprovideuswithadecentsourceofincomeduringourearlyretirementyears.Thewithdrawalswemadewerereplenishedforthemostpartbyourtaxableinvestmentearnings.
Notsurprisingly,ourtaxableaccounthasslowlydiminishedoverthepastsixyearswhileouruntapped401(k)andRothIRAinvestmentshavecontinuedtogrow.Comparetheyear-endtotalsin2006(whenweretired)totheyear-endtotalsin2012:
Youcanseethetotalsforbothyearsarealmostidentical,buttheallocationofinvestmentshasshiftedtowardsmoremoneyinour401(k)andRothIRAsandlessinourtaxableaccount.
Thisisinlinewithouroverallexpectations,inwhichweenvisionourtaxableaccountstayingevenorslowlydiminishingwhileour401(k)andRothIRAaccountscontinuetogrowuntilage59½.Atthatpointwecantapintothosefundsaswellwithoutpenalty.Thisstrategyhasworkedwellforusoverall,andwewouldrecommendittoothersasaviableapproachtoultra-early
retirement.Keepinmindtheabove
resultsencompasstheGreatRecessionanditsaftermath,adifficultperiodbyanyone’sreckoning.Breakingevenisprobablyaboutthebestwecouldhavehopedforduringthischallengingtime,butitseemsreasonabletohopeforbetterresultsintheyearstocome.
Tax-Advantaged
AccountsandtheUltra-EarlyRetireeWefinditsomethingofa
comforttohaveasubstantialportionofourinvestmentscontinuingtogrowuntouchedinour401(k)andRothIRAs.Wefeellikewestillhavearetirementfundofftothesidethat’smeantforthelongterm,evenwhilewetapintothetaxableaccountforourshorter-termneeds.
Ourhope,ofcourse,isthatouroverallinvestmentportfoliowillcontinuetogrowthankstoour401(k)andRothIRAinvestments.Thatshouldallowustowithdrawmoremoneyinfutureyears,whichinturnwillallowustokeepupwithinflationandmaintainastandardoflivingsimilartoorbetterthantheoneweenjoytoday.Onlytimeandmarketconditionswilltellif
ourexpectationsaretoberealizedornot,butwecontinuetobelievewe’reontherighttrack.
AnotherGoodOptionforRetireesAge55andOverForthoseretiringator
aroundtheageof55,thereisanothergoodoptiontoconsider:relyingonthedirectcontributionsyou’vemade
overtheyearstoyourRothIRA.
You’realwaysallowedtowithdrawyourowncontributionstax-andpenalty-freefromaRothIRA(butnottheearnings).Whetherthosecontributionswillbeenoughtocoveryouuntiltherestofyourtax-advantagedfundskickinatage59½isfoodforcarefulthought.Butifyouliketheideaofinvestingsolelyin
tax-advantagedaccounts,thisgivesyouapromisingstrategytopursue.
Todetermineifthisisfeasibleforyou,adduphowmuchofyourRothIRAaccountislikelytoconsistofyourowncontributionsbythetimeyoureachyourtargetretirementage.Forexample,let’ssayyouandyourspouseareage30andeachofyouhasstartedinvestingthecurrentmaximumof$5,500
peryearinaRothIRAaccount.Youhopetoretirebyage55.Thatgivesyou25yearsx$11,000peryear=$275,000ofcontributionstoyourRothIRAs(orpossiblymorethanthat,assumingcontributionlimitsgoupinthefuture).
You’llneedtocoveraboutfiveyearsofearlyretirementuntilage59½,sothatworksoutto$275,000÷5=$55,000ofincomeper
year.That’snottoobad.Overthecourseofthosefiveyearsyoumaydepletemostofthecontributionsfromyouraccount,butyourearningswillcontinuetogrow.
RelyingonRothcontributionsalonebecomeslessfeasibletheearlieryoudecidetoretire.Forinstance,ifyouweretoretireatage50insteadof55intheexampleabove,thatwouldgiveyou20yearsinsteadof25in
whichtosave,resultingin20yearsx$11,000peryear=$220,000ofcontributions,whichwouldneedtolastforroughly10yearsinsteadof5.Thatworksouttojust$22,000ofincomeperyearuntilage59½,whichisprobablyinsufficientinandofitself.However,ifyouplannedtosupplementthisamountwithincomefromataxableaccountorapart-timejob,thenitwouldbecome
morefeasible.
OtherWaystoAccessYourMoneyEarlyOtherstrategiesfor
accessingyourmoneyearlyarelessattractivebecausetheytendtobemorecomplicated.Forexample,undercertaincircumstancesitispossibletomakewithdrawalsfromyour401(k)
accountpenalty-freeafterage55.Butforthistowork,youhavetobesuretoterminateyouremploymentnoearlierthanage55.Ifyoustopworkingatage54¾,thenpenaltiesforearlywithdrawalwouldstillapply.Your401(k)alsohastobewithyourcurrentcompany,notwithacompanyyouworkedforearlierinyourcareer,soyouwouldwanttobesuretoalwaysrolloveryour401(k)
toeachnewemployerwithwhomyoutakeajob.
Nowlet’ssayyouturn55andit’stimetotakethemoneyoutofyour401(k).Youmaybeofferedthechoicetodoitintheformofperiodicwithdrawals.Sincealumpsumwithdrawalwouldrocketyouintothehighestpossibletaxbracketfortheyear,periodicwithdrawalsarethesmartwaytogo.However,manycompanies
don’twantthehassleofmanagingperiodicwithdrawals,soyoumaynotbegiventhisoption.Inthatcase,assumingyoudon’twanttopaytaxesontheentirelumpsumamount,youwouldneedtorollitoverintoatraditionalIRA.Atthatpointtheage59½limitwouldonceagainapply.Butreadon,there’sawayaroundthattoo.
Theloopholefor
traditionalorrolloverIRAsisthis:youcanwithdrawmoneypenalty-freebeforeage59½ifyoutakethemoneyoutinwhattheIRScalls“substantiallyequalperiodicpayments”(SEPP).ThisinvolvesannuallywithdrawingafixedsumofmoneyfromyourIRAasdeterminedbyanIRSformulathattakesintoconsiderationyourlifeexpectancyamongother
factors.Youwouldhaveto
continuemakingSEPPwithdrawalsforatleastfiveyearsoruntilyoureachage59½,whicheverislonger.Thatmeansifyouretireatage50,youwouldneedtocontinuewithdrawingSEPPsfor9½yearsuntilyouturned59½.Ifyouwere58you’dhavetotakethemuntilyouwereage63sincethe5-yearminimumwouldapply.
Otherwiseyou’llgethitwiththe10%penaltyandretroactiveinterestcharges.
Honestly,wefindallthisabittoointimidating,andsowedecidedlongagonottotakethisroute.Itseemedtouslikethepotentialforbureaucraticandtaxheadacheswassimplytoohigh.However,itdoesofferanotherviableapproachtotappingintoyour401(k)andtraditionalIRAmoneysooner
thanyoucouldotherwisewithnopenalty.
InaNutshellOnlyyoucandecideon
theexactpercentagesthatarerightforyou,buthereareourgeneralrecommendationsregardingallocationsbetweentaxableandtax-advantagedaccounts:–Ifyouplantoretireinyourthirtiesorforties,
invest50%ofyourmoneyintax-advantagedaccountsand50%inataxableaccount.–Ifyouplantoretireinyourearlyfifties,allocate75%totax-advantagedaccountsand25%toataxableaccount.–Ifyouplantoretireinyourmidtolatefiftiesorbeyond,allocate100%totax-advantagedaccounts,
withanyoverflowgoingintoataxableaccount.Ifyoufeelyoualready
knowallyouneedtoknowabout401(k)sandIRAs,feelfreetoskipaheadtothenextchapter.Otherwise,readon.Weprovideaquickoverviewofeachmajortypeoftax-advantagedaccount:401(k),RothIRA,andTraditionalIRA.Wealsomakebriefmentionofeducational
savingsaccounts.
401(k)PlansNearlyeveryinvestorthe
worldoverwillagreeononething:neverturndownfreemoney.That’swhynearlyeverybookorarticleyou’lleverreadonretirementwillurgeyoutocontributeatleastenoughtoyouremployer-sponsored401(k)plantogetthefullcompanymatch.Infact,contributingenoughto
getthemaximummatchistheveryfirstthingyoushoulddoasaninvestor.
The401(k)CompanyMatchMatchesdifferfromone
companytothenext.Somecompaniesoffernomatchatall.Othersmatchtheiremployees’contributionsatfiftycentstothedollaruptoaspecifiedpercentageofpay
(commonly6%).Othersareevenmoregenerousandmatchdollarfordollar.Butanymatchisanofferoffreemoneyjustforparticipatinginaplanthatisgoodforyouanyway.It’ssuchano-brainerthatmanycompaniesautomaticallyenrollyouintheir401(k)plans,requiringyoutooptoutifyoudon’twanttoparticipate.
Let’ssayyou’reearning$80,000grossandyour
companymatchesfiftycentstothedollarupto6%ofpay.Yourmaximummatchwouldbecalculatedasfollows:$80,000x6%=$4,800x$0.50=$2,400.Youwouldneedtocontribute$4,800(6%ofyourgrosspay)toreceivethemaximumcompanymatchof$2,400peryear.That’s$7,200altogether,makinganicedentinyourinvestmentgoalsfortheyear.
Tax-DeferredGrowthAnymoneyyouinvestin
your401(k)comesstraightoutofyourgrosspaycheckandgrowstax-deferred.Usingpre-taxmoneytofundtax-deferredgrowthisaverynicedealindeed.Supposeyouearn$100,000grossperyearandput10%ofyourpaycheckintoyour401(k).That’s10%ofyourgross
salary,notyournet.Thatmeansyou’reinvesting$10,000,not$7,500aswouldotherwisebethecaseaftertaxes.Thislargertax-deferredamountcompoundsmorequicklythanasmalleramountwould,givingyoualeguponreachingyourretirementgoalssooner.Thedividends,interest,andcapitalgainsinsideyour401(k)accountalsogrowtax-deferred.
ReducedIncomeTaxesMatchingfundsplustax-
deferredgrowthisaprettypowerfulcombinationinitsownright,butwhatmakesitevenmorepotentisthis:youactuallyloweryourfederalincometaxesinthecurrentyearbyinvestingina401(k)plan.Intheexampleabove,it’sasifyoueffectivelyerased$10,000offthetopof
yoursalaryasfarastheIRSisconcernedandonlyearned$90,000insteadof$100,000.Youwouldhavehadtopayabout$2,500intaxesonthatextra$10,000,butinsteadthattaxpaymentisdeferredintothefardistantfuture.
Ofcourseyou’llhavetopaytaxesonthatmoneyeventuallywhenyouwithdrawitinretirement,butbythenyou’llundoubtedlybeinalowertaxbracketthan
youarenow.Atpresentyou’reearningahealthysalaryandpayingtaxeslikethere’snotomorrow,inpartbecauseyou’repayingtaxesonallyourincomebutonlyusingaportionofittoliveon(withtherestbeinginvested).Butwhenyouretireyou’llbelivingafinanciallysimplerlife,andyourtaxbillwillreflectthat.Thusitmakessensetoinvestasmuchaspossibleinyour401(k)to
reduceyourcurrenttaxload.
RaisingYourPercentageWheneveryougetaraise,
it’sagreattimetorevisityour401(k)percentages.Sinceyouhaven’tbecomeusedtolivingonthehigheramountyet,youcantakealloraportionofthepayincreaseoffthetableandputitintoyour401(k)instead.
Youcanbe“pretendpoor”andconvinceyourselfyoustillhavetomakedoonroughlythesameamountasyoudidbeforetheraise.Thisisapowerfulwaytoincreaseyoursavingsforthefuture.Ifyouneverseethemoneyinyourcheckbookaccount,it’salmostasifitneverexisted.Butwhenyoulookatyour401(k)statementattheendoftheyear,you’llrealizeallthoseextradollarsaremaking
abigdifferencetoyourbottomline.
Ifyouincreaseyourpercentagesincrementallyandtimethemtocoincidewithpayraises,youmaynotnoticethatmuchofadifferenceintermsofyourtake-homepay.Sinceyour401(k)deductionsloweryourgrosssalary,thetaxesbeingwithheldfromyourpaycheckarealsocomparablyless,sotheoveralleffectonyour
take-homepayisoftensmallerthanyoumightexpect.
InvestingforLong-TermCapitalAppreciationMost401(k)plansoffera
widerangeofmutualfundoptions.Werecommendyoudoyourmostaggressiveinvestingintax-advantagedaccountslikeyour401(k)and
IRAsinceyouwon’tbetouchingthismoneyforalongtimetocome.Compoundingcanworkitsgreatestmagicifyouinvestinassetssuchasstock-basedmutualfundsthathaveastrongpotentialforlong-termcapitalappreciation.
Onecaution:manycompaniesallowyoutopurchasesharesofcompanystockwithinyour401(k),andwhileyoumaywanttoinvest
somemoneyinsuchafashion,wesuggestyoudon’tgooverboard.It’sriskytoputallyourretirementeggsinonebasketincaseyourcompanyshouldturnouttobe(heavenforbid)thenextEnron.
SetItandForgetItOnceyou’vemadeyour
selections,you’redonefortheyear.Youdon’thavetorevisityour401(k)planor
makeanyotherdecisionsuntilnextyear’sbenefitsreview,whenyoushouldreevaluateyourpercentagesandinvestmentselectionstomakesurethey’restillrightforyou.Meanwhile,automaticdeductionsfromyourregularpaycheckallowyoutosimply“setitandforgetit.”
ContributionLimits
andVestingTheIRSsetslimitson
howmuchyoucancontributetoyour401(k)planinanygivenyear.Thelimitfor2013is$17,500;thislimitmayriseinthefuturebasedoncostoflivingincreases.Yourcompanymayalsoimposeamaximumpercentagesalarylimitsuchas15%ofsalary.Someplansallowforcatch-upcontributions,withhigher
limitsforpeopleage50andolder.
Many401(k)plansmakeyouwaitbeforeyoubecomefullyvestedinmatchingfunds.Thisisdesignedtoincentivizeyoutoremainemployedwiththecompanyforlongerthanjustayearortwo.Youarealways100%vestedinmoneyyoucontributedirectly,butacompanymay,forinstance,giveyou25%vestingof
matchingfundsafteryourfirstyearofemployment,50%afterthesecondyear,75%afterthethirdyear,and100%afterthefourthyearandbeyond.
401(k)PortabilityIfyouleaveyourjob,you
caneitherkeepyour401(k)fundsinplaceortakethemwithyou.Takingthemwithyouentailsrollingyour401(k)moneyover,withits
tax-deferredstatusintact,toyournewemployer’splan.Alternatively,youcanrollitoverintoatraditionalIRAsetupwithanaccountproviderofyourchoice,suchasVanguardorFidelity.Thisisworthconsidering,especiallyifyournewcompany’splanislimitedintermsofitsinvestmentchoices.Theonethingyoushouldnotdounderanycircumstancesiscashouttheproceedsfromyour
401(k)planwhenyouleaveyourjob.Besideshavingtopaytaxesatordinarytaxratesplusa10%penaltyfee,youloseoutonpotentiallydecadesworthoftax-deferredcompounding.
PenaltiesforEarlyWithdrawalTherulesarequitestrict
withregardtoearlywithdrawalsfroma401(k).
Almostanywithdrawalsbeforeage59½willresultinyourhavingtopaytaxesatordinarytaxratesplusa10%penaltyfee–givingyouastronginducementtoleaveyour401(k)moneyinplaceonceit’sthere.Evenso-calledhardshipwithdrawals(i.e.,tocoverthedownpaymentonafirsthome)aresubjecttothesetaxesandpenalties.
Ifyousimplymustaccessyour401(k)moneybecause
youhavenootheroption,considertakingouta401(k)loan.Wedon’trecommendthisapproachexceptasalastresort,sinceyouarereducingtheamountofmoneythatcancompoundinyouraccountuntiltheloanisrepaid,butit’sbetterthantakingthemoneyoutaltogether.
401(k)TaxesinRetirement
Allmoneywithdrawnfroma401(k)oratraditionalIRAafterage59½istreatedasordinaryincome.Eventax-favoredcapitalgainsaretreatedassuch.Thisisonereasonwerecommendyouinvestsomemoneyina401(k)andsomeinaRothIRA.Thatwayyoucanchoosehowmuchmoneytowithdrawfromeachtypeofaccountdependingonyourtaxsituationinanygiven
retirementyear.Youmustbeginmaking
requiredminimumdistributionsfromyour401(k)ortraditionalIRAafteryouturnage70½.TheamountyouneedtotakeouteachyearisbasedonIRSlifeexpectancytables.OnebenefitofaRothIRAisthatitdoesn’thavetheseminimumdistributionrequirements.
Roth401(k)HybridsAhybrid401(k)
investmentcalledaRoth401(k)hasbecomepopularinrecentyearsandisbeingofferedbymoreandmorecompanies.Itcombinessomeofthebestfeaturesofbothtypesofinvestmentinthatittypicallyincludesamatchwhilealsoallowingyourearningstogrowuntaxedforever.
Thedownsideisthatyouhavetoinvestafter-taxdollarsinsteadofpre-taxdollars,soyouloseoutonsomeofthetaxdeferralbenefitsofatraditional401(k).Somecompaniesofferbothtypesof401(k)soyoucanchoosewhichportionofyourretirementplancontributionsshouldgointowhichtypeofaccount.
RothIRAsBynowyouknowthe
mainbenefitoftheRothIRAisitsabilitytoperpetuallyshelteryourinvestmentearningsfromtaxation–andthat’squitethebenefit.WhenyouwithdrawmoneyfromaRothIRAafterage59½,youneedpaynotaxesonitwhatsoever.Yourcontributionswerealready
taxedbeforehand,andyourearningsescapetaxationaltogetherbyvirtueoftheRoth’sdesign.Sinceearningsareperpetuallysheltered,aRothistheperfectplacetodosomeofyourmostaggressiveinvesting.Ifyouareconvincedaparticulartypeofinvestmentwillappreciatedramaticallyoverthelongterm,makethatinvestmentinyourRothaccount.
NoRequiredMinimumDistributionsAnimportantadvantage
ofaRothisthatminimumdistributionrulesatage70½don’tapply.Thatmeansifyou’reabletogetbyonotherresourcesinretirement,youdon’thavetodrawdownyourRothasyoumusta401(k)ortraditionalIRA.Asaresult,
yourRothearningscancontinuetogrowtax-freeeventhroughyourgoldenyears.ThismakestheRothIRAagreatsavingsvehicleforthelongterm–andwhenwesaylongtermwemeanit,sincetheassetsinaRothIRAcanbepassedontoheirs.
OnlyasurvivingspousecancontinuetocontributetoaninheritedRothIRAorcombineitwithhisorherown.Otherbeneficiariescan,
however,setupdistributionsoverthecourseoftheirownlifetimes–andpassonwhatevermightremaintoasecondarybeneficiarywiththetax-freestatusstillintact.
WithdrawalsofContributionsandEarningsWe’vealreadytouchedon
thefactthatwithaRothIRAyourowndirectcontributions
canalwaysbewithdrawntax-freeatanytimewithnoearlydistributionpenalties.Ofcourseyouwouldwanttoavoiddoingsoifatallpossibleduringyourinvestingyears,sinceitwouldruncountertotheveryreasonyouinvestedintheRothinthefirstplace.
FivetaxyearsmusthaveelapsedsinceyourveryfirstRothIRAcontributionwasmadebeforeearningsare
consideredqualifiedandcanbedistributedtax-free.Thisholdstrueevenifyouareoverage59½.However,thefive-yearclockdoesnotreseteachtimeyoumakeanothercontributiontoyourRoth.
NoEffectonSocialSecurityAnymoneywithdrawn
fromaRothIRAisnotincludedintheformulaused
todeterminehowmuchofyoursocialsecuritybenefitsaretaxable.Othersourcesofincome–suchaswages,interest,dividends,andpensions–canallresultinyourhavingtopaytaxesonyoursocialsecuritybenefits,butnotRothwithdrawals.
Supposeyou’reearningsocialsecuritybenefitswhiledoingabitofworkontheside.Ifyou’remarriedfilingjointlyandearnedbetween
$32,000and$44,000in2012,thenupto50%ofyoursocialsecurityincomemaybetaxable–orupto85%ifyouearnedover$44,000.However,anyamountswithdrawnfromyourRothIRAhavenotaxconsequenceswhatsoeverandwon’taddtoyourpotentialtaxburden.
First-Time
HomebuyerExceptionTheusualearly
withdrawalpenaltiesapplyifyouwithdrawearningsfromyourRothIRAbeforeage59½–withoneimportantexception.Youcanwithdrawupto$10,000inearningstax-andpenalty-freeifyouareafirst-timehomebuyerorhavenotownedaprincipalresidenceformorethantwo
years.(ThisassumesyourRothaccounthasbeeninplaceformorethanfiveyears.)Ifyouareacouplewithtwoaccounts,youcaneachwithdrawupto$10,000.Wearen’trecommendingyouuseyourRothinsuchafashion,butagain,itincreasesyourflexibility.
RothContributionandIncomeLimits
Asof2013youcancontributeupto$5,500toaRothIRA(plusanextra$1,000ifyou’reoverage50).Limitsarelikelytoincreasein$500incrementsinthefuturebasedoninflation.Formarriedcouples,eachspousecancontributeuptotheyearlylimit.Aworkingspousecancontributeonbehalfofanonworkingspouse.
Youcanonlyinvestina
RothIRAifyouhaveearnedincomefromajob.Youcannotuseunearnedincomesuchasinterest,dividends,capitalgains,rentalpropertyincome,pensions,orsocialsecuritybenefits.WehadinitiallyplannedoncontinuingtofundourRothIRAsduringourearlyretirementyearsusingproceedsfromourtaxableaccount,butweeventuallycametorealizethiswasnot
anoption.Ifyou’reahighlypaid
worker,incomelimitscanaffecthowmuchyou’reallowedtocontributetoaRothIRAorwhetheryoucancontributeatall.Asof2013theupperincomelimittoqualifyforafullcontributionis$112,000forsinglefilersand$178,000forjointfilers.Ifyou’rerunningupagainsttheselimits,onewayyoucanreduceyourgrossincomeis
tomakecontributionstoyour401(k)plan.
RothConversionsConvertingatraditional
IRAor401(k)toaRothIRAhassignificanttaxconsequences.Sincesuchmoneyhasneverbeentaxed,incometaxesareowedontheentireconversionamount.Thetaxbillforsuchaconversionshouldideallybepaidnotoutofthe401(k)or
IRAitself,butratheroutofnon-IRAfundstoavoidreducingyourinvestedamount(andtoavoidpayinga10%penaltyontheportionofthemoneyusedtopaythetax).
Youdonothavetoconvertyourentireaccountinonefellswoop.Ifyouhave$100,000youwanttoconverttoaRoth,forexample,youcanconvert$10,000eachyearfortenyears,thus
spreadingyourtaxbilloveralongertimeperiod.TherearenoincomelimitsforconvertingtoaRoth,whichgiveshighearnerswhootherwisemightnotqualifytocontributetoaRothabackdoorintoaRoth.
SettingUpaRothAccountYoucansetupaRoth
IRAaccountwithanymajor
investmentfirm(Vanguard,Fidelity,CharlesSchwab,etc.).Youcannotopena“jointIRA”account;eachIRAneedstobeopenedinthenameofanindividualperson.Thatmeansyou’llhavetosetupaseparateaccountforyourselfandoneforyourspouseifyou’remarried.Thistendstoresultinsomeinevitableduplicationoffundswithinyouroverallportfolio.Whileyoucould
choosetoowndifferentfundswithineachaccount,it’susuallyeasiesttohavethetwoaccountsmirroroneanother.
Inourowncaseweactuallyhavefourdifferenttypesofaccounts:aRothIRAinmyname,aRothIRAinRobin’sname,a401(k)inmyname,andajointtaxableaccountinbothournames.Thisjustgoestoshowthatevenwhenyoutrytokeep
thingssimple,somecomplexityisunavoidablewhenyouinvest.
SynergyBetween401(k)sandRothIRAsWelikethesynergythat
comesfrominvestinginbotha401(k)andaRothIRA.Theyaretheyinandyangoftheinvestingworld.The401(k)givesyoumatching
funds,tax-deferredgrowth,andcurrenttaxdeductions,whiletheRothIRAgivesyouentirelytax-freewithdrawalsandnominimumrequireddistributionsatage70½.Thetwoworkwelltogetheranddon’tinterferewitheachotherthewaya401(k)andatraditionalIRAsometimescan,asdiscussedbelow.
TraditionalIRAsandOtherOptions
AtraditionalIRAfunctionssimilarlytoa401(k)butwithoutthematchingfundaspect.Investmentearningsgrowtax-deferred,andinmostcasesyoucandeductyourcontributionsfromcurrent
taxes.Contributionlimitsin2013are$5,500perindividual,plusanother$1,000ifyou’reoverage50.Theusualagelimitof59½appliesbeforeyoucanwithdrawmoneywithoutpenalty.
TraditionalIRARestrictionsThereasonwe’reless
enthusiasticabouttraditional
IRAsisthattheyhavemorerestrictionsonthembothintermsoftaxdeductioneligibilityinthepresentandwithdrawalsinthefuture.Forinstance,youcangenerallydeductcontributionsfortaxpurposes–butnotalways.Supposeyouandyourspousefilejointlyandarebothcoveredbyaretirementplanatwork.Iftogetheryouearnmorethan$95,000(asof2013),thenyoucannotfully
deductyourtraditionalIRAcontributions.Beyond$115,000youcannotdeductthematall.Thisistheconflictwereferredtoabovewhenwesaida401(k)andtraditionalIRAcansometimesinterferewithoneanother.
Ifonlyoneofyouiscoveredbyaretirementplanatwork,thelimitsarehigherbuttheystillexist.Yourdeductionbeginstophaseout
beyond$178,000,andnodeductionisallowedbeyond$188,000.Yourearningsstillgrowtax-deferredwithintheIRAaccount,butyouhavetopaytaxesupfrontoncontributionamounts,whicheliminatesoneoftheincentivesforinvestinginatraditionalIRAinthefirstplace.
TraditionalIRAsalsorequireyoutobeginmakingrequiredminimum
distributionsatage70½.Ifyoudon’tmakethem,youautomaticallylose50%ofthemandatoryyearlyamounttotheIRS.
WhenTraditionalIRAsStillMakeSenseTraditionalIRAsarestill
worthconsideringundercertaincircumstances.Ifyourcurrenttaxbracketisvery
high,forinstance,andyouexpecttobeinamuchlowertaxbracketonceyouretire,theremightbegoodcausetoconsiderinvestinginatraditionalIRAinordertoloweryourcurrentincometaxes.Also,ifneitheryounoryourspousearecoveredbyaretirementplanatwork,oryouclearlywon’tbebumpingupagainsttheincomelimitsanytimesoon,thentraditionalIRAsbecome
moreattractive.Atsomepoint,decisionsabouthowbesttoallocateyourmoneycomedowntoweighingthespecificsofyourownpersonaltaxsituation.
OtherEmployment-SpecificAccountsWhilewewon’tgointo
detailhere,thereareotherkindsoftax-advantagedaccountsthatfocuson
specificemploymentsituations.–403(b)plansofferpublicschoolteachersandnon-profitemployeesessentiallythesamebenefitsas401(k)plansintheprivatesector.–SEPIRAsbenefittheself-employed,particularlybusinessownerswithoutemployees.Theyoffertax-deferredgrowthandvery
highcontributionlimits($51,000in2013)whichare100%taxdeductible.–SIMPLEIRAsletsmallbusinessownerssetuplow-cost,easy-to-manageretirementplansfortheiremployeesthatincludematchingfundsandtax-deferredgrowth.–ThriftSavingsPlans(TSPs)are401(k)-likeplansforfederal
employeesandmembersofthemilitary.
Tax-AdvantagedEducationalAccountsManyparentsfacethe
unenviabletaskofsavingatthesametimeforboththeirownretirementandtheirchildren’shighereducation.Tax-advantagededucationalaccountsmakethetaskalittle
easier.Perhapsthemostpopulartypeofaccountisa529plan,whichcanbeusedtocovertuition,roomandboard,andotherexpensesataccreditedinstitutions.Moneycanbewithdrawntax-freefromtheseaccountstopayforqualifiededucationalexpenses.Studentloansandstudentloaninterestarenotcovered.Ifadistributionisn’tforaqualifiededucationalexpense,thentheusual
incometaxand10%penaltyapply.
Eachstateadministersitsown529plans,andwhileyoucaninvestinonefromoutofstate,it’susuallybesttoselectonefromyourownstatesoyoucanqualifyforstateincometaxdeductionsandhavethepotentialtoreceivematchinggrantsandscholarshipsiftheyareoffered.Since529plansarecountedaspartofyourassets,
theyhavelittleimpactonyourchild’seligibilityforfinancialaidwithinyourownstateofresidence.
Unfortunatelyyoudon’tgettodeduct529plancontributionsfromyourfederalincometaxes,butyourmoneydoesgrowtax-deferred.Youmaintaincontroloftheaccountandcaneventransferanyunusedamountstootherqualifiedmembersofyourfamily
(includingyourselfandyourspouse).Youdon’tmakeyourowninvestmentselectionswitha529plan;insteadyouenrollinaparticularplanwhichisprofessionallymanaged.
Chapter13.LiveBelowYourMeans“Mindthegap.”WhenwevisitedLondon
forthefirsttimeasyoungadultsbarelyoutofcollege,westoodatHeathrowAirportwaitingforthemetrotoarrive.
Asitapproachedandthedoorsopened,adeepBritishvoiceintonedovertheloudspeaker,“Mindthegap.Mindthegap.”Thevoicewassimplyremindingustowatchourstepandnotfallintothespacebetweentheplatformandthetrainasweboarded,butthephrasesoundedoddenoughtoourAmericanearsthatitstuckwithus.Overtimewecametoapplyittoourfinancialsituation:welearned
tomindthegapbetweenmakingandspendingaswesavedforthefuture.
Learningtolivebelowyourmeansisabsolutelycrucialifyouwanttoretireearlyandstayretired.Toachievefinancialindependenceyouneedtobuildcapital,andtheonlywaytodothat(withouthelpfromanoutsidesource)istomakemorethanyouspend.Thegapbetweenmakingandspending
hastobebigenoughthatyoucanputasignificantamountofmoneyasideonamonthlybasis,yearinandyearout,forthesolepurposeofinvesting.
Onewaytoincreasethemake-spendgapistoincreaseyoursalary–whichiswhywesuggestyouinvestinyourselffirst.Theotheristoalteryourspendinghabitsuntilyouarelivingwellbelowyourmeans.Toachievefinancialindependence,mostpeople
needtotackletheproblemfrombothends–makingmoreandspendingless.Thistwo-prongedapproachgivesyouthebestchanceofwideningthegapdramaticallyenoughtomakearealdifference.
We’vealreadydiscussedtheimportanceofinvestinginyourselffirst,solet’smoveontotheothersideoftheequation,spendingless.
TrackingYourExpenses
Thebestwaytoreducespendingistobecomeaconsciousconsumer.Considertheprice,lookatittwice,anddecideifit’sreallyworthittoyougivenhowhardyouhavetoworkforyourmoney.Makethisonesimpleadjustment–becomeconsciousofeachdollaryouspend–anditcan
makeaworldofdifferenceinhelpingyoureachyourearlyretirementgoals.
ConsumerBootCampThemosteffectivewaywe
knowtobecomeamoreconsciousconsumeristoputyourselfthroughtheequivalentofconsumerbootcampandcarefullytrackyourexpensesdowntothepenny
foraperiodoftime.Wetrackedourexpenses
downtothepennyforonewholeyearandfounditburdensome,tobehonest,butalsoenlightening.Wewouldsuggestyoutrackyourexpensesforaperiodofthreemonths.Theexercisewillmakeyoufocuslikeneverbeforeonwhereyourmoneyisgoing.Theresultsmaysurpriseyou,andyoumaywellcomeawaywithaclearer
understandingofwhereyouneedtocutspendingthemost.
Duringbootcampyouraimistolookforpatternsinspending.Suchpatternsareeasiesttoidentifyifyoucategorizetheinformationyou’vecollectedattheendofeachmonth.Wesuggestyougroupyourexpensesintothefollowingmaincategories:food,shelter,utilities,clothing,transportation,health,recreation,and
miscellaneous.Undereachcategoryyoucancreatesubcategoriesasneeded.Forexample,underfoodyoumighthavesubcategoriesforgroceries,diningout,andtakeout.Letyourownspendinghabitsdictateyoursubcategories.
Youroverallgoalistoidentifyblindspotsinyourspendinghabitswherecutscanbemade.Forexample,youmightdiscoveryou’re
spendingmuchmorethanyourealizedondiningout,oronclothing,oronsomeformofentertainment,oronfancycoffeedrinksforthatmatter.Ifyoufindyourselfsaying,“IneverknewIspentthatmuchonsuch-and-such,”you’veidentifiedablindspotwhereyoumightbeabletomakesomecuts.
Duringourownbootcampexperience,wehadseveral“aha”momentsinthe
firstfewmonths.Wemadecutsinthoseareas,butafterthatwecouldn’tfindanywhereelseobvioustoreducespending.Wehadtrimmedawaymostofthefatbythen.Wantingtofinishwhatwehadstarted,wecontinuedwiththeexercisefortherestoftheyearbutfounditlesshelpfulafterthat.
Infact,theexerciseeventuallybecamecounterproductiveforus.Our
spendinghabitsactuallybecametooconstrained,ifsuchathingispossible.Sincewe’realreadyfrugalbynature,wereallydidn’tneedanyextraencouragementtocutbackonspendingevenmore.Ifyou’reonthefrugalsidetoo,rememberit’simportanttokeepasenseofbalance.Savingupforearlyretirementdemandsself-discipline,certainly,butitshouldnotdemandself-denialtothe
pointwhereyoufeellikeyou’remissingoutonthings.
Intheend,howlongyoucontinuetheexerciseoftrackingyourexpendituresdependsonyourownpersonality.Somepeoplekeepabudgetforlifeandswearbyit,whileothersdoitforaperiodoftimethendecidetomoveon.Ifyouspendmoneyfreely,orifyoufrequentlyfindyourselfwonderingwhereithasallgone,youmaywant
tocontinuetrackingyourexpensesforalongerperiodoftime.
ThebookYourMoneyorYourLifebyVickiRobinandJoeDominguezisonewewouldrecommendforitsdescriptionofhowtobecomeaconsciousconsumer,trackyourexpenses,andreininspending.Theauthorsclearlydescribehowtotrackexpensesdowntothepennyanddevelopamonthlybudget
basedontheinformationyoucollect.Thebookintroducesaconceptthatwasnewtous:thatmoneyissomethingwetradeour“lifeenergy”for,soweshouldmakecertainwearegettingafairtradeforit.
TrackingandBudgetingSoftwareTrackingandcategorizing
expensesbyhandcanbelaborious,soyoumaywantto
useasoftwareprogramtosimplifytheprocess.PersonalfinancewebsiteslikeMint(mint.com)arefreetouseandmakeiteasytomanageyourmoneyonline.MintcomesrecommendedbyMoneyMagazineandTheNewYorkTimes,whichdubsit“yourfinancialsituationinthepalmofyourhand.”
ThefirststeptousingMintisalsothemostintimidating:youhavetoadd
yourbank,creditcard,homeloan,andinvestmentaccountstothewebsitesoMintcansecurelypullintheinformationandorganizeitforyou.Fromthatpointforwardyoucanseeallyouraccountsinoneplace,anywhereandanytime,includingonyourmobilephone.Mintusesbank-levelsecurity,soifyoucangetpasttheconcernsofhackers,thentherearealotofbenefits
tousinganonlineprogramlikethisthatcanlinkallyourfinancialaccountstogetherandgiveyouthebigpictureinrealtime.Ifyou’reuncomfortablewiththeonlineoption,youcanuseasimilarstand-aloneprogramlikeQuicken.
BothMintandQuickenletyouorganizeallyouraccountsinoneplace,trackyourspending,andcreateapersonalizedbudget.Theyuse
simplepiechartsandgraphstoshowyouwhereyourmoneyisbeingspenteachmonth.Expensesareautomaticallycategorized–soyoucankeeptracknotonlyofhowmuchyou’respendingbutwhere.Programslikethesetakealotofthehassleoutoftrackingandbudgetingandaredefinitelyworthalook.
LivingSimplyThereisanattractionto
notover-buying,tonotoverdoingthings,tokeepingthingssimple.Beingunencumberedbytoomanypossessionscanactuallybeareliefbothforthepocketbookandforthemind.Spendinglessdoesn’thavetoequatewithbeinglesshappy–infact,itcanbejustthe
opposite.Livingsimplymeans
adoptinganewmindset.ItmeanslettinggoofconcernsaboutkeepingupwiththeJonesesandfocusinginsteadonyourownwell-being,financialandotherwise.Asyoubecomemoremotivatedaboutachievingfinancialindependence,you’llleaveoldwaysofthinkingbehindandadoptnewonesthataremoresuitedtoachievingyour
goal.Doingwhatsomany
othersaredoing–namely,spendingtillthey’redeepindebtorbarelybreakingeven–willnevergetyouwhereyouwanttogo,sowhynottakeadifferenttack?Learntothinkoutsidetheboxwhenitcomestoyourownfinancialwell-being.Openyoureyestowhatlifecanbelikeifyouliveitonyourowntermsandrejectmindlessconsumerism.
Moreandmorepeoplearecomingtorealizethattheendlesspursuitofstuffdoesnotmakethemhappy,andinfactcluttersthepathtohappiness.
We’renotadvocatingyoulivelikeamonkandneverpartwithapenny,butwedosuggestyoukeepasenseofbalancewhenitcomestospending.Findingthatrightbalancehastodowithdefiningwhatisgenuinely
importanttoyouversuswhatyoucandowithoutatminimalsacrificetoyourself.
KidsandSpendingExercisingfinancial
restraintbecomesevenmorechallengingwhenchildrenareinvolved.It’sawfullyhardtodenyachildsomethingheorshereallywants.Wewanttobegenerousanddenythemnothing.Wesaytoourselves,“Whyshouldtheyhavetogo
without?It’sonethingformetodenymyselfsomething,butwhoamItodenythem?”ItaddsawholenewtwisttokeepingupwiththeJoneseswhenit’syourkidswhoareseeingwhattheJoneses’kidshaveandwantthesame.
Butyou’renotdoingthemanyfavorsifyou’reteachingthembyexamplethatit’sokaytooverspendandlivebeyondyourmeans.Frankly,it’snothealthyfor
anyonetolivebeyondtheirmeansforaprolongedperiodoftime.It’sstressfulandeatsawayatyoursenseofhappinessandself-esteem.Thestressyoufeelaboutitinevitablyrubsoffonyourkidstoo.Wouldn’titbebettertoteachthembyexamplewhatittakestoactuallylivewithinyourmeansasafamily?Thatacertainamountofsacrificeinpursuitofalong-termgoal–whetherit
beretirementorcollegeeducation–isagoodthing?
Bysettinganexampleforyourkidsandinvestingforthefuture,you’reteachingthemanimportantlifelesson.Afterall,itwon’tbelongbeforeit’stheirturntomakeasimilarjourneytowardsfinancialindependence.Thatjourneywillbeeasieriftheyhaveanexampletolookuptoandcansay,“Myparentsdidit.Iftheycoulddoit,socan
I.”
RetiringEarlyonLessAdoptingasimpler
lifestylemakesiteasiertoretireearlyforonesimplereason:yournesteggcanbesmaller.Ifyoulearntoliveon$40,000peryear,thenyouonlyneedanesteggofabout$1million.Anincomeof$80,000peryearwillrequirea
nesteggofabout$2million.Ofcourseittakeslongertosave$2millionthanitdoes$1million,soyourretirementwillnecessarilycomelaterthanitwouldhaveotherwise.
Bysimplifyingyourneeds,yousimplifythewholeequationofyourlife.Ifyourcurrentneedsareless,youspendless,whichletsyousavemore.Andifyourneedsinretirementareless,thenyoudon’thavetosaveas
muchasyouwouldhaveotherwise.Lesseningbothyourcurrentneedsandyourfutureneedsmakesiteasiertobalancethemake-spendequationofyourlifeandfreesyoufromhavingtoworkanylongerthanyouhaveto.
Whereyouliveisalsoanimportantfactorinbeingabletoretireearlyonless.Ifyouresideinanexpensivecity,youmaywanttoconsidermovingtoalessexpensive
locationonceyouretire.Otherwise,you’llneedtocompensateforthehighercostoflivingwhereyouresidebysavingupalargernestegg.Retiringearlyonlessismuchmoredifficultifthecostoflivingisdoublewhatitwouldbeinalessexpensivepartofthecountry.
ReducingSpending
Everydaywemakealotoflittledecisionsabouthowtospendourmoney,andthosedecisionsaddup.Whentakentogether,theyplayabigroleindeterminingouroverallfinancialhealthandwell-being.Learningtopayattentiontothesmallthingsthatescapemostpeople’s
noticehelpsusreininspendingandtakecontrolofourpersonalfinances.
Wheneveryouwalkintoastoreorshoponline,ithelpstorememberyou’reonthewrongsideofthemake-spendequation.You’reinenemyterritory,sotospeak.Ofcourseweallneedtoshop,butthere’sadifferencebetweenshoppingoutofnecessityandshoppingforpleasure.Shoppingtillyoudropisa
funnyexpression,butit’salsoalittledepressingwhenyouconsiderhowmanypeopletakeitliterally.It’scertainlynotagoodfitfortheaspiringearlyretiree.
Exercisingalittleself-restraintshouldnotbeconsideredabadthing,butnowadaysitissometimesseenasanindicationofnotvaluingyourselfhighlyenoughtogetwhatyouproperlydeserve.Thewords
“Ideserveit”havebecomethemantraforthosewhowouldjustifybuyingwhatevertheywantwithoutregardfortheirfinancialwell-being.It’sashamethosesamewordsaren’tusedmoreoftentodescribewhyweshouldbuylessinordertoachievefinancialindependencesooner.
Let’stakealookatafewareasofourlivesinwhichweallregularlyspendmoneyand
considersomestrategiesthatcanbeemployedtoreducespendingandkeepitundercontrol.
Food,GloriousFoodWeadmittobeingfoodies
whoenjoyamemorabledinneroutjustasmuchasthenextperson.It’soneofthegreatpleasuresoflifeandshouldn’tbemissed.Sowearen’tsuggestingyougocoldturkeyandonlyeatcold
turkey!Butwearesuggestingyoulimitdiningoutduringyourprimaryinvestingyearstoonceaweekorspecialoccasions.
Let’sfaceit,restaurantdiningcanbeexpensive.Bythetimeyoufigureinthecostofthefood,drinks,taxes,andtip,itcantakequiteachunkoutofyourbudget,especiallyifyou’rediningoutmultipletimesperweek.Thesimplestsolutionistolimityour
numberofoutings.Whenyoudodineout,
somestrategiesforkeepingcostsdownmightincludesplittingagenerouslysizedmeal,bringingleftovershomeforasecondmeal,ortakingadvantageofcouponoffersandhappyhourspecials.Orderingtakeoutcanalsobeagoodin-betweenoption.Sometimeswewouldbehard-pressedtocookamealforanythinglessthanwepayto
splitadelicioustakeoutdinner.
Thatsaid,buyingyourownfoodatthesupermarketandcookingitathomeisusuallythemosteconomicalwaytogo.It’swhatwerecommendasthenormwhenyouarein“fullsavemode”anddoingeverythinginyourpowertokeepcostsdown.Theeconomicsbecomeevenmorecompellingifyou’reafamily.
Provenstrategiesforspendinglesswhenyougogroceryshoppingincludeclippingcoupons,takingadvantageofin-storespecials,buyinginbulk,checkingoutthebottomshelveswheresupermarketstendtoputtheirlowest-priceditems,andbuyinggenericinsteadofbrand-nameproducts.Wholebooksarededicatedtothesubjectofshoppingforgrocerieseconomically,sowe
won’tgointofurtherdetailhere.
Onlyyoucandecideifapremiumgrocerystoreisworththeextraexpense,butwedosuggestyoumakesuchdecisionswithatleastoneeyeoncost.
It’salsowisetolimitimpulsepurchasesatthegrocerystore.IknowofwhatIspeakinthisregard.Ioncecamehomewithashoppingcart’sworthofnewtaste
sensations–andasensationallyhighreceipttomatch.IcametorealizeI’dbeenthinkingofsupermarketsascheapbydefinitionbecausetheydidn’tinvolvediningout.Butsupermarketscanbeexpensivetoo,andyoucan’tjustshoponauto-pilotwithnoregardforprices.
Youmayhavesimilarblindspotsinyourownspendinghabitsthatneedto
bereinedin.Ifso,identifythemandcomeupwithastrategyfordealingwiththem.Myownsolutioninvolvedlearningtoshopwithalist,limitingmyselftooneortwoitemsoff-listeachtrip,andshoppingwhenpossibleonafullstomach.
ClothingandtheJoysofMadMoneyIfyoulovetoshopfor
newclothingandknowyou’respendingmoreonitthanyoushould,tryreininginyourspendingbysettingamonthlyclothingbudgetandkeepingtoit.Thismaybeoneareainwhichyouandyourpartnerhavedifferingopinionsaboutwhatisasensibleamounttospendeachmonth.Sitdowntogetherandseeifyoucancometoanagreementaboutwhat’sreasonablegivenyouroverallbudget.Yourclothing
budgetandyourpartner’smaydifferinamount,butthat’sokayaslongasthetotalisacceptabletobothofyou.
Onestrategythatworkswellforusistokeepasmallstashofpersonalmoneytotheside.Thisisourmadmoneythatwecanuseanywaywewantwithoutfeelingguiltyorfeelinglikewehavetojustifyourpurchasestoeachother.(Notthatwereallyhaveto,butit’sapsychologicalthing.)
Robinusesherpersonalmoneytobuy“unnecessary”clothing,andIuseminetobuy“unnecessary”videogames.It’sasimplethingthatkeepsusbothhappyanddoesn’tbreakthebank.
Thankfullyyoucanreturnimpulseclothingpurchasesifyourealizeyou’vegoneoverboard,butanothertackistowalkawayfromanitemifyou’reunsureaboutbuyingit.Ifit’sstillonyourmindlater
on,thenyouknowit’ssomethingyoureallywant.Thisgivesyoutimetomullthingsoverbeforemakingapurchase.Occasionallyyoumaycometotheconclusiontheitemistoosimilartosomethingyoualreadyownorissomethingyouwouldn’twearoftenenoughtogetyourmoney’sworth.Thisiswhatbeingaconsciousconsumerisallabout:thinkingaboutyourpurchasesbeforemaking
them.Anotherstrategyistoshop
forclothingatsecondhandstores.Robinenjoysthetreasurehuntaspectoffindingclothingshelikesatsignificantlylowerpricesthanshewouldpayelsewhere.Thegentlyuseditemsatthesestorescanbeofsurprisinglygoodquality.Youcanalsosavetimeandmoneybystickingwithclassiclooksinsteadofchasingtrendsthat
goinandoutoffashionandrequirefrequentreplacement.
Whenitcomestojewelryandaccessories,havingafewitemsyoutreasure–andactuallywear–isbetterthanhavingloadsofthemclutteringupyourjewelryboxesanddrawers.Forsimplicity’ssakealone,keepingthesepurchasestoaminimummakessense.
Entertainment:
ProvingGroundforDelayedGratificationDelayedgratificationis
theabilitytowaittoobtainsomethingyoureallywant.Ofcoursethebiggestformofdelayedgratificationisretirementitself,whereyouworkhardforaperiodofyearsinordertobuytimelateronwithouthavingto
work.Thissameprincipalappliestomanysmallerthingsinlife.Forinstance,ifyoucanbringyourselftowaittoseeamoviethathasjustbeenreleased,youcanseeitonDVDorstreamingvideoinjustafewmonths’timeatafractionoftheprice.
We’renotsayingyoushouldalwaysdelaygratification.Sometimesyouwanttoseesomethingonthebigscreen,andthat’sthat.
Butyoushouldpickandchoosecarefullywhenyouknowyou’respendingmoreonsomethingjustforthepleasureofseeingitnow.Thequalityofthemoviecertainlyisn’tgoingtodeteriorateinthemeantime.
Consideralmostanyelectronicdevicecurrentlyonthemarket.Waitsixmonthsandthere’sagoodchanceitwillhavecomedowninprice,sometimes
dramatically.Somethingnewerandbetterwillhavecomealongtoreplaceit.Butwhyshouldyoubuythelatestversionthathasafewextrabellsandwhistleswhen,justafewmonthsago,youwouldhavebeenperfectlyhappywiththepreviousversionwhichisnowonsaleformuchless?Advertiserswilltrytosellyouontheideathatthenewestversionisthemostamazingthingsincesliced
bread,butyoushouldmakeyourowndecision.
Beonthelookoutforlessexpensivewaystodothesamething.Considerbuyingpaperbackbooksatausedbookstoreinsteadofbuyingthemnewinhardcover.Visitthelibraryandcheckoutbooks,audiobooks,DVDs,CDs,andmagazinesforfree.Readclassicsinthepublicdomainatnocostonelectronicdevices.Project
Gutenberg(gutenberg.org)offersmorethan36,000freeeBooksthatcanbedownloadedontoanyportabledeviceorPC.
Keepingyourselfentertainedcanbesurprisinglyaffordablethesedays.WithonelaptoporiPhoneyoucancarryweeks’ormonths’worthofentertainmentwithyou.Thetruthis,somuchfreeentertainmentisavailable
online,youcouldprobablyentertainyourselfforalifetimewithasimpleinternetconnectionandnotmuchelse.Youcanalsoeducateyourselfonlineonjustaboutanysubjectunderthesunatnocostwhatsoever.
RecurringExpenses:TheLittleThingsAddUpWe’vesuggestedliving
belowyourmeansrequiresanewmindsetthatinvolvesaskingyourselfonaregularbasisifyou’regettinggoodvalueforyourmoney.Itmeansbeingcognizantofthefactthatalotofseeminglylittleexpensescanadduptoalotovertheyears.Thisisespeciallytruewhenitcomestorecurringexpenses,whichbytheirverydefinitionarepaidmonthinandmonthout.
Withthisinmind,we
recommendyoutakeasecondlookatyourphone,internet,cable,andotherrecurringmonthlybillsandconsiderifthereareanywaysyoumightreducespendingwithoutcausingyourselftoomuchgrief.Ifyou’repayingforservicesyourarelyuse,orforduplicativeservices(e.g.,landlinesandmobileservices),thinkaboutwhethertheremightbealessexpensivewaytogo.
Ifyourarelyuseyourcellphone,forexample,youmightconsideraprepaidcellphoneorano-contract“payasyougo”phoneinsteadofpayingamonthlyrate.Wefoundwecouldsavemoneybyhavingnolandlineandonlycarryingasinglecellphonewithusmostofthetime.Robinalsokeepsabackupcellphone(TracFone)foremergenciesandoccasionaluse.Itoffers
nationwidecoveragewithnobills,nocontracts,andnodailyormonthlyfees.Instead,wepayapproximately$100peryearforthelowestnumberofminutesavailableatthemostaffordableprice.
AnotheroptionwhenitcomestophoneserviceisSkype,whichletsyoumakecallsfromyourcomputertootherpeople’sphonesallaroundtheworldforaslittle
astwocentsperminute.WeuseSkypeheavilywhentravelingoverseas.We’vealsocometouseitoccasionallyathome.Ifweknowwe’regettingclosetousingupourfree“anytime”minutesforagivenmonthonourVerizoncellphone,weswitchtousingSkypewhenmakinglengthycallsduringpeakperiods.
Insteadofpayingrightoffthebatforthehighest-priced
premiuminternetconnection,whynottryoutthebasicoptionfirst,thenupgradeifyoufindit’stooslowforyourneeds?Thisisabetterapproachthanalwaysassumingyouneedthemostexpensiveserviceonofferandspringingforitwithouteventryingthelower-costoption.
Ifyou’repayingforextendedcableserviceandyetrarelyventurebeyondthe
majornetworks,you’renotgettinggoodvalueforyourmoney.Considerbasiccable,whichcancostaslittleas$20permonthandmaystillgiveyoumostofthechannelsyouwatch.Ifthere’sasportingeventyoureallywanttoseethatisn’tavailableonthebasicchannels,considergoingtoyourlocalsportsbarandwatchingitforthepriceofabeer.Anothergoodoptionisanindoordigital
antennaliketheLeafHDTVAntenna–whichmightjustallowyoutogetridofcableandsatellitebillsaltogether.
We’renotsuggestingyoueliminateordownsizeservicesyougenuinelyuse,onlytheonesyoudon’tuseenoughtojustifythecost.WepayamonthlyfeeforNetflix,forexample,andconsideritmoneywellspentsincewereallydouseit.Whenwe’reawayonvacationoverseas,
wetemporarilyputaholdonourNetflixmembershipsowe’renotpayingforaservicewecan’tuseduringthatperiodoftime.
Thegoodnewsis,moreandmoreoptionsfordifferentkindsofservicesarebecomingavailableeveryday.Youdon’thavetogowithcableanymoresimplybecausethere’snootherchoice.Takeadvantageofthebountyofoptionsoutthere,
customizingyourchoicestoyourlifestyletogetthemostbangforyourbuck.
Chapter14.KeepHomeandCarExpensesLow
DuringmyearlyworkingyearsIwouldsometimes
daydreamaboutretiringearlyandlivingonayachtintheCaribbean.Nowassoonasyachtsareinvolvedinyourdreamsofthefuture,youknowyou’reintrouble,butinmymind’seyeIcouldseeuslivinghalftheyearintheCaribbeanandtheotherhalfintheRockies.I’mreluctanttoadmitIevenhaveajournalentrywhereIlistmydreamgoalsasfollows:1)toownaloghomeintheRockies,2)to
ownanislandhomeintheCaribbean,3)toownanRVfortoolingaroundNorthAmerica,and4)toownasmallyachtfortoolingaroundtheCaribbean.
You’llnotetheself-restraintinvolvedinonlyrequiringasmallyachttogoalongwithourislandhome–oneoftwohomes,mindyou.IsuspecteventhenIknewIwasbeingatadunrealistic.Icanstillenvisionowningor
rentingeachofthesethingsoneatatime,butcertainlynotallatonce.
Fortunately,overtimewecametosimplifyourdreamsalongwithourlives,orotherwisewewouldhavebeenworkingwellintoouroldage.Wecametorealizethatsimplifyingyourlifegoespartandparcelwithretiringearlyonless.Andabigpartofkeepinglifesimpleiskeepingtwoofyourbiggestexpenses
inlife–homeandvehicles–aslowasreasonablypossible.Makingwisedecisionsinthesetwoareasalonecanmakeabigdifferenceinwhetherornotyoureachyourearlyretirementgoals.
KeepingYourMortgageAffordable
Yourhomecanbecomeoneofyourbestinvestmentsoranalbatrossaroundyourneck,dependingonwhetheryoustaywithinyourmeansorgetintoodeep.Here’ssomehelpinhowtotellthedifference.
The28/36Rule:WhatConventionalWisdomSaysConventionalwisdom
saysyourmortgagepaymentcanbeupto28%ofyourgrossincome,aslongasyourtotaldebtpaymentsdon'texceed36%ofyourincome.Thisissometimescalledthe28/36rule,andit’swhatmortgagelenderstypically
useasaruleofthumbindecidingwhetherornotyouqualifyforaloan.
Supposeyouandyourspousemake$80,000grossperyear.Accordingtothe28/36rule,yourmortgagepaymentshouldnotexceed$1,867permonth($80,000x28%=$22,400÷12=$1,867),andyourmortgagepaymentplusanyotherdebts(creditcards,carpayments,collegeloans,etc.)shouldnot
exceed$2,400permonth($80,000x36%=$28,800÷12=$2,400).Keepinmindthesearenottoexceedamounts.Inessence,theyarethemaximumsmortgagelenderswanttoseeinorderforyoutoqualifyforaloan.
The20/28Rule:AMoreConservativeApproachWerecommendyoukeep
yourhousingcostsconsiderablylowerthanthe28/36ruleallows.Conventionalwisdomassumesyourgoalistolivewithinyourmeans,butsinceyourgoalistolivesubstantiallybelowyourmeans,conventionalwisdomdoesn’tnecessarilyapply.
Werecommend20%ofyourmonthlygrossincomegotowardhousingcostsinsteadof28%.Foracouple
making$80,000peryear,thatwouldworkouttobe$1,333permonthinmortgagepayments.Ideallyyouwouldbedebt-freebeforebuyingyourhome,butifthat’snotfeasible,wewouldsuggestyouuse28%insteadof36%asaguideforthetotalamountofdebtyoushouldcarry.Thatwouldbe$1,867permonthforourhypotheticalcouple.
Thismoreconservative
20/28rulegivesyoumoreofacushionforinvestingforyourfuture.Thelastthingyouwantistobehousepoorifyou’retryingtosaveforearlyretirement.
TheDownsideofStretchingTooFarNow,somewouldargue
youshouldstretchasfarasconceivablypossibletopayforthebiggest,nicesthome
youcanafford.Theysuggestyoursalarywillonlygrowinthefuturesothehousepaymentsthatseemsocumbersometodaywillbecomemoreaffordablelateron.
Whilethereisacertainlogictothis,itputsalotofyoureggsinonebasketandmakesyourhomeaconsiderablepartofyouroverallfinancialportfolio.Asweallknowfromrecent
experience,thereisnoguaranteehousingpriceswillalwaysgoup.Webelieveitstillmakessensetoownyourprimaryhome,butmakingittoobigapartofyouroverallfinancialpicturemeansyoumaynothavesufficientfundsleftovertodootherkindsofinvesting.
Anotherriskofthebuy-the-biggest-home-you-canphilosophyisthatitleavesyounobufferifthingsdon’t
goexactlyasplanned.Itassumesyoursalarieswillalwaysgoup,butwhatifoneofyouisletgofromwork,orstopsworkingtoraiseachild,orhastotakeanextendedleaveofabsenceforhealthreasons?Youdon’twanttostruggletomakeyourmonthlypaymentsbecauseyouboughtmorehousethanyoucouldcomfortablyafford.Sooursuggestionis,buyahomebutbuyanaffordable
onethatiswithinyourmeanstodayandnotsomedistanttimeinthefuture.
Ofcourserealitydon’talwaysmatchupwithwhatwemightallagreeonpaperistheideal.Ourownfirsthomepurchaseisagoodexample.Atthetimewewereearninglessthan$40,000combined.Ourinitialmortgagepaymentwas$936permonth,whichwasrightattheouterlimitofthe28/36rule($40,000x
28%=$11,200÷12=$933).Sowestretchedfinanciallyjustasfaraswecouldinbuyingourownhome.
Butweessentiallydidthingsbackwards–buyingourhomefirst,theninvestinginourselvessoourjobsimprovedandthemonthlymortgagepaymentsbecamelessonerous.Itwouldhavebeenpreferabletohavethebetterjobsfirst,sincemorerobustsalariesmake
everythingaboutowningahomeandinvestingforretirementeasier.
AFineTimetoBuyaHomeMortgageinterestrates
arecurrentlyathistoricallylowvaluations:below3%APRfora15-yearfixed-ratemortgage,andbelow3.5%APRfora30-yearfixed-ratemortgageasofthefirst
quarterof2013.Homeprices,meanwhile,
remainquiteaffordable.Whiletheyhaverecoveredsomewhatsincetherealestatebubbleburstin2007,valuationsarestillattractivecomparedtowhattheywerebefore.Thecombinationofreasonablehomepricesandhistoricallylowmortgageinterestratesmakesitagreattimetoconsiderbuyingahome.
We’renotsuggestingyouspeculateonhomesperse,butifyou’reinthemarketforyourprimaryhomeanywayandhappentofindtheoneofyourdreams,youshouldbeabletobuyitmoreaffordablythanyoucouldhavepriorto2007.
SavingUpforaDownpayment
Somanyfinancialobligationsseemtohitallatoncewhenyou’reyoungandjuststartingout.Youwanttobuyyourfirsthome,educateyourselfforabetterfuture,payoffyourdebts,andstartinvestingearly,butit’shardtodoallofthatatthesametime.Howdoyoudecide
whatcomesfirst?Intermsofprioritizingwe
wouldadviseyouto:1)investinyourselvesfirstsoyoucangetdecent-payingjobsrightfromthestart,2)payoffyourdebts,3)saveforadownpaymentonanaffordablehome,and4)startlivinginyourhomeatthesametimeyoustartinvestinginearnestforretirement.
20%vs.10%
DownpaymentsHowmuchshouldyou
saveupforadownpayment?Theidealis20%–that’swhatlenderswouldprefertosee.But20%ofa$250,000homeis$50,000,andthat’safairchunkofchange.Ifyoucanafforda20%downpayment,thenyougetthebestmortgagetermswiththelowestinterestrate,sothat’sthepercentagewe
wouldrecommend.Ifthat’snotfeasible,see
ifyoucanarrangea10%downpaymentwithyourbank.Thatamountislessdauntingandwillgetyouintoyourhomeinashorterperiodoftime.A10%downpaymentmaybeenoughtoqualifyyouforaloan,assumingyou’redebt-freeotherwiseandhavesolidcreditscores.Keepinmindthatifyoustartwitha10%downpaymentanda
highinterestrate,youcanalwaysrefinancetoalower-ratemortgageonceyourequityreaches20%.
PrivateMortgageInsuranceWithdownpaymentsof
lessthan20%,you’rerequiredtopayformandatorysupplementalinsuranceknownasprivatemortgageinsurance.PMIprotectsyour
lenderagainstnon-paymentshouldyoudefaultonyourloan.Ittypicallyamountsto0.5%oftheloanamount,sofora$250,000mortgagethatwouldamounttoslightlyover$100extrapermonth.Whileit’snofunhavingtopayPMI,it’sarelativelysmallpricetopayforgettingintoyourhomesooner.PMIispayableuntilyoureach20%equityinyourmortgage,thenyoucannotifyyourlendertocancel
it.
LeveragingYourInitialInvestment
Thehugebenefitofhomeownershipisthatyoubuildequityinyourhomewhilegettingtoliveinit.Ifyou’relucky,you’llseethemarketvalueofyourhomeincreaseovertime,whichmeansyourequitywillalsoincrease.
Takeourownsituation.Weboughtourhomein1991forjustover$100,000andsolditin2007forjustunder$300,000.Notonlydidwegettoliveinthehomefor16years,butattheendofthatperiodweownedthehomeoutrightbecausewehadrefinancedfroma30-yeartoa15-yearmortgageandthencompletelypaidthemortgageoff.Wewereabletoleverageasmallinitialinvestment
(i.e.,ourdownpayment)intoasignificantgain.
SmallDownpayment,BigRewardsAleveragedinvestmentis
anyinvestmentmadewiththeuseofborrowedmoney,allowingyoutoincreasethepotentialreturnoftheinvestment.Byfarthemostcommonformofleveragingistheuseofamortgageto
purchaseahome.Let’ssayyouhavea
$100,000condoandyourdownpaymentis20%.That’s5:1leverage(since$20,000isonefifthof$100,000).Ifyourcondoappreciates5%overthecourseoftheyear,thenyou’vejustearned$5,000onyourinitial$20,000investment–a25%return.
Bycomparison,let’ssayyourdownpaymentis10%insteadof20%.That’s10:1
leverage(since$10,000isone-tenthof$100,000).Ifyourcondoappreciatestheexactsame5%,you’vejustearned$5,000onaninitial$10,000investment–a50%return.
That’sleveragingatwork.Justlikeusingaphysicallever,you’vemanagedtoliftupsomethingheavywithlesseffort.Youbenefitfromtheappreciationonthefullvalueofthecondoeventhough
mostofthemoneyusedtobuyitwasnotyoursbutthelender’s.
WhyLeveragingYourHomeMakesSenseWebelieveprimaryhome
ownershipistheoneformofleveragedinvestmentthatreallymakessensefortheaverageinvestor.Leveragingmagnifiesbothgainsand
losses,soyouneedtobecarefulusingitifyoudon’twanttogetburned–forexample,bybuyingonmargininthestockmarket.
However,whenwe’retalkingaboutyourprimaryhome,yourrisksarelowerbecauseyou’relivinginthehomepresumablyforthelongtermandhaveahighstakeinmakingcertainthemonthlypaymentsaremade.Yourrisksarelower,too,ifyou
buyahomewithinyourfinancialcomfortzonetobeginwith.
Owningvs.Renting
Ourhometurnedouttobeoneofourbestinvestments,soperhapswe’reabitbiased,butwethinkhomeownershipmakesgreatsenseforthemajorityofpeoplesavingforearlyretirement.Yourmonthlymortgagepaymentremainsfixed,whichgivesyousomethingyoucanrely
onduringyourinvestingyears,andyourhomeactuallybecomespartofyouroverallinvestmentplan.
Homeownershipisaforcedsavingsplanofsortsthatallowsyoutogrowyourwealthasthepriceofthepropertyappreciates.Intheendyoucansellthehome,downsizetosomethingsmaller,andusetheremainingequitytohelpfundyourretirement.
Theonecautionwehaveisthis:ifyouthinkyoumaymovelocationsovertheshortterm–forjobreasons,say–youmightenduphavingtosellyourhomeinadownmarket.Forthisreasonyoumaywanttowaituntilyou’rereasonablysecureinyourjobbeforebuyingyourhome.
TheProsofRentingRentinggivesyou
increasedflexibilitywithno
long-termcommitments.Youhavelittleornoresponsibilityorexpenseformaintenance,homeimprovements,oryardwork.Youroverallcostscouldconceivablybelowerthanowningahomeifyoumanagetorentcheaplyenough.Andontopofallthat,youavoidtheneedforadownpaymentandamortgagealtogether,thusallowingyoutostartinvestingsooner.
Wecertainlybelieveitis
possibletorentratherthanownandstillretireearly.Ifyoukeeprentalcostsreasonablylowandinvestevenmoremoneythanyouwouldhaveotherwiseinthemarketstomakeupfortheequityyouwon’thavefromowningahome,youcankeepyourlifeultra-simpleandstillretireearly.Dependingonyourlifestyleandwhereyoulive,rentingcouldbetherightanswerforyou.
TheConsofRentingPerhapsthemost
significantdownsideofrentingisthatyoucan’tcontroltherentalprice,whichtendstogoupwithtime.Yourlandlorddetermineswhattocharge,andsometimestheyearlyincreasescanbedramatic.Thesameone-bedroomapartmentwerentedfor$500permonthin1991nowrents
for$1,200permonth–morethandouble.ApartmentsinplaceslikeNewYorkCityandSanFranciscohaveprobablyseengrowthfactorsmuchhigherthandoubleoverthatsamespanofyears.
Bycomparison,thecostsofhomeownershipremainessentiallysteadywithafixed-ratemortgage.Theymaygoupslightlyduetosmallincreasesininsuranceandpropertytaxes,butthe
underlyingmortgagerateitselfremainsfixedthroughout.Thisstabilityisacomfort–somethingyoucancountonduringyourinvestingyears.
Anotherdownsideofrentingisthatintheendyouhavenothingtangibletoshowforalltherentalpaymentsyou’vemadeovertheyears.It’sasifallthatmoneysimplyevaporatedintothinair.Comparethistohome
ownership,whereyoubuildequityasyougoandcantakethatequitywithyouonceyousellyourhome.Whenwesoldourhomein2007,wewereabletoput$200,000intoabondfundandusetheother$100,000tobuyasmallcondo.Downsizingallowedustoincreaseourliquidinvestments,whichwasjustwhatweneededasearlyretireesrelyingonanincomestreamfromthose
investments.Athirddownsideof
rentingisthatyoucan’tmodifyarentalpropertyasyoucanahome.Withrentals,whatyouseeistypicallywhatyouget,frompaintcolorstoappliancestoflooring.Butwithhomesyoucanmakechangesbothtothehomeitselfandtothelanditsitson,whichinturncanincreasethehome’sfinalvalue.
DeductingMortgageInterestAfinaldownsideof
rentingisreallymoreofanupsidetoowning:withahomeyougettodeductmortgageinterestpaymentsfromyouritemizedtaxes,whichyoucan’tdowitharental.It’snowonderthishasbecomethefavoritetaxdeductionformillionsofU.S.homeowners.Ahomeowner
whospends$12,000ininterestpaymentsand$3,000inpropertytaxescandeductall$15,000fromhisincometaxesfortheyear.
Themortgagedeductionbenefitismostnoticeableduringtheearlyyearsofyourloanwhenyou’repayingthemostininterest.Sinceinterestlowerseachyearonanamortizationschedule,onedayyouwillreachacrossoverpointwherethe
standarddeduction($12,200in2013foramarriedcouplefilingjointly)isworthmorethanthemortgageinterestdeduction.
15-Yearvs.30-YearMortgages
Werecommend15-yearmortgagesasaparticularlygoodfitforthosewhohopetoretireearly.You'llsavealotoninterest,andthe15yearsmatchesupnicelywithanearlyretirementgoal.Wethinkit’simportanttohaveyourhomecompletelypaidoffbeforeyouretire,anda
15-yearmortgageletsyouaccomplishthat.
Let’stakealookattwodifferentscenarios,oneinvolvinga15-yearandtheothera30-yearfixed-ratemortgage,togetasenseofthedifferenceincostbetweenthetwo.We’llassumea20%downpaymentona$250,000home,leavingaloanamountof$200,000.(Bytheway,weusedmortgagecalculator.orgtocalculatethefollowingtwo
scenarios.Youmaywanttouseacalculatorlikethistorunyourownscenarios.)
Notethatwehaveassumeda5%fixedinterestrateforbothloans.However,interestratesaretypicallylowerfora15-yearmortgagethantheyarefora30-yearmortgagebecauseoftheshorterloanduration.Thedifferencesbetweenthetwoexampleswouldbeevenmoredramaticifwehadtakenthatintoaccount,butitalsowouldhavemadeit
hardertocompareapplestoapples.
ComparingMonthlyPaymentAmountsLet’slookfirstatthe
monthlypaymentamount.Fora30-yearmortgageyourmonthlypaymentwouldbeabout$1,300,andforthe15-yearmortgageitwouldbeabout$1,800.Foradifferenceofabout$500per
monthyoucancut15yearsoffyourmortgage.
Here’safairquestion:Whatifthedifferencebetweenthetwopaymentsisenoughtoputyououtsidetheidealrangeofthe20/28rulewerecommendedearlier?We’llgiveyouapartialanswerhere,butbesuretoalsoreadthefollowingsectionon“unofficial”15-yearmortgagesforwhatmightbeabetteralternative.
Webelievethebenefitsofdoinga15-yearmortgagearesogreatcomparedtoa30-yearmortgagethatwewouldmakeanexceptionandrecommendyoustretchforthe15-yearmortgageaslongasyourmonthlypaymentsremainedwithinthe28%maximumrequiredbythetraditional28/36rule.Thatstillputsyouwithintheboundsofwhatmortgagelendersacceptasthe
qualifyingrangeforaloan,andintheenditwillgetyoutoyourretirementgoalfaster.
ComparingTotalInterestPaidAsnotedabove,interest
ratesaretypicallylowerfora15-yearmortgagethantheyarefora30-yearmortgage.However,evenwhenyouassumethesame5%rateofinterestforbothmortgages,
notethehugedifferenceintheamountoftotalinterestpaid:approximately$187,000versus$85,000.That’sadifferenceofover$100,000youdon’thavetopayifyougowitha15-yearmortgage.
Forthefirstseveralyearsofa30-yearmortgage,almostallyou’repayingisinterest;you’rehardlymakingadentintheprincipal.Butwitha15-yearmortgageyoumakeanoticeabledentinthe
principalrightfromthebeginning.Thatmeansyourequitygrowsfaster,andyourhomeismoreyourownandlessthebank’s.
Ifyoushouldneedtosellyourhomeearlierthanexpected,yourequitystakewillbegreaterwiththe15-yearmortgage.Youcanusethathigherstaketoputagreaterdownpaymentonyournexthome,keepingyourborrowingcostslower.
ComparingTotalPropertyTaxPaidThetotalpropertytax
paidfora15-yearmortgageishalfwhatitisfora30-yearmortgage,butthisisabitmisleading.Youwouldhavetocontinuepayingpropertytaxesonyourhomeevenafteryoupaidoffthe15-yearmortgage,assumingyoucontinuedtoliveinitafterwards.
Undereitherscenario,ifyouendedupstayinginthehomefor30years,thetotalpropertytaxpaidwouldbethesame.However,ifyousoldthehomeafter15yearsanddownsizedtoasmallerproperty,yourpropertytaxesfromthatpointforwardwouldbecomparablyless.Wepayalotlessinpropertytaxesonour400-square-footcondothanwedidonour1,800square-foothome.
ComparingPMIPaidTheabovecomparison
doesnotincludeprivatemortgageinsurance,butifitdid(i.e.,becauseyourdownpaymentwaslessthan20%,inwhichcasePMIisrequired),thenthetotalPMIpaidfora15-yearloanwouldgenerallybelessthanhalfwhatitisfora30-yearloan.Thereasonisthatyoureach
20%equityinyourmortgagemuchfasterwiththehighermonthlyprincipalpaymentsyou’remakingona15-yearloan,andthusyoucancancelthePMIsooner.
ComparingTotalAmountPaidWhenallissaidanddone,
thetotalamountpaidintheabovecomparisonisabout$480,000fora30-year
mortgageversus$332,000fora15-yearmortgage.That’sadifferenceofnearly$150,000.Wethinkit’sworthanextra$500permonthinmortgagepaymentstosavenearly$150,000,don’tyou?
MatchingYourMortgagetoYourRetirementDateIfyouknowtheexact
retirementdateyou’re
shootingfor,youcanmatchthelengthofyourhomemortgagetothatdate.Forexample,ifyouplantoretirein20years,youcouldconsiderdoinga20-yearmortgage.
Thatsaid,anequallyattractivealternativeistostickwiththe15-yearmortgageevenifyouknowyou’regoingtoretirein20years.Thatwaythelastfiveyearsbeforeyourretirement
arecompletelymortgage-free,allowingyoutosaveupevenmoremoneyduringthoseyears–orspendalittlemorefreelyontravelandfunasyoueasetowardsretirement.
Refinancingtoa15-YearMortgageIfa15-yearmortgageis
notfinanciallyfeasibleforyouatfirst,youcanalwaysrefinancetooneafteryou’ve
livedinyourhomeforaperiodoftime.However,beawarerefinancingcaninvolvesteepfinancecharges.It’snotunusualtopay3%ormoreofyouroutstandingprincipalinrefinancingfees.Thusrefinancingoftendoesn’tmakesenseunlessyou’repayingamuchhigherinterestratethanyouwouldotherwisehavetopay.
Refinancingmadesenseforusbecausewewere
payinganexceptionallyhighinterestrateonourfirstloan,a30-yearFHAmortgagewith10%down.Werefinancedtoa15-yearmortgageonceourequityreachedthe20%mark.Atthatpointwecouldqualifyforaconventionalloanwithbetterinterestrates.WewereabletodropthePMIsincewenowhad20%equity,andwewereabletogetanextra-lowinterestratebecausewewereswitchingtoashorter-
durationmortgage.Intheendwesavednearly$125,000ininterestchargesbyrefinancingtoa15-yearmortgage,andourmonthlypaymentswereonlyslightlyhigherthantheywerebefore.Itwouldhavebeencleanerandcheapertohavestartedwithaconventionalmortgageinthefirstplace,butsometimesyoudowhatyouhavetodotomakeabeginning.
“Unofficial”15-YearMortgages
Iftheinterestrateonyour30-yearmortgageisalreadyacceptablylow,youcanavoidrefinancingchargesbystickingwithyour30-yearmortgagebutunofficiallyturningitintoa15-yearmortgagebypayingdowntheprincipalfaster.
MakingExtraPrincipalPaymentsIfyoumakeextra
paymentstowardstheprincipaleachmonth(oronabiweeklybasis),thatwillhavetheeffectofloweringyouroverallinterestpaymentsandreducingthetermoftheloan.
Forinstance,ifyoupayanextra$100permonthtowardstheprincipalona
$180,000loanat5%interest,your30-yearfixed-ratemortgagebecomesineffecta25-yearmortgage.Anextra$200permonthmakesittheequivalentofa20-yearmortgage.Anextra$450permonthgetsyoutheequivalentofa15-yearmortgagewithouteverhavingtodotheofficialpaperworktomakeitone.
Anaddedbenefitofthisapproachisthatyou’renot
lockedintotheextrapayments.Ifyoushouldfindyourselftemporarilyunemployed,youcouldbackoffonmakingtheextrapaymentsforaperiodoftimeuntilyouwerere-employed.Youthushavelessriskofdefaultingonyourloan.
Theonlydownsideofthisapproachishumannature.Itrequiresagooddealofself-disciplinetokeepmakingthevoluntarypaymentsthrough
thickandthin,yearafteryear.Thatsaid,ifyouaresufficientlymotivatedtoretireearlyandhavethedisciplineittakes,thiscanbeagreatsolution.
Inourowncase,weswitchedtoan“official”15-yearmortgagebecauseofthebetterinterestrateswecouldobtain,butwealsomadeextrapaymentstowardstheprincipalof$100permonth,turningour15-yearmortgage
intosomethingclosertoa13-yearmortgage.Thisletusretireafewyearsearlierthanwecouldhaveotherwisebecauseourmortgagewaspaidoffsooner.
PrepaymentCalculatorsMortgageamortization
calculatorsliketheoneatHSH.comletyourundifferentprincipal
prepaymentscenarios.Justplugdifferentamountsintothe“MonthlyAdditionalPrincipalPrepaymentAmount”boxandhit“Calculate.”Youcanquicklyseetheresultsofmakingdifferentprepayments,includingthetotalinterestyouwillpayandthepayoffdate.Thisallowsyoutotailoryourprepaymentstrategytomatchyourneeds.
StayingPutinYourHome
Manypeopletradeupfromtheirfirsthome,usingitasasteppingstonetoabiggerhome,thentradingupyetagaintoanevenbiggerone.Why,exactly?Whenyouthinkoftheenergyandexpenseinvolvedinpackingandunpacking,remodelingandrefurnishing,repainting
andredecorating,andbuyingthenbuyingagaintosuittheneedsanddimensionsofeachbiggerhome,itmakesyouwonderwhatit’sallfor.
Wesuggestinsteadyoustayputinyourfirsthome.Keepyourlifesimplerandyourneedssmallerbystayinginoneplace.Increaseyourexistinghome’svaluebymakingimprovementstoitinsideandout.Ifyouhavenootherchoicebuttomove
becauseofyourjoborsomeothernecessity,thentrymovingsidewaysandbuyingahomethat’scomparabletotheoneyoualreadyhaveinsteadofupsizing.
Tradingupformoreandmorehomeiscounterproductiveifyou’reseekingearlyretirement.Yourgoalistominimizeyourexpenseswhilemaximizingyoursavings.Keepingyourhousingexpensesaslowas
reasonablypossiblewillletyouachievethatgoalwithmuchlessdifficulty.
Ifyouhavekidsorplanonhavingthem,trytobuyafirsthomebigenoughtoaccommodatethemrightfromthebeginningsoyoudon’thavetomovetoabiggerhomelateron.Ofcoursenoonehasacrystalballandallyoucandoisyourbest.Sometimesparentshavenootherchoicebuttobuya
biggerhomeiftheyenduphavingmorekidsthanexpected.
Ifyoubuyahomethatendsupbeingtoobigforyourneeds,youcanalwaysconsidercreativewaystousethatextraspacetoyourownadvantage.Forexample,whenweboughtourhome,weboughtitwiththeintentionofhavingchildren.Wepurchasedan1,800squarefootbi-levelhome
withthreebedroomsandtwobathsandaschooljustdownthestreet.Butwhenitturnedoutwecouldn’thavekids,wefoundourselveswithalotmorehomethanweneeded.Thebottomfloorofthehomewasjustsittingempty,sowedecidedtoputittogooduseandrentitout.Intheendthatextraspaceturnedouttobeafinancialhelptousaswesavedforearlyretirement.
IsaRenterRightforYou?
Wewereabletorentoutthebottomhalfofourhomefor$550permonth.Thatextra$550eachmonthhelpedoffsetourmortgagecostsduringatimewhenmoneywastightandeverydollarcounted.Infact,itcutourmonthlymortgagepaymentsroughlyinhalf,evenafter
factoringinthetaxesowedontherentalincome.
Ifyou’rewillingtoentertainthepossibilityofhavingarenter,thenconsiderfirsthowyourhomeisconfigured.Doesitallowforafairamountofprivacyforyouandyourrenter?Doesitofferaseparateentrance?Arethereseparatebathroomswithshowers?Canyousetupamini-kitcheninthepartofthehomeyou’llberentingout?
Themoreyoucanminimizetheneedtosharespacewithyourrenter,theeasieritwillbeforallparties.
Ourbi-levelhomeofferedagooddealofprivacybothforusandourrenter,sotheinconveniencewasminorcomparedtothefinancialbenefitsofreceivingamonthlyrentalcheck.Ofcoursewewerediligentaboutqualifyingourrenterbeforeacceptinghimintoourhome
(hewasanolderretiredgentleman),andovertheyearsheendedupbecomingnotjustarenterbutafriend.Weevenbenefitedfromtherelationshipunexpectedlywhenheofferedtowatchourdogforuswhenwewentawayontrips.
Weknowmanypeoplefeelstronglyaboutnotwantingtosharetheirhomewithanyoneelse,andwerecognizethismayormay
notbearightoptionforyou.Ifyou’reuncomfortablewiththethoughtofhavingarenter,perhapsyoucangivesomethoughttootherwaysyoucoulduseanyextraspaceinyourhomethat’sjustsittingempty.Maybeyoucansetupasmallhomebusinessofsomesort,forexample.Letyourcreativejuicesflowwhenconsideringdifferentwaysofbringinginalittleadditionalincomeontopof
yourregularsalaries.Evenalittleextraincomecangoalongwaywhenyou’restrivingmightilytolivebelowyourmeans.
DownsizingWhenYouRetire
Youmaywanttoconsidersellingyourbiggerhomeanddownsizingtoasmallerhomeorcondoonceyouretire.Aswetouchedonearlier,thisallowsyoutotakeaportionoftheequitybuiltupinyourhomeandinvestitinamore
liquidassetsuchasabondfund.
Liquidassetsaremoreusableassetsforearlyretirees.Youcantake$10,000outofabondfundanduseitforlivingexpensesonceyouretire,butyoucan’ttake$10,000outofyourhomeinthesameeasymanner.You’deitherhavetotakeoutahomeequityloan(whichmeansgoingbackintodebt)orrentoutallorapart
ofyourhome(whichcanbeinconvenient)togainaccesstothesame$10,000.Butifyoudownsizeafteryouretire,youcantakewhateverremainsandinvestitinamutualfundofferingbothliquidityandanincomestream.
Oneofthegreatbenefitsofhomeownershipundercurrentlawisthatwhenitcomestimetosellyourprimaryhome,youoweno
taxeswhatsoeveronthefirst$250,000ofcapitalgains(or$500,000forcouples).Thiscanbeagodsendifyou’relookingforsomeextramoneywithwhichtocushionyournesteggonceyouretire.
Ofcourseanotheroptionistobuyasmallerhomeorcondorightfromthestartandstayinitevenafteryouretire.Ifyoudecidetomovetoadifferentlocation,youcouldalwaystradesideways,
buyinganotherhomeorcondoforaboutthesameprice.Thebenefitsofthisapproachare,itkeepsyourhomemortgagetoaminimum(i.e.,youneverboughtmorehomethanyouneeded),yourpropertytaxesarelower,andyourutilitycostsarelowersinceyoursquarefootageisless.
Ifyougothecondoroute,besuretotakeintoconsiderationmonthlyHOA
fees.You’llwanttomakesurethey’reaslowasreasonablypossiblesincetheyaretheequivalentofpayingrenteachmonth.Aterrificdealonacondocanseemlessterrificonceyoufactorinthesefees.
KeepingCarExpensesLow
Untilweretiredin2006,wedrovethesametwocarsfortheentireperiodoftimeduringwhichwesavedforearlyretirement.Tousitjustdidn’tmakesensetopouralotofmoneyintocarswhenweknewtheirvaluewouldonlygodowninsteadofupastheygotolder.Wesawthem
asawaytogetaroundandnotmuchmore.Thatkindofthinkinghelpedusgettoourgoalmorequicklythanwewouldhaveotherwise.
TheRealCostofaNewCarTheaveragepricefora
newcarthesedaysisover$30,000.Ifinsteadofanewcarfor$30,000,youweretobuyausedonefor$10,000,
theremaining$20,000couldfundawholeyear’sworthofinvestingforretirement.Ifyou’reacoupleandeachofyoudecidestobuyausedcarfor$10,000insteadofanewonefor$30,000,that’s$40,000extrathatcouldbeputtowardsretirementsavings.
Nowlet’ssupposeyouhavea20-yearretirementplanandyourgoalistoputaway$20,000peryearon
average.That’s$400,000totalyouneedtoinvest,withtherestofyourportfolio’sgrowthcomingfromcompounding.The$40,000youcouldhavesavedbybuyingtwousedcarsinsteadoftwonewonesrepresentsone-tenthofyourtotalinvestmentamount.
That’stherealcostofanewcar.Youcouldbetradinginthechancetoretireseveralyearsearlier.
Self-FinancingIfyou’rebuyingaused
carfor$10,000insteadofanewonefor$30,000,thepossibilityofself-financingbecomesmuchmorefeasible.Youcouldstartacarfundandsaveupthewholeamountaheadoftime,payingforthecarincashandtherebyavoidingtheneedtopayinterestonacarloan.
Evenifyouonlymanage
tosaveuphalftheamount,aloanof$5,000islessintimidatingtopayback(andpaybackquickly)thanaloanof$10,000ormore.Thelessdebtyouhavehangingoveryouthebetter.
SharingOneCarorGoingCarlessFormostofourworking
yearsweeachhadacarsinceourjobstookusindifferent
directionsandweoftenworkeddifferenthours.Butonceweretired,wesoldthetwocarsandboughtasingleusedonefor$11,000thatwenowshare.Wefindonecarissufficientforourneedsnow.Havingjustonemeansmaintenanceandrepairexpenses,licensingandregistrationfees,andautoinsurancefeesarealllessthantheywouldbeotherwise.
Formanypeopleacarisa
necessityduringtheirworkingyears,butifyoucangetbywithoutoneandrelyonpublictransportinstead,somuchthebetter.WhenIworkedinDenverforanumberofyears,Itookanexpressbusintothecityeachdaynotonlytolowermyexpensesbutalsotoavoidtheheadachesofcitydriving.
Anyonelivinginamajorcitywithasubwaysystemshouldconsiderdoing
withoutacarsimplytoavoidthehighexpenseofparking.Ifyouonlyventureoutofthecityonrareoccasions,considerrentingacarjustwhenyouneedone.Itwouldalmostcertainlybecheaperthanowning.
Ifyou’reacoupleandoneofyouisluckyenoughtobewithinbikingdistanceofwork,thenyoumaybeabletogetbywithonecarinsteadoftwo.Notonlywillyour
costsgodown,butyou’llgetsomegoodexerciseeachday.
BuyingaUsedCarBuyingausedcarisnot
particularlyriskyifyoudoyourhomeworkfirst.Armedwithknowledgeyoucanbecomeaninformedbuyer.WesuggestyoustartwithKellyBlueBook(kbb.com)orEdmunds(edmunds.com),whichcansupplyyouwiththeestimatedpricerangefor
thecaryou’reinterestedinbuying.
Carfax(carfax.com)letsyoucheckonausedcar’svehiclehistory.SimplyentertheVINorthestateandlicenseplatenumbertopulluptherecord.Thecurrentcostis$35foronecar,$45foruptofive,and$50forunlimitedreportswithin30days.
Avehicleinspectionfromalocalmechanicisfrequently
offeredatalowcostasanincentiveforfuturebusiness.It’ssmarttohaveamechaniclookatausedcarfirstbeforeyoubuyit.
UsingCraigslisttoBuyorSellaCarConsiderbuyingor
sellingyourcaronCraigslist(craigslist.com).Thewebsite’sfreeclassifiedsofferaheavilyusedforumfor
buyingandsellingusedcarsandjustabouteverythingelseunderthesun.Wesoldourtwocarsinlessthanaweekafterpostingadsonthesiteandwereabletogetthepricewewanted.WealsofoundourcurrentusedcarviaapostingonCraigslist.Ifyou’reasinglewoman,wewouldrecommendbringingsomeonewithyouwhenbuyingorsellingforsafetyreasons.
Besuretopostqualityphotoswithyourad–itmakesabigdifferenceintermsofyoursuccessrate.Youcanrepostyouradevery48hourstomoveittothetopofthequeue,whichisworthdoingsinceitincreasesyourvisibilitytoprospectivebuyers.
Asasidenote,wealsosoldmostofourfurnitureandbelongingsthroughCraigslistwhenwesoldourhome.
Postingaphonenumberinyouradworksbest;ifyoupostanemailaddressyougetafairamountofspammixedin,butallthephonecallswereceivedweregenuineandfromlocalresidents.
Buyingvs.LeasingWedonotrecommend
leasingacarinsteadofbuyingone.Thelong-termcostofleasingisvirtuallyalwaysmorethanthecostof
buying.Itstandstoreasonwhenyouthinkaboutit.Ifyoupurchaseasinglecaranddriveitforadecadeormore,you’regoingtodobettercost-wisethanifyouleaseseveralcarsoverthatsameperiodoftime.
Mostpeopleweknowwholeasetheircarsturnthemineverytwoorthreeyearssothey’realwaysdrivingwhatamountstoaneworclose-to-newcar.Butthere’sapriceto
bepaidforthatprivilege.Yourarelygetsomethingfornothinginthisworld.
Whatconfusesmanypeople,andunderstandablyso,isthatmonthlyleasepaymentsaretypically30%to60%lessthanregularcarloanpayments.Thisseemslikeagreatdealatfirstglance,butit’sdeceptivebecausemonthlyleasepaymentsneverendaslongasyouareleasingthecar.
Onceyoupayoffaregularcarloan,youownthecaroutright.Otherthanmaintenanceandrepaircosts,youcandrivethecarpayment-freeforyearstocomeforaslongasitremainsroad-worthy.Yourloancostsareeffectivelyspreadoutovertheentireownershipperiodofthevehicle.Thus,eventhougharegularloanpaymentmayseemhigherwhencomparedtoamonthly
leasepayment,it’sactuallymuchlowerwhenyoutakethisintoaccount.
PayingforCarRepairsConsiderrepaircosts
carefullybeforedecidingtotradeinyouroldercarforanewerone.It’struethatrepaircostsarehigherforoldercars,buteveryextrayearyoucansqueezeoutof
yourexistingcarisonemoreyearwithoutmonthlyloanpaymentsorabigcapitalexpendituretobuyanewerone.
Payingahighcarrepairbillcanbepainfulbecauseithitsallatonceandoftenoutoftheblue,butitislesspainfulifyoumentallyspreadthecostoutoveralltheextramonthsyou’llgettodrivethecaronceit’sfixed.
Ofcourse,atsomepoint
thetransmissionmaybloworsomeotherrepaircostmaybesohighthatitnolongermakessensetopourmoremoneyintoacarthathaslittleornovaluelefttoit.Atthatpointit’ssensibletoputitouttopastureandlookforareplacement.KellyBlueBook(kbb.com)canhelpyoudetermineyourcar’scurrentvalueandwhetherornotyoushouldspringforexpensiverepairs.
Chapter15.KeepYourLifePortfolioBalanced
Likeyourinvestmentportfolio,yourlifeportfolioshouldbebalanced.Whetheryourmixoflivingfortoday
andlivingfortomorrowisbalanced50/50,or60/40,or70/30isuptoyou,butahighlyunbalancedportfolioisariskyportfolio.Ifyouonlylivefortodayyou’llbebroketomorrow,andifyouonlylivefortomorrowyou’llbemiserabletoday.Aswithmostthingsinlife,themiddlewayisthebestway.
Sincemostofuscan’tsprintallthewaytoearlyretirement,wehavetopace
ourselvesforthelongrun.Wehavetotakedeepbreathsalongtheway(vacations)andremembertohydrate(havefun).Ifwetrytoruntoofastweriskexhaustingourselvesandgivingup.Slowandsteadywinstherace–andletsusenjoythesceneryalongtheway.
SplurgeonWhatYouEnjoyMost
Ouradviceis,figureoutwhatyoucareaboutmostinlifeandspendmorefreelyinthatarea.Forusthatmeansspendingmoreontravelandlessonmaterialpossessions(otherthancampingequipment).Ifyoufeelyou'redeprivingyourselfofsomethingyoureallylove,
you'llneverbeabletosticktoyourplanoverthelongrun.
Whateveryourpassionis,youshouldn’thavetogiveitupinordertoretireearly.Wechoosetospendourextramoneyontravel,butperhapsthat’snotyourpassion.Ifyoufeelabouttheater,orfoodandwine,orfixingupantiqueautomobilesthewaywedoabouttravel,thenperhapsthatisyour“splurgearea”inlife.Besuretomakealittleextra
roominyourbudgetforit.Youshouldspendmoney
onthethingsthatmattermosttoyou,butyoushouldalsospendlessintheareasthatdon’t.Ifyou’relivingabalancedlife,thenyoushouldbeabletohavefuntodayandsavefortomorrow.It’snotaneither/orproposition.
LiveaLittle!Ifyoudon’talreadyhave
abucketlistofthingsyou’dliketoseeanddobeforeyoudie,wesuggestyoustartone.Pulloutamapandbeginthinkingaboutwhereyou’dliketogo.Addtoitcreativepursuitsyou’dliketotry,experiencesyou’dliketohave,andthingsyou’dliketoaccomplish.Thengetstarted
checkingoffafewofthoseboxeswhileyou’restillfullyemployed.Wesuggestyougivespecialprioritytoactivitiesthatareclosetohome(sinceyoucandothemmoreeasilywhilestillatwork)andadventuresthatarephysicallydemanding.Someofthemostamazingexperiencesinlife–bungeejumping,mountaintreks,walkingsafaris,whitewaterrafting,skydiving,andso
forth–aremosteasilyaccomplishedwhileyou’restillyoungandfit(nottomentionfearless).
Ofcourse,themorefunyouhavealongtheway,themorefityouwillremainandtheyoungeratheartyouwillbe.Westillhopetobehavingadventureseveninourgoldenyears,albeitofamoresubduednature.ThinkrivercruisinginEurope,extendedRVtripsinNorthAmerica,
islandlivingintheSouthPacific,andhousesittinginafewofourfavoriteforeigncountrieslikeItalyandNewZealand.
Nowhere’saquestion:Ifyouweretowaituntilyouwere65–“normal”retirementage–togetstartedonyourbucketlist,howmuchofitdoyourealisticallythinkyou’dgetdone?Probablynotasmuchasyou’dlike,andmaybeonlya
fractionofwhatyouhavelisted.Butifyougetstartednow,youcanmakerealinroadswhileyou’restillatwork,thenkeeprightonacceleratingintoearlyretirementandhaveadecentchanceofdoingratherthanjustdreamingaboutallthewonderfulthingsonyourlist.
Enjoyinglifetothefullestisnotcontradictorywithsavingforthefuture.It’spossibletodobothifyou
balanceworkwithplayandmixinplentyoffunalongtheway.It’snotnecessarytosacrificefunonthealtarofthefuture:it’ssimplynecessarytobalancefunwithfunding.
HaveFaithinYourOwnFuture
It’sundeniablesavingforthefuturetakesfaith.Youhavetohavefaithyou’llstillbealiveand“stillyou”15to20yearsfromnow.Thatlifewillstillbeworthlivingandyou’llstillhaveyourhealth.Thatyourretirementplanwill
actuallyworkasplanned.Thatsavingsmallamountsofmoneyeachmonthreallycanadduptobigrewardslateron.Andthatthemarketswillperformasexpectedoverthelongtermtogetyoutoyourgoal.
That’salotoffaith!It’ssafetosayyouhavetobeanoptimisttoplanadecadeortwoinadvanceforearlyretirement.
Nevertheless,oneofthe
reasonsweliketalkingaboutretirementin15to20yearsisthat,yes,it’salongwayoff,butatleastit’simaginableandworththinkingabout.Talkingaboutsomething15yearsdowntheroadisn’tquitesoelusiveastalkingaboutsomething40yearsdowntheroad.(“Areyoukiddingme?Icouldbedeadin40years!”)Atleasta30-year-oldcanmeasure15yearsasbeingtwohalvesof
hisownlifethusfarandpicturehimselfasnotbeingtooradicallydifferentbythetimehereaches45.Butasktheaverage20-somethingtopicturehimselfatage65andhe’llsimplyshakehishead.Itdoesn’tbearthinkingabout.
Weencourageyoutohaveatleastamustardseedoffaithinyourownfuture.Retiringearlyisnotanimpossibledreambyanymeans.Itisachievableby
normaleverydaypeople,asweourselvescanattest.Ifanyonetriestotellyouyou’remissingoutonlifeandwastingyourtimesavingupforearlyretirement,tellthemtothinkagain.They’remissingoutonlifeiftheydon’tsaveuptomaketheirdreamscometrue.
Chapter16.HealthCareinRetirement
WhatshouldIdoabouthealthcare?ThisisthequestioneveryAmericanwhohaseverthoughtaboutretiringearlywantsananswerto,andupuntilnowithas
beenoneofthehardestanswerstoprovide.Wesayupuntilnowbecausethingsarechangingfast.Newrulesarecomingintoeffectthataremuchmorefavorabletoearlyretirees.Infactthenewregulationsopendoorstohealthcarethatareclosedtothosecurrentlycoveredbyemployeehealthplans.
ByJanuary1,2014,mostprovisionsofthePatientProtectionandAffordable
CareActwillbeinfulleffect,andatthatpointthehealthcareoutlookforearlyretireesonabudgetwillhaveimproveddramatically.Affordablehealthcarewillnolongerbetiedinextricablytoholdingdownafull-timejobwithbenefits.Whatthatmeansforthosestillworkingismoreflexibilityindecidingwhentoretire.Forthosealreadyretired,itmeansamuchbetterdealwhenit
comestopayingpremiumsandreceivingaffordablehealthcarebenefitsinreturn.
Overthepastsixyearsofearlyretirement,weestimatewe’vepaid$23,000inhealthcarepremiumswhilereceivingnomeaningfulhealthcarebenefitsinreturn.Ourexistingcatastrophicpolicy’shighdeductiblelimitsmeanthatineffectwe’vehadtopaythefullcostofeveryofficevisittoevery
doctor,dentist,oroptometrist,everytestorscreeningreceived,everyfillingfilledandtoothcrowned,andeveryprescriptiondrugpurchased.Ourinsuranceprovidesuswithfinancialprotectionmorethantruehealthcare,butsinceoneseriousillnesscouldwipeoutourentiresavings,we’vefeltwehadlittlechoicebuttocoverourselveswithsomekindof
policy,nomatterhowrudimentary.
Needlesstosay,we’vetriedtokeepourhealthcarevisitstoaminimum.It’svirtuallyimpossibletowalkintoadoctor’sordentist’sofficewithoutwalkingoutwithabillfor$300ormore.Weestimatewe’vespent$6,000overthepastsixyearsonmedicalanddentalservices,andofcoursethatnumbercouldhavebeen
dramaticallyhigherifwehadn’tbeeninreasonablygoodhealth.
Butstartingnextyear,forthefirsttimeinsixyears,weexpecttoreceiveactualbenefitsinreturnforthehealthcarepremiumswepay.Perhapsequallyimportantly,wecancountonourpremiumsstayingrelativelystableovertheyearstocome.Ourpremiumswon’tbemuchlowerthantheyarenow,but
ourdeductibleswillbesignificantlylower,andwe’llonlyhavetopayaco-payinsteadoftheentirebillifwemakeavisittothedoctor.We’llalsohavetopaylessoutofpocketifweshouldeverfaceaseriousillness.Inshort,ourhealthcarecoveragewillfeelalotmorelikeitdidbackinthedayswhenwewerecoveredunderouroldemployeehealthcareplansatwork.That’sno
coincidence,sincethenewlegislationisessentiallydesignedtomimicthelevelsofcoverageprovidedundermostemployeehealthcareplans.
KeyAspectsoftheAffordableCareAct
WithoutquestiontheAffordableCareActisagamechangerforearlyretireesonabudget.Practicallyspeaking,itmeansoneofthemainroadblockstoearlyretirement–thelackofaffordablehealthcare–has
finallybeenclearedaway.Here’sasummaryofsomeofthekeybenefitsoftheact:–Guaranteedissue:youcannotbedeniedcoveragebecauseofapreexistingconditionorchargedhigherratesifyouhaveamedicalcondition.–Subsidizedpremiums:monthlypremiumsstayreasonableasyouage(assumingannualincome
fallswithincertainlimits,asdiscussedbelow).–Subsidizedout-of-pocketexpenses:annualexpensesfordeductiblesandcoinsurancestaymanageable(assumingincomefallswithincertainlimits).–Freepreventivehealthservices:freeservicesareofferedforregularbloodpressureandcholesterol
checks,screeningsforcoloncanceranddiabetes,wellwomanexams,andmanyotherpreventivetests.–Healthcareexchanges:asingleonlinemarketplaceforeachstatemakesiteasiertocompareplancostsandbenefits.Theactrequiresinsurers
tospendbetween80%and85%ofeverypremiumdollar
onmedicalcare(asopposedtoadministration,advertising,etc.).Ifinsurersexceedthisthreshold,theyhavetorebateanyexcesstotheircustomers.Thisaspectofthenewlawisalreadyineffect,andthenation'shealthinsurancecompanieshavealreadyrefundedover$1billiontotheircustomers.
Theinformationinthissectionisbasedprimarilyondataprovidedonthe
government’shealthcarewebsite,HealthCare.gov,andtheKaiserFamilyFoundation’sSummaryofNewHealthReformLaw.We’vemadeeveryefforttobeasaccurateaspossibleinourdescriptionofhowthenewregulationsaffectearlyretirees,butanyerrorsarewhollyourownandwecanonlysaywedidourbesttoexplaininastraightforwardfashionarathercomplicated
pieceoflegislation.
GuaranteedIssueUndertheAffordable
CareActalldiscriminationagainstpre-existingconditionsisprohibited.Youcannotbedeniedaffordablecoverageduetoyourhealth,andyourinsurancewillactuallyhavetocoveryoushouldamedicalneedarise,withoutconcernthatsomepaperworkerrormightresult
inacancellationofcoverage.Mostwouldagreethisisasignificantimprovementoverthepreviousstateofaffairs.
AccordingtotheKaiserFamilyFoundation,overone-fifthofpeoplewhoappliedforhealthinsuranceontheirowninthepastgotturneddown,orwerechargedahigherprice,orwereofferedaplanthatexcludedcoveragefortheirpre-existingcondition.Butthedaysof
cherry-pickingonlythehealthiestcustomersarepast.Insurancecompaniescannolongerputannuallimitsonessentialhealthbenefitssuchashospitalstays,norcantheyputalifetimecapontheamountofcaretheyarewillingtocover.
Differencesinpremiumsbasedongenderarealsoprohibited.Genderdiscrimination,somethingthatwasonlyproscribedby
lawinone-fifthofthestates,isnowbannedinallfiftystates.Thatmeanswomenwillnolongerhavetopaypremiumsthatweresometimes50%to100%higherthanmen’s.
FreePreventiveCareAllnewplansmustcover
certainpreventiveserviceswithoutchargingadeductible,co-pay,orcoinsurance.Theseservices
includescreeningsforbloodpressure,cholesterol,diabetes,andHIVaswellasroutinevaccinations,fluandpneumoniashots,mammograms,papsmears,andcolonoscopies.TheofficialgovernmentwebsiteatHealthCare.govprovidesafulllistofpreventivecareservices.
TheactmakesitpossibleforallAmericanstoavailthemselvesofproven
preventivemeasureswithouthavingtothinktwiceaboutwhethertheycanaffordit.Womeninparticulararebeneficiariesofthenewlaw,sinceprivatehealthplansmustnowprovidefreewell-womanvisits,newbabycare,breastfeedingsupplies,contraception,andmanytypesofscreeningsatnocharge.Somespecificsarestillbeingworkedout,buttheoverallintentisclear:to
makeiteasierforwomentogetthebasichealthcareservicestheyneedirrespectiveoftheirfinancialsituation.
RequiredHealthInsuranceVirtuallyallcitizenswill
berequiredtohavebasichealthinsurancebeginningin2014orelsepayafederaltaxpenalty.Theprovisionis
intendedtodrivedownhealthcarecostsbyspreadingtheexpenseofhealthcareoveralargerpoolofpeople,includingyoungerandhealthieradultswhomightotherwisedeclinepurchasinginsurance.Ofcourse,youngeradultswillturnolderthemselvessomedayandwilllikelyrequiremoremedicalcareinthefuture,sowhiletheymightunderstandablygrumbleaboutthenewlaw
overtheshortterm,theystandareasonablechanceofbenefitingfromitoverthelongterm.
Thosewhorefusecoveragewillhavetopayataxpenaltyof$95perindividual,$285perfamily,or1%ofincome(whicheverisgreater)in2014.Thosepenaltyamountsincreaseto$695perindividual,$2,085perfamily,or2.5%ofincome(whicheverisgreater)by
2016.After2016thepenaltyincreasesannuallybasedoncost-of-livingadjustments.Exclusionsapplyforindividualswhomaketoolittlemoneytofileafederaltaxreturn,orwhowouldhavetospendmorethan8%oftheirhouseholdincomeonthecheapestqualifyingplan.
Americanslivingabroadareexemptfromhavingtopurchasehealthinsuranceorpayanyassociatedpenalties.
However,thedefinitionoflivingabroadappearstobefairlystrict.Youmustbeabonafideresidentofaforeigncountryinordertooptout.Therulesseemtosuggestyoumustbe“anindividualwhosetaxhomeisinaforeigncountry,”andyoumustresideinaforeigncountryorcountriesforatleast330fulldaysoutoftheyearinordertobeexempt.Clarificationsmayeventuallypointtoaless
restrictiveinterpretation,butfornowitappearsthatsimplytravelinginforeigncountriesforextendedperiodsoftime(i.e.,sixmonthsormore)isnotenoughinandofitselftoexemptyoufromhavingtoeitherpayforbasichealthinsuranceorelsepayapenalty.
HowPremiumsandOut-of-PocketLimitsAreDetermined
Nowwegetintothenitty-grittyofhowyourhealthcarepremiumsandout-of-pocketmaximumsaredeterminedunderthenewlaw.It’sworthnotingupfrontthatyoudon’t
havetowaituntilyousubmityourtaxestoclaimyourpremiumsubsidiesundertheAffordableCareAct.Rather,subsidiesare“advanceable,”whichmeanstheyarebuiltrightintothereducedpremiumsyoupayonamonthlybasisonceyouenrollinaqualifiedhealthcareplan.Thetaxcreditissentdirectlytoyourinsurancecompanyandappliedtoyourpremium,soyouimmediately
paylessoutofpocket.
SubsidiesandtheFederalPovertyLevelTounderstandhowthe
AffordableCareActappliestoyouasanearlyretiree,youhavetobegin,strangelyenough,withthefederalpovertylevel.That’sbecausesubsidiesformonthlyhealthcarepremiums(andannual
out-of-pocketlimits)aretiedtothefederalpovertylevel.
Summarizedintheshadedboxesbelowarethe2013federalpovertyguidelinesforhouseholdsofonetofourpeopleforthe48contiguousstates.Startwithyourhouseholdsize,thennotetheannualincomelimitsspecifiedunderthebaseline100%column.
Asthe100%columnshows,theofficialpovertylevelforresidentsofthe
continentalU.S.is$11,490forasingleindividualand$15,510foracouple(asof2013).TheseamountsaretypicallyadjustedeachyearbytheDepartmentofHealthandHumanServicestoaccountforinflation.
Nowreadacrosstherowthatappliestothenumberofpeopleinyourhousehold.Aslongasyourincomefallswithin400%ofthefederalpovertylevel,yourhealth
carepremiumsarecappedonaslidingscalethatgoesnohigherthan9.5%ofyourannualhouseholdincome.(Technicallytheslidingscaleisbasedon“modifiedadjustedgrossincome,”butthisisthesameasgrossincomeforthemajorityofhouseholds).Annualout-of-pocketlimitsarealsosubsidizedaslongasyourincomefallsbelowthe400%mark.
Whatthismeansforyouasanearlyretireeisthatyoumaywanttomanageyourincomeleveltokeepitbelow400%ofthepovertyline–inotherwords,$45,960foronepersonor$62,040foracoupleasof2013–inordertobeeligibleforpremiumassistance.Assoonasyoucrossthe400%threshold,thesubsidyimmediatelydropstozero.Thusitiscrucialtostaybelowthismarkifatall
possibleifyouwanttoqualifyforasubsidizedpremiumandloweryourmaximumout-of-pocketexpensesaswell.
SubsidizedHealthCarePremiumsLet’stakeacloserlookat
howhealthcarepremiumsworkundertheAffordableCareAct.We’llstartwithanexample.Let’ssayyouarea
marriedcouple50yearsofageandyourannualincomeis$62,000peryear.Thatmeansyou’rebumpingrightupagainstthe400%limitasshownintheprevioustable,soyourannualhealthcarepremiumsarecappedat9.5%ofyourincome.That’s$62,000x9.5%=$5,890peryear,or$491permonth.
Butifyouearnjust$1,000moreandhaveanannualincomeof$63,000,
thesubsidyimmediatelydropstozero.Suddenlyyouneedtopaythefullcostofthemonthlypremium,andthepremiumwithoutsubsidiesforacoupleyourageislikelytorunabout$15,420peryear,or$1,285permonth(basedonnationalestimatesbytheCongressionalBudgetOffice).That’sadifferenceofnearly$10,000peryearor$800permonth.Soyoucanseehowimportantitisto
keepyourannualincomewithinthe400%limitifyouareanywhereclosetothatlimittobeginwith.
Here’sthegoodnews,though.Ifyouareanearlyretireelivingonabudget,thenwhetheryouareage44or54or64,yourpremiumsarealwayscappedbasedonyourincomelevelaslongasyoustaywithin400%ofthepovertylevel.Thatmeansyourpremiumswon’t
skyrocketasyougetolder.Insteadyourpremiumcostswillstayroughlythesame,otherthanrisingwithoverallincreasesinhealthcarecostsandinflation.Asyouage,moreandmoreofthepremiumamountwillbesubsidized.Thatmeansyouwillcontinuetoreceiveaffordablehealthcareevenbetweentheagesof55and64whenpremiumstendtobeattheirhighest.Onceyouhit
age65,ofcourse,youqualifyforMedicare.
Thinkabouthowimportantthisisforearlyretireesonabudget:itmeanstheynolongerhavetoworryaboutskyrocketingpremiumsastheygrowolder.Speakingforourselves,weweredreadingthesuper-highpremiumsweknewwerecomingjustaroundthebend.InfactwehadbeenconsideringdroppingU.S.
healthcoveragealtogetherduringthoseyearsandrelyinginsteadsolelyonmedicalcareoverseas.ButaslongastheAffordableCareActremainslaw,thedaysofexorbitantpremiumsformostAmericansage55to64areathingofthepast.
Ageandthe3:1RatioTheAffordableCareAct
stipulatesthatthemostexpensivepoliciesforolderindividualscanbenomorethanthreetimesthepriceofpoliciesforyoungeradults.Thusa64-year-oldwouldhavetopaynomorethanthreetimeswhata20-year-oldwouldpayforthesamecoverage.
The3:1ruleiseasiesttounderstandifyouconsidertwoindividuals,aged20and64,bothwithincomeshigher
than400%ofthepovertylimitandthereforeunabletoqualifyforpremiumsubsidies.Ifthe20-year-oldpaysapremiumof,say,$200permonth,thenbylawinsurancecompaniescannotchargethe64-year-oldmorethan$600permonth.Theendresultofthe3:1ruleisthatyoungerparticipantswillpaymoreforhealthinsurancethantheywouldhaveotherwise,whileolder
participantswillpayless.Inessence,theburdensofhigherhealthcarecoststhatcomewithgrowingolderhavebeenspreadoutmoreevenlyacrosstheentirepoolofinsured.
Keepinmindthe3:1ratioappliesprimarilytounsubsidizedpolicies.Onceyoureachacapforyourincomelevel,youcan’tgohigherthanthat,period.Forexample,ifacoupleintheir
twentiesandacoupleintheirsixtiesbothhaveincomesof$60,000(meaningtheybothfalljustwithinthe400%limit),theywouldbothpaythesamepremiumamountof$475permonth($60,000x9.5%incomecap=$5,700÷12=$475).Thedifferenceisthatthecoupleintheirtwentieswouldreceivepremiumsubsidyassistanceofabout$40permonth,whilethecoupleintheir
sixtieswouldreceivepremiumsubsidyassistanceofabout$1,040permonth.Whilethelevelofassistancediffersdramaticallybehindthescenes,thetwocouplespaythesamemonthlypremiumsupfront.
TheSlidingScaleSofarwe’vediscussed
howpremiumsworkforpeoplebumpingrightupagainstthe400%levelofthe
povertylimit.Butwhatifyourincomefallssomewherelowerinthespectrum,say,atthe250%mark?Thesimpleansweristhatyouwouldpaylessbasedonaslidingscale.Premiumcapsbeginatjust2%ofincomeifyourannualincomeislessthan133%ofthepovertylevel,andtheyclimbsteadilyfromthereuptothemaximum9.5%cap.Thefollowingtableshowsthepremiumcappercentages
thatapplyasyourannualincomeincreases.
Thetableillustrates,forexample,thatamarriedcouplewithincomeof$40,000peryearwouldfallbetween250%and300%ofthepovertylimit,andthustheirpremiumwouldbecappedonaslidingscalebetween8.05%and9.5%oftheirannualincome.Asshownintheright-handcolumn,theirmaximumannualpremiumwould
thereforefallbetween$3,121and$4,420peryear,orbetween$260and$368permonth.
Togetanevenmoreexactidea,youcanmultiplyyourspecificannualincome(e.g.,$40,000)by8.05%thenby9.5%toascertaintherangeofyourmaximumannualpremium(e.g.,$3,220to$3,800peryear,or$268to$317permonth).
Out-of-PocketMaximumsUnlikemonthlyhealth
carepremiumsthatmustbepaidregardlessofhowmuchorhowlittleoneusesthehealthcaresystem,out-of-pocketexpensesaretiedtoactualvisitstodoctorsandhospitalsandsuch.Ifyoumakenosuchvisitsandpurchasenoprescriptiondrugs,thenyourannualout-
of-pocketcostsmaywellbezeroorclosetozero.Butifyoumakefrequentvisitstothedoctororfaceasuddenmedicalemergency,yourout-of-pocketexpensesmaybesignificantlyhigher.
Fortunately,theseexpensesarecappedonanannualbasisunderthelaw.MaximumsundertheAffordableCareActarebasedonout-of-pocketlimitsalreadyestablishedbythe
IRSeachyearforHealthSavingsAccounts(tax-advantagedaccountsassociatedwithhigh-deductiblehealthcareplans).Out-of-pocketHSAlimitsfor2013,forexample,are$6,250foranindividualand$12,500forafamily.
ThesesamelimitshavebeenadoptedforhealthcareplansundertheAffordableCareAct.Thesearetheunsubsidizedmaximumsany
personorfamilyenrolledinaqualifiedhealthcareplanshouldhavetopayoutofpocketinanygivenyear,nomatterwhattheirincomelevel.Oncethemaximumisreached,yourplanpaysforallcoveredexpensesbeyondthatpoint.
Justlikehealthcarepremiums,out-of-pocketlimitsaresubsidizedundertheAffordableCareActbasedonincomelevel.
Subsidiesapplyaslongasyourincomefallswithin400%ofthefederalpovertylevel.Beyond400%thesubsidyimmediatelydropstozero.Asshowninthefollowingtable,yourmaximumout-of-pocketexpensesmaybeone-third,one-half,ortwo-thirdsofthecurrent-yearHSAlimit,dependingonwhereyourhouseholdincomefallsinrelationtothefederalpoverty
level.
HealthCareCalculators
Theinformationintheprevioussectiongivesyouabehind-the-sceneslookathowyourhealthcarepremiumsandout-of-pocketmaximumsaredetermined,butitwillallbemuchsimpleronce2014rollsaround.Then,whenyouconsideraparticularinsuranceplan
online,itwillletyouknowyourestimatedpremiumandannualout-of-pocketmaximumonceyouhavepluggedinbasicinformationaboutyourself.
Infact,healthcarecalculatorsarealreadyavailablethatwilldomostoftheworkforyou.TheonewelikebestistheNationalHealthCareCalculatorprovidedbyUCBerkeleyLaborCenter
(laborcenter.berkeley.edu/healthpolicy/calculator).Yousimplypluginyourhouseholdsize,annualincome,andageanditinstantlyestimatesyourmonthlypremium.Theexampleonthefollowingpageisbasedonourowninputtedinformation.
Thecalculatorshowsthatwefallat258%ofthepovertylevelandthatourtotalestimatedhealthcarepremiumwithoutsubsidywouldbe$1,436permonthfora“Silver-level”plan(discussedinthenextsection).Sinceactualpremiumsaren’tknownyet,thesearebasedonnationalestimatesfromtheCongressionalBudgetOffice.
Thecalculatorindicatesthatthemostweshouldhavetospendonhealthcarepremiumsis8.3%ofourannualincome,or$276permonth.(Themanualcalculationwouldbe$40,000x8.3%=$3,320÷12=$276.)
Thedifferencebetweenthepremiumwithoutsubsidy($1,436)andthepremiumwithsubsidy($276)is$1,160permonth.Thusthefederal
premiumsubsidyamountstoanestimated$13,920peryear.
Partoftheutilityofcalculatorsliketheseisbeingabletoplugindifferentvaluestoseehowtheyaffect(ordon’taffect)yourpremium.Forinstance,changingtheageintheexampleabovefrom49toeither19or64(thelowestandhighestagesyoucanenter)hasnoeffect
whatsoeveronthepremium.Instead,whatchangesdramaticallyistheamountofthesubsidy.It’salsoeducationaltopluginamountsslightlyhigherthanthe400%limitandseehowthemonthlypremiuminstantlyshootsupwardsoncethesubsidiesdisappear.
Bronze,Silver,Gold,andPlatinumPlans
Beginningin2014,healthcareplanswillbeofferedatfourdifferentcoveragelevels:Bronze,Silver,Gold,andPlatinum.Platinumplanshavethehighestpremiumsbutthelowestout-of-pocketcosts.Gold,Silver,and
Bronzeplanseachinturnhavelowermonthlypremiumsbutcostincreasinglymoreoutofpocket.Thecolorcodinghelpsyouquicklyidentifythetypeofhealthcareplanthatbestsuitsyourneeds.
Thelowest-costplanmaynotalwaysbethebestplanforyou.Forinstance,Bronze-levelplanshavethelowestmonthlypremiums,butout-of-pocketexpensesare
unsubsidizednomatterwhatyourincomelevel.Instead,out-of-pocketlimitssimplymatchwhateverthecurrentHSAlimitis(e.g.,$6,250forindividualsand$12,500forfamiliesin2013).SowhileBronze-levelplansmayhavethelowestpremiumcost,theymaynotalwaysrepresentthebestvalue.
Intheend,ofcourse,bestvaluedependsonthedetailsofyourownpersonal
situation–yourhealth,yourincomelevel,yourlikelyfrequencyofmedicalcarevisits,andsoforth.Forpeoplewithongoingmedicalconditions,theGoldorPlatinumplansmightrepresentbestvalueevenafterfactoringinthehigherpremiumcosts.Then,too,noneofusknowswhenanunexpectedmedicalemergencymightoccur,andthatmightbereasonenough
toconsidergoingwithaslightlymoreexpensiveplan.
Thesecond-lowest-levelSilverplansareespeciallyworthconsideringifyouareanearlyretireeonabudget.TheseplansaretypicallyusedasbaselinemodelsinillustrationsabouttheAffordableCareActbecausetheyrepresentagoodbalancebetweencoverageandcost.Formanypeopletheymayrepresentthebestvalue.
UnderSilver-levelplans,bothhealthcarepremiumsandout-of-pocketmaximumsaresubsidized(assumingyourincomefallswithin400%ofthefederalpovertylimit).YourlevelofcostsharingisalsolesswithaSilverplanthanitiswithaBronzeplan,asdiscussedbelow.
CostSharingUnderDifferentColorTiers
Eachcolortier–Bronze,Silver,Gold,Platinum–hasbeendesignedwithadifferentpercentageofcostsharinginmind.Costsharinghastodowithhowmuchyouspendoutofpocketversushowmuchyourplancovers.Deductibles,coinsurance,co-pays,andanyotherpoint-of-servicechargesallgointothecostsharingequation.Bydesign,eachcolortierhasitsown“actuarialvalue,”which
isanestimateoftheoverallfinancialprotectionprovidedbyahealthplanacrossastandardpopulationofbothhealthyandsickconsumers.Herearetheactuarialvaluesthateachcolortierisdesignedtomeet:–Bronze:60%–Silver:70%–Gold:80%–Platinum:90%Becausewe’retalking
averageshere,thepercentagelistedforeachcolortierdoesnotnecessarilyrepresenttheexactamountyourplanwillpayyouasanindividualenrollee.Rather,itrepresentswhatpercentagetheplanislikelytopayonaverageacrossalargegroupofpeople,bothhealthyandsick.
Ingeneral,though,it’ssafetosaythatthehigherthepercentage,themoreyourout-of-pocketmedical
expenseswillbecoveredoverthecourseofayear.Everythingfromdeductiblestoco-paystocoinsurancepercentageswillbeless.Ontheotherhand,you’llhavetopayupfrontforthosebenefitswithhighermonthlypremiums.
Ifyourincomefallswithin400%ofthefederalpovertylevel,youmaywanttoconsideroneofthehigher-levelplans(Silver,Gold,or
Platinum)becausetheymayrepresentabettervalueforyou.Theresultofallthosesubsidiesandcost-sharingreductionsisthatyougainaccesstoahigher-qualityplanthanyoumightotherwisebeabletoafford.
Asanextremeexample,ifyourincomefallswithin150%ofthepovertylevel,youcantakeadvantageofaPlatinumplanwithanactuarialvalueof94%once
allcostsharingmeasuresandsubsidieshavebeenfactoredin.Whatthatmeans,essentially,isthatyouhavetospendverylittlemoneytogetquitealotofcoverage.
NotethatplanswithineachcolortierwillnotbeexactlyidenticaltoeachotherbecausethereismorethanonewayforaSilverplan,say,toreachanactuarialvalueof70%.Oneplanmayofferahigherdeductiblebut
withlowercoinsurance,whileanothermighthavealowerdeductiblebuthighercoinsurance.Eachachievesthesameactuarialvalueindifferentways.Thisisactuallyagoodthingforconsumers,becauseitgivesthemmorechoiceinfindingtheplanthatbestfitstheirneeds.
HealthInsuranceExchanges
ByJanuary1,2014,eachstateisrequiredtohaveaHealthInsuranceExchangesetupthatwillallowyoutoeasilycomparehealthcarecoveragefromcompetingplansandselecttheonethatbestfitsyourneeds.Each
planwillprovidea“SummaryofBenefitsandCoverage”thatquicklyallowsyoutoseewhateachplanoffers.Onthefollowingpageisagenericexampleofthetypeofinformationthatwillbeprovidedonthefirstfewpagesoftheseplans.(Source:www.dol.gov/ebsa/pdf/SBCSampleCompleted.pdf.)
Withtheseoverviewsyoucanquicklyassessyourdeductibleandout-of-pocket
limitsandtellwhatavisittothedoctorwillcost,whatadiagnosticorimagingtestwillrun,whatgenericdrugswillcostascomparedtobrand-namedrugs,andwhatyourcoinsurancewillbeforoutpatientandhospitalstays.Theonlythingnotspecificallylistedisthemonthlypremium,andthatwillbeprovidedattheHealthInsuranceExchange’stoplevelbeforeyoureachthis
moredetailedinformation.
MedicalandDentalTourism
Thecostsofhealthanddentalcarecanberadicallyloweroverseas–somuchsothatevenafterfactoringintheexpenseoftransportationthereandback,itcanstillcostsignificantlylesstohaveaprocedureperformedabroadthanitwouldbetohavethesameprocedureperformedin
theU.S.Manywhohavereceived
medicaltreatmentabroadwriteglowingreportsabouttheirexperiencesandsaytheywishedtheyhaddiscoveredsuchoptionssooner.Whattheyfindmoreoftenthannotisn’tsomepoorcousinofAmericanhealthcare,butrathertop-notchmedicalfacilities,superblytrainedphysicianswithimpeccablecredentials,andstaffwho
speakclearEnglishandprovidealevelofpersonalserviceandcarethatwouldbehardtoduplicateintheU.S.duetostarkdifferencesincosts.
Ifyouliketheideaofworldtravelasmuchaswedo,thenreceivingatleastsomeofyourmedicalordentalcareabroadisanappealingoption.Forexample,we’vetakenadvantageofdentalcare
servicesandprescriptiondrugbargainsinAlgodones,Mexico(justacrosstheborderfromYuma,Arizona)andhaveonlygoodthingstosayabouttheexperience.Inthissectionwe’llsharesomeofourownexperiencesandpointyoutowardssomeofthebestcountriesintheworldwhenitcomestomedicaltourism.
MedicalTourism
andtheAffordableCareActEvenwiththeadventof
theAffordableCareAct,webelievemedicaltourismwillcontinuetothrivebyofferingdealsthataresimplytoogoodtopassup.Forexample,certainelectivesurgeriesatThailand’sBumrungradHospitalcostonlyone-tenthofwhattheydointheU.S.,andakneeorhipreplacement
inIndiamaystillrunyoulessthantheamountofyourannualout-of-pocketmaximumintheU.S.Aslongasthesekindsofdramaticcostdifferentialsexist,medicaltourismwillcontinuetoflourish.
The“MedicalTourism”website(medicaltourism.com)offersusefulcomparisoncostsforthesameproceduresindifferentcountries.While
costsareapproximate,theyarestillquiteaneye-opener,especiallywhenyourealizetheyalreadybuildintheestimatedexpenseofairfarefortwo.AnotherusefulwebsitewithdozensofhelpfullinksaboutmedicaltourismistheRetireEarlyLifestylewebsiterunbyearlyretireesBillyandAkaishaKaderli(retireearlylifestyle.com/medical_tourism).
Admittedly,mandatory
coverageundertheAffordableCareActdoesputsomethingofadamperonmedicaltourism,sinceU.S.citizensarealreadyinvestedtoacertainextentinthehealthcaresysteminthiscountry.Afterall,notonlyareyoupayingamonthlypremium,butyoumayalsohaveasubsidizedout-of-pocketlimitthateliminatesannualhealthcareexpensesbeyondacertainpoint.
Forexample,evenifaheartbypasssurgerycosts$15,000inThailandcomparedto$150,000intheU.S.–awholeorderofmagnitude’sdifference–U.S.citizensmightthinktwicebeforepayingthe$15,000inThailandsincetheirsubsidizedannualout-of-pocketlimitmightonlybe$7,500,say,intheU.S.Theyknowtheirinsurancewillcovertherestoftheamount,
sothereisnoincentiveforthemtoseektreatmentoverseassincetheirpersonalcostswouldactuallybehigher.
MedicaltouristsfromtheU.S.maythereforeendupmigratingtowardselectivesurgeriesandspecializedtreatmentsthataren’tcoveredbytheirinsuranceathome–thingslikecosmeticsurgery,dentalimplants,Lasiksurgery,in-depthwellness
exams,groundbreakingstemcelltherapies,andinnovativecancertreatmentsthataren’tyetcoveredbyU.S.insurance.
Wherevergapsincoverageexist,orwheneverprocedurescanbeperformedforlessthanout-of-pocketmaximums,medicaltourismwillcontinuetoofferaviablealternative.Anysurgerythatinvolvesalongwaitingperiodforwhateverreason
mightalsoofferstrongincentiveformedicaltourismtoplaceslikeIndia,Thailand,orMalaysiawherethesurgerycouldbeperformedalmostimmediately.
Earlyretireeslivingbeyondthe400%federalpovertylimitremainparticularlygoodcandidatesforcontinuedmedicalcareabroad.TheAffordableCareActdoesn’thelpthemasmuchasitdoestheirless
affluentbrethren.Theydon’treceivesubsidies,forexample,thatreducetheirannualout-of-pocketlimits.Thatmeanstheirout-of-pocketcostscouldbeashighas$6,250forindividualsor$12,500forfamilies,basedoncurrent-yearlimits.
Ifwell-offretireescanreceiveamedicalprocedureoverseasforsubstantiallylessthantheselimits,thentheyarelikelytoconsiderit.The
onlydownsideisthatthey’repayingamonthlypremiumforservicestheyaren’treallyutilizing,andthedollarsthatwouldhavegonetowardsmeetingtheirout-of-pocketlimitsfortheyearhavegonesomewhereelseinstead.
WhatAboutSimplyPayingthePenaltyTax?Someearlyretireesmay
bewonderingwhetheritmakessensetosimplypaythepenaltytaxandnothavehealthcareinAmerica,relyinginsteadsolelyonoverseascare.Whileworthpondering,it’snotasteptobetakenlightly.Speakingforourselves,wewouldbemorethanalittlenervousaboutlivingintheU.S.forasmanymonthsaswedowithnoupperlimitonourhealthcareexpenses.Whatifasudden
emergencyshouldhitandwecouldn’tgetoverseastoaddressit?Thenourhealthcarecostscouldquicklyskyrocket.
Toourminds,theonlywaysuchastepmightbeworthconsideringisifwealreadyspentthevastmajorityofourtimeoverseas.Otherwisetheapproachseemstoofraughtwithrisks.Abetteroptionmightbetopurchasethecheapest
Bronze-levelplanavailableandbalancethatwithoverseasmedicaltreatmentwhenappropriate.Alternatively,youcouldconsidertakingthenecessarystepstoestablishresidencyabroadinordertoavoidtheneedforU.S.healthcarealtogether.
WhichCountriesAreBest?
Somecountriesconsistentlymakethetoptenlistswhenitcomestomedicalanddentaltourism.HereisaquickrundownofthebestofthebestbasedonourrecentreviewoftoptenlistspostedbyInternationalLiving,Forbes,HealthyTimesBlog,BusinessPundit,MedicalTravelQualityAlliance,andmore:–Thailandisatornear
thetopofmostlists.BumrungradHospitaljustwestofBangkokhasbeencalledthecrownjewelofmedicaltourism.BangkokHospitalisanother.YoucanrecuperateafteryourprocedureononeofThailand’smanylovelybeaches.–Malaysiaisparticularlyfamousforits“wellman”and“wellwoman”
preventivecarepackagesthatincludeextensivephysicalsandabatteryoftestsatafractionofwesterncosts.Malaysiaalsohasitsshareofpristinebeaches.–SingaporeisathirdpowerhouseinSoutheastAsia,offeringsomeofthebesttreatmentcentersintheworld(e.g.,GleneaglesHospital)forseriousissues
rangingfromcardiologytooncologytostemcelltherapy.–Indiaisknownforhigh-qualitycardiacandorthopedicproceduresatlowcost.Medicalanddentaltourismarebothgrowingrapidlyhere.Bangalore’sFortisHospitalisrankedasoneofthebestsurgicalcentersintheworldformedical
travelers.–Mexicoistheultimateclose-to-homedestinationforAmericans.Convenienceandreasonablepricescombineforagreatsolutionwhenitcomestodental,vision,andprescriptiondrugservices,aswellasroutinephysicalsandtestsandcertainoperationssuchaskneeandhipreplacements.
–CostaRicaisanotherpopulardestinationforAmericans,withaparticularemphasisondentalcareandcosmeticsurgery.Itoffers“medicalspas”inasafe,convenient,English-speaking,andecologicallybeautifulcountry.–HungaryisaprimeEuropeandestinationespeciallywhenitcomes
todentaltourism.Germanshavebeencrossingtheborderforyearsforqualitydentalandmedicalcare.Dentalprocedurescancosthalfwhattheydoinmostwesterncountries.–Turkeymakesmosttop-tenlistsbecauseofitshighnumberofaccreditedmedicalfacilities,lowcost,andwestern-traineddoctorsfluentinEnglish.
TurkeyisespeciallyknownforeyetreatmentslikeLasiksurgeryandfordentalvacations.Theaboveeightcountries
makemosttop-tenlistsonaconsistentbasis,butthelasttwocountriestendtovaryquiteabit.SouthKoreaisonmanylistsasyetanotherSoutheastAsiancountryofferingstate-of-the-artmedicalservices,aswellas
thePhilippines.PanamafrequentlymakesthecutfordestinationsclosetotheU.S.,andGuatemalaisanup-and-comer.Braziliswellregardedforplasticsurgeryatalowprice,asisEgypt.AnothergoodoptionisSouthAfrica,whichofferstemptingmedicalsafaris.Israelmakessomelistsforitslow-costcancertreatmentcenters.OtherpopularEuropeandestinationsformedical
tourismincludePoland,theCzechRepublic,Lithuania,andSpain.
Asyoucansee,thelistofcountriesisextensive,andthesearefarfromtheonlyqualityoptionswhenitcomestoaffordablemedicalanddentalcareabroad.Usethislistasastartingpoint,butaquickweb-basedsearchwillrevealmanyotherfineoptions.
Ifyouliketheideaof
medicaltourismbutdon’tactuallywanttogoabroad,here’sonefinaloption:theSurgeryCenterofOklahoma.Thisstate-of-the-artmulti-specialtyfacilityoffersup-frontandbundled(all-inclusive)pricingpostedonlineforalltosee(surgerycenterok.com).Itintentionallyworksoutsidetheconfinesofthebighospital/insuranceenvironmentandstrivesfor
pricetransparencyandaffordability.Thosewithhighdeductiblesorhighout-of-pocketlimitsmayfindthisaviablealternativeandonemoregoodoptionworthconsidering.
DentalTourismTheextentofdental
coverageundertheAffordableCareActisstillsomethingofamystery.Ifitturnsoutsuchcoverageis
minimalornonexistentundermanyplans,thenaffordableoptionsabroadwillofferanimportantalternativeforearlyretirees.
Wheredentaltourismshinesmostbrightlyiswhenitcomestocostlyproceduressuchasrootcanals,crowns,implants,veneers,andbleaching.WecanspeaktothisissuepersonallysinceRobinrecentlyreceivedarootcanal,postandcore,and
porcelain-and-metalcrowninAlgodones,Mexicoforatotalpriceof$530.ThiscomparesquitewelltothetwoquoteswereceivedfromdentistsintheU.S.for$1,400and$1,850forthesameworkandmaterials.
Robin’sexperiencewassuchapositiveonethatIplantoreturntoherdentistinthenearfutureforanimplantandcrown.Thisprocedurewouldgenerallycost$3,000ormore
intheU.S.,whereaswereceivedaquoteof$1,200totalfromherdentistinAlgodones(withsomequotesbeinglowerthan$1,000).Nowofcourse,ifthequalityofserviceisn’thigh,thennoamountofcostsavingsisgoingtomakeupforit–butifyoucancombinehighqualitywithreasonablecost,thenyouhavesomethingworththinkingabout,andsuchisthecasehere.
AlgodonesisMexico’snorthernmosttown,anditcatersprimarilytoAmericanslookingforheavilydiscountedmedicalanddentalcareaswellasprescriptionsandeyeglasses.It’ssaidthatwithinafour-blockradiustherearemorepharmacies,doctors,dentists,andopticiansthananywhereelseintheworld.Whetherthat’strueornotwedon’tknow,butitcertainlyisa
happeninglittleplace,anditfeelsquitesafe.
Theoralsurgeon/endodontistwhoperformedRobin’srootcanal–Dr.GasparatSimplyDental–has32yearsofexperience,andRobinfeltthecareshereceivedwasbothprofessionalandattentive.Infactitwasoneoftheleastpainfulproceduresshehaseverexperienced.HerdentistspokebasicEnglish,buthis
nephewwhoisalsoanoralsurgeonspokeflawlessEnglish,andhewasonhandtoansweranyquestionsshemighthave.Thevisitincludedafreeexamandconsultwithfreedigitalx-rays.
LikemostdentalofficesinAlgodones,thewaitingareawassmall.InfactitwassomethingofashocktoourAmericansensibilitieswhenwefirstwalkedinthedoor
andsawhowsimpleandunpresumingitwas.Thatsaid,itdidhaveaKeurigcoffeemaker,bottledwater,andwifi,andthedentalequipmentitselfwasstate-of-the-art.Oursensewasthatnoextramoneywasbeingspentonimpressingus.Rather,asthename“SimplyDental”implied,thefocuswasonthequalityofthedentistryitself.
Robinsetupherappointmentatnocost
throughthewebsiteDentalDepartures(dentaldepartures.com).Thewebsitelistsdentistsfromcountriesallaroundtheworldandoffershelpfulpatientreviewsandpricelistsforeach.Robinchoseherdentistafterreadingastringofglowingfive-starreviews.ThepersonsheworkedwithatDentalDeparturesrespondedquicklytoheremailsandevenarrangedfor
hertospeakdirectlytoherdentistwhenshehadsomespecificquestions.
Ratherthandriveacrosstheborder(whichisopenfrom6amto10pmdaily),weparkedinahugeparkinglotontheU.S.sidefor$5perdayandsimplywalkedacross,whichiswhatmostpeopledo.(Formappingprograms,usethebordercrossingaddressof235AndradeRoad,Winterhaven,
CA92283.)Wehadplentyofcompanyduringourshortwalk.LiterallyhundredsofAmericans,mostofthemseniorsfromthesouthwesternU.S.,walkacrossthisborderpointeverydayforlow-costmedicalanddentalcare.
ThewalkacrosstheborderintoMexicoisacinch:wejuststrolledrightacross.However,thereisoftenawaittogetbackthroughU.S.Customs.Itcantakeanhour
ormoreduringthebusiesttimesofday(usually1-3pm),butwewentinthemorningandcamebackbeforenoonsotherewasonlyashortwait.Wesawsomepeopletakingbicyclerickshawsinordertoavoidthepedestrianline.OfcourseyoushouldalwaysbesuretohaveavalidU.S.passportwithyou.
VisionTourismand
PrescriptionDrugsRobinneededsome
antibioticsrelatedtoherdentistrywork,sowemadeaquickstopatThePurplePharmacyinAlgodones.Visitorshavetheirpickoffriendlyandefficientpharmaciestheycanvisitinthefour-blockarea.Staffareeagertoassistyou,andchalkboardsandhandwrittensignsprominentlydisplay
prescriptiondrugprices,makingiteasytocomparisonshop.
It’slegaltobringa90-daysupplyofmostantibioticsandotherprescriptiondrugsintotheU.S.,andCustomswillcheckyourpurchasesasyourecrosstheborder.It’shelpfultoknowthegenericnameofthemedicationandthedosageyouneedbeforearrivinginAlgodones.
Wehaven’tyetavailed
ourselvesofthevisionservicesofferedinAlgodones,butreportsfromothertravelerssuggestatypicaleyeexamrunsabout$10.Glassesstartat$100fortwopairsofsingle-visionglasseswithframes,andgoupfromthereto$100-$150perpairformoreexpensiveprogressivelenses.IfvisioncoverageturnsouttobeminimalornonexistentundertheAffordableCareAct,then
thisbecomesanothercompellinggapareainwhichearlyretireesmightwanttoseekcareabroad.
Judgingfromthenumberofvisitorstothislittletown,wearen’ttheonlyoneswhoenjoyfindingqualityhealthcareataffordableprices.EvenourcelebratorylunchoffishandshrimptacosafterRobin’sdentistappointmentwasaffordableanddelicious.Whichremindsus:don’t
forgetthe“tourism”partofmedicaltourism.Besuretomixinalittlefunalongtheway.Sure,therearepracticalaspectstoyourvisitabroad,butrememberthatoneofthemainbenefitsofmedicaltourismisgettingtodosomesightseeinginaplacethatperhapsyou’veneverbeentobefore.
Chapter17.ExtendedTravelinRetirementWeretiredearlyforone
mainreason:totravelmoreextensivelyandseetheworld.Oneofourgreatestjoyssince
retiringhasbeenhavingnotimelimitonhowlongwecanspendinanothercountryseeingthesightsandgettingtoknowadifferentculturefromtheinsideout.Weprefertravelingslowlyandonfootasmuchaspossible,stayinginacountryforweeksormonthsatatimewhenwecan,andthatsimplyisn’tfeasiblewithafull-timejob.Welovetohike,somostofourtripsincludehikingor
trekkinginoneformoranother,andweusuallychoosenaturalsceneryandsmalltownsoverbigcities.Ourpersonalwebsite,wherewebe.com,givesyouagoodideaofthekindoftravelweenjoythemost.
Overthepastsixyearswe’velearnedafairamountaboutlong-termtravelandhowitdiffersfromshort-termvacations.Extendedtravelrequiresadifferentmindset
thanyourtypicalweek-longgetaway.Inthisfinalchapterwe’dliketoshareafewsuggestionsabouthowyoucantravelmoreeconomicallyoverlongerperiodsoftimeshouldyouwishtodosoonceyouretire.
PickingAffordableDestinations
Choosingalow-costdestinationisthesinglemostimportantthingyoucandotokeepanextendedtripaffordable.Everything(otherthanairfare)becomeslessexpensiveifthedestinationisinexpensivetostartwith.
Lodging,diningout,groceries,transportation,guidedtours,entryfees,activityfees,incidentals–allofitismuchmorereasonableincountrieswhereyourdollargoesfurthertostartwith.
Ifyoupickyourdestinationwithcare,youcaneasilyliveonless–sometimessignificantlyless–thanyoucanintheU.S.InEcuador,forexample,wecouldbuyapplesandbananas
forfivecentseach,anhour-longbusridesetuseachbackadollar,andadoubleroomwithprivatebathranus$15to$20pernight.Lodgingsrentedbythemonthwerecheaperstill.Withpriceslikethese,youcanseewhyretireeswhocomeforavisitsometimesendupstayingforgood.
AnevenmoredramaticexampleisIndiaandNepal,wherewecouldliveverywell
indeedonverylittlemoney.Duringaone-monthhikeoftheAnnapurnaCircuitinNepal,westayedinteahousesforjust$4pernightforaprivateroomwithbath.Admittedlytheroomswererustic,but$4pernight?EvenwhenwestayedinKathmandu,thecapitalcity,astylishandconvenientlylocatedmidrangehotelwithalltheWesterncomfortsofhomeonlyranus$15per
night.FoodinbothIndiaandNepalwasalsoinexpensive,delicious,andplentiful.Wecouldessentiallyorderwhateverwewantedwithoutregardtoprice.
That’snottosaytherearen’tluxuryaccommodationsandexpensiverestaurantsintheseandotherlow-costcountries,becauseofcoursethereare.Youcanspendalotofmoneyeveninaninexpensive
countryifyoutryhardenough,butittakeslittleeffortonyourparttoliveandeatwellonlowsumsofmoneyindestinationssuchasthese.
Manytimeswhatyouremembermostabouttravelaretheadventuresandexperiencesyouhavealongtheway,andyoucanhavemoreofthemandatalowerpricewhenyouvisitalow-costdestination.Tocitejust
threeexamples,wewereabletorideandbatheelephantsinNepalfor$5,sailSuperman-styleonaziplineacrossalushcanyoninEcuadorfor$12,andraftdowntheYulongRiverinChinaonabambooraftfor$5whilesurroundedbyspectacularviewsoflimestonemountains.ConsiderwhatexperiencessimilartothesemighthavecostintheU.S.–thendoublethatagainto
determinewhattheymighthavecostinanexpensiveEuropeancountry.
Oftentheonlynoteworthyexpenseinvolvedinvisitingalow-costdestinationistheairfaretogetthereandback.That’sonereasonweliketostayforawhileoncewereachadistantdestination:itallowsustoamortizetheexpenseoftheairfareovermultiplemonths.(Italsojustifiesalltheefforttogetthere.)Once
you’vearrived,thelivingisactuallycheaperthanitisbackhome,sothere’snoparticularrush:youmightaswellsitback,relax,andenjoyyourselfforawhile.
Livingabroadisfranklymorefunwhenyoudon’tfeelcrimpedformoneyallthetime.WewouldencourageyoutolookbeyondtheobviousWesternEuropeancountriesandbroadenyourfocustoincludeplaceslike
SoutheastAsia,Mexico,CentralandSouthAmerica,andEasternEuropewhereyourdollarwillstretchfurtherandbuyyoumore.
SurvivingExpensiveDestinations
Themostobviousstrategyyoucanemploywhenvisitingexpensiveforeigncountriesissimplytostayforshorterperiodsoftime.Saveyourextendedtripsforcountrieswhereyourdollargoesfurther.Planshorter,more
intensivesightseeingtripstocountrieswherethedollarisworkingagainstyou.
Whenwevisitexpensivedestinations,wedothingsalittledifferentlythanwewouldotherwiseinordertokeepcostsdown.Weeatmoresimply,sleepmoresimply,andchooseouractivitieswithmorecare.Insomecasesweresearchandpre-booklodgingsaheadoftimesoweknowwhatwe’re
payingupfront.Webuygroceriesandcookourownmealsin,orelserelyonsimpletakeoutoptions.Andwestrategizeaheadoftimeabouthowtokeepourtransportationcostsdown.Forexample,inSwitzerlandwepurchasedhalf-farecardsgoodforamonthoftraintravelin-country,andinNewZealandweactuallyboughtausedcarthensolditbackagainfourmonthslater.
Wetrynottoskimponexperiences,however,becauseafterall,what’sthepointofvisitingaplaceifyouaren’treallygoingtoseeit?Amulti-dayvaporettopassisessential,forexample,ifyouwanttofreelyexplorethecanalsofVenice.Similarly,aone-weekcruiseoftheGalapagosIslandsaboardasmallyachtcanbeanintegralpartoftheexperienceofseeingthoseislandswell.
Bookingthetriplast-minuteandathalf-pricekeptcostsasreasonableaspossible,butthefinalpricetagwasstillunavoidablyhigh(andwortheverypennyinouropinion).
Youcan’talwayscutcornersanddoaplacejustice.ItwouldbeapitytomissoutondiningalfrescoinFranceorItaly,forinstance,wherefoodandwinearesuchanintegralpartofthepleasureofbeingthere.Likewiseit
wouldbeunfortunatetomissoutonathrillingadventurelikebungeejumpingorskydivinginaplacelikeQueenstown,NewZealand(“adrenalinecapitaloftheworld”)solelybecauseofprice.Thememoriesfromtheseexperienceslastalifetime,andyouonlyhavetopayforthemonce.
Sofarwe’vemanagedtostaywithinouryearlybudgetof$40,000evenwhenour
travelhastakenustoexpensivedestinationslikeSwitzerlandandtheGalapagos.Sometimesthathasmeantlivingmorefrugallytherestoftheyear,butweconsiderthatasmallpricetopayfortheprivilegeofgettingtovisitsuchunforgettableplaces.Thatsaid,thenexttimewevisitSwitzerland,wemaynotstayforquitesolong!
StayinginPlacevs.MovingAround
Oneimportantquestionyou’llhavetoanswerforyourselfisthis:doyouprefertobaseyourselfinoneplaceormovearoundalot?Ourowntripsoflatehavetypicallyinvolvedmovingeverythreeorfourdaysfrom
onetowntothenextaswecrisscrossacountryinordertoseeitwell.
Butnear-constantmovementhasitsprice.Ourexpensesarehigherthantheywouldbeotherwisebecausewe’repayingnotonlyfortransportationbutalsoforlodgingonaper-nightbasis.Ontheotherhand,wegettoseemoreofacountrythatway,andsometimesthatoutweighsthecostissuesfor
us.Withoutquestion,staying
inoneplaceforamonthatatimeorlongercanbemorecost-effective.WerentedaroominPuertoVaras,Chile,forexample,forlessthan$250forthemonth–andPuertoVarasisarelativelyexpensivetouristtownbyChileanstandards.
Togetalowmonthlyrate,it’sbestnottobookaheadoftimefromtheU.S.
Instead,simplyshowupinthetownorcityofyourchoosingandstayatahostelforafewdayswhilescopingoutlonger-termrentalpossibilities.Manyrentalsonlyadvertiselocallywithasigninthewindoworanoticeonabulletinboard.That’swhywesuggestyouwaituntilyouarriveintownbeforemakinglong-termarrangements.Thatwayyoucanseearentalwithyour
owneyesbeforedecidingifit’srightforyou.
Negotiatinginpersoncanalsoincreaseyourbargainingpower.Manyownerswillagreetoadiscountforstaysofamonthorlonger,especiallyifyouoffercashupfront.Iftheroomisobviouslysittingemptyandyou’restandingrightthereinfrontofthemwithcashinhand,they’remorelikelytoacceptalowerprice.
Stayingputoffersamorerelaxingwayoftravelingforanextendedperiodoftime.DuringourstayinPuertoVaras,forexample,wewentonexcursionstosurroundingtownsandthenearbyislandofChiloe.WetookSpanishlessonsatatinyschoolacrossthestreet,andwetradedinformalEnglish-for-Spanishlessonswithlocalfriendswemadeintown.Makingfriendsiseasierwhenyoustayput
forawhile,andtakinglanguagelessonsorcookingclassesorlessonsinanysortofregionalspecialtycanbeagreatwaytogettoknowthelocalsandfellowtravelersalike.
DiscoveringYourOwnApproachtoTravel
Knowingwhatmakesyougenuinelyhappyhelpsyoudetermineyourownapproachtotravel.Ifwhatyoureallyloveisstayinginluxuryhotels,there’snopointin
kiddingyourselfandpretendingyoulikehostels.Iffive-starresortswithbeachsideservice,spatreatments,andgolfaremoreyourspeed,you’llsimplyhavetofactorinthehighercostsofstayinginsuchplaces.Perhapsyou’lldecidetotravelforshorterperiodsoftimebutreallypamperyourselfwhenyoudogo.
Ontheotherhand,ifyou’recomfortablestayingin
simplerdigsandliketowalkaroundandexploreonyourown,thenyoucanaffordtostaymuchlongerinthecountryofyourchoosing.Perhapsyou’llimmerseyourselfinthelocalcultureandbeginpickingupthelanguage.Orperhapsyou’llfocusonseeingeverysightyoucanwhileyou’rein-country,aswetendtodo.Ormaybeyou’lljustkickbackandrelaxandsoakitallin.
Afterall,it’syourtrip:youcanbeasbusyoraslaid-backasyoulike.
Therearesomanyvariablestotravelthatit'shardtogeneralize,butifthequestionis,canyoutraveloverseasaffordably,theanswerisdefinitelyyes.Pickingyourdestinationwithcareisthenumberonethingyoucandotoloweryourcosts,andthesecondmostimportantthingistochoose
yourlodgingswithcare,whichiswhatwe’lldiscussnext.
StayinginHostels
Whenitcomestolodgingsonaper-nightbasis,wethinkhostelsofferthebestvalueforyourmoney.Hostelscatertoallagesthesedays.Youngertravelerstendtobetheirprimarymarket,butaslongasyou’reyoungatheartyou’llfitrightin.Theaccommodationsareusually
(butnotalways)onthebasicside,sohostelsarenotforeveryone,butifyoudreamofseeingtheworldonabudgetwhilemeetingfriendlypeopleandstayingintheoppositeofcookie-cutteraccommodations,hostelsjustmightbearightanswerforyou.
Sharedkitchensmakehostelsagreatoptionifyou’retryingtokeepcostsdown,andfreewifiaccessis
almostagiventhesedays.Wealwayslookforhostelsofferingdoublerooms(preferablywithprivatebath)andnotjustdormrooms.Weprefertheprivacyandsecurityofhavingourownroom.
Youcanpickupusefultraveltipsfromfellowtravelersathostels,andeachplaceyoustaywillbedifferentfromthenext.Togetanideaofjusthow
memorablesomehostelstayscanbe,checkoutthewebsitesforHopewellBackpackersinMarlboroughSound,NewZealand(hopewell.co.nz)andPalafitoHostelinChiloe,Chile(palafitohostel.com).
Websiteslikehostelworld.comandbbh.co.nz(specifictoNewZealand)assignapercentagerankingtoeachhostelbasedonthereviewsofpeoplewho
havestayedthere,soyoucanquicklyidentifythebesthostelsinaparticulararea.Pricesarelistedforeachtypeofroom.Thesewebsitesallowyoutomakeanonlinebookingafewdaysinadvance,whichcanbeawiseideaifyou’retravelinginhighseason.
TravelingIndependently
Thelongerthetripyou’replanning,themoreimportantitbecomestotravelindependently–thatis,withoutaguideoraspartofatourgroup.Beingonyourownsignificantlyreducesthecostofthetrip,butperhapsequallyimportantly,itchangesthewholetenorof
theexperience.Travelbecomesmoreof
anadventureandlessofasetpiecewhenyoumakeyourowndecisionsaboutlodging,food,andactivities.Yougettodetermineyourownpaceanditineraryratherthanturningthosedecisionsovertoanother.You’realsomorelikelytohavegenuineencounterswithlocalresidentsifyoutravelindependently.You’llstrike
upconversationsonbusesandtrains,orwhenyou’reeatingatsmallcafesnotfrequentedbytourgroups,orwhenyou’restayingatlodgingsnotspecificallyaimedat(andpricedfor)foreigners.
Independenttravelcanbecomeaddictiveonceyougetusedtoit.Itcanbehardtogobacktohavingsomeonetellyouwhattodo,whattosee,howlongtoseeitfor,
andwhattimeofdaytogo(oftenatmidday,itseems,whencrowdsareattheirworst).
Admittedlyguidedtripsmakesenseundercertaincircumstances.Ifyou’reafemaletravelingalone,forexample,oriflogisticalorlanguageissuesmakeplanningaparticulartripmoreintimidatingthanusual,thenaguidedexcursionmightbetherightanswer.
Butwewouldencourageyoutoweanyourselffromonlytravelinginsuchafashion,asitcandramaticallyincreaseyourcostswhilediminishingyourfreedomtoexplore.
ResearchingYourTrip
Travelingindependentlymeansdoingyourownresearchbeforehandorasyougoalong.Ithelpstohaveatleastaroughideaaheadoftimeofwhereyouwanttogoandwhatyou’dliketosee.
Togetaninitialsenseofacountry,weenjoyFrommer’sfreeonlinetravelguides,
whichcoverjustabouteverydestinationunderthesun.Theirintroductorylistsoffavoriteexperiencesandtheirreviewsofkeysightsarehighlyreadable.However,theirlodginganddininginformationtendstobefocusedonthepricierendofthespectrum.
WeusuallyendupbuyingaLonelyPlanetguidebookforeachcountrywevisit,inpartfortheattentionthey
givetoeconomicallodginganddiningoptions,butmoreimportantlyfortheirexceptionalregionalandcitymaps.Wecutoutonlythepagesweneedandstaplethemtogetherforaparticularcityorregionsowecanbringjustthosepagesalongwithusonanyparticulardayofexploring.
We’vecometorelymoreandmoreonsiteslikeTripAdvisorforideasonthebest
thingstodoandthebestplacestostayinaparticularlocation.Thereviewsofhundredsofindividualtravelers,takenasawholeandthenranked,seemtoprovidemoreconsistentlysatisfyingandup-to-dateresultsforactivities,lodging,anddiningthananysingleguidebookcan.Individualreviewersarealsomoreapttocommentonthenegativeaspectsofaparticularoption,
givingyouamorecompletepicturethanyoumightgetotherwisefromaterselywordedguidebookdescription.
ManagingYourFinancesOverseas
Animportantpracticalconsiderationbeforeyourfirstextendedtripishowtomanageyourfinanceswhileoverseas.Fortunatelythishasbecomemucheasiernowthatelectronicbillpayingissocommonplace.Wepaymost
ofourbillsautomaticallythroughourcreditcard,andtherestarepaidthroughautomaticdeductionsfromourcheckingaccount.It’seasytosettheseupbyvisitingthewebsiteforeachofyourserviceprovidersandupdatingyouraccountinformationtoallowforautomaticmonthlypayments.Werecommendyoudothisafewmonthsinadvanceofyourtripsoyoucanmake
sureeverythingisworkingproperlybeforeyouleave.
Yourbank’sonlinebillpayservicecanalsobeausefulfeatureincaseyouhavetomakeanunexpectedpaymentfromtheothersideoftheworld.
UsingATMsOverseasWhenoverseaswerely
primarilyonATMsforcash.
Wepayabankfeeeachtimewewithdrawmoney(typically$5),whichcanbeannoying,butit’scheaperthanmostotheroptions.WeusuallywithdrawthemaximumamounttheATMwillallowinordertominimizethesecharges.Insomecountriesthemaximumamountssetbybankscanbefrustratinglylow,soweendupsearchingaroundforATMswithahigherlimitthat
alsohappentobecompatiblewiththePLUSsystemourcardutilizes.
MakesureyourATMwithdrawallimitsaresetsufficientlyhighbyyourownbank.ThisisespeciallyimportantifyouarevisitingacountrywherethelocalcurrencyisstrongerthantheU.S.dollar.Ifyou’remarried,itmakessensetocarryasecondcardinyourspouse’snamesoyoucandouble-dip
fromthesameaccountwhenneeded.
ATMstypicallyprovideyouwithlocalcurrency,soyoudon’thavetoworryaboutcurrencyexchange,butyoumightneedtovisitalocalbanknowandagaintoobtainsmallerbills.
UsingCreditCardsOverseasInfirst-worldcountries
weoftenrelyonourcreditcardinsteadofcashwhenmakingpurchases.Wepaya1%feeforeachinternationalpurchase,whichisn’ttoobad.Checkwithyourcreditcardcompanytoseewhatrateyouhavetopayforinternationalpurchases.Somecardshaveratesashighas3%,whichistoohighinouropinionifyou’replanningonstayingoverseasforanextendedperiodoftime.Ifyour
percentageistoohigh,considerapplyingforacreditcardwithnointernationalpurchasefeeandusingitspecificallyfortravelsabroad.
It'sagoodideatocarryabackupcreditcardfromacompletelydifferentfinancialinstitutionincasethefirstonegetslost,stolen,orinvalidated.Morethanonceourcreditcardhasbeencanceledwhilewewere
travelingoverseasduetoacompromisedbatchofcreditcardnumbershavingbeenstolenfromonestoreoranotherbackintheStates.AnothercardwasimmediatelyreissuedandmailedtoourhomeaddressintheU.S.,butthatdiduslittlegoodsincewewerestillabroad.Nowwe’velearnedourlessonandalwayscarryabackupcard.
DownsizingforLifeontheRoad
Whenyou’replanningforamobilelifeontheroad,youwanttodoallyoucantodownsizeyourelectronicsandotherpossessionssoyoucanpackaslightlyaspossible.Ifyouplantotravelwithalaptopcomputer,besuretogetalightweightandcompactone.Apocketsize
CanonPowerShotcamerawithachargerandextrabatterygivesusallweneedfortakingqualityphotos.WealsobringiPodShufflesformusicandatinyhandheldmicrophoneandearbudsforSkyping.WerelyprimarilyonemailandSkypetostayintouchwithfamilyandfriendswhentraveling.
AsmallPacSafemesh-linedbagletsuslockuppassportsandothersensitive
documentswhilewe’reawayfromourroom,andasimplelockingcablehelpskeepourlaptopsafe.
Asmalldaypackholdsallourelectronicsandincidentalsandfitsinsideourlargerbagwhenwewalkfrompointtopoint.Whenwegettothebusortaxi,wecanpulloutthedaypackfilledwiththeelectronics,passports,andotherthingswereallycareaboutandkeepit
closeathand,whileallowingourbiggerbagsfilledwithclothestobestoredworry-freeinthevehicle’soutercompartmentortrunk.
WeuseRickStevesconvertiblecarry-onbagsthatconvertintobackpacksfornearlyallofourtrips,andweswearbythem.Ifyoucancomfortablyfitallyourbelongingsintooneofthesebags,thenyou’redoingquitewellpacking-wise.Ifthebag
isburstingattheseams,thenyou’reprobablybringingtoomuchandshouldtrytolightenupabit.
Everyexperiencedtravelerwilltellyouthesamething:lessismore.You’llenjoyyourselfmoreifyouaren’tburdeneddownlikeapackanimal.Trydressinginlayers,andlimityourbulkyouterlayersasmuchaspossible.Youcanalwaysbuyanextrasweaterontheroad
ifneeded.Qualityraingearthat
packsintoitsownpocketisalwaysworthhaving.Thatplusalightweightfleecejacketgoesalongwaytowardskeepingyouwarmininclementweather.
ForwardingPhysicalMail
Asfarasphysicalmailgoes,we’vefoundthemaximumtimepermittedforholdingmailatthelocalpostofficeisthirtydays.Thatusuallyisn’tenoughtimeforus,soinsteadwetemporarilyforwardourmailtoarelative’saddress.Youcansetthisuponlineatusps.com,
specifyingthetemporaryaddressandthestartandenddates.Themaximuminitiallengthoftimefortemporaryforwardingissixmonths,butyoucanrenewforanothersixmonthsifneeded.Notethatyou’llhavetoenteracreditcardnumberforverificationpurposeswhenyouusethisonlineservice,andthereisa$1chargetoyourcard.Savetheconfirmationemailsenttoyousoyoucanextendor
canceltheforwardingorderasneeded.
UsingSeasonalDisconnects
Weuseaseasonaldisconnectserviceforbothcableandinternettoreducecostswhenwe’reawayforanextendedperiodoftime.ForourservicewithComcast,thedisconnecthastobebetween3and6monthsinduration,andyoustillmustpay$11perservicepermontheven
thoughyouaren’tusingit.Atpresentyouhavetomakeaphonecalltosetuptheseasonaldisconnect;thereisnoonlineoption.
Yourservicerestartsautomaticallyonthedateyouset,orelseyoucancallifyougetbacksoonerthanexpectedtostartitupagain.Thereisnofeetodisconnectorreconnecttheservice.
BecomingaPerpetualTraveler
IfyouplantobeaperpetualtraveleroranRVerwithoutapermanenthomeaddress,considermakingastatewithnoincometaxyourofficialresidence.Youmustcallsomewherehome,soyoumightaswellpickastatethat
doesn’ttaxyoufortheprivilegeofnotbeingthere.
Wetriedthisapproachourselvesforaperiodoftwoyears.AftersellingourhomeinColorado,weheadedoffonaneight-monthroadtripthroughtheU.S.,travelinginaconversionvanwithabedintheback.WealsotraveledoverseasforextendedperiodsoftimetoplaceslikeArgentinaandChile.Duringthesetwoyearswelisted
SouthDakotaasourhomeaddress.SouthDakotahasnostateincometax,nordoesitrequireyearlyvehicleinspectionsoremissionstests.
MyDakotaAddress(mydakotaaddress.com)isaparticularlyusefulserviceforperpetualtravelers.TheycanhelpyouregisteryourvehicleandgetyousetupasaresidentofSouthDakota.You’llneedtotakeaneyeexaminpersontoobtaina
SouthDakotadriver’slicense,butnotmuchelseisrequired.
MyDakotaAddressforwardsyourphysicalmailonaweeklyormonthlybasisforareasonablefee,providesyouwithaphysicaladdressthatdoesn’tappearasaP.O.box(usefulwhenfillingoutforms),andgenerallymakesyourperpetualtravelinglifeeasier.Ifweeverdecidetosellourcondoandrecommit
tothenomadiclifestyle,we’llprobablymakeSouthDakotaourhomeaddressonceagainandusethissameservice.
Forthoseofourreaderswhohavemadeitthisfar,wewanttowishyoueverysuccessduringyourownjourney.Achievingearlyretirementisinmanywaysonlythebeginning:fromtherethedoorsopenwideandtheworldisyourstoexplore.Here’shopingourpathsmay
crossonedayinsomefar-offcorneroftheworld!
AppendixA.DetailedSalaryandInvestmentInformation
AppendixB.CreatingYourOwnInvestmentSpreadsheetIfyouwouldpreferto
createyourowninvestment
spreadsheetfromscratchratherthandownloadingthetemplateonourwebpage(wherewebe.com),weprovidedetailedinstructionshere.Theseinstructionsmayalsobeusefulforthoseofyouwhodownloadedthespreadsheetbutaren’tfamiliarwithaprogramlikeExcelandneedabitmorehelp.
Whencreatingyourownspreadsheetfromscratch,be
suretouseaspreadsheetprogramlikeMicrosoftExcelthatcanautomaticallyaddcolumnsofdata,applysimpleformulastocalculateannualratesofreturn,andaddtogetherresultsfromonecolumntothenext.Thatwillallowyoutotweakthespreadsheettoplaywithdifferentinvestmentscenarios.Youcanmakechangesandinstantlyseetheresultstothebottomline.
AsampleinvestmentspreadsheetisprovidedinChapter10.Youmaywanttohavealookatthatfirsttogetanoverviewofwhatthespreadsheetlookslikeintermsofcolumnsizesandlayout.Wechosetousealandscaped11”x17”papersizetogiveourselvesplentyofroomtoworkwith,butthespreadsheetcanalsofitonalandscaped8½”x11”sheetofpaper.
Nowlet’shavealookateachcolumninthespreadsheetandseewhat’sinvolvedinreproducingit.Forcellsthatcontainformulas,we’veuseditalicstoidentifythespecificExcelformulathatneedstobeaddedtoeachcellinthecolumn.Noneoftheformulasareparticularlycomplicated.
TaxableColumnsColumnA–Year:
Manuallyentertheyearsasnecessary.Toeditthem,simplyclickonthecell,typeinthecorrectinformation,andhitenter.Youcandeleterowsatthebottomofthespreadsheettocreatea15-yearplan.(Besuretoselecttheentirerowbyclickingontherownumbertotheleftthenhittingdelete.)Ifyouwanta25-yearplan,youcancopyandpasteexistingrowstoaddmoreyears(again,be
suretoselecttheentirerows).ColumnB–Amount
Invested:Manuallyentertheamountyouplantoinvestperyearinyourtaxableaccount(i.e.,anymoneyyou’resettingasideforusebeforeyouturnage59½).Youcantryoutalternatesavingsscenariosbyenteringdifferentnumbersandseeinghowthetotalschange.
ColumnC–PlusPrev.YearTotal:Thiscolumn
automaticallyaddsthe“TotalTaxable”(ColumnE)amountfromlastyeartothe“AmountInvested”(ColumnB)thisyear.TheformulaincellC6forexample(whichshows$2,000inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=E5+B6.
ColumnD–Annual%Return:ThiscolumnautomaticallycalculatestheannualreturngeneratedfromtheamountinColumnC.Youcanchangethe
percentagebyenteringthecell(double-clickonit)andchangingthenumber–forexample,fromthedefault0.09(for9%)to0.08(for8%)or0.1(for10%)oranyotherpercentageyouwishtoexperimentwith.Youcanthencopyandpastethiscelltoallotherapplicablecellsbelowit.TheformulaincellD6forexample(whichshows$180inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=C6*0.09.
ColumnE–TotalTaxable:ThiscolumnautomaticallyaddstheamountsinColumnsCandDtogiveyourtotaltaxableamountfortheyear.TheformulaincellE6forexample(whichshows$2,180inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=C6+D6.
ColumnFisablankcolumnforspacing.
401(k)Columns
ColumnG–AmountInvested:Manuallyentertheamountyouplantoinvestperyearinyour401(k).Youcantryoutvariousscenariosbyenteringdifferentnumbersandseeingtheresults.
ColumnH–Match:Automaticallycalculatesa401(k)matchforyou.Thedefaultissetto50%oftheamountinColumnG.Thepercentagecanbechangedtobringitinlinewiththe
particularsofyour401(k)plan.Double-clickonthefirstcellyouwouldliketoupdateandchangethepercentage–forexample,from“0.5”(50%)to“1.0”(100%).Youcanthencopyandpastethiscelltoallotherapplicablecellsbelowit.TheformulaincellH6forexample(whichshows$2,000inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=G6*0.5.
ColumnI–PlusPrev.YearTotal:Automatically
addsthe“Total401(k)”(ColumnK)amountfromlastyeartothe“AmountInvested”(ColumnG)and“Match”(ColumnH)forthisyear.TheformulaincellI6forexample(whichshows$6,000inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=K5+G6+H6.
ColumnJ–Annual%Return:Automaticallycalculatestheannualreturngeneratedfromtheamountin
ColumnI.(SeeColumnDinstructionsforchangingthepercentagerate.)TheformulaincellJ6forexample(whichshows$540inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=I6*0.09.
ColumnK–Total401(k):AutomaticallyaddstheamountsinColumnsIandJtogiveyouyourtotal401(k)amountfortheyear.TheformulaincellK6forexample(whichshows$6,540inthesamplespreadsheet)is:
=I6+J6.ColumnLisablank
columnforspacing.
RothIRAColumnsColumnM–Amount
Invested:ManuallyentertheamountyouplantoinvestperyearinyourRothIRA.Aswiththeothershadedcolumnsinthespreadsheet,youcantryoutdifferentscenariosbyenteringdifferentnumbersandseeing
theresults.ColumnN–PlusPrev.
YearTotal:Automaticallyaddsthe“TotalRothIRA”(ColumnP)amountfromlastyeartothe“AmountInvested”(ColumnM)forthisyear.TheformulaincellN6forexample(whichshows$4,000inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=P5+M6.
ColumnO–Annual%Return:Automaticallycalculatestheannualreturn
generatedfromtheamountinColumnN.(SeeColumnDaboveforinstructionsonchangingthepercentagerate.)TheformulaincellO6forexample(whichshows$360inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=N6*0.09.
ColumnP–TotalRothIRA:AutomaticallyaddstheamountsinColumnsNandOtogiveyouyourtotalRothIRAamountfortheyear.TheformulaincellP6for
example(whichshows$4,360inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=N6+O6.
ColumnQisablankcolumnforspacing.
GrandTotalColumnColumnR–Grand
Total:AutomaticallyaddstheamountsinColumnsE,K,andP(i.e.,thetotalsfortaxable,401(k),andRothIRA)togiveyouthegrandtotalfortheyear.Theformula
incellR6forexample(whichshows$13,080inthesamplespreadsheet)is:=E6+K6+P6.