chapter 17 pp. 542-569 from prentice-hall world history (2007) the enlightenment

44
CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Upload: alison-jacobs

Post on 26-Dec-2015

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

C H A P T E R 1 7 P P. 5 4 2 - 5 6 9 F R O M P R E N T I C E - H A L L W O R L D H I S T O R Y ( 2 0 0 7 )

THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Page 2: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Background to the Revolution Medieval scientists, known as “natural

philosophers,” did not make observations of the world and nature so much as rely on ancient authorities, especially Aristotle, for their scientific knowledge.

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Changes in the 1400s and 1500s caused European scientists to adopt new views and methods.

(pages 511–512)

(pages 511–512)

Page 3: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Background to the Revolution (cont.) Renaissance humanists studied the newly

discovered works of Ptolemy, Archimedes, Plato, and other ancient thinkers.

They learned that some ancient thinkers had disagreed with Aristotle and other accepted authorities.

(pages 511–512)

(pages 511–512)

Page 4: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Technical problems, like calculating how much weight a ship could hold, spurred a movement towards observation and measurement.

New instruments like the telescope and microscope made fresh observations and discoveries possible.

Printing spread ideas more quickly than ever before.

Background to the Revolution (cont.)

(pages 511–512)

(pages 511–512)

Page 5: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

The study of mathematics in the Renaissance contributed to the scientific achievements of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.

The great scientists of the day believed that the secrets of nature were written in the language of mathematics.

These intellectuals–Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, Newton, and others–developed new theories that became the foundation of the Scientific Revolution.

Background to the Revolution (cont.)

(pages 511–512)

(pages 511–512)

Page 6: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Born in the second-century A.D., Ptolemy was antiquity’s greatest astronomer.

Medieval philosophers constructed a geocentric (Earth is at the center) model of the universe called the Ptolemaic system.

It is a series of concentric spheres with a motionless Earth in the middle.

Page 7: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) According to Ptolemy, the planets are in

different, crystal-like spheres.

They rotate, which accounts for the movements of the heavenly bodies.

The tenth sphere is the “prime mover,” which moves itself and gives motion to the other spheres.

Beyond this is Heaven, where God and all the saved souls reside.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 8: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) Nicholas Copernicus of Poland published

his famous work, On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres, in 1543.

He believed his heliocentric (with the Sun in the center) system was more accurate than the Ptolemaic system.

Copernicus argued that all the planets revolved around the sun, the Moon revolved around Earth, and Earth rotated on its axis.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 9: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) The German mathematician Johannes

Kepler also helped destroy the Ptolemaic system.

His observations confirmed that the Sun was at the center of the universe, and he tracked the elliptical orbits of the planets.

Ptolemy had insisted that the orbits were circular.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 10: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) The Italian scientist and mathematician

Galileo Galilei answered one of the two remaining questions for the new astronomy: What are the planets made of?

He was the first European to make regular observations with a telescope.

He saw mountains on the Moon and the four moons orbiting Jupiter.

Ptolemy had said the heavenly bodies were pure orbs of light, but now it appeared they were material.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 11: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) Galileo’s work began to make Europeans

aware of the new view of the universe.

He got into trouble with the Catholic Church, which ordered him to abandon the new system because the Copernican conception contradicted that of the Church and the Bible.

In the Copernican system, the heavens were not spiritual but material, and God was no longer in a specific place.

Most astronomers believed the new conception, however.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 12: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) The Englishman Isaac Newton responded to

the second question for the new conception of the universe: What explains motion in the universe?

He was a mathematics professor at Cambridge University.

Newton published his views in Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, also known as the Principia.

He defined the three laws of motion in the universe.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 13: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

A Revolution in Astronomy (cont.) Crucial to his view was the universal law of

gravitation: every object in the universe is attracted to every other object by a force called gravity.

This explained why planetary bodies did not go off in a straight line, but traveled in elliptical orbits.

Newton gave the world a picture of the universe as a huge, regulated, uniform machine.

This picture dominated the modern worldview until Einstein’s theory of relativity.

(pages 512–515)

(pages 512–515)

Page 14: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Breakthroughs in Medicine and Chemistry

(page 515)(page 515)

In the Late Middle Ages, medicine was still dominated by the teaching of the Greek physician Galen (second century A.D.).

His views about anatomy were often wrong because he used animals, not people, for dissection.

Page 15: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Breakthroughs in Medicine and Chemistry (cont.) The new anatomy of the sixteenth century

was based on the work of Andreas Vesalius, published in his On the Fabric of the Human Body (1543).

He reported his results from dissecting human bodies as a professor of surgery at the University of Padua, presenting an accurate view of the individual organs and general structure of the human body.

He erroneously believed that the body had two kinds of blood.

(page 515)(page 515)

Page 16: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

William Harvey’s On the Motion of the Heart and Blood (1628) showed that the heart, not the liver as Galen had thought, was the beginning point of the blood’s circulation.

He also showed that the same blood runs through veins and arteries and that the blood makes a complete circuit through the body.

Harvey’s work was based on close observation and experiment.

Breakthroughs in Medicine and Chemistry (cont.)

(page 515)(page 515)

Page 17: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

The work of Robert Boyle in chemistry was also based on close observation and experiment.

He formulated Boyle’s Law about gases–the volume of a gas varies with the pressure exerted on it.

In the eighteenth century, Antoine Lavoisier, the founder of modern chemistry, invented a system of naming the chemical elements.

Breakthroughs in Medicine and Chemistry (cont.)

(page 515)(page 515)

Page 18: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Women and the Origins of Modern Science

(pages 515–516)

(pages 515–516)

One of the most prominent female scientists of the seventeenth century was Margaret Cavendish.

In works such as her Observations Upon Experimental Philosophy, she criticized the belief that humans, through science, were the masters of nature.

Page 19: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Women and the Origins of Modern Science (cont.) In Germany, many women scientists were

astronomers.

They often received training in family observatories from their fathers or husbands.

Maria Winkelmann was the most famous; she assisted her husband, the famous Prussian astronomer Gottfried Kirch, and discovered a comet.

(pages 515–516)

(pages 515–516)

Page 20: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Winkelmann was denied a post as assistant astronomer at the Berlin Academy because of her gender.

In the view of most people of the seventeenth century, science and scholarship conflicted with the domestic roles women were expected to fulfill.

Women and the Origins of Modern Science (cont.)

(pages 515–516)

(pages 515–516)

Page 21: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Descartes and Reason

(pages 516–517)

(pages 516–517)

The work of the French philosopher René Descartes strongly reflects the Western view of humankind that came from the Scientific Revolution.

In his Discourse on Method (1637), he asserts that he can rationally be sure of only one thing–his own existence.

He asserted he would accept only those things his reason said were true.

Page 22: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Descartes and Reason (cont.) Descartes asserted that while he could not

doubt the existence of his mind–“I think, therefore I am”–he could doubt the existence of the material world.

He concluded that the material world and the mental world were two different realms. He separated mind and matter.

This made matter something inert and independent of the observer that could be investigated by a detached rationality.

(pages 516–517)

(pages 516–517)

Page 23: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

Descartes has been called the father of modern rationalism.

This system of thought is based on the idea that reason is the chief source of knowledge.

Descartes and Reason (cont.)

(pages 516–517)

(pages 516–517)

Page 24: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

The Scientific Method

(page 517)(page 517)

During the Scientific Revolution, people were concerned about how they could best understand the physical universe.

They created the scientific method. The philosopher Francis Bacon was most

responsible for this method.

Page 25: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

Click the mouse button or press theSpace Bar to display the information.Click the mouse button or press the

Space Bar to display the information.

The Scientific Method (cont.) Bacon emphasized arriving at conclusions

about nature using inductive reasoning, or making generalizations from particular observations and experiments organized to test hypotheses.

He believed science was to give humankind new discoveries and the power to serve human purposes by conquering “nature in action.”

The control and domination of nature became an important concern of science and its accompanying technology.

(page 517)(page 517)

Page 26: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

PHILOSOPHY IN THE AGE OF REASON

• Enlightenment sparked by scientific revolution of 1500s and 1600s• Scientific discoveries of 1500s and 1600s changed the

way people looked at the world• Natural law- rules that can be discovered through reason• People started to believe that reason could solve social

problems as well as scientific problems= The Enlightenment

Left: Rene Descartes, French scientist of the late Renaissance, stressed human reasoning in understanding the world

Right: Immanuel Kant, German philosopher of late Renaissance/early Enlightenment era, first to speak of an “enlightenment”

Page 27: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

OPPOSING VIEWS OF SOCIETY

• Thomas Hobbes and John Locke: conflicting views• Hobbes: supported strong government (absolute monarchy),

thinks people are basically terrible, developed idea of a social contract

• Locke: people basically good, had natural rights (life, liberty, property), supported limited government

John Locke, whose ideas inspired revolution around the world!

Of Hobbes and Locke,which do you think hadmore of an impact on the American Revolution?

Page 28: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

THE PHILOSOPHES

• Montesquieu and the Separation of Powers• Freedom of Thought: Voltaire• Denis Diderot’s works: First Encyclopedia • The Social Contract: Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Left: Voltaire, French author of Candide

Right: Rousseau, author of The Social Contract

Page 29: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

NEW ECONOMIC THINKING

• Mercantilism- government regulates prices and tariffs to gain favorable balance of trade

• Laissez-faire economics= government should stay out of the economy, free trade

• Adam Smith- argued for free market, said economy runs on a system of supply and demand

• Smith also believed government should stay out of economy, but did have a responsibility to protect society

Page 30: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

SOME THINGS TO THINK ABOUT:

• How did the Scientific Revolution that took place during the Renaissance affect the Enlightenment?

• How were the opinions of Hobbes and Locke different, as they relate to government’s role?

• What kinds of ideas or topics did the Philosophers address in their writings?

• How did Rousseau’s and Voltaire’s beliefs differ?

Page 31: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

ENLIGHTENMENT IDEAS SPREAD

• New ideas challenge society• People began to question “divine right” & class system• Church & government censored writers, banned books

• Writers sometimes wrote fiction to expose corruption without getting in trouble (Jonathan Swift, Voltaire, Montesquieu)

• Salons in women’s homes, Philosophers’ ideas spread• Started with noblewomen hosting poetry readings in homes• Middle class women began to do it as well

Re-creation of a French Salon from the Museum of Decorative Arts in Lyon, France

Page 32: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

NEW IDEAS REFLECTED IN LITERATURE AND THE ARTS

• Movement of Baroque to Rococo• Heavy, bright, grandiose to light, charming, and elegant• Religious and military themed art to lighter topics• Popular in spite of Philosophers dislike

Portrait of Carl Gustaf Wrangel by David Klöcker Ehrenstrahl

Jean-Frédéric Schall - Gardener in Straw Hat

Page 33: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

• Introduction of what we call classical music• Opera and ballet become popular all over Western Europe• Bach, Handel, Haydn, Mozart

• Drawing of Mozart painting of • By Doris Stock, 1789 J.S. Bach

• New literary form: the Novel• Growing middle class wanted stories in prose form• Daniel Defoe, Robinson Crusoe

Composers inspired by Enlightenment

Page 34: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

ENLIGHTENED DESPOTS LIKE THE NEW IDEAS

• Reform attempts by Frederick II• Prussian king from 1740 to 1786, absolute monarch• Allowed free press, religious toleration, reduced torture use

• Catherine the Great’s response• She studied works of Philosophers & admired them • Religious toleration, reduction of torture, criticism of serfdom

• More reforms by Joseph II• Traveled in disguise to get a feel for regular people• Like his mom(Maria Theresa), wanted to improve peasants’ lives• Religious equality for Protestants and Jews, abolition of serfdom• Many of his reforms were canceled after his death

Page 35: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

LIVES OF THE MAJORITY

• Slow to change• Early 1700’s

• Most people lived in country, didn’t hear new ideas

• Late 1700’s• Enlightenment ideas started to spread to even the lower

classes• Some people didn’t want change, just wanted stable lives• Others started revolutions to try to bring about social change

Three PeasantsEngraving by Albrecht Dürer

Page 36: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

QUESTIONS TO THINK ABOUT:

• What did people opposed to the Enlightenment do to stop these new ideas from spreading?

• Why did the philosophers want to share their ideas with the rulers of Europe?

• Why was life so slow to change for many Europeans?

Page 37: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

BIRTH OF THE AMERICAN REPUBLIC

• Britain as a global power• Location- island, large navy= good position to control trade• Few restrictions on trade= good for business• Won wars against France• gained control of Spanish slave trade (later abolished slavery in

their territories)• 1707= union of England, Scotland, & Wales (Ireland added

later)• King George III

• 60 year reign started 1760• Placed his friends in important positions to strengthen his power

• Got them to Parliament to gain support for his policies

• Many of his policies did not work out well for him

Page 38: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

MID-1700S IN AMERICAN COLONIES

• String of colonies on east coast of what would become US, not united or connected

• Britain applied mercantilist policies to force colonists to buy from them and sell to them

• Navigation Acts were supposed to regulate trade and production, (were not enforced)

• Smuggling was so common that the colonists didn’t see anything wrong with it

• Colonists were more diverse than in Great Britain, social lines were blurred

• Colonists set up their own assemblies and practiced open and free discussion

Page 39: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

COLONISTS UNHAPPY WITH THE SITUATION

• Various actions by Parliament and King George III were making colonists mad (taxes)

• Colonists rebel• March 1770= Boston Massacre• 1773- Boston Tea Party• First Continental Congress met in Philadelphia to discuss options

• Colonists declare their independence• April 1775= Revolutionary War started in Massachusetts • 1776= 2nd Continental Congress set up the Continental Army with

George Washington in charge• Thomas Jefferson wrote Declaration of Independence, full of Enlightenment ideas

• Life, liberty, pursuit of happiness Popular sovereignty= government by consent of the governed

Adopted by Continental Congress on July 4, 1776

Page 40: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

AMERICAN REVOLUTION

• Advantages:• Britain: better trained soldiers, huge navy, natural resources,

support of about 1/3 of colonists and some Native tribes• Colonists: home court advantage, strong leadership, dedicated

to winning their independence

• France supports the colonies• 1777- Colonists won the Battle of Saratoga, France decided to

join (so did other nations)• Washington held his troops together in dire circumstances

• Treaty of Paris ends the war• 1781- French blockade of Chesapeake Bay forced British to

surrender (Yorktown)• 1783- Treaty of Paris ended the war, forced Britain to recognize

the United States of America

Page 41: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

A NEW CONSTITUTION

• Articles of Confederation• Too weak, focused on states’ rights, not central gov’t• 1787- framers met to write new constitution (Washington,

Madison, Franklin, etc.)

• Huge impact of Enlightenment ideas• Took Montesquieu’s idea of separation of powers & checks and

balances• Federal Republic- states within a nation, each with rights• Government as social contract (Locke, Rousseau)

• elected president and legislature (could be replaced)

• Bill of Rights guaranteeing certain freedoms• Became supreme law of the land in 1789 (over 235 years old!)

Page 42: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

SYMBOL OF FREEDOM

• Our struggle for independence inspired revolutions in Latin America and France

• Many other nations have constitutions that are based on ours!

Page 43: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

QUESTIONS TO THINK ABOUT:

• What Enlightenment ideas are found in the Declaration of Independence?

• What advantages did the British have in the American Revolution? What advantages did the colonists have?

• What Enlightenment ideas are found in the Constitution?

Page 44: CHAPTER 17 PP. 542-569 FROM PRENTICE-HALL WORLD HISTORY (2007) THE ENLIGHTENMENT

WORKS CITED:

• Ellis, E. G., & Esler, A. (2007).Prentice Hall world history. Boston, Mass.: Pearson Prentice Hall.

• All photographs are from Wikimedia Commons and are in public domain due to one of the following reasons:• Copyright expired due to age of the work• Reproduction of a work already in public domain• No copyright exists