![Page 1: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
MineralRights‐RealPropertyDisputes
PresentedinCincinnati,ColumbusandClevelandforNorthAmericanTitleInsuranceCompany
February7th,8th,and10th
141E.TownStreetSuite200Columbus,Ohio43215(614)228‐6888Fax(614)228‐6878Cell(614)496‐[email protected]
![Page 2: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Oil‐GasMineralRightsPropertyDisputes
• Ohio Overview I. History of Mineral Industry II. Current Statistics III. Regulatory Framework
• Natural Gas I. Current Statistics II. Geology of Natural Gas/Shale III. Drilling
A. What is Horizontal Drilling? B. What is Fracking?
IV. Shale “Plays in Ohio A. Marcellus
I. General II. Ohio
B. Utica I. General II. Ohio
• Ohio Investment/Economic Impact/Politics I. Big Business II. Taxes and Jobs III. Environmental Issues
• Oil and Gas Lease Terms I. Key Provisions II. Legal Issues III. Environmental Issues
• Title Defects I. Ohio Law II. Current Issues III. Potential Cures IV. Endorsement Changes
• Valuation I. Coverage
A. Title Policy Terms B. Underwriter Options
II. Who Determines A. Rule 702 B. MAI-OH Licensed Appraiser-Realtor
III. Appraisal Methodology A. Highest-Best Use B. Cost C. Income Capitalization D. Sales Comparison
IV. Geological Considerations A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract
in question B. Well Location Map. Tract in Question Located
Here C. Plat Map of Gilead Township,
Morrow County, Ohio D. Cross Section Map showing Erosion al Remnants
along Knox Unconformity in Ohio. E. The Oil Production for the Wells Located in the
Yellow Circle range form 40,000 BO to 70,000 BO. The dry holes that were drilled along the green oval trend contained > 40 feet of Glenwood Shale. Tract in Question is red circle.
F. Old Shot Point Base Map Shows Location of Seismic and Possible Oil Well located on the Tract in Question.
![Page 3: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
OhioOilandGasIndustryOverview
• History/Statistics
• TotalMarketValue:$718,089,496(roughlyevenlysplit)– Non‐fuel:another1.27billion
• NumberofWellsDrilled:LeadingStates 1. Texas.Nosurprisehere. 2. Oklahoma.Makessense. 3. Pennsylvania.O.K. 4. Ohio.Yep.274,733welldrilled.
• Regulations
![Page 4: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
NaturalGas
• Characteristics
– “WetGas”(ethane,methane,propane,butane)
• Geology
– “Conventional”Play
![Page 5: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Shale
• Geology
• Domestic“Plays”– Haynesville(TX/LA)– Barnett(TX)– Fayetteville(AR)– MarcellusandUtica(OH/PA)
![Page 6: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
![Page 7: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
![Page 8: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
![Page 9: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ShaleDrilling
• HorizontalDrilling
• “Fracking”
![Page 10: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ShaleDrilling(Cont…)
• EconomicsofShaleDrilling
– GreaterCost/ReturnfromTechnology
• WhyOhio?– Shallowdepthofformations
– NGL’s
![Page 11: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
![Page 12: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
![Page 13: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
![Page 14: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
![Page 15: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOhio:Marcellus
• Area:95,000squaremiles(estimated)– KY,MD,NJ,NY,OH,PA,TN,VA,WV
• Depth:4,000–9,000feet
• MostdrillinginPennsylvania
![Page 16: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
![Page 17: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Marcellus(Cont…)
• SoutheastCounties:
– Belmont– Carroll– Columbiana– Guernsey– Harrison– Jefferson– Mahoning– Monroe– Noble– Washington
• ShallowerinOH(3,000–4,000feet)butthinner
![Page 18: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Marcellus(Cont…)
• Permits:2010(5);2011(11)
• Permits:– Monroe=8– Belmont=6
• StatusofWells:– Drilling=1– Drilled=5– Producing=3
![Page 19: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Utica
• Area:170,000squaremiles(estimated)– NY,KY,MD,OH,PA,TN,WV,VA(noNJ)
• Depth:2,000–7,000feetbelowMarcellus
• GeographicallymoreexpansiveandthickerthanMarcellus
![Page 20: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
![Page 21: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Utica(Cont…)
• ShallowerinOH(6,000–9,000feet)
• ClosertoMarcellus(3,000vs.7,000feet)
• MoreNGL’sandOilthanMarcellus
![Page 22: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
![Page 23: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
![Page 24: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Utica(Cont…)
• Permits:2009(1);2010(2);2011(147)
• Permits:(Actionintheoverlap)– Carroll=47– Jefferson=21– Columbiana=17– Mahoning=13– Noble=12– Guernsey=10
![Page 25: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Shale“Plays”inOH:Utica(Cont…)
• WhoisBuying?– ChesapeakeExplorationLLC=112
• 2477filingsinCarrollsince11/2010– AnadarkoE&PCo.LP=18
• StatusofWells:– Drilling=26– Drilled=31– Producing=4
![Page 26: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
UticaImpact
• Economic• Revenue/Taxes/Investment
– ChesapeakeandHessCorpover1bil.each– 34billion(estimated)
• Jobs(whereneededmost)(204,000estimated)• State/Countiesaslessors?
• Environmental/Political– ProposedmoratoriumuntilEPAstudydone– Groundwater/Earthquakes
![Page 27: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
OilandGasLeases• Signingbonus
– Recent:$2,000‐$4,000/acre
• Royalties– Production:usually12.5%(1/8)– Delay– Shut‐in(royaltyorrental)
• Term– Primary– Secondary(“producing”“payingquantities”)
• Pooling/MinimumAcreage
![Page 28: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
TitleDefects
• OhioLaw– Conveyance(deed;reserve;lease)
• Mineralsseparatepropertyright(royaltytoo)• Defaultrule:movewiththesurfacerights
– Execution/Recording/Assignments• RC5301.01;5301.09;1509.31
– Whatdoes“minerals”mean?
• CurrentIssues– Reservation(separatechain)=needtoreadthedocs– Mechanics’liens(RC1311.021)– UCCliens(RC1309)
![Page 29: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
TitleDefects:CuresDormantMineralAct(RC5301.56)
Background:MarketableTitleAct(RC5301.47‐.56)
Doesnotapplyto: Coal Publicbodies
Rights“abandoned”and“vest”insurfaceownerifchainsilentfor20years
Chainnot“silent”if: Partofarecoded“titletransaction” Actualproduction/withdrawal Usedinundergroundgasstorage Adrillingorminingpermithasbeenissued Apreservationnoticehasbeenfiled Aseparatetaxnumberhasbeencreated
![Page 30: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
TitleDefects:Cures(Cont…)DormantMineralAct(Cont…)
Theprocedure/contentsofapreservationnoticearelaidoutinSubsectionC.
Theabandonmentprocedurehastwosteps:
1. Servicenoticebycertifiedmailtothelastknownaddressoftheholder(ortheirsuccessors/assignees).Ifservicecan’tbemadethisway,publicationisused.TherequiredcontentsaredescribedinSubsectionF.
2. Fileanaffidavitwiththerecorderbetween30and60daysafterthenoticeisgiven.TherequiredcontentsaredescribedinSubsectionG.
Inresponsetothenotice,iftheholder(ortheirsuccessors/assignees)claimstheirinterest,thenithas60daystofilecertainthingswiththerecorderunderSubsectionH(1).Ifnot,thesurfaceownercanhavetherecordermemorializetheabandonmentinthechainoftitleunderSubsectionH(2).Itisthisfilingthatcreatestheabandonment.
![Page 31: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
TitleDefects:Cures(Cont…)LeaseForfeiture(RC5309.332)(breach)
When: Noproducingordrilling Lesseebreachedcovenantsinleaseorexpired
Servicenoticebycertifiedmailtothelastknownaddressofthelessee(ortheirsuccessors/assignees).Ifservicecan’tbemadethisway,publicationisused.Therequiredcontentsaredescribed.
Fileanaffidavitwiththerecorderbetween30and60daysafterthenoticeisgiven.Therequiredcontentsaredescribed.
Inresponsetothenotice,iftheholder(ortheirsuccessors/assignees)claimstheirinterest,thenithas60daystofilecertainthingswiththerecorder.Ifnot,thesurfaceownercanhavetherecordermemorializetheforfeitureontheleaseitself.Itisthisfilingthatcreatestheforfeiture.
![Page 32: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
TitleDefects:Cures(Cont…)
• Lease“Expiration”(onitsownterms)– EX.Noproductionin“payingquantities”
• OSBAStandardsofTitleExamination(section4.4)
– ProblemA:Shouldanoil,gasorcoalleasebeshownwhensatisfactoryevidenceisfurnishedthatrentalsareindefaultandthatmineralsarenotbeingproduced?
– StandardA:No,providedfurtherthattheprimarytermoftheleasehasexpired.
![Page 33: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
TitleDefects:Cures(Cont…)• Superpriority(R.C.1509.31(D))(effective6/30/10)
– Preservesoilandgasleases(etc)frombeingextinguishedinaforeclosure
– Onlyifrecordedafterthemortgage
• NewexceptionforScheduleBinloanpolicies: “OilandGasleases,pipelineagreements,oranyotherinstruments
relatedtotheproductionorsaleofoilornaturalgaswhichmayarisesubsequenttotheDateofPolicy.”
![Page 34: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
AdditionalResources
• OhioDepartmentofNaturalResources:DivisionofMineralResourcesManagement
• OhioStateUniversity:TheSubsurfaceEnergyResourceCenter
• Geology.com
• TheOhioEnvironmentalProtectionAgency
• TheOhioOilandGasAssociation
• OhioOilandGasEnergyEducationProgram
• U.S.DepartmentofEnergy/EnergyInformationAgency
• U.S.GeologicalSurvey
![Page 35: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
SUBJECTTOTHEEXCLUSIONSFROMCOVERAGE,THEEXCEPTIONSFROMCOVERAGECONTAINEDINSCHEDULEB,ANDTHECONDITIONS,NORTHAMERICANTITLEINSURANCECOMPANY,aCaliforniacorporation(the"Company"),insures,asaDateofPolicyand,totheextentstatedinCoveredRisks9and10,afterDateofPolicy,againstlossordamage,notexceedingtheAmountofInsurance,sustainedorincurredbytheInsuredbyreasonof:
1.…………..2.AnydefectinorlienorencumbranceontheTitle………..
![Page 36: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Underwriter’sfouroptions
5.DEFENSEANDPROSECUTIONOFACTIONS• Litigateorlegalacttoresolve.7. OPTIONSTOPAYOROTHERWISESETTLECLAIMS;TERMINATIONOFLIABILITY
• Paypolicylimittoinsured.
• Payfairmarketvalueoflosstoinsured.• Paymoneydirectto3rdpartytoresolve.
![Page 37: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Whoisqualifiedtocalculateorcomputetheamountofloss?
• EvidR702Testimonybyexperts
• Awitnessmaytestifyasanexpertifallofthefollowingapply:• Thewitness'testimonyeitherrelatestomattersbeyondtheknowledgeorexperiencepossessedbylay
personsordispelsamisconceptioncommonamonglaypersons;
• Thewitnessisqualifiedasanexpertbyspecializedknowledge,skill,experience,training,oreducationregardingthesubjectmatterofthetestimony;
• Thewitness'testimonyisbasedonreliablescientific,technical,orotherspecializedinformation.Totheextentthatthetestimonyreportstheresultofaprocedure,test,orexperiment,thetestimonyisreliableonlyifallofthefollowingapply:
• Thetheoryuponwhichtheprocedure,test,orexperimentisbasedisobjectively• verifiableorisvalidlyderivedfromwidelyacceptedknowledge,facts,orprinciples;• Thedesignoftheprocedure,test,orexperimentreliablyimplementsthetheory;
• Theparticularprocedure,test,orexperimentwasconductedinawaythatwillyieldanaccurateresult
![Page 38: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
HowManyMAIsareinOhioandhowmanyLicensed
AppraisersareinOhio?• TheAppraisalInstituteoffers3differenttypesofdesignations(i.e.MAI,SRPA,andSRA).Youareableto
getalistofprofessionalsinOhiowithanyofthese3designationsfromtheAIwebsite.Iprintedoffall3listswithadescriptionofthedesignation(seeattachedfolder).Tosummarize,inOhio,thereare:
• 137MAIs;
• 16SRPAs;• 157SRAs• Ohiooffers3typesofappraiserlicenses/certifications(i.e.“State‐certifiedgeneralrealestateappraiser,”
“State‐certifiedresidentialrealestateappraiser,”and“State‐licensedresidentialrealestateappraiser”).ThesearedefinedinR.C.4763.1(K,L,M)(Seeattachedfolder).Thereisawebsitecalled“OhioDepartmentofCommerceOnlineLicensingwebsite.”Thiswebsitehasacomprehensivelistingofalllicensedrealestateprofessionalsinthestate,includingappraisers.YoucandownloadanExcelSpreadsheetandsortthroughprofessionalsbydesignation,activestatus,etc(note:Ihaveasavedspreadsheetonmydesktopbutdidn’tprintitbecauseitwastoolong).Doingthis,Imadethefollowingfindings:
• Thereareapproximately738Active“State‐certifiedgeneralrealestateappraisers”inOhio(includesthosewithtemporaryandreciprocallicenses)
• Thereareapproximately1241Active“State‐certifiedresidentialrealestateappraisers”inOhio(includesreciprocallicenses)
• Thereareapproximately790Active“State‐licensedresidentialrealestateappraisers”inOhio(includesreciprocallicenses)
• OrCombingthethreetypes,thereareatotalof2769AppraiserProfessionalsbasedonthisdatabase
![Page 39: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
AppraisalMethodology
Highestandbestuseisdefinedas:
1.Thelegalpermissibilityoftheintendedimprovements.2.ThePhysicaladaptabilityofthesite.
3.Theeconomicfeasibilityoftheintendedimprovements.4.Theeconomicprofitabilityoftheintendedimprovementsin
termsoftheircapabilitytogeneratethegreatestamountofnetincometothesite.
AppraisalInstitute,TheAppraisalofRealEstate,ThirteenthEdition(AppraisalInstitute,550WestVanBuren,Chicago,Illinois60607,2008)277.
![Page 40: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
ValuationProcedure
• Threegenerallyacceptedtechniquesavailableforestimatingthevalueofrealestate.
1. CostApproach‐estimatingthereproductionorreplacementcostnew.
2. IncomeCapitalizationApproach‐Measurevaluebyestimatingthepresentworthofanyanticipatedfutureincomestreamtobegeneratedbyaproperty.Oneyear’sincomeexpectancycanbecapitalizedatamarketderivedcapitalizationratethatreflectsaspecifiedincomepattern,returnoninvestment,andchangeinthevalueoftheinvestment.
3. SalesComparisonApproach‐Salesofsimilarpropertiesareresearchedandadjustedbasedupontheircomparabilitytothesubjectproperty.
![Page 41: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
AssetValuation
Return(Howmuchinterestisexpectedfor
anassetrisk?)
Capitalization
(Howmuchwouldyoupayforastreamofpayments?)
![Page 42: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
ExhibitA.PlatMapofGileadTownship,MorrowCounty,Ohio
![Page 43: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
ExhibitB.CloseupofPlatMapShowingLocationofTractinquestion
![Page 44: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
ExhibitC.WellLocationMap.TractinQuestionLocatedHere
![Page 45: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
ExhibitD.CrossSectionMapshowingErosionalRemnantsalongKnoxUnconformityinOhio
![Page 46: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
ExhibitE.TheOilProductionfortheWellsLocatedintheYellowCirclerangeform40,000BOto70,000BO.Thedryholesthatweredrilledalongthegreenovaltrend
contained>40feetofGlenwoodShale.TractinQuestionisredcircle.
![Page 47: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
ExhibitF.OldShotPointBaseMapShowsLocationofSeismicandPossibleOilWelllocatedontheTractinQuestion
![Page 48: Mineral Rights‐Real Property Disputes · A. C.Marcellus I. General II. Ohio B. Utica I. General ... A. Close up of Plat Map Showing Location of Tract in question B. Well Location](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042306/5ed1bf60da60d73eea292808/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
ContactUs
HavensLimited141EastTownStreet,Suite200
Columbus,OH43215
(614)228‐6888
JimHavens
AdamSchwartz