does month 3 response to ranibizumab predict long-term

19
Does Month 3 Response to Ranibizumab Predict Long-term Response to Treatment in Patients With Age-Related Macular Degeneration? Presented at the Retina Society 53 rd Annual Meeting | Virtual Presentation | September 21-22, 2020 Paul Hahn, MD, PhD 1 Min Tsuboi, PharmD 2 ; Steven Blotner, MS 2 ; Ivaylo Stoilov, MD 2 1 NJRetina, Teaneck, New Jersey, USA 2 Genentech, Inc., South San Francisco, California, USA.

Upload: khangminh22

Post on 12-May-2023

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Does Month 3 Response to Ranibizumab Predict Long-term Response to Treatment in Patients With

Age-Related Macular Degeneration?

Presented at the Retina Society 53rd Annual Meeting | Virtual Presentation | September 21-22, 2020

Paul Hahn, MD, PhD1

Min Tsuboi, PharmD2; Steven Blotner, MS2; Ivaylo Stoilov, MD2

1NJRetina, Teaneck, New Jersey, USA

2Genentech, Inc., South San Francisco, California, USA.

Disclosures

• Financial disclosures:− PH: Consultant: Allergan; Consultant: Dutch Ophthalmic DORC;

Consultant/Speaker: Genentech, Inc.− MT, SB, IS: Employee: Genentech, Inc.

• Study disclosures:− This study includes research conducted on human subjects− Institutional Review Board approval was obtained prior to study initiation− Funding was provided by Genentech, Inc., a member of the Roche Group, for the study

and third-party writing assistance, which was provided by Fiona Nitsche, PhD, CMPP,of Envision Pharma Group

2

Summary

• Vision gains in patients with nAMD treated with ranibizumab in the HARBOR (NCT00891735) clinical trial were examined− Patients were categorized based on their vision response from baseline at Month 3

• At first glance, mean BCVA gains (at a population level) may appear stable across 24 months

• However, analysis of individual patient responses demonstrates considerable variation over the 24-month period

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; nAMD, neovascular age-related macular degeneration. 3

Month 3 vision outcomes for an individual nAMDpatient are not highly predictive of long-term outcomes

The HARBOR Trial Compared Monthly and PRN Ranibizumab in nAMD for 24 Months

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; CNV, choroidal neovascularization; IRF, intraretinal fluid; LD, loading dose; nAMD, neovascular age-related macular degeneration; PRN, as-needed; SD-OCT, spectral-domain optical coherence tomography; SRF, subretinal fluid.

Treatment-naïve patients withnAMD and active subfoveal CNV (N = 1097)

0.5 mgMonthly(n = 275)

0.5 mg3 LD + PRN

(n = 275)

2.0 mgMonthly(n = 274)

2.0 mg3 LD + PRN

(n = 273)

Re-treatment criteria for the PRN groups:≥ 5-letter decrease in BCVA from previous visit or any evidence of disease activity on SD-OCT (SRF, IRF, or subretinal pigment epiretinal fluid)

4

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The present analysis examines patients from the HARBOR trial, in which treatment-naïve patients with nAMD and active suvfoveal CNV received 0.5 mg or 2.0 mg ranibizumab either monthly or PRN (PRN retreatment criteria: if they exhibited a ≥5-letter decrease in BCVA from the previous visit, or any evidence of disease activity on SD-OCT, defined as SRF, IRF, or subretinal pigment epiretinal fluid.)

Key Clinical Question

5

Do Month 3 vision outcomes in patients with neovascular age-related macular degeneration

predict long-term outcomes?

Presenter
Presentation Notes
This analysis aimed to answer the question: Do month 3 vision outcomes in patients with neovascular age-related macular degeneration (nAMD) predict long-term outcomes. This was to determine whether these early responses to treatment can guide optimal therapeutic management.

Methods

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study; nAMD, neovascular age-related macular degeneration, PRN, as-needed; RBZ, ranibizumab. 6

1057 patients with nAMD who received RBZ (0.5 mg/2.0 mg monthly/PRN) in the HARBOR trial

Treatment arms were pooled for analysis

Patients were categorized into response ‘lanes’ based on BCVA response at month 3

<5 ETDRS letters 5 to 9 ETDRS letters ≥10 ETDRS letters

• Baseline demographic and ocular characteristics were assessed for the Month 3 response groups and evaluated for between-lane differences

• Outcome measures included:• Mean change in BCVA from baseline at Months 3 and 24• Mean BCVA over time by BCVA response at Month 3• Mean change in central foveal thickness (CFT) from baseline at Months 3 and 24

• Sensitivity analyses were conducted in the ranibizumab 0.5 mg monthly and PRN arms

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The present study examined 1057 patients with nAMD who received 0.5 or 2.0 mg ranibizumab either monthly or PRN during the phase III HARBOR trial. Treatment arms were pooled for analysis. Patients were categorized into response lanes based on their BCVA response at Month 3: <5 letters, 5 to 9 letters, or ≥10 letters. Baseline demographic and ocular characteristics were assessed within these groups, and were evaluated for between-lane differences Outcome measures of the present analysis included: Mean change in BCVA from baseline at month 3 and month 24 Mean BCVA over time by BCVA response at month 3 Mean change in CFT from baseline at month 3 and month 24 Sensitivity analyses were performed in the RBZ 0.5 mg monthly and PRN treatment arms

Response Lanes Were Determined by Month 3 Vision Improvements From Baseline

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study. 7

35.6%

20.2%

44.3%

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

<5 letters 5 to 9 letters ≥10 letters

Patie

nts

(%)

Mean BCVA Improvement from Baseline at Month 3 (ETDRS Letters)

n= 376/1057 213/1057 468/1057

Presenter
Presentation Notes
At Month 3, patients were categorized by their vision gains from baseline. 35.6% of patients gained <5 letters, 20.2% of patients gained between 5 and 9 letters, And 44.3% of patients gained at least 10 letters.

Baseline Characteristics Were Similar Between Patients Improving <5 and 5 to 9 ETDRS Letters From Baseline at Month 3

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity, CFT, central foveal thickness; CST, central subfield thickness; CNV, choroidal neovascularization; ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study. 8

Patients with ≥10 letter gain at month 3 were on average:younger, had worse BCVA, had thicker retinas, and had a smaller lesion size

<5 Letters(n = 376)

5 to 9 Letters(n = 213)

≥10 Letters(n = 468)

Age, years, mean (SD) 80.0 (8.2) 78.9 (8.2) 77.6 (8.3)

Mean BCVA (ETDRS letters) 55.1 (13.0) 55.4 (12.0) 52.5 (12.8)

Mean CFT, μm (SD) 333.3 (146.8) 326.8 (129.7) 362.0 (146.6)

Mean CST, μm (SD) 372.4 (129.9) 361.6 (105.6) 392.7 (119.3)

Total area of lesion, μm3 (SD) 3.8 (2.4) 3.4 (2.1) 2.9 (2.0)

Total area of CNV, μm3 (SD) 3.6 (2.3) 3.3 (2.06) 2.8 (2.0)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
On average, baseline characteristics were comparable between patients who improved <5 and 5-9 ETDRS letters from baseline at Month 3 when patients were assigned response lanes. Patients who gained ≥10 letters from baseline at Month 3 were, on average, younger, had worse BCVA, had thicker retinas, and had a smaller lesion size.

At the Population Level Patients Stay in Their Lanes

All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN). Mean change and 95% confidence intervals.BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity. ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study, PRN, as-needed. 9

-10

-5

0

5

10

15

20

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24Mea

n C

hang

e in

BC

VA fr

om B

asel

ine

(ETD

RS

Lette

rs)

Month

<5 letters 5 to 9 letters ≥10 lettersMean BCVA Improvement from Baseline at Month 3 (ETDRS Letters)

7.2

-1.6

17.4

-2.6

7.1

17.4

Presenter
Presentation Notes
After patients were characterized by their response to treatment at Month 3, populations remained divided. The population of patients who improved ≥10 ETDRS letters from baseline at Month 3 maintained greater mean change in BCVA each month through Month 24, while those who improved 5-9 and <5 letters maintained their lower gains, respectively.

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 10

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
However, at the individual patient level, there is notable movement between lanes. *CLICK*

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 11

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
At Month 24, 38% of patients who had gained less than 5 letters at month 3 had changed lanes, with 21% improving to a gain of ≥10 letters. *CLICK*

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 12

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
80% of patients who gained 5-9 letters at Month 3 had moved either up (45%) or down (35%) lanes. *CLICK*

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 13

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Finally, of patients who gained ≥10 letters at Month 3, 80% remained in lane, but 11% declined to a gain of <5 letters from baseline at month 24. *CLICK*

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes: 38% of patients switched lanes by Month 24

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 14

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

In total, 38% (355/931) of patients switched lanes by Month 24Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
In total, 38% of patients, or 355 out of the 931 total, switched lanes by month 24.

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes: 38% of patients switched lanes by Month 24

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 15

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

In total, 38% (355/931) of patients switched lanes by Month 24Of these, 58% (206/355) moved to higher lanes

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Of these 355 patients, 58%, or 206 patients, switched to a higher lane.

At the Individual Patient Level There is Notable Movement Between Lanes: 38% of patients switched lanes by Month 24

BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis. Data from HARBOR trial. All treatment groups pooled (RBZ 0.5 mg monthly, 0.5 mg PRN, 2 mg monthly, 2 mg PRN)BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; PRN, as-needed. 16

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5 to 9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 62% (n=202) 17% (n=54) 21% (n=69) n=325

5 to 9 Letters 35% (n=66) 20% (n=37) 45% (n=83) n=186

≥10 Letters 11% (n=45) 9% (n=38) 80% (n=337) n=420

Total n=313 n=129 n=489 n=931

Notably, 80% (337/420) of patients that had gained ≥10 letters at Month 3 stayed in their lane at Month 24

Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Notably, of the 420 patients who achieved ≥10-letter gain at Month 3, 80% or 337 patients, remained in their lane at Month 24.

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; CFT, central foveal thickness; ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study. 17

Decreases in CFT From Baseline at Month 3 Were Maintained Through Month 24, Regardless of Month 3 Vision Response

-146.9

-169-182.1

-138.8 -142.8-156.7

-173.7-184.7

-191.4

-250

-200

-150

-100

-50

0M

ean

Cha

nge

From

Bas

elin

e in

CFT

(μm

)

<5 letters 5 to 9 letters ≥10 letters

Month 3 Month 12 Month 24n = 375 213 467 347 193 446 320 185 416

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Across all groups, robust CFT reductions from baseline at Month 3 were maintained through Month 24 regardless of Month 3 vision response.

Findings from the Ranibizumab 0.5 mg Monthly Treatment Arm Mirrored Those of the Pooled Analysis*

*Similar trends observed in the 0.5 mg PRN treatment arm.BCVA response shows notable movement between response groups from M3 to M24 (numbers in red text). All patients with BCVA score at both M3 and M24 included in analysis.BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; M, month; PRN, as-needed. 18

All Treatments Pooled Change in BCVA at Month 24

Change in BCVA at Month 3

<5 Letters 5-9 Letters ≥10 Letters Total

<5 Letters 60%% (n=47) 20% (n=16) 20% (n=16) n=79

5-9 Letters 29% (n=14) 31% (n=15) 40% (n=19) n=48

≥10 Letters 7% (n=7) 9% (n=9) 84% (n=83) n=99

Total n=68 n=30 n=118 n=226

In total, 36% (81/226) of patients switched lanes by Month 24Moved up lane(s)

Stayed in lane

Moved down lane(s)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
A sensitivity analysis examining only those patients who received ranibizumab 0.5 mg monthly was performed, and the findings mirrored those of the pooled analysis. Here, 36% of patients switched lanes by Month 24 in comparison with the 38% identified in the pooled analysis. Similar trends were also observed in an analysis of only those patients in the 0.5 mg PRN treatment arm.

Conclusions

• Patient-level data indicate that month 3 vision outcomes are not predictive of long-term nAMD outcomes− At first glance, population-level data may falsely suggest that month 3 vision outcomes are

predictive

• Nearly 40% of patients changed BCVA ‘lanes’ after month 3, with most showing vision improvement; of these, approximately 60% changed to the higher vision gain lanes

• Further biomarkers are needed to predict the long-term nAMD outcomes and optimal timing for switching to novel-mechanism treatments when available

BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; nAMD, neovascular age-related macular degeneration. 19

Presenter
Presentation Notes
From this study, we have determined that while population-level data suggest that month 3 vision outcomes are predictive of long-term nAMD outcomes, patient-level data do not support this observation. Nearly 40% of patients changed BCVA lanes after month 3, with most showing vision improvement. Of these, approximately 60% change to the higher vision gain lanes Further biomarkers are needed to predict the long-term nAMD outcomes and optimal timing for switching to novel-mechanism treatments, when available.