from the lancet, saturday, may 1st, 1830. on the medical service of the east india company

1
1300 LOOKING BACK.-VITAL STATISTICS. Looking Back. FROM THE LANCET, SATURDAY, May 1st, 1830. ON THE MEDICAL SERVICE OF THE EAST INDIA COMPANY. LETTER IV.l To the Editor of THE LANCET. SIR,-Before proceeding further in the consideration of the ultimate and sole recompense to medical officers of the East India Company’s service, that is, their retiring pensions, it may be proper to mention the form of admission, at the India House, of recruits for this establishment, which is well calculated to deceive. It is this; that "assistant surgeons are permitted to proceed to their respective presidencies, Calcutta, Madras, or Bombay, as the case may be, to practise as surgeons, and to be admitted on the establishments as vacancies may occur." This form has been observed for the last ten or twelve years. To practise as surgeons, where ?-Upon whom ?-For what ? -The thing is quite absurd, and ridiculous ; and merely "ad captandum"-to deceive, by giving an idea that, independent of the high prospects which the Company’s service holds out, money is to be made in India, even on landing, by private practice ! 1 It is but fair, however, to mention, that, according to the present writer’s informa- tion, no one has hitherto been left to absolute starvation in this way. Medical officers, shipped for India, in compliance with requisitions to the Court of Directors from the several i presidencies, have hitherto been wanted to fill up vacancies, occasioned by casualties, long before the period of their arrival in India. At the presidencies, medical practice is in the hands of two or three Company’s surgeons. It is only at the Presidencies, that medical officers are paid for professional attendance. At out-stations, a " honorarium," or fee, to the medical attendant, is seldom, if ever, dreamt of ; so that, on the Madras establishment, at least, not above one surgeon in one hundred, after from twenty to thirty years’ service, happens to receive, in fees and presents, a sum equal to the payment of his passage-money back to England, or 2,000 rupees. Medical men are not prohibited from receiving presents, or fees, in India, on account of professional practice ; but their patients (excepting at the Presidencies, or towns of Calcutta, Madras, or Bombay) must necessarily be Compaiy’s servants ; and it is not obligatory on them to pay for medical advice and attendance ; whereas, the attendance of medical men, on all occasions, is obligatory, with or without a fee. Medical men never expect, it may be said never accept, a remuneration from the military ; and civilians, who alone are able to pay them, very seldom think any return for their assistance necessary. It has been ruled, however, by the supreme government, and by the subordinate governments, that it is the duty of every medical man, to attend at the call of any person within his reach who may want his services, without fee or reward, and at his own expense for personal conveyance. Let it be understood that such unrequited summonses are often frivolous, and at distances of upwards of fifty miles. Disobedience of these calls renders the surgeon liable to trial by court-martial; or to suffer by the more usual mode of punishing medical delinquents-marching them incessantly about the country to the most distant places, until they sink under fatigue, privation of every sort, despondency, and the malignant influence of the climate. From natives, who seldom ask the help of an English surgeon, the compliment seldom exceeds a small present of fruit, or sweetmeats, a fowl, or a lean goat, or sheep, and, on very extraordinary occasions, perhaps, a well-darned shawl, not worth 20 rupees, and which has been an heir-loom in the family for the best 1 part of a century. So much for the practice of a surgeon in India....... Let us now see, by a comparative statement, in what pro- portions the Honourable Company compensate and appreciate the labours of their two classes of servants-soul-curers and i body-curers. 1 Excerpts only have been transcribed. Pay on Reti’l’ement. "A chaplain, after eighteen years’ service in India, including three years for one furlough," (that is, after fifteen years’ actual residence in India), " is allowed to retire on the pay of lieutenant-colonel, 3651. per annum." " A medical officer, after twenty years in India, including three years for one furlough," (that is, after seventeen years’ service in India,) "is permitted to retire from the service on the pay of captain, 1911. 12s. a year." After twenty and thirty years’ service in India, the same, 1911. 12s. " A chaplain, if compelled to quit the service on account of ill health, after ten years’ service in India, is allowed to retire on the half-pay of lieutenant-colonel, 200l. 15s. a year. "A medical officer, if compelled to quit the service on account of ill health, after ten years’ service in India, is (or rather was) permitted to retire on the half pay of lieutenant, 731. ; after six years, on the half pay of ensign, 541. 15s. after thirteen, on the half pay of his rank, that of fall surgeon, if fortunate, 1271. 15s. ; or of lieutenant, if the reverse, 73l. - " A chaplain, after seven years’ residence in India, is allowed to come home on furlough, and receive the pay of major, 292l. a year ; should he come home from sickness prior to this period, he is to receive the pay of captain only." " A medical officer, after ten years’ service in India, is allowed to come home on furlough, and receive the pay of lieutenant, 951. 16s. 3d. a year." ______________ X. VITAL STATISTICS. HEALTH OF ENGLISH TOWNS. IN 76 of the largest English towns 8013 births and 4780 deaths were registered during the week ending April 25th. The annual rate of mortality in these towns, which had steadily declined in the four preceding weeks from 17’ 4 to 15’ 2 per 1000, was equal to 15’ 4 irn the week under notice. During the first four weeks of the current quarter the death-rate in these towns has averaged only 15’7 per 1000 ; the rate in London during the same period did not exceed 15’ 4. The lowest annual death-rates in the 76 towns during the week under notice were 6.7 in Hornsey, 7.3 in Willesden, 8’1 in Southampton, and 9’ 3 in King’s Norton; the rates in the other towns ranged upwards to 20’ 5 in Devonport, 20’ 9 in Oldham, 22.9 in Rochdale, and 23.5 in Stockton-on-Tees. The rate of mortality in London during the week did not exceed 15’ 4. The 4780 deaths in the 76 towns during the week showed an increase of 32 upon the low number returned in the previous week, and included 376 which were referred to the principal epidemic diseases, against numbers declining from 487 to 382 in the four preceding weeks ; of these, 138 resulted from whooping-cough, 101 from measles, 49 from diphtheria, 35 from diarrhoea, 32 from scarlet fever, and 21 from "fever" (principally enteric), but not one from small-pox. The deaths from these epidemic diseases were equal to an annual rate of 1.2 per 1000, corresponding with the rate in the previous week ; the rate from the same diseases in London was equal to 1 3. No death from any of these epidemic diseases was registered last week in Leicester, York, Aston Manor, Coventry, or in nine other smaller towns; the annual death-rates from these diseases, however, ranged upwards to 2’ 8 in Hudders- field, 3’ 0 in Smethwick and in Birkenhead, and 3’ 5 in Rochdale. The fatal cases of whooping-cough in the 76 towns, which had been 204, 150, and 134 in the three pre- ceding weeks, rose again to 138 in the week under notice; the highest death-rates from this disease in these towns last week were 2’ 0 in Sunderland and in Newport, 2.3 in Smethwick, and 2’ 6 in Devonport. The 101 deaths from measles were fewer by 26 than those in the previous week; they caused death-rates, however, equal to 1.1 in Salford and in Swansea, 1’ 3 in Birkenhead, and 1.8 both in Preston and in Rochdale. The deaths from diphtheria, which had been 53 and 39 in the two previous weeks, rose again to 49 last week. and included 13 in London, four in West and East Ham, two in Wolverhampton and in Walsall, four in Liverpool, five in Manchester and Salford, three in Hull, and two in Middlesbrough. The 32 fatal cases

Upload: duongdang

Post on 03-Jan-2017

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FROM THE LANCET, SATURDAY, May 1st, 1830. ON THE MEDICAL SERVICE OF THE EAST INDIA COMPANY

1300 LOOKING BACK.-VITAL STATISTICS.

Looking Back.FROM

THE LANCET, SATURDAY, May 1st, 1830.

ON THE MEDICAL SERVICE OF THE EASTINDIA COMPANY.

LETTER IV.lTo the Editor of THE LANCET.

SIR,-Before proceeding further in the consideration ofthe ultimate and sole recompense to medical officers of theEast India Company’s service, that is, their retiring pensions,it may be proper to mention the form of admission, at theIndia House, of recruits for this establishment, which is wellcalculated to deceive. It is this; that "assistant surgeonsare permitted to proceed to their respective presidencies,Calcutta, Madras, or Bombay, as the case may be, topractise as surgeons, and to be admitted on theestablishments as vacancies may occur." This form hasbeen observed for the last ten or twelve years. Topractise as surgeons, where ?-Upon whom ?-For what ? -The thing is quite absurd, and ridiculous ; and merely"ad captandum"-to deceive, by giving an idea that,independent of the high prospects which the Company’sservice holds out, money is to be made in India, even on

landing, by private practice ! 1 It is but fair, however, tomention, that, according to the present writer’s informa-tion, no one has hitherto been left to absolute starvation inthis way. Medical officers, shipped for India, in compliancewith requisitions to the Court of Directors from the several ipresidencies, have hitherto been wanted to fill up vacancies,occasioned by casualties, long before the period of their arrivalin India. At the presidencies, medical practice is in thehands of two or three Company’s surgeons. It is only at thePresidencies, that medical officers are paid for professionalattendance. At out-stations, a " honorarium," or fee, to themedical attendant, is seldom, if ever, dreamt of ; so that, onthe Madras establishment, at least, not above one surgeon inone hundred, after from twenty to thirty years’ service,happens to receive, in fees and presents, a sum equal to thepayment of his passage-money back to England, or 2,000rupees. Medical men are not prohibited from receivingpresents, or fees, in India, on account of professionalpractice ; but their patients (excepting at the Presidencies,or towns of Calcutta, Madras, or Bombay) must necessarilybe Compaiy’s servants ; and it is not obligatory on themto pay for medical advice and attendance ; whereas, theattendance of medical men, on all occasions, is obligatory,with or without a fee. Medical men never expect, it maybe said never accept, a remuneration from the military ;and civilians, who alone are able to pay them, very seldomthink any return for their assistance necessary. It hasbeen ruled, however, by the supreme government, and bythe subordinate governments, that it is the duty of everymedical man, to attend at the call of any personwithin his reach who may want his services, without feeor reward, and at his own expense for personal conveyance.Let it be understood that such unrequited summonses areoften frivolous, and at distances of upwards of fifty miles.Disobedience of these calls renders the surgeon liable to trialby court-martial; or to suffer by the more usual mode ofpunishing medical delinquents-marching them incessantlyabout the country to the most distant places, until they sinkunder fatigue, privation of every sort, despondency, and themalignant influence of the climate. From natives, whoseldom ask the help of an English surgeon, the complimentseldom exceeds a small present of fruit, or sweetmeats, afowl, or a lean goat, or sheep, and, on very extraordinaryoccasions, perhaps, a well-darned shawl, not worth 20 rupees, and which has been an heir-loom in the family for the best 1part of a century. So much for the practice of a surgeon inIndia....... Let us now see, by a comparative statement, in what pro-

portions the Honourable Company compensate and appreciatethe labours of their two classes of servants-soul-curers and ibody-curers.

1 Excerpts only have been transcribed.

Pay on Reti’l’ement."A chaplain, after eighteen years’ service in India,

including three years for one furlough," (that is, afterfifteen years’ actual residence in India), " is allowed to retireon the pay of lieutenant-colonel, 3651. per annum."

" A medical officer, after twenty years in India, includingthree years for one furlough," (that is, after seventeen years’service in India,) "is permitted to retire from the service onthe pay of captain, 1911. 12s. a year." After twenty andthirty years’ service in India, the same, 1911. 12s.

" A chaplain, if compelled to quit the service on accountof ill health, after ten years’ service in India, is allowed toretire on the half-pay of lieutenant-colonel, 200l. 15s. a year."A medical officer, if compelled to quit the service on

account of ill health, after ten years’ service in India, is (orrather was) permitted to retire on the half pay of lieutenant,731. ; after six years, on the half pay of ensign, 541. 15s.after thirteen, on the half pay of his rank, that of fall

surgeon, if fortunate, 1271. 15s. ; or of lieutenant, if thereverse, 73l.

-

" A chaplain, after seven years’ residence in India, isallowed to come home on furlough, and receive the pay ofmajor, 292l. a year ; should he come home from sicknessprior to this period, he is to receive the pay of captain only."

" A medical officer, after ten years’ service in India, isallowed to come home on furlough, and receive the pay oflieutenant, 951. 16s. 3d. a year."

______________

X.

VITAL STATISTICS.

HEALTH OF ENGLISH TOWNS.

IN 76 of the largest English towns 8013 births and 4780deaths were registered during the week ending April 25th.The annual rate of mortality in these towns, which hadsteadily declined in the four preceding weeks from 17’ 4 to15’ 2 per 1000, was equal to 15’ 4 irn the week undernotice. During the first four weeks of the current quarterthe death-rate in these towns has averaged only 15’7per 1000 ; the rate in London during the same period didnot exceed 15’ 4. The lowest annual death-rates in the76 towns during the week under notice were 6.7 inHornsey, 7.3 in Willesden, 8’1 in Southampton, and9’ 3 in King’s Norton; the rates in the other towns

ranged upwards to 20’ 5 in Devonport, 20’ 9 in Oldham,22.9 in Rochdale, and 23.5 in Stockton-on-Tees. The rateof mortality in London during the week did not exceed 15’ 4.The 4780 deaths in the 76 towns during the week showed anincrease of 32 upon the low number returned in the previousweek, and included 376 which were referred to the

principal epidemic diseases, against numbers declining from487 to 382 in the four preceding weeks ; of these, 138resulted from whooping-cough, 101 from measles, 49 fromdiphtheria, 35 from diarrhoea, 32 from scarlet fever, and 21from "fever" (principally enteric), but not one from

small-pox. The deaths from these epidemic diseases wereequal to an annual rate of 1.2 per 1000, correspondingwith the rate in the previous week ; the rate from thesame diseases in London was equal to 1 3. No deathfrom any of these epidemic diseases was registered lastweek in Leicester, York, Aston Manor, Coventry, or innine other smaller towns; the annual death-rates fromthese diseases, however, ranged upwards to 2’ 8 in Hudders-field, 3’ 0 in Smethwick and in Birkenhead, and 3’ 5 inRochdale. The fatal cases of whooping-cough in the 76towns, which had been 204, 150, and 134 in the three pre-ceding weeks, rose again to 138 in the week under notice;the highest death-rates from this disease in these towns lastweek were 2’ 0 in Sunderland and in Newport, 2.3 inSmethwick, and 2’ 6 in Devonport. The 101 deaths frommeasles were fewer by 26 than those in the previous week;they caused death-rates, however, equal to 1.1 in Salfordand in Swansea, 1’ 3 in Birkenhead, and 1.8 both in Prestonand in Rochdale. The deaths from diphtheria, whichhad been 53 and 39 in the two previous weeks, rose

again to 49 last week. and included 13 in London,four in West and East Ham, two in Wolverhampton andin Walsall, four in Liverpool, five in Manchester and Salford,three in Hull, and two in Middlesbrough. The 32 fatal cases