doing business in india: anti-corruption best practices momentum webinar may 29, 2014
TRANSCRIPT
Doing Business In India: Anti-Corruption Best Practices
Momentum Webinar
May 29, 2014
2
Agenda
• Introduction
• Overview of FCPA
• Corruption Challenges / Enforcement in India
• Compliance Best Practices
• Questions
33
India’s Business Potential …
• Growing economy
• Barriers to entry eroding
• Cost-competitiveness
• Talent pool
• Emerging middle class
• Outpacing China in Foreign Direct Investment
… and Business Challenges
• Corruption cited as second most problematic factor by World Economic Forum
• Lack of infrastructure is ranked first
• Others: • bureaucracy • tax regulations• restrictive labor regulations• administrative delays
4
Overview of the FCPA
66
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA)
• Prohibits bribery of non-U.S. government officials
• Requires companies to maintain accurate records and robust internal controls
• Regulators– Department of Justice (DOJ)– Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
77
Anti-Bribery Provisions
• No covered person may make, offer, promise, or authorize,
• A payment or anything of value,
• With corrupt intent,
• To a government official,
• To obtain or retain businessbusiness or an unfair advantageunfair advantage.
88
Payment
• Can be an actual payment or gift
• Can also be an offer or promise to pay
• May be in response to request from official
• It is enough to authorize a payment
** Includes direct and indirect payments**
99
Thing of Value
• Anything of value to the recipient
– Money
– Gift
– Hospitality
– Loan/favorable financing
– Discounted/free maintenance
– Donation
– A job for official’s son / daughter
1010
Foreign Official
• An officer, employee, or agent of any– Indian government, whether national,
state, local, etc.– Department or agency of the Indian
government– Company, entity, or other
instrumentality owned/controlled by the Indian government
– Public international organization (e.g., the UN, the WTO)
– Indian political party
1111
Foreign Official (cont.)
• Candidate for Indian political office
• Anyone acting on behalf of a Foreign Official
• Person holding ceremonial title (e.g., royal family member with no government position)
• Rank or title is irrelevant
1212
Obtain Business / Advantage
• Obtain contract from government agency
• Achieve regulatory change that benefits business
• Direct award of business opportunity to family member
• Receive favorable ruling on applicable customs duties
1313
Permissible Payments
• When permitted under written laws of country
• Mere custom is not adequate
OR
• Reasonable and bona fide expense directly related to:• Execution or performance of a contract with government
party, or
• Demonstration, promotion, or explanation of a product or service
1414
Facilitating Payments
• Payments to expedite non-discretionary “routine governmental actions” such as:• Loading / unloading cargo
• Award of a visa
• Many companies prohibit facilitation payments entirely
1515
Third Party Risks
Any party acting on your behalf, e.g., a
•Subsidiary or other affiliate
•Agent, sponsor, representative, distributor, consultant
•Joint venture party
Examples:
• Your Customs broker in Mumbai
• The lobbying firm you engage in Delhi
• A marketing agent in Hyderabad
1616
Recordkeeping and Internal Controls
• Keep detailed and accurate transactional records
• Maintain system of internal controls to ensure management has oversight over and control of transactions
− Obtain authorizations prior to transactions
− Collect necessary approvals before reimbursement
− Record transactions fully and accurately
− Take steps so partners do the same
Enforcement Related to India
• Oracle (2012): Indian subsidiary involved in alleged bribery; $2 million fine to SEC
• Diageo (2011): Subsidiaries in India (and elsewhere) alleged to have paid $2.7 million in bribes for sales and tax benefits; $16.4 million in penalties to SEC
• Pride International (2010): Company apparently made $500,000 in improper payments to judges on India’s Customs, Excise, and Gold Appellate Tribunal; $32.6 million to DOJ and $19.3 million to SEC
17
Enforcement (cont.)
• Control Components Inc. (CCI) (2009): Allegedly made $4.9 million in illicit payments to officials in various countries, including Maharashtra State Electricity Board in India; $18.2 million in fines
• Wabtec (2008): Subsidiary said to have made over $170,000 in payments to Indian Railway Board employees, inspectors, and customs personnel to obtain railway contracts; $300,000 to DOJ and $87,000 to SEC
• Electronic Data Systems (EDS) and Srinivasan (2007): Former president of AT Kearney India caused ATKI to make over $720,000 in payments to employees of state-owned companies to retain contracts worth $7.5 million; Srinivasan paid $70,000 fine; EDS paid $490,902 in penalties
18
FCPA Enforcement (cont.)
Wal-Mart: Company investigating wide-ranging bribery allegations
Company’s agents in India allegedly procured numerous licenses required for setting up stores
Partnered with Indian company to expand India operations; ended partnership amidst FCPA probe
19
Corruption Challenges / Enforcement in India
Corruption in India
• Ranked 94 of 177 countries in TI’s 2013 Corruption Perceptions Index
• Indian economists estimate government officials earn as much as 1.26% of GDP through corruption
• Evidence of some companies halting business in India because of corruption
21
Factors Contributing to Corruption
• Government officials are poorly paid
• General attitude toward bribery more relaxed
• Bribery viewed as an accepted part of doing business
• Cumbersome procedures/red tape
• Officials have substantial discretion22
Highest Corruption Risks
• Sales to government customers
• Obtaining licenses, permits, and registrations
• Clearing customs – paying duties and taxes; logistics (using freight-forwarders)
• Navigating bureaucracy / complex laws
23
Where Corruption is Pervasive
• Vulnerable sectors– metals & mining
• $194 billion lost in government sale of coalfields to companies without competitive bidding
– aviation• Air India reportedly losing millions due to corruption and
mismanagement of aircraft repairs
– power & utilities – aerospace & defense– infrastructure & construction– telecoms
24
Common Schemes and Themes
• Small sums • Services already due: customs clearance, taxation,
water and land records issuance• Use of agents and/or consultants• Slush funds or petty cash funds• Fictitious invoices• Indirect benefits – hiring third parties at official
suggestion• Lavish gifts and entertainment• Donations to organizations owned/recommended by
officials
25
Potential Compliance Gaps
Improper gift-giving (cash, computers, large dollar travel)
• “Check the box due” diligence – consider specific local factors to take risk-based approach
Improper use/oversight of third parties
Customer relationships built on trust – resistance to memorializing business agreements in formal contracts
26
Indian Anti-Corruption Law
• Limited in scope and enforcement
• Prevention of Corruption Act (PCA) 1988
• India ratified United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in 2011
• Lokpal Bill passed in December 2013; new agency established to investigate and prosecute
27
Recent Events
• In recent years, public has taken to streets to voice outrage after corruption scandals
• January 2014 - $670 million helicopter deal with British-Italian company terminated due to corruption allegations
• April 2014 – DOJ asked India to arrest member of Indian parliament who granted mining rights for $18 million in bribes
• Modi’s election and pro-business platform
28
Indian Government Investigations
• 2010: Investigation of Commonwealth games in New Delhi
• 2011: CBI arrested Chief and aides of organizing committee for awarding illegal contracts to Swiss manufacturer
• Officials being tried for illegalities in issuing 2G telecom licenses – revenue losses reportedly $40 billion
29
Compliance Best Practices
Compliance Best Practices
• Establish transparent tone at top
• Prioritize / address risks
• Tailor policies and procedures to risks
• Keep good records
31
Tone at the Top
• Establish top-down culture of compliance
– Regularly assert importance of compliance
– Commit resources to compliance infrastructurecompliance infrastructure
• Dedicated compliance personnel
• Regular training
• Helpline / reporting mechanism
32
Prioritize Risk
• Expressly contemplated by DOJ and SEC Guidelines
• Focus compliance resources on most significant risk areas such as:
• Industry
• Use / non-use of agents
• Amount of interaction with government
• Past compliance issues
• Importance of cash to operation
• Other factors
33
Policies and Procedures
• Establish processes for:
• Vetting business partners
• Providing hospitality and gifts
• Monitoring and auditing compliance
• Internal reporting mechanisms
• Opportunity for anonymous reporting
• Prompt review and investigation as needed
• Protect personnel from retaliation when report is in good faith
34
Questions?
35
THANK YOU!
Jennifer GormanAECOM
Thad McBride
Sheppard Mullin
Fatema Merchant
Sheppard Mullin