hidden victims of a u.s. war - the new york times

1
North Vietnamese Army to infiltrate troops into the South. In one of the bamboo-and-thatch stilt houses, the ladder to the living quarters was made from metal tubes that for- merly held American cluster bombs. The family had a 4-year-old boy named Suk, who had difficulty sitting, standing and walking — one of three children in the extended family with birth defects. A cousin was born mute and did not learn to walk until he was 7. A third child, a girl, died at the age of 2. “That one could not sit up,” their great-uncle said. “The whole body was soft, as if there were no bones.” The women added Suk to the list of people with disabilities they have com- piled on their intermittent treks through Laos’s sparsely populated border dis- tricts. Hammond, Chagnon and Sengthong make up the core of an organization It was a blazing-hot morning in October 2019 on the old Ho Chi Minh Trail, an in- tricate web of truck roads and secret paths that wove its way across the densely forested and mountainous bor- der between Vietnam and Laos. Susan Hammond, Jacquelyn Chagnon and Niphaphone Sengthong forded a rocky stream along the trail and came to a village of about 400 people called Labeng-Khok, once the site of a logistics base inside Laos used by the called the War Legacies Project. Ham- mond, whose father was a military offi- cer in the war in Vietnam, founded the group in 2008. Chagnon was one of the first foreigners allowed to work in Laos after the conflict, with the American Friends Service Committee. Sengthong, a retired schoolteacher, is responsible for the record-keeping and local coordi- nation. The focus of the War Legacies Project is to document the long-term effects of the defoliant known as Agent Orange. Named for the colored stripe painted on its barrels, Agent Orange — known for its use by the U.S. military to clear vege- tation during the Vietnam War — is no- torious for being laced with 2,3,7,8-Tet- rachlorodibenzo-P-dioxin, or TCDD, re- garded as one of the most toxic sub- stances ever created. The use of the herbicide in the neutral nation of Laos by the United States re- mains one of the last untold stories of the American war in Southeast Asia. When the Air Force in 1982 released its official history of the defoliation cam- paign, Operation Ranch Hand, the three pages on Laos attracted almost no at- tention, other than a statement from Gen. William Westmoreland, a former U.S. commander, that he knew nothing about it — although it was he who had ordered it. In the last two decades the United States has finally taken responsibility for the legacy of Agent Orange in Viet- nam. But Laos has remained a forgotten footnote to a lost war. While records of spraying operations inside Laos exist, the extent to which the U.S. military broke international agree- ments has never been fully docu- mented, until now. An in-depth review of Air Force LAOS, PAGE 6 PHOTOGRAPHS BY CHRISTOPHER ANDERSON Clockwise from top left: Bounta, Khao, Yenly, Choi, Nan and Bouam. They suffer from congenital defects linked to herbicides that were sprayed in Laos during the Vietnam War. Hidden victims of a U.S. war FROM THE MAGAZINE The toll of Agent Orange in Laos is an untold story of the Vietnam conflict BY GEORGE BLACK Sunny, driven and with a new engineer- ing master’s degree in hand, Joshua Morgan was hopeful that he could find a job despite the pandemic, move out of his mother’s house and begin his life. But as lockdowns in Britain dragged on and no job emerged, the young man grew cynical and self-conscious, his sis- ter Yasmin said. Mr. Morgan felt he could not get a public-facing job, like working at a grocery store, because his mother, Joanna, had open-heart surgery last year and Mr. Morgan was “excep- tionally careful” about her health. He and his mother contracted the co- ronavirus in January, forcing them to quarantine in their small London apart- ment for over two weeks. Concerned by things he was saying, friends raised the alarm and referred him to mental health services. But days before the end of his quaran- tine last month, Mr. Morgan, 25, took his own life. “He just sounded so deflated,” his sister said of their last conversation, adding that he said he felt imprisoned and longed to go outside. Suicides are challenging to link to spe- cific reasons, but Mr. Morgan’s sudden death has left his sister with a feeling that is hard to shake. “The cost of the pandemic was my brother’s life,” she said. “It’s not just people dying in a hos- pital — it’s people dying inside.” More than 2.7 million people have died from the coronavirus — nearly 127,000 in Britain alone. Those numbers are a tangible count of the pandemic’s cost. But as more people are vaccinated and communities open up, there is a tally that experts say is harder to track: the psychological toll of months of isola- tion and global suffering, which for some has proved fatal. There are some signs indicating a widespread mental health crisis. Japan recorded a spike in suicide among wom- en last year, and in Europe, mental health experts have reported a rise in the number of young people expressing suicidal thoughts. In the United States, many emergency rooms have faced surges in admissions of young children and teenagers with mental health is- sues. Mental health experts say prolonged symptoms of depression and anxiety may prompt risky behaviors that lead to self-harm, accidents, or even death, es- SUICIDES, PAGE 4 Suicides hint at the painful cost of isolation LONDON Issues of mental health may be hard to pin down, but signs of a crisis grow BY ELIAN PELTIER AND ISABELLA KWAI .. INTERNATIONAL EDITION | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 31, 2021 NOT A ‘TIGRESS’ A GOLF PRODIGY ON WOODS’S PATH PAGE 15 | SPORTS GARDEN PLAN GROWING ROSES THE SMART WAY PAGE 19 | LIVING NEARING EXTINCTION THE DECLINE OF AFRICA’S FOREST ELEPHANTS PAGE 9 | SCIENCE On the edge of a vast park in Tehran sits a Neo-Brutalist structure the color of sand. Inside is one of the finest col- lections of modern Western art in the world. You enter the Tehran Museum of Con- temporary Art through an atrium that spirals downward like an inverted ver- sion of Frank Lloyd Wright’s Guggen- heim Museum in New York. Photos of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the fa- ther of Iran’s 1979 revolution, and Aya- tollah Ali Khamenei, who succeeded him as the Islamic Republic’s supreme leader, glare down at you. A series of underground galleries awaits. There is nothing quite like the feeling of coming face-to-face for the first time with its most sensational mas- terpiece: Jackson Pollock’s 1950 “Mural on Indian Red Ground,” a 6-foot-by-8- foot canvas that was created with rusty reds and layered swirls of thick, dripped paint and is considered one of his best works from his most important period. Monet, Pissarro, Toulouse-Lautrec, Degas, Renoir, Gauguin, Matisse, Cha- gall, Klee, Whistler, Rodin, van Gogh, Pi- casso, Braque, Kandinsky, Magritte, Dalí, Miró, Johns, Warhol, Hockney, Lichtenstein, Bacon, Duchamp, Rothko, Man Ray — they are all here. The museum was conceived by the Empress Farah Diba Pahlavi, wife of Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi, and opened to international acclaim in 1977. Just 15 months later, in the face of a widespread popular uprising, the couple left the country on what was officially called a “vacation.” The revolution re- placed the monarchy with an Islamic Republic weeks later. The new regime could have sold or de- stroyed the Western art masterpieces. Instead, the museum was closed, its treasures hidden in a concrete base- ment, and the shah’s palaces were pre- TEHRAN, PAGE 2 An American, an empress and a trove of art Farah Diba Pahlavi, left, the empress of Iran, and Donna Stein, a curator, in 1977. Stein feels robbed of the credit she said she deserves for her work at a modern art museum. JILA DEJAM Just before its revolution, Iran built an impressive museum. It’s still there. BY ELAINE SCIOLINO The New York Times publishes opinion from a wide range of perspectives in hopes of promoting constructive debate about consequential questions. In the First Cold War, the United States and its allies had a secret weapon against the Soviet Union and its satel- lites. It didn’t come from the C.I.A. Nor was it a product of DARPA or the weapons labs at Los Alamos. It was Communism. Communism aided the West because it saddled an imperialist Russian state with an unworkable and unpopular economic system that could not keep up with its free-market competitors. “They pretend to pay us and we pre- tend to work” — the quintessential Russian joke about working life in the workers’ paradise — goes far to explain why a regime with tens of thousands of nuclear warheads simply petered out. Now we are enter- ing the Second Cold War, this time with China. That’s the takeaway from this month’s U.S.-China summit in Anchorage, in which both sides made clear that they had not only clashing interests but also incom- patible values. Secretary of State Antony Blinken bluntly accused China of threatening “the rules-based order that maintains global stability.” Yang Jiechi, his Chinese counterpart, replied that the U.S. had to “stop advancing its own democracy in the rest of the world.” A few days later, China and Iran signed a 25-year, $400 billion strategic pact, including provisions for joint weapons development and intelligence sharing. As challenges to the U.S.-led “rules-based order” go, it’s hard to get more frontal than that. Maybe things will get better. But it would be foolish to count on it, much less suppose that conciliatory behavior by the Biden administration will do anything other than embolden Beijing. Say what you will about either the Trump or the Obama administrations, but they did not provoke China to crush democracy in Hong Kong, or brutalize Uyghurs in Xinjiang, or vio- late international law in the South China Sea, or help North Korea sub- vert international sanctions, or use military force to bully its neighbors, or undertake campaigns of cyberwarfare and industrial espionage against Strategizing in a Second Cold War OPINION President Biden has a chance to turn China’s strengths into weaknesses. STEPHENS, PAGE 13 Bret Stephens A TERRIFYING SIDE EFFECT Doctors report paranoia and other psychotic symptoms in patients who have recovered from Covid-19. PAGE 9 The weekend paper that gets to the point. Award-winning news, opinion, lifestyle, culture and more. In one concise paper. Pick up the Weekend Edition. Y(1J85IC*KKOKKR( +@!"!$!#!@ Issue Number No. 42,934 Andorra € 5.00 Antilles € 4.50 Austria € 4.00 Belgium € 4.00 Bos. & Herz. KM 5.80 Britain £ 2.60 Cameroon CFA 3000 Croatia KN 24.00 Cyprus € 3.40 Czech Rep CZK 115 Denmark Dkr 37 Estonia € 4.00 Finland € 4.00 France € 4.00 Gabon CFA 3000 Germany € 4.00 Greece € 3.40 Hungary HUF 1100 Israel NIS 14.00/ Friday 27.50 Israel / Eilat NIS 12.00/ Friday 23.50 Italy € 3.80 Ivory Coast CFA 3000 Sweden Skr 50 Switzerland CHF 5.20 Syria US$ 3.00 The Netherlands € 4.00 Tunisia Din 8.00 Turkey TL 18 Poland Zl 19 Portugal € 3.90 Republic of Ireland 3.80 Serbia Din 300 Slovenia € 3.40 Spain € 3.90 Luxembourg € 4.00 Malta € 3.80 Montenegro € 3.40 Morocco MAD 35 Norway Nkr 40 Oman OMR 1.50 NEWSSTAND PRICES U.A.E. AED 15.00 United States Military (Europe) $ 2.30

Upload: others

Post on 18-Nov-2021

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Hidden victims of a U.S. war - The New York Times

North Vietnamese Army to infiltratetroops into the South.

In one of the bamboo-and-thatch stilthouses, the ladder to the living quarterswas made from metal tubes that for-merly held American cluster bombs.

The family had a 4-year-old boynamed Suk, who had difficulty sitting,standing and walking — one of threechildren in the extended family withbirth defects. A cousin was born muteand did not learn to walk until he was 7.A third child, a girl, died at the age of 2.

“That one could not sit up,” theirgreat-uncle said. “The whole body wassoft, as if there were no bones.”

The women added Suk to the list ofpeople with disabilities they have com-piled on their intermittent treks throughLaos’s sparsely populated border dis-tricts.

Hammond, Chagnon and Sengthongmake up the core of an organization

It was a blazing-hot morning in October2019 on the old Ho Chi Minh Trail, an in-tricate web of truck roads and secretpaths that wove its way across thedensely forested and mountainous bor-der between Vietnam and Laos.

Susan Hammond, JacquelynChagnon and Niphaphone Sengthongforded a rocky stream along the trail andcame to a village of about 400 peoplecalled Labeng-Khok, once the site of alogistics base inside Laos used by the

called the War Legacies Project. Ham-mond, whose father was a military offi-cer in the war in Vietnam, founded thegroup in 2008. Chagnon was one of thefirst foreigners allowed to work in Laosafter the conflict, with the AmericanFriends Service Committee. Sengthong,a retired schoolteacher, is responsiblefor the record-keeping and local coordi-nation.

The focus of the War Legacies Projectis to document the long-term effects ofthe defoliant known as Agent Orange.Named for the colored stripe painted onits barrels, Agent Orange — known forits use by the U.S. military to clear vege-tation during the Vietnam War — is no-torious for being laced with 2,3,7,8-Tet-rachlorodibenzo-P-dioxin, or TCDD, re-garded as one of the most toxic sub-stances ever created.

The use of the herbicide in the neutralnation of Laos by the United States re-

mains one of the last untold stories of theAmerican war in Southeast Asia.

When the Air Force in 1982 releasedits official history of the defoliation cam-paign, Operation Ranch Hand, the threepages on Laos attracted almost no at-tention, other than a statement fromGen. William Westmoreland, a formerU.S. commander, that he knew nothingabout it — although it was he who hadordered it.

In the last two decades the UnitedStates has finally taken responsibilityfor the legacy of Agent Orange in Viet-nam. But Laos has remained a forgottenfootnote to a lost war.

While records of spraying operationsinside Laos exist, the extent to which theU.S. military broke international agree-ments has never been fully docu-mented, until now.

An in-depth review of Air Force LAOS, PAGE 6

PHOTOGRAPHS BY CHRISTOPHER ANDERSON

Clockwise from top left: Bounta, Khao, Yenly, Choi, Nan and Bouam. They suffer from congenital defects linked to herbicides that were sprayed in Laos during the Vietnam War.

Hidden victims of a U.S. warFROM THE MAGAZINE

The toll of Agent Orange in Laos is an untold story of the Vietnam conflict

BY GEORGE BLACK

Sunny, driven and with a new engineer-ing master’s degree in hand, JoshuaMorgan was hopeful that he could find ajob despite the pandemic, move out ofhis mother’s house and begin his life.

But as lockdowns in Britain draggedon and no job emerged, the young mangrew cynical and self-conscious, his sis-ter Yasmin said. Mr. Morgan felt hecould not get a public-facing job, likeworking at a grocery store, because hismother, Joanna, had open-heart surgerylast year and Mr. Morgan was “excep-tionally careful” about her health.

He and his mother contracted the co-ronavirus in January, forcing them toquarantine in their small London apart-ment for over two weeks. Concerned bythings he was saying, friends raised thealarm and referred him to mental healthservices.

But days before the end of his quaran-tine last month, Mr. Morgan, 25, took hisown life. “He just sounded so deflated,”his sister said of their last conversation,adding that he said he felt imprisonedand longed to go outside.

Suicides are challenging to link to spe-cific reasons, but Mr. Morgan’s suddendeath has left his sister with a feelingthat is hard to shake. “The cost of thepandemic was my brother’s life,” shesaid. “It’s not just people dying in a hos-pital — it’s people dying inside.”

More than 2.7 million people havedied from the coronavirus — nearly127,000 in Britain alone. Those numbersare a tangible count of the pandemic’scost. But as more people are vaccinatedand communities open up, there is atally that experts say is harder to track:the psychological toll of months of isola-tion and global suffering, which forsome has proved fatal.

There are some signs indicating awidespread mental health crisis. Japanrecorded a spike in suicide among wom-en last year, and in Europe, mentalhealth experts have reported a rise inthe number of young people expressingsuicidal thoughts. In the United States,many emergency rooms have facedsurges in admissions of young childrenand teenagers with mental health is-sues.

Mental health experts say prolongedsymptoms of depression and anxietymay prompt risky behaviors that lead toself-harm, accidents, or even death, es-SUICIDES, PAGE 4

Suicideshint at thepainful costof isolationLONDON

Issues of mental healthmay be hard to pin down,but signs of a crisis grow

BY ELIAN PELTIERAND ISABELLA KWAI

..

INTERNATIONAL EDITION | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 31, 2021

NOT A ‘TIGRESS’A GOLF PRODIGYON WOODS’S PATHPAGE 15 | SPORTS

GARDEN PLANGROWING ROSESTHE SMART WAYPAGE 19 | LIVING

NEARING EXTINCTIONTHE DECLINE OF AFRICA’SFOREST ELEPHANTSPAGE 9 | SCIENCE

On the edge of a vast park in Tehran sitsa Neo-Brutalist structure the color ofsand. Inside is one of the finest col-lections of modern Western art in theworld.

You enter the Tehran Museum of Con-temporary Art through an atrium thatspirals downward like an inverted ver-sion of Frank Lloyd Wright’s Guggen-heim Museum in New York. Photos ofAyatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the fa-ther of Iran’s 1979 revolution, and Aya-tollah Ali Khamenei, who succeededhim as the Islamic Republic’s supremeleader, glare down at you.

A series of underground galleriesawaits. There is nothing quite like thefeeling of coming face-to-face for thefirst time with its most sensational mas-terpiece: Jackson Pollock’s 1950 “Mural

on Indian Red Ground,” a 6-foot-by-8-foot canvas that was created with rustyreds and layered swirls of thick, drippedpaint and is considered one of his bestworks from his most important period.

Monet, Pissarro, Toulouse-Lautrec,Degas, Renoir, Gauguin, Matisse, Cha-gall, Klee, Whistler, Rodin, van Gogh, Pi-casso, Braque, Kandinsky, Magritte,Dalí, Miró, Johns, Warhol, Hockney,Lichtenstein, Bacon, Duchamp, Rothko,Man Ray — they are all here.

The museum was conceived by theEmpress Farah Diba Pahlavi, wife ofShah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi, andopened to international acclaim in 1977.Just 15 months later, in the face of awidespread popular uprising, the coupleleft the country on what was officiallycalled a “vacation.” The revolution re-placed the monarchy with an IslamicRepublic weeks later.

The new regime could have sold or de-stroyed the Western art masterpieces.Instead, the museum was closed, itstreasures hidden in a concrete base-ment, and the shah’s palaces were pre-TEHRAN, PAGE 2

An American, an empress and a trove of art

Farah Diba Pahlavi, left, the empress of Iran, and Donna Stein, a curator, in 1977. Steinfeels robbed of the credit she said she deserves for her work at a modern art museum.

JILA DEJAM

Just before its revolution,Iran built an impressivemuseum. It’s still there.

BY ELAINE SCIOLINO

The New York Times publishes opinionfrom a wide range of perspectives inhopes of promoting constructive debateabout consequential questions.

In the First Cold War, the United Statesand its allies had a secret weaponagainst the Soviet Union and its satel-lites.

It didn’t come from the C.I.A. Norwas it a product of DARPA or theweapons labs at Los Alamos. It wasCommunism.

Communism aided the West becauseit saddled an imperialist Russian statewith an unworkable and unpopulareconomic system that could not keepup with its free-market competitors.“They pretend to pay us and we pre-tend to work” — the quintessential

Russian joke aboutworking life in theworkers’ paradise —goes far to explainwhy a regime withtens of thousands ofnuclear warheadssimply petered out.

Now we are enter-ing the Second Cold

War, this time with China. That’s thetakeaway from this month’s U.S.-Chinasummit in Anchorage, in which bothsides made clear that they had notonly clashing interests but also incom-patible values. Secretary of StateAntony Blinken bluntly accused Chinaof threatening “the rules-based orderthat maintains global stability.” YangJiechi, his Chinese counterpart, repliedthat the U.S. had to “stop advancing itsown democracy in the rest of theworld.”

A few days later, China and Iransigned a 25-year, $400 billion strategicpact, including provisions for jointweapons development and intelligencesharing. As challenges to the U.S.-led“rules-based order” go, it’s hard to getmore frontal than that.

Maybe things will get better. But itwould be foolish to count on it, muchless suppose that conciliatory behaviorby the Biden administration will doanything other than embolden Beijing.Say what you will about either theTrump or the Obama administrations,but they did not provoke China tocrush democracy in Hong Kong, orbrutalize Uyghurs in Xinjiang, or vio-late international law in the SouthChina Sea, or help North Korea sub-vert international sanctions, or usemilitary force to bully its neighbors, orundertake campaigns of cyberwarfareand industrial espionage against

Strategizingin a SecondCold War

OPINION

PresidentBiden hasa chance toturn China’sstrengths intoweaknesses.

STEPHENS, PAGE 13

Bret Stephens

A TERRIFYING SIDE EFFECTDoctors report paranoia and otherpsychotic symptoms in patients whohave recovered from Covid-19. PAGE 9

The weekend paper that gets to the point.

Award-winning news, opinion, lifestyle, culture and more. In one concise paper.

Pick up the Weekend Edition.

Y(1J85IC*KKOKKR( +@!"!$!#!@

Issue NumberNo. 42,934Andorra € 5.00

Antilles € 4.50Austria € 4.00Belgium € 4.00Bos. & Herz. KM 5.80Britain £ 2.60

Cameroon CFA 3000Croatia KN 24.00Cyprus € 3.40Czech Rep CZK 115Denmark Dkr 37Estonia € 4.00

Finland € 4.00France € 4.00Gabon CFA 3000Germany € 4.00Greece € 3.40Hungary HUF 1100

Israel NIS 14.00/Friday 27.50

Israel / Eilat NIS 12.00/ Friday 23.50

Italy € 3.80Ivory Coast CFA 3000

Sweden Skr 50Switzerland CHF 5.20Syria US$ 3.00The Netherlands € 4.00Tunisia Din 8.00Turkey TL 18

Poland Zl 19Portugal € 3.90Republic of Ireland ¤� 3.80Serbia Din 300Slovenia € 3.40Spain € 3.90

Luxembourg € 4.00Malta € 3.80Montenegro € 3.40Morocco MAD 35Norway Nkr 40Oman OMR 1.50

NEWSSTAND PRICES

U.A.E. AED 15.00United States Military

(Europe) $ 2.30