assuring coherence of ideas
TRANSCRIPT
How to Assure Coherence of Ideas in Your
Thesis/Dissertation
Coherence of Ideas Is The First Step to
Assure Consistency
Have your own material at hand and most important open your mind to focus on consistency
In this interactive session, you reflect, write, and assure coherence of your ideas
What Does Coherence of Ideas Mean?
• It is also known as logical coherence
• Ideas must be related to achieve the purpose of the study
• Ideas must harmonically connected
How Do You Achieve Coherence of Ideas?Same line of thought in each chapter, especially with basic elements: problem, purpose, research question, theoretical framework, and methodology
Tools to Build Coherence of Ideas
• Focus (your interest)• Harmonic connection (all foci
reflect the same interest)
Counterexample to Illustrate Coherence of Ideas
• Problem: Middle school students of a Chicago school district who are taught using traditional reading strategies get low scores in the NWEA test.
• Purpose: The purpose of this study is to know why middle school students do not like to read.
• Research Question: Why do middle school teachers prefer to teach reading using traditional strategies?
• Theoretical Framework: This study will be based on behaviourism.
• Methodology: A qualitative design with a snowball sampling will be used.
Let’s apply the suggested tools
• Focus• Harmonic connection of
foci
Research ProblemMiddle school students of a Chicago school district who are taught using traditional reading strategies get low scores in the NWEA test.
Focus:Teaching using traditional reading strategies seems to be related to low scores in the NWEA test
Purpose of StudyThe purpose of this study is to know why middle school students do not like to read.
Focus:Reasons to dislike reading
Research QuestionWhy do middle school teachers prefer to teach reading using traditional strategies?
Focus:Teachers’ reasons to use traditional reading strategies
Theoretical FrameworkThis study will be based on behaviourism
Focus:Teachers’ reasons to use traditional reading strategies
MethodologyA qualitative design with a snowball sampling will be used
Focus: A research method focused on finding out perceptions, feelings, grounded theory, etc. will be used and sampling will be developed by asking participants to recommend peers with similar points of view
Connection of Foci Traditional
reading strategies and
low scores
Reasons to dislike reading
Reasons to use traditional
strategies
Theory associated to
traditional strategies
Method based on human experience
and sampling by
recommending peers
Are these foci connected harmonically?
Keep the same problem and write down the rest of pivotal elements coherently
Research ProblemMiddle school students of a Chicago school district who are taught using traditional reading strategies get low scores in the NWEA test.
Focus:Teaching using traditional reading strategies seems to be related to low scores in the NWEA test
Now You Practice
Write down a coherent purpose, research question, theoretical basis (if you know about reading), and research method
If you write something like: • Research Problem: Middle school students of a Chicago school
district who are taught using traditional reading strategies get low scores in the NWEA test.
• Purpose: To know if scores of middle school students in the NWEA test can be improved using non-traditional reading strategies
• Research Question: What is the difference between the scores of middle school students in the NWEA test when applying non-traditional versus traditional reading strategies?
• Theoretical Framework: Constructivism and behaviourism
• Methodology: A quantitative quasi-experimental design will be used in which the control group will be taught using traditional reading strategies and the experimental one using non-traditional strategies.
Now You Practice
Write down your research problem, purpose, research question, theoretical basis, and research method.
Then check how coherent they are.
Advanced Idea for Today:
To write a high quality thesis/ dissertation, you must assure that its ideas are coherent (harmonically connected to reflect the same line of thought).
Now You Know
• What coherence of ideas is• What tools you can use to built
it