bridging behaviorism: a new approach to employee engagement
DESCRIPTION
HealthFitness’ Dennis Richling, M.D., chief medical and wellness officer, and Ed Framer, Ph.D., director of health and behavioral sciences, joined Fred Hanna, Ph.D., professor of counselor education, University of Northern Colorado, to discuss a new approach to employee engagement at the 23rd Annual Art & Science of Health Promotion Conference March 20-22, 2013. Listen to an audio recording of the presentation here: http://healthfitness.com/insights/events/TRANSCRIPT
Bridging Behaviorism A New Approach to Engagement
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
2
Speakers:
• Dennis Richling, MD, Chief Medical and Wellness Officer, HealthFitness (moderator)
• Edward Framer, Ph.D., Director, Health & Behavioral Sciences, Science and Analytics, Health Fitness Corporation
• Fred Hanna, Ph.D., Professor of Counselor Education, University of Northern Colorado; author, Therapy with difficult clients: Using the precursors model to awaken change
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
3
Two Models, One Goal: Sustained Engagement Dennis Richling, MD, Chief Medical and Wellness Officer, HealthFitness (moderator)
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
4
Engagement
• A Pledge, or a Promise
…is a marriage -an alignment of purpose and values
Participation
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
5
How Do We Engage People?
Educate
them…
Incent them… Reframe
the message…
Open a
door
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
6
Motivation is Important to Change Behavior
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
7
Goal: Adopt Healthy Behaviors for the rest of their life
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
8
How much motivation do we need?
• A new behavior model…
Dr. BJ Fogg Stanford Persuasion Technology Laboratory
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
9
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
9
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
9
B = M A T M
otivation
High Motivation
Low Motivation
Hard to do Easy to do Ability
Fogg Behavior Model Behavior Shaping
Desired Behavior
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
10
Exciting New Research?
Yes, but...
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
11
When Do Behaviors Change?
• Epiphanies
• Change of context
• Psychological processes
• Make it easier
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
12
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
12
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
12
Bridging Science to Increase Engagement
15%
65%
10% 10% Motivated with Risks
Little Motivation andRisks
No Motivation andRisks
No Risks
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
13
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
13
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
13
Bridging Behaviorism
Radical Behaviorism
Fogg Behavior
Model
Precursors Model
Transtheoretical Model
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
14
A New Look at What Radical Behaviorism (Behavior Analysis) has to Offer Health Promotion and Engagement
Edward Framer, Ph.D., Director, Health & Behavioral Sciences, Science and Analytics, Health Fitness Corporation
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
15
Behavioral Approach?
• Emphasis on measurement
• Emphasis on observable results
• Criteria = behavior change
• Justification
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
16
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
16
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
16
How the conversation got started
1. Can we work together to improve how HealthFitness builds it intervention models?
2. Engagement is critical to the success of health promotion and in fact all therapeutic change
3. Schools of psychotherapy, coaching and health behavior change, including even the Eastern thinking of yoga psychology
4. Why behaviorism is often the odd man out
5. Assertion: Radical behaviorism also deals with consciousness, thoughts and feelings
6. How can we use these various approaches, together, to improve engagement?
7. How can we use the various approaches, together, to improve health behavior change?
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
17
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
17
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
17
Bridging Behaviorism
Radical Behaviorism
Fogg Behavior
Model
Precursors Model
Transtheoretical Model
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
18
Radical Behaviorism
• Skinnerian behaviorism or operant psychology
• Why radical?
– Methodological behaviorism only what is observable from the outside?
– Radical behaviorism accepts consciousness
– Thoughts are behaviors, too
– The same rules that apply to learning to stop a car when the light turns red apply to learning to have or change thoughts or statements
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
19
Radical Behaviorism and Health Promotion
• What does behaviorism, and especially radical behaviorism, have to offer the health promotion/wellness field that most of us have come to love?
– An analytic framework
– Behavior change technologies
– A way to clarify the intrinsic/extrinsic incentives fight
– Both individual-clinical and population-culture approaches
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
20
Incentives, Rewards, Reinforcers
• Incentive
– “…the expectation of reward that induces action or motivates effort.” (www.thefreedictionary.com)
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
21
Incentives, Rewards, Reinforcers
• Reward
– “Something given or received in recompense for worthy behavior….” (www.thefreedictionary.com)
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
22
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
22
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
22
Incentives, Rewards, Reinforcers
• Positive Reinforcer
Don't Shoot the Dog! The New Art of Teaching and Training.
By Karen Pryor
Strengthens behavior it follows
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
23
Example: Timeframes for Incentives, Rewards & Reinforcers
Incentive Reward Reinforcer
Long-term Intermediate Brief
$650/Yr $10/Wk $0.05/Min
500 pts/Yr Movie ticket 1 pt/20 steps
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
24
Two Types of Learning/Conditioning
• Pavlovian or Classical Conditioning
• Operant Conditioning
http://psychology.about.com/od/behavioralpsychology/a/classical-vs-operant-conditioning.htm
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
25
Discriminative Stimulus
• “When a stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement it is called the SD, or discriminative stimulus. …it reliably signals the availability of reinforcement.”
• “Stimulus control is said to occur when an organism behaves in one way in the presence of a given stimulus and another way in its absence.”
• In plain English: A reliable cue or trigger
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stimulus_control
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
26
Subtle reminders to make healthy choices easier
Jim Rogers
Chairman & CEO
Eastman Chemical Company
Case Example: Eastman Chemical Company As part of the company’s health management efforts, Eastman leadership told employees the company was placing green spoons in the cafeteria’s healthy food choices and red spoons in the less healthy foods. “Hopefully, over time, we’re going to find ourselves reaching for the green spoon a lot more than the red spoon.”
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
27
Antecedent(s), Behavior & Consequence
Antecedent(s)
•Doctor says I need to exercise more
•Worksite Health Coach asks about my doctor’s exercise rec.
•Plan results in 10 daily 1 minute calls from my coach in 3 weeks
Behavior
•I wonder how I, someone who hates exercise, will do that.
•I get upset, but admit that I need help
•With each cue I get up and walk at least 100 steps. I also try to get 100 steps on non call days. (Use Outlook)
Consequence
•I feel bad, but do nothing. I don’t think about PA.
•Coach praises my honesty and offers to help me setup a plan.
•I earn regular praise from my coach and even begin to praise myself. I also start to feel more relaxed.
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
28
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
28
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
28
Incentives, Rewards, Reinforcers
• Positive Reinforcer
Don't Shoot the Dog! The New Art of Teaching and Training.
By Karen Pryor
Strengthens behavior it follows
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
29
Negative Reinforcer; Punisher
• Negative Reinforcer or Reinforcement (strengthens behavior)
• Punisher or Punishment (weakens behavior)
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
30
Escape and Avoidance Behavior
ESCAPE: perform an operant response that gets you away from an ongoing punishing stimulus. “Get me out of here” AVOIDANCE: perform an operant response that prevents the occurrence of a punishing stimulus. “Prevent pain/discomfort”
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
31
Escape and Avoidance Shuttle Box
www.themezoom-neuroeconomics.com
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
32
Summary
• Many more principles that have application to health promotion
• Attaches to so much else in the field, including the work Dr. Hanna will speak about next and the introductory material that Dr. Richling used to set up our discussion.
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
33
Precursors Model: Foundations for Successful Engagement and Change Fred Hanna, Ph.D., Professor of Counselor Education, University of Northern Colorado; author, Therapy with difficult clients: Using the precursors model to awaken change
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
34
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
34
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
34
Three Levers for Engagement
Motivation
Perseverance
Involvement
Engagement
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
35
Involvement • Dedication to a task or undertaking that often
includes strong interest, devotion, fascination and/or commitment.
Motivation • The desire to attain a goal; includes the exertion
of effort and willpower toward achieving that goal.
Perseverance • Sustained drive and energy toward a desired
goal; includes the determination to break through any barriers.
Defining the Levers
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
36
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
36
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
36
Maintenance
Action
Preparation
Contemplation
Precontemplation
Stages of Change and Engagement
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
37
Bridging Behavior, Cognition and Affect
The dynamic Interplay of Self, Mind, Body and Therapeutic Change
Source: Fred J. Hanna, PhD
I
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
38
Precursors and Change
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
39
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
39
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
39
Precursors Assessment
Problem or Issue:
Precursor and its Markers None (0) Trace (1) Small (2) Adequate (3) Abundant (4)
1. Sense of Necessity • Expresses desire for change
• Feels a sense or urgency
2. Willing for Anxiety or Difficulty • Open to experiencing emotion
• Likely to take risks
3. Awareness • Able to identify problems
• Identifies thoughts, feelings
4. Confronting the Problem • Courageously faces the problem
• Sustained attention toward issue
5. Effort toward Change • Eagerly does homework
• High energy; active cooperation
6. Hope for Change • Positive outlook; open to future;
• High coping; therapeutic humor
7. Social Support for Change • Wide network of friends, family
• Many confiding relationships
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
40
Radical Behaviorism
Fogg Behavior
Model
Precursors Model
Bridging Behaviorism
Transtheoretical Model
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
41 © Used with permission
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
42
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
42
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
42
Q & A
• Dennis Richling, MD, Chief Medical and Wellness Officer, HealthFitness (moderator)
• Edward Framer, Ph.D., Director, Health & Behavioral Sciences, Science and Analytics, Health Fitness Corporation
• Fred Hanna, Ph.D., Professor of Counselor Education, University of Northern Colorado; author, Therapy with difficult clients: Using the precursors model to awaken change
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
43
Appendix
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
44
Antecedent(s), Behavior & Consequence
Antecedent(s)
• Stop light turns from green to yellow
• Stop light turns from yellow to red
• Stop light turns from red to green
Behavior
• Foot moves from gas pedal to brake pedal
• Foot presses harder on the brake pedal
• Foot moves from brake to gas pedal and presses down
Consequence
• Car begins to slow down
• Car slows to a stop
• Car begins to speed-up
© 2013 Health Fitness Corporation
45
Antecedent(s), Behavior & Consequence
Antecedent(s)
• Girl in class smiles at me
• My watch alarm rings 3 times per hour
• A new girl in class smiles at me
Behavior
• I look away thinking: “She probably doesn’t really like me”
• Each time I try to think: “When someone smiles at you, smile back”
• I smile back at her and introduce myself
Consequence
• Next time the girl and I look at each other, neither of us smiles
• When I think this 10 times, my Mom gives me $1.00 extra
• She says “I’m Sue and I just transferred here