const mgmt vfinal

24
 Construct io n Management Perf ormance Readiness Assessment for Managing Large Projects January 2008

Upload: tonbaldin

Post on 03-Nov-2015

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

sda

TRANSCRIPT

  • Construction Management Performance

    Readiness Assessment for Managing Large ProjectsJanuary 2008

  • 1Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Contents

    The Construction Management Landscape is difficult and getting worse Construction costs continue to escalate Global construction activities increasing, fuel continued demand-driven cost increases Competition for key construction resources (e.g., project managers, heavy equipment, etc.) to

    complicate domestic / U.S. power projects Compressed project schedules as owners wait for environmental picture to crystallize

    Construction Management Tables Have Turned Owners held the trump card previously when construction and supplier over-capacity was rampant;

    now contractors and suppliers have the leverage Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management Skills

    Owners need to build (or rebuild) a number of construction management skills, both organizational and individual, to succeed in the new environment

    How ScottMadden Can Help You

  • The Construction Management Landscape

  • 3Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    The cost increases are impacting all infrastructure projectsgeneration-, transmission-, or distribution-relatedand they will impact utilities in direct and indirect ways. For example, rising copper prices will increase T&D cable costs

    This creates sizeable challenges for utilities. Infrastructure spending must continue. U.S. electric utility net plant is over $700 billion today, and CERA projects that $800 billion needs to be invested in the North American power industry over the next 15 years (excluding potential CO2 reduction-related capex). With a current market capitalization of just over $500 billion, investor-owned electric utilities have not faced this level of investment in 30 years

    This spending will likely be in steadily increasing increments rather than a quick peak with an abrupt fall-off

    Rate cases, which had been dormant for years, might proliferate. There is some risk of 1970s-style rate case pancaking if the environment is significantly inflationary

    What Does This Mean for Utilities? Labor scarcity, especially skilled workers, will likely

    drive up labor costs long-term, as firms increase wage rates to attract candidates to the construction trades. Indeed, skilled labor supply and demand curves crossed in April 2007

    From January 2000 through January 2007, the Skilled Labor Index increased at a 4.1% CAGR; this rate was 4.8% between 2003 and 2007

    While less dramatic than materials cost increases, labor wage inflation contributes significantly to construction cost increases, given labors cost as a percentage of total energy and utilities construction costs

    Shop and fabrication costs have increased as well, compounding this problem

    The world economy continues to grow at a brisk pace, led by China. This growth has sparked a significant run-up in construction inputs, both for commodities and equipment like transformers and turbines

    Oil price increases have impacted materials transportation costs as well as inflation. Crude oil domestic prices during 2005-06 were on par in real terms with their highest levels in the late 1970s and early 1980s

    From January 2000 through January 2007, the Material Price Index increased at a 2.3% CAGR; prices decreased from 2000 to 2003 but have since escalated at 6.8% per year

    The United States is also hampered by lower currency valuation, so imported goods are now more expensive across the board

    Manufactured equipment prices have risen dramatically in 2005 and 2006. Estimated price escalations for major power plant components were 13.0% in 2006 and 9.3% in 2005

    Skilled Labor Vital to Construction Is More Costly, As Well

    Worldwide Economic Growth Stimulates Construction Inflation

    Sources: The World Bank; Edison Foundation; The Keystone Center; U.S. Geological Survey; SNL Financial; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; EIA; The New York Times; Platts Electric Utility Week (Feb. 19, 2007) (citing CERA)

    The Construction Management LandscapeConstruction Costs Going Through the Roof

    0%

    10%

    20%

    30%

    40%

    50%

    60%

    70%

    80%

    Columns,Vessels

    Line Pipe Exchangers Switchgear Pumps &Drivers

    Compressor& Drivers

    StructuralSteel

    OtherEquipment

    2003 2004 2005 2006

    But commodity prices have spiked in recent years

    And infrastructure equipment prices have increased

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    3 MonthT Bill(BEY)

    6 MonthT Bill(BEY)

    1 YearBill

    (BEY)

    2 Year TNote

    3 Year TNote

    5 Year TNote

    10 YearT Note

    30 YearT Bond

    Y

    i

    e

    l

    d

    (

    %

    )

    Current

    6 Months Ago

    1 Year Ago

    3 Years Ago

    Long-term interest rates haveremained relatively stable

    Source: SNL Financial

    Source: Edison Foundation

    U.S. Treasury Yield Curve(Recent and 6-Months, One Year & Three Years

    Ago)

    Annual Price Increase for Selected Equipment (By Year)

    50

    75

    100

    125

    150

    175

    200

    225

    250

    275

    300

    1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

    R

    e

    l

    a

    t

    i

    v

    e

    P

    r

    i

    v

    e

    s

    (

    v

    s

    .

    1

    9

    9

    7

    )

    Sources: BLS; Edison Foundation

    Selected Materials Prices vs. General Inflation (Index: 1997=100)

    Copper

    Cement

    GDP Deflator

    Steel mill products

  • 4Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Petroleum Industry Oil refiners are continuing to roll out plans for expansions and

    upgrades 1

    Similar projects have been canceled or delayed due to rising costs, labor shortages, and equipment delays

    Seventeen expansion projects were planned in the U.S. from late 2006 through the year 2010

    Maintenance projects were pushed backed due to delays of ordered equipment and the availability of construction contractors said Chevron Corp. spokeswoman Stephanie Price and there were labor shortages as skilled workers flocked to the Gulf Coast to work on repairs on facilities there. This created a backlog that continues today.2

    Power Generation New nuclear constructions is ongoing in Europe, looks likely in U.K.

    and France, and is being considered in the Netherlands and Canada while India and China have some of the worlds most robustconstruction programs3

    China added 102 GW of capacity in 2006 and is expected to more than double that capacity by 20204

    Many U.S. power generators are re-evaluating plans to build new generation as a result of estimated construction cost increases

    Limited resources worldwide to provide equipment for nuclear construction programs

    Construction Equipment Manufacturers Overseas heavy equipment sales by Caterpillar rose 35% in Europe,

    the Middle East and Africa and rose 23% in the Asia/Pacific region Both Komatsu and Hitachi experienced a sales decline in North

    America and noted that demand grew in Europe & CIS, China, Asia & Oceania, and the Middle East & Africa

    Many industries across the globe are increasing construction activities, creating demand on labor, heavy equipment, logistics, engineered components, and commodities

    1. Upgrade Plans Flow While Oil Prices Ebb, ENR, October 2, 2006 by Thomas Armistead with Beth Evans2. Refineries Summer Break, The Wall Street Journal Online, June 26, 20073. New Realities Bring About a Construction Climate Change, ENR, September 18, 2006 by Thomas Armistead with Peter

    Reina and Dan OReilly4. Costs Hit Coal Building Plans, February 2007, Power Engineering by Amethyst Cavallaro

    Construction Equipment Price Hikes

    0.2%

    2.3%

    1.4%0.9%

    1.5% 1.3%

    3.7%

    2.5%3.2%

    6.9%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    B

    u

    r

    e

    a

    u

    o

    f

    L

    a

    b

    o

    r

    S

    t

    a

    t

    i

    s

    t

    i

    c

    s

    C

    P

    I

    D

    a

    t

    a

    Note: Year-to-year percent change for August

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    T

    h

    e

    B

    r

    a

    t

    t

    l

    e

    G

    r

    o

    u

    p

    National Average Labor Cost Index

    100

    110

    120

    130

    140

    150

    160

    170

    180

    1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

    Year

    I

    n

    d

    e

    x

    (

    1

    9

    9

    1

    =

    1

    0

    0

    )

    Labor for Heavy Construction and Reinforced Concrete Common Labor Craft Labor GDP Deflator

    The Construction Management LandscapeGlobal Construction Activities Increasing

    National Average Labor Cost Index

    Construction Equipment Price Hikes

  • 5Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    1. From The Top 400 Contractors, Prosperity Allows Firms to be More Selective, ENR, September 24, 2007 by Gary Tulacz

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    T

    h

    e

    B

    r

    a

    t

    t

    l

    e

    G

    r

    o

    u

    p

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    T

    h

    e

    B

    r

    a

    t

    t

    l

    e

    G

    r

    o

    u

    p

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    T

    h

    e

    B

    r

    a

    t

    t

    l

    e

    G

    r

    o

    u

    p

    S

    o

    u

    r

    c

    e

    :

    T

    h

    e

    B

    r

    a

    t

    t

    l

    e

    G

    r

    o

    u

    p

    Current and future environment Growing backlog of project contracts at large EPCs Equipment availability, e.g., cranes, limited to none Longer lead times for materials and scheduling work Higher fuel prices increase material extraction/production

    and transportation costs More delays (start and ongoing) are due to labor and skill

    availability constraints (management, engineers, craft levels)

    Construction productivity is declining, in part due to the scarcity of skilled labor

    Contractors are experiencing:1 Opportunity to focus on projects where expertise

    is possessed, owners are reliable and a reasonable return can be expected

    Margins are on the rise with fewer fly-by-nightcontractors low-balling on bids

    Freedom to turn down contracts with onerous terms or simply walk away

    Difficulty in finding and retaining skilled and competent workers in trades and management

    Material and equipment cost estimates are higher than original project plans due to strong demand and low supply

    Demand is not just raising prices, it is making projects harder to start and complete on-time with implications on budgets

    Compressed Project Schedules are the ResultCompressed Project Schedules are the ResultCompressed Project Schedules are the Result

    Delivery Schedules

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    Air Co

    olers

    Large

    Motors

    (>500

    HP)

    Exchan

    gers

    Colum

    ns

    Vesse

    ls

    React

    orsCo

    mpres

    sors

    Pump

    s (excl

    . LNG)

    Contro

    l Valve

    s

    W

    e

    e

    k

    s

    2004 2005 2006

    0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1

    1.2

    1.4

    Air Co

    olers

    Motors

    Exchan

    gers

    Colum

    ns/Ve

    ssels

    Pump

    s

    Contro

    l Valv

    es

    2004 Shop Load Current Shop Load Anticipated 2006 Shop Load

    Annual Backlog at Major EPC Firms

    25000

    30000

    35000

    40000

    45000

    50000

    55000

    60000

    65000

    2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

    Year

    A

    m

    o

    u

    n

    t

    (

    M

    i

    l

    l

    i

    o

    n

    s

    o

    f

    $

    )

    National Utility Infrastructure Cost Indices

    100

    110

    120

    130

    140

    150

    160

    170

    180

    190

    1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

    Year

    I

    n

    d

    e

    x

    (

    1

    9

    9

    1

    =

    1

    0

    0

    )

    Total Plant-All Steam Generation Gas Turbogenerators GDP Deflator Transmission Distribution

    The Construction Management LandscapeCompetition for Key Construction Resources

    Delivery Schedules

    Annual Backlog at Major EPC Firms

    Shop Capacity

    National Utility Infrastructure Cost Indices

  • Construction Management Tables Have Reversed

  • 7Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    DevelopmentDevelopment Scheduling Scheduling Execution Execution CommissionCommissionDesign Design CloseClose--Out Out

    Detailed engineering design development

    Long lead time materials ordering

    Contract specifications development

    Planning and materials supply

    Assessing (detailed estimate information inputted into work management and scheduling systems)

    Completion of work package

    Short lead time materials ordering

    Development of operations and maintenance documentation

    Outage planning interface

    Implementation/ installation

    Permitting Work

    performance monitoring

    Work management/ schedule and cost monitoring

    Weekly progress status reporting

    Construction check and testing

    Certification and testing of equipment operability

    Operations and maintenance documentation delivery

    Initial training completion

    System punch-list items closed-out

    Design drawings updated with field changes

    Documentation closed-out

    Creation of scope-level design for planning and estimating

    Information structure [for work management, scheduling and cost systems] prepared

    Development of project PEP

    Contract strategy (make versus buy) development

    Construction Management Tables Have ReversedProject Management Stages and Definitions

  • 8Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    RisksRisks

    Scheduling Scheduling Execution

    Execution

    CommissionCommission

    Design Design Clos

    eClose--Out Out

    Developme

    nt

    Developme

    nt Pressure toStart Later

    Pressure toPressure toStart LaterStart Later

    Project Life CycleProject Life Cycle

    Engineering design delays

    Fabricator / equipment supplier queues lengthening

    Acquisition of labor

    Pressure toFinish Sooner

    PressurePressure totoFinish Finish SoonerSooner

    Competitive markets Cash flow Low reserve margins

    Pressure to start later and end sooner affects every stage of large capital project development

    Underestimated costs and under funded project

    Inadequate contract specifications

    Incomplete designs and design documentation

    Adverse impacts on other projects

    Schedule Compression Escalates Every Project RiskSchedule Compression Escalates Every Project RiskSchedule Compression Escalates Every Project Risk

    Delayed permitting

    Lack of commissioning time and plans

    Delayed start-up Missing or incorrect

    documentation

    Construction Management Tables Have ReversedRisks of Project Schedule Compression

  • Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management Skills

  • 10Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    The Need to Refocus on Construction Management Skills

    Large capital projects have always been extremely complex and difficult to manage. Emerging conditions have increased the complexity through price escalations, lack of key construction management skills and schedule compression.

    Construction management governance, through its eight key skills, provides the foundation for managing construction project risk well.

    Regulatory Regulatory ManagementManagement

    Financial Financial ManagementManagement

    Stakeholder Stakeholder ManagementManagement

    Quality Quality ManagementManagement

    Process Process ManagementManagement

    Workforce Workforce Performance Performance ManagementManagement

    Work Work ManagementManagement

    Project Project ManagementManagement

    Performance Performance DriversDrivers

  • 11Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Regulatory Regulatory ManagementManagement

    Financial Financial ManagementManagement

    Stakeholder Stakeholder ManagementManagement

    Quality Quality ManagementManagement

    Process Process ManagementManagement

    Workforce Workforce Performance Performance ManagementManagement

    Work Work ManagementManagement

    Project Project ManagementManagement

    Performance Performance DriversDrivers

    Planning and scheduling Engineering and design Scope management Project controls Decision making

    Job estimating Work package development Sourcing Materials management and

    logistics

    Staffing Productivity management Overtime management Contract management Work rule management Skills training Skills / job matching Safety

    Work continuity Work method development Standardization Procedure management Process measurement Knowledge management

    Environmental management Project performance auditing Schedule variance monitoring Work quality monitoring

    Equity partner interface Intervener management Governmental relations Community relations

    Project scoping Project financing Budgeting Project financial reporting Project approval hold points

    Permitting and licensing Public accountability reporting Regulatory filing management Regulatory requirements

    management

    To address the challenges and mitigate risk exposure, companies should initially focus on rebuilding (or building) construction management skills in five areas

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsConstruction Management Governance Initial Focus

  • 12Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Relies on formal management processes defined by Board and CEO

    Addresses enterprise process needs comprehensively

    Uses business objectives to drive decision making

    Implements rigorous processes to increase owner comfort levels

    Emphasizes business, financial, human capital and operations management enterprise focus (i.e., strategic)

    Exhibits high-capability of decision tool infrastructure

    Relies on formal communication, review and decision processes

    Incorporates multi business unit process dimensions to integrate enterprise considerations

    Uses project requirements to drive fact-based decisions

    Focuses on owner key issues Emphasizes overall project and

    business management program focus (i.e., tactical-strategic)

    Exhibits moderate to high capability of decision tool infrastructure

    Relies heavily on consensus Includes few sub-processes to

    integrate enterprise considerations Relies on perceptions, less

    empirically-driven Invites active and broad owner

    involvement Emphasizes project cost and schedule

    performance project focus (i.e., tactical)

    Exhibits low to moderate capability of decision tool infrastructure

    Description

    When business complexity is demanding

    With increased business management goal diversity

    If balanced and strong buyer-supplier power market conditions exist

    When business scale is expanding With need to preserve owner

    interests When buyer-supplier market

    conditions are balanced

    When business scope is narrow With a small, tight management group When strong buyer-power market

    conditions exist

    Relevance

    Owners define and drive decisions and reporting

    Decisions grounded in enterprise value

    Decision-making driven by information over dialogue

    Sophisticated use of a full range of contracting options

    Owners collaborate with suppliers to define requirements and protocols

    Decisions reflect project economics Decision-making based on selected

    fundamentals Appearance of alliance and

    partnership arrangements

    Reliance by owners on third parties to define requirements

    Group decision-making predominates Decisions driven by project needs and

    progress Decision making is less factor- or

    empirics-based Prevalence of bid-buy practices with

    some incentive-based contracting

    Key Practices

    MarketMarket--Based ApproachesBased ApproachesLimited Process ModelsLimited Process ModelsInformal Style and ProcessesInformal Style and Processes

    There are three broad approaches to construction management governance

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsConstruction Management Governance Approaches

  • 13Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    80%

    100%

    0%

    %

    o

    f

    T

    o

    t

    a

    l

    C

    o

    s

    t

    Project Activities

    Planning DetailedEngineering

    Procurement Construction

    Costs committed by planning and design decisions

    Spend

    100%

    80%

    Source: Construction Industry Institute

    Project spend lags initial planning and engineering The greatest impacts on project success are developed during project planning and detailed engineering phases

    Preliminary planning enables downstream project activities

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsImpact on Execution of Planning

  • 14Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Effective governance practices establish the foundation for realizing the benefits of project management best practices namely cost leadership and process efficiency, according to the Construction Industry Institute

    Mean Performance ScoreSource: Construction Industry Institute

    Best Practice ValueBest Practice Use versus Quartile Performance

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsBest Practices in Project Management

    Project Performance

    4th Quartile 3rd Quartile 2nd Quartile 1st Quartile

    Low Best Practice Use

    High

    High Impact

    Medium Impact

    Low Impact

    Cost Savings

    Low Impact

    Medium Impact

    Low Impact

    Design / Information Technology

    Project Change

    Management

    Pre-Project PlanningZero Accident

    Technique

    Team BuildingPlanning for

    Startup

    Constructability

    Materials Management

    Best Practice Use vs. Quartile Performance Best Practice Value

    Schedule Reduction

    HighImpact

  • 15Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Lean construction is the adoption of the lean manufacturing technique pioneered by Toyota and Honda The key to lean construction is the decentralization of planning and decision making, managing for process, not speed, and the minimization

    of process waste through ruthless standardization Constructability concepts of feed-forward process input are also included in lean construction Elimination of process variance within this methodology has seen >15% cost and schedule improvements in large projects such as airport

    design and construction

    Lean ConstructionLean Construction

    Stage gating is used to control major project segments with approval to proceed to subsequent stages contingent on meeting each stages preset objectives

    Stage gating technique is being pursued in some regions as a regulatory management tool Large projects employing stage gating also have seen >15 % project improvements with severe-duty construction efforts (e.g., Suncor at

    Alberta refinery construction) benefiting from this technique

    Stage GatingStage Gating

    Up-front decisions have the most significant impact on downstream activities All upstream events (e.g., design, engineering, etc.) must be executed around construction and commissioning requirements >15% overall project cost and schedule improvements common with constructability implementation Applications of constructability implementation typically include severe-duty projects such as oil pipelines, power plant construction, shale-oil

    refinery construction, etc.

    ConstructabilityConstructability

    Classic construction methodology, with centralized CPM scheduling and PMO-driven project management Production driven centrally through schedule adherence, tight work package preparation and strong push drivers for process efficiencies Speed of execution through efficient functional execution is the primary project throughput driver PMBOK methodology driven by optimizing performance along each element of the activity chain PMBOK is the most prevalent project management methodology in industry today

    Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK)Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK)

    There are several broad project management approaches in use today

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsProject Management Approaches

  • 16Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    QUALITY

    SAFETYSAFETY

    SCHEDULECOST

    Regardless of the project management approach selected, the success criteria and levers available to construction project managers remain the same

    Contract Management

    Contract Contract ManagementManagement

    ProcurementManagement

    ProcurementProcurementManagementManagement

    Project ExecutionProject Project

    ExecutionExecutionProject Risk ManagementProject Risk Project Risk ManagementManagement

    Decision DriversDecision Drivers

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsSuccess Criteria and Decision Drivers

  • 17Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Contracts entered in a timely manner to minimize financial and project delivery risk

    Change order management process clearly defined and rigorously applied

    Web-based tools used to manage interactions with contractors in near real-time

    Array of contracting approaches employed depending upon project type, scale, and risk profile

    Contract ManagementContract Management

    Appropriate hedging tools used to minimize price volatility exposure

    Continuous evaluation of suppliers fabrication queues and lead-times to ensure on-time deliveries

    Open, frequent communications with project managers, asset owners, and finance personnel regarding deadlines, resource availability and delivery, and the corporate integrated construction and maintenance plan

    Supplier options expanded through appropriate identification and qualification processes

    Procurement ManagementProcurement Management Project management process is clearly defined

    with procedures and communicated as the expected process to complete project work

    Projects are executed from start to finish by the same project manager

    Project controls are used to monitor the project continuously and hold project managers accountable for results

    Functional silos are not allowed to impede project structure and activities

    Construction and maintenance schedules are integrated to optimize use of contractors and craft labor

    Project ExecutionProject Execution

    Each of the decision drivers has specific leading practices associated with it. Examples include:

    Priorities and metrics for both the organization and project are fully aligned

    During planning, likely project variances are identified and previous project actual activity durations considered

    Performance standards are clearly identified and appropriate training provided before project initiation

    Planning and milestone development processes are evaluated after each project

    Significant time and effort are spent on stakeholder communications

    Project Risk ManagementProject Risk Management

    Supported bySupported by OrganizationalOrganizational ProcessProcess ToolsTools MeasurementMeasurement

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsProject Management Leading Practices

  • 18Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    M

    a

    i

    n

    t

    a

    i

    n

    a

    b

    i

    l

    i

    t

    y

    &

    O

    p

    e

    r

    a

    b

    i

    l

    i

    t

    y

    C

    o

    n

    s

    t

    r

    u

    c

    t

    a

    b

    i

    l

    i

    t

    y

    F

    r

    o

    n

    t

    -

    E

    n

    d

    L

    o

    a

    d

    i

    n

    g

    V

    a

    l

    u

    e

    E

    n

    g

    i

    n

    e

    e

    r

    i

    n

    g

    S

    t

    a

    r

    t

    -

    u

    p

    &

    C

    o

    m

    m

    i

    s

    s

    i

    o

    n

    i

    n

    g

    T

    Q

    M

    P

    r

    o

    c

    e

    s

    s

    H

    a

    z

    a

    r

    d

    A

    n

    a

    l

    y

    s

    i

    s

    P

    r

    e

    f

    a

    b

    r

    i

    c

    a

    t

    i

    o

    n

    P

    r

    e

    a

    s

    s

    e

    m

    b

    l

    y

    &

    M

    o

    d

    u

    l

    a

    r

    i

    z

    a

    t

    i

    o

    n

    Best Practice Inter-Relations Defined

    Maintainability & Operability Designing equipment layout to ensure that maintenance and operations tasks can be conducted efficiently and effectively

    Constructability The optimum use of construction knowledge and experience in planning, design, procurement, and field operations to achieve overall project efficiencies and objectives

    Front-End Loading Defining and incorporating strategic information into the project planning phase to influence overall project capital costs, schedule reworks, construction turnover to operation, andsteady state operations costs

    Value Engineering the systematic effort directed at analyzing functional requirements of systems, equipment, facilities, procedures, and supplies for the purpose of achieving the essential functionality at the lowest life cycle cost, and consistent with meeting all performance requirements for reliability, quality, safety, etc.

    Start-up and Commissioning The process of ensuring that systems are designed, installed, functionally tested, and capable of being operated and maintained to perform within design specification

    TQM A strategy for continuous improvement performance in every level and in all areas of management

    Process Hazard Analysis Ensuring safety of a facility by identification of hazards or problem areas that result from deviations from normal design operations

    Prefabrication Preassembly & Modularization use off-site construction and assembly in controlled environments to minimizestick-building tasks

    L

    o

    w

    H

    i

    g

    h

    I

    m

    p

    a

    c

    t

    o

    n

    P

    r

    o

    j

    e

    c

    t

    C

    o

    s

    t

    s

    Half of the key best practices are executed during construction

    Possessing the skills and best practices sets the stage for achieving the project benefits

    Building (or Rebuilding) Construction Management SkillsProject Management Best Practice Inter-Relations

  • How ScottMadden Can Help You

  • 20Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    QA/QC program, process and procedure development and oversight support

    Project performance monitoring and performance improvement

    Schedule and budget variance monitoring and remediation

    Supplier quality and queue management

    Quality Management

    Work schedule integration and optimization Work methods Standardization and modularization Knowledge capture and transfer

    Process Management

    Work sampling and productivity estimates Overtime management processes Work rule management practices Skills sourcing and training activities Safety training materials and practices

    Workforce Performance Management

    Project estimating procedures and data sources Work package structures suitable for estimating and

    construction Maximo and Passport management

    Work Management

    Hands on experience managing large capital projects and fossil plant outages

    Major projects readiness assessment ScottMadden proprietary best practices

    library

    Outage planning and preparation Construction organization design Documentation hierarchy (management

    model)

    Strategic sourcing and supplier management

    EPC contract management best practices Communication planning and execution Outage management augmentation QA/QC program augmentation Productivity sampling (wrench time

    studies)

    Post-project reviews, lessons learned, and knowledge transfer

    Project roles and responsibilities Tools and measures for decision making and

    progress reporting Skill training and organization depth Scope definition and control processes

    Project Management

    ScottMadden ScottMadden Demonstrated CapabilitiesDemonstrated CapabilitiesAssessment AreasAssessment Areas

    Construction Project Construction Project Performance CriteriaPerformance Criteria

    How ScottMadden Can Help YouGovernance Needs Assessment Approach

  • 21Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Week 7Week 7Week 6Week 6 Week 8Week 8

    3. Opportunity Identification Identify and prioritize gaps in risks and

    potential mitigation alternatives Identify and prioritize improvement

    opportunities Identify actions required to achieve

    improvements Prepare high-level project plan for

    next steps

    2. Operations Assessment Conduct interviews Review available documentation Identify primary risks and exposure Review mitigation options and plans

    already in place Review existing metrics/monitoring

    mechanisms

    1. Planning and Organization Finalize scope Identify data needs Schedule interviews and update

    meetings

    Week 5Week 5Week 4Week 4Week 3Week 3Week 2Week 2Week 1Week 1TaskTask

    Six to eight weeks in duration, depending on finalized scope Interviews with key internal stakeholders (typically 15 20 interviews) Review of internal strategy, commitments, requirements, plans, reporting and other internal documentation Small project team comprised of senior level consultants working collaboratively with key client personnel

    How ScottMadden Can Help YouSample Project Timeline Readiness Assessment

  • 22Copyright 2008 by ScottMadden. All rights reserved.

    Project PhaseProject Phase

    Lessons LearnedLessons Learned

    Outage planning and preparation

    Construction organization design

    Documentation hierarchy (management model)

    Strategic sourcing and supplier management

    EPC contract management best practices

    Outage management

    QA/QC program

    Productivity sampling (wrench time studies)

    Post-project reviews, lessons learned and knowledge transfer

    Communication planning and execution

    ExecutionExecutionPlanningPlanningTaskTask

    Duration of consulting support varies depending on finalized scope Small project team comprised of senior level consultants working collaboratively with key client personnel

    How ScottMadden Can Help YouSample Project Timeline Construction Management Auditing

  • Jere JacobiPartner

    ScottMadden, Inc.Ten Piedmont Center

    Suite 805Atlanta, GA 30305

    Phone: 404-814-0020Mobile: 262-337-1352

    [email protected]

    Steve SandersPartner

    ScottMadden, Inc.Ten Piedmont Center

    Suite 805Atlanta, GA 30305

    Phone: 404-814-0020Mobile: 770-490-8684

    [email protected]