grandfathers, cogs and bots
Post on 30-Oct-2014
268 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Grandfathers, cogs and bots:Learner choices for designs of companion agents
EDMEDIA, 25th June, 2013
The Shift
• Aimed at NEETs – not in education employment or training
• Ravensbourne based in Greenwich, London, Creative and Media Industries
• Courses will pull OER content together• Website constructed from widgets, profile
info, badges, social networks, drag and dropped between public and private spaces
The bot
• Bot is an autonomous interactive program, interactive and social - aka companion agent. Can be text only, can be situated in a 3D virtual world (when it is an embodied companion agent).
• Distinct from an avatar in that avatar refers only to a digital representation of a human although Nowak, K.L. and Biocca, F. (2003) found that people don’t distinguish.
• Previous research indicates learning effectiveness relates to affinity to avatar
The research
• User-centred design ethos• Four workshops– Learners design a series of bot images– Learners vote on these and discuss the pros and
cons– Learners trial the bot and give initial responses– Learners use website and bot and we assess
learning.
What do you think?
1. Really very bad2. Dislike it 3. Meh4. It’s OK5. It’s excellent
Second Thing
So, what should it be able to do?• Must have• Should have• Could have• Would be nice if …
How realistic should it be?
1. Like an outline cartoon?
2. Like a detailed cartoon
3. Like an outline photo
4. Like a realistic photo
Anthropomorphism and realism
Low detail High detail
Low anthropomorphic
1 10
High anthropomorphic
2 3
Methodology
• Attributed a score for each response on Lykert scale, then ranked the designs
• Removed those where responses indicated additional elements associated with factors outside of appearance were having effect
• Grouped them according to degree of realism and anthropomorphism.
Anthropomorphic realistic appearance
• Photorealistic facial features.
• High appearance realism.
• High behaviour realism.• High presence.• Very low rated.• UNCANNY.• Scored 6
Anthropomorphic non-realistic
• Facial features.• Nuanced personality.• Medium appearance
realism.• High behaviour.• High presence.• Medium rated.• DISTRACTION.• Score 8 - 14
Non-anthropomorphic realistic
• Facial features.• Nuanced personality• Low appearance realism.• High behaviour realism.• Medium presence.• Very highly rated.• ENGAGING (BUT NOT
TOO MUCH)• Score 16 – 21 points
Non-anthropomorphic non-realistic
• Facial features.• No or simple personality.• Low appearance realism.• Low behaviour realism.• Low presence.• Low rated.• UNENGAGING• Score 6 -7 points
Functionality
• Ranking of functionality– Highest: Student tracking and info, personality– Upper mid-range: interactivity– Lower mid-range: growth and change– Lowest: Customisability– Negative: Ability to speak
• In third workshop– Students reiterated usefulness over personality– Wanted control over turning personality on and off
Conclusions
• Students did not want to sacrifice any usability for “fun” factors
• Students wanted behavioural and design realism as long as it was not anthropomorphic (the Uncanny Valley lives).
• There is an optimum level (from the learners’ perspective) of social presence in bots, too much and they are not engaging, too little and they are distracting.
Further work
• Need to test learners’ perspectives against actual learning effectiveness
• Ideally would work with a design team and larger learner base to create range of designs, altering the separate variables, to identify which factors are influencing affinity, presence and preference.
Further reading
• Nowak, K.L. and Biocca, F. (2003) The Effect of the Agency and Anthropomorphism on Users’ Sense of Telepresence, Copresence, and Social Presence in Virtual Environments, Presence, Vol. 12, No. 5, October 2003, 481–494
Authors
Mark Childs mark@markchilds.orgAcademic lead: presence
Anna Peachey anna@annapeachey.co.ukAcademic lead: learning pathways
Lizzie Jackson lizzie.jackson@rave.ac.uk Principle Investigator
Phil Hall phil.hall@elzware.com Programmer, lead designer
top related