andrew bashford, jim cooper. scientific development group ...€¦ · quantified confluence and...
TRANSCRIPT
14 November, 2016 © Crown copyright
INTRODUCTION METHODS
RESULTS
• The three cell types displayed a similar morphology and the IncuCyte accurately
quantified confluence and cell number (fig 2).
• Cells reached mid-log phase after ~72 hours as determined by growth curve.
• IC50 values calculated using confluence (72 hours) or cell number (120 hours)
produced very similar IC50 values (fig 3, fig 4).
• A2780cis showed a ten-fold resistance to cisplatin.
• A2780ADR showed over ten-fold resistance to Adriamycin.
• These results are consistent with those published over 20 years ago generated
using different experimental techniques(1,3-6) (table 1).
DISCUSSION & CONCLUSION
• A2780cis and A2780ADR are an order of magnitude resistant to their respective therapeutic agents. These results
are consistent with the originally published data describing these cell lines(1+2).
• The IncuCyte ZOOM enabled the automation of imaging and quantification of confluence and nuclear count data.
• By comparing IC50 determination using cell number we have shown that cell confluence is a valid parameter to
determine IC50 in these cell lines.
• This study has verified that A2780 and its drug resistant counterparts, A2780cis and A2780ADR, have retained
resistance as reported over 20 years ago. The selective culture conditions used in the production of these cell lines
in ECACC has ensured the cells continue to be fit for purpose.
• This study has demonstrated the proof of principle of a label-free, fast and convenient way study in vitro drug
resistance.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Special thanks go to Edward Burnett and Joseph Taylor of the
Scientific Development Group for on-going help and advice
relating to project work.
REFERENCES 1) Behrens, B. C. et al., 1987. 'Characterization of a cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II)-resistant
human ovarian cancer cell line and its use in evaluation of platinum analogues', Cancer Res,
47: 414-8.
2) Behrens, B. C. et al., 1984. 'Resistance and cross-resistance of human ovarian cancer cell lines
to Adriamycin, melphalan, and irradiation', Proc. Am. Assoc. Cancer Res, 25: 336.
3) Masuda, H., R. et al., 1988. 'Increased DNA repair as a mechanism of acquired resistance to cis-
diamminedichloroplatinum (II) in human ovarian cancer cell lines', Cancer Res, 48: 5713-6.
4) Louie, K. G. et al., 1985. 'Radiation survival parameters of antineoplastic drug-sensitive and -
resistant human ovarian cancer cell lines and their modification by buthionine sulfoximine',
Cancer Res, 45: 2110-5.
5) Sasaki, H. et al., 1991. 'Human ovarian cancer cell lines resistant to cisplatin, doxorubicin, and L-
phenylalanine mustard are sensitive to delta 7-prostaglandin A1 and delta 12-prostaglandin
J2', Gynecol Oncol, 41: 36-40.
6) Hamilton, T. C. et al., 1984. 'Experimental model systems of ovarian cancer: applications to the
design and evaluation of new treatment approaches', Semin Oncol, 11: 285-98.
Andrew Bashford, Jim Cooper.
Scientific Development Group, Culture Collections, National Infection Service
Analysis of Drug Resistant Properties of A2780 Ovarian Cancer
Cell Lines Using Label-Free Automated Microscopy (IncuCyte ZOOM)
Drug Method
Time after
seeding
(hr)
IC50 values
A2780 (µM) A2780cis (µM) A2780ADR (µM)
Experimental IC50
Adriamycin
Cell number 120 0.007 0.016 0.070
Cell number
(DMSO normalised) 120 0.005 0.012 0.060
Confluence 72 0.004 0.023 0.071
Confluence
(DMSO normalised) 72 0.004 0.010 0.086
Range : 0.004 - 0.007 0.01 - 0.02 0.06 – 0.9
Published IC50 (Refs: 4, 5, 6)
Adriamycin Range: 0.01 - 0.1 - 1.6-710
Drug Method Time after
seeding (hr)
IC50 values
A2780 (µM) A2780cis (µM) A2780ADR (µM)
Experimental IC50
Cisplatin
Cell number 120 0.736 7.044 1.009
Confluence 72 0.438 7.812 0.997
Range : 0.4 - 0.7 7 - 8 1
Published IC50 (Refs: 1, 3, 5)
Cisplatin Range: 0.3 - 1.1 8-39 1.4
Adriamycin (doxorubicin) and cisplatin are frequently used cancer therapeutics which
interfere with DNA replication by different mechanisms. The A2780 series of ovarian
cancer cell lines are unique to The European Collection of Authenticated Cell Cultures
(ECACC) and its distributors. They have been effective in vitro tools for cancer
research for over 20 years(1,2).
A2780cis (ECACC 93112517) and A2780ADR (ECACC 93112520) (derivatives of A2780 (ECACC
93112519)) are resistant to cisplatin and Adriamycin respectively. They are useful in the
study of cancer biology and resistance to chemotherapies, enabling the search for new
treatments.
Drug resistance has been quantified in these cell lines using IC50 values; the dose of a
drug which causes a 50% inhibition in normal cell growth. The methods employed to
determine IC50 values often have different durations (4-21 days), they are labour
intensive and can yield inconsistent results(1-4).
Authenticated cell lines were provided from ECACC and grown
according to recommended instructions. Cells were seeded in 96-well
plates at densities of 3x104 cell/cm2 (A2780) and 1x104 cell/cm2
(A2780cis, A2780ADR) followed by addition of a drug dilution series.
• Cisplatin (P4394, Sigma) dissolved in PBS was diluted in media
(final well concentration: 500μM-0.001μM).
• Adriamycin (44583, Sigma) was dissolved in DMSO and diluted
in media, (final well concentration: 150μM-0.001μM). DMSO was
serially diluted in media to act as vehicle control.
Plates were incubated in the IncuCyte ZOOM (Essen BioScience).
Phase contrast images were obtained every two hours to provide data
for confluence determination. For cell number count, nuclear stain
Syto16 (S7578, Life Technologies) was added after 120 hours and
fluorescently imaged.
We used the two distinct parameters of confluence and cell count and
subsequent analysis using GraphPad Prism7 to determine IC50 values.
Adriamycin treatment was normalised using DMSO controls and no
difference was seen between IC50 values calculated using normalised or
raw values.
Table 1. IC50 values for A2780, A2780cis and A2780ADR (experimental and published data)
Fig 2) The IncuCyte
ZOOM is able to
accurately quantify
confluence and
nuclear count.
Representative images
from A2780 cells after
120 hr showing a)
phase data, b)
fluorescence of nuclear
stain Syto16. The
IncuCyte ZOOM trained
processing definition to
quantify c) percentage
confluence and d)
nuclear count as
number per mm2.
Scale bar: 70μm
Fig 1) The IncuCyte ZOOM
Fig 4) Cell number-
based IC50 values
show A2780cis and
A2780ADR have
higher drug
resistance than
parental A2780
cells. Error bars are
SEM generated from
6 (Adriamycin) or 8
(cisplatin) technical
replicates at each
drug concentration.
Fig 3) Confluence-
based IC50 values
show A2780cis and
A2780ADR have
higher drug
resistance than
parental A2780
cells. Error bars are
SEM generated from
6 (Adriamycin) or 8
(cisplatin) technical
replicates at each
drug concentration.
To independently characterise the cell lines and
investigate whether they have retained their drug
resistant properties, we developed a novel automated
approach using the IncuCyte ZOOM and a label-free
assessment of IC50 values. The study demonstrated a
proof of principle for the analysis of in vitro drug
resistance using cell lines.