diving deeper into the million cat challenge: alternatives to intake
TRANSCRIPT
The Million Cat Challenge: Diving deeper with Alternatives to Intake
What would YOU do?
What would YOU do?
3
Why do people bring cats to shelters?
4
In order to help a lost cat get back to its
owner?
In order to protect the cat from danger or
suffering?
To get a behavior to stop that is bothering or
worrying them?
Because there is a barrier to keeping the cat and they want it to
have a new home?
Why do people bring cats to shelters?
5
Why do people bring cats to shelters?
6
“One of the biggest challenges we have isn’t figuring out a solution to keep the pet in the home, or private rehoming, but debunking the myth that shelters are the #1 place for animals. People honestly believe they are doing the right thing, that there aren’t other options; the responsible and best thing to do is surrender to a shelter.”
Lisa Bassi, SF SPCA, San Francisco, CA
Alternatives to Intake
When to consider alternatives
• Underage kittens?• Feral cats?• Owner
surrenders?• Stray cats?
When to consider alternatives• Any time you could provide
as good or a better outcome for the cat, the person, the shelter, the community by some means other than intake
• Engage your community as a safety net
• Reserve the shelter for animals that can only be served by the shelter
Alts to in for neonates• Consider:
– The goal of the finder/owner
– Shelter resources for in-house foster/neonatal nursery
• Are they really orphaned? – If not, can they stay where
they are? – If so, can the finder/owner
raise them with support?
10Are they really orphan kittens?
What’s on your website?
11
• Be friendly but honest about shelter resources
• “Wait until 8” • Wait and watch for a
few hours• What to do if:– Friendly mom returns?– Feral mom returns? – No mom returns?
http://humanebroward.com/found-kittens/
The “Stray Kitten” Scenario
http://www.maddiesfund.org/assets/documents/Institute/Community%20Pet%20Adoption%20Partnerships_WEB.FINAL.5.26.15.pdf
Worth asking• 68% of organizations
that were “extremely likely” to ask community members to care for kittens reported many or some people agreed; organizations unlikely to ask reported only 33% agreement when they did ask
13
Take home messages• Cultivate strong and
enthusiastic approaches when asking community members to care for underage kittens – Or do anything, really
• Find ways to offer veterinary care and supplies if possible
• Offer but do not require training in kitten care
14
http://www.maddiesfund.org/orphaned-kitten-care-how-to.htm
What could be cuter?• Miami-Dade Milkman
program• Animal service officers
deliver kitten care kits to finders of orphaned kittens
• No increase in field service staffing, neonatal care coordinator added
• Initially funded by grants, then success used to justify funding from municipality
15http://aspcapro.org/blog/2015/09/21/they-did-it-offsite-neonatal-care-kittens
All the details
16Half hour lunch n’ learn with the Million Cat Challenge: email [email protected] for registration info
The buy-in has been incredible…the assumption was that people wanted the kittens gone, but really most
people just wanted the kittens to be taken care of.
Alts to in for feral cats• Cut out the middleman and
encourage community based solutions
• Decentralize services by local TNR referrals
• Refer to in-house “TNG”: Trap/neuter/give back– Ask with conviction– Offer drop off services if
possible– Weave into daily surgery
schedule– Soft pilot for full RTF or as an
end unto itself17
Alts to in for feral cats• If no on-site or local
TNR option– It’s ok to start by
stopping– Create a plan over time– Offer support/solutions
in the meantime for coexistence and nuisance abatement
18
Changing times
19
• Because of education now more readily available in our community, the acceptance of TNR programs are becoming more widespread. We now are able to explain to people why feral cats do not do well in shelter environments and how they can live better in the environment they were raised on with just a little support from a caretaker. Once we explain the reasoning behind all this, they really catch on and it has opened numerous spots here at the shelter for us to instead take in cats that will be adopted or ones that really need the medical care.
Sally Hubbard, Save-a-Pet, Grayslake, IL
The right tool for the job
20
• Sac Ferals serves as a starting point for complaints about too many cats. Gone are the days of an animal control officer immediately responding to a nuisance call of too many cats, issuing citations and impounding ferals. Working closely with Sac Ferals, we instead ask for their assistance to triage these complaints. Volunteers assist with those difficult conversations, convince well intentioned people to allow trapping and vetting…They are often able to accomplish what a uniform and badge cannot.
Gina Knepp, Front Street Animal Shelter, Sacramento, CA
Alts to in for owned pets• Resources for keeping
– Medical – Behavioral– Cost of care– Life circumstances
• Resources for rehoming– Rehoming readiness
(spay/neuter/vax/ID)– Photos– Flyers– Web and social media posting– Media posting (radio, TV, news)
21
http://www.animalhumanesociety.org/admissions/alternatives-surrendering-your-pet
Helping cats think inside the box (and other behavior issues)
22
http://www.animalsheltering.org/page/guide-cat-behavior-counseling
http://www.animalsheltering.org/content/cat-behavior-and-retention-course
Problem solving scripts and systems
23
Rehoming, help!
24
Needs a home with no other pets. She
becomes very attached to her humans. Does
not do well with other animals.
Helping rehome
25
Looking for someone to cuddle with on a rainy
afternoon? Che’s your girl! You can’t help but fall in love with this affectionate, sweet
lady who loves laps, head rubs and quiet time. She can
also catch the red dot! Better hurry and meet her…
she won’t be here long!
Alts to in for healthy strays• Most free roaming cats
brought to shelters aren’t lost pets– Some aren’t pets– Some weren’t lost!
• Most lost cats aren’t recovered by a call or visit to a shelter
• Even if there’s room, admitting a healthy stray may not be in anyone’s best interest
Lost cat reality check• Random digit dialed national
survey• 15% of households had lost a
cat• Of those, 75% were found
– 1/54 by visit to shelter– 48/54 by returning on their
own or searching neighborhood• Out of 506 households, 18
cats were lost and never found within the preceding 5 years
27
Resources for finders• Resources for finding the
owner– Post on shelter website– Lost and found facebook
page– Third party website– Scan for microchip– Downloadable flyer to print
• Resources for co-existence– Spay/neuter/vaccination– Non-lethal deterrents– Responsible care
28
Alt to in
FOUND, FOUND, FOUND
30
Web and social media
What sites do you like? • Facebook? • Shelter software linked? • Custom in-house solution? • Third party website? • Smartphone app?
32
Finders, Keepers
33
• “When a stray finder calls, if we have space, we welcome the cat. If we don't, we offer the finder a microchip scan, free vaccines, food, litter, a crate, etc. Person after person says to us that they want to keep the cat and giving them these items plus a scheduled spay/neuter helps them to do so.”
Emily Klehm, South Suburban Humane Society
Dear Million Cat Challenge...
34
That all sounds great, but how can we afford to
give people all those goodies?
Smart investment
35
• We fund it by recognizing that preventing intake saves us cost-of-care hours. By managing our population, our adoptions have skyrocketed because our population is healthier. We have four PetSmart locations that permanently house our cats and with healthier populations, we're able to get them there faster which increases our funding.
Emily Klehm, South Suburban Humane Society
Take Credit! Communicate to staff &
stakeholders Report help calls and
results along with intake and outcome numbers Still helping animals Still using resources
Shelter software can help you track
All In on Alts to In• Small public shelter
– Private shelter does cat and dog adoption
– Staff of 6, serving ~ 90,000 people
• Discontinued intake of healthy cats– Healthy owner surrenders
private shelter for adoption– Finders of strays resources to
find owner and/or TNR group in community
– Staff counsel community members on coexisting with cats
The new policy means more work on the front
end for staff, who have to explain the options for
people who have unwanted cats in their
yard, for example, Mohr says.
But the trade-off is that fewer cats enter
the shelter, and fewer get euthanized—which makes for a
happier staff.
http://www.animalsheltering.org/magazine/articles/change-better-chico
• People no longer could use the shelter as the “Easy Button” – a place to drop off cats without trying to find their own solutions to the problem, sometimes of their own making. So for example, someone contacts us saying there are stray cats in their yard/neighborhood. The old answer would have been: set traps and animal control will go out and pick up the cats. This option has been eliminated. Now we have a conversation…our job is to help facilitate the public to engage in the desired behavior which could be TNR or helping a neighbor with TNR, not feeding their pets outside which could be attracting cats, making their yard unattractive to cats in various ways, having a stray cat scanned for a microchip, advertising a found cat on Craigslist, etc.
Real solutions
Tracy Mohr, Chico City Animal Shelter, Chico, CA
A whole new ballgame
40Intake ↓ from 1881 to 442, euthanasia ↓ from 527 to 88 (including ORE)
Initiated 2/2013
Letting the community step upWord is out since we had a gentleman come in saying he knows we don't accept feral cats, but where can he get
traps to do TNR. We have gotten a lot of support from the media and the
public, and it vastly outweighs the people who are against it.
41
It takes a village
42
Hi Dr. Hurley, You made a presentation in Chico on December 18, 2012 about community cats, and TNR. In response, myself and nine other awesome ladies decided to form a trap-neuter-return group in Chico that we call Neighborhood Cat Advocates (www.neighborhoodcatadvocates.org). We just tallied our final numbers for 2013 - we trapped, neutered, and returned 683 cats. 683!!! We also facilitated the adoptions of over 150 kittens that were trapped, socialized, and became pets. What a great year! Let's do it again!
Last month
43
Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2016 6:37 AMTo: Kate HurleySubject: Re: Chico TNR - great successes!!! Hi Dr. Hurley, I'm Shelly Rogers in Chico. We just got our final numbers for 2015, and we TNR'd 1,026 cats in 2015!! That brings our total number of cats TNR'd in three years to 2,778!
Dear Million Cat Challenge...My question is always, "if we don't
take them, what will happen to them? What field will they be
dumped in? What river or creek will they be drowned in?" The
possibilities if we didn't take them eliminated the possibility of turning
an animal away.
Initiated 2/2013
No measurable impact on risk
I get it
“Santa Cruz County Animal Shelter is an open-admission shelter, meaning that we turn no animal away.”
Reality check• Population 822,553• 1 pet cat/~4.1 people• 1 community cat/~7 people
47
158,587 pet cats117,508 community
cats
Reality check• Estimated ~ 50 million outdoor
pet cats and 30-80 million un-owned cats in the United States
• ~ 3.4 million cats admitted to animal shelters annually– Average of 1 in ~11,800 outdoor
cats admitted per day– No meaningful change to risk
unless special circumstances• Provide alternatives to keep
the cats safer, whether indoors or out
Dear Million Cat Challenge...
How is alternatives to intake not just foisting
the problems on other organizations?
Referrals that make sense• Complementary services
– E.g. TNR group for shelter without in-house program
• Cut out the middleman– E.g. direct to receiving
partner rather than transfer• Specific focus
– E.g. breed, age or condition specific rescues
– Including neonatal kittens• Balancing resources
– Changes over time
Dear Million Cat Challenge...
We don’t have a TNR partner we can refer people to and
we’re a public shelter, so we still end up taking in ferals
and healthy strays for euthanasia. We don’t like it, but how can we turn people
away?
Just start somewhere
52
We took a very quiet approach. Since we work for a police department my direct supervisor alerted the Chief and the admin team of our plan and we really just went for it. We made up a brochure with some basic information. We told our citizens we would take healthy adoptable owner releases, babies that were too young to survive, and the injured/dying.
Betty Cochran, Supervisor of Animal Services, Clovis Police Department, Clovis, CA
Let the community step up
53
I expected all heck to break loose BUT starting this on December 1st helped as it was the slowest time of the year for us with cats. I had many conversations about why we’re doing this and the main one being we were not going to keep killing healthy community cats.
Let us help ;-)
54
Yes there are those that gave us the “we pay your salary” and all the other threats citizens come at city employees with. We countered some of the negative by saying we didn’t just make this up. (Throwing ucd under the bus) We were working with experts in shelter medicine and other experts in the area of community cat management across the United States. That seemed to help give credibility to our actions.
A world of difference
55
Since we housed 1000 less cats in 2014 we were able to spend time saving the little’s that we didn’t have the time/staff before.That was huge obviously for the animals but the staff did an amazing job raising little monsters and getting them adopted. The other thing that happened is we had time and space and money to rehab injured/special cases.
Same shelter, different world
Last week From: Betty Cochran [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, February 16, 2016 8:41 AMSubject: Had to share For the first time ever I got an email from the adoption center asking for cats because the beautiful community cat room was empty.Now that was a victory in so many ways for me….then of course I had to round up some cats for adoption
57
More questions for the Million Cat Challenge?
???http://www.millioncatchallenge.org/resources/dear-million-cat-challenge#cat2 [email protected]
#ThanksToMaddie!
60