-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
1/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
2/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
3/122
Rolutions In Rrs
DavID GRaebeR
O
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
4/122
Rvun n Rv: Ey n P, Vn, A, ndInnD G
ISBN 978-1-577-43-1
C H SzI M Kj
R M C, L / N Y / P WM C & , - , .
M C A.. | @.
D APO Bx 568 W SB, NY 1111
P/x: 718-963-568.. @.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
5/122
ContntsIntroduction 1
Th Shock o victory 11
Hop in Common 31
Rolution in Rrs 41
army o altruists 67
Th Sdnss o Post-workrism 79
aginst Kmikz Cpitlism 107
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
6/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
7/122
Introductionhe editors have asked me, not unreasonably, to pro-
x -. I q . A, G, , , (Mvn, Vn, A nd Rvun.A: B P P, 9), , , S K. W I G M 1 I
; ; , I , G , , -, D 9.
S ?I , , x -
. A 4 1. T -, , . B 1998 , j .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
8/122
2 | David Graeber
T 9/11 . F ; , , ,
, , , - . F , I 4 US , G W. B . A , 9/11, W W I: 188 1914
q B W: j , , -, , , - . T
, - , , , j ( ) . I , 9/11, ; , - , z -
, - I , , x- , , q- x. I . Y , A j. W, I - G8, G, C
C , , - - (, , !), , , . I , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
9/122
Introduction | 3
, . B
. , z .
I , 7, G-8 J, J - , . I , M N I
. (E, x- , .) I - - . P :
. A , .W ? H ?
O , .T -
. T , , , . N - 8, -. B x. T x 4 8
q- q . I .
O
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
10/122
4 | David Graeber
T . I . I , ,
, , , , , - , , , .
T , j
; , , .I , , Te Shock
of Victory, x . M j , I , . W x zz , - , x-
, , , -, , A , j . T , , . M q - j
, IMF WO q. T z , - , - ! ,
q, Tuun z - , W ? B x , (
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
11/122
Introduction | 5
) z -, , .
Hope in Common . W z , -, ? P .N - , M T -
198, . I , , j, , , , - . R, ,
j z, , . (I - q q, C W, S U . O, , . A . B ,
, - , , - j , x . I , S U x, 7 , R j .)
A
C W, - , - . B j :
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
12/122
6 | David Graeber
j , j, - , -z j
. B , , , x- x .
T , Revolution in Reverse, . I . T - Nw L Rvw, -
; , , j ( Nw L Rvw, , - .) T - I , q , E- - ; G, I, F. (O
, , .)W,
, I . T D A N -- , : W TR? F 19 , US G
, , ; , . W, , ? A , , - , - , - , q ,
. I , . I, - -, ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
13/122
Introduction | 7
, , -
, , , . T z S, P, G, G, C S K, . U , , j - , , .
T x , . E - . I - , Army of Altruists. T .I W, N 4, 4 G W. B P USA, , , . A I
A C S T Y - Mx W . N . I, - z : , , , ? D T -
j , , , ?A , ? W ( US , C Mx,
N L U US J). B q ; . I , , - . I , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
14/122
8 | David Graeber
, , - , -
U C I , , I -, .T , I , j . WI , 1, I . N , I U--C- z . C -
?W, I q
. T . W - j N A , , , ,
. T - , , j- q, , , , , ,, x . T ( !) , , ,
- US , . O . T , , j . I ,
, - , .T Sadness of Postworkerism
- : 6 ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
15/122
Introduction | 9
L M 6. T - -
, .A, , , , x . M , , 7 I E-
, . S q -W , , , , x , ,
, - , . U, , , , ; , -
.T , Against Kamakaze Capitalism,
G ; ; q , , 1. B I . M q , q . H, ,
x q: , , F O 1. M x
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
16/122
10 | David Graeber
, , , 6, -
S 1999 . T - ( , / , ), j x , ,
x. A j , - , , , x , . A .
T . I - , , , - .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
17/122
Th Shock o victoryThe biggest problem facig irect actio moemets is
w dn knw w nd vy.T
. M j : , -, , z . T - S 11, 1 , ,
, z. T , , j . N .
I . L :
1) O , . T ,
A , . I x- z,
B
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
18/122
12 | David Graeber
, - .
) I j. M - z . O A, : - 7, -z 1999-1.1 I , q
.
3) T .W . I -. W . T - . T -
z . A , , .
L x :
I: Th anti-Nuclr Momnthe anti-nuclear movement 7 N A z: , , , , j , z . I
1 I x 5 ,
C R , SNCC (SN-V C C)
- -. I
, x, ,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
19/122
he Shock o Victory | 13
, , - , G- -
. F , z - . T q, .
I , 1974, - N E M, M.I 1976, j N E ,
- G, C A. C S, NH. W - -, j , , , - z - q
. S : P S C,O M, S K, , A A C, D C, - j .
C , 1976 1977, . B q
. I M 1978, CC - - S ( x - ). A - , x - ( , , ),
, , . B 1979 , , , , S ( ) . T A A , 1985, -,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
20/122
14 | David Graeber
, D C D 1988.
, .
B . W : ?
I :
1) Short-erm Goals: - q (S, D C)
) Medium-erm Goals:
, z , - -
3) Long-erm Goals: ( )
I . S- . D (, - , j) . G .L- . B - - . T z
T M I 1979, . W S D C , j - , q . T -, , z z- q. A q
.I , q .R . A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
21/122
he Shock o Victory | 15
, j- . O -
, NGO , - j . E .
T .I , , - , -
, . T - . - q . A j. L , I , j. Cq, -
- -. A - , . T - .
T , I q . E , . M z A G 11. T US , - . I , z . T
, , . T .I - j nd
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
22/122
16 | David Graeber
V; - nd CW, S W x A
C A; j W nd G W . A SDS z - -; - z ; z DAN PGA - z ANSWER UFPJ. G,
. T , V ( , G W -.)T - A . B - , -
. S , , - . F , , . Oz , , - z . T - . W - z
8 C A , , , x .
II: Th Glol justic momntIll assume our -
S, IMF-W B x W A16, .I US, q
. I q - . D A N
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
23/122
he Shock o Victory | 17
j A. W ( S L A DAN) , -, - -, ( N Y
C DAN) , . O - (M, W D.C.) x - A C. T . T - DAN , , , . T : -,
-, , - . T 9/11, , NGO. A z-. B M, 3, , (G, M,H) .
A, . A 9/11. S 11, , , , , . I , z . B j - z
, j, , x, .
M, I j NYC DAN A16. A , DAN j
I,
. I ,
, ,
-
. W I wy -
,
I , ,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
24/122
18 | David Graeber
j. O N A , W C,
, (WO,FAA), z IMF. T ( --) : z, -, , - z q. A -, x
x , . T -; DAN j . W , x , . O , , .
A , .O, . B -
, , q. q z. W - , - , - , -
Mx z S M D - . T . B . A, . T W . S , S . M, I q . C
, . (F - , A, z.) I
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
25/122
he Shock o Victory | 19
. T , , -- ,
. G j , CNN N, - -, - x - . A , CNN N , , ,
.U I
j: , , , .
I . A - . B ( z, - )
j , , RR.
L
FREE RADE AGREEMENS. A 1998 , MAI ; FAA, Q C M, . M -
3 FAA M x - . I . B x M - FAA . N , .T US ---
S K P, CAFA, C A, .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
26/122
20 | David Graeber
HE WORLD RADE ORGANIZAION. A ( ) S, z
x P G D, - O L - DAN . F x D . T , , S
, S . S US - , . I J6, P L, WO, D WO
, z x.
HE INERNAIONAL MONEARY FUND ANDWORLD BANK. T z . B8, IMF , z . :
, IMF .3
TW B . B , -.
T , x:
3 T 7. T IMF x
(11) ;
j ,
E U, -
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
27/122
he Shock o Victory | 21
T IMF - . I , , , 5
S, , - . I x , IMF j - , , , - z . S j , j ,
j.T IMF , , : -
. I j ( ) W - ( ). I , S ; IMFj , ,
, x( ) . U C C . I , , IMF . (I , ;
. B , .) T .
W , A .
I 9, A IMF LA z x
. T 1, . T - : , , - , , - Hz ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
28/122
22 | David Graeber
- -. W ,
- . W N K, , 3, , . S . H , , . H A .
A K q . H IMF . H A , - 75 . T -. C C IMF, , . B , IMF . F , A , q
. S ,j IMF A . T , j : IMF , - A j .
S A . A , - . B , Bz A - IMF .W Cz, .I 3, L A IMF $49 . N $694 .4 : 98.6%.F , L A . A . C I
IMF . T K, T, I,M, P . A R. T F
4 T 7.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
29/122
he Shock o Victory | 23
A, ME S ( ). A 8% . I
, IMF . N . W , IMF . T G8 z , - -
. E IMF , - .
T W B, , . B , 6%, 8%, . O B I C , ,
.O,
. I L A, , C I , E , A, B , , z C. T US, -
, Mx C A. W . B . T q dd.
O M, PGA Sz, : , IMF, j x ,
, x , , . E ,, . T A, N K? H
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
30/122
24 | David Graeber
! W -z ? I , z , , -
IMC! O, , , . W, , z P C G S. H ? N j , , , , -z. S
.M, I -
. T -. Y j - , . L :
1) Short-erm Goals:
(IMF, WO, G8, )
) Medium-erm Goals: WC , , z WO, IMF, W B; .
3) Long-erm Goals: ( ) .
H , . A S, , . B - ,
. T , , q. M 1 IMF W B x -
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
31/122
he Shock o Victory | 25
; , , .
B , . T .
H, , q - . NGO, , Mx, j - ; , , , , , , -
, . H, , - .
I , I , Iq, q .B . S 6, V, US
z . B -. E, --. T GW, 1991, x . T - Iq ,- , x , , V-
A , , . T, , x , , - -, , , q,
, , - I. A , .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
32/122
26 | David Graeber
PeRSPeCTIveS (WITH a bRIeF ReTURN TO 30s SPaIN)How, then, to ? I . R I
, .
S, . T x j , I . O , - q, , . W z ,
. x: - S. M , I, . T - - x- , - . T ,
. M , z . T , , - , . T , , j
- ; , , , -- , , , z, . I - , A, :
, , . A , - - , , US ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
33/122
he Shock o Victory | 27
- . Y, - . B
.5
T q. W , j - , ? A , 19 . A , ,
, . T , .
I , : W - S 1937? I z q.W j R
R, , , .B j . T R R R A R E, q . L S , . L
- R G B M. T - . B x? W S -R, - x x ? W
S? H? W , , S -x.
5 A ,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
34/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
35/122
he Shock o Victory | 29
T , . A, , , B
, , x- M B ?M - ; - ; R L , -
S , - S. F z , x - FAI, FAI x , . I , ,
S - C, - . U . T , , , , , x, . F , ,
, - x - , z. I , S .
T x j . T -
, , - . R . I , - , . T
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
36/122
30 | David Graeber
; . - . F - :
? C , , j - x , , ? O . U , - . P
, , - . I . B -, z , , . A, , q .T q x ( )
, .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
37/122
M
Hop in CommonWe seem to have reached an impasse. Capitalism as we
. B , . Oz ; j . T , , x: ( ) - . Y , -j
, ,, x .
T q : H ?I - ?
O
H . I . I - , -
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
38/122
32 | David Graeber
, , , . A
, , ; x- , , . q , , , , , , j-
, . M - , x , . H x, , S U, CW KGB ,
? T j x x . E, ; , , - x x , , , , .
T z x .
I U S j () j . T x z , . A , , .W , , z : , x-
. F ; , q
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
39/122
Hope in Common | 33
, x . F
.A ,
.
O
T . I -
j , - . T 9 , , . I US, , - , : -
, z .I 5 ; 7, - . T , -. T x . C j - . F z x q. N , -
z S 1999 IMF DC , , WO , , MIA F A A , W B -, IMF , . B . T
IMF . O GS, , , , , - . M, . A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
40/122
34 | David Graeber
z , , A -
L A . A I , - .
B . N - , U S, . W ,
- ; (, ; ), - . T - ; , , z. S V, - x E S N, j
, W . B , : - . I 8, , 9/11,
, .
O .
O
W . I j . C,
; , , . I . M . F - , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
41/122
Hope in Common | 35
. C . R . T , ,
, . C, , .
A x S , C - . G, , - -, z j , , ,
. T 3: S U 1% . B - z , - C, - . T ( - , ), ,
x . G, . B .
I j , . I x
, , I ?(T , x.) T B C. T . T -- , ( , ,
x .) T q, , - : R , , . I
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
42/122
36 | David Graeber
z , . B -
, , z x .
C, , . T q - z . C, , j , , . C : , q - .
O
A x . C j - : . E ,
, - j - , . T - , , x ,
.T , G D , x
ny - S U 193 , M A - .
T x j .
I -- . (A S U !) I , z q
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
43/122
Hope in Common | 37
S U, ,
x . A, I , . F . I , H, . I z . B , , , , S U ,
. B - , , .
O
N -
S U. T - , x-, . I , : A S A, A, , -x, ,
. S .I , , . T - x, P A -z -
I, K, C B, , q, , . A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
44/122
38 | David Graeber
x x, . A
, . E x , . W , z.
V , , ,
, , , . . z j, , .
O
O j: .T . I , j . I . F , x. T . D
q . W , x. A . C, , . I z. S , .P
: , , . T j ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
45/122
Hope in Common | 39
. A : , . O ;
, . O . A . W . D. W - . T : , ,
, ?
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
46/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
47/122
Rolution in RrsAll power to the imagination. Be realistic, demand
A x . U x- , , j . R j .
I j, . W ,
, . I q , , . T , -, , , . I x z , ,
- . C - . I , , , - - 196, ? W
G
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
48/122
42 | David Graeber
? W x- , -? T q -
. I I x , q : I x .
H :
1) R L , , -
. T R - , . I L , ( , ) .
) T q - . I x .
3) O -
: x , , - . O z , . A , -
, .
4) O - . I , - q. R
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
49/122
Revolution in Reverse | 43
- , - , -
, z z, , z . T j , ,
L .
Prt I: rlisticFrom early 2000 I D
A N N Y z j - . A, DAN , -, , z , , , . I z I . DAN x
; , - , . T DAN . T , , . W , z . C , , . G . B . U -
( q z ) x- . B , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
50/122
44 | David Graeber
; , , .B DAN
.I . W
j DAN j z ? I , , - : z . I ( )
j , - , , j: , , , , -. T j - - , DAN , ,
.I A, I x . A q z ; , - . Oz x z -. T , ,
, z (, n -). A . , , , , , x, ,, . T j . T
- , z , -, , j .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
51/122
Revolution in Reverse | 45
W , - z , ; .
N . I . W, x, , ? T L , : S , , , . A ; . T . B
, . J G A , , z . I , I R, , , . W z?
C . T - .T K F . F .W - , , , z
. N .T ,
. W , , ,, ( j ) q . C, ,
:
S .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
52/122
46 | David Graeber
P x .
T R- : - , x .
T L, , . O L . M L q . B -
.1 I, I L I (I j .) N, - Mx, - . B Mx , , ,
, , R - P L .Mx , , , , . I q , Mx, ,
. I . A ,
1 H M
, Mx, -
,
, .
B . T , I
, W
: , , - -
j. W j
j ;
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
53/122
Revolution in Reverse | 47
S. S vnd , , ,
. W - , -, . I , , , ,
, j . I , x q- L.
R - : , , x, ,, , . P
, , , - .
O, I . O q. T - Mx x - Mx
. E R , Mx - , . N, I - , q , - . F
, , , q , .L ,
I - :
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
54/122
48 | David Graeber
Prt II: on iolnc nd imginti displcmntIm an anthropologist -
, , .I , .
T . N . A .3 B .I
- wu . O . V - . P , , ,
, . H , . I q .B , - , , . W, , q
( , , ), q . M - , - x , x . T q ; - . T
3 T . A -
.
B ,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
55/122
Revolution in Reverse | 49
- . I : .., I
I . T , , : , , .
T , , q .T -, . I
q , . A . , x, x. I - . O , , , ,
. T . T . I q - , , .
O : q
, , -. A , x . I . S, z , . R, .
L . A
195 , A, j . T j . W . O , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
56/122
50 | David Graeber
. T : - ,
. A, - : , , , , - , , . B V
W : -, , j I . T .W . M .
T
( , ), , x . F , . I US, ,
x. T x : - q; .A x - .
I x. W , -
z , x . L j : , , .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
57/122
Revolution in Reverse | 51
I . W -
. C A S, y M Snn ( 1761), . H, , , , , j . T , , j , , , -, . T
- , , , . T . W , : , , , . Sq - . A , S
, , - , , . I , ( ) .4
I x . O z -
x- . , - , x - -. W , , , q-, . U
4 W I ,
: P H C, D H, S H, N
H. S -
S A-A .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
58/122
52 | David Graeber
: x, .
T , , , - . P . P , , , ( x, - .) S, , , A
, j . I , , - V , , , .
II: xcursus on trnscndnt rsus immnnt imgintiono imaginatively identiy - ( A ). T , - z .
I -
. T A M , z . P , x , - . I . I D, , , ,
: , (ME, N, Gx, K PJ), . B - . T . I
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
59/122
Revolution in Reverse | 53
, .I -
, . I V . T , x. I , I , , . C, -, j , ,
. T q - j, .
O - 68 . I - , x , , . H,
. O , - , n , , q .
T q , , . C -
. P - : , , , . T - j. T - . T : , E
M V H P, x . S, , .I , (..,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
60/122
54 | David Graeber
z ),5 q , x j ( x,
I ).
N - , z , x, , . z . I , , ,
.T , , , - ; , - - . I , I , x
.
Prt III: on lintion
In wn nuy, d n n n . A dd, -nzd, zd n, n
und dy un nd nd dy xud, un d w n nd u n un w n.
Ru Vn,T R E L
Creativity and desire ,
, - . S q , ,
5 I ,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
61/122
Revolution in Reverse | 55
. T - -, , j , -
, , , . I , , CEO , , , -. M q I .6
T j x - .
I , x - , L . I , , F -
S G D R V, , C C. F I zz A , , RV Rvun Evydy L , , P . I I V , , -
x , , x. T , ; ;
x, , 6 I ,
. I , , I
; Mx
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
62/122
56 | David Graeber
, .
T q . C
x. P, - 68, j . I , , - , . S
, -, . , .7 B x?
I , , . A , -? T j, , , . T -
. . B : ? A ?8 I - ,
7 B
j x -
, x, - -
. F ,
:
x ,
, -
.
8 P C R -
-
; ,
; , , I , -
. A,
,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
63/122
Revolution in Reverse | 57
.9 T . O - j -
, , - x, . N, . Tq, , , , j. T,I ,
.
Prt Iv: On Rolutionhe Situationists, like 6 , : S -
. A , , . I M 68 , z , , - . T S - . N . T
: , x , x -. C CI, - S :
W - ,
, , . P -
9 I Twd n
An y Vu.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
64/122
58 | David Graeber
- , , , j
F x
. A . C, , - , .
W : ? T - q , - . H, . M .I . L ,q . B
x , , .
I , , , -z , : , - , . B ,
zz , -, x . I , - , q .
O , , j q. H
, P C, S C W, - ? O, M 68,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
65/122
Revolution in Reverse | 59
/ - ? T x-
, - q. F , - , , . I , , , , ,
. T , , , . T ; z - q z , z ,
. I j .
I , A, x . T -, , -. T ,
A z j , .. I : , , , , , , ,
. A .I , - . W ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
66/122
60 | David Graeber
(), j x - , , .
A -
, , z -. H ; -, , .
A :, , ? F - ,
-, , , - . T , , - . A E, , - , , ;
. F j .I I , , -
, , z , , -. V , , , , . T
. I -z. D -z . T x x . (T , R S - , x .) T x
,, . N q ; x- .N q ;
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
67/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
68/122
62 | David Graeber
, R L I Cv Sun A,
.
Iv: Rolution in Rrshere is a x Mx .G , Mx , , , I , ,
. W , , . T -, , .
T , I , Mx ,
. P I . I q q .
I , , - ; , - -. I A, z . W , 6 7, , , -
- z. R - -, - . T, , Q (
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
69/122
Revolution in Reverse | 63
- ) - . B 7, -
, , .T - . I z j, , , -
. T -- z - , , - , , ---, .
T z -
, x z x , , x . O z, , . T . A , ,
. T , , - , .S , , , -. H, I ,
, z , . M, .
T -. P j
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
70/122
64 | David Graeber
. E , -: , ,
. T , , . W z -, , x . T , , x
, .
O , , . T . F , - . O -
, , , , .T . I . O ; ,
, - x j . I x , - x.
Conclusion
Obviously it is x , , ( ) x- - z
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
71/122
Revolution in Reverse | 65
. O , - , ,
. A , - x , -, x, , x x -, . I , ,
.H z .
T q . M . R , , q ; x-
. T . T . B j -.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
72/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
73/122
army o altruistsYu knw, dun, yu k
, yu udy d, yu d yu wknd yu k n , yu n
d w. I yu dn, yu uk n Iq.
Jn Ky (D-M.)
Ky w n y ny und An vn n Iq, w nwd uny u y nd n
u ny dn n dun.
Jn MCn (R-Az.)
he one leeting moment o hope or Republicans dur- - 6 - j S J K j -
G B K . I . M K P .B . T -
O
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
74/122
68 | David Graeber
K, N R , Iq ( ) -
- W j 4 .
A , , A - .B q :
( K ) ? O : R ?
I , A -, , . W
/: , -- j . I j R. C, j . B q : ?
I q. I
I CLz, B U.S. . M z - , - . T , . W, , ? T
, x : .., Ij ; T j , . PLz
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
75/122
Army o Altruists | 69
. T : - -
. I, - .
C, A - . Q : . T ; ; , . T
x . A - , , . A , , x
zz, - , x . A , A, f , .
I . S , x, : , -. T , , : x 3 f , -
5 - . (A .) M, . I A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
76/122
70 | David Graeber
. .A - , x
; , -: , , , x- - . O j ( x ?) . E - . S, j
x- . P: , - . H ? I ,
: T - .
W A . I, , U S x - . W
- ? C . F - ( : - - ) , , , j, -
AIDS A. W - , ,A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
77/122
Army o Altruists | 71
. S , - . I z.
I , I R
, , L. E, - A . L x I .
PROPOSITION I:
Nithr goism nor ltruism r nturl urgs; thy r in ct ris in rltion toon nothr nd nithr would concil without th mrktFirst o all, I I - .H . R . H, . I , x,
B, C, I. I , H q , , , : Y, , , , . I , , .
E , , - - . W , , , : , , ,- , , , ,, , , j,
, . T j , D z, , , . I x ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
78/122
72 | David Graeber
N G Az . I ,
, , - , , -, . T - .A x , , ,
, , - .
N, - -
. M, , ; G . A , , , . O , , ,
. A , x , - , , .
PROPOSITION II:Th politicl right hs lwys trid to nhnc this diision, nd thus clim to
chmpions o goism nd ltruism simultnously Th lt hs trid to c it
Might this not x U S, - z , -? O, , D - ?
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
79/122
Army o Altruists | 73
W - ,
. I U S, x, R : -, C . A x, R - ( ); , ,
j, , . A ( , ). B - - . O , ; , ,
, . A , ; . T , , , : x x .
C, , . W
, ; , .W , , . B , - , . T
( , - - ), - , , , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
80/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
81/122
Army o Altruists | 75
D , R - z C
? A I , q . I A .
L I - , , G W. B. I 4, A . A ,
B x B . C , x. I -, A G B JK , K , B . I , K , , .
T . T - q .N , A,Y, H, x - , . I I . A A
197 , j Y, I B., z- . B , A.
A -, H B, . N
, B F. B A - und . T - , - . L
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
82/122
76 | David Graeber
A . I L ,
, : , .
T ; A . E , . T , , x
A .P W W II, x , x, q x . T C W , j - .
T , , - x . A - q, , . D , C M F
C , , , . B x , x , , , x.
W . C , -
. A , , x ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
83/122
Army o Altruists | 77
. T - j -, x, .
I - B , , , - , , ? I , . A N - E x. B . T
, , , Nw Yk T. H j , , , . I U S , . T :
, j , NGO, - . B q B : , , . T . S x x- , , .
I - , , , - ? L j . S , . O j A.
T , , . -, -, , .B . T -
x -: (, q) . S , - 196 I . C
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
84/122
78 | David Graeber
, . I , , , :
, , , , , , . O . B .N j j: I , A .
A I
- : j A ? B , , . T j A .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
85/122
Th Sdnss o Post-workrism
On January th, 200 several o the heavyweights oI -W N, F B B,Mz Lzz, J R M . T .
O, . I
. B I I . F , j ,, ; q - ?, z , I L ? A q
, , -, , I - .
J
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
86/122
80 | David Graeber
Wht hppndHeres a very :
T z P O,
Mx C jRd Py, E Az, Muud.N z . N . E x . T , I, . T , , ,
- . A , , N ,, . M - j : , ,
. P .
T . C . G , , . E , ; , , -
x. I Lzz x ; R ; B W Jq D -; N E , .I I , ,
. T x , , , -, , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
87/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 81
. E - j . T -
. B , x . I .M : N j , B ( ) Lzz - . I
z , ( I ), , .
(N : 5 , , , ,
, .)A , x ,
, , , - q , q , B - . T
, , , , .
H :
MAURIZIO LAZZARAO Art, Work and Politics in Disciplinary Societies andSocieties o Security, D
K J , x- , , F . D - -
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
88/122
82 | David Graeber
; - , j
, , , .
JUDIH REVEL Te Materialo the Immaterial: Against the Return o Idealisms and
New Vitalisms,x - - : nn . T -, A . S j, Dz . R, -
F, - -; j x .
a lively discussion A
Dz . N -
BIFO Connection/Conjunction.H M F. T . B . I , j , -
. C- , - - . T -z; L , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
89/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 83
; ; j . I ,
, , , .
a conused and depressing discussion , B , - , Dz B. T , . I I .
ONI NEGRI ConcerningPeriodisation in Art: Some Approaches to Art andImmaterial Labour , , , 184, . (T q . T .) T 68, P-M,
, , :C, , ; x, x , . D x ,
q - B , , .W , , , , (
I !) , x, .
a fnal discussion was proposed . T
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
90/122
84 | David Graeber
. Lzz , . B .B . N B -
, q , , , , , -q -. O J R , , q ,
C
R , , - . E , . B - ; , - , x -
, x, . I .
I I , .I , I F Dz
z - , q - I , , . H I , , , I :
1) T .J
(D,F, D, A Ex) N 6, B B. B .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
91/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 85
) W I I L, I
( P-W) , .R, x- F 68 : MF, J B, Dz G A , Muud, E Az, N - -
, , .
3) I , F , . F , q: W z
? W q? I , , ? O j ? H x ? O ? O ,, ?
4) E . D , , B, -. T . M -
. , (N 7), : , L , . B
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
92/122
86 | David Graeber
, : B, R, A.
T , I . W, x, - 8 q , , F - 196 7 x 1916 19?
T . S, I
. W : F, D,C , F 68 , -? A q . E -: I W , 1917 , 1968 . E x E G . T
, - , ,, .
T E . F D 1914, H B D 1916, M W W 1918, B D
1918 19, , , j : , - , , , -j z . A S ,
, . O , , . B , . I , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
93/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 87
A G - ( J P AW), - (, ,
D R); ( S) A G , x .
W C M 68 q . A , ( q D ): M, , T S, R, D, D. B . W ,
G -C , , x-. T . W , , - . T , z. J x- -
, S , q - .
I x -q . I , -, , ,
- , - , - ; C D , .
aout th concpt o immtril lor
he notion o q-. I .T , Mz Lzz
. H,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
94/122
88 | David Graeber
, - x
, , , , , -, , , , .1 C - , . F, , , , , -, ; , ,
, , q z . A , - vu -, , , .
j L
. B , , I 7 8. O , L , , N - . C - . B
W H , , . T , .O, , : , -, - , , .
T , z , , -- Mx . I .
1 I L (://.-.//-
3.).
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
95/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 89
P , I , :
1) x , x . F ( ), - 6 7 x I Mx C.
) x ( j : , , - ).
3) !, 1968 1975, . N
. N .
T , , - . O - j - . W -, , 19 ,
, , ?W j -? A, ( L. F B, Wzd Oz)? W ?
O , , Mx , z (
) , , ny , ,, ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
96/122
90 | David Graeber
. O ,
x, .
O - . I -. M , , , .B 8, , D H -
. x: , z - z - : x x -- z , -, -
. G, z - . T , , ( , ) . H - . T, , z,
: z, , ( ) . T . B - , - .
T x , -
, - - Mx. I , , - . I ( ?) . T
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
97/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 91
,
( , , , ) ( , ,, , ). T - Mx j , x .
W - , Mx
: ( ) j , . T , , , . T , , , , -
, - . S x. O x - , , j dun , , - , , . A -
, , . B , Lzz N, -z, 1935.
Lzz x
, -
, -
, . T
x, , ,
z (Mz Lzz, G I:
Iq I L, ://..
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
98/122
92 | David Graeber
(A , I , q
, , . T x : - Fz , . T : , , , x - q. A ,
. T , , , , . I z , , j x
x, x- , . T - , x .)
Th rt world s orm o politics
his reluctance to q - - q . C
//zz--.. N
() Lzz /
w , ()
x -
j
( ): -
, . N Lzz
-, ,
q;
() dud.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
99/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 93
N . H 184
: 1848-187 , , 1871-1914, , -, 1917, - , .T . T
, ( ), , , , ( ) . O , , , q ? B - , , ( )
.T ,
-. I , , -z . O . T . T
, j, , , , z --- - x q: ? O, , , .
I . A I
. O x , , , ( .) A
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
100/122
94 | David Graeber
: .
L x I .
I , -. I , : , . O , - K F, K F. (I , j F -
.)T . P -
. T -, . N j . P -z ; ,
. T ,, , . B , I - .
I , I M - z
; , - . T -, T I, - x . A .
I , z z , -
.S . I , , . T ( , , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
101/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 95
, x ) - , -
, N Y L B M.
C , I -, - -. I , , , .
O,
, , , , , , x . I , - : . B . F C S A N
Y, , , B, , Z, , , - , , . Y
, , q x , j -z, , , - j , .
I , x, x .3
E , , , 3 T , . T
x
-
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
102/122
96 | David Graeber
19 R q . B ,
, . M . B , , x , x, ( ), , x
, . C , , ; -, , , j . E , . I , , I NEED MONEY,
. I . A , M D?4
D, , j , , j, , . I
. I , x , , , .
P . P - . T
4 A , N M N Y, - ,
-. I
q , -
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
103/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 97
, , - . P . A G
C , .I -j, , . A q j, q q - . E , - . O
, , .T -. L , , , x , .G -. B , , , . W
, - . P , , , I , , j , , x , ,
.I ,
-. T . T - . O .
W I z
. W - , , . W - ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
104/122
98 | David Graeber
.M, I -. F ,
x- , x, - . W - , - ; , x- , . T
- -, , . x, j , .
On Prophcy nd Socil ThoryNow, this is . R .B .
G, C
, J B, j (D T S) - . BB, , .T . Lzz -
,, . N -, , x,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
105/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 99
, , ( z -
z , , , , .)
B . I N Lzz j , , j . C,
, E A, , x . B I .T .
P x . I A J C I, . T
, , . O , , . A , . T j.I , , -. A Sz z,
H , . N q - .H . A , , - Sz , z .5 T . T . F
, - : j ,
5 E, . 66.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
106/122
100 | David Graeber
, , - . C,
z , , x . W C, z . T : z , -x- . B ,
z - .
I - -, , . S F ; Mx C 1848, j F
M 68. S , x, ( ) . S - , ; I . B N
q.
On th ullnss o timAt this point I I q: I ? W ?
B , . O
- .C, N, B,
. T . W ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
107/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 101
. W , x . T j x q,
z -; q, , .
C , , . T , - . F Lzz -
; R, -. F B, j ; N, -. E x , q , ,
I . A W Bj , . I , , q: , , , . T - x. T . H
j , j .
T , I , . O - , I , x
. I , : , j , . W ; ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
108/122
102 | David Graeber
. B , q - ud , , ,
. I Mx, -- , , , , - , . (T Mx, , .) I , , j M F,6
z - - : - x. H, , ; , , .
A ,
, Mx F ( , ) x . T . H ? H ?
T q. J , . I F : A, O .
O , B x F .
T , , 6 R, I , S. F -
-, -
,
.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
109/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 103
( F). B , , -. W
j - , - . C, . W . A : NA . E , , - , . B I
, F -, , . O .
S . T F - , -. A , . H, , , . T F -
, , , . I : , -, T F , : , . G
F , O . T F D.
O S. A E, P, P, F - . B I D . AA -
( , ), , , . I ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
110/122
104 | David Graeber
-, , , ,
, , .
N , , , zz .
a fnl not
Perhaps this seems . I , , , -W ( , N 7) , - q Mx, x
. I I . B I .
F , I z . A -- . I - ,
, q .T , , . W , I , x ?P . W j . P K Muu Ad, z
- , .
7 J : I , ,
M N S F,
G Cz, M A.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
111/122
he Sadness o Post-workerism | 105
I x , - q ( , , ,
) , . T , , , . I .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
112/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
113/122
K
aginst KmikzCpitlism
On Saturday, October th, 200, some 00 activists L, C A, , ,
. T z q . Oz L , , - , , Ex, . A , j , , -x - ; ,
: - C S--H 8% L .A z , ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
114/122
108 | David Graeber
; .
I , . B , - . H q , z , , , -
. W - , , - , . B , j . A . N
, 375, x . I, : , , , , V z -, , , , x .
I . F
M S j , z . B , , , .
L Hrhe Coryton blockade CJ A , - C D 9
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
115/122
Against Kamikae Capitalism | 109
-C , - .1 Y - , , , -
B , , G D. T q - , ? E, ? A , - . F C C L H, F ,
16, - 11 F 1 . E q , , , j
. (E, .)
E j j, F C C . T x , , , . . T ;
.
B F ? A . B , - . T z 6 6; , F ,
.
1 O 1, C ,
, UK
F S 16.
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
116/122
110 | David Graeber
W -. S ;
, , , -, - .T . B , , , - , , n wk, .
Th productiist rgin nd th prdox o th twntith cnturyOne o the -, z . I -,
, -, . T ; ; , , , ( - Mx ) . Y ? A Mx-B ,
, j : S, R, C,N, , A Mzq. Y - - , , . T - S U
, j ; -
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
117/122
Against Kamikae Capitalism | 111
. B , , . , ,
- - . G, , . T .
A j , j ( )
, . A , x ( , ?) n, x . W -
( I ) , , - .
H ? I q. O , , , , , - -
, j , j .T . I . I , , .Y , : ! T
, , F - ,z , , , , , .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
118/122
112 | David Graeber
So, wht ws nolirlism?In this, the , , -
: . A . N , , - , , -, -
. N , , . A,
. T . W z , , , .
A . Y . P -z . I z .
T -.E, - ( - ); , , , . S -
z . A , 8, z
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
119/122
Against Kamikae Capitalism | 113
, . T .
Kmikz cpitlismIt only makes , , , , G C, , , , . T .A -
. T -, , j j . T . F , j
, ( , ). F , , - .
I , . A -
: . A , , - , , : (, z, ) - x . I , , . I , , z -
.I x .
H, , ? T ,
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
120/122
114 | David Graeber
. A . I - ,
, , -. T , . , . T .H , - , x,
( ), , , - , ? T , , .
R j ,
, . U x , , , : (), ( -, , , z .) I ,
, , , ), x . Y .
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
121/122
-
7/27/2019 Revolutions in Reverse Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, And Imagination 2011
122/122
Minor Compositions
O :Pu Rdy F B BIn Mn S SNw Ln An, Nw S Ly Fx G A N
Oun CkkU Gud Dndn I L I ISu C R G-OMk N C E. G C & C W.J
Forthcoming:
Cunzn & Dnn E. Bj N19 & 20 C SA Vy Cu Sk P DPunkd E. Z FA, Pdun nd S Mvn E. G G
A