CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 1
Lecture 11: Theological Developments 1303-1648Dr. Ann T. Orlando
5 April 2011
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 2
Introduction
Historical Review Precursors to Reformation and Renaissance Lutheran Theology Calvin’s Theology Anabaptists Catholic Response Development of Catholic Spirituality
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 3
Historical Review 14th – 16th C Black death, Hundred Year’s War Avignon Papacy Great Schism: 2 Popes Conciliar Movement: 3 Popes Fall of Constantinople, 1453 Development of strong, competing nations in
Europe in 16th C
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 4
Review: Situation Early to Mid 16th C
Powerful Ottoman Turks in control of Eastern and Southern Mediterranean
Spain newly unified after expulsion of Muslims France and England in uneasy truce France and HRE in occasional battles over eastern France Strong National Rulers
Francois I of France Charles V HRE (Spain, Germany, Netherlands) Henry VIII in England
Popes in very weakened political situation after Avignon papacy; reliant on sale of indulgences and simony for funds
Age of Spanish and Portugese discovery and exploration
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 5
New Theological and Intellectual Movements Key to all new movements was : Opposition
to Scholasticism and Aristotle Move from Scholastic terminology and methods to
philology (language) Move from natural theology to Bible and early
Christian sources Move from intellect to will
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 6
Early Reactions Against Scholasticism Duns Scotus, Franciscan (1265-1308)
Man comes to knowledge only by illumination from God Divine will takes precedence over divine intellect; known as
volunteerism William of Ockham, Franciscan (1285-1347)
‘Ockham’s razor’ there should be no hypotheses that are not directly necessary; man is saved by direct action of God’s grace without any intermediary action
Nominalism; that is, universals are not necessary Attacked wealth of clergy
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 7
Early Reformers
John Wycliffe, Wyclif, Wycliff (1324-1384) Englishman, denounced Papal control over Church property Church as spiritual not a political society Emphasis on Scripture and priesthood of all believers Opposed to indulgences Lollards remained active in England promoting Wycliffe’s
theology Wycliffe condemned by Council of Constance, 1415
John Hus (1369-1415) Bohemian, influenced by Wycliffe Did not accept priesthood of all believers; otherwise in general
agreement with Wycliffe Condemned and burned at stake by Council of Constance Leader of Bohemian national movement
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 8
15th – 16th Century Intellectual Reform Movements Renaissance - Southern Europe
Art Humanism
Reformation – Northern Europe Nationalism Theological Reform
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 9
Renaissance: Humanism
Starts in Italy as part of Italian Renaissance Renaissance is said to begin when Petrarch reads
Confessions when he ascends Mt. Ventoux, April 26, in 1336
Emphasizes philology over philosophy; Study of structure and literal analysis of ancient texts
in original languages, including Bible, rather than using philosophical methods
Especially critical of Aristotle Return to the original religious and classical
sources, ad fontes
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 10
Erasmus of Rotterdam (1469 – 1536) Augustinian monk Humanist who encouraged
return to Bible and early Fathers of Church as a way to reform
Scripture as the philosophy of Christ
Optimistic about man’s ability to know and understand; ancient maxim that if one
knows what is right, one will do what is right
Detailed textual work on Bible and Augustine
Most famous scholar of his time
http://www.tate.org.uk/images/cms/12567w_messages_erasmus.jpg
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 11
Martin Luther (1483-1546)
Luther was influenced by humanism; studied Biblical languages and the early Church Fathers, especially Augustine
Driven by internal and external events
Internal struggle As a young Augustinian
monk, Luther struggles to appease God for his sins
Finally realizes that nothing he can do can appease God;
Salvation must be God’s free gift that one accepts by faith
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/images/h2/h2_55.220.2.jpg
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 12
External Struggle:German Reformation The proximate cause of the Reformation: 1517, Albrecht of
Mainz wants to be Archbishop Albrecht buys his archbishopric from Rome (Leo X); Rome needs
the money in part to help pay for rebuilding of St. Peters Rome authorizes the preaching of a special indulgence in
Germany, with the money to go to Albrecht to repay him Martin Luther
Responds to this situation with 95 Theses Go far beyond denouncing sin of simony and corruption;
fundamentally calls into question Rome’s primacy and theology of indulgences; denounces scholasticism
German princes, especially Fredrick the Wise of Saxony, support Luther against Rome and against HRE Charles V
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 13
Lutheran Theology: Three Solas Sola Scriptura
Rejection of philosophical developments; Scripture is all that one needs Scripture should be available to everyone, unmediated; Luther translates
Bible into German, although with his own interpretation built into it Return to original Biblical languages for Biblical study; reject any OT
books not written in Hebrew (deuterocanonical books; i.e., most philosophical books)
Very important that everyone can read Sola Fides
Faith in Jesus Christ is necessary and sufficient for salvation Universal priesthood of all believers
Sola Gratia Only God’s grace can save you Only two sacraments: Baptism and Eucharist Accepts Real Presence, but not transubstantiation
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 14
Implications of Luther’s Solas Rejection of intercession of saints
Destruction of images of saints, Churches stripped of decorations Rejection of relics
Rejection of indulgences Theory of indulgences implies Pelagianism There are no intermediaries between person and God
Rejection of Scholasticism (and philosophy in general) The only way to know is by the illumination of grace Salvation is not a process, but an instantaneous change of nature Does not accept traditional Christian views of anthropology: body, soul, spirit; there is
only one whole person Rejection of inherent value celibacy
Since all are priests, monks, nuns and ordained clergy are no holier than anyone else Luther and most of his ordained followers marry
Reading and Education Important that everyone be able to read the Bible Luther wrote two catechisms (Large and Small) in a question and answer format
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 15
Luther-Erasmus Debates on Free Will Replay of Pelagian controversy Erasmus writes a book, called On Free Will,
like Augustine wrote early in his career In response Luther writes a book called On
Bondage of Will, makes points similar to Augustine against Pelagius on need for grace, predestination
As in Pelagian controversy, how does one interpret Paul’s Letter to Romans?
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 16
Lutheran Theologian: Philip Melanchthon (1497-1560) A humanist who studied classical languages
very carefully Became a close friend of Luther Wrote the Augsburg Confession (1530)
An apology for Reformers given to Charles V Tries to be as conciliatory as possible,
emphasizing points of common belief Charles V rejects it
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 17
Swiss Reformation: Huldrych Zwingli (1484-1531) A priest, Zwingli becomes member of Zurich city
council Preaches against Catholic liturgical practice Denies Real Presence in Eucharist; breaking point
with Luther Because two can not agree at Marburg (1529), there is
no united Reform movement Upholds sovereignty of Swiss cantons; but sovereignty
in combination of religion and civil rule based on Bible Dies in battle fighting for Zurich against Catholic Swiss
cantons in 1531
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 18
John Calvin (1509 - 1564)
Accepted Luther’s maxim “Sola Scriptura, Sola Fides, Sola Gratia” and extended it Accepted double predestination (as
defined by Augustine) Rejected real presence in Eucharist
Established a ‘holy’ city in Geneva: Calvinism, had an extensive influence on
Protestant movement, especially in Scotland (Presbyterians), France (Huguenots) England (Puritans) Netherlands (Reformers)
Note that all reformers looked to Augustine as their ‘patron saint’ Calvin said, “He is one of us”
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 19
Protestants in France
Francois I supported Humanists in France Claimed that the French Church had a special relationship with Papacy (Pepin,
Charlemagne, Avignon) Defended Pope, but French Church also claimed some independence of Pope
(Gallicanism) with special ties to French throne Calvin, who was French, sends reformers to France from Geneva When Francois I dies, French throne is up for grabs with both Catholic and
Calvinists making claims; Catherine de Medici becomes regent, waivers between appeasement and persecution of Huguenots (French Calvinists)
Religious wars in France, leading to St. Bartholomew Day’s Massacre, 24 August 1572
Eventually Henry IV becomes king; issues Edict of Nantes (1598) in which Catholicism is official religion of France, but Huguenots have some civil rights Originally a Protestant, converted to Catholicism Henry really a champion of very strong monarchy Assassinated in 1610 Young son becomes king, Louis XIII
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 20
Anabaptists (Radical Reform) Opposed infant baptism; rather baptism should be
accepted when one accepted faith in Jesus Christ Zwingli and Luther were both opposed to them Considered themselves completely separate from
State; did not believe that all professing Christians were part of Church
Politically and religiously exclusive; thus persecuted by all others as a threat to civil unity
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 21
Models of Church-State Development Catholic: Pope over civil rulers Lutheran: Civil rulers over Church (Romans
13) Calvinists: Combined into one ruling body to
form a holy community Anabaptists: Perfect congregation within
broader evil society; witness to, but does not try to participate in broader society
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 22
Catholic Response Main Points Reform of corrupt practice Affirmation of basic Catholic doctrine Renewal of Catholic spiritual practice Arts in service of theology Historians are at odds what to call
Catholicism in this period Counter Reformation Catholic Reformation Early Modern Catholicism
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 23
Catholic Response: Jesuits Jesuits (Society of Jesus)
founded by Ignatius Loyola (1491-1556)
NOT founded to counter Reformation; but charter put Jesuits on front lines against Reformers
Education very important in Jesuit belief
Jesuits very focused on work among people
Jesuit life-style in many ways opposite that of a monastery
saintpetersbasilica.org/Statues/Founders/IgnatiusLoyola/St%20Ignatius%20Loyola-FounderSaint.jpg
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 24
Key Points of Jesuit Charter (1541) Vow not to accept ecclesiastical dignities; Special relationship to Pope Increased probations:
The novitiate is prolonged from one year to two, A third discernment year after ordination, Final solemn vows may take years.
The Society does not keep choir. It does not have a distinctive religious habit. It is also said to have been the first order to undertake officially
and by virtue of its constitutions active works such as the following:
foreign missions, at the pope's bidding; the education of youth of all classes; the instruction of the ignorant and the poor; ministering to the sick, to prisoners, etc.
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 25
Catholic Response: Council of Trent Called by Pope Paul III
Pope initially reluctant to call council because of bad experiences with councils (especially Council of Constance) in 15th C
Purpose was both to address reform of practice and to uphold Catholic doctrine
Lengthy, intermittent (1545-1563) Developed in 25 several sessions Spanning three popes: Paul III, Julius III, Paul IV
Jesuits play a major theological role at Trent; encouraged explicit statement of Catholic doctrine in opposition to Protestant views
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 26
Key Theological Statements from Trent Scripture and Tradition Sacraments are effective by the fact of the
sacramental action being performed, ex opere operato
Affirmed Mass as sacrifice and transubstantiation of bread and wine into Body and Blood of Christ
Affirmed 7 sacraments Affirmed faith with good works together brings about
salvation Affirmed indulgences and intercession of saints
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 27
Revived Catholic Spirituality:
Teresa of Avila (1515 – 1582) Pioneered major reforms of
monastic orders (men and women) Special relationship with John of
Cross Encouraged renewed devotion of
Catholics in opposition to Protestants
First woman declared a doctor of Church (1970)
John of Cross 1542-1591 Follower of Theresa of Avila Mystic and writer of popular
devotional works
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 28
St. Frances de Sales (1567-1622) Educated by Jesuits Argued against Calvinists;
bishop in absentia of Geneva
Wrote popular devotional works; On Devout Life very influential Intended for lay people
(women)
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 29
Religious Map of Europe c. 1560www.wwnorton.com/college/history/ralph/resource/religion.htm
CH 500 Lecture 11 Theology 1303-1648 30
Readings
McManners Ch 7 (233-266) Read carefully Luther, Melanchthon, Calvin, Ignatius
Loyola, Theresa of Avila, Trent documents, De Sales
OPTIONAL Joint Catholic-Lutheran Declaration on Justification Petrarch, Ascent of Mt Ventoux,
http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/petrarch-ventoux.html
As always, read secondary sources critically for emphasis (bias) of author