de theory j÷ · physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) starobinshy's stochastic...

44
Soft , de Sitter Effective Theory Tim Cohen with Dan Green University of Oregon arXiv : 2007.03693 All Things EFT , Nov 18

Upload: others

Post on 07-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Soft

,de Sitter Effective Theory

j÷Tim Cohen with Dan Green

University of Oregon arXiv : 2007.03693

All Things EFT, Nov 18

Page 2: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

k physical= It) UV modes

Modes : 9+19.

Symmetries ;Sd SET TH

' 'spacetime treparametrization

Each* Initial conditions

Page 3: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

The IR of QFT in de Sitter• What Does emerge ?

Conceptual . What governs their dynamics?• What symmetries persist ?

• How are operators organized ?

Practice • Can divergent integrals be tamed?

• Can IR logs be systematically summed?

Page 4: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Confusions Abound• Want to expose late time

and long wavelength behavior

of ( in - in ) correlation functions

• Calculate in a frame⇒ space t time treated independently

* Full theory calculations use hard cutoffs

Page 5: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Soft de Sitter Effective TheoryFull theory

so, -fd3xdta÷¥ftp.oloro-tmzor.to!SdSET

SE-fdkdtf-vf.to. - 9+97 GHI"" '÷, gift

Page 6: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Applications of Sd SET

1) Correlations for massive scalars in DS"

Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant"

2) Starobin shy 's stochastic inflation"

Resume marginal operators using RG"

3) Metric fluctuations during inflation"

Power counting ⇒ super horizon modes freeze out"

4) Eternal inflation" Tower of relevant operators appear ⇒ novel phase

"

Page 7: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Why EFT ?• DS provides natural

"

ruler"

:

the inverse Como ving horizon Anu-

- a H

• Interested in long wavelengths ka att• Large separation of scales

begs for EFT with power countingXu kKalt)

Page 8: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

uV

yaI & (inflationary background)

It.

ti" """s""au modes

Irish." '

I←-

X= ÷ a H

Page 9: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

(continuum ) EFT• Isolate propagating Does

Conceptual • Quadratic action ⇒ dynamics• Expose symmetries• Power counting I dim analysis

Practical • Regulate integralsw/o breaking symmetries

• RG sums full theory IR logs

Page 10: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

One. - to - many Mode Expansion

Factorize into soft and hard modes

GCI, t ) : 4$ II. t ) to, (I. t )

Integrate out hard modes

⇒ Local operator expansion

Observables reconstructed order - by - order in X

Page 11: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Isolating the

soft Modes

Page 12: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

ds spacetime

DS metric : d5= - d. Et att) DIZ

← propertime

Notation : I Ht

t E: - expl-thtTconformal time

Page 13: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Scalar fields in DS

EOM To +307+1%4+774=0Soft limit 0/5 ( att)

- ""

Cfs

w/ v=±f¥-7or 2=3 - v p -

- f-tr S.t. its =3

WLOG Lsp

Page 14: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Sd SET Fields

Two IR degrees of freedom•

"

Growing" mode oft ← EF:

'fetes't•

"

Decaying"

mode of-

w/ Os -- H ((att5-Ot t @HIP9- )

Page 15: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Stochastic

Initial

conditions

Page 16: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Canonical Quantization

Full theory quantum field ¢=f(§att§*a)

w/ fatman]=erPs(E - I ')

Bunch - Davies OT -- - ie :(" t) afHf⇒%HyHfu⇒

Page 17: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Take soft Limit

Expand ¢ for heatI

-0/5-5CaH5^pI(eisratteisra)(t (att)

-B g- ( ie- ikat. half--

J

w/ In at ten is

Page 18: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Stocastic Random Variables

Tui and Iie are real

satisfy [It, I ] -- [It, I] -- o

Tainan = 45, I = (ziti shitii)

ails

Page 19: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Initial Conditions

Identify ft-

- f Etaoperators 9- =/ g- I

Endowed with classical power spectra

(9th) at Y - ¥, CzapskiTE'tAugmented by non - Gaussian corrections from UV

Page 20: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Sd SET

Page 21: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Defining Sd SET

• DOF Cft and 9-

• Power counting X - ate,

w/ Aur -- alt

• Symmetries( l )

"

spacetime"

(2)"

reparametrization"

• Initial conditions

* Very close analogy w/ Heavy Quark EFT

Page 22: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Power Counting

k t - Iin-alt In 'Ixt ⇒ In a

§ n do an old

9- - tf

Page 23: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Symmetriesc- → t I → qui

(1) Spacetime I → thx 9+-22×9t

a → ya 9. →P9(t additional isometry transformation for static ds)

(z )Reparametrization Cf → Ot t Catti

-

Bcf-invariance

(RPI) Cf- → (I - e) 9-

Page 24: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Free Sd SET from Top Down

Plug ¢s=H( a-'

9, ta-

Pg-) into SH

Combine terms using int by partsand e.g . H2 ( x Z - 3D + m2 -- O

, xtp =3, .. .

⇒,I

Page 25: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Free Sd SET from Top DownDrop sub leading terms

xx

Int by parts and let f- → of- t t Catti "9t

TTreat as interaction ⇒ 044) (Weinberg)

Page 26: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Free SdSET

µ

Leading power solutions are constant

Page 27: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Locality• 9± to, are momentum eigenstates• Momentum conservation ⇒ L,¥• Leading effect of integrating out to,occurs at l - loop

SS'n f to:( I. e) I:(g. ⇒ y e-

Pk- "I

⇒ Local interaction Ft t keep

Page 28: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Leading Interactions

Stint > - f@ H)3- nd

cnn.gg!

Can be removed with

9- → 9- t 5¥.tn?CaHP-"

9;'

Page 29: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Power counting Interactions

s:p - Haaf" -

mean;÷.AE~ g. nxtmp

-3w/ m ? I

relevant natmp <3

Marginal na tmp =3irrelevant nations > 3

Page 30: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Power counting Interactions

s:p - Gaap- n . - me gie

~ ya - 1) at (m -Dp w/ m ? I

mZ¥o 0 Lack and % Cpc 3

Interactions are on , ⇒ irrelevant

m2-so ⇒ L -70 . . .

Page 31: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Dynamical Dimensional RegularizationOften encounter SDIpd⇒ dim reg fails

Introduce"

dyn dim rag"

Trick : analytically continue in a

⇒ s÷→s:÷.

Page 32: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Applications

Page 33: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Massive Scalars in DS

• Massive scalars are"

free"

Interactions are irrelevant

• See paperfor variety of calculations

(Green and Prem Kumar )

• Non - trivial role of initial conditions

Page 34: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Light scalars in ds

As m2 → O,a -20

Stint = -SE,Cath" -" "

gig.

(n - 1)a~ I → to

⇒ Tower of marginal interactions(z-nk Cn n

EOM : Zvi - §,

(att) ⇒ of

Page 35: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Light scalars in DS

Composite operatorsOn -- Anni

-

→ to

⇒ RG mixing expectedcontract any two legs

ton . . . > Hon . . . . . > (HEISE!÷"÷÷.

Page 36: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Light scalars in DS

f,dz!÷g is scaleless and

diverges as a -20

Isolate UV divergencep'→ pZtI±r

(on . . . ) > Ton . . . . . > (4) f÷(÷ -re - ios

Page 37: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Dynamical RG Stocastic Inflation

Resume time dependent logs :

⇒ con . . . > = - EE,

son. ,Om . .

+n (n - i )

¥ (On- z . . . )(Sta robin shy ; Starobinsky , Yokoyama )

Is equivalent to a Fokker - Planck eg

for plat ) w/ for > = Sdg plat) pm (Bs Kitt)

Page 38: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Metric Fluctuations During InflationPower counting t symmetries⇒ no time dependence

L is adiabatic scalar fluctuation

Vij is tensor fluctuation

N t Ni are Lagrange multipliers (Arg?!:{htt)

Page 39: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Metric Fluctuations During InflationFull theory quadratic Lagrangian

Many non - linear symmetries , e. g .I → e-II ⇒ I→ Ice

-

re) - y

can take Sd SET limit w/ I → Ltt . . .

Page 40: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Metric Fluctuations During Inflationwhat types of operators couldcause time evolution ?

Lint > 4 t . . .

Violate shift symmetries⇒ Only allowed terms involve ?÷,L±

⇒ power suppressed ! * Also appliesFull theory ; Salopek

t Bond; Malda cena (tree) to tensor modes !argument Assassin Baumann

,Green ; Senatore , Zaidarriaga (all orders)

Page 41: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Eternal Inflation

Metric dynamics are important⇒ sin

.

> fFsCaH5"

e:

can not be removed by field redef

( int by parts generates gravitional contributions)As a → 0

, QI ~ 11×3 ⇒ relevant operators⇒ Non - perturbative !

Page 42: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Summary

Page 43: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Su m m a ry

It works !!

S±-

- fd 'x dt f-vHe - ft E) -⇐kitI-"" '÷, e:If

Page 44: de Theory j÷ · Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant " 2) Starobinshy's stochastic inflation " Resume marginal operators using Rb " 3) Metric fluctuations during inflation "

Summary1) Correlates for massive scalars in DS

"

Physics beyond the horizon is irrelevant"

2) Starobin shy 's stochastic inflation"

Resume marginal operators using Rb"

3) Metric fluctuations during inflation"

Power counting ⇒ super horizon modes freeze out"

4) Eternal inflation" Tower of relevant operators appear ⇒ novel phase

"