europe\'s bologna process
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
EUROPEAN HIGHER EDUCATION IN A CHANGING ENVIRONMENT – Impacts of the Bologna Process
Fiona HunterImmediate Past President, European Association for International Education (EAIE)International Director, Università Carlo Cattaneo - LIUC, ItalyMember of Bologna Experts’ Team, Italy
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 2
OUTLINE OF THE PRESENTATION
The way we were and the great leap forward
The emerging European Higher Education Area
Looking to the future – the road less travelled
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 3
THE WAY WE WERE
1980’s - First wave of internationalisation – intra-European co-operation and exchange
EC policy to stimulate education and research Erasmus – largest programme in the world
(1987-2003 one million students) Model for international exchange
From academic experimentation to integrated institutional approaches - foundations for change
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 4
THE GREAT LEAP FORWARD…
Bologna Process 2010 – building the European Higher Education Area drivers changes achievements ambitions implications
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 5
DRIVERS FOR CHANGE
European Challenges Integration Knowledge based economy Globalisation
Bologna Objectives Promote employability Facilitate cross border educational and
professional mobility Increase competitiveness
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 6
MOBILITY: KEY TO THE PROCESS “As the European Union progresses as a
knowledge-based society in a globalising world economy, we must work to boost further the mobility of workers and citizens. This is not only good for the economy, but also for society. Europe needs a mobile and flexible workforce for its future economic prosperity but mobility also breaks down barriers between Europeans, thereby helping to build a more cohesive European society.”
Jan Figel EU Commissioner for Education, Training, Culture and Youth
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 7
BOLOGNA PROCESS ACTION LINES
introduced in the Bologna Declaration 1999
1. Adoption of a system of easily readable and comparable degrees 2. Adoption of a system based on two cycles3. Establishment of a system of credits4. Promotion of mobility5. Promotion of European cooperation in quality assurance6. Promotion of European Dimension in Higher Education
introduced in the Prague communiqué 2001
7. Lifelong learning8. Involving Higher Education institutions and students9. Promoting the attractiveness of the EHEA
introduced in the Berlin Communiqué 2003
10. Doctoral studies and synergy between EHEA and ERA
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 8
DRIVING THE PROCESS FORWARD1998 - Sorbonne – 4 countries - harmonisation 1999 - Bologna – 30 countries - creation of European
Higher Education Area2001 - Prague – 33 countries - goals reconfirmed and
debate broadened2003 - Berlin – 40 countries - extension to doctoral
studies, measurable priorities, intermediate deadlines
2005 - Bergen – 46 countries - stocktaking and priorities – degree systems, quality assurance and recognition
2007 - London – 46 countries - commitment to progress and global strategy
2009 - Leuven/Louvain-La-Neuve – looking back, looking forward
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 9
EMERGING EUROPEAN HIGHER EDUCATION AREA Stretching from the Atlantic to the Pacific Single biggest educational reform ever
46 countries (so far) Over 4000 institutions and 31 million
students An initiative to restructure and harmonise
historically diverse systems Voluntary participation and jointly agreed
principles
Reflects a search for a common answer to common problems
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 10
CONVERGING SYSTEMS
Three key features:
1. Three cycles of easily readable and comparable degrees variety of content with similar structures and
comparable learning outcomes flexibility, employability, multidisciplinarity,
European dimension2. Compatible credit system - ECTS3. Co-operation in quality assurance
NOT an attempt at harmonisation/homogenisation but creating connections/convergence between diverse national educational systems
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 11
THE ACHIEVEMENTS: ENHANCING COMPARABILITY AND MOBILITY Reformed Higher Education Structures - Bachelors and
Masters – 83% 50% studying in reformed national programme
(Continental Europe) Doctoral reforms underway Widespread use of ECTS (75% transfer - 66%
accumulation) and Diploma Supplement (47%) European Quality Assurance Guidelines and Register European and National Qualifications Frameworks
Significant levels of interaction and co-operation at European, national and institutional level
Reforms happening at different speeds in different countries
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 12
QUESTION 1
Europe is undertaking major reform of its higher education systems to bring them into line with a changing global environment.
What commonalities and differences do you see with the Canadian approach?
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 13
NEW STRUCTURES AND TOOLS Three cycles – Bachelor Master
and Doctoral Credit System Qualifications Frameworks Quality assurance Recognition
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 14
FIRST CYCLE – BACHELOR LEVEL Common criteria 3-4 years/180-240 credits Access varies in different countries Shorter bachelor level more relevant to
(European) labour market, more flexible, more multidisciplinary
Access to second cycle Adopted in virtually all fields of study Traditional long first degree programmes
still offered in some countries in professional fields (EU directives)
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 15
SECOND CYCLE – MASTER LEVEL Common criteria – 1-2 years/60-180
credits Vast majority give access to doctoral
level New trend - vertical mobility Growth of English taught programmes
and European/international university consortia for double/joint degrees
Boosting global attractiveness
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 16
THIRD CYCLE – DOCTORAL STUDIES
Reforms currently underway Emphasis on doctoral schools –
European dimension, interface with industry, interdisciplinarity
New legislative frameworks for joint doctorates
EUA Council for Doctoral Education Boosting global competitiveness
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 17
CHALLENGES FROM EUA REPORT Co-existence of old and new
structures/practices Employability questions Academic vs professional qualifications Admission to first cycle and articulation
between cycles Range of institutional attitudes from those
who feel obliged to change to those who push for change
(Lack of) government support
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 18
TOOLS FOR TRANSPARENCY AND COMPARABILITY ECTS compatible systems for transfer and
accumulation introduced in the majority of countries …but still many misunderstandings
European Qualifications Framework – three cycles- credits - competences - outcomes…but lack of understanding and knowledge
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 19
TOOLS FOR TRANSPARENCY AND COMPARABILITY Lisbon Recognition Convention – vast
majority of countries have ratified … but procedures still cumbersome in some
countries
Diploma supplement for transparent and reliable information and fair academic and professional recognition introduced in most countries… but it is not fully understood… or used yet.
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 20
“INTERESTING” DS STATISTICS FROM EUA 3% of students say that all master
graduates receive the Diploma Supplement
44% of institutions say all master graduates receive it
20% of institutions don’t know it 25% of employers don’t know it 38% of academics don’t know it … and 56% of students don’t know
it…..
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 21
QUALITY ASSURANCE
Most countries have implemented a QA system
Common standards for internal and external QA and QA agencies
European register of QA agencies ….but a genuine quality culture still
to emerge www.qrossroads.eu
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 22
CHANGING ERASMUS MOBILITY PATTERNS Since 1987 1.7 million students 9 out of 10 HEIs 3.4% of graduates Target 3 million by 2012, growth of 8% Average 6.2% but strong variation and imbalances
across countries EU solutions – increased grants and better
recognition EU High level expert forum to extend reach of
mobility
Greater internal mobility for greater understanding and dialogue or greater educational efficiency and effectiveness?
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 23
CHALLENGES FOR CHALLENGES FOR INTERNATIONAL CO-INTERNATIONAL CO-OPERATIONOPERATION Transition phase
new names, structures, content
Shorter course duration and rigidity of curriculum
Shifting objectives English vs local language National legislation for tuition “the anglicisation of competitive labour market
oriented European graduate education?” (EUA)
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 24
OPPORTUNITIES FOR OPPORTUNITIES FOR INTERNATIONAL CO-OPERATIONINTERNATIONAL CO-OPERATION
Mobility encouraged at all levels of study New tools for new partnerships Greater institutional commitmentGreater institutional commitment Flexible curricula with mobility windowsFlexible curricula with mobility windows Careful choice of partners and programmesCareful choice of partners and programmes Creative “made to measure” solutionsCreative “made to measure” solutions Individual and institutional gainsIndividual and institutional gains
International co-operation as a competitive International co-operation as a competitive advantageadvantage
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 25
DOUBLE AND JOINT DEGREESDeveloping the European Dimension double degrees - two institutions award
own degree clearly defined, straightforward
administration, built in quality difference in content and workload for two
awards often unclear. joint degree - single document issued by
the institutions involved issues of legal validity and quality
assurance
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 26
ERASMUS MUNDUS
Model for double and joint degrees in Europe New EU flagship programme since 2004 Promotion of European Joint and Double
master degrees Attracting talented students from other parts
of the world 103 masters courses funded and some 6000
students and scholars supported so far New enlarged phase from 2009 to 2013 with
€900 million budget
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 27
QUESTION 2
Europe has developed new degree structures and tools for comparability and transparency to promote mobility.
How do you see these changes impacting on co-operation between Canada and Europe?
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 28
LISBON AGENDA 2000-2010
EU heads of state and government decide to make Europe by 2010:
“an advanced knowledge society with sustainable development, more and better jobs and greater social cohesion”
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 29
AMBITIONS OF AN ATTRACTIVE AND COMPETITIVE EUROPE
Harmonised structures Increasing use of English Study abroad opportunities Consortia offering double and joint degrees Erasmus Mundus Competitive fees Affordable and safe destinations
A European qualification as a gateway to Europe
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 30
THE AMBITIONS: CREATING THE EUROPEAN HE BRAND
Effective marketing strategy and coherent information policy required to promote advantages:
Lack of knowledge Little understanding of qualifications, institutions and
countries No perception of Europe as a HE destination Seen as “traditional” rather than “dynamic, innovative” Diversity of languages and cultures not necessarily an
asset Few universities with high visibility Lack of information on employment opportunities
ACA survey
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 31
THE AMBITIONS: “THE MOST FAVOURED DESTINATION OF STUDENTS AND SCHOLARS” Lack of information on international mobility Eurodata study - 2003 1.1 million foreign students - 6% of tertiary
population 50% from outside Eurodata region 6% Chinese, 4% Germans, Greeks, French, 2% US Highest proportion in Switzerland 17%, Austria 13,5%, Belgium 11,2% Largest countries UK 11.2%, Germany 10.7% and France 10.5% Less than 2% (Estonia, Italy, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia
and Turkey 575,000 Eurodata students registered outside region- 3% of total number Call for better data in London Communique Key Lisbon indicator for attractiveness
International student recruitment increasingly viewed by universities as a means to enhance institutional reputation and to generate income
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 32
INTERNATIONAL PROMOTION AND VISIBILITY Institutional – no overview available as yet National campaigns– developing brand, websites, events,
media campaigns, information offices, recruitment agents, market research but very unevenly distributed
European - global promotion project funded by EU - web portal
Feasibility study for European information offices, network of promoters, study on European TNE presence, training, tool kits, fairs, media campaign, information and promotion materials
8 European Higher Education Fairs in 7 Asian countriesACA survey
Greater visibility than 10 years ago but still much to be done
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 33
Welcome to Study in Europewww. study-in-europe.org, There are more than four thousand higher education
institutions in Europe, from top-level research establishments to small, teaching-focused colleges. Europe itself is no less diverse, extending from the Arctic Circle to the coast of Africa, where tiny principalities sit side-by-side with many of the world’s leading economies.
A fascinating destination, but which country should you go to? Which university should you choose? What do you need before you leave? What will happen when you arrive? These are just some of the questions you’re probably asking yourself already.
Study in Europe is here to help. We provide up-to-date information on thirty two European countries, their universities and what it takes to live and study in them.
Use Study in Europe to find the university that suits you best. A well-informed decision will make your time abroad even more valuable.
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 34
SHIFTING STRATEGIES
Internationalising the curriculum, programmes, teaching and learning strategies
Creating international research focus and collaborations
Attracting international talent Providing cross border education Setting up business linkages Developing commercial contracts
From ad hoc activities to integrated strategies and processes
From bilateral agreements to strategic partnershipsNew internationalisation in response to new challenges
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 35
EUROPE AS A GLOBAL PLAYER Co-operation and competition in the global
market place External dimension increasingly important Information and promotion of brand Partnership with other world regions (policy
dialogue) Converging models –Bologna as soft model
for domestic reformsLondon Conference placed Bologna in a global
setting
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 36
QUESTION 3
The EHEA is increasingly taking on a global dimension.
Is Europe creating new initiatives/soft standards for the world and to what extent will this impact on Canada as an international study destination?
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 37
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE – THE ROAD LESS TRAVELLED Bologna has put the wheels of change in motion
and commitment to a new vision beyond 2010 is a positive sign
Build on Bologna successes for a more ambitious reform agenda
European Higher education is ill-equipped to face the changes ahead – it is fragmented, over regulated and under funded
Emerging issues Funding and fees, public and private roles of
education, greater autonomy and accountability, regulation and competition, organisational governance and professional management
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 38
PRESSURES TO MODERNISE Increase mobility within and from outside Europe Improve academic quality / be more responsive to
labour market providing graduates with more employable skills
Provide compatible curricula across Europe / maintain cultural diversity
Be more local, regional, European, global Be more competitive / be more socially inclusive Increase & widen participation Concentrate on research / respond to regional needs
and do all of above with decreasing public funding...European University
Association
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 39
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE – THE FUNDING DEBATEThe debates Who pays for higher education? Average student fees in EU
Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Finland, Iceland, Greece, Ireland, Poland €0
Portugal, France, Hungary, Germany €350-500 Belgium, Spain, Austria, Italy €800-1000 Netherlands €1500 UK £3000
Differential fees and support systems Alternative funding models
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 40
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE – FURTHER DEBATES The debates Who drives curricular reform?
Universities or stakeholders? Who governs the institutions?
Issues of autonomy and accountability Who has access to higher education?
Social dimension, lifelong learning, admissions Differentiation of institutions
What role for universities? Balancing tensions – attractive and competitive vs
socially responsible and democratic
Building the Europe of Knowledge
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 41
THE GLOBAL DIMENSION
“One of the greatest strengths of the Bologna Process is that governments have joined forces with institutions of higher education and their national and European associations. A successful Global Dimension Strategy must be based on the same model.”
Global Dimension Strategy, London Ministerial Meeting 2007
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 42
WORDS OF WARNING FROM THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION “Within the next 20 years, Europe’s economic
paradigm will change fundamentally. Its manufacturing base will continue to shrink, future growth and social welfare will rely increasingly on knowledge-intensive industries and services, and ever more jobs will require a higher education qualification. Yet European universities, motors of the new, knowledge-based paradigm, are not in a position to deliver their full potential contribution to the re-launched Lisbon strategy.”
Mobilising the brainpower of Europe: enabling universities to make their full contribution to the Lisbon Strategy, European Commission 2005
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 43
SOME STARK STATISTICS
21% of working age population attaining tertiary education (US 38%)
6 million (18-24 year olds) have left education prematurely – to reach 10% benchmark, 2 million need to continue
1.1% GDP on HE (US 2.7%) – need to spend extra €150 billion per year to match US
1.9% GDP on research (US 3%) – higher research investment from industry
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 44
NEW WAYS FORWARD FOR EUROPEAN UNIVERSITIES Strategic international inter-university
alliances Stronger collaboration with employers for
curriculum reform and design Closer collaboration with industry for research Greater investment in human resources and
technology Commitment to lifelong learning Greater institutional autonomy, openness
and flexibility
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 45
A NEW POLICY APPROACH FOR BOLOGNA Funded Bologna: balance between public, business
and private Cyber Bologna: investment paramount for access to
information Quality Bologna: crucial for mobility and credit transfer Communicating Bologna; information and promotion
of the brand Lifelong Bologna: incentivised and promoted, more
part time study Skilled Bologna: wider access for people with low skills
levels Virtual Bologna: virtual environments for teaching and
research beyond borders of university or countryBrenda Gourley, Vice Chancellor Open University, London 2007
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 46
BOLOGNA PROCESS 2009
The next Ministerial Conference of the Bologna Process will be hosted by the Benelux countries on 28-29 April 2009 in Leuven and Louvain-la-Neuve (Belgium).
www.ond.vlaanderen.be/hogeronderwijs/bologna/
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 47
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE – THE ROAD LESS TRAVELLED
Internationalisation is the road that in 2020 will “have made all the difference.”
CBIE Conference, St.Johns, Canada 2nd November 2008 48
QUESTION 4
The 2009 Ministerial Meeting will look forward to the post 2010 scenario and a new process for change.
Should this be a pan-European effort or should universities be left to develop on their own? Does Canada have examples of best practice for Europe?