June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 1
The Birmingham experience; problem solving at the Birmingham MC40
Carl WheldonCarl Wheldon
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 2
Overview
● Operation and uses
● Technical changes and challenges
● A look to the future
● Summary
● (Brief history)
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 3
History of accelerators at Birmingham
RDI 3MV Dynamitron(1970 - )
3 MeV p on Li for Boron Neutron Capture Therapy(BNCT).
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 4
History of accelerators at Birmingham
MC40 cyclotron(2002-2004) transferred from Minneapolis, USA (installed 1988, run 1991-2001).
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 5
History of accelerators at Birmingham
MC40 cyclotron(2004 - )In 2005 we added a 12-way switching magnet (blue) [ex Vivitron, Strasbourg, France]
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 6
Beam lines
More recently, we were asked to provide high dose-rate damage studies (LHC ATLAS group and metallurgy) so extended a second beam-line into a specially shielded area.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 7
Beam lines
High current irradiation cell:(Left) ATLAS line on the (Right) Metallurgy chamber
Low current irradiation line:(Right/upstream) Radiobiology, space applications.(Left/downstream) Nuclear physics scattering chambers.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 8
Isotope production
In 2009 Birmingham acquired most parts from the decommissioned Hammersmith MC40 cyclotron.
Spare parts critical to the low down-time necessary for medical isotope production.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 9
MC40 cyclotron – uses
Hot filament ion source
Beams available:p: 11-39 MeV and 3-9 MeV (N=2)d: 5.5-19.5 MeVα: 11-40 MeV3He 33-54 MeV and 13-27 MeV.
Also 46 MeV 14N4+ and 70 MeV 14N5+ for nuclear physics.
•Producing positron emitting nuclides for Engineering PET [NOT FDG1].•Producing 81Rb for 81mKr generators.•Thin Layer Activation.•Other isotope production:
• 69Ge for labelling oil,• 62Zn supplied to St Thomas’ Hospital, London,• Various irradiations for NPL.
•Radiation effects studies:• Radiobiology + dosimetry (proton imaging),• Space electronics etc.,• ATLAS components,• Metallurgy of nuclear materials.
•Nuclear physics• Research,• Undergraduate research projects,• Postgraduate training.
1FDG = fluorodeoxyglucose.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 10
MC40 cyclotron – uses
81Rb (4.6 h)● Parent of 81mKr (gas), which decays
(13s) to ground state emitting 190 keV gamma; (parent/daughter generator).
● 81mKr used for imaging lung function using gamma camera
Production 5 evenings per week, 50 weeks per year
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 11
Rubidium-81 production
Using the technique developed at Medical Reserach Council (MRC) Cyclotron Unit (Hammersmith Hospital, London):
● Irradiate target containing 82Kr gas (6 bar pressure) with 29 MeV protons (30 A).
● 81Rb is produced and deposits on walls of target.
● At end of irradiation, recover 82Kr gas cryostatically.
● Then elute 81Rb from target: 3 x 40ml transferred to dispensing room.
● Finally evacuate target ready for reuse.● Currently making approx 60 generators per week – fairly stable.
Entire procedure is controlled by Beckhoff Programmable Logic Controller (PLC).
Same PLC has gradually been extended to control cyclotron interlocks etc.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 12
Positron emission particle tracking (PEPT)
Modular camera installed on Modified Leistritz 27mm TSE
Label a single particle (e.g. grain of sand) with positron-emitter
(usually 18F from 3He on natural oxygen) and track it as it moves
inside equipment
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 13
Tracer particles of PEPT
Most are labelled with 18F (half-life 110 min.) produced by cyclotron irradiation of oxygen [16O(3He, p)18F]:
● “Large” (>1mm) particles of silica, alumina etc. are directly activated – activity firmly fixed in bulk
● Smaller particles, and other materials (plastics etc.) are indirectly labelled – produce 18F in solution and then attach it to particle using appropriate surface chemistry (bridging ions, etc.) - these tracer particles are generally OK except in aqueous environments, when the activity rapidly leaches off again.
For aqueous environments, we have developed other radioisotope labels. For example, 66Ga (9 hours) produced by proton irradiation of Zn, followed by cation exchange separation.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 14
Thin layer activation
Steel:• 56Fe(p,n)56Co (77 days, 0.85 MeV and 1.24 MeV gammas).• 56Fe(d,n)57Co (270 days, 0.122 MeV gammas).
Can activate different surfaces with each for simultaneous studies.Aluminium:
• 27Al(3He, 2α) 22Na (2.7 yrs, 0.511 MeV & 1.27 MeV gammas)Diamond-like carbon (DLC) coatings•12C(3He, 2α )7Be (53 days, 0.47 MeV gamma).
For measuring wear on components (especially automotive parts, for R&D): ● Irradiate surface with beam to create long-lived
radionuclide in well-defined surface layer (typically ~ 50 μm deep).
● Subsequently monitor surface removal by detecting gamma-rays either from remaining layer or from wear debris.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 15
ATLAS radiation hardness testing
Samples in cold box (fed with liquid nitrogen) scanned through 27 MeV proton beam.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 16
A difficult year
TragedyOn the 24th January 2017 Mike Smith, our cyclotron manager, died unexpectedly.
Mike dismantling the MC40 in Minneapolis.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 17
Current view
Rb production targets
System 8500, MPS854T900A/150V output
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 18
Recent technical issues
● October 2016: Main magnet power supply failure due to cooling water leak.
● Approximately four weeks to repair supply.
● March 2017 new Danfysik power supply installed.
● March 2017 deflector change to solve extraction problems
● Due for change – typically once per year
● ‘New’ deflector conditioning lost every 24-48 hours.
● Might be due to a tiny water leak. Not a problem for running at the moment if machine is well used. Better than previous.
● Three or four usable deflectors available.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 19
Magnet supply change
Old and new magnet supplies
System 8500, MPS854T900A/150V output. Accuracy +/-10ppm over 8 hours.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 20
Recent technical issues
● January 2017, RF braid problems in cavities.
● Burnt hole through cavity to water jacket – water leak in cavity
● Changed from 27 MeV protons to 26 MeV (~2 cm apart).
● Cleaning in resonator but problem persisted, new holes, moved to 29 MeV protons.
● Found PLC air pressure threshold set too low…leading to catastrophic damage. Now running at 28 MeV.
● Have tried four different braid suppliers. Too tight pressure, and tube won’t inflate, too slack and tube protrudes.
● Ultimate solution might be to swap to taller, Hammersmith resonators.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 21
Resonator cavity damage
Fixed leaks with combination of soldering and plumbers compound. Access difficult even to see problem. Need to solder using mirror.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 22
Difficult to clean after problem
After several attempts at cleaning in situ – dismounted plate.
Difficult to reach outer surface for cleaning following burning from bad contact. Removal was less time consuming that thought.
braid Grounding plate
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 23
Rubidium/krypton production
Rubidium statistics: since 2006 made rubidium for 35252 generators.
– 1 for a successful production run,– 0.5 for a run where production was less than requested– 0 for a complete failure.
On this basis:– 2015 we had a 99.1% reliability– 2016 88.5% (disappointing) 224 runs out of 253 requested were successful (2167 generators produced in total).
Overall since 2006, success rate 96.2%(2673.5 out of 2778 successful).
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 24
Rubidium/krypton production
Rubidium statistics: since 2006 made rubidium for 35252 generators.
– 1 for a successful production run,– 0.5 for a run where production was less than requested– 0 for a complete failure.
On this basis:– 2015 we had a 99.1% reliability– 2016 88.5% (disappointing) 224 runs out of 253 requested were successful (2167 generators produced in total).
Overall since 2006, success rate 96.2%(2673.5 out of 2778 successful).
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 25
Dose recording
Improvements made:
● Development of a touch-screen interface for entering dose information per task. Justification, optimisation, limitation.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 26
Summary and perspectives
● One new appointment (March 2017).● One operator retired (June 2017).● Power supply replaced (spare) and new one installed.● RF braid and air pressure threshold issues in
resonators resolved.● Deflector short circuits – deflector change.
Future
Discussion under way for post-5-year future. Uncertain. Thanks to Prof. David Parker and Robert Goodwin for providing information shown in this presentation.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 27
Thanks for your Thanks for your attention.attention.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 28
Birmingham in the sunshine
The tallest free-standingclock tower in the world.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 29
History of accelerators at Birmingham
60” Nuffield cyclotron (1948-1999).
10 MeV p, 40 MeV α.
Construction started 1937: copy of Lawrence’s 60” cyclotron.
Operated 51 years.
Yoke etc. still in place.
2015
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 30
History of accelerators at Birmingham
1 GeV proton synchrotron(1953-1967).
Mark Oliphant had idea for proton synchrotron.
Birmingham machine overtaken during construction by Brookhaven Cosmotron.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 31
History of accelerators at Birmingham
Radial Ridge cylotron(1960-2002).
(Axially injected polarised beams)12 MeV d, 24 MeV α,33 MeV 3He.
Completely decommissioned after 2002: yoke now in Nuffield vault.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 32
Safety
Decontamination area – wipes, eyewash etc.Soon to be
added, alarm to attract attention.
Lockable physical barrier.
Lockable door motor controls.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 33
Safety
Ozone monitor.
Dose monitor data logger
and interlock.
June 2017 Copenhagen, Scanditronix meeting 34
Safety
Health and Safety Executive (HSE) visit in April 2016.
Improvements made:● Continuous training of operators (annually) and focused on
unexpected scenarios – contingency planning.● Personal Electronic Dosimeters (PEDs) for all classified
workers.● Berthold dose monitor (10µSv/h-10Sv/h) installed inside the
cyclotron vault with display and logger outside area.● Interlock above 200 µSv/hr controlled by monitor.● Ozone monitor.
● Physical barriers to prevent casual access – lockable cover over door motor controls and metal barrier to demark supervised area.