Transcript
Page 1: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

SKA and the Cradle of LifeFormation of Planets and Search for Extraterrestrial Life

Marc Audard (U of Geneva)Swiss SKA days, June 21, 2019

Slides from I. Jimenez-Serra & D. Johnstone with a personal flavour

Page 2: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

SKA Big Questions

SKA Cradle of Life

• TheCradleofLife&Astrobiology– Howdoplanetsform?Arewealone?

• Strong-fieldTestsofGravitywithPulsarsandBlackHoles– WasEinsteinrightwithGeneralRelativity?

• TheOriginandEvolutionofCosmicMagnetism– Whatistheroleofmagnetismingalaxyevolutionandthe

structureofthecosmicweb?• GalaxyEvolutionprobedbyNeutralHydrogen

– Howdonormalgalaxiesformandgrow?• TheTransientRadioSky

– WhatareFastRadioBursts?Whathaven’twediscovered?• GalaxyEvolutionprobedintheRadioContinuum

– Whatisthestar-formationhistoryofnormalgalaxies?• Cosmology&DarkEnergy

– Whatisdarkmatter?Whatisthelarge-scalestructureoftheUniverse?

• CosmicDawnandtheEpochofReionization– Howandwhendidthefirststarsandgalaxiesform?

Page 3: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Science Themes

1) How do rocky planets form?2) How did life originate?

3) What are exoplanets like?

4) SETI project

Page 4: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formation of rocky cores of planets via grain growth and settling

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 4

Ned Wright - UCLA

Hope Ishii - UH

Page 5: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formation of rocky cores of planets via grain growth and settling

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 5

Testi et al. 2014 Hoare et al. 2015

SKA covers the right λ’s to probe cm-sized grainsmatching beams of

40 mas≈4 au radius of snow line at 100pc

à measure strength and and spectral index

Opacity curve

SKA1-MID

Page 6: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Flattening of the spectral index has been observed in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 6

AS209 Dust traps help overcome grain growth barriers è‘spiral density waves’

van der Marel et al. (2016)

Perez et al. 2012, 2015; Tazzari et al. 2016

Page 7: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 7

SPH simulationGravitationally Unstable Disk

(Run2 from Hall+2017)

Mdisk=0.25 MoM*=1 Mo

50 au

t = 4100 yrs

George

Ringo

Column Density N(H2) (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)

Page 8: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 8

40 mas beam@12 GHz

SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes)

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeSPH simulation

Gravitationally Unstable Disk (Run2 from Hall+2017)

Mdisk=0.25 MoM*=1 Mo

distance = 100 pc

1000 hr integration

Peak= 19 µJy/beam (Tb=115 K) Noise= 0.07 µJy/beam (Tb=0.4 K) 50 au

Witnessing the formation of planets

Page 9: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 9

@12 GHz

SKA-Mid

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeALMA 1.3 mm

MAPPING OF β ACROSS THE SNOW LINE OF WATER

40 mas beam

50 auTobin+2016

Page 10: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 10

@12 GHz

SKA-Mid

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeALMA 1.3 mm

MAPPING OF β ACROSS THE SNOW LINE OF WATER

40 mas beam

50 auDSHARP (Andrews+ 2018)

Intermediate to high optical depths at mm

Page 11: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• From the ISM to the Origin of Life

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 11

35 mas x 40 mas beam

Planetary systems

Protoplanetary disks

Complex Organics (COMs)

How complex can organic chemistry become in the ISM and disc?Pre-biotic species!!

?Molecular clouds(Pre-stellar Cores)

Page 12: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Complex Organic Molecules (COMs) … in Space

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 12

COMs are carbon-based compounds with >6 atoms (Herbst & van Dishoeck 2009)

Page 13: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Complex Organic Molecules (COMs) … in Space

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 13

Glycolaldehyde(CH2OHCHO)

Amino Acetonitrile(NH2CH2CN)

Prebiotic COMs: species believed to be involved in the processes leading to the origin of life

Formamide(NH2CHO)

Simplest naturally occurring amide containing all elements needed for the synthesis of bio-molecules (Saladino+12,15)

Page 14: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formamide undetected in discs: SKA will be a pre-biotic COM detector

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 14

50 au

Simulations of NH2CHO (gas & solid) in the disk

SPH simulation (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)+

chemistry of NH2CHO (Quenard+2018a)

Gas-phase NH2CHO (Quenard+2018b)

Page 15: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formamide undetected in disks: SKA as a pre-biotic COM detector

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 15

Simulations of NH2CHO (gas & solid) in the disk

SPH simulation (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)+

chemistry of NH2CHO (Quenard+2018a)

distance = 100 pc1000 hr integration

Peak= 87 μJy/beam (Tb=530 K) Noise= 7 μJy/beam (Tb= 40 K)

t = 4100 yrsGas-phase NH2CHO with SKA1

40 mas beam

50 au

NH2CHO transition at 13.489 GHz

Credit: D. Q

uenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee

Page 16: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Detection of pre-biotic COMs will be challenging

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 16

Problems:• High spectral line densities at mm/sub-mm l’s Þ Line blending/confusion!!• Broad linewidths (a few to some km s-1) Þ Line identification problematic

interferometry reduces linewidths

cm l’s are cleanerSKA

Belloche+2013Rest Frequency (MHz)

SgrB2(N) & SgrB2(M)

Tmb

(K)

Page 17: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres– Magnetospheres may be key for habitability of planets …

• Low-frequency (~50 MHz) bursts seen from Jovian planets– Cyclotron-Maser Instability Emission (CMI) --- see also activity in brown dwarfs!

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 17

SKA1-LOW

Page 18: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 18

Zarka et al. 2015

Earth’s ionospheric cutoff

metric-decimetric synchrotron

CMI, auroral, Io-induced

Page 19: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 19

Zarka et al. 2015

What can we learn??

® Magnetic field strength : planet interior structure® Tilt of magnetic axis® Rotation and revolution periods® Orbit inclination® Stellar wind activity® Presence of exo-moons?

Page 20: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 20

SKA1-LOW, sensitivity improved by a factor ~8

Jupiter-like planet could be detected to ~10 pc

~200 known stars and ~35 known

exo-planets within this volume !

Zarka et al. 2015

Max emission frequency

Page 21: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Searching for Extraterrestrial Life

SKA Cradle of Life 21

Page 22: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Known Technology Detection Limits …

Searching for Extraterrestrial Life

SKA Cradle of Life 22

Siemion et al. 2015(tintegration = 60 min, SNR = 12)

§ SKA1: high-power airport radars detectable for >104 stars

§ SKA2: low-power TV and radio stations detectable for a fewnearest stars

Volume-limited search

Long range Aircraft Radar 1017 erg/s

High power TV and radio5x1012 erg/s

Page 23: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Key Science Projects

SKA Cradle of Life 23

KSP 1) Young Stellar Cluster Deep Field – Mapping β across snow lines

² Oph A star-forming cluster : 2/3 Class 0, 7 Class I, 12 Class II² 1000 hours in SKA1-Mid (Band 5, @12 GHz)² Angular resolution ~ 40 mas, i.e. 5 au at 125 pc

² Additional Science: Pre-biotic COMs, Jets, 6D Tomography, Magnetic Flaring

KSP 2) Stars, Planets and Civilizations

² Key Obs # 1 (SKA1-LOW): All sources within 25 pc è 2500 hours

² Key Obs # 2 (SKA1-LOW): Selected sample (>25 pc) è 1500 hours

² Key Ob # 3 (SKA1-LOW): Search for low Galactic latitudes è 833 hours

² High commensality with SWGs “Our Galaxy”, “Epoch of Reionization”, “Cosmology” and “Transients”

Page 24: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

The Cradle of Life Working Group

+ 33 associate members from 15 countries

Page 25: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Science Themes

1) How do rocky planets form?2) How did life originate?

3) What are exoplanets like?

4) SETI project

Page 26: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Top Related