Download - Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
1/72
Wrigley Field Gameday OperationsTraffic Management Plan
Prepared for the Chicago Cubs
July 15, 2013
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
2/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
1.Executive SummaryThe unique, urban location of Wrigley Field offers numerous benefits to the residents and businesses of
Lakeview. Located in the heart of the thriving North Side neighborhood, the Friendly Confines provides
many advantages by bringing potential customers to area businesses and highlighting the neighborhood to
a worldwide audience, many of whom come to visit to tour the ballpark even on non-game days. The
presence of Wrigley Field is highlighted by real estate professionals who have named the community
Wrigleyville to honor the home of the Cubs and to help give the area a unique identity which hasbecome synonymous with one of the most attractive places to live in all Chicago. Wrigley Field offers a
world class venue to residents who enjoy baseball, music and other events.
Wrigley Field is also unique among major league stadiums and arenas with respect to transportation.
Almost every other professional sports ballpark and venue in the United States is situated amid an
abundance of parking and in close proximity to interstate highways; Wrigley Field is neither. Both the
Cubs and the neighborhood have thrived over the years by managing traffic and parking congestion. Oneof the reasons for this is the many fans who choose not to drive to Wrigley Field because of their
knowledge of the relative absence of parking around the ballpark. By adopting the recommendations in
this report, traffic management can be enhanced and the ballpark and currently-proposed development can
thrive without additional adverse traffic impact on the community.
This traffic and management plan was conducted by Sam Schwartz Engineering (SSE) for the Chicago
Cubs. The study was compiled with input from the Chicago Department of Transportation (CDOT), the
Office of Emergency Management and Communication (OEMC), the Chicago Transit Authority (CTA),
Pace and neighborhood expertise, including Chester Kropidlowski who has decades of experience in
Wrigley Field traffic operations. We thank all those who helped for their input.
The Cubs can reduce the impact on the neighborhoods traffic and parking system in two ways: (1) by
reducing the number of fans who drive and park at the game; and, (2) by reducing the amount of time fans
who are driving remain in the neighborhood.
This plan addresses the existing gameday traffic and parking operations at Wrigley Field, as well as new
strategies to encourage more ticket holders to use the existing Remote Parking facility and take transit.
The Cubs have committed to reviewing this plan with CDOT on an annual basis.
The following are the primary conclusions of the traffic management plan:
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
3/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
The Cubs can increase the manner in which they encourage fans to take transit to games insteadof driving. For those fans who do drive, Cubs can offer parking solutions online and at the time of
ticket purchase to reduce the amount of driving through the neighborhood looking for parking.
There will always be traffic congestion around Wrigley Field during Cubs games. Understanding the
issues is important and helps to isolate which hours and traffic patterns pose the greatest challenge.
Implementing the suggestions in this study offers an approach to help move traffic and people out of the
neighborhood more quickly.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
4/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
2.IntroductionWrigley Field is unique in comparison to other sporting venues both around the country and in Chicago in
part because of its urban setting and context. Wrigley Field is nestled tightly into a single block in a
neighborhood of residences and small businesses. Unlike the United Center or U.S. Cellular Field, both of
which are surrounded by vast tracts of parking (often provided to the team with public assistance),
Wrigley Field incorporates parking provided officially by the Cubs with public street parking, neighbors
who sell their garage space to fans as a means of earning income and other surface parking also used bybars, restaurants, and rooftop businesses. The Cubs own or operate approximately 1205 parking spaces in
the blocks immediately adjacent to the ballpark for season ticket holders, staff and the press, including
200 spaces leased from the Chicago Park District in a lot at Challenger Park approximately half a mile
north of the ballpark and other spaces leased from private operators such as the Vic Parking lot at
Belmont and Sheffield. A description of the parking supply owned and operated by the Cubs is included
in Page 13. To further reduce the physical footprint related to the ballpark and accommodate for the
crowds it draws, the Cubs make available to fans remote parking spaces using existing lots on the DeVryUniversity campus, approximately two miles west of the ballpark. Overall, there are an estimated 5,300
off-street parking spaces available in the community to Cubs fans. It is estimated sold-out games generate
anywhere between 4,500 to 5,300 vehicles1, mainly from the north and northwest suburbs. Concerts and
other special events typically generate less.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
5/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
3.Existing ConditionsThe traffic and parking conditions at Wrigley Field are unlike those at US Cellular Field, the United
Center or any other ballpark in Major League Baseball. Though it lacks an abundance of parking lots or
access to an interstate highway, Wrigley Field is well-situated with respect to the CTA Red Line and is
located in one of the densest neighborhoods in Chicago, allowing people to walk and bike to the venue.
The neighborhood has thrived for years with this volume of traffic and a significant amount of
development has occurred over the last decade.
The most stressful time for traffic congestion in the community is the weekday evening rush hour. This
recognition leads to a number of conclusions, supported by the data on the pages which follow:
a. Arrival times for daytime events do not pose a significant traffic problem in the community.Because fans do not arrive during rush hour and most residents are at work, fans are able to
access the ballpark and the community without posing significant traffic management issues.
b. Exiting from nighttime events does not pose a significant traffic problem in the community.Because fans leave well into the evening when most residents are home and not driving, fans
are able to depart the community without posing significant traffic management issues.
c. Weekend events, whether daytime or nighttime, do not pose a significant traffic problem inthe community. Fans are able to arrive and depart the community without posing significant
traffic management issues. Weekend events should not impact theaters or other businesses in
the neighborhood, each of which is assumed to have its own traffic and parking management
solution.
The primary issue for traffic management related to Wrigley Field events, therefore, is when those events
coincide with weekday evening rush hour traffic. This section of the report provides an overview of
existing transportation conditions around Wrigley Field, analysis and observations of the existing
transportation conditions and recommendations to improve the existing situation.
Transit
Wrigley Field is very well served by the regions transit system which is why so many people use public
transportation to get to Cubs games. The most recent prior survey on Cubs fans travel patterns to Wrigley
Field was conducted in 2001 by Siim Soot and estimated approximately 31% of fans used CTA Rail to
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
6/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
The CTA Red Line, which runs between Howard Avenue and 95 th Street, has a station at Addison
Street and is well-used by both residents and fans accessing Wrigley Field. In 2012, more than
3,000,000 people entered the Addison Red Line Station, making it one of the busiest in the City.
Before weekday night games, southbound Purple Line Express trains stop at the Sheridan station,
which is north of Wrigley Field. After games, CTA provides additional staff in the Addison Station to
assist with ticketing and platform loading.
CTA Buses
There are two bus routes, Route 22 (Clark) and Route 152 (Addison), which run adjacent to WrigleyField. A number of additional bus routes are within mile of Wrigley Field. A map of all the CTA
buses is shown in Figure 1.
Pace Express
To provide direct connections between the suburbs and Wrigley Field, Pace provides two Wrigley
Field Express Routes: Route 282, which runs between the Northwest Transportation Center in
Schaumburg and Wrigley Field, and Route 779, which runs between Yorktown Shopping Center in
Lombard and Wrigley Field. Fans are able to park for free at these locations and it costs $4 to ride the
service in each direction. Paces website provides an excellent instructional video on how to use the
service. Exhibit 1 shows the ridership on each route over the last five years and the annual
attendance.
Exhibit 1
Pace Express Ridership Last Five Years
YearRoute 282
(Schaumburg)
Route 779
(Lombard)Total
Annual
Attendance
Ridership
per 10,000
fans
2012 22,711 11,491 34,202 2,882,756 118.64
2011 25,797 14,662 40,459 3,017,966 134.06
2010 25,797 14,661 40,458 3,062,973 132.09
2009 25,741 13,052 38,793 3,168,859 122.42
2008 - - 45,516 3,330,200 136.68
The Cubs service is the most popular sports service Pace runs and the fares cover approximately 50%
of the operating costs of the service. Paces Six Flags service is the only service which covers a
higher percent of operating costs.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
7/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Counties and the closest stop to Wrigley Field is Clybourn, located at 1900 N Ashland Avenue,
approximately 3.6 miles south of Wrigley Field.
One challenge of getting fans to take Metra to the game is Metra runs on a fixed schedule and Cubs
games do not. This can force a fan into the decision to leave a game early to catch a train or watch the
entire game and possibly have to wait at the train station for more than an hour. Exhibit 2 shows the
Metra schedule for each of the existing start/end times for Cubs games.
The Cubs experimented with a shuttle between the UP-N station and Wrigley Field, but disbanded theservice due to low ridership.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
8/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Exhibit 2
Metra Schedules
Gameday and Start Time Metra Line ArrivalDepartur
e
Weekday Day Game, 1:10 PM Start Time, 4:10 Estimated End
Time
UP-N (Ravenswood)
11:10
AM3:33 PM
1:10 PM 3:45 PM
4:48 PM
5:15 PM
5:27 PM
5:34 PM5:49 PM
UP-NW (Clybourn)
11:12
AM3:33 PM
12:12 PM 4:13 PM
1:22 PM 4:48 PM
4:54 PM
4:57 PM
5:06 PM
5:15 PM
5:29 PM5:32 PM
5:41 PM
5:56 PM
Weekday Night Game, 7:05PM Start Time, 10:05 Estimated End
Time
UP-N (Ravenswood)
5:15 PM 8:48 PM
5:53 PM 9:48 PM
6:12 PM 10:48 PM
6:29 PM 11:48 PM
7:19 PM
UP-NW (Clybourn)
5:27 PM 8:38 PM
6:12 PM 9:38 PM
6:46 PM 10:39 PM
7:12 PM 11:38 PM
Saturday Afternoon Game, 1:10 PM Start Time, 4:10 Estimated
End Time
UP-N (Ravenswood)
11:10
AM3:47 PM
1:10 PM 4:48 PM
5:49 PM
5:58 PM
UP-NW (Clybourn)
11:12 PM 3:38 PM
12:12 PM 4:38 PM
1:12 PM 5:38 PM
Sunday Afternoon Game, 1:10 PM Start Time, 4:10 Estimated
End Time
UP-N (Ravenswood)12:10 PM 4:43 PM
1:10 PM 5:43 PM
UP-NW (Clybourn) 12:12 PM 4:30 PM
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
9/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Remote Parking
The Cubs operate a Remote Parking facility at DeVry University near Addison Street and Rockwell
Avenue (west of Western Avenue) for all weekend and night games. The cost to use this service is
currently $6.00 and includes a round trip on the CTA 154 Route which runs direct between Wrigley
Field and DeVry University. Post-game, passengers board the bus on the east side of Clark Street,
north of Addison Street. The 154 routes start running two and a half hours before the game and runs
one hour after night games and two hours after weekend day games. The number of cars and fans who
have used the Remote Parking facility over the last five years is shown in Exhibit 3. The Cubs took
over operation of the lot from the City of Chicago in 2004 and as the information in Exhibit 3 shows,use of the lot has increased dramatically under Cubs leadership.
Exhibit 3
Number of Cars and Fans that Used Remote Parking Facility
YearCars Using Remote
Parking
Fans Using Remote
Parking
Annual
Attendance
Fans Using
Remote
Parking per
10,000
Attendance
2012 15,000 40,000 2,882,756 138.76
2011 16,997 46,109 3,017,966 152.78
2010 19,250 52,854 3,062,973 172.56
2009 20,761 54,952 3,168,859 173.41
2008 22,083 57,121 3,330,200 171.52
2004 11,421 30,745 3,170,184 96.98
2001 2,963 7,661 2,780,465 27.55
Remote parking increases at a higher rate as attendance gets higher, since the price of parking around
the stadium increases during these times as well. If parking is cheap because of low attendance, it
reduces the incentive to use the remote lot.
Bicycling
To encourage fans to bicycle to Wrigley Field, the Cubs provide a free bike valet service which
allows fans to securely store their bike during the game. It is located on the south side of Waveland
Avenue, between Clark Street and Wrigley Field. It is sponsored by SRAM and World Bicycle
Relief. The bike valet service is open two hours before the game and closes one hour after the game.
Th l f th bik l t i i h i E hibit 4
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
10/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Exhibit 4
Annual Usage of Bike Valet Service
Year BikesAnnual
Attendance
2012 5,000 2,882,756
2011 6,063 3,017,966
2010 8,568 3,062,973
2009 20,761 3,168,859
2008 10,238 3,330,200
In addition to the free service, many fans bicycle to the ballpark and lock their bikes to one of the
many area bike racks offered by the Cubs and the City. For example, self lock bike racks are provided
on the southeast corner of the intersection of Clark Street and Waveland Avenue and it is typically at
capacity during Cubs games.
The City of Chicago will be launching a bike share program in the summer of 2013. It is anticipatedthere will be a number of bike share stations in close proximity to Wrigley Field.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
11/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Vehicular Traffic
While there are many options to access Wrigley Field, some fans clearly prefer to drive and continueto seek parking near the ballpark. This section discusses traffic conditions in and around the ballpark.
Street Network
The existing street network is shown in Figure 2 and identifies one-way streets and traffic signal
locations.
Clark StreetClark Street is a two-lane, northwest/southeast street adjacent to the west side of Wrigley Field. It is
signalized at its intersections with Irving Park Road, Addison Street and Sheffield Avenue/Newport
Avenue. It is under all-way stop control at its intersection with Waveland Avenue, Roscoe Avenue,
and School Street. A buffer protected bike lane is provided on Clark Street, south of Addison Street,
and a marked shared bike lane is provided on Clark Street, north of Addison Street. Clark Street is
under the jurisdiction of CDOT.
Addison Street
Addison Street is a two-lane, east/west street adjacent to the south side of Wrigley Field. Addison
Street is signalized at its intersections with Racine Avenue, Clark Street and Sheffield Avenue. It is
under the jurisdiction of CDOT.
Irving Park Road
Irving Park Road is a major east/west arterial roadway connecting to both Lake Shore Drive and
Interstate 90/94. In the area of Clark Street, Irving Park Road provides one lane of travel in eachdirection and a center left-turn lane, though parking is prohibited on the north side of Irving ParkRoad after games to allow for two travel lanes, between Clark Street and Southport Avenue. To the
west of Southport Avenue, the westbound direction of Irving Park Road is striped to provide two
travel lanes. To the west of Ashland Avenue, the road widens to provide two lanes of travel in each
direction and a center left-turn lane/median. Irving Park Road is under the jurisdiction of the Illinois
Department of Transportation (IDOT).
Waveland Avenue
Waveland Avenue is a two-lane, east/west street adjacent to the north side of Wrigley Field. It is
under the jurisdiction of CDOT.
Sheffield Avenue
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
12/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Charter buses drop-off passengers on the south side of Waveland Avenue before a game. On-street
space is provided for charter buses to stage during the game on both sides of Irving Park Road,between Clark Street and Seminary Avenue and on the east side of Clark Street, between Byron Street
and south of Irving Park Road. After games, charter buses pick up passengers on the south side of
Waveland Avenue and the west side of Sheffield Avenue.
Taxis
Taxis are popular around Wrigley Field at all times, but particularly on event days. Taxi drivers
typically want to drop-off and pick-up passengers as close to Wrigley Field as possible. Taxi cabstands were experimented with in the past, but were not successful because taxi drivers felt they were
too far away from Wrigley Field and fans exiting from gates distant from the taxi stand preferred to
and did - hail cabs on the nearest street.
Limousines
Limousines are seen fairly infrequently during most Cubs games, but their use picks up significantly
for concerts. Neighbors have raised one primary issue regarding limousines: limousines illegally
parking (double parking or parking in No Parking Zones) on residential streets as they wait for the
concert to end. In most cases, the driver remains with the parked vehicle.
Parking
There are a number of options for parking in the area around Wrigley Field:
Off-street parking
The Cubs currently own or lease and operate nine parking lots, including one at Challenger Parkowned by the Chicago Park District. A description of each parking lot is listed below:
Red Lot: The Red Lot is located directly adjacent to Wrigley Field and has a capacity of 68parking spaces.
Blue Lot: The Blue Lot is located on the west side of Seminary Avenue, between Grace Streetand Waveland Avenue and has a capacity of 150 parking spaces.
Purple Lot: The Purple lot is located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Clark Streetand Waveland Avenue and has a capacity of 73 parking spaces.
Orange Lot: The Orange lot is located on east side of Clark Street just north of Grace Street and
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
13/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Brown Lot: The Brown lot is located on Eddy Street, just east of Racine Avenue and has acapacity of 200 parking spaces.
Gold Lot: The Gold lot is located on the northeast corner of the intersection of Clifton Avenueand Waveland Avenue and has a capacity of 48 parking spaces.
McDonalds Lot: The McDonalds lot is located on the northwest corner of the intersection ClarkStreet and Addison Street and has an estimated capacity of 35 parking spaces.
Challenger Park: The Challenger Park parking lot is located on the north side of Irving ParkRoad, directly under the CTA rail tracks and has a capacity of 200 parking spaces.
A map of the parking lots is shown in Figure 3.
Parking at Cubs-operated lots can be purchased in advance of the game by calling the Cubs. Many
lots also offer cash parking on game days when the lot is not otherwise filled.
In addition to the parking provided by the Cubs, there are a number of privately-owned surface and
structure parking lots which offer gameday parking. Exhibit 5 lists a number of these lots as well as
their estimated capacities. This number has diminished in recent years as surface parking lots have
been developed and replaced with commercial businesses, such as some of the new bars and
restaurants along Clark Street.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
14/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Exhibit 5
Existing Private Off-Street Parking SupplyAddress Parking Supply
801 W Addison St 12
808 W Addison St 122
835 W Addison St 27
932 W Addison St 22
1015-1023 W Addison St 80
1109 W Addison St 74
1110 W Addison St 74
1111 W Addison St 58
1150 W Addison St 14
2848 N Broadway Ave 125
3012 N Broadway 70
3114 N Broadway 27
3115 N Broadway 80
3157 N Broadway 76
3440 N Broadway Ave 139
3901 N Broadway Ave 18
2836 N Clark St 427
3134 N Clark St 102
3211 N Clark St 38
3310 N Clark St 12
3427 N Clark St 28
3455 N Clark St 26
3458 N Clark St 32
3650 N Clark St 58
3701 N Clark St 31
3745 N Clark St 75
3848 N Clark St 23
3701-3709 N Clifton Ave 37
635 W Grace St 180
3514-3522 N Halsted St 53
3532 N Halsted St 15
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
15/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
832 W Sheridan Rd 20
851 W Waveland Ave 49
1141 W Waveland Ave 17
Total 2890
The pricing of off-street parking in 2013 during events varies between $10 and $50, depending on the day
of the event and location of the lot.
In addition to parking spaces provided by the Cubs and private operators, many residents and businessessell individual parking spaces. This is not licensed and the City of Chicago does not receive taxes on these
purchases. This market seemingly changes on a daily basis, so it is difficult to estimate the precise
number of spaces available, but based on our observations we estimate between 200 and 400 additional
spaces per game.
Pre-paid parking helps reduce traffic in the community by reducing the travel time and transaction costs
as fans circle neighborhood streets looking for an open parking lot and then often try to negotiate a price
with a community resident selling his or her garage. At least two companies, ParkWhiz and SpotHero,
maintain relationships with parking owners in the community and allow fans to purchase parking online
before the game. This reduces over-circulation, which is the driving when fans are looking for parking.
On-street parking
While fans who drive to Wrigley Field are strongly encouraged to use the Remote Parking facility or to
pay for parking at one of the Cubs or privately-owned facilities, some park on residential streets when
such parking is permitted by law. The following provisions are in place related to residential street
parking:
Vehicles without a Zone 383 permit are prohibited from parking from 6 PM to 6 AM in the areabounded by Irving Park Road to the north, Belmont Avenue to the south, Ashland Avenue to the
west and Broadway Avenue to the east. Vehicles parking in this area without a permit during a
night game can be towed. It is legal to park in these areas during day games.
Vehicles without a Zone 383 permit are prohibited from parking any time on segments of CliftonStreet, Seminary Avenue, Kenmore Avenue, Wilton Avenue and Fremont Street.
Vehicles without an LV2 permit are prohibited from parking in the areas generally bounded byMontrose Avenue to the north, Irving Park Road to the south, Ashland Avenue to the west and
Clark Street to the east and in the area bounded by Irving Park Road to the north, Roscoe Street to
the south Ravenswood Avenue to the west and Ashland Avenue to the east
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
16/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
issuance of parking tickets is handled by the Chicago Police Detail Unit, the Department of Revenue and
the 19th Police District.
Night baseball parking enforcement activities are coordinated at the Wrigley Field Police Command
Center in the 19th District Police Station at 850 W. Addison. The Command Center was previously
located in the Cubs-owned Brown lot at 1140 W. Eddy.
Towing enforcement actions for night baseball resident parking violations are initiated as a result of any
one of the following: A citizen request to the night baseball telephone hotline 1-866-4CPD-TOW. A request from an involved Aldermans office (32nd, 44th, 46th, 47th Wards). Police designated street surveys for parking violators in one of two designated zones which rotate
on a game-by-game basis.
o Zone 1 is the area bounded by and including Grace Street on the north, Belmont Avenue onthe south, Racine Avenue on the east and Ashland Avenue on the west.
o Zone 2 is the area bounded by and including Grace Street on the north, Belmont Avenue onsouth, Halsted Street on the east and Racine Avenue on the west.
The Zone not enforced as part of the towing operation is enforced with parking violation
enforcement by Parking Enforcement Aides of the Department of Revenue.
Vehicles towed as a result of any enforcement action are towed to Auto Pound #6 at 701 N. Sacramento
(773) 265-7605. It will cost, at minimum, $160.00 to retrieve a vehicle. A citizen can check to see iftheir car has been towed by calling 311.
The Cubs have helped greatly in this effort by sponsoring a hot line for neighbors to call to report traffic
and parking violations. Few calls have been reported to the hot line on an annual basis.
SSE conducted spot counts and observations of residential parking during evening games and did not find
many vehicles parked without a residential permit. Many vehicles were parked with guest permits. Thesecould be legitimate guests of residents in the neighborhood or these passes could have been provided by
residents to ticket holders.
A map of the existing parking restrictions is shown in Figure 4.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
17/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Existing Traffic Counts
To quantify the operations in the study, both on gamedays and non-gameday, traffic counts wereconducted in May 2013 using Miovision cameras. Counts were conducted during the following time
periods:
Friday, May 3, 4:00 PM 7:00 PM to study post-game traffic. The post-game peak hour traffic isshown in Figure 5.
Tuesday, May 7, 4:00 PM 11:00 PM to study pre- and post-game traffic. The pre-game peakhour traffic is shown in Figure 6. The post-game peak hour traffic is shown in Figure 7.
Wednesday, May 8, 4:00 PM 7:30 PM to study post-game traffic. The post-game peak hourtraffic is shown in Figure 8. Friday, May 10, 2:00 PM 8:00 PM to study non-gameday traffic. The 4:30-5:30 PM traffic
volumes are shown in Figure 9. The 6:15-7:15 PM traffic volumes are shown in Figure 10.
Thursday, May 9, 4:00 PM 6:00 PM and Saturday, May, 11, 11:30 AM 1:30 PM to studynon-gameday traffic. The weekday and Saturday peak hour traffic volumes are shown in Figure
11.
Exhibit 6 lists the ticketed attendance and weather for each game.
Exhibit 6
Details of Cubs Games Studied
Date
Gametim
e
Game
Length Opponent Ticketed Attendance Weather
Friday, May 3 1:20 PM 3:29 Cincinnati Reds 32.579
41 degrees,
cloudy
Tuesday, May 7 7:05 PM 2:37
St. Louis
Cardinals 30,161 64 degrees, clear
Wednesday, May
8 1:20 PM 2:53
St. Louis
Cardinals 26,354 63 degrees, sunny
The locations and times of the traffic counts were based on input received in community meetings and theoverall scope was approved by the Chicago Department of Transportation. The locations, dates, and times
of the counts are shown in Exhibit 7.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
18/72
Wrigley Field Traffic and Parking Study
Page 17
Exhibit 7
Traffic Count Locations and Times
Intersection
Friday, May 3 1:20 PM Game time Tuesday, May 7 7:05 PM Game time
Wednesday, May 8
1:20 PM Game
time
Thursday, May 9
No Game
Friday, May 10
No Game
Saturday, May 11
No Game
11:30 AM - 1:30 PM 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM 4:00 PM - 7:30 PM 9:30 PM - 11:30 PM 4:00 PM - 7:30 PM 4:00 PM - 7:30 PM 2:00 PM - 8:00 PM 11:30 AM - 1:30 PM
Clark Street/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Racine Avenue X X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Grace Street X X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Waveland Avenue X X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Addison Street X X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Sheffield Avenue/Newport Avenue X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Roscoe Street X X X X X X X
Clark Street/School Street X X X X X X X
Clark Street/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X
Sheffield Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X Sheffield Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Racine Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X X
Ashland Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
Ashland Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Ashland Avenue/Belmont Avenue/Lincoln Avenue X X X X X X X
Western Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
Western Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Oakley/Irving Park Road X X
Leavitt/Irving Park Road X X
Leavitt/Addison Street X X
Damen Avenue/Irving Park Road/Lincoln Avenue X X Damen Avenue/Addison Street X X
Wolcott/Addison Street X X
Ravenswood Avenue/Irving Park Road X X
Ravenswood Avenue/Addison Street/Lincoln Avenue X X
Paulina Avenue/Addison Street X X
Broadway Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
Broadway Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Broadway Avenue/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X
N Lake Shore Drive/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
N Lake Shore Drive Southbound Ramps/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X
N Lake Shore Drive Northbound Ramps/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X Southport Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
Southport Avenue/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Halsted Street/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Halsted Street/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X
Sheridan Road/Belmont Avenue X X X X X X X
Inner Lake Shore/Addison Street X X X X X X X
Clarendon Avenue/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
Marine Drive/N Lake Shore Drive/Irving Park Road X X X X X X X
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
19/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
An analysis was conducted of each time period using Synchro. Synchro is a modeling program providing
a level of service for each intersection using a methodology from the Highway Capacity Manual. Theresults from the Synchro analysis included in the Appendix. Our conclusions and recommendations from
the Sycnrho analysis are listed below:
The interconnect systems designed and implemented by CDOT on Irving Park Road andAddison Street have a tremendous impact on moving traffic out of the neighborhood after
a game.
Consider raising the cycle lengths during post game flush period (day and night game) onIrving Park from Southport to Damen from 90 secs to 100 secs. This will match the
existing cycle lengths on Irving at: Western, Oakley, Leavitt and Clark, and provide
opportunity for better progression (assuming no manual control). It would also reduce
delay at Lincoln/Damen/Irving by 25%.
Consider raising the cycle lengths during post game flush period (day and night game) onAddison from Ashland to Leavitt from 90 secs to 100 secs. This will match the existing
cycle lengths at Western and provide opportunity for westbound progression out of the
neighborhood from Ashland to Western.
Existing Game Day Operations
SSE conducted observations throughout the month of May and found the following:
General Observations
There is significantly more traffic congestion in the immediate area of Wrigley Field post-game,compared to pre-game, because the majority of fans are leaving the area in the first 30 minutesafter the game, whereas fans coming to the game are spread throughout the approximate 90
minutes before a game. By 45 minutes after an event, streets are generally clear of the majority of
Cubs fans.
The majority of people driving are coming from the north and northwest suburbs. The zip codeswith the highest number of season ticket holders are located in Chicago, close to Wrigley Field
(60657, 60613, 60614, 60618, 60611, 60610). The highest number of season tickets holdersoutside of Chicago are located in 60062 (Northbrook), 60015 (Deerfield), 60093 (Winnetka),
60201 (Evanston), and 60068 (Park Ridge). This is consistent with the 2002 Traffic and Parking
Study conducted for Wrigley Field. The majority of traffic, pre- and post-game, is east-west on
Irving Park Road and Addison Street. Other than Clark Street, there is much less traffic on the
north-south streets in the neighborhood
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
20/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Both Sheffield Avenue, between Waveland Avenue and Addison Street, and Waveland Avenue,between Seminary Avenue and Sheffield Avenue, are closed by Chicago Police officers before
(approximately 120 minutes), during and after (approximately 30-60 minutes) Wrigley Field
events. Vehicles can turn on to Waveland Avenue from Clark Street to access the Blue or Gold
Lots.
There is no messaging on city streets to provide information to drivers about Cubs game dayactivities or to ask motorists to avoid the area. The only messaging is provided on the KennedyExpressway and it only advertises the remote parking lot.
There is no signage at Wrigley Field to help people get to their destination on transit, whether it isCTA, Pace or Metra.
There are no CTA fare card machines other than at the Addison Red Line station. There are a small number of limousines at Cubs games, but their use is considerably higher
during concerts.
Pre-Game
Turns are prohibited at the intersection of Clark Street and Addison Street. This helps trafficmove smoother, makes it safer for pedestrians and provides more space for pedestrians.
No information is provided to drivers on where parking is located or the price of parking. Thisleads to fans overcirculating through the neighborhood, looking for the best deal on parking with
regard to price and location.
Fans who take the Red Line, both northbound and southbound, typically exit at the AddisonStreet stop. There are three exits at this station: one on the south side of Addison Street, one of
the north side of Addison Street and one on the north side of the station on an alley. The majority
of people exit on the north side of Addison Street and the sidewalk is fairly narrow. This leads tocongestion on the sidewalk, which is made worse by the ticket scalpers, bar solicitors,
merchandise sales, street peddlers and other commercial activity on this segment of Addison
Street.
A b i d i id d t th d f th id lk l b th id f Addi St t t
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
21/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
The Wrigley Field entrance gate at Clark Street and Addison Street is by far the most congestedof the four main gates due to the limited footprint as well as the demand. Because of this, fansoften spill out into the intersection.
Both Pace buses and CTA Route 154 buses drop passengers off on the west side of Clark Street,between Waveland Avenue and Addison Street. Most passengers were observed using the main
gate at Clark Street and Addison Street.
Many fans who park in the Green Lot were observed walking along Clark Street to reach theballpark. This adds to the congestion on Clark Street by adding to the conflicts between
pedestrians and vehicles. It is not the most direct route for pedestrians.
The check-in area for charter buses, on Waveland Avenue at Seminary Avenue, is short in lengthand gets easily congested. Buses routinely queued on Clark Street waiting to turn.
There is a considerable amount of congestion at Clark Street and Waveland Avenue, withpedestrians, charter buses, vehicles and CTA buses.
Northbound charter buses waiting to turn onto Waveland Avenue were observed queuing onClark Street, blocking northbound through traffic.
Charter buses were observed stopping adjacent to Gate K, which blocks Waveland Avenue. After dropping off passengers, charter buses were observed turning right from Addison Street to
Clark Street. All charter buses should be directed away from Wrigley Field after dropping off
passengers.
Charter buses are permitted to park on both sides of Irving Park Road, between Clark Street andSeminary Avenue, and the west side of Clark Street, both north and south of Irving Park Road.
After dropping off passengers, charter buses typically first take up the space on the north side of
Irving Road then the south side of Irving Park Road then the Clark Street, south of Irving ParkRoad. No buses were seen parked on the west side of Clark Street, north of Irving Park Road.
Though the free bike check is very popular and close to Wrigley Field, it is somewhat difficult tofind. There is no signage on Clark Street directing bicyclists to it. After the game there was a line
t th bik h k Thi ld di f t bik
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
22/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
Traffic flows about as well as it can after the game under the control of the Traffic Control Aidesconsidering the number of vehicles leaving the area at one time. This is a challenging job as thereare many conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians following the game.
Irving Park Road has the most capacity of any street in the area. Traffic should be directed to itas much as possible.
OEMC has successfully established a clear zone at the intersection of Clark Street and AddisonStreet. Eastbound, westbound and southbound traffic is prohibited from reaching the intersectionof Clark and Addison. This helps ease pedestrian congestion at the main gate of Wrigley Field
and makes it easier for buses to exit.
Assuming current conditions, the five critical intersections to post-game traffic flow are ClarkStreet/Waveland Avenue, Clark Street/Grace Street/Racine Avenue, Clark Street/Irving Park
Road, Southport Avenue/Irving Park Road, and Ashland Avenue/Irving Park Road. If one of
these intersections is operating poorly, it affects the entire operations of outbound traffic. A
discussion of the observations of each intersection is listed below:
o Waveland Avenue/Clark Street: There is no traffic signal at this intersection and it is operatedentirely under the manual control of TCAs. In addition to vehicle traffic, there is significant
pedestrian traffic crossing Clark Street and Waveland Avenue, Pace and CTA buses and
charter buses turning on to Waveland Avenue to pick up passengers. The volume of
pedestrians makes this a very difficult intersection to control manually. Delays at this
intersection have the greatest impact on charter buses turning on to Waveland Avenue andPace and CTA buses which want to travel north on Clark Street. A traffic signal has been
proposed for this intersection and could improve operations. A bridge over Clark Street will
also help manage pedestrian traffic at the street level.
o Clark Street/Grace Street/Racine Avenue: The largest parking lot in the area is the Green Loton Grace Street and the majority of traffic exits the Green Lot to this intersection. Racine
Avenue and Grace Street do not intersect with Clark Street at the same location, which causeschallenges. Traffic is prohibited from travelling south on Clark Street, making a northbound
left-turn from Clark Street and making a southbound left-turn from Clark Street during post-
game.
The TCAs control the traffic signal and limit it to three phases: northbound/southbound
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
23/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
o Clark Street/Irving Park Road: This is the critical intersection for outbound traffic as well astraffic operations on Irving Park Road. The only movement prohibited at this intersection iswestbound left-turns (with the exception of charter buses). The northbound approach of Clark
Street provides a left-turn lane, a through lane and a right-turn lane at Irving Park Road.
When westbound traffic on Irving Park Road is queued to Clark Street from Southport
Avenue, then northbound and westbound traffic at the intersection cant move through the
intersection. This causes further backups on westbound Irving Park Road and northbound
Clark Street.
o Southport Avenue/Irving Park Road: This intersection causes a considerable amount of theissues in moving post-game traffic. Southport Avenue dead-ends two blocks to the north of
Irving Park Road and the majority of vehicles travelling north at the intersection are those
cutting through the neighborhood to avoid Clark Street and Southport Avenue. Southport
Avenue is located approximately 450 to the west of Clark Street. When traffic on Southport
Avenue receives green times, traffic on westbound Irving Park Road has a red signal. This
means that no traffic can travel westbound on Irving Park Road at Clark Street or make a
northbound left-turn from Clark Street to Irving Park once this small distance between thetwo intersections has cars queued in it. We observed a number of instances where the amount
of green time provided to traffic on Southport Avenue caused gridlock at the intersection of
Irving Park Road and Clark Street.
o Ashland Avenue/Irving Park Road: Both Ashland Avenue and Irving Park Road are arterialroadways and carry high volumes of traffic. The operations at this intersection must be made
as efficient as possible. TCAs control the traffic signal at this location during the post-game.Through traffic on both streets should be prioritized over the left-turn lanes, which should
only be given minimum green times. We often observed the traffic signal being adjusted to
provide more than the minimum green time in order clear the left-turn queues. This has a
large impact on the operations of through traffic on both streets. We also observed cycle
length times in excess of 200 seconds, which is not efficient.
Traffic does get congested at Irving Park Road and Seminary Avenue. This is due to Irving ParkRoad being reduced to one lane in each direction at this location and the volume of pedestrians
crossing Irving Park Road to reach the Challenger Park parking lot.
The #152 buses line up along Addison Street after the game and the CTA loads one bus at a time.The front door of each bus allows both fare card and cash transactions and the rear door has a
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
24/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
There are a large number of pedicabs on Waveland Avenue and Sheffield Avenue after the game.These users were observed using space reserved for charter buses and adding to congestion on
Clark Street after the games.
Taxi operations are very unpredictable after the games. Drivers are looking to pick up passengersright outside of Wrigley Field, which results in all cabs trying to get as close as possible.
Potential ImprovementsBased on SSEs observations, the intersection analysis and discussions with residents, CDOT, OEMC,
CTA and Pace, we offer the following recommendation to potentially improve traffic flow before and
after games. The potential improvements are shown in Figure 13.
1. The Cubs, CDOT and OEMC should annually review how Traffic Control Aides are deployedand how they are controlling the traffic signals. This is a very difficult job and the TCAs do a
very good job. Having additional expertise reviewing operations will only make the system work
better. All TCAs should be trained in the operations of signals and how the pedestrian clearance
interval works. In addition, because traffic patterns are most critical post-game, consideration
should be given to altering shifts to allocate more Traffic Control Aides following the game and
fewer before.
2. Traffic signals should be installed at the intersections of Clark Street/Waveland Avenue, ClarkStreet/Roscoe Street, and Clark Street/School Street as well as an interconnect system on Clark
Street, between Belmont Avenue and Irving Park Road. CDOT has conducted signal warrantstudies for these intersections in the past and show that these intersection do warrant a traffic
signal. This should improve traffic flow on Clark Street.
3. Additional study should be conducted on the impact of minimizing the amount of green time thatSouthport Avenue traffic receives at Irving Park Road to promote through traffic on Irving Park
Road. Consideration should be given to prohibiting westbound right-turns at the intersection of
Southport Ave/Grace Street to minimize the amount of northbound traffic on Southport Avenue
at Irving Park Road. Reducing Southport Avenue traffic will reduce the amount of time gridlock
is experienced at Clark Street/Irving Park Road.
4. Consideration should be given to restricting all parking after events on Clark Street, betweenIrving Park Road and Grace Street. This will allow for two northbound lanes on Clark Street on
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
25/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
6. The intersection of Clark Street/Grace Street/Racine Avenue could be re-configured with conesafter games to improve traffic flow. This could allow the northbound left-turn from Racine
Avenue and the northbound through movement on Clark Street to operate at the same time. A
right-turn lane and a combination left-turn/through/right-turn lane could be provided on
westbound Grace Street.
7. The manual controlled cycle length at Ashland Avenue and Irving Park Road should matchCDOTs suggested cycle length as closely as possible. Left-turn phases should be the minimum
and the priority should be on through traffic on Ashland Avenue and Irving Park Road.
8. Additional analysis should be conducted of existing variable message boards used by the City forCubs game and determine if they should be relocated. The Cubs should also work with traffic
reporting companies to alert drivers of congestion due to Cubs games and to avoid driving
through the neighborhood if its not necessary.
9. The Cubs should explore the possibility of pre-selling parking, both Cubs owned and non-Cubsowned, on a website or app.
10.Determine how wayfinding could be improved to provide more information on the location andavailability of Cubs-operated parking pre-game and signs to the highway post-game.
11.The Cubs should continue to provide in-game announcements and information on the messageboards throughout the stadium on transit.
12.Explore the feasibility of installing CTA fare card machines on the sidewalks immediatelyoutside Wrigley Field.
13.All charter buses should be encouraged to pull up as close to Sheffield Avenue as possible.14.Barricades on Addison Street should always be placed in the street (just off the sidewalk) and not
on the sidewalk to provide as much room for pedestrians as possible. Ticket brokers should not be
allowed to delay or slow pedestrians by offering merchandise outside their storefronts.
15.CTA passengers, both rail and bus, should be encouraged to purchase their return fare before thegame. The Cubs should work with the CTA to develop messaging in the Addison Red Line
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
26/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
17.Consideration should be given to establishing a temporary auto pound to improve the efficiencyof the towing operation for night events. More study is necessary to determine the feasibility ofthis recommendation.
18.Street peddlers and street performers should not be allowed to perform in the public rights of waywhere they pose obstacles for pedestrians and potentially impact public safety.
19.Cubs should promote bicycle ridership through events and prizes (e.g. free pair of tickets forwhomever rides his/her bike most often in a season; Divvy Bikeshare night).
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
27/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
4.
Additional RecommendationsFor the past decade, the Cubs have strengthened their commitment to reducing the impact of Wrigley
Field events on traffic and parking in the neighborhood. This has been accomplished through the Remote
Parking facility at DeVry University, messaging on the Interstate, the free bike check service and
encouraging people to take transit among other steps. The recommendations listed in this report will, if
adopted, enhance the Cubs existing programs and further reduce traffic and parking in the neighborhood.
The success of this program will be the responsibility of not only the Cubs, but the City, Chicago TransitAuthority, Pace, Metra and the rooftop owners. Importantly, the suggestions in this report are
recommendations only. It is not critical every one of these be adopted, but an open discussion on this
topic will help clarify issues and allow all concerned to have a say in enhancing transportation issues
related to Wrigley Field.
The Cubs have already begun to implement a number of the recommendations. Some of the
recommendations will require as approvals from multiple agencies. The recommendations have been
grouped into those which could happen in the short term and those which will take at least a year to
investigate, analyze and consider.
Short Term
1. Eliminate the fee for Remote Parking facility and heavily promote its use.It currently costs $6 to use the Remote Parking facility at DeVry University. This cost and the time it
takes to travel to and from the ballpark are likely the largest obstacles to increasing use of this facility.
Alderman Tunney has asked the Cubs to consider eliminating this fee to encourage more people to use thefacility. This option should also continue to be promoted on the Cubs website, during the game and
through other marketing strategies. A free and well-promoted Remote Parking facility has to potential to
vehicles from the local street system before and after the games as well as reduce the on- and off-street
parking demand. The Cubs should work with CTA to determine if additional incentives can be provided
on the bus, such as free wireless or food, if such incentives encourage more people to use the service.
The system should then be evaluated to determine the impact of the change.
2. Actively promote alternatives to driving and provide information to ticket holders.The use of alternative options to driving can potentially be increased by ensuring fans are fully aware of
the availability and attractiveness of potential alternative choices. Travel choices, once established a few
times, tend to become habits and individuals do not necessarily invest the time or effort to (re)consider
alternative choices In addition to promoting the viability of alternatives there is considerable value to
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
28/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
after the survey respondents were presented with information about the transportation options available to
reach it, 54.4% of respondents then stated they would travel via public transit (an increase of 9.0percentage points from the initial responses). These results quantify what has been experienced at other
venues; namely, promoting the viability of transit can have a profound effect on the travel choices people
make.
3. Implement a formal transportation demand management programThe Cubs should implement a formal transportation demand management program to continually address
the traffic and parking demand generated for Cubs games and other events at Wrigley Field. This sort of
program should reflect the flexibility to change during the course of a season or during the course of an
event in response to increased demand. A staff member should be responsible for administering the
program and being a liaison with the Chicago Department of Transportation, the Office of Emergency
Management & Communications, the Chicago Transit Authority, Pace and Metra. Because the
transportation demand is due to not only the Cubs, but also local bars, restaurants, and rooftops, all
entities should contribute to the solutions to improve the overall traffic and parking conditions in the
community.
Precedent: At CenturyLink Field, home of the Seattle Seahawks, the stadium has an on-staff
transportation manager to coordinate event day parking and transportation needs, community outreach
and the distribution of access information. At the Barclays Center in Brooklyn, they have an on-staff
transportation manager as well as an on-site transportation control room where arena operators
communicate in real-time with the transit agency, traffic and pedestrian managers and the police.
4.
Redesign the presentation of transportation information on cubs.com.The official Cubs website presents transportation information on five separate web pages: a main
transportation page [Homepage -> Wrigley Field -> Transportation] and four subpages for different travel
modes (Bike Riders; CTA Information; Driving directions; Transportation Hubs). The Getting
to Wrigley Field link on the homepage, which sports the tagline Find out the best ways to get to the
game! connects not to the main transportation page but to the Driving Directions page. Fans have to
navigate back from the driving page get to information on transit and cycling from the homepage link.
This portion of the Cubs website should be overhauled and substantially redesigned to emphasize public
transit access as the best way to Wrigley Field. Different modes of travel and their time and costs should
be presented side-by-side or in an easy to compare format on the same page. The Cubs should integrate
CTA Train Tracker and Bus Tracker widgets into the website so fans can access up-to-date transportation
information. Consideration should also be given to developing an application for mobile devices to
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
29/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
same map which fans can easily click through to compare. Estimated travel times by train are also
presented.
5. Change Residential Parking Signs to Provide More Information.The current on-street signage prohibiting parking for night games at Wrigley Field reads No Parking
Game Days. While it would be great to have this signage apply for concerts and other events, the
wording of the signs makes it unclear whether this also applies to events such as concerts. Two
alternatives would improve the information provided:
a. All signs be changed to read NO PARKING WRIGLEY FIELD NIGHT EVENTS and the noparking hours on Fridays should be modified to begin at 3 PM.
b. The Cubs, the City and the neighborhood should explore additional methods to alert people ofparking restrictions on residential streets. This could involve an app for mobile devices or
physical changes to the signs, such as a small red light to alert people when parking is prohibited
by non-residents. The City of Chicago piloted a similar program for street sweeping in 2008.
6. Promote the Citys bike share program.The Cubs should work with CDOT to promote the Citys Divvy bike share program. This could include
in-game announcements and promotions or include it in other advertisements for transit.
7. Improve the information on the variable message signs to encourage people to use RemoteParking.
The current variable messaging signs provide information on how to access the Remote Parking lot. This
should be modified so to incentivize drivers to use it. One way to accomplish this would be to display thetime/cost of driving to the Remote Parking as opposed to Wrigley Field.
8. Promote CTA Remote Parking lots.The CTA currently provides four Remote Parking lots (Red Line Howard, Purple Line Linden,
Yellow Line Skokie, Brown Line Kimball) which could be used by fans from the north and northwest
suburbs. The Cubs should market these options much more aggressively on their website and mailings to
season ticket holders.
9. Incentivize fans to take Metra, Pace or to use the Remote Parking.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
30/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
10.Pilot strategies to better manage taxi operations.Managing taxis around Wrigley Field is extremely challenging due to the dynamic and unpredictablenature of taxi drivers. A taxi stand was previously installed on Sheffield Avenue but was unsuccessful
because taxi drivers did not want to wait for customers to find them. For taxi stands to be successful, they
must be the most convenient location for both drivers and passengers and promoted accordingly. The City
would also need to step up enforcement to ensure the taxi drivers all use the designated location and do
not pick up fares on other streets.
The Cubs should work with CDOT and the Department of Business License and Affairs to develop and
pilot different strategies with the goal of making the operations more organized. Consideration should be
given to allowing only taxis and CTA buses to use Addison Street, between Clark Street and Halsted
Street, after games and prohibiting taxis from using Clark Street.
10. Treat limousines as charter buses during events.Concerts and events at Wrigley Field often times generate a higher volume of limousines; these events
also generate considerably fewer charter buses. It is recommended limousines be directed to pick-
up/drop-off on Waveland Avenue before and after games and limousines are given a special permit topark where charter buses park during games. The signs on Irving Park Road and Clark Street should be
changed to read NO PARKING EXCEPT BUSES OR LIMOS ON WRIGLEY FIELD NIGHT
EVENTS.
11.Rooftop Traffic and Parking Plan.In addition to the fans who attend games inside Wrigley Field, approximately 2,500 to 3,000 fans
purchase tickets at the adjacent buildings on Waveland Avenue and Sheffield Avenue to watch from therooftops. However, there is no parking formally provided for these fans or any sort of traffic management
plan.
It is recommended the rooftop owners develop a traffic and parking study which includes a mode choice
survey and encourages users to use options other than driving to the neighborhood. Rooftop owners
should contribute to the cost of the recommendations in this report to the same extent as the Cubs, except
in 7% of the cost amount, since rooftop attendance constitutes approximately 7% of the attendance of
Wrigley Field on game days.
12.Promote the purchase of CTA, Metra and Pace fare media along with Cubs ticket sales.Obtaining and paying for the correct fare media may be a potential barrier to public transit use, especially
for fans who are not regular users of the CTA, Metra or Pace systems. To reduce this barrier, transit fare
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
31/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
programmed to enable rides after Cubs games to be charged at discounted rates. Transit options should
also be printed on tickets.
13. Continue to encourage employees to participate in the RTA/CTA Transit Benefit Fare Program.The RTA/CTA Transit Benefit Fare Program allows employees to deduct up to $245 per month from
their paychecks pre-tax to pay for their transit fares. With the pre-tax deduction, employees can save up
to 40% on their annual transit spend. The Cubs should continue to administer this program to encourage
more employees to take transit to work.
Long Term
14.Northbound Red Line Express service to Howard, Davis or Skokie.Adding post-game express CTA service northbound to Howard would reduce travel times from Wrigley
Field to Howard by 6 minutes and reduce crowding on Red Line trains and at the Addison Station. The
reduction in travel time and convenience of an express ride could help encourage CTA ridership for fans
in the northward reaches of the CTA service area and also help increase the use of Remote Parking lots
available at Howard (592 spaces), Linden (328) and Skokie (441).
To accomplish this, the addition of CTA trains into service would be necessary to maintain existing
headways and capacity on the Red Line. This could be achieved by using either the Red Line Addison
platform and having trains cross over to the Purple Line track after boarding passengers or using the outer
platform at Sheridan. The latter would be ideal, since it would help distribute some of the load of
northbound CTA passengers from Addison to Sheridan, thereby helping relieve post-game congestion at
Addison. It is recommended the ridership potential of this option is further investigated by examining
post-game Red Line use patterns in depth.
Precedent: The CTA already adjusts service for game days to include a stop at Sheridan on the
southbound Purple Line before games on weekdays and extend the duration of service until midnight for
the Yellow Line to Skokie after weeknight games. As part of the Transportation Demand Management
plan for the Citi Field construction, the New York City MTA introduced special super-express service in
the post-game period on the 7 subway line which skips 13 stops along the route, greatly reducing the
travel time between the ballpark and Manhattan and addressing the concerns of some fans comfortable
with taking the subway to the game but apprehensive about riding the subway late at night.
15.Explore new Pace express bus.The existing Wrigley Field service is one of Paces most successful programs and ridership has grown
tremendously since it was initially launched. There definitely is a demand for this type of service in the
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
32/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
configured to a center platform in 1994, the facilities are in many ways still inadequate and as a result
transit patrons end up queuing back out of the station and onto the sidewalk along Addison Street.
There is a potential to improve the overall configuration and design of the station, including a larger
concourse area and additional stairways to the platforms. The footprint of the station could be expanded
under the four-track elevated structure, especially on the south side of Addison where the current
configuration is no entry with a high barrier gate control.
The Addison station is not part of the CTAs $86 million Red North Interim Station
Improvements program. However, it is recommended the Cubs work closely with the CTA to develop a
suitable station design for game-day conditions and input these contributions for construction in the Red
& Purple Modernization project (or sooner if other suitable sources of funding can be identified).
In addition, the station should be renamed as Cubs-Addison or Wrigley Field-Addison, similar to the
station adjacent to U.S. Cellular Field being named Sox-35th. This makes it easier and more comfortable
for fans from outside the City to take the Red Line and access the White Sox park. Changing the name of
the Addison station would increase awareness among fans from out of town and others who are notfamiliar with Chicagos transit system. This would likely increase usage of the El and reduce usage of
taxis and private vehicles.
Precedent: At Fenway Park in Boston, the Kenmore MBTA station included a larger head-house,
elevators for ADA accessibility and escalators and an expanded mezzanine and queuing space to
accommodate the game day crush. As part of the TDM plan for the Citi Field construction, physical
changes were made to the to the Mets-Willets Point station to improve pedestrian flow to the subwayplatforms. There are numerous transit stations across the station associated with teams and fields (Target
Field Station Minneapolis, Mets-Willet Point New York, Sports and Entertainment Complex
Philadelphia).
17.Explore RideShare.Pace RideShare is a free carpool and vanpool matching service offered to the Chicagoland area, typically
for commuters. The Cubs should work with Pace to determine if there is a possibility to offer a RideShare
program to Cubs games for fans that live close together and want to carpool or vanpool together.
18.Parking Management.In addition to parking officially provided by the Cubs, there is an informal and entrepreneurial industry of
surface parking lot operators around Wrigley Field. The model for many of these parking small
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
33/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
purchase system for parking. Since drivers likely select facilities based on a balance of convenience and
cost, a pre-purchasing system may enable drivers to select parking locations along their route of travel,therefore limiting the amount of cruising and circulating through the congested area around the ballpark.
A pre-payment model has already emerged organically in the Wrigley Field neighborhood with online
parking reservation sites such as parkwhiz.com and spothero.com, which create a market to enable
individuals to temporarily rent their private parking space on games days (rather than standing in the
street). It is recommended the Cubs, in conjunction with the City, investigate ways to make the use of
such pre-payment systems mandatory and prohibit the solicitation of parking for sale at curbside (but not
online).
The City and the Cubs should also work with the Lakeview Chamber to promote existing parking lots in
the area through their website and parking reservation sites.
Precedent: At the Prudential Center in Newark, there is a centrally coordinated event parking program,
administered by Click and Park, where fans pre-purchase parking passes at facilities convenient to their
direction of their access route to/from the ballpark. Similarly, at the Barclays Center, an online parking
space reservation system is operated by Click and Park.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
34/72
Wrigley Field Gameday Traffic and Parking Management Plan
5.
ConclusionWrigley Field is also unique among major league stadiums and arenas with respect to transportation.
Almost every other professional sports ballpark and venue in the United States is situated amid an
abundance of parking and in close proximity to interstate highways; Wrigley Field is neither. Both the
Cubs and the neighborhood have thrived over the years by managing traffic and parking congestion. One
of the reasons for this is the many fans who choose not to drive to Wrigley Field because of their
knowledge of the relative absence of parking around the ballpark.
There will always be issues with traffic congestion in the neighborhood. Implementing the suggestions in
this plan will offer an incremental approach to reducing the number of fans that drive in the area of
Wrigley Field and moving traffic and people out of the neighborhood quicker. Traffic and parking will be
continually evaluated with CDOT in the future to determine additional improvements that can further
improve the situation.
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
35/72
VE
VE
AVE
TST
AVE
OOD
AST
AVE
AVE
AVE
NRD
AVE
AVE
RD
FIG
EXISTING STREET NET
35
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
36/72
RACINEAV
HALSE
DAVE
HERIDANRD
HLN
DAVE
E
TEN
AV
HLANDAV
E
TERNAV
OAKLEYAVE
LEAVITTST
WOLCOTT
VE
RAVENSWOOD
AVE
PAULINAS
GREENVIEA
VE
SOUTHPORTAVE
HOYNEAVE
LAKEWOODAVE
CLIFTONAE
SEMINARYAV
E
KENMOREVE
SHEFFIELDAVE
BROADWAYAVE
OAKLEY
LEAVIT
WOLCOTT
RAVENSWO
AVE P
AULINA
GREENVIEW
SOUTHPORT
HOYNE
SHERIDAN
BELL
HERMITAGE
LAREND
N
ELM NT AVE
DDI N T
IRVING PARK RD
BYRON STREET
GRACE STREET
WAVELAND AVE
CORNELIA AVE
ROSCOE ST
SCHOOL ST
MELROSE ST
A
CLARKST
CLARKST
LINCOLNAVE
LINCOLN
AVE
EXISTING STREET NET
LEGEND
Eastbound only
Westbound only
Northbound only
Southbound only
VE
VE
YAVE
TTST
TAVE
OOD
NAST
WA
VE
TAVE
EAVE
NRD
LAVE
EAVE
NRD
FIG
EXISTING PARKING
36
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
37/72
RACINEAV
HALSE
DAVE
HERIDANRD
HLN
DAVE
E
TEN
AV
HLANDAV
E
TERNAV
OAKLEYAVE
LEAVITTST
WOLCOTT
VE
RAVENSWOOD
AVE
PAULINAS
GREENVIEA
VE
SOUTHPORTAVE
HOYNEAVE
LAKEWOODA
VE
CLIFTONAE
SEMINARYAV
E
KENMOREV
E
SHEFFIELDAVE
BROADWAYAVE
OAKLEY
LEAVIT
WOLCOTT
RAVENSW
AVE P
AULIN
GREENVIEW
SOUTHPORT
HOYNE
SHERIDAN
BELL
HERMITAGE
LAREND
N
ELM NT AVE
DDI N T
IRVING PARK RD
BYRON STREET
GRACE STREET
WAVELAND AVE
CORNELIA AVE
ROSCOE ST
SCHOOL ST
MELROSE ST
A
CLARKST
CLARKST
LINCOLNAVE
LINCOLN
AVE
Green Lot
650 SpacesOrange Lot16 Spaces
Red Lot150 Spaces
Gold Lot48 Spaces
Purple Lot73 Spaces
Brown Lot200 Spaces
McDonalds Lot35 Spaces
Challenger Lot650 Spaces
LA
KST
RVIN PARK R
GRACE STREET
WAVELAND AVE
SHEFFIELDA
RACINE
AVE
EXISTING PARKING
Blue Lot150 Spaces
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
38/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
39/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
40/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
41/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
42/72
FIGUR
Friday M
42
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
43/72
14
10
6
8
11
10
6
510
Friday, M
Post-Game Tr
Pedestrians and Bicyc
1. Belmont Avenue at Clark Street and Halsted Street
2. Addison Street at Racine Avenue, Clark Street, and Sheffield Avenue 3. Belmont Avenue at Sheridan Road and Lake Sho
207
204
140
157
465
561
302
185
170
174
137
201
785
761
723
533
134
46
81
103
27
21
12
6 FIGURE
43
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
44/72
5
5
5
18
78
23
5
21
Friday, Ma
Post-Game TraPedestrians and B
4. Addison Street at Lincoln Avenue and
Ravenswood Avenue
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
6. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
5
19
7. Clark Street at Sheffield Ave
and Newport Avenue
11
112
353
47
52
1
56 2
16
77
146
46
84
68
189
65
75
109
40
46
312
208
216
4
17
3
60
156
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
45/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
46/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
47/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
48/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
49/72
47
FIGURE
T esda Ma181
49
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
50/72
2927
23
4
67
Tuesday, Ma
Pre-Game TraPedestrians and B
4. Addison Street at Lincoln Avenue and
Ravenswood Avenue
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
6. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
21
77
7. Clark Street at Sheffield Ave
and Newport Avenue
18
3
25 2
39
96
146
380
129
133
206
100
195
92 6
6
122
480
256
241
7
29
706
367
10 14
22
20
21
11
14
5
11
1
1
7
1
1
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
51/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
52/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
53/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
54/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
55/72
12
FIGURE
Tuesday Ma92
55
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
56/72
5
32
12
32
1722
68
12
78
Tuesday, Ma
Post-Game TraPedestrians and B
4. Addison Street at Lincoln Avenue and
Ravenswood Avenue
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
6. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
29
38
7. Clark Street at Sheffield Ave
and Newport Avenue
46
108
31
29
65
188 4
30
148
319
45
39
26
86
100
91
43
32
55
834
391
403
375
865
464
7
5 6
9
18
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
57/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
58/72
110
40
30
360
FIGUR
Wednesday, Ma
85
145
15
-
5
500
58
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
59/72
15
20
115
10 1
05
505
20
335
200 2
00
5 320
260
15
Wednesday, Ma
Post-Game Tra
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
4. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
20
15
45
25
85
15
35
75
10
5005000
00
500
25
345
50
-
6. Clark Street at Sheffield Avenue
and Newport Avenue
35
10
650
15
125
170
105
25
645
50
30
80
40
30
640
30
95
640
45
35
320
105
20
330
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
60/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
61/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
62/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
63/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
64/72
60
85
15
40
415
FIGUR
Firday, May
64
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
65/72
15
25
70
15
50
320
30
95 3
65
5 355
35 5
4:30-5:30 PM Tra
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
4. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
65
150
600
10
10
135
75
30
620
35
30
65
35
40
615
80
65
690
60 4
5
315
110
25
330
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
66/72
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
67/72
40
30
55
20
40
435
FIGURE
Friday, May
67
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
68/72
10
30
65
25
55
385
30
85 4
10
5 355
90 5
6:15-7:15 PM Tra
5. Irving Park Road at Broadway
Avenue and Clarendon Road
4. Clark Street at Grace Street and
Racine Avenue
10
60
520
10
100
135
55
35
625
35
30
65
50
40
585
45
100
515
60 4
5
31
5
85
20
250
IRVIN PARK RD(50) 30
65 (65)
35 (35)
740 (745)
15(
25)
100(
85)
325(29
5)
FIGURE 11
Non-Gameday Traffic Volumes
XX W kd PM P k H (XX) S t d Midd P k H
68
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
69/72
RA E TREET
WAVELAND AV
(50) 30
(115) 140
(660) 710
(150)155
(45)
25
(305)42
0
(15) 10
(30) 25(50) 60
(20)20
(40)35
(390)520
55 (50)
30 (20)
85 (70)
20(
30)
45(
35)
430(
330)
(95)12
0
(-)
5(20)20
(455)465
20(
30)
390(31
5)
(5) 5
(25) 20
(45) 30
(20)35
(35)20
(325)405
65 (65)
30 (40)
55 (75)
5(
5) 2
5(
30)
365(
360)
XX: Weekday PM Peak Hour (XX): Saturday Midday Peak Hour
FIGURE 11Non-Gameday Traffic Volumes
XX: Weekday PM Peak Hour (XX): Saturday Midday Peak Hour5
0(
465)
69
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
70/72
ADDI N T
CLA
RKSTREET
(5)5
(5)5
(40) 20
(95) 95
(435) 400(35)30
(265)340
75 (85)
30 (40)445 (420)5
0(
65)
70(
75)
325(
330)
(90)95
(15) 20
(40) 65
(470) 455
(5)5
(230)235
15 (10)
45 (30)505 (505)
35(45)
5(5)
110(65)
-(-)
(-)5
(75)55
(50)50
(10
5)130
(-) -
(5) 5(-) -
10(10)
210(135)
45
0(
465)
(390)465
(10)5
(10)1
0
45
(390)465
ASHLANDAVE
DAMENAVE
WE
TERNAV
OAKLEYAVE
LEAVITTST
WOLCOTTAVE
RAVENSWOOD
AVE P
AULINAST
GREENVIEWA
VE
SOUTHPORTAVE
HOYNEAVE
SHERIDANRD
A
HERMITAGEAVE
LAREND
NR
CLARKST
LINCOLNAVE
F
Traffic Control A
LEGEND
Posts Secondary Posts
70
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
71/72
RACINE
AV
HA
L
EDAVE
HERIDANRD
A
HL
NDAVE
WE
TE
NAVE
OAKLEY
AVE
LEAVITT
ST
WOLCOTT
VE
RAVENS
WOOD
AVE
PAULIN
AS
GREENVIE
AVE
SOUTHP
ORTAVE
HOYNEAVE
LAKEWOODAVE
CLIFTONA
E
SEMINA
RYAVE
KENMO
RE
VE
SHEFFIELDAVE
BROADWAYAVE
BELM NT AV
DDI N T
IRVIN PARK R
BYRON STREET
GRACE STREET
WAVELAND AVE
CORNELIA AVE
ROSCOE ST
H L T
MELROSE ST
CLARKST
LINCOLN
AVE
ASHLANDAVE
DAMENAVE
WE
TERNAV
OAKLEYAVE
LEAVITTST
WOLCOTTAVE
RAVENSWOOD
AVE P
AULINAST
GREENVIEWA
VE
SOUTHPORTAVE
HOYNEAVE
SHERIDANRD
A
HERMITAGEAVE
LAREND
NR
CLARKST
LINCOLNAVE
F
Potential
Impr
71
-
7/28/2019 Wrigley Gameday Traffic Management Plan
72/72
RACINE
AV
HA
L
EDAVE
H
ERIDANRD
A
HL
NDAVE
WE
TE
NAVE
OAKLEY
AVE
LEAVITT
ST
WOLCOTT
VE
RAVENS
WOOD
AVE
PAULIN
AS
GREENVIE
AVE
SOUTHP
ORTAVE
HOYNE
AVE
LAKEWOODAVE
CLIFTONA
E
SEMINA
RYAVE
KENMO
RE
VE
SHEFFIELDAVE
BROADWAYAVE
BELM NT AV
DDI N T
IRVIN PARK R
BYRON STREET
GRACE STREET
WAVELAND AVE
CORNELIA AVE
ROSCOE ST
H L T
MELROSE ST
CLARKST
LINCOLN
AVE
1
1
1
1
2
3
4
5
5
6
7
8
9
10
Potential Improvements
1. Traffic signals should be installed at theintersections of Clark Street/Waveland Avenue,Clark Street/Roscoe Street, and ClarkStreet/School Street.
2. Traffic on Southport Avenue should be givenminimal green time to promote through traffic onIrving Park Road.
3. No parking of any type should be permittedafter events on Clark Street, between Irving ParkRoad and Grace Street.
4. Temporary signage should be provided atClark Street and Irving Park Road to allow thenorthbound direction to provide a left-turn lane, acombination left-turn/through lane and a right-turn lane.
5. The intersection of Clark Street/Grace
Street/Racine Avenue should be re-configuredwith cones after games to improve traffic flow.
6. The manual controlled cycle length at Ash-land Avenue and Irving Park Road should matchCDOTs suggested cycle length as closely as pos-sible.
7. All charter buses should be encouraged topull up as close to Sheffield Avenue as possible.
8. Barricades on Addison Street should alwaysbe placed in the street (just off the sidewalk) andnot on the sidewalk to provide as much room forpedestrians as possible.
9. CTA passengers, both rail and bus, shouldbe encouraged to purchase their return farebefore the game.
10. Restripe the Blue Lot to provide 90 degreeparking spaces, as opposed to the angle parking it
provides now.