emergency salvage and restoration of the pillar coral ... · 1.department of environment, cayman...

1
Tammi Warrender 1 *, William F Precht 2 , Jeremy Olynik 1 , Cody Panton 1. , Aaron Hunt 3 , Robert Walton 1 , Paul Chin 1 , Ivan Montieth 1 , John Bothwell 1 & Timothy Austin 1 1.Department of Environment, Cayman Islands Government 2. Dial Cord and Associates Inc., Miami, Florida 3. Grand Cayman Eco Divers Emergency salvage and restoration of the pillar coral, Dendrogyra cylindrus in response to a catastrophic disease outbreak in the Cayman Islands 1. Placing silicone tape around the pillar directly above the active disease band (1) 2. Applying quick-setting, two-part underwater epoxy directly to the active disease band (2) 3. Creating a trench (3) above the active disease band and smothering the disease band and filling void with chlorinated-epoxy. 4. Healthy tissue fragments were removed from 4 individual pillars and dipped in povidone iodine + seawater solutions (4a) before hanging on a nursery structure (4b) 5. Salvaging 16 healthy portions of individual pillars and relocating to a new location away from the disease site. Reattached directly to the reef using Portland type II cement (5) Silicone tape (1) and epoxy (2) proved unsuccessful for mitigating disease spread, one month post treatment. Trenching and chlorinated epoxy (3) method has been successful showing no signs of active disease on two individual pillars, two months post treatment. Based upon preliminary results, it appears that three out of five methods have shown moderately successful results. Trenching and chlorinated-epoxy offers a less invasive technique to limit disease virulence while rapid removal and relocation has additional merit for isolation and propagation of healthy coral tissue. If longer-term monitoring results prove equally successful, the salvage, relocation and restoration of actively diseased coral colonies could become an everyday tool in the restoration toolbox for coral reef managers. BACKGROUND & MOTIVATION METHODS CONCLUSIONS RESULTS: PHYSICAL BARRIER Acknowledgements: Many thanks to the Cayman Islands, Department of Environment for boat usage and equipment, to Cayman Eco Divers for assistance during coral nursery and dipping experiment and to Karen Neely for advice on pillar trenching. RESULTS: TRANSPLANTATION & FRAGMENTATION 1 2 3 4a 4b 5 1 2 3 4 5a 5b Nursery and dipping experimentation has shown 100% initial survivorship and minor disease presence, three months post treatment. White-plague on nursery nubbin (4). The salvaging effort demonstrated 81% survival of transplants (5a), 23% of which have signs of white- plague disease (5b) after five months. Accidental contamination during Extraction 2 may account for lower health status within that sample and suggests direct transmission is a likely vector for this disease. In February 2018, coral disease was observed at the Killer Pillar dive site in the Seven Mile Beach Marine Park, Grand Cayman. By June 2018, nine individual colonies of Dendrogyra cylindrus were infected by a combination of black-band and white-plague coral disease. Within a few months, the disease had spread rapidly both within and between colonies of D. cylindrus leading to high levels of partial mortality and morbidity of the infected colonies. Because this charismatic coral is rare, and based on the rapid and catastrophic losses (~99%) of D. cylindrus in Florida from 2014- 2017 to a similar combination of diseases, it was determined that rapid intervention was warranted. Map Location of diseased colonies Monitor progression of the disease through time and space. Map Out-plants

Upload: others

Post on 18-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Emergency salvage and restoration of the pillar coral ... · 1.Department of Environment, Cayman Islands Government 2. Dial Cord and Associates Inc., Miami, Florida 3. Grand Cayman

Tammi Warrender1*, William F Precht2, Jeremy Olynik1, Cody Panton1., Aaron Hunt3, Robert Walton1, Paul Chin1, Ivan Montieth1, John Bothwell1 & Timothy Austin1

1.Department of Environment, Cayman Islands Government 2. Dial Cord and Associates Inc., Miami, Florida 3. Grand Cayman Eco Divers

Emergency salvage and restoration of the pillar coral, Dendrogyra cylindrus in response to a catastrophic disease outbreak in the Cayman Islands

1. Placing silicone tape around the pillar directly above the active disease band (1)

2. Applying quick-setting, two-part underwater epoxy directly to the active disease band (2)

3. Creating a trench (3) above the active disease band and smothering the disease band and filling void with chlorinated-epoxy.

4. Healthy tissue fragments were removed from 4 individual pillars and dipped in povidoneiodine + seawater solutions (4a) before hanging on a nursery structure (4b)

5. Salvaging 16 healthy portions of individual pillars and relocating to a new location away fromthe disease site. Reattached directly to the reef using Portland type II cement (5)

Silicone tape (1) and epoxy (2) proved unsuccessful for

mitigating disease spread, one month post treatment.

Trenching and chlorinated epoxy (3) method has been

successful showing no signs of active disease on two

individual pillars, two months post treatment.

Based upon preliminary results, it appears that three out of five methods have shown

moderately successful results. Trenching and chlorinated-epoxy offers a less invasive technique

to limit disease virulence while rapid removal and relocation has additional merit for isolation

and propagation of healthy coral tissue.

If longer-term monitoring results prove equally successful, the salvage, relocation and

restoration of actively diseased coral colonies could become an everyday tool in the

restoration toolbox for coral reef managers.

BACKGROUND & MOTIVATION

METHODS

CONCLUSIONS

RESULTS: PHYSICAL BARRIER

Acknowledgements: Many thanks to the Cayman Islands, Department of Environment for boat usage and equipment, to Cayman Eco Divers for assistance during coral nursery and dipping experiment and to Karen Neely for advice on pillar trenching.

RESULTS: TRANSPLANTATION & FRAGMENTATION

1 2 3 4a 4b 5

1 2 3

4 5a 5b Nursery and dipping experimentation has shown 100%

initial survivorship and minor disease presence, three

months post treatment. White-plague on nursery

nubbin (4).

The salvaging effort demonstrated 81% survival of

transplants (5a), 23% of which have signs of white-

plague disease (5b) after five months. Accidental

contamination during Extraction 2 may account for

lower health status within that sample and suggests

direct transmission is a likely vector for this disease.

In February 2018, coral disease was observed at the Killer Pillar dive site inthe Seven Mile Beach Marine Park, Grand Cayman. By June 2018, nineindividual colonies of Dendrogyra cylindrus were infected by a combinationof black-band and white-plague coral disease. Within a few months, thedisease had spread rapidly both within and between colonies of D.cylindrus leading to high levels of partial mortality and morbidity of theinfected colonies. Because this charismatic coral is rare, and based on therapid and catastrophic losses (~99%) of D. cylindrus in Florida from 2014-2017 to a similar combination of diseases, it was determined that rapidintervention was warranted.

Map Location of

diseased colonies

Monitor progression of the disease through time and space.

Map

Out-plants