wittgenstein's aesthetic misunderstandings
TRANSCRIPT
sHg 3 rgsYF Fia = o .:< !i**'I a >Fjq26'Y H rd P p{c-.6 q U =-Y.
-q L -i a
€6fi E a*.$nSir F > c; Fdie ci * tr P_*ri<tF i 1L-oST6 S uJspiE*'6o ,! XSg:sEs 6 5S€dbm- .} E=E€o = : <\ n<xSg 3 O >--s \r!!; s i[<r:(g0 Fi :C$cc- :. ET-r 5.i;_V!a- X 's oJtr- = uI'Et * ! -'" (!s x h I P.!..;r u.E -5 b €.-9 -:s i M za" r;id{5 5 >Ys^Ec o o d > -ooioFa
'gsip vc jry;n6S-q o" {; 5.i *rrr-^a!igI
.E. a E -rd [i Po';5SoE -;F E53g>'F P= cIi trE- "bo.PPU O- o . n, Q? .do
E:gt";€ tr€$.lioiis t<o LDgIO\s- GF4 D. - J - ;*JU
u f,fi ilttfft[* EgEErE u ;;e I ggxE tigF*
;: i;
'llgiligffgigffil;aHH gEit
srs$igiligIgi!li*
U)
oFltiq,)€0.)
A
E€€ =-e-?.9E=Xi r* o I o " 6F€; k; HIeiYE ' !* bo*f o'lit oi = )j'E.,E* 53td i=:5o__, o cl
€€s #ii"H*E ils i;ETs'9-t F- " ? GFr o,iE $' g Ei a a s9('S A: E'sot*i=s$g€E E
€ifiii*s€F'E#:E;EE'EtrE
-qv-!F-sEoqlieilsUG.qX+rpSSo!5!u FE P s ts E-B Eeb.Dtr r;^ A rr: q'-.-€
:EE€ir-8:E;sEba E€e iiEE*i:ss rE+97i€ H E H .93€sE
c.iNN
o.Oca)
d
6Hoxoh
0,)E56zN.\
F
:Fl
oaoF
(g
OJ
JoTT
..o
H(cIlroU
Uf U]'J4 0)
A!;ir
3ho.l .r-qoFo
o 0'l
o.!6o;'o.q
L(,
'o-o-lt^aqr
-d6obDai(6e'€trOE
cD 0J>*OH,P-o,O-
I qr.!,FQTis 0JlOu
/ #+i I UDH L A al \/
-g -,s ' 5.i'.!H o (s oH.!-!!Z>odU)P[.d!s-EOJHAAPl:.\A-|!-
6 *.r-F o tU'{*-- hs-rS'; fifl-{-I-d
f SE 6 E.UIH--H,5Ft''H Hr
L-!AxNIHJ*tsgJRd-to(,}\LJ i- UD Ur*!-
FFF. I Fs >-- F hFa-.t "qrY\l!
.E H *SEL gt.: H qEe R.c€oY'X tr (!><r(J (6 Nd co ,-'-
-C oo o.! Id\VvH/P,.cHHo-c or.H L: cid o.E _o .!" FF E;9E--3 E>JJH-_
i sE s,E 96 E\-,i - ("i $
- 0J; sq-ErFo f a{QJdI Cco !Fi'=:'d>- x* ;.rtrin Uui qJ
b gr !p{ .! ar**E :fi 3x) 3= bo-o: A '!: 'l .i.5b .9s 3:! \ 'IJd'i .9; 56-ii .c ci JqF.SOr"i djq F Yv o -\ tt4 r_is- px Ei.! 65 gO
v>LA ,!':.O P=s cHT b Y.s s?uob ++o iD-.s Ehi "€r c,l.-: d o"Ea-d gDE . :=,rti .! !\ \ uigN. > Hs s.FA P:'a 'EHANU\<il ^i €g 3t1"; i i KE9 93TE s X d_u6€ €sba ci o. .3f ASLnJ*ikS
89 s F S;< EAart.Y -s ".b - u - (tJ\v! l2>' sN -O : -l-O : s
E 5E E F{ Ergiti iI
I FI gI
$gE E iiai Itigggg EitEi iiitE tlit!i
Fr
0.\oco.m
-'ipctdG)-
tANL
-!F(.j'!Y
>=E3Er@C
'-L:3ya2!
Uo>\dA
!F
oiEo.vU)
!+,
:<iEK&_-EH'-o:XCAci.68troJbo F<9..= -'>.:>o
F-c oJ'!>
ts'69k
eAov
uE-!J
>'sp5 :.:ii<lJq
U5asCJ:(nq
$iE I gBgi gFIff
EHE SififfBH$t
g;t gss{g €f;siqi; ltE:EiR'Ei: #{$E,E':* E
rE!i{Qist €,F$;;6il t:+gEils=s: gE;E;iS;sFfi*5c[-[ gei=!''i :a;s;;BSrH sFs:tEE STS:g#[S$* rsSB;ss "s5-8.c5$iS F -EsXs E si. .Se:-u-Eid SSEEf ,E: *€ ^,N fl S ;
€i!$iriss i*l:HIg sE
it*igsIit€itEritEsEiHHE{iFIg sgi?*jH EtEHSo:a*a* EE3E9.sN ai1?E:E€5:i E;E:;# e F;;sEEEsg88 : s is;i.E rE
slt$$IE EEiEE rIflsrEii€ j !H€;i E*i
sFggi;E'lE!$'l-N t&Eib$*s;:F: =.$; f,iatEE€5EIt:i i:Ef *E;[i rs:EnE e:t
i't *ft9€Hg gE , HEj
EEFitE€BEtE€ f E!€
l*F*H$HHlieffilffi1li #fi* $ilgtfirlE=u*tfi=*guii
'**aEBE }gt$g il
lllttfiffi**3gffig-iffigtfi El*i * ii
'cJN*itra.i\so-fiox0JitrFtr'i \qU9T2. .^ :..',
-hsa' co ba
9>U\>
d.{i Uc.l Yi a o\'\ l-F\oa.Y\-:6^t
5 i'FN oo d":O6*U ^ \ 6!
t>Lv(dYF-(dUb. o_ _^\E6 r EiF.t o' bo ,^-o? = !Ui
-:90J-.trTlH- i HC. tr) caiF--id9. .s 9'd o. P"
-A*L.:UIN
* 6 z.E e ed)N=
igit i ig iE {iigifl#igiil iggi
iE i! ff Es= Ef Esi r;[s g=E!s tgEE
Ko' ...i 9oE*R $ 6.9-ii' a ,q€!rvSE J \HU.i9o*Y I !.,i ii-x *J -c.):: a) . ^.->\\
u 5 : aN>.i J Q-
^:; E ed-F9 e SE# 6 \N
o qOr= G Ae<P .9 l.
.g 'ii E S'E\oru ! .'q -!tJ+ q
- x)-'bo > *l9f F HO-2a> u ;>=t\la:-\AJ_::*09 :5 o: o3ro L> 4^\/6U*qlJA\(u. o F ; *Ehr A !.-
- #* J a
N EgO :. FA* >-9 ! i3LV9.^t-\ ;rn ! -: FUj nY e b-;oY "; I bo'i
Lr^VL!i),-'4t^t)! ! - .i>'F c-' - >
,i ari gl PCV ES U .spg2 c" $+ d F_wniE 8i- H 3'!<v) urs d_ cji r b\9 N * F - ^ ts\S * ; ; QF
gruff*pFiggffiiI;mgigi
ffF;$iifffffiiifiiff#iff;fsru$$fgffi$fffffffg;fffite *a: c
>9!oajjd- F*>ci
G&.;OJ U,^' >EO'p- ooE
ooc.)aY^f.boe x.! F,-!S-.,m(! 3.:
3e ix.* b- @ljcJ6.:l -r1 ii;69rlp
^trp.'OcJdd ,. g(dii5_"bLo,(6(dtH* o.qPbO
t-rqt
;KH
h;H
$+ESEE ! E EEi H6fi FFEIgIE ;F gEgIiEfS$:
;;gf I +t$;itEt#g* g+g$Eif i $EEiE{0rr€gin; ;iicr€tl€tilE gEffsn
EEi f$ifB*g
lii titiggggsiiisi$ii ii* l sigiiai; lgflt
liggglgllgi liiiigti ggl iigi
gill
<ticO
o.
.jo
\"sH0,)
roF.n
\_dHU)
gi;* i$;iasEggfrEii lgEi?gttggiri*; rEH$;t Fg$i ssE?s
iElEiE*$*;*frEat i:gHE$igir$rafg :
R;:s: rat*[sEff€is€;fi _fii{ itEEflfi f
f;lg 5ti5f;g$iigi9gg
=s li:;tts Eie
Ili auiEigi iifitssrEg iagElt*i;; iu'g$E
igagiggiiFui lig '*;
*u iEili ;*
=oo)i-i q>AU;6<-v>u-.o:e ta L d
-6 "'1 . q, .c
oE*i-dc.\:ulil idr$
--oV;iU\-A
'6 \.,,/i E (!
€ bbq R.EI qp: o.::-FL+9F t! o slh-444.\'
; Fri H!R€ €J dos*(EZL0)*L O -.\ .q €* ;s>E Et €e;ll oO
--O @
.^Pk-riN
E" 3# 6!so bF: p >-o-B EF'gEg>. - H .== 0rT <s t8Fa=.T erFq hi"q ^v-ul-9 !L T U
E E':o g" Pgc .5 .;'= cJei o sJ Ttt a.'Ed frhH; i. i6gi A+ c>H- lJci\ a) u o= * e-\ _ ..1^- c
69L
i ilstff il gii g
i ii;i i iit gigi lg
ggiFifgs;iii t gl
Fii gg
Fgi ggiagg
ifiFFi iiii I iEii iiE iiFF$
iI ! iiIt-.
.\ I : .--.i ,a-
N S,q J' d6.o.r v -i!e (, a.
> Sri .;^'5 .: ^ Y !-$:il E I i-^;A O 9 U
s s 6 E'V
o o \ /-;, o o; I u: FFE JI; :l€ .^-Hbo -o.! X JF.g u o; 6-3 83,1- Y:;Rl-Jv)O- H oJ-O *^X: - boo 6Ht ot.t F ^iI e5? E{I Eoo,. EFH H'i"a \qo !.ir ^, o C
'q .r i 8b Z4,.:tw6:.,(E:riC:g; F:V: BiSo ;9 or,r-E q€sR'8:E@ o.l tr:4. b0(J\", b0ii !a)Z ti *si E.u RP5y<.. 2 r .- ? P4::_ ) .. )-itr '^^* <d O Oo'6o9.5FC p- I.{d9 ScoF :58- ! . .R :- >\@ 5rOH.: -i r i.or\OLO.O!=-6 :-dd E ^ ? F-rj Xj dHJ & 2 u
iilit t ! l i iii ii l gfi g
; ti g#
l I
*lEEigHitfi il $iii ff I' I ags
;iE$E fIE i rsr E silgE {iliEiiiliii
i fti
ai gs
; t l l li lttiiiiiE ii *fiig
iiiFiFiil ifiii{iiff i$fllllgii iiiiii;IigtEfgg llgisf il€g;EFlig$iil if;ilfli *; iiqil
si gi gg iitggi;iii ii F$* ;ffiiii
igii i{ig* Es{grg rEE$*;$ifi FiEgi E$i;fIi
iiiEE fflEi igBEE{iE :t*;€ f i5=;;I€€EE1
tfftts;
FfgII €gf[i iggii$$$ E i Fi$fi iiiii E €ii
.fult
Io
'oACJ
,y(J(!
to
\ti
\Do
fld
b\osco$o\g3i::o-o>(!gr(!
oiH}
VU^r boL,/ di I
g; ig* E !
i s r{
j iiEliagi E iiiit lii i
bo€hs 6dro 3(, 1l J4
U-LAU+- o.)
^:* =o\O (god Fo rj
gN.ti\N E En9 b 5o:' M <\{-5.j .'h <
\/L<G.
-'xMl\'d ^
'n"hv s Io .XN 0J
M4 .i- G
p a a\ !-.Y Sn 0J.^u.Hbs +,T o
S= S'3 S=!c; \ 0r
.:g!!6
E ,: . AJa- r'- JEt" Es SL>!H
tr6 cX 6boYi llj: g'lrgqJ€-v9 =d
goU.i FqEE J€ 5HqJ=X
- F.< + A6 guJ d v
ggiiiaiil iiasl iiilfi iigi iilii
o(6
FO
bo!
o
+U
)
B
bo
.o
q crjrs ro'usFqbQd
>vc'x.:cs --: .i>:\JZ\G
E€gEU iFE * g g: ;
BFiiEEEgi IEE;EIiiEgHgEt$I!
E;'g I f,:ii sigE ii siiir flii
'pg*gg;Iillig,
giigg ! fiiis +t;-iBt
ii€tci*;iE liE' gii3at gElttrTli*iflE
FI i ff Bii igE i i iiiEIgfigiiiI Fi i$ii
di3
o.roo\o\
I
=Li o.o,4ro
\ooo>;l<Y2
!E<rZd..I' ZNoJqJ5-6tro-b2SrdJ*Ssi R'i+^S9*tsLl
,+-Ro=sv\\vN€
Iiiii$f FI fi {iE$n
E rE EBa$ff ii
;;iisEi5;iEiiEj
; t ggIgas
n: i g gFi
i Ij agigi giiii
oUOJ(n
3OJ
^/roO'
!(d
k-o
c.)Fi-toSo!.soH
ES H ^H^g(Eo.,gq+OLLHN>'o - - .
E org'$ *(d 5 0J!. Eo iro- I rS e c FSL^.H W^
tr*->-q .p.. bO> t!9^9-Lc -=:J d'/u\.io X o-FtJ.:vA-. o !+HE 3€S.;g.E5X E.^'o J sAH ; .] { U
.Y E bO\U !o rO OPlltr tiJ ,zcJ'! , \bob l"s'{^'i 5 o \9e>= 6 R^!r
- d<Htr 6 9s q
:.Y !i I-r
C O.l e tt.er'.; sOu d.a di q)
!YV.itlHE ES9or G'i(r)4.i 9F:=ts
.!'- . Oi -F g 9os.!i.F t 6 ls'dF o.-O€ F*o N< !u<, 9 E ..1V uJi 0J
fi E ii g{gi li$i iliigaiiitigfiigg
Eig€i: j
: : ii BiiiiliiE1t ii lEiEgE Sti EEg€
sI i E sEE $tg?iFl1E aii;;EEliliiEgfi!
gIaIt igtgiltig [i
g i i;iE l
g ig{ € tis E E E
ilgrugg iffiiffffigggg *Firu
;g; ff gfggi
sagagiiff : ig fmii gi
lgffffigffiruiiimggigruiffim
/
E eEFESi Ei : c";z h-'*, 2ltr. r- L'- - =' 0J6r V 6 L -: -: L &L
-t'i L U= u S.u L\, .:i-*f 6x sEgs!! E.:=
o:. + i' i'i'l OE 3!:s1E **\ E*
= F S i .Esg-r!io-G 9.='6:i-o :HS-.^U:\.^
\ d obqiiri;i +)! -. F. >-cn o- bo 'CU YEcn- -(J -=t t', E p-*'E B6 :EEEf; A
= :EHE+S ;i TE$rrs Fi *Eg5s* E! dt->=--: =JA F''=€E,i- *sJ HS q o-s - t-q, F (,.^ s.: T
rf ^
O_ .5.='- A';G' FEE=Et =i-:,X CJ ! ri s s&E E:gs&S EgEa $E:=SS i:-A-:!O+!>-ut-t6\a t :- iw
= ^ *
=-tuF 3tsb:+;E ==.uta=r-i a=E-j -"-j; =''^J!\J:=--EE Zls-.'=i: !:?=*
.9.--7=i: -!;Fiar:-J{==aFV._--r--=t3,= - ==. r=" .I : I:-
Eir $-:i E;6i F $!!69$fiiiIE U# h; $l$d; !€:;5::I:; ;ETlE F*giCE r I: E*{i FEg: He;€;g* i n:H ! H:E *tt+ Ee E
= {g EiE 5t !it;=;;ii*gtE; $?gi FEgEi us
gl*E ;E*i ;iil* t'Efiit ffiu
E ;ggt?E ; i aggi i il EF E ifH q
Ei;€i Eli t*l#f g*:i?E€€€ iEsE;i;asisil;t: i:E:i: 5gt ?t
=f,i
p.Lo\
H9.
co\ocoti-oE
znlN
I
o
s-o
LU
E €iEiii qgE?ii{ltiEa Eg,
efi[fi$'!!.li;!t ii Blg;E 1€ti
iE :ei - r +;e
f;Ef,!3 :J
s€ EEs?affi!i?si iiElfi3E!$tlH$ lEii