growth and characterization of tgs single crystals doped...
TRANSCRIPT
1
CHAPTER - 1
INTRODUCTION
A brief introduction to the actual work done in the present study is provided in
this chapter along with a brief non-comprehensive review of various studies made on
TGS crystals by various researchers in the near past is provided in this chapter.
1.1. Importance of crystals
Man had admired crystals for long, as he had appreciated beauty. The gems
and crystals delivered by mother earth have always attracted our mankind and the
belief in the virtues of gems and some minerals dates back to atleast two thousand
years. During the 15th century man has learned the tactics of cutting, cleaving and
polishing of gemstones to raise the appearance of gems and enhanced the sparkle in
gems, that is the inherent optical effects which arise from their high refractive index
and dispersion. The significance of that beauty for a technological society and for the
development of scientific knowledge has only begun to be realized, however.
Crystallization of salt is mentioned on a Chinese print of 2700 B.C and was
also described on the Egyptian “Papyrus Ebers” of about 1500 B.C and by Aristoteles
(384 - 322 B.C). There were also reports during 300 B.C about the crystallization
processes and the preparation of sugarcane syrup in India mentioned by Ray (1956).
Behind every new solid state device there stands a single crystals and the explosion in
solid state device development, which followed the invention of the transistor in 1948.
This meant that many new crystals had to be grown and fabricated in order to assess
their device properties. The ever increasing application of semiconductor based
2
electronics creates an enormous demand for high quality semiconducting,
ferroelectric, piezoelectric oxide single crystals.
There is a vast market for solid state devices using crystalline materials
(crystals) are used in several appliances which are highly useful to mankind. The
requirements of the electronics industry has stimulated many advances in crystal
growth both extending existing techniques and bringing forward new ones. The
modern technology is very much dependent upon crystalline materials such as
semiconductors, polarizers, transducers, radiation detectors, ultrasonic amplifiers,
ferrites, magnetic garnets, solid state lasers and non-linear optic, piezoelectric,
acoustooptic and photo sensitive materials and crystalline films for microelectronics
and computer industries. All these involve research in the preparation (formation) and
characterization of crystalline materials [1-15].
1.2. Triglycine Sulphate (TGS) crystal
This chapter gives a review of various studies made on Triglycine sulphate
(TGS) single crystals in the near past. Some old reports are also added for
comprehensiveness in the properties of TGS crystals.
1.2.1. General and Structural properties
Triglycine Sulphate (NH2CH2COOH)3H2SO4, and its isomorph crystals have
been subjected to numerous studies in the past about 50 years because of its excellent
ferroelectric and pyroelectric properties. The ferroelectric property of TGS was
discovered by Mathias et al [16] in 1956. It has immediately attracted the attention of
many researchers, because it exhibits ferroelectric properties at room temperature,
3
and it can be grown easily as large samples. The b-cut / (0 1 0) crystals, this is also a
cleavage plane, are used for infrared detector fabrication [17], earth exploration,
radiation monitoring and astronomical telescopes [18], it is reported to be the best
choice among available materials as a sensitive elements in pyroelectric sensors due
to high pyroelectric coefficients reasonably low dielectric constant and best figure
of merit [19]. TGS crystal shows a ferroelectric phase transition at the curie
point temperature (Tc = 49°C) [20-21]. Its crystallizes in monoclinic structure with
non-centrosymmetric space group P21 below curie temperature (Tc = 49°C) and
changes to centrosymmetrical P21/m group [22-23], in the paraelectric phase above
curie temperature. TGS shown second-order ferroelectric phase transition at the
curie point and it is an order-disorder ferroelectric. The crystal structure of TGS
crystal is shown in the figure 1.
Figure 1: Crystal Structure of Triglycine sulphate
4
The crystals structure was determined from full three-dimensional X-Ray
diffraction data using CuKα radiation by [24]. Out of the three glycine molecules in
the crystal, one has the usual zwitter - ion configuration, with the - NH3+ group out of
the plane of the other atoms; the remaining two glycines are mono-protonated, and
planar within experimental error, and are designated as glycinium ions. Thus the
chemical formula is properly written as (NH3+ CH2COO-).(NH3
+ CH2 COOH)2. SO4-,
and the compound is best described by the chemical name glycine-di-glycinium
sulfate. One of the planar glycinium ions lies near but not in the plane y = ¼ which
becomes the mirror plane in the high - temperature phase.
The nitrogen atoms form N-H..O hydrogen bonds of the usual strength,
whereas a quite strong O-H..O hydrogen bond of a distance of 2.43 Å is found
between the oxygen atom of the carboxyl group of the zwitter-ion glycine and that of
the planar glycinium ion which lies near the plane y = 1/2. Above the curie point, at
49°C, mirror symmetry is attained by statistical arrangement of atoms around the
mirror planes at y = 1/4 and ¾. The disorder of the glycinium ions near the mirror
planes, and the above mentioned strong O-H..O bond are of particular importance for
the ferroelectric behaviour of the crystal.
It consist of SO42-(G1), 2(N+H3CH2COOH) (G2), and N+H3CH2COO-(G3)
species held together by hydrogen bonds [25] (hydrogen atoms are not shown), these
bonds are easily broken by the polar molecules of water that explain the
hygroscopicity of TGS – its crystals are easily etched by water. Along the b-axis, the
G1-SO4 and G2-G3 layers are stacked alternately. The nearest two neighbouring
layers with identical chemical composition are rotated 180° around the b-axis against
5
each other [23, 26]. Below the curie point TGS exhibits antiparallel 180° domains,
which are generally rod like parallel to the b-axis [27, 28].
1.2.2. Effect of dopants on TGS crystals
Inspite of the promising features of TGS crystal, such as room temperature
detector operation and without any external bias, it has major disadvantage that it
depolarizes by thermal, mechanical and electric means. The depolarization negatively
influences the pyroelectric figure of merit [29]. In order to overcome this difficulty,
several studies attempted with different dopant to achieve effective internal bias and
desired ferroelectric properties of TGS crystals. Investigation on the doping of TGS
crystals by amino acid [30-33] reveal that this drawback may overcome. Many
researchers have investigated the properties of pure TGS single crystals and influence
of amino acids, simple organic and inorganic compounds, metallic impurities, etc., on
the physical and other properties of TGS single crystals. [34-246, 322-336, 338-340]
Alanine dopant molecule is similar to the glycine molecule, except the
CH3 asymmetric group. Doped TGS crystals show a modified habitues versus the
pure ones, mirror external shapes of L-alanine versus D-alanine doped crystals
[80,81] suggest an equivalent substitution of the glycine G1 molecule in the crystal
lattice [82], however, the hysteresis loops and some other characteristic data of TGS
crystals, doped with racemic mixture (L+D- alanine) [83], suggest a non-equivalent
substitution. L-alanine molecule substituted for glycine1 in the crystal lattice cannot
be inverted upon switching because of its chiral structure. Thus L-alanine doped TGS
crystal causes an internal bias field Eb and results in a macroscopic irreversible
polarization in one predetermined sense of the ferroelectric b-axis [84].
6
The effect of amino acids doping in TGS has then studied extensively
[30,40,53,55,60,61,85]. In case of lysine doped TGS dielectric permittivity and
spontaneous polarization decrease with improved pyroelectric properties. In addition
lysine doped TGS crystals possess higher mechanical hardness when compared to
pure TGS [53]. It has also reported that L-threonine, DL-threonine, and L-methioine
doped TGS results decrease of dielectric constant when compared to pure TGS. The
L-threonine doped TGS has the maximum pyroelectric coefficient and hence material
is suitable for detector applications [55]. Raghavan et al [60] found that the presence
of optically active dopants of leucine and isoleucine increases the coercive field and
decreases the spontaneous depolarization of TGS crystals, will be useful for
pyroelectric applications. Jayalakshmi and Kumar [61] have recently observed an
increase of coercive field and spontaneous polarization for L-tryptophan added TGS
when compared to that for pure TGS crystal. Meera et al [34] observed an increase of
coercive field for L-cystine added TGS crystal. L-asparagine addition [51] increases
whereas L-tyrosine addition [46] decreases the microhardness of TGS single crystal.
The study of the temperature dependence of the absorption edge of a certain
substance provides a deep understanding of the interaction processes between the
optical excitation (ie, electronic excitations) and the phonon spectra. In particular the
measurements of the absorption edge of ferroelectrics in the vicinity of the phase
transition temperature gives an opportunity to obtain information on the character of
the phase transition and the nature of the chemical bonds between lattice units [86].
The admixture (addition) of transition metal ions essentially modifies the physical
properties of TGS, causing bands in the ultraviolet spectral range. These bands make
these crystals a candidate for short wavelength holographic recording.
7
E1-Fadl [43,44] has carried out optical absorption measurements near the
absorption edge in the energy range 3 to 5.5 eV on pure TGS and TGS crystals doped
with Cu2+, Mn2+ or Ni2+ in the temperature range 290 to 360°K. Temperature
dependence of the band gap Eg (T) reveals an anomaly at the phase transition
temperature for both pure and doped TGS crystals. The indirect allowed transition is
the most probable type of transition near the fundamental edge of pure TGS and TGS
crystals doped with divalent ions, and the phonon energy associated with the allowed
indirect transition changes from one dopant to another. Doping of TGS crystals with
small concentration of divalent ions considerably affects the measured optical
parameters. The effect however, varies from one dopant to another according to their
physicochemical activity. I.V. Vavresyuk et al [87] have studied changes in properties
of TGS doped with metal ions
Mihaylova and Byrne [48] have studied TGS crystals doped with Nd by
Raman spectroscopy. Doping of TGS with Nd does not cause a change in the crystal
structure and the symmetries of groups in the unit cell remain unaffected. A new
mode at 1535cm-1 appeared for all crystals doped with Nd, which indicates that Nd is
co-ordinated with the glycine molecule. Doping with Nd affects significantly the
C-CO bending mode at 584 cm-1, The O-C-O bending mode at 665 cm-1, the SO42-
mode at 1086 cm-1 and the CH2 wagging and twisting mode at 1310 cm-1. The Raman
bands at 1374 and 1413 cm-1 indicate the presence of a zwitterion, which supports
Hoshino’s theory for spontaneous polarization reversal in TGS.
CO2+ doped TGS crystals studied by Prokopova et al [88] have been shown to
possess a very good structural quality with stabilized domain structure at room
temperature. The results obtained by Novotny et al [50] on the preparation of TGS
8
single crystals doped by palladium (especially on the growth of non-polar (001)
pyramid) could be important for the growth of high-volume crystals for application
purposes. Novotny et al [56] have reported the procedure of single crystal growth of
full faceted TGS and deuterated TGS (DTGS) with varying content of Pt (II) and
Pt (IV) ions and with L-alanine impurities in the growth solution. They measured in
great detail the main physical properties of prepared LATGS / Pt (IV) and
LADTGS / Pt (II) singles crystals such as spontaneous polarization PS, values of
coercive fields EC, Internal electric field Eb, dielectric permittivity εr and dielectric
losses tan δ. Their results suggest that the prepared modified TGS single crystals are
suitable material for preparation of high sensitivity broad area infrared detectors.
Muralidharan et al [38, 52] have reported the rare earth ions dopants La, Ce
and Nd on the growth aspects and ferroelectric properties of TGS single crystals.
The dopants significantly modify the morphology of the crystals. Dielectric
measurement revealed that the dielectric constant of Ce doped TGS increases rapidly
at the transition temperature. Well – structured rectangular hysteresis loop have been
observed for all the doped crystals. Lenticular ferroelectric domain patterns were
observed on the (010) plane of the grown crystals. La doped TGS crystals possess a
high Tc and coercive field values. Among the three dopants, Nd doped TGS possesses
low dielectric constant and high pyroelectric coefficient suggesting that this can be a
potential material for infrared detectors. Sun et al [45] have grown guanidine doped
TGS crystal and found that this crystal has better pyroelectric properties than those of
pure TGS crystal.
Chang et al [42] have reported the growth and properties of TGS crystals
doped with urea. It was found that the normalized growth yield and pyroelectric and
9
dielectric constants could be increased significantly by urea addition. TGS crystals
doped with 5 and 10 wt% urea exhibited upto five times higher material figures of
merit for infrared pyroelectric detectors compared with undoped TGS crystals. The
Vicker’s hardness of doped crystals increased with urea content to about three times
the undoped value in the (010) direction at 10% urea. No significant increase in the
hardness was found, however, in the (001) direction.
Based on Devonshire [89] thermodynamic theory the relationship λ/X = Ps/C
can be obtained and can be regarded as a method to increase the pyroelectric material
figure of merit of ferroelectric crystals. Shi et al [47] have grown modified TGS
crystals doped with urea or co-doped with urea and other dopants and investigated the
pyroelectric properties. The pyroelectric figures of merit M(λ/εr) of the doped TGS
crystals are obviously higher than those of pure TGS.
Meera et al [53] have grown and characterized thiourea doped TGS crystals.
Dielectric studies show a shift in the curie temperature because of doping pyroelectric
coefficient was found to be increased due to thiourea addition on TGS. Very recently,
Krishna kumar et al [62] have grown thiourea doped TGS single crystals and
subjected them to X-Ray diffraction, FTIR and Raman spectroscopic and optical
absorption measurements. The powder technique of Kurtz and Perry confirmed the
non-linear optical (NLO) property of the grown crystals. The shift and the appearance
of additional wave number in the IR and Raman spectra of doped crystal establish the
co-ordination of thiourea with TGS in the lattice. The results of the response of the
mechanical behaviour of thiourea doped TGS crystal will have significant effect on
machining the crystal for device purpose. From the results of optical transmission it
was found that the doped crystal exhibit excellent transmission in entire UV-Visible
10
range studied than undoped crystal. This property enables the material for the
fabrication of IR detectors and in some optoelectronics device technology. Also
sufficient shift in the lower cut off wavelength towards UV region in doped crystal
makes this material to find application in generation of UV light. Higher second
harmonic generation (SHG) efficiencies were observed for pure (52.5 mV) and
thiourea doped (60.2 mV) TGS crystals when compared to that for potassium
dihydrogen orthophosphate, KDP (15 mV).
Many metallic dopants modified the properties to some extent, but in general
they have been found ineffective for achieving the desired changes in the
properties [90]. Metallic ions like Fe3+ and Cr3+ ions changed the crystal growth
characteristics, but decreased the pyroelectric coefficient and spontaneous
polarization [91]. Li+ and Mn2+ modified the growth habit and produced a high
pyroelectric coefficient, but the high dielectric constant value did not affect the
pyroelectric material figure of merit (P/εr), where P = pyroelectric coefficient,
εr = dielectric constant [92]. Ni2+ ions at a concentration level of 10% by weight in
the solution increased the pyroelectric figure of merit but did not enhance the crystal
growth rate [90], whereas Mg2+ and Cu2+ modified the growth habit but marginally
increased the pyroelectric material figure of merit [91].
Phosphoric acid (H3PO4) as a dopant has been found to yield crystals with a
large ‘ac’ plane area useful for IR detector applications [49,54,93,94]. Even at a very
low concentration level of H3PO4, a significant improvement in the pyroelectric
coefficient, lowering of the dielectric permittivity at transition temperature (Tc) and
increase in the coercive field of the TGS crystal have been reported [95-97]. The
replacement of sulphur by phosphorous in the lattice introduces asymmetry in the
11
P-E hysteresis loop [96]. It has also been found that the concentration of H3PO4 is
critical for achieving the desired material properties for commercial IR detector
applications [98].
Very recently, Balu et al [63] have grown ammonium dihydrogen
orthophosphate (ADP) doped TGS single crystals and characterized. X-Ray analysis
showed a slight variation in the lattice parameters for doped crystals. The optical
transmission spectra indicated a wide optical transparency in the entire visible and
near IR region. Dielectric measurements revealed a shift of curie point to lower
temperature with increase in dopant concentration. Microhardness studies have
shown that the hardness decrease with increase in ADP concentration. Nakatani [99]
has studied temperature independent internal bias field in L-α-alanine doped TGS
crystal. Serna et al [100] has studied the positron life time spectra of pure and
L-alanine doped TGS.
Arunmozhi et al [101] have studied the effect, of anti- ferroelectric ADP with
TGS crystals. They shown that inhomogeneous incorporation of dopants gives rise to
a distribution in coercive fields in the different growth sectors. The incorporated
dopant hinders polarization switching, which results in the increase in coercive field.
N.Theresita Shanthi et al [70] have grown sodium bromide doped TGS single crystal
from aqueous solution. They shown that the dopant addition increases the hardness
number for low concentration and decreases the hardness when the concentration is
high, they also show that there is no change in the curie point temperature due to
dopant addition.
Copper sulphate doped TGS crystal were grown by K.Balasubramanian and
P.Selvarajan [72]. They observed that the dielectric parameters increased when the
12
TGS crystal are doped with copper sulphate. They also noticed that there was an
increase of microhardness number when TGS crystal was doped with copper sulphate.
Farhana Khanum and Jiban Podder [77] have studied the effect of nickel sulphate
doped TGS crystals. They found that the lattice parameters are slightly distorted
due to the incorporation of nickel ion into the lattice size of the TGS crystal,
M.Costache et al [102] have grown alanine doped TGS crystal in the pyroelectric
phase. They found that remarkable asymmetry of measure pyroelectric coefficient of
d and L-alanine doped TGS crystal. Suggest a non-equivalent substitution of glycine
in host lattice. Farhana Khanum and Jiban Podder [76] have doped potassium bromide
with TGS and they shown that the doped crystal have wide optical transparency in the
entire visible region. K.Balasubramanian et al [71] have grown TGS crystal in
CdS nano particle dispersed water by solution method and studied the effect of
Cd2+ ions. Alexandru and Ann NY [75] has studied the effect of D-alanine in TGS
crystal in the dielectric parameters. They found that the relaxation time is not a real
constant on such large time interval. In a semi long scale, permittivity shows three
stages, probably related to several mechanism of relaxation. A.J.Jeya Prakash
Manoharan et al [78], have studied the effect of amino acid in TGS crystal. They
found that the D.C conductivity increases with temperature as well as dopant
concentration.
Farhana Khanum and Jiban Podder [79] have studied that effect of LiSO4 on
TGS crystal. They found that the D.C conductivity increases with temperature as well
as dopant concentration and also shown that the curie point temperature remain same
for pure and doped crystal. But the dielectric constant and loss factor increases with
doped concentration grown by n bromo succinide added TGS crystal were grown by
Rai and his co workers [74]. They found that, the dielectric constant of NBSTGS
13
crystal decrease with the increase in NBS concentration and considerable shift in the
phase transition temperature (Tc) towards the higher temperature.
1.2.3. Various methods of growth of TGS crystal
TGS crystals were grown by several authors by different crystal growth
methods in several environment.
In low gravity
TGS crystals were grown from aqueous solutions in Spacelab 3 in 1985 [103].
A. Natarajah et al [104] have modelled this experiment in two dimensions employing
the finite volume code PHOENICS. Thermal and solutal convection were included in
this model and the crystal growth rate was chosen as the sensitivity parameter for the
response to convective transport. Simulations were carried out for steady, impulsive
and periodic acceleration in order to determine tolerable acceleration levels.
The apparatus consist of a temperature controlled cylindrical growth cell with
a cylindrical pedestal (string) inside. The string was insulated on all sides except the
top, on which the seed crystal was mounted. The temperatures of the container walls
and string were independently controlled. The seed was enclosed by a cap during a
long storage period prior to launch and until the experiment was started on the shuttle.
The cap separated the seed from the nutrient solution with which the container was
filled, preventing premature growth or etching. At the start of the experiment the
nutrient solution was brought to its saturation temperature, following which the cap
was withdrawn. The string and wall temperatures were then increased briefly in order
to dissolve any spurious crystallites, after which the system was cooled at a relatively
rapid rate to induce growth. Hence it was necessary to reduce the temperatures
14
of the walls and the string to avoid damage to the crystal. For the experiments on
Spacelab 3, the cooling was continued for 10hr after which the temperature was held
steady for atleast another 15hr.
In silica gel
Bhatt and Patel [105] have grown TGS single crystals upto 11x7x3 mm3 in
size in silica gel at room temperature by the reaction method. It has been found that
when PH of the gel is 2.5 or higher, only TGS crystals are formed and for PH between
2.0 and 2.4 both TGS and DGS (diglycine sulphate) crystals are formed. When PH of
the gel is less than 2.0, only DGS crystals are produced in the gel.
The growth of the crystals in microgravity holds the promise of producing
large defect free crystals. This is because the absence of gravity eliminates gravity –
driven convection flows at the crystal- liquid interface. Yoo et al [103] studied the
growth of TGS in microgravity. TGS is a non-linear optical material used in infrared
detectors. Yoo et al [103] were unable to match their observed concentration profiles
around the growing crystal to those predicted by a computer model.
The rate of crystal growth is determined by the slowest step in the growth
process. This can either be the diffusion of the materials to the surface or the kinetics
of the surface processes. Both factors need to be understood to successfully predict
growth rates. Both the diffusion and the surface integration kinetics are processes
driven by differences in chemical potential, not supersaturation. The initial
appearance of nuclei is also driven by differences on chemical potential. For diffusion
limited processes the diffusion coefficient is the important parameter. In zero gravity,
it is the exclusive method of transport to the surface. In normal gravity there is a
15
boundary layer near the surface where diffusion is the dominant mode of transport.
Yoo et al [103] used the under saturated values of the diffusion coefficient in their
analysis. Myerson and co-worker [106,107] have shown that for supersaturated
solutions of salts. The diffusion coefficient and the viscosity are strong functions of
concentration in the supersaturated regime. This behavior cannot be predicted by
extrapolating from data in the under saturated region. Myerson and Lo [108] have
also shown that the diffusion, being a function of crystal face, impurity concentration
and other factors. In addition, Yoo et al [103] used concentration in their calculations
as the supersaturated driving force. While concentration supersaturation is normally
used, the true driving force for crystal growth is a difference in the chemical potential.
The variation of the diffusion coefficient with time is believed to be due to the
formation of subcritical solute clusters. Their average size grows larger as the
solution remains in the metastable state. Evidence for such clusters was reported by
Mullin and Leci [109] for citric acid. This effect was not found in under saturated
solution. Larson and Garside [110] explained this phenomenon by assuming the solute
in excess of saturation was joined in clusters. Myerson and Lo [108] repeated this
experiment for glycine. They assumed a distribution of cluster sizes. The number
average cluster size was between 2 and 100 solute molecule. Most of the clusters
were low molecular weight dimers or trimers. Other evidence for the existence of
clusters comes from spectroscopy.
In preparation for the space experiments, Kroes and Reiss [111] measured the
following properties of aqueous solutions of TGS: Viscosity and density as a function
of temperature and concentration, solubility and diffusion coefficient as a function of
temperature. All the data were for unsaturated solutions. The Spherical Void
16
Electrodynamic Levitor Trap (SVELT) can be used to measure the activity of highly
supersaturated solutions. The SVELT suspends micron-sized droplets by means of
electrodynamic levitation. In this containerless environment very high supersaturation
can be achieved and the activity of the solvent can be measured. This provide a
technique to measure properties of solutions beyond those that could ordinarily be
measured in bulk solutions. Bohenek et al [112] used this technique to obtain
thermodynamic data for TGS through a large part of the metastable zone. They have
found that the metastable zone is very wide. The spinodal concentration is many
times the saturated concentration. It has also been found that critical cluster size for
nucleation is a small number over most of the metastable region.
Sun at al [113] studied the growth kinetics of (110) and (010) faces of
TGS crystals at high supersaturations under the curie temperature. The analysis of
experimental data proved that the growth of TGS crystals was mainly controlled by
the surface diffusion spiral dislocation mechanism (BCF surface diffusion model)
Earlier, Alexandru and Berbecaru [114] measured the growth rates of the (110) face
of TGS crystal with the supersaturation under 3% and Reiss et al [115] obtained the
growth rates with the supersaturations lower than 4.5%. Later Sun et al [116]
investigated the growth kinetics and mechanism on the (001) and (100) faces of TGS
crystals. They found the growth on the (001) and (100) faces at high supersaturation
was mainly controlled by a BCF surface diffusion mechanism.
Different techniques have been used to grow large crystals of TGS. Their
growth morphology depends on several parameter: PH value of solution, impurities or
additives, degree of supersaturation, and also process parameters such a seed
orientation and manner of attachment of seed [117]. The growth rates of the different
17
habit faces of TGS are widely different. Generally, the growth rate of the (010) face
is much higher than that of (001). Therefore the probability of appearance of the
(010) face on the grown crystal is rather small.
G.Sivanesan et al [156] studied that the single crystals of triglycine sulphate
with increased size with respect to the earlier report (Bhatt et al) and improved
morphology were grown in silica gel at room temperature
Slow evaporation technique
To grow crystals of TGS from aqueous solution, researchers have used
different types of crystallizers. The techniques used include the reciprocating-motion
technique [118] and the rotating–disc techniques [119]. The method of seed
attachment is also an important parameter in solution growth. Various types of seed
holders have been used for TGS. Often, the seed is secured to the Lucite holder with a
plastic thumb screw or the top of seed plate is inserted into a bevel in the holder [120].
The seed has a tendency to grow laterally at the point of contact between it and the
holder. This causes considerable difficulty during removal of the grown crystal from
the holder. Another way of holding the seed plate is that of inserting four screws to
support the seed plate. But the disadvantage in this method is that, if there is a slight
dissolution of the seed, it detaches from the grip of the screws.
Seeded Growth
To eliminate the above problems, the cylindrical seed method (CSM) was
developed [121]. In the rotating disc technique for growing TGS crystal, the seed was
recessed in a bed of silicone rubber in a circular Perspex holder. The Perspex holder
was dipped into the solution, and the crystal grow downwards. Satapathy et al [122]
18
have reported the growth of TGS crystal by the platform technique, using seeds which
need not be long along the c-axis. Crystals were grown from aqueous solution by
placing seeds of size 5x5x5mm3 in different orientations on the platform. The
variation of growth rate of various habit facets with different orientations of seeds was
determined. An optimum seed orientation was found such that the platform technique
permits one to grow TGS crystals, from which large-area (010) plates can be cut. The
crystals grown by this method exhibit high growth rates and good optical quality.
They demonstrated the use of such a crystal in a laser energy meter.
Solution Growth
Metastable zone width is an essential parameter for the growth of large size
single crystals from solution since it is the direct measure of the stability of the
solution in its supersaturated region [123]. Conventionally, purification of raw
material is the only method being adopted to enhance the metastable zone width of
solutions. Srinivasan et al [124,125] have developed a contemporary method to
enhance the metastable zone width of the solution in their supersaturated region in
order to enhance their stability to grow large size crystals with faster cooling rates. In
which the incorporation of a small quantity (1 wt %) of ethylenediamine tetra
acetic acid (EDTA), a well known gelating agent, enhances the zone width
significantly due to its gelating action. It was observed that this addition reduces the
nucleation rate and enhances the growth rate of the crystal appreciably. However,
Meera et al [126] have found that, by carrying out microhardness measurement, the
EDTA added TGS crystal was softer than pure TGS crystal.
19
SR method
Recently, TGS crystals were grown by SR method in both (010) and (001)
direction by so many authors [127-130]. Large single crystal of triglycine sulphate
(dimension 100mm along monoclinic b-axis and 15mm in diameter) was grown using
the unidirectional solution growth technique (SR method) by Justin Raj et al [127].
M.Senthil Pandian and P.Ramasamy et al [128] have grown TGS crystals from the
solution by unidirectional SR method in (010) direction. They shown that there was
improvements in the properties of TGS crystals grown by SR method when compared
to those grown by the conventional slow evaporation technique. M.Senthil Pandian et
al [129] have also grown (001) directional TGS crystal by SR method, they shown
that the TGS crystals grown by SR method have higher hardness than conventional
method grown crystals. Dislocation density (DD) is less in SR grown crystal
compared to conventional method grown TGS crystals. The transmittance of SR
grown TGS is 8% higher than that of the conventional grown crystal. N.Balamurugan
et al [130] have grown TGS crystal by SR method and they prove the suitability of the
modified SR method for oriented TGS crystal.
1.2.4. Physical properties of TGS crystals
X-Ray diffraction studies to determine the crystal structure was carried out by
several authors [24,50,62,63,77] they all shown that the Triglycine Sulphate crystal
belongs to monoclinic system and also they observed slight change in the lattice
parameters for doped crystal. Muralidharan and his co-workers [38,52] have reported,
the rare earth ion dopants La, Ce and Nd on the growth aspect and ferroelectric
properties of TGS single crystals. The dopants significantly modify the morphology
of the crystals. FTIR spectrum recorded by the authors [23,25,26,48] confirm the
20
presence of all the functional groups which were present in glycine and sulphuric
acid.
S.Lijewski et al [131] have studied the electron spin echo technique in
triglycine sulphate (TGS) family crystals from the sound velocities derived from
elastic constant. And they determined the debye temperature of TGS family crystals.
They reported that the debye temperature of TGS crystals as 190ºK. The
microhardness studies were made for pure and several doped TGS crystals by several
authors [46,53,63,70,132]. Therasita Shanti et al [70] and Meera et al [53] have shown
that the microhardness number of TGS crystals increased with increase in dopant
concentration, while Balu et al [63] and Meera et al [46] have grown ADP and
L-tyrosine doped TGS crystal respectively. They shown that the hardness number
decreases with increase in dopant concentration. K.Balasubramanian et al [132] have
grown copper sulphate doped TGS crystal, they found that the doped crystals were
more harder than pure TGS crystal.
Mikhnevich [133] have studied the effect of impurity concentration on the
dielectric properties of TGS crystal with the non isomorphic impurity ions of
chromium and mixed isomorphic crystals of TGS and TGSe. The lectrical
measurement like dielectric constant, A.C. conductivity and D.C. conductivity made
by so many authors for pure and doped TGS crystals [19,30,40,53,55,60,61,72,
74,75,79,85,92,127]. They all shown that the dielectric constant increases with the
temperature and it is maximum at curie point temperature (49°C) and decrease further
with increase in temperature. Also they shown that there was no change in the curie
point temperature due to dopant addition, Justin Raj et al [127] have studied the
frequency response of dielectric constant and they shown that the dielectric constant
value decreases with increase in frequency. Kashevich et al [134] has studied the
21
dielectric properties of TGS crystals with a periodical stratified impurity distribution.
Stankowiska [135] have studied the dielectric properties of TGS crystals admixture
with b-d and dl- phenylalanine.
B.Hilczer and M.Michalczyk [136] have measured the temperature
dependence of D.C conductivity in the three crystallographic directions for pure and
y-irradiated TGS single crystal. An exponential law is obeyed from 20 to 80°C with a
change in activation energy at Tc, the electric conductivity is the highest along the
c-axis, the three activation energies increase slowly with increasing defect
concentration in the paraelectric state. In the ferroelectric phase, they increase
initially upto about 0.5 MR and then decrease. Various radiation induced changer in
the three axes. Many suggest that the electric conductivity in TGS can vary in type
from different crystallographic directions.
Therasita Shanthi and P.Selvarajan [137] have studied the temperature and the
concentration dependence of some halides doped TGS crystal. They found that the
D.C electrical conductivity increases with the increase in both the temperature
and impurity concentration. Farhana khanum et al [79] also shown that the
D.C conductivity increases with both the increase in temperature and impurity
concentration
1.2.5. Ferroelectric and hysteresis studies
Ferroelectric and hysteresis studies were made for pure and doped
TGS crystals by various author, Muralidharan and his co-workers [38] studied the
hysteresis effects of TGS crystals. They reported that lanthanum doped TGS crystals
possess, a maximum coercive force field value. Also they found that ES is high for
dopant ions having less number of 4f electrons.
22
Justin Raj et al [127] recorded the ferroelectric domain pattern using an optical
microscope and by scanning electron microscope, they observed that majority of
domains were elliptical or circular of 2 -10 μm. Also they observed the damaging the
domain pattern due to charging by the electron beam by focusing on the domain for
few seconds.
Arunmozhi et al [101] have found that there is no distinct change in the
spontaneous polarizations due to ADP doping in TGS. They also reported that the
dopant creates non-polar effects in the lattice and ADP doping increase the coercive
force.
Nakatani et al [138] has studied about changes in ferroelectric domain
structure of TGS with passage of time after heat treatment. Zhang and Zhang [139]
have used the order–disorder model to explain the mechanism of the average field of
ferroelectrics. Furthermore, the order-disorder structure is a common character for all
the ferroelectrics. Likodimos et al [140] have reported the surface charges
compensation and ferroelectric domain structure of TGS revealed by voltage-
modulated scanning force microscopy.
Afonskaya et al [211] has studied the re-arrangement of the domain structure
of cobalt and chromium doped TGS crystals. Toshio Kikuta et al [141] have studied
the domain pattern of TGS after exposure to an electric field perpendicular to the
ferroelectric axis, they found that the spontaneous polarization could be observed after
a prolonged application of electric field, the domain pattern appears have become a
rigid straight and the direction of the perpendicular electric field but is parallel to
c-axis. Montemezzani et al [142] have studied the effects of ultraviolet illumination
on Fe3+ doped TGS crystals and aqueous solutions. Montemezzani et al [143] have
23
studied the influence of ultraviolet irradiation on the optical absorption spectra of
iron-doped TGS crystals and aqueous solutions. Montemezzani et al [144] have
studied phase grating in Fe3+ doped TGS crystals recorded in the ultraviolet spectral
region.
1.2.6. Optical properties
Santra et al [145] has studied about the Raman spectroscopy of alanine doped
TGS ferroelectric single crystal. Sahai and Arya [146] have studied the temperature
dependence of Raman scattering spectra of internal modes in TGS. Sheen et al [147]
have studied the low temperature phase transition of TGS from Raman scattering in
the range of temperature between 10 and 300°K.
1.2.7. Pyroelectric properties
Many metallic dopants modified the properties to some extent, but in general,
they have been found ineffective for achieving the desired changes in the
properties [148]. Metallic ions like Fe3+ and Cr3+ ions changed the crystal growth
characterizations, but decreased the pyroelectric coefficient and spontaneous
polarization [91]. Li+ and Mn2+ modified the growth habit and produced a high
dielectric constant value did not affect the pyroelectric figure of merit (p/εr), where
p-pyroelectric coefficient, εr-dielectric constant [149]. Ni2+ ions at a concentration
level of 10% by weight in the solution increased the pyroelectric figure of merit but
did not enhance the crystal growth rate [148], whereas Mg2+ and Cu2+ modified the
growth habit but marginally increased the pyroelectric figure of merit [91].
Phosphoric acid (H3PO4) as a dopant has been found to yield crystals with a
large “ac” plane area used for IR detector application [49,54,94,150]. Even at a very
24
low concentration level of H3PO4, a significant improvement in the pyroelectric
coefficient, lowering of the dielectric permittivity at transition temperature (Tc) and
increase in the coercive field of the TGS crystal have been reported [95-97]. The
replacement of sulphur by phosphorous in the lattice introduces asymmetry in the P.E
hysteresis loop [96] it has also been found that the concentration of H3PO4 is
critical for achieving the desired material properties for commercial IR detector
applications [98].
1.2.8. Device Fabrication
Chavan [151] has reported about the battery formation of solid state by
applying D.C electric field on ferroelectric Triglycine Sulphate at high temperature.
Investigation of functional devices based on molecular materials organic
conductors and biomaterials has developed devices rapidly with the progress of the
nanotechnology. Especially, the fabrication of functional devices based on molecular
materials has been investigated by many researches with much interest [152-154].
Pentacene (C22H14) is one of the molecular materials and has very interesting
properties, for example, Pentacene film prepared by sublimation becomes a highly
oriented film [157]. It is expected from this feature that the highly orderly surface (the
interface between pentacene and another material) will be realized. It is also known
that the iodine (acceptor) or rubidium (donor) is intercalated between pentacene
molecular layers and the intercalation compounds are formed [214,238]. Moreover,
electrical conductivity increases drastically more than 108 times larger than that of
pure pentacene by doping of iodine and rubidium [214,238]. In addition to these
fundamental investigations, the devices based on pentacene have also been
investigated with much interest (153,154,327).
25
Matsuo et al [155] have fabricated a Field Effect Transistor (FET) based on
the ferroelectric TGS single crystal and pentacene film and investigated the electrical
properties. Figure 2 [155] illustrates the FET based on TGS and pentacene.
Figure 2: FET based on TGS and pentacene
It was found that the drain current decreases drastically with the increase of
the gate electric field around 100 V/cm and shows a minimum at 400 V/cm. Which
corresponds to the coercive electric field of TGS. This decrease of the drain current is
caused by the appearance of the depletion layer in the pentacene film. This result
indicates that the FET based on the TGS single crystal and pentacene film operates at
low gate electric field owing to the rapid generation of the surface charge
accompanied by the appearance of the spontaneous polarization in the ferroelectric
TGS insulator. It was also found that the drain current does not return to the initial
value (before the gate electric field of 450 V/cm is applied) for one week even in the
gate electric field is turned from 450 to 0V/cm. This result indicates that the surface
charges of pentacene remains for one week. From these results, it is suggested that the
26
FET based on the TGS single crystal and pentacene film shows a memory effect.
Very recently, P.R.Deepti et al [195] shown that KDP doped TGS crystals is suitable
for optoelectronic applications in their studies. The lattice parameters determined by
various authors for pure TGS crystal grown by different methods are given in table 1.
27
Table 1: Lattice parameters of TGS crystals by different researchers
a (Å)
b (Å)
c (Å)
β ( º )
Reference
9.418
9.417
9.398
9.6010
9.453
9.41
9.15
9.167
9.424
9.15
9.419
9.15
9.419
12.662
12.643
12.634
12.56
12.644
12.61
12.64
12.64
12.643
12.69
12.647
12.69
12.65
5.740
5.735
5.784
5.45
5.735
5.73
5.72
5.729
5.735
5.73
5.727
5.73
5.732
110.31
110.4
109.55
-
106.52
110.23
105.53
105.58
110.36
105.67
110.3
105
110.36
[339]
[159]
[328]
[76]
[330]
[24]
[331]
[39]
[332]
[333]
[334]
[335]
[338]
28
1.3. Present work
Today, crystals are the pillars of the modern technology, without crystals there
would no electronic industry, no photonic industry, no fiber optics communication,
very little modern optical equipment. Pure as well as mixed and doped crystals are
grown in every day in large quantities due to the increased need of crystals in solid
state devices
TGS is the order – disorder type ferroelectric crystal. Since the discovery of its
ferroelectric nature in 1956 by Mathias, TGS is one of the best studied ferroelectric
materials TGS exhibits good pyroelectric properties and finds wide application as
pyroelectric detectors. It shows second – order phase transition at curie point
temperature (Tc = 49°C). [20,21,233]
In the present study, TGS was synthesized from glycine and sulphuric acid, pure,
calcium and lanthanum doped single crystals of TGS were grown by slow evaporation
technique. Totally, eleven crystals (1 pure TGS, 5 calcium doped TGS, and 5
lanthanum doped TGS) were grown in identical condition.
The concentration of calcium in the calcium doped TGS crystal were
determined from Atomic Absorption spectrum and the lanthanum concentration in the
lanthanum doped TGS crystals were determined from EDAX spectrum taken.
Powder X-Ray diffraction data were collected for the eleven samples and they were
indexed using the standard methods, lattice parameters were also determined.
Thermal parameters like debye-waller factor, mean square amplitude of vibration,
debye temperature and debye frequency were determined from X-Ray diffraction
intensity data
29
The microhardness, and melting point of all the grown crystals were
determined by Vicker’s microhardness apparatus and TG/DTA thermal analysis
respectively. Work hardening coefficient was also determined from the hardness
value and the activation energy was calculated from the mass changes with respect to
temperature in the DTA curve. Debye temperatures were also determined from both
microhardness and melting point of the grown crystals.
The D.C electrical conductivity was determined by the conventional two probe
setup at various temperature ranging from 30°C to 120°C. Activation energy was also
determined from the D.C conductivity data.
The dielectric parameters like, dielectric constant and dielectric loss factor
(tanδ) were measured at different frequency viz. 50Hz, 100Hz, 1KHz, 10KHz,
50KHz, 100KHz, 200KHz, at various temperature ranging from 30°C to 120°C.
A.C conductivity was also calculated from the above two values. Activation energy
and debye temperature were also calculated from the A.C conductivity data. The
cole-cole plot also been drawn from the calculated complex dielectric values.
Electrical impedance measurement were carried out on all the eleven grown
crystal in the frequency range 1Hz to 1MHz at two temperature viz. 30°C and 49°C
(curie point temperature). Optical measurements like UV – Visible and FTIR studies
have been carried out for all the eleven grown crystals. Ferroelectric hysteresis curve
were drawn for all the grown crystals and the coercive field were determined.
The results obtained and detailed report of present research work are provided
in this thesis which is organized as follows. The topic of research is introduced in the
first chapter. The detail explanation of the synthesize of sample TGS crystal and their
chemical characterization are discussions in chapter two. Chapter three deals with the
30
structural characterization of the grown crystal along with the results and discussions.
The fourth chapter gives the mechanical characterization of the grown crystals along
with results and discussions. Electrical characterization including D.C conductivity,
dielectric constant, A.C conductivity, Cole-Cole plot and ferroelectric domain
structures are discussed in chapter six along with results and discussions. Electrical
impedance analysis is discussed in chapter seven along with results and discussions.
The optical characterization are discussed in chapter eight along with the result
obtained. Summary, conclusion and future scope are given in chapter nine. References
are provided in chapter ten.