daniel duarte-mendez, a205 208 430 (bia aug. 5, 2015)

8/20/2019 Daniel Duarte-Mendez, A205 208 430 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

1/8

Downer, Bryce ErickMyRights Immigration8205 . Colfax AveDenver CO 80220

Name: DURTEMENDEZ DNIEL

U.S Departmen of Jusice

Executve Oce r Imigrion Review

Board ofImmigraton AppealsOce of h Crk

5/07 Leesburg Pike, Ste 000Fals Chc Vn 204/

DHS/ICE Oice of Chief Counsel - DEN12445 East Caley venueCentennial CO 80115663

A 205208430

Date of this notice 8/5/205

nclosed is a copy of he Board's decision nd order in e above-rerenced case.

ncosue

Pane Members:Gt, Edwd Gug. JohHolio Hop

Snceely,

DO caDonna C

Cef erk

Userea Dockt

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visitwww.irac.net/unpublished/index/

I m m i g r a n t & R e

f u g e e A p p e l l a t e C e

n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r

a c . n e t

Cite as: Daniel Duarte-Mendez, A205 208 430 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)


2/8

Executive Oe r Imiaion Rew

Decsion of e Boad of maon Appeals

Fa Chc, Vgna 22041

File: A205 208 430 Dnver, CO

re: IL DUARTE-MENZ

I MOVAL PROCEDINGS

APPEAL

ate:

ON BEHALF OF RESPONENT: Bryce Eick Doer, squire

ON BEHALF OF HS: Michelle SmithSenior Atoey

APPLICATION: Reopenng

AUG 5 2Dl5

e respondent h appeald te Immiation Judge's decision dated July 25, 2014, denyinghis motion to reopen. The Immiation Judge had prviously ordered the respondents removalm e United Stes, llowing e respondnt's ile to app r a heaing on Mch 5,2014. e appa will be sustaind, proceedings ill e reopend, d the record will be

remded

e Bod reviws an Imiion Judge's ndings of ct, including crediilitydtenons and te likelihood of tu events, der a "clly eoneous standd

CFR. § 1003(d)(3)(i); Mater ofZ-Z0, 26 I&N c. 586 (BIA 2015) We rview all oerissus, including questions of law, judent, or discretion, under a de novo standd 8 CF.R 10031(d)(3 )(ii)

On appa th resondent contends tat he did not receive notice of te Mch 5, 2014,hing d he has presnted sucint vidnce to overcome the presmption of rceipt Th

rsondnt asses that h received l por earing notices, d e had atended al piorhegs.

Te mmiation Judg detend tat te respondent rceived e notice of eng datedOctober 23, 203, providing a rscheduled hing date of Mch 5, 2014 e Iion

Judge und e noce of heaing was proper as it as sent to te respondents last oadress, d te respondent iled to rebut te presumption of dlivey.

e record reects that aer te respondent was relasd om cutody, a notic of hing was mailed to him on Octoer 29, 2012, d he appee r th schedled heing onDcmber 12, 2012 Purst to a heaing notice sered on th respondent in cou on ecmbr12, 2012, he appeed r te scheduld hearig on Juy 31, 2013, bt he was inoed that heng had ben rescdued to Octobr 30, 2013 The rspondent assts on appea th heapped r is eaing on that day, bt h was inoed that e woud e receiving a new

notice of hng Te respondent claims that he did not receive a subsqnt heing notice r the ch 5, 2014, heing, and e did not app r th heing on that d due to lack of

p p

Cite as: Daniel Duarte-Mendez, A205 208 430 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)


3/8

.

A20 208 430

notie e noe of eing was not reted to e Iigratio Cour as undelverable erespot dd ot appe r s eg o Mr , 2014 ad e was orered removed inabsetia o tat date

Base o e evidee of reord w reets at e responet ene l of hs prior eigs d e coties to resde at e same address to wih the eg ote was set, we nd at e respodent s preseted suient evidene to overome e presumpton oeivery o e otie o eig. Se Mater of R-A-, 24 &N De 665, 674-6 (BIA 2008)(seig r e stdrds r eteining i a respondet preseted set eviee tooverome e weaker presumptio of delvery tat aaes to oties set by regu mail.Fureore, it appes at wen e respoet leed o is order of removal e exerisede diligee i obtaing ousel d requesting reopeig of te poeeings.

Aordigy, e owing order will be entered.

OER: Te appeal is sustaine, e i absetia order o remova is resided, e proeedigs e reopeed, d e reord is r ade r her proeedgs onsistent wi eregog opinio

2




a c . n e t

Cite as: Daniel Duarte-Mendez A205 208 430 (BIA Aug 5 2015)


4/8

0.

. 0

Levesque a PLLCDowne, Bryc Erick

NITED STTES DEPATMET O JSTICEEXECUTIVE FFIE FO IM�IGTIO RVIEW

IMGTION CUR

196 TOUT STRE, TE. 101ENVER CO 80294

176 E Calewd Dr te 50edan I 83642IN THE MATTER FDURTE-ENEZ, 'DANIEL

FILE A 202080 DATE Ju 25, 204

NABLE T FORWAD NO ADDRESS POVIDED

v A T TAE;I S A OY OF T HE DECISION OF TE IMMIT N GE TH I EISIONI IS NAL UNSS AN APPEA IS FILED WITH T OD OF IMIGON APALSWIIN CALENDA DAYS F THE DATE OF HE MILNG OF THIS WRITTN DCIION.SEE TE ENSE FOMS ND INSTRUTION FOR PROERL · PEPARING YOR APEA.YOUR NOTIE OF PPEA, TTAHE DOUENTS, ND EE R FEE IVER EQUETUSTE AILED T: BORD F IIGTION PPEALSOFICE OF THE CERK

507 Lesbug Pike uit 2000FLLS CURCH VA 20530

TED IS A COP O THE DECISION OF THE IMIGATION UDGE AS TE RESUTOF YOU FAIUE T APEAR T YOUR SCHEDUED DEPORTION O EMOVAL EAING.THIS EISIO I FNAL UNLESS A MOTION O REOPE· IS FILED IN ACCORDACEWITH SECTION 2 2B c( 3) OF E IMIGION AD NTIONAITY ACT, 8 .S.SECTION 25 (c) (3) N DEPRTATION PROCEEDINS OR SECTION 240 ( 68 U.SC SECTION 229a(c) (6) IN REOVL RCEEDNGS IF YFILE A OTION± REOPEN YOR OTION MST E FLED WITH TS CURT

OTHE:

IIGTION COURT196 STO STREE STE 301DENVER, CO 0294

IITION COURT ATZ MIY244 E. Ca Aenueeena C 01F




a c . n e t


5/8

ITED STAES DEPRN F STICEXECUVE OICE F IGATION EVIEW

MGR COR96 SOU SET, SITE 30

DENVER C 809

In The Maer Of:

DUAE-ENEZ Die

Respodnt.

: A205 208430

))))

)

))

De 25 July, 2014

IN L PRCDNGS

OON oo o eop ur N§ 40(b)(5)(C)

ON BEF OF SPDENBe'. ower, Esq.yRis Iiio L i805 Col Avnueer, CO 80220

O BEF F SEVC mi B Kaz s ssist Cf CoUS D o Holn Suriy125 as y A uCtnal, CO 8011

WEN CSON

cs n Pocra Hsr

iel Due ez ("spoe) is 21-yearl l e cte x,w eer Stats r r Duglas, ra o or bo Je 15, 009 tousei. he mt f Hel uty ("S s espot i tce t pper () o ctobr 0, cgg Rso s rbl o e its prst to so 21()(6)(A)(i) A s l prst t ed Saeswou beg itt o pl e ws l o Oc 1, 0, ry vgjrisc wit is Co

cbe 1 201, o ese a c orer o obt sle u g eses quest pro Rspoe tc o g,

sg h e as sule o apper e Der Imio C o ly 3, 013

A tc g, Jue 21, 20, ws s ons las w rs,ig t s eg ae w sul to Ocobr 30, 2013. ob 3 03,te Cou mil w Notc f Hg o pos l kow rss g t s heag e was schul c 5, 0 Rspo l o p hisast heg a 5, 01

e a o 13, Rer Dpble/ssble Ai o 5, 0.


6/8

DUTE-MENZ

A 205 08430

. ,_-

e ou n ha e 213 esablshe e o e aa alegaions nned in he s su e Cou und espond emovable as d, o im eoved inaentia o exi. e Cou mail e n absena od o emoval o esodes lnon ades o 5, 04

On May 23, 014, Responden, u uel, oon o eoe Moon)allen a e id no eeve noe o s eang on a 04 H d no le aspone o he Moion

o e easos se belo, e Cou will deny Responden's oon

II. Motion to Reopen Respodet's In Absenta Orer

. Lak o Noe

e esonden be a hvy buden o eonsae ha the oening o is ase isw. See INS v. Abudu, 8 U.S 9, 0 {1988); Matterof Coelho 0 & De. 46 3 BIA 1992). A Iaion Jge "IJ) ay p a e esind n ab oduon a oon o open le a ay ime e ponen did o appe euse se was oven pop noie o f he esponde was in Fedeal o Sae usody ou no ul o erow. 8 FR. 10033)()i § 240{)){){i) Noe is deem ope i i is alo a onens as nown as. § 20(b)()). Wee noe is sen o e lson addess a esumion o eeip eiss Lopes Gonae 468 F.3d 8, 8-8 . i. 006).

en noie s sen by elar mail aog o noal oe poedu, ere apuion o ep a ponen mus overcome o sow a la of poper oie Gurug Ashco 371 F.3d 8 1 10h i. 200) Matt of-R &N D 665, 612 A 008) owev, his is a weake pesumpon an ha whi aopan mail sen byied ail. aterofA I& D. a 6-. Teee when a esoen lasa e d no rive e noi sen va elar mal, e quesion o be eein s weete ponden pened suen eviden o ovee he weer pesumpon odelivery aahed o noi delive by ela mal Id a 673.

Move, noe s sue i e esond an be harg w aving eevede noie, even when he did no eeive aual noie. ee Maer of Griaa 21 &N De. 2,3 IA 199) (superse by enments o e IN wh egards o mehos o see). eo as un a a ponen need no peonally eeve ea a unersan e noe in

oe he no uien o be saise. ae of GYR 23 &N D 8 8 I 00) Consve noe is appopae wen, eple he noe eah e ponens aess bu due o some beakown n e neal wokngs o he ome, e esonedoe no eeive aual noie. Id.

I his avi, Responden alleges a e e o he maon Cou on July 3

2

g g p p


7/8

DUE-MENDEZ 5 4

2012 1 on a date, he was v pape prodng te reschul cou date of Octoer30, 2013 oton, Eht A at 3. "The got a let ncatng my u as cged Butever receve anote cou date ld.2 Respondets otce o Heang dat Jue 21, 2013,howe, roves a new heng date oOctober 30 203 Fueore, he Notce of eagda Octoe 23, 2013, pves a new eag date of Mc 5, 24 Accordngl,Resonet recee notice tat s heag was chg ch oice of eag contante schue eg ate

Reoent does ot allege tha t te Cou male he notce to the ncoec adrs, desonents adavt tablshes that he receed coesondece om the Cou at hs adso e Cou nd that the notce oearng was ope s t was sent to espondetslast kown ads Resoet fal to rut te presmto oret Gng v.shc 37 3d at 721; MatterofRA- 24 I&N D at 7172

B Sa Sponte

A may also open ny ce pon s or er ow moto at any tme' 8 C.F.R §100.23) e power to rpe [sa sonte] s not meat to e use as a genl ce rlg ets or to oewse crcumvt the regulatos, we enrcng th mt result nhship Maer ofJ-, 2 &N 976, 984 (BA 997 Sa sponte rpeng, tre,s exaonay remy r r tly extonal statos Matte oG-D, 22 &D. 132, 1134 BA 1). e rodent s the uren to show tat an extonalsaton exss MatterofBelr, 22 & D 12, 129 (BIA 2000)

Resondent ar tat hs case mets sa snte rpenng ecaue o hs tnuopece n te Ut Stat snce 200 a because e may qua r the vsoalWaer to otan Lawl Peent Resdent status. oton at 4 Resondent aso arues tathe may be elle r asylum, wthholdng of removal, or voltary daure Id. at 4-5.Faly, Rpondent alleg that he wll lose the $15,00000 bond. Id at 5

he Cou rst not tat rng a case to aly r relef s ot a bs r renga in absentia order, nd as such, te Cou eclnes to anale ts argment ee 8 CF R1003.23()(4)). Te Cour nds tat Resondet does not mert sua sonte renng of hscase e Cou canot use ts power oua spne rpeng s a general remy r ayass creat by rcemet o te tme an number ms n te motos gulatonsaer GD 22 N ec. 32 3334 BIA 1) It s Rponent's ben to show tat

I

Ba enent as oginaly sue Cou o J 1 , 2 e Cou us tat dat of Juy 1 20 2, a togil er

2 In t oo sont>s ous as o ed ng not ad W 2 0 ,chulg hs hearin m uly 3 t Otbr 0, 20 3 oton at 2. Fuer e aues tht Rsnntappd n Cou r e Octr 2 3 wh h was nd that hs heng hd b schduld d tt wold eve a hrng notce wh he nvr eived Id. Te u wl aume Rspndt's veon o theevnts pentd n s Adavt Te allgatn and gumns ade by Resndens ons "do nocttute evdnc nr do they blh aral ac Beltr-Ve/oz v Muk, 33 3d 7 st i 28);see alo Mter ofRmi-Snchez, & . c 3 S6 (A 980

g g p p


8/8

DUTE-MEND

A 205 08 430

excepona circumsce ests d he h fai o do s. Mater ofBeckrd, 2 I&N Da 19

As suc, Rn has o me s bu o abs he wans opng o hs

ase oly e C ee he ong er:

ORDER

T S HEREBY ORDEED esond's Moo oe DED

5 J 0 4

4

g g p p

daniel duarte-mendez, a205 208 430 (bia aug. 5, 2015)

Documents