design science in action
DESCRIPTION
Presentation at ICIS 2012TRANSCRIPT
DSV - Stockholm University1
Design Science in Action: Developing a Framework for Introducing IT
Systems into Operational Practice
Ilia Bider - DSV SUPaul Johannesson – DSV SU
Erik Perjons – DSV SULena Johansson – DSV SU
problem
situation as-is
situation to-be
s
s’
P
generic problem
generic situation to-be
t’
GP
?
generic situation as-is
?
1
2a
2b
3
4
test case
hypothesist
Presentation at ICIS 2012, Orlando, Florida December 18, 2012Pre-proceedings: http://bit.ly/YXp47rProceedings: http://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2012/proceedings/EngagedScholarship/4/
DSV - Stockholm University2
Dual Goal with the presentation
1. Present our view on Design Science Research (DSR) as a process of generating and testing hypothesis for adoption in practice.
This process can be driven in numerous ways beside the traditional cycle of problem->requirements->solution->demonstration->evaluation
Bider, I., Johannesson, P., and Perjons, E. 2012. "Design science research as movement between individual and generic situation-problem-solution spaces," (to appear) in Baskerville R., De Marco, M., and Spagnoletti, P. (eds.) Organizational Systems. An Interdisciplinary Discourse, Springer.
2. Present an example that serves to illustrate and be a test case for the above view
DSV - Stockholm University3
Difference between DSR and empirically-based research (EMR)
EMR DSR
Timeline Past & Present Future
Aimed at Explaining the world as it was or as it is
Suggesting a new world that does not yet exist
Process Establishing facts and developing theories that explains these facts
Generating and testing hypothesis for adoption
Relation to practice
Follow practice Lead practice
Example: communism as designed by K. Marx and his followers
DSV - Stockholm University4
DS process as movement between the two worlds
problem
situation as-is
situation to-be
+1 s
s’
P
generic problem
generic situation to-be
t’
GP
0
generic situation as-is
hypothesis
test case
t
http://bit.ly/YXp47r
DSV - Stockholm University5
Example to be discussed - Generic innovation
problem
situation as-is
situation to-be
s
s’
P
generic problem
generic situation to-be
t’
GP
?
generic situation as-is
?
1
2a
2b
3
4
test case
hypothesist
DSV - Stockholm University
Organization• Non-for-profit (interest) organization
• Association of tenants in West region of Sweden
• Central office – about 60-70 employees
• Democratic management style with a strong CEO
trying to become process oriented• With the help of an IT system
Situation at hands
DSV - Stockholm University
Structure of the process case/instance
System – a BPS system based on the shared spaces & collaborative
planning
DSV - Stockholm University
Plans for a particular user
System - continuing
DSV - Stockholm University
• General comment – It might be a good system, but I do not understand what I should use it for?
• Specific problem - Collaborative planning not intuitive
• New processes introduced at the same time (customer feedback) – no experience of dealing with them
• Previously totally ad-hoc processes (lobbying) are to be structured – requires adaptation
Problem – the users do not use the system
DSV - Stockholm University
Generic situation:
• Introduction in organizational practice of an IT systems that aim at changing the work and communication practices of an organization = organizational change
• The introduction process = ad hoc and already started
Generic problem
• The process stammer – nothing happens
Generic solution required
• Introduction process model – methodology of driving an introduction process
• That can be used in the middle of an unsuccessful introduction process
Generalization
DSV - Stockholm University
• State-oriented view of business processes
• Kotter’s [1996] eight stages for change management
• Sharma and Yetton [2003]
• The Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT)
Developing a solution – theoretical background
DSV - Stockholm University
State-oriented view on business processes
• For each item Ordered = Delivered
• To pay = Total + Freight + Tax• Ordered > Delivered
shipment
• To pay > Invoiced invoicing
• Invoiced = To pay• Paid = Invoiced
DSV - Stockholm University
1. Establishing a sense of urgency
2. Creating the guiding coalition
3. Developing a vision and strategy
4. Communicating the change vision
5. Empowering broad-based action
6. Generating short-term wins
7. Consolidating gains and producing more change
8. Anchoring new approaches in the culture
Kotter’s eight stages for change management
DSV - Stockholm University
1. New structures, e.g. create a training group, or introduce a help-desk.
2. New performance control systems -the ones that favour system usage, e.g. introduce a system that rewards active users.
3. New coordination mechanisms. New IT systems often require changes in existing work processes, which have to be redesigned in order to ensure benefits from the system.
4. Changes to performance goals. An introduction process is often characterized by a period of decline in performance, which should be planned in advanced.
Sharma and Yetton suggestions on institutional context changes
DSV - Stockholm University
Factors that define users’ behaviour:
1. Performance expectancy – how much I will gain
2. Effort expectancy - how hard I need to work
3. Social influence – what happened if I don’t do it.
4. Facilitated conditions – how much help I will get from the organization
The Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT)
DSV - Stockholm University
Solution – the A3 frameworkGeneral Scheme
DSV - Stockholm University
Solution – the A3 frameworkProcess model
DSV - Stockholm University
• DS is difficult to plan in advance
• Tight deadlines so that not to miss an opportunity for testing a solution in the current case
• Even when a known problem have known solutions there could be an opportunity for DS if the context is different
• The demonstration phase requires tight cooperation between researchers and practitioner to implement the solution
Reflections from the project
DSV - Stockholm University1
9
Thank you for your attention!
Main ContactIlia Bider, SU/IbisSoft
Email: ilia@{dsv.su,ibissoft}.se