9/21/20151 coachella valley 2011 competitiveness? john husing, ph.d. economics & politics, inc
TRANSCRIPT
State Taxes
04/19/23 18
State
Business Income Individual Income Sales Tax Gasoline Property TaxUnemployment Tax
(Avg)
California 8.84% 9.55% 8.25% 46.1 $1,397 3.85%
Oregon 7.90% 9.00% 0.00% 25 $1,167 3.60%
Nevada 0.00% 0.00% 6.85% 33.1 $1,344 2.83%
Arizona 6.97% 4.24% 6.60% 19 $1,139 3.05%
Texas 0.00% 0.00% 6.25% 20 $1,600 4.66%
Colorado 4.63% 4.63% 2.90% 22 $1,322 2.70%
Washington 0.00% 0.00% 6.50% 37.5 $1,257 3.50%
New Mexico 6.40% 4.90% 5.13% 18.8 $589 2.72%
Utah 5.00% 0.00% 5.95% 24.5 $846 4.75%
Highest Highest Highest Highest 2ndHighest
2ndHighest
Public HealthBlue Collar Sectors
Bring Rising Asthma Asthma & & CancerCancer Risk From Airborne Toxics
Social Justice
Blue Collar Sectors Hurt Modest Income Families Living Near
Factories, Rail Yards, Ports, Freeways
California Solution
Single Issue Regulatory Agencies
CA Air Resources Board
South Coast Air Quality Management District
CA Environmental Protection Agency
CA Water Resources Control Board
& More
BlueBlue Collar Collar Work Is Much of Our Workforce’s Best Chance To Reach The Middle ClassMiddle Class
2. Downward Pressure On Blue Collar Jobs
Few Training BarriersFew Training Barriers To Beginning Employment
Mining ($96,996) Blue Collar
Manufacturing ($47,933) Blue Collar
Logistics ($46,665) Blue Collar
Wholesale Trade ($43,492) Median Blue Collar
Construction ($41,453) Blue Collar
Retail Trade ($28,840)
Gaming ($28,385)
Hotel/Motel ($24,019)
Agriculture ($22,793)
Eating & Drinking ($15,132)
$13,000 Gap
Results Of Job Suppression
• Unemployment Higher Than It Needs To Be
• Underemployment A Constant Difficulty
• Lack of Access to Jobs Leading to the Middle ClassLeading to the Middle Class
• Health Issues of Poverty
• Divorce
• Spousal Abuse
• Drug & Alcohol Abuse
• Suicide
• Lack of Timely Medical Care
Public Health Issues!
Over 60% Of These Populations Also Stopped Their Educations With High School or Less Schooling
Suppressing Blue Collar Jobs Is Also A Social Justice IssueSocial Justice Issue
Clean Air, Asthma & Cancer
Are Health & SocialHealth & SocialJusticeJustice Issues
Lack of Blue Collar Jobs & Poverty Are
Health & SocialHealth & SocialJusticeJustice Issues
Public Policy Dilemma
After Years Of Focus on Concentrating Solely On The EnvironmentConcentrating Solely On The Environment
Job Creation Is Our Forgotten PriorityForgotten Priority!!
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 32
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction•Hotels & Conventions•Tourism•Tourist Shoppers•Agriculture•Clean Tech•Creative Arts•Distribution•Retirees•Health Care•Manufacturing
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 41
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions•Tourism•Tourist Shoppers•Agriculture•Clean Tech•Creative Arts•Distribution•Retirees•Health Care•Manufacturing
Wheeler’s Desert Letter
Hotel Rates, Coming Back!
04/19/23 42
Corporate Meetings & Conventions Coming Back
2nd quarter 2011 Coachella Valley hotel occupancy up 14.8%
Average room rate up 5.4% Palm Springs Desert Community Convention Bureau
Labor Day hotel occupancy is 25% higher than 2010
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 46
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture•Clean Tech•Creative Arts•Distribution•Retirees•Health Care•Manufacturing
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 49
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech•Creative Arts•Distribution•Health Care•Retirees•Manufacturing
Clean Energy Initiatives
04/19/23 50
DemandProperty Assessed Clean Energy
Financing (PACE)Palm Desert Municipal Program
AB 811Net Metering
DevelopmentSkill Training To Work In the
IndustryElectric Vehicle Production
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 51
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts•Distribution•Health Care•Retirees•Manufacturing
Major Films & Important CommercialsAre Already Shot in the Coachella Valley
04/19/23 53
Value of Filming Activity Coachella Valley
Coachella Valley Riverside Co. Share
2006 $11,892,591 $24,225,500 49.1%
2007 $10,174,750 $15,336,750 66.3%
2008 $11,705,000 $13,551,000 86.4%
2009 $4,732,000 $9,639,200 49.1%
2010 $11,019,500 $16,479,750 66.9%Assumes Coachella Valley equal to lowest share of 2007-2009Source: Inland Empire Film Commission
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 54
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts B-•Distribution•Health Care•Retirees•Manufacturing
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 58
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts B-•Distribution D•Health Care•Retirees•Manufacturing
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 62
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts B-•Distribution D•Health Care A-•Retirees•Manufacturing
Economic Base Grades
04/19/23 65
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts B-•Distribution D•Health Care A-•Retirees A•Manufacturing
Setting Conditions For The Future
04/19/23 67
•Competitiveness D thanks to CA•Construction D-•Hotels & Conventions C+•Tourism C+•Tourist Shoppers C•Agriculture A•Clean Tech C-•Creative Arts B-•Distribution D•Health Care A-•Retirees A•Manufacturing D
Over All Grade
C- to C
04/19/23 73
2010, 2011
When Will “Normal” Start To Return?
x2012
If Mortgages Fixed! x2015-2016
Not
x