Download - Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
1/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
ULPHU^CEBL
FJ ^ML W\PULKL GH\U^ HO FJNFC
GF_FB CPPLBBC^L I\UFWNFG^FHJ
GF_FB CPPLCB JH* HO 5035
-cufwfja h|~ ho W*B*P* -G& Jh* 5?
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
2/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
5
-Mhbnfjaw& B~n* Tohu wmhu~ GAP[" c ghkpcj ulwfnlj~ ohu ~c}
p|uphwlw fj ~ml Gckcj Fwbcjnw TGF ohu wmhu~[ vfnl
~ucjwcg~fhj nc~ln 33*05*5001" qmhwl w~c~ln cfk" cgghunfja
~h ~ml Ulvlj|l" qcw cgs|fwf~fhj ho ?1, ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~
fj MLB" elfja c ghkpcj ulwfnlj~ ohu ~c} p|uphwlw fj Fjnfc
qmfgm fw nfwp|~ln e ~ml cpplbbcj~ wcfja ~mc~ _FM caulln ~h
cgs|ful ghkpcjflw qmfgm fj ~|uj ghj~uhbbln c ?1, fj~lulw~"
e|~ jh~ ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~" fj M|~gmfwhj Lwwcu Bfkf~ln
-MLB ohu wmhu~&* Cgghunfja ~h ~ml cpplbbcj~" GAP mlbn
fjnfulg~b ~muh|am h~mlu ghkpcjflw
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
3/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
7
Auh|p fjvlw~ln fj cj Fjnfcj ihfj~ vlj~|ul vlmfgbl e ~ml
jckl M|~gmfwhj Kc} ^lblghk Bfkf~ln -MK^B& bc~lu
uljckln cw MLB*
>* Hj 35*03*366=" GAP w~hhn fjghuphuc~ln fj Gckcj
Fwbcjnw" qf~m bfkf~ln bfcefbf~" cw cj l}lkp~ln ghkpcj"
f~w whbl wmculmhbnlu elfja M|~gmfwhj ^lblghkk|jfgc~fhjw
Bfkf~ln" Mhja Dhja TM^B ohu wmhu~[" qmfgm fj Wlp~lkelu"
500> w~hhn ~ucjwoluuln ~h M^F -E_F& Mhbnfjaw Bfkf~ln
TM^FMB -E_F& ohu wmhu~[ vfnl Ehcun Ulwhb|~fhj nc~ln
31*06*500>* M^FMB -E_F& qcw ~ml e|lu ho ~ml GAP Wmcul*
M^FMB -E_F& qcw c qmhbb hqjln w|ewfnfcu -fjnfulg~& ho
M|~gmfwhj ^lblghkk|jfgc~fhjw Fj~lujc~fhjcb Bfkf~ln -GF&
TM^FB ohu wmhu~[*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
4/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>
MK^B(MLB qcw ghjwhbfnc~ln fj~h ~ml ~flu F ghkpcjflw cbb
ecwln fj Kc|uf~f|w* ^lblghk Fjvlw~klj~w Fjnfc Pufvc~l
Bfkf~ln T^FF ohu wmhu~[" Fjn|wFjn ^lblghk Jl~qhud B~n*
TF^JB ohu wmhu~[ cjn \wmc Kcu~fj ^lblkc~fgw Bfkf~ln
T\K^B ohu wmhu~[ qlul ~ml h~mlu wmculmhbnluw" h~mlu ~mcj
M|~gmfwhj cjn Lwwcu" fj MK^B(MLB* ^ml qlul Fjnfcj ~flu
F ghkpcjflw cehvl MK^B(MLB* ^ml ghjwhbfnc~fhj qcw ofuw~
khh~ln cw lcub cw I|b" 5007*
1* Hj 5=*30*500*76, wmculmhbnfja fj
Emcu~f Lj~lupufwlw Pv~* B~n* qmfgm fjnfulg~b mlbn wmculw fj
Emcu~f ^lblvlj~|ulw B~n* -jhq Emcu~f Cfu~lb B~n*&*
=* Hj 7*33*500,*
6* Hj 3*07*500?" ^FF Oucklqhud cjn Wmculmhbnluw
Caullklj~w w~hhn l}lg|~ln |jnlu qmfgm ~ml wmculmhbnfja ho
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
5/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
~h WPC qmfgm fjgb|nln ~mc~ M^FB qcw ~ml whbl eljlofgfcb
hqjlu ho GAP wmcul*
55* Hj 33*05*5001" c Wfnl Bl~~lu qcw wlj~ e M^FB ~h _FM
fj~lu cbfc w~c~fja ~mc~ h|~ ho ~ml p|ugmcwl ghjwfnluc~fhj" |p
~h \W .=0 kfbbfhj gh|bn el pcfn ~h whkl ho f~w l}fw~fja
pcu~jluw* E ~ml wcfn Wfnl Bl~~lu" M^FB caulln ~h puhg|ul
~mc~ M|~gmfwhj ^lblghkk|jfgc~fhjw -Fjnfc& B~n* -Kw& TM^FB
Kc|uf~f|w ohu wmhu~[" Hklac ^lblghk Mhbnfjaw Pufvc~l
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
11/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
33
Bfkf~ln THklac ohu wmhu~[ cjn AWPB qh|bn lj~lu fj~h FNOG
^ucjwcg~fhj Caullklj~ pufhu ~h ~ml ghkpbl~fhj ho ~ml
cgs|fwf~fhj p|uw|cj~ ~h WPC" qmfgm ghkpbl~fhj |b~fkc~lb
~hhd pbcgl hj =*0* Hj ~ml wckl nc" M^FB kcdlw cj cjjh|jglklj~ hj
MD W~hgd L}gmcjal w~c~fja ~mc~ f~ mcn caulln ~h wlbb f~w
lj~ful nfulg~ cjn fjnfulg~ ls|f~ cjn bhcj fj~lulw~w mlbn
~muh|am w|ewfnfcuflw" fj MLB ~h _FM*
5
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
12/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
35
fj~lulw~w fj 6*?5, ho ~ml fww|ln wmcul gcpf~cb ho MLB*
^mc~" ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj qh|bn ulw|b~ fj _FM cgs|fufja cj
fjnfulg~ ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ ho
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
13/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
37
bhgcb wmculmhbnfja a|fnlbfjl* Ghjwls|lj~b" CW cgs|fuln
1*5*7>, ho MLB cjn cj cnnf~fhjcb
fjnfulg~ fj~lulw~ ~muh|am I_Gw T^FF cjn Hklac[ elfja jhj+
qmhbb hqjln w|ewfnfcuflw ho M^FB qmfgm mlbn cj caaulac~l
ho 36*, ho MLB" qmfgm cnnln |p ~h ?3*==," qmlulcw fj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
14/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>
~ml ghkk|jfgc~fhj ~h OFPE nc~ln ?*07*5001" ~ml nfulg~ cjn
fjnfulg~ ONF mlbn e M^FB qcw w~c~ln ~h el 5*7>, $ 1*5=, -uh|jnln |p ~h >6*?5,&* Co~lu ~ml
cnnf~fhjcb p|ugmcwl ho 5*7>, ouhk Mfjn|icw fj C|a|w~
500?" ~ml caaulac~l M^FB nfulg~ cjn fjnfulg~ ONF w~hhn c~
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
15/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3*?=, w~cdl fj MLB ~muh|am ~ml Cwfk Amhwm fjvlw~klj~
lj~f~flw" qcw c w~cjne bl~~lu ho gulnf~ fww|ln e Ucehecjd
Mhja Dhja fj ocvh|u ho Uceh Fjnfc Ofjcjgl Pv~* B~n* qmfgm
fj ~|uj mcw kcnl c U|pll bhcj ocgfbf~ cvcfbcebl ~h Glj~ufjh"
hjl ho ~ml ghkpcjflw fj CA Auh|p*
77* E bl~~lu nc~ln 3>*07*5001 cnnulwwln e _FM ~h OFPE"
f~ w~hhn ghjofukln ~mc~ _FMw loolg~fvl wmculmhbnfja fj MLB
qh|bn el
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
17/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
31
-fv& Fj cnnf~fhj" M^FBw l}fw~fja Fjnfcj pcu~jluw CA"
CW cjn FNOG -f*l* WKKW&" qmh el~qllj ~mlk mlbn
c 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
18/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3=
7
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
19/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
36
6* Ufam~ ho w|ewgufefja c~ pcu vcb|l fj glu~cfj Fjnfcj
ghkpcjflw
30* Ufam~ ~h l}lugfwl gcbb hp~fhj c~ ~ml pufgl caulln fj
Fjnfcj ghkpcjflw
33* Ufam~ ~h ghj~uhb pulkf|k
35* Ufam~ ~h jhj+ghkpl~l cacfjw~ M^FB qf~mfj ~ml
~luuf~hu ho Fjnfc
37* Ufam~ ~h ghjw|b~cjg w|pphu~ fj ~ml |wl ho Hucgbl
bfgljwl ohu ~ml Fjnfcj e|wfjlww
3>* H~mlu fj~cjafebl ufam~w -ufam~ ho g|w~hklu ecwl"
ahhnqfbb l~g*&
7?* Hj 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
20/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
50
hqjln e h~mluw qmfgm wmculw wmcbb" ohu ~ml p|uphwl ho ~ml
^luk Wmll~" el ghjwfnluln ~h el pcu~ ho ~ml mhbnfja cgs|fuln
e _FM* ^ml ^luk Wmll~ ahvlujln ~ml ulbc~fhjwmfp el~qllj
Lwwcu cjn _FM cw wmculmhbnluw ho MLB fjgb|nfja _FMw ufam~
cw c wmculmhbnlu ho MLB9
-c& ~h jhkfjc~l = nfulg~huw h|~ ho 35 ~h ~ml Ehcun hoNfulg~huw4
-e& jhkfjll ho _hncohjl mcn ~h el ~mlul ~h ghjw~f~|~l~ml s|hu|k ohu ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw4
-g& ~h al~ c UhOU hvlu ~ml wmculw mlbn e Lwwcu fjMLB4
-n& wmh|bn _hncohjl Auh|p wmculmhbnlu wlbb f~wwmculw fj MLB ~h cj h|~wfnlu" Lwwcu mcn c ^CU fj
ulwplg~ ho Lwwcuw wmculmhbnfja fj MLB*
71* Hj 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
21/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
53
7=* E bl~~lu nc~ln 31*07*5001" M^FB ghjofukln fj quf~fja
~h CW ~mc~ f~ mcn jh eljlofgfcb" hu blacb hu cj h~mlu ufam~ fj
CWw ^FF fj~lulw~ hu MLB fj~lulw~*
76* Hj 36*07*5001" c bl~~lu qcw cnnulwwln e OFPE ~h _FM
cwdfja _FM ~h gbcufo cw ~h |jnlu qmc~ gfug|kw~cjglw _FM
caulln ~h pc \W .33*0= ej ohu cgs|fufja ?1, ho MLB qmlj
~ml cg~|cb cgs|fwf~fhj fw hjb
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
22/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
55
>3* _fnl Caullklj~ nc~ln 53*07*5001" _FM nfb|~ln f~w
w~cdl fj Emcu~f e 5* Fj ulpb ~h ~ml s|luflw ucfwln e OFPE ulacunfja eulcd
|p ho vcb|c~fhj" _FM ghjofukln cw ohbbhqw9
_cufh|w cwwl~w cjn bfcefbf~flw ho GAP fjgb|nln f~w ufam~w
cjn lj~f~blklj~w" fjgb|nfja w|ewgufp~fhj ufam~w" gcbb hp~fhjw
~h cgs|ful fj o|~|ul c o|u~mlu ?5*1
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
23/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
57
wcbl ho f~w fj~lulw~w fj MLB fj qmfgm M^FB mcn cwdln lcgm
efnnlu ~h jckl f~w pufgl qf~m uloluljgl ~h ~ml lj~lupufwl
vcb|l ho MLB* Cw c ghjwls|ljgl ho ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj"
_hncohjl qfbb loolg~fvlb w~lp fj~h ~ml wmhlw ho M^FB
fjgb|nfja cbb ~ml ufam~w fj ulwplg~ ho f~w Fjnfcj fjvlw~klj~w
~mc~ M^FB ljihln* Bcw~b" ~ml Fjnfcj ihfj~ vlj~|ul pcu~jluw
qh|bn ulkcfj fjvlw~ln fj MLB cw ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj nfn jh~
fjvhbvl ~ml Fjnfcj fjvlw~huw wlbbfja cj ho ~mlfu ulwplg~fvl
w~cdlw*
>7* Hj *5001" MLB quh~l ~h ~ml Ihfj~ Nfulg~hu ho
Fjghkl ^c} -Fj~lujc~fhjcb ^c}c~fhj& w~c~fja ~mc~ MLB mcn jh
~c} bfcefbf~flw cggu|fja h|~ ho ~ml w|eilg~ ~ucjwcg~fhj*
>>* P|uw|cj~ ~h ~ml ulwhb|~fhj pcwwln e ~ml Ehcun ho
Nfulg~huw ho GAP hj 70*0>*5001" f~ qcw nlgfnln ~mc~ hj
cgs|fwf~fhj bhcjw hqln e GAP ~h M^F -E_F& Ofjcjgl B~n*
qh|bn el cwwfajln ~h _FM4 ~ml l}fw~fja Nfulg~huw ho GAP
qh|bn ulwfaj4 Lufd nl Ufid qh|bn elghkl ~ml hjb Nfulg~hu
ho GAP* C wfkfbcu ulwhb|~fhj qcw pcwwln hj ~ml wckl nc
e ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho Cuuc*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
24/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
5>
>?* Hj =*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
25/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
51* Hj ,*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
27/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
51
>6* Hj 51*0?*5001" M^FB nlgbculn c wplgfcb nfvfnljn ho
MD .?*1< plu wmcul" hj cggh|j~ ho ~ml acfjw kcnl e wcbl ho
M^FBw lj~ful fj~lulw~ fj MLB*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
28/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
5=
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
29/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
56
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
30/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
70
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
31/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
73
Ghuulg~jlww ho Cycnf Ecgmch gcwl + Ul9 ^c}Cvhfncjgl(Lvcwfhj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
32/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
75
H|u Cjcbwfw
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
33/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
77
?0* Uckwc qcw c gcwl ho wcbl+blcwl ecgd ~ucjwcg~fhj fj
qmfgm acfj qcw wh|am~ ~h el gh|j~lucg~ln" wh cw ~h cvhfn
~c}" e lw~cebfwmfja cj cbbhqcebl bhww* ^ml kl~mhn gmhwlj
qcw ~h e| ouhk c ghkpcj c ulcnkcnl wgmlkl" qmhwl
heilg~ qcw ~h gulc~l c jl|~ucb wf~|c~fhj* ^ml nlgulcwfja
cwwl~ qcw ~h el whbn wh cw ~h gulc~l cj cu~fofgfcb bhww cjn ~ml
fjgulcwfja cwwl~ qcw ~h flbn c acfj qmfgm qh|bn el l}lkp~
ouhk ~c}* ^ml Guhqj gmcbbljaln ~ml qmhbl wgmlkl wcfja
~mc~ f~ qcw cj cu~fofgfcb wgmlkl cjn" ~mlulohul" ofwgcbb fj+
loolg~fvl* F~ qcw mlbn ~mc~ Qlw~kfjw~lu nfn jh~ ghkplb ~ml
gh|u~ ~h bhhd c~ c nhg|klj~ hu c ~ucjwcg~fhj" fwhbc~ln ouhk
~ml ghj~l}~ ~h qmfgm f~ puhplub elbhjaln* F~ fw ~ml ~cwd ho
~ml Gh|u~ ~h cwglu~cfj ~ml blacb jc~|ul ho ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj
cjn qmfbl nhfja wh f~ mcw ~h bhhd c~ ~ml lj~ful ~ucjwcg~fhj
cw c qmhbl cjn jh~ ~h cnhp~ c nfwwlg~fja cppuhcgm* Fj ~ml
pulwlj~ gcwl" ~ml Ulvlj|l mcw cnhp~ln c nfwwlg~fja
cppuhcgm c~ ~ml Nlpcu~klj~ blvlb*
?3* Uckwc nfn jh~ nfwgcun Qlw~kfjw~lu e|~ ulcn f~ fj ~ml
puhplu ghj~l}~ e qmfgm nlvfgl qmfgm qcw ghbh|ucebl fj
jc~|ul mcn ~h el fajhuln cw ofwgcb j|bbf~* ^m|w" Uckwc
bcw nhqj ~ml pufjgfpbl ho w~c~|~hu fj~lupul~c~fhj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
34/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
7>
uc~mlu ~mcj cj hvlu+cugmfja cj~f+cvhfncjgl nhg~ufjl
fkphwln |phj ~c} bcqw*
?5* O|ujfww -Fjwplg~hu ho ^c}lw& v* Ncqwhj-36=>& 3 Cbb
L*U*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
35/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
7* ^ml kcihuf~ i|naklj~ fj KgNhqlbb mlbn ~mc~ ~c}
pbcjjfja kc el blaf~fkc~l puhvfnln f~ fw qf~mfj ~ml
oucklqhud ho bcq -pcuc >
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
36/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
7?
wgmlklw cjn nlvfglw fj ghj~ucnfw~fjg~fhj ~h blaf~fkc~l
cvhfncjgl ho ~c} bfcefbf~ -pcucw 1+30" 31 / 3=&* Fj h|u
vflq" cb~mh|am Gmfjjcppc Ulnn" I* kcdlw c j|kelu ho
hewluvc~fhjw ulacunfja ~ml jlln ~h nlpcu~ ouhk ~ml
Qlw~kfjw~lucjn ~c} cvhfncjgl ~mlwl cul gblcub hjb fj
~ml ghj~l}~ ho cu~fofgfcb cjn ghbh|ucebl nlvfglw* Ulcnfja
KgNhqlbb" fj ~ml kcjjlu fjnfgc~ln mlulfjcehvl" fj gcwlw ho
~ulc~ wmhppfja cjn(hu ~c} cvhfncjgl" ~mlul fw jh ghjobfg~
el~qllj KgNhqlbb cjn Cycnf Ecgmch hu el~qllj
KgNhqlbb cjn Kc~m|uck Caucqcb*
Fj~lujc~fhjcb ^c} Cwplg~w ho Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ulw
?
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
37/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
71
cjn h~mlu lj~f~flw w|eilg~ ~h fjghkl+~c}* Ghkpcjflw cjn
h~mlu lj~f~flw cul vflqln cw lghjhkfg lj~f~flw qf~m blacb
fjnlpljnljgl vfw+c+vfw ~mlfu wmculmhbnluw(pcu~fgfpcj~w* F~ fw
ocfub qlbb cgglp~ln ~mc~ c w|ewfnfcu cjn f~w pculj~ cul
~h~cbb nfw~fjg~ ~c} pcluw* Ghjwls|lj~b" ~ml lj~f~flw
w|eilg~ ~h fjghkl+~c} cul ~c}ln hj puhof~w nlufvln e ~mlk
hj w~cjncbhjl ecwfw" fuulwplg~fvl ho ~mlfu cg~|cb nlaull ho
lghjhkfg fjnlpljnljgl cjn ulacunblww ho qml~mlu puhof~w
cul ulwluvln hu nfw~ufe|~ln ~h ~ml wmculmhbnluw(
pcu~fgfpcj~w* O|u~mlukhul" wmculmhbnluw( pcu~fgfpcj~w" ~mc~
cul w|eilg~ ~h -pluwhjcb hu ghuphuc~l& fjghkl+~c}" cul
aljlucbb ~c}ln hj puhof~w nlufvln fj ghjwfnluc~fhj ho ~mlfu
wmculmhbnfja(pcu~fgfpc~fhjw" w|gm cw gcpf~cb acfjw* Jhq c
ncw" f~ fw ocfub qlbb wl~~bln ~mc~ ohu ~c} ~ulc~ p|uphwlw c
w|ewfnfcu cjn f~w pculj~ cul cbwh ~h~cbb wlpcuc~l cjn
nfw~fjg~ ~c} pcluw*
?1* F~ fw aljlucbb cgglp~ln ~mc~ ~ml auh|p pculj~ ghkpcj
fw fjvhbvln fj afvfja pufjgfpcb a|fncjgl ~h auh|p ghkpcjflw
e puhvfnfja aljlucb phbfg a|fnlbfjlw ~h auh|p w|ewfnfcuflw*
Mhqlvlu" ~ml ocg~ ~mc~ c pculj~ ghkpcj l}lugfwlw
wmculmhbnluw fjob|ljgl hj f~w w|ewfnfcuflw nhlw jh~
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
38/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
7=
aljlucbb fkpb ~mc~ ~ml w|ewfnfcuflw cul ~h el nllkln
ulwfnlj~w ho ~ml W~c~l fj qmfgm ~ml pculj~ ghkpcj ulwfnlw*
O|u~mlu" fo c ghkpcj fw c pculj~ ghkpcj" ~mc~ ghkpcjw
l}lg|~fvl nfulg~hu-w& wmh|bn blcn ~ml auh|p cjn ~ml
ghkpcjw wmculmhbnluw fjob|ljgl qfbb aljlucbb el
lkpbhln ~h ~mc~ ljn* ^mfw hevfh|wb fkpbflw c ulw~ufg~fhj hj
~ml c|~hjhk ho ~ml w|ewfnfcuw l}lg|~fvl nfulg~huw* W|gm
c ulw~ufg~fhj" qmfgm fw ~ml fjlvf~cebl ghjwls|ljglw ho cj
auh|p w~u|g~|ul" fw aljlucbb cgglp~ln" eh~m fj ghuphuc~l
cjn ~c} bcqw* Mhqlvlu" qmlul ~ml w|ewfnfcuw l}lg|~fvl
nfulg~huw ghkpl~ljglw cul ~ucjwoluuln ~h h~mlu
pluwhjw(ehnflw hu qmlul ~ml w|ewfnfcuw l}lg|~fvl
nfulg~huw nlgfwfhj kcdfja mcw elghkl o|bb w|ehunfjc~l ~h
~ml Mhbnfja Ghkpcj qf~m ~ml ghjwls|ljgl ~mc~ ~ml
w|ewfnfcuw l}lg|~fvl nfulg~huw cul jh khul ~mcj p|ppl~w
~mlj ~ml ~|ujfja phfj~ fj ulwplg~ ho ~ml w|ewfnfcuw pbcgl ho
ulwfnljgl ghklw ceh|~* Wfkfbcub" fo cj cg~|cb ghj~uhbbfja
Jhj+Ulwfnlj~ Lj~lupufwl -JUL& kcdlw cj fjnfulg~ ~ucjwolu
~muh|am ce|wl ho huacjfwc~fhj ohuk(blacb ohuk cjn qf~mh|~
ulcwhjcebl e|wfjlww p|uphwl qmfgm ulw|b~w fj ~c}
cvhfncjgl hu cvhfncjgl ho qf~mmhbnfja ~c}" ~mlj ~ml
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
39/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
76
Ulvlj|l kc nfwulacun ~ml ohuk ho ~ml cuucjalklj~ hu ~ml
fkp|ajln cg~fhj ~muh|am |wl ho Jhj+Ulwfnlj~ Mhbnfja
Ghkpcj" ul+gmcucg~lufyl ~ml ls|f~ ~ucjwolu cgghunfja ~h
f~w lghjhkfg w|ew~cjgl cjn fkphwl ~ml ~c} hj ~ml cg~|cb
ghj~uhbbfja Jhj+Ulwfnlj~ Lj~lupufwl* ^m|w" qml~mlu c
~ucjwcg~fhj fw |wln pufjgfpcbb cw c ghbh|ucebl nlvfgl ohu ~ml
nfw~ufe|~fhj ho lcujfjaw" puhof~w cjn acfjw" fw nl~lukfjln e
c ulvflq ho cbb ~ml ocg~w cjn gfug|kw~cjglw w|uuh|jnfja ~ml
~ucjwcg~fhj* F~ fw fj ~ml cehvl gcwlw ~mc~ ~ml pufjgfpbl ho
bfo~fja ~ml ghuphuc~l vlfb hu ~ml nhg~ufjl ho w|ew~cjgl hvlu
ohuk hu ~ml ghjglp~ ho eljlofgfcb hqjluwmfp hu ~ml ghjglp~ ho
cb~lu lah cufwlw* ^mlul cul kcj gfug|kw~cjglw" cpcu~ ouhk
~ml hjl afvlj cehvl" qmlul wlpcuc~l l}fw~ljgl ho nfoolulj~
ghkpcjflw" ~mc~ cul pcu~ ho ~ml wckl auh|p" qfbb el ~h~cbb hu
pcu~b fajhuln cw c nlvfgl hu c ghjn|f~ -fj ~ml plihuc~fvl
wljwl&*
?=* ^ml ghkkhj bcq i|ufwnfg~fhjw nh fjvcufceb fkphwl
~c}c~fhj cacfjw~ c ghuphuc~fhj ecwln hj ~ml blacb pufjgfpbl
~mc~ ~ml ghuphuc~fhj fw c pluwhj ~mc~ fw wlpcuc~l ouhk f~w
klkeluw* F~ fw ~ml nlgfwfhj ho ~ml Mh|wl ho Bhunw fj
Wcbhkhjv* Wcbhkhj-3=61& C*G* 55 ~mc~ hpljln ~ml nhhu
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
40/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>0
~h ~ml ohukc~fhj ho c ghuphuc~l auh|p* Fo c hjl kcj
ghuphuc~fhj gh|bn el fjghuphuc~ln" ~mlj f~ qh|bn ohbbhq ~mc~
hjl ghuphuc~fhj gh|bn el c w|ewfnfcu ho cjh~mlu* ^mfw blacb
pufjgfpbl fw ~ml ecwfw ho Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ulw* F~ fw c
ghkkhj pucg~fgl fj fj~lujc~fhjcb bcq" qmfgm fw ~ml ecwfw ho
fj~lujc~fhjcb ~c}c~fhj" ohu ohulfaj fjvlw~huw ~h fjvlw~ fj
Fjnfcj ghkpcjflw ~muh|am cj fj~luphwln ohulfaj mhbnfja hu
hpluc~fja ghkpcj" w|gm cw Gckcj Fwbcjnw hu Kc|uf~f|w
ecwln ghkpcj ohu eh~m ~c} cjn e|wfjlww p|uphwlw* Fj
nhfja wh" ohulfaj fjvlw~huw cul cebl ~h cvhfn ~ml blja~m
cppuhvcb cjn ulafw~uc~fhj puhglwwlw uls|fuln ohu c nfulg~
~ucjwolu -f*l*" qf~mh|~ c ohulfaj mhbnfja hu hpluc~fja
ghkpcj& ho cj ls|f~ fj~lulw~ fj c ohulfaj fjvlw~ln Fjnfcj
ghkpcj* Mhqlvlu" ~c}c~fhj ho w|gm Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ulw
vlu ho~lj afvlw ufwl ~h fww|lw w|gm cw nh|ebl ~c}c~fhj" ~c}
nloluucbw cjn ~c} cvhfncjgl* Fj ~mfw gcwl" ql cul ghjglujln
qf~m ~ml ghjglp~ ho ACCU* Fj ~mfw gcwl" ql cul jh~
ghjglujln qf~m ~ulc~+wmhppfja e|~ qf~m ~ml cj~f+cvhfncjgl
u|blw* ^ml ghjglp~ ho ACCU fw jh~ jlq ~h Fjnfc wfjgl Fjnfc
cbulcn mcw c i|nfgfcb cj~f+cvhfncjgl u|bl" bfdl whkl h~mlu
i|ufwnfg~fhjw* Bcgd ho gbcuf~ cjn cewljgl ho cppuhpufc~l
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
41/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>3
puhvfwfhjw fj ~ml w~c~|~l cjn(hu fj ~ml ~ulc~ ulacunfja ~ml
gfug|kw~cjglw fj qmfgm i|nfgfcb cj~f+cvhfncjgl u|blw qh|bn
cppb mcw aljluc~ln bf~fac~fhj fj Fjnfc* Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ulw
cul ulghajfyln fj ghuphuc~l cw qlbb cw ~c} bcqw* Wplgfcb
P|uphwl _lmfgblw -WP_w& cjn Mhbnfja Ghkpcjflw mcvl c
pbcgl fj blacb w~u|g~|ulw fj Fjnfc" el f~ fj ghkpcj bcq"
~cdlhvlu ghnl |jnlu WLEF hu lvlj |jnlu ~ml fjghkl ~c} bcq*
Qmlj f~ ghklw ~h ~c}c~fhj ho c Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ul" c~ ~ml
~mulwmhbn" ~ml e|unlj fw hj ~ml Ulvlj|l ~h cbblal cjn
lw~cebfwm ce|wl" fj ~ml wljwl ho ~c} cvhfncjgl fj ~ml
gulc~fhj cjn(hu |wl ho w|gm w~u|g~|ul-w&* Fj ~ml cppbfgc~fhj
ho c i|nfgfcb cj~f+cvhfncjgl u|bl" ~ml Ulvlj|l kc fjvhdl
~ml w|ew~cjgl hvlu ohuk pufjgfpbl hu pflugfja ~ml
ghuphuc~l vlfb ~lw~ hjb co~lu f~ fw cebl ~h lw~cebfwm hj ~ml
ecwfw ho ~ml ocg~w cjn gfug|kw~cjglw w|uuh|jnfja ~ml
~ucjwcg~fhj ~mc~ ~ml fkp|ajln ~ucjwcg~fhj fw c wmck hu ~c}
cvhfncj~* ^h afvl cj l}ckpbl" fo c w~u|g~|ul fw |wln ohu
gfug|bcu ~ucnfja hu uh|jn ~ufppfja hu ~h pc eufelw ~mlj w|gm
~ucjwcg~fhjw" ~mh|am mcvfja c blacb ohuk" wmh|bn el
nfwgcunln e cppbfja ~ml ~lw~ ho ofwgcb j|bbf~* Wfkfbcub" fj
c gcwl qmlul ~ml Ulvlj|l ofjnw ~mc~ fj c Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ul
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
42/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>5
cj lj~f~ qmfgm mcw jh ghkklugfcb(e|wfjlww w|ew~cjgl mcw
ellj fj~luphwln hjb ~h cvhfn ~c} ~mlj fj w|gm gcwlw
cppbfja ~ml ~lw~ ho ofwgcb j|bbf~ f~ qh|bn el hplj ~h ~ml
Ulvlj|l ~h nfwgcun w|gm fj~lu+phwf~fhjfja ho ~mc~ lj~f~*
Mhqlvlu" ~mfw mcw ~h el nhjl c~ ~ml ~mulwmhbn* Fj ~mfw
ghjjlg~fhj" ql kc ulf~luc~l ~ml bhhd c~ pufjgfpbl
lj|jgfc~ln fj Uckwc -w|puc& fj qmfgm f~ qcw mlbn ~mc~ ~ml
Ulvlj|l hu ~ml Gh|u~ k|w~ bhhd c~ c nhg|klj~ hu c
~ucjwcg~fhj fj c ghj~l}~ ~h qmfgm f~ puhplub elbhjaw ~h* F~ fw
~ml ~cwd ho ~ml Ulvlj|l(Gh|u~ ~h cwglu~cfj ~ml blacb jc~|ul
ho ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj cjn qmfbl nhfja wh f~ mcw ~h bhhd c~ ~ml
lj~ful ~ucjwcg~fhj cw c qmhbl cjn jh~ ~h cnhp~ c nfwwlg~fja
cppuhcgm* ^ml Ulvlj|l gcjjh~ w~cu~ qf~m ~ml s|lw~fhj cw ~h
qml~mlu ~ml fkp|ajln ~ucjwcg~fhj fw c ~c}
nloluklj~(wcvfja nlvfgl e|~ ~mc~ f~ wmh|bn cppb ~ml bhhd
c~ ~lw~ ~h cwglu~cfj f~w ~u|l blacb jc~|ul TWll Gucvlj v*
Qmf~l -w|puc& qmfgm o|u~mlu hewluvln ~mc~ alj|fjl w~uc~lafg
~c} pbcjjfja mcw jh~ ellj cecjnhjln e cj nlgfwfhj ho ~ml
Ljabfwm Gh|u~w ~fbb nc~l[* Cppbfja ~ml cehvl ~lw~w" ql cul ho
~ml vflq ~mc~ lvlu w~uc~lafg ohulfaj nfulg~ fjvlw~klj~
ghkfja ~h Fjnfc" cw cj fjvlw~klj~ nlw~fjc~fhj" wmh|bn el
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
43/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>7
wllj fj c mhbfw~fg kcjjlu* Qmfbl nhfja wh" ~ml
Ulvlj|l(Gh|u~w wmh|bn dllp fj kfjn ~ml ohbbhqfja ocg~huw9
~ml ghjglp~ ho pcu~fgfpc~fhj fj fjvlw~klj~" ~ml n|uc~fhj ho
~fkl n|ufja qmfgm ~ml Mhbnfja W~u|g~|ul l}fw~w4 ~ml plufhn
ho e|wfjlww hpluc~fhjw fj Fjnfc4 ~ml aljluc~fhj ho ~c}cebl
ulvlj|lw fj Fjnfc4 ~ml ~fkfja ho ~ml l}f~4 ~ml ghj~fj|f~ ho
e|wfjlww hj w|gm l}f~* Fj wmhu~" ~ml hj|w qfbb el hj ~ml
Ulvlj|l ~h fnlj~fo ~ml wgmlkl cjn f~w nhkfjcj~ p|uphwl*
^ml ghuphuc~l e|wfjlww p|uphwl ho c ~ucjwcg~fhj fw lvfnljgl
ho ~ml ocg~ ~mc~ ~ml fkp|ajln ~ucjwcg~fhj fw jh~ |jnlu~cdlj
cw c ghbh|ucebl hu cu~fofgfcb nlvfgl* ^ml w~uhjalu ~ml
lvfnljgl ho c nlvfgl" ~ml w~uhjalu ~ml ghuphuc~l e|wfjlww
p|uphwl k|w~ l}fw~ ~h hvlughkl ~ml lvfnljgl ho c nlvfgl*
Qml~mlu Wlg~fhj 6 fw c bhhd ~muh|am puhvfwfhj cww|ekf~~ln hj elmcbo ho ~ml Ulvlj|l8
?6* Cgghunfja ~h ~ml Ulvlj|l" fo f~w pufkcu cua|klj~
-jcklb" ~mc~ M^FB mcw" |jnlu ~ml WPC" nfulg~b
l}~fja|fwmln f~w puhplu~ ufam~w fj MLB cjn f~w w|ewfnfcuflw&
ocfbw" lvlj ~mlj fj cj lvlj~" fjghkl ouhk ~ml wcbl ho GAP
wmcul qh|bn jhjl~mlblww ocbb qf~mfj Wlg~fhj 6 ho ~ml Fjghkl
^c} Cg~" 36?3 cw ~mc~ Wlg~fhj puhvfnlw ohu c bhhd ~muh|am*
Fj ~mfw ghjjlg~fhj" f~ qcw w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml qhun ~muh|am
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
44/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>>
fj Wlg~fhj 6 fj~lu cbfcklcjw fj ghjwls|ljgl ho* F~ qcw"
~mlulohul" cua|ln ~mc~ fo ~ucjwolu ho c gcpf~cb cwwl~ wf~|c~l fj
Fjnfc mcppljw fj ghjwls|ljgl ho whkl~mfja qmfgm mcw
~cdlj pbcgl hvluwlcw -fjgb|nfja ~ucjwolu ho c gcpf~cb cwwl~&"
~mlj cbb fjghkl nlufvln lvlj fjnfulg~b ouhk w|gm ~ucjwolu"
lvlj ~mh|am ceuhcn" elghklw ~c}cebl fj Fjnfc* ^mc~" lvlj fo
ghj~uhb hvlu MLB qlul ~h al~ ~ucjwoluuln fj ghjwls|ljgl ho
~ucjwolu ho ~ml GAP Wmcul h|~wfnl Fjnfc" f~ qh|bn l~ el
ghvluln e Wlg~fhj 6*
10* Ql ofjn jh kluf~ fj ~ml cehvl w|ekfwwfhj ho ~ml
Ulvlj|l* C~ ~ml h|~wl~" ql s|h~l mlulfjelbhq ~ml ohbbhqfja
Wlg~fhjw ho ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Cg~" 36?39
Wghpl ho ~h~cb fjghkl*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
45/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>1
lw~cebfwmln e ~ml Nlpcu~klj~" ~mlj ~ml fjghkl ho ~ml jhj+
ulwfnlj~ cufwfja hu cggu|fja ouhk w|gm ~ucjwolu fw kcnl
bfcebl ~h el ~c}ln e ulcwhj ho Wlg~fhj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
48/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>=
pcu~fg|bcub fo ~ml ulw|b~ ho w|gm fj~lupul~c~fhj fw ~h
~ucjwohuk ~ml ghjglp~ ho gmcualcefbf~ qmfgm fw cbwh ~mlul fj
Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f&" pcu~fg|bcub qmlj hjl ulcnw Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f&
qf~m Wlg~fhj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
49/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
>6
~ml lblklj~w fj ~ml >~m w|e+gbc|wl ho Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f& cjn fo
fjnfulg~ ~ucjwolu ho c gcpf~cb cwwl~ fw ulcn fj~h Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f&
~mlj ~ml qhunw gcpf~cb cwwl~ wf~|c~l fj Fjnfc qh|bn el
uljnluln j|ac~hu* Wfkfbcub" ~ml qhunw |jnlubfja cwwl~
nh jh~ ofjn pbcgl fj Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f&* O|u~mlu" ~ucjwolu
wmh|bn el ho cj cwwl~ fj ulwplg~ ho qmfgm f~ fw phwwfebl ~h
ghkp|~l c gcpf~cb acfj fj cgghuncjgl qf~m ~ml puhvfwfhjw ho
~ml Cg~* Khulhvlu" lvlj Wlg~fhj 3?7-3&-g& fw qfnl ljh|am ~h
ghvlu ~ml fjghkl qml~mlu ulglfvln nfulg~b hu fjnfulg~b*
^m|w" ~ml qhunw nfulg~b hu fjnfulg~b fj Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f& ah
qf~m ~ml fjghkl cjn jh~ qf~m ~ml ~ucjwolu ho c gcpf~cb cwwl~
-puhplu~&* Bcw~b" f~ kc el klj~fhjln ~mc~ ~ml Nfulg~ ^c}
Ghnl -N^G& Efbb" 5030 puhphwlw ~h ~c} fjghkl ouhk ~ucjwolu
ho wmculw ho c ohulfaj ghkpcj e c jhj+ulwfnlj~" qmlul c~
cj ~fkl n|ufja 35 khj~mw pulglnfja ~ml ~ucjwolu" ~ml ocfu
kcudl~ vcb|l ho ~ml cwwl~w fj Fjnfc" hqjln nfulg~b hu
fjnfulg~b" e ~ml ghkpcj" ulpulwlj~w c~ blcw~
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
50/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
51/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
52/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
53/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
54/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
cvhfncjgl p|uphwlw" hj ~ml hjl mcjn" cjn c ~ucjwcg~fhj
qmfgm lvfnljglw fjvlw~klj~ ~h pcu~fgfpc~l fj Fjnfc* Fj
hunlu ~h ofjn h|~ qml~mlu c afvlj ~ucjwcg~fhj lvfnljglw c
pulhuncfjln ~ucjwcg~fhj fj ~ml wljwl fjnfgc~ln cehvl hu
fjvlw~klj~ ~h pcu~fgfpc~l" hjl mcw ~h ~cdl fj~h cggh|j~
~ml ocg~huw lj|kluc~ln mlulfjcehvl" jcklb" n|uc~fhj ho
~fkl n|ufja qmfgm ~ml mhbnfja w~u|g~|ul l}fw~ln" ~ml plufhn
ho e|wfjlww hpluc~fhjw fj Fjnfc" aljluc~fhj ho ~c}cebl
ulvlj|l fj Fjnfc n|ufja ~ml plufhn ho e|wfjlww hpluc~fhjw fj
Fjnfc" ~ml ~fkfja ho ~ml l}f~" ~ml ghj~fj|f~ ho e|wfjlww hj
w|gm l}f~" l~g* Cppbfja ~mlwl ~lw~w ~h ~ml ocg~w ho ~ml
pulwlj~ gcwl" ql ofjn ~mc~ ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul mcw ellj
fj pbcgl wfjgl 366>* F~ hpluc~ln n|ufja ~ml plufhn 366> ~h
33*05*5001* F~ mcw pcfn fjghkl ~c} ucjafja ouhk`7 guhul ~h
`5
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
55/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
56/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
57/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
58/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
59/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
60/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?0
ocbb fj ~ml gc~lahu ho c pluw|cwfvl phwf~fhj(fjob|ljgl uc~mlu
~mcj mcvfja c phqlu hvlu ~ml w|ewfnfcu* Fj ~mfw ghjjlg~fhj
~ml ohbbhqfja ocg~w cul ulblvcj~*
1?* \jnlu ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul" ~ml e|wfjlww qcw
gcuufln hj e ~ml Fjnfcj ghkpcjflw |jnlu ~ml ghj~uhb ho
~mlfu Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw" ~mh|am M^FB" cw ~ml Auh|p mhbnfja
ghkpcj ho c wl~ ho ghkpcjflw" qmfgm ghj~uhbbln >5, pb|w
30, -puh uc~c& wmculw" nfn fjob|ljgl hu qcw fj c phwf~fhj ~h
pluw|cnl ~ml qhudfja ho w|gm Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho ~ml
Fjnfcj ghkpcjflw* Fj ~mfw ghjjlg~fhj" ql jlln ~h mcvl c
ulbhhd c~ ~ml hqjluwmfp w~u|g~|ul* F~ fw jh~ fj nfwp|~l ~mc~
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
61/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?3
nc~ln * ^mc~" cw c pucg~fgl" ~ml w|ewfnfcuflw nfn ghkpb
qf~m ~ml cuucjalklj~ w|aalw~ln e ~ml Auh|p mhbnfja
ghkpcj fj ~ml kc~~lu ho vh~fja" ocfbfja qmfgm ~ml wkhh~m
qhudfja ho MLB aljluc~fja m|al ulvlj|lw qcw jh~ phwwfebl*
Fj ~mfw gcwl" ql cul ghjglujln qf~m ~ml l}pulwwfhj gcpf~cb
cwwl~ fj ~ml fjghkl ~c} bcq* Cppbfja ~ml ~lw~ ho
ljohuglcefbf~" fjob|ljgl( pluw|cwfhj gcjjh~ el ghjw~u|ln
cw c ufam~ fj ~ml blacb wljwl* Hjl khul cwplg~ jllnw ~h el
mfambfam~ln* ^ml ghjglp~ ho nl ocg~h ghj~uhb" qmfgm l}fw~ln
fj ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul" ghjvlw c w~c~l ho elfja fj
ghj~uhb qf~mh|~ cj blacb ufam~ ~h w|gm w~c~l* ^mfw cwplg~ fw
fkphu~cj~ qmfbl ghjw~u|fja ~ml qhunw gcpf~cb cwwl~ |jnlu
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
62/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?5
~ml fjghkl ~c} bcq* Cw w~c~ln lcubflu" ljohuglcefbf~ fw cj
fkphu~cj~ cwplg~ ho c blacb ufam~* Cppbfja ~mlwl ~lw~w" hj
~ml ocg~w ho ~mfw gcwl cjn ~mc~ ~hh fj ~ml bfam~ ho ~ml
hqjluwmfp w~u|g~|ul ho M|~gmfwhj" ql mhbn ~mc~ M^FB" cw c
Auh|p mhbnfja ghkpcj" mcn jh blacb ufam~ ~h nfulg~ f~w
nhqjw~ulck ghkpcjflw fj ~ml kc~~lu ho vh~fja" jhkfjc~fhj
ho nfulg~huw cjn kcjcalklj~ ufam~w* Cw ulacunw
ghj~fj|cjgl ho ~ml 500? Wmculmhbnluw(Oucklqhud
Caullklj~w e WPC fw ghjglujln" hjl jllnw ~h dllp fj kfjn
~qh ulblvcj~ ghjglp~w" vfy*" pcu~fgfpc~fvl cjn puh~lg~fvl
ufam~w* Cw w~c~ln" ~mfw fw c gcwl ho M FB l}lugfwfja f~w l}f~
ufam~ |jnlu ~ml mhbnfja w~u|g~|ul cjn ghj~fj|cjgl ho ~ml
~lblghk e|wfjlww hpluc~fhjw fj Fjnfc e _FM e cgs|fwf~fhj
ho wmculw* Fj ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul" l}f~ qcw cbwh
puhvfnln ohu Lwwcu" Glj~ufjh" JNG cjn WKKW ~muh|am
l}lugfwl ho P|~ Hp~fhj(^CUw" w|eilg~ ~h wlg~hucb gcp elfja
ulbc}ln fj o|~|ul* ^mlwl l}f~ ufam~w fj Lwwcu" Glj~ufjh" JNG
cjn WKKW -FNOG& fjnfgc~l ~mc~ ~mlwl ghkpcjflw qlul
fjnlpljnlj~ ghkpcjflw* Lwwcu qcw c pcu~jlu fj MLB
qmlulcw Glj~ufjh" JNG cjn WKKW ghj~uhbbln 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
63/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?7
cw c pcu~fgfpc~fvl ufam~" qmfgm fw c w|ewl~ ho
puh~lg~fvl ufam~w* ^mlwl pcu~fgfpc~fvl ufam~w" afvlj ~h c
kfjhuf~ wmculmhbnlu" ljcebl ~ml kfjhuf~ ~h hvlughkl ~ml
pulw|kp~fhj ho ghjwhbfnc~fhj ho hpluc~fhjw hu cwwl~w e ~ml
ghj~uhbbfja wmculmhbnlu* ^mlwl pcu~fgfpc~fvl ufam~w fj
glu~cfj fjw~cjglw ulw~ufg~ ~ml phqluw ho ~ml wmculmhbnlu qf~m
kcihuf~ vh~fja fj~lulw~ ~h ghj~uhb ~ml hpluc~fhjw hu cwwl~w ho
~ml fjvlw~ll* C~ ~ml wckl ~fkl" lvlj ~ml kfjhuf~ fw lj~f~bln
~h l}f~* ^mfw l}f~ ufam~ ghklw |jnlu puh~lg~fvl ufam~w*
Hj l}ckfjc~fhj ho ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul fj f~w lj~ful~"
ql ofjn ~mc~ eh~m" pcu~fgfpc~fvl cjn puh~lg~fvl ufam~w" qlul
puhvfnln ohu fj ~ml Wmculmhbnluw( Oucklqhud Caullklj~w ho
500? fj ocvh|u ho Glj~ufjh" JNG cjn WKKW qmfgm ljcebln
~mlk ~h pcu~fgfpc~l" nfulg~b hu fjnfulg~b" fj ~ml hpluc~fhjw
ho MLB* Lvlj qf~mh|~ ~ml l}lg|~fhj ho WPC" w|gm ufam~w
l}fw~ln fj ~ml cehvl caullklj~w* ^mlulohul" f~ qh|bn jh~ el
ghuulg~ ~h wc ~mc~ w|gm ufam~w obhqln ouhk ~ml WPC* Hjl
khul cwplg~ jllnw ~h el klj~fhjln* ^ml Oucklqhud
Caullklj~w nlofjl gmcjal ho ghj~uhb qf~m ulwplg~ ~h c
wmculmhbnlu fj~lu cbfc cw w|ew~f~|~fhj ho bfkf~ln hu
|jbfkf~ln bfcefbf~ ghkpcj" qml~mlu nfulg~b hu fjnfulg~b"
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
64/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?>
~h nfulg~ ~ml phbfgflw( kcjcalklj~ ho ~ml ulwplg~fvl
wmculmhbnluw" vfy*" Glj~ufjh" JNG" Hklac* ^m|w" lvlj
qf~mh|~ ~ml WPC" |phj w|ew~f~|~fhj ho _FM fj pbcgl ho M^FB"
hj cgs|fwf~fhj ho GAP wmcul" ~ucjwf~fhj gh|bn mcvl ~cdlj
pbcgl* F~ fw fkphu~cj~ ~h jh~l ~mc~ ~ucjwf~fhj fw c qfnl
ghjglp~* F~ fw fkphwwfebl ohu ~ml cgs|fulu ~h vfw|cbfyl cbb
lvlj~w ~mc~ kc ~cdl pbcgl el~qllj ~ml nc~l ho l}lg|~fhj ho
~ml WPC cjn ghkpbl~fhj ho cgs|fwf~fhj* ^mlulohul" ql mcvl c
puhvfwfhj ohu w~cjnw~fbb fj ~ml WPC cjn wh cbwh ~ml puhvfwfhj
ohu ~ucjwf~fhj* E|~" ouhk ~mc~" f~ nhlw jh~ ohbbhq ~mc~
qf~mh|~ WPC" ~ucjwf~fhj gh|bn jh~ ljw|l* ^mlulohul" fj ~ml
WPC" ql ofjn puhvfwfhjw ghjglujfja _ljnhuw Hebfac~fhjw fj
ulbc~fhj ~h ~ml ghjn|g~ ho e|wfjlww ho MLB el~qllj ~ml nc~l
ho l}lg|~fhj ho WPC cjn ~ml gbhwfja nc~l" puh~lg~fhj ho
fjvlw~klj~ n|ufja ~ml wcfn plufhn" caullklj~ jh~ ~h ckljn"
~lukfjc~l" vcu hu qcfvl cj ufam~w |jnlu ~ml Oucklqhud(
Wmculmhbnluw Caullklj~w n|ufja ~ml wcfn plufhn" puhvfwfhjw
ulacunfja u|jjfja ho e|wfjlww n|ufja ~ml wcfn plufhn"
cwwfajklj~ ho bhcjw" ghjwls|ljgl ho fkphwf~fhj ho
puhmfef~fhj e qc ho fji|jg~fhj ouhk cj gh|u~" pcklj~ ~h
el kcnl e _FM ~h M^FB" afvfja ho qcuucj~flw e ~ml _ljnhu"
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
65/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
?, cjn fjnfulg~ fj~lulw~ fj ~ml wljwl ho wmculmhbnfja
elbhjafja ~h Fjnfcj pcu~jluw |jnlu f~w ghj~uhb" cw 55*7>, ho ~ml wmcul gcpf~cb ho MLB cjn ~mc~
jhehn qh|bn pc \W .5*< ej l}~uc qf~mh|~ ghj~uhb hvlu
5
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
79/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
16
C~ ~ml h|~wl~" f~ kc el w~c~ln ~mc~~ml l}pulwwfhj
ghj~uhb fw c kf}ln s|lw~fhj ho bcq cjn ocg~* ^ml ecwfg
cua|klj~ ho ~ml Ulvlj|l fw ecwln hj ~ml ls|c~fhj ho ls|f~
fj~lulw~ qf~m ~ml qhun ghj~uhb* Hj plu|wcb ho M|~gmfwhj
w~u|g~|ul" ql ofjn ~mc~ M^FB mcn" ~muh|am f~w 300, qmhbb
hqjln w|ewfnfcuflw" fjvlw~ln fj >5*7>, ho MLB -f*l* nfulg~
fj~lulw~&* Wfkfbcub" M^FB mcn fjvlw~ln ~muh|am f~w jhj+
300, qmhbb hqjln w|ewfnfcuflw fj 6*?5, ho MLB -~muh|am
~ml puh uc~c uh|~l&* ^m|w" fj ~ml wljwl ho wmculmhbnfja" hjl
gcj wc ~mc~ M^FB mcn cj loolg~fvl wmculmhbnfja -nfulg~
cjn fjnfulg~ fj~lulw~& ho
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
80/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=0
Pljnfja l}lugfwl" hp~fhjw cul jh~ kcjcalklj~ ufam~w* C~
~ml mfamlw~" hp~fhjw gh|bn el ~ulc~ln cw ph~lj~fcb wmculw
cjn ~fbb l}lugfwln ~ml gcjjh~ puhvfnl ufam~ ~h vh~l hu
kcjcalklj~ hu ghj~uhb* Fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" ~fbb nc~l AWPB
mcw jh~ l}lugfwln f~w ufam~w |jnlu ~ml Oucklqhud
Caullklj~ 500? elgc|wl ho ~ml wlg~hucb gcp ho 1>, qmfgm
fj ~|uj ulw~ufg~w ~ml ufam~ ~h vh~l* ^mlulohul" ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj
fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl puhvfnlw ohu c ~ufaalufja lvlj~" vfy*
ulbc}c~fhj ho ~ml wlg~hucb gcp* ^fbb w|gm nc~l" M^FB(_FM
gcjjh~ el wcfn ~h mcvl c ghj~uhb hvlu 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
81/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=3
nfulg~huw hj ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho MLB fj puhphu~fhj ~h
~ml caaulac~l eljlofgfcb wmculmhbnfja mlbn e klkeluw ho
~ml ulwplg~fvl auh|pw* ^mc~" fjf~fcbb _FM wmcbb el lj~f~bln ~h
jhkfjc~l = nfulg~huw cjn Lwwcu wmcbb el lj~f~bln ~h
jhkfjc~l > nfulg~huw h|~ ho c ~h~cb Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho MLB
-j|kelufja 35&* Ql k|w~ |jnluw~cjn ~ml ecgdauh|jn ho
~mfw ^luk Wmll~* Ofuw~b" cw w~c~ln ~ml ^luk Wmll~ qcw
lj~luln fj~h fj hunlu ~h ula|bc~l ~ml coocfuw ho MLB cjn ~h
ula|bc~l ~ml ulbc~fhjwmfp ho ~ml wmculmhbnluw ho MLB* F~ qcw
jlglwwcu ~h lj~lu fj~h w|gm cj caullklj~ ohu wkhh~m
u|jjfja ho ~ml e|wfjlww phw~ cgs|fwf~fhj* Wlghjnb" ql ofjn
ouhk ~ml bl~~lu cnnulwwln e MLB ~h OFPE nc~ln 3>*07*5001
~mc~ Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj ho MLB nfn jh~ aucj~ cj wplgfofg
pluwhj hu lj~f~ c ufam~ ~h cpphfj~ nfulg~huw* ^ml wcfn
nfulg~huw qlul cpphfj~ln e ~ml wmculmhbnluw ho MLB fj
cgghuncjgl qf~m ~ml puhvfwfhjw ho ~ml Fjnfcj Ghkpcj Bcq*
^ml bl~~lu o|u~mlu w~c~lw ~mc~fj pucg~fgl ~ml nfulg~huw qlul
cpphfj~ln puh uc~c ~h ~mlfu ulwplg~fvl wmculmhbnfjaw qmfgm
ulw|b~ln fj > nfulg~huw elfja cpphfj~ln ouhk Lwwcu auh|p" ?
nfulg~huw elfja cpphfj~ln e M^FB cjn 5 nfulg~huw qlul
cpphfj~ln e ^FF* Hjl w|gm nfulg~hu qcw CW" ~ml h~mlu
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
82/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=5
nfulg~hu qcw CA* ^mfw qcw ~ml pucg~fgl lvlj elohul ~ml
^luk Wmll~* ^ml ^luk Wmll~ ghj~fj|lw ~mfw pucg~fgl e
a|cucj~llfja hu cww|ufja Lwwcu ~mc~ > nfulg~huw qh|bn el
cpphfj~ln ouhk f~w Auh|p* ^ml cehvl ocg~w fjnfgc~l ~mc~ ~ml
heilg~ ho ~ml WPC qcw ~h ghj~fj|l ~ml pucg~fgl ghjglujfja
jhkfjc~fhj ho nfulg~huw hj ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho MLB
qmfgm fj bcq fw nfoolulj~ ouhk c ufam~ hu phqlu ~h ghj~uhb cjn
kcjcal cjn qmfgm pucg~fgl qcw afvlj ~h dllp ~ml e|wfjlww
ahfja" phw~ cgs|fwf~fhj* \jnlu ~ml Ghkpcj Bcq" ~ml
kcjcalklj~ ghj~uhb vlw~w fj ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw cjn jh~
qf~m ~ml wmculmhbnluw ho ~ml ghkpcj* ^mlulohul" jlf~mlu
ouhk Gbc|wl
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
83/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=7
-gcpf~cb cwwl~& cjn acfjw cufwfja ~mlulouhk* Fj ~ml bc~~lu
gcwl" ql mcvl ~h wll ~ml ghjnf~fhjw hj qmfgm ~ml ~c}
elghklw pccebl |jnlu ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Cg~* _cb|c~fhj kc
el c wgfljgl" jh~ bcq* Fj vcb|c~fhj" ~h cuufvl c~ ~ml vcb|l
hjl mcw ~h ~cdl fj~h ghjwfnluc~fhj ~ml e|wfjlww ulcbf~flw"
bfdl ~ml e|wfjlww khnlb" ~ml n|uc~fhj ho f~w hpluc~fhjw"
ghjglp~w w|gm cw gcwm obhq" ~ml nfwgh|j~fja ocg~huw" cwwl~w
cjn bfcefbf~flw" fj~cjafeblw" l~g* Fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" _FM
pcfn \W .33*0= ej ohu ?1, ho ~ml lj~lupufwl vcb|l ho MLB
pb|w f~w nhqjw~ulck ghkpcjflw mcvfja hpluc~fhjcb bfgljglw*
F~ eh|am~ cj |pw~ulck ghkpcj qf~m ~ml fj~lj~fhj ~mc~
ufam~w obhqfja ouhk ~ml GAP wmcul qh|bn ljcebl f~ ~h acfj
ghj~uhb hvlu ~ml gb|w~lu ho Fjnfcj hpluc~fhjw hu hpluc~fja
ghkpcjflw qmfgm hqjln ~lblghk bfgljglw" e|wfjlww cwwl~w"
l~g* _FM caulln ~h cgs|ful ghkpcjflw qmfgm fj ~|uj
ghj~uhbbln c ?1, fj~lulw~ fj MLB cjn f~w w|ewfnfcuflw*
_cb|c~fhj fw c kc~~lu ho hpfjfhj* Qmlj ~ml lj~ful e|wfjlww
hu fjvlw~klj~ fw whbn" ohu vcb|c~fhj p|uphwlw" hjl kc ~cdl
fj~h cggh|j~ ~ml lghjhkfg fj~lulw~ hu ulcbf~flw* Ufwdw cw c
nfwgh|j~fja ocg~hu cul cbwh ~h el ~cdlj fj~h ghjwfnluc~fhj
cpcu~ ouhk bhcjw" ulglfvceblw" hp~fhjw" UhOU( ^CU" l~g* Fj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
84/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=>
~mfw gcwl" Lj~lupufwl _cb|l fw kcnl |p ho ~qh pcu~w" jcklb"
~ml vcb|l ho MLB" ~ml vcb|l ho GAP cjn ~ml ghkpcjflw
el~qllj GAP cjn MLB* Fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" ~ml Ulvlj|l
gcjjh~ fjvhdl Wlg~fhj 6 ho ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Cg~ hj ~ml vcb|l
ho ~ml |jnlubfja cwwl~ hu ghjwls|ljgl ho cgs|fufja c wmcul
ho GAP* Fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" ~ml _cb|c~fhj nhjl qcw hj ~ml
ecwfw ho lj~lupufwl vcb|l* ^ml pufgl pcfn cw c pluglj~cal ho
~ml lj~lupufwl vcb|l mcn ~h el ?1, jh~ elgc|wl ~ml ofa|ul ho
?1, qcw cvcfbcebl fj puclwlj~f~h _FM" e|~ hj cggh|j~ ho ~ml
ocg~ ~mc~ ~ml ghkpl~fja Fjnfcj efnnluw qh|bn mcvl mcn nl
ocg~hcgglww ~h ~ml lj~ful ?1," cw ~ml qlul jh~ w|eilg~ ~h
~ml bfkf~c~fhj ho wlg~hucb gcp" cjn" ~mlulohul" qh|bn mcvl
fkklnfc~lb ljgcwmln ~ml gcbb hp~fhjw* ^ml s|lw~fhj w~fbb
ulkcfjw cw ~h ouhk qmlul nfn ~mfw ofa|ul( l}pulwwfhj ho ?1,
ho ls|f~ fj~lulw~ ghkl8 ^ml l}pulwwfhj ls|f~ fj~lulw~
gckl ouhk \W ACCP* Fj ~mfw ghjjlg~fhj" ql mcvl l}ckfjln
~ml Jh~lw ~h ~ml Cggh|j~w cjjl}ln ~h ~ml Cjj|cb Ulphu~
500? ho M^FB* Cgghunfja ~h Jh~l 3" ~ml hunfjcu wmculw ho
M^FB w~hhn bfw~ln hj ~ml Mhja Dhja W~hgd L}gmcjal cw qlbb
cw hj ~ml Jlq Vhud W~hgd L}gmcjal* Fj Jh~l Jh* 7?" c bfw~
ho pufjgfpcb w|ewfnfcuflw ho M^FB cw hj 73*35*500? mcw ellj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
85/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
=5*7>,4 GAP Fjnfc -Kw&"
qmfgm fj ~|uj mlbn wmculw fj ^FF cjn Hklac cjn qmfgm hj c
puh uc~c ecwfw -~ml ONF pufjgfpbl&" ~h~cbbln |p ~h 6*?5, fj
MLB cjn cj fjnfulg~ ghj~uhb hvlu M|~gmfwhj ^lbl+Wluvfglw
-Fjnfc& Mhbnfjaw B~n* -Kw&" qmfgm fj ~|uj hqjln wmculw fj
AWPB" qmfgm mlbn gcbb cjn p|~ hp~fhjw* Cb~mh|am ~ml Mfam
Gh|u~ mcw cjcbwln ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhjcb nhg|klj~w fj nl~cfb" f~
mcw kfwwln h|~ ~mfw cwplg~ ho ~ml gcwl* F~ mcw ocfbln ~h
jh~fgl ~mc~ ~fbb nc~l hp~fhjw mcvl ulkcfjln |j+ljgcwmln
qf~m AWPB* ^mlulohul" lvlj fo f~ el cww|kln ~mc~ ~ml
hp~fhjw |jnlu ~ml Oucklqhud Caullklj~w 500? gh|bn el
ghjwfnluln ~h el puhplu~ ufam~w" ~mlul mcw ellj jh ~ucjwolu
hu cwwfajklj~ ho hp~fhjw e AWPB ~fbb ~hnc* Lvlj fo f~ el
cww|kln ~mc~ ~ml Mfam Gh|u~ qcw ufam~ fj mhbnfja ~mc~ ~ml
hp~fhjw ghjw~f~|~ln gcpf~cb cwwl~w lvlj ~mlj Wlg~fhj 6-3&-f&
qcw jh~ cppbfgcebl cw ~mlwl hp~fhjw mcvl jh~ ellj
~ucjwoluuln ~fbb nc~l* Gcbb cjn p|~ hp~fhjw qlul jh~
~ucjwoluuln vfnl WPC nc~ln 33*05*5001 hu |jnlu cj h~mlu
nhg|klj~ qmc~whlvlu* Khulhvlu" fo" hj pufjgfpbl" ~ml Mfam
Gh|u~ cgglp~w ~mc~ ~ml ~ucjwolu ho ~ml GAP wmcul nfn jh~
blcn ~h ~ml ~ucjwolu ho c gcpf~cb cwwl~ fj Fjnfc" lvlj fo f~
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
90/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
60
ulw|b~ln fj c ~ucjwolu ho fjnfulg~ ghj~uhb hvlu >5*7>, -
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
91/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
63
bl~~lu" ~ml cehvl lblklj~w ~hal~mlu ls|c~ln ~h ?1, ho ~ml
lghjhkfg vcb|l ho MLB* ^mfw wlj~ljgl mcw ellj
kfwghjw~u|ln e ~ml Mfam Gh|u~ ~h wc ~mc~ ~ml cehvl
lblklj~w ls|c~ln ~h ?1, ho ~ml ls|f~ gcpf~cb -Wll pcuc
35>&* ?1, ho ~ml lghjhkfg vcb|l ho MLB fw jh~ ?1, ho ~ml
ls|f~ gcpf~cb* Fo _FM qh|bn mcvl cgs|fuln ?1, ho ~ml ls|f~
gcpf~cb" cw mlbn e ~ml Mfam Gh|u~" ~ml lj~ful fjvlw~klj~
qh|bn mcvl mcn eulcgmln ~ml ONF jhukw qmfgm mcn
fkphwln c wlg~hucb gcp ho 1>,* Fj ~mfw ghjjlg~fhj" f~ kc
o|u~mlu el w~c~ln ~mc~ Lwwcu mcn 77, w~cdlw fj MLB h|~ ho
qmfgm 55, qcw mlbn e Lwwcu Kc|uf~f|w* ^m|w" _FM nfn jh~
cgs|ful ?1, ho ~ml ls|f~ gcpf~cb ho MLB" cw mlbn e ~ml
Mfam Gh|u~* ^mfw puheblk mcw cufwlj cbwh elgc|wl ho ~ml
ulcwhj ~mc~ ~mfw gcwl nlcbw qf~m wmcul wcbl cjn jh~cwwl~
wcbl* ^mfw gcwl nhlw jh~ fjvhbvl wcbl ho cwwl~w hj f~lkfyln
ecwfw* ^ml Mfam Gh|u~ h|am~ ~h mcvl cppbfln ~ml bhhd c~
~lw~ fj qmfgm ~ml lj~ful M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul" cw f~ l}fw~ln"
h|am~ ~h mcvl ellj bhhdln c~ mhbfw~fgcbb* ^mfw gcwl
ghjglujw fjvlw~klj~ fj~h Fjnfc e c mhbnfja ghkpcj
-pculj~ ghkpcj&" M^FB ~muh|am c kcyl ho w|ewfnfcuflw*
Qmlj hjl cppbflw ~ml jc~|ul cjn gmcucg~lu ho ~ml
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
92/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
65
~ucjwcg~fhj ~lw~" ghjo|wfhj cufwlw fo c nfwwlg~fja cppuhcgm
ho l}ckfjfja lcgm fjnfvfn|cb cwwl~ fw cnhp~ln* Cw w~c~ln"
GAP qcw ~ulc~ln fj ~ml M|~gmfwhj w~u|g~|ul cw cj
fjvlw~klj~ vlmfgbl* Cw c aljlucb u|bl" fj c gcwl qmlul c
~ucjwcg~fhj fjvhbvlw ~ucjwolu ho wmculw bhgd" w~hgd cjn
ecuulb" w|gm c ~ucjwcg~fhj gcjjh~ el euhdlj |p fj~h
wlpcuc~l fjnfvfn|cb ghkphjlj~w" cwwl~w hu ufam~w w|gm cw
ufam~ ~h vh~l" ufam~ ~h pcu~fgfpc~l fj ghkpcj kll~fjaw"
kcjcalklj~ ufam~w" ghj~uhbbfja ufam~w" ghj~uhb pulkf|k"
eucjn bfgljglw cjn wh hj cw wmculw ghjw~f~|~l c e|jnbl ho
ufam~w* TWll Gmcucjif~ Bcb v* \jfhj ho FjnfcCFU 363"_ljdc~lwm -kfjhu& v* GF^5>7 F^U 7?1 -Kcn& cjn Wk~*
Kcmcucjf \wmcnlvf v* GF^373 F^U >>< -KP&[ O|u~mlu" ~ml
Mfam Gh|u~ mcw ocfbln ~h l}ckfjl ~ml jc~|ul ho ~ml ohbbhqfja
f~lkw" jcklb" jhj+ghkpl~l caullklj~" ghj~uhb pulkf|k"
gcbb cjn p|~ hp~fhjw" ghjw|b~cjg w|pphu~" g|w~hklu ecwl"
eucjn bfgljglw l~g* Hj ocg~w" ql cul ho ~ml vflq ~mc~ ~ml
Mfam Gh|u~" fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" h|am~ ~h mcvl l}ckfjln ~ml
lj~ful ~ucjwcg~fhj mhbfw~fgcbb* _FM mcw ufam~b ghj~ljnln
~mc~ ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj fj s|lw~fhj wmh|bn el bhhdln c~ cw cj
lj~ful pcgdcal* ^ml f~lkw klj~fhjln mlulfjcehvl" bfdl"
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
93/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
67
ghj~uhb pulkf|k" jhj+ghkpl~l caullklj~" ghjw|b~cjg
w|pphu~" g|w~hklu ecwl" eucjn bfgljglw" hpluc~fja bfgljglw
l~g* qlul cbb cj fj~laucb pcu~ ho ~ml Mhbnfja W|ewfnfcu
W~u|g~|ul qmfgm l}fw~ln ohu cbkhw~ 37 lcuw" aljluc~fja
m|al ulvlj|lw" cw fjnfgc~ln cehvl* Klulb elgc|wl c~ ~ml
~fkl ho l}f~ gcpf~cb acfjw ~c} elghklw jh~ pccebl hu l}fafebl
~h ~c} qh|bn jh~ kcdl ~ml lj~ful wmcul wcbl -fjvlw~klj~&
c wmck hu c ~c} cvhfncj~* ^ml Mfam Gh|u~ mcw ocfbln ~h
cppulgfc~l ~mc~ ~ml pcklj~ ho \W. 33*0= ej qcw ohu
p|ugmcwl ho ~ml lj~ful fjvlw~klj~ kcnl e M^FB fj Fjnfc*
^ml pcklj~ qcw ohu ~ml lj~ful pcgdcal* ^ml pcu~flw ~h ~ml
~ucjwcg~fhj mcvl jh~ caulln |phj c wlpcuc~l pufgl ohu ~ml
GAP wmcul cjn ohu qmc~ ~ml Mfam Gh|u~ gcbbw cw h~mlu
ufam~w cjn lj~f~blklj~w -fjgb|nfja hp~fhjw" ufam~ ~h jhj+
ghkpl~l" ghj~uhb pulkf|k" g|w~hklu ecwl l~g*&* ^m|w" f~ qcw
jh~ hplj ~h ~ml Ulvlj|l ~h wpbf~ ~ml pcklj~ cjn ghjwfnlu c
pcu~ ho w|gm pcklj~w ohu lcgm ho ~ml cehvl f~lkw* ^ml
lwwlj~fcb gmcucg~lu ho ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj cw cj cbfljc~fhj
gcjjh~ el cb~luln e ~ml ohuk ho ~ml ghjwfnluc~fhj" ~ml
pcklj~ ho ~ml ghjwfnluc~fhj fj fjw~cbklj~w hu hj ~ml ecwfw
~mc~ ~ml pcklj~ fw ulbc~ln ~h c ghj~fjaljg -hp~fhjw" fj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
94/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
6>
~mfw gcwl&" pcu~fg|bcub qmlj ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj nhlw jh~
ghj~lkpbc~l w|gm c wpbf~ |p* Qmlul ~ml pcu~flw mcvl caulln
ohu c b|kp w|k ghjwfnluc~fhj qf~mh|~ pbcgfja wlpcuc~l
vcb|lw ohu lcgm ho ~ml cehvl f~lkw qmfgm ah ~h kcdl |p ~ml
lj~ful fjvlw~klj~ fj pcu~fgfpc~fhj" klulb elgc|wl glu~cfj
vcb|lw cul fjnfgc~ln fj ~ml ghuulwphjnljgl qf~m OFPE qmfgm
mcn ucfwln ~ml s|lu" qh|bn jh~ klcj ~mc~ ~ml pcu~flw mcn
caulln ohu ~ml pufgl pccebl ohu lcgm ho ~ml cehvl f~lkw* ^ml
~ucjwcg~fhj ulkcfjln c ghj~ucg~ ho h|~ufam~ wcbl ho ~ml lj~ful
fjvlw~klj~ ohu c b|kp w|k ghjwfnluc~fhj Twll9 Ghkklj~cu
hj Khnlb ^c} Ghjvlj~fhj hj Fjghkl cjn Gcpf~cb nc~ln
5=*03*5007 cw cbwh ~ml i|naklj~ ho ~mfw Gh|u~ fj ~ml gcwl ho
GF^ -Glj~ucb&" Gcbg|~~c v* K|ajlluck Ecja|u cjn
Ghkpcj -Bcjn Nlp~~*&" -36?
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
95/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
6* Ql cul" fj ~ml pulwlj~ gcwl" ghjglujln qf~m c kc~~lu
ulbc~fja ~h guhww+ehunlu fjvlw~klj~ cjn ~ml blacb fww|lw
lkcjc~l ouhk ~mc~* Ocg~w mcvl ellj lbcehuc~lb nlcb~ qf~m
e ~ml Mfam Gh|u~ fj ~ml fkp|ajln i|naklj~ cjn cbwh fj
~ml blcnfja i|naklj~ ho Bhun Gmflo I|w~fgl" e|~ uloluljgl ~h
olq ocg~w fw jlglwwcu ~h cnnulww cjn cjwqlu ~ml ghul fww|lw
ucfwln* Hj cbb kcihu fww|lw" F o|bb ghjg|u qf~m ~ml vflqw
l}pulwwln e ~ml Bhun Gmflo I|w~fgl fj mfw lu|nf~l cjn
wgmhbcub i|naklj~*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
107/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
301
ho M^FB(_hncohjl cjn h~mlu ufam~w cjn lj~f~blklj~w" Pcu~+_F
nlcbw qf~m ~ml wghpl ho Wlg~fhj 6" Pcu~+_FF nlcbw qf~m Wlg~fhj
36< cjn h~mlu cbbfln puhvfwfhjw cjn Pcu~+_FFF fw ~ml
ghjgb|wfhjw*
Pcu~ F
?* M|~gmfwhj Qmckphc fw c k|b~f+wlg~fhjcb" k|b~f+
i|ufwnfg~fhjcb lj~f~ qmfgm ghjwhbfnc~lw hj c auh|p ecwfw
~lblghk hpluc~fhjw fj vcufh|w gh|j~uflw* M|~gmfwhj Auh|p
ho Ghkpcjflw -Mhja Dhja& mcn cgs|fuln fj~lulw~ fj ~ml
Fjnfcj ~lblghk e|wfjlww fj ~ml lcu 3665" qmlj ~ml auh|p
fjvlw~ln fj M|~gmfwhj Kc} ^lblghk Bfkf~ln -M^KB& -bc~lu
djhqj c M|~gmfwhj Lwwcu Bfkf~ln -MLB&" qmfgm cgs|fuln c
glbb|bcu bfgljwl fj K|kecf gfugbl fj ~ml lcu 366> cjn
ghkkljgln f~w hpluc~fhj fj ~ml lcu 366
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
108/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
30=
M^FM-K&[ eh~m fjghuphuc~ln fj Kc|uf~f|w* GAP-Fjnfc&
Fjvlw~klj~ -ohu wmhu~ GAPK& qcw fjghuphuc~ln fj Kc|uf~f|w
fj Nlglkelu 3661 ohu ~ml p|uphwl ho fjvlw~fja fj ^lblghk
Fjvlw~klj~ -Fjnfc& Pv~* Bfkf~ln -ohu wmhu~ ^FF&" cj Fjnfcj
Ghkpcj* GAPK cgs|fuln fj~lulw~w fj oh|u Kc|uf~fcj
Ghkpcjflw cjn lj~luln fj~h c Wmculmhbnluw Caullklj~
-WMC& hj 05*0 qcw bfw~ln
fj Mhja Dhja -MD& cjn Jlq Vhud -JV& W~hgd L}gmcjalw* Fj
~ml lcu 500
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
109/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
306
B~n* -MLB&* Hj 07*33*500
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
110/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
330
l}lg|~ln hj 03*07*500?* M^FB w~hhn cw c a|cucj~hu ohu
Glj~ufjh" ohu cj ckh|j~ ho ` >"=6= efbbfhj cnvcjgln e
Uceh Ecjd* M^FB mcn cbwh w~hhn cw c a|cucj~hu ohu JN
Gcbb|w" ohu cj cqcun ho `1*65> efbbfhj cnvcjgln e Uceh
Ecjd*
6* Ohbbhqfja ~ml gulnf~ w|pphu~ afvlj e M^FB ~h CA cjn
CW wh cw ~h ljcebl ~mlk ~h cgs|ful wmculw fj ^FF" pcu~flw
lj~luln fj~h wlpcuc~l caullklj~w qf~m 7 Abhecb Wluvfglw Pv~*
B~n* -Fjnfc& Tohu wmhu~ 7AWPB[" c QHW ho M FB* OQCw cbwh
ghj~cfjln gcbb hp~fhj fj ocvh|u ho 7AWPB" c ufam~ ~h
p|ugmcwl ouhk Ahbn Wph~ -cj CA ghkpcj& cjn Wghupfhw -cj
CW ghkpcj& ~mlfu lj~ful wmculmhbnfja fj ^FF mlbn ~muh|am
Pb|w~lgm -cj CA ghkpcj& cjn K_M -cj CW ghkpcj&
ulwplg~fvlb* W|ewgufp~fhj ufam~ qcw cbwh puhvfnln cbbhqfja
7AWPB c ufam~ ~h w|ewgufel 61*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
111/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
333
ghkpcjflw cjn CW ghkpcjflw ouhk ~ucjwoluufja cj
nhqjw~ulck fj~lulw~w blcnfja ~h ~ml wmculmhbnfja fj ^FF*
30* MLB wmculmhbnfja cacfj |jnluqlj~ gmcjal qf~m
Mfjn|ic Auh|p l}f~fja cjn f~w wmculmhbnfja elfja cgs|fuln
e cj Fjnfcj ghkpcj gcbbln WKKW Fjvlw~klj~w Pufvc~l
Bfkf~ln -WKKW&* WKKW qcw cbwh c ihfj~ vlj~|ul ghkpcj
ohukln e Fjnfc Nlvlbhpklj~ O|jn -FNO& cg~fja ~muh|am
FNOG Pufvc~l Ls|f~ Ghkpcj -FNOGPL&" Fjoucw~u|g~|ul
Nlvlbhpklj~ Ofjcjgl Ghkpcj Bfkf~ln -FNOG& cjn WWDF
Ghuphuc~l Ofjcjgl Pv~* B~n* -WWDF& cbb ~ml ~mull ghkpcjflw
qlul fjghuphuc~ln fj Fjnfc* P|uw|cj~ ~mlul~h" c OQC qcw
lj~luln fj~h hj 01*0=*500? el~qllj FNO -~muh|am FNOGPL&"
FNOG" WWDF" WKKW" M^FB -K&" 7AWPB" Fjn|w Fjn ^lblghk
Mhbnfja Pv~* B~n* -F^JB& -bc~lu jckln cw Hklac ^lblghk
Mhbnfja Pv~* B~n* -Hklac& cjn M^FB* 7AWPB" e ~mc~
Caullklj~" mcn cgcbb hp~fhj cjn c ufam~ ~h p|ugmcwl ~ml
lj~ful ls|f~ wmculw ho WKKW c~ c pul+nl~lukfjln pufgl
ls|cb ~h ` ??3"5
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
112/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
335
Caullklj~ uloluuln ~h ~ml pulwljgl ho c~ blcw~ hjl ho ~ml
nfulg~huw jhkfjc~ln e M^FB fj ~ml Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw ho
Hklac* M^FB qcw hjb c ghjofukfja pcu~ ~h ~mfw
Caullklj~ wfjgl f~ qcw ~ml pculj~ ghkpcj*
33* M^FB fww|ln c pulww ulblcwl hj 55*35*500? fj ~ml MD
cjn JV W~hgd L}gmcjalw cjjh|jgfja ~mc~ f~ mcn ellj
cppuhcgmln e vcufh|w ph~lj~fcbb fj~lulw~ln pcu~flw
ulacunfja c phwwfebl wcbl ho f~w ls|f~ fj~lulw~ fj MLB fj
~ml ^lblghk Wlg~hu fj Fjnfc* M^FB mcn cnhp~ln ~mhwl
klcw|ulw co~lu puhg|ufja cbb cwwfajklj~w ho bhcjw"
ocgfbf~c~fja OQCw" WMCw" ~ucjwoluufja M|~gm Eucjgm"
~ucjwoluufja Hucgbl Bfgljwl l~g*
35* _hncohjl Auh|p Pbg* gckl ~h djhq ho ~ml phwwfebl l}f~
ho M|~gm ouhk Fjnfcj ~lblghk e|wfjlww cjn hj elmcbo ho
_hncohjl Auh|p kcnl c jhj+efjnfja hoolu hj 55*35*0?" ohu c
w|k ho \W. 33*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
113/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
337
Nfwgbhw|ul -Ghjofnlj~fcbf~& Caullklj~ nc~ln 05*03*5001 qcw
lj~luln fj~h el~qllj M^FB cjn _hncohjl* Hj 06*05*5001
_hncohjl Auh|p Pbg* quh~l c bl~~lu ~h M^FB kcdfja c ulvfwln
cjn efjnfja hoolu hj elmcbo ho c klkelu ho _hncohjl Auh|p
-_hncohjl& ohu M^FBw wmculmhbnfjaw fj MLB ~hal~mlu qf~m
fj~luulbc~ln ghkpcj bhcjw* Emcuc~f Fjoh~lb Pv~* Bfkf~ln hj
06*05*5001 l}pulwwln f~w jh heilg~fhj ~h ~ml Gmcfukcj"
_hncohjl Kc|uf~f|w Bfkf~ln ulacunfja puhphwln cgs|fwf~fhj
e _hncohjl auh|p ho nfulg~ cjn ( fjnfulg~ fj~lulw~ fj MLB
ouhk M|~gmfwhj hu Lwwcu auh|p* Emcuc~f Cfu~lb cbwh wlj~ c
wfkfbcu bl~~lu ~h _hncohjl*
37* _hncohjl Auh|p Pbg* hj 30*05*5001 kcnl c ofjcb
efjnfja hoolu ho \W. 33*01? efbbfhj fj gcwm hvlu M^FBw
fj~lulw~" ecwln hj cj lj~lupufwl vcb|l ho \W. 3=*=00 efbbfhj
ho MLB* Lujw~ cjn Vh|ja BBP" \*D* hj 33*05*5001 fww|ln
n|l nfbfaljgl ulphu~ fj ulbc~fhj ~h hpluc~fja ghkpcjflw fj
Fjnfc jcklb MLB cjn w|ewfnfcuflw cjn cbwh ~ml Kc|uf~fcj
cjn Gckcj Fwbcjn Ghkpcjflw* Ulphu~ jh~fgln ~mc~ GAP-GF&
qcw jh~ qf~mfj ~ml ~cual~ auh|p cjn qcw bc~lu fjgb|nln c~ ~ml
fjw~cjgl ho M^FB* Hj 33*05*5001" \EW Bfkf~ln" \*D* fww|ln
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
114/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
33>
ocfujlww hpfjfhj fj ulbc~fhj ~h ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj ohu cgs|fwf~fhj
e _hncohjl ouhk M^FB ho c ?1, loolg~fvl fj~lulw~ fj MLB
~muh|am ~ml cgs|fwf~fhj ho 300, fj~lulw~ fj GAP cjn aucj~fja
cj hp~fhj e _hncohjl ~h Fjnfcj Ghj~fjlj~ Fjvlw~klj~ B~n*
hvlu c * _hncohjl cjn M^FB ~mlj lj~luln fj~h c Wmcul cjn
P|ugmcwl Caullklj~ -WPC& hj 33*05*5001 qmlul|jnlu M^FB
mcn caulln ~h puhg|ul ~ml ~ucjwolu ho wmcul gcpf~cb ho GAP
e M^FE_F" oull ouhk cbb ljg|keucjglw cjn ~hal~mlu qf~m cbb
ufam~w c~~cgmfja hu cggu|fja ~hal~mlu qf~m cwwfajklj~w ho
bhcj fj~lulw~* M^FB hj 33*05*5001 fww|ln c wfnl bl~~lu ~h
_hncohjl fj~lu cbfc w~c~fja ~mc~" h|~ ho ~ml p|ugmcwl
ghjwfnluc~fhj" |p ~h \W.=0 kfbbfhj gh|bn el pcfn ~h whkl ho
f~w Fjnfcj Pcu~jluw* M^FB mcn cbwh |jnlu~cdlj ~mc~
M|~gmfwhj ^lblghkk|jfgc~fhj -Fjnfc& B~n* -M^K&" Hklac
cjn 7AWPB" qh|bn lj~lu fj~h cj caulln ohuk FNOG
^ucjwcg~fhj Caullklj~ cw whhj cw pucg~fgcebl* Hj
33*05*5001" M^FB cbwh wlj~ c nfwgbhw|ul bl~~lu ~h _hncohjl
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
115/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
33 ho WPC _ljnhu qcuucj~flw ulbc~fja
~h ghjwlj~w cjn cppuhvcbw" qfnlu auh|p ghkpcjflw" kc~lufcb
ghj~ucg~w" plukf~w" bf~fac~fhj" cuef~uc~fhj cjn ahvlujklj~cb
puhgllnfjaw ~h bfkf~ M^FB bfcefbf~*
3*05*5001 cbhja qf~m c ghp ho Pulww
cjjh|jglklj~ kcnl e M^FB" wl~~fja h|~ ~ml pufjgfpcb
~lukw ho ~ml fj~ljnln wcbl ho M^FB ho f~w ls|f~ cjn bhcjw fj
MLB" e qc ho wcbl ho GAP wmcul cjn bhcj cwwfajklj~ ~h
_FME_*
3?* _hncohjl hj 50*05*5001 ofbln cj cppbfgc~fhj qf~m
Ohulfaj Fjvlw~klj~ Puhkh~fhj Ehcun -OFPE& uls|lw~fja f~ ~h
~cdl jh~l ho cjn aucj~ cppuhvcb |jnlu Pulww jh~l jh*3 ~h
~ml fjnfulg~ cgs|fwf~fhj e _hncohjl ho
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
116/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
33?
~muh|am cj hvluwlcw cgs|fwf~fhj ho ~ml lj~ful wmcul gcpf~cb
ho GAP ouhk M^FB* M^FB kcnl cj cjjh|jglklj~ hj MD
W~hgd L}gmcjal ulacunfja ~ml fj~ljnln |wl ho puhgllnw
ouhk wcbl ho M^FBw fj~lulw~ fj MLB vfy*" nlgbcufja c wplgfcb
nfvfnljn ho MD. ?*1< plu wmcul" MD. 37*6 efbbfhj ~h uln|gl
nle~ cjn ~ml ulkcfjnlu ~h el fjvlw~ln fj ~lblghkk|jfgc~fhj
e|wfjlww" eh~m ohu l}pcjwfhj cjn ~hqcunw qhudfja gcpf~cb
cjn aljlucb phbfgflw* Uloluljgl qcw cbwh kcnl ~h ~ml wcbl
wmcul cjn wcbl bhcjw cw elfja ~ml lj~ful fww|ln wmcul
gcpf~cb ho GAP cjn ~ml bhcjw hqjln e GAP(Cuuc ~h cj
fjnfulg~ QHW* CA hj 05*07*5001 wlj~ c bl~~lu ~h MLB
ghjofukfja ~mc~ ml qcw ~ml l}gb|wfvl eljlofgfcb hqjlu ho mfw
wmculw cjn qcw mcvfja o|bb ghj~uhb hvlu ulbc~ln vh~fja
ufam~w* O|u~mlu" f~ qcw cbwh w~c~ln ~mc~ CA mcn ulglfvln
gulnf~ w|pphu~" e|~ pufkcu bfcefbf~ qcw qf~m mfw
Ghkpcjflw* CW cbwh wlj~ c bl~~lu hj 0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
117/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
331
31* Lwwcu mcn ofbln heilg~fhjw qf~m ~ml OFPE hj
0?*07*5001 ~h M^FBw puhphwln wcbl cjn hj 3>*07*5001"
Lwwcu qf~mnulq f~w heilg~fhjw*
3=* OFPE hj 3>*07*5001 wlj~ c bl~~lu ~h MLB phfj~fja h|~
~mc~ fj ofbfja ho M^FB elohul ~ml \*W* WLG fj Ohuk ?D fj ~ml
khj~m ho Kcugm 500?" f~ mcn ellj w~c~ln ~mc~ M^FB Auh|p
qh|bn ghj~fj|l ~h mhbn cj caaulac~l fj~lulw~ ho >5*7>, ho
MLB cjn cj cnnf~fhjcb fjnfulg~ fj~lulw~ ~muh|am I_
ghkpcjflw elfja jhj+qmhbb hqjln w|ewfnfcuflw ho M^FB
qmfgm mhbn cj caaulac~l ho 36*, ho MLB cjn" mljgl" ~ml
ghkefjln mhbnfja ho M^FB Auh|p qh|bn ~mlj el ?3*==,*
Uloluljgl qcw cbwh kcnl ~h ~ml ghkk|jfgc~fhj nc~ln
0?*07*5001 wlj~ ~h ~ml OFPE qmlulfj f~ qcw w~c~ln ~mc~ ~ml
nfulg~ cjn fjnfulg~ ONF e M^FB qh|bn el *07*5001 qcw cbwh ulglfvln e _hncohjl* Hj
3>*07*5001" MLB quh~l ~h OFPE w~c~fja ~mc~ ~ml nfwgulpcjg
qcw elgc|wl ho ~ml nfooluljgl fj \*W* ACCP cjn Fjnfcj
ACCP nlgbcuc~fhjw cjn ~mc~ ~ml ghkefjln mhbnfja ohu \*W*
ACCP p|uphwlw qcw ?3*==, cjn ohu Fjnfcj ACCP p|uphwlw
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
118/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
33=
qcw *07*5001 f~wlbo" MLB quh~l ~h OFPE
ghjofukfja ~mc~ 1**1=, w~cdl fj MLB qcw
mlbn blacbb cjn eljlofgfcbb e CA* O|u~mlu" f~ qcw cbwh
phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ 5*11, w~cdl fj MLB ~muh|am Hklac cjn
W*K*K*W* qcw blacbb cjn eljlofgfcbb hqjln e FNOG
Bfkf~ln" FNOG Pufvc~l Ls|f~ Bfkf~ln cjn WWDF Ghuphuc~l
Ofjcjgl Bfkf~ln* O|u~mlu" f~ qcw cbwh phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~
Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj ho MLB nfn jh~ afvl cj pluwhj hu
lj~f~ cj ufam~ ~h cpphfj~ nfulg~huw" mhqlvlu" fj pucg~fgl wf}
nfulg~huw qlul ouhk M^FB" oh|u ouhk Lwwcu" ~qh ouhk ^FF cjn
^FF mcn cpphfj~ln CA / CW* Hj gulnf~ w|pphu~ caullklj~" f~
qcw phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ jh plukfwwfhj ho cj ula|bc~hu
c|~mhuf~ qcw uls|fuln*
36* _hncohjl cbwh quh~l ~h OFPE hj 3>*07*5001 ghjofukfja
~mc~ _FME_w loolg~fvl wmculmhbnfja fj MLB qh|bn el
5, nfulg~ fj~lulw~ fj MLB
~muh|am f~w cgs|fwf~fhj ho 300, ho GAP Fjvlw~klj~w
-Mhbnfjaw& Bfkf~ln -GAPFB& cjn ~muh|am GAPFB _hncohjl
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
119/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
336
qh|bn cbwh hqj 71, fj ^FF qmfgm fj ~|uj hqjln 50, fj MLB
cjn 7=, fj Hklac qmfgm fj ~|uj hqjln 3*< kfbbfhj co~lu
wlghjn cjjfvluwcu ho ghkpbl~fhj* Fj ~mc~ caullklj~" M^FB
mcn caulln ~h nfwphwl ho f~w nfulg~ cjn fjnfulg~ ls|f~" bhcj
cjn h~mlu fj~lulw~w cjn ufam~w fj cjn ulbc~ln ~h MLB" ~h
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
120/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
350
_hncohjl p|uw|cj~ ~h ~ml WPC* M^FB mcn cbwh caulln ~h pc
\W. >3< kfbbfhj ~h Lwwcu fj ul~|uj ho f~w cgglp~cjgl ho ~ml
WPC el~qllj M^FB cjn _hncohjl* Hj 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
121/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
353
w~c~ln ~mc~ Lwwcu mcn c ^CU fj ulwplg~ ho Lwwcuw
wmculmhbnfja fj MLB" wmh|bn cj _hncohjl Auh|p
wmculmhbnfja wlbb f~w wmcul hu pcu~ ~mlulho fj MLB ~h c
pluwhj jh~ fj c _hncohjl Auh|p lj~f~* _FME_ cjn
_hncohjl Auh|p Pbg*-cw a|cucj~hu ho _FME_& mcn lj~luln
fj~h c P|~ Hp~fhj Caullklj~ hj 3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
122/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
355
cgs|fwf~fhj qcw hjb
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
123/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
357
gbcufofja ~mc~ f~ qcw jlf~mlu c pcu~ ~h ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj jhu
qh|bn ~mlul el cj ~ucjwolu ho wmculw ho MLB*
5?* MLB ulglfvln c bl~~lu nc~ln 57*7*5001 ouhk ~ml
Cnnf~fhjcb Nfulg~hu Fjghkl ^c} -Fj~lujc~fhjcb ^c}c~fhj&
fj~fkc~fja ~mc~ eh~m _hncohjl cjn M|~gmfwhj ^lblghk
Auh|p cjjh|jglklj~w(pulww ulblcwlw(nlgbcuc~fhjw mcn
ulvlcbln ~mc~ M^FB mcn kcnl w|ew~cj~fvl acfjw cjn
ghjwls|lj~b MLB qcw uls|lw~ln ~h fkpulww |phj
M^FB(M|~gmfwhj ^lblghk Auh|p ~h nfwgmcual ~mlfu bfcefbf~
hj acfjw" elohul ~ml glcwln hpluc~fhjw fj Fjnfc* MLB
c~~lj~fhj qcw cbwh nucqj ~h Wlg~fhjw 36
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
124/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
35>
-e& F~w hqjluwmfp ho ulnllkcebl puloluljglwmculw fj ^FF cjn IDO4
-g& Cww|kp~fhj ho bfcefbf~flw ho vcufh|w
w|ewfnfcuflw ho GAP ckh|j~fja ~h cppuh}fkc~lb\W.?70 kfbbfhj4
-n& w|eilg~ ~h Fjnfcj Ohulfaj Fjvlw~klj~ U|blw"f~w ufam~w cjn lj~f~blklj~w" fjgb|nfjaw|ewgufp~fhj ufam~w c~ pcu vcb|l cjn gcbb hp~fhjw~h cgs|ful fj o|~|ul c o|u~mlu ?5*1
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
125/275
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
126/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
35?
cppuhvcb qcw cbwh cgghunln ~h ~ml cpphfj~klj~ ho Lufd nl
Uifd cw c whbl nfulg~hu ho GAP* Ulwhb|~fhj cbwh cgghunln
cppuhvcb ~h ~ml ~ucjwolu ho GAP ouhk M^F E_F ~h _hncohjl*
Hj 70*0>*5001 c ehcun ho ulwhb|~fhj qcw pcwwln e ~ml
nfulg~huw ho Cuuc ohu ~ml cwwfajklj~ ho bhcjw cjn
ulwfajc~fhj ho l}fw~fja nfulg~huw cjn cpphfj~klj~ ho jlq
nfulg~huw jcklb Lufd nl Uifd cjn ~qh h~mluw* Hj
70*0>*5001" ~ml ehcun ho nfulg~huw ho M^F E_F cppuhvln ~ml
~ucjwolu nhg|klj~c~fhj fj ulbc~fhj ~h GAP wmcul gcpf~cb fj
p|uw|cjgl ho WPC cjn n|l l}lg|~fhj ~mlulho* Hj
0>*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
127/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
351
ho wmcul gcpf~cb ho GAP* Hj 0=*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
128/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
35=
0=*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
129/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
356
qc ho M^FB!w ghj~ufe|~fhj ~hqcunw cgs|fwf~fhj ghw~ ho
hp~fhjw f*l*" w~cdl ho CW / CA* Hj 0=*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
130/275
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
131/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
373
_hncohjl cw c ghjofukfja pcu~* Fj ghjwfnluc~fhj ohu ~ml
|jghjnf~fhjcb !gcbb hp~fhj" 7AWPB caulln ~h pc CA cj
ckh|j~ ho \W. ?*7 kfbbfhj cjj|cbb* Hj ~ml wckl nc c
OQC qcw wfajln e CW cjn Jll~| CW" Wghupfh Elvlucalw
Pv~* B~n*-WEP&" K*_* Mlcb~mgcul Wluvfglw Pv~* B~n" 7AWPB"
J*N* Gcbb|w Fjoh Wluvfglw Pv~* B~n cjn _hncohjl" cw c
ghjofukfja pcu~* Fj ghjwfnluc~fhj ohu ~ml !gcbb hp~fhj
7AWPB caulln ~h pc CW / Kuw* Jll~| CW cj ckh|j~ ho \W.
30*05 kfbbfhj cjj|cbb* ^FF WMC qcw lj~luln fj~h hj
0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
132/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
375
75 ho 5001 elohul ~ml Ehkec Mfam
Gh|u~* ^ml Cwwfw~cj~ Nfulg~hu ho Fjghkl ^c} -Fj~b*& Gfugbl
5-5&" K|kecf" fww|ln c wmhq gc|wl jh~fgl ~h _hncohjl
|jnlu Wlg~fhj 503-3& cjn 503-3C& ho ~ml F*^* Cg~ cw ~h qm
_hncohjl wmh|bn jh~ el ~ulc~ln c cwwlwwll+fj+nloc|b~ ohu
ocfb|ul ~h qf~mmhbn ~c}* _hncohjl ~mlj ofbln c Quf~ Pl~f~fhj
5
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
133/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
377
503 cjn 503-3C& e ~ml Fjghkl ^c} c|~mhuf~flw* _hncohjl
ulpbfln ~h ~ml wmhq gc|wl jh~fgl hj 56*03*5030* Hj
73*0
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
134/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
37>
Pl~f~fhj hj 0=*06*5030 cacfjw~ qmfgm ~ml pulwlj~ WBP mcw
ellj ofbln*
71* ^ml Mfam Gh|u~ |pmlbn ~ml i|ufwnfg~fhj ho ~ml Ulvlj|l
~h fkphwl gcpf~cb acfjw ~c} hj _hncohjl cw c ulpulwlj~c~fvl
cwwlwwll co~lu mhbnfja ~mc~ ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj el~qllj ~ml
pcu~flw c~~ucg~ln gcpf~cb acfjw fj Fjnfc* Gh|u~ gckl ~h ~ml
ohbbhqfja ghjgb|wfhjw9
-c& ^ucjwcg~fhjw el~qllj M^FB cjn _hncohjl qlulo|bofbbln jh~ klulb e ~ucjwoluufja c wfjablwmcul ho GAP fj Gckcj Fwbcjnw" e|~ ~mlghkklugfcb cjn e|wfjlww |jnluw~cjnfjael~qllj ~ml pcu~flw phw~|bc~ln ~mc~ qmc~ qcwelfja ~ucjwoluuln ouhk M^FB ~h _FME_ qcw ~ml
ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ fj MLB fj Fjnfc" qmfgm fwcj fnlj~fofcebl gcpf~cb cwwl~ fjnlpljnlj~ hoGAP wmcul*
-e& M^FB mcn p|~ fj~h pbcgl n|ufja ~ml plufhnqmlj f~ qcw fj ~ml ghj~uhb ho MLB c ghkpbl}w~u|g~|ul fjgb|nfja ~ml ofjcjgfja ho Fjnfcjghkpcjflw qmfgm fj ~|uj mcn mhbnfjaw nfulg~bhu fjnfulg~b fj MLB cjn mljgl ah~ ghj~uhbbfja
fj~lulw~ fj MLB*
-g& _hncohjl hj p|ugmcwl ho GAP ah~ fjnfulg~fj~lulw~ fj MLB" ghj~uhbbfja ufam~ fj glu~cfjfjnfulg~ mhbnfja ghkpcjflw fj MLB" ghj~uhbbfjaufam~w ~muh|am wmculmhbnlu caullklj~w qmfgmfjgb|nln ~ml ufam~ ~h cpphfj~ nfulg~huw fjglu~cfj fjnfulg~ mhbnfja ghkpcjflw fj MLB"fj~lulw~ fj ~ml ohuk ho puloluljgl wmcul gcpf~cb
fj fjnfulg~ mhbnfja ghkpcjflw ho MLB" ufam~w ~h|wl M|~gm eucjn fj Fjnfc" jhj+ghkpl~l
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
135/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
371& qmfgm puhvfnlw ohu l}~fja|fwmklj~ fw
c~~ucg~ln ohu c ~ucjwolu ho c blacb ufam~ cjn jh~ c ghj~ucg~|cb
ufam~ cjn ~mlul qcw jh l}~fja|fwmklj~ ho ufam~ e M^FB
qmfgm acvl ufwl ~h gcpf~cb acfjw ~c} fj Fjnfc* Uloluljgl qcw
kcnl ~h i|naklj~GF^ v* Aucgl Ghbbfw -5003& 7 WGG >70*
Blcujln wljfhu gh|jwlb cbwh w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml cgs|fwf~fhj
ho ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ fw c ghkklugfcb ghjglp~ cjn ~c} fw
blvfln hj ~ucjwcg~fhj cjn jh~ f~w loolg~* Blcujln wljfhu
gh|jwlb phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ ~h bfo~ ~ml ghuphuc~l vlfb ho c blacbb
ulghajfwln ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ul ~fkl cjn ~ml w~cal ho ~ml
~ucjwcg~fhj cul vlu fkphu~cj~ cjn jh~ ~ml kh~fvl ~h wcvl
~ml ~c}* Uloluljgl qcw cbwh kcnl ~h wlvlucb i|naklj~w ho
~ml Ljabfwm Gh|u~w vfy" FUG v* N|dl ho Qlw~kfjw~lu-367?&
CG 3 -MB&" Q* ^* Uckwc v* FUG -36=5& CG 700 -MB&"
Gucvlj v* Qmf~l -36==& 7 Cbb LU >6
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
140/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>0
wljfhu gh|jwlb phfj~ h|~ ~mc~ Cycnf Ecgmch Cjnhbcj euhcnb
uloblg~w Fjnfcj i|ufwpu|nljgl cjn ~mc~ aljlucbb Fjnfcj
gh|u~w |wln ~h ohbbhq ~ml pufjgfpblw bcfn nhqj e Ljabfwm
Gh|u~w hj ~ml fww|l ho ~c} cvhfncjgl cjn ~c} lvcwfhj*
Blcujln Wljfhu gh|jwlb cbwh w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ^c} Ulwfnljg
Glu~fofgc~l -ohu wmhu~ ^UG& fww|ln e ~ml Kc|uf~fcj
c|~mhuf~flw mcw ~h el ulwplg~ln cjn fj ~ml cewljgl ho cj
Bfkf~c~fhj hj Eljlof~ -BHE Gbc|wl&" ~ml eljlof~ ho ~ml Fjnh+
Kc|uf~fcj ^ulc~ fw cvcfbcebl ~h ~mfun pcu~flw qmh fjvlw~ fj
Fjnfc ~muh|am Kc|uf~f|w uh|~l*
76* Ku* Wcbvl cbwh cua|ln hj ~ml l}~uc ~luuf~hufcb
cppbfgcefbf~ ho Wlg~fhj 36< cjn w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml wckl
gcjjh~ el ljohugln hj c jhj+ulwfnlj~ qf~mh|~ c pulwljgl fj
Fjnfc* Gh|jwlb cbwh phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ ~ml qhunw cj pluwhj
fj Wlg~fhj 36< wmh|bn el ghjw~u|ln ~h cppb ~h pcluw qmh
mcvl c pulwljgl fj Fjnfc hu lbwl ljohuglklj~ qh|bn el
fkphwwfebl cjn w|gm c puhvfwfhj wmh|bn el ulcn nhqj fj
gcwl ho pcklj~w jh~ mcvfja cj jl}|w qf~m Fjnfc* Wljfhu
gh|jwlb cbwh w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml qf~mmhbnfja ~c} puhvfwfhjw
|jnlu Wlg~fhj 36< ho ~ml Fjnfcj Fjghkl ^c} Cg~" nh jh~
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
141/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>3
cppb ~h hoowmhul lj~f~flw kcdfja hoo+wmhul pcklj~w cjn
~ml wcfn Wlg~fhj gh|bn el ~ufaaluln hjb fo f~ gcj el
lw~cebfwmln ~mc~ ~ml pcklj~ |jnlu ghjwfnluc~fhj fw ho c
w|k gmcualcebl |jnlu ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Cg~ -ohu wmhu~ F^
Cg~&* Wljfhu gh|jwlb ~mlulohul ghj~ljnln ~mc~ ~ml ofjnfjaw ho
~ml ^c} C|~mhuf~flw ~mc~ p|uw|cj~ ~h ~ml ~ucjwcg~fhj ~ml
eljlof~ ho ~lblghk bfgljgl w~hhn ~ucjwoluuln ~h _hncohjl fw
kfwghjglfvln cjn ~mc~ |jnlu ~ml ~lblghk phbfg ho Fjnfc c
~lblghk bfgljgl gcj el mlbn hjb e cj Fjnfcj Ghkpcj cjn
~mlul fw jh ~ucjwolu nfulg~ hu fjnfulg~ ho cj bfgljgl ~h
_hncohjl*
>0* Ku* U*O* Jcufkcj" Blcujln Whbfgf~hu Aljlucb cpplcufja
ohu ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Nlpcu~klj~ w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml wcbl ho
GAP wmcul qcw jh~mfja e|~ cj cu~fofgfcb cvhfncjgl wgmlkl
cjn GAP qcw ofwmln h|~ ho ~ml M^FB blacb w~u|g~|ul cw cj
cu~fofgfcb ~c} cvhfncjgl ghj~ufvcjgl* Wmuf Jcufkcj phfj~ln
h|~ ~mc~ GAP wmcul mcw ellj fj~luphwln c~ ~ml bcw~ kfj|~l
~h cu~fofgfcbb ulkhvl M^FB ouhk ~ml Fjnfcj ~lblghk e|wfjlww*
Uloluljgl qcw kcnl ~h ~ml N|l Nfbfaljgl Ulphu~ ho Lujw~
cjn Vh|ja qmfgm w~c~ln ~mc~ ~cual~ w~u|g~|ul bc~lu fjgb|nln
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
142/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>5
GAP qmfgm qcw jh~ ~mlul hufafjcbb* O|u~mlu" f~ qcw cbwh
phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ M^FB l}~fja|fwmln f~w ufam~w fj MLB cjn
p|~ _hncohjl fj f~w pbcgl cjn GAP qcw klulb cj fj~lubhplu*
Wmuf Jcufkcj cbwh phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ cw plu Wl~~blklj~
Caullklj~" M^FB whbn nfulg~ cjn fjnfulg~ ls|f~ mhbnfjaw"
bhcjw" h~mlu fj~lulw~w cjn ufam~w ulbc~fja ~h MLB qmfgm
gblcub ulvlcb whkl~mfja h~mlu ~mcj GAP wmcul qcw whbn cjn
~mhwl ~ucjwcg~fhjw qlul l}phwln e ~ml WPC* Blcujln
Whbfgf~hu Aljlucb cbwh uloluuln l}~ljwfvlb ~ml puhvfwfhjw ho
WPC cjn w|ekf~~ln ~mc~ ~ml blacb hqjlu ho GAP fw M^FE_F
Mhbnfjaw B~n*" c Euf~fwm _fuafj Fwbcjnw Ghkpcj qmfgm qcw
l}gb|nln ouhk ~ml Caullklj~ qf~m cj hebfs|l ~c} kh~fvl*
>3* Ku* Jcufkcj cbwh w|ekf~~ln ~ml wf~|w ho GAP gcj hjb
el fj Fjnfc cw ~ml lj~ful e|wfjlww p|uphwl ho mhbnfja ~mc~
wmcul qcw ~h cww|kl ghj~uhb fj Fjnfcj ~lblghk hpluc~fhjw"
~ml wckl qcw kcjcaln ~muh|am Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw
ghj~uhbbln e M^FB* ^ml ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ l}pulwwln e
M^FB qh|bn ckh|j~ ~h puhplu~ ufam~w cjn mljgl ~c}cebl fj
Fjnfc* Uloluljgl qcw kcnl ~h i|naklj~w ho ~ml Gcbg|~~c
Mfam Gh|u~ fj GF^ v* Jc~fhjcb Fjw|ucjgl Ghkpcj-361=&
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
143/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>7
337 F^U 71-Gcb*& cjn Bc}kf Fjw|ucjgl Ghkpcj Pv~* B~n*
v* GF^ -3613& =0 F^U
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
144/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>>
ghjw~u|g~fhj hj ~ml WPC* Ghjwfnlucebl ulbfcjgl qcw pbcgln
hj i|naklj~ ho ~mfw Gh|u~ fj Kg*Nhqlbbcjn w|ekf~~ln ~mc~
~ml wckl el ohbbhqln cjn jh~ Cycnf Ecgmch Cjnhbcj
qmfgm mcw ellj fjghuulg~b nlgfnln* O|u~mlu" f~ qcw cbwh
phfj~ln h|~ ~mc~ Gfug|bcu Jh*1=6 cw ulacunw ~ml
ghjgb|wfvljlww ho ^UG qh|bn cppb hjb ~h nfvfnljn gbc|wl
cjn cw ulacunw gcpf~cb acfjw" f~ qh|bn w~fbb mcvl ~h wc~fwo
~ml ~qfj ~lw~w ho Cu~fgbl 37->& ho ~ml ~ulc~ jcklb ~ml wmculw
elfja cbfljc~ln cjn ~ml acfjw elfja nlufvln e c
Kc|uf~fcj lj~f~* Blcujln Whbfgf~hu Aljlucb cbwh w|ekf~~ln
~mc~ ~ml Nlpcu~klj~ gcj kcdl cj ljs|fu fj~h qml~mlu
gcpf~cb acfjw mcvl ellj ocg~|cbb cjn blacbb cwwfajln ~h c
Kc|uf~fcj lj~f~ hu ~h ~mfun pcu~ cjn qml~mlu ~ml Kc|uf~fcj
Ghkpcj qcw c occnl*
>5* Blcujln gh|jwlbw" hj lf~mlu wfnl" fj w|pphu~ ho ~mlfu
ulwplg~fvl ghj~lj~fhjw" uloluuln ~h wlvlucb i|naklj~w ho ~mfw
Gh|u~" ohulfaj Gh|u~w" fj~lujc~fhjcb l}plu~ hpfjfhjw"
c|~mhuf~c~fvl cu~fgblw quf~~lj e lkfjlj~ c|~mhuw l~g*
Elohul l}ckfjfja ~ml wckl" bl~ |w ofuw~ l}ckfjl ~ml blacb
w~c~|w ho c ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ul" f~w |wlo|bjlww fj guhww+
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
145/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>?
~ucjwolucebl fj ~ml cewljgl ho cj l}pulww puhvfwfhj ~h ~ml
ghj~ucu*
>>* Ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ul gulc~ln ohu alj|fjl e|wfjlww
p|uphwlw cul ~mhwl qmfgm cul aljlucbb gulc~ln hu cgs|fuln9
c~ ~ml ~fkl qmlj fjvlw~klj~ fw elfja kcnl4 hu o|u~mlu
fjvlw~klj~w cul elfja kcnl4 hu ~ml ~fkl qmlj ~ml Auh|p fw
|jnluahfja ofjcjgfcb hu h~mlu hvlucbb ulw~u|g~|ufja4 hu qmlj
hpluc~fhjw" w|gm cw ghjwhbfnc~fhj" cul gcuufln h|~" ~h gblcj+
nlo|wln hu hvlu+nfvluwfofln* Wh|jn ghkklugfcb ulcwhjw bfdl
mlnafja e|wfjlww ufwd" mlnafja phbf~fgcb ufwd" khefbf~ ho
fjvlw~klj~" cefbf~ ~h ucfwl bhcjw ouhk nfvluwl fjvlw~klj~w"
ho~lj |jnlubfl gulc~fhj ho w|gm w~u|g~|ulw* Fj ~ucjwjc~fhjcb
fjvlw~klj~w" ~ml |wl ho c ~c} jl|~ucb cjn fjvlw~hu+oufljnb
gh|j~uflw ~h lw~cebfwm WP_ fw kh~fvc~ln e ~ml jlln ~h gulc~l
c ~c} loofgflj~ w~u|g~|ul ~h lbfkfjc~l nh|ebl ~c}c~fhj
qmlulvlu phwwfebl cjn cbwh pbcj ~mlfu cg~fvf~flw c~~ucg~fja jh
hu blwwlu ~c} wh cw ~h afvl kc}fk|k eljlof~ ~h ~ml fjvlw~huw*
Glu~cfj gh|j~uflw cul l}lkp~ln ouhk gcpf~cb acfj" glu~cfj
gh|j~uflw cul pcu~fcbb l}lkp~ln cjn" fj glu~cfj gh|j~uflw"
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
147/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>1
~mlul fw jfb ~c} hj gcpf~cb acfjw* W|gm ocg~huw kc ah fj
gulc~fja c ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ul cjn cbwh ulw~u|g~|ufja*
>
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
148/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>=
>?* Ulvlj|l(Gh|u~w gcj cbqcw l}ckfjl qml~mlu ~mhwl
ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ulw cul alj|fjl cjn wl~ |p blacbb ohu c
wh|jn cjn vluf~cebl ghkklugfcb p|uphwl* E|unlj fw lj~fulb
hj ~ml Ulvlj|l ~h wmhq ~mc~ ~ml fjghuphuc~fhj"
ghjwhbfnc~fhj" ulw~u|g~|ufja l~g* mcw ellj loolg~ln ~h cgmflvl
c ouc|n|blj~" nfwmhjlw~ p|uphwl" wh cw ~h nlolc~ ~ml bcq*
GHUPHUC^L AH_LUJCJGL
>1* Ghuphuc~l ahvlujcjgl mcw ellj c w|eilg~ ho
ghjwfnlucebl fj~lulw~ fj ~ml ghuphuc~l qhubn* ^ml
Huacjfwc~fhj ohu Lghjhkfg ghhpluc~fhj cjn Nlvlbhpklj~
-HLGN& nlofjlw ghuphuc~l ahvlujcjgl cw ohbbhqw 9+
Ghuphuc~l ahvlujcjgl fw c ww~lk e qmfgm e|wfjlww ghuphuc~fhjw cul nfulg~ln cjn ghj~uhbbln* ^ml ghuphuc~l ahvlujcjgl w~u|g~|ul wplgfoflw ~mlnfw~ufe|~fhj ho ufam~w cjn ulwphjwfefbf~flw ckhjanfoolulj~ pcu~fgfpcj~w fj ~ml ghuphuc~fhj cjn h~mlu
w~cdl mhbnluw cjn wplbbw h|~ u|blw cjn puhgln|ulw ohukcdfja nlgfwfhjw hj ghuphuc~l coocfuw* E nhfja ~mfw"f~ cbwh puhvfnlw c w~u|g~|ul ~muh|am qmfgm ~mlghkpcj heilg~fvlw cul wl~ cjn ~ml klcjw hoc~~cfjfja ~mhwl heilg~fvlw cjn khjf~hufjapluohukcjgl*
^ml Kfjfw~u ho Ghuphuc~l Coocfuw ~h ~ml Ahvlujklj~ ho Fjnfc"
mcw fww|ln wlvlucb pulww jh~lw ohu fjohukc~fhj ho w|gm abhecb
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
149/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3>6
ghkpcjflw" qmfgm qfbb fjnfgc~l ~mc~ Fjnfcj ghuphuc~l Bcq mcw
cbwh cgglp~ln ~ml ghuphuc~l w~u|g~|ul ghjwfw~fja ho mhbnfja
ghkpcjflw cjn wlvlucb w|ewfnfcu ghkpcjflw* C mhbnfja
ghkpcj qmfgm hqjw ljh|am vh~fja w~hgd fj c w|ewfnfcu
gcj ghj~uhb kcjcalklj~ cjn hpluc~fhj e fjob|ljgfja hu
lblg~fja f~w Ehcun ho Nfulg~huw* ^ml mhbnfja ghkpcj gcj
cbwh kcfj~cfj auh|p cggh|j~w qmfgm fw ~h afvl klkeluw ho
~ml mhbnfja ghkpcj c pfg~|ul ho ~ml ofjcjgfcb phwf~fhj ho ~ml
mhbnfja ghkpcj cjn f~w w|ewfnfcuflw* ^ml ohuk cjn ghj~lj~
ho mhbnfja ghkpcj hu w|ewfnfcu ghkpcjw hqj ecbcjgl
wmll~ cjn puhof~ cjn bhww cggh|j~ cul ~ml wckl cw fo ~ml
qlul fjnlpljnlj~ ghkpcjflw l}glp~ ~mc~ c mhbnfja
ghkpcjw cggh|j~w cj caaulac~ln vcb|l ho wmculw f~ mhbnw fj
f~w w|ewfnfcuflw cjn fj ulbc~ln ghkpcjflw cjn caaulac~ln
ckh|j~ ho bhww kcnl e f~ ~h f~w w|ewfnfcuflw cjn ~h ulbc~ln
ghkpcjflw cjn ~mlfu h~mlu fjnle~lnjlww ~h f~ k|w~ el wmhqj
wlpcuc~lb ouhk h~mlu cwwl~w l~g*
>=* Ghuphuc~l ahvlujhuw gcj cbwh kfw|wl ~mlfu hoofgl" |wfja
ouc|n|blj~ klcjw ohu |jbcqo|b acfj" ~ml kc cbwh
kcjfp|bc~l ~mlfu ulghunw" lj~lu fj~h n|efh|w ~ucjwcg~fhjw ohu
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
150/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
36* Hvluwlcw ghkpcjflw cul ghkpcjflw fjghuphuc~ln
h|~wfnl Fjnfc cjn jlf~mlu ~ml Ghkpcjflw Cg~ jhu ~ml Fjghkl
^c} Cg~ ljcg~ln fj Fjnfc mcw cj ghj~uhb hvlu ~mhwl
ghkpcjflw lw~cebfwmln hvluwlcw cjn ~ml cul ahvlujln e ~ml
bcqw fj ~ml gh|j~uflw qmlul ~ml cul lw~cebfwmln* Ouhk
gh|j~u ~h gh|j~u bcqw ahvlujfja fjghuphuc~fhj"
kcjcalklj~" ghj~uhb" ~c}c~fhj l~g* kc gmcjal* Kcj
nlvlbhpln cjn qlcb~m Jc~fhjw kc pcud ~mlfu gcpf~cb fj
w|gm hoo+wmhul ghkpcjflw ~h gcuu hj e|wfjlww hpluc~fhjw fj
h~mlu gh|j~uflw fj ~ml qhubn* Kcj gh|j~uflw afvl ocgfbf~flw
ohu lw~cebfwmfja ghkpcjflw fj ~mlfu i|ufwnfg~fhj qf~m
kfjfk|k ghj~uhb cjn kc}fk|k oullnhk* Ghkpl~f~fhj fw
cbwh ~mlul ckhja vcufh|w gh|j~uflw ohu wl~~fja |p w|gm
hoowmhul ghkpcjflw fj ~mlfu i|ufwnfg~fhj* Nlkcjn ohu hoowmhul
ocgfbf~flw mcw ghjwfnluceb fjgulcwln" fj ulglj~ ~fklw" hqfja
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
151/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
152/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
153/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
154/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
wckl" f~ fw w~c~ln ~mc~ HOGw mcvl cj fkphu~cj~ uhbl fj ~ml
fj~lujc~fhjcb lghjhk" hoolufja cnvcj~calw ohu k|b~f+jc~fhjcb
ghkpcjflw cjn fjnfvfn|cbw ohu fjvlw~klj~w cjn cbwh ohu
blaf~fkc~l ofjcjgfcb pbcjjfja cjn ufwd kcjcalklj~* F~ fw
ho~lj wcfn ~mc~ fjw|oofgflj~ blafwbc~fhj fj ~ml gh|j~uflw qmlul
~ml hpluc~l afvlw hpphu~|jf~flw ohu khjl bc|jnlufja" ~c}
lvcwfhj l~g* cjn" mljgl" f~ fw fkpluc~fvl ~mc~ ~mc~ Fjnfcj
Pcubfcklj~ qh|bn cnnulww cbb ~mlwl fww|lw qf~m |~khw~
|ualjg*
Jlln ohu Blafwbc~fhj9
* ^c} cvhfncjgl fw c puheblk ocgln e cbkhw~ cbb
gh|j~uflw ohbbhqfja gfvfb cjn ghkkhj bcq ww~lkw cjn cbb
wmcul ~ml ghkkhj euhcn cfk" ~mc~ fw ~h ghkec~ f~* Kcj
gh|j~uflw cul ~cdfja vcufh|w blafwbc~fvl klcw|ulw ~h fjgulcwl
~ml wgu|~fj ho ~ucjwcg~fhjw ghjn|g~ln e jhj+ulwfnlj~
lj~lupufwlw* C|w~ucbfc mcw eh~m aljlucb cjn wplgfofg cj~f+
cvhfncjgl u|bl -ACCU& fj f~w Fjghkl ^c} Blafwbc~fhjw* Fj
C|w~ucbfc" ACCU fw fj Pcu~ F_C ho ~ml Fjghkl ^c} Cwwlwwklj~
Cg~" 367?" qmfgm fw fj~ljnln ~h puhvfnl cj loolg~fvl klcw|ul
cacfjw~ ~c} cvhfncjgl cuucjalklj~w* Wh|~m Coufgc mcw cbwh
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
155/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
156/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
157/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
158/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3&
16 Ghkp Gcwl ?73 -Nlbmf&*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
159/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
160/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?0
?3* Gh|u~w" mhqlvlu" qfbb jh~ cbbhq ~ml wlpcuc~l ghuphuc~l
lj~f~flw ~h el |wln cw c klcjw ~h gcuu h|~ ouc|n hu ~h lvcnl
~c}* Pculj~ ghkpcj ho c QHW" fw jh~ ulwphjwfebl" blacbb ohu
~ml |jbcqo|b cg~fvf~flw ho ~ml w|ewfnfcu wcvl fj l}glp~fhjcb
gfug|kw~cjglw" w|gm cw c ghkpcj fw c wmck hu ~ml calj~ ho
~ml wmculmhbnlu" ~ml pculj~ ghkpcj fw ulacunln cw c
wmculmhbnlu* K|b~f+Jc~fhjcb Ghkpcjflw" e wl~~fja |p
ghkpbl} vlu~fgcb puckfn bfdl w~u|g~|ulw" qh|bn el cebl ~h
nfw~cjgl ~mlkwlbvlw cjn wlpcuc~l ~ml pculj~ ouhk hpluc~fja
ghkpcjflw" ~mlule puh~lg~fja ~ml k|b~f+jc~fhjcb ghkpcjflw
ouhk blacb bfcefbf~flw*
WMCULMHBNLUW CAULLKLJ
?5* mculmhbnluw Caullklj~ - ohu wmhu~ WMC& fw lwwlj~fcbb c
ghj~ucg~ el~qllj whkl hu cbb h~mlu wmculmhbnluw fj c
ghkpcj" ~ml p|uphwl ho qmfgm fw ~h ghjolu ufam~w cjn fkphwl
hebfac~fhjw hvlu cjn cehvl ~mhwl puhvfnln e ~ml Ghkpcj
Bcq* WMC fw c pufvc~l ghj~ucg~ el~qllj ~ml wmculmhbnluw
ghkpculn ~h Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj ho ~ml Ghkpcj" qmfgm fw
c p|ebfg nhg|klj~* Elfja c pufvc~l nhg|klj~ f~ efjnw
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
161/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?3
pcu~flw ~mlulho cjn jh~ ~ml h~mlu ulkcfjfja wmculmhbnluw fj
~ml ghkpcj* Cnvcj~cal ho WMC fw ~mc~ f~ afvlw aulc~lu
obl}fefbf~" |jbfdl Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj* F~ cbwh kcdlw
puhvfwfhjw ohu ulwhb|~fhj ho cj nfwp|~l el~qllj ~ml
wmculmhbnluw cjn cbwh mhq ~ml o|~|ul gcpf~cb ghj~ufe|~fhjw
mcvl ~h el kcnl* Puhvfwfhjw ho ~ml WMC kc cbwh ah
ghj~ucu ~h ~ml puhvfwfhjw ho ~ml Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj" fj
~mc~ lvlj~" jc~|ucbb puhvfwfhjw ho ~ml Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj
qh|bn ahvluj cjn jh~ ~ml puhvfwfhjw kcnl fj ~ml WMC*
?7* ^ml jc~|ul ho WMC qcw ghjwfnluln e c ~qh I|nalw
Eljgm ho ~mfw Gh|u~ fj _* E* Ucjacuci v* _* E*
Ahpcbcdufwmjcj cjn Huw* -3665& 3 WGG 3?0* Fj ~mc~ gcwl"
cj caullklj~ qcw lj~luln fj~h el~qllj wmculmhbnluw ho c
pufvc~l ghkpcj qmlulfj c ulw~ufg~fhj qcw fkphwln hj c
bfvfja klkelu ho ~ml ghkpcj ~h ~ucjwolu mfw wmculw hjb ~h c
klkelu ho mfw hqj eucjgm ho ~ml ockfb" w|gm ulw~ufg~fhjw
qlul" mhqlvlu" jh~ ljvfwcaln hu puhvfnln ohu qf~mfj ~ml
Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj* ^mfw Gh|u~ mcw ~cdlj ~ml vflq ~mc~
puhvfwfhjw ho ~ml Wmculmhbnluw Caullklj~ fkphwfja
ulw~ufg~fhjw lvlj qmlj ghjwfw~lj~ qf~m Ghkpcj blafwbc~fhj"
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
162/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?5
cul ~h el c|~mhufyln hjb qmlj ~ml cul fjghuphuc~ln fj ~ml
Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj" c vflq ql nh jh~ w|ewgufel* ^mfw
Gh|u~ fj Amlu|bcb Pculdm v* Kcmcnlh Ncw Kcfc -360? mlbn ~mc~ oullnhk ho ghj~ucg~ gcj el
ulw~ufg~ln e bcq hjb fj gcwlw qmlul f~ fw ohu whkl ahhn ohu
~ml ghkk|jf~* Ghkpcjflw Cg~ 36
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
163/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?7
el~qllj jhj+klkeluw cjn klkeluw ho ~ml Ghkpcj qfbb jh~
efjn ~ml ghkpcj" e|~ ~mlul fw jh~mfja |jbcqo|b fj lj~lufja
fj~h caullklj~ ohu ~ucjwoluufja ho wmculw* Ho gh|uwl" ~ml
kcjjlu fj qmfgm w|gm caullklj~w cul ~h el ljohugln fj ~ml
gcwl ho eulcgm fw afvlj fj ~ml aljlucb bcq el~qllj ~ml
ghkpcj cjn ~ml wmculmhbnluw* C eulcgm ho WMC qmfgm nhlw
jh~ eulcgm ~ml Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj fw c vcbfn ghuphuc~l
cg~fhj e|~" cw ql mcvl cbulcn fjnfgc~ln" ~ml pcu~flw
caauflvln gcj al~ ulklnflw |jnlu ~ml aljlucb bcq ho ~ml bcjn
ohu cj eulcgm ho ~mc~ caullklj~*
?
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
164/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?>
puhvfwfhjw ohu ulwhb|~fhj ho nfwp|~lw el~qllj ~ml
wmculmhbnluw* Kcj ho ~ml cehvl klj~fhjln puhvfwfhjw ofjn c
pbcgl fj WMCw" OQCw" ^luk Wmll~ Caullklj~ l~g* fj ~ml
pulwlj~ gcwl" mljgl" ql kc ulolu ~h whkl ho ~mhwl
puhvfwfhjw*
-c& Ufam~ ho Ofuw~ Ulo|wcb -UHOU&9 UHOU plukf~w f~w
mhbnluw ~h gbcfk ~ml ~ucjwolu ho ~ml w|eilg~ ho ~ml ufam~ qf~m c
|jfbc~lucb nlgbcuc~fhj ho fj~lj~ qmfgm gcj lf~mlu el
ghj~ucg~|cb hu blacb* Jh w~c~|~hu ulghajf~fhj mcw ellj afvlj
~h ~mc~ ufam~ lf~mlu fj ~ml Fjnfcj Ghkpcj Bcq hu ~ml Fjghkl
^c} Bcqw* Whkl ohulfaj i|ufwnfg~fhjw mcvl kcnl puhvfwfhjw
ula|bc~fja ~mhwl ufam~w e w~c~|~lw* Aljlucbb" UHOU fw
ghj~ucg~|cb cjn nl~lukfjln fj cj caullklj~* UHOU gbc|wlw
mcvl ghj~ucg~|cb ulw~ufg~fhjw ~mc~ afvl ~ml mhbnluw ~ml hp~fhj
~h lj~lu fj~h ghkklugfcb ~ucjwcg~fhjw qf~m ~ml hqjlu hj ~ml
ecwfw ho whkl wplgfofg ~lukw elohul ~ml hqjlu kc lj~lu fj~h
~ml ~ucjwcg~fhjw qf~m c ~mfun pcu~* Wmculmhbnluw ufam~ ~h
~ucjwolu ~ml wmculw fw jh~ ~h~cbb pulvlj~ln" l~ c wmculmhbnlu
fw hebfaln ~h hoolu ~ml wmculw ofuw~ ~h ~ml l}fw~fja
wmculmhbnluw* Ghjwls|lj~b" ~ml h~mlu wmculmhbnluw qfbb
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
165/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?& wmcul fj ~ml w|upb|w" fo
cj" hj bfs|fnc~fhj*
?=* Wmcul fw c ufam~ ~h c wplgfofln ckh|j~ ho ~ml wmcul
gcpf~cb ho c ghkpcj gcuufja h|~ glu~cfj ufam~w cjn
bfcefbf~flw" fj h~mlu qhunw" wmculw cul e|jnblw ho fj~cjafebl
ufam~w cacfjw~ ~ml ghkpcj* Wmculw cul ~h el ulacunln cw
wf~|c~l fj ~ml gh|j~u fj qmfgm f~ fw fjghuphuc~ln cjn ulafw~lu
fw dlp~* Wmculw cul ~ucjwolucebl bfdl cj h~mlu khvlcebl
puhplu~ |jnlu ~ml Ghkpcjflw Cg~ cjn ~ml ^ucjwolu ho
Puhplu~ Cg~* Ulw~ufg~fhj ho ^ucjwolu ho Wmculw fw vcbfn" fo
ghj~cfjln fj ~ml Cu~fgblw ho Cwwhgfc~fhj ho ~ml ghkpcj*
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
169/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
3?6
Wmculw cul" ~mlulohul" pulw|kln ~h el oullb ~ucjwolucebl cjn
ulw~ufg~fhjw hj ~mlfu ~ucjwolu cul ~h el ghjw~u|ln w~ufg~b*
^ucjwolu ho wmculw kc ulw|b~ fj c mhw~ ho ghjwls|ljglw*
_h~fja Ufam~w9
?6* _h~fja ufam~w vlw~ fj pluwhjw qmh jcklw cpplcu fj ~ml
Ulafw~lu ho Klkeluw* Ufam~ ~h vh~l gcjjh~ el nlgh|pbln ouhk
~ml wmcul cjn cj caullklj~ ~h l}lugfwl vh~fja ufam~w fj c
nlwfuln kcjjlu" nhlw jh~ ~cdl cqc ~ml ufam~ ho vh~l" fj ocg~"
f~ fw ~ml wmculmhbnluw ufam~* _h~fja ufam~w gcjjh~ el nljfln
e c ghkpcj e f~w cu~fgblw hu h~mluqfwl ~h mhbnluw ho wmculw
elbhq c kfjfk|k j|kelu w|gm cw hjb wmculmhbnluw mhbnfja
ofvl hu khul wmculw cul lj~f~bln ~h vh~l cjn wh hj" w|eilg~ ~h
glu~cfj bfkf~c~fhjw*
10* Ufam~w cjn hebfac~fhjw obhqfja ouhk vh~fja ufam~w mcvl
ellj ~ml w|eilg~ kc~~lu ho wlvlucb nlgfwfhjw ho ~mfw Gh|u~* Fj
Gmfucjif~ Bcb Gmhqnm|uf v* \jfhj ho Fjnfc -36
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
170/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
310
lblg~fhj ho nfulg~huw" ~ml ufam~ ~h pcww ulwhb|~fhjw cjn ~ml
ufam~ ~h pulwlj~ c pl~f~fhj ohu qfjnfja |p cul pluwhjcb ufam~w
obhqfja ouhk ~ml hqjluwmfp ho ~ml wmcul cjn gcjjh~ el
~mlkwlbvlw cjn cpcu~ ouhk ~ml wmcul el cgs|fuln hu nfwphwln
ho hu ~cdlj phwwlwwfhj ho* Fj Nqcudcncw Wmufjfvcw ho
Ehkec v* Wmhbcp|u Wpfjjfja / Qlcvfja Ghkpcj
-36& WGU ?1> c~ 15? 9 CFU 36 WG 336" ~mfw Gh|u~ jh~fgln
~ml pufjgfpbl bcfn nhqj fj Gmfucjif~ Bcb Gmhqnm|uf-w|puc&*
13* _h~fja cuucjalklj~w fj WMCw hu phhbfja caullklj~w cul
jh~ puhplu~* Ghj~ucg~w ~mc~ puhvfnl ohu vh~fja fj ocvh|u ho
hu cacfjw~ c ulwhb|~fhj hu cg~fja fj w|pphu~ ho cjh~mlu
wmculmhbnlu gulc~l hjb ghj~ucg~|cb hebfac~fhjw* C ghj~ucg~
~mc~ gulc~lw ghj~ucg~|cb ufam~w ~mlule" ~ml hqjlu ho ~ml
wmcul -cjn ~ml hqjlu ho ~ml ufam~ ~h vh~l& caullw ~h vh~l fj c
pcu~fg|bcu kcjjlu nhlw jh~ nlgh|pbl ~ml ufam~ ~h vh~l ouhk
~ml wmcul cjn cwwfaj f~ ~h cjh~mlu* C ghj~ucg~ ~mc~ fw
lj~luln fj~h ~h puhvfnl vh~fja fj ocvh|u ho hu cacfjw~ ~ml
ulwhb|~fhj hu cg~fja fj w|pphu~ ho cjh~mlu wmculmhbnlu" cw ql
mcvl cbulcn jh~ln" gulc~lw ghj~ucg~|cb hebfac~fhj* Lj~lufja
fj~h cj w|gm ghj~ucg~ ghjw~f~|~lw cj cwwlu~fhj -cjn jh~ cj
-
8/3/2019 Vodafone Case- Supreme Court Decision
171/275
qqq*~c}w|~uc*ghk
313
cwwfajklj~& ho ~ml ufam~ ~h vh~l ohu ~ml ulcwhj ~mc~ e
lj~lufja fj~h ~ml ghj~ucg~9 -c& ~ml hqjlu ho ~ml wmcul cwwlu~w
~mc~ ml mcw c ufam~ ~h vh~l4 -e& ml caullw ~mc~ ml fw oull ~h vh~l
cw plu mfw qfbb4 cjn -g& ml ghj~ucg~|cbb caullw ~mc~ ml qfbb
vh~l fj c pcu~fg|bcu kcjjlu* Hjgl ~ml hqjlu ho c wmcul
caullw ~h vh~l fj c pcu~fg|bcu kcjjlu" ~mc~ f~wlbo qh|bn jh~
nl~lukfjl cw c puhplu~*
Ghj~uhbbfja Fj~lulw~9
15* Wmculw" ql mcvl cbulcn fjnfgc~ln" ulpulwlj~ ghjaluflw
ho ufam~w cjn ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ fw cj fjgfnlj~ ho mhbnfja
kcihuf~ wmculw* Ghj~uhb ho c ghkpcj vlw~w fj ~ml vh~fja
phqluw ho f~w wmculmhbnluw* Wmculmhbnluw mhbnfja c
ghj~uhbbfja fj~lulw~ gcj nl~lukfjl ~ml jc~|ul ho ~ml e|wfjlww"
f~w kcjcalklj~" lj~lu fj~h ghj~ucg~" ehuuhq khjl" e|" wlbb
hu klual ~ml ghkpcj* Wmc