Agenda10/15/12

Debate Discussion/Work1. Develop a position statement2. View Sample Debate and take notes on Do’s

and Don’ts

1 Aaleah M.: Con

2. Amber Hughes: Pro

3. Sunia Ali: Con

4. Elyjah: Con

5. Desmond: Con

Sharon Ofei: Con

Jade Butler: Pro

Roxana: Con Timmia: Pro James: Pro

Cynthia: Pro Brittany Freeman: Con

Marielly: Pro

John: Con Ben: Con

Feurquan: Pro

Aaliyah Dandridge: Con

Dijon: Pro Blake: Pro Trevante: Pro

Terry: Con

Topic: Influence of Television

Topic: High School Uniforms

Topic: Gay Marriage(good choice)

Topic: Immigration(good choice)

Topic: Foreign Policy

6. Destiny: Pro Individual

Selina: Pro Individual

Tyler: Con Individual

Matt: Con Individual

Topic: Benefits of College Tuition: individual or Country(good choice)

7. Yagor: Pro Arturo:

Taylor: Con Romai:

Shania: Con Justin:

Kelsey: Pro

Topic: 16 and Pregnant(good choice)

Topic: Video Games

1. Paul: Pro 2. Joelle: Pro

3. Pharoll: Pro

4. Vlad: Con 5. Alex S.: Pro

Nik H.: Pro Kaylynn: Pro Mohammed:Con

Katherine: Pro

Ali: Pro

Kendal: Pro Essence: Con

Nick B.: Con Rochelle: Pro

Janeya:Con

Ernie: Con

Julie: Con

Ra’anna: Con

Berry: Pro Rovid: Con Tiaunna:Con

Topic: Euthanasia(good choice)

Topic: Abortion

Topic: Illuminatti real or fake?(good choice)

Topic: Gay Marriage(good choice)

Topic:Does gun control reduce crime?

6. Niles: con

Arynn: pro

Alex M.: Con

Nyya: Pro

Topic: Should Prostitution be legalized?

7. Stephanie: Pro

Kadesha: Pro

Sierra: Con

Clezze: Con

Topic: Child Pagaents

TEWWG: IRB (Completed Prior to Wednesday’s Mtg)

- Annotations (MPs, SPs, Exs, Likes, Dislikes, Think Abouts, Unfamiliars)

- 4 IRB responses (ensure that you refer to the IRB Policy hdt)

- Role Assignment work (e.g. Discussion Director brings in 5 thought-provoking and open-ended questions)

Homework*** Amber, Katherine, Kadesha (see me for Post-Its): Extra Credit for IRB Annotations: Lit. Circle Mtg #5-Lit. Circle Mtg #8)***

Randomly-chosen names for IRB and Daily Journal (Lit. Circles Wks 2-6…should have 24 entries by Lit. Circle Mtg 6)

Begin the research for prepping your Debate

IRB Work/Entries for Mtg #6

*Check Edmodo for VP Debate entry*

Wednes.-Fri. (Oct. 17 (except 4th per.: rescheduled for Oct.23),19, 25): Meet in Media Center for source info. session/ Research Paper Work: Debate Topic/Learning Centers

Mon., Oct. 22: Persuasive Speech or Debate Outline Due (from Pros and from Cons)

Mon.-Tues., Oct. 29-30: Persuasive Speech or Debate

Claim-Analysis Test

A claim states your position on the issue you have chosen to write about. (w/o using I, me, my).→A good claim is not obvious. →A good claim is engaging. →A good claim is not overly vague. →A good claim is logical.

DOES YOUR CLAIM PASS THE CLAIM-ANALYSIS TEST?

Student-Claims(SP-focus)

When children grow up watching horror movies there are many psychological effects in the form of family life, social interactions and thought processes.

My Response: Hummmm, okay… Not too shabby! I’m interested in the way this author is going to prove this...what avenues will be taken to support this claim. Work on crafting this with better word choice(in other words, build up your argument more). Keep chipping Away…Great Start.

The development of robotics is accelerating at a blistering pace; soon robots will be a part of our daily lives just like computers. My Response: Hummmm, okay… needs some fine-tuning. This claim is too vague. Consider specifying a particular area. That would be more interesting and arguable to me. Keep chipping Away…you’re getting there.

With the rise of Coca-Cola products, the beverage industry is slowly evolving into a more competitive market. My Response: Hummmm, okay… this claim has peaked my interest. I’d like to see how this person is going to prove how Coca-Cola products have risen (reword “rise”), and how the ENTIRE industry has become more competitive as a result. Keep Chipping Away at this, though…Great Start!!

Set design is just as important as the actual production.My Response: Hummmm, okay… needs some fine-tuning. This claim is too obvious, and doesn’t engage me.

This author needs to build up the argument so that I will care about how the . Keep chipping Away…you’re getting there.

Student-Claims(SP-focus)

Cosmetologists are creative artists who make a difference in people’s lives, giving them the confidence and positive energy needed to make a difference in the community.

My Response: Hummmm, okay… Much improved. I hear where the author is going with this and I appreciate her leap. Cosmetologists=community-builder… I like it! Work on the diction. Keep Chipping Away at this, though…Much-improved!! Although there are many acceptable pastimes for teens, there are far too many still finding themselves in trouble.

My Response: Hummmm, okay… needs a good bit of fine-tuning. This claim is too vague; it lacks specificity. Further, the author needs to build up the claim in such a way that I’ll be engaged. Upon reading this for a 2nd time, it reads in an incongruent fashion (acceptable pastimes ≠ too many in trouble. Not sure where you’re going with this. Keep chipping Away… Playing an instrument helps stimulate brain activity and improves intelligence.

My Response: Hummmm, okay… needs some fine-tuning. The author needs to craft this claim using more engaging diction to engage me. Keep chipping Away…Almost! Is good advertising a direct correlation to increased sales or does the product speak for itself?

My Response: Hummmm, okay… much fine-tuning. I can tell where the author is TRYING to go, but the argument is formed using an interrogative, and it needs to be a definitive statement. Rephrase this so that you are building/crafting your argument in a concise and engaging manner. Keep chipping away…

Claim/Evidence Requirements Intro. ¶: attention-grabber (INTERESTING • FACT/STAT., anecdote, INTERESTING • quote)• Basic 2-3 sent. background summary of • the topic• Central assertion/thesis/claim that you are • PROVING in your essay• Body ¶: Transitional word or phrase• Topic sentence• Lead in for Evidence (in the form of a • Quote or Passage or another • form of Concrete Detail • Commentary about the provided • evidence• Concluding ¶: A general statement that explains how your central • Claim/Argument/Thesis is resolved• *Cited Sources (…….)• *Included Vocabulary Words from Units 1 & 2 or 3