renn v. utah : brief of appellantbrigham young university law school byu law digital commons utah...

Brigham Young University Law SchoolBYU Law Digital Commons

Utah Court of Appeals Briefs

1993

Renn v. Utah : Brief of AppellantUtah Court of Appeals

Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca1

Part of the Law Commons

Original Brief Submitted to the Utah Court of Appeals; digitized by the Howard W. Hunter LawLibrary, J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah; machine-generatedOCR, may contain errors.David A. Renn; Pro Se.Angela F. Micklos; Assistant Attorney General; Jan Graham; Attorney General; Attorneys forAppellee.

This Brief of Appellant is brought to you for free and open access by BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Utah Court ofAppeals Briefs by an authorized administrator of BYU Law Digital Commons. Policies regarding these Utah briefs are available athttp://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/utah_court_briefs/policies.html. Please contact the Repository Manager at hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu withquestions or feedback.

Recommended CitationBrief of Appellant, Renn v. Utah, No. 930796 (Utah Court of Appeals, 1993).https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca1/5693

en te r -. ,_, UTAH *^ ° ' G o y S S ° DOCUMENT (3<J^K)tst>K>yUTT\W. ^ M k 3 4-K F U 50 . - D A r g l W M 3 I S < , ( ^ H -.A10 MfPAk (A

, DOQKET NO. J L f L _ ± - L _ _ # - a g a - m

u r a u (imA-vr of appeals: o ^ f i ^ , o f TM*g (Mevic 7 MN 1 5 1994

gt^-o So^TU> S O P g=rf\3Tj 3 V u r g 4-QO <TftAT ( - K ^ - ^ ^-t VM ,> U ^ V . <2 M- I S3 A COURT OF APPEALS

T H fi^s'. R e - M ^ v g ' S P R T ^ o f UTF\U , (VftSQ. Mtt, M^^-CiA-,

T ) & f t v CAS.. U i f . l

F / U C - U ^ y . r l L

B Y I W F " IW ^oVwyiy, r . ^ QYi^f LNC ^ A ] V \ \ ^ Vy, T- ft4V\. (v ffM L i u a I JQ >4)>Vw 4-2 Vn g V~ ( I <£

flpp**U . 7 ^_

hAW r ( y ^ i TTETN2 ( ^ . ^ T ^ . N ^ n f fe !ntAy?a TJ>/ pf d j fUs VrC\ s -

<j<0<? <T N O V gYQYldg . . U i f \„OirL. , a L . A W Ltkv-pyVV) ^ Q V j flft£g

T"^ &*>UA pV-t^^vJ Titpx?- MV t T a \ r ^ ; p U o T t ^ c<^ p ^c ry <r } QV~ pVgj p ^ frTo c<o pg.-^: n f NM.U s_£ L g ^ L pAp«v^sr ajsisi ^ ^ ^ - 1 ^

a <^tK»q(^c pl\oT"o- h+Mj A\idv\rre>Q — O.^pu o£ \VH..I ^ftppfU G v f i g ^ F^>v ><?)w. T g typ>>v^g, (^"\\g J ^ i v ( >g^ \-irO T^^ -

• ^ i fiV)^VJ2,— g=T^"nTl O. gj Qfp\,^g C tO lr\y ^^, A {*_ t ^ o g ^ v u v,i^>y.v- C1. aucv

T Q C(

lVf\ ioW^-) a k i ? ) ^ F Q V i . U u . r T I M / . ) fM\)d C^K^SI cjg;rATUK>

^ ^ RTT^VKvg,^ TTM f T Q - ^ e

L\s r o f pav-iiss. i^vsivei \u

tar TUJZ- C«-*rw*L UTRL um-ednso^L fatiUru, itsf fe<AK>W<>SO^y CAYftt . . _ _

R S ^ t STTRt^"^ ftTVoVtoq w 6<2wQ,<»- & L . .

T^e>(^ o F CoNtgMTs_ Pft§<

TKfottf o f ftuTkoviTcss -CQSe^ ^tre-d , , X£_.

&H<L UTRU. ^ u ( ^ s of 6 w ( C R*o<i CriKiftOf\L -XX

ST^r-s-en^^T s ^ X s s u s s p y g s e ^ T s i o*/ ftp?^AL » . , ,. _ . £--3.

STT*T%<vt«-tov or Cas^ . . . _ ,. *f

{Vr ucv\<s§^4~Cs . — - g-<Mo .... U&e/Rva-v TVv^SixTkDlsTViCT" & u * T WAS (WskY'

JK cWouuoa "RSMU<SX PsTcnoM UilTW)UT (\o(ckwo<j £\

kefw\«a o r ^v-ovicutoa V O V I T T ^ fuOc(uo«s of fflkX^ .Bvici CbNclvASVows o f .UW- fis Veaawre d t>u __ ..vm(e- o f CiviC f H t ) t ^ u x ^ - V a ( ^ t s s . ( t ) d a . ) .

He.S0\uTl0K). O f ( S ^ U ^ S USS U\Tk "TUCS F W Y T -

\ ' - SysL

L o c \ . •,>*•% V.OV^ L

• F e f e K f t H c l E z '" ' ^ v 'OQ^ r « u ^ • •<- • ^ , . _ , i& 'A , . - I I -

U.S. HK>X) KKXU\S C^tosT^. ^lV^HDS, SmTuXfes,

£^i

JL

•Jt-34'S-

v * i « H ^ r 0 * ! mmm

° ^ ^ ' ^ Hi Ttts UraU ( W r OF ftppeals

STRTe: O F UTT\tt

UTAH COURT or AffERLS

Case Vfo-.teom-dft. .._ CftVec\ow No,_3_*

T ^ ^ L F O F Ryf^LLfiN"r

/

- -Coo^ss Usw ,A)MLD A. fe^M, \u: pvo-se: ; Ytas" fttovn:

Ttaor ke. is (D&IMO uul^wiFaLLu V^esTV-aitoeci OF Cos

SKH^<ZX& J lovj F\re.c£e\Mc(£ V ^ "Dev-- \fs2_\XTy S W f e

TKi^ a p p e a l is Ff.ocv. & cU<oif\U of & p e r m o o _.. FaV 00>Ko&ci\^?w-L4 ~RelWF • TTu-S COVJW-V h<\s SXCtuS(V€

. cJ UY i s. du e n QN3 To V\ea\r T^us Ap^>s(\L faV5af\w"C "B__

UTfck 1?*a« of (\ppeLLftTs .fVoCeci^ve. —^wW^f (appeal

R s oC_ « J J U T 5 ; A«4ci .UT»(X- Ruts: o f 6ivi*L p ^ o ^ J l u f e r

/

o r (\pf^-l(ev^T3 (no"noO Fov- &*o ^V j dThrift<o-w

F w i m a s of F K ^ T ' Rtod C^)^c(asio<as of Woo f\s__

C w c T OVclor-s; , U)toe»\--<L- \T l ^ j e f f e t r STTNTSSi

Tks, CourT ^ R C L stores fTioitwo^ or Ff\c/T ANJO _

CoK)C\usit>K2s of l^vOifts Appvopv-iar^, FoC(joioA(o«y ._

cHs^>osmY«=: fvvor\oto , _ _

c&s-s, ^3 TVUL s^xru- ^KsVHtY Cowr cTwcW. "DON V^

T^ f cC t ^ TUL_ Tv-mC COVA^TJS ev-votoeovts _

. kc^s -p - r ^ to t ^ o(^ ftppsiUtovs / ^ ^ U K of ^ CONTSST

To ft T H ^ ° ^ a CVCivi^ To W i r ^ ^ ^ - S r l A u a U T e Y - ^ ..

. T t aT CoUitU- U L <ftc£ K o r Co.M<vuT. X K s T e ^ d y fl-S

KoTs"c( Us> TU_ I D I S T V J O T COUNTS ^ C o u ^ r ov-cL^v-

..OF cL^sw^Sf tC^ TLz_ C J U J Q ^ " SlMftvv p i cked . ..jUOd.,

~CUoo.se.cI UiUfcL O U T .cf T V J ^ SIX OV S O CtfUMS.O

AM Uus d i s r \ i s ^ ^ L o f appeiUoT-s p^enTioo For

PVoCer(iv.vx2- Fov K D l s T f t n V C O V A V T ~R> Q"D ^ /

. TuTttM^TOir or Tu^ easts

&).. "Ous Cases R \MS«S FTOK TW SixTk.. DtsTYitr toufcT^-

d^swvss^L OF TU* f\pp«u.Mori f€xms*o f*<c ocr^aQ^d^^ Veli^F puvsui\«oT To Ru(e: £>S 6 , SUlos. Ct) GU> ^

(A)« APP«LLP\K>'F is ( H C W C S V - R T S J I ivr Tu. £ ^ o T K t

(j>), owVW afcuuf ftuou^v l i > , H H 3 . Tk*L Pet i r ioO

. tTur tag :Doto V,TTbUs«TW f e x m ^ O U a s GPUpTiotoed

pule £ s s , (ft) W^oto^Fu.L XMpv-lsoO^^NtV^ Of). T k c P«-nVrfttO V-fU:S«d f\ P t e t k o ^ A O F ._

TKeTT Tke. ftppsCU^ri ^ p c i * oFTCo^r^rr -^ To c

f^(otoM) ; \K) Vi^ tan^ fO o F 7t~>S.-.Z..o5 (u ' rn l^— C*<U,GUQN7, Cl°\^o^)Cof\^ iWVAlfJ 0 ^ \Xs Face-

F a \ \ e d To. <l<$(np(v/j WtTK- -ga i t s - -11 . OF T X R _

UT&L, RvAl r Of C V ^ W V O A L p ^ C ^ c ^ v ^ ^ S u b SecnfoUS

0&) Ci ) Ajod ( 5 ) of ^ s e r i o O 3 OF TuVs M m -

STANDARD OF RtaV(^\A/

"TW So l« . IS-SIA^" ato ^pp€.ftL_ IS U)lvxTKjOr "Wis:

KeasntOa o^r fn>v\ditO<i W Y I T V ^ K " R*oa.\to«.s: Of f r o

Rud COMCIU.S\ON>-S o r Law fts tovAivei Lvi ..flats: __&£. cLyi L P\TOC^3CLUY<£ — Vu\^ i o S 6 . Suios, ( t } Ci_) ,__

..of UTnL RcAi^ of* CiviC PvoCs^ave.-tali*. &SS* Tkis.

. .ci«Te.\r(AJtoanoO fv - -e3eMT^ f\ 9 (A^STl t )0 o f LAW

. 1^4- ) (T^*nwflj 6e.YrlsU. v*' BftRNKss, 8<f<f f. %d

..Cook, ^ £ 3 p.<ai ^H*7 (fuVTUi U g Q i 6fl^casTH6.v s '

_ XW &&£. iT(ot^ j "TW f\ff elLKTVs teVt e W S"m^<i KV- d

S&r ftvTW u r B^<oc(u ^ C D e l f u o c L ? ^ fVj J ^ 3 , ^ 0 5

. ^ f s L L ^ r s f<rr\T^o u^dev Rule- £s 6 , (V) CL)> U/rrt<!ou F U ^ M , Fa\r(u ; k >cL TWjLvefor . (to cUf etodetoTtu V<2.V(<3UM*0cr

.£Atl~ ^ TU. f\ffeiU»oT5 S^x tUir/us of" b£i<0>a dewia

d a ^ PY^ci^3_s of Lf\vo uOcW TW. fbu.vTes'NTU^._

. ( \n^Ndcv\«uf OF T W IUCHTEFCI .STTFflps-S Ut^s-nrocTXoto (!

covA-v-r ^v-ie-v A(^5(v\t^sieoo f\ppsLCftoT-£ p e r m o O ^ K .. ._..

^^(Ap\vA b ^ U s t a s c i O V ^ a p p s t U o T S £A*\t|VV_S bu. _

. .pick/too. f\»jA CUoojsitoa C^rrTFttrO Clf\((AS" o f T l o ^ -

. .RppsLuvioT-s peJrmsiO To Vevi^v/O ftwJy^v ftddre^S

..fUod Tta.K) WVTwitfa oTkiLX^: TTv f\T \/OVuc.L TLs^— -

...App-e.\UuT Wad \rai>s^c( ^fbv-<2_. Tloc t?^v sf Uis CoaH-r. XK" F<\t.T> LL Tk^T" JUcL^r "D^K) V.Ti bias's^ S t ^ w ^ d C w v r o v c k N - d t s M t s s i w a RppnCLatoT-s

p ^ T \ r \ o ^ ; {if\s To 6 A M ftbouT f\pf^LLfMoT^3 C(ai^^

o^> b«.iK?o aLUuoedl "Tb ^ K i T e v ftO INVfth'l. f(e.A

uWic-tv VSL cL{<L Mtr COMMIT", To coir: Vifttosfawslasty l S TK eO" Q £ Tk*- FQ U o u) Cto <J STaT^c/ i^ K>TS I

_ ' ' T W V*«.c*vJ \W 6v<MitOfcL C R S ^ : KUA/lbsJr l3lT_-=-

. f e f t s ' t T ^ ft WtoOWi*^ ftvid VoU^TRV-vj pUsA bu

TW cWfss*oc£?s T> TV* T ^ T W C ^ ^ F ^ N C ^ - F w a s - -fuUvJ A«Lvis^c£ <te To T W p s V ^ T m L S»0*feW^

J\v/A T^^TTkcre . U(\s ^QJMVT' HO Qe:(v\o^sr\r-^s .n

-Viot&tiW of - t-o^sr(ruriDK)f\L Ho(\Ts\ u^-WoTs*

Ik

C(MM>S K^d fVrra^^cA 5uf>fQv-T(v-sL. ^VICCHIOC,^ , (/Of\s fl

e ^ r r o g e ^ u s , Uftseci , ato A a*o ftkuJUL of7 dKstv^YiON)

..COSAYT^ ^VcU-Y- d i i N U ^ s n o a f\p£«lUo"Cs ^ e T I T l o O UXTUDVT

^^ ^AeqLVH^T ..Vev^«v>o of apfcUtticnrs Cl*Mtv\.s_ of io«.\toa c U w i g d i d u e PVorp^C of L*\0O U *YVJ _ T V W L -

..C<5UvY>lvQ adde.?Y\tOc| hus. fk-K Qf K>0 NuTesT TO MfUvJSlAuftVi

(*CT). ftpf^llftwT F i l e d (ru^ ^ N ^ n ^ e <0F flppsftL* UO

...Tkis MavreV' og tft)Ve<nbev- <23yciy \ ^ 3 , d«sWf\Tito_fr -...

07% af f^LL^or FlUdt U s ^ D o t k s r i ^ a SWsMetfi

A*oA RTTHC-WCVUUOT^ oto O atoufvV'v.i 3 ^ / ( ^ 1 ^ - , ...

•Summ^v-v] or RVawvuZNT

ftS Mc£(CfVr«d ft(oW«_,Tke_ f l p p e l U o T U x o . fcWT^tfck

C w s r i r u T i o u a L \MQU~T5 CCfcL(eA (A* S» Cstosr : 0(W^c( —

- C g * 3 S T l T U * n o * O S Q f W t ^ V T S pV-OVlSlOtO O f l k c _

Ct>vA\r of L<\wj b u r f\^ U/eLL U^X CWMTSCIL . TW.

fr(n*s^<i<niiAj>-f YutvTS Tb h*w«- bus.. S T J V T ^ pe.TTrtoNfcs* C\f\fM»!

COVETS Actafr<\(o c_»- of (\(s '"pfe^ of NJO C ^ T S S T V / y 1

"TVJLWV. La-foY^Z, T V A , S u T k T X S ' m e T £<D^VT l<0 Wis . p«.TlX10*C

( \ T T < ^ k \ t o q T U A Yf*U d L t r u O f Wis- pl<2* &.F. NO . . . £WfesX

To TV*. «L(j^«.dl C V \ M ^ <af (W^(K)s(f\u.«UT'e,V; bettoa (KYfluc

0\0 I T S Ff\fc.e_, p f t vncu i f vn ivy Ovo Tk&, ^V-ouOols T h f t T ' _

R p p ^ L C ^ ^ T ^ "TViaL cLfe*^s-e fWoYtoeu o f R^c*>^d wfta

devVlwd TWx- f\p$>enfWC bus fco^STtTUTto^ftL :SlXTI*

f \ M ^ H d m ^ ) r V u l T Tb V<2.C*svv^ e f f eC iT ' lV^ - . . A ( d / 0

AssisTfttoCi-ar o^ Covno,se\ IK" fvis fUUv^itOg R f f e((fv&oT"

To EYrov \*0 e.toTe,v»toa (f\! r p U * of '^> £otft%sX^

To <\ T^P^ *>F A KoMCc cLe- of M ^ S I A ^ I V T C Y - C Y W l S "

TWKT Oo(v(fc.tu T U . Rf^«2.((f\to-T dlc£ MOT CwtVUT j f\tO<L

r^vTk jOr T ^ A T Afbv<2-.£>McI C L L ^ P ^ - X I . ftTTQvroe(/| SF

Af^esLt-KuT kfevxsei F ; " H A T U - UXVS ^ ( N ) N 0 ( 1 < S K ) T N N O f

d e , v « 2 - FeUtovj MAiO^(pvU3hT€-V'/, iN" V?o(f\T(OK) OF

^ k - S - ^ O S , U*m^v £<3cU ftKlfCK C ^ O - E b t M O B B M

cLlsuMssitoQ f \ p f € ( I ^ K > " r ^ fe-TVnaO y CU*\r(y.._>Skoej£

T k ^ T TW.. 5 0 O V " X > ( s T a V r Cwv-T OV Tluz_ STATS" S _

IVrr.QH-to.eM Mevev Vcv i ^v^ed ONT . HcLAyQS^e<L_E\T^y

Of T k ^ a p f e U ( \ « T i ftio<»v<2.- d1sfcvss««i T\OT» AV3TTOCLT '

o^ C^uvj-s-el fttoci G O T K A V Tkx. T M V L CTUci<3^ [\(\l

f a \ l ed To C^Mflu lo\Tk- \h*l« 1 1 , <Suks<2.cYtoiO ( a j

O ^ »sTf t i> U s k\'*o a « FftfcTuAL b f t s u s OF AppeKk^T.

_To TVJL S W U S . (aU^3Ji4 &Yme o f ^ C ^ ^ U u a k T e ^ Y

.- - "UjLYcFov^TkjL. Rff-e(!<\PT IOLST^CD^ Ve^o^^TS" TfoKf"

TkU ^ ^ r v^^FH^d Wts Cass- Tt> °TW SIXT^IMSTCK

.. (VppeA) c?v*oT Cou\i b ^ fttU. To CLLV^U P-O_ a V"<e<lovcl—.. .o*a TKJL £la\<ws Qf TVs*, ftpf ^U(\«or,s R>r TKW d o w n f To Wvi^vJy o v , ^Xf\MJ«o-s- A,«1 Tkos ft depress • ._

.y AffslU^-Cs X53VAS3 RPUS^LD >ro APPEAL

^\vi L C a s e HO, 1 £ 1 : L C^Ar^-ci TUx. lil*p ^AOI of <3\AIU

Uotoor,W)<\s X c ( o ^ ' T V-<2 Pk(jL Q<ou pUusicAC- (SioTftlT

-flpfeLu^^-r" Uias TgCLi a. _ TU*. TVi&C O u J ^ TU T""'. _ LSL. a I d MW V e < i<2_ TA t .QXL. _ &ts) MTU t o a R Jo 9 v\T" h «Vi rs? a._ ._

FiailcAY . To ^Mpiwi STV-ICU^M UMT*~ "RUis: i i _ ItO

C^ussy to A MfOffiav- o r Luw/y Fsv T\*. loiTk-av-fU-OflC

OF TkKT p U t f \ \ U?<TK. Tk*- App*5((MoT~i CFVS3.fltO.cL

.tus C(A\(WS o f TU_ U n ^ T Y m L t a w F s FKclMYie Tc

S u t s « t T l ^ ^ ( f c^ ^ * 0 ^ u ^ Q ^ l K l ftt^pTTcOtt _.

(\pp«LU\tOTi- ^ f ( « * o r Ko d o N T e - s r ^ To Tkx^r..__

T U . T r \ W - C ^ w c 0 ^ FfulvAvx^ To ^ S T f t l o t u s k - R

F f t t T M ^ l L e ^ i s ON? v e c o v c i o r TV*- Rpp<dIf \*oV"3

.AVAAW t h r o v e acc^pTU^o (r\u f U & q f N? &)K>T^T

Tku.-s„ I f is tCaiO Tka~ ApfeWMJTs Cs toT^T IoO

T K « r TKcs C o c o r i ^ C a ^ o T ^xarv \ \K)^ : T W ^r€.tov-d 01

TKfi. .s ' lxTk. 7 D i s * m c T COCAV-T-S F ^ V (\ (oasis T o

k F f v v - f ^ "Out- ^ ) X fk . T>LSTcit-Y~ COCAVT^ OV-dUy oF

CILSCVU-SSKL^ OF kT,s f e r r r i ^ fov extW\\>f\c!ufco<\v-u

R M m f ; t e c a u s s - Qs I T S B ^ d s t c ^ v - e - T k T . s _ _

Cowf-r Toc(f\vjy Tke-r^ |,s KO Y-ecovd FONT This tesAYT'"'-

.Xo-.V3.YieW 0TW2.V- TVifctO. f l p p e l U i o v i ^ K s f i W of flffeftl

*..c£c>.fck«T\N>a -STftT^M^toV f\tO cL ITS (\VCf\&i\.MsuJ^S%) ~— . J ) ) ' ' r

y * l * W * _ - _ _ - - •:_ _. r Tk^eR>v-'e-j T W . N « E d . F©v Tv*« ^ ixTk-DtSTV- f t X _

y

. (k EXAwivOi toq /o r A d d v e r s i i o a ACL o r Tk^sr ......_

..App«LC*aT\s CUKYLS IK) Uts (pexmoo f bv EKTV^oV-dmN

^ e d ^ ^ W b e A ^ a ftVt'^Voe-d To etoTev ft^ INVftUd /pte.

o r ^ o Cotofdsxr ^ Tb °n\£~ ^Vime - Q ^ ^f\»osUualiYe.r

w k \ t L - (s A Tup42_ ^f= a <tvwvs Tk-c\V tOhicL- Tk-£— -

..ftpp^LLfctoT d i d WoT & M M V T . A?od a s "ftsL. Appe((/\ioT

UPVS f \ v « w e d Ivvs Cas-C TkrocActlvouT' TK^te COViTT^Q

f?\QjL^ o r V\us AP£<ZKL Cv-i^r iT Oof s G.rro^- Ebv „ T W S\XTVV X ) \STV \CT COIAYV^S TVmC oUcUo, To -

e * > t / . / J / _

. . d i s m i s s APP<3>CC*MT"^ PeVlTTOK) U5\TkouY~ F \TST^

... <o\r<=it=?viua Atf e v i d ^ w T l ^ v j h£AY^K><7 OtO Tta^ ufVlNIS V t u s e d uo T U - Appe l la to rs f e n T i o t o W fttordAwe.^:

Aud HSfeaiftCCu o« FOUO<AMP<( pro p e r P r o c i ^ d w e , IK)

review?i toa Rppe(lf\K)T\s peHTVgtC) pw*5uf twV T o

*Sod*;s>sfc"rt<Jias (%) Cs<aaviV-B <*r peTvrnws^) C^)(|esfnK):six

. . fUf tc£( to< is" ) Ato<A A s W)^LL 1(0 ACdoV* C(RVO t e R ^ ( s (>£

Sub-Sv u o ) i\*oi CliJ) Cotoe<tv-tO\^Q /£ouv-T"0^deRSN___

U ) U X < L i r S T A T E S TkfOT* ^Tta- W n \ L Cw+r si**LL-

£LUTe.V FuodlNJa-S- OF . . .FfifcXAtfd CotOClw^ioiOs: JQF U l

L)Ufc.L- UJPuS NoV .CoMplvsrd OotTZ^ o r do«o£, tv^ .Tkn-^.._

d^scA\ss\M<i apps-LL^oT"^ p e n ^ o t o . BK)d .un.Yko.ur

/ '

C l e a n s - 6 f t>euo<j cLewiwd. due? P r o c e s s oF LPKVO b

T k « T \ n * L £o^v-r\ XWSTsaa. ._ix: Apfe^v^s:(ta__Ho*—

ftp^llp^Tj^ p U ^ i u ^ a s <\*o.c{ a s U> CL.. TIOL S(XT&v—

D W I L T C O U V T ^ ^ov-dcV^N d - i s w i s s i w o AfpaLlRfoT-

M<L <\s> to^LL \to nor FuUwy F a w l u , <wl Tk*vs-F©v.e_

. (^«LLFVWTS CIACOOS.. Ot/" TVx. TVlftL CoWFS -: -—

' / ' p i * * o r KO 6 o i o T s s r ^ To PS J^P*- ^ ^ CY.fi\*_.. T W T wU^cLs- U*- citd Ko*r CoM(v\(ryTV\*\T'Tkx-

U l U C t L rLS f\W lSJSU,<^~ T h a T - S h o u l d hfW<L (ai2J2 (O

£o^s idev^< i low TU- S\KTK_ T)(svc\tY CQUYT' oUc^e "Poo v, TikU^, U r coas tOoT" I gg^jCo^MMA vs> -

.1*1*7 p.ad loa^ (wcfck l ^ m ) ; awd Iftuftftsreg1* dookj _.(61tr.uT>^ [<\z%) 153 f.^ci 5\?s, ss>G'>..(viftrrfKez.y^-'-

5Mtrw. ; 6o.a f . a i 7 * ^ 1 0 2. (fuTHL 1^7^) C ^ ^ ^ 3

Af-P-eLLAT^r. COCA -TS- k^vs- .Foufod... UUUSWf\ L-...

0<si "TVs' t ^ ^ ^ ^ s W^av-e, "Hou V^fc^wsl U>f\X (t^ftc

To A«Te.v-rvuto«r U)keTW- TU- peTirtOtoeV- Utf<N"feioTto£>f

P ( « * A * < i S U U T M To A 6(<vMge kurkev " H A O CV*_ H a <£_..-"

( w T s H t i ^ c i fMoi F f t \ \ s ^ To a p p e A l L?€.caoSi2_ g p _

r ^ cr f ^ J

X d . ( \T ?, 5 o G ,

>tiCAU-S^O

/ / / tKSTV i o r " &oCAVT" Rs v- ft * j e v i c(s K>T( psv vy\ vu W i ro a

OK) Wis CUIC/LJ o r TVA-TV-iftC C o ^ T ^ (H-ewf\vrrM / ' t ' /r , A' J (W TVc Vecs^TtotO o f In us pl<2A SF K ) COfOTSST

To.. ft T^ fe r of f\ dV'tMe' " T ^ A T to(ue,L tut. clidt Ho"

CocA^Wy To U i i v : M & o s U a a k T - e - T , (to V to lM lo tO

"X>ATeX>! MftM 3 i S T "y ( ^ H ^ - .

.. <fiW-Sf><L&TFu I (U SuloM J TTEcl >

IE Ivsuv- - vj C^vnFv/i Th^T oto-s "TVu"© pWorocop^

l o a s CAfM I® d , ^ S T ^ S " fv<2.pM A , T o S X r o n s Qssis JteXo*.*o<LM Q<2 eoe V l\ L _ ( \Kis la fT JYu £. W (*s , fcr~ £3-G

ftrrov-voeu Fow R«s3pQ»o d^roT^ This (M*\u 3 t ^ i M l f

/s/ a

GRNN(st i<o ; UTftU SHG34-

3 ^ V / " ^ h

^

3 ^ TMer iiTftii C O U R T O F APP^AIST /O

0>avUD f^-Rcttm,

permo^cNy^AfpeiLAfjT/

Srpons OF u raW , Rggp«ts><(gNT/ftPPgLk

B v u s F OF ftppgLLflMY~

&?p«.ftL F\K>r A d^NfAL OF A P e n r t o t O .fo\r

Tkx. i i > , dftu O F A u g u s r 1 ^ 3 , iff TW_ SiXTU. -

Couuru, s r a r ^ OF araW^fWo^U^ 0a<£ r < ^

~OoW V. Tth-ksr, pves t^ iKig ®

. ftss (STRUT" fttTovwu £fe«ev<>vL _«?. 3_.G s xir\r& C a > ITO L _>Sa LTT_ U k e C ixs/j {AT. %.!* iiH-

* *

p o , 8 o * 53"0

GwtO'UoM, ttTfcVu 2 H 3 H

P s~\ r^ r\ t