Then and Now: Sun yong Interviews Susan Haack/' Guangdong Social Science 2 (2014): 6-24.

[m ~J ~~~*~~. ~•·+~~~r~m~~~~~m~~~~~~~~£~. ~m~~

~~~~~~•~~~"+~~~~#~**~~~~m~~~~~~~~~±. ~•M.~~.~

~~t~A~~~~#m~~~. &~rAm~~m~~a~~~A~~±~~ft~#m~*J~

~"+~~~. "~~~m~~#~" ~-~~±~19~~*~*~~*~~" ~m~~$~~-#

,\l'. ~Jf 0- il<- , ,rn ;~f. - :tl' '"F 1H-J;.. :;'; ; 11; Jg 0- il<- , 'e; 1$-J~,tf. -1- >t(. ~ ~ a'J ~ fJ: '!i.L*. a'J ;fUJrJ ~ " :?i ~ ~ m ~ ~ -41

~*~~~~~-#~*~&~OC~: ~~·~~~£«~~*~~$.~~#~&~~**~~~

M~~&~. -#•~~~•~~~~~~~~. -#~~~~~~~~~~~~*~· ~a-#~

_;p,J·-ftJ!i1ta0 )·~.'1., o/.';- ~-i.J. .. f.J, -"JJ~J;l:.iinJ l!iJ ~flU.!. w;?rt;fYLf.J ~m ~~g~~hi ~ s0-1'*4!'t,t±~iiiA

~"~*~$%~m~~. ~~~~m~~~#~,t£.~~~0M~*.~~~~-~~~~~~m~

~J!Ji~1F., ~ ~ lr- ±MJ ,X:·!M?i ;fL ~;m ~~~ -1'-;JJ:'if," --~~ JJ'§.)f<.a{J~*1Htc.., 11L1.:fiJ,f\-xt1t"

[~e~J *~~m~~ ~~± 4~M ~~ ml!iJ ~*

[r:j:IJ!15J'-~~J 13087 [)Z::~}(t~iR1i!:J] A [:s'C~UU~J 1000-114X (2014) 02-0062-13

Jlj\r)JJ(: Pit)l~)C:JS't' 1~H! i]j·i~j·f~{-EEf'l't!=fHi!~:f~M1&~8{JiJ]i!R,J 1~1£ r:j=1J~:Jgf$Jf-f'f1~~8{J~;g

oc, f~rj{J~fF nn~:J,g-$} 0)to HiEtm.53~n}'2l~i:E!=f oo e.~~~it!±lJW, 1~xt~OOw!f1t*Jili:x n'gtJtUdiJI)·c:, 1&~ 1 Jilt!:ry.r:-t~·J:V;t-tf-J·:t~~iari{J o;t.>z., JiQ.JIJl 1J1iZ:9J-~HLt-:X.t?.~~-x:tfu» ·r 2001 ~r,::.

tEA~ !:8 lt&tl.:l±l Jt&,o(J.,

§ JAJ::. tx ~ t :5?: *-$1~~ lBz ~)C :JS't xt 1&~ ss * i}] U *' 1 , s~· !'sJ B i'S:. ii ~ 7\ if T '0 f.lt :liJl 1~ 1± 1rt tx. iJJ i1R

I=J=l, ~~~TM~M~~*ffl~X.#~m&~~~£~~~~0

~:R::f.ltm~~~~~i!R.#~W~f'fm~~~!=fOO~~#Mm-®~Mof.lt•~.f.lt~~

N~UM~~~ffl~X.~~~H~.~~~~WB.~ii*ffl~x~~*ffl~X.~=+M~~~

ht, f;j~rJJ~JI:J +x:tr: !1lf-\;;J'.I t~** 8{Ji]iJ.l~l:?

#~:M~uf.lt~%-~M~*ffl~x~~~J::.~-®~&un~~-*~i:EM~(~~

62

---- ----- ---

9;J] i,Ji, i-f::~ ( contemporary theories of knowledge) ( - * :tE 9=r 00 ~ lf!.lt11 io¥ # lf if§~~ p~ 1¥1 -=1=5 ) xt '* ffl .:E:X.lf!.:JW),Jma'J1!-ffi9=r, ~&:/J\±2Js:Af2/Gt:fBt'*ffl.:E:X. 'B~~f!AI¥15R~, ti1/G1~~mwrt~~¥F, re ;$;ffl.:EX~~ffl~~m•~;#~&:/J\±i¥1.:E~~~~'*ffl.:EX~~.~I¥1lf®m~~~~'*ffl

3::: 'X. i.P ~ 1¥1 '5) o rm 1~ :tE Om~;$; ffl.:E 'X.~ - ::t 9=r iA J;; , 1E ~ &: /I\ § iX iJ I A T " ;$; ffl 3::: 5C' J3: 1-i'l:iJ, # ~:tE "$;$;J:, ;$;ffl.:ExA~t:lf!lf!. B?~~~ &:/I\± lit*~ 1868 - 1869 41BJ 8{]tll~® & Tif-F /I\ .:EX a'J~~ it::t 9=r, VJR OQfilJ {~;yj(;ffJ a'J x.m~trr!ltT~ c 1878 > - x 9=r ·c, (ii);yj(;ffJJt3[,Glzit-~Q1i1J i-¥ ~&:/J\±:tE~OO;$;ffl3:::51...9=ri¥J~m~~ffl? C~T*~~-~;$;ffl3:::51...1¥J~~Z*.&:/J\±~~

:tt vJ Fo '* ffl.:£5( 1¥1 tt~ 9=r ~~ ,'G ¥F a'J ~ p~ ~ ~ m?) Pfcf51: i'~¥J\Z7sr "0~J~-;$;ffl =t:51...~flf£5C' m, Jlk·· -:Jmlt!t:fE: 19 JIHC.?1ZA'J~l~IB""?'=~iYJ, -~

*~f19~~m4~W.&:/J\±~~mwr:tt~Pm¥ffl~~~~~rmJ:~-~$1¥JW~o&:/J\

l:fiif.J;'Ql:J:Y!friWIHffiiNtl, Jl;JI=Li~Y...hir:' 1Hl:: ·t1/ 1 }l\;lo\J·H1~, rni Jl: ·T1/1'}:~J~1**, rrrH1::JgJJ"It, '~{;zJ~:;~:JiltE

~>J<:;'f,5f...I¥J;$;~5f~~*8'J?iJnU 9=r u :tEJJ:t, fgi~~ ffl.:£5( n'Jt~ ,L.,JJH~, 1±&:~~ :::t lit* =f 1878 ltf:~ 1¥1 { ~JJfilJ f~f.JGffJ E!{] x.m~1f~rfl1fr ~ cv -­

X9=r1~~UT§{XIlfiJSJ3; 1ilrf:Ef§Fo--X~9=r~~JJ:tj(tfa:i£:1-J "--;J\x, "f::"*itTf.JG-1[ [:tf~ "'n· t ~": l.ffil. W: 'l':l) J Jl=j =r:::. :i'c FR :::1::: 1'1 /v .r~,, -I':· jet J]:l:::. vm 2.1 " @:< lr=J ·of~: ':k ~~"''Il-l·,:": ·illr 1'1 60 " 'JJ: 133 =i= 1'1 " .•. ; 21 , ev F"-111. --~ :f "1; .... ....,/J'- i=J Y- J 7"FIJ ~L . .A-1"-=-t IJYJ\ 1· 71~ .:-:.1\lUnn o ·l~--f-"C.J6JJ>II ~="- .:/ ,c.,., .An~ ~ FIJ ..:.J_.A yPJJJ-UJI=t

#* :tE EWJJU ::t;zJs: 9=r tl:l JJ\l , 11~ 1898 4 ~~~WT ;t :tE fJg ~ s'J tl¥€~ ;fQ ;$; ~5f %010 - ::t 9=r f~ffl T J3: 1-WJ-J~: J'E:)-}·i£J J;E. [ &: jJ~ · i·: E!'J ltP.1Sr. u 'w fLI ¥U 1903 {[0 &: jJ< I: ;(:r: rl# till A ·7: ?J;if vJ: HJ , :;j· ),J J;!fz 7}~ i_A l'cl 12 Jg

~ffl~51...1¥J~~A.~:tE*M9=r~m,QW~:tE1~84~atl:li¥J~~~*@~~~~.ill"Fo

*;ffl~~- ·i%~1U%B~Flt~, ~ 'Bff] 8'J33~~ ~J=rqo~TiJ VJJ~t~, J~1J)U:H 8{]~% fB~Y~T ·;fuL ·•®

&:/J\±Fo*m~~i5t 1mzm u1st~tJ£~15em 1878 4tR:tl:ll¥1 "~ m.:Ex, -ii'il, ~~ZS~ 7srfm/G .&&:tEx2Js:9=r1~ffl;!twJT8'JT§"~J:I¥J~51..., tEI.'L'B~~:i!1-iffl E!'J:®'ffi~E!'J, ~~T§"~i¥Jffl1*¥ffi¥~ o ®:tf~ 7CE!{] 8 ';f~i-8-r=F, "~ffl.:£51..." E!'J;'f,}~,~ "3};$;8], ~,c_,;tx1l:Zitrm~~~IJ1U E!{]"; :tE&:/J\±~fF

E!'J41-t, "~ffl~Y..." :tE:® 1it~i-B-9=r E!{]§~;W:J~,~~£ 0-A&~: "* § ;t;zfr I¥J:i:1)t=ffJJf' u

J3:~WI¥Jffi~@~*SJ3,~/J\~*~~~~~£J:Eu~~,Jt/J\±~l'[":J'Et:~-~Jsr~}tj

.:EX 'Buftfl A a{] 5R~", 02' &: /I\± 3 st aM~ 1~ EJX:itr~ tl:l ~AJiJf WJ 9;p s'Ji*ig; aJts *, 1m 91 AT -1-miffl

"~~Jc 3::: x " -:tE 1905 4 tl~ ~ ~ ~ E!{] it 9=r , 1lli i.£ 113 ~ ~ J! 1- ii'il ~~ " ,~ ~ J:l ~IN VJ 1i2. :i~Uf~ ~, -**~1t!!.t#1~E!'J~ffl 3:::51...1e#o 1E!&:/J\±:tEJ3:~il59=r8'J § E!'J, lE:tWft!!. -t)t1¥fJ:g:J;lQ.*~ E!'J, /G~~re1m2Js:A~Jifm:l'tffEJX:;f±mlt:!4Uirr:W~~. ~~t!L/G~~~OOE!{]i!t:ilt~ffl.:£51...~ F. C. S.

r.ti11:!4H¥r w.~~, rm ~~it§ B ~JEff::tE::t~AA f!J9=r E!Jxt "~m .:EX" -iffl a{]1Jlii:ffl:!4u¥¥r w.rs~u'l? :ilt-~.~/J\-~~iAJ;;,~WWT~~ffl3:::51...~~~ffl~~mi¥1M~J:.&:/J\±$~~u~

~5fJ:, &:/J\±fn~fti#mt~te:J3:~?iJniJ;;gfr:~m.:Ex1J1~1:ETff~9=r E!J~,c_,. ft7sr-#1t~~;W:Y...s{]

~rmJ:~$~1¥11J~.mJJ:t~¥J~m~~ma~¥J,rm~~-#~~~~T§"~M~I¥1~xi¥11J~.m

~t~i'lkl¥1u #13., ft!!.ffJtHe:"f::"m~~JJlHI¥£~: ~mm~if {~ffl.:£5/...~~r'ifn {~J!s'J;W:Y...~ r=F 0";

rm&:/J\±~lf!.,:tt<~M15e:f.JG11JI¥Jm~m~~ 9=r.~~~m. "~~-~~-m~*~•Jti¥JA '"'rr ~Si§'frhi§i- m ->;;;.s 'fl.}l'JI1r:::'EElfrh-;!;f:rm "db' 1'lfJ-::t:)(.IPJ,.,dl:J,.,,_I}t:,, )i'yl./E':J'..>(; rl 1/llFJ P~~J'.X.u

~ZS~JJ:t.illl:t~t, ~/J\¥Ci:t:tt-~a'JJ3:®•1R. §JIG~te:~m.:EX~[i'fJ~~mwr, ;t±.ootfQc. 1. x!J ~WTI¥Jm~.~Fo~~&:/J\±1¥Jm~:tE~~1fJ*)t~~~~&~ffl~51...1¥Ju:i!~F~I¥J~~u$

~J:, &:/J\±a'JT§"~x.m,8/G[i'fJ~JifmWTs1. J3:#/G;W:~;@f1m~ "&~m 3:::51...~", ~~~:lLJE ~J3:

63

f¥-;ff1EfU;£-iE:t!Q~Bf£iliHf-:ctsf.J, j!1-f13U;£:£HrHR8f.J-JffftHJ:WT£-1'1{iEsf.J, 0-0\sf.J~ffl

~~~.W~~±~:f&v~ill~~~MB"J-0\~~~A~~B"J~~~H~#.~~~.~~ffl~)(

~M~.~~±~~m~T~~B"J~~~~M.WJffftHJ:WT~~~m~T~~B"J·~~~~o

{.§_£, ~~~*· ;ffi-$~:*8f.Jfil]~£{i3-0\1sr~ffl~5(.£-#'fg'~~i5?.f**, ffij!.iE£~~±

5fi:JJffftHJ:WTl!£tk:&xtB"Jo ~~af.J~ffl~)(~-~t~af.J£~~±, JfiftHJ:WT, ;f±,OO(;fQ*:f.t-ss~~

~~~~-;ff'fg'~~~B"1m~=~~~~5Z5fi:IS~=*~B"1&~.~~~~~8"J'fg'~~~B"1~~

~5<.~~~-#~·~**W~£:ct~B"JM~.-;ff~~~B"Jtl~~005fll~~B"J~@. ~H-;ff

-0\J{~~*~B"JWmo•:*~~ffl~)(~G·M~~B"J-~~~~~~~~~:~ffl~)(" •• ··· ·1-!it'r§ lffi!.E!f.J/Eifi~, :\llirfiJJc~E!f.JuHSJ o tE ·1' J%i8J1I!.1~z rlJ ~l:ZfJI.\ ·1' A:tr:'1cJ J[;;ft{rrt;!=i.~=: ·r --1'

17§-fSJJilJf'~-1-AiENfB~Ysrf~fCPtnW; m --l"D§-ISJ£1t~~iE~~**f?0{2js:sf.J·t'£JJB: ... v fi3ifJ~~3m:1f

j!}}]~J£ Jfifi. mr=r A tf~lHJJt~~:ct·t: u,@ :r~ifJ Jilt:~''! Jlfj f'I'* ;:~:~ t: scm· Jnf:x•J1'Ff··?: rru ~ nf.J 1 · ·lffil :IlJJ_!f'l-;fQ ~;f1 !1

r~B"Jfi~~~:m~ill~@~mm.~~m~~@B"J:*~~fi~~~5fll~JJB:ttB"Jfi~~*~·

1i3 ifJ 1§-:1f ~ ~ 0

1-'N!TJ<: ~ffl~)(i;?.J{JJ.*i!B:~~~iiE~, #~~~Wi:izt1g "~1fJJ.Il,~~~sMxH~it" }j)il:iJ~

:tr: J::f:l(;1fJ /G i'J~&:i1 *iS~ , ·1-{ii:f;Q: ~:1f ~)( 8f.J EI..X: ;fg; J!Hf i¥J iili :t~~~!lVtJl t:J 1sT t£. v 8~ 1HStrr. ~ffKftliH~~ J§'

JJ.sf.J~:Izt C:lm;ffl-~m-0\:1>JB"J'1~.) ~3&7 "~xJ\.\~5(.", l?f~ "Pi~~"?

Pit 5l : ·§r )'c :f~ ~ ib~, fEEl jJ\ :1:: 8f.J 1EJ!cU.lli~ i'I"X# .LI-. (:rf.J~J''C~J§ ~trJU\. ifJ ·· · 3& ~:'iii~ sf.J ~J§ :l&:Jil.

af.Jx.m~~~i~J{JJ!W~, _!::]JffftHJ:WTB"J:J=EJ{JJ.ft!Hl¥:1-J~ tiE~·t':Esf.J~~Pi~i~1tW~ af.JiJ?.l'Yj. ~Ht±.ootaf.J

"iJ\nff~" (tried and true) 8f.JIJl~)(JtJ1.fll!t~~fs], £&:1fr:ifJ~(:jf.Jj!~·ti:, -!E.:ff.H[jff(:jf.J~:lfo 11.;

&~~~.~~~~±,JffftHJ:WT5flltt.ootm~•.£~*~~~·~~~*~Ysrnr.mj!f¥~£~

MB"J, '8~M~fJG1fJ~iEri5J*J{J1.8f.J1'l~, ~ff,Jt£-l-5?., 1~:1f*ffl ~5Zaf.Jil5l*, ~JJ.fm~Q*-1-fri

~tf:~sf.J~~*M#/G~af.Ji~*u 1i3ifJ- A~~IAI!l~ ~ C.IM9'8f.J:1f~, *~~JE Ci~m~J1.1'l~) JlJT{ijk;£EJ{J*[§"o

~~±~~~B"Jffl~tt~*~=~~~=m-~~~~*:1f~m--t-#~B"J~h:M=~~

~*~ili~~~~B"J~h;@9~~-~A~fm7·~~@ffl~~~*~*¥~~~~*~~~.

~~~~m=~m.~~ffl~)(~~mu~~_!::J**~~.~~±*.&&£-~"~5<.~"

af.J~~, R~¥um=~~sf.J~~~tt, 1t!!.xt1~~t!:~* -t-eP~ffl~5ZIVI'm~sf.JJ{JJ.5fll~~t-l~a1

fm~.~~*·~~~~~~f-*8"1.~: R:1f~~~~~~-HIT~A-J&~-~-~~£~~.

~~:lf}t£~i~•Jll.af.Jxt*o &~~

~~.j!-t-fm~/G£~:1frn~.ft1t£.'800~~~~±~~Ysr•*~~~~B"J~~=#~

~-®_!::J;ct~~*B"J~~frJ~C~~.~~~-~m~~B"JmA-t-~s~rrT~&~~>oj!®

frJ~~00~~112Ff~~J{I:lP{~1. 1EI.;ft1{11I~Xltiltt1'if~(:Jf.J~~*1iiH~u ~~±8f.J@l~£. ~ifJ1f£

~y:1fey~~j!®frJ~~~~ili*~*W:#-~*·~*j!¥f-~~~~1{m*~X~-~.

~~.Z\, j!-'i"frJ~:lf}t{ijk;£~ffls1•5<.® u {.§.j!-@l~xtiCf~ A*i5?.112Pf ~/G9 A?ifJJ. C §~. ~J§ _r..t 8=1 +b Mf,T " 7 i=R """- \'! " -';.);. AHP '<Jil ft"' 7 'X ± \'! fr/,1 " ; I tr:n il§f \'I " _Hi: -==-A;;'=' 18:i " -/=;" il§f \'I " ')!: -

PJ 3:'.18 P~ *m J[fi,_A. ii',;u z;: I"JI.:IZ.flt* llL=/'-. P~ l!\7'1-l ,..,,/'-.. 'IT', 7G ±. A 19 'F.l '"'' /'-.. JC.

tm sf.J il '*~ mrt > o

~~@]~~B"J~~=-~_!::j~~.~~~±~*·;ft~~£~~tlB"J.~~~~#~~~~

tt~1*ll::.B"J~~~t~~-¥Y:miJ\ af.J *® u@ C j!£~~ ~ 1* 815!:a i%1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ± 81lf.M W -F JL i1::Jc

64

9=t 8':J-$:5t, 1:E1JfHlL 1£1-F JL~jUF J5Jtttiif8':J'ff~:5t JZi: 1251 ~$: jy\ ±#.l\/91£1-F jj\ "~~ 8':1" 1-A3:: X.B{] ~JllHff-l1L) &;j {.§.Ez:j]\±FJ~~H J3Jiftl~:7c{5fHij :l:-tl!.ffi.iA8':J $:Ell! "~~o.tlt:i!~, 7ci-t;1~, :JJtW:1f1iiJ AiA/9~~W:~~~~:i3:~" 0 , ~1:E~~~~~-i3tW:1f~A~~iA/9~~1:Eeo ~~. *~&: ~±B{]J!i~M~&~1f~3::m3::X.#W:~~~B{]~:5tv

1EJ.~. 1~8':JrPJJ@1b\-¥ ~§;~~-#i3Hli~-B:i.t~~-1-1~-m~ m8':1i3%fftt1J)l, :7tA~xt~mmB{] ~Jll!xJ\\8':J~fmu ~~HJ:WT:J'~~{;$:$:£11! ( ~P/9~8':Jift~2L 1§~~) !31EE~~Jl Oo~~B{]J3:-·11:J!JJ:) ~~**o~re:Jtl3a1t~~~~~~~tt.~~~~Am~~-~B{]. w~~B{]~~~~~.~

mwr~:JJo~t:'lt~f2ls:J!i~. ffl1m8':1i?iiR.fik1±i.iE~tt~9=t~7sr~a':1, 1.tz7sr1ta':1®' 0 ~r~. :13:#~~ Jf:~~ ~::rc rn xit o 1§ 5t, Jdn r~ ~ 11 ~ fPJ : l~ T " ~ 1JJ£ .ill!: 7F /9 11" z 51!- , " nH.iE ~" :"§: ~ ;;®' 1-r 7,.? -~~!TJIJ~1:E$J11!~~1~J:£1ffi'~~~Er':Jl!W:~89 Bt{~ u {EJ.:i3:.m~~iii't;:i3: ® LV-RA{il!,fPJ~B{]:l:ill }fo

:JJt-!~, ~~HJ:WT89Tiii--~iJ5:@~ T 1~xt1m89:i3:#Jll!ill~, ~p "~B{]JK"® ······ Q~~1fJ 89,1[Sl, ~#U:T.J:\:89;f..Z~§:zit", {liJik, ~~Hfr\i:U7'ti}J-ZJ.lt~r"J~. J]fJG01LQ{I'f~:tillbt:E!I\:i~Jf: -1-~fW~. t~~tt·f

*i.R.: "/.r{!... f&Jk!f:@:foJlJt~1-~t:VtE~89; 1251:7sr/.rf!:l:ill~JE§~!W89m~~¥fr, ~-JE~~

~1? AiV4J&~i'lt!.irm JE?Jf1f ~ill--- tv 8':1 ~MoL, %':¥fr. . . t:J ?i~ !±\ 1'19 Ji :c.\;, 1se- ~J(; ff] ?)CIIAJ<:1fJ fcj fiT 89 0 ito "®~~HJ:WT~f!~~f§:B'ir~, 9-~~Jll!xt~A~;f..Z~Zit, Jl;ft;f§1§~!§:~89; {lli5$.lfiil, ~~1§~

~~~~~m~~~~*~K:@B{]~~v~*~~~n~~~~re~~~~T~m.~-z..~~

•w"xt$~ffl?" B{]~J@.ill~m-~~m~J£TLV-~B{]~fi. *~~mMB{]~~m~3::m3::

)( !!J; Pi 1J(; i't; 89 ltGtl;: ~~ EI1'T y~ f:] '0

1:E «~$!:: ~1t89Jll!i't;} r:p ( 1938), ;f±~:J'~Ez:~±B{]J!iJli!JEX. "1.1JE~*BZ?Jf~~!3~1t6{]

A -3&1PJ;i1¥ts9;i1¥tm" m~n "~1!J£5C' Q @1EJ.J&, w~1~~mM-~. 1mirmrP1r5!iftil~~~-*~rli!Jrt~

5.1iUfiiJ~Jlll*5it, 5$.ifiil~~ff-i.iE~Jrt~5Erlfiilii1± 89~ iiE~'I1:o 1:E 1911 ~ 89- ~J"!JitJ:~ t=p, ;f±~ E! ~ E! BtE "~:f:Ei't;i¥1" (:;k:f::tf§~~f-ffhB) ;fiJ "PflA,,i't;89" (:;k:f:H§~ri%H't~) 89~Jll!t!W:~Z.

~AABo•~mM,tt~*~T~m~~~~~ifJJ@/9~;@~.~-8mM.~fi~~.~ift

~/9~~ "-*f~~;f!J?JI::@:~" 1[j0~§~fil$~~~~" :f:E~·Ifl~T. 1tB:J'~~Jll!£§fF ";f§K@JJ:ill", -#1:EJ!iJll!:fJJ~1:EzrSJ s9;f§K~~ () 011 :i3:1JJY.~r9:~~J61f~ 3::xJ\\3::X.W:ot~iB; r~rm, ~1iftl~~~. t± ~891!1t~~§~?&.&B{]-®Pi{,'j::)(W;Jtt~3::X.897C~-:lt~~i§l~~1fJ¥0{~89T-1-IOJ~,

{!j\~]c: ;f±~:f&X>J5'rJ\!.J,;P[Qj~:;k:89~ffl 3::5(# u 1:E:*~%li5HPJJ@89foJT~~fF9=t, ;f±~~ -1'~

* 89 ,I[SI, !~ , ff;ftfik~ifJ Jii ~ 1~ -M.%1 71~1±~1t 89 :Ef:lJt t:f *~ tfi--#'lf:lJt 3::5C {.§. ftM':J *{;$:i-t;~ :l:m ~~-~~~. ~Jll!:B{]~iA~~ili~~~B{]~mtt;f!J~~tto~m!ii~~M~~~B{]*~~~~

*~fmftB89iJd,Ri't;?

JJg-J?:: 1:E OflliE't'i89 ~3:JZ} -45 ( 1929 ~) :w 9=t, ;f±~:J'Jfdft T -1-m~ i~/J!If: :J&$:89%1-~,Ri-t;

M~#-.Mffim~;f!J~~±§;e*~ftmlii!Wu1:E:i3:#~~9=t.~~B{]-h~~R~~ftAB{]

~~.rm5it~B{]~fF. LV-~?Jf~B{]~~JEtt;f!J~~.*BZ~-~~*5it~u ~~~§&Txt~~-~

~;f!J~~JEttB{]~~.:i!#m~~~TMffim~,1£1-Fjj\~~E!B~~B{]iA~~B{]~~ott~~

~mili,:i3:#1i~~~~1:EM~B{]~m~~•m•E!5itJ¥J!Zi:~~~=~~~®%lmJ&~-~~B{]

%1m; ili~xt~~~~ttJ¥Jam.re~~tt~~~-m~~utt~~~:Jt-%1~~~~•~~~ B{]W$:~1ttt~mm~Au 1251~. §!Wxt~-M.m~B{]~m~v~. ffi.iA~~~B{],~-~B{]%Jm

65

,g,tt;t~2jq9:1§~iJUf1~$, # B.~~#i, ~~t!tWMJ:!f:!}J ( X!Jl~EI:lllt~tz:::i:®1tz\, NP:®tt~ 1t:i!1-*~xttJ~1-jfg~PrPJ) VJf.\.\Z1§8':J:!:tMiL t-§xt-Ttt-*8':1 "~:XJil~:fJ!H~", t±,®t~ixFo~QJ l~Milli

:izt 1:7-# 1i:!}J ~ a-g 9;Q iJH~;t~ o

~~~~~tl,®(;~~' "~-jfg~~~~~]f~#§*u~illlfg·~~~~~~~' ~~~

iJ:AJf~. ?Jf1§ At~i~jfg~IPJ-14$0 fillill-~iAn, ~Jt89:i!!:1i:J:I~~ff1PJ~tf:~tii:!}Jjfg~~ o"®

~~ffl.~:i!~ma-g~*•~~.~mT•t!t~~P£:®tt•:!}J~~a-g~~.m~•~a-g£~~ 8':i:XJil~fQi-Jt%! ( NP~:J'Jt, #~~%!8':1'/'IW*~, -E:u:@, ~f(J;!!J31~~~{yj;{~ili ~~1fJ1§1~f!Wik:jfg i'PJJW ~~a-gxm~~#);#.a.~m~~~~~*~~ma-g~%!~~~~a-g*~•~.~~%!~m~ ( :g)(; tl:mlt ~ xJ\i~ MJ , " ~lt! %? " ) tE- - t~' R tl: 1Jl11 :Ef r=!=~ \'Pi tJJ iH'I~ u

m~a-g·~~~~~*a-g£,:®ttT•t~t~.~m~~#~~a1tB; W:i!~~£~-#~

~.ffiJ'B)i\tSU·.: -1;;fX fX~:f.\i;1fJxtlltWFV?J,ii89f.l~lllfJ~J5X: Jx•J't:fi':JlH'H, 1ITiJHbt T·iA iJ~x·J~mh~JJ~;J=~ *..tB!z:':ftTxt*o ~*A5f1Jt. ~:i!~*JEt±mltiJtOOi~~IZ~ffJm~Jttl~#J'Jttt. ep P~!I&JJ.Ixt*m ~Jffit9t4: ( ~~-'~i:J!B:, ~)t1~ I El ~%! ~J(~iJ~ 8':1) ~f{jE J~t:~ m, mBIT!ff~ iU i!H~ ;fiJ ifJ ~~jj:J!B: -IE. ~if)Cy~~'jj:® o mVJ, ~~~~w~f-t!t~~~.IE~flr-#ui,t:.,~J(o fEL:tm*1lli1iftl~tr1f:f~.:Em

J'Jt lt ~ ;f171~ ~ 1*-~ ;!f~ ifrHffi.Jl: J: ~ El3 :JJ<;ffHt.l Jt 8':1 , :JJt 8':1 J3E r;iz ~5.3-~ t:i<:ili&: ~J\ 1: : " ~- · Jl:iE * T5' fJ:I· ~ m $:9iM*19:~1Ji!H-friU:i!~m~J.I, NPiJd,q-1-~IEX1*891i:!}JBY:1tTX>t*u fillffJ£A~~s9-M

'FlA. :J:j:_l~l. ... :JJt~JI::J=trl" ·IJL"® PI £ft~~1~1~tl~~, {Y.~m "!I&JJ!B:t!t~" 8':J~:XJI:jj:*~:iztBu IZSJ nf~~J\±-~, ~;if(

iAf~T~Jj (!!)(;1llim~~ "5'Hf!3o':J") $~, ;~~:fLHIHJ\\~5'~, ili1'F~i!f:friJ ( "J~tf[58{]") ~~:!I&J, ~~:{'1:

~JYl*o 19u:sm, :J!®J'Jttt~~~8':Jatf'*~~{,'£~~~m, IE:tmftffJs':ii~~~~BffJmat1'*~1m 1fJ;L.,JE~~~8':i-~; ~B'F~1~81~~~~~m-NP15!!~~89$'1'1WJA*~IEbt':E:tL IPJ~. -~EJf!;j:t};N~ ~£~~8':1, B*'J UllJ 89 EJf!;j:t; A!I&J1ifH*if;J\i~£ rnH¥~~-ff~B#J:izt89:i! ® A!Jm89 ?fi1~mn1~*~1¥~, H-B.:J!®4Jf4-IB.ix~~.IE89tz:::i:ttu 1*1:iJi!i~, ~eJG~£l9u.L T'L'RZ!I&J (mind- independent) O:l, ~~~~~MY.r~r:WffB:t!t~o

f~\~1<: i!JIZSJ.i4=$ A~ft~OO~ffl~J(bt~ttifffi.~;if(..tJIS~m r:p !l£Afll o pg-:R;~~, 1~~Q1PJ

w~•IZSJ~~oom~ffl~J(~M:i!!:~~m~m?mRNA~W~AAUIZS!m~•*~·•IZS!m~~

:XJ!l , * 1*-i~ a-g ;if( it , ~ 2SZ * tJT'Ii i'PJ JW? pg-:R;: c. 1. xu~:wr1§at37u/9~Fomtl ~~ffl.:tx~; AAUIZSI, f1=:1:Jpg-1~*$:t~1!:1Jo · &:J\±

~~~~~:wr~~ff~.~~•iAn~tl~~ffl~xwm~~ft~ffl~xz~~~m~m~u&

£.:1!•~-ra~ZSJ~~ffl~J(~&~moo•~-#~~;ftiA.n.~~:wr~~m~xwm~mm

~~~~-~~. WxtDIZS!m~~m:Jzt~~~~mu xU~ WT~fm 89 { ~ iRfQ 1fl'11I 89 * tJT)) ® :m1~ 89 ~ iJ!J.I i~ £-1-5! 89 , ~ i:iJ !tlfi~ 89 £:Pili ~X.,

J.Aw~•Tt~~~ffl~J(Wmv~tt~PJR~~:wrc~~W£&:J\±~~-m~•~.@~~

Fomili T) ~1lli89~~~$~*1~~M&:J\± 1903 ~81 "f]Df&OO"® £PlL!5cT -®J'gito 7~®, XIJ ~m§~j]~ffl~X.1!fs':li~it, *~*~£-Tfillxt "~fflm7tiJfr" (pragmatic apriori) [I{j_.iff:

tt;t~8':im1¥, ~~& EI3.IJt~~891t-z\iiJJW~;r;tr:sT.rr£IJ:&:w-ar~ss, £-:rffi*ffl 8':1$'/'IW, ep-:rff!:J'Jt¥U ~~~-arBmM~m~~•mu:i!~~_.~ .. *ffl"~~~~~r:i!1-~:tE:®#m~~~~x., W~~B~tl~~ffl~J(W~~m-X.o

66

~Tmmm~~~m~x~~~.u~*~*m~•w~~--X~-*~~~~fitt~~ Mu~~~~-·~~%~~-~~~~%~~-~00v~ffim~~:@:.~~±~~~~-~­~A~-(~ffi~~~~~-~-*~~~~-£&WT-~~-~~-~-~~~~-~ ~)•oa~W~T~~±~~~-~~2~.~3~~~4~@.~~~M-®~~±~--~ ~~-~~;mm•~~.•~~~~~~~±~-~~~m~~~ttc~~±~~~*~­

••~$~.Mft~-~~~~~~£&W-~~~~~~~*~~•).MW~~~*~~x

~~-~~-~ttc$~~~.~~m~~~.~~·~~WT. ~~Q, ~-M~Wm~£~~

8"J:I:1tJ.Ii£--·~f~~B~ ( JEJ~) M~~±13~£~~T~-1m~~$~~~J.I·~~~~** s"J=~~;}DJJI5~}fr/f:.:~. ~:l(;1J]£JJI!ID!~f!Slifc.iAT~/J\::I::8<JJ;~·rrJ)(: tE 1985 ,;F:1c:J:@:: " [ -f~-il:1t:Et~i£-]

...... tff,;G;'i'~$~~JJ\!fctle~v 1!f~:IJJT · *1-~:IJJT · ~~±tt9iHIH1T~IZ9~5£a~j:-tf!.:f~:itT~o 4l!" ~

*:f'E 1995 -tF, Wi~J1;p;g:@:: "EOJ<j:, T(J]+:ffb:J'IHl~iffiJ~JH:1t:E~h£-89 'tj~)J~z)(' "®'<J M~li;l~~·~

~~~~~~~~*®W~~~~re~~~-~~ffl~X#o

~'J_:~Jlf:!, ;;(~·--,~;~~¥~!~~: M~l3lfiE1'\~f1ll:l'ff!.t2ff\ T Ez/r< 1:8<Jt!Et~o £.i~l:~_t.-~QJI'id$ftt'F

~:tmA-,~~ A~r1~-~¥~~ic1~. ~~AA~~~ {ifrii:TifQM*> ~-:§it~x>t ~~±8'-JXJI

!EXR<J;FJN F'f-~1:.-®. 1@1~~~~ ·IJ:it~J Ez./r<J:~ <xan. 3Hl~iiiAJHiff3'i:r~l ~tlt~HJJ-:X W~ 9=t ~:g~~ffJ 0

~~z*·•~~~~~Jjm~~fi*W~~Mo~~~*~~~~ifrXJ.I~.@~. +* 4:-A~~8"J~. 1lli{b(~~~j:1f~~~8"Jx.W.,~ifJJ.lt "-*51%" ~i£-q:,v o 1EL:I!~~*~~iE1if@~; ~1if§lltl

8"JiiEmt;&r:!J3*Nr¥11£tk:&x~·-*51-'%1:I"JxJ7~,r~~o */J<J!fT~lHE; "J~" ~ff:' 1n:Jr8"Jit\·X~~i!, 3HE;~J£

)(~~M*~FJT:fr;=fftlFJTttijJEo ;f§&. -*51%Jll!i£-/G£:fE "J@i" ~~-1'-1iJ-=f~i~i!. W~1t

~-#-*51%8'-Ji&it: f¥tl~o." ''§"~a~· ~~8'-J" s<J~,i[tUJ'X~~. fsJijij:-tf!.iR.. "'§"~88'-Jo"

~~~.m~~~~--t-;&ook~ffi~~~.~*:~JJT¥~~~~~~tt~#~a:E.~J£X~,

{ffiiJJ'E*~J£Xt~®:~~-g- "T-m~" s"J~~~Wtl: "S£~1:1'-J, ~~{.£~p" (:!!£. tr:Jti "S" ~1:5 T W lJ\!~;:(:J;ill 8'-J ~1111iJ -=f) o {E!.~, *M£11£1# ffl51 %tff,·JR8<J -1'-1iJ -=f ~ 1:5 ~, ~Q

" , 1§~88'-J',, ~-~wJT8"J¥-;&:tt~. it1iJrz!s::5r~i!Xk*~~:I!~*:tt~~-$*; * ;f§~SJHJ§j:-tlf~iA. lJ'i'" (p) ( 'p' ~J@is"J. ~~f.£~p)'" 8'-J~t~. 1tiT-m~*~1~-1'­

J@iJ.IJ£5(~PJ§~8'9, M:t1f~¥*iR., :i!%~~:7G;f11Zi~; p ~1iJ-=f'!£5f;, 1EL "p" iB.~~::le'¥-BJ:

;&~ 161'-'¥-BJ:8"J;g':f=u ~7;;~1ffilf'rn&-r, :7Git•t!f~~~~*~1tW1ffPJj!-m-8"J~~M!I~x>tJ@iJI~ ~~ss~.m. ~i.A~t~r~~j:-tf!.;&~, ~~~i!it~1:f:1i'iJ.!=3~ffl~X~JitJ~~z~o

~1JJPJ~J.I•M!I~*~*~~~~.m.~~-~~~~~-~1:5~:g~o%: "#~-~­~'!£Jl;~111" C f~~21s:f2!q.t;rJtilf~tr,?t) ~ "i!it~~-'~ff,Jti!it~~~, C f~8"J7H!f~XJL.:I:m)® o ~~~-1'-/G~ffM~~tt~21s:~~~~;~R:ii:*~-1'-J.I~;rJtmTM#~~#~u*~~m

~-~. t*~~.--t-:E.~~**Tfffi'iJ:I!~~~~#~.tm~~*~~~#~•~~-~12

Jl;~~.W#~:I:~ili~~~~~J.I~~~-~*~~~~u~=~~~m~T/G~~~~~®

~~~:E.I~.m®J.~~-a~:x>tm~~x.~•~•tt~*~~**·~*~n~~*~~~~~

iJU11J;fo-t-~1to ~*-$i3t, ~miR.s"J~. /G®:itt~~:I!~8"JJii£-. ~1fJ*ilrT~~~~8"J#

~. 1E!.xtit~~f**P~*~~ili 4- Arfij~8s IPJ-'~tff,?1L :!!£, w~m "4- J.Jfij~ss" ~tl§' "7~

J!£8'-J" 0

67

~~~~~-~~~~~~$±*~~~~-~~uWffi~*~~' "~, ~~" Q~-~ 15" )(;Q1'~/J\±*P1Bf¥~ (existence, t~7!K!WS"J~~j]J:\) ~~~ (reality , f!;.;f§Sf.Jf¥~:7Jj\) 13:

:51-3f*o ®JlJffiaf.J*~i~ffi.mtT>liaf.J-~Fo*J1Jt~, :t!Ll*fillffi.~ 1::111, 1ill~~~1~~1B~tt, ms~, ~wtt••••~~-~~~!W. ~~~-~/I\±~~~. ~-~~f!;.mu®~*· ~-~$± ~~~~~~~~. ~*~.~~~~--~~#~~~~. ~~~~--~~~Wtt.~Ma ~fEL*JJ\\~1-taf.J~~~tL 5'~

~~~$oomw~.•mAA~~~0~~~~-#~~~~~.~~~~ft~~~~~~~

!fll3JW..{i.jl:, t~71Ka:EI~~~-J.I*%, ~-~~-ttiTii:~~IZ5!o {§.~. ~lf!.AA~~f\J$jfl: · ~f,J§!®~ EfT -1iflii~Y.:-~1N.::fnf£-Z;i~~i'ff.J'§§-zFo, M~I?Sl{Nf-JAl~£-Z;i~~-!~:Llli1-lrfF1!11~tx~--~

~ffJ, ill~~u T )71,E£±X.~fliE~~•xt•8"J.1L.~, :t~oxt-=f~~i$8"1~ ~J9 Ai~:f::f:m~~1ta9*rt9

i'l"J'Y~~v ~~), tJ:Ji1J~I~I89*f21q~JiS',1~ 1'1 1 • ti119:ff{-l·z,t;j~)JiJ1f 'f-:XHJ tX.Z5ll:u

~tt.Amm~reW125!M:51-W~~z:5t~fflfF*~-#~m±X.~~~:$~.~M"M

~fi~~~~~" ~~ili~tt~~-~~~~m+x.~~~z -c~~±m~M.••m"~

lW~" s"JJ!fi, ~PM1HJTifu-~~±5-lf~~~~11Hfii~, "ffi7Jfill~'iji~*~~") o@ff!~. ~~re

M~ 13lxt 0'-;fJT It~~ Z7Hf.J1ttJ"U 1=ff {ill~ fn] ~~:~'cjli G · 'PF4~q;: !A lrf JJ:.f& 8"; C 5-HIT 1'3 i*~: -~ f£111 /G{±

m~=~~>~*~-g~~~. ~£~.~~~~~~~~-125!~m~~A~m±x.5~; • ~~.~~~~~~B~~Y*~ttd~-~+B~£~. ~-~~~BM~ili~*tt~~~-

1-~~/G~~f~~. ~P~$~~2~±X.f~~Q

~c~~~~~~ft*> ~•m-m.DI25!~m=

"-F$~f\Jiiff,, :xu~m, 5fl:l;Jtfill-® A~:tztJ~m§%s:\a"J f21J;If:]J:.**~m 8"J~:I:m···; 1EL 1illffJ ~~ffl±X.~7tfi~~~~~-~7t~~_t~~To~rlfflfi~f$~7t~~.ft~*-#~m~ s"J'§;;ffl ±X.o" ®

*r~-~~~~~:t:~~~.M~~~Mcm~~~) %~1A'!f;;ffl±x.~~~~~mffi.

T -®*@, {f!fj)\~f\JiiffE~?9:~~i$%~T v ~~~~~_!:_, :iJIZ5!~l'[~~iJts"J1~~tt~. ~~ffJ

Flf~Er"JJ.Ii~:illi~~, {ill~~U T -~:Q'g~~~, ~Pt"JJE (convention); )j!Jt~Fk*'L'Bf.J~~#~ffl ±X.

W~.~**/G~ft~K~~~ffl±X.u

1\la ~ -Jf-AH$1'~ ili 8"1 J'PJ ~. ~ ~ 1+ fE iJG , WiiJ 125! s"J < § f.-{t # ~ r"" s"J J:. * $71-~;% ® :7J 00 1t-A ~~®&:$±~K'!f;; "f!;.;f§" :tilt~. W~ fill8"J < § ?'&1t89~i,R~) 57 ill ~~~~i1A~~¥U.!:3~ffl ±X. ~*c@~<§~#~)~~*$)1-,WiiJIZ5!~~~@T~~$*$)1-~~*$)1-~u~§~±

X.~±~~.~~·*·~·ffi·~~lf!.~-ili~"§~±X.~~-~~"~~~~~~-~~ ••~,~~~M~~~~~ffl~X.M~o-~J:..~~~.M~~Witll25!~~~~-~~'!f;;ffl~

X.§t!=!:JR:~~-1-*S~rll:ltA~ v

#~:m~woo~m~~~w~~. ~~FmmwT~~•·~~~~~m~x.o~~~

~~E~W~T~A~ffl±~u~~§B~~~~~~tt-.#~-tt--i$~~ffl±X.~~±

:ttfit:9, {EL{ill~atm~JET%~J:.~5fl:l~i,Ri~:7J~•1~~J:.•f!I\~1§"~8"J~,c,-8"Ji~~c 1$~~~ ~~~s"J "Jf{~~ffl±X." ( ~Llf~~~s"J) ~~ffl~X. § %1*Jtr~8"Jf2§tJi?Jf3&, ~ffl~X.~~~;% #~~.•~~~~#•ill~,mFo~ft~x.~~~~?ff~~~~~~·*~~~~~./G~

*E3~m±x.*%· w~*§~mAA~tt•~•&:/J\±'§;;m±x.~m#¥#?

68

~~:~£~~~§~~~~B:~~~~~~~~~cW%~~ffl~~~~~~ffl~~¥

#~~~~~~~~*· ~~&~~-~m~ttd~~ffl~~~*~-~~±~~~~*"m &.~~~~~~~c~•tt> ~~.~~~hre~~rrm~•~•~m~~~~~*~-~0 ~~~ffl~~~~~~~~OO&~~*±~~~~. ~~ffl~~" -~M*$~00A~X~~~

P~, rm~~~~ffi~;ffi~±-tl!)fiJffl~#~P~, * "ffE'f~" {ill8~t~?!u ;EJn~it:~i~gfB~ii8~St{~T u ~~~~~m~~~~~~~~~~~tt~*~· ~~~~~~£.~X~*~~x~~~

~~~~C&)~~o~~~~<~m~~~> ~~m~®.~#m~-mm&o~-~~m

"~:Uifl~)(" ~.::p-g-x8~*~T~f.~.:t_t- "~Eifl~5C' PJ~~~t~ (1) -~~-T~iJH't:¥it:f?8~

:mn'f::; (2) ~i-Ri'f::Ji::~if4"¥:~~ii'r~it-1!tl:tJiH~;!J~:nm~ ·fr51c~~~~=UJr.; EJ<:1r~ (3) ~~~:t51f. J2 -T~~~~~~m~~~~~~~. *m-T~~~X~.:t~~~*u~~~~T~~~~~=~ ~'\- -ftJq<n%J'i_~fl1 )e~~ tJJZJi~:titli +:~li"Ji'f::¥1¥, &~i'Etf'\ ::f11 1 Xil~ J·.J.SU!Htli:i:~i'r"Ji'f::¥1¥, rM;t;~?]\J::. 1:-=-~

~-~#-~~~*~~m~~if~tt~o#~. ~~~R~•=#~--~~&~~~~~~ ~.-~~-~F~~~~=*~Z.L:~~Xn~~~~~~if.~~X~R~~~"~PJ lV-~.x iiR !:f ~ w.Yr fffPJ J'f ix rm w .n 8"1 * ® .. 0

~%!HiT~ fb 'l::%i'\---~:iZ'P.Y!~{IJJ(zn]lFJ I JJ ~%-Ji VJ iSGJJIXi3~1Vf·1§<5l:%f'\ -·. ~:lzP.YL {E1J&, 1J<~~ ~13,

f"F~;l't~:Uifl~=n"-i!~-1-·I~A~!ffi'~. -jt;l't'tJiU'-8~~* ~1~~~~~*x.X:f~ ~ ~:FH7fnlt:f± J.r•;ol~fth'·j>I,.-.r:;; ·.J>'.fth) '·'·•'·''·''··jj· 1~11\fi'fth•n,-~ -<')'·>'· .r·-•._.,., ... ,.111 nrr -'•''v·j··''j:'IJlfth "/>..-'T.·fth" {!l{';f,)!(r;'-• :l9<,r:I'J:!'.if.7J~1'C:HI:J \.; JX.l'-'0j·: : k I.A-'1]11'.1 :rz:!;:FI'v /I'- .liU~/I'{i:J.,J,;t:~, 57 'r'(.T A' J:J.. . :II '.I i.drHI:J ltl'H+*

~ffi _t~~ ~ ± 8~ JE~ r:p :if-~~ T ff1PJ:f~X:EJ. E§t!:t Jl!.!f~ *~* 8~ *®-~ ~ ± 8~ 1t:EJ.JE~ ifriftf-T~ ~#~~~~~~~*~~~~m~~J£.#~-~~~~~lV-~~~tt~~~~~~~~•w m5~~ff.a'ifi11f; !.l.t3§: r~~ ~8~ X:EJ.f!!Jt~~f~ffl ® ( erzatz) jij~£~WF s"J R~.tltBt llt±ill 8~-¥Xo &~~~~~-~.tt•m~~~~"~~#~~m~"~~~§~.~~~m~m~.w~

~ .N~-#wJT 8~ , 1m~PT m-i't: 8~ fR:t.&:ittii% u ~ ~ 8~ "~ m ~ 5C' a~1iftl ~~ ~ ~ ± 8~ ~ m ~5( :fl§fi!e ~~;@~&~~~-tt~~~ffl~5(~.#~.~~~m. ~~-•~m~~m~~~m~u

~-~ffl~)(J2SJ31Jr~lf!.8"J~~m~if · JLtf.8~~iiE~~8~--t-~if1iE:5';it~. ~~~JLtf.8-9~iiE ~~re~~mrm.r.~~m~~~-~~.~m~~~-~&¥~~~mw~~9 =~~-~~~ ±~l*ii't:i=f s"Jr£2b-1:: ( agapism) flli'JL~iB ( tychism), ~#~fill{,'~ :J&~ i:f B"J~:X.ffiPf!A.~' ~~ <§;

~~-~•~m~"$~~~~*" ~~~w~~~~5(;~~~-Ttt~~~~~~~~z

**~~huffi~~~M#T~~%rm~~~~.#~~~mm. ~fflrM~"t!:tJF.~~~~

s:t" :13:-:x.m~ s"J st rSJ Jt:~ ttm -TM~;g::x.m1t:EJ.~- :x.m~ a~ st rSJ ~ $ v"" ~-T~-~-~.-ft~~*-~1-A~$u~~.~-*B®~~~_t.~m~~~*~

i:f~1~. ~~;:_m~ ~/G1~~~~~:itt1itL~B~~SH. ~1fJ8~x-iiR~~ttt.Z~Jf[-o ~~¥U:@:~i:fiL~

~&.~~~~~~~~~~~1iu~~m.~.~N~~~~1i;~m~~~#. ~~•m.

R~~~*~~~~~mlV-~~*~~~~~.~~~~~~~~ttu~~m~-~-ili~M:

"ffi~.~~.~m~~mm't!:tJF.~~~~s:t·;m~ ·~~mu~~*~~~~~~~~·

PJ§M~ft.Z\ ?" fEL¥:iE~~. ~1fJ8~i~ii511t~~:ill~~81~~88~~~n!fflT, ~1fJ1~lV-tL~:!:ill

~~*•xi~JJIJ a~•·rn u

~~mftW~-iiR-iiR*-T~~~~~~~M.~~~~~~-~~tt~~~~vffi~~~~.

~00~--~~~m~~~~o~~.tt~re~~~~~~*~*;#~.~~~~m~~PTm-

69

~~~~~~~~~m~~~zoo. ~~~~~~~tt~~m~~~~~~zoom~ww~~

~uffi~.~;f±~~tl~~~~~~~tl~~~ZOO$~~**~~u~~tt~m~~.~-~

m~~•tt~.~m•~~~§~~~~~~.~~~~~~~*· ~~m~~~~~~u~m

JA:i3:)L~UJt~~)L; El3-T~~:a~~1f1i1J~W.~~iJUB-tiFli, ~~:a~-1ftltW21s:?t~~~~:r\:, 1m -~~~~:i3:®aF~*m. ~~~&~~~~u~~-T~~~•m~~~~~~•o

#~:~~-~.WW~~~~~ffl~~~~~~~~~Wu

~~~~~m~~~~~~~~~W~?~~:a~~xm~~.~~#~~~m~~~~~m

~?~~~~~~ftmili~-re~ffl~XJA~~~~~~~~~~N~ili*~~~~?~~M~

1~t~R=J ~X~~H~I 8"'**? ~~=-~.~ft~~~§~~~~~~~~~=-~.~~~~~~~~~~~~ffl~X

f!im B"J fJ}TJi:-JJJiitxi!gG%5~* /f~ 1f, {l=fJ=t 14=11=J JJ:Hf8 ~ :1 ~ ·,~r-+ t~r' u 1J Jl:HZ:f·-':(:% B"J ~r. fr=: JVft !:i:'t ~ R=J :t: ~#~~~~.~T*~*··~~~~~-®A,ft~ili~M~~Bu~~.~~(~-~

j)j~Ji: ~ 0 tff:tU~ B"J -· iff1 ~ i.J.=~ ~B- ~fr.: ~I¥Jf)t1JUx 1± ;IX- · f!imJ5U;t~ 1'1'1 , t~J' )J!J ~i.i:\ 1~1 ilil~ ffi 1Jt :11i' 20 tiHc ~ i.R if; 8"J~fgz=:5H*Zf~; ~~ (1!f,J2f4~-~Jll['i1Jl1!IIpq~ -~~3 , tJH!~T -1'-xH4~~31~~31

~i=r ~ltMlT.B"JfffJ:;f,t, J!~)t:51-l~tJ&Wz T lt~J\:::1: i'I"J:ii~iB-~;frlt; t.Z ~~B-x ( iB-?*1-'~ ~1=~ 8"J~$Ei:~ 0 fiH*Jlli ~MJi:®~~T·~~~~~~~ffl~X~~~~W.~o&~~$~~~~Z*~~~.~~~

&~~~m~x~~~= "~~~m~%ill"~~tt~~tt~~~. ~~.~~~~*Wmf~

~±8"J1593~:Jt:flli (abduction), f-1%~* ( semeioticians) ~~~~±~~1lliffJ~f4~'BU~frA, ;f±

~~~#~x~~~*MW~#~X21s:~li~. "N~§~~~W"#tl~#9EOO*tt*•· ~~rit;o

~~-1'~~. ~~~~Q~-1'-~~.~~~JA~~wm~~tlt~.~~~~~~~h

~~OOB~r~1~;f§~JJJ~. &itt~~tltW~113:J:m7J~~,_ ~&~:i3:~8"JfP~. ~Pft~.tltZ~.

~:51-*~W(~~pq*~~-~~~~.M~~~~k~~~~T) B~*~*~~~~M~

8"J ~ ~ r*~Yi ~ = :13: ~ , ~fn *~€!~ ~u ~ ~ 8"J r!Q:J1!~ ~:tm :tcti ~~ ~ iJUB- , u ~~ iJHB- ili JJl\ T ?Bii ~ :n\. *~~~o~~. ~ffi~·~~~(R~~B~~m)~m~"%*~ffl~~"~~B~~~T

-fP:i.gH1ft~-&it~:5t~~~~~~fflfFriiHJG~1?f8"Ja~rl'f. ftzn.x:~ro±1:~1:J<;i5!M28"J--t-i~A

§;fiF; -rEjf~%~~~~~~ffl]~H~ T;f§~~x.m~~i\" f.~rm. ¥U §~:7J_LI::.~8"JJJR5m~. ~~~ffl~ I~~~~~%m~~-#~~g~~m£~~oo~~-€~~~~m:r\:~~. rm~~-#~A

~m~X#1~m~~~o

~~~~B-~~-.ffi~$~ffiOO~ffl~~~**; §~~~-*$~~~ffi~m~u~

fJt*~fr~~M318"JBtf~, ii~fJl~Uf~~*'~' · -~ (Brian Leiter) t.f~~8"JA~1f~~.Yf~~~~.f)l!

~~~~~~-~?¥~.m-t-~~~*~~~~;m~•~~~¥-t-A~~g~~~MR:1:~

~.~~~+~~~£*~~~~.~~~~~~~~~00 (~M*~~) ~~~,~ft~~

ffl.~R~~~-1'1f~~tt*~~~~u~~.S~~-~h~~~Z*. ~~~~(~~ ~**~~@.~~~$A~re~m~~~tt~;-~k.~~~.~~~-~W~k~~~M

~~~~**•~~~*,:13:~-1'--~$~§-u rtrm. fti~*gEJ.iJtt±l~~~~ffl~X.8"'**~~~s"J u ~A~ffl~X.s"Jf~~. ~~~8"J1'H1

#~~, ~-1'-~~-m~~~JJ.X:-8{]1~~; rmR, ~~{J.tE-JET~~k~~ ~ 5t8"JBt1~&1f~.Yf~~

70

~.®~~~ill~~~~£~~oM•~*·~~m~~~~A~~ffl~~~~~. ~~~~­~JJX:5e3c8"J1J.J:tjt~~~ffl~X.~t~3IU8"Jrli!J%-~?t. ~~~if A£J!il\i1~ffl~501i!J%;f!:J* §A ftM~m 8"1 11m% 3JFf 8"1 :@:~ o

~~:WW~! ~~-~!~rl~~~~~.~E~;f!:J~-®**T~~~~~ffl~X.£~ ~lli~rlW~M~nX:*vm~~~M~~~~ili$~Z*!

i7JPJJ7&f: :VNJ,J<. -!J;. _t:/BtiizVA~~~rgz?t:~~=rg-~•~. 1956 ~ili~ru~mrr. 1982 ~¥

21tri¥iR::k~=f§-~-*, 1991 -1992 ~~:ltR::k~=f§-~-**1~~~, 2oo8- 2oo9 ~r~~illJiiJW +~:f.ll-~7;Z '*1':;1~~ /'-.::::.f- ""::::.f-7.1'1-/J OJ"f'--'S o

:mi7Ji'~iJ;:&f: l1r1JY} • ~~ (Susan Haack), -tr..·, ~41~~=~C fg~*, L-j::.f=f't::k~=f§"~iJ:=I:, AX

~~±.~m*~~±. ea~~~-~::k~=f§-#•~.~~~~ill~@::k#x~#~Ax~~ IIJ,$:S<:r1, ;!,~ifl'lf'~6f.&'~:;fr·, i!J·'7:~}§:, lt''f:~}JL ;WJ:~tJ£UJ\ I:''J:~T]iJ{f0 Ku

(j);tj:J)J}j-. "%it: {1!.~4-1§-*>. 1il]#-: §i]#fk.*tl:l!l&..

~±, 1978 if-; 'f x~, 7 ~J:. ~, .:11:. i:": rJf 1J- ~f' ·'IH~,

2003 fo

~@ $ J)J}j- • "%it : { i.iF.. t% 19 4*-Jt-k. faJ i.J... i.?-iN.(nt

:fi.J > , 4- i:f: ;;lf1 ;)tit .:f; IF ~ Jt , 1993 if- o 'f x !!&.. , f/f.

~-*h~.~~~~. ~i:": tj>OOA~k.~tl:l~

~±, 2004 fo *X~ 2 ~: {-J.iF..t%-J9;j*-Jt.-;<fi.J...iJ;

~~~m~~~~>. tt~, M~M#:+Y'**M

m ~, 2009 fo

@;tts)J}j- ·"%it~~. f/f.i;t, ~ffiif~&~J~~= Ct~.

-fPl'..!91t#J-~m~~t~~XitJ, .:It:."*: A~tl:l

!!&..~±, 2001 if.; *x!l&..: orr:::t~m~~r~~xi.U,

r.E..r<;, 1rur ~Jt.-r# = * 7 * 1~,n,r m ~, 2oo6 -+ 0

@~~: {$~·"%it#*~--~.i!.#*~.-t§­

~ ~ ~ Jl'. *.r JJj >Y.t> , ;It:. i:": « i!t .1} {§- * », 2003 -+ 5f; 5

.ft}], ~ 101 -113 :9f 0 *Xi!&.: Susan Haat:k: A Lady of

Distinctions ( Amherst, NY: Prometheus Boob, 2007 ) ,

p. 17-370

@@l@@.t.S~J!Jf · E · -;/f;IF: {J.!iL1\4ioiJ;.Vr;>, Y-"'lk.tt-~

it, ttr9: Y'i0J1.ttl:lJI&.;,..'-6), 19614-, .:ll:.i:": 'tOOA

~i\:.Cfti:JJ!§..~±, 1989 f, $367, 295, 307 :Vfo (•1;-it

,(f. i.Ht'fi.iL, J<t~,(f. *- 00111.-f-R* ,(f. 'f 00 **J•f.J) o

@"%it: { liif::t" ~ m ~~ i~~Xi!S)), ttt'J, 1rar ~it-T

~4'-: +Jr:i/d}$.,1-[fJ~, 2006lf., ~ 15 :Vfo

(f) { Jt IF ± X 2;10 Charles Hartshorne, Paul Weiss .i.

~; 5f; 7-8 %., Arthur Burks .i.#il!, ~ ifi)f£'l·l·j, #:

%., ~ 388-410 :Vi ( 1878) o ii.$$;x:t'fi!.-*Hl-~#

:!%! c ;.G. m T " ~ m .i. ~" • " ~ m ~ :1uw· ~ > J.¥- :ff.i

'fR~.~~~~~~b~~~o~X~~~$~·

"%it:ft=>Fff.iJt~~ = << ~ ~. J\..Jl'..i94t-iJJ-~m ~~

K~Xi!)) .:lt:.i:", AK,tl:lJI&..~±, 2007 fc

@ { ;t IF± X~)) ~ 5 Je;. ( 1906 if-) , ~if i)f £. 'l·IP.t

;;lj;Jr.Jj-: "%1Jl;k.*:±:~~±, 1938-J951lf., 5f; 13 :Vfo

®@®h*M: (-1§-*••:ft:>~~M*>. b~~~~ )·l·j_;i. k_ ~ 0 lEJ it ;;J'Ij : (( k_ ~ f .:Jf. » , J898 f 9 }) , ~

287-310 :Vi; ~i'f'~h"*.it-1-: {~Jfl~~» (1907),

;;lf1"%#:fto~IFM~~. ~if~£.ffl~;;lf1£.!J-:+•k

# tl:l !!&..~±. 1975 4-' 5f; 355 -70' 97' 106 :Vi 0

® { ;t IF ± x ~)) ~ s J/!i.. ( 1903 ) , ~ if i)f £ !·1'1, J.t

;;lj;J[.Jj-; •%1Jl;k.*ti:JJ!§..~±, 1975lf-, 5f; 17 :Vfo

@ {Jt~F±x~> 5f; s%. c I906), ~ ifilf£1·1·1, ~;;lf1

Jr.!J-: "%1Jl;k~:±:J!§..#, 1975lf., 1906lf-, 5f; 13 :Vfo

®<Jt~F±x~>~sJI!i... ~if~£ffl~;;lf1£.!J-:"%

1?j; k ~ :±: !!&..~±' 1905 -+, 5f; 414 :Vi,,

@/;r*J!If: ((~lfl~~)), ;;lf1"%#;fo~I!,IF$.Jf~#f.J, ~

if ilf m. 'l·I·J.t.t ;lfl £ -tr: "%1Jl; k. ~ :±: !l&.i±, 1975 -+, 5f; 95

-113 :Vi 0 .:lt:.i:": i!t-.1}4ioiJ; :±: !!&..~±, 2007 -+. 5f; 45-

139 :Vi 0

®~*it-T: {J\..Jl'.!\I.J~~~)) 1909 f; ;;lf1"%#:;fo~I!,IF)t.,T

~ff.J, ~ifilfm.'l·l·l~;;lj;Jr*: "%1Jl;k.*:±:J!&.~±, 1975

if-, {~rn~~» . .:~t:.i:", i!t-.1t-4ioi;;:±:tr&..~±. 2001 -+. 5f; 140- ISO :Vi

@ ( Jt {J, ± ~ ~ > 5f; 5 {f. ( 1878) , ~ if i)f £ )·I'I.J:j: ;;/j1

71

:£. -t: 'fi-1#; .:k. ~ rl:l *-:f±, 1975 .sf-, ;f; 407 JL * YL

((~X.., J\..J.fl:j-ft#J)), .:il:.i':: A.l'\.i±lJI&.:f±, 2007 4-, ;r; 312-331 ~ 0

@~-}tq:-.Jl.JT: ((~Jfl.i..X..)) (1909), ~..g.t;f:f<>~I?.~J!~.i..

rt.J , 1!; ilfi i;lt it J·l'l, ;~J: ~ :£. -t : ..g.1#; *-~ rl:l Jl&. :f± , 197 5

.sf-, ;r;n~"*YL«~x..,J\..ml:jff#J)), ~i'::A.

1'\.rl:lJI&.:f±, 2007 4-, '140 -150 ~ 0

® « ;t ~ -±- :UIO ;r; 5 *- C 1878 ) , E; if 11i' *- J·i·J , #:.

~ :£. -t: ..g.1#; *- ~ rl:l Jl&. :f±' 1938 - 1951 .sf-' ' 407

~, i.i ~, Jt ~±it:£ JfJ a'-J ;lt.jLF!ti%-~ ( "the opinion

that will be agreed. _ . ") , Tr7 T- ;lt.ht .ft.z 1%-~ ( "the opin­

ion that would be agreed .. - " ) o

@ « ;t ~± X.~J ;r; 5 *- ( 1878)' ;tp..g.#:f<>~l?. ~ .Jl.!T

.i.. #~ ' 1!; ilfi i;lt .it J·l'l, .tk ;tp :£. -t : ..g.1#; *- ~ rl:l Jl&. ;f± '

1975 .sf-, ;f; 409 ~ o ,tf. T i!iH"J -f.tii- tf, ;t ~ -±-iJ...;/v,

~~~m~-+~~h$~GZ;lt.~~~;lt.T-~, ~

#k-~*~*~~·~· -#*~~~~~~0~

*· ~~~T.i..~:GZ~~;it_~~. ~~~~*~ ~~~~~=~~~~~-~~.~;it_~~~~~

..-;to ;f; 5 3/i-, ;f; 457 ~ ( 1905) ( ¥1 A1iiZ ..-~& a<J.

~,tf. -T "-+-Alt•t:l MJ ffi-14-~~ a<;.$\-~ •t:l------ [ :!lcr

*] ~~~~A~~~~#~Jfl, ~~P±~#~~

:tavli.t*"") @ (( Jt ;T- -±- :i:. ~J ;f; 5 {_, ( 1878 ) , ~ uf;- #fer~!?. ~ .Jl.JT

.i.. ~ ' 1!; if i;lt it J·l'l, .tk ~ :£. -tr : uf;- 1#; *- ~ rl:l Jl&. ;f± '

1975 4-, '407 ~"

@ « ;t ~ ± 3:.411::)) ;r; 5 4 ( 1868) ' ;tp..g.#:f<> ~!?. ~ .Jl.!T

.i.. r~ , E; if i;lt .:t. J·I·J , ;~J: ~ :£. -if : ..g.1#; *- ·:¥ rl:l Jl&. :f± ,

1868 4-, '265 ~"

® ((;t~-±-X.Jf:)) '54 ( 1902)' ;tp..g.#:f<>~I?.~.Jl.JT

.i.. #~ , Jl; if iJI- .ft_ J•l'l, Jk_ ;fp :£. -t)- : uf;- 1#; :1c ~ :±l Jl&. ;f± ,

1975 4-, '135 ~ 0

@((;t~±X.Jf,)) ;f;54, ;tp..g.#~-~~.i..~, 1!;

if i;lt .it J·i·J , ;iJ: ;tp :£. -t : ..g.1#; *- ':¥ rl:l tvU± , 1978 .sf-, $

405 ~ 0

@G. E./!!:.~: ((~-J\~a"J~Jfl.i..X.J, ((3E:£.-±-~.f:t

~~~f,J)), ;f;84,1907-84-, $33-77~; #YL

-r-4 ~ = « -tt ~*1L», *:-:i}.t = wtH'l -t~ £.tfl1>1t 7 r±l

Jl&., 1922 .sf-, ;r; 97 - 146 ~; 7 :~: «h•.Jl.JTa'J Ji-m ;j!!t~)) (1908), YL-t-7:~: «-tt~x~». mr<J: tJJX.

.0-~ rl:l Jl&., 1910, ;f; 112- 130 ~, ~ ~ *'il.J Fiif 7L>b~t

72

· 49" -i'- :t. A_: ((iiE..fJH.f i!~ * i~)) 1~ :t Jl&., 1960 .sf-, * ~#~3:.*-: ~:i:.rl:l*-~. ;f;18~: "~-~-~~ ~A,·~· ~k~m~•*~~~~~*"-+~

* k ' .$\- a0 ' ~,{f. -T ~ xt ~ 1rH0 ± i* ~ f'l "" ®~A: «~~=~1L~~~». m~: ~~~~#rl:l

Ji&.:f±, 1938 .sf-, ;r; 345 ~" ;t~-±-a0-5l :trl:l m ((;t~

± :t ~0 ' 5 .:1£- ( 1878 ) 1!; if ill-$. J·l'i, .tk ~ :£. -t : ..g.

1#; *-* rl:l Jl&.:f±' 1938 - 1951 .sf-' ' 407 ~"

®W-A: ((~~~'OJ~)) (1911), ;lf.t:lt:f<>3EmJJ7c.i..

~. ((~A~·~~)), ~;f;~Mffl, ~fo~M: ~;f;

~ ~~ 7c ~ rl:l M.:f± , ;f; 2 4 , ;f; 10 I - 130 ~ o ..g. ;t :f<> fit

ilt.i..r~: « ~ x.., ~J.f l:j H#J-~ m .i.. x.. &-.i ~ 3:.

~)),t~T ((~~MM)) ~;f;~~~. ~i'::A.l'\.

rl:l t!&.:f±' 2007 .sf-' ;r; 344 - 364 ~ 0

l@@.t±A: ((..-/ii~·t±~-'f-,;]()), m&-9: Caprieorn Books,

19294-, lf.;;!;f ((~Jfl.i..X..)), O±JJiV~lfl.i..X..-t§'~)),

.:il:.i':: i!tJf.,fr;p-£Y,rl:lJIIJ..;f±, 2007 f, if; 273-283, 22 ~.,

@;f±;iX.: ((~Hit l:j §} t.~)) ( 1925) , f.B.f'J: ~ 1#; rl:l Jl&.:f±,

1958 if' ' 18 ~ c

@)Jt~-±-3::.~)) $5 .:1£.__ (1903), ~ufi-44':fcr~I?.~.Jl.JT.i..

rt.J , E; if i;lt tu-1·1 , ;~J: ;tp :£. -t : ..g.1#; *-~ rl:l t& :f± , 197 5

.sf-;f; 555 ~"

@ $ >}Jfj- • ·1:-- .t : < ~ 1l. i~ &. Jt:.-:t ~ ::tr : ·r-*. .i. ~ 1n ~ i-k 0)), Facta Philosophic-a, 4. I , 2002 .sf- 3 }] , ;f; 67 -

88 ~; <~·r:£.ft;lf-JZ.#'*-1l.;f4-~.i..X..l:j :k..11t.i..X..

~ fSJ » r.B.t9 : r-or -;* t.JT # : % 7 -*.1<t t.JT I!B .:fl , 2oo3 4- ,

' 161 -163 ~ 0

@C. 1. J') $1 f.JT: {4;PiY.~11\'"1.0'.a0~~if)) (La Salle,

1L: Open Court), 1946 .sf-,

@ { ;t ;G-±- .X. Jf,)) $ 4 ilt.~ ( 1903 ) , ;tp ..g.# :f<> ~!?. ~ $.~

.i.. j~ ' 1!; if i% £ J·i·J ' .ik ;tp :£. * : ..g.1#; *- ~ rl:l Jl&. ;f± '

1975 .sf-' '510 -529 ~ 0

@l;t~±: <-r~~~.lf-t\4l)) (1880) :f<> «~~Ht~»

(1883), _!)/_, ((Jt~±X.~)) ;f;34, Jf;154-251 ~;

$34, $328-58~; v:J.&.Jt~-±-~~±, 0. H.

*- -ln ~: (( i!to~~H\!lfd, (( i'0 :itllr • ~ %1:-.Jl.JT *-~A .9l.

,Pfr 1t.t ~ ~.if.li)f 1l. )) ( 1!; if i;lt :&:. 'l·I'J ' ilt ± ;J;ji : 'J' ~ t}J '

1883), ;r; n- I06 ~, c ij:-¥ 1fT Jt ~±~~.if, ~'t1e

a<J .z ~i.t~ rl:l I.!), 91'> '~'*-= ((1ft* 3:. ~)) ( 1879) , 3lt

~r-t~1t",f.. ((;j!?t~iEi!-&.;;fET:9U~X.)), Terrell Ward By­

num.i..rt.J, 4-¢: Clarenrlonrl:lJI&.;f±, 1972.If-, $101

-203 Jf n

®~ IZil : {:X: -t < ;;t ;f- ± ::t ~) jf; 2 .td'i iti-8-> ' 1?" f-1)

i;;Jt,.f'l·l'], ~J;a ~ ::k. *til Jl&.;f.±., Isis, 19, 1933 if-, jf;

220-229Jf; ((:k-t (;;t;f-±51:.~) jf;3t-;f<>jf;4.;ffi..

a'i iti-8-> , Isis, 22, 1935 if- : jf; 285 - 97 ;ft> jf; 551 -

553 w 0

®-iHhtJ: «~~.if*~Jt;T-±>, ((4't~Jt*-rn, ~if i;ll- ;t 'l·i·J , if;_ ;f- ?t, -k/!J:, Elsevier ~ t.:. til Jl&. ;f.±., 1982 Jf-,

1f; 9 J!Jl , 1f; 290 - 20 I w 0 -:f ~ J:. , 7 -;t Jt ?../;; xt ;;t ;f- ±

3t 1t .>.! 1!.>: a'i ;jf 1t J:t -if # m 1;p ilt 1.'tf it ~ ; ~ .!t Irving

Anellis: (( ;;t ;f- ±a<; 7 -;t-1t, 7 -;t a'i ;;t ;f- ±1t: ;;t ;f- Jl..f

;fa 7 -;1:-~o1"Tilk.ft~ §) a'i~~.ij: .:r:.1-D, (( JJt1\~~.ij:)), ~

.#j-:!}.. 'l•i'J, 'Jt -k/!J:Jl-1", J}t1\~~.ij: til Jl&..;f.±.o 1995 Jf-, Jf 5 .t~,

jf; 3 J!Jl, 1f 270 - 378 w '-'

®~!Zil: ((,tf.~~.ifa'ifl.JT>. ((~B{j-±.:f~5i:.~&HD,

1985-t7JJI2EJ, jji;767w: :lt~r-t:i-!Zil: «~~h''~

5i:.~)~f~;tffl, ~~~~:~~*-*tll!t&..;f.±.,~

iTJI&., 1995..<f., jf;251-57Yfo ~1ZiJ,tf.;f-5i:..:f~tll, G.

lt~*~-tft;f-±a'i.:r:.1t~J:..~·~~e<;.:r:.1tk8

.i.1i:.Aa'1 o

@l~ !Zil: (( ;;t ;f- ± friJ ~~.if), (( ~~.ij:i-8- 5i:.ilt)), .J.iifiT /,&.,

1995 if-, tJli'i: wiley, 1960 if., jf; 258-65 W, 1f;

259 Yf 0

®~!Zil: 0~-i~ ifo xt ~)), tJli'i: Wiley, 1960 if., jf;

23-24 Yf 0

®~IZil= «~m~~ta'i~~>, ~f~am, ~~~

~: ~1**-*tllJI&.;f.±., 1990 ..f: 1f 2 Jl&.1992 if-, 1f

WJf,~IZiJ~ilt: u~~~~~·~~ffieJ.;, -~~

;f-a'i~~~4,t£.-t~ma'i~~-i!r:t"~ffi~~·~k

0a!.;' ~~~A~~~k0a'ik-+•~o~ffi~~

~*~·~·k-+.~' a<;~~~~,*~~·~

.:f-~o ... ~me<;v=r$,;;k;m-~T~I-%-o"

®For ;T- $~it · ~~..r .tt~: « ~ A.1tit-ir t a<; ~mtflt

~)), 1931 if-, ~Jl..f~: ((~~.if, 1.%5Z.;ft>JtAt~), J.

H. 11i,~.i.r~, -'fi:f: -'f;'f::k.~tllr.&.~.±., 19564-, jf;

152 -278 w, jf; !59 Yf 0 1~11i1i- ii. it a<; k, ~ at~ IZil

~ .ki~il-1-£~-ft~ -t,-~1-%- 01 a'i ~it!. A.~ k -+~1

-5-i;>f*a'iit-:X..-&!>0--, Jt~!Zil: ((~J.!~~.if)) (1940..<f.,

ffi.i'i: ~J€1 :k.;I:E. .:f; JS, 1962 if-, jf; 26 Yf 0 # ~Jt ;j]:

JJll} • ~ .>t: ((~»-~it!. A.)), (( .iH.lf .ki 0-i'f)) J:t if') at,

1fi -1Ht. ;T-, l!il ~~~if.A?tit t ,-:_; 17 iif., 1974 Jf-, jji; 277

-294 w"

®~!Zil: Ot-1or4h4,t£.) (1948..<f.), Jt~!Zil: ((;;...~

~.ifa'i~Jt.¥-.i"> ( 1953), •%-.>€! :k.1e .:p; !S, 1961 -+ jf; 2

Jl&., jji; 1-19 w; #~Jt;jj:JJliJ- · •%-.>t: ((~~if'!r*)

c ~J:.ii.#-1 >, *5tn&., jji; 43 -49 Yf 0

®~!Zil: «~~.if..ki*;ffla'i~,t£.1t)) (1947), Jt ((M.~

~.if.a'i~YL~L·t:r)), 1f; 102- 129 w, jf; 105 w" # ~Jt~

X.: ((~~.ij:1§"~)) (~ii.~tl), *5i:.n&., jf;48Jf"

@ ((Jt;f-±::t~J ~6-t~ (1901), ~ifi;il-;t'l+J, ~

1Ji~~: ~19j;;k.*tllJI&.~.±., J938Jf--J951Jf-o jf;549

w ( "4,t£.k~,tf.a'i-tHt7!f.i'.fA."): ffi 6 .t~, ffi 495 Pf (c:. 1906) ( "$_§) C.-Ji.,tf. '.kj£1-.l>tt.JJ:.ilt

A~•~~~ttm· ~-?~it:X..J:.~m '4

,tE.' a ... $_.:t.:X..a'i ~,tf.Jl:.;;f.J m C.a'i#J9t, ,tf.-$:.atJ!Jl

0J.~~A~AA~~~R~~a'i#J9t~tll~~~£

1'\'-. . . . ~ :f 4h a'i 4t J9t ~if-1*-.:lt ~ {: i1i:k 7W a'i ~k. .0 o" )

i@l$Jfi!t • ~ ..t: O~t.ft,;\; *it A. a'i ~,t£.~~= ~ .ki ~ 4-:1+

*1r'#:a'i!k.!f,)), ((Jt;T-±*~~-t~». ffi 28 t-, ~rlf

*if! 1·1·1, :1Jl f aJJ ;J;J!, ~r ~*if!*-* til n&.#., 1992 -tlf

I J!JJ , $ 19 -50 W o

® « ;t ;t ± 5i:. Jli:J ~ 6 'it~ ( 1908 ) , ~ if idt tE. i·i·J , ~

:1Jl~-il-: •%-111?*-*tllJI&.;f.±., 1938-1951-f, Jf486 w

(w4,tf.·~~a'i~~,,t£.~*4~~~m~~a'i~~

T, ~.fi-w:R~±Jf~., J-J..,Tnk~~6'i*';ffl)r") Jf8-t~,

1f 216 w ( 1910 +) ( w ~if 4 ,tf. a<; ( the will be, s ) ,

J)t ~ 4 ,tE. a'i ( the actually is' 8) , C.~ 4 ,tE. a<; ( the

have been, 8) * ~ k ~ ,tf. a'i it- ;fa" Ji:l:. 7r , ~if .fi-4 ,tf.

(would be' s) if<>1i~GJ54,t£.a'i (can be' 8) ~k~

~~,tf.W') r

®~!Zil;faif.J ;f-jfJ:.. -t-i.t~: ((JtfoJ-#~>Ii:JeJ.;"'(ti;f'~)),

((~-%-~~.if.-*';0)), 12 .t~, 1947 .{f-, $ 105-122 Wo

@;;t;f-±: «~*~#~-:t) ffi4iif-,~7*·~~

.i.~, if!fit~: A5i:.>ff*tllJI&.~.±., 1976-f, jf;84Yfo

@~~·~#: ((0-#;ft>~~: -#~~d~a'i~~

~~ » , ;tt Jt. · NJ .>t .i. f~ : ((;f.±. m.. : >t+ * .ki m 1iJ a'i 11' * ~)), ffih: Dial tll.li&.~.±., 1930 .{f-, jf; 316-30 Jf;

t5i:.n&.: ~}L;foF$ilt.i.f~: ((~:X.., ~J.!;f<>itilJ)), ~!:.

't: At\,tll/,&.~.±., 2007-f, ~5J5-530Jfo

®~!Zil: 0.£llti:-f'~friJ p;g+:;ji~)) ( 1952 -t), Jt ((!-A.~

Ma'imA~))~f*tE.ffl, ~:1Jl~*=~~::k.'#:tll~

;f.±., 1938 Jf- -1951 Jf-, ~ 20 -46 Pf, jf; 46 w 0

73

®~~~~~~M%~A~~~1~,~~R~~~

iP1%fi-J l*l ~nr-*~ g ::B--j(_l'i ::B--~.vt;~;1;--60 g ::B--*- '* 1!.­

~fi-J.~~I~,.'(_-~•~,~~~M%: (~-~.

-i%5l~:ift>;f.#-i~)). (OOI'f--\r~ih~)), 1950 +, jf; 4

JJJ , ffi 20 - 40 w ; -Jt ~'r r ~ ;r, ii'J % : ( 1t 5l :ift7 ·X..· ?.~

·ri)) ~;l;o-.¥}: ~;l;o-.¥} :k. ~til JI.U±., $ 2 Jl&., 1956 +.

ffi 205-221 9f o ~ ~: ( i'~~ ~ iP)ft~* r ;f.#-~60 ~Yl.

.~u. «-tr~hJfJt». 1951if-ffi2$JJ, $65-nw; -Jt

~'v r~ fJ: « ·ltiN0 ;;t A.» m.r0 = it*~ & , 1966,

ffi 126-134 Yfo ;ti:J!IIf · 'l@-.>t «~~r;f..#-i'~fi-J;lt'.\E;flly

if-~)) , ( -tlf ~ :iZ. ~.if-~ ;0)) , ~JL i0 , Springer til Jl&. ;f±.,

I976if-jf;5$}l, $457-474 Wo

®~ ~ : ( m ~~~ # ~)) , (;f.#- i'~ fi-J ~ro ~HLR $,. 1-1!!. ~

3::..)) , i1Li0 : -.¥}tt;- J:t JE k ~ til Jl&.;f±. , 1969 if- , $ 114 -

138 w, %<-~~ .>t:ift>l'.f- ihti:.rt.,: <Ut 5l. J\-.>£:if<>.:ft7/J)),

$ 531 -556 9f 0

®~~: ( m ?.~1ta0iJ..if..i~)), (;f.#-i'~fi-J~ro~Ht::f"Ji;.

1-l!!.k~.)), ffiflj, .:fif;fi 00 ~, 1936 +, % 69-90 pfo

®.~.ttk · -.!JJ .>t, « ro 1.~ i:. 5l :ift7 *-m YJO, -.!JJ .>t i:.

rt.J: (.:r:.1t'fe<J:!Jt00-tlf~~1f1)), mi0: .:fif;ftOO~.

1936 +, ffi 236 - 68 9f 0

®7*:(E~~~~-tlf~~~-~~Jfli:.5l~~.~

i&;:ift>)i;-1-f-tff~)). ~;1}-ij:-:;ttllJt&.~. 2003 +. ffi 3 9f Q

®7*= «-tr~:ift>ro~~•». #~~=•#~·*-~ tllJI&.;f±., 1989 +G

® ;n: J!llf . 'l@- .>t = <OiE t,% l'i :Jij( 1t » ffi 1voit = « !t!r 1~ ~ rn i:. 5l:-~~A~~fl-;~;)) +*: *•5t*;F~~.

I993 fo

1@1!. <0iEt,%JH~Zft)) 'f. -t\n"-JJ 1]f.l~~~ ",J<~60,£~.o:l:

~~hJf#~j(_1l.:!JtOO-lr*~~~+~~~~fi-J, §~

~--~;If._ .:ftfi-J tr&.;f..11-5~;f-f iHfiJI..")

@;ti:J!IIf · 'l@-.>t: (~~~~a01;--*-·ri: JJit.f:HEii;-Jt;F

±fi-J~~:ift>Jt;F±mii;-~~-tff~fi-J~~». •&«~

it-llf*~·t»' 2007 +. % 1 $}j, ffi 29-43 9f 0

@ << ;t ;f, ± 3::_ 4i0 , $ 6 ;if~, $ 287 - 317 9f ( 1893 )

C*ri-Z:ti'~); .$ 6~ • .$47-65 w (1892) C*r

.tJL.i!!l~); %6;/f~, %24-25Pf (1894) C*r-'t->YI..

~~i:.5l) *'l@-#:ift>M;F~i:.~, ~f*~~~~*

X-if": 'l@-1;1J7:k.*tllJI§..;f±., I975 fo

I@ 7 * : ( i! ~ fi-J -tli: 1lz.)) ( I 972 if-) , ~ r 7 * : ( ~

Jf1 i:. 5l6'J E Jf0 J&J i.Ht 63, $ 3 - I 8 9f .,

@$J!IIf · 'l@-.>t: (-t.f.:E.:H*-1l-JJ!.H.60ie:OO I*J)), :z ~ 'l@- .>t , « ::r-: ,.'(_ 7drt i:. 5l , ~ ,.'(_ iHP< 1-~-;"" -t-~ ~ rn i:. )l 'f .fHtJ {/.; :;tt iJt/)) 2005 if- ; .;@- 5t : (.te. -\lf ~ t~A. i£

rn », mt0, for* Jl.Jf 4-t, 11- 7 :i/U>t-Jl.!f oo ~, 2oo8 +, $79-94 9f"

@;ti:J!IIf. 'l@-.>t: (k)i;-1;f:'f601Z.~.if-: ~::B--. 1E.;;(-j(_~

.&j!)), (i!-J.I)), ~fi%~1·1'1, ~;f-1f-, Wiley.$20~,

$ I J!}l , 2007 if- : jf; I - 3 I 9f o

@J$J!IIf . .;@- .>t: «} 7t1t60 )i;-J.f. >:f: •.J;-001 fa)- ~ffif

;!; ~*1-f ~ Jf1 i:. .:X..)), ( )i;-JJ?.)), ~ f i% ~ j·l·/ ~ ~ *' wiley, $2I~, 2008-4'-, $4JIJJ, _$453-809fo

®71Ed-t · *it.4!Pr: (i51..~1tt~f"l: k.falfiiif..t!f60~rn

j:_)l)) 4-i~: +**-*tll!l&.;f±., 2008 +, .:1\i.i~~iU,

§?.~.{E.~ ;f.-¥ 'f, *it .J!Pf 1~ ;F~i'J T .t±A, 1E.~'.\E 1/

rn~~;f-f~*%<-*k~fi-J~#.11-A~~j(_~;;r-:~~

60~~~-~~~;j;:.~~~Jt~±~*.f.to

®**~··#i:.~: (-tlf~60~*)), +*= +$:k. i:. )l" ( foundationalism) ,fo " :k. ~ 60 £.,;;!: i:. )l" ( FO * til Jl&.;f±, 2004 + ~ UNDATTONALISM) o ;ti:J!IIf · .;@- .>t: (OiEt/bl'i :j~yt)) $

~*o ~*~~: ~M*, * *· ~~*~~~~ @~-~*~7*60(~Jfli:.5l60~*»--¥ ('l@-t

X,.)l.Jf, $£.5tft.!f: Harvester til Jl&.;f.±., I982) {/.; h}f-it~

~. 7*~~$~~~A·~60~~~~~R. "~

~&~I~+•~A~~#60~-~:ift>~~fi-J·~·

~4\},11-~-~#~~}", ~&"~*~*_;(_•

~*::r-:*W~*rn~A60~~. ~~·~rni:.5l' 60

.f-i%"o JJ!.:;it.f.t · 7*: (if [~_i{~_:k] @~:ift> [JE1E1

.t.i:!F] }~,f.t,;f,)), (-!:;f-Jl.Jf. Jt~±*~~.::..t--!tl1hJf

it~iUA)), I985 if-, _$ 39 -48. 39 9f ,, ( .:l\;fEJ1t,

74

Ai:-~fJt{g-~,;fi.j{o ~i~ 201209; ~kitl~*'

~~·~~' *~~~$~~X~~~Ak~ ..u .!'• Iii: J.l. _,_."" ;;!.._d;t.. q.>:..1:t , 1-T "'t:~ ~ "IX. 7' ~ o