-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
1/36
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{gv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq=Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{
Fd{p Uvckpakd{
[TUUGVPAON
GVNCOA]CPAGO[D`a{go Djdkpvak Ao{paptpd
Dodvnq[dk
Ndgvnd Lc{go Toaydv{apq
Nva`~a{d Cjjacokd
Aopdvodp [dktvapq Cjjacokd
[tuujq Kbcao Va{h Jdc`dv{bau
Kgtokaj
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
2/366 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
Go fdbcj g pbd T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp "T[VU!* A cl
ujdc{d` pg vdjdc{d [tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp
Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{/
Pbd T[VU ~c{ jctokbd` ao 6533 ~apb p~g kgvd
ao{anbp{=
Iav{p* pbd fd{p uvckpakd{ pbcp ft{aod{{d{ cvd
`dujgqaon pg lcocnd va{h cj{g {dvyd ocpagocj
la{{ago{* co` ocpagocj {pvcpdnad{ {bgtj` fd
ftaj`aon go pbd{d ft{aod{{ uvckpakd{/
[dkgo`* utfjak,uvaycpd ucvpodv{bau{ lt{p fd p~g,
~cq/ Uvaycpd {dkpgv ygakd{ co` fd{p uvckpakd{ ~ajj
fd kvapakcj ao kjcvaqaon vgjd{ co` vd{ugo{afajapad{*
co` aokvdc{aon pbd jdydvcnd co` ddkpaydod{{ g
ucvpodv{bau{/
^d cuujad` pbd{d p~g uvaokaujd{ pg co a{{td pbcp bc{
fddo vdkdayaon ocpagocj cppdopago= pbd ug{{afajapq pbcp
kgvvtupd`* kgtopdvdap gv kgluvgla{d` kglugodop{
kgtj` dopdv pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao co` kct{d
{dvagt{* jcvnd,{kcjd `a{vtupago/
Ao Lcvkb g 6536* odcvjq 355 {tuujq kbcao lcocndv{*
AP co` kqfdv{dktvapq drdktpayd{ vgl c otlfdv g
{dkpgv{ aokjt`aon pbd ug~dv* djdkpvgoak{* {gp~cvd*
pdjdkglltoakcpago{* kbdlakcj* `ddo{d ao`t{pvacj
fc{d* cdvg{uckd* co` bdcyq lcotckptvaon ao`t{pvad{
ucvpakaucpd` ao c ~gvh{bgu pg=
Kcuptvd kvg{{,{dkpgv fd{p uvckpakd{* uvgkd{{d{*
ldpvak{* pdkbogjgnad{ co` ngydvocokd {pvtkptvd{
ao {tuujq kbcao8
C{{d{{ bg~ ktvvdop co` dldvnaon uvaycpd,{dkpgv
fd{p uvckpakd{ kgtj` vd`tkd pbd va{h{ pg pbd
{lcvp nva`8 co`
A`dopaq ncu{ co` guugvptoapad{ gv kgjjcfgvcpayd
uvgfjdl {gjyaon/
Uvagv pg pbd ~gvh{bgu* ucvpakaucop{ vdkdayd` drdkt,
payd,jdydj fvadion lcpdvacj{ {tllcva}aon pbd vd{tjp{
g {dlaocj {pt`ad{ co` cvpakjd{ go pbd od~ jco`{kcud
g va{h* ~apb {udkacj {dkpago{ go kqfdv va{h{* kgtopdv,
dapaon* od~ {pvcpdnad{ gv {tuujq kbcao va{h lcocnd,
ldop* co` T/[/ co` DT {lcvp nva` va{h lcocndldop
{pvcpdnad{/ C``apagocjjq* fd{p uvckpakd kc{d {pt`ad{
vgl c otlfdv g kglucoad{* aokjt`aon Ydva}go* @g~*
@tUgop* Ka{kg* BU* co` Pdjydop* banbjanbpd` ao`t{pvq
cuuvgckbd{ pg {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq/ Iaocjjq* c otlfd
g gvncoa}cpago{ uvgya`d` pggj{ co` ldpbg`gjgnad{
gv {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq fgpb ubq{akcj co` kqfdv/
Pbd{d* cjgon ~apb pbd hdqogpd uvd{dopcpago{* kco fdgto` cp ~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn/
Pbd ao{anbp{ njdcod` vgl pbd ckajapcpd` `acjgntd*
fd{p uvckpakd kc{d {pt`ad{* co` va{h lcocndldop
pggj{ docfjd` pbd T[VU pg a`dopaq ~bdvd {pvgon
{gjtpago{ cjvdc`q dra{p* c{{d{{ odd`{ gv lgvd ckpago
co` a`dopaq banb uvagvapq cvdc{ gv utfjak,uvaycpd
ucvpodv{bau{/
A ~gtj` jahd pg pbcoh gtv ~gvh{bgu {ugo{gv{* pbd
T/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq co` Ndgvnd Lc{goToaydv{apq* gv {tuugvpaon pba{ ~gvh/ ^d cj{g
cuuvdkacpd` pbd {tuugvp g gtv ucvpodv gvncoa}cpago{
D`a{go Djdkpvak Ao{paptpd* Dodvnq[dk* Nva`~a{d
Cjjacokd* Aopdvodp [dktvapq Cjjacokd* co` pbd [tuujq
Kbcao Va{h Jdc`dv{bau Kgtokaj/
A ~gtj` jahd pg pbcoh T[VU [doagv C`ya{gv @doa{d
[~aoh gv bdv {pvcpdnak ao{anbp{ co` c`yakd* co` Hcpad
Mdvd}c* gtv uvgnvcl lcocndv vgl Dodvndpak{* ~bg
~c{ ao{pvtldopcj ao lchaon pbd ~gvh{bgu c {tkkd{{
@coc Lcvpao co` [bcoogo Bcqd{ ~dvd cj{g coaoycjtcfjd ucvp g pbd T[VU pdcl/
@dfvc yco Gu{pcj
Drdktpayd @avdkpgv
T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
Ivgl pbd Drdktpayd @avdkpgv
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
3/36
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ gv [lcvpNva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{Fd{p Uvckpakd{
@dfvc yco Gu{pcj
Drdktpayd @avdkpgv* T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
Kgopdop{
PchdC~cq{
[dkpago 3= Gydvyad~= Dldvnaon Va{h{ co` [tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{
[dkpago 6= Odrp [pdu{ 3
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd 3
[lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbcao
^gvh{bgu Ucvpakaucop{ ;
^gvh{bgu Cndo`c ;
Cfgtp pbd T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp ;
6536 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd uvgmdkp
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
4/36
PCHDC^CQ[
[tuuj Kbcao [gjtpago{ gv [lcvp Nva` [dktvap= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
6 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
Pbd aopdnvcpago g aogvlcpago co` kglltoakcpago{
pdkbogjgnad{ pbvgtnbgtp pbd ug~dv nva` a{ vdygjtpago,
a}aon pbd ~cq djdkpvakapq a{ `djaydvd` co` t{d`/ Pbd
uvgfjdl a{ pbcp dlfd``d` AP dyakd{ pbvgtnbgtp pbd
{q{pdl cj{g kvdcpd od~ {dp{ g kqfdv va{h{
Iao`aon ~cq{ pg lcocnd pbd{d va{h{ ubq{akcj
c{ ~djj c{ kqfdv a{ aokvdc{aonjq tvndop gv fgpb
dkgoglak kgludpapaydod{{ co` ocpagocj {dktvapq/
^bdo pbd djdkpvakapq gd{ ogp ~gvh* odapbdv gd{cjlg{p coqpbaon dj{d/
Pbd kqfdv{dktvapq g pbd {lcvp nva` a{ ogp gojq co AP
uvgfjdl* ap a{ cj{g c {tuujq kbcao uvgfjdl/ Cp dckb
ubc{d ao pbd drpdo`d` {tuujq kbcao vgl uvg`tkp
`d{ano* lcotckptvaon stcjapq* {dktvd pvco{ugvpcpago*
~cvdbgt{aon* lcaopdocokd co` vducav pbvgtnb
{dktvd do`,g,jad a{ug{cj pbdvd cvd va{h{ pbcp
kgtopdvdap uvg`tkp{ gv kgluvgla{d` kglugodop{
kgtj` fd ao{dvpd` aopg pbd {lcvp nva`/
[tuujq kbcao va{h{ pg pbd {lcvp nva` cvd nvg~aon
fdkct{d pbd od~ pdkbogjgnq a{ njgfcjjq {gtvkd`
co` od~ ydo`gv{ pg pbd {dkpgv cvd ogp cj~cq{ claj,
acv ~apb pbd {dktvapq co` vdjacfajapq odd`{ g kvapakcj
aovc{pvtkptvd {q{pdl{ ~apb ;5,qdcv jad {uco{/ Pbdvd
a{ cj{g pbd uvg{udkp g pcvndpd` aopdvocpagocj cppckh{
yac pbd {tuujq kbcao/
Fd{p uvckpakd{ g pbd njgfcj jdc`dv{ ao {tuujq kbcao
va{h lcocndldop kgtj` bdju vd`tkd kqfdv va{h{ pg
pbd {lcvp nva`/ Gydv pbd uc{p `dkc`d* c otlfdv
g kglucoad{ bcyd `dydjgud` lgvd {guba{pakcpd`
uvgkd{{d{ pg c{{tvd kgo`dokd ao pbd aopdnvapq g
njgfcjjq {gtvkd` lcpdvacj{* uvgpdkp ubq{akcj c{{dp{
co` AU vgl pbdp* vd`tkd kgtopdvdapaon* co` do{tvd
kgopaotapq g pbd {tuujq kbcao ao pald{ g kva{a{/
Ucvpakaucop{ g pbd [dktvapq pbd [lcvp Nva` ^gvh{bgao Lcvkb 6536 vdkglldo`d =
Fdokblcvh co` [bcvd Ft{aod{{Fd{p Uvckpakd{
[tuujq kbcao fd{p uvckpakd{ ao {dktvapq co` vd{ajadok
odd` pg fd fdokblcvhd` co` {bcvd` ~apb pbd
ug~dv {dkpgv/ Pbd{d uvckpakd{ odd` pg fd drujgvd`
co` drujcaod` ao `acjgntd{ fdp~ddo AP co` {tuujq
kbcao uvgd{{agocj{* co` fdp~ddo tpajapad{ co` pbdav
{tuujadv{/
Kjcva Vgjd{ co` Vd{ugo{afajapad{ ao Utfjak,UvaycpdUcvpodv{bau{
[lcvp nva` kqfdv{dktvapq a{ c {bcvd` vd{ugo{afajapq pbc
vdstavd{ utfjak,uvaycpd ucvpodv{bau{/ Ucvpodv{bau{
kco gojq fd ddkpayd a vgjd{ co` vd{ugo{afajapad{
cvd kjcvad` ogp fq ~bcp odd`{ pg fd `god* ftp ~bg
bc{ pbd drudvpa{d pg `g ap/ Ao lcoq kc{d{* pbd {tuujq
kbcao drudvpa{d* kgludpdokad{ co` pggj{ pg lcaopcao
pbd {dktvapq* aopdnvapq co` kgopaotapq g pbd {lcvp nva`{tuujq kbcao vd{a`d ~apb pbd uvaycpd {dkpgv/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
5/36~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
Pchd,C~cq
Uvagvapa}d [{pdl Va{h{
[guba{pakcpd` {tuujq kbcao{ uvagvapa}d va{h ao gv`dv
pg cjjgkcpd pbd lg{p {pvaondop {kvtpaoq co` {dktvapq
pg pbd banbd{p uvagvapq kglugodop{/ Pba{ hao` g va{h
vcld~gvh a{ cj{g odd`d` gv pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq
kbcao/ ^apb ugpdopacjjq lajjago{ g AP `dyakd{ go pbd
nva`* ap a{ ogp dc{afjd pg nayd dckb g pbdl pbd {cld
jdydj g ubq{akcj co` kqfdv {kvtpaoq co` {dktvapq/
Pbd vcld~gvh {bgtj` docfjd c padvd` {q{pdl g
va{h,fc{d` {dktvapq ldc{tvd{* ~bakb uvgya`d pbd tjj
ldc{tvd g uvgpdkpago ~bdvd pbdvd cvd {q{pdl,~a`d*
drpdo`d` aluckp{/
Kg,Aoyd{p ao Pdkbogjgnad{
God ~cq pg aokvdc{d pbd {dktvapq co` vd{ajadokd g
pbd {lcvp nva` a{ pg lchd pbd {tuujq kbcao {lcvpdv/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ a`dopad` c otlfdv g kco`a,
`cpd pdkbogjgnad{ gv utfjak,uvaycpd kg,aoyd{pldop
pbcp ~gtj` {altjpcodgt{jq aluvgyd {tuujq kbcao
va{h lcocndldop gv kglucoad{ co` bdju c{{tvd
pbd aopdnvapq g pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao gv pbd
kgtopvq/
Ig{pdv Kgllgo To`dv{pco`aon{ g Kbcjjdond{ co`[gjtpago{
@aydv{d {pchdbgj`dv{ vgl AP co` {tuujq kbcao
va{h lcocndv{ pg KDG{ co` fgcv`{ pg utfjak tpajapq
kglla{{agodv{ co` {pcpd jdna{jcpgv{ gpdo `g
ogp cnvdd go pbd ocptvd g pbd uvgfjdl gv pbdav
vd{udkpayd vgjd{ ao c ucpb gv~cv`/ Ucvpakaucop{{pvd{{d` pbd odd` pg cvpaktjcpd pbd kbcjjdond{*
drujcao pbd ugpdopacj vgjd{ gv advdop {pchdbgj`dv{*
co` uvd{dop aogvlcpago ao ~cq{ pbcp dokgtvcnd mgaop
g~odv{bau g pbd {gjtpago/
Jdydvcnd [odvnad{ g [gjtpago
Pbd t{d g kqfdv faogktjcv{ {gldpald{ ocvvg~{ pbd
{dcvkb gv ddkpayd va{h lcocndldop pggj{/ Pggj{*
uvckpakd{ co` uvgkd{{d{ pbcp {pvdonpbdo ubq{akcj
{dktvapq co` {tuujq kbcao kgopaotapq kco cj{g bdju
ocvvg~ kqfdv va{h{* ftp cvd gpdo ogp {ddo c{ ucvp g
pbd kqfdv pggjhap/
Ctnldop Uvgd{{agocj Hog~jd`nd co` [hajj{ pg[tuugvp Kfdv{dktvap [gjtpago{
Lcocnaon kqfdv va{h{ ckvg{{ pbd {tuujq kbcao
pgtkbd{ lcoq a{kaujaod{ {kadopa{p{ co` donaoddv
lcotckptvaon co` stcjapq c{{tvcokd uvgd{{agocj{*
aogvlcpago pdkbogjgnq lcocndv{* uvgktvdldop
co` jgna{pak drdktpayd{* copa,kgtopdvdapaon co`
`a{pvaftpago {udkacja{p{* co` gudvcpago{ lcocndv{* pg
ocld c d~/ Pbd{d uvgd{{agocj{ odd` pg hog~ pbcp
pbdq cvd ucvp g c kqfdv{dktvapq {pvcpdnq co` ncao
od~ hog~jd`nd* {hajj{ co` pggj{ pbcp dobcokd pbdav
cfajapq pg lcocnd kqfdv va{h{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
6/360 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
Pbd Tu{a`d{ co` @g~o{a`d{ g Fdaon [lcvp
Pbd aopdnvcpago g aogvlcpago co` kglltoakcpago{ pdkbogjgnad{ pbvgtnbgtp pbd ug~dv nva` a{
vdygjtpagoa}aon pbd ~cq djdkpvakapq a{ djaydvd` co` t{d`/ bcp lchd{ pbd od~ nva` {lcvp cvd pbd
p~g,~cq kgoodkpago{ fdp~ddo `dyakd{ ~bakb lchd{ pbd {q{pdl lgvd cnajd* c`cupayd co` cfjd
pg {do{d co` uvd,dlup ugpdopacj `a{ptvfcokd{8 nayd{ kt{pgldv{ lgvd cfajapq pg vd{ugo` pg lcvhdp
{anocj{8 co` nayd{ pbd kgtopvq pbd cfajapq pg aopdnvcpd vdod~cfjd {gtvkd{ g dodvnq/
Pbd uvgfjdl a{ pbcp dlfd``d` AP `dyakd{ pbvgtnbgtp pbd {q{pdl cj{g kvdcpd od~ {dp{ g va{h{
vgl=
Aokvdc{d` ckkd{{ ugaop{= Pdo{* ugpdopacjjq bto`vd`{* g lajjago{ g `dyakd{ go pbd {q{pdl
~apb p~g,~cq kglltoakcpago{ kcucfajapad{ kvdcpd ckkd{{ ugaop{ pg pbd nva` ~bakb kgtj` fd
drujgapd`/
Aopdvkgoodkpayapq= Pbd {lcvp nva` ~ajj jaoh a{ucvcpd odp~gvh{* lchaon ap {t{kdupafjd pg
ytjodvcfajapad{ g gpbdv odp~gvh{ co` kvdcpaon c fva`nd gv lcj~cvd pg kvg{{ vgl god odp~gvh
pg cogpbdv/
Kglujdrapq= Pbd aokvdc{aon kglujdrapq g pbd {q{pdl kvdcpd{ guugvptoapad{ gv cajtvd* dydo
~apbgtp c lcjakagt{ pvanndv/
Kgllgo kglutpaon pdkbogjgnad{= [aokd pbd nva` ~ajj `dudo` go kglldvkacj pdkbogjgnad{*
lcoq g pbd uvgfjdl{ pbcp dra{p ao pbd gkd kglutpaon doyavgoldop "yavt{d{* ~gvl{* Pvgmco{*
vggphap{! ~ajj cdkp pbd {lcvp nva`/
Ctpglcpago= Pbd {lcvp nva` ~ajj ctpglcpd lcoq lcotcj tokpago{* kglugto`aon pbd ugpdopacj
aluckp g gudvcpgv dvvgv/
Pbd{d od~ va{h{ kvdcpd kbcjjdond{ pg pbd {dktvapq* vdjacfajapq co` vd{ajadokd g ~bcp a{ cvntcfjq
pbd lg{p kvapakcj fckhfgod aovc{pvtkptvd/ Iao`aon ~cq{ pg lcocnd pbd{d va{h{ ubq{akcj c{
~djj c{ kqfdv a{ aokvdc{aonjq tvndop gv fgpb dkgoglak kgludpapaydod{{ co` ocpagocj {dktvapq/^bdo pbd djdkpvakapq gd{ ogp ~gvh* odapbdv `gd{ cjlg{p coqpbaon dj{d= ocokacj* pvco{ugvpcpago*
pdjdkglltoakcpago{* ~cpdv co` {d~dv odp~gvh{ cjj dudo` go djdkpvak ug~dv cp {gld ugaop ao
pbdav uvg`tkpago gv djaydvq kqkjd/ Yavptcjjq dydvq vdpcaj kc{b vdna{pdv* dydvq nc{ utlu* dydvq kdjj
ubgod* dydvq kglutpdv co` djdkpvak kcv dudo`{ go c bgp ujtn/ Pbd `ddo{d aovc{pvtkptvd vdjad{
go pbd ug~dv nva` gv pbd jgon,pdvl kgopaotapq g gudvcpago{* ~bakb kvdcpd{ c ocpagocj {dktvapq
aludvcpayd pg {dktvd pbd {lcvp nva` cncao{p kqfdv pbvdcp{/
[dkpago 3= Gydvyad~Dldvnaon Va{h{ co` [tuujq Kbcao[gjtpago{
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
7/36~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 3= Gydvyad
[lcvp Nva` Kfdv{dktvap @dlco`{ [tuuj Kbcao [gjtpago{
Lcoq udgujd pbaoh g kqfdv{dktvapq c{ co AP uvgfjdl kvdcpaon pbd vanbp ddo{d{ cncao{p
cppckh* doacj g {dvyakd co` {q{pdl aojpvcpago/ Pbcp a{ ogp ~vgon* ap a{ mt{p ogp pbd ~bgjd {pgvq/
Kqfdv{dktvapq cj{g dudo`{ go {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq pg uvdydop pbd ao{dvpago g kgtopdvdap
gv kgluvgla{d` kglugodop{ aopg pbd {q{pdl/ Pbd do`,pg,do` {tuujq kbcao drpdo`{ vglpdkbogjgnq `dydjguldop co` `d{ano pg lcotckptvaon stcjapq c{{tvcokd pg {dktvd {bauldop
co` do`,g,jad a{ug{cj co` pbdvd cvd ugpdopacj kqfdv{dktvapq uvgfjdl{ cp dydvq {pcnd ao pbcp
jadkqkjd/
Igv drclujd* vgntd kg`d kgtj` fd ao{dvpd` aopg pbd {gp~cvd jgon fdgvd `dyakd{ cvd kgoodkpd`
gv hajj {~apkbd{ gv fckh ggv{ kgtj` fd ftajp aopg pbd bcv`~cvd pg docfjd vdlgpd ckkd{{ ~bakb
kgtj` fgpb {pdcj `cpc co` `a{cfjd pbd {q{pdl/ Kgtopdvdap apdl{* ~bakb kco `dnvc`d {q{pdl
udvgvlcokd* dopdv pbd {tuujq kbcao ao pvco{ap* ao pbd ~cvdbgt{d{ co` ao a{pvaftpago{ kdopdv{/
Lcaopdocokd co` vducav ckpayapad{ {gp~cvd tunvc`d{ co` dstauldop {dvyakd{ ~bdpbdv go{ap
gv `god vdlgpdjq* kvdcpd guugvptoapad{ pg kgvvtup gv kgluvgla{d {q{pdl{/ Co` ctjpq do`,gjad
`a{ug{cj kco kvdcpd od~ kgtopdvdapaon guugvptoapad{/
Cjpbgtnb pbd ug~dv ao`t{pvq bc{ dkc`d{ g drudvadokd ao c{{tvaon vdjacfajapq ao utvkbc{d{
g djdkpvakcj dstauldop* pbd cksta{apago g {lcvp kglugodop{ gv pbd nva` bc{ kvdcpd` od~
kbcjjdond{ pbd odd` gv aokvdc{d` {kvtpaoq g njgfcj AP ydo`gv{ co` lcocnaon pbd udvgvlcok
g c od~ {dp g kglugodop {tuujadv{* ~bg lcq ogp fd clajacv ~apb pbd {dktvapq co` vdjacfajapq
vdstavdldop{ g {q{pdl{ ~apb ;5,qdcv jad {uco{/
Cogpbdv kbcjjdond a{ pbd jckh g kglltoakcpago co` kggv`aocpago clgon pbd tokpago{ pbcp pgtk
{tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq/ Igv drclujd* {tuujq kbcao uvgd{{agocj{ to`dv{pco` bg~ pg d{pcfja{b
c {dktvd kbcao g kt{pg`q* ftp cvd ogp pquakcjjq ucvp g pbd kqfdv{dktvapq {pvcpdnq/ AP uvgd{{agocj{
pquakcjjq jdc` kqfdv{dktvapq {pvcpdnq* ftp cvd gpdo toclajacv ~apb pbd {dktvapq uvgkd`tvd{ pbcplchd {tuujq kbcao pcludv,dya`dop gv ~apb stcjapq c{{tvcokd uvgnvcl{ pbcp `dpdkp pbd ao{dvpago
g to~copd` AP tokpago{/
Gvncoa}cpagocj {ajg{ cvd kct{aon fjao` {ugp{ fgpb pg dldvnaon va{h{ co` guugvptoapad{ pg kcuapcja}
hog~jd`nd* uvckpakd{ co` pggj{* dydo ~apbao pbd {cld gvncoa}cpago/
C pbav` kbcjjdond lanbp fd `doapagocj/ Pbd tpajapq ao`t{pvq `dod{ {tuujq kbcao c{ kgoodkpago{
fdp~ddo pbvdd uajjcv{= ndodvcpago "ug~dv ujcop{!8 `djaydvq "pvco{la{{ago co` `a{pvaftpago odp~gvh{!
co` kt{pgldv{ "vd{a`dopacj* kglldvkacj* ao`t{pvacj* lajapcvq* dpk/!/ Pbd {lcvp nva` gojq c``d`
c`ycokd` AP kcucfajapad{ co` fa,`avdkpagocj kglltoakcpago{ pg pbg{d kgoodkpago{/ C{ c
vd{tjp* ~bdo ug~dv drudvp{ bdcv pbd ubvc{d {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq* pbdq pbaoh cfgtp pbd{dktvapq g pbd aogvlcpago co` kglltoakcpago{ ig~aon fdp~ddo ug~dv ujcop{* pvco{la{{ago co`
`a{pvaftpago {q{pdl{* co` kgo{tldv{/
Ftp* pbd va{h g kgluvgla{d` gv kgtopdvdap djdkpvgoak kglugodop{ pbd {g,kcjjd` Pvgmco
Bgv{d uvgfjdl dldvnd{ gtp g c ydvq advdop udv{udkpayd g {tuujq kbcao/ Ao pba{ yad~* {tuujq
kbcao {dktvapq fgpb ubq{akcj co` kqfdv a{ gkt{d` go lcocnaon pbd uvgkd{{d{ co` ydo`gv{
aoygjyd` ao lgyaon c uvg`tkp vgl ap{ fc{ak kglugodop{ pbvgtnb uvg`tkpago* c{{dlfjq* {bauldop
~cvdbgt{aon co` a{pvaftpago/ "Ajjt{pvcpago go ucnd{ 9,> `dlgo{pvcpd{ pbd{d udv{udkpayd{!/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
8/369 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
35=69=55
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
9/36~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 3= Gydvyad
YA[AFAJAPQ PG DO@,T[DVJg~ ya{afajapq ' banb va{h Banb ya{afajapq ' jg~ va{h
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
10/362 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva`=
C hdq o`aon vgl pbd gvh{bgu a{ pbcp {gld g pbd fd{p kqfdv{dktvapq {gjtpago{ cvd ba`aon ao
ujcao {anbp/ Fdokblcvhaon cncao{p pbd fd{p uvckpakd{ g {tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ kgtj` uvgya`d ckkd{{
pg od~ va{h lcocndldop pggj{ pbcp vd`tkd pbd va{h g kgtopdvdap gv kgluvgla{d` kglugodop{ ao
pbd {lcvp nva`/Gydv pbd uc{p dkc`d* pbdvd bcyd fddo pvdldo`gt{ c`ycokd{ fq kgvugvcpd jdc`dv{ ao {tuujq
kbcao va{h lcocndldop/ Jgondv {tuujq kbcao jaod{* gpdo ~apb jd{{ pvt{pd` ucvpodv{* kvdcpd`
od~ kbcjjdond{ vgl cfvtup `a{vtupago{ pg stcjapq cajtvd{ pg AU pbdp{ ~apb `dlgo{pvcfjq
odncpayd aluckp{ go {cjd{* vdydotd{* fvco` vdutpcpago co` {bcvdbgj`dv ycjtd/ Pbd{d od~ va{h{
pvco{gvld` {tuujq kbcao uvgfjdl{ aopg fdp,pbd,fgppgl,jaod va{h{* ~apb kgludjjaon aokdopayd{
gv aoyd{pldop ao {dktvapq co` vd{ajadokd/
Ao Lcvkb g 6536* pbd T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp kgoydod` odcvjq 355 {tuujq kbcao lcocndldop co` AP
co` kqfdv{dktvapq drdktpayd{ vgl c otlfdv g {dkpgv{ vconaon vgl ug~dv* djdkpvgoak{* {gp~cvd*
pdjdkglltoakcpago{* kbdlakcj* ddo{d ao`t{pvacj fc{d* cdvg{uckd* co` bdcyq lcotckptvaon pg
drujgvd p~g std{pago{=
^bcp fd{p uvckpakd{ ao {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq* uvg`tkp aopdnvapq co` kgopaotapq kgtj bdju
vd`tkd kqfdv va{h{ pg pbd {lcvp nva`7
^bcp cvd pbd odrp {pdu{ pg jdydvcnd {tuujq kbcao fd{p uvckpakd{ ao {tuugvp g {lcvp nva`
kqfdv{dktvapq7
Pbd fd{p uvckpakd{ a`dopad` fq gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ pbcp kgtj` bdju {dktvd pbd {lcvp nva`
aokjt`d`=
Do`,pg,do` va{h lcocndldop uvckpakd{/ Ap ~gtj` fd bcv` pg pbaoh g c va{h pbcp {uco{ lgvdtokpagocj {udkacjpad{ co` {pchdbgj`dv{ pbco kqfdv{dktvapq/ Njgfcj {tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ lcocnd
va{h do`,pg,do` ~apb aopdnvcpd` kvg{{,tokpagocj pdcl{/
Lcvhdp @vaydv{ gv Aoyd{pldop ao [tuuj Kbcao [dktvap co` Vd{ajadokd
Kg{p g @a{vtupago{ Kglucoad{ pbcp coogtokd` c {tuujq kbcao `a{vtupago drudvadokd` c 1 udvkdop `vgu ao {bcvduvakd{/ P~g,pbav`{ g kglucoad{ {pajj jcnnd` pbdav uddv{ c qdcv cpdv pbd `a{vtupago/3
Kg{p g Kgtopdvdap{ Cootcj jg{{d{ gv djdkpvgoak{ d{palcpd` cp $355 fajjago/6
Jg{{ g AU Aokvdc{aonjq cp va{h ao njgfcj {gtvkaon cvvcondldop{ co` kgopvckp lcotckptvaon/
Kg{p g Kcvng Pbdp Cootcj jg{{d{ d{palcpd` cp $34,;5 fajjago ao pbd Toapd` [pcpd{ cjgod/;
3/ Ivgl Ytjodvcfjd pg Ycjtcfjd= Bg~ Aopdnvapq Kco Pvco{igvl c [tuujq Kbcao* Uvakd cpdvbgt{d Kggudv{* @dkdlfdv 6552/
bppu=''~~~/u~k/kgl'doWT['t{'{tuujq,kbcao,lcocndldop'c{{dp{'u~k,{ka,336552/u /
6/ Djdkpvgoak Kglugodop{ Ao`t{pvq C{{gkacpago* bppu=''~~~/dkacgojaod/gvn'kgtokaj{'c`ygkckq/c{ur/
;/ IFA* Ao{a`d Kcvng Pbdip* Ogydlfdv 36* 6535* bppu=''~~~/fa/ngy'od~{'{pgvad{'6535'ogydlfdv'kcvngW333635'kcvngW333635/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
11/36~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 3= Gydvyad
Va{h,fc{d` vcld~gvh{/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ uvagvapa}d va{h{ fc{d` go ugpdopacj aluckp co` t{dpbcp va{h vcld~gvh c{ c nta`djaod gv dpdvlaoaon {dktvapq odd`{/
Ya{afajap `g~o pbd {tuuj kbcao padv{/ Hog~o {tuujadv{ co` pvt{pd` odp~gvh{ cvd {gld g pbd{pvgond{p uvgpdkpago{ ao njgfcj {tuujq kbcao{/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ bcyd dydjgud` ydo`gv
lcocndldop uvckpakd{ pbcp a`dopaq* ydp* stcjaq co` ct`ap {tuujadv{/Aogvlcpago {{pdl{ pg uvgya`d vdcj,pald dka{ago,lchaon pggj{/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ bcydaoyd{pd` ao aogvlcpago pggj{ cpc cocjqpak{* {altjcpago* ya{tcja}cpago pggj{ pbcp lapancpd pbd
aluckp g todrudkpd` dydop{ g tohog~o `tvcpago co` aluckp/
Kbcao g kt{pg` kgopvgj{/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ aoyd{p ao {dktvd bco`,g uvgkd`tvd{ co` NU['{do{gv kcucfajapad{ pg kvdcpd c{{dp ya{afajapq co` pcludv,dya`dop {bauldop{/
[pvaondop copa,kgtopdvdapaon ugjakad{ co` uvgkd`tvd{/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ vdaogvkd copa,kgtopdvdapaon uvgkd`tvd{ ~apb pvcaoaon* od~ pdkbogjgnq co` kgo{pcop kglltoakcpago{ ~apb
ydo`gv{* {bauudv{ co` kt{pgldv{/
[dktvd `d{ano uvaokaujd{ co` gongaon pd{paon/ [tuujq kbcao jdc`dv{ gkt{ go uvg`tkp aopdnvapqvgl pbd gtp{dp* vdaogvkd` fq {dktvd {gp~cvd `dydjguldop ldpbg`gjgnad{* stcjapq c{{tvcokd
{pco`cv`{ co` uvgkd{{d{* co` gongaon pd{paon/
Pbd{d hao`{ g kglldvkacj {tuujq kbcao uvckpakd{ kco ng c jgon ~cq pg~cv` uvdydopaon pbd
ao{dvpago g to`dv,udvgvlaon* kgtopdvdap gv kgvvtupd` dyakd{ aopg pbd {lcvp nva`/ Ftp* pbdq cvd
ogp ~djj hog~o gv ~djj aopdnvcpd` aopg kqfdv{dktvapq ujcooaon gv pbd {lcvp nva`/
Bg~dydv* pbd{d uvckpakd{ kcoogp uvgya`d c kglujdpd {gjtpago gv pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao/ Pbd
ug{{afajapq g kqfdv cppckh{ fq gvdano c`ydv{cvad{ yac pbd {tuujq kbcao pchd{ pbd uvgfjdl fdqgo`
pbd fgto`cvad{ g c ft{aod{{ kc{d/ Cjpbgtnb pbd ngydvoldop lcq fd cfjd vdjq go fd{p uvckpakd{
gv c >4 udvkdop {gjtpago* lcvhdp gvkd{ cjgod kcoogp mt{paq pbd kg{p g `ddo`aon pbd {tuujqkbcao cncao{p aopdvocpagocj kqfdv cppckh{/ Ngydvoldop lt{p bdju `dydjgu pbd c`ycokd` pggj{*
njgfcj c~cvdod{{ co` {pvcpdnad{ pg bdju ddo` tpajapad{ co` pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao cncao{p
{guba{pakcpd` kqfdv pbvdcp{ co` fd vdc`q pg {bcvd aogvlcpago go pbd dygjyaon pbvdcp ~apb pbd
uvaycpd {dkpgv ao vdcj,pald/
Pbd gvh{bgu vdugvp {tllcva}d{ vdkglldo`d` odrp {pdu{ ao [dkpago 6 co` a`dopad{ fd{p
uvckpakd{ g jdc`aon {tuujq kbcao gvncoa}cpago{ ao [dkpago ;/
^gvh{bgu Fvadon Lcpdvacj{ co` Kc{d [pt`ad{Uvagv pg pbd ~gvh{bgu* ucvpakaucop{ vdkdayd` drdktpayd,jdydj fvadaon lcpdvacj{ {tllcva}aon pbd vd{tjp{ g {dlaocj
{pt`ad{ co` cvpakjd{ go pbd od~ jco`{kcud g va{h* ~apb {udkacj {dkpago{ go kqfdv va{h{* kgtopdvdapaon* od~ {pvcpdnad{ gv
{tuujq kbcao va{h lcocndldop* co` T/[/ co` DT {lcvp nva` va{h lcocndldop {pvcpdnad{/
C``apagocjjq* fd{p uvckpakd kc{d {pt`ad{ vgl c otlfdv g kglucoad{* aokjt`aon Ydva}go* @g~* @tUgop* Ka{kg* BU* co`
Pdjydop* banbjanbpd` ao`t{pvq cuuvgckbd{ pg {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq/ C otlfdv g gvncoa}cpago{ uvgya`d` pggj{ co`
ldpbg`gjgnad{ gv {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq fgpb ubq{akcj co` kqfdv/ Pbd{d* cjgon ~apb pbd hdqogpd uvd{dopcpago{* kco fd
gto` cp ~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
12/3635 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ {c~ co guugvptoapq pg druco` pbd {lcvp nva` {dktvapq jdo{ fdqgo` AP
{gjtpago{ co` fdnao pbd uvgkd{{ g doncnaon ~apb pbd uvaycpd {dkpgv pg dod c kgjjcfgvcpayd
cndo`c gv {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq/
Pbdvd cvd p~g pvdo`{ ~bakb lchd pba{ pguak vaud gv `acjgntd/ Iav{p* pbd nvg~aon kgoydvndokd
fdp~ddo ubq{akcj co` kqfdv va{h{ kvdcpd{ co aludpt{ pg aopdnvcpd AP co` {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq aopg
c bgja{pak va{h lcocndldop {gjtpago gv pbd {lcvp nva`/ [dkgo`* ftaj`aon go ft{aod{{ uvckpakd{pg ocvvg~ va{h{ pg pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao ~gtj` docfjd pbd ngydvoldop pg pcvndp ap{ g~o
vd{gtvkd{ pg cvdc{ ~bdvd pbd lcvhdp `vaydv{ cvd ao{tkadop* ~bdvd pbd pdkbogjgnad{ pg lcocnd
pbd uvgfjdl `g ogp dra{p gv ~bdvd pbd {kgud g pbvdcp a{ fdqgo` pbd utvyad~ g kglucoad{ gv
ao`t{pvad{/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d` c otlfdv g alld`acpd odrp {pdu{ pg ckkdjdvcpd c`gupago
g fd{p uvckpakd{ co` {pvdonpbdo utfjak,uvaycpd kgjjcfgvcpago pg {dktvd pbd {lcvp nva`/
3/ Fdokblcvh co` [bcvd Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd ao [tuuj Kbcao [dktvapco` Vd{ajadokd
6/ Kjcva Vgjd{ co` Vd{ugo{afajapad{ ao Utfjak,Uvaycpd Ucvpodv{bau{
;/ Uvagvapa}d [{pdl Va{h{
0/ Kg,aoyd{p ao Pdkbogjgnad{
4/ Ig{pdv Kgllgo To`dv{pco`aon g Kbcjjdond{ co` [gjtpago{
9/ Jdydvcnd [odvnad{ g [gjtpago
>/ Ctnldop Uvgd{{agocj Hog~jd`nd co` [hajj{ pg [tuugvp Kfdv{dktvap [gjtpago{
[dkpago 6= Odrp [pdu{
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
13/36 3~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 6= Odrp [pdu
3/ Fdokblcvh co` [bcvd Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd ao [tuuj Kbcao [dktvapco` Vd{ajadokd
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ cnvdd` pbcp tpajapad{ co` {lcvp nva` kglucoad{ kgtj` jdcvo vgl gpbdv
{dkpgv{ fq fdokblcvhaon pbdav fd{p uvckpakd{* uvgkd{{d{* ldpvak{ co` pggj{ ao {tuujq kbcao va{h
lcocndldop/ Pbd{d fd{p uvckpakd{ odd` pg fd {bcvd` lgvd fvgc`jq pg bdju ocvvg~ pbd va{h{ g
kgtopdvdap co` kgluvgla{d` kglugodop{ ao pbd {lcvp nva`/
@gD bc{ drpdo{ayd drudvadokd ao ~gvhaon kgjjcfgvcpaydjq ~apb pbd uvaycpd {dkpgv pg {dktvd pbd
{lcvp nva`/ Aoapacpayd{ {tkb c{ pbd Ocpagocj [KC@C Pd{p Fd`* pbd kgo{do{t{ Vgc`lcu pg Ckbadyd
Dodvnq @djaydvq [q{pdl Kqfdv{dktvapq* co` pbd Djdkpvakapq [tf{dkpgv Kqfdv{dktvapq Kcucfajapq
Lcptvapq Lg`dj ~dvd ftajp go pbd kgjjdkpayd ao{anbp{ g g~odv{ co` gudvcpgv{* kglldvkacj
ydo`gv{* ocpagocj jcfgvcpgvad{* ckc`dlac* ao`t{pvq c{{gkacpago{ co` ngydvoldop cndokad{/ Pbd{d
kgjjcfgvcpayd drdvka{d{ kvdcpd` c kgjjdkpayd ujco pg aluvgyd pbd {dktvapq gv {lcvp nva` AP {q{pdl{
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ uvgug{d` druco`aon pbd `acjgntd pg aokjt`d pbd {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvap
co` vdkglldo`d` pbcp c tptvd vgc`lcu dgvp kgtj`=
Fdokblcvh fd{p {dktvapq uvckpakd{ ao njgfcj {tuujq kbcao{ co` {bcvd drudvadokd{ co`
uvckpakd{ ~apb pbd ug~dv {dkpgv8
Kcpcjq}d {tuujadv {tllap{ pg d{pcfja{b kgllgo drudkpcpago{ co` vdstavdldop{ gv {tuujq
kbcao {dktvapq* aopdnvapq co` kgopaotapq8 co`
Kvdcpd co gongaon aopdvckd gv {bcvaon {tuujq kbcao aogvlcpago co` lapancpago uvckpakd{
fdp~ddo kt{pgldv{ co` {tuujadv{/
6/ Kjcva Vgjd{ co` Vd{ugo{afajapad{ ao Utfjak,Uvaycpd Ucvpodv{bau{
[lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq a{ c {bcvd` vd{ugo{afajapq ~apb {bcvd` fdodp{/ Igv
ngydvoldop* {dktvaon pbd {lcvp nva` a{ d{{dopacj pg do{tvaon pbd nvg~pb* vdjacfajapq co` stcjapq gpbd ocpago{ ug~dv aovc{pvtkptvd/ Igv kglucoad{* pbd {dktvapq fgpb ubq{akcj co` kqfdv g pb
{tuujq kbcao a{ aludvcpayd pg uvgpdkp pbdav fvco`* fgppgl jaod co` {bcvdbgj`dv ycjtd/
Fdodp{ pg fgpb {a`d{ kvdcpd c {pvgon aokdopayd pg kgjjcfgvcpd/ God g pbd hdq uajjcv{ g ddkpayd
ucvpodv{bau{ a{ c ~ajjaonod{{ pg dod vgjd{ co` vd{ugo{afajapad{ ogp gojq fq ~bcp lt{p fd god
ftp fq ~bakb {pchdbgj`dv bc{ pbd fd{p kcucfajapq pg g ap/ Ao lcoq kc{d{* pbd {q{pdl{ drudvpa{d*
kgludpdokad{ co` pggj{ vd{a`d ao pbd uvaycpd {dkpgv/ Kglucoad{ odd` pg kgllap pg `dujgq kgl,
ldvkacj fd{p uvckpakd{* co` ngydvoldop odd`{ pg aopdnvcpd pbg{d uvckpakd{ ao ap{ kqfdv{dktvapq
ujcooaon co` {pvcpdnq gv pbd {lcvp nva`/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d`= C`gup uvaycpd {dkpgv {pco`cv`{ ~bdvdydv ug{{afjd8
Vdkgnoa}d'vd~cv fd{p uvckpakd alujdldopdv{8
Druco` aogvlcpago {bcvaon* ftp ng fdqgo` pbvdcp aogvlcpago pg {bcvaon vdld`acpago co`
vdkgydvq fd{p uvckpakd{8 co`
Docfjd ogo,cppvaftpd` vdugvpaon vgl pbd {dkpgv pg djalaocpd jdncj co` vdntjcpgvq kgokdvo{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
14/3636 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
;/ Uvagvapa}d [{pdl Va{h{
[tuujq kbcao va{h lcocndv{ pquakcjjq dydjgu c vcld~gvh gv uvagvapa}aon va{h{ fc{d` go ugpdopacj
aluckp co` t{d pbcp va{h vcld~gvh pg {dp {dktvapq vdstavdldop{ co` cjjgkcpd vd{gtvkd{/ Igv
drclujd* uvg`tkp{ gv {q{pdl{ pbcp kgld vgl cvdc{ `ddld` banb va{h ~cvvcop drpvc {dktvapq
uvdkctpago{ fggp{ go pbd nvgto` co` tjj pvckh co` pvckd kcucfajapad{* pg ocld c d~/
Pba{ hao` g {q{pdl{,fc{d` cocjq{a{ ~ajj fd d{{dopacj gv ddkpayd {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq gv pbd
{lcvp nva`/ apb ugpdopacjjq lajjago{ g dyakd{ go pbd {q{pdl* ap a{ odapbdv dc{afjd ogv cgv`cfjd
pg nayd dydvq {lcvp kglugodop ao pbd {tuujq kbcao pbd {cld jdydj g ubq{akcj co` kqfdv {kvtpaoq
co` {dktvapq/ Va{h{ lt{p fd drujakapjq uvagvapa}d` ao gv`dv pg dydjgu c vd{gtvkd cjjgkcpago {pvcpdnq
~apb pbd lg{p {pvaondop vdstavdldop{ fc{d` go ugpdopacj aluckp pg pbd {q{pdl/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d`=
To`dvpchd {q{pdl{ jdydj c{{d{{ldop{ pg `dydjgu c va{h uvagvapa}cpago vcld~gvh* a`dopaqaon
pbd odd` gv bdanbpdod` {dktvapq gv pdkbogjgnad{* kglugodop{ gv {q{pdl{ ~bdvd jg{{ g
udvgvlcokd gv kgopvgj kgtj` jdc` pg ocpagocj jdydj aluckp{ ydv{t{ vdnagocj gv jgkcja}d` aluckp/
0/ Kg,Aoyd{p ao Pdkbogjgnad{
God ~cq pg aokvdc{d pbd {dktvapq co` vd{ajadokd g pbd {lcvp nva` a{ pg lchd pbd {tuujq kbcao
{lcvpdv ~apb pvckh co` pvckd pdkbogjgnad{ co` {do{gv odp~gvh{ pg dobcokd {bauldop {dktvapq*
aopdjjandop uckhcnaon pg pb~cvp kgtopdvdapaon* coglcjq dpdkpago pggj{* co` cocjqpak pggj{ pg
a`dopaq ndgnvcubak co` ydo`gv va{h{/ Pbd gvh{bgu uvgya`d` ao{anbp{ go c``apagocj guugvptoapad{
pg druco` pbd kgjjcfgvcpayd pdkbogjgnq cndo`c pg {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao{/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d` c otlfdv g banb jdydvcnd guugvptoapad{ gv kg,aoyd{pldop/
Pdkbogjgnad{ gv va{h c{{d{{ldop* aokjt`aon=
@cpc cocjqpak{ pg c{{d{{ va{h bgja{pakcjjq* ctpglcpd va{h c{{d{{ldop* a`dopaq coglcjad{ co`
lcu {tuujq kbcao padv{8
Lg`dj{ pg to`dv{pco` co` uvagvapa}d {q{pdl jdydj va{h{8 co`
@anapcj {altjcpago g {tuujq kbcao va{h{ co` vd{ajadokd/
Pdkbogjgnad{ gv {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq* aokjt`aon=
@dpdkpago g drpvc tokpagocjapq ao {gp~cvd gv bcv ~cvd8
Kcucfajapq pg stcvcopaod kglugodop{8
Pdkboastd{ co` pd{paon {q{pdl{ pg kbcvckpdva}d co` stcopaq va{h8 co`
[dj,kbdkhaon dyakd{ co` {q{pdl{* cp pbd pdkboakcj jdydj/
Pdkbogjgnad{ gv copa,kgtopdvdapaon* aokjt`aon=
Aopdjjandop* {dktvd uckhcnaon "toastd {anocptvd pdkbogjgnq pg `a{paonta{b ndotaod ucvp{ vgl
kgtopdvdap!8
Gtpfgto` fdckgoaon8 co`
Ubgod bgld kcucfajapq pg pvckh jgkcpago{ g dstauldop co` kglugodop{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
15/36 3~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 6= Odrp [pdu
4/ Ig{pdv Kgllgo To`dv{pco`aon{
Pbdvd a{ c `aydv{apq g guaoago{ c{ jcvnd c{ pbd `aydv{apq g {pchdbgj`dv{ cfgtp ~bcp pbd
{tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq uvgfjdl a{* ~bg g~o{ ap* co` ~bcp {gjtpago{ cvd odd`d` gv cycajcfjd/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ {tnnd{pd` pbcp c Fcfdj{b kcucfajapq ~c{ odd`d` c hao` g toaydv{cj
pvco{jcpgv pbcp ktp{ ckvg{{ {pchdbgj`dv{* {dkpgv{ co` {udkacja}d` jcontcnd{/
Pbd pvco{jcpago pggj{ ~gtj` kjdcvjq cvpaktjcpd pbd kbcjjdond{ co` drujcao {gjtpago{ ao pdvl{ g pbd
vgjd{ pbcp ao`aya`tcj {pchdbgj`dv{ lt{p ujcq ao pbdav `dujgqldop/ Pbd ngcj a{ pg dokgtvcnd to`dv,
{pco`aon co` mgaop g~odv{bau g c {gjtpago {dp/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ uvgug{d` {dydvcj pqud{ g nta`dfggh{ pg ckkdjdvcpd c kgllgo to`dv,
{pco`aon g pbd va{h{ co` ugpdopacj {gjtpago{=
C nta`dfggh gv AP uvgd{{agocj{ pg drujcao bg~ {tuujq kbcao fd{p uvckpakd{ kgtj` bdju lddp
kqfdv{dktvapq odd`{8
C nta`dfggh gv tpajapq {tuujq kbcao uvgd{{agocj{ pg {bg~kc{d bg~ fd{p uvckpakd{ ao {tuujq
kbcao va{h co` ydo`gv lcocndldop kco bdju c``vd{{ pbd kqfdv{dktvapq kbcjjdond8 C nta`dfggh gv tpajapq K,{tapd{ co` fgcv`{ go pbd odd` pg kgoodkp aogvlcpago pdkbogjgnq*
gudvcpagocj pdkbogjgnq* co` {tuujq kbcao ao gv`dv pg fvaon c bgja{pak {gjtpago pg {lcvp nva`
kqfdv{dktvapq co` bg~ pba{ kco kvdcpd kg{p dkadokad{ ao {dktvapq pggj{ co` uvgkd{{d{8
C nta`dfggh gv utfjak tpajapq kglla{{agodv{ go pbd kgoydvndokd fdp~ddo ubq{akcj co` kqfdv
{dktvapq co` pbd odd` pg uvgya`d kg{p vdkgydvcfajapq gv do`,pg,do` cuuvgckbd{ pbcp c{{tvd
pbd vdjacfajapq co` aopdnvapq g pbd ug~dv aovc{pvtkptvd8 co`
C nta`dfggh gv {pcpd co` d`dvcj jdna{jcpgv{ pg `d{kvafd {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq
kbcjjdond{* pbd odd` gv do`,pg,do` cuuvgckbd{ co` pbd odd` pg ftaj` go dra{paon ft{aod{{
fd{p uvckpakd{ gv kvapakcj aovc{pvtkptvd {dktvapq* vcpbdv pbco {ddh pg vdntjcpd od~ god{/
9/ Jdydvcnd [odvnad{ g [gjtpago
Pbd t{d g kqfdv faogktjcv{ {gldpald{ ocvvg~{ pbd {dcvkb gv ddkpayd va{h lcocndldop pggj{/
Pggj{* uvckpakd{ co` uvgkd{{d{ pbcp {pvdonpbdo ubq{akcj {dktvapq co` {tuujq kbcao kgopaotapq kco
cj{g bdju ocvvg~ kqfdv va{h{* ftp cvd gpdo ogp {ddo c{ ucvp g pbd kqfdv pggjhap/
Ngg` ubq{akcj {dktvapq cp pbd lcotckptvaon ujcop* ao pvco{ap co` ao pbd ~cvdbgt{d kco vd`tkd
kgtopdvdap co` kqfdv va{h{/ Fq pbd {cld pghdo* {tuujq kbcao vd{ajadokd uvgnvcl{ kco bdju {d,
ktvd pbd {tuujq kbcao cncao{p kgtopdvdap co` kgluvgla{d` uvg`tkp{ ao p~g hdq ~cq{/ Ao gv`dv pg
{ugp kbghdugaop{ co` ugpdopacj {tuujadv kgopaotapq va{h{* vd{ajadokd uvgnvcl{ odd` pg hog~ ~bg
pbd ydo`gv{ g~o pbd {tuujq kbcao padv{ cvd/ Pba{ cj{g kvdcpd{ c fc{d g hog~jd`nd gv kvdcpaon cpvt{pd` ydo`gv odp~gvh/ Vd{ajadokd uvgnvcl{ cj{g kvdcpd fckhtu {gtvkaon gv hdq lcpdvacj{ co`
kglugodop{ ao pbd dydop g a{vtupago/ Pba{ cj{g bdju{ pg vd`tkd pbd va{h pbcp kgtopdvdap gv uggv
stcjapq ngg`{ ~ajj dopdv pbd {tuujq kbcao `tvaon kva{a{ uvgktvdldop{/
Pbd{d hao`{ g pggj{* ~bakb vd{a`d gtp{a`d pbd AP {dktvapq {ajg* bcyd ogp pquakcjjq fddo jdydvcnd`
gv kqfdv{dktvapq ftp* g kgtv{d* pbdq kgtj` fd/ Co`* cp pbd {cld pald* pbdq kgtj` aokvdc{d pbd
uvg`tkpayapq co` tpajapq g dra{paon aoyd{pldop{ ao {dktvapq co` vd{ajadokd/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
16/3630 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d`=
Kvdcpd hdq udvgvlcokd ao`akcpgv{ "HUA{! gv uvgkd{{d{ co` kcucfajapad{8
Kvdcpd c ~df,fc{d` pggj pbcp kglltoakcpd{ ugpdopacj va{h{ co` a{{td{ ckvg{{ pbd kgvugvcpago
co` uvgya`d{ gv {udkak cjdvp{ pbcp vdstavd c vd{ugo{d8 co`
Kvdcpd ldkbcoa{l{ gv kglltoakcpago clgon {ajg{ donaoddvaon* jdncj* {tuujq kbcao*stcjapq c{{tvcokd pg {bcvd jd{{go{ jdcvod` co` fd{p uvckpakd{/
Dclujd{ g [odvnad{ g [gjtpago Clgon [tuuj Kbcao [dktvap* Aopdnvapco` Vd{ajadokd
Ubq{akcj [dktvapq Uvgkd`tvd{ Kco
Bdju Uvgpdkp Cncao{p Lcj~cvd gv
Iavl~cvd ao pbd [tuujq Kbcao/
[dktvapq pggj{ co` fd{p uvckpakd{ aokjt`d=
Ao{dvpaon {dktvapq vdstavdldop{ ao pbdav kgopvckp{ ~apb {tuujadv{co` {bauudv{
Udvgvlaon fggp{ go pbd nvgto` ct`ap{ g {tuujadv{* ucvpaktjcvjq ao banb,va{h cvdc{ Ao{pcjjaon pvckh co` pvckd pdkbogjgnad{ pbcp docfjd pbdl pg lgoapgv {bauldop{ co`{do{gv pdkbogjgnad{ pg fd cfjd pg `dpdkp pcludvaon
Ao{paptpaon kt{pg`q kgopvgj{ pg kvdcpd ckkgtopcfajapq pbvgtnb pbd {tuujq kbcao
Aoyd{paon ao V)@ gv copa,kgtopdvdapaon co` copa,pcludvaon
Uvgpdkpaon pbd Aopdnvapq g AP
[q{pdl{ co` Kglugodop{ Kco Bdju
[dktvd Ubq{akcj [bauldop{/
[tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq pggj{ aokjt`d=
[dktvaon pbd aogvlcpago {q{pdl{ pbcp {tuugvp {tuujq kbcao vd{ajadokd
Aokgvugvcpaon {dktvapq uvgkd{{d{ aopg pbd {gp~cvd `dydjguldop ubc{d
Kgo`tkpaon dycjtcpago{ g ydo`gv uvgkd{{d{ gv stcjapq c{{tvcokd* ubq{akcj co` AP{dktvapq
Udvgvlaon kglugodop aopdnvapq pd{paon
Vd{ajadokd Pggj{ Kco Bdju C{{tvd
Yacfajapq co` [dktvapq g [tuujadv
Odp~gvh{/
Vd{ajadokd pggj{ aokjt`d=
Uvgya`aon gv 60,> lgoapgvaon g njgfcj dydop{ pbcp kgtj` cdkp {tuujq kbcao{dktvapq
Lcuuaon pbd {tuujq kbcao odp~gvh pg a`dopaq {aonjd ugaop{ g cajtvd* {tuujadvocokacj bdcjpb* co` ytjodvcfajapad{ pg `a{vtupago
Kvdcpaon va{h lg`djaon pggj{* `cpc {dp{ co` kva{a{ ujcqfggh{ pg c{{a{p fgpb ao va{hujcooaon co` vdkgydvq
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
17/36 3~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago 6= Odrp [pdu
>/ Ctnldop Uvgd{{agocj Hog~jd`nd co` [hajj{
Lcocnaon pbd va{h pbcp kgluvgla{d` gv kgtopdvdap kglugodop{ kgtj` fd ao{dvpd` aopg pbd
{tuujq kbcao pgtkbd{ lcoq uvgd{{agocj{ gtp{a`d pbd AP tokpago {apd {djdkpago drudvp{*
lcotckptvaon co` stcjapq c{{tvcokd lcocndv{* uvgktvdldop co` jgna{pak{ uvgd{{agocj{* co`
copa,kgtopdvdapaon co` {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq drdktpayd{/ Ao ndodvcj* uvgd{{agocj{ gtp{a`d AP
tokpago{ vdkdayd ydvq jappjd pvcaoaon c{ pg pbd ocptvd g dldvnaon kqfdv va{h{* gv pbd vgjd pbdav fd{
uvckpakd{ kgtj` ujcq ao vd`tkaon pbdl/ Ao lcoq kc{d{* pbdq ~gtj` fdodp vgl fdppdv ao{anbp{ aopg
pbd va{h{* c {udkak gvncoa}cpagocj vgjd ao kqfdv{dktvapq {pvcpdnq* co` udvbcu{ c``apagocj pggj{ co
{hajj{ pg c``vd{{ kqfdv va{h{ lgvd ddkpaydjq/
^gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ vdkglldo`d`=
Aokjt`d {dktvapq co` kqfdv{dktvapq pvcaoaon co` kdvpakcpago ao uvgd{{agocj `a{kaujaod{*
dlubc{a}aon pbcp pbdq bcyd pg fd fchd` aopg dydvq ft{aod{{ uvgkd{{ co` gudvcpagocj tokpago
Aokjt`d uvgd{{agocj `dydjguldop ao {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq co` kqfdv{dktvapq c{ c ug{apayd
djdldop ao udv{goodj vdyad~{ co` dycjtcpago8
Pvcao vdntjcpgv{ ao ft{aod{{ fd{p uvckpakd{ ao {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq8 co`
C{{d{{ odd`{ gv od~ {hajj{* uvgkd{{d{ co` pggj{ pg lcocnd {tuujq kbcao kqfdv{dktvapq va{h{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
18/3639 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
Pbd pggj{ co` fd{p uvckpakd{ pbcp njgfcj kglucoad{ bcyd dydjgud` pg lcocnd {tuujq kbcao
va{h{ kco aogvl co` {bcud kqfdv{dktvapq {pvcpdnad{/ Ftp* pbd{d pggj{ cvd ogp ~djj hog~o gv ~djj
aopdnvcpd` aopg kqfdv{dktvapq ujcooaon ao ngydvoldop gv ao`t{pvq/ [dktvaon pbd {lcvp nva` ~ajj
fd c kvapakcj uvagvapq* co` {gld g pbd fd{p {gjtpago{ cvd ba`aon ao ujcao {anbp/
Ucvpakaucop{ cp pbd ~gvh{bgu ~dvd c{hd` pg a`dopaq pbd fd{p uvckpakd{* uvgkd{{d{ co` pggj{ pbcp
pbdav gvncoa}cpago{ ~dvd t{aon pg lchd pbdav {tuujq kbcao{ ubq{akcjjq {dktvd co` vd{ajadop* co`pg uvgpdkp pbd aopdnvapq g pbd uvg`tkp{ ao pbd {tuujq kbcao/ Pbdq gdvd` c otlfdv g gudvcpaon
uvaokaujd{* cjgon ~apb kc{d {pt`q drclujd{ g bg~ pbd{d uvaokaujd{ cvd alujdldopd`/ Pbd gtv hdq
cvdc{ g gkt{ aokjt`d`=
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd[lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbcao
3/ Gvncoa}cpagocj Fd{p Uvckpakd{
3c= D{pcfja{b Va{h Lcocndldop Uvagvapad{
3f= Lcocnd [tuujq Kbcao Va{h{
Do`,pg,Do`
6/ [tuuj Kbcao Pvco{ucvdok co` Pvt{p6c= Ydp [tuujadv Uvckpakd{
6f= Ftaj` Pvt{pd` Odp~gvh{
6k= @dujgq Aogvlcpago [q{pdl{ co` Cocjqpak{
gv [aptcpagocj C~cvdod{{* [tuujq Kbcao
Pvco{ucvdokq co` Vd{ajadokd
;/ [tuuj Kbcao [dktvap
;c= D{pcfja{b Kbcao g Kt{pg`q Kgopvgj{
;f= @dujgq Copa,kgtopdvdapaon Kgopvgj{
0/ [tuuj Kbcao Aopdnvap
0c= Lcaopcao Aopdnvapq g Djdkpvgoak Kglugodopco` [gp~cvd pbvgtnbgtp pbd [tuujq Kbcao
Pbd gjjg~aon {dkpago{ d{kvafd pbd {udkak uvckpakd{ co` uvgkd{{d{ pbcp kglucoad{ bcyd
`dydjgud` co` `dujgqd` pg ckkgluja{b pbd{d gfmdkpayd{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
19/36 3~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
3/ Gvncoa}cpagocj Fd{p Uvckpakd{
3c= D{pcfja{b Va{h Lcocndldop Uvagvapad{
[aokd ap a{ alug{{afjd pg uvgpdkp dydvq uvg`tkp cncao{p dydvq kgopaondokq* pbd v{p {pdu ao va{h
lcocndldop a{ c kgo{dstdokd cocjq{a{ pbcp bdju{ pg dod ugpdopacj aluckp/ Va{h lcocndv{
odd` pg to`dv{pco` ugpdopacj kgo{dstdokd{ ao gv`dv pg dpdvlaod ~bdpbdv pbd va{h lco`cpd{
c gkt{ go uvdydopago* lapancpago gv vdkgydvq/ ^bdo c {pvcpdnq fdkgld{ gydv,gkt{d` go
uvdydopago* ~gvh{bgu ucvpakaucop{ lcaopcaod` pbcp pbd kbcjjdond fdkgld{ aooapd co` pbd kg{p
tocgv`cfjd/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
@dydjgu c va{h,fc{d` vcld~gvh pbcp uvagvapa}d{ hdq kglugodop{ co` pdkbogjgnad{ fc{d` go
pbd ugpdopacj aluckp gv pbd ft{aod{{ gv pbd {q{pdl/
@g~ Kbdlakcj= Va{h,Fc{d` Njgfcj [tuuj Kbcao[dktvap Ldc{tvd{
@g~ bc{ `dydjgud` c kgluvdbdo{ayd va{h lcocndldop
{q{pdl gv pbd {cd co` {dktvd `a{pvaftpago g vc~ lcpdvacj{*
aopdvld`acpd{ co` uvg`tkp{ ~gvj`~a`d/ Pbd {q{pdl aokjt`d{
co c{{d{{ldop g ugpdopacj {cdpq co` {dktvapq va{h{ ckvg{{
ap{ kbdlakcj {tuujq kbcao* aokjt`aon co dycjtcpago g pbd
{cdpq co` {dktvapq uvckpakd{ g ap{ vc~ lcpdvacj {tuujadv{*
pbd bc}cv`{ g pbd lcpdvacj{ {bauud`* pbd {cdpq co` {dktvapq
uvckpakd{ g ap{ jgna{pak{ {dvyakd uvgya`dv{* pbd `g~o{pvdcl
t{d{ g ap{ uvg`tkp{ co` pbd stcjakcpago{ g kt{pgldv{pg ~bgl pbd uvg`tkp{ cvd {bauud`/ Pba{ {tuujq kbcao va{h
c{{d{{ldop co` lcocndldop uvgnvcl docfjd{ @g~ pg
a`dopaq co` alujdldop cuuvguvacpd* kgo{a{pdop* laoaltl
{cdpq co` {dktvapq ldc{tvd{ gv uvg`tkp* aopdvld`acpd co`
vc~ lcpdvacj {bauldop{ ~gvj`~a`d/
@g~ bc{ uvducvd` co` alujdldopd` c {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq
ujco* ~bakb d{pcfja{bd{ c padvd` {q{pdl g va{h,fc{d` {dktvapq
ldc{tvd{ pbcp aokvdc{d ~apb va{aon pbvdcp jdydj{/ @g~ cj{g
bc{ d{pcfja{bd` pvco{ugvpcpago {cdpq co` {dktvapq {pco`cv`{
ao pbg{d cvdc{ ~bdvd c``apagocj va{h vd`tkpago ldc{tvd{ cvd
`d{avd` cfgyd co` fdqgo` pbg{d vdstavd` fq ngydvoldop
vdntjcpago{/ Co`* ao pbg{d cvdc{ vduvd{dopaon pbd nvdcpd{p{cdpq co` {dktvapq kgokdvo* @g~ a{ utv{taon ao`t{pvq,
jdc`aon* {pcpd,g,pbd,cvp {dktvapq aoapacpayd{/
@tUgop= Iao`aon pbd Vanbp Fcjcokd Fdp~ddoUvdydopago* Lapancpago co` Vdkgydv
Ivgl c uvdydopago ugaop g yad~* c kglucoq `gd{ c{ ltkb c{
ap kco dkgoglakcjjq cgv`/ [aokd ap a{ alug{{afjd pg uvgpdkp
cncao{p dydvqpbaon* pbd v{p {pdu ao va{h lcocndldop a{ c
kgo{dstdokd cocjq{a{ pbcp bdju{ `dod pbd ugpdopacj aluckp/
Va{h lcocndldop {pvcpdnq vdstavd{ hog~aon pbvdd pbaon{=
^bcp a{ pbd kcuckapq pg c`cup7
^bcp cvd pbd lapancpago ujco{ "{cd co` {dktvd {btp `g~o
g pbd ujcop!7
^bcp kcucfajapad{ cvd odd`d` pg vd{ugo` co` vdkgydv vgl
dydop{ pbcp lcq ogp bcyd fddo copakaucpd` co` kcoogp fd
kgopvgjjd`7
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
20/3632 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
3f= Lcocnd [tuuj Kbcao Va{h Do`,pg,Do`
Ap ~gtj` fd bcv` pg pbaoh g co ckpayapq pbcp {uco{ lgvd tokpagocj {udkacjpad{ co` {pchdbgj`dv{ pbco
{tuujq kbcao/ C kqfdv{dktvd {tuujq kbcao {pvcpdnq fdnao{ ao pbd d{ano co` `dydjguldop {pcnd*
co` kgopaotd{ pbvgtnb lcotckptvaon* {bauuaon co` ~cvdbgt{aon* {dvyakd co` vducav pg do`,g,jad
`a{ug{cj/ Kqfdv pbvdcp{ pg pbd {lcvp nva` kgtj` dldvnd coq~bdvd ao pbcp kbcao* co` va{h{ lt{p fd
c``vd{{d` bgja{pakcjjq/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
Dlug~dv kvg{{,tokpagocj pdcl{ gv aopdnvcpd` {tuujq kbcao va{h lcocndldop co` aoka`dop
vd{ugo{d* aokjt`aon BV* jdncj* AP* {dktvapq* ocokd co` UV co` do{tvd pbcp pbd pdcl bc{
`dka{ago,lchaon ctpbgvapq/
Kvdcpd c ~df,fc{d` pggj pbcp kglltoakcpd{ ugpdopacj va{h{ co` a{{td{ "d/n/ a`dopakcpago
g kgtopdvdap ucvp{! ckvg{{ pbd kgvugvcpago co` uvgya`d{ gv {udkak cjdvp{ pbcp vdstavd c
vd{ugo{d/
Kvdcpd aopdnvcpd` ~gvhig~ lcocndldop uvgkd{{d{ fgpb ctpglcpd` co` drudvadopacj pbcp uvgya`d gydvcvkbaon va{h c{{d{{ldop vgl ujcooaon pg pvcaoaon pg vd{ugo{d co` dd`fckh
ldkbcoa{l{/ Kcuptvd jdcvoaon vgl drdvka{d{ co` aoka`dop{ ~apb c gkt{ go pbd btlco
djdldop/
Udvgvl kgo{pcop fdokblcvhaon cncao{p gpbdv jdc`dv{ ao gpbdv {dkpgv{/
Ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq ujcooaon/
Druco` ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq kgtokaj{ pg cjj aopdvocj {pchdbgj`dv{/
Uvckpakd co` t{d ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq ujco{* kgvd cajtvd lg`dj{* vajj co` drdvka{dkgopaotgt{jq/
Vdstavd {tuujadv{ pg bcyd ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq ujco{/ @dydjgu co` dujgq vcua vd{ugo{d pdcl{ pg ujco co` lcocnd aoka`dop vd{ugo{d/ Kvdcpd
pvcaoaon drdvka{d{ gkt{d` go {tuujq kbcao a{{td{* co`
aoygjyd {tuujadv{/
@dydjgu c vgft{p kgllgo jcontcnd "pdvlaogjgnq co` uvgfjdl `doapago{! pg aokvdc{d
kgllgocjapq ao kgopvckp{ co` aluvgyd lcocndldop g pdkbogjgnq* uvg`tkp{ co` uvgkd{{d{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
21/36 3~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
@tUgop= Aopdnvcpaon [tuuj Kbcao Dkadok co`Didkpaydod{{ ~apb Gudvcpagocj Dkdjjdokd
Pbd uvaokaujd{ gv {tuujq kbcao dkadokq co` ddkpaydod{{cvd pbd {cld god{ pbcp nta`d gudvcpagocj drkdjjdokd co`
uvg`tkpayapq ckvg{{ pbd @tUgop Uvg`tkpago [q{pdl/ Pbdq cvd
ftajp go ft{aod{{ aopdnvcpago* {tudvagv drdktpago co` kdopdv{
gv gudvcpagocj kgludpdokq* ~bakb uvgya`d fd{p uvckpakd{*
pdkbogjgnad{ co` pggj{ pbcp cvd {pco`cv`a}d` co` jdydvcnd`
ckvg{{ @tUgop{ 3; ft{aod{{d{/
Pbd ngcj a{ pg kvdcpd kgvd uvgkd{{d{ pbcp cvd {alujad`*
{pco`cv`a}d` co` {t{pcaocfjd/ Pbd {tuujq kbcao gudvcpagocj
kdopdv{ g kgludpdokq `dujgq uvckpakd{ co` uvgkd{{d{*
pdkbogjgnad{ co` lg`dj{ pg `vayd kgopaotgt{ uvgkd{{aluvgydldop ckvg{{ vdnago{ co` ft{aod{{ ujcpgvl{/ Ao pbd
{tuujq kbcao cvdc* pbd kdopdv{ gkt{ {uco{ dkadokq co` va{h
lcocndldop/ Ap kvdcpd{ {pco`cv`{ co` uvgkd{{d{ pg drdktpd
pbg{d {pco`cv`{ ~bakb cvd pbdo `dujgqd` kgjjcfgvcpaydjq
~apb pbd ft{aod{{ toap{/
@tUgop Uvg`tkpago [{pdl
Aopdnvcpd` Gudvcpago{
Ft{aod{{ Aopdnvcpago
[pvgon {tuujq kbcao aopdnvcpago~apbao ft{aod{{ pdcl{ co` ft{aod{{
{pvcpdnad{
Drdktpago
@vayd ddkpaydod{{ co` dkadokqao drdktpago ao ujcop{ co` {tuujq
kbcao{ ckvg{{ ft{aod{{d{ co`
vdnago{
Gudvcpago{ Kdopdv g Kgludpdokq
Do{tvd gvncoa}cpagocj kcucfajapqa{ ao ujckd
[pco`cv`a}d co` jdydvcnd
@djaydvcfjd{
Aopdnvcpd` {pvcpdnad{ co`gudvcpagocj ujco{
C`ycokaon kgvd ycjtd{
Uvg`tkpayapq co` c{{dp ddkpaydod{{clgon {tuujq kbcao{
Kcucfajapq ftaj`aon= udgujd co`gvncoa}cpagocj dydjguldop
Pdkbogjgnq g~odv{bau co`aopdnvcpago cjgon {tuujq kbcao{
Lao`{dp{ co` fdbcyagv{ pbcp g{pdvdoncndldop co` {tudvagv drdktpago
Uvgnvd{{ Dodvn= Jaohaon Gudvcpagocj Pdkbogjgn*Aogvlcpago Pdkbogjgn co` [tuuj Kbcao pg[dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva`
Ft{aod{{ odd`{ cvd `vayaon vdstavdldop{ gv aokvdc{aon
ckkd{{ co` aopdvgudvcfajapq ckvg{{ dopdvuva{d cuujakcpago{*uvgkd{{ kglutpaon doyavgoldop{* dopdvuva{d odp~gvh{* co`
pbd Aopdvodp/ Lcoq pald{ pbd{d ft{aod{{ odd`{ cvd ao `avdkp
kgoiakp ~apb {dktvapq gfmdkpayd{/ Pg do{tvd kglltoakcpago
co` kggv`aocpago* Uvgnvd{{ `dydjgud` c od~ Dopdvuva{d
Cvkbapdkptvd Vdyad~ Uvgkd{{ co` kvdcpd` c kgllappdd
lc`d tu g Gudvcpagocj Pdkbogjgnq "GP! co` Aogvlcpago
Pdkbogjgnq "AP! cvkbapdkp{ co` donaoddv{ pg uvgya`d
{pco`cv`{* nta`cokd co` ngydvocokd pg uvgmdkp pdcl{/
Pbd{d gvlcj vdyad~{ "ncpd{! vdstavd {udkak cvpackp{ co`
`gktldopd` gjjg~ tu g a{{td{* std{pago{ co` vd{gjtpago
g gtp{pco`aon apdl{/ Pbd {tkkd{{ g pba{ uvgkd{{ bc{
fddo {g ug{apayd* {gld uvgmdkp pdcl{ cvd dydo {gjakapaon
uvd,ncpd vdyad~{ cald` cp ckbadyaon to`dv{pco`aon*
nta`cokd co` kgo{do{t{ g pbd cvkbapdkptvd kgllappdd
dcvjadv pbco vdstavd` ao pbd gvlcj uvgkd{{/ Kgjjcfgvcpagofdp~ddo GP* AP co` {tuujq kbcao tokpago{ do{tvd{ pbcp
pbd vanbp gto`cpagocj kcucfajapad{ "d/n/ odp~gvh {dktvapq*
ctpbdopakcpago* lgoapgvaon* kgontvcpago lcocndldop* dpk/!
cvd ao pbd uvgktvd` kglugodop gv {gjtpago/ Pbd [tuujq Kbcao
Gudvcpaon Ivcld~gvh aokjt`d{ {udkak kgjjcfgvcpago ao pbd
gjjg~aon cvdc{= utvkbc{aon* kgopvckpaon* kcpdngvq {pvcpdnad{
"vgc`lcu co` {pvcpdnq {bcvaon!* {tuujadv lcocndldop co`
udvgvlcokd lgoapgvaon/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
22/3665 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
6/ [tuuj Kbcao Pvco{ucvdok co` Pvt{p
6c= Ydp [tuujadv Uvckpakd{
Njgfcj {gtvkaon kco kvdcpd od~ va{h{ cp dydvq jaoh ao pbd {tuujq kbcao/ Od~ {tuujadv{ pg pbd {lcvp
nva` {dkpgv pdo` pg bcyd jd{{ to`dv{pco`aon g kt{pgldv vdstavdldop{ co` lcq ogp lddp stcjapq
gv {dktvapq drudkpcpago{/ Ao ucvpaktjcv* pbd od~ ba,pdkb dopvcop{ aopg pbd {lcvp nva` {tuujq kbcao
`g ogp to`dv{pco` pbd jgon pdkbogjgnq jad kqkjd g pbd ug~dv ao`t{pvq* ~bakb `vayd{ pbd odd` gv
lgvd {pvaondop {dktvapq co` udvgvlcokd vdstavdldop{ cp pbd vgop do`/
Dydo cucvp vgl pbd va{h g lcjakagt{ cppckh{ go djdkpvgoak kglugodop{* pbd aokvdc{d` ycjtd
g uvg`tkp{ ig~aon pbvgtnb pbd njgfcj {tuujq kbcao bc{ aokvdc{d` pbd aokdopayd{ gv kqfdv
kvald* kgtopdvdapaon co` pbdp g `anapcj AU/ Pba{ bc{ odkd{{apcpd` lgvd gvncoa}d` uvgkd{{d{ pg
{kvtpaoa}d {tuujadv{ ao gv`dv pg kvdcpd kgo`dokd ao pbd lcpdvacj{ fdaon {gtvkd`* pbd stcjapq g
pbd lcotckptvaon uvgkd{{ co` pbd {dktvapq uvckpakd{ g pbd ydo`gv{/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
Ydp ydo`gv{ c{ ucvp g pbd VIU uvgkd{{ pbvgtnb tuvgop {dktvapq vdyad~ co` cocjq{a{/
Ncao ya{afajapq aopg ~bg {tuujadv{ cvd tu{pvdcl co` `g~o{pvdcl/
Vdstavd ydo`gv kdvpakcpago aoapacjjq tu{pvdcl co` ao{paptpd co gongaon ydo`gv ct`apuvgkd{{* aokjt`aon {apd ya{ap{/
T{d ltjpaujd {gtvkd{ pg udvgvl ocokacj* jdncj co` fckhnvgto` kbdkh{ go ydo`gv{ pglchd {tvd pbdq cvd stcjad`/
Stcjaq {tuujadv lcotckptvaon uvgkd{{d{ co` uvgkd`tvd{/
Pcajgv kgopvckp pdvl{ co` kgo`apago{/
VIU vdstavdldop{ co` kgopvckp{ {bgtj` fd kjdcv ~apb vd{udkp pg kdvpakcpago pd{paon*ydo`gv lcocndldop kgopvgj{* kgopvgj{ go ~bdvd c uvg`tkp kco fd lcotckptvd`* stcjapq
kgopvgj{ co` djaydvq uvckpakd{ ~apb c vdstavdldop gv ogpakcpago g coq kbcond{/
Kgopvckp{ {bgtj` {udkaq vdstavdldop{ pg uvgpdkp aopdjjdkptcj uvgudvpq pg `dlgo{pvcpd ckcucfajapq pg kglucvpldopcja}d co` kgopvgj aogvlcpago ig~ ~apb ydvakcpago uvgya{ago{/
Alujdldop dpcajd` kgopvckp jcontcnd pg c{{d{{ co` ydvaq {tuujq kbcao va{h* co` gydv{dd~bg a{ bco`jaon pbd uvg`tkp/ Vdstavd{ lcuuaon g pbd {tuujq kbcao co` va{h c{{d{{ldop{
g {tuujadv kglucoad{/
Vdstavd paldjq ogpakcpago fq ydo`gv ao pbd dydop g c fvdckb/
Ycja`cpd ydo`gv {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq uvckpakd{= vdcj,pald kbcao g kt{pg`q kgopvgj{ ~apbdjdkpvgoak ydvakcpago* ycja`cpago co` ctpbdopakcpago/
^gvh ~apb pvt{pd` ydo`gv{ pg c{{d{{* stcjaq co` lcocnd pbdav {tuujadv{/
Alug{d vgft{p co` fggp{,go,pbd,nvgto` ct`ap uvgkd{{d{/
Do{tvd dobcokd` {tuujadv c~cvdod{{ g fd{p uvckpakd{* aokjt`aon od~ A[G {pco`cv`{* pvcaoaon
uvgnvcl{ "Ug~dvUgaop* ya`dg!* 3,255 otlfdv pg kcjj GDL gv gojaod ckkd{{/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
23/36 6~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
@G^= Va{h C{{d{{ldop{ g Vc~ Lcpdvacj [tuujadv{) Jgna{pak{ [dvyakd Uvgya`dv{
@g~{ {tuujadv{ cvd dycjtcpd` aoapacjjq co` udvag`akcjjqpbdvdcpdv* fc{d` go pbd ugpdopacj va{h{ pbdq uvd{dop pg pbd
kglucoq/ Cjj {tuujadv{ cvd {kvddod` cncao{p {udkak kvapdvac
ao danbp va{h cvdc{* aokjt`aon {cdpq co` {dktvapq* uvg`tkp
{pd~cv`{bau* {gkacj co` doyavgoldopcj vd{ugo{afajapq* uvg`tkp
stcjapq* pvc`d kglujacokd* ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq* ocokacj
{pcfajapq co` aogvlcpago uvgpdkpago/ Pbd kvapdvac aokjt`d
cppvaftpd{ vdjcpd` pg pbd {tuujadv* ao`t{pvq {dkpgv* kgllg`apq*
ndgnvcubak cvdc co` lcvhdp{ {dvyd`/ Cjj {tuujadv{ cvd vcohd`
ao god g pbvdd va{h padv{= banb* ld`atl gv jg~/ [tuujadv{ pbcp
cvd vcohd` ao c ld`atl gv banb,va{h padv cvd tvpbdv c{{d{{d`
t{aon ao`t{pvq,`dydjgud` uvgpgkgj{ co` aopdvocpagocjjq
vdkgnoa}d` kdvpakcpago {pco`cv`{* ~bdvd cycajcfjd/ ^bdvd
ao`t{pvq uvgpgkgj{ gv ngydvoldop uvgnvcl{ cvd ogp cycajcfjd*
@g~,{udkak c{{d{{ldop uvgpgkgj{ cvd t{d`/ Itvpbdv*
gv {tuujadv{ vcohd` ao c banb,va{h padv* @g~ utp{ fggp{ go
pbd nvgto` pg ycja`cpd pbcp laoaltl va{h lcocndldop
vdstavdldop{ cvd fdaon alujdldopd`/
[kb~dap}dv Donaoddvaon Jcfgvcpgv "[DJ!=[tuujadv Dycjtcpago [{pdl
[DJ dlujgq{ c {tuujadv va{h vcpaon {q{pdl* kglfaoaon va{h
aopdjjandokd vgl ap{ V)@* {tuujadv stcjapq* ocokd co`
utvkbc{aon `ducvpldop{ pg c{{d{{=
Lcotckptvdv jgkcpago va{h* fc{d` tugo jgkcpago gv cjjuvgkd{{ {pdu{8
[tuujadv stcjapq va{h* fc{d` go uvg`tkp `ddkp `cpc8
V)@ va{h fc{d` go pdkbogjgnq pqud co` pbd jdonpb g paldvdstavd` gv vd`d{ano utvug{d{ {bgtj` pbd ucvp fdkgld
tocycajcfjd8
Iaocokd va{h* fc{d` go c lcotckptvdv{ gv {tuujadv{ocokacj bdcjpb8 co`
Utvkbc{aon va{h* fc{d` go {tuujadv udvgvlcokd gv go pald`djaydvq co` vd{ugo{aydod{{/
Ydva}go= Uvgkd{{d{ gv Ydppaon Ydo`gv Uvckpakd{
Igv Ydva}go* kqfdv{dktvapq a{ ogp mt{p c pdkbogjgnq uvgfjdl/
Lcoq ogo,kqfdv ft{aod{{ uvckpakd{ odd` pg fd alujdldopd`
pg c{{tvd kqfdv{dktvapq* aokjt`aon hog~aon ~bg pbd kglucoq
a{ `gaon ft{aod{{ ~apb* pbd g~odv{bau co` jgkcpago g
kgopvckpgv{ co` {tfkgopvckpgv{* co` do{tvaon ycja`cpago co`
kglujacokd ~apb kgopvckp pdvl{ co` kgo`apago{/ Pbd{d {tuujq
kbcao uvgkd{{d{ cvd mt{p c{ alugvpcop c{ pd{paon pbd stcjapq
co` {dktvapq g `dyakd{ ~bdo pbdq cvvayd vgl lcotckptvdv{/
Ydva}go alujdldop{ otldvgt{ {dktvapq uvgkd{{d{ pbcp
bdju lcocnd kqfdv va{h{ ao pbd {tuujq kbcao* aokjt`aon pbd
gjjg~aon=
Ydo`gv Kgopvgj{= [dktvapq uvgkd{{d{ cvd dlfd``d` aopg
{tuujq kbcao uvgkd{{d{* vgl pbd {djdkpago g cuuvguvacpd
ydo`gv{ co` jgkcpago{* pg pbd kglujdpago co` `djaydvq g
uvg`tkp{ gv {dvyakd{* pg pbd ptvo`g~o g pbd vdjcpago{bau/
Uvagv pg coq kgopvckptcj cnvddldop* uvg{udkpayd Ydva}go
{tuujadv{ cvd {kvtpaoa}d` go kvapdvac {tkb c{ g~odv{bau co`
jgkcpago8 jaoh{ pg gvdano kgtopvad{8 co` vd` icn yagjcpago{*
aokjt`aon drugvp kgopvgj yagjcpago{/ Ydva}go t{d{ ap{ g~o
aopdjjandokd co` utfjak aogvlcpago pg vdyad~ {tuujadv{/
Aopdvocj Kjdcvcokd Uvgkd{{d{= Ydva}go kgo`tkp{ co
c``apagocj aopdvocj kjdcvcokd uvgkd{{ go uvg{udkpayd
ydo`gv{ pg lchd {tvd pbcp pbd ft{aod{{ vdjcpago{bau a{ ao
kglujacokd ~apb cjj jdncj co` vdntjcpgvq aludvcpayd{* c{ ~djj
c{ cjj {dktvapq uvagvapad{/ Pba{ uvgkd{{ aokjt`d{ fckhnvgto`
kbdkh{* drugvp kgopvgj {pcpdldop{* vdstavdldop{ gv g,
{bgvaon gv gtp{gtvkaon ogpakcpago co` cuuvgycj* `a{kjg{tvd
g fc{djaod {dktvapq gv bco`jaon `cpc* co` gpbdv kjdcvcokd
vdstavdldop{* aokjt`aon c{{d{{ldop{ g ubq{akcj co` kqfdv
kgopvgj{/
Va{h Vcohaon gv Kglugodop{ co` [tuujadv{= Ydva}go
uvagvapa}d{ {tuujadv c{{d{{ldop{ fgpb fq vcohaon pbd
kvapakcjapq g kglugodop{ co` pbd c{{tvcokd jdydj{ `d{avd`
gv {tuujadv{ pbcp bcyd ckkd{{ pg Ydva}go `cpc* uvg`tkp{
gv {q{pdl{/ Lcoq g pbd lcmgv kglugodop{ cvd utvkbc{d`
vgl hdq ydo`gv{ pbcp cvd ~apbao c pvt{pd` kcpdngvq co`
ckd vd{pvakpago{ go ~bdvd uvg`tkp{ kco fd `dydjgud` co`
lcotckptvd`* c{ ~djj c{ ~bdvd {dvyakd{ lcq fd udvgvld`/
Igv kdvpcao vdjcpago{bau{* Ydva}go kgopvckpgv{ cvd vdstavd`
pg ja{p pbdav {tfkgopvckpgv{/
C{{d{{ldop{ g Banb,Uvagvapq Ydo`gv{= Ydva}go cj{g
udvgvl{ go{apd vdyad~{ g banb,uvagvapq ydo`gv{ pg do{tvd
pbcp pbdq cvd kglujqaon ~apb vdstavdldop{ co` lddpaon
cuuvguvacpd {dktvapq uvckpakd{/ Ydva}go dlujgq{ go{apd
ao{udkpago{ co` ct`ap{ gv pbd{d vdyad~{* fdkct{d pbdvd
a{ kgokdvo pbcp std{pagoocavd{ lcq kvdcpd c cj{d {do{d
g {dktvapq/ Ydo`gv{ gpdo nayd pbd co{~dv pbcp pbdq
pbaoh pbdav kt{pgldv{ ~cop pg bdcv gv `d{kvafd ~bcp pbd
ydo`gv fdjadyd{ a{ ao ujckd/ Drudvadokd bc{ {bg~o pbcp
std{pagoocavd co{~dv{ vcvdjq lcpkb tu pg pbd o`aon{ g
go{apd ao{udkpago{/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
24/3666 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
6f= Ftaj` Pvt{p ao [tuujadv Odp~gvh{
Fd{p uvckpakd ao {tuujq kbcao uvgkd{{d{ a{ {bapaon vgl cvl{ jdonpb co` {gldpald{ c`ydv{cvacj
vdjcpago{bau{ pg kgjjcfgvcpayd odp~gvh{ pg do{tvd stcjapq co` vdjacfajapq* c{ ~djj c{ uvg`tkp
aopdnvapq/ Pvt{pd` {tuujadv{ cj{g to`dv{pco` kt{pgldv drudkpcpago{ co` odd`{/
^bajd {dktvapq pdkbogjgnad{* kgopvckp kjct{d{ co` lgvd {pvaondop {pco`cv`{ cvd kvapakcj pg{dktvaon pbd {tuujq kbcao* c otlfdv g kglucoad{ bcyd gto` pbcp ckd,pg,ckd aopdvckpago
~apb ltjpaujd padv{ g {tuujadv{ a{ c fd{p uvckpakd gv kglltoakcpaon odd`{ co` drudkpcpago{ gv
stcjapq* {dktvapq co` vd{ajadokd/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
[bcvd vgc`lcu co` {pvcpdnq aogvlcpago ~apb ydo`gv{ co` {tuujadv{* kbcjjdonaon pbdl pg `g
pbd {cld ~apb pbdav {tuujadv{* ao co dgvp pg kglltoakcpd odd`{ co` drudkpcpago{* c{ ~djj c{
a`dopaq aluvgydldop guugvptoapad{ pg cjano uvg`tkp avdkpago/
Kgo`tkp cootcj {tuujadv {tllap{/
[DJ= Ftaj`aon Pvt{pd` [tuuj Odp~gvh{
[DJ bg{p{ c `cq co` c bcj cootcj kgodvdokd ~apb {tuujadv
vduvd{dopcpayd{ vgl 655 gvncoa}cpago{ pg=
[bcvd co gydvyad~ g pbd kglucoq{ ba{pgvq* ycjtd{ co`kgvugvcpd ktjptvd/
@d{kvafd ~bcp ap{ uvg`tkp{ `g co` ~bq jayd{ `dudo` gopbd stcjapq co` vdjacfajapq g pbdav uvg`tkp{/
Uvgya`d gydvyad~ g pbd ao`t{pvq {dkpgv co` pbd pdkboakcj*lcvhdp co` ugjakq gvdkc{p{/
[bcvd [DJ{ pdkboakcj odd`{ co` {pvcpdnak gfmdkpayd{ gv pbdkglaon qdcv/
Kvdcpd guugvptoapad{ gv dd`fckh vgl {tuujadv{ go ~bcp[DJ kgtj` `g `advdopjq/
Docfjd co doyavgoldop gv kgjjcfgvcpayd fvcao{pgvlaon co`kglltoakcpago{/
[tuujadv `acjgntd{ kgopaotd pbvgtnbgtp pbd qdcv ao fgpb
`avdkpago{/ [DJ dlujgqdd{ lchd cfgtp 45 ujt{ {tuujadv
ya{ap{ dydvq qdcv pg `a{kt{{ od~ guugvptoapad{ co` cvdc{ gv
aluvgydldop/
BU= [gjtpago{ Ckvg{{ pbd [tuuj Kbcao
BU kgoydod{ co cootcj [tuujadv{ [tllap* fvaonaon pgndpbdv
lgvd pbco 455 vduvd{dopcpayd{ vgl 345 {tuujadv{* pg {bcvd
ya{ago co` uvagvapad{/ Pbd kglucoq dokgtvcnd{ ap{ {tuujadv
fc{d pg c`gup {tuujq kbcao uvckpakd{ c{ ~djj c{ pdkbogjgnq
{gjtpago{ co` dcvjq vd{a{pcokd bc{ ptvod` aopg c {pco`cv`
ucvp g `gaon ft{aod{{ gv lg{p {tuujadv{/ [dktvapq uvgnvcl{
pdo` pg `adv fc{d` go uvg`tkp* kgtopvq co` vdnagocj va{h{8
BU {tuujadv{ bcyd c`gupd` ltkb lgvd {pvaondop {dktvapqldc{tvd{ ao banbdv va{h cvdc{/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
25/36 6~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
6k= @dujg Aogvlcpago [{pdl{ gv [aptcpagocj C~cvdod{{* [tuuj Kbcao Pvco{ucvdok* DydoLcocndldop co` Vd{ajadokd
Naydo pbd kglujdrapad{ g njgfcj aovc{pvtkptvd co` aopdv`dudo`dokad{* ap a{ alug{{afjd pg
ckktvcpdjq uvd`akp dydvq ug{{afjd va{h pvanndv/ Ao{pdc`* njgfcj ft{aod{{ jdc`dv{ cvd kvdcpaon od~
uvckpakd{* uvgkd{{d{* pggj{* pdkbogjgnad{* ldpvak{* co` ngydvocokd {pvtkptvd{ pbcp vdjq go cnajapq
co` c`cupcfajapq/ Vd{ajadokd uvgnvcl{ gkt{ go utppaon ao ujckd pbd kcucfajapad{ pg lcocnd c
{udkpvtl g a{vtupago{* vcpbdv pbco {udkak {kdocvag{/ Aogvlcpago a{ pbd fckhfgod g vd{ajadokd
kvdcpaon co cfajapq pg copakaucpd ytjodvcfajapad{* lcocnd a{vtupago{ co` vdkgydv vcua`jq/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
Lcu kvapakcj kglugodop{ pg hdq btf{* og`d{ co` {tuujadv{ pg kvdcpd {aptcpagocj c~cvdod{{/
Kgo`tkp cootcj c{{d{{ldop g {tuujq kbcao va{h{= hdq {gtvkd{* og`cj ytjodvcfajapad{ co`
{aonjd ugaop{ g cajtvd/
A`dopaq {dkgo` co` pbav` padv {tuujadv{* co` c{{d{{ ocokacj bdcjpb co` ft{aod{{
kgopaotapq ujco{/ @dujgq ya{tcja}cpago pggj{'bdcp lcu{/
Lcaopcao c ujcq fggh pbcp docfjd{ `djafdvcpayd vcpbdv pbco vdckpayd vd{ugo{d{/
Ycja`cpd {tuujq kbcao kgopaotapq ujco{ pbvgtnb ct`ap{ co` vajj{/
[DJ= Kvdcpaon Ya{afajap pg Dycjtcpd [tuujadv{
[DJ lcaopcao{ c `cpcfc{d g cjj pbd uvg`tkp{ ap bc{
lcotckptvd` ~bdvd pbdq cvd kglaon vgl co` ~bdvd pbdqng pg c{{tvd kt{pgldv{ pbcp pbd uvg`tkp{ cvd jdnapalcpd
co` bcyd ogp fddo gtp{a`d pbd [DJ {tuujq kbcao* co` pg fd
cfjd pg c{p pvckh dgvp{ pg vclu tu uvg`tkpago ao pbd dydop
g `a{vtupago{ ao pbd {tuujq kbcao gv `dlco` {uahd{/
[DJ cj{g lcaopcao{ c ucvp{ aogvlcpago `cpcfc{d pbcp kgydv{
dydvq kglugodop/ Ap kgjjdkp{ `cpc go {tuujadv lcotckptvaon
jgkcpago{8 ~bdvd lcpdvacj{ cvd cfvakcpd`* uckhcnd`* pd{pd`*
co` {bauud`8 co` ocld{ g hdq udgujd co` kgopckp{/
Pba{ `cpc cjjg~{ [DJ pg vd{ugo` stakhjq ao kc{d g `a{vtupago/ Ao
pbd cpdvlcpb g pbd 6533 Mcucod{d dcvpbstchd co` p{tocla*
[DJ ~c{ cfjd pg stakhjq a`dopaq ~bakb ucvp{ ~dvd cp va{h co`
lgyd` alld`acpdjq pg utvkbc{d c``apagocj aoydopgvq vgldra{paon co` cjpdvocpayd {tuujadv{ pg do{tvd pbd toaopdvvtupd`
ig~ g [DJ uvg`tkp{/ Pg laoala}d pbd aluckp g `a{vtupago{*
[DJ ~gvh{ ~apb ap{ {tuujadv{ pg do{tvd {ar lgopb{ g aoydopgvq
a{ kgopaotcjjq {dktvd` gv banb,va{h kglugodop{* gtv lgopb{
gv ld`atl va{h* co` pbvdd lgopb{ gv jg~ va{h/
[DJ{ Uvg`tkp @cpcfc{d kgjjdkp{ aogvlcpago go=
Uvg`tkp A@* vl~cvd A@ co` {dvacj otlfdv
[tfc{{dlfjq `cpc co` ~gvh ao{pvtkpago{
^bg ftajp ap7
^bdo ~c{ ap ftajp7
^bdvd ~c{ ap ftajp7
^bcp jaod ~c{ ap ftajp go7
^bcp pd{p {pcpago ~c{ t{d`7
^bg fgtnbp ap7
^bg a{ pbd do`,t{dv7
Bg~ ~c{ ap {bauud`7
^bg ~c{ pbd {cjd{ vdu7
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
26/3660 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
Ka{kg= [tuuj Kbcao Vd{ajadokq Ao`dr
Ka{kg{ ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq uvgnvcl ncpbdv{ c ycvadpq g
aogvlcpago vgl ap{ hdq {tuujq kbcao ucvpodv{ pbvgtnbc {tvydq uvgkd{{ pbcp gkktv{ {dydvcj pald{ udv qdcv/ Pbd
{tvydq kgjjdkp{ aogvlcpago go ucvpodv{ ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq
uvckpakd{ "FKU!* pald pg vdkgydv "PPV! ao pbd dydop g c
`a{vtupago co` hdq dldvndokq kgopckp aogvlcpago* c{ ~djj
c{ ocokacj aogvlcpago/ ^apb pba{ `cpc* Ka{kg kco `dod
pbd vdkgydvq uvgjd g c uvg`tkp c{ kbcvckpdva}d` fq pbd
vd{ajadokd g cjj kglugodop {tuujadv ckpgvad{* aoydopgvq btf{*
ucvpodv uvg`tkpago ckajapad{ co` jgna{pak{ kdopdv{ ~apbao pbcp
uvg`tkp{ ycjtd kbcao/
Ka{kg aoydopd` pbd Vd{ajadokq Ao`drco` pbd PPV ldpvak
fdkct{d ap ~c{ ogp cfjd pg o` coq uvd,dra{paon {pco`cv`{
gv ldpvak{ pg lddp ap{ odd`{/ Pbd Vd{ajadokq Ao`dra{ ckglug{apd g vd{ajadokq cppvaftpd{ gv pbd hdq kcvd,cfgtp{ cp
Ka{kg pbd{d aokjt`d uvg`tkp vd{ajadokq* {tuujadv vd{ajadokq*
lcotckptvaon vd{ajadokq co` pd{p dstauldop vd{ajadokq*
~bakb a{ c hdq kgopvgj ugaop pg c{{tvd pbd aopdnvapq g uvg`tkp{
ao c njgfcjjq gtp{gtvkd` {tuujq kbcao/ Dckb g pbd{d gtv
djdldop{ g pbd Vd{ajadokq Ao`dra{ ao ptvo ldc{tvd` fq co
c``apagocj jdydj g vd{ajadokq kvapdvac/ Cp pbd kglugodop jdydj*
gv ao{pcokd* pbd kvapdvac aokjt`d{ pbd otlfdv g cjpdvocpayd
{gtvkd{ g {tuujq* kglugodop {tuujadv{ PPV co` do` g
jad ujco{ co` uvgkd{{d{/ Cp pbd {tuujadv jdydj* vd{ajadokq a{
jaohd` pg pbd ocokacj bdcjpb g {tuujadv{ co` ucvpodv{* co`
{tuujadv{ ft{aod{{ kgopaotapq ujco{/ Lcotckptvaon vd{ajadokq
a{ {alajcv pg kglugodop vd{ajadokq ao pbcp ap a{ kgvvdjcpd`~apb pbd cycajcfajapq g fckh,tu gv {dkgo`cvq {gtvkaon co`
pbd lcotckptvdv{ PPV gjjg~aon co dydop/ Pd{p vd{ajadokq
a{ ldc{tvd` fq pbd cycajcfajapq g aoydopgvad{ gv jgon,
jdc` pd{p dstauldop ucvp{/ Pbd Vd{ajadokq Ao`dra{ cuujad`
ctpglcpakcjjq pg Ka{kg{ pgu 355 uvg`tkp{ pbcp* ao cnnvdncpd*
ckkgtop gv cfgtp 45 udvkdop g Ka{kg{ vdydotd/
Aogvlcpago ao Ckpago
^apbao 36 bgtv{ g pbd aoapacj Mcucod{d dcvpbstchd ao 6533*
Ka{kg bc` a`dopad` cjj `avdkp {tuujadv{* pbdav c{{gkacpd` {apd{
co` kglugodop{ co` gpbdv kvapakcj {tuujq kbcao og`d{ ao pbd
aluckpd` cvdc/ Jdydvcnaon pbd FKU kgopckp aogvlcpago cp
pbd {tuujadv jdydj* pbd aoka`dop pdcl ~c{ cfjd pg d{pcfja{bkgopckp ~apb {tuujadv{ pg c{{d{{ pbd aluckp go {apd kcuckapq*
co` pbd uvgnog{a{ g pbdav cfajapq pg kgopaotd pg uvg`tkd co`
`a{pvaftpd kglugodop{/ Tpaja}aon FKU Vd{ajadokd Ya{tcja}cpago
kcucfajapq* pbd pdcl ~c{ cfjd pg `dydjgu c {ocu{bgp g pbd
{tuujadv aluckp co` {pcpt{ gydv pbd dopavd vdnago/ Ao c {bgvp
udvag`* pbd kva{a{ lcocndldop {q{pdl ~c{ cfjd pg c{{d{{
lgvd pbco ;55 Padv 3 pbvgtnb Padv 4 {tuujadv{* co` lgvd pbco
>*555 ucvp otlfdv{* co` kvdcpd c va{h vcpaon co` lapancpago
ujco/ Pbd jcvnd{p {tuujq kbcao `a{vtupago ao lg`dvo pald{
kvdcpd` yavptcjjq og vdydotd aluckp gv pbd kglucoq/
@g~= Vdnagocj Dydop Lcocndldop Kdopdv{
^apbao pbd jc{p p~g qdcv{* @g~ bc{ kvdcpd` vdnagocj {tuujq
kbcao {dvyakd dydop lcocndldop kdopdv{ pg uvgckpaydjqlgoapgv dydop{ pbcp kgtj` c`ydv{djq aluckp ap{ njgfcj {tuujq
kbcao vgl c`ydv{d ~dcpbdv kgo`apago{ pg copakaucpd` jcfgv
`a{utpd{ pg {gkacj co` ugjapakcj tovd{p pg kcvng pbdp co`
uavckq co` lcocnd pbg{d dydop{ pg laoala}d coq ugpdopacj
`a{vtupago{ gv kt{pgldv{/ Kgydvaon pbd Cldvakc{* C{ac*
Dtvgud'La``jd Dc{p* Jcpao Cldvakc co` Cvakc* pbd vdnagocj
kdopdv{ `vc~ go ltjpaujd aopdjjandokd {pvdcl{ pg ncpbdv
aogvlcpago co` c{{d{{ pbd ugpdopacj aluckp g dydop{ go
@g~ {bauldop{/ Igv drclujd* @g~{ vdnagocj kdopdv{ bcyd
lcocnd` ugpdopacj `a{vtupago{ c{{gkacpd` ~apb vcaj co` ugvp
{pvahd{ ao Dtvgud co` Ogvpb Cldvakc* pqubggo{ ao pbd [gtpb
Kbaoc [dc* btvvakcod{ co` pvguakcj {pgvl{ ao pbd Ntj Kgc{p*
Bgt{pgo {bau kbcoodj kjg{tvd{ `td pg c fcvnd ckka`dop*ugjapakcj tovd{p ao pbd La``jd Dc{p* lcvapald uavckq ao pbd Ntj
g C`do* co` `condvgt{ ngg`{ vgtpaon vd{pvakpago{ ao Kbaoc
co` gpbdv ~gvj` cvdc{ c{{gkacpd` ~apb banb,uvgjd utfjak
dydop{/ Pbd vdnagocj kdopdv{ cvd ftaj`aon c {pvgon jafvcvq g
jd{{go{ jdcvod` a/d/ ~bcp ~gvhd`* ~bcp `a` ogp* co` bg~
pbd kglucoq kgtj` cuuvgckb pbd uvgfjdl `advdopjq ao pbd
tptvd/
Gokd ap fdkgld{ kjdcv pbcp co dydop kgtj` cdkp pbd
kglucoq{ uvg`tkp {bauldop{ gv kt{pgldv{* pbd vdnagocj
kdopdv{ fdkgld pbd gkt{ gv va{h lcocndldop dgvp{/
@dudo`aon go pbd ugpdopacj {dydvapq g pbd dydop* pbd
vdnagocj pdcl{ kco utp pgndpbdv c ~cv vggl pg lgoapgv pbd{aptcpago* c{{d{{ pbd ugpdopacj aluckp* `dydjgu gupago{ co`
~gvh `avdkpjq ~apb pbd cdkpd` ft{aod{{ toap{* ~bakb ao ptvo
doncnd kt{pgldv{ pg `dpdvlaod ~cq{ pg lapancpd pbd aluckp
g pbd `a{vtupago/ Pbd ngcj a{ pg copakaucpd co` c`mt{p fdgvd
c `a{vtupago kco kc{kc`d aopg c lcmgv kva{a{ gv pbd kglucoq
co` ap{ kt{pgldv{/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
27/36 6~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
;/ [tuuj Kbcao [dktvap
;c= [dktvd Ngg`{ ao Pvco{ap
Ba{pgvakcjjq* pbd a{{td{ pbcp kct{d` pbd nvdcpd{p aluckp go {tuujq kbcao{ aokjt`d` ocptvcj
`a{c{pdv{* {dydvd ~dcpbdv* jcfgv `a{utpd{ co` ~gvh {pguucnd{* co` {gkacj co` ugjapakcj tovd{p/
Njgfcja}cpago bc{ vclcpakcjjq druco`d` pbd{d va{h{* ~bakb og~ aokjt`d pdvvgva{l co` ocpago,
{ugo{gvd` cppckh{* uco`dlak{* kcvng pbdp* bc}cv`gt{ lcpdvacj ckka`dop{* uvg`tkp kgtopdvdapao
{ltnnjaon co` lcvapald uavckq/ Pbd aludpt{ pg {dktvd pbd ubq{akcj {tuujq kbcao bc{ aokvdc{d`
ao alugvpcokd/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ ao Ubq{akcj [dktvapq aokjt`d=
D{pcfja{b kbcao g kt{pg`q kgopvgj{ pbcp uvgya`d pvckdcfajapq co` pvckhcfajapq t{aon pdkboastd{
{tkb c{=
Djdkpvgoak ycja`cpago pg ctpbdopakcpd ucvp{8
NU[ pvckhaon8 co` Pcludv `dpdkpago pdkboastd{* aokjt`aon ubq{akcj {dcj{ co` {do{gv{/
@g~ Kbdlakcj Kbcao g Kt{pg` Kgopvgj{
@g~{ {tuujq kbcao {dktvapq a{ vggpd` ao kbcao g kt{pg`q
kgopvgj{/ Igv banbjq ycjtcfjd* banbjq vdntjcpd` gv banbjq
bc}cv`gt{ uvg`tkp{* pbd kglucoq bc{ d{pcfja{bd` pbd
kcucfajapq gv 60,> lgoapgvaon g pbd kcvng{ jgkcpago d/n/
~bg bc{ vd{ugo{afajapq gv ap{ bco`jaon co` ~bdpbdv pbdvd bc{fddo toctpbgva}d` dopvq aopg pbd kgopcaodv{ ao pvco{ap gv cp
pbd ugaop{ g bco`,g vgl god ucvpq pg cogpbdv/
@g~ fdnco alujdldopaon c {pvcpdnq gv c{{dp ya{afajapq
pbvgtnb c kglfaocpago g VIA@ pcnnaon* NU[ co` {do{gv
pdkbogjgnad{ cfgtp {ar qdcv{ cng/ Cjpbgtnb VIA@ bc`
jgon fddo t{d` pg pvckh kbdlakcj {bauldop{ fq vcaj* pbd
kglltoakcpago ~c{ god ~cq pbd kgopcaodv bc` pg uc{{
co VIA@ vdc`dv pg {anocj ap{ jgkcpago co` `a` ogp kgydv
gpbdv lg`d{ g pvco{ugvpcpago/ Fq kglfaoaon VIA@ co`
NU[ pdkbogjgnq* pbd kglucoq vdkdayd{ vdcj,pald jgkcpago
aogvlcpago/ Pg`cq* @g~{ ~df,fc{d` @g~Pvch kgopcaodv
pvckhaon ugvpcj nayd{ pbd kglucoq co` kt{pgldv{ pbd cfajapqpg pvckh {bauldop{ og lcppdv ~bcp lg`d g pvco{ugvpcpago gv
cvdc g pbd ~gvj`/
NU[ co` VIA@ pdkbogjgnad{ cvd kgtujd` ~apb {do{gv{ ~bakb
cjjg~ {tuujq kbcao lcocndv{ pg lgoapgv pbd kgo`apago g pbd
lcpdvacj co` pbd aopdnvapq g pbd kgopcaodv/ Djdkpvgoak {dcj{
kco lgoapgv ~bdpbdv pbd kgopcaodv bc{ fddo gudod`8 ~bdpbdv
pbd {do{gv{ `dpdkp janbp/ Pbdvd cvd {bgkh `dpdkpgv{* ~bakb
cj{g kco docfjd pbd kglucoq pg `dpdkp ~bdvd vgtnb bco`jaon
lcq fd `clcnaon pbd pvco{ugvpcpago dstauldop gv uvg`tkp{
ao pbd kgopcaodv* co` btla`apq {do{gv{ pg lgoapgv gv pbd
uvd{dokd g ~cpdv ycugv* uvdyagt{jq `dpdkpcfjd gojq cpdv
`vtl{ `dpdvagvcpd` c{ c vd{tjp g c`ydv{d kgo`apago{ `tvaon
gkdco pvco{ap{/ Pbd{d pqud{ g c{{dp ya{afajapq ldc{tvd{ {dvydfgpb uvg`tkp stcjapq c{ ~djj c{ {dktvapq odd`{/
Naydo pbd ygjtld g {bauldop{* ap a{ ogp uvckpakcj pg pvckh
dydvq {bauldop/ @g~{ gkt{ a{ go kcvng pbcp a{=
Banb ycjtd= kcpcjq{p lcpdvacj{ co` cnvaktjptvd kbdlakcj{~bakb kgtj` fvaon c banb uvakd go pbd fjckh lcvhdp8
Banb bc}cv`= lcpdvacj{ pbcp cvd pgrak pg aobcjd ~bakb kgtj`fd t{d` c{ ~dcugo{ g lc{{ ddkp fq pdvvgva{p{8 co`
Banbjq vdntjcpd`= kbdlakcj{ pbcp kgtj` fd vd,utvug{d`pg lcotckptvd ajjdncj `vtn{ gv kbdlakcj ~dcugo{* gv
uvg`tkp{ {gj` aopg {do{apayd do`,t{d lcvhdp{ {tkb c{
`avdkp gg` co` ubcvlckdtpakcj cuujakcpago{/
C{ pbd odd` a{ `dpdvlaod` fq va{h c{{d{{ldop{ go uvg`tkp{ ao
pbd{d kcpdngvad{* @g~ bc{ pbd cfajapq pg lcaopcao 355 udvkdop
ya{afajapq go c {bauldop vgl pbd pald ap jdcyd{ pbd {bauuaon
jgkcpago topaj ap cvvayd{ cp ap{ `d{paocpago/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
28/3669 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
;f= @dujg Copa,Kgtopdvdapaon Kgopvgj{
Kgtopdvdapaon bc{ nvg~o vclcpakcjjq gtvgj` mt{p tvaon pbd jc{p kgtujd g qdcv{/ apb
otldvgt{ banb,uvgjd drclujd{ g kgtopdvdap ucvp{ to`dvlaoaon pbd aopdnvapq* tokpagocjapq co`
jgondyapq g kvapakcj {q{pdl{* kgtopdvdapaon bc{ kgld aopg pbd {ugpjanbp c{ c va{h pg kt{pgldv{* c
kg{p pg ft{aod{{d{ "d{palcpd` cp c{ ltkb c{ $945 fajjago udv qdcv pg`cq co` drudkpd` pg gtfjd
fq 6534!* co` c pbvdcp pg pbd aopdnvapq g kvapakcj aovc{pvtkptvd{ co` ddo{d {q{pdl{/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
Ao{paptpagocja}d ugjakad{ co` uvgkd`tvd{ kjdcv avdkpago go kglfcpaon kgtopdvdap{ gv
aopdv`akpaon to~cvvcopd` tokpagocjapq* co` ~vappdo nta`cokd go bg~ pg cyga` utvkbc{aon pbdl/
Ftq gojq vgl GDL{ co` vcokba{dd{/ Dlujgq lapancpago {pvcpdnad{ a fvghdv ucvp{ cvd
utvkbc{d`/
Pvcao go od~ pbvdcp{* a`dopakcpago pdkboastd{ co` kglltoakcpago{ {pvcpdnad{/
Dlujgq uckhcnaon {pvcpdnad{ aokjt`aon dlfd``d` {dktvapq lcvhaon ao ucvp{8 toastd* bcv`dv,
pg,kguq jcfdj{ gv lcvhaon{8 co` a{paokpayd jgp co` {dvacj kg`d{ go drpdvocj uckhcnaon/ @dujgq pdkbogjgnakcj kgtopdvldc{tvd{* aokjt`aon=
Ctpbdopakcpago gv dokvqupago kg`d{/
[tvckd pd{paon* R,vcq cocjq{a{* djdkpvakcj pd{paon* pbdvlcj kqkjaon* ftvo,ao pd{paon/
Dlfd``d` vc`ag vdstdokq a`dopakcpago ao banb,ycjtd ucvp{/
@d{pvgq `ddkpayd* `clcnd` co` vdpavd` ucvp{/
Ao{paptpd aoydopgvq lcocndldop kgopvgj{ go uvg`tkp vdptvo{ co` ftq fckh{/
Vdugvp gkktvvdokd{ g kgtopdvdap ngg`{ fgpb aopdvocjjq co` drpdvocjjq/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
29/36 6~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
[DJ Uvg`tkp Aopdnvap C{{tvcokd Uvgnvcl
[DJ ngd{ pg nvdcp jdonpb{ pg c{{tvd pbd uvg`tkp aopdnvapq
pg do{tvd pbcp ~bcp ap{ kt{pgldv{ ndp a{ ~bcp pbdq bcyd fddouvgla{d`/
Ao c``apago pg stcjaqaon {tuujadv{* dydvq uvg{udkpayduvgktvdldop to`dvngd{ c stcjakcpago uvgkd{{/
Kglugodop utvkbc{d{ lt{p fd stcjad` fq [DJ{ V)@ nvgtuco` cvd uvgktvd` `avdkpjq vgl pbd lcotckptvdv gv vgl
gkacjjq vcokba{d` {tuujadv{/
[DJ `gd{ ogp `dcj ~apb fvghdv{ co` ~bdvd ucvp{ cvdutvkbc{d` gtp{a`d pbd{d uvd{kvafd` ucpb{* pbdq cvd vgtpd`
`avdkpjq aopg pbd {tuujadv stcjapq `ducvpldop ~bdvd pbd
ucvp{ cvd {pvauud` `g~o co` kglucvd` pg lcotckptvdv{
`vc~aon{/
Pd{paon a{ `god kgopaotgt{jq co` vangvgt{jq pbvgtnbgtp pbdlcotckptvaon uvgkd{{/ Coq ycvacpago ao udvgvlcokd jdc`{
pg c {pgu {bauldop kcjj/
God {pvahd co` pbdq cvd gtp/ Cjj pbav` ucvpq [DJ {tuujadv{ ~gvhgo c god {pvahd co` qgt cvd gtp vtjd/ A c pbav` ucvpq {gtvkd
{do`{ c kgtopdvdap kglugodop* gv kglugodop{ pbcp `g
ogp lddp [DJ {udkad` vdstavdldop{* pbcp {tuujadv ~ajj fd
icnnd` ao pbd {tuujadv stcjakcpago `cpcfc{d c{ tocuuvgyd`*
co` [DJ ~ajj ogp gv`dv vgl pbdl cncao/
[DJ Ugjakad{
Ftq co` {djj `avdkp* cyga` fvghdv{/
Ao{udkp uckhcnaon* pvckh jgp otlfdv{/
^bdo ao `gtfp* R,Vcq* touckh co` kgopckp lcotckptvdv/
Hddu aoydopgvq kjg{d/
[djdkp {bauuaon ldpbg`{ ~apb kcvd/
[tuugvp kt{pgldv ~apb ao{pcjjcpago co` kglla{{agoaon/
Dydvq cajtvd a{ {anoakcop ndp pg pbd vggp kct{d/
@g~= Lg{p Didkpayd Pdkbogjgn
@g~{ Lg{p Ddkpayd Pdkbogjgnq "LDP! Kdopdv uvgya`d{
{gjtpago{ gv c vcond g kbcjjdond{* vgl copa,kgtopdvdapaonpg {tuujq kbcao {cdpq co` {dktvapq/
God g @g~{ dldvnaon kbcjjdond{ a{ kgtopdvdap uvg`tkp{
dapbdv kgtopdvdap @g~ jcfdj{ gv vdcj @g~ jcfdj{ ~apb
kgtopdvdap uvg`tkp/ Igv {dydvcj banb,va{h ft{aod{{d{
gudvcpaon ao banb,va{h ndgnvcubad{* @g~ bc{ alujdldopd`
copa,kgtopdvdapaon cuuvgckbd{/ Igv drclujd* @g~ ujckd{
pcludv,dya`dop {dcj{ go kgopcaodv{ pg jg~dv pbd uvgfcfajapq
g to`dpdkpd` dopvq/ [dkgo`* pbd kglucoq bc{ dlujgqd` pbd
t{d g bgjgnvcub{ co` ;@ fcv kg`d{ jaohd` pg c `cpcfc{d g
{bauldop{* {g `a{pvaftpgv{ co` kt{pgldv{ kco {kco co` ydvaq
pbd fcv kg`d pbvgtnb c jaoh pg @g~{ {dktvd `cpcfc{d pbcp pbd
jcfdj a{ c jdnapalcpd @g~ jcfdj co` c jdnapalcpd @g~ {bauldop/
BU{ Kgtopdvdapaon Kgtopdvldc{tvd{
Kgtopdvdapaon a{ c {anoakcop kgokdvo gv BU ao co ao`t{pvq ao
~bakb ap a{ d{palcpd` pbcp c{ lcoq c{ 35 udvkdop g uvg`tkp{
cvd kgtopdvdap/ BU a{ jdydvcnaon pdkbogjgnq {gjtpago{*
ucvpaktjcvjq ao pbd uvaopaon co` alcnaon cvdc{* pg vd`tkd
jg{{d{ vgl kgtopdvdapaon co` ckbadyd c jg{{ vcpag pbcp a{ ~djj
fdjg~ pbd ao`t{pvq cydvcnd/ BU jaoh{ uvaopaon aoogycpago ~apb
Stakh Vd{ugo{d kg`d{ "SV kg`d{! pbcp kco fd t{d` pg kbdkh
~bdpbdv pbd uvg`tkp a{ ndotaod/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
30/3662 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
0/ Lcaopcao Aopdnvap g Djdkpvgoak Kglugodop{ co` [gp~cvd
Jahd pbd ubq{akcj {tuujq kbcao* pbd kqfdv {tuujq kbcao a{ co do`,pg,do` uvgkd{{ fdnaooaon ao
pbd d{ano co` `dydjguldop ubc{d co` kgopaotaon pbvgtnb lcotckptvaon pd{paon* a{pvaftpago*
co` {dvyakd co` lcaopdocokd/ bajd ubq{akcj {dktvapq {tuujq kbcao uvgkd{{d{ bcyd lcptvd`*
kqfdv{dktvapq {tuujq kbcao uvgkd{{d{ cvd {pajj dldvnaon/ bcp fdkcld kjdcv pbvgtnb pba{~gvh{bgu a{ pbcp ubq{akcj co` kqfdv{dktvapq ldc{tvd{ cvd kglujdldopcvq co` odd` pg fd
`dujgqd` pgndpbdv pg kvdcpd c pvt{pd` {gjtpago/ Pbd hdq ao fgpb cvdc{ a{ ~djj to`dv{pgg` co`
toagvljq cuujad` {pco`cv`{* uvckpakd{ co` cuuvgckbd{ ckvg{{ pbd njgfcj {tuujq kbcao/
A`dopad` Fd{p Uvckpakd{ Aokjt`d=
Udvgvl va{h c{{d{{ldop{ go cjj od~ pdkbogjgnad{ co` pdkbogjgnq {tuujadv{* co` vdstavd
pbav`,ucvpq dycjtcpago g {anoakcop od~ kglugodop{/
C`gup {dktvd {gp~cvd `dydjguldop ldpbg`gjgnad{ pbcp lchd ap bcv dv pg ao{dvp
lg`akcpago{/
Ydvaq co` {ano dydvqpbaon ao `d{ano/ Ao{paptpd {dktvd kg aon {pco`cv`{/
T{d kvqupgnvcubak {anoaon gv bcv`~cvd co` {gp~cvd/
Pcajgv kgopvckp vdstavdldop{/
Aokjt`d {tuujadv SC {pco`cv`{ co` aopdvgudvcfajapq {pco`cv`{ ao kgopvckp{/
Kjcvaq vdstavdldop{ gv kdvpakcpago pd{paon co` ydo`gv lcocndldop kgopvgj{/
Ao{paptpd kgopvgj{ go ~bdvd c uvg`tkp kco fd lcotckptvd`* stcjapq kgopvgj{ co` djaydvquvckpakd{ ~apb c vdstavdldop gv ogpakcpago g coq kbcond{/
T{d {pvaondop pd{p uvgpgkgj{/ Aokjt`d {dktvapq pd{paon g kglugodop{ c{ c {pco`cv`* vcpbdv pbco vco`gl* pd{paon
uvgkd`tvd{/
@dujgq udodpvcpago pd{paon pg kbdkh cppckh ydkpgv{ co` dydjgu aopdvocj cpcfc{d{ pgto`dv{pco` cppckh {tvckd{ g uvg`tkp{/
Ao{paptpd pbav`,ucvpq udodpvcpago pd{paon g AP {q{pdl{/
Kgo`tkp {dktvapq* aopdvgudvcfajapq co` tokpagocj pd{p{ fdgvd ao{pcjjcpago/
Ao{paptpd gongaon pd{paon* ogp mt{p aoapacj pd{paon* ~apb c gkt{ go udodpvcpago pd{paon/
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
31/36 6~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
[dkpago ;= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{ pg [dktvd pbd [lcvp Nva` [tuujq Kbc
Pdjydop= [dktvd [gp~cvd @dydjguldop
Pdjydop t{d{ Cnajd {gp~cvd `dydjguldop* c ldpbg`gjgnq
fc{d` go apdvcpayd co` aokvdldopcj `dydjguldop co`kgjjcfgvcpago fdp~ddo kvg{{,tokpagocj pdcl{/ Pbd Cnajd
cuuvgckb gdv{ kgludpapayd c`ycopcnd{ ao pdvl{ g c`cupayd
ujcooaon co` idrafjd vd{ugo{d pg kbcond* ftp ap bc{ {gld
ftajp,ao {dktvapq {cdntcv`{ c{ ~djj/
Kg`dv{ ~gvh ao ucav{ gv ckptcj uvgnvcllaon pc{h{/ Go
pbd {tvckd* coq cppdlup pg ftaj` `a{vtupayd gv lcjakagt{
tokpagocjapq "lcj~cvd! aopg pbd kg`d ~gtj` vdstavd cp jdc{p
p~g udgujd ~gvhaon ao pco`dl/ Ao ckp* dydo pbd kg`aon ucav{
kgtj` ogp {tkkdd` ao `djaydvaon kg`d ~apb dlfd``d` lcj~cvd/
Pbd ldpbg`gjgnq `akpcpd{ pbcp pdcl{ odydv ftaj` coqpbaon
pbcp pchd{ jgondv pbco p~g co` c bcj ~ddh{ "c {uvaop!* ~bakb
kgtj` fd coqpbaon vgl c kgtujd g bto`vd` pg c kgtujd gpbgt{co` jaod{ g kg`d/ Dckb {uvaop aoygjyd{ cp jdc{p god kg`d
vdyad~* `tvaon ~bakb ldlfdv{ g pbd pdcl ~cjh pbvgtnb
dckb gpbdv{ kg`d/ Itokpagocjapq a{ pd{pd` cp pbd do` g dckb
{uvaop cncao{p ydppd` vdstavdldop{ fq c Stcjapq C{{tvcokd
"SC! {udkacja{p c{{anod` pg pbd pdcl/ Pg aopvg`tkd lcj~cvd
aopg co cuujakcpago ao co Cnajd {q{pdl ~gtj` jahdjq vdstavd pbd
kglujakapq g dydvqgod go pbd {tfpdcl* cuuvgralcpdjq gtv pg
danbp ldlfdv{/
C {dkgo` jdydj g {dktvapq a{ cppcaod` `tvaon pbd pd{paon
uvgkd{{/ Dydvq {gp~cvd `dydjguldop gvncoa}cpago `gd{
pd{paon/ Cp Pdjydop* bg~dydv* pba{ a{ ogp c {ducvcpd ckpayapq
cpdv pbd uvg`tkp `dydjguldop a{ kglujdpd/ Pd{paon a{ ftajpaopg pbd `dydjguldop uvgkd{{ vgl vdstavdldop{ ycja`cpago
pg toap pd{paon gv dckb {uvaop pg uvg`tkpago pd{paon gv dckb
{gp~cvd vdjdc{d/ Gokd `tvaon dckb vdjdc{d kqkjd* dckb
uvgmdkp pdcl pchd{ c god,`cq fvdch ao pbd kg`aon kqkjd pg
{pvd{{ pd{p/ Pba{ drdvka{d* kcjjd` [^CP "[gp~cvd ^apb C jgp
g Pd{pdv{!* pchd{ ujckd cp c hog~o `cpd uvagv pg vdjdc{d co`
a{ co cjj,bco`{,go,`dkh drdvka{d ao ~bakb cjj uvgnvclldv{
{pgu kg`aon co` {pcvp pd{paon* jgghaon ogp gojq gv stcjapq ftn{
ftp {dktvapq a{{td{= bgjd{* ujckd{ ao pbd kg`d ~apb c {aonjd
{ano,go* bcv`,kg`d` ucpb{* jdnckq uvgpgkgj{* coqpbaon pbcp
kvdcpd{ gv aokvdc{d{ pbd pbvdcp {tvckd/ Pbd vd~cv`{ cvd
ndcvd` pg~cv` o`aon co` jdcvoaon vgl la{pchd{* co` pbdvd
cvd uva}d{ gv pbg{d ~bg o` pbd lg{p ftn{ co` pbd lg{p{anoakcop {dktvapq pbvdcp{/
Fdqgo` btlco pd{paon* Pdjydop t{d{ lckbaod,fc{d`
ctpglcpd` pd{paon {kvaup{ gv banbjq kglujdr {kdocvag
pd{paon* c{ ~djj c{ gv vdnvd{{ago pd{paon/ Ctpglcpd` pd{paon
a{ ucvpaktjcvjq ycjtcfjd ~bdo t{d` pg dycjtcpd pbd aluckp
g od~jq vdjdc{d` kg`d go jdnckq cuujakcpago{/ Lckbaod,
fc{d` pd{paon kco {altjcpd ltjpa,t{dv kgo`apago{ co`
banbjq vdudpapayd pc{h{/ ^bajd ogp {udkakcjjq cfjd pg {oa gv
lcj~cvd* ctpglcpd` pd{p {kvaup{ kco `a{kgydv tokpagocj
coglcjad{ fc{d` go vdudpapayd t{d kgo`apago{ pbcp kco fd
fc{d pvanndv{ gv lcj~cvd* {tkb c{ Pvgmco bgv{d{ gv gpbdv
hao`{ g `a{vtupayd tokpago{/
Pdjydop= [dktvd Aopdvgudvcfajap
[lcvp nva` pdkbogjgnq ap{dj a{ gpdo {ddo c{ c ugpdopacj
{dktvapq uvgfjdl fdkct{d ap gudo{ tpajapq nva`{ pg lcoq
ugpdopacj udodpvcpago ugaop{* aokjt`aon pbd Aopdvodp/ C
{lcvpdv nva` ~ajj vdstavd aopdnvcpago clgon {q{pdl{ pbcp
bcyd pvc`apagocjjq fddo a{gjcpd`* tvpbdv drpdo`aon pbd
pbvdcp {tvckd/ Ftp cuujakcpago g {pco`cv`a}cpago co`
aopdvgudvcfajapq uvaokaujd{ kgtj` aokvdc{d pbd {dktvapq g pbd
{lcvp nva`/ [pco`cv` cvkbapdkptvcj ucppdvo{ co` {pco`cv`
aopdnvcpago pdkboastd{ lchd ap ug{{afjd pg kvdcpd nvdcp
dkadokad{* ftp cj{g docfjd gudvcpgv{ pg a`dopaq coglcjad{
lgvd dc{ajq/
Pdjydop c`bdvd{ pg hdq cvkbapdkptvcj uvaokaujd{ pbcp docfjd
pbd kglucoq pg `d{ano ao* vcpbdv pbco c`` go* {dktvapq/
Fq c`gupaon c {pco`cv` vddvdokd cvkbapdkptvd* {tkb c{
Lakvg{gp{ [lcvp Dodvnq Vddvdokd Cvkbapdkptvd* ydo`gv{
kco do{tvd pbcp pbd aopdnvcpd` doyavgoldop a{ ftajp tugo
c gto`cpago pbcp bc{ fddo `d{anod` ~apb kqfdv{dktvapq c{
c hdq vdstavdldop/ Itvpbdv* {pakhaon pg ao`t{pvq aopdnvcpago
{pco`cv`{* {tkb c{ pbd Kgllgo Aogvlcpago Lg`dj* cjjg~{
gv uvd`akpcfjd aopdnvcpago ~apb {q{pdl{ co` `dyakd{ fdqgo`
pbg{d `djaydvd` fq c {aonjd ydo`gv/ [pco`cv` aopdnvcpago
uvckpakd{ vd`tkd kt{pgla}d` kg`d* c hdq cajtvd ugaop co` c
kvapakcj guugvptoapq gv kqfdv pbvdcp/ Iaocjjq* {gja` cvkbapdkptvd
cjjg~{ gv pbd {pvcanbpgv~cv` dlfd``aon g aopvt{ago co`
lcj~cvd `dpdkpago co` pcludv,uvggon pggj{ pbcp cvd ftajp pg
uvgya`d aopdvocj {dktvapq/
Pbd lg{p {dktvd {gp~cvd uvg`tkp{ lt{p dydoptcjjq jdcyd
pbd `dydjguldop {bgu co` fd alujdldopd` ao pbd vdcj ~gvj`
g nva` lg`dvoa}cpago/ Alujdldopcpago ldco{ pbcp nva`
lcocndldop {gp~cvd lt{p pgtkb co` fd pgtkbd` fq jdnckq
{q{pdl{ co` drpdvocj `dyakd{ ~apb ycvqaon jdydj{ g {dktvapq
`d{ano co` lcocndldop pggj{/ Fq c`gupaon c {pco`cv`
cvkbapdkptvd co` t{aon {pco`cv` aopdnvcpago pdkboastd{* pbd
pbvdcp {tvckd vgl pbd{d drpdvocj ckpgv{ a{ {anoakcopjq
vd`tkd`/
FD[P UVCKPAKD[ AO CKPAGO
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
32/36;5 T/[/ Vd{ajadokd Uvgmdkp
[tuujq Kbcao [gjtpago{ igv [lcvp Nva` [dktvapq= Ftaj`aon go Ft{aod{{ Fd{p Uvckpakd{
^gvh{bgu Ucvpakaucop{
Mgo Cla{[tuujq Kbcao Va{h UvgnvclLcocndv* @djj
[bcvjc Cvp}@avdkpgv g [dktvapq' Dodvnq Ugjakq
[kb~dap}dv Donaoddvaon Jcfgvcpgvad{
Md{{akc C{kgtnbC`ycokd` Uvgnvcl{ Donaoddv
Bcvva{ Kgvugvcpago
Ubajau Ctdv{~cj`C{{gkacpd Uvgd{{gv
Ndgvnd Lc{go Toaydv{apq
@cya` Fcp}Lcocndv* Kqfdv ) Aovc{pvtkptvd
[dktvapq D`a{go Djdkpvak Ao{paptpd
Hdo FdakbodvYakd Uvd{a`dop* [tuujq KbcaoDj{pdv [gjtpago{
C`cl Fa{bguLcocndv* AP [dktvapq*
OVN Dodvnq* Aok/
Mgo Fgdo{AP [udkacja{p* Kglutpdv [dktvapq @aya{ago
Ocpagocj Ao{paptpd g [pco`cv`{ co` Pdkbogjgnq
Kbva{pgubdv FgdvC{{a{pcop Yakd Uvd{a`dop gv Utfjak Ugjakq
CP)P
[co`gv Fg{goVd{dcvkb Uvgd{{gv ) Kg,@avdkpgv* [tuujq Kbcao
Lcocndldop Kdopdv Vgfdvp B/ [lapb [kbggj g Ft{aod{{
Toaydv{apq g Lcvqjco`
Mcld{ FvdopgoUvaokaucj* Vdnagocj [dktvapq Kggv`aocpgv
Djdkpvak Vdjacfajapq Kgtokaj g Pdrc{
[pck Fvd{jdvYakd Uvd{a`dop* Gtpvdckb ) Gudvcpago{
Dodvnq[dk
Mcld{ Fvagod{Uvgmdkp Lcocndv* Dodvnq [q{pdl{ [dktvapq* ODPJT/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq
Jcvv Kgjjao{Yakd Uvd{a`dop D,[gjtpago{
]tvakb Iaocokacj [dvyakd{
D`oc Kgo~cKbad [dktvapq [pvcpdna{p* Ycjtd Kbcao
Ka{kg [q{pdl{* Aok/
Mgkd Kgvdjj@avdkpgv* Cksta{apago Va{h @avdkpgvcpdGkd g pbd @avdkpgv g Ocpagocj Aopdjjandokd
Yakha Kgt{aogCocjq{p* Cksta{apago Va{h @avdkpgvcpd
Gkd g pbd @avdkpgv g Ocpagocj Aopdjjandokd
Mdidv @cnjdKbad Djdkpvakcj Donaoddv* C`ycokd` Ug~dv ) Dodvnq[q{pdl{
Uckak Ogvpb~d{p Ocpagocj Jcfgvcpgvq
Lakbcdj @cya`Cocjq{p* Cksta{apago Va{h @avdkpgvcpd
Gkd g pbd @avdkpgv g Ocpagocj Aopdjjandokd
@go @cya`{goKbad* Gtpvdckb* [kadokd ) [pco`cv`{Pvt{pd` La{{ago [q{pdl{ ) Odp~gvh{ Gkd
T/[/ @ducvpldop g @ddo{d
Uctj @cya{Kbad Pdkbogjgnq Gkdv
OMYK
A`g @tfvc~{h[doagv Uvaokaucj [q{pdl{ Donaoddv* [dktvapq DonaoddvaonPdcl Jdc` Apvgo
Vbgo`c @toddKgopvgj [q{pdl{ [dktvapq
T/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq
Hdyao Dondv@avdkpgv* [tuujadv La{{ago C{{tvcokd
Ogvpbvgu Nvtllco Aogvlcpago [q{pdl{
D`~cv` Dvakh{goYakd Uvd{a`dop
AopvcUgaop
[ptcvp IdvdokKbad* Kvapakcj Lcotckptvaon [dkpgv [[C
T/[/ @ducvpldop g Bgldjco` [dktvapq
Ncv Iaokg[doagv C`ya{gvq DonaoddvA`cbg Ocpagocj Jcfgvcpgvq
Lakbcdj Ncjjt}}a[tuujq Kbcao Lcocndv
T/[/ Ocpagocj Cdvgoctpak{ co` [uckd C`laoa{pvcpago
Mg{b NdvfdvJdc` Cvkbapdkp* [lcvp Nva`
[dluvc Dodvnq
Fajj Njoo@avdkpgv* Aogvlcpago [dktvapq
^d{pcv Dodvnq* Aok/
D`~ao NgiDopdvuva{d Cvkbapdkp* AP)P [dktvapqUvgnvd{{ Dodvnq
D`~cv` NvcYakd Uvd{a`dop* Jdna{jcpayd ) Vdntjcpgvq Ccav{Dj{pdv [gjtpago{
Kcvgj Bc~hUvgnvcl Lcocndv* Kqfdv{dktvapq gv Dodvnq @djaydvq
[q{pdl{ T/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq
@cvvdjj BanbjjIgto`dv ) Lcocnaon Ucvpodv
Tpaja[dk
Ucpvakac BgilcoC{{a{pcop [dkvdpcvqT/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq
Vgfdvp Btpkbao{go[doagv Lcocndv* Aogvlcpago [kadokd{ Nvgtu
[co`ac Ocpagocj Jcfgvcpgvad{
Vakh Hcbjd [v/Kcpdngvq Lcocndv* Ldpdv{ co` CLA Pdkbogjgnq*
Drdjgo
Bdov Hdokbaonpgo@dutpq C{{a{pcop [dkvdpcvq gv Vd{dcvkb ) @dydjguldop
T/[/ @ducvpldop g Dodvnq
Balco{bt HbtvcocCkpaon @avdkpgv gv Njgfcj Pdkbogjgnq* Hog~jd`nd [q{pdl{
Jcfgvcpgvq
Bgodq~djj
Hdoodpb Hgoan{lcvh[doagv Lcocndv* [tuujq Kbcao ) Cyacpago [dktvapq
Kglujacokd
Fgdaon
Pbdvd{c Jcon@avdkpgv* Id`dvcj [dktvapq
@djj
^cod JgonkgvdKbad Dodvnq [gjtpago{ Drudvp
[CU
Pvg LcppdvoLajapcvq Drdktpayd C{{a{pcop pg pbd @dutpq Kgllco`dv* T/
Kqfdv Kgllco`
T/[/ @ducvpldop g @ddo{d
Mg{b LcnvaC{{gkacpd Yakd Uvd{a`dop
Aopdvodp [dktvapq Cjjacokd
Vdnaocj` LkKctjd@avdkpgv* [tuujq Kbcao
Udukg Bgj`aon{* Aok/
Mcld{ LkKgoodjj@avdkpgv g [dktvapqYdva}go
Mdivd Lddv{@avdkpgv g [lcvp Nva` [cjd{
Pdjydop
Ct{pao Lgopngldv[lcvp Nva` Uvgnvcl Jdc`
[gp~cvd Donaoddvaon Ao{paptpd*Kcvodnad Ldjjgo Toaydv{apq
Mcld{ Lgvg}}aUvd{a`dop ) Kbad Drdktpayd Gkdv
Nva`^a{d Cjjacokd
Ocfaj Oc{vC{{a{pcop Uvgyg{p ) @avdkpgv
Ngja{cog Ao{paptpd g [t{pcaocfajapqVgkbd{pdv Ao{paptpd g Pdkbogjgnq
-
7/30/2019 Supply Chain Solutions for Smart Grid Security
33/36 ;~~~/t{vd{ajadokduvgmdkp/gvn
^gvh{bgu Ucvpakauco
@cya` GjaydUvaokaucjKcpcjq{p Ucvpodv{
Lahd Ubajjau{Kgvugvcpd Aogvlcpago [dktvapq @avdkpgv
KdopdvUgaop Dodvnq
[pck Uvg~djjKbad