ska cradle of life - École polytechnique fédérale de ...€¦ · ska cradle of life 8 @12 ghz 40...

26
SKA and the Cradle of Life Formation of Planets and Search for Extraterrestrial Life Marc Audard (U of Geneva) Swiss SKA days, June 21, 2019 Slides from I. Jimenez-Serra & D. Johnstone with a personal flavour

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

SKA and the Cradle of LifeFormation of Planets and Search for Extraterrestrial Life

Marc Audard (U of Geneva)Swiss SKA days, June 21, 2019

Slides from I. Jimenez-Serra & D. Johnstone with a personal flavour

Page 2: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

SKA Big Questions

SKA Cradle of Life

• TheCradleofLife&Astrobiology– Howdoplanetsform?Arewealone?

• Strong-fieldTestsofGravitywithPulsarsandBlackHoles– WasEinsteinrightwithGeneralRelativity?

• TheOriginandEvolutionofCosmicMagnetism– Whatistheroleofmagnetismingalaxyevolutionandthe

structureofthecosmicweb?• GalaxyEvolutionprobedbyNeutralHydrogen

– Howdonormalgalaxiesformandgrow?• TheTransientRadioSky

– WhatareFastRadioBursts?Whathaven’twediscovered?• GalaxyEvolutionprobedintheRadioContinuum

– Whatisthestar-formationhistoryofnormalgalaxies?• Cosmology&DarkEnergy

– Whatisdarkmatter?Whatisthelarge-scalestructureoftheUniverse?

• CosmicDawnandtheEpochofReionization– Howandwhendidthefirststarsandgalaxiesform?

Page 3: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Science Themes

1) How do rocky planets form?2) How did life originate?

3) What are exoplanets like?

4) SETI project

Page 4: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formation of rocky cores of planets via grain growth and settling

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 4

Ned Wright - UCLA

Hope Ishii - UH

Page 5: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formation of rocky cores of planets via grain growth and settling

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 5

Testi et al. 2014 Hoare et al. 2015

SKA covers the right λ’s to probe cm-sized grainsmatching beams of

40 mas≈4 au radius of snow line at 100pc

à measure strength and and spectral index

Opacity curve

SKA1-MID

Page 6: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Flattening of the spectral index has been observed in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 6

AS209 Dust traps help overcome grain growth barriers è‘spiral density waves’

van der Marel et al. (2016)

Perez et al. 2012, 2015; Tazzari et al. 2016

Page 7: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 7

SPH simulationGravitationally Unstable Disk

(Run2 from Hall+2017)

Mdisk=0.25 MoM*=1 Mo

50 au

t = 4100 yrs

George

Ringo

Column Density N(H2) (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)

Page 8: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 8

40 mas beam@12 GHz

SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes)

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeSPH simulation

Gravitationally Unstable Disk (Run2 from Hall+2017)

Mdisk=0.25 MoM*=1 Mo

distance = 100 pc

1000 hr integration

Peak= 19 µJy/beam (Tb=115 K) Noise= 0.07 µJy/beam (Tb=0.4 K) 50 au

Witnessing the formation of planets

Page 9: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 9

@12 GHz

SKA-Mid

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeALMA 1.3 mm

MAPPING OF β ACROSS THE SNOW LINE OF WATER

40 mas beam

50 auTobin+2016

Page 10: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Using SKA to observe continuum emission for dust in discs

How Do Rocky Planets Form?

SKA Cradle of Life 10

@12 GHz

SKA-Mid

Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. IleeALMA 1.3 mm

MAPPING OF β ACROSS THE SNOW LINE OF WATER

40 mas beam

50 auDSHARP (Andrews+ 2018)

Intermediate to high optical depths at mm

Page 11: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• From the ISM to the Origin of Life

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 11

35 mas x 40 mas beam

Planetary systems

Protoplanetary disks

Complex Organics (COMs)

How complex can organic chemistry become in the ISM and disc?Pre-biotic species!!

?Molecular clouds(Pre-stellar Cores)

Page 12: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Complex Organic Molecules (COMs) … in Space

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 12

COMs are carbon-based compounds with >6 atoms (Herbst & van Dishoeck 2009)

Page 13: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Complex Organic Molecules (COMs) … in Space

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 13

Glycolaldehyde(CH2OHCHO)

Amino Acetonitrile(NH2CH2CN)

Prebiotic COMs: species believed to be involved in the processes leading to the origin of life

Formamide(NH2CHO)

Simplest naturally occurring amide containing all elements needed for the synthesis of bio-molecules (Saladino+12,15)

Page 14: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formamide undetected in discs: SKA will be a pre-biotic COM detector

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 14

50 au

Simulations of NH2CHO (gas & solid) in the disk

SPH simulation (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)+

chemistry of NH2CHO (Quenard+2018a)

Gas-phase NH2CHO (Quenard+2018b)

Page 15: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Formamide undetected in disks: SKA as a pre-biotic COM detector

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 15

Simulations of NH2CHO (gas & solid) in the disk

SPH simulation (Hall+2017; Ilee+2007)+

chemistry of NH2CHO (Quenard+2018a)

distance = 100 pc1000 hr integration

Peak= 87 μJy/beam (Tb=530 K) Noise= 7 μJy/beam (Tb= 40 K)

t = 4100 yrsGas-phase NH2CHO with SKA1

40 mas beam

50 au

NH2CHO transition at 13.489 GHz

Credit: D. Q

uenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee

Page 16: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Detection of pre-biotic COMs will be challenging

How Did Life Originate?

SKA Cradle of Life 16

Problems:• High spectral line densities at mm/sub-mm l’s Þ Line blending/confusion!!• Broad linewidths (a few to some km s-1) Þ Line identification problematic

interferometry reduces linewidths

cm l’s are cleanerSKA

Belloche+2013Rest Frequency (MHz)

SgrB2(N) & SgrB2(M)

Tmb

(K)

Page 17: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres– Magnetospheres may be key for habitability of planets …

• Low-frequency (~50 MHz) bursts seen from Jovian planets– Cyclotron-Maser Instability Emission (CMI) --- see also activity in brown dwarfs!

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 17

SKA1-LOW

Page 18: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 18

Zarka et al. 2015

Earth’s ionospheric cutoff

metric-decimetric synchrotron

CMI, auroral, Io-induced

Page 19: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 19

Zarka et al. 2015

What can we learn??

® Magnetic field strength : planet interior structure® Tilt of magnetic axis® Rotation and revolution periods® Orbit inclination® Stellar wind activity® Presence of exo-moons?

Page 20: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Planet dynamos è large-scale Bmag è magnetospheres

What are Exoplanets like?

SKA Cradle of Life 20

SKA1-LOW, sensitivity improved by a factor ~8

Jupiter-like planet could be detected to ~10 pc

~200 known stars and ~35 known

exo-planets within this volume !

Zarka et al. 2015

Max emission frequency

Page 21: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Searching for Extraterrestrial Life

SKA Cradle of Life 21

Page 22: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

• Known Technology Detection Limits …

Searching for Extraterrestrial Life

SKA Cradle of Life 22

Siemion et al. 2015(tintegration = 60 min, SNR = 12)

§ SKA1: high-power airport radars detectable for >104 stars

§ SKA2: low-power TV and radio stations detectable for a fewnearest stars

Volume-limited search

Long range Aircraft Radar 1017 erg/s

High power TV and radio5x1012 erg/s

Page 23: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Key Science Projects

SKA Cradle of Life 23

KSP 1) Young Stellar Cluster Deep Field – Mapping β across snow lines

² Oph A star-forming cluster : 2/3 Class 0, 7 Class I, 12 Class II² 1000 hours in SKA1-Mid (Band 5, @12 GHz)² Angular resolution ~ 40 mas, i.e. 5 au at 125 pc

² Additional Science: Pre-biotic COMs, Jets, 6D Tomography, Magnetic Flaring

KSP 2) Stars, Planets and Civilizations

² Key Obs # 1 (SKA1-LOW): All sources within 25 pc è 2500 hours

² Key Obs # 2 (SKA1-LOW): Selected sample (>25 pc) è 1500 hours

² Key Ob # 3 (SKA1-LOW): Search for low Galactic latitudes è 833 hours

² High commensality with SWGs “Our Galaxy”, “Epoch of Reionization”, “Cosmology” and “Transients”

Page 24: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

The Cradle of Life Working Group

+ 33 associate members from 15 countries

Page 25: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation

Cradle of Life Science Themes

1) How do rocky planets form?2) How did life originate?

3) What are exoplanets like?

4) SETI project

Page 26: SKA Cradle of Life - École Polytechnique Fédérale de ...€¦ · SKA Cradle of Life 8 @12 GHz 40 mas beam SKA-Mid Band 5 (64 dishes) Credit: D. Quenard, C. Hall, J. Ilee SPH simulation