atlantic oceanographic laboratory · gauges, values of the harmonic constituents m2, s2, n2, k1, 0...
TRANSCRIPT
LIBRARY,
FISHERIES RESEARCH BOARD OF CANADA,
DEPARTMEW -95PikreftY,MINES AND RESOURCES CH
MINISTERE DE L'ENERGIE DE MINES ET DES RESSOURCES DIRECTION DES SCIENCES DE LA MER
ATLANTIC OCEANOGRAPHIC LABORATORY Cr)
BEDFORD INSTITUTE
LABORATOIRE OCEANOGRAPHIQUE DE L'ATLANTIQU INSTITUT de BEDFORD
Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Canada
TIDAL TRANSPORTS AND STREAMS
IN THE
ST. LAWRENCE RIVER AND ESTUARY
by
W. D. FORRESTER
REPORT B.I. 69-2
APRIL 1969
PROGRAMMED BY-
THE CANADIAN COMMITTEE OF OCEANOGRAPHY
ATLANTIC OCEANOGRAPHIC LABORATORY
BEDFORD INSTITUTE, DARTMOUTH, N.S. - CANADA
This is a technical report to our Headquarters which has received only limited circulation. On citing this report in a bibliography, the title should be followed by the words "UNPUBLISHED MANUSCRIPT", in accordance with accepted bibliographic custom.
TIDAL TRANSPORTS AND STREAMS
IN THE
ST. LAWRENCE RIVER AND ESTUARY
by
W.D. Forrester
REPORT B.I. 69-2
April 1969
TIDAL TRANSPORTS AND STREAMS IN THE
ST. LAWRENCE RIVER AND ESTUARY
INTRODUCTION
The principle of continuity makes it possible to calculate the
transport through any cross-section of a channel from a knowledge of
the changes in the surface elevation along the channel and the trans-
port through a single cross-section. This principle was used by
Forrester (1967) to calculate the average M2 tidal streams in a
cross-section of the St. Lawrence estuary near Pte. au Pere for
comparison with the value observed directly with current meters. The
good agreement obtained indicated that it would be valuable to calcu-
late similar information for other cross-sections and for other tidal
constituents in addition to M2 .
During the summer of 1967 the Tides and Water Levels Section
of the Department of Energy, Mines and Resources had in operation a
network of about 20 additional temporary tide gauges in the estuary
between Quebec and Pte. au Pere. The availability of this new tidal
data below Quebec to supplement that already available above Quebec
decided the author to prepare tidal transport and average tidal
stream information for various cross-sections between Lake St. Peter
and Pte. des Monte.
METHOD
For the purposes of this study tidal movements are considered
to be negligible above the head of Lake St. Peter, which provides the ,
boundary condition that tidal transports have zero amplitude at this
cross-section. To carry out the continuity calculations the river
and estuary were divided into 22 regions as delineated in fig. 1.
2
The surface area of each region at mean water level was scaled from
Canadian Hydrographic Service charts. The regions and also their
surface areas are referred to as Ai, i being the number of the
region. The area of the vertical cross-section at the downstream
end of each region was also determined from the charts. The cross-
sections and also their areas are referred to as ai. From the tide
gauges, values of the harmonic constituents M 2, S 2, N2, K1, 0 M4,
and MS4 of the vertical tide were assigned to each region; where
more than one tide gauge was taken to represent a region, a vector
average was employed. The symbols H i and g i (of M2 , etc.) are used
to denote the amplitude and phaselag respectively of the constituents
of the vertical tide in the ith region. Fig. 1 shows the regions and
cross-sections treated, along with the locations from which tide
gauge information was obtained. Where information from one tide
gauge was used in two regions this has been shown by arrows pointing
from the gauge to the two regions. The prefix "T" identifies the
temporary gauges placed in 1967. All tide gauge information came
from the Tides and Water Levels Section of the Department of Energy,
Mines and Resources in Ottawa.
The harmonic constituent of tidal volume above cross-section
an is denoted as having amplitude Vn and phaselag Gn (of M2 , etc.).
Thus, n
(Vn , Gn) =
E (HiAi, gi)
1=1
the summation being carried out vectorially.
The harmonic constituent of tidal volume transport through
cross-section an is the time derivative of (Vn
, Gn) and is denoted
(1)
3
as (Tn
, Jn). Thus,
(T n
, J n dt ) ■ — (V n , G n) = (w Vn , Gn - 90° ), (2)
where w is the angular frequency of the constituent (M 2 , etc.).
The corresponding harmonic constituent of the average tidal
stream through cross-section an is obtained by dividing the tidal
volume transport by the cross-sectional area, so
(vn , Jn — ) = (Tn, J n). an
(3 )
Values of the average river diicharge volume through the
various cross-sections and the corresponding average river current
are also given for comparison with the tidal volume transports and
tidal streams. The discharge values came from a variety of sources
and are only approximate. The actual river discharge is subject to
considerable variation through changes in run-off and water level
control conditions.
Farquharson (1966) describes a current meter survey in
cross-section a22 near Pte. des Monts in 1963, and Forrester (1967)
describes a current meter survey in cross-section a21 near
Pte. au Pere in 1965. For comparison with the continuity calcula-
tions, weighted averages of the tidal constituents were formed from
the eleven current meters of Forrester in a21 and from the ten
current meters of Farquharson in a22. The weighting was done on
the basis of the depth of the meters, and the same weights were used
for each of the tidal constituents (M 2 , etc.).
RESULTS
Table I lists the surface areas of the regions, the areas of
their downstream cross-sections, the distance along the channel from
-4-
Quebec to the downstream cross-section, the river volume discharge,
and the average river current through the cross-section.
Table IIa lists the M2 harmonic constituent of the vertical
tide for each region and the tidal volume transport and mean tidal
stream through each downstream cross-section. The average M 2 tidal
stream through cross-sections a21 and a22 as obtained from the
current meters is also shown in Table Ha. Tables IIb to IIg contain
the same information for the harmonic constituents S2' N2, K1 , 0
1' M4,
and MS4 respectively. All phaselags refer to Eastern Standard Time
(EST). Inflowing tidal streams have positive sign.
DISCUSSION
Comparison in Tables IIa to IIg of the average tidal streams
in cross-sections a21 and a22 obtained by the continuity calculation
and by direct current measurement shows remarkably good agreement:
the greatest disagreement is 0.02 m/sec., which occurs for the M2
constituent. The agreement, however, would probably be worse in
sections above Quebec because of the greater effect of the sloping
banks in the narrow cross-sections, for which no allowance was made
in the continuity calculations. Insufficient current meter obser-
vations are available above Quebec, however, to permit such a
comparison. The calculated values of the constituents M 4 and MS4
above Quebec should be regarded as particularly suspect.
The tidal volume transport as a function of distance from
Quebec varies much more smoothly than does the mean tidal stream.
For this reason, interpolation to cross-sections intermediate to
those treated in the tables should be done only on the tidal volume
transport as a function of distance from Quebec: to obtain the
- 5 -
corresponding mean tidal stream, the appropriate cross-sectional
area should be measured from a chart and divided into the interpolated
tidal volume transport.
The current or tidal stream calculated for a particular
cross-section is the average over the entire cross-section, and as
such tells nothing of possible variations from top to bottom or
from shore to shore; direct current measurement is still required
to supply this information. The calculated averages for the large
cross-sections below Ile d'Orleans, are, however, more accurate
than could be obtained by direct current measurement with the limited
quantity and reliability of equipment at present available.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author wishes to acknowledge the assistance of
Mr. G.C. Dohler and the staff of the Tides and Water levels Section
of the Department of Energy, Mines and Resources in Ottawa in
providing the tidal height information and some of the cross-
sectional area information used in this study. It is also wished
to thank Dr. C.D. Maunsell and Mr. R.C. Melanson of the Bedford
Institute for reading and commenting on the manuscript for this
report.
REFERENCES
Farquharson, W.I., 1966: St. Lawrence estuary current surveys. Bedford Institute Oceanography, Dartmouth, N.S., Can. Unpubl. man. rep. 66-6.
Forrester, W.D., 1967:
Currents and geostrophic currents in the St. Lawrence estuary, Bedford Institute Oceanography, Dartmouth, N.S., Can. Unpubl. man. rep. 67-5.
70.103,
• TIDES A1■0 WATER LEVELS GAUGING SITE (T• temporary gouge.1967)
Ai • Oh region of • Coscahnan cross-wilco of im regko
Fig. 1. Regions and cross-sections of St. Lawrence River and estuary, showing tide gauge locations.
- 7 -
Table I
Distance (21.) along chan- Downstream nel from
(Al) Cross- Quebec to Surface Section end
Region Area Area downstream
(km2) (km2) (km)
River Mean Discharge River Volume Current
(106m3/sec) (m/sec)
Al 347 0.017 -142 0.0076 0.45 A2 14 0.017 -134 0.0076 0.45 A3 27 0.013 -119 0.0079 0.61
A4 48 0.019 -1p3 0.0079 0.42
AS 31 0.013 - 90 0.0081 0.62
A6 24 0.010 - 81 0.0081 0.81
A7 24 0.014 - 68 0.0084 0.60 A8 52 0.028 - 47 0.0084 0.30 A9 96 0.022 12 0.0087 0.39
A10 110 0.056 + 25 0.0087 0.16
All 106 0.110 + 37 0.0087 0.08 Al2 416 0.200 + 63 0.0087 0.04 A13 392 0.25 + 81 0.0090 0.04 A14 392 0.32 + 98 0.0090 0.03 A15 316 0.57 +117 0.0090 0.02
A16 683 0.77 +154 0.0093 0.012
A17 313 0.68 +170 0.0093 0.014
A18 742 1.04 +190 0.0102 0.010
A19 769 4.28 +220 0.0108 0.003 A20 1278 5.28 +258 0.0113 0.002 A21 1501 8.59 +290 0.0119 0.001
A22 5804 11.58 +402 0.0125 0.001
- 8 -
Table Ha
Tidal constituent M2 (EST)
Region
Mean Vertical Tide
(m)
Tidal Volume Transport
(106m3/sec
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
(m/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Observed)
(m/sec)
Al (0.03, 085 ° ) (.0013, 355 ° ) (0.08, 355 ° )
A2 (0.07, 018 ° ) (.0014, 350 ° ) (0.08, 350 ° )
A3 (0.08, 355 ° ) (.0015, 338 ° ) (0.12, 338 ° )
A4 (0.26, 326 ° ) (.0020, 280 ° ) (0.11, 280° )
A5 (0.35, 314 ° ) (.0032, 257 ° ) (0.25, 257 ° )
A6 (0.71, 283 ° ) (.0047, 230 ° ) (0.49, 230 ° )
A7 (0.86, 275 ° ) (.0071, 213 ° ) (0.52, 213 ° )
A8 (1.46, 245 ° ) (.0156, 178 ° ) (0.55, 178 ° )
A9 (1.54, 226 ° ) (.0340, 154 ° ) (1.55, 154 ° )
A10 (1.83, 174 ° ) (.0512, 123 ° ) (0.91, 123 ° )
All (2.00, 162 ° ) (.0739, 104 ° ) (0.67, 104 ° )
Al2 (1.98, 150 ° ) (.1765, 077 ° ) (0.88, 077 ° )
Al3 (1.93, 137 ° ) (.2736, 066 ° ) (1.10, 066 ° )
Al4 (1.86, 125 ° ) (.3655, 058 ° ) (1.16, 058 ° )
Al5 (1.81, 108 ° ) (.4306, 051 ° ) (0.75, 051 ° )
Al6 (1.68, 092 ° ) (.5507, 038 ° ) (0.71, 038 ° )
All (1.58, 084 ° ) (.6028, 033 ° ) (0.89, 033 ° )
A18 (1.56, 074 ° ) (.7197, 023 ° ) (0.69, 023 ° )
Al9 (1.45, 062 ° ) (.8261, 015 ° ) (0.19, 015 ° )
A20 (1.35, 055 ° ) (.9994, 004 ° ) (0.19, 004 ° )
A21 (1.32, 054 ° ) (1.226, 356 ° ) (0.14, 356 ° ) (0.12, 353 ° ) A22 (1.16, 048 ° ) (2.056, 339 ° ) (0.18, 339 ° ) (0.16, 341°)
- 9 -
Table IIb
Tidal constituent S 2 (EST)
Mean Vertical
Region Tide
Tidal Volume Transport
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
Mean Tidal Stream (observed)
(m) (106m
3/sec) (m/sec)
(m/sec)
Al (0.01, 112 ° ) (.0005, 022 ° ) (0.03, 022 ° )
A2 (0.02, 052 ° ) (.0005, 018 ° ) (0.03, 018 ° )
A3 (0.02, 027 ° ) (.0005, 007 ° ) (0.04, 007 ° )
A4 (0.06, 003 ° ) (.0007, 324 ° Y (0.04, 324 ° )
A5 (0.08, 356 ° ) (.0009, 304 ° ) (0.07, 304 ° )
A6 (0.14, 329 ° ) (.0012, 282 ° ) (0.12, 282 ° )
A7 (0.18, 318 ° ) (.0017, 264 ° ) (0.12, 264 ° )
A8 (0.29, 294 ° ) (.0033, 230° ) (0.12, 230 ° )
A9 (0.34, 278 ° ) (.0076, 205 ° ) (0.35, 205 ° )
A10 (0.44, 221 ° ) (.0117, 169 ° ) (0.21, 169 ° )
All (0.48, 213 ° ) (.0177, 152 ° ) (0.16, 152 ° )
Al2 (0.49, 197 ° ) (.0442, 123 ° ) (0.22, 123° )
A13 (0.53, 182 ° ) (.0715, 111 ° ) (0.29, 111 ° )
A14 (0.50, 162 ° ) (.0954, 100 ° ) (0.30, 100° )
A15 (0.48, 142 ° ) (.1117, 091 ° ) (0.20, 091 ° )
A16 (0.52, 129 ° ) (.1486, 076 ° ) (0.19, 076 ° )
A17 (0.48, 122 ° ) (.1652, 070° ) (0.24, 070° )
A18 (0.50, 113 ° ) (.2059, 059 ° ) (0.20, 059 ° )
A19 (0.47, 101 ° ) (.2437, 050 ° ) (0.06, 050° )
A20 (0.43, 094 ° ) (.3053, 039 ° ) (0.06, 039 ° )
A21 (0.42, 095 ° ) (.3850, 031 ° ) (0.04, 031 ° ) (0.03, 023 ° )
A22 (0.34, 083 ° ) (.6368, 015 ° ) (0.06, 015 ° ) (0.06, 022°)
- 10 -
Table IIc
Tidal constituent N 2 (EST)
Mean Mean Mean Tidal Tidal Tidal Vertical Volume Stream Stream
Region Tide Transport (Calculated) (Observed)
(106m
3/sec) (m/sec) (m/sec)
Al (0.01, 045 ° ) (.0003, 315 ° ) (0.02, 315 ° )
A2 (0.01, 353 ° ) (.0003, 312 ° ) (0.02, 312 ° )
A3 (0.02, 328 ° ) (.0003, 302 ° ) (0.02, 302 ° )
A4 (0.04, 309 ° ) (.0005, 264 ° )' (0.03, 264 ° )
A5 (0.06, 307 ° ) (.0006, 248 ° ) (0.05, 248 ° )
A6 (0.10, 266 ° ) (.0008, 226 ° ) (0.08, 226 ° )
A7 (0.12, 246 ° ) (.0010, 205 ° ) (0.07, 205 ° )
A8 (0.19, 225 ° ) (.0019, 164 ° ) (0.07, 164 ° )
A9 (0.33, 188 ° ) (.0055, 117 ° ) (0.25, 117 ° )
A10 (0.28, 155 ° ) (.0088, 094 ° ) (0.16, 094 ° )
All (0.30, 142 ° ) (.0124, 081 ° ) (0.11, 081 ° )
Al2 (0.36, 125 ° ) (.0308, 052 ° ) (0.15, 052 ° )
A13 (0.37, 114 ° ) (.0497, 041 ° ) (0.20, 041 ° )
A14 (0.33, 099 ° ) (.0654, 033 ° ) (0.21, 033 ° )
Al5 (0.35, 082 ° ) (.0776, 025 ° ) (0.14, 025 ° )
A16 (0.30, 064 ° ) (.0977, 012 ° ) (0.13, 012 ° )
A17 (0.31, 056 ° ) (.1073, 007 ° ) (0.16, 007 ° )
A18 (0.31, 049 ° ) (.1309, 357 ° ) (0.13, 357 ° )
Al9 (0.30, 038 ° ) (.1535, 348 ° ) (0.04, 348 ° )
A20 (0.27, 031 ° ) (.1887, 337 ° ) (0.04, 337 ° )
A21 (0.25, 031° ) (.2323, 330° ) (0.03, 330° ) (0.03, 330° )
A22 (0.24, 030° ) (.4129, 316 ° ) (0.04, 316 ° ) (0.04, 318°)
(m)
- 11 -
Table IId
Tidal constituent K1 (EST)
Region
Mean Vertical Tide
(m)
Tidal Volume Transport
(106m
3/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
(m/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Observed)
(m/sec)
Al (0.02, 090 ° ) (.0004, 000 ° ) (.02 , 000° )
A2 (0.02, 052 ° ) (.0004, 358 ° ) (.02 , 358 ° )
A3 (0.03, 034 ° ) (.0004, 352 ° ) (.03 , 352 ° )
A4 (0.06, 359 ° ) (.0005, 327 ° ) (.03 , 327 ° )
A5 (0.08, 353 ° ) (.0006, 311 ° ) (.05 , 311 ° )
A6 (0.12, 330° ) (.0007, 294 ° ) (.07 , 294 ° )
A7 (0.14, 329 ° ) (.0009, 281 ° ) (.07 , 281 ° )
A8 (0.19, 302 ° ) (.0013, 251 ° ) (.05 , 251 ° )
A9 (0.19, 288 ° ) (.0024, 224 ° ) (.11 , 224 ° )
A10 (0.23, 263 ° ) (.0038, 202 ° ) (.07 , 202 ° )
All (0.24, 253 ° ) (.0054, 189 ° ) (.05 , 189 ° )
Al2 (0.24, 246 ° ) (.0121, 170°) (.06 , 170 ° )
Al3 (0.23, 240 ° ) (.0185, 163 ° ) (.07 , 163 ° )
Al4 (0.25, 232 ° ) (.0254, 157 ° ) (.08 , 157 ° )
A15 (0.25, 222°) (.0308, 153 ° ) (.05 , 153 ° )
A16 (0.24, 215 ° ) (.0419, 145 ° ) (.05 , 145 ° )
A17 (0.24, 213 ° ) (.0471, 142 ° ) (.07 , 142 ° )
A18 (0.25, 209 ° ) (.0596, 137 ° ) (.06 , 137 ° )
A19 (0.24, 205 ° ) (.0721, 133 ° ) (.017, 133 ° ) A20 (0.23, 200° ) (.0919, 128 ° ) (.017, 128 ° )
A21 (0.23, 201 ° ) (.1157, 124 ° ) (.014, 124 ° ) (.013, 150 ° )
A22 (0.23, 201 ° ) (.2111, 118 ° ) (.018, 118 ° ) (.015, 120°)
- 12 -
Table He
Tidal constituent 01 (EST)
Region
Mean Vertical Tide
(m)
Tidal Volume Transport
(106m
3/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
(m/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Observed)
(m/sec)
Al (0.02, 052 ° ) (.0004, 322 ° ) (.02 , 322 ° )
A2 (0.03, 020 ° ) (.0004, 320 ° ) (.02 , 320 ° ) A3 (0.03, 005 ° ) (.0005, 316 ° ) (.04 , 316 ° ) A4 (0.07, 336 ° ) (.0006, 296 ° ). (.03 , 296 ° )
A5 (0.09, 330 ° ) (.0007, 284 ° ) (.05 , 284 ° )
A6 (0.13, 312 ° ) (.0008, 271 ° ) (.08 , 271 ° )
A7 (0.14, 306°) (.0010, 260 ° ) (.07 , 260 ° )
A8 (0.18, 286 ° ) (.0014, 236 ° ) (.05 , 236 ° )
A9 (0.20, 271 ° ) (.0024, 209 ° ) (.11 , 209 ° ) A10 (0.22, 244 ° ) (.0036, 187 ° ) (.06 , 187 ° ) All (0.24, 235 ° ) (.0050, 174 ° ) (.05 , 174 ° ) Al2 (0.24, 232 ° ) (.0113, 156 ° ) (.06 , 156 ° )
Al3 (0.24, 221°) (.0172, 147 ° ) (.07 , 147 ° )
Al4 (0.25, 214 ° ) (.0234, 141 ° ) (.07 , 141 ° ) A15 (0.24, 204 ° ) (.0281, 136° ) (.05 , 136 ° )
A16 (0.24, 197 ° ) (.0381, 128 ° ) (.05 , 128 ° )
A17 (0.23, 195 ° ) (.0427, 125 ° ) (.06 , 125 ° )
A18 (0.24, 192 ° ) (.0541, 120 ° ) (.05 , 120° )
A19 (0.23, 187 ° ) (.0651, 116 ° ) (.015, 116 ° )
A20 (0.22, 182°) (.0829, 111 ° ) (.016, 111 ° )
A21 (0.23, 183 ° ) (.1047, 107 ° ) (.012, 107 ° ) (.010, 107 ° ) A22 (0.21, 183 ° ) (.1858, 101 ° ) (.016, 101 ° ) (.015, 115°)
- 13 -
Table IIf
Tidal constituent M4
(EST)
Region
Mean Vertical Tide
(m)
Tidal Volume Transport
(106m
3/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
(m/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Observed)
(m/sec)
Al (0.01, 039 ° ) (.0006, 309 ° ) (.04 , 309 ° )
A2 (0.02, 301 ° ) (.0006, 301 ° ) (.04 , 301 ° )
A3 (0.03, 254 ° ) (.0004, 277 ° ) (.03 , 277 ° )
A4 (0.09, 217 ° ) (.0008, 142 ° ) (.04 , 142 ° )
A5 (0.10, 196 ° ) (.0016, 124 ° ) (.12 , 124 ° )
A6 (0.21, 124 ° ) (.0022, 083 ° ) (.23 , 083 ° )
A7 (0.24, 113 ° ) (.0033, 057 ° ) (.24 , 057 ° )
A8 (0.33, 043 ° ) (.0051, 352 ° ) (.18 , 352 ° )
A9 (0.22, 009 ° ) (.0089, 312 ° ) (.40 , 312 ° )
A10 (0.27, 273 ° ) (.0073, 253 ° ) (.13 , 253 ° )
All (0.27, 256 ° ) (.0113, 207 ° ) (.10 , 207 ° )
Alt (0.15, 239 ° ) (.0256, 171 ° ) (.13 , 171 ° )
Al3 (0.05, 173 ° ) (.0264, 159 ° ) (.11 , 159 ° )
Al4 (0.05, 068 ° ) (.0207, 159 ° ) (.07 , 159 ° )
A15 (0.09, 046 ° ) (.0138, 172 ° ) (.02 , 172 ° )
A16 (0.08, 060° ) (.0060, 269 ° ) (.008, 269° )
A17 (0.06, 077 ° ) (.0087, 304 ° ) (.013, 304 ° )
Al8 (0.05, 123 ° ) (.0135, 353 ° ) (.013, 353 ° )
A19 (0.03, 113 ° ) (.0195, 003 ° ) (.005, 003 ° )
A20 (0.03, 064 ° ) (.0285, 353 ° ) (.005, 353 ° )
A21 (0.03, 085 ° ) (.0401, 354 ° ) (.005, 354 ° ) (.007, 021 ° )
A22 (0.01, 081 ° ) (.0550, 353 ° ) (.005, 353 ° ) (.008, 332°)
- 14 -
Table IIg
Tidal constituent MS4
(EST)
Region
Mean Vertical Tide
(m)
Tidal Volume Transport
(106m3/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Calculated)
(m/sec)
Mean Tidal Stream (Observed)
(m/sec)
Al (.003, 072 ° ) (.0003, 342 ° ) (.02 , 342 ° )
A2 (0.01, 000 ° ) (.0003, 336 ° ) (.02 , 336 ° )
A3 (0.02, 300° ) (.0003, 314 ° ) (.02 , 314°)
A4 (0.04, 268 ° ) (.0004, 205 ° ) (.02 , 205 ° )
A5 (0.04, 251 ° ) (.0007, 184°) (.05 , 184 ° )
A6 (0.07, 182 ° ) (.0009, 148°) (.09 , 148 ° )
A7 (0.09, 160°) (.0012, 116 ° ) (.09 , 116°)
A8 (0.12, 105 ° ) (.0019, 052 ° ) (.07 , 152 ° )
A9 (0.11, 073 ° ) (.0042, 008 ° ) (.19 , 008 ° )
A10 (0.13, 324 ° ) (.0033, 301 ° ) (.06 , 301 ° )
All (0.13, 318 ° ) (.0059, 260 ° ) (.05 , 260 ° )
Al2 (0.07, 295 ° ) (.0127, 227 ° ) (.06 , 227 ° )
A13 (0.03, 237 ° ) (.0139, 212°) (.06 , 212 ° )
A14 (0.02, 109 ° ) (.0115, 214 ° ) (.04 , 214 ° )
A15 (0.04, 086 ° ) (.0088, 230 ° ) (.02 , 230° )
Al6 (0.04, 100 ° ) (.0057, 284 ° ) (.007, 284 ° )
Al7 (0.02, 120 ° ) (.0055, 303 ° ) (.008, 303 ° )
A18 (0.02, 187 ° ) (.0027, 344 ° ) (.003, 344 ° )
A19 (0.02, 186 ° ) (.0034, 049 ° ) (.001, 049 ° )
A20 (0.01, 137 ° ) (.0056, 048 ° ) (.001, 048°)
A21 (0.01, 162 ° ) (.0094, 058 ° ) (.001, 058 ° ) (.003, 079 ° )
A22 (.003, 251 ° ) (.0096, 089 ° ) (.001, 089 ° ) (.001, 005°)