diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in the ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 present address:...

17
Clays and Clay Minerals, Vol.44, No. 1, 96-112. 1996. DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE HELVETIC ALPS OF EASTERN SWITZERLAND HEJING WANG, 1,2 MARTIN FREY, 1 AND WILLEM B. STEr~N1 Mineralogisch-Petrographisches Institut der Universit~it, Bernoullistrasse 30, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic sediments from the northern margin of the Alps in eastern Switzerland were studied by clay mineralogical methods. Based on illite "crystallinity" (Ktibler index), the study area is divided into diagenetic zone, anchizone and epizone. Data on the regional distribution of the following index minerals are presented: smectite, kaolinite/smectite mixed-layer phase, kaolinite, pyrophyllite, paragonite, chloritoid, glauconite and stilpnomelane. Isograds for kaolinite/pyrophyllite and glauconite/stilpnomelane are consistent with illite "crystallinity" zones. Using the ordering of mixed-layer illite/smectite, the diagenetic zone is subdivided into three zones. The illite domain size distribution was analyzed using the Warren-Averbach technique. The average illite domain size does not change much within the diagenetic zone, but shows a large increase within the anchizone and epizone. The average illite bo value indicates conditions of an intermediate-pressure facies series. The Helvetic nappes show a general increase in diagenetic/metamorphic grade from north to south, and within the Helvetic nappe pile, grade increases from tectonically higher to lower units. However, a discontinuous inverse diagenetic/metamorphic zonation was observed along the Glarus thrust, indicating 5-10 km of offset after metamorphism. In the study area, incipient metamorphism was a late syn- to post-nappe-forming event. Key Words--Clay mineralogy, Diagenesis, Helvetic Alps, Incipient metamorphism, Switzerland. INTRODUCTION Diagenetic and very low-grade metamorphic sedi- ments are widespread in external parts of the Alps (Frey 1986). Therefore, an understanding of incipient metamorphism is important to unravel the tectono- thermal evolution of such areas. Contrasting methods have been applied to quantify the degree of incipient metamorphism during Alpine orogenesis such as illite "crystallinity," index minerals, coal rank and fluid in- clusion data. The aim of this study is to provide new information on diagenesis and incipient metamorphism of the Helvetic Alps of eastern Switzerland based on clay mineral data. Besides the classical approach using illite "crystallinity" and index minerals, additional in- formation was obtained from the ordering of illite/ smectite mixed-layer minerals and the domain size of illite. Information on coal rank, based on vitrinite re- flectance data using the same samples of the present study, is given by Erdelbrock (1994). GEOLOGICAL SETTING The study area is located in northeast Switzerland and extends from AppenzeU in the north to Chur in the south (45 kin) and from Lake Walen in the west to the Rhine River in the east (30 km) (Figure 1). Tectonically the study area belongs to the Helvetic zone along the northern margin of the Alps. To the north, nappes of the Helvetic zone override the Terti- ary clastics of the adjoining Molasse basin, a foredeep which formed during the later stages of the Alpine collision. To the south and east, the Helvetic nappes are overlain by the Penninic nappe system. The Me- sozoic sediments making up the largest part of the Hel- vetic zone comprise essentially a carbonate shelf se- quence of the northern European margin. In the course of the Alpine collision the Penninic nappes were thrust onto the Helvetic zone. During this process, the rocks of the Helvetic zone were buried, deformed and meta- morphosed up to lower greenschist facies conditions. The Helvetic zone of the area investigated is sub- divided by the Glarus thrust, which has a displacement of up to 40 km, into the Helvetic nappes (above) and the Infrahelvetic complex (below). The Helvetic nappes represent classic detachment tectonics, whereas the Infrahelvetic complex is a thick-skinned fold-and- thrust belt, cored by the Aar massif basement uplift. The stratigrapbic sequence of the Helvetic zone in- cludes Permian conglomerates, Triassic dolomites, various thick limestones of Jurassic and Cretaceous age and Tertiary sandstones that are interbedded with various shaly and marly horizons. On top of the Hel- vetic S~intis nappe, Southhelvetic units and separated by the basal Penninic thrust, several Penninic klippes are found (Figure 1). The Southhelvetic units comprise mainly limestones and marls of Upper Cretaceous to Eocene age. The Penninic klippes consist mainly of Cretaceous Northpenninic flysch. For more detailed in- formation on the geologic evolution of the Helvetic zone, the reader is referred to Trtimpy (1980), Pfiffner (1986) and Pfiffner et al. (1990). Very low-grade metamorphism of the Helvetic zone of eastern Switzerland has been studied by many an- Copyright 1996, The Clay Minerals Society 96

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Clays and Clay Minerals, Vol. 44, No. 1, 96-112. 1996.

DIAGENESIS A N D METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE HELVETIC ALPS OF EASTERN SWITZERLAND

HEJING WANG, 1,2 MARTIN FREY, 1 AND WILLEM B. STEr~N 1

Mineralogisch-Petrographisches Institut der Universit~it, Bernoullistrasse 30, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland

2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China

Abstract--Helvet ic sediments from the northern margin of the Alps in eastern Switzerland were studied by clay mineralogical methods. Based on illite "crystallinity" (Ktibler index), the study area is divided into diagenetic zone, anchizone and epizone. Data on the regional distribution of the following index minerals are presented: smectite, kaolinite/smectite mixed-layer phase, kaolinite, pyrophyllite, paragonite, chloritoid, glauconite and stilpnomelane. Isograds for kaolinite/pyrophyllite and glauconite/stilpnomelane are consistent with illite "crystallinity" zones. Using the ordering of mixed-layer illite/smectite, the diagenetic zone is subdivided into three zones. The illite domain size distribution was analyzed using the Warren-Averbach technique. The average illite domain size does not change much within the diagenetic zone, but shows a large increase within the anchizone and epizone. The average illite bo value indicates conditions of an intermediate-pressure facies series.

The Helvetic nappes show a general increase in diagenetic/metamorphic grade from north to south, and within the Helvetic nappe pile, grade increases from tectonically higher to lower units. However, a discontinuous inverse diagenetic/metamorphic zonation was observed along the Glarus thrust, indicating 5-10 km of offset after metamorphism. In the study area, incipient metamorphism was a late syn- to post-nappe-forming event.

Key Words- -Clay mineralogy, Diagenesis, Helvetic Alps, Incipient metamorphism, Switzerland.

INTRODUCTION

Diagene t ic and ve ry low-grade m e t am or ph i c sedi- ments are widespread in external parts of the Alps (Frey 1986). Therefore , an unde r s t and ing of inc ip ien t m e t a m o r p h i s m is impor tan t to unrave l the tec tono- the rmal evolu t ion of such areas. Cont ras t ing me thods have been appl ied to quant i fy the degree of inc ip ien t m e t a m o r p h i s m dur ing Alp ine orogenes is such as i l l i te "c rys ta l l in i ty , " index minera ls , coal r ank and fluid in- c lus ion data. The a im of this s tudy is to p rov ide new in format ion on d iagenes is and inc ip ien t m e t a m o r p h i s m of the Helvet ic Alps of eas tern Swi tzer land based on clay minera l data. Bes ides the classical approach us ing il l i te " c rys t a l l i n i t y " and index minerals , addi t ional in- fo rmat ion was ob ta ined f rom the order ing of i l l i te/ smect i te mixed- laye r minera l s and the d o m a i n size o f illite. In fo rma t ion on coal rank, based on vi t r ini te re- f lectance data us ing the same samples of the p resen t study, is g iven by Erde lb rock (1994).

GEOLOGICAL SETTING

The study area is loca ted in nor theas t Swi tzer land and ex tends f rom AppenzeU in the nor th to Chur in the south (45 kin) and f rom Lake Walen in the west to the Rh ine Rive r in the east (30 km) (Figure 1). Tectonical ly the s tudy area be longs to the Helve t ic zone a long the nor thern marg in of the Alps. To the north, nappes of the Helve t ic zone overr ide the Terti- ary clast ics o f the ad jo in ing Molasse bas in , a foredeep wh ich fo rmed dur ing the later stages o f the Alp ine coll ision. To the south and east, the Helvet ic nappes

are over la in by the Penn in ic nappe system. The Me- sozoic sed iments mak ing up the largest par t of the Hel- vet ic zone compr i se essent ia l ly a ca rbona te she l f se- quence of the nor the rn European margin . In the course of the Alp ine col l is ion the Penn in i c nappes were thrus t on to the Helvet ic zone. Dur ing this process , the rocks o f the Helvet ic zone were buried, de fo rmed and meta- m o r p h o s e d up to lower g reensch is t facies condi t ions.

The Helvet ic zone of the area inves t iga ted is sub- d iv ided by the Glarus thrust, wh ich has a d i sp l acemen t of up to 40 km, into the Helvet ic nappes (above) and the I n f r a h e l v e t i c c o m p l e x (be low) . T h e H e l v e t i c nappes represen t c lassic de t achmen t tectonics, whereas the Inf rahe lve t ic complex is a th i ck - sk inned fo ld-and- thrus t belt , cored by the Aa r m a s s i f b a s e m e n t uplift. The s t ra t igrapbic sequence of the Helvet ic zone in- c ludes Pe rmian conglomera tes , Triassic dolomites , var ious th ick l imes tones of Jurass ic and Cre taceous age and Tert iary sands tones that are in te rbedded wi th var ious shaly and mar ly hor izons . On top of the Hel- vet ic S~intis nappe, Southhe lve t ic uni ts and separated by the basa l Penn in i c thrust, several Penn in ic kl ippes are found (Figure 1). The Southhe lve t ic uni ts compr i se ma in ly l imes tones and mar ls of U p p e r Cre taceous to Eocene age. The Penn in i c kl ippes cons is t main ly o f Cre taceous Nor thpenn in i c flysch. For more deta i led in- fo rmat ion on the geologic evo lu t ion of the Helvet ic zone, the reader is re fer red to Trt impy (1980), Pf i f fner (1986) and Pf i f fner et al. (1990).

Very low-grade m e t a m o r p h i s m of the Helvet ic zone of eas tern Swi tze r land has been s tudied by m a n y an-

Copyright �9 1996, The Clay Minerals Society 96

Page 2: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1 9 9 6 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 97

Figure 1. Tectonic map of NE Switzerland, modified after Spicher (1980). Marginal numbers refer to the Swiss coordinate network system. Fb = Flfischerberg, La = Landquart.

thors, using mainly the illite "crystallinity" technique and index minerals, supplemented by a few virtrinite reflectance and fluid inclusion data. Frey (1970) noted a general increase of illite "crystallinity" from the lower anchizone south of Lake Walen to the epizone in the parautochthonous cover of the Aar massif. Frey (1988) found epizonal illite "crystallinities" in the Verrucano of the lower Helvetic nappes and mid-an- chizonal values in the underlying flysch units of the Infrahelvetic complex. The discontinuous inverse metamorphic zonation was explained by post-meta-

morphic thrusting along the Glarus thrust. Frey et al. (1973) and Frey (1987a) mapped index minerals in glauconite-bearing limestones. A stilpnomelane-in is- ograd was located in the mid-anchizone and a biotite- in isograd at the beginning of the epizone. Frey (1987b) located the isograd kaolinite + quartz = py- rophyllite + H20, running in a WSW-ENE direction close to the eastern end of Lake Walen, and estimated metamorphic conditions at the isograd from vitrinite reflectance and fluid inclusion data to be 1.3-2.1 kbar and 240-270~ at a water activity of 0.6-0.8. Recent-

Page 3: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

98 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

ly, Erdelbrock et al. (1993) presented a coalification map of the study area, based on about 450 vitrinite reflectance values. The thermal maturity was found to increase from ca. 0.5% R~ in the Subalpine Molasse in the north to Rr~ >5% in the south. Hunziker et at. (1986) dated the main phase of Alpine metamorphism at 30-35 Ma, based on concordant K-Ar, 4~ and Rb-Sr illite ages, while a second age group between 20 and 25 Ma was attributed to movements along the Glarus thrust.

METHODS

MATERIAL STUDIED. Some 386 samples were analyzed. Lithologies included - 4 0 % shales and slates, --30% sandstones, --20% marls and --10% limestones and marbles. The location of the samples is given in Figure 2. Note the uneven sample density with few samples west of Sargans and in the southernmost part of the study area.

SAMPLE PREPARATION. Samples were cleaned with a steel brush, crushed into small pieces with a hanuner and - 7 0 g of sample were ground in a tungsten-car- bide swing-mill for 30 sec. Carbonate was removed by treating with 5% acetic acid and by washing with deionized water. The <2 ixm fraction was prepared using differential settling tubes and millipore filters with 0. I mm pore size. The clay fraction was then Ca- saturated with 2N CaC12. Oriented slides were pre- pared by pipetting suspensions onto glass slides (--5 mg/cm 2) and allowing it to air-dry. Glycolated mounts (for 228 samples) were prepared in a glycol steam bath at 60~ overnight. Heat-treated mounts (for 48 sam- ples) were prepared in an oven at 375 or 500~ for 1 h. Randomly oriented samples were prepared using the technique proposed by Handschin and Stern (1989) and Stern (1991) needing only 20 mg of material.

X-RAY DIFFRACTION (XRD). Measurements w e r e p e r -

formed with a Siemens D500 diffractometer, opti- mized for counting statistics and acceptable resolution (Table 1).

DOMAIN SIZE ANALYSIS. The method proposed by War- ten and Averbach (1950) and the Scherrer equation were used to investigate the domain size or the mean domain thickness. Analyses were performed on XRD patterns after deconvolution. For the Scherrer equa- tion, the constant K was set at 1.84 for layer-minerals according to Klug and Alexander (1974, p. 667).

GUINIER CAMERA X-RAY ANALYSIS. The <2 t~m fractions of 41 samples were analyzed using a Guinier-de Wolff camera for the "060" d-spacing analysis. Measuring conditions were with FeKct 1 radiation at 36 kV, 20 mA and with 16 h. exposure time. The films were trans- formed into diffractograms by use of a CR-650S den- sitometer.

RESULTS AA~D DISCUSSION

Incipient metamorphism in the study area will be documented by use of several index minerals and var- ious properties of illite, mixed-layer illite/smectite and chlorite. Results from illite "crystallinity" will be pre- sented frst, because it will serve as a reference frame for other indicators of incipient metamorphism.

Illite "Crystallinity"

GENERAL. Illite "crystallinity" (IC) was measured from X-ray diffractograms of air-dried preparates using the technique of Ktibler (1967, 1968). This IC index is defined as the full width at half maximum intensity (FWHM) of the first illite basal reflection at around 10 ,~, expressed as a difference in 20 values. The nu- merical value of the Kiibler index decreases with im- proving "crystallinity." Since illite/smectite mixed- layer minerals are abundant in the study area, especial- ly in the diagenetic zone (see below), the measurement of the FWHM includes both illite and illite/smectite basal reflections. For simplicity, however, the term IC will be retained here.

RESULTS. I f was determined on 368 samples. In order to avoid interfering basal reflections, paragonite- and pyrophyllite bearing samples from the anchizone were avoided, but some paragonite-bearing samples show- ing epizonal IC values were retained. FWHM values range from 2.50 to 0.16 ~ The regional distribu- tion of IC data is depicted in Figure 2, grouping the data into four classes using an arbitrarily chosen value of 0.80 ~ and the limiting IC values of 0.42 and 0.25 ~ for the anchizone. In general, IC improves southward. The transition from the diagenetic zone to the anchizone is shown as a 2-3 km broad band lim- ited by two lines labelled 1 and 1'. Line 1 is defined by the first anchizonal IC values going southward (ne- glecting three anchizonal values east of Appenzell), and line 1' is defined by the disappearance of diage- netic IC values (neglecting four data points south of Sargans). In a similar way, the transition from the an- chizone to the epizone is shown as a 2-3 km broad band limited by two lines labelled 2 and 2'. Line 2 is defined by the first epizonal IC values going south- ward (neglecting four epizonal data points further north, three from the Verrucano and one from the basal part of the Axen nappe), and line 2' is defined by the disappearance of anchizonal IC values.

The following tectonic units belong to the diage- netic zone (compare Figures 1 and 2): the Subalpine Molasse, Penninic and Southhelvetic units as well as the major part of the underlying Helvetic Santis nappe (excluding a small area east of Alvier and the Fl~is- cherberg east of Sargans). Localities with IC values >0.8 and 0.8-0.43 ~ are intermixed in the diage- netic zone. The transition from the diagenetic zone to the anchizone occurs mainly in the lower part of the

Page 4: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1996 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 99

Figure 2. Illite "crystallinity" distribution map. Lines 1 and 1' indicate the transition from the diagenetic zone to the anchizone. Lines 2 and 2' indicate the transition from the anchizone to the epizone. The two dashed lines 2 and 2' W of Sargans indicate the transition from the anchizone to the epizone in the Verrucano.

A x e n nappe nor theas t of the Seez Valley (be tween Lake Walen and Sargans) . This area is charac te r ized by a s trong re l ief o f a lmos t 2 km. Fur ther to the west , this b o u n d a r y is located in the Mi i r t schen nappe south- east of Lake Walen. Nor th -nor theas t of Sargans, this

b o u n d a r y is cut t ing th rough the Santis thrust, separat- ing S~intis and A x e n nappes. The fo l lowing tec tonic uni ts of the s tudy area be long to the anchizone" the A x e n nappe and the Ver rucano southeas t of the Seez Valley (F lumserberge) , A x e n and S~ntis nappe of the

Page 5: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

100 Wang, Frey, and Stern

Table 1. Instrumental conditions and measurement procedure.

Clays and Clay Minerals

Equipment Radiation Slits

Goniometer

Computer

Software

Ka2 IC (Ktibler index)

d001J001 of I/S Domain size

bo

Diffractometer SIEMENS D 500 Cu, 40kV, 30mA, no primary filter automatic divergence set at 3 ~ , slits on primary side 3~ secondary

side 1 ~ 0.05 and 0.15 ram. Graphite monochromator routine measurement cell parameter low angle medium angle high angle low to high angle 2-15~ 15-42~ 42-48~ 5-65~ 0.05 ~ increment 0.02 ~ 0.02 ~ 0.02 ~ 30 sec. 1 sec. 10 sec. 10 sec. Sicomp 32-20 80-386 with internal and external hard discs and CD-

rom for JCPDS-data Diffrac AT Version 3.2 by Socabim/Siemens 1986, 1993, JCPDS data

bank system version 2.14. Sets 1-43, PDF-1, 2 not stripped measured from the unresolved 10 A complex using single peak-op

tion in Diffrac AT deconvoluted from the 10 A complex for glycolated samples I/S and illite were deconvoluted using Pearson function for the 10 ,~

complex at air-dried state, the backgrounds were subtracted, no smoothing operation. The deconvoluted profiles were then trans- ferred to the WlN-CRYSIZE programme (version 1.03, Sigma-C. 1991-1994), from which the average domain size of US and illite, and the domain size distributions were calculated using the W-A method. Single crystal of muscovite was used as standard

The background was subtracted first, no smoothing operation, zoom editing technique was used. At least 20 reflections of illite were edited and transferred to the WIN-METRIC programme (version 2.0B, Sigma-C. 1991-1994), from which the cell parameters were refined using the least square method assuming a 2M 1 polytype for all investigated samples. The tolerances are 0.08-0.05~ rejected reflections less than 10%

Fl~scherberg , and m a j o r parts o f the Sardona flysch, South Helvet ic uni ts and Nor th Helve t ic flysch. The t rans i t ion f rom the anch izone to the ep izone is loca ted main ly in the Nor th Helvet ic f lysch wes t of Landquar t , but fur ther to the wes t this t rans i t ion takes place in the Sa rdona flysch. Ep izona l condi t ions are encoun te red in the pa rau toch thonous of the Aar massif , but also in the Ver rucano nor th of Pizol above the Glarus thrust.

DISCUSSION. IC is dependen t on m a n y variables , in- c luding tempera ture , fluid chemis t ry and pressure , stress, dura t ion of al terat ion, il l i te chemis t ry , interfer- ing basal ref lect ions of o ther phases and exper imen ta l condi t ions (Frey 1987a; Yang and Hesse 1991). Fol- lowing Ktibler (1967, 1968) it is be l i eved that tem- pera ture is the mos t impor t an t var iable affect ing IC in the s tudy area, because the lower and h igher anch izone boundar ies are subpara l le l to i so rank l ines de t e rmined by vi t r ini te ref lectance (Erde lb rock 1994).

The fo l lowing conc lus ions can be d rawn f rom the IC dis t r ibut ion pat tern o f F igure 2: 1) Penn in ic kl ippes in the nor the rn par t of the s tudy area seem to have reached a s imilar stage of d iagenes is as the under ly ing Southhe lve t ic uni ts and the Santis nappe; 2) The lower and h ighe r anch izone boundar i e s cut th rough impor- tant thrus t planes. Therefore , inc ip ien t m e t a m o r p h i s m occur red af ter these tec tonic m o v e m e n t s ; and 3) Epi- zonal condi t ions were r eached in the Verrucano nor th-

wes t o f Pizol above the Glarus thrus t bu t anch izona l condi t ions exis t in the f lysch uni ts be low the Glarus thrust. This d i scont inuous inverse m e t a m o r p h i c zona- t ion is exp la ined by pos t -me tamorph ic thrus t ing a long the Glarus thrust. The same p h e n o m e n o n was already obse rved for an ident ical tec tonic s i tuat ion 20 k m fur- ther to the wes t (Frey 1988). The amoun t of this post- m e t a m o r p h i c th rus t ing can be es t imated as 5 - 1 0 kin, co r respond ing to the d is tance be tween the anch izone- ep izone b o u n d a r y in the Verrucano west of Sargans (dashed l ines in F igure 2) and the same b o u n d a r y in the Inf rahe lve t ic complex . Us ing vi t r ini te ref lectance data, E rde lb rock (1994) deduced an a m o u n t of 5.5 km.

Chlor i te " C r y s t a l l i n i t y "

GENERAL. Chlor i te 7 A peak wid th measu red under the same exper imen ta l condi t ions as ill i te 10 * peak wid th is used to de te rmine chlor i te " c rys t a l l i n i t y " (CC). Ar- kai (1991) p roposed that CC " c a n be appl ied as a re- l iable regional , stat ist ical t echn ique c o m p l e m e n t a r y with, or ins tead of, the ill i te crys ta l l in i ty m e t h o d . "

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION. F igure 3 shows that chlor i te has an enhanced "c rys t a l l i n i t y " compared to tha t of illite f rom the same sample . Due to the ra ther poor corre la t ion be tween IC and CC, the lat ter was not used as an ind ica tor o f inc ipient m e t a m o r p h i s m in this study.

Page 6: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1996 101 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland

0.7 I v I I n v

I N = 105

"el eLi l

l,,.t

P,.l eJml

% d +

=

0 .6

0.5

0 . 4

0.3

0.2

I o ~

�9 �9

t " . ' o : . . . .

Figure 3. spection.

0.1 V , , , , , I 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7

I C , * A 2 0 C t t l K ~ ( K i i b l e r I n d e x )

Illite "crystallinity" vs chlorite "crystallinity." The line of equal IC and CC values is indicated for visual in-

Regional Distribution of Index Minerals

SMECTITE. Smectite was identified by the strong 001 reflection at about 15 A on air-dried preparates, shift- ing to about 17 A after glycolation, and the 002 re- flection at about 8.45 ,~. After heating at 500~ for 1 h. these smectite reflections disappeared and the inten- sity of the first illite basal reflection increased. The position of the (060) reflection at 1.499 ,~ is indicative for dioctahedral smectite. Pure smectite was only found in 3 sandstones and 4 pelitic samples of the Subalpine Molasse near Appenzell (Figure 4), indicat- ing temperatures <100~ (Velde 1985, p. 115).

K A O L I N I T E / S M E C T I T E M I X E D - L A Y E R P H A S E . (K/S) was identified by its characteristic peaks and shoulders at spacings of 7.43-7.70 ,~ and 3.48-3.53 ,~ after gly- colation and by the shift of these peaks after heat treat- ment at 375~ (Figure 5). In addition, a slightly ele- vated background was observed between 13-15 ~ 20 on glycolated and heat-treated XRD traces. From com- parison with calculated diffractograms for the K/S compositional series (Moore and Reynolds 1989, Ta-

ble 7.5), our K/S are randomly interstratified and con- tain about 75%-90% kaolinite layers. K/S was detect- ed in four pelitic samples from the Upper Cretaceous (Amden shales) and the Lower Tertiary (Globigerina shales) belonging to the S~intis nappe and Southhel- vetic units near the Alpine border (Figure 4).

KAOHNITE. (Kln) was distinguished from chlorite by resolved reflections at about 25 ~ 20 CuKc~. For ka- olinite-poor samples containing large amounts of chlo- rite, an acid treatment with HC1 was used. A few ka- olinite occurrences from the study area were already reported by Briegel (1972) and Burger (1982), and Frey (1987b) documented two localities containing ka- olinite + pyrophyllite in the same sample. In the course of this study, 29 new kaolinite occurrences were found (Figure 6) mainly in pelites, marls and sandstones of the Subalpine Molasse, Penninic and South Helvetic units and the S~intis nappe. With one exception, all kaolinite localities belong to the diage- netic zone (compare with Figure 2), while the K l n + Prl locality at the eastern end of Lake Walen is from the transition to the anchizone.

Page 7: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

102 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

250

240

230

220

210

200

190

730 740 750 I ] I

760

O smectite ~ 5 Ak Kaolinite/Smectite j l

Appenze l l 4~ Paragoni~te / N []

O O

10km

~e w.m_en_: ~..V.

4t

I 1 I I 730 740 750 760

Figure 4. Distribution map for smectite, mixed-layer kaolinite/smectite and paragonite.

250

240

230

220

210

200

190

PYROPHYLLITE. (Prl) was easily identified by its first three basal reflections. Most of the pyrophylli te oc- currences shown in Figure 6 were already docu- mented by Frey (1987b). Three new occurrences of pyrophylli te were added in this study, two from Upper Liassic black shales and one from a Middle Jurassic (Mols fm.) pelitic sandstone, all located

closely together in the lower Axen nappe between Sargans and Lake Walen. These new findings allow for a more precise location of the isograd Kin + Qtz = Prl + H20 in the study area, running from the eastern end of Lake Walen in an almost west-east direction and crossing the S~intis thrust. In terms of IC data, this isograd is located approximately at

Page 8: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1 9 9 6 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 103

Figure 5.

I I I I I I

196-Am69 r

o

7.868 \ 3.53~:/ .

3.498 1 4.997 I 12;259 II /~ 3.531 i

14.118 9.904 ^~ 5.196/I 4.742 ~ /

I �9 �9 �9 �9 I �9 �9 �9 �9 I �9 �9 �9 �9 I . . . . I �9 �9

5 I0 15 20 25

8

�9 �9 I �9 �9 �9 �9

30 35

Diffraction Angle (~ CuK( ) X-ray diffractograms for sample 196-Am69 containing mixed-layer kaolinite/smectite for CuKa radiation.

the transition from the diagenetic zone to the anchi- zone.

PARAGONITE. (Pg) was identified by its first four basal reflections. However, the first paragonite basal reflec- tion is only barely visible as a weak shoulder on the high-angle side of the first illite basal reflection. The presence of paragonite/muscovite mixed-layer (Pg/Ms) was identified by two reflections at 4.9 and 3.26 A. 30 occurrences of paragonite, including those of Pg/Ms, from various stratigraphic and tectonic units are de- picted in Figure 4, and comparison with Figure 2 shows that paragonite begins to appear from the be- ginning of the anchizone.

CHLORITOIO. (Cld) was reported from a single locality in the study area by Frey and Wieland (1975). This

chloritoid was found in middle Jurassic slates belong- ing to the parautochthonous cover of the Aar massif south of the V~ittis window (Figure 6). The growth of chloritoid postdates the main phase of folding and thrusting (Calanda phase) in the Infrahelvetic complex (Pfiffner 1982).

GLAUCONITE. (Glt) was identified under the optical mi- croscope. On XRD traces, glauconite yields a strong first and a very weak second basal reflection and a (060) reflection at t.51 i 30 occurrences of glauco- nite are indicated in Figure 7, mainly from Cretaceous limestones and sandstones of the Garschella formation ("Gault") of the S~intis nappe. All these occurrences are restricted to the diagenetic zone.

Frey et al. (1973) described the progressive recta-

Page 9: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

104 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

Figure 6. Distribution map for kaolinite, pyrophyllite and chloritoid. The isograd Kin + Qtz = Prl + H20 crosses tectonic nappe boundaries (cf. Figure 1).

m o r p h i s m of g lauconi te -bear ing fo rmat ions and dist in- gu ished three m e t a m o r p h i c zones in the Glarus Alps. The new occurrences of g lauconi te repor ted in this s tudy (Figure 7) a l low one to map the zone I/II bound- ary in some detail , co r respond ing to the isograd Glt + Qtz • Chl = Stp + Kfs + H20 + 02. The p resence

of n e o f o r m e d K-fe ldspar as a p roduc t was d o c u m e n t e d by Frey et al. (1973).

STILPNOMELANE. (Stp) occur rences in F igure 7 were al- ready depic ted by Frey (1987a, F igure 2.12) but with- out g iv ing fur ther details. The three occur rences in the

Page 10: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1996 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 105

Figure 7. Distribution map for glauconite, stilpnomelane and biotite. The isograd for Glt + Qtz + Chl = Stp + Kfs + fluid is shown as a dashed line parallel to the IC lines of Figure 2.

sou thern par t of the Santis nappe are f rom Cre taceous g lauconi te beds ( A l t m a n n s c h i c h t e n and " G a u l t " ) . The no r the rnmos t of these three locali t ies wi th coexis t ing Gl t + Stp was first descr ibed by O u w e h a n d (1987, p. 162) f rom a quar ry located S W of R~fis in the Rh ine valley. Note that these occur rences o f s t i lpnomelane

are located in the d iagenet ic zone, about 2 - 3 k m downgrade f rom the beg inn ing of the anch izone , in accordance wi th obse rva t ions by Bre i t s chmid (1982) f rom the Reuss Valley, some 70 k m fur ther west- southwest . The s t i lpnomelane occur rence in the A x e n nappe direct ly nor th of Sargans is f rom midd le Juras-

Page 11: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

106 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

103-Mo6

I I I

g g

293-Zs15 14.15 /

I I I

i 10.01

7.14

10.06

f 74A'60__7_/ 5 I i I I I I

2 6 10 14~ Figure 8. X-ray diffractograrns for five representative sam- ples arranged from north (103-Mo6) to south (74-Am60). Thick lines refer to air-dried patterns, thin lines to glycolated patterns. The ordering state R of mixed-layer illite/smectite is indicated. (CuKa radiation).

sic iron ore (Niggli and Niggli 1965). The stilpnome- lane locality west of the Vattis window is from the Cretaceous (Lidernenscbichten) of the parautochthon- ous cover of the Aar massif. The occurrence with Stp + Bt at the southern end of the study area was men- tioned by Frey et al. (1973, Abb. 3) and is also from the Cretaceous of the parautochthonous cover of the Aar massif. Biirgisser and Felder (1974) have shown that the growth of such epizonal stilpnomelane post- dates the main phase of folding and thrusting (Calanda phase) in the Infrahelvetic complex.

Ordering of Illite/Smectite

GENERAL. Ordering of mixed-layer illite/smectite (US), interpreted from XRD profiles, correlate with changes in temperature due to burial depth (Pollastro 1993). The alternation and position in d-spacing of I/S basal reflections after glycolation can be used to determine the different ordering types and percentage of illite in US (Moore and Reynolds 1989). A reflection at 5 ~ indicates random interstratification (Reichweite -- R = 0), one near 6.5 ~ indicates R1 ordering, and a no- ticeable peak at angles greater than about 7 ~ sug- gests long-range ordering, that is R > 1 (Moore and Reynolds 1989, p. 252).

RESULTS. The Reichweite (ordering type) and the per- centage of illite in I/S were determined using the meth- od of Moore and Reynolds (1989) and the computer program NEWMOD (Reynolds 1985). Representative diffraction patterns arranged according to diagenetic/ metamorphic grade are shown in Figure 8, and the calibration curve used to estimate the illite percentage in I/S is depicted in Figure 9.

In our study area US is abundant in the diagenetic zone, less abundant in the lower anchizone and not detectable in the higher anchizone and the epizone. The ordering type and the illite content in I/S were determined in 279 samples, and the following four zones are distinguished (Figure 10):

Zone 1 is defined by the presence of randomly in- terstratified 1/S (R = 0) with 20-50% illite in US. The ordering types R = 1 with 50-85% illite in I/S and R > 1 with >85% illite in US are also found in this zone. Zone 1 is present in the NE part of the study area.

Zone 2 is defined by the presence of the US ordering type R = 1 with 50-85% illite in US and the absence of the R = 0 type. The ordering type R > 1 with >85% illite in US is also found in this zone. Zone 2 covers large parts of the Santis nappe, including South Helvetic units and Penninic klippes.

Zone 3 is defined by the presence of the US ordering type R > 1 with 85-90% illite in US and the absence of the R = 1 type. The ordering type R > 1 with >90% illite in US is also found in this zone. Zone 3 comprises the SE part of the S~intis nappe, a major

Page 12: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1 9 9 6 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 107

100

~ 80

~ I 60

40

10 11 12 13 14

d(001)1o/(001)17 (/~) spacing of I/S

after glycolation

Figure 9. Calibration curve used to estimate the illite per- centage in mixed-layer illite/smectite. The curve is valid for "dimica (1 Fe, 0.7 K) mixed with trismectite (1 Fe, 2 gly)" using the terminology of NEWMOD (Reynolds 1985).

part of the Axen nappe northeast of the Seez valley, and the Miirtschen nappe N of Lake Walen.

Zone 4 is defined by the presence of the US ordering type R > 1 with >90% illite in US and the absence of the other ordering types mentioned above. Zone 4 is mainly found in the Axen nappe N and NW of Sar- gans, the Fl~ischerberg, the MiJrtschen nappe SE of lake Walen, and in the Infrahelvetic complex S and SE of Sargans.

DISCUSSION. Zones 1-3 mentioned above are covering the diagenetic zone as defined by IC data. In other words, ordering L of US is a more sensitive indicator of diagenetic grade than IC.

As recently reviewed by Pollastro (1993), the changes in ordering of US may be used as a reliable semiquantitative geothermometer. However, in zones 1-3 described above different ordering types were found, presumably due to lithologic control and the presence of detrital clay minerals. Therefore, this geo- thermometer cannot be applied in our study area.

Domain Size of Illite in the C-direction

GENERAL. XRD line broadening is caused by the co- herent crystalline domain size or crystallite size, lattice strain and instrumental factors (Klug and Alexander 1974, p. 618). The domain size of clay minerals may be used as an indicator of incipient metamorphism (Eberl et al. 1990). At least six methods exist separat- ing the domain size from the general XRD line broad- ening (Scherrer 1918; Stokes 1948; Warren and Av- erbach 1950; Ergun 1968; Langford 1978; Balzer and

Ledbetter 1993). In the present study, the Warren-Av- erbach technique is used to measure illite domain size.

RESULTS. Line profiles of the first illite basal reflection obtained after deconvolution were analyzed on air- dried specimens by the Warren-Averbach method for 35 samples. In general, the position of the maximum frequency position increases and domain size distri- butions spread out as diagenetic/metamorphic grade increases. In the study area, the mean domain size of illite increases from 11 nm in the north to 145 nm in the south, with a major change occurring between km 210 and km 190 of the Swiss coordinate system. With respect to illite "crystallinity," the illite average col- umn length does not change much within the diage- netic zone, but shows a large increase within the an- chi- and epizone (Figure 11).

The domain size of illite/smectite was also mea- sured with the Warren-Averbach method, and it was always found to be thinner than that of accompanying illite. I/S domain size increases from 7 nm in the North to 34 nm in the South, therefore showing the same general tendency as illite.

DISCUSSION. Assuming the presence of strain-free illite, the Scherrer equation was also used to calculate the mean domain size of illite. A range from 7 to 97 nm was obtained, compared with 11-145 nm by the War- ren-Averbach method. This difference may be ex- plained by the fact that the Scherrer equation does not take account of the strain effects. Furthermore, the Warren-Averbach technique is model-dependent and will not correspond to a real distribution of grain sizes of natural clays that may preserve strain across semi- coherent packets, as discussed by Lanson and Ktibler (1994).

Eberl et al. (1990) analyzed the particle thickness distributions for 20 anchizonal and epizonal illites from shales from the Glarus Alps, located directly in the West of our study area. The general shape of par- ticle thickness distribution curves obtained was similar to those derived in this study, and it was concluded that these illites underwent recrystallization by Ost- wald ripening. However, these authors reported small- er illite average column length values than obtained for illites of comparable grade in this study; e.g., <35 nm (Eberl et al. 1990) vs 100--145 nm (this study) for epizonal illites. More work is needed to explain this discrepancy.

Most recently, Warr and Rice (1994) proposed illite domain (crystallite) sizes of 23 for the lower and 52 nm for the upper limit of the anchizone determined by the Warren-Averbach method. These values are much smaller than the limiting values of about 50 and 100 nm determined in this study. It should be mentioned that Warr and Rice (1994) were using glycolated spec- imens for the domain size analyses but made a cor- relation with illite "crystallinity" determined on air-

Page 13: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

108

250

240

230 -

730 I

Wang, Frey, and Stern

740 750 l I

* R = 0

[] R = I O

N

R>I, 85-90% I in I /S R>I, >90% I in I /S

5

AppenzeU [] |

O

10km

Clays and Clay Minerals

760

11 , 250

240

2 2 0 - ~ ~ - 220

210 210

200 d "~I ] , ,-.~_ ~ J ~ ; \ ~ 200

J 190

I I I - " I

730 740 750 760

190

Figure 10. Distribution map for different ordering types of mixed-layer illite/smectite and percentage of illite in US. These data allow for a four-fold zonation as discussed in text.

dried specimens. In addition, the correlation proposed by these authors is based on four specimens only. The authors of this article feel that much more experience is needed with domain size analyses and that the lim- iting values of Warr and Rice (1994) should be re- garded with caution.

Chlorite Polytypes

GENERAL. During late diagenesis and incipient meta- morphism a change in the polytype of trioctahedral chlorite is observed. Hayes (1970) proposed that the polytype transformation sequence Ib d ---> Ib 03 = 97 ~

Page 14: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1 9 9 6 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 109

r <1 o

Figure 1 I.

2.5

2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.0

I I I

m

Q o

N

m

o o

�9 N u u w

0 �9 Anchizone

i I I

0 50 100 150 200

Illite Average Column Length (urn) Variation of illite domain size or illite average column length vs illite "crystallinity" (Kiibler index).

-~ Ib (~ = 90 ~ --~ lib (13 = 97 ~ occurs in chlorites in sedimentary rocks with increasing temperature, and that the final transformation from type-I to type-II chlorite requires a temperature of about 150-200~ However, as recently reviewed by Walker (1993), oth- er factors including grain size of the host rock, may be at least as important as temperature in controlling the stability of type-I chlorite polytypes. In addition, systematic studies suggest that type-II chlorite is stable at temperatures well below 200~ and that it can form as the initial chlorite phase without passing through any intermediate polytypic stages (Walker 1993).

RESULTS. Chlorite polytypes were determined on 19 chlorite-rich samples following the methods proposed by Bailey (1988) and Moore and Reynolds (1989). In- terference with illite reflections were stripped by using deconvolution technique. For 12 samples from the dia- genetic zone (5 sandstones, 4 pelites and 3 lime- stones), exclusively the Ib (13 = 90 ~ polytype was found, while in 7 pelites and marls from the anchizone and epizone only the IIb chlorite polytype was present.

DISCUSSION. If compared to other indicators of incipient metamorphism in the study area, the simple chlorite polytype distribution pattern seems to follow the ob- servations made by Hayes (1970), for example the Ib ([3 = 90 ~ chlorite polytype of the diagenetic zone is followed by the IIb polytype in the anchizone and ep- izone. Therefore, the chlorite polytype conversion in the study area appears to be controlled mainly by tem- perature.

bo of illite

GENERAL. The bo cell parameter of muscovite or illite may be used as a semiquantitative geobarometer for epizonal (Sassi and Scolari 1974) or upper anchizonal (Padan et al. 1982) shales and slates. This geobaro- meter is based on two observations: 1) the celadonite content of potassic white mica increases with increas- ing pressure (if temperature is held constant); and 2) there exists a positive correlation between the bo pa- rameter and celadonite content. Although this barom- eter uses unbuffered assemblages lacking K-feldspar, it has been successfully applied in many field areas. Therefore, the statement by Essene (1989) that "i t seems prudent to avoid the use of Sassi's phengite ba- rometer for thermobarometry" seems not justified.

RESULTS. The bo parameter is usually determined through the measurement of the d(060) spacing. If ran- domly oriented preparates are used for that purpose, as was attempted in this study, then the (060) peak is overlapped and obscured by the (531) peak and addi- tional weak reflections. In order to test the reliability of our bo determinations through the measurement of illite d(060, 331) values, the bo cell dimension was also calculated from a unit cell refinement using at least 20 reflections. Results of this comparison for 33 samples ranging in grade from the diagenetic zone to the epizone show a rather good linear correlation (Fig- ure 12). bo values calculated from d(060, 531) are slightly smaller than bo values obtained from unit cell refinement, with a maximum deviation of 0.015 _~.

Page 15: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

110 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

9.05 I I I ,-, Y = 0.28521 + 0.96883x / j

*~ R^2 = 0.897 '.,. /

9 . 0 3 i ~ '

9.01

~ ' Vert ical error 8 . 9 9 ~ ' ~ T b a r = 2 ~ _

~ / ~ N = 3 3

8 .97 I i i

8 .97 8 .99 9 .01 9 .03 9 .05

"bo", calculated from d(0~,~31) (•)

Figure 12. bo values calculated from d(331, 060) vs bo val- ues calculated after least-square refinement. The thick line refers to correlated data, the thin line is the equal data line.

This result is to be expected because the (531) peak has a smaller d-value than the (060) peak (e.g., Borg and Smith 1969). In conclusion, for illite bo-geobaro- metry using randomly oriented preparates, the bo pa- rametermay be calculated from the relation bo = 6 • d(060, 331) with some confidence.

The d(060, 531) values for 32 illites (including il- lite/smectite mixed-layer) from the Santis nappe range from 1.495-1.503 ~ (mean value 1.499 A), for 12 lower anchizonal illites range from 1.500-1.506 (mean value 1.502 A), and for 18 upper anchizonal and 4 epizonal illites range from 1.499-1.506 ,~ (mean value 1.501 A).

oISCUSSIO~, b o or d(060, 531) of illite increases in the study area with grade during incipient metamorphism, in accordance with results reported by Padan et al. (1982) and Yang and Hesse (1991). The bo parameter increases with an increasing replacement of A1 by Fe + Mg in the octahedral layer and K in the interlayer position (Radoslovich and Norrish 1962; Hunziker et al. 1986). The general decrease of expandable layers in illite/smectite from north to south means a concom- itant increase of K, but whether Fe + Mg are also increasing is not known.

Because lower and upper anchizonal illites of the study area yielded almost identical b o values, lower anchizonal samples were included in bo geobarometry. A cumulative frequency plot of bo values for anchi- and epimetamorphic samples indicates conditions of an intermediate-pressure facies series as for northern New Hampshire (Figure 13). The mean bo value of 9.010 A obtained for the southern part of the study

100 I N--34

80 -

240

0 I

I / I . I I

I I I 8.96 8.98 9.00 9.02 9.04 9.06 9.08

White K-Mica bo (/~)

Figure 13. Cumulative frequency curve of illite bo values for 34 anchizonal and epizonal samples (thick line). Refer- ence curves (thin lines) are from Sassi and Scolari (1974).

area is very similar to the 9.013 A reported by Frey (1988) for North Helvetic flysch from the adjacent Glarus Alps.

Correlation Between Indicators of Incipient Metamorphism

The mineral distribution with increasing grade is summarized in Figure 14. The presence of smectite in the Subalpine Molasse at vitrinite reflectance <0.6% Rmax (Erdelbrock 1994) indicates diagenetic zone 2 of Kiibler et al. (1979). Kaolinite is a typical index mineral of the diagenetic zone, and the isograd Kin +

zones Diagenetie Anchizone Epizone zone

Glauconite

Stilpnomelane

Biotite

Smectite

Kaolinite/Smectite

Kaolinite

Pyrophyllite

Paragonite

Chloritoid

Illite/Smectite

Illite Domain Size

Illite bo

R=0,1 and >1 illite in I/S:0-90%

11 - 50 (nm)

8,993 (,~)

R>I Ulite in I/S:85-100%

3 2 - 9 9 (nm)

9.009 (~)

>99 (nm)

Figure 14. Summary of indicators of diagenesis and incip- ient metamorphism for the Helvetic Alps of eastern Switzer- land. The distribution of index minerals and various proper- ties of mixed-layer illite/smectite and illite are plotted against grade as defined by illite "crystallinity" data.

Page 16: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

Vol. 44, No. 1, 1996 Diagenesis and metamorphism of clay minerals in eastern Switzerland 111

Qtz = Prl + H20 is located at the b e g i n n i n g of the anch izone (Figures 2 and 6). Phys ica l condi t ions for two locali t ies a long this i sograd (Figure 6, s tat ions wi th Kin + Prl) were es t imated as 240-260~ kbar based on coal r ank and fluid inc lus ion data (Frey 1987b). Paragoni te is widespread in the anch izone and ep izone . G l a u c o n i t e - b e a r i n g s a n d s t o n e s and l ime- s tones are widespread in the d iagenet ic zone, and the i sograd Glt + Qtz • Ch l = Stp + Kfs + fluid is loca ted in the uppe rmos t d iagenet ic zone.

Several proper t ies of mixed- laye r i l l i te /smect i te and illi te are also useful indicators of inc ip ien t me tamor - phism. The order ing type or Re ichwei t e o f US changes f rom R = 0 to R > 1, a l though dif ferent order ing types were found wi th in a res t r ic ted area. Never the less this a l lowed to d i s t inguish four zones with d i f ferent R val- ues and illi te contents in US, and three of these zones a l lowed a subdiv i s ion of the d iagenet ic zone as def ined by illi te "c rys ta l l in i ty . " Il l i te d o m a i n size general ly increases wi th increas ing grade, and l imi t ing values of 50 and 100 n m were de t e rmined for the lower and upper boundar i e s o f the anchizone .

Regiona l S igni f icance

Three ma in tectonic features o f the s tudy area are the Glarus thrust, the S~ntis thrust and the basa l Pen- ninic thrust. In this sect ion, poss ib le breaks in diage- net ic or m e t a m o r p h i c grade across these thrusts will be discussed.

The presence o f d ioc tahedra l smect i te in the Sub- a lp ine Molasse and its absence in s imilar l i thologies o f the Santis nappe indicates a h igher d iagenet ic grade for the upper tectonic uni t (Figure 1). Such a b reak in grade was also o b s e r v e d by Erde lb rock (1994) based on vi tr ini te ref lectance data: R m a x < 0 .6% for the Suba lp ine Molas se a round Appenze l l and R m a x > 1.3% for the adjacent S~rltis nappe. Us ing the termi- no logy of Kiibler et al. (1979), the Suba lp ine Molasse be longs to the d iagenet ic zone 2 whereas the S~intis nappe be longs to zones 3 and 4. Obvious ly , the h igher grade SSaatis nappe d is located a long the Glarus thrus t ove r the Suba lp ine Molasse caus ing a d i scon t inuous inverse d iagenet ic zonat ion.

The Helvet ic nappes show a general increase in dia- gene t i c /me tamorph ic grade f rom nor th to south, main- ly d o c u m e n t e d by the regional d is t r ibut ion o f var ious index minerals , i l l i te " c rys t a l l i n i t y " data, the overal l d iminu t ion of expandab le layers and the order ing of i l l i te/smecti te . Wi th in the Helvet ic nappe pile, grade increases f rom tec tonica l ly h igher to lower units . This is bes t d o c u m e n t e d in the Alv ie r -Sargans- lake Walen area by vi tr ini te ref lectance data (Erde lb rock 1994), bu t is also suppor ted by IC data (Figure 2) and the Kin ~ Prl conve r s ion (Figure 6). As m e n t i o n e d earlier, the d i agenes i s / anch izone b o u n d a r y as wel l as the is- ograds Kin + Qtz = Prl + H 2 0 and Glt + Qtz • Ch l = Stp + Kfs + fluid a lmos t co inc ide in the s tudy area,

and are c ross ing nappe boundar ies , inc lud ing the Shn- tis thrust, thus indica t ing that inc ip ien t m e t a m o r p h i s m was a late syn- to pos t -nappe- fo rming event .

Fur ther to the south, in the Pizol area, IC data in- dicates a d i scont inuous inverse me tamorph ic zona t ion across the Glarus thrust , separa t ing the Ver rucano f rom the Inf rahelvet ic complex , wi th some 5 - 1 0 k m of post- me t amorph i c thrust ing. This feature is in accordance wi th the d i scon t inuous inverse d iagenet ic zona t ion near the Alp ine bo rde r men t ioned above.

Ava i l ab le data f rom this s tudy and Erde lb rock (1994) show no d i f fe rence in d iagenet ic grade be tween the S~intis nappe and Penn in ic kl ippen, ind ica t ing no break in d iagenet ic grade across the basa l Penn in i c thrust, and thus a c o m m o n late d iagenet ic h i s to ry for these tec tonic units .

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Most samples used in this study were collected by Kersten Erdelbrock. The first author is grateful to Josef Mullis for his help during field investigations and additional sample collec- tions. Reynald Handschin guided with the preparation of ran- domly oriented sample. Michael Dalla Torre and Meinert Rahn provided additional help, Dennis D. Eberl and Eric Es- sene kindly reviewed the manuscript and improved the En- glish. The first author was supported by Basel University.

REFERENCES

Arkai P. 1991. Chlorite crystallinity: an empirical approach and correlation with illite crystallinity, coal rank and min- eral facies as examplified by Palaeozoic and Mesozoic rocks of northeast Hungary. J Metamorph Geol 9:723-734.

Bailey SW. 1988. X-ray diffraction identification of the po- lytypes of mica, serpentine, and chlorite. Clays & Clay Miner 36:193-213.

Balzer D, Ledbetter H. 1993. Voigt-function modeling in Fourier analysis of size- and strain-broadened X-ray dif- fraction peaks. J Appl Cryst 26:97-103.

Borg IY, Smith DK. 1969. Calculated X-ray powder patterns for silicate minerals. Mem Geol Soc Am 122:896 p.

Breitschmid A. 1982. Diagenese und schwache Metamor- phose in den sedimentaren Abfolgen der Zentralschweizer Alpen. Eclogae Geol Helv 75:331-380.

Briegel U. 1972. Geologie der 6stlichen Alviergruppe, unter besonderer Berficksichtigung der Drusberg-und Schratten- kalkformation. Eclogae Geol Helv 65:425~:~83.

Burger H. 1982. Tonmineralogische und sedimentpetrogra- phische Untersuchungen in der untersten Kreide des 6s- tlichen Helvetikums. Schweiz Mineral Petrogr Mitt 62: 369-414.

Btirgisser HM, Felder TE. 1974. Zur Geologie der Stidab- dachung der Segnas-Ringel-Gruppe (Vordenheintal, Grau- btinden). Eclogae Geol Helv 67:457-467.

Eberl DD, Srodon J, Kralik M, Taylor BE, Peterman ZE. 1990. Ostwald ripening of clays and metamorphic miner- als. Science 248:474-477.

Erdelbrock K. 1994. Diagenese und schwache Metamor- phose im Helvetikum der Ostschweiz (Inkohlung und IiIit- "'Kristallinit~it"). Diss Rhein-Wesff Techn Hochschule Aa- chen 219 S.

Erdelbrock K, Wolf M, Krumm H, Frey M. 1993. Vitrinite reflectance data from a transect through the Helvetic Zone of eastern Switzerland. TERRA abstracts, Suppl. No 1 to TERRA nova 5:415.

Ergun S. 1968. Direct method for unfolding convolution

Page 17: DIAGENESIS AND METAMORPHISM OF CLAY MINERALS IN THE ... 44/44-1-96.pdf · 2 Present address: Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, RR. China Abstract--Helvetic

112 Wang, Frey, and Stern Clays and Clay Minerals

products--its application to X-ray scattering intensities. J Appl Cryst 1:19-23.

Essene EJ. 1989. The current status of thermobarometry in metamorphic rocks. In:Daly JS, Cliff RA, Yardley BWD, editors. Evolution of Metamorphic Belts. Geol. Soc. Spec. Pub. London:Geol Soc 43:1-44.

Frey M. 1970. The step from diagenesis to metamorphism in pelitic rocks during Alpine orogenesis. Sedimentol 15: 261-279.

Frey M. 1986. Very low-grade metamorphism of the Alps- - an introduction. Schweiz Mineral Petro Mitt 66:13-27.

Frey M. 1987a. Very low-grade metamorphism of clastic sedimentary rocks. In:Frey M, editor. Low Temperature Metamorphism. Glasgow: Blackie. 9-58.

Frey M. 1987b. The reaction-isograd kaolinite + quartz = pyrophyllite + HzO, Helvetic Alps, Switzerland. Schweiz Mineral Petro Mitt 67:1-11.

Frey M. 1988. Discontinuous inverse metamorphic zonation, Glarus Alps, Switzerland: evidence from illite "crystallin- ity" data. Schweiz Mineral Petro Mitt 68:171-183.

Frey M, Hunziker JC, Roggwiller R Schindler C. 1973. Pro- gressive niedriggradige Metamorphose glaukonitftihrender Horizonte in den helvetischen Alpen der Ostschweiz. Con- trib Mineral Petrol 39:185-218.

Frey M, Wieland B. 1975. Chloritoid in autochthonparau- tochthonen Sedimenten des Aarmassivs. Schweiz Mineral Petro Mitt 55:407-418.

Handschin R, Stern WB. 1989. Preparation and analysis of microsamples for X-ray diffraction and -fluorescence. SIE- MENS Anal Appl Note 319.

Hayes JB. 1970. Polytypism of chlorite in sedimentary rocks. Clays & Clay Miner 18:285-306.

Hunziker JC, Frey M, Claner N, Dallmeyer RD, Friedrichsen H, Flehmig W, Hochstrasser K, Roggwiller R Schwander H. 1986. The evolution of illite to muscovite: mineralog- ical and isotopic data from the Glarus Alps, Switzerland. Contrib Mineral Petrol 92:157-180.

Klug HR Alexander LE. 1974. X-Ray Diffraction Procedu- res, 2nd ed. New York:Wiley. 966p.

Kiibler B. 1967. La cristallinit6 de l'illite et les zones tout ~t fait suprrieures du mdtamorphisme. Etages tectoniques, Colloque h Neuchgtel 1966. Neuchhtel, Suisse:A la Bacon- nitre. 105-121.

K~ibler B. 1968. Evaluation quantitative du mrtamorphisme par la cristallinit6 de l'illite. Bull Cent Rech Pau-SNPA 2: 385-397.

Ktibler B, Pitton J-L, Hrroux Y, Charollais J, Weidmann M. 1979. Sur le pouvoir rdflecteur de la vitrinite darts quelques roches du Jura, de la Molasse et des nappes prralpines, helv6tiques et penniques. Eclogae Geol HeN 72:347-373.

Langford JI. 1978. A rapid method for analysing the breadths of diffraction and spectral lines using the Voigt function. J Appl Cryst 1 I:10-14.

Lanson B, Kabler B. 1994. Experimental determinations of the coherent scattering domain size distribution of natural mica-like phases with the Warren-Averbach technique. Clays & Clay Minerals 42:489-494.

Moore DM, Reynolds RC. 1989. X-Ray Diffraction and the Identification and Analysis of Clay Minerals. Oxford, New York:Oxford University Press. 332p.

Niggli E, Niggli CR. 1965. Karten der Verbreitung einiger Mineralien der alpidischen Metamorphose in den Schweiz-

er Alpen (Stilpnomelan, Alkali-Amphibol, Chloritoid, Stau- rolith, Disthen, Sillimanit). Eclogae Geol Helv 58:335-368.

Ouwehand P. 1987. Die Garschella-Formation ("Helvetisch- er Gault", Aptian-Cenomanian) der Churfirsten-Alvier Re- gion (Ostschweiz), Sedimentologie, Phosphoritgenese, Stratigraphie. Mitt Geol Inst ETH u Univ Zfirich NF 275.

Padan A, Kisch HJ, Shagam R. 1982. Use of the lattice pa- rameter bo of dioctahedral illite/muscovite for the charac- terization of P/T gradients of incipient metamorphism. Contrib Mineral Petrol 79:85-95.

Pfiffner OA. 1986. Evolution of the north Alpine foreland basin in the Central Alps. Spec Publ Int Assoc Sedimentol 8:219-228.

Pfiffner OA. 1982. Deformation mechanisms and flow re- gimes in limestones from the Helvetic zone of the Swiss Alps. J Struct Geol 4:429-442.

Pfiffner OA, Frei W, Valasek P, Stauble M, Levato L, DuBois L, Schmid SM, Smithson SB. 1990. Crustal shortening in the Alpine Orogen: results from deep seismic reflection profiling in the eastern Swiss Alps, line NFP 20-east. Tec- tonics 9:1327-1355.

Pollastro RM. 1993. Considerations and applications of the illite/smectite geothermometer in hydrocarbon-bearing rocks of Miocene to Mississippian age. Clays & Clay Min- er 41:119-133.

Radoslovich EW, Nolrish K. 1962. The cell dimensions and symmetry of layer-lattice silicates: I. Some structural con- sideration. Amer Mineral 47:599-617.

Reynolds RC. 1985. NEWMOD, a computer program for the calculation of one-dimensional diffraction patterns of mixed-layer clays. Hanover, N.H.:R. C. Reynolds, 8 Brook Rd.

Sassi FP, Scolari A. 1974. The bo value of the potassium white micas as a barometric indicator in low-grade meta- morphism of pelitic schists. Contrib Mineral Petrol 45:143- 152.

Scherrer P. 1918. Bestimmung der Grbsse und der inneren Struktur von Kolloidteilchen mittels R6ntgenstrahlen. GOt- tinger Nachr Math Phys 2:98-100.

Spicher A. 1980. Tektonische Karte der Schweiz. Schweiz geol komm 1:500 000.

Stern WB. 1991. Preparation and cell refinement of mica microsamples. Schweiz Mineral Petro Mitt 71:151-159.

Stokes AR. 1948. A numerical Fourier-analysis method for the correction of width and shapes of lines on X-ray pow- der photographs. Proc Phys Soc 61:382-391.

Trfimpy R. 1980. Geology of Switzerland, Part A. Basel, New York:Wepf & Co. Publishers. 104p.

Velde B. 1985. Clay minerals, a physico-chemical explana- tion of their occurrence. Dev. Sedimentol. Elsevier, Am- sterdam-Oxford-New York-Tokyo 40:427p.

Walker JR. 1993. Chlorite polytype geothermometry. Clays & Clay Miner 41:260-267.

Warr LN, Rice AHN. 1994. Interlaboratory standardization and calibration of clay mineral crystallinity and crystallite size data. J Metamorph Geol 12:141-152.

Warren BE, Averbach BL. 1950. The effect of cold-work distortion on X-ray patterns. J Appl Phys 21:595-599.

Yang C, Hesse R. 1991. Clay minerals as indicators of dia- genetic and anchimetamorphic grade in an overthrust belt, external domain of southern Canadian Appalachians. Clay Miner 26:211-231.

(Received 15 November 1994; accepted 12 June 1995; Ms. 2594)