etw physics ceworkshop2018 - indico-fnal (indico)...alex sousa, jae yu high-e/nucleon decay lisa...
TRANSCRIPT
PhysicsAnalysis
ElizabethWorcester,BNLSPTPCElectronicsWorkshopJuly18,2018
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 1
Topics
• DUNEsimulaGonandsensiGvitytools• protoDUNEanalysis
Message:AbilitytodophysicsanalysesistheulGmateperformancerequirement.Physicseffortislimited.TheconsorGummodelreliesonanalysiseffortfromtheconsorGaincollaboraGonwiththephysicsworkinggroups.
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 2
OrganizaGon
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 3
High-levelcoordina0onPhysicsWorkingGroups
RyanPaTersonDeputy:ElizabethWorcester
FarDetectorSim/RecoAlexHimmel,ChrisBackhouse,TingjunYang
NearDetectorMikeKordosky,SteveManly
Long-BaselineMaTBass,DanCherdack,MaylySanchez
BSM/Exo0cAlexSousa,JaeYu
High-E/NucleonDecayLisaKoerner,GregPawloski,VitalyKudryavtsev
Low-E/SNνInesGilBotella,KateScholberg,AlexFriedland
CalibraGonsTaskForce:SowjanyaGollapinniKendallMahn
protoDUNEAnalysisGeorgiosChristodoulou,TingjunYang
DUNEAnalysis• GEANT4beamsimulaGonofupdatedbeamdesign• FullLArSo_MonteCarlosimulaGon
– GENIEeventgenerator– GEANT4parGclepropagaGon– DetectorreadoutsimulaGonincludingGarfield-basedwaveformsandwhitenoise
• Automatedsignalprocessingandhitfinding• Toolsexisttostudy
– Missing/badchannelsdistributedthroughoutthedetectorrandomly,bychip,byFEMB
– Impactofreduceddri_field– Impactofchangesinwhitenoiselevel
• ToolsinprogresstostudymoresophisGcatednoisemodel(exponenGal+coherentnoise)
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 4
PrimaryOscillaGonAnalysis• AutomatedenergyreconstrucGon
– Muonmomentumfromrange(contained)ormulGpleCoulombscaTering(exiGng)
– Electronandhadronenergyfromcalorimetry• EventselecGonusingconvoluGonalvisualnetwork(CVN)• OscillaGonanalysisusingCAFAnafifngframework
– SharedframeworkwithNOvA• ReweighGngtoolsforsensiGvityanalysisinprogress
– OpGontousesimpleCDR-stylesystemaGcsexistsnow– AnalysisincludingNDfitalsoinprogress
• ResultsshownatNeutrino2018achieve/surpassCDR-levelsensiGvity
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 5
DUNEMCAnalysisResultsCDR New!
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 6
DUNEMCAnalysisResults
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 7
BadChannelsStudies• Workinprogress• SomeiniGalresultsshowninAPAconsorGummeeGng:
hTps://indico.fnal.gov/event/16642/contribuGon/1• Resultsavailablefor5%and25%badchannelsrandomlydistributed• MCsamplescreatedfor5%and25%badchannelsbychipandboard• StudyaddressesonlyenergyresoluGon&CVNeventselecGonefficiency
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 8
5%
25%
RandomBadChannels:Results
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 9
MissingenergycorrecGon: Efficiencyresults(inclcutopGmizaGon):
DUNENucleonDecay• Protonandneutrondecay
sensiGvitystudiedusingMVAanalysisofDUNEMC– Primarybackgroundfrom
atmosphericνµinteracGonsisverychallenging
– Proton/kaonPIDforshorttracksanimportanthandle
– p→KνanalysissubgroupstarGngnow
• N-NbaroscillaGonsensiGvitystudiedusingdeeplearningbasedanalysisofDUNEMC
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 10
DUNESNBNeutrinos• MARLEYeventgenerator• Low-energysignal:
– 5-100MeV• Workongoingto
improveeventreconstrucGonandselecGon–verydifferentfromhigh-energytracksinotherphysicsgroups
• DAQ/Triggeringforsupernovaburstveryimportant:eventsarrivein10sburstwithmuchofthephysicsoccurringinfirst0.1s
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 11
40 kton argon, 10 kpc
Time (seconds) 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
Even
ts p
er b
in
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80 Infall Neutronization Accretion Cooling
No oscillationsNormal orderingInverted ordering
40 kton argon, 10 kpc
DUNESimulaGon30.25-MeVν
protoDUNE@Neutrino2018
• SuccessesachievedsofaratprotoDUNEwereahighlightofDUNE’sNeutrino2018show–peopleweresurprisedandimpressed!
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 12
protoDUNEAnalysis• ForphysicsTDR,protoDUNEanalysiswillbeusedto
validateMonteCarlosimulaGonusedforsensiGvitystudies• UlGmateproofthatdetectorworksisactuallydoingphysics
analysis• protoDUNEanalysisgroup(DRA=DetectorReconstrucGon
andAnalysis)addressesanalysisatalllevelsfromdataprocessingtocalibraGontophysicsresults– Newanalyzersatalllevelsverywelcome!
• Followingslidesareprimarilyli_edfromTingjun’scollaboraGonphonecallpresentaGon–thanksTingjun!–andrepresentasnapshotofthecurrentstatusofprotoDUNEanalysis.
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 13
AnalysisGoals
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 14
Short-termgoals–detectorperformance
Deadchannels,noisychannelsNoiselevel,signaltonoiseraGoElectronlifeGme
Medium-termgoals–detectorresponse
dE/dxofpions,protons,kaons,electronsEnergyandmomentumresoluGons
Long-termgoals–crosssecGons
InclusivepioncrosssecGonExclusivechannels–chargeexchange,etc.
InformaGonforDUNEphysicsTDR
PhysicspublicaGons
T.Yang
DAQ
Raw Data
Deconvoluted Data
Reconstructed Data
Calibrated Data
Detector Performance and Physics Analysis
Raw data decoding
Noise filtering, Stuck codemitigation, Deconvolution
Hit finding, DisambiguationPMA, Pandora, WireCell, PD, CNN
Space Charge EffectsdQ/dx and dE/dx calibration
protoDUNEDRAOrganizaGon• DRA–DetectorReconstrucGonandAnalysis• DRALevel1–overallresponsibilityoncodedevelopment
andorganizinganalysiseffort– T.Yang(FNAL)– G.Christodoulou(CERN)
• DRALevel2– ReconstrucGon–L.Whitehead(CERN)– DQM–M.Potekhin(BNL)– CalibraGon–M.Mooney(CSU)– Analysis–S.Bordoni(CERN)
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 15
WeeklymeeGngonWednesday9:30amFermilabGme,4:30pmCERNGmeMailinglist:[email protected]
T.Yang
RawDataDecoding• OfflineRawDecoderModulesarebasedonthosewriTenfortheOnline
MonitoringbyJingboWang,ToninoSergi,PaoloFranchini,PatrickTsang,andPhilipRodrigues.RCEunpackingcodefromJJRussell.FELIXoverlaysbyMiloVermeulen.Rawdecoder:convertrawdatatolarso_analyzableformatChannelmap:convertonlinechannelnumbertoofflinechannelnumber
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 16
Rawdecoder Channelmap
TPC(RCE) Exists VerifiedbychannelIDdata
TPC(FELIX) Exists VerifiedbychannelIDdata
Photondetectors(SSP) Exists IniGalversionexists
Timing InpreparaGon
Triggers(CTB,CRT) InpreparaGon InpreparaGon
T.Yang
DataQualityMonitor• ConGnuetodevelopDQMpayloads-George
Christodoulou,TomJunk,BruceBaller,DavidAdams– Alreadyavailable:TPCmonitor,hitmonitor,SSPmonitor,electronlifeGme,signaltonoiseraGo,eventdisplay
– Inprogress:CRTmonitor,triggermonitor,beamlineinstrumentaGonmonitor
• ConGnuetoimproveDQMinfrastructure–MaximPotekhin– Upgradedpayloadscriptsforthe"DQMmonitor”toincludeXROOTDstagein,stageoutandtheROOTmacrotoproducethegraphics(PNGs).
– WorkingtobuildtheUIforefficientaccesstoalltheplotsfromtheDQMwebpages.
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 17
T.Yang
CalibraGon• ADCCalibraGon–seeD.Adamstalk• SpaceChargeEffect
– Data-drivencalibraGonnecessaryforsurfacedetector
– SimplesimulaGonandsimulaGonwithargonflowmodelexist(Mooney,Voirin)
• CRT-matchedtracksprovidevaluableinformaGonfordetectorcalibraGon– FinalizeCRTframeposiGons– Updategeometry(MarGnTzanov)– ImplementCRTsimulaGoninLArSo_
(AndrewOlivier)– MatchTPCinformaGonwithCRT
informaGon(ArbinTimilsina)•
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 18
T.Yang
CalibraGonwithCosmics• Similarproceduredeveloped
byMicroBooNE:MicroBooNE-NOTE-1048-PUB(2018).
• dQ/dxcalibra0onusingthrough-goingmuons–completewithMC– Removespa0alandtemporal
variaGonsindetectorresponse– CalibraGonconstantsarebeing
uploadedtodatabasebyJonPaley
• dE/dxcalibra0onusingstoppingmuons–inprogress– Determineabsoluteenergyscale
usingmuonstoppingpower
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 19
0 100 200 300 400 500 600Z Coordinate(cm)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Y C
oord
inat
e(cm
)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
plane_2_negativeX
APA 1APA 2APA 3
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50residual range (cm)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
dQ/d
x (A
DC
/cm
)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
plane_2 calibrated dQ/dx vs residual range with SCE ON
dQ/dxcalibraGon
dE/dxcalibraGon
AjibPaudel
T.Yang
BeamlineInstrumentaGon
• WorkingwithbeamlineinstrumentaGongrouptosavebeamlineinformaGonandmatchTPCinformaGonwithbeamlineinformaGon.
• AddthecharacterisGcvariableofeachbeammonitor,andsmearaccordingtotheinsightsaboutthebeammonitorsgivenbyPaola(fromBIgroup).Thisisalmostdone.
• BuildinganothermodulefortheBeam-TPCmatchingvariables.WaiGngfortheBIgrouptogiveusinformaGonaboutthecoordinatesystemstheyareusinginthesimulaGon.
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 20
PabloFernandezLeighWhitehead
T.Yang
ReconstrucGon• ThePandorateamconGnues
tomakeamazingprogresstoimprovereconstrucGonforProtoDUNE.
• AdapGveBoostDecisionTreebasedBeamParGcleID:– Efficiencies:72.3%forbeam
and94.5%forcosmicmuons– PFParGclehierarchyand
taggingtofacilityanalysis• Werecommendpeopleuse
PandorareconstrucGonfortheanalysisandgivefeedbacks.
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 21
Test Beam Particle Creation: Reconstructed Parent Particle: !+ Vertex: Start Vertex Hits: !+
Daughter Particles: 4 x p, 2 x "+
2 x !- !+
p"+
p
p
!-
p
"+
Interaction Vertex
!+
Default Reconstruction Reconstructed Parent Particle: Neutrino Vertex: Interaction Vertex Hits: No Visible Hits
Daughter Particles: 4 x p, 2 x "+
2 x !-
1 x !+
Start Vertex
!-
10 cm
SteveGreen
T.Yang
AnalysisPlans• CurrentlypreparingdE/dxmeasurements
– DetectorcalibraGon– Beam-TPCmatching– ReconstrucGondevelopment– PreliminaryresultswithMCsoon
• PlanningforcrosssecGonmeasurementsison-going– LearninglessonsfromLArIAT
• Photondetectoranalysisplansarebeingformed– FirstpriorityistomeasurethedetecGonefficiencyforthe3PDtechnologiesandprovideinformaGontoTDR
• WorkonacommonanalysisandsystemaGcsframeworkhasstarted
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 22
T.Yang
Summary
• ForbothDUNEandprotoDUNE,organizaGonsandtoolsexisttofacilitatephysicsanalysis
• Manystudiesremainundoneduetolackofpersonpower
• EffortfromconsorGaiswelcomeandneeded!
ETW:PhysicsAnalysis 23