chapter 5 results and discussion -...
TRANSCRIPT
Chapter 5
Results and discussion
This chapter is the core of thesis, which deals with results,
discussion and conclusion. Effects of calcinations temperature,
swift heavy ion irradiation on the structural, magnetic and
dielectric properties of barium hexaferrite (BaFe12O
19) are
explained in detail. A detailed analysis of the magnetic and
dielectric properties of Cu substituted M type barium hexagonal
ferrite with composition BaCuxFe
12-xO
19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8,
1.0) and Al substituted BaAlxFe
12-xO
19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
hexaferrite is investigated. Nature of interactions between hard
(Ba2Ni
2Fe
12O
22) and soft (CuFe
2O
4) ferrites and incorporation of
ferroelectric material (BiFeO3) into the hexaferrite (BaFe
12O
19)
phase for tuning the magnetic and dielectric properties
components are highlighted in both Ba2Ni
2Fe
12O
22 / CuFe
2O
4 and
BaFe12O
19 / BiFeO
3 composites material. The combination of the
magnetic particles with conducting polymer leads to formation
of ferromagnetic conducting polymer composite. Structural,
magnetic and dielectric properties of Polyaniline / Ba2Ni
2Fe
12O
22
composite are given in detail.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 107 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.1 Synthesis of M-type hexaferrite (BaFe12O19) using Sol-gel auto
combustion technique
5.1.1 Effect of calcinations temperature
M type Barium hexagonal ferrite (BaFe12O19) has been synthesized by Sol-gel
auto combustion method. The combusted powders were calcined in air for 4 hours at
different temperatures 250 oC, 500
oC, 950
oC as well as 500
oC followed by 950
oC
respectively using a muffle furnace to investigate the effect of calcinations
temperature on the structural, magnetic and dielectric properties of barium hexaferrite.
The prepared hexaferrite samples were characterized using FTIR, XRD, SEM, VSM
and dielectric measurements.
5.1.1.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.1.1. FTIR spectra of combusted and calcined BaFe12O19 powder
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 108 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.1.1 shows the FTIR spectra of combusted and calcined BaFe12O19
samples in a wave number ranging from 4000 to 400 cm-1
. The combusted powder
and sample calcined at 250 oC show almost similar kind of spectrum. They have
dominant absorption bands at 3433 cm-1
, 1629 cm-1
, 1426 cm-1
, 628 cm-1
, 555 cm-1
and 442 cm-1
. The bands below 650 cm-1
are due to the iron-oxygen bonds which are
characteristics of hematite (γ-Fe2O3) [1]. The adsorption bands at 3433 cm-1
exhibit
the stretching vibration of hydroxyl group (O-H) [2,3] which indicate the presence of
free or absorbed water in the samples. There are two weak and broad absorptions
around 1400 and 1600 cm-1
corresponding to the presence of small amount of residual
carbon in the samples as observed usually in the case of samples prepared by citrate
precursor method [4].
The band corresponds to the O-H vibration of water molecules (3433 cm-1
)
disappear for the samples calcined at 500 oC, 950
oC, and 500
oC followed by 950
oC.
The annealing at 950 oC for 4 hours leads to the complete removal of residual carbon
from the samples. In the samples calcined at 950 oC, two strong and sharp absorption
bands at 580 and 440 cm-1
are found to be in agreement with the characteristic
infrared absorption bands for the metal oxygen stretching vibrations of hexaferrite
[5,6].
Fig. 5.1.2. XRD patterns of combusted and calcined BaFe12O19 powder
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 109 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.1.3. XRD pattern of prepared BaFe12O19 powder calcined at 500 oC followed by 950
oC (Up),
JCPDS file - PDF#840757 of BaFe12O19 (Down)
Phase formation and the structural properties of prepared samples were
investigated using an X-ray powder diffractometer (CuKα radiation, λ=1.5405 Ǻ). The
X-ray diffraction studies were carried out on as-burnt powder, the powders calcined at
500, 950 oC and the preheated (500
oC followed by 950
oC) powder and results are
shown in Fig. 5.1.2. The XRD pattern of as-burnt powder indicates the presence of
γ-Fe2O3 as a major phase and some other minor phases such as α-Fe2O3, BaCO3 and
BaFe12O19 which confirms the completion of decomposition process and states that
released heat during self combustion process has been observed to be sufficient for
complete conversion of the metal compounds to metal oxides and carbonates [7]. The
interaction between CO or CO2 generated from citric acid decomposition and Ba2+
ions leads to formation of BaCO3.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 110 - Ph.D. Dissertation
By increasing the annealing temperature to 500 oC, α-Fe2O3 appears as a major
phase and BaFe12O19 as minor phases is detected. During annealing BaCO3
decomposes and Ba2+
librated reacts with γ or α-Fe2O3 to form a small amount of
barium monoferrite (BaFe2O4). The reaction between barium monoferrite and iron
oxide leads to formation of barium hexaferrite [8]. At 950 oC, BaFe12O19 appears as
major phase and some minor phases α-Fe2O3 and BaFe2O4 are still noticed. The
sample preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC shows pure single phase of barium
hexaferrite. The calculated lattice parameters a = 5.892 Ǻ and c = 23.183 Ǻ are in
close agreement with the standard JCPDS file - PDF#840757 [9] (Fig 5.1.3). From
above results it has been observed that the calcination condition plays an important
role in the formation of pure barium ferrite phase.
Table 5.1.1 Lattice parameters and unit cell volume of calcined BaFe12O19 powder
5.1.1.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.1.4. SEM images of BaFe12O19 powder calcined (a) at 950 oC (b) preheated at 500
oC
and calcined at 950 oC
Fig. 5.1.4 (a) and (b) show SEM micrographs of the sample calcined directly
at 950 oC and the sample preheated at 500
oC followed by 950
oC respectively. It can
be seen from micrograph that the powder are composed of many tiny clusters grains.
The grains of sample preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC are found more uniform
in both shape and size compared to the sample directly calcined at 950 oC.
Calcination
Temperature
Lattice constants Unit cell
volume (Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
500 + 950 oC 5.892 23.183 696.99
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 111 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.1.1.3 Magnetic properties
Fig. 5.1.5. Hysteresis loop of BaFe12O19 powder calcined at 500 oC followed by 950
oC
Magnetic measurement at room temperature was carried out using VSM with
a maximum applied field of 15 kOe. Fig. 5.1.5 shows Magnetic hysteresis loop of
BaFe12O19 sample calcined 500 oC followed by 950
oC. The hysteresis curve thus
obtained yielded an intrinsic coercivity (Hc) of 4625 Oe, a saturation magnetization
(Ms) of 56.24 emu/g, a remanent magnetization (Mr) of 30.0 emu/g and the squareness
ratio (Mr/Ms) is about 0.53, which confirms the formation of single domain.
5.1.1.4 Dielectric properties
Fig. 5.1.6. shows variation of dielectric constant (ε') as a function of frequency
for the sample preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC. It can be observed that the
sample exhibit dielectric dispersion where dielectric constant decreases with
increasing frequency. The decrease in dielectric constant is rapid at low frequency and
approach to frequency independent behaviour. This is a normal behaviour observed in
most of the ferri-magnetic materials.
This can be explained on the basis of Koop’s theory, which based on the
Maxwell–Wagner polarization model [10,11]. According to Maxwell-Wagner
polarization model, the dielectric structure of the ferrite material is assumed to be
made up of two layers. The first layer consists thick layer of ferrite grains of fairly
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 112 - Ph.D. Dissertation
well conducting boundaries. The other is a thin layer of ferrite grains of relatively
poor conducting boundaries. The mobile electrons reach the grain boundaries through
hopping and if the resistance of the grain boundaries is high enough the electrons pile
up at the grain boundaries and produce induced polarization. However, as the
frequency of the applied field increases, the electrons cannot follow the applied ac
field. This results in the decrease of the probability of electrons reaching the grain
boundaries and as a result polarization decreases and hence dielectric constant
decreases [12,13].
10k 100k 1M4
5
6
7
8
9
Die
lectr
ic c
on
sta
nt
(real)
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 5.1.6. Variation of dielectric constant (real) as a function of frequency for
BaFe12O19 hexaferrite powder preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC
Dielectric loss factor is represented as the energy dissipation in the dielectric
system. The variation of dielectric loss factor (tan δ) as a function of frequency for the
sample preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC is shown in Fig. 5.1.7. It is seen that
dielectric loss factor decreases continuously as the frequency of the alternating field
increased. In the low frequency region, which corresponds to high resistivity (due to
grain boundaries), more energy is required for electron exchange between Fe3+
and
Fe2+
ions; thus the energy loss is high. In the high frequency range, which corresponds
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 113 - Ph.D. Dissertation
to low resistivity (due to grain boundaries), less energy is needed for electron transfer
between Fe3+
and Fe2+
in the grains and hence the energy loss is small [14].
10k 100k 1M0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4D
iele
ctr
ic lo
ss
fa
cto
r (t
an
)
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 5.1.7. Variation of dielectric loss factor (tan δ) as a function of frequency for
BaFe12O19 hexaferrite powder preheated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC
5.1.1.5 Conclusions
M-type BaFe12O19 hexaferrite powders have been successfully synthesized via
Sol–gel auto-combustion technique. The results from FTIR, XRD, VSM and
dielectric measurement studies can be summarized as follows:
Two strong and sharp absorption bands observed in the FTIR spectra
attributed to the metal oxygen stretching vibrations.
XRD results show formation of to single phase of M-type BaFe12O19.
SEM micrographs show the formation of homogeneous grains.
Magnetization result of pure BaFe12O19 sample indicates that formed particles
are single domain.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 114 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Pure BaFe12O19 sample shows frequency dependent phenomena, i.e. the
dielectric constant decreases with increasing frequency and then reaches a
constant value.
5.1.2 Effect of Swift Heavy Ion (SHI) irradiation on BaFe12O19
In order to study the effects of Swift Heavy Ion irradiation on structural,
surface morphology and magnetic properties of material, pure BaFe12O19 sample
which is preheated at 500 oC followed final calcinations at 950
oC was irradiated with
200 MeV Ag16+
ions at a fluence of 1 x 1013
ions/cm2 using 15 UD Pelletron
Accelerator at Inter University Accelerator Centre, New Delhi, INDIA. The irradiated
BaFe12O19 sample was characterized using FTIR, XRD, SEM and VSM.
5.1.2.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.1.8. FTIR spectra of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 powder
FTIR spectra of pristine and irradiated (200 MeV Ag16+
ions at a fluence of
(1 x 1013
ions/cm2) samples of BaFe12O19 powder preheated at 500
oC followed by
950 oC is shown in Fig. 5.1.8. The two absorption bands correspond to vibrations of
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 115 - Ph.D. Dissertation
the bond between the metal-oxygen ions are observed in both pristine and irradiated
BaFe12O19 samples. Intensity of these bands is found to decrease in irradiated sample.
Fig. 5.1.9. XRD patterns of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 powder
Table 5.1.2. Estimation of lattice constants and unit-cell volume of pristine
and irradiated BaFe12O19 powder
XRD patterns of both pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 samples are shown in
Fig. 5.1.9. XRD results show pure single phase barium hexaferrite. The basic
hexagonal crystal structure remains almost same after SHI irradiation. The peak
intensities of irradiated BaFe12O19 sample are found to be decreased where as the peak
widths are found to be increased, which indicates that SHI irradiation have generated
point/cluster of defects which cause certain amount of amorphization in the materials
[15,16]. The calculated values of lattice constants and unit-cell volume of both
Samples Lattice constants Unit cell volume
(Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
Pristine 5.892 23.183 696.99
Irradiated 5.890 23.188 696.68
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 116 - Ph.D. Dissertation
pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 samples are given in Table 5.1.2. There is no much
change in lattice constants and unit-cell volume values.
5.1.2.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.1.10. SEM images of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 powder
The SEM micrographs of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 samples are shown
in Fig. 5.1.10. The uniformity of the grain size is slightly changed with irradiation; the
pristine sample shows more uniform grains while SHI irradiated sample show slight
non uniform clusters.
5.1.2.3 Magnetic properties
Fig. 5.1.11. Hysteresis loops of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 powder
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 117 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Table 5.1.3. Magnetic parameters of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19 measured under maximum
applied field of 15 KOe.
Samples Ms (emu/g) Mr (emu/g) Mr / Ms Hc (Oe)
Pristine 56.24 30.00 0.533 4625
Irradiated 53.34 30.48 0.571 4250
Room temperature hysteresis loops of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19
hexaferrites are shown in Fig. 5.1.11 saturation magnetization and coercivity of
irradiated sample are slightly less than that of pristine sample. On irradiation,
amorphous tracks are produced which lead to the suppression of the atomic and
ferrimagnetic long-range orders [17]. SHI irradiation may be affected more
effectively Fe3+
site 4fIV (tetrahedral) besides 4fVI (octahedral) site than the 12k sites
[18]. Therefore, this decrease in magnetization can be attributed to the reduction of
Fe3+
ions, both at the octahedral as well as at the tetrahedral sites.
5.1.2.4 Conclusions
The results of the comparative study of pristine and irradiated BaFe12O19
hexaferrite particles lead to the following conclusions:
The strong absorption bands of FTIR confirm the metal oxygen stretching
vibrations of hexaferrite.
XRD result reveals the formation of single phase M-type barium hexaferrite
for the both pristine and irradiated samples.
SHI irradiated sample show slight non uniform clusters.
The irradiated sample shows lesser value of magnetisation as well as
coercivity.
5.1.3 Preparation of BaFe12O19 in presence of surfactant CTAB
M-type BaFe12O19 hexaferrite was prepared in the presence of cationic
surfactant cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) using Sol-gel auto combustion
technique. The prepared sample was pre-calcined at 500 °C in a furnace for 4 hours
followed by final calcination at 950 °C for 4 hours. The effect of surfactant on the
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 118 - Ph.D. Dissertation
phase purity, microstructure and magnetic properties were studied using FTIR, XRD,
SEM and VSM.
5.1.3.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.1.12. FTIR spectra of BaFe12O19 powder with and without surfactant CTAB
Fig. 5.1.12 shows FTIR spectra of calcined BaFe12O19 hexaferrite with and
without surfactant CTAB. Two major absorption bands correspond to the metal
oxygen vibrations are found in the range 600-550 cm-1
and 450-400 cm-1
for both the
samples.
The indexed XRD patterns of barium hexaferrite samples with and without
surfactant are shown in Fig. 5.1.13. XRD analysis of normal sample shows mono
phase of barium hexaferrite while surfactant added sample revealed two phases;
hexagonal barium ferrite BaFe12O19 and small amount of intermediate phases
(α - Fe2O3 and γ - Fe2O3). Most of the peaks were ascribed to diffraction planes of
hexagonal barium ferrite BaFe12O19 and the intermediate phases also can be
eliminated by selecting proper molar ratio of metal nitrates to citric acid in the auto
combustion method [7,19].
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 119 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.1.13. XRD patterns of BaFe12O19 powder with and without surfactant CTAB
Table 5.1.4. Estimation of lattice parameters and cell volume of calcined
BaFe12O19 powder with and without surfactant CTAB
Samples Lattice parameters Volume of
unit cell (Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
Normal 5.892 23.183 696.99
CTAB 5.893 23.190 697.43
5.1.3.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.1.14 (a,b) show SEM micrographs of calcined BaFe12O19 hexaferrite
samples prepared without and with surfactant CTAB. Morphology of BaFe12O19
sample was changed in the presence of surfactant; Shape of grains was changed from
spherical to the flakes type and grain size is also increased in presence of surfactant.
More agglomeration was observed in BaFe12O19 sample prepared in presence of
cationic surfactant CTAB.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 120 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.1.14. SEM images of BaFe12O19 (a) without surfactant and (b) with surfactant CTAB
5.1.3.3 Magnetic properties
-15000 -10000 -5000 0 5000 10000 15000
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
M (
em
u/g
)
H (Oe)
Normal
CTAB
Fig. 5.1.15. Hysteresis loops of BaFe12O19 powder with and without surfactant CTAB
Table 5.1.5. Magnetic parameters of BaFe12O19 with and without surfactant CTAB
measured under maximum applied field of 15 KOe.
Sample Ms(emu/g) Mr (emu/g) Mr / Ms Hc (Oe)
Normal 56.24 30.00 0.533 4625
CTAB 34.65 22.58 0.652 375
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 121 - Ph.D. Dissertation
The magnetization curves of both the samples were measured on a VSM at
room temperature under an applied field of 15 kOe. The experimental results (Table
5) show that the low values of the saturation magnetization and coercivity in the
sample prepared in the presence of cationic surfactant CTAB. The squareness ratio,
Mr / Ms for both samples clearly indicates that this typical behaviour is due to the
transition from single domain to multi-domain structure with increasing particle size
[20]. The presence of small amount of intermediate phases (α - Fe2O3 and γ - Fe2O3)
which are weak ferromagnetic, leads to a reduction in magnetization of surfactant
added samples.
5.1.3.4 Conclusions
M-type barium hexaferrite hexaferrite powders have been successfully
synthesized via Sol–gel auto-combustion technique in the presence of surfactant
CTAB. Effect of surfactant on phase purity, microstructure and magnetic properties
can be summarized as follows:
XRD analysis reveals the formation of intermediate phases along with pure
phase in the sample prepared in presence of surfactant
Morphology of the sample was changed in the sample prepared in presence of
cationic surfactant; shape of grains were changed from spherical to the flakes
type.
The presence of small amount of intermediate phases (α - Fe2O3 and γ - Fe2O3)
which are weak ferromagnetic, leads to a reduction in magnetization of
surfactant added sample.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 122 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] M. Ahmad, R. Grössinger, M. Kriegisch, F. Kubel, M.U. Rana, Curr. Appl.
Phys.,12 (2012) 1413.
[2] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, I.H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 323 (2011) 259.
[3] Y.Y. Meng, M.H. He, Q. Zeng, D.L. Jiao, S. Shukla, R.V. Ramanujan, Z.W. Liu,
J. Alloys Compd., 583 (2014) 220.
[4] V.K. Sankaranarayanan, C. Sreekumar, Curr. Appl. Phys., 3 (2003) 205.
[5] R. Patil, S. Kakatkar, A. Sanlepal, S. Sawant, J.Pure Appl. Phys., 2 (1994) 193.
[6] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, I.H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010) 1720.
[7] A. Mali, A. Ataie, Ceram. Int., 30 (2004) 1979.
[8] A. Ataie, S.E. Zojaji, J. Alloys Compd., 431 (2007) 331.
[9] Obradors, J. Solid State Chem., 56 (1985) 171.
[10] A.M. Abo El Ata, S.M. Attia, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 257 (2003) 165.
[11] G. Sathishkumar, C. Venkataraju, R. Murugaraj, K. Sivakumar J Mater Sci:
Mater Electron (2011) 395.
[12] J.C. Dyre, T.B. Schrøder, Rev. Mod. Phys., 72 (2000) 873.
[13] C.G. Koops, Phys. Rev., 83 (1951) 121.
[14] M.N. Ashiq, M. J. Iqbal, M. Najam-ul-Haq, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 324 (2012)
15.
[15] M. Singh, A. Dogra, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. B, 196 (2002)
315.
[16] S.N. Dolia, P.K. Sharma, M.S. Dhawan, S. Kumar, A.S. Prasad, A. Samariya,
S.P. Pareek, R.K. Singhal, K. Asokan, Y.T. Xing, M. Alzamora, E. Saitovitach, Appl.
Surf. Sci., 258 (2012) 4207.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 123 - Ph.D. Dissertation
[17] B.P. Rao, K.H. Rao, P.S.V. Subba Rao, A.M. Kumar, Y.L.N. Murthy,
K. Asokan, V.V. Siva Kumar, Ravi Kumar, N.S. Gajbhiye, O.F. Caltun, Nucl.
Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. B, 244 (2006) 27.
[18] B. Kaur, M. Bhat, R. Kumar, S.D. Kulkarni, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 305 (2006)
392.
[19] G. Xu, Hongliang Ma, M. Zhong, J. Zhou, Y. Yue, Z. He, J. Magn. Magn.
Mater., 301 (2006) 383.
[20] H.S. Sozeri, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 321 (2009) 2717.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 124 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.2 Synthesis of Copper doped M-type barium hexaferrite,
BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0)
Series of Cu substituted M-type barium hexagonal ferrite with chemical
composition BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0) have been prepared using
Sol-gel auto combustion technique. The combusted powders were pre-calcined at
500 °C in a furnace for 4 hours followed by final calcination at 950
°C for 4 hours in a
furnace and then slowly cooled to room temperature. The prepared hexaferrite
samples were characterized using FTIR, XRD, SEM, VSM and dielectric
measurements.
5.2.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.2.1. FTIR spectra of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.6, 1.0) hexaferrite powder samples
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 125 - Ph.D. Dissertation
FTIR spectra of copper substituted barium hexaferrite (BaCuxFe12-xO19) with
x = 0.0, 0.6 and 1.0 compositions are shown in the Fig. 5.2.1. Two absorption bands,
namely, high frequency band ν1 (600 cm-1
) and low frequency band ν2 (430 cm-1
) can
be seen in all spectra. These IR bands are assigned to the metal - oxygen stretching
vibrations of hexaferrite [1, 2]. The higher splitting and shifting of these bands
towards higher frequency were observed with Cu substitution. The intensity ratio
between these two bands may give the fraction of occupancy of cations to the lattice
sites while the difference in the band positions is because of the difference in the
Fe3+
- O2-
distances for five distinct sites i.e. 2a, 2b, 4f1, 4f2 and 12k [3].
Fig. 5.2.2. XRD patterns of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0) powder samples preheated
at 500 °C followed by final calcinations at 950 oC for 4 hours.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 126 - Ph.D. Dissertation
XRD patterns of the copper substituted BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6,
0.8, 1.0) hexaferrite samples are shown in Fig. 5.2.2. XRD analysis of all the samples
confirms the formation of M-type BaFe12O19hexaferrite as major crystalline phase,
which indicates that the Fe3+
ions are substituted by Cu2+
ions in the crystallography
sites of the BaFe12O19 structure. The peaks for Cu substituted hexaferrite appear
approximately at the same position as for pure (un-doped) barium hexaferrite. Some
minor Spinel ferrite (CuFe2O4) phase is also noticed in the XRD patterns. Spinel
ferrite may be attributed to the distribution of Cu and Fe cations between the two non-
equivalent lattice tetrahedral and octahedral sites [4]. The lattice parameters a and c
were calculated from the value of dhkl corresponding to the most intense (114) peak.
The lattice constants of BaCu0.6Fe11.4O19 were a = 5.895 Å and c = 23.215 Å, which
are slightly larger than that of BaFe12O19. These slight changes in the lattice constant
may have been caused by the difference between the ionic radius of Cu2+
(0.73 Å) and
Fe3+
(0.645 Å).
Table 5.2.1: Estimation of Lattice parameters and unit cell volume of BaCuxFe12-xO19
(x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0).
5.2.2 Morphology
The morphology of Copper substituted hexaferrite particles were examined by
SEM. Fig. 5.2.3 shows SEM images of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0)
hexaferrite powder samples. Grains of samples BaCu0.2Fe11.8O19 and BaCu0.6Fe11.4O19
show flake-like structure, while the samples BaCu0.4Fe11.6O19, BaCu0.8Fe11.2O19 and
BaCu1.0Fe11.0O19 show agglomerated clusters. The grains size decreased with
increasing in Cu content except for the sample BaCu0.6Fe11.4O19 where, grain size is
larger among all the samples.
Sample Lattice constants Unit cell volume
(Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
BaFe12O19 5.892 23.183 696.99
BaCu0.2Fe11.8O19 5.892 23.198 697.44
BaCu0.4Fe11.6O19 5.892 23.183 696.99
BaCu0.6Fe11.4O19 5.895 23.215 698.54
BaCu0.8Fe11.2O19 5.892 23.183 696.99
BaCu1.0Fe11.0O19 5.892 23.183 696.99
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 127 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.2.3. SEM images of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0) hexaferrite powder samples
5.2.3. Magnetic properties
Fig. 5.2.4 and Fig. 5.2.5 show initial magnetization curves and hysteresis
loops of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.6, 0.8) hexaferrite samples respectively
measured at room temperature under applied field of 15 KOe. Magnetic parameters -
saturation magnetization (Ms), coercivity (Hc), and remanent magnetization (Mr) were
calculated and listed in Table 5.2.2. The variation of the saturation magnetization
(Ms), coercivity (Hc), and remanent magnetization (Mr) as a function of Cu
concentration are shown in Fig. 5.2.6. Magnetic properties of BaFe12O19 hexaferrite
depend on 12 Fe3+
ions distributed over five distinct sites i.e. 2a, 2b, 4f1, 4f2 and 12k.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 128 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Out of these five, 2a, 4f2 and 12k are octahedral, 4f1 is tetrahedral and the last 2b is
trigonal bipyramid. The 12 Fe3+
are arranged as: 6 Fe3+
are in 12k site having the spin
up, 2 ions in 4f2 and 4f1 having spin down and 1 ion in 2a and 2b site having spin up.
So the 8 Fe3+
are in the upward direction and 4 in the downward direction. So 4
upward spin and downward spin cancel each other and the net magnetic moment is
obtained of 4 Fe3+
per formula units. According to the configuration of Fe3+
, there are
5 unpaired electrons in the 3d orbital, each Fe3+
ion has the magnetic moment of 5μB
and the total moment is 20 μB per formula unit [5-7].
Fig. 5.2.4. Initial magnetization curves of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.6, 0.8) hexaferrite samples
Table 5.2.2: Estimation of magnetic parameters of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0)
hexaferrite samples measured under maximum applied field of 15 KOe.
Sample
Saturation
magnetization
Ms (emu/g)
Remanent
magnetization
Mr (emu/g)
Mr / Ms coercivity
Hc (Oe)
BaFe12O19 56.24 30.00 0.533 4625
BaCu0.2Fe11.8O19 61.10 26.60 0.435 1063
BaCu0.6Fe11.4O19 53.70 20.10 0.374 750
BaCu0.8Fe11.2O19 39.30 20.70 0.527 3250
0 3000 6000 9000 12000 150000
10
20
30
40
50
60 x = 0.0
x = 0.2
x = 0.6
x = 0.8
M (
em
u/g
)
H (Oe)
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 129 - Ph.D. Dissertation
-15000 -10000 -5000 0 5000 10000 15000
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
M (
em
u/g
)
H (Oe)
X = 0.0
x = 0.2
x = 0.6
x = 0.8
Fig. 5.2.5. Hysteresis loops of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.6, 0.8) hexaferrite samples
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
40
45
50
55
60
65
Value of x in BaCuxFe
12-xO
19
Ms
20
22
24
26
28
30
Mr
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
Hc
Fig. 5.2.6. Variation of Ms, Mr and Hc with copper concentration.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 130 - Ph.D. Dissertation
The saturation magnetization increases and decreases alternatively with the
addition of copper content. The variation of Ms can be explained on the basis of
microstructure and distribution of cations at different sites in the crystal structure of
hexaferrite [8]. Usually large size and non-magnetic dopant ions prefers to occupy
octahedral sites [9]. Since ionic radius of Cu2+
is larger than that of Fe3+
, Cu ion
occupies the octahedral sites (2a, 4f2 and 12k). Increase in the value of Ms is due to
the occupancy of 4f2 site by Cu2+
which enhances the hyperfine fields at 12k and 2b
sites and strengthening the Fe3+
– O – Fe3+
super-exchange interaction giving higher
net magnetization [3,8,10]. Hence, the value of Ms reaches a maximum of 61.1 emu /
g for x = 0.2 sample. The decrease in MS can be caused because of the occupancy of
2b site with the increase of Cu2+
content [11].
Copper substitution in barium hexaferrite led to a significant decrease of Hc
compared to that of pure BaFe12O19 hexaferrite. Saturation magnetization (Ms), play a
direct role in decreasing coercivity through Brown’s relation [12] which is given by
(5.2.1)
Where, μ' is initial permeability and k1 anisotropy energy. According to this relation,
Hc is inversely proportional to Ms. In the copper substituted composition, the sample
x = 0.8 shows least saturation magnetization and highest coercivity. It can be seen
from SEM images, grain size is getting smaller with increase of copper content and so
numbers of grain boundary are increased. The increase of Hc may be due to the
increasing grain boundary existed as defects during magnetization process. The
sample x = 0.6 shows larger grain size, so coercivity is decreased in larger amount
[8].
5.2.4 Dielectric properties
Fig. 5.2.7 and 5.2.9 show variation of dielectric constant (real) and loss factor
(tan δ) as a function of frequency of BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0 to 1.0). All samples
exhibit frequency dependent phenomenon, dielectric constant decreases with
increasing frequency. At low frequency electron hopping occurs between Fe3+
and
Fe2+
. The electrons reach the grain boundary through hopping and are piled up at the
grain boundaries, which results in the interfacial polarization. However, as the
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 131 - Ph.D. Dissertation
frequency is increased, the probability of electrons reaching the grain boundary
decreases, which results in a decrease in the interfacial polarization. Therefore, the
dielectric constant decreases with increasing frequency [13-15].
10k 100k 1M
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 x = 0.0
x = 0.2
x = 0.4
x = 0.6
x = 0.8
x = 1.0
Die
lec
tric
co
ns
tan
t (r
ea
l)
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 5.2.7. Variation of dielectric constant (real) as a function of frequency for BaCuxFe12-xO19
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
4
6
8
10
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
tan
D
iele
ctr
ic c
on
sta
nt
(re
al)
Cu content (x) in BaCuxFe
12-xO
19
Fig. 5.2.8. Dielectric parameters Vs Copper concentration in BaCuxFe12-xO19
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 132 - Ph.D. Dissertation
10k 100k 1M0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30 x = 0.0
x = 0.2
x = 0.4
x = 0.6
x = 0.8
x = 1.0
Die
lec
tric
lo
ss
fa
cto
r (t
an
)
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 5.2.9. Variation of loss factor (tan δ) as a function of frequency for BaCuxFe12-xO19
The compositional dependence of dielectric constant (real) and dielectric loss
factor (tan δ) at frequency of 3170 Hz is given in Fig. 5.2.8. Since Cu ion occupies the
octahedral site (2a, 4f2 and 12k) then the total number of iron ions at that site is
decreased. As a result the hopping of electrons between ferric and ferrous ions also
decreases; consequently the values of dielectric constant and loss factor are decreased
[16]. The above assumption is valid up to x = 0.2; after which the increase in
dielectric constant is due to decrease in grain size with copper substitution. When
grain size is decreased, the resistivity increases and hence dielectric constant is
increased [17]. Sudden increase in dielectric constant with Cu ion concentration at x =
0.6 may be due to corresponding changes in microstructure or grain boundary as seen
in the SEM image.
5.2.5 Conclusions
Cu doped M-type barium hexaferrite with chemical composition
BaCuxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0) have been successfully synthesized
using Sol-gel auto combustion technique. Effects of Cu2+
ion on crystallography,
magnetic properties and dielectric properties can be summarized as follows:
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 133 - Ph.D. Dissertation
In all XRD patterns, M type hexaferrite (BaFe12O19) appears as major
crystalline phase, which indicates that the Fe3+
ions are substituted by Cu2+
ions in the crystallography sites of the BaFe12O19 structure.
SEM images show flake-like and agglomerated clusters.
The saturation magnetization increased and decreased alternatively with
substitution of copper content. It was found that coercivity values of all doped
samples were lower than those of undoped samples.
All samples exhibit frequency dependent phenomenon, dielectric constant
decreases with increasing frequency. There were no systematic changes in the
values of dielectric constant with Cu substitution; it was due to corresponding
changes in microstructure or grain boundary and grain size.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 134 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] R. Waldron, Phys. Rev., 99 (1955) 1717.
[2] R. Patil, S. Kakatkar, A. Sanlepal, S. Sawant, J.Pure Appl. Phys., 2 (1994) 193.
[3] F. Khademi, A. Poorbafrani, P. Kameli, H. Salamati, J. Supercond Nov. Magn., 25
(2012) 525.
[4] S.A. Farag, M.A. Ahmed, S.M. Hammad, A.M. Moustafa, Cryst. Res. Technol. 36
(2001) 85.
[5]. P. Wartewig, M.K. Krause, P. Esquinazi, S. Rosler, R. Sonntag, J. Magn.
Magn.Mater., 192 (1999) 83.
[6] J. Li, T.M. Gr, R. Sinclair, S.S. Rosenblum, H. Hayashi, J. Mater. Res., 9 (1994)
1499.
[7] Y. Liu, M.G.B. Drew, Y. Liu, J. Magn. Magn.Mater., 323 (2011) 945.
[8] A. Haq, M. Anis-ur-Rehman, Physica B, 407 (2012) 822.
[9] S. Thongmee, P. Winotai, I.M. Tang, Sci. Asia, 29 (2003) 51.
[10] A.L. Geiler, Y. He, S.D. Yoon, A. Yang, Y. Chen, V.G. Harris, C. Vittoria, J.
Appl. Phys., 101 (2007) 09M510.
[11] W. Li, X. Qiao, M. Li, T. Liu, H.X. Peng, Mater. Res. Bull., 48 (2013) 4449.
[12] M. Ahmad, R. Grössinger, M. Kriegisch, F. Kubel, M.U. Rana, Curr. Appl.
Phys., 12 (2012) 1413.
[13] A.M. Abo El Ata, S.M. Attia, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 257 (2003) 165.
[14] J.C. Dyre, T.B. Schroder, Rev. Mod. Phys., 72 (2000) 873.
[15] C.G. Koops, Phys. Rev., 83 (1951)121.
[16] G. Sathishkumar, C. Venkataraju, R. Murugaraj, K. Sivakumar, J Mater Sci:
Mater. Electron., (2011) 395.
[17] S. M. Reda, International Journal of Nano Science and Technology, 5 (2013) 17.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 135 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.3 Synthesis of trivalent (Al) doped M-type barium hexaferrite,
BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
Series of Al substituted BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
hexaferrite samples have been prepared using Sol-gel auto combustion technique. The
combusted powders were pre-heated at 500 oC for 4 hours and followed by 950
oC for
4 hours in a muffle furnace and then slowly cooled to room temperature. The prepared
hexaferrite samples were characterized using FTIR, XRD, SEM, VSM and dielectric
measurements.
5.3.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.3.1. FTIR Spectra of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) hexaferrite samples
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 136 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.3.1 shows FTIR spectra of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6 and
2.0) hexaferrite samples. The spectra of pure and Aluminium substituted barium
hexaferrite samples show two bands in the range 400 - 700 cm-1
corresponding to Al-
O bending vibrations and Fe-O stretching vibrations [1]. These bands are
characteristic infrared absorption bands for the metal oxygen stretching vibrations of
hexaferrite [2, 3]. The intensities of bands are decreased with Al substitution. This
may be due to replacement of heavier element (Fe) with lighter element (Al) and the
contraction in the unit cell [1].
Fig. 5.3.2. XRD patterns of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) hexaferrite samples
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 137 - Ph.D. Dissertation
X-ray diffraction patterns of BaAlxFe12-xO19 samples with x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8,
1.2, 1.6, 2.0 are shown in Fig. 5.3.2. XRD analysis show hexagonal structure with
space group P63/mmc and matches well with the literature [4]. It should be noted that
Al3+
substitution for Fe3+
in the concentration range reported in this work do not affect
the hexagonal structure of BaFe12O19. A similar result was obtained in a study of the
preparation of doped barium ferrite when Fe3+
was replaced by Al3+
[5]. The result
could be rationalized by the fact that for the synthesis of pure barium ferrite, a
significant amount of Fe3+
must be present alongside Fe2+
. But for Al-doped barium
ferrite, the presence of Fe3+
is not necessary as its role is taken by Al3+
. All aluminium
ions enter the lattice of barium ferrite [6].
The lattice constants (a and c) and unit cell volume are calculated from the
XRD data are listed in Table 5.3.1. The value of lattice parameters ‘a’ and ‘c’
decreases with increase in Al3+
substitution, The maximum reduction in lattice
parameters is about 0.7 – 0.8%. These change in lattice constant results from the
difference in ionic radii of Al3+
ion (0.535 Å) and Fe3+
ion (0.645 Å). The smaller
Al3+
ion, replacing Fe3+
ion leads to lattice contraction of the unit cell [7,8].
Table 5.3.1 Lattice parameters and unit cell volume of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
powder
Sample Lattice parameters Volume of
unit cell (Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
BaFe12O19 5.892 23.183 696.99
BaAl0.4Fe11.6O19 5.872 23.207 692.91
BaAl0.8Fe11.2O19 5.858 23.106 686.75
BaAl1.2Fe10.8O19 5.857 23.113 686.52
BaAl1.6Fe10.4O19 5.849 23.040 682.63
BaAl2.0Fe10.0O19 5.842 23.020 680.75
5.3.2 Morphology
The surface morphology and microstructure of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4,
0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) powder samples were observed by the scanning electron microscopy
(SEM) technique and images are shown in Fig.5.3.3. The surface morphology of pure
sample shows well crystalline nature with an almost uniform grain size distribution
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 138 - Ph.D. Dissertation
but it changes dramatically with Al substitution. The grain size of the pure sample
appears to be smaller than that of the doped samples. This is probably caused by the
Al3+
doping which could inhibit the development of grain size. This result agrees well
with X-ray data, where the values of the lattice parameter (a- Å) found to decrease
gradually with increasing Al content.
Fig. 5.3.3. SEM images of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) hexaferrite powder
5.3.3 Magnetic properties
The measured hysteresis loops for the Al substituted samples as a function of
applied magnetic field are shown in Fig. 5.3.5. The values of saturation magnetization
(Ms), remenance magnetization (Mr), squareness ratio (Mr/Ms) and coercivity (Hc) for
all BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) hexaferrite samples are listed in
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 139 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Table 5.3.2. An increase in the coercivity from 4625 Oe to 8500 Oe and decrease in
the saturation magnetization and remenance magnetization from 56.24 to 26.21 emu/g
and from 30.0 to 15.79 emu/g, respectively were observed for the Al-substituted
barium ferrite. The increase in coercivity and decrease in the magnetizations with Al
substitution is in agreement with the observation made for Al-substituted barium
hexaferrite prepared by glass-ceramic method [9].
Fig. 5.3.4. Initial magnetization curves of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
hexaferrite powder
Table 5.3.2 Estimation of magnetic parameters of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
hexaferrite powder measured under maximum applied field of 15000 Oe.
Sample Ms(emu/g) Mr (emu/g) Mr / Ms Hc (Oe)
BaFe12O19 56.24 30.00 0.533 4625
BaAl0.4Fe11.6O19 37.52 21.07 0.562 5500
BaAl0.8Fe11.2O19 19.18 11.55 0.602 6500
BaAl1.2Fe10.8O19 35.69 21.02 0.589 7375
BaAl1.6Fe10.4O19 26.84 13.19 0.491 7500
BaAl2.0Fe10.0O19 26.21 15.79 0.602 8500
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 140 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.3.5. Hysteresis loop of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0) hexaferrite powder
Fig. 5.3.6. Variation of Ms, Mr and Hc with increase in Aluminium concentration.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 141 - Ph.D. Dissertation
The magnetic moment in M-type hexaferrite is due to the distribution of iron
on five non equivalent sublattices of which three are octahedral (2a, 12k 4f2), one
tetrahedral (4f1) and one trigonal bipyramidal (2b) [10,11]. The total magnetic
moment (i.e., 20 µB) is due to uncompensated upward spins. In the present case Fe3+
ions having magnetic moment of 5 µB are replaced by Al3+
ions having zero magnetic
moment. Owing to the magnetic moment of Al3+
(0 µB) ion it is not able to cancel out
with spin down moments of Fe3+
ions (5 µB), which is responsible for the reduction in
saturation magnetization and remanence of the synthesized materials. The
replacement of Fe3+
with diamagnetic Al3+
also reduces the super-exchange
interaction between Fe3+
- O - Fe3+
[1, 7, 12]. This decrease in exchange interaction
also leads to a non-collinear spin arrangement [13]. The sample BaAl0.8Fe11.2O19
(x = 0.8) shows different behaviour, it has lowest value of saturation and remenance
magnetization among all the samples. It may be due to various causes such as small
size character, lattice defects. Amorphous aluminum oxide also may be present in the
samples, which are not observable in the XRD patterns; it may be attributed to the
occurrence of local combustion during annealing [14].
This increase in coercivity is thus attributed to the increase in anisotropy field
Ha, since the coercivity is proportional to magnetic anisotropy field [15].
Hc α Ha (3.3.1)
Hc α 2K / MS (3.3.2)
Where, MS is the magnetic saturation and K is the magneto-crystalline anisotropy.
According this equation, the decrease in the MS upon Al3+
doping, leads to an increase
in the intrinsic coercivity Hc.
5.3.4 Dielectric properties
Figs. 5.3.7 and 5.3.8 show the effect of frequency on the dielectric constant
(real) and the dielectric loss factor (tan δ) of BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6,
2.0) samples. It is clear from the figure that dielectric constant decrease with increase
in frequency. The decrease in the values of both dielectric constant and loss factor
with the frequency is a normal behaviour for ferrites and can be explained on the basis
of charge polarization [16,17].
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 142 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.3.7. Variation of dielectric constant (real) as a function of frequency for BaAlxFe12-xO19
hexaferrite samples
Fig. 5.3.8. Variation of loss factor (tan δ) as a function of frequency
for BaAlxFe12-xO19 hexaferrite samples
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 143 - Ph.D. Dissertation
0.0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
tan
D
iele
ctr
ic c
on
sta
nt
(re
al)
Al concentration (x) in BaAlxFe
12-xO
19
Fig. 5.3.9. Dielectric parameters Vs Aluminium concentration in BaAlxFe12-xO19 hexaferrite samples
It has been concluded that the electron exchange between Fe2+
and Fe3+
results
in the local displacement of charges, and this is responsible for polarization in ferrites.
The magnitude of exchange, which also controls the conduction in ferrites, depend
upon the concentration of Fe3+
/ Fe2+
ion pairs present in lattice sites. The dielectric
loss represents the phase lag of the dipole oscillations with respect to the applied
electric field. The decrease of dielectric loss with an increase in frequency is due to
the fact that the dipole oscillations cannot follow the changes of the external field at
high frequencies [1,18]
The compositional dependence of dielectric constant (real) and dielectric loss
factor (tan δ) at 1000 Hz is given in Fig. 5.3.9. It can be seen that the values of
dielectric constant (real) and tan δ increase with the substitution level of Al3+
ions.
The increase of dielectric constant with composition can be attributed to reduction of
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 144 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fe3+
and the excess amount of Fe2+
. Since Fe 2+
ions are easily polarizable, therefore,
the samples with higher substitution level (large number of Fe 2+
ions) will have high
dielectric constant [19]. The sudden decrease in the dielectric parameters for
BaAl1.2Fe10.8O19 (x = 0.8) might be due to the existence of an insulating secondary
phase on grain boundaries, which may reduce the Fe2+
ions in the lattice sites and also
it is true that extra phase at grain boundaries limits the reduction of Fe2+
ions
concentration [20].
5.3.5 Conclusions
A series of Al substituted BaAlxFe12-xO19 (x = 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0)
hexaferrites have been prepared using Sol-gel auto combustion technique. Role of
Al3+
ion in place of Fe3+
in the preparation of M-type barium hexaferrite can be
summarized as follows:
FTIR spectra of pure and Aluminium substituted barium hexaferrite samples
show two bands corresponding to Al-O bending vibrations and Fe-O
stretching vibrations.
The X-ray diffraction patterns reveal the formation of hexagonal structure with
space group P63/mmc for all level of Al3+
substitutions without any trace of
secondary phases. A decrease in the lattice parameters with increasing Al3+
doping level is due difference in ionic radii of Al3+
ion (0.535 Å) and Fe3+
ion
(0.645 Å).
Increasing the amount of aluminium affected the morphology of the particles;
agglomeration is increased with increase of Aluminium content.
It was found that replacement of Fe3+
with diamagnetic Al3+
leads to a
decrease in saturation magnetization and to a significant increase in the
coercive field.
The substitution of Al3+
ions leads to an increase in the polarization on the
sample, and results in the increase of dielectric constant. Also, with the
increase of Fe2+
ions, the chance of electron transfer increased between Fe3+
and Fe2+
leading to higher dielectric loss.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 145 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] S.M. El-Sayed, T.M. Meaz, M.A. Amer, H.A. ElShersaby, Physica B, 426 (2013)
137.
[2] R. Patil, S. Kakatkar, A. Sanlepal, S. Sawant, J.Pure Appl. Phys., 2 (1994) 193.
[3] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, I.H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010) 1720.
[4] Obradors, J. Solid State Chem., 56 (1985) 171.
[5] J. Qiu, Q. Zhang, M. Gu, H. Shen, J. Appl. Phys., 98 (2005) 103905.
[6] Y. Liu, M.G.B. Drew, J. Wang, M. Zhang, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010)
366.
[7] V.N. Dhage, M. L. Mane, A.P. Keche, C.T. Birajdar, K.M. Jadhav, Physica B, 406
(2011) 789.
[8] T.T.V. Nga, N.P. Duong, T.D. Hien, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 324 (2012) 1141.
[9] T. Suzuki, K. Kani, K. Warri, S. Kawakami, Y. Torii, J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 11
(1992) 895.
[10] L. Lechevallier, J.M.L. Breton, J.F. Wang, I.R. Harris, J. Magn. Magn. Mater.,
269 (2004) 192.
[11] X. Liu, P. Hernandez-Gomez, K. Huang, Sh. Zhou, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 305
(2006) 524.
[12] H. Luo, B.K. Rai, S.R. Mishra, V.V. Nguyen, J.P. Liu, J. Magn. Magn. Mater.,
324 (2012) 2602.
[13] G. Albanese, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 147 (1995) 421.
[14] D. Mishra, S. Anand, R.K. Panda, R.P. Das, Mater. Lett., 58 (2004) 1147.
[15] P. Gornert, W. Schüppel, E. Sinn, F. Schumacher, K.A. Hempel, G. Turilli, , J.
Magn. Magn. Mater., 114 (1992) 193.
[16] I.T. Rabinkin, Z.I. Novikova, “Ferrites”, Izv Acad. Nauk USSR Minsk 146
(1960).
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 146 - Ph.D. Dissertation
[17] S. Shakoor, M.N. Ashiq, M.A. Malana, A. Mahmood, M.F. Warsi, M. Najam-ul-
Haq, N. Karamat, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 362 (2014) 110.
[18] P. Singh, T.C. Goel, S.L. Srivastava, Indian J. Pure Appl. Phys., 42 (2004) 221.
[19] Z. Haijun, L. Zhichao, M. Chengliang, Y. Xi, Z. Liangying, W. Mingzhong,
Mater. Sci. Eng. B, 96 (2002) 289.
[20] K.M. Nair, “Advances in Electroceramic Materials”, Ceramic Transactions,
John Wiley & Sons,Inc., Publicaiton, 204 (2008).
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 147 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.4 Preparation of hexa-spinel (Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4) ferrite
composites
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 (Y) and CuFe2O4 (S) ferrite powder samples were prepared
separately using Sol-gel auto combustion technique and then physically mixed in
different mass ratios (1:0, 1:1, 1:2, 1:5,1:8 and 0:1 coded as Y,Y:S, Y:2S, Y:5S,Y:8S,
S). Then mixed powders were calcined at 800 oC for 4 hours in a muffle furnace and
then slowly cooled to room temperature. The structural properties on prepared
composite samples were investigated using FTIR and XRD measurements. Scanning
electron micrographs (SEM) were obtained to observe surface morphology of the
samples. Field dependent magnetization behaviour of composite samples was
examined at room temperature using VSM. The dielectric measurements were carried
out at room temperature in a frequency range of 20 Hz to 2 MHz using inductance
capacitance resistance Meter Bridge.
5.4.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.4.1. FTIR spectra of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 ferrite composites
with different mass ratios (1:0,1:1, 1:2, 1:5, 1:8, 0:1)
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 148 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.4.1 shows FTIR spectra of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 composites
samples with different mass ratios (1:0,1:1, 1:2, 1:5, 1:8, 0:1). It is clear from Fig.
5.4.1 that all samples show two absorption bands around 430 and 600 cm-1
, which are
due to metal oxygen stretching vibrations [1, 2]. The intensity of low frequency band
(around 430 cm-1
) is slightly decreased and the high frequency band (600 cm-1
) is
broadening with increasing in spinel ferrite in the composite. These are due to
variation in the number of metal ions in the lattice sites.
Fig. 5.4.2. XRD patterns of CuFe2O4 (S) and Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 (Y) ferrites
Fig. 5.4.2 shows XRD patterns of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 (Y) and CuFe2O4 (S) ferrite
powder samples prepared using Sol-gel technique. The XRD analysis of
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 sample confirms formation of mono phase with high crystallinity. The
lattice parameters and unit cell volume for all the samples were calculated from XRD
and listed in Table 5.4.1 are in close agreement with the standard JCPDS file -
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 149 - Ph.D. Dissertation
PDF#511880 [3]. The XRD analysis of CuFe2O4 has confirmed formation of
tetragonal spinel phase with lattice parameters a = 5.802 Ǻ and c = 8.701 Ǻ match
with the standard JCPDS file – PDF#340425 [4].
Table 5.4.1: Lattice parameters and unit cell volume of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 (Y) and
CuFe2O4 ferrite samples.
Fig. 5.4.3. XRD patterns of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 composite ferrites
Fig. 5.4.3 shows the XRD patterns for the composite samples with different Y-
type hexaferrite - Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 to spinel ferrite - CuFe2O4 mass ratio 1:1, 1:2, 1:5
and 1:8. The figure clearly shows that the characteristic peaks for both the hexagonal
(Y) and spinel (S) ferrite are present in all XRD patterns. As the spinel content
increased in relation to Y phase the reflections at 2θ = 34.5o becomes stronger and the
Samples Lattice constants Unit cell volume
(Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 (Y) 5.839 43.386 1281.012
CuFe2O4 (S) 5.802 8.701 292.911
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 150 - Ph.D. Dissertation
hexaferrite reflections decrease in relative intensities indicating that the composites
contained only two phases spinel and hexaferrite. The absence of any new phase
proved that there was no chemical reaction between spinel and hexagonal ferrites
[5,6].
5.4.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.4.4. SEM micrographs of the Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 composite ferrites
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 151 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.4.4 shows series of SEM micrographs of single and composites of hexa
(Y) and spinel (S) ferrites. Micrograph of pure Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite powder
sample represents hexagonal plate-like grains and micrographs of pure CuFe2O4
ferrite sample shows cluster of grains, they are irregular in shape. But for composites,
non-homogeneity nature was observed. With increasing ratio of spinel phase in the
composite ferrite, the average grain size decreased.
5.4.3 Magnetic properties
0 3000 6000 9000 12000 150000
10
20
30
40
50 Y
Y:S
Y:5S
Y:8S
S
M (
em
u/g
)
H (Oe)
Fig. 5.4.5. Initial magnetization curves of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22, Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 composite and
CuFe2O4 samples
Fig. 5.4.5 and Fig. 5.4.6 show initial magnetization curves and magnetic
hysteresis loops respectively of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22, CuFe2O4 and their composites with
different mass ratio (Y:S, Y:5S and Y:8S). The magnetic parameters are listed in
Table 5.4.2. Crystallographically two phased composites showed a good single-phase
magnetic behaviour suggesting that the magnetic hard and soft phases are exchange
coupled in these composites irrespective of size irregularity and large size ratio of
hard and soft ferrite grains [7]. If it is not exchange coupled, then the magnetization
could have been shown as the superimposition of two loops corresponding to the soft
and the hard ferrites instead of a single one [8].
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 152 - Ph.D. Dissertation
-15000 -10000 -5000 0 5000 10000 15000
-40
-20
0
20
40
M (
em
u/g
)H (Oe)
Y
Y:S
Y:5S
Y:8S
S
Fig. 5.4.6. Hysteresis loops of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22, Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4
composite and CuFe2O4 samples
Table 5.4.2: Estimation of magnetic parameters of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4 composites measured
under maximum applied field of 15 KOe.
Generally, the exchange coupling interaction and dipolar interaction play a
major role for the determination of magnetic properties of the composite materials. As
the composite is a mixture of the hard and soft phases, there are three types of
exchange interactions. The major one is the interaction between soft–hard grains
whereas the other two are the hard–hard and soft-soft [9]. So the relative strength of
the exchange interaction between the soft and hard phases acts as a tuning factor for
Sample Ms (emu/g) Mr (emu/g) Mr / Ms Hc (Oe)
Y 46.84 22.05 0.471 750
Y:S 18.11 6.41 0.354 330
Y:5S 22.39 9.11 0.407 450
Y:8S 41.09 19.16 0.466 500
S 10.08 5.10 0.506 500
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 153 - Ph.D. Dissertation
determining the magnetic property of the composite. But if the dipolar interaction is
also considered, then along with the hard and soft exchange interaction, the competing
dipolar interaction also decides the magnetization in the soft grains [10].
10
20
30
40
50
5
10
15
20
25
300
400
500
600
700
800
Ms
Mass ratios of Ba2Ni
2Fe
12O
22 / CuFe
2O
4 composites
Mr
Hc
SY:8SY:5SY Y:S
Fig. 5.4.7. Variation of Ms, Mr and Hc with increase in Spinel (CuFe2O4) content
From the Table 5.4.2, it is noticed that saturation magnetization (Ms) value of
Y (Ba2Ni2Fe12O22) sample is maximum and S (CuFe2O4) is minimum. The hard
barium ferrite (Ba2Ni2Fe12O22) phase is having large anisotropy; therefore, it is
difficult to achieve magnetization reversal with the lower applied field. So
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite possesses high saturation magnetization compared to CuFe2O4
ferrite. In case of composite, saturation magnetization (Ms) increases with increasing
in soft phase. Coercivity values of composites are less than that of hard phase
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and nearly equal to that of soft phase CuFe2O4.
In low contents of the soft ferrite, the exchange force on the soft magnetic
moments excreted by the hard ferrite is strong, so initially the coercive field will
increase with increase in soft ferrite, but saturation magnetization is decreased due to
low anisotropy of soft phase CuFe2O4. In high contents of the soft ferrite, the
exchange force on the soft grains is enervated and dipolar interaction among soft
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 154 - Ph.D. Dissertation
moments becomes significant [11]. The reverse domains in the soft ferrite with low
nucleation field could be nucleated easily [12]. So there is no significant change in the
coercivity values with further increase in soft ferrite and dipolar interaction among
soft moments leads to a higher value of magnetization.
5.4.4 Dielectric properties
Fig. 5.4.8 shows the variation of dielectric constant (ε') of all the composites
and individual hard and soft ferrite samples with frequency (20 Hz – 2 MHz) at room
temperature. It is seen that dielectric constant decreases with increasing frequency and
then reaches a constant value at higher frequency. Dielectric nature of pure Y-type
hexaferrite (Ba2Ni2Fe12O22) can be explained based on Verwey mechanism [13] and
Heiks model [14]. Two exchange interactions: electron hopping between Fe2+
and
Fe3+
and hole transfer between Ni3+
and Ni2+
in the octahedral sites are responsible for
the dielectric behaviour. The first exchange give rise to the displacement of the local
charges in the direction of the external field leading to the main source of polarization
in the ferrite, while the latter exchange gives rise to displacement of the holes in
opposite direction of the external field leading to the second source of polarization in
the ferrite [15].
10k 100k 1M0
10
20
30
Y
S
YS1
YS2
YS5
YS8
Die
lectr
ic c
on
sta
nt
(re
al)
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 5.4.8. Variation of dielectric constant (ε') with frequency for Y - Ba2Ni2Fe12O22, S - CuFe2O4 and
their composites at room temperature
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 155 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Dielectric constant of spinel ferrite (CuFe2O4) is higher than that of hexaferrite
(Ba2Ni2Fe12O22). The high value of dielectric constant of the spinel ferrite may be due
to the structural changes associated with the copper ferrite. Cu2+
ions occupy
tetrahedral site and Fe3+
ions are equally divided between the tetrahedral (A) and
octahedral (B) sites in spinel lattice. All composite samples have high dielectric
constants than pure Y type hexaferrite; it seems that dielectric constants increase with
spinel ferrite. But some abnormal behavior was also observed in the composite
samples, where one has higher and lower values of dielectric constants compared to
the pure state of spinel ferrite. It is probably associated with the sizes of the grains in
both phases and to the interface between these grains [16].
5
10
15
20
25
30
Die
lec
tric
co
nsta
nt
(rea
l)
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.40
0.45
0.50
0.55
SY:8SY:5SY:2SY:SY
Mass ratio of Y/S composites
tan
Fig. 5.4.9. Variation of dielectric constant and loss factor with mass ratio of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 / CuFe2O4
composites at 3170 Hz.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 156 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.4.10. Variation of loss factor (tan δ) with frequency for Y - Ba2Ni2Fe12O22, S - CuFe2O4 and their
composites at room temperature
Fig. 5.4.10 shows the variation of dielectric loss as a function of frequency at
room temperature. The dielectric loss gives the loss of energy from the applied field
into the sample. At higher frequencies, the losses are found to be low. From Fig. 8, it
is seen that dielectric losses for composites Y:2S, Y:5S, Y:8S and pure S show the
peaking nature and a slight shift in these maxima is also observed. The maxima shift
towards high frequency region with increasing spinel ferrite in hexa ferrite.
The condition for having maxima in the dielectric losses of a dielectric
material is given by the relation [8].
ωτ = 1 (5.4.1)
where ω = 2πfmax and τ is the relaxation time.
A relation relates the relaxation time to the jumping probability per unit time is as
follow as
τ =1/2p (5.4.2)
fmax α p (5.4.3)
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 157 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Therefore, from the above relation it is clear that, maxima can be observed
when the jumping or hoping frequency of electrons between Fe2+
and Fe3+
becomes
approximately equal to the frequency of the applied field [17].
5.4.5 Conclusions
The composites with different ratios of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and CuFe2O4 (1:0, 1:1,
1:2, 1:5, 1:8 and 0:1) have been successfully synthesized via Sol-gel auto-combustion
technique. The results from FTIR, XRD, SEM, VSM and dielectric measurement
studies can be summarized as follows:
Two absorption bands observed in FTIR spectra due to metal oxygen
stretching vibrations.
XRD patterns of composites exhibited the characteristic peaks of both hard
ferrite and soft ferrite showing the coexistence of both the phases in composite
material.
SEM images of composites consist of both larger and smaller grains which
also confirm the coexistence of both the phases.
Magnetic measurements suggest that the competition between exchange and
dipolar interactions of soft and hard ferrite grains determines the magnetic
properties of magnetic composites.
All the samples show the frequency dependent phenomena, i.e. the dielectric
constant decreases with increasing frequency and then reaches a constant
value. All composite samples have high dielectric constants than pure
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite, the dielectric constants increase with spinel ferrite.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 158 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] R. Patil, S. Kakatkar, A. Sanlepal, S. Sawant, J. Pure Appl. Phys., 2 (1994) 193.
[2] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, I.H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010) 1720.
[3] L. Fang, R. Yuan, H. Zhang, State Key Lab. of Advanced Technology for
Materials Synthesis & Processing, Wuhan Univ. of, ICDD Grant-in-Aid (2000).
[4] Natl. Bur. Stand. (U.S.) Monogr. 25 (1983).
[5] W. Qu, X. H. Wang, L. Li, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 257 (2003) 284.
[6] C. Sudakar, G.N. Subbanna, T.R.N. Kutty, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 268 (2004) 75.
[7] J. Xiang, X. Zhang, J. Li, Y. Chu, X. Shen, Chem. Phys. Lett., 576 (2013) 39.
[8] R.K. Kotnala, S. Ahmad, A.S. Ahmed, J. Shah, A. Azam, J. Appl. Phys., 112
(2012) 054323.
[9] F. Song, X. Shen, M. Liu, J. Xiang, J. Solid State Chem., 185 (2012) 31.
[10] D. Roy, P. S. Anil Kumar, J. Appl. Phys., 106 (2009) 073902.
[11] D. Roy, C. Shivakumara, P.S.A. Kumar, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 321 (2009)
L11.
[12] M.A. Radmanesh, S.A. SeyyedEbrahimi, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 324 (2012)
3094.
[13] E. J.W. Verwey, J. H. de Boer, J. Less Common Met., 106 (1985) 257.
[14] R.R. Heikes, W.D. Johnston, J. Chem. Phys., 26 (1957) 582.
[15] A.M. Abo El Ata, S.M. Attia, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 257 (2003) 165.
[16] F.M.M. Pereira, C.A.R. Junior, M.R.P. Santos, J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Electron.,
19 (2008) 627.
[17] M.A. Dar, K.M. Batoo, V. Verma, W.A. Siddiqui, and R. K. Kotnala, J. Alloys
Compd., 493 (2010) 553.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 159 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.5 Preparation of magnetoelectric (BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3) composites
In present study, composites BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 with different mass
percentage of BiFeO3 ( 0 to 100 %) were prepared. BaFe12O19 (BHF) and BiFeO3
(BiF) ferrites were prepared separately using Sol-gel auto combustion technique and
then physically mixed. The mixed samples were again calcined 500°C for 4 hours and
slowly cooled to room temperature. Prepared composite samples were characterized
using FTIR, XRD, SEM, VSM, dielectric measurements and PE loop tracer. The
composite samples with the mass percentage mentioned above were coded as 100%
BHF, 25% BiF, 50% BiF, 75% BiF and 100% BiF.
5.5.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.5.1. FTIR spectra of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 ferrite composites
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 160 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.5.1 shows FTIR spectra of indivitual BaFe12O19 and BiFeO3 ferrites
and the composites with different mass percentage (25%, 50% and 75%) of BiFeO3.
FTIR spectra of pure and composite samples show two strong absorption bands
around 580 and 440 cm-1
, which are due to metal oxygen stretching vibrations [1].
The intensity and sharpness of these peaks decreased with increase in BiFeO3 amount.
In case of BiFeO3 ferrite, the FTIR peaks at 410, 547, 649 and 750 cm-1
are
corresponding to the vibrations bonds of Bi – O or Fe – O [2].
Fig. 5.5.2. XRD patterns of BaFe12O19 (BHF) and BiFeO3 (BiF) ferrites
Table 5.5.1. Lattice parameters and unit cell volume of BaFe12O19
and BiFeO3 ferrites
Sample Lattice constants Unit cell
volume (Å3) a (Å) c (Å)
BaFe12O19 (BHF) 5.892 23.183 696.99
BiFeO3 (BiF) 5.577 13.861 431.12
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 161 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.5.2 shows XRD patterns of BaFe12O19 and BiFeO3 ferrites prepared
using Sol-gel auto cumbustion technique.Tthe XRD pattern of BaFe12O19 (BHF)
sample heated at 500 oC followed by 950
oC shows pure single phase M-type barium
hexaferrite. In case of BiFeO3 (BiF) heated at 500 oC, the prominent peaks in XRD
plot are indexed to the pure rhombohedral structure of BiFeO3 of space group R3c
with lattice parameters of a = b = 5.577 Ǻ and c = 13.861 Ǻ , which are in good
agreement with the standard JCPDS file- PDF# 861518 [3]. Besides these prominent
peaks, some other peaks are also observed, which assined to Bi2O3. The high
temperature synthesis of BiFeO3 usually results in the evaporation loss of bismuth as
well as the formation of impurity phase like Bi2O3 [4]. Hence the calcination
temperature was restricted to 500 oC for this sample.
Fig. 5.5.3. XRD spectra of composites BaFe12O19/ BiFeO3 with different mass percentage of BiFeO3
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 162 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.5.3 shows the XRD spectra of composites BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 with
different mass percentage (25%, 50% and 75%) of BiFeO3. The XRD patterns of
these three compositions reveal that mixed hexaferrite and bismuth ferrite phases have
been formed in each case without any detectable strong third phase. This indicates
that no significant chemical interaction has occurred between the two phases and
provides a wide range of composition to study their properties. In the sample with
50% of BiF, the intensity of XRD peaks of both hexaferrite and bismuth ferrite is high
compared to other two compositions. The intensity of BHF peaks from the planes
such as (1 1 4), (2 0 1), (2 0 5), (2 0 6), (2 2 0), (2 3 8) and (3 1 7) has been decreased
with the increase of BiF content in the composition.
5.5.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.5.4. SEM micrographs of BiFeO3 ferrites and the composite with 50% of BiFeO3
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 163 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig.5.5.4 shows the morphology of BaFe12O19, BiFeO3 and the composite with
50% of BiFeO3 powder calcined at 500 °C for 4 hours. The surface morphology of
calcined BaFe12O19 powder sample revealed formation of dense grains. SEM
micrograph of calcined BiFeO3 ferrite shows the formation of porous clusters of non
uniform grains. The SEM image of composite sample (50% of BiFeO3 powder
calcined at 500 °C for 4 hours) shows irregular, porous grains, which are randomly
distributed.
5.5.3 Magnetic properties
-12000 -9000 -6000 -3000 0 3000 6000 9000 12000
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60M
(em
u/g
)
H (Oe)
100% BHF
25% BiF
50% BiF
75% BiF
Fig. 5.5.5. Hysteresis loops of BaFe12O19 and composites BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3
with different mass percentage
The variation of magnetization M (emu/g) versus the applied magnetic field H
(Oe), for BaFe12O19 and composites BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 at room temperature, is given
in Fig. 5.5.5 and the magnetic parameters are listed in Table 5.5.2. It is noticed that
saturation magnetization (Ms) decreases gradually with increasing in BiFeO3 content.
Similar results were also reported for CrFe2O4 - BiFeO3 and MnFe2O4 - BiFeO3
nanocomposites [5,6]. This may be due to the ferroelectric material incorporated into
the ferrite phase which acts as pores in the presence of applied magnetic field and
break the magnetic circuit, resulting in the decrease of magnetic behavior with
increasing ferroelectric content [7]. And also the individual ferrite grains act as
centres of magnetic moment and the Ms of the composites is the vector sum of all
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 164 - Ph.D. Dissertation
these individual contributions [8]. Thus the net magnetic moment of the BaFe12O19/
BiFeO3 composites decreases with increase of BiFeO3 content and result in decrease
of the net magnetization. However, there were no drastic changes in coercivity values
for composite samples with increase in BiFeO3 content. Coercivity slightly increased
for the 25% and 50% BiF composites and then decreased for 75% BiF composition
compared to BaFe12O19 ferrite.
Table 5.5.2 Estimation of magnetic parameters of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites
Sample
Ms
(emu/g)
Mr
(emu/g) Mr / Ms
Hc
(Oe)
100% BHF 56.24 30.00 0.533 4625
25% BiF 34.90 20.20 0.579 4860
50% BiF 27.30 15.60 0.571 4860
75% BiF 15.40 8.20 0.532 4540
10
20
30
40
50
60
75 %
BiF
50 %
BiF
25 %
BiF
100
% B
HF
Ms
5
10
15
20
25
30
Mr
4500
4600
4700
4800
4900
Hc
Fig. 5.5.6. Variation of Ms, Mr and Hc with increase in BiFeO3 content
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 165 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.5.4 Dielectric properties
Fig. 5.5.7. Variation of (a) dielectric constant and (b) dielectric loss versus frequency for BaFe12O19
(BHF) and BiFeO3 (BiF) and their composites at room temperature
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 166 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig.5.5.7 shows the frequency dependence of dielectric constant (ε') and
dielectric loss (tan δ) of the composites at room temperature. Both dielectric constant
(ε') as well as dielectric loss (tan δ) decrease at lower frequencies and they remain
constant at higher frequencies. It is due to the different polarization mechanisms at
different frequencies. At low frequency, electron displacement polarization, ion
displacement polarization, turning direction polarization and space charge
polarization contribute to dielectric constant. At high frequency, dielectric constant
just results from the electron displacement polarization [9]. In additional, the high
value of dielectric constant at lower frequency is due to the predominance of species
like Fe2+
ions, interfacial dislocation pile-ups, oxygen vacancies and grain boundary
defect [10]. Dielectric constant of bismuth ferrite (BiF) is higher than that of
hexaferrite (BHF). Because of oxygen vacancy in bismuth ferrite materials, which is
mostly generated during the heat treatment, is the major origin of the deterioration of
insulation and the formation of Fe2+
[11]. Hence space charge polarization is always
present.
10
15
20
25
30
35
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.40
100
% B
iF
75 %
BiF
50 %
BiF
25 %
BiF
100
% B
HF
tan
D
iele
ctr
ic c
on
sta
nt
(re
al)
Fig. 5.5.8. Variation of dielectric constant and loss factor with mass percentage of BiFeO3 at 1002 Hz
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 167 - Ph.D. Dissertation
In case of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composite samples, the dielectric constant
increases with BiFeO3 content. The high values of dielectric constant at lower
frequencies may be explained on the basis of space charge polarization due to
inhomogeneous dielectric structure in the ferromagnetic and ferroelectric system [12].
When the composites of two phases BaFe12O19 and BiFeO3 with different
conductivity and permittivity are subjected to an electric field, the space charge
carriers provided by BiFeO3 accumulate in the interface of two phases, thereby
intensifying the interfacial polarization that contributes to a higher value of dielectric
constant permittivity [7]. Dielectric loss factor is represented as the energy dissipation
in the dielectric system. Dielectric loss decreases with increase in BiFeO3, which is
right opposite that of dielectric constant; similar result was reported for multiferroic
composites [7]. It may be due to density, oxygen vacancy concentration and
secondary phase of Bismuth ferrite.
5.5.5 Ferroelectric properties
-20 -10 0 10 20 30
-1
0
1
2
Po
lari
za
tio
n (C
/cm
2)
Electric field (kV/cm)
100 % BHF
25 % BiF
50 % BiF
75 % BiF
100 % BiF
Fig. 5.5.9. Polarization-electric field (P-E) loop for BaFe12O19 (BHF) and BiFeO3 (BiF)
and their composites at room temperature
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 168 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Table 5.5.3 Estimation of ferro-electric parameters of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites
Sample Emax
(kV/cm)
Pmax
(µC/cm2)
Ec (kV/cm) Pr (µC/cm2)
100% BHF 17.646 1.188 16.834 1.134
25%BiF 23.148 0.999 22.034 0.969
50%BiF 17.912 0.784 17.113 0.747
75%BiF 14.092 0.411 12.633 0.353
100%BiF 19.621 0.270 13.467 1.134
Fig.5.5.9 shows the polarization-electric field (P-E) hysteresis loop measured
at room temperature for the BaFe12O19/ BiFeO3 composites. Due to conductivity of
the samples at high electric filed, measurement of the polarization data beyond 25
kV/cm has been restricted. The P-E loop of BaFe12O19 displays elliptical shape, which
means the sample has serious electrical leakage [13-15]. The loop is not fully
saturated because of the low applied electric field. High leakage current indicates the
highly conductive nature of BaFe12O19 ferrite at high electric field. The P-E loop for
pure BiFeO3 displays well-saturated rectangular shape-like loop revealing the good
ferroelectric properties. Since the particle size of BiFeO3 seems to be small, which
results in lower space charge density, smaller leakage current density and this
increases spontaneous polarization [16]. Normally a single crystal or a specimen with
100% c-oriented grains exhibits nearly a square loop with high remanent polarization
close to the spontaneous polarization value [17].
The P-E loop of the BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites is elliptical in shape, but
much improved in comparison with that of BaFe12O19 ferrite. With increasing BiFeO3
content in the composite, the P-E loops became more and more typical, which means
the electric leakage is greatly reduced in the presence of BiFeO3. However, the
ferroelectric parameters such as remanent polarization, maximum polarization and the
coercive electric field decreased with BiFeO3 amount. This may be due to the
randomly oriented BiFeO3 grains in the composite system which affects the domain
reversal, as a result remanent polarization value decreases [17]. Low coercivity values
indicate that there was no sufficient growth of ferroelectric domains due to the
random orientation of grains and further due to the masking effect of BaFe12O19
grains in the microstructure.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 169 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.5.6 Conclusions
The composites BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 with different mass percentage of BiFeO3
(100% BHF, 25% BiF, 50% BiF, 75% BiF and 100% BiF) have been successfully
synthesized via a Sol-gel auto-combustion technique. The results from FTIR, XRD,
SEM, VSM, dielectric measurement and PE loop studies can be summarized as
follows:
FTIR specta of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites reveal the strong two
absorption bands corresponding the metal – oxygen vibrations.
XRD spectra of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites reveal that mixed hexaferrite
and bismuth ferrite phases have been formed.
Micrographs of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites show that irregular, porous
and randomly distributed grains.
Saturation magnetization (Ms) of BaFe12O19/ BiFeO3 composites decreased
gradually with increasing in BiFeO3 content. There were no drastic changes in
coercivity values for composite samples with increase in BiFeO3 content.
Dielectric constant of bismuth ferrite is higher than that of Barium hexaferrite.
In case of BaFe12O19 / BiFeO3 composites, the dielectric constant increases
with BiFeO3 content.
The P-E loop of BaFe12O19 displays elliptical shape, which means the sample
has serious electrical leakage. The P-E loop for pure BiFeO3 displays well-
saturated rectangular shape-like loop revealing the good ferroelectric
properties. With increasing BiFeO3 content in the composite, the P-E loops
became more and more typical, which means confirms the electric leakage is
greatly reduced in the presence of BiFeO3.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 170 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, I.H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010) 1720.
[2] Y. Hu, L. Fei, Y. Zhang, J. Yuan, Y. Wang, H. Gu, Journal of Nanomaterials ,
Hindawi Publishing Corporation, 2011.
[3] Sosnowska, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 160 (1996) 384.
[4] H. Yang, T. Xian, Z.Q. Wei, J.F. Dai, J Sol-Gel Sci Technol, 58 (2011) 238.
[5] A. Kumar, K.L. Yadav, H. Singh, R. Pandu, P.R. Reddy, Physica B, 405 (2010)
2362.
[6] A. Kumar, K.L. Yadav, Physica B, 406 (2011) 1763.
[7] Y. Liu, Y. Wu, D. Li, Y. Zhang, J. Zhang, J. Yang, J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Electron.
24 (2013) 1900.
[8] R.C. Kambale, K.M. Song, N. Hur, Current Applied Physics, 13 (2013) 562.
[9] W. Cai, C. Fu, W. Hu, G. Chen, X. Deng, J. Alloys Compd., 554 (2013) 64.
[10] M.N. Ashiq, M.J. Iqbal, M. Najam-ul-Haq, P.H. Gomez, A.M. Qureshi, J. Magn.
Magn. Mater., 324 (2012) 15.
[11] A. Kumar, K.L. Yadav, Mater. Sci. Eng. B, 176 (2011) 227.
[12] M. Kumar, K.L. Yadav, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 68 (2007) 1791.
[13] G.S. Lotey, N.K. Verma, J. Nanopart. Res., 14 (2012) 742.
[14] Z.X. Cheng, A.H. Li, X.L. Wang, S.X. Dou, K. Ozawa, H. Kimura, S.J. Zhang,
T.R. Shrout, J. Appl. Phys., 103 (2008) 07E507.
[15] A. Srinivas, R. Gopalan, V. Chandrasekharan, Solid State Commun., 149 (2009)
367.
[16] G.S. Lotey, N.K. Verma, J. Nanopart. Res., 15 (2013) 1553.
[17] A. Srinivas, T. Karthik, R. Gopalan, V. Chandrasekaran, Mater. Sci. Eng. B, 172
(2010) 289.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 171 - Ph.D. Dissertation
5.6 Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites prepared by in situ
polymerization method
Polyaniline (PANI) / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites with different aniline /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite weight ratios (1:1, 1:2 and 2:1) have been prepared by in
situ polymerization method. In order to study the effect of surfactants on the particle
size, microstructure and dielectric properties, Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites
were prepared in the presence of different surfactants using in situ polymerization
method. Three different surfactants; cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB),
Sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and Polyethylene glycol sorbitan monooleate (Tween-
80) (cationic, anionic and non-ionic, respectively) were used for preparing three
Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites in which the aniline:Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ratio was
1:1. The obtained composites were characterized by Fourier transform infrared
spectra (FT-IR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) and
dielectric measurements were carried out at room temperature in a frequency range of
20 Hz to 2 MHz using inductance capacitance resistance Meter Bridge.
5.6.1 Structural properties
Fig. 5.6.1. FTIR spectra of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and Polyaniline/ Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites with
different aniline/ Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite weight ratios (1:1, 1:2 and 2:1).
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 172 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig.5.6.1 shows the FTIR spectra of Y-type Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite and
polyaniline/Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites powder with different aniline /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite weight ratios (1:1, 1:2 and 2:1). Two strong and sharp
absorption bands at 580 and 440 cm-1
are found in Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 sample which are
characteristic infrared absorption bands for the metal oxygen stretching vibrations
[1,2]. The characteristic peaks of polyaniline appear at 1587, 1496, 1303, 1130 and
802 cm-1
. The peaks at 1587 and 1496 cm-1
are attributed to the characteristic C = C
stretching of the quinoid and benzenoid rings [3,4], the peak at 1303 cm-1
is assigned
to C – N stretching of the benzenoid ring [5], the broad and strong peak around 1130
cm-1
is associated with vibrational modes of N = Q = N (Q refers to the quinonic-
type rings) [6,7]. The peak at 802 cm-1
is attributed to the out-of-plane deformation
vibration of the p-disubstituted benzene ring [8,9]. With an increase in the polyaniline
content, the intensity of the bands corresponding to polyaniline characteristics
increases distinctively.
Fig. 5.6.2. FTIR spectra of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites in the presence of surfactant
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 173 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.2 shows FTIR spectra of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composite
samples prepared in the presence of surfactant. The spectra show the characteristics
peaks of Polyaniline (1587, 1510, 1311 and 800 cm-1
) but some notable changes in
positions of peaks are observed in the presence of surfactants. Characteristics peaks of
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite (metal-oxygen vibrations) have also been observed at 580
and 440 cm-1
in the spectrum but these peaks disappear in presence of SDS surfactant
and there is no significant change in the presence of other two CTAB and Tween-80
surfactants.
Fig. 5.6.3. XRD patterns of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites samples
with different aniline/ Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 weight ratios (1:2, 1:1, 2:1)
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 174 - Ph.D. Dissertation
XRD patterns of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composite samples exhibit both
the characteristic peaks of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and polyaniline (Fig. 5.6.3). Polyaniline is
an amorphous nature, and has a certain degree of crystallinity. Due to presence of
Y-type Ba2Ni2Fe12O2 ferrite, XRD patterns of composites show high degree of
crystalline order. For polyaniline phase, the crystalline peaks appeared at 2θ: 22.7,
23.6, 29.0, 34.1, 37.9, 40.2, 46.4, 52.5 and 57.6o corresponding to (021), (112), (211),
(221), (132), (310), (115), (006) and (421) reflections, respectively [10]. The relative
intensity of these peaks might differ, depending on the amount of aniline /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite compositions. The same phase of the metal oxides are found in
their respective composites with polyaniline [11,12].
Fig. 5.6.4. XRD patterns of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composite
prepared in the presence of surfactant.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 175 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.4 shows XRD patterns of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composite
prepared in the presence of surfactant. The characteristic peaks of both Ba2Ni2Fe12O22
and polyaniline are observed for cationic and non-ionic surfactants CTAB and
Tween-80 added the polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite composites. It was similar to
the polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite composite in the absence of surfactant. In case
of anionic surfactant SDS added composite, Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 appears as a major phase.
5.6.2 Morphology
Fig. 5.6.5. SEM images of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites with and without surfactants.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 176 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.5 shows series of SEM micrographs of pure Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite
and Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites with and without surfactants.
Micrograph of pure Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite represents hexagonal plate-like
structure. Different morphologies were observed when hexaferrite is dispersed in
polyaniline. The SEM images of the composites with aninline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 ferrite
weight ratios 1:1 and 2:1 reveal that polyaniline is deposited on the surface of ferrite
particles which possesses coral like structure [5]. It is observed from the pictures that,
compared to the composite samples (1:1, 2:1) and the composite sample prepared in
presence of CTAB; SDS and Tween-80 composite samples have smaller grain size
and less agglomeration. It seems that in the surfactants (SDS, Tween-80) control the
microstructure of the formed composites.
5.6.3 Dielectric properties
Fig. 5.6.6 shows variation of dielectric constant (ε') as a function of frequency
of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites with and
without surfactants. It can be observed that dielectric constant of all the samples
decreases with increase in frequency. Dielectric nature of pure Y-type hexaferrite
(Ba2Ni2Fe12O22) can be explained based on Verwey mechanism [13,14] and Heiks
model [15]. In case of polyaniline, there are two types of charged species, one
polaron/bipolaron system which is mobile and free to move along the chain, the others
are bound charges (dipoles) which have only restricted mobility and account for
strong polarization in the system. When the frequency of the applied field is
increased, the dipoles present in the system cannot reorient themselves fast enough to
respond to applied electric field and as a result, dielectric constant decreases [16,17].
Polyaniline/Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrites are having high values of dielectric
constants compared to the pure ferrite. Initially dielectric constant reaches highest
value with little amount of polyaniline and then decreases with increase in polyaniline
amount in the composite. With more amount of polyaniline the dielectric behaviour is
similar to the pure Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite. Surfactant added polyaniline /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites also have similar nature like pure ferrite due to
large amount of polyaniline.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 177 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.6. Variation of dielectric constant (ε') as a function of frequency for polyaniline /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite composites (a) without and (b) with surfactants.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 178 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.7. Variation of dielectric loss tangent (tan δ) as a function of frequency for Polyaniline/
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites (a) without and (b) with surfactants.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 179 - Ph.D. Dissertation
Fig. 5.6.8. Dielectric parameters Vs (a) aniline:ferrite ratio and
(b) different surfactant in the composites
Fig. 5.6.7 shows the variation of dielectric loss as a function of frequency at
room temperature. The dielectric loss tangent is found to decrease with increase of
frequency as a similar trend to that of dielectric constant for all the composition at low
frequency. This is usually associated with ion drift, dipole polarisation or interfacial
polarisation [18]. It can be observed that for the composites with aninilie /
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 hexaferrite ratio 1:2 and 1:1, the loss tangent increases with frequency
followed by appearance of the broad dielectric relaxation peak at 89.3 kHz and 28.2
kHz respectively. Surfactant CTAB added polyaniline composite shows highest value
of loss factor at low frequency among other surfactant added composites.
5.6.4 Conclusions
Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites with different aniline/Ba ferrite
weight ratios (1:1, 1:2 and 2:1) showing remarkable magnetic and dielectric properties
have been obtained by in situ polymerization of aniline in the presence of
Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 particles. Effect of aniline/ferrite ratios and role of different
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 180 - Ph.D. Dissertation
surfactants; cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB), Sodium dodecyl sulfate
(SDS) and Polyethylene glycol sorbitan monooleate (Tween-80) in the preparation of
Polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites can be summarized as follows:
FTIR spectra of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites show absorption
bands correspond to both metal-oxygen stretching vibrations and stretching of
the quinoid and benzenoid rings.
XRD patterns of polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 composites exhibit both the
characteristic peaks of Ba2Ni2Fe12O22 and polyaniline.
The SEM images of the composites reveal that polyaniline is deposited on the
surface of ferrite particles which possesses core shell structure.
Polyaniline embedded ferrites are having high values of dielectric constants
compared to the pure ferrite. Surfactant added polyaniline / Ba2Ni2Fe12O22
ferrite composites also have similar nature like pure ferrite due to large
amount of polyaniline.
Results and discussion Chapter - 5
- 181 - Ph.D. Dissertation
References
[1] R. Patil, S. Kakatkar, A. Sanlepal, S. Sawant, J.Pure Appl. Phys., 2 (1994) 193.
[2] M. N. Ashiq, M. J. Iqbal, I. H. Gul, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 322 (2010) 1720.
[3] L. Li, J. Jiang, Feng Xu, Eur. Polym. J., 42 (2006) 2221.
[4] C.L. Yuan, Y.S. Hong, C.H. Lin, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 323 (2011) 1851.
[5] L. Li, H. Liu, Y. Wang, J. Jiang, F. Xu, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 321 (2008) 265.
[6] J. Jiang, L. Li, M. Zhu, React. Funct. Polym., 68 (2008) 57.
[7] J.C. Aphesteguy, P.G. Bercoff, S.E. Jacobo, Physica B, 398 (2007) 200.
[8] Y. Li, H. Zhang, Y. Liu, Q. Wen, J. Li, “Nanotechnology”, IOP Publishing Ltd.,
UK. 19 (2008) 105605.
[9] C.L. Yuan, Y.S. Hong, J. Mater. Sci., 45 (2010) 3470.
[10] A. Mani, J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 14 (1995) 1594 (PDF # 531891).
[11] X. Tang, Y. Yang, Appl. Surf. Sci., 255 (2009) 9381.
[12] Y. Wang, Y. Huang, Q. Wang, Q. He, L. Chen, Appl. Surf. Sci., 259 (2012) 486.
[13] A. M. Abo El Ata, S. M. Attia, J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 257 (2003) 165.
[14] E. J. W. Verwey, J. H. de Boer, J. Less Common Met., 106 (1985) 257.
[15] R. R. Heikes, W. D. Johnston, J. Chem. Phys., 26 (1957) 582.
[16] A. Ohlan, K. Singh, A. Chandra, S. K. Dhawan, Appl. Phys. Lett., 93 (2008)
053114.
[17] S. Bhadra, N. K. Singha, D. Khastgir, Current Applied Physics, 9 (2009) 396.
[18] S. Saravanan, M. R. Anantharaman, S. Venkatachalam, Mater. Sci. Eng. B, 135
(2006) 113.