albert motivans, uis mark waltham, unicef€¦ · profiles, barriers and bottlenecks • systematic...
TRANSCRIPT
Albert Motivans, UIS
Mark Waltham, UNICEF
The global scope of OOS
Disparities in learning opportunities
Sources: UNESCO Institute for Statistics and EFA GMR
Achieving quality education for all children
is still an unfinished agenda
Sources: UNESCO Institute for Statistics and EFA GMR
% ever
enrolled
% reach
grade 5
% with
minimum
mastery in
language
Malawi
91
31
7
Namibia
97
74
19
What is the OOSCI?
• Overall objective: Strengthen national data collection, analysis and policy on OOSC
• Coordinated by UNICEF and UIS
Around half of the
world’s OOSC live in
these countries
Three core components
1. Analysis of data: Develop comprehensive profiles of excluded children based on standardized and innovative statistical methods
2. Analysis of barriers: Link quantitative data with the socio-cultural barriers and resource-based bottlenecks that create exclusion
3. Analysis of policies: Identify policies which address exclusion from education from a multisectoral perspective
Core components: example
Profile of
excluded children
6 year old children
living in rural areas
Related policies
Improve offer of
pre-primary
programs in rural
areas
Socio-cultural
barriers and
bottlenecks
Parents hold children
back, “not ready” for
school
The Five Dimensions of Exclusion Model
Primary school students Lower secondary school students
Out of
school
In
school
Primary age children Lower secondary age children
Dimension 4
At risk of dropping
out of primary school
Dimension 5
At risk of dropping out
of lower secondary
school
Dimension 2
Attended
but
dropped
out
Will never
enterWill enter
late
Dimension 3
Attended
but
dropped
out
Will never
enterWill enter
late
Dimension 1
Not in pre-
primary school
Pre-primary
age children
Analysis of children out of basic school
n OOSC
Primary age children Lower secondary age children
Out of
school
Dimension 2
Attended
but
dropped
out
Will never
enter
Will enter
late
Dimension 3
Attended
but
dropped
out
Will never
enter
Will enter
late
• Disaggregated analysis to identify complex profiles of OOSC
• In-depth analysis of administrative data
• Typology of OOSC based on past and future school exposure
• Not all out-of-school children are ‘permanently excluded’
Identifying types of out of school children
• Identify characteristics associated with dropout risk by studying
early school leavers
• Indicators potentially linked to risk of dropout (ie. overage)
In
school
Dimension 4
At risk of
dropping out
of primary
school
Dimension 5
At risk of
dropping out of
lower secondary
school
Primary school students Lower secondary school students
Analysing the risk of children
dropping out of school
The OOSCI approach
Who are children out of school and where are they?
Why are they out of school?
How can they be brought to school and stay there?
Profiles, Barriers and Bottlenecks
• Systematic identification and analysis of key barriers and bottlenecks
that obstruct school participation
• Avoid fallacy of equating profiles with barriers
Boys / girls
Children with HIV/AIDS
Working children
Children from poorest
families
Gender
HIV/AIDS
Child Labour
Poverty
Lack of gender sensitive schools
and systems
Lack of treatment or awareness
Inflexible school systems,
opportunity costs
Lack of social support
Causes of Exclusion
Four areas:
• supply side barriers
• demand side socio-cultural
barriers
• demand side economic
barriers
• political, governance,
capacity and financial
bottlenecks
Supply side barriers
Barriers include:
• School infrastructure
• Teachers
• Learning materials
• School management
• Safety
Possible responses:
• Within education sector
School improvement
• Outside education sector
School health programs
School feeding programs.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Pri
mary
gro
ss a
tten
da
nce
ra
tio (
%)
<1 km 1 km 2 km 3-4 km 5+ kmDistance to primary school (km)
Total Male Female
Demand side socio-cultural barriers
Barriers include:
• Social or cultural practices
• Disagreement on purpose or process of education
• Violence in homes and community
Possible responses:
• Within education sector:
Community mobilization
Awareness-raising
Combatting stigmatization
Partnerships
• Outside education sector:
Removing discriminatory legislation
or policies
Demand side economic barriers
Barriers include:
• School fees, other costs
• Food insecurity
Possible responses:
• Within education sector:
Remove school fees
Scholarships
Subsidies
• Outside education sector:
Cash transfers
School feeding
Micro-supplements
• Opportunity costs
• Emergencies
Political, governance and financial barriers
Possible responses:
• Evidence based policies
• Costed strategies
• Devolution to schools
• Transparency
• Monitoring and evaluation
Barriers include:
• Political commitment
• Legal provisions
• Decentralization
• Accountability
• Budget allocations
Progress so far
Studies in 26 countries in 7 regions:
• Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka
• Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Mexico
• Cambodia, Indonesia, Philippines, Timor-Leste
• DRC, Ghana, Liberia, Nigeria
• Ethiopia, Mozambique, Zambia
• Kyrgyzstan, Romania, Tajikistan, Turkey
• Morocco, Sudan, South Sudan
• 10 Country and Regional Reports published
• New partnerships in more than 5 countries
• Policy development
Plans for the future
Second phase of OOSCI:
• Produce OOSCI Guide and Operational Manual
• Regional workshops
• New studies in up to 15 countries
• Capacity building in partner countries
• Support for policy development
• Support with implementation
Thank you