etw physics ceworkshop2018 - indico-fnal (indico)...alex sousa, jae yu high-e/nucleon decay lisa...

PhysicsAnalysis

ElizabethWorcester,BNLSPTPCElectronicsWorkshopJuly18,2018

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 1

Topics

•  DUNEsimulaGonandsensiGvitytools•  protoDUNEanalysis

Message:AbilitytodophysicsanalysesistheulGmateperformancerequirement.Physicseffortislimited.TheconsorGummodelreliesonanalysiseffortfromtheconsorGaincollaboraGonwiththephysicsworkinggroups.

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 2

OrganizaGon

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 3

High-levelcoordina0onPhysicsWorkingGroups

RyanPaTersonDeputy:ElizabethWorcester

FarDetectorSim/RecoAlexHimmel,ChrisBackhouse,TingjunYang

NearDetectorMikeKordosky,SteveManly

Long-BaselineMaTBass,DanCherdack,MaylySanchez

BSM/Exo0cAlexSousa,JaeYu

High-E/NucleonDecayLisaKoerner,GregPawloski,VitalyKudryavtsev

Low-E/SNνInesGilBotella,KateScholberg,AlexFriedland

CalibraGonsTaskForce:SowjanyaGollapinniKendallMahn

protoDUNEAnalysisGeorgiosChristodoulou,TingjunYang

DUNEAnalysis•  GEANT4beamsimulaGonofupdatedbeamdesign•  FullLArSo_MonteCarlosimulaGon

–  GENIEeventgenerator–  GEANT4parGclepropagaGon–  DetectorreadoutsimulaGonincludingGarfield-basedwaveformsandwhitenoise

•  Automatedsignalprocessingandhitfinding•  Toolsexisttostudy

–  Missing/badchannelsdistributedthroughoutthedetectorrandomly,bychip,byFEMB

–  Impactofreduceddri_field–  Impactofchangesinwhitenoiselevel

•  ToolsinprogresstostudymoresophisGcatednoisemodel(exponenGal+coherentnoise)

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 4

PrimaryOscillaGonAnalysis•  AutomatedenergyreconstrucGon

–  Muonmomentumfromrange(contained)ormulGpleCoulombscaTering(exiGng)

–  Electronandhadronenergyfromcalorimetry•  EventselecGonusingconvoluGonalvisualnetwork(CVN)•  OscillaGonanalysisusingCAFAnafifngframework

–  SharedframeworkwithNOvA•  ReweighGngtoolsforsensiGvityanalysisinprogress

–  OpGontousesimpleCDR-stylesystemaGcsexistsnow–  AnalysisincludingNDfitalsoinprogress

•  ResultsshownatNeutrino2018achieve/surpassCDR-levelsensiGvity

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 5

DUNEMCAnalysisResultsCDR New!

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 6

DUNEMCAnalysisResults

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 7

BadChannelsStudies•  Workinprogress•  SomeiniGalresultsshowninAPAconsorGummeeGng:

hTps://indico.fnal.gov/event/16642/contribuGon/1•  Resultsavailablefor5%and25%badchannelsrandomlydistributed•  MCsamplescreatedfor5%and25%badchannelsbychipandboard•  StudyaddressesonlyenergyresoluGon&CVNeventselecGonefficiency

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 8

5%

25%

RandomBadChannels:Results

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 9

MissingenergycorrecGon: Efficiencyresults(inclcutopGmizaGon):

DUNENucleonDecay•  Protonandneutrondecay

sensiGvitystudiedusingMVAanalysisofDUNEMC–  Primarybackgroundfrom

atmosphericνµinteracGonsisverychallenging

–  Proton/kaonPIDforshorttracksanimportanthandle

–  p→KνanalysissubgroupstarGngnow

•  N-NbaroscillaGonsensiGvitystudiedusingdeeplearningbasedanalysisofDUNEMC

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 10

DUNESNBNeutrinos•  MARLEYeventgenerator•  Low-energysignal:

–  5-100MeV•  Workongoingto

improveeventreconstrucGonandselecGon–verydifferentfromhigh-energytracksinotherphysicsgroups

•  DAQ/Triggeringforsupernovaburstveryimportant:eventsarrivein10sburstwithmuchofthephysicsoccurringinfirst0.1s

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 11

40 kton argon, 10 kpc

Time (seconds) 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25

Even

ts p

er b

in

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80 Infall Neutronization Accretion Cooling

No oscillationsNormal orderingInverted ordering

40 kton argon, 10 kpc

DUNESimulaGon30.25-MeVν

protoDUNE@Neutrino2018

•  SuccessesachievedsofaratprotoDUNEwereahighlightofDUNE’sNeutrino2018show–peopleweresurprisedandimpressed!

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 12

protoDUNEAnalysis•  ForphysicsTDR,protoDUNEanalysiswillbeusedto

validateMonteCarlosimulaGonusedforsensiGvitystudies•  UlGmateproofthatdetectorworksisactuallydoingphysics

analysis•  protoDUNEanalysisgroup(DRA=DetectorReconstrucGon

andAnalysis)addressesanalysisatalllevelsfromdataprocessingtocalibraGontophysicsresults–  Newanalyzersatalllevelsverywelcome!

•  Followingslidesareprimarilyli_edfromTingjun’scollaboraGonphonecallpresentaGon–thanksTingjun!–andrepresentasnapshotofthecurrentstatusofprotoDUNEanalysis.

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 13

AnalysisGoals

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 14

Short-termgoals–detectorperformance

Deadchannels,noisychannelsNoiselevel,signaltonoiseraGoElectronlifeGme

Medium-termgoals–detectorresponse

dE/dxofpions,protons,kaons,electronsEnergyandmomentumresoluGons

Long-termgoals–crosssecGons

InclusivepioncrosssecGonExclusivechannels–chargeexchange,etc.

InformaGonforDUNEphysicsTDR

PhysicspublicaGons

T.Yang

DAQ

Raw Data

Deconvoluted Data

Reconstructed Data

Calibrated Data

Detector Performance and Physics Analysis

Raw data decoding

Noise filtering, Stuck codemitigation, Deconvolution

Hit finding, DisambiguationPMA, Pandora, WireCell, PD, CNN

Space Charge EffectsdQ/dx and dE/dx calibration

protoDUNEDRAOrganizaGon•  DRA–DetectorReconstrucGonandAnalysis•  DRALevel1–overallresponsibilityoncodedevelopment

andorganizinganalysiseffort–  T.Yang(FNAL)–  G.Christodoulou(CERN)

•  DRALevel2–  ReconstrucGon–L.Whitehead(CERN)–  DQM–M.Potekhin(BNL)–  CalibraGon–M.Mooney(CSU)–  Analysis–S.Bordoni(CERN)

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 15

WeeklymeeGngonWednesday9:30amFermilabGme,4:30pmCERNGmeMailinglist:dune-proto-sp-dra@fnal.gov

T.Yang

RawDataDecoding•  OfflineRawDecoderModulesarebasedonthosewriTenfortheOnline

MonitoringbyJingboWang,ToninoSergi,PaoloFranchini,PatrickTsang,andPhilipRodrigues.RCEunpackingcodefromJJRussell.FELIXoverlaysbyMiloVermeulen.Rawdecoder:convertrawdatatolarso_analyzableformatChannelmap:convertonlinechannelnumbertoofflinechannelnumber

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 16

Rawdecoder Channelmap

TPC(RCE) Exists VerifiedbychannelIDdata

TPC(FELIX) Exists VerifiedbychannelIDdata

Photondetectors(SSP) Exists IniGalversionexists

Timing InpreparaGon

Triggers(CTB,CRT) InpreparaGon InpreparaGon

T.Yang

DataQualityMonitor•  ConGnuetodevelopDQMpayloads-George

Christodoulou,TomJunk,BruceBaller,DavidAdams–  Alreadyavailable:TPCmonitor,hitmonitor,SSPmonitor,electronlifeGme,signaltonoiseraGo,eventdisplay

–  Inprogress:CRTmonitor,triggermonitor,beamlineinstrumentaGonmonitor

•  ConGnuetoimproveDQMinfrastructure–MaximPotekhin–  Upgradedpayloadscriptsforthe"DQMmonitor”toincludeXROOTDstagein,stageoutandtheROOTmacrotoproducethegraphics(PNGs).

–  WorkingtobuildtheUIforefficientaccesstoalltheplotsfromtheDQMwebpages.

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 17

T.Yang

CalibraGon•  ADCCalibraGon–seeD.Adamstalk•  SpaceChargeEffect

–  Data-drivencalibraGonnecessaryforsurfacedetector

–  SimplesimulaGonandsimulaGonwithargonflowmodelexist(Mooney,Voirin)

•  CRT-matchedtracksprovidevaluableinformaGonfordetectorcalibraGon–  FinalizeCRTframeposiGons–  Updategeometry(MarGnTzanov)–  ImplementCRTsimulaGoninLArSo_

(AndrewOlivier)–  MatchTPCinformaGonwithCRT

informaGon(ArbinTimilsina)• 

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 18

T.Yang

CalibraGonwithCosmics•  Similarproceduredeveloped

byMicroBooNE:MicroBooNE-NOTE-1048-PUB(2018).

•  dQ/dxcalibra0onusingthrough-goingmuons–completewithMC–  Removespa0alandtemporal

variaGonsindetectorresponse–  CalibraGonconstantsarebeing

uploadedtodatabasebyJonPaley

•  dE/dxcalibra0onusingstoppingmuons–inprogress–  Determineabsoluteenergyscale

usingmuonstoppingpower

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 19

0 100 200 300 400 500 600Z Coordinate(cm)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Y C

oord

inat

e(cm

)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

plane_2_negativeX

APA 1APA 2APA 3

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50residual range (cm)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

dQ/d

x (A

DC

/cm

)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

plane_2 calibrated dQ/dx vs residual range with SCE ON

dQ/dxcalibraGon

dE/dxcalibraGon

AjibPaudel

T.Yang

BeamlineInstrumentaGon

•  WorkingwithbeamlineinstrumentaGongrouptosavebeamlineinformaGonandmatchTPCinformaGonwithbeamlineinformaGon.

•  AddthecharacterisGcvariableofeachbeammonitor,andsmearaccordingtotheinsightsaboutthebeammonitorsgivenbyPaola(fromBIgroup).Thisisalmostdone.

•  BuildinganothermodulefortheBeam-TPCmatchingvariables.WaiGngfortheBIgrouptogiveusinformaGonaboutthecoordinatesystemstheyareusinginthesimulaGon.

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 20

PabloFernandezLeighWhitehead

T.Yang

ReconstrucGon•  ThePandorateamconGnues

tomakeamazingprogresstoimprovereconstrucGonforProtoDUNE.

•  AdapGveBoostDecisionTreebasedBeamParGcleID:–  Efficiencies:72.3%forbeam

and94.5%forcosmicmuons–  PFParGclehierarchyand

taggingtofacilityanalysis•  Werecommendpeopleuse

PandorareconstrucGonfortheanalysisandgivefeedbacks.

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 21

Test Beam Particle Creation: Reconstructed Parent Particle: !+ Vertex: Start Vertex Hits: !+

Daughter Particles: 4 x p, 2 x "+

2 x !- !+

p"+

p

p

!-

p

"+

Interaction Vertex

!+

Default Reconstruction Reconstructed Parent Particle: Neutrino Vertex: Interaction Vertex Hits: No Visible Hits

Daughter Particles: 4 x p, 2 x "+

2 x !-

1 x !+

Start Vertex

!-

10 cm

SteveGreen

T.Yang

AnalysisPlans•  CurrentlypreparingdE/dxmeasurements

–  DetectorcalibraGon–  Beam-TPCmatching–  ReconstrucGondevelopment–  PreliminaryresultswithMCsoon

•  PlanningforcrosssecGonmeasurementsison-going–  LearninglessonsfromLArIAT

•  Photondetectoranalysisplansarebeingformed–  FirstpriorityistomeasurethedetecGonefficiencyforthe3PDtechnologiesandprovideinformaGontoTDR

•  WorkonacommonanalysisandsystemaGcsframeworkhasstarted

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 22

T.Yang

Summary

•  ForbothDUNEandprotoDUNE,organizaGonsandtoolsexisttofacilitatephysicsanalysis

•  Manystudiesremainundoneduetolackofpersonpower

•  EffortfromconsorGaiswelcomeandneeded!

ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 23