careers information provision in secondary schools of zambia
Post on 25-Jan-2023
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
1
1.0. Chapter 1- Introduction and Background
1.1. Introduction
The rationale to offer guidance and counselling services to secondary school pupils is clear. The
secondary school years is a periods of academic, social, personal, emotional and intellectual
growth for most adolescents. By resolving physical, emotional, social and academic difficulties of
the students and by helping students understand their learning strengths and weaknesses; their
academic achievement can be improved and their overall development can be enhanced. On top
of this, the increasing complexities in the society, industrial and technological development,
changes of the nation's educational system and increasing number of students necessitated the
provision of effective guidance and counselling service more than any other time. Thus, supporting
adolescents in all aspects of their development is very critical to their success.
Gysbers (2007) define guidance as a process of helping the individual find solutions to his/her
own problems and accept them as his own. Gillie et al. (2002) state that guidance is a general
label, an umbrella term that covers all the means whereby an institution identifies and responds
to the individual needs of pupils/students and thereby helping the individual to develop his or her
maximum potential. Counselling, on the other hand, is a subset of the general term we call
guidance services.
The purposes of guidance and counselling (G&C) programs for school children are many folds.
It is evident that G&C programs have significant influence on improving discipline problems,
enhancing pupils’ grades, strengthening social skills, helping students make wise decision on
career development and college choices, and developing positive study habits and study skills
(Lapan et al., 1997).
Career information makes possible systems that support career development and processes such
as career guidance and career education. Career information is absolutely the one tool upon which
nearly every step in the process of making informed and considered career decisions depends.
Informed and considered career decisions result in improved matches between people and their
work. Such matching manifests itself in improved utilization of education and training resources,
higher levels of worker satisfaction, preferred patterns of employment stability and mobility,
increased income and benefits, and many attendant benefits to families and communities.
Career guidance professionals may facilitate the career development process. Not all people will
engage in all steps, and the sequence may vary; but however obtained, informed and considered
2
career decisions represent a match of person and work in which the individual’s skills, interests,
values, beliefs, and purposes fit, align with, inform, and contribute to work, and work contributes
to the individual’s well-being and life goals (Whiston and Sexton, 1998).
In this study, the contextual use of the main variables in the problem was as defined below:
Career is a general work description that includes occupation, vocation and profession. Career is
a sequence of jobs, positions or occupations which one is engaged in all through his or her life. It
is the totality of work – paid and unpaid – that one does in one’s lifetime (Baker and Taylor, 1998).
Information is variedly defined as raw data processed into usable form and becomes a basis for
decision making (Hutchison and Sawyer, 1996). Another meaning according to Hicks (1990) is
that of information being used in a conceptual schema language as any kind of knowledge about
things, facts, or concepts of a universe of discourse that is exchangeable among user. This study
adopted the first definition of information above.
Career information is the intelligence that guides workers (and the professionals who advise them)
in the analytical process of examining, comprehending, and making decisions about the world of
work (Gillie et al, 2002). Career information comprises occupational information, industry
information, education and training information, financial aid information, and career
development process information (Ibid). Career information is an essential component of career
information systems, career guidance, and career education.
Thus from the above definition, it is vivid that pupils in secondary schools must know about
various careers in the world of work so as to decide which one to pursue. As such, career
information in this study was viewed as information on a varied number of careers that pupils in
secondary schools could pursue depending on their competences and interests. It is also worth
noting that career guidance and counselling services were not used so much in this study as the
focus was on careers information which can be provided either through guidance or counselling.
A secondary school is a part of the education systems that runs from early childhood to tertiary in
the education setup (Mwanakatwe, 1968). It is sometimes differentiated into junior and high
school levels but it may also be a one way system (Ibid). For this study, secondary schools was
taken to mean all those schools that run from Grade 8 to Grade 12.
1.1.1. Role of Information in Career Decision Making
Information has now been acknowledged by many as a factor of production in the same context
as labour, land and capital are. Some have elevated information to one of the four main ingredients
3
of modern industrial activity, side by side with labour, energy and flow of materials (Lundu, 1996).
It is being recognized as an essential catalytic element in development efforts to improve the living
standards of the population and for economic growth.
According to Kahneman and Tversky (2000), a decision is a reasoned choice among alternatives.
Every decision is made within a decision environment, which is defined as the collection of
information, alternatives, values and preferences available at the time of the decision
(Triantaphyllou, 2000). An ideal decision environment would include all possible information; all
of it accurate, and every possible alternative. Decision making is the study of identifying and
choosing alternatives based on the values and preferences of the decision maker. Another
definition of decision making according to Kepner et al (1965) is that of it being the process of
sufficiently reducing uncertainty and doubt about alternatives to allow a reasonable choice to be
made from among them. Every decision making process is viewed as producing a final choice
(Monahan, 2000).
The definitions above stress the information gathering function of decision making. It should be
noted here that uncertainty in decision making is merely reduced rather than vanquished. There
are few decisions that are made with absolute certainty because complete knowledge about all the
alternatives is seldom possible (Ibid). Pupils in secondary schools therefore require relevant,
timely and rightly packaged information when making career decisions. This would help them in
choosing careers that will bring personal satisfaction and fulfilment at the same time.
Informed and considered career decisions are the product of a career development process that
includes experimenting through work sampling, volunteering, or employment, creating awareness
of options, exploring possible career pathways, reviewing available information, clarifying
interests, values, and skills through assessment, reflecting upon experiences, relating education
and training options to occupational goals, consulting with knowledgeable people in the field of
interest, formulating plans for education, training, career entry, and retraining, making decisions
and refining plans, implementing and adapting plans, and applying the career development process
throughout the lifespan (Lokan et al, 1993).
Career information is part of a nexus of products, services, and processes that facilitate informed
and considered career decisions. As depicted in the graphic below, career information extends
outward in a direction of increased complexity and value. The outer circles of increased
complexity act upon career information in extending, organizing, relating, integrating, and
applying it to myriad human situations. The outermost circle provides a feedback loop that
4
informs, improves, and extends the reach and effectiveness of career information, processes, and
services (Phillips, 2008).
Figure 1- Complexity and value of Career information Model
(Source: Carl D. Perkins Vocational and Technical Education Act of 1998 Reauthorization)
Giving young people the tools and knowledge to realistically plan for their future is a primary goal
of education. Career information is important for the youths today who are characterized by
directionlessness which is a result of rapid shift from traditional cultural ways and occupations to
the modern, global identities and technological change paradigm with its new demands (Sadler,
and Reisenberger, 1997). Most of the school leavers do not feel equipped to make informed
decisions on careers and they are at a loss as to where to turn to for guidance.
Pupils in secondary schools are given an education that plays a key role in their development. It
equips them with relevant skills, knowledge and values to enable them participate in national and
global development. In Zambia, as is the case in many other developing countries educational
setting, it is significant that a majority of pupils are unaware of training opportunities and
requirements at various levels of post secondary schools education (Okumu, 2009). Career
information needs to be provided and accessed by pupils in secondary schools in order for them
to make well informed decisions that will help them make smooth transitions from school to higher
institutions; from school to work, and from school to lifelong learning in this twenty-first century.
Gysbers, (2007) captures this 21st century scenario as a time when organizations are developing
5
global identities; and technological change is rapid. Okumu, (2009) states that with the
complexities of unemployment and the technological shifts in today’s labour market, young people
need not only information but also the skills they can get to ensure they make sound career
decisions.
Thus the crucial role of information in decision making need not be emphasized. It facilitates the
development of individuals into responsible, accountable, participative, expressive citizens who
make well informed rational decisions. To this end, lack of appropriate information in the decision
making process would entail making of decisions that would be unsound; regrettable sooner or
later or even failure at all to make any decision. Therefore, for right decision making either at a
personal level, corporate level or governmental level, accurate, timely, relevant, complete and
reliable information is key.
1.2. Background Information Career information enables secondary school pupils to have such skills as evaluating themselves
realistically and understanding their abilities, making sound decisions, working effectively and
independently and comparing themselves realistically (Gysbers, 2007). These skills need time to
develop. It is therefore imperative that career guidance is taught in a coordinated way in schools.
Unfortunately, this is not the case in many countries. For example, in Britain, the Skills
Commission concluded that the government should give funding and political support for career
information and guidance for all adults and young people. Millions are stuck in “a wrong job”
says the survey (The Standard, pp. 29.)
Career guidance should be integrated into the subjects taught in the school because it would help
relate the subjects to the careers the students would join. This would be helpful especially in the
case where the career teacher cannot cope with the normal teaching workload, the great numbers
of students seeking career information, lack of resources and knowledge since career teachers have
no formal training (Howieson and Semple, 1996). When the subject teachers and the career
guidance teacher work as a team, the students stand to gain in their ability to understand
themselves and to make career choices (Ibid).
Career information and guidance should have a curriculum and program as is the case in most
states in America. The American School Counsellor Association (ASCA), for instance, has
developed National Career Development Guidelines that have been adopted in 46 states
(American Counselling Association, 2003). Similarly, in Canada the Ministry of Education and
Training has a career guidance program that runs from elementary grades and continues through
6
secondary. In contrast, in most third world countries Zambia inclusive, career guidance is provided
in a haphazard way and is a fringe benefit instead of being directly linked with students learning
(Rukwaro, 2011).
Sources both print and online, are necessary in order to help students to keep focused on their
careers. In the United States of America, a vast majority of schools stock computerized and non-
computerized career information sources and college catalogues as well as conducting testing for
career planning (Hughes and Karp, 2004). In many African countries, the situation is different
mainly due to lack of government policy and commitment (Rukwaro, 2011). In many secondary
schools in Kenya, for example, even a newspaper is hard to come by. This is not different from
the Zambian scenario too. Watts (2010) commenting on this situation states that relevant reading
materials on career information for both teachers and students is lacking. Students therefore need
to be guided in order to be able to choose careers that are commensurate with their abilities and
interests.
In Zambia, career information is provided through guidance and counselling in secondary schools.
The Ministry of Education has the mandate to provide careers information. The ministry is guided
by the vision to provide quality, lifelong education for all which is accessible, inclusive and
relevant to individual, national and global needs and value systems. Its mission is to guide the
provision of education for all Zambians so that they are able to pursue knowledge and skills,
manifest excellence in performance and moral uprightness, defend democratic ideals, and… Thus
the ministry is entrusted with the responsibility of developing not only individuals into responsible
citizens but also that of putting up infrastructure that will facilitate their development such as
schools.
However, the Ministry of Education has not had documents on career information provision in
schools until recently in 2004 when it developed two modules one and two on the same. Though
the modules are not primarily intended to cater for career information provision as evidenced from
a shallow coverage of the subject, they lay out some background to career information provision.
The School Guidance Services Unit of the Ministry of Education has produced various guidelines
to help the school in particular (Ministry of Education, 2004).
Under the guidelines, guidance and counselling is not to be considered a subject with a specifically
allotted slot on the timetable, it is rather a comprehensive programme meant to be integrated into
the total school programme and be part of the curriculum (Ibid: 64). The Head Teacher is entrusted
with the overall responsibility for making sure that a G&C programme is established and two
7
teachers designated as Guidance Teachers depending on the size of school. Thus the Head Teacher
is an overseer of the G&C programme in a school.
The Guidance Teachers are the contact persons between the school and MOE G&C Unit support
systems. All the responsibility to provide career information and to organize activities that involve
the dissemination of career information lies within the Guidance Teachers. It should be noted too
here that these Guidance Teachers must also assume full responsibility of their own slots on the
timetable (Ministry of Education, 2001). This has created negligence where provision of career
information is concerned. Furthermore, the Ministry of Education has suggested some methods to
be used to give careers information to learners. These include hosting careers exhibitions;
establishing careers corner; conducting educational tours; forming careers clubs; holding careers
talks, and providing reading materials on careers (Ministry of Education, 2004). Whether these
methods have been implemented or helped in the provision of careers information is highly
debatable.
The University of Zambia exists basically for teaching, research and public service. This takes
place at different levels. Teaching mainly takes place at undergraduate level while research takes
place at postgraduate level and also the faculty in the institution does research for various purposes.
The University offers public service through some of its individuals being asked by organizations
or government to offer professional advice or help on some committees or wherever deemed fit.
Thus for the University to carry out its aims or goals, it is guided by the vision to be a leader in
provision of higher education in the region, celebrated for providing comprehensive and rigorous
teaching-learning, research and scholarly programmes that are responsive to needs of the
individual, industry and society. Its mission is to be a centre of excellence in higher education for
individuals industry and society through the provision of quality education, research and scholarly
programmes for strategic human resource development, in order to promote national and regional
development, through relevant and appropriate partnerships.
In order to achieve its vision and mission, the university library plays a critical role. The library
provides the much needed information to students at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels
and to the teaching faculty. It facilitates teaching, research and also the provision of public service
by providing individuals with the information on various issues. Hence the library is such an
indispensable tool in the provision of education and ultimately to the development of individuals
who will be responsible and useful in their communities and the nation as a whole. Thus the
university compliments the core business of the Ministry of Education.
8
There is a huge discrepancy in the way career information and guidance is handled in the
developed world as compared to the developing world. Yet the world has become a global village
and there is need to prepare youths to seize international careers and opportunities.
1.3. Statement of the Problem The decision of which programme to pursue at university or college is very important to secondary
school students, their teachers and parents. This importance is underscored by the fact that often,
this decision determines the career that the pupils will take for the rest of their working lives.
Access to careers information would enable pupils to understand the educational and career
opportunities and the decision that they must make in choosing careers which should be
commensurate with their abilities and talents. Deciding on the future career is not quite easy. It is
even more difficult when you lack the necessary information on the different types of careers. In
an ideal situation the process of career development stretches throughout one’s lifetime with a
greater emphasis during the secondary and tertiary years (Hughes and Karp, 2004).
Secondary school teachers play an important role for students during their formative years by
fostering the intellectual and social development of their students (Isaacson, 1985). They provide
their students with an environment and the proper tools to develop into responsible adults.
However, though recognizing the importance of career information, no school has paid appropriate
attention to the work (Jassat and Liebenberg, 2004).
In most countries, there are gaps and overlaps in the career information and guidance services.
Availability is uneven. Few countries, it seems, have coherent policies, systems and delivery
structures for career information and guidance that support transitions across the span of life,
learning and work (Hoyt and Lester, 1995). Apparently, it is evident from a number of studies and
through observation from the case of the University of Zambia students that in most secondary
schools in the developing world, career information is less provided if provided at all. It is in view
of this that this study was conducted in order to explore, through the review of literature various
issues underlying the provision of career information in secondary schools using School of
Education first year students at the University of Zambia as a case study.
1.4. Objectives of the Study This study was guided by the following objectives:
9
1.4.1. General Objective To examine the provision of careers information in secondary schools for informed career
decisions.
1.4.2. Specific Objectives 1.4.2.1. To establish whether pupils in secondary schools have access to careers
information.
1.4.2.2. To investigate the extent of access to careers information by pupils.
1.4.2.3. To determine the extent of awareness of careers and their requirements
by pupils in secondary schools.
1.4.2.4. To evaluate the relevance of careers information to careers choices.
1.4.2.5. To examine the adequacy of provision of careers information by careers
facilities, programs and information.
1.4.3. Research Questions
The study was guided by the following research questions:
1.4.3.1. Do pupils in secondary schools have access to careers information?
1.4.3.2. To what extent do pupils access careers information at secondary
schools?
1.4.3.3. Are pupils aware of careers and their requirements while at secondary
schools?
1.4.3.4. To what degree is the career information obtained in secondary
schools useful in making career choices in tertiary educational
institutions?
1.4.3.5. How adequate is the careers information provided by careers facilities,
programs and information?
1.5. Rationale of the Study Since Informed and considered career decisions are linked to improved educational achievement,
attainment, and efficiency, pupils who make informed and considered career decisions are more
likely to graduate from secondary school and to succeed in postsecondary education. Therefore,
though this paper was primarily for academic purposes, it was hoped that the results of the study
in one way or another could impact positively on the secondary schools’ need to provide careers
information as it is vital for informed career decision making and also that the study could add a
speck of knowledge in the recognition of the critical important role of careers information not only
10
to the benefit of individual pupils but also to their families, communities and ultimately to the
whole country.
11
2.0. Chapter 2 -Literature Review
2.1. Introduction
In order to understand the underlying issues in the provision of careers information in secondary
schools, this chapter of the study explores the various theoretical frameworks which best helped
in the understanding of the problem and also other studies conducted in the area under
consideration, filling the gaps and extending prior studies. The theoretical framework on which
the study was based comprised theories that explain why people choose one career instead of
another.
2.2. Theoretical Framework
2.2.1. Introduction
A theoretical framework is an examination of the existing theories in relation to the research
objectives. It refers to a set of interrelated variables, definitions and propositions that present a
systematic view of a phenomenon by specifying relations among variables with the purpose of
explaining a phenomenon (Oso and Onen, 2005). The theoretical framework in this study is
derived from theories examined on career information guidance. These theories show how various
variables interrelate, causes and effects, and explanations that will bring understanding of current
issues in career information provision situation and career decision making.
This study was based on Trait and Factor Theory postulated in 1909 by Frank Parson and Theory
of Personalities whose exponent is John Holland. Frank Parson’s Trait and Factor Theory posits
that a choice of vocation depended upon: an accurate knowledge of yourself, your aptitudes,
abilities, interests, ambitions, resources, limitations and their causes; thorough knowledge of job
specifications, requirements and conditions, success, advantages and disadvantages,
compensation, opportunities and prospects in different lines of work, and the ability to make a
proper match between the two.
The major assumptions underlying Trait and Factor theory include: individuals and job traits can
be matched, and that close matches are positively correlated with job success and satisfaction. On
one hand, John Holland’s Theory of Personalities proposes that people can function and develop
best and find job satisfaction in work environments which are compatible with their personalities.
The personality types and work environments are labelled as realistic, investigative, artistic, social,
enterprising, and conventional. A more detailed discussion of Frank Parson and John Holland’s
theories will be done in isolation respectively.
12
2.2.2. Trait and Factor Theory
Frank Parson (1909) held that career decision is the greatest decision (Muro and Kottman, 1995).
His theory is used in career counselling. Trait and Factor Theory engulfs three basic factors which,
if taken into consideration would help a person in choosing a career that would bring satisfaction
and productivity. An individual has to understand him/herself, his/her talents, abilities, aptitude,
interests, ambitions, resources, limitations and their causes. These personal traits have to be
matched with knowledge of job specifications: the requirements of the job, conditions, success,
advantages and disadvantages, compensation, opportunities, and prospects in different lines of
work. A decision on what line of work one will pursue will then be reached. This would lead a
person to a job that would be satisfying thus leading to productivity.
However, this theory does not consider the aspect of change in an individual and therefore the job
can be dissatisfying. On the other hand, job conditions and trends do change for various reasons
and thus become dissatisfying. Nevertheless it is hoped that a person who had a great ability to
analyse in the first place before choosing a job will be able to analyse the cause of dissatisfaction
and know what steps to take.
This theory also disregards socio-economic contexts that may force people to take whatever job
is available irrespective of his/her personal traits or even job conditions. The theory also would be
more comprehensive if it sought to elaborate why one has the traits he/she finds him/herself
possessing. It would have helped the person understand him/herself.
2.2.3. Theory of Personalities
The first publication of John Holland’s theory was in 1959 in a publication entitled “A Theory of
Vocation Choice” (Muro and Kottman, 1995:352). This theory was espoused to organize data
about people in different jobs; organize the data about different work environments, suggest how
people make career choices; explain how job satisfaction and vocational achievement occur.
Holland proposed that people can find job satisfaction in work environments that are compatible
to their personalities. He classified personality types and work environment into six types which
he labeled Realistic, Investigative, Artistic, Social, Enterprising and Conventional (RIASEC) (see
figure 2, pp.15). The closer the match of personality to the job, the greater the job satisfaction. He
also stated that although all types are part of us, one type is usually most prominent and through
self-analyses, one would know the prominent one. The theory was applicable to both men and
women but it was noted that there was a question of gender bias for most women tended to score
on mainly three personalities: artistic, conventional and social. Holland attributed this to gender
13
which caused many women to display greater interest in traditionally female-dominated
occupations.
This theory emphasizes self-knowledge and knowledge of work environment for wise career
decision making.
RIASEC denotes:
Realistic–basically involves physical demands. People work with tools, machines, or animals.
Technical competence and the ability to manipulate things is the most important aspect of these
jobs. These personalities like to work with their hands, separate from people, on concrete tasks.
Investigative - basically involves intellectual challenges that require using reasoning,
mathematics, or scientific principles to solve problems. Problem solving, abstract thinking, logic,
and creativity are essential competencies for these jobs. These personalities enjoy puzzles,
intellectual challenges, and working independently to solve problems. Examples of such careers
are computer science and urban planning among others.
Artistic - basically involves free, open, creative environments in which people have very little
structure. Creativity and personal expression are essential competencies for these jobs. These
personalities enjoy freedom and unstructured situations in which they can express themselves in
original ways through various media. Journalism, media and theatre arts are in this category.
Social–basically involves people working together to support and understand each other.
Communication and listening competencies are essential for these jobs. These personalities feel a
strong need to be in a cooperative, supportive environment. Social work, nursing, teaching are in
this category.
Enterprising–basically involves persuading other people to do what one wishes. Communication,
leadership, management competencies are essential for these jobs. These personalities like to use
data and /or their social skills to get others to do what they want, accomplish group goals, and to
achieve higher status. Such people fit in marketing and business among others.
Conventional - basically involves carefully organized, structured, and planned environments in
which people keep records, file papers, organize data and work under close supervision of another
person. The most important competencies for these jobs are organization and the ability to
carefully follow orders. These personalities enjoy settings that are highly structured in which they
14
have little autonomy. Examples of such settings may include accounting and office systems
administration.
The theory does not also explain that personalities do change, and thus one may not be satisfied
with a job which one chooses before the change. Similarly, the job may change due to global
trends. Nonetheless it may have been assumed that one who gets dissatisfied with a job due to
change in personality will be expected to move to one that is compatible with the new personality.
The same is expected to happen to one who gets dissatisfied with a job due to change in the job.
Mobility to a compatible job with one’s personality is expected.
Furthermore, it would have been of great help if an explanation was given as to how one acquires
the personality that he/she has. This theory also disregards the socio-economic contexts that may
force a person to take whatever job is available irrespective of his/her personal traits or even job
conditions.
Figure 2- Holland's Hexagonal Relationship of Occupational classes,
(Source: Attridge, W. C)
2.2.4. Justification in choosing the two theories
There are many theories on career guidance, counselling and development like that of Super’s and
Ginzberg’s et al. Life Span Theory. The theory proposes a developmental model of career
development. The theory can be viewed as concentrating much on the development stage of
Artistic Conventional
Social Enterprising
Realistic Investigative
15
students/pupils in the early years of their (primary) education. However, for this particular study,
the researcher has settled on aligning the study to Parson’s and Holland’s theories due to these
theories’ appropriateness and continued dominance in career practice overtime and to under gird
counselling for career practice (Patton, 1990). Some of the ways these theories continue to
dominate and under gird career practice include the following:
Parson’s first element, self-knowledge, was to be assessed through test of abilities, aptitudes and
inventories of interest. This is in keeping with contemporary practice of career assessment.
Holland’s work on understanding of one’s personality influenced and pushed the development of
interest inventories further. The second element, which relates knowledge about the world of
work; and which Holland referred to as work environment is still an important concept in career
planning and development and it has led to organized classifications and descriptions of
occupational information. Parson’s third element of true reasoning alludes to the cognitive
processes and analytical skills as fundamental to career decision making; a concept that is in
keeping with contemporary career guidance concepts.
Parson’s and Holland’s theories are still relevant and they inform contemporary career counselling
in the above ways and also in introducing key concepts in understanding career development. a
study done in the United States of America by Osborne and Baggerly (2004) in which Florida
Public Schools’ Counsellors were asked whether they used any career theory in their practice,
found out that three fourths were using a career theory in their practice; and Holland’s RIASEC
theory was the most popular, perhaps due to the number of applicable tools such as elf-Directed
Search. In another observation made in Osborne and Baggerly (2004) study, the top three
identified theories were based on trait and factor approach. A conclusion was thus made by the
Osborne and Baggerly that this suggests that trait and factor theory still has prominence in
informing career decision making. Isaacson (1985) also observed that every theory of career
development has in it aspects of trait and factor theory and is regarded as a bedrock of all career
guidance and counselling theories.
For all these reasons among others, the researcher will employ Parson’s and Holland’s theories
for this study because they auger well with the study and the principle concepts of these theories
are still used to inform and communicate career practice and research.
2.2.5. Relevance of the Theories to the Study
Parson’s wise choice of vocation which is based on a clear knowledge of oneself, of the job and a
matching of the two calls for true reasoning. Reasoning can only be done where there is
16
information to enable one to weigh the alternatives and arrive at a decision. Parson called career
choice the greatest decision.
Knowledge of self in terms of academic potential, attributes, talents, interests, values,
expectations, resources, “do not appear suddenly on the day students are ready to leave school as
they require substantial time and attention to develop, be assimilated and used by students
beginning with elementary school” (Gysbers, 2007). One needs to be engaged in several services
and activities such as career day/week where dissemination of career information through group
discussions, films, talks and visits to organizations are done. An individual can also be helped to
understand him/herself when the career counsellor collects and analyses the student’s personal
data and relates it to the wider social, cultural, economic and vocational context. In this way, the
student will understand him/herself and the career suitable for them.
Understanding of oneself is important to a pupil especially in the context of socio-cultural-
economic changes taking place. UNESCO (2002) stated that access to information through media
and other forms of technology is giving young people aspirations that for the most part, cannot be
satisfied in their environment. These aspirations that the pupil is exposed to must be carefully
adapted and fine-tuned by the career counsellor to fit in with the realities in Zambia and the world.
Parson’s theory also presses emphasis on the need for knowledge of the jobs. The variations of
the job world ought to be understood. No longer can one think of a job in a specific industry or
country. For now we are all employees of various industries and countries. For instance, someone
who has a bachelor’s degree in education can work as a banker or a lecturer in one university can
be an external examiner in universities in other countries; an employee in Lusaka office is in touch
daily with the multinational company offices in Beijing, Canberra or Tokyo. With each passing
day, the world of work changes in order to suit the global changes and remain on the cutting edge
of knowledge and best practices. Quite a number of workers and their organizations in which they
work are developing global identities (Gysbers, 2007). Career counselling and dissemination of
knowledge of jobs must take cognizance of the intricacies of a rapidly changing world and jobs.
There are various types of jobs in the world of work; some are part-time, short stint, volunteer,
casual, permanent, temporary, among others. When the pupil is given information on jobs, it must
encompass all these dynamics.
Holland’s Theory of Personality is modeled after Frank Parson’s Trait and Factor theory. Like
Parsons, Holland also stresses self-knowledge in order to know which of the six personalities –
realistic, investigative, artistic, social, enterprising and conventional – is your type. He agrees that
17
each of us has a bit of the personality types but one is dominant. To know which one needs self-
analyses, an individual’s personality type “could be identified by preferences for school subjects,
extracurricular activities, hobbies and work” (Ibid). This can be done in school and home by the
subject teachers, career teacher and parents, among other.
Holland also did not attempt to give an explanation as to how people become the types they are.
Holland simply asserted that people simply tended to reproduce themselves. Holland did not take
into consideration the changes in personalities or even work organizations that happen due to
varied reasons over time.
Both Frank Parson’s and Holland’s theories regard self-knowledge and career information
essential for career decision making.
2.2.6. Conclusion This study was on provision and access to career information in order to ensure that a career
decision is made that will be a catalytic transition to job satisfaction. This is in view of the
prevailing scenario in Zambia where people enter careers which they are not interested in or have
no ability in (Ministry of Education, 2004). It was hoped that if these theories are taken into
consideration and information given on self and job analyses, especially in secondary schools, the
tide of Zambians landing in the jobs that are not complementary to their abilities and interests will
be stemmed.
2.3. Empirical Review There are many studies and reports on career information provision in secondary schools. Several
studies have found that career classes, workshops, and structured groups are useful interventions
(Muro and Kottman, 1995; Gillie and Fall, 2003; Watts, 2010; Rothman and Hillman, 2008) that
produce a variety of documented outcomes.
Ogle (2001) found that lower student-counselor ratios resulted in increased college-going rates for
high school graduates, an effect that persists when taking into account socio-economic and
demographic differences. Increasing the amount of time that students spend talking with
counselors and teachers about students’ plans is associated with increased achievement in
mathematics, science, and reading.
Blustein (2002), notes that researchers and policy analysts are linking educational development
and career development. There is an emergent understanding that students who have an awareness
of the career relatedness of education are more likely to engage and achieve in school. Blustein
18
cites two meta-analyses (Baker and Taylor, 1998; Evans and Burck, 1992) and three specific
studies that document academic gains from career interventions. Another study of a systematic
guidance program (Lapan, Gysbers, and Petroski, 2001) found that seventh graders had improved
attitudes toward education and better grades than students who did not take part in the program.
Dykeman et al. (2003) posit that career interventions lead to increased academic efficacy and
motivation, two variables that are known to be related to improved academic achievement. In their
study, academic planning counselling was found to have a positive influence upon mathematics
achievement. The authors speculate that mathematics is particularly susceptible to influence,
because counsellors can help students understand how mathematics relates to their lives and future
plans.
According to the New Zealand Education Review office report (1999), schools have the
responsibility to provide appropriate career information and counselling to all students, but special
attention is recommended to be paid to those who are nearing the completion of their education
cycle. They have to be provided with specific career guidance and counselling to enable them to
make informed decisions on further education. Similarly, Hoyt and Lester (1995) stressed the
importance of comprehensive career information that should be organized into instructional
programs offered to all students. Requirements for a variety of jobs are changing as new jobs are
emerging while others become obsolete.
In their contribution to careers decision making, Jassat and Liebenberg (2004) explained that
career guidance and counselling is an important avenue through which students acquire the ability
to make rational career decisions, and by extension, programmes for study at universities that
impact on their future working lives. This understanding is based on the fact that during the career
counselling process, all aspects of an individual’s life are considered as an integral part of the
career making and planning. After orientation into their degree programmes in a number of
academic institutions, a significant percentage of students come wishing to revise their degree
programmes, citing dislike for some aspects thereof. Secondly, others come to change, from
degree programmes they were admitted into after choosing them as first choice and meeting the
degree programme requirements, to others degree programmes they perceive to be better (Lugulu,
2011). The inter school transfer process carried out during orientation period in Kenya assists this
category of students. The number transferred thus is however, very small and it leaves a large
group of students dissatisfied (Ibid).
19
As Koontz and Weihrich (1990) observe, decision making is the selection of a course of action
from among alternatives, they recognized it as a major part of planning. For the decision reached
to be rational, the decision maker must have a clear understanding of alternative courses by which
a goal can be reached under existing circumstances and limitations. They must also have the
information and ability to analyses and evaluate the alternatives in the light of the goal sought. For
students, the goal here refers to the future careers, and choosing relevant degree programmes
prepares them for the desired end. Lastly they must have the desire to come to the best solution by
selecting the alternative that must effectively satisfy goal achievement (Ibid). In relying on the
manpower planning theory therefore (Herbert, 1962) it is necessary to align educational
opportunities to economic needs and aspirations. Otherwise it may lead to oversupply of
manpower in some areas which may lead to wastage in their training and impose a heavy
opportunity cost or failing to train manpower in the other critical but supposedly unpopular areas.
A survey by the Vietnam Education Science Institute found out that 70 percent of high school
pupils do not receive career education (Kellett and Conger, 1995). Most students kept quiet when
they were asked about the career education curriculum for 10th graders. No 11th grader could
answer the question; saying that they would only decide what they would become when they finish
the 12th grade (Ibid).The problem of many high school students now is that they do not know
what they would study and what jobs they would take. A lot of pupils said the same thing that they
would ask others or their parents to decide what to do next after finishing high school (Johnson,
1988).
A study was conducted to investigate the selection of undergraduate student degree programs in
Moi University, Kenya (Lugulu, 2011). It explored the attitudes and perceptions of the participants
on what determines the choice of undergraduate degree programmes. A mixture of Quantitative
and Qualitative methodologies and Case Study research design was used. Simple random sampling
technique was used to select 11 schools out of 15 and stratified random sampling to select 754
respondents to constitute the sample. A questionnaire was administered to 742 student respondents
in order to measure their perceptions, attitudes, values and behaviour on the subject of study and
also to identify key research themes that were probed further. Three Focus Group Discussions and
ten face-to-face interviews were conducted with selected respondents who were believed to be
more knowledgeable about the selection of students’ in undergraduate degree programs (Ibid).
Document analysis of the archival documents was also done. Descriptive statistics such as
frequencies and percentages were used to determine and explain proportions. In the light of
findings, the study concluded that the level of career guidance and counseling provided in
20
secondary schools was neither well planned nor organized. In addition, there were no clear policies
within which the service is provided. Students’ degree programme decisions were guided by other
factors rather than interest. Universities do not sufficiently market degree programmes in
secondary schools.
In Australia, a report examined young people’s participation in career advice activities while at
school and their perceptions of the usefulness of the advice they receive (Rothman and Hillman,
2008). The data are from the 2003 15 year old cohort of the Longitudinal Surveys of Australian
Youth (LSAY). Most members of this LSAY Y03 cohort were in Year 10 in 2003. The present
report examines how much career advice students accessed in Years 10, 11 and 12 across three
years of data collection (2003–2005). A smaller group of the cohort was followed each year; this
group was in Year 10 in 2003, Year 11 in 2004, and Year 12 in 2005. For this group of more than
5000 young people, analyses were conducted to determine what influences their perceptions of
the usefulness of career advice while at school.
The findings of the study were that all students in the LSAY Y03 cohort participated in at least
one type of career advice activity across Years 10, 11 and 12. Most activity occurred in Year 10,
when 99 per cent of students accessed at least one activity (Ibid). On average, Year 10 and Year
12 students reported accessing five different types of activity, and Year 11 students reported four
out of seven selected activities.
The most common type of career advice activity across Years 10, 11 and 12 was the distribution
of written material and handouts. In Year 10, 95 per cent of students received such material. This
was followed by a talk from the school’s career advisor; with 87 per cent of students reporting this
activity (Ertelt and Seidel, 1998).More than one-half of Year 10 students (54%) reported having a
talk from a representative of a TAFE institution or a university. By contrast, 76 per cent of Year
12 students reported this activity (Ibid). During that same period, employer representatives spoke
to 54 per cent of Year 10 students and 50 per cent of students in Year 12.
The most common grouping of activities included a talk from the school’s career advisor, written
materials, an individual session with the career advisor and—in Year 10—group discussion.
Members of the LSAY Y03 cohort were generally positive about the value of the career advice
they received at school, although some types of advice were seen as more useful than others. In
Years 10, 11 and 12, an individual conversation with the career advisor was perceived as the most
21
useful. For example, in Year 10, 60 per cent of students stated the conversation was ‘very useful’.
Group discussion was seen as the least useful at all three year levels.
The relationship between how useful cohort members perceived career advice at school and a
number of background factors highlighted some significant differences, but the overall influence
of these factors was extremely small. Gender and socioeconomic status had small, significant
influences on perceptions of usefulness, but explained less than 1 per cent of the variation in
usefulness scores.
Academic achievement as measured by students’ performance on PISA tests in mathematical
literacy, reading literacy, scientific literacy and problem-solving skills was statistically significant,
with lower-achieving students reporting that career advice was more useful, although the
contribution of this factor was very small.
One of the strongest associations was between perceptions of the usefulness of career advice and
the number of career advice activities accessed during the year. As young people participated in
more activities, they found career advice overall to be more useful. There was very little difference
between schools in students’ perception of the usefulness of career advice (Rothman and Hillman,
2008). Nearly all of the variation and only a small proportion of that variation could be accounted
for was because of differences between students.
Many countries have come to recognize the contributions of quality guidance and career
information services to the development of motivated learners who are productive and committed
workers (Bezanson and Kellet, 2001). However, there are many other kinds of services that also
contribute to the development of motivated and productive learners and workers. Examples of
such services may include community development services, economic services, front-line youth
services and the services of adult educators. The providers of these skill development and lifelong
learning services are important stakeholders in the provision of career information and guidance
services.
Some of the stakeholders important to a coherent career information and guidance system include:
the individual, families, employers, counsellors, social and community agencies, community,
peers/role models, government and schools (Ibid). Parents may be active catalysts for career
development and lifelong learning, but often require information and understanding about how to
do so effectively. Their potential contributions remain untapped. The involvement of employers
in career information and guidance services is not extensive (Watts, 2010).
22
It is clear as revealed from a number of studies that many students do not have information which
pertains to the career that they would want to get into. While in developed countries the scenario
could be better than that of the developing world, provision of careers information in both worlds
is still not as expected. It was therefore at the core of this study to have a further examination of
this issue and contribute immensely on the improvement of the foregoing problem.
23
3.0. Chapter 3- Research Methodology
3.1. Introduction
This chapter covers the methodology that was used in data collection and analysis. It discusses
research design, study population and justification, sampling procedure and sample size,
instrumentation, data collection procedures and data analysis techniques of the research study.
3.2. Research Design Research design is the conceptual structure within which research is conducted; it constitutes the
bedrock for the collection, measurement and analysis of data and interpretation of observations.
The important features of a research design are the advance planning of the techniques to be used
in analysing the data, keeping in mind the objective of the research and the time and financial
implications since most studies are done under these two constraints (Babbie, 2005; Kothari,
2004;).
The study adopted both qualitative and quantitative methodologies to maximise on the strength of
both (Best and Kahn, 1983). It also adopted a case study design in order to examine the careers
information provision in secondary schools for the process of students’ selection of career courses
programmes in public universities and colleges in their natural settings. It employed the
questionnaire methods of data collection.
3.3. Study Population and Justification In this study, the research population consisted of first year undergraduate students in the School
of Education at the University of Zambia. The rationale for the selection of first year students at
the UNZA was guided by the fact that these comprise a number of students from various secondary
schools in Zambia. Thus their diverse views on the matter helped in getting the much sought
information. Additionally, taking into account the time and cost constraints, the choice of this case
study made it ideal for carrying out this study.
3.4. Sample Size and Sampling technique A sample is a subset of the population having similar features to the population and representative
of the population. It constitutes selected elements from a population which is used to make
statements about the whole population. Observations made and conclusions of the sample are
representative of the entire population. A sample is considered to be representative if the analysis
made using the researcher’s sampling unit produce results similar to those that would be obtained
had the researcher analysed the entire population (Frankfort – Nachmias and Nachmias, 1996;
Cresswell, 2003).
24
In this study, the sample size consisted of 40 first year students in the School of Education at
UNZA, Great East Road main Campus. The choice of 40 respondents is influenced by the rule of
the central limit theory which states that a random sample equal or greater than 30 is able to
provide a normal distribution on the characteristics of the population under consideration (Blalock,
1972). A purposive sampling method was used to select research objects from various first year
programmes in the School of Education.
3.5. Data Collection Techniques The main data collection tool in this study was the questionnaire. Frankfurt-Nachmias and
Nachmias (1996) state that questionnaire is the main instrument in survey research. Researchers
use questionnaires so that they can obtain information about the thoughts, feelings, attitudes,
beliefs, values, perceptions, personality, and behavioural intentions of the research participants in
a large population. Questionnaires provide data in the same form from all respondents. The content
and organization of a questionnaire corresponded to researcher’s research objectives. (Johnson
and Christenser, 2008; Babbie, 2007).The questionnaire included both open and closed ended
questions allowing the respondents to give both direct and opinion answers. However, more closed
ended questions were used due to the desire for quantitative data which was analysed statistically
using a computer.
3.6. Data Analysis Techniques
The analysis and interpretation of the data was done through the use of computer software known
as Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 16.0 and Microsoft Excel. SPSS was
used to analyse quantitative data due to its ability to analyse quantitative data without difficulties.
Microsoft Excel on the other hand was used to analyse qualitative data due to its ability to produce
quality graphs and tables that are necessary in the analysis process.
25
4.0. Chapter 4-Data Presentation and Interpretation
4.1. Background Characteristics
4.1.1. Respondents by their sex
Figure 3- Respondents by thier sex
Majority of the respondents were female being 63% of the total respondents while the males
comprised only 38% of the respondents.
4.1.2. Respondents by their age groups
Table 1 -Respondents by age group
Age Group Respondents
16-19 11
20-24 36
25-29 2
30 and above 1
Majority of the respondents were of the age group between 20-24 years and comprise of 72% of
the all the respondents while 22% are aged between 16-19 years with those aged 25-29 being 4%
and those aged above 30 were only 2%.
Male, 19, 38%
Female, 31, 62%
Respondents by Their Sex
26
4.1.3. Respondents by program of study
Figure 4- Respondents by their programs of study
The majority of the respondents are studying Bachelor of Arts with Education which represents
49% of all the respondents while Bachelor of Arts in Environmental Education was second with
15% of the respondents with Bachelor of Arts with Library and Information Studies and Bachelor
of Science with Education being third with 13% each of the respondents followed by Bachelor of
Arts with Special Education and Bachelor of Adult Education representing 8% and 2%
respectively.
4.1.4. Respondents by province of secondary school attended
Figure 5-Respondents by secondary school attended
23, 49%
6, 13%
4, 8%
6, 13%
7, 15%
1, 2%
Programme of Study
B.A ED B.A LIS B.A Sp BSc ED B.A EED B.A AD
13
6 53
96
2 2 2 2
Schools attended by respondents
27
Majority of the respondents are from more highly urbanised provinces of Zambia such as Lusaka,
Southern, Central and Copperbelt provinces. Typically rural provinces have shortage of manpower
as most teacher tend to abandon the rural schools and careers masters have to spend more time
teaching than providing career guidance and counselling to pupils.
4.2. Access to Career Information
4.2.1. Whether the respondents received career information at their
secondary schools
Figure 6- Whether respondents accessed career information
Majority of the respondents did access career information and these represent 62% of the
respondents while those who had no access only present 38% of the respondents. The data also
reveals that majority of the respondents who had no access to career information where from rural
provinces and further that those who did have access to the information found it generally
irrelevant to their current career choices.
Of those who had no access to career information, 50% attributed it to lack of emphasis by the
schools on the importance and value of this information hence were generally not interested, 20%
of them attributed it to non-availability of careers guidance teachers in their offices while 30%
attributed it to lack of career guidance and counselling facility.
In terms of seeking access to careers information, only 8% of the respondents never sought careers
information while 82% sought to access the information and 10% never responded. And of those
who sought to obtain the careers information 56% sought it rarely while 44% sought it often.
Yes, 31, 62%
No, 18, 36%
NR, 1, 2%
Whether Respondents were provided with career information
28
4.2.2. Mode of career choice provision
Table 2- Mode of provision/Access to career information
Mode of Provision Respondents Percentage
Talks 4 12%
Teachers 16 52%
Leaflets 3 10%
School Careers Activities 3 10%
Visits from tertiary Institutions 5 16%
Majority of the respondents representing 52% of those who accessed career information accessed
it from their teachers in classroom set ups with 16% accessing it from visits from tertiary
institutions while the rest obtained it from independent talks, literature, and school careers
activities.
4.2.3. Hindrances to Accessing Career Information
Figure 7- Hindrances to accessing career information
There are several factors cited as hindrances to accessing career information by most pupils
however, majority attribute it to lack of access to careers masters due to various factors including
the careers master’s teaching engagements, the high pupil-careers master ratio and lack of
cooperation of careers masters. Others cited lack of programs by schools to promote and provide
career related information and some just had no interest also attributed to lack of proper education
on the value of career information.
16%
18%
20%
46%
Hindrances to accessing career information
Lack of interest Non-availability of CI programs
No Access to careers Masters Non Applicable
29
4.3. Awareness of Careers and Requirements
4.3.1. Extent of awareness of careers and their requirements
Figure 8- Extent of knowledge of careers and career requirements
Respondents were asked whether they were aware of careers and their requirements and 60% were
aware while only 40% were not aware. A follow up question however as shown in figure 6 above
reveals that though the majority of the respondents were aware, only 6, representing 12% of the
respondents were very aware while 20% were only quite aware of careers and their requirements
with the majority of 58% either never knew or were not very aware. The levels of awareness
therefore as illustrated in the number of responses reflects a decreasing level of awareness hence
a general lesser extent of awareness.
0
10
20
Very AwareQuite Aware
Not that AwareNot Aware at all
6 10 14 20
Extent of Knowledge of Career information
30
4.3.2. Sources of Information on careers and their requirements
Figure 9- Sources of career information on career requirements
Available Careers and their requirements as a critical part of career information at the time of
enrolment into the university was obtained in many ways with the majority being through career
talks at school and current or former university students and staff having 24% each followed by
parents and family members with 22% and internet and adverts with 18% the least being from
friends with 12%.
The school therefore only contributes as much as 24% with the rest of the 76% being from other
sources. This therefore implies that the majority of the respondents got information on career
requirements from sources outside the secondary schools.
Career Talks at Schools
24%
Current or former
students at the university
24%
Parents and family
members22%
internet and adverts
18%
Friends12%
Sources of information on career requirements
31
4.4. Career Information and Career Choices
4.4.1. Influence for current career (program of study) choice
Figure 10- Influences on career choices
Majority of the respondents had their career choice determined or influenced by their parents’
choices or decisions and this represents 42% of all respondents. 24% however had their career
choices determined by their Grade 12 results, a situation which would have been different had
adequate and relevant information been given before exams. Only 8% of the respondents were
influenced by their teachers. This implies that the career information obtained from schools
reduced in relevance at the point of making career choices. A follow up question revealed that
most of the students found the career information obtained from school largely irrelevant when
making their current career choices as they still had to seek for more and new information such
that 92% of the respondents had to seek extra information to make their career choices.
0 5 10 15 20 25
Teachers
Parents
Friends
University students/staff
Own Choice
Results
8
21
4
2
3
12
Influence on career choices
32
4.4.2. Current Career Choices, Career Information and Dream Careers
Figure 11- Satisfaction with current career choices
Asked whether they are satisfied with current career choices, the majority, as revealed in figure 7
above, expressed that they were not satisfied.
Asked again what career choices they would they have made if they had the career information
during their secondary school level of education that they currently have, only 8% chose their
current career choice with the rest falling prey to poor career information which limited their career
choices.
When asked why they would have made different career choices, majority stated that their Grade
12 results prevented them from pursuing their dream careers as they had little information of the
exact needed subject combination and requirements hence in principle got influenced by academic
performance.
12%
88%
Wether the respondents are satisfied with current career choices
Yes No
33
4.5. Adequacy of Provision of Career Facilities, Programs and
Information
4.5.1. Available facilities, programs and information
Figure 12- Availability of information, facilities and programs
As revealed in figure 10 above, majority of the respondents revealed that there were inadequate
programs and facilities in the schools from which to access career information despite the ready
availability of the information as revealed above. There is therefore a discrepancy between
availability of career information and their channel of dispersion being the programs and facilities.
Asked whether the available information was adequate, 70% found the information inadequate
while 30% found it adequate. Further, asked whether they found the facilities adequate, majority
being 78% found the available facilities inadequate with only 12% finding it adequate. As for the
programs, the majority (56%) found them useful in providing career information while 22% found
them useful with 14% not responsive while 8% had the question inapplicable to them since they
had no such programs.
0
20
40
ProgramsFacilities
Information
1411 31
36 39
19
Wether programs, facilities and information was available at the
schools
Yes
No
34
5.0. Chapter- Discussion of findings and Conclusion
5.1. Introduction
An established fact it is that information is foundational to proper planning and decision making
and that the quality of information is key to quality decision making. Given this case therefore,
correct, comprehensive, appropriate and relevant career information is a key ingredient to effective
career decision making which results into a proper match between an individual’s abilities and
skills with the job and career requirements and evidently so, pupils in secondary schools do not
have adequate and reliable information about their career opportunities and their requirement. This
chapter therefore discusses the research findings and their implications and impacts.
5.2. Characteristic features of career information provision in Zambia
5.2.1. Introduction
Information is generally accepted as a key decision making tool and input and given that the role
of the education institution is not only to educate the pupils on various subject matters but also to
provide career and lifetime guidance training and coaching, it is imperative that both aspects of
the roles of education be effectively and adequately covered in both curricula and extra curricula
activities. Career information is seen as part of a complex and process of child developmental
growth and coaching and that it is critical to career systems, career processes and career functions
in the light of the entire systematic and social societal function ( Phillips, 2008). Career
information is therefore a cornerstone of a well functional society as it provides avenues for the
proper preparation of pupils for appropriate and relevant job and career placement which
ultimately results into a specialised and well functional society in which every member contributes
their best.
However several features of our career information provision systems in Zambia render it quite
dysfunctional and distortional to the general tone of society’s needs. This section therefore
discusses these characteristic features as derived from section 4.1 of the data presentation
supported by other findings within the entire chapter four hence provides a general outlook of the
entire research findings.
5.2.2. Gender and career information provision
OECD Council of Government Ministers (2011: 89) report notes that “gender differences in
educational choices appear to be related to student attitudes (motivation, interest) in studying a
particular subject rather than their ability and school performance.” This is clearly pictured in the
higher number of women in the school of education as noted in figure 3 which indicates that 62%
35
of students in the school of education are female simply because the school and field of education
has been stereotyped to be feminine while the school of natural sciences has been stereotyped as
masculine a feature which consciously or unconsciously is engrafted into the pupils’ school
environment composed of the majority of female teachers. This has resulted into greater career
path distortions for most females and general poor career performance in the education system as
teachers are not necessarily teaching based on their skills and abilities but by mere adherence to
societal career stereotyping. In Kenya, the situation is reported to even be worse as revealed by
Rukwaro (2011) that “girls in rural areas choose careers that are generally poorly paid because
they are in keeping with the socio-cultural norms.” This can be further hypothesised to be one of
the contributing causes of the failure of career guidance systems in secondary schools as well as
the provision of distorted career information provision the schools.
OECD report further notes that “gender gaps in performance are smaller than gender gaps in fields
of tertiary study, indicating that young women often do not translate their good school
performance into field of studies for higher education that offer better employment prospects, such
as STEM studies. Furthermore, even when women complete STEM studies they are less likely
than men to work in these sectors. While it is difficult to separate innate and learned behaviours
and to assess the influence of stereotypes, the effect of this gender imbalance is very clear. It
hinders women’s careers; it lowers their future earnings levels and deprives OECD economies of
a source of talent and innovation. Stereotyped school environments, activities, and career
information therefore has far reaching impacts especially on women evidently caught up in the
society’s career and social guidance distortions. Several other research findings indicate that career
paths in field of education, nursing, child care and support, catering and hospitality have been
relegated to women while the more high paying ones have been dominated by men.
The research findings further indicate that there is a much more general lack of interest in seeking
career information by women than it is for men comparatively such that 95% of the males sought
career information while at school and as for the women, the entire 10% of the none respondents
where female, 75% of those who never sought for career information being female and hence
statistically 88% of the girls sort for career information if we treat the non-respondents as blank
files (for statistical reference see data interpretation under figure 6).
The research findings indicate a similar trend in other countries including Ethiopia where Alemu
(2013) in a study on the Assessment of the Provisions of Guidance and Counselling Services in
Secondary Schools of East Harerge Zone and Hareri Region of Ethiopia reports that male pupil’s
36
utilization of the career guidance and counselling services was significantly higher than their
female counter parts. However while this study attributed it to sex role stereotyping Alemu’s study
attributed the discrepancy to fear of seeking help from career guidance counsellors.
5.2.3. Age and career information provision
Statistics on age in relation to career information seems unavailable in the many available avenues
of information sources. However, the data reveals that majority of the respondents’ age range was
20-24 which corresponds with Silanda et al (1999)’s statistical data on majority university
entrants. They note that “2 present of the 20-24 age group enter a university or some other form
of higher education” and this 2% age group constitutes the majority 72% University students
sampled from the school of education as noted by figure 7 of this report. The rationale for the late
career information introduction as stipulated in the education policy of Zambia dabbed “Educating
Our Future” is that learners are only mature enough to consider such matters after their ninth grade.
They state that it is believed that on completion of nine years of schooling the learner would be
more mature when facing career or educational choices, and would base these on a fuller
realization and understanding of his or her abilities, talents and interests.
This age group however is a youthful and productive age group which should have gone miles in
their career paths and results, however, it is at this age group that majority of the respondents gain
real and relevant career information and forces them into “alternative” career choices due to
mismatches in the career requirements demands and career qualifications possessed which would
have been avoided if correct, adequate and comprehensive career information was provided in
schools. This results in general mismatch of individual skills and abilities with job demands and
results into greater dissatisfaction with career choices and poor performance in the work place.
The need therefore to adopt an all age career guidance and training program embedded into the
existing levels and stages of education is a key imperative for effective career information and
guidance provision. Watts (2010) argues that the notion of an all-age careers service is supported
by the existing international evidence. The OECD Career Guidance Policy Review pointed out
that all-age services have a number of organisational and resource-used advantages. By allowing
a diverse range of services to be provided throughout the lifespan within one organisational
framework, they are potentially more cost-effective, avoiding unnecessary duplication of
resources. More recent reviews benchmarked against the OECD review, of the three major existing
examples of all-age services – in New Zealand, Scotland and Wales – have all been very positive.
Together, they indicate that an all-age service has an opportunity to think more broadly and more
37
systematically about the nature and applicability of its professionalism, the allocation of its
resources across the whole population, and the links between career guidance and public policy,
than is the case with age-segmented services, especially those that are embedded into particular
service sectors (e.g. schools). In effect, such a service provides a strong professional spine for a
lifelong career guidance system. So long as it recognises that it cannot provide all the career
guidance that is needed, and must pay significant attention to supporting embedded career support
in educational institutions, in workplaces and in the community, the evidence indicates that it
provides a particularly robust base for such a system.
In the USA, Section 29 of their Education Act of 2011 placed schools under a duty to secure access
to independent careers guidance for their pupils in school years 9 to 11 hence career information
provision is started in the early years. This is noted to be a statutory guidance from the Department
for Education. This means that recipients must have regard to it when carrying out duties relating
to the provision of careers guidance for young people. This guidance has been updated to help
schools plan for the extension of the duty to secure independent and impartial careers guidance
down to year 8 and up to years 12 and 13 from September 2013.
The purpose of this guidance as they review is to identify the key responsibilities of schools in
relation to careers guidance for young people. Schools therefore are noted to have a role to play
in supporting their pupils to make well informed and realistic decisions by providing access to
impartial and independent information and guidance about the range of education and training
options that are most likely to help young people achieve their ambitions.
The need to therefore carefully rethink our legislation and policies in Zambia is imperative as
evident from the success stories other countries such as New Zealand, Scotland and Wales and the
lessons learnt and by countries like the USA in their legislative and policy reforms. The age factor
therefore for introduction as well as intensive career information provision as well as guidance
and counselling of the pupils must be considered highly to begin with those at primary school
level.
5.2.4. Urban-rural schools disparities in career information provision
Characteristic of the career information provision system in Zambian schools is depicted by the
high levels of disparity in access to facilities, programs and information in relation to careers. This
is evident firstly in the low number of university entrant from rural provinces as compared to those
from urban provinces. Secondly, it is also evident in the fact that of the 18 respondents who did
not have access to career information, 15 where from rural provinces of Zambia representing 83%
38
of those who lack access to career information. The problem of lack of access to career information
is therefore seen as primarily a rural problem whereas the problem of inadequate and inappropriate
information is seen as primarily an urban problem.
These rural-urban disparities have thus resulted in greater inequalities and low social mobility for
the rural population especially that the rural population is primarily dependant on education as a
key mobility factor. The rural schools are faced with a lot of challenges which affect their ability
to effectively provide career information to their pupils and these include lack of man power in
terms of teaching staff which forces the careers master to take up full time roles in teaching rather
than providing career guidance programs. Secondly there is lack of adequate infrastructure and
facilities such as offices and material to aid in the career information provision process. Thirdly,
there is lack of well outlined programs by the schools since much of the programs require
collaboration with universities and colleges which are reluctant to do so in the rural areas
especially those not easily accessible by roads.
5.2.5. Conclusion
Career Information provision is a critical part of the roles of secondary school and as noted above,
that role has been poorly undertaken. The career information provision has been characterised by
such features as gender disparities to access of information, sex role stereotyping of career choices,
rural-urban disparities to access of career information, age gap differentiation of career
information provision, late adequate access to career information, and general collapse of the
relevance of the school’s role in the child career guidance program. There is therefore need to
effectively tackle these pertinent issues currently affecting the career information provision
process. Eyo et al (2010) in a similar study conducted in Nigeria unveiled that “gender and school
location significantly influenced students’ attitude towards guidance services. The results further
revealed that there are significant differences between attitude of male and female students in rural
and urban schools towards guidance and counselling services.” The gender, age and rural-urban
factors must therefore be carefully subjected to a rigorous policy analytic procedure to develop
policies with relevant institutional and legal frameworks to ensure proper implementation.
5.3. Access to career information in Zambia’s secondary schools
5.3.1. Introduction
Access to information is seen as a civil right and further embedded in the United Nations chatter
for children’s rights. Information is a key to informed decision making and lack of adequate
information results into serious error of judgement and this can even be fatal when that information
39
pertains to lifelong decisions such as career choices. Lack of access to career information is not
only a violation of the children’s rights but also a failure of the key objective of educational
institutions hence a critical need to ensure that there is adequate access to careers information.
However, the Zambian secondary school situation in terms of career information access is
worrisome. While it shows bright situations its real impact is quite negative as already seen and
as shall be further elaborated.
5.3.2. Access to career information
Chileshe (2006:3) in his doctoral thesis report makes the following profound statement
“Adolescence is a period of making choices, especially concerning the future. Stead (1987:13)
states that adolescents need assistance in making subject choices and deciding on careers. This
view is illustrated by Hamrin and Erickson’s (1939:9) and Kochhar’s (2003:19-20; 25)
observations that many young men and women enter higher education institutions with little
knowledge of the courses to be selected and careers to follow. Consequently, guidance and
counselling by schools is a systematic effort to improve the quality of choices. In view of the
above, schools should consider ways and means of giving assistance to the student in choosing his
or her career on a more informed basis. Therefore, schools should have effective G&C services
for the adolescents they serve.”
Given the value of informed decision making, the provision of adequate, comprehensive and
relevant information is critical in ensuring that career choices are made in an informed manner.
However, the Zambian situation is quite hideous in that though it shows that there are high levels
of access to career information (62% as noted in figure 6), majority of these are from urban areas,
and get largely inadequate and irrelevant information to real issues faced in career choice making.
The lack of access clearly shows that our education system as well as educational institutions have
rather lapsed in their effort to provide this information to their pupils and ensure that they are
adequately prepared for the after school life. The need to provide this information is the ultimate
goal of the education system which is career development and training. A gap in information
results in misplacement of human resource such that careers do not reflect individual abilities
fitness.
It is therefore due to lack of adequate access to career information that majority of the respondents
(88%, see figure 11) are dissatisfied with their chosen careers as they chose their current careers
on the basis of necessity due to results and subject combinations. The information therefore is
40
critical at every point of secondary and primary school level and must be emphasised as much as
possible.
5.3.3. Factors for lack of adequate access to career information
As Chileshe notes above, career choices begin with the choice of subject combinations at
secondary schools which unfortunately for the Zambian situation is done arbitrarily with no career
considerations and is often limited by the limited subjects available at the secondary school. The
subject provided at the schools often is as a result of availability of teaching staff that are in critical
shortage in rural areas due to rural hardships which teachers deployed there cannot stand. Further,
access to adequate and relevant career information has been barred by ineffective or unavailable
career guidance and counselling programs, facilities and information.
5.3.4. Conclusion
While there is evidently and statistically access to career information, it is just as factually evident
that this information is gender and urban biased, is limited and is largely inadequate as the ultimate
career decisions were made not using the information gotten while at the secondary school but
that gotten after secondary school. There is evidently failure by the schools especially in rural
areas to provide proper career information, and further to ensure that the schools have enough
facilities, programs and information for career guidance, counselling and training. The secondary
schools in Zambia therefore have to heighten their efforts in ensuring adequate and relevant careers
information is provided.
5.4. Career information and career choices
5.4.1. Introduction
To make career choices, career information is always obtained from various sources. The used
sources generally denoted unreliability and inadequacy. The need to therefore ensure that right
career choices are made is relegated much to the need to ensure that right career information is
obtained which in most cases is too late for most pupils. Early provision of career information
ensures that there is early preparation done for various desired careers and that the pupil is fully
aware of the odds and challenges of their desired and chosen careers. In Zambian secondary school
as shall be seen later, there is a great discrepancy in information provision such that the influence
of the school on their pupils’ career choices is limited and almost positively insignificant
ultimately.
5.4.2. Secondary school careers information’s influence on/relevance to career choices
Evidently, the role of career information obtained in secondary schools reduces in relevance at the
point of making career choices in universities. This is evident in that while as much as 62% had
41
access to careers information at school, only 8% used this information to influence their career
choices with the majority springing from parents (42%) while 24% from their secondary school
Grade 12 results, a situation which, as already noted, would have been avoided had adequate and
relevant information been given before exams by the secondary schools.
The research also reveals that the career information obtained from the secondary school is largely
irrelevant when making career choices as it was deemed by the respondents as inadequate, who
still had to seek for more and new information such that 92% of the respondents had to seek extra
information to make their career information. This therefore points to the general inadequacy of
the career information obtained at school in career decision making as also reported by Lugulu
(2011) who argue that career guidance and counselling provided in schools is inadequate to enable
students make informed choices of degree programs.
Invaluable to career choice is the knowledge of careers and their requirements. In terms of
awareness of careers and career requirements therefore, the awareness levels where high such that
60% were aware while only 40% were not aware. However, only 12% of the respondents were
very aware while 20% were only quite aware of careers and their requirements with the majority
of 58% either never knew or were not very aware. In other words, though the schools manage to
instil some level of awareness, the awareness levels are very low such that the information
provided is largely deemed irrelevant when making career choices as already seen above.
The failure to provide adequate and relevant career information has resulted in a majority of 88%
students dissatisfied with only 8% of the total pursuing their dream careers as the rest fell prey to
poor career requirement information which limited their career choices. The majority had their
secondary school (Grade 12) results baring them from pursuing their dream careers as they had
little information of the exact needed subject combination and requirements hence in principle got
influenced by academic performance. As also revealed by Lugulu (2011) in a similar study in
Kenya, students’ degree programme decisions were guided by other factors rather than interest.
5.4.3. Conclusion
While there is high levels of access to career information and while there are high levels of
awareness of careers and career requirements in secondary schools career information provision,
there is evidently low levels of relevance of the information to career choices as well as low levels
of awareness of the exact career requirements. The resultant dissatisfactions of this scenario is that
these would-be educators are likely to result into poor job performers hence poor performance and
motivation of their pupils. Career guidance and counselling is therefore a major issue in hindering
42
students in making right choices for their future careers as revealed by a study conducted by Khan
et al (2012) in Pakistan.
5.5. Availability of career information, facilities and programs in
secondary schools
5.5.1. Introduction
Many schools especially in rural areas are faced with real challenges when it comes to the
provision of career information to their pupils. This is primarily due to lack of adequate financial,
human and material resources as well as adequate infrastructure. As we shall see, the availability
of the necessary means and ways of providing career information when missing may result in poor
information service delivery to end user. As theorised in the D&M model (DeLone and McLean
2008), information service delivery in general and information systems in specific are only as
efficient dependant on the quality of technology used, the quality of the information used, the
usability of the technology/information if there is going to be a resultant satisfactory use of it, net
benefits and service quality.
5.5.2. Available career information delivery systems or channels
While at school, the major source of channel of delivery of careers information was classroom
lessons on careers representing 52% of those who access career information, with 16% accessing
it from visits from tertiary institutions and 10% from independent talks while the rest obtained it
from literature, and school careers activities. These statistics vary from studies conducted in
developed countries such as Australia where it is reported that on average, students were reported
to have accessed at least five different types of career information provision activities. This implies
that the majority 80% of the information delivery channels in Zambian secondary schools is
through verbal communication while only 20% is non-verbal. Effectiveness of verbal
communication alone tends to reduce with time as it suffers from memory loss (memory
interferences) hence tend to be more easily forgotten. The difference therefore between verbal and
non-verbal modes can be attributed in part to the “irrelevance” of the information.
At the stage of enrolment into the university however, there is a broader range of information
sources exposure not utilised in the secondary school. Information delivery systems or rather
sources now include the internet, media, families and friends, university faculty and students.
These include as broader range of both verbal and non-verbal sources as well as the inclusion of
ICTs.
43
5.5.3. Levels of availability and exposure to career information, programs and facilities
in secondary schools
The research findings reveal that there were inadequate programs, information channels and
facilities in the schools from which to access career information. While information is readily
available, there is a discrepancy between availability of career information and their channel of
dispersion being the programs and facilities.
Further, the available information was found to be inadequate by 70%, the facilities inadequate by
78% while the programs where found to be inapplicable by 22%. These findings are however not
strange to literature as even Alemu (2013:1) reports in his study that the schools guidance
and counselling programs did not have written plans, specific roles and responsibilities and private
counselling rooms. There was loose coordination among principals, teachers, and guidance and
counselling programs. Indicating that there were program, facility and informational huddles in
the provision of career guidance and counselling in secondary schools even in Ethiopia. Lugulu
(2011:196) also found that “the level of career guidance and counselling provided in secondary
schools was neither well planned nor organized.” Also indicating a problem with the career
information provision programs in Kenya where Rukwaro (2011) also found that there is need for
career information for teachers, parents and pupils because the existing career programme is
inadequate for efficient dissemination of career information for the pupils to be able to make wise
career decisions.
5.5.4. Conclusion
Information provision and dissemination is a complex process requiring systems, processes,
programs, facilities and technologies for effectiveness. This however is problematic in the
Zambian situation to attain because of various factors ranging from lack of availability of
resources, lack of political will, and poorly trained careers master. There is a critical shortage of
material, financial and human resources as well as administrative skills to effectively lay out
programs which will be relevant, appropriate and adequate enough for the career information need
of their pupils.
5.6. Conclusion The study and research has therefore unveiled a lot of issues pertaining to career information
provision in Zambian secondary schools as seen in both chapter four and chapter five of this report.
One fact however is clear and this is that the Zambian situation is not very different from that of
other developing countries including Kenya, Nigeria, Ethiopia and Zimbabwe in contrast to
developed countries such as Scotland, Australia, Wales and New Zealand.
44
5.6.1. Summary of major research conclusion
Several conclusions can be drawn in relation to the major research findings and these include the
following:
Gender inequalities still characterise the Zambian education system such that even in terms
of access to and provision of career information males seem to have an upper hand.
Career information provision in Zambian secondary schools has been characterised by sex
role stereotyping and is gender biased in favour of the males despite the fact that the
majority of the teachers are female.
Zambian schools in general and the secondary schools in particular introduce career
guidance programs late hence the results of their efforts are almost insignificant.
Rural-urban discrepancy exists in relation to career information provision such that pupils
in rural areas have lesser access to career information while those in urban areas have
greater access. This is due to the fact that they generally lack adequate material, financial,
and human resources as well as access to new career information, facilities and programs.
There is access by majority pupils to some form of career information in secondary school
which however is inadequate, and generally not relevant enough to make career informed
choices. Hence greater dissatisfaction due to career frustrations.
Channels for information provision in Zambian secondary schools are narrow and not
effective enough to achieve an effective and efficient career education system. There is
need to ensure that a much broader range of information sources, channels, systems and
programs are put in place.
Rural areas as well as most urban areas face financial, material and human resources
constraints hence have inadequate facilities, undertake inefficient and inadequate programs
as well as having lesser access to effective information sources and systems.
5.6.2. Research and policy recommendations
Every social research must prove itself relevant to both the scientific community and social
community hence must be an applied to some degree. The extent of relevance shall therefore be
reflected in the recommendation for both policy and research. Given the above research findings
and conclusions therefore the following recommendations can be forwarded:
5.6.2.1 Policy Recommendation
The following are some of the few recommendations isolated to help redress the problems and
challenges identified in the research findings, discussions and conclusions and these include:
45
The Ministry of Gender and child development must step in with other stakeholder to assist
the Ministry of Education Science, Vocational Training and Early Education in developing
a Policy Document to help redress the gender inequalities in the career development and
counselling programs both at school and other places as well as help redress sex role
stereotyping as the current Gender policy has failed to yield effective results so far.
Zambian Schools need to introduce an all age career guidance process that does not
relegate the task of career guidance to secondary school as this stage is rather too late as
many would have already selected their subject combination which determines their career
choices.
Career guidance and training programs must be mainstreamed into the curriculum from
early childhood levels alongside sex role and gender education
There is need for increased funding by the Ministry of Education Science, Vocational
Training and Early Education for provision of adequate material, financial, and human
resources especially in rural areas to ensure the pupils gain access to career information,
facilities and programs.
The current high levels of career information access must be improved in terms of greater
access and adequacy hence schools must ensure compulsory career counselling, and
increasing avenues for promotion of career information.
Channels for information provision in Zambian secondary schools must be broadened to
include ICTs and visual technologies.
5.6.2.2 Research Recommendations
5.6.2.2.1 Introduction
Academic and professional literature in various fields has been flooded with various works on the
subject of careers. Several reports have been developed and published with many more
unpublished ones discussing it from its many facets and dimensions and the critical question which
emerges is of the relevance of this piece of work to academia and science. Here, a justification of
the relevance of this study will be presented in highlighting the significance of the findings and
make relevant recommendations to the research community for further investigations.
5.6.2.2.2 Significance and recommendation of findings
Given the characteristic features of Career information provision in Zambian secondary schools
which include: Gender bias towards the male, sex role stereotyping, Post adolescence career
training and information provision, inadequacy of information provision as well as an urban bias
to career information access, a new dimension to the characteristic problems of career information
46
provision has been significantly added. Having had unearthed these factors, several research
recommendations can be made which include:
A Gender policy evaluation study to further investigate the impact of this gender bias in
career information provision in Zambian Schools on career choices, development and
training. This is because while this study significantly revealed the gender bias, it is not a
policy monitoring and evaluation to ensure a comprehensive impact assessment is done in
that regard.
An investigation can be under taken on the provision of career information in the pre-
Secondary School levels of education to investigate the potential of an all age career
information policy in Zambian Schools
The impact of the post adolescence career information guidance and counselling program
can be undertaken.
A comparative investigation can be undertaken on the rural-urban Secondary school Career
information provision challenges and constraints in Zambia so as to further investigate the
extent of the discrepancy and develop policy, institutional and even legal framework of
action to ensure equality and equity is attained.
The research further reports that there exist a lot of challenges by Zambian Secondary schools in
the provision of career information dues to such factors as lack of facilities, and resources (human,
capital and material) as well as technical and technological factors in information acquisition,
processing and determination and delivery. Further investigations can therefore be undertaken on
some of the following informational gaps revealed by this study:
Information delivery systems in Zambian secondary schools on careers and their
requirements
Extent of non-availability of careers programs, facilities and information available to the
Zambian secondary schools and its impact on provision of career information to the pupils.
Availability of capital, financial and material resources to Zambian secondary schools’
guidance and counselling program and facilities
Use of ICTs in career information acquisition, storage, processing and dissemination in
Zambian secondary schools
5.6.2.2.3 Conclusion
Though this research, within its scope, has provided a lot of insights into the problems and
challenges of career information provision and has unearthed a lot of findings it must be noted that
47
with its many limitations of scope it has also left research gaps as those proposed above which
provide avenues for even further research investigations.
48
Bibliography ACA (2003). School counseling services -- research summary. Alexandria: Office of Public Policy
and Legislation.
ACTE (2003). The role of the guidance profession in a shifting education system. Alexandria, VA:
Association for Career and Technical Education.
Alemu, Y. (2013). Assessment of the Provisions of Guidance and Counseling Services in
Secondary Schools of East Harerge Zone and Hareri Region. Middle Eastern & African Journal
of Educational Research, Issue 2. Haramaya University.
Babbie, E. (2007). The practice of social research. California: Thompson Wadworth.
Babbie, E. (2005). The basics of social research. California: Thompson Wadsworth.
Baker, S., & Taylor, J. (1998). Effects of career development interventions: A meta-analysis. The
Career Development Quarterly, 46, 376-385.
Best W., & Kahn V. (1983). Research in Education. New Delhi: Prentice Hall Ltd.
Bezanson, L., & Kellet, R. (2001). Integrating Career Information and Guidance Services at a
Local Level. OECD and OCDE
Blalock Jr. M.H. (1972). Social Statistics (2nd ed.). London: Routledge.
Brown, S.D., & Ryan Krane, N.E. (2000). “Four (or five) sessions and a cloud of dust: New
assumptions and new observations about career counseling”, In S.D. Brown & R.W. Lent (Eds.)
Handbook of counseling psychology (3rd ed. pp. 740-766). New York: Wiley.
Blustein, D. (2002). The relationship between career development and educational development:
A selected review of the literature. Boston College.
Cohen, M., & Marrison (2000). Research Methods in Education (5th ed.). London: Routledge and
Palmer.
Cresswel, J.W. (2003). Research design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods
Approaches (2nd ed.). London: Sage.
49
Eyo, M. B.; Joshua, A. M.; & Esuong, A. E. (2010). Attitude of Secondary School Students towards
Guidance and Counselling Services in Cross River State. Edo Journal of Counselling Vol. 3, No.
1. Calabar.
Khan, H.; Murtaza, F., & Shafa, D.M. (2012). Role of Teachers in Providing Educational and
Career Counseling to the Secondary School Students in Gilgit-Baltistan of Pakistan. International
Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development, April, Vol. 1, No. 2.
Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (2000). Choice, Values, Frames. Cambridge University Press.
Dykeman, C., Ingram, M., Wood, C., Charles, S., Chen, Meng-Yin; & Herr, E. L. (2001). “The
Taxonomy of Career Development Interventions that Occur in America's Secondary Schools”.
ERIC Digest CG-01-04. The Educational, Social, and Economic Value of Informed and
Considered Career Decisions 22
Evans, J., & Burck, H. (1992). “The Effects of Career Education Interventions on Academic
Achievement: A meta-analysis”. Journal of Counseling & Development, 71, 63-68.
Ertelt, B.-J & Seidel, G. (1998). Information needs for individual career decisions. Luxembourg:
Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
Frankfort-Nachmias., & Nachmias, D. (1996). Research methods in the social sciences. London:
Arnold.
Gillie, S. (2002). “Career information delivery systems”. In the online version of Improved career
decision-making. Washington: U.S. Department of Education Office of Vocational and Adult
Education. Retrieved Sept.19, 2003, from http://www.acrnetwork.org/icdm/topics.htm - listed as
Activity - Accessing State and Local Labor Market Information (CIDS).
Gillie, S., & Fall, M.G.I. (2003). The Education, Social, and Economic Value of Informed and
Considered Career Decisions. ACRNA
Gillie, S., Buhl, C., Miwa, L., Mollerup, C., Shatkin, L., & Shenk, P. (2002). “ACSCI standards
implementation handbook”. Tulsa: Association of Computer-based Systems for Career
Information.
Grimme, D., & Grimme, S. The realities and options. Retrieved September 19, 2003, from
Workplace Violence Headquarters. Available at http:// www.workplace-violence-hq.com/.
50
Gysbers, N.C. (2007). “Facilitating career development through comprehensive guidance and
counseling programs K-12”. Professional Counselling Digest ACAPCD-04.
Gysbers, N., & Henderson, P. (1994). Developing and managing your school guidance program
(2nd ed). Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association.
Herbert S.P. (1962). Forecasting Educational Needs for Economic Development: Mediterranean
Regional Project. Paris: OECD
Hicks, O.J. (1990). Information Systems in Business: an introduction (2nd ed.). New York: West
Publishing Co.
Hutchison, S.E., & Sawyer, S.C. (1996). Computers and Information Systems, (5th ed.). New York:
McGraw-Hill.
Hoyt, K., & Lester, J. (1995). Learning to work: The NCDA Gallup survey. Alexandria, VA:
National Career Development Association.
Howieson, C., & Semple, S. (1996). Guidance in secondary schools: Career and the World of
Work. Centre for Educational Sociology Briefings. 5 June.
Hughes, K.L., & Karp, M.M. (2004). School based career development: a synthesis of the
literature. Available at www.tc.columbia.edu/ieee/public.html. (Accessed on 2nd June, 2008).
Isaacson, L.E. (1985). Basics of career counseling. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Jassat, M., & Liebenberg, M. (2004). Career choice and life aspirations: an exploratory study at
South African University of Natal. Available at
41.204.53.186.8080/dspace/bitstream/…/1/OCANSEY%202005.pdf, (Accessed 0n 21st
December 2009).
Johnson, B., & Christensen, L. (2008). Educational research: quantitative, qualitative and mixed
approaches. Los Angeles: Sage.
Johnson, P. (1988). Effective secondary schooling: factors affecting academic achievement in the
common wealth of Bahamas (Doctoral Thesis). University of Toronto.
Kepner, C. H., & Tregoe, B. B. (1965). The Rational Manager: A Systematic Approach to Problem
Solving and Decision-Making. McGraw-Hill
51
Kellett, R., & Conger, S. (1995), “A Three-Tiered Model of Career Counseling Services”,
Greensboro, NC,ERIC Clearinghouse on Counseling and Student Services. Ottawa: Greensboro,
NC, and Canadian Career Development Foundation.
Kothari, C.R. (2004). Research methodology: methods and techniques. New Delhi: Wiley Eastern.
Lapan, R., Gysbers, N., & Petroski, G. (2001). “Helping seventh graders to be safe and successful:
A statewide study of the impact of comprehensive guidance and counseling programs”. Journal of
Counseling & Development, 79, 320-330.
Lapan, R., Gysbers, N., & Sun, Y. (1997). “Effects of Comprehensive Guidance Programs”.
Journal of Counseling and Development, 75, 292-302.
Lokan, J., Fleming, M., & Tuck, B. (1993). “Career-related information: Australian perspectives
on its importance and usefulness”. Australian Journal of Career Development, 2(1), 14-19.
Lugulu, J.M.A., & Kipkoech, L.C. (2011). “The Effect of Provision of Career Guidance
Information in Secondary Schools on Choice of Degree Programme”. Eldoret: Scholarlink
Research Institute Journals
Lundu, M. (1996). The Economy of Information. Harare: SAPES Books.
Marks, G.N. (2006). “The transition to full-time work of young people who do not go to
university”. LSAY Research Report No. 49. Melbourne: ACER.
Ministry of Education (2004). Managing a School Guidance and Counselling Programme:
Module 1. Lusaka: Ministry of Education
Ministry of Education (2001).Teacher’s Curriculum Manual. Lusaka: CDC
Monahan, G. (2000). Management Decision Making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Muro, J.J., and Kottman, T. (1995). Guidance and Counselling in the Elementary and Middle
Schools: A practical Approach. Iowa: Wm.c. Brown Communications, inc
Mwanakatwe, J.M. (1973). The growth of education in Zambia since independence (Revised
Edition). Nairobi: Oxford University Press
New Zealand Education Review Office, 1999.
52
OECD .(2011). Report on the Gender Initiative: Gender Equality in Education. Employment and
Entrepreneurship, Meeting of the OECD Council at Ministerial Level Paris, 25-26 May 2011.
Ogle, T. (2001). The Effects of Public School Spending for Instruction and Counseling Services
on College Attendance (Doctoral dissertation). Indiana State University.
Osborne, D.S., & Baggerly, J.N. (2004). School counselor’s perception of career counselling and
career testing; preferences, priorities and predictors. Journal of career development 31(1) pp.45-
59.
Oso, W.Y., & Onen, D. (2005). A general guide to writing research proposal and report: a
handbook for beginning researchers. Kisumu: Options.
Patton, M.Q. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research methods. California: Sage.
Phillips K.P.A. (2008). Review of Career Development Services in Australian Tertiary
Institutions. Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations, Canberra.
Rothman, S., & Hillman, K. (2008). “Career Advice in Australian Secondary Schools: Use and
Usefulness. Longitudinal Survey of Australian Youths (LSAY)”, Research Report 53. Victoria:
ACER
Rukwaru, M.W. (2011). Provision and Access to Career Information to Secondary School Girls
in Nyahururu Division, Laikipia West District, Kenya. Eldoret: Moi University (Thesis DPHIL)
Sadler, J., & A. Reisenberger. (1997). On Course for Next Steps: Careers Education and Guidance
for Students in FEDA. London.
The Standard (UK), 18th April 2008, pp. 29.
Triantaphyllou, E. (2000). Multi-Criteria Decision Making: A Comparative Study. Dordrecht:
Springer Publishers.
UNESCO (2000). Guidance and Counseling Programme Development Module 8. Paris:
UNESCO.
Watts, A.G. (2010). Career Guidance and Post-Secondary Vocational Education and Training.
Paris: OECD
53
Watts, A.G. (2010). National all-age career guidance services: evidence and issues. British
Journal of Guidance and Counselling, 38(1), 31-44.
http://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1698/Zambia-EDUCATIONAL-SYSTEM-
OVERVIEW.html
54
Appendixes
Appendix 1- Research Question
Instructions:
1. Do not indicate your name on the questionnaire.
2. Mark the answer that expresses your view with an X.
3. Write answers where required in blank spaces provided.
SECTION B
ACCESS TO CAREERS INFORMATION
5. Was careers information provided at your former secondary school? (If Yes, go to Q8)
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
SECTION A
BACKGROUND
1. Sex.
a. Male [ ]
b. Female [ ]
2. How old were you on your last birthday?
a. 16-19 [ ]
b. 20-24 [ ]
c. 25-29 [ ]
d. 30 and above [ ]
3. What is your programme of study?
...........................................................................................................................................
4. Which secondary school(s) did you go to? (State school name and province)
................................................................................................................................................
0FFICIAL USE
ONLY
55
6. If No to Q5 above, what are some of the reasons for not accessing and using the careers
information facility in order to gain access to careers information?
...................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
7. If Yes to Q5 above, how often did you seek careers information at secondary school?
..................................................................................................................................................
8. How was careers information provided? (State the methods).
...................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
9. Did you experience hindrances when accessing careers information? If any please briefly
explain.
……………………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………………….
SECTION C
AWARENESS OF CAREERS AND THEIR REQUIREMENTS
10. Were you aware of various courses you could choose for your college or university
education while you were at secondary school?
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
11. If you were aware of any courses, what was your level of awareness?
a. Very aware [ ]
b. Quite aware [ ]
c. Not that aware [ ]
d. Not aware at all [ ]
12. If Yes to Q 10 above, how did you know about the courses in colleges or universities?
...................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
56
13. Were you aware about the requirements for each course you knew while at secondary
school?
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
14. In your opinion, do you think secondary schools provide enough careers information
about various courses and their requirements to pupils?
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
SECTION D
SOURCES OF CAREERS INFORMATION
15. What influenced you to choose the course or programme you are doing?
a. Teachers through guidance and counselling [ ]
b. Parents [ ]
c. Friends [ ]
d. Other specify.....................................................
16. Was the careers information you received useful when making careers choice?
a. Yes
b. No
17. What sources of careers information were available at your secondary school?
i).................................... ii)...................................... iii)...........................
iv)..................................
18. Are you satisfied with the course you are studying?
a. Yes
b. No
19. If No to 18 above, what careers choices would you have made now? Give reasons for
such a choice.
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
57
20. Which source(s) of careers information did you find useful for career decision making
while at secondary school?
i)…………………………… ii)………………………….. iii)……………………..
iv)………………………….
SECTION E
ADEQUACY OF PROVISION OF CAREERS INFORMATION
21. Did the school provide any of the following? (Tick appropriate).
a. Careers programs [ ]
b. Careers facility [ ]
c. Careers information [ ]
22. If the school provided careers programs and careers facility, how useful were they in
providing careers information?
................................................................................................................................................
23. Did you find the careers information available at secondary school adequate? (If any
was provided)
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
24. If No to 22 above, give reasons why you think the careers information was insufficient.
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
25. What careers activities were put in place for providing careers information in secondary
school? (i.e. careers talks, visits by colleges or universities)
i).............................................. ii)............................................ iii)................................
iv)............................................
58
26. If there were any activities, do you think such activities were useful in providing careers
information?
a. Yes [ ]
b. No [ ]
27. What would you recommend to be done in order to improve careers information
provision in secondary schools?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
THANK YOU...
59
Appendix 2- Budget
Activity 1 – Secondary Data Collection (Literature review)
Activity/items Cost (ZMK)
Internet browsing K50
Transport to and from school for research purposes K50
Food K200
Subtotal K300
Activity 2 – Preparation of Research Proposal (Proposal writing)
Stationary Cost (ZMK)
Plain Paper (2 reams) K60
Pens (pack of ten) K15
Writing pads (2) K16
Typing and Printing of draft proposal K90
Printing and binding of final research proposal K40
Subtotal K221
Activity 3 – Preparation and pre-testing of data collection Instruments
Activity/Items Cost (ZMK)
Cost of typing and printing of questionnaire K36
Cost of pre-test sample material K50
Food K80
Subtotal K 166
Activity 4 – Data collection
Activity/Items Cost (ZMK)
Photocopying of 50 copies of questionnaires K70
Food K150
Subtotal K220
Activity 5- Data Analysis and Interpretation (Report Writing)
Activity/Items Cost (ZMK)
Typing and colour printing of the draft research report K210
60
Printing and binding of final Research Report K80
Subtotal K290
Contingency K150
Grand Total K1, 3471
1 The budget was affected by unforeseen expenses due to the elongated period of the research. The planned budget was K841.
61
ACTIVITIES MONTH September October November December January February March April May June July August
WEEEK 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Verification of
research topic
Plan
Actual
Literature review Plan
Actual
Compilation of
research proposal
Plan
Actual
Developing Research
tools
Plan
Actual
Editing/submitting of
final proposal
Plan
Actual
Assessment Plan
Actual
Pre-Testing of
Research tools
Plan
Actual
Data collection Plan
Actual
Data editing/coding
and entry
Plan
Actual
Data Analysis and
interpretation
Plan
Actual
Report writing Plan
Actual
Final Report editing
and submission
Plan
Actual
top related