03079

19
Cardiovascular Imaging Systems GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000 Philips Integris Allura Flat Detector F Siemens Axiom Artis FC

Upload: ahmedgalalwaly1056

Post on 24-Nov-2015

76 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

DESCRIPTION

Cardiovascular Imaging Systems comparisons

TRANSCRIPT

  • Cardiovascular Imaging Systems

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems4

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000

    Philips Integris Allura Flat Detector F Siemens Axiom Artis FC

  • Cardiovascular Imaging Systems

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 5

    Siemens Axiom Artis dFC Toshiba Infinix CCi

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 6

    Table A: Angiographic table design

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Table name Omega IV(Omega V option)Omega IV

    (Omega V option) Angio Diagnost 5 Artis Artis CAT-850B

    Tabletop dimensions (cm) 300 46 300 46 293 50 344 a 344 a 295 75

    Tabletop profile Flat Flat Flat Flat Flat Flat

    Tabletop material Carbon fibre Carbon fibre Carbon fibre Carbon fibre Carbon fibre Carbon fibre

    Max patient weight (kg) 202 b 204200

    + 100 forresuscitation c

    200 200200

    + 100 forresuscitation

    Aluminium equivalent oftabletop (mm Al) 0.8 0.8 0.6 1.0 1.0 1.0

    Range of longitudinalmovement (cm) 110 110 100 125 125 135

    Range of lateral movement(cm) 14 14 18 17.5 17.5 20

    Tabletop height range fromthe floor (cm) 78 to 108 78 to 108 76 to 104 77.5 to 110 77.5 to 110 78 to 115

    Range of pivot of tabletop() 180 180 90 as option

    120 120 +90 to 180

    Notes:a. 2 widths: narrow cardiac and wide universal (option)b. Weight limit increased to 210 kg if tabletop is over the support during CPRc For patient resuscitation with the table fully extended and the patient at the end of the table - no additional support is needed.

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 7

    Table B: Standard accessories

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Mattress Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    IV pole Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Armrest Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Headrest/ head end holder No No No Yes Yes (narrow) Yes

    Radiation protective shields Ceiling, tableside,mobile YesOptional ceilingand tableside

    Ceiling, tableside,mobile

    Ceiling, tableside,mobile Option

    Table side rails Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Rail accessory clamps 2 2 5(2 tabletop) Option OptionProvided withaccessories

    Handgrip No No No Yes Yes Yes

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 8

    Table C: Optional accessoriesGE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000 Philips Integris Allura

    Flat Detector FSiemens Axiom Artis

    FCSiemens Axiom Artis

    dFCToshiba Infinix CCi

    Contrast injector, IVpoles, cable clips

    Additional IV poles,cable clips

    CD-R, PC basedDICOM viewing

    software, examinationdose reporting, secondtableside control, pan

    handle, injector,handles, arm holder,

    lead protection,examination lamp,contrast injector

    Injector, rail accessoryclamps, cable clips,

    wide tabletopPatient dose reductionoptions: CAREVISION(Standard with some

    systems),CAREPOSITION and

    DIGITALACQUISITION ZOOM

    Injector, rail accessoryclamps, cable clips,

    wide tabletopPatient dose reductionoptions: CAREVISION(Standard with some

    systems),CAREPOSITION

    Higher spec. armrest,handswitch joystick-operated satellite

    control stand

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 9

    Table D: C-arm support

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Name Advantx + LC positioner G stand Artis Artis CAS-830A

    Floor/ceiling mounted Floor Floor Floor Floor Floor Ceiling

    Range of rotations:

    LAO/RAO ()

    Max Speed (/s)

    CRA/CAU ()

    Max Speed (/s)

    105/117

    10 (fast 40)

    55/55

    10

    105/117

    20

    50/45

    20

    120/120

    25

    45/45

    18

    120/120

    25

    55/45

    18

    120/120

    25

    55/45

    8

    120/180

    20

    50/90

    20

    C-arm depth (along table)(cm)

    Reaches mid-thigh; 6 patient 55 105 90 90 123

    FDD range (cm) 84 to 119 82.5 to 116 86.5 to 123 53 to 83 53 to 83 91 to 121

    C-arm support standmovement range ()

    95 motorised 100 manual

    95 motorised 100 manual

    90 motorised &manual +119 to -185 +119 to -185 135 motorised

    No. of pre-programmablepositions 72 72

    100 + 2 scratchpositions (service

    installed)55 55 100

    Anti-collision protection Software andmechanicalSoftware andmechanical

    Bodyguardcapacitance

    sensing

    Software andmechanical

    Software andmechanical CAS-830A

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 10

    Table E: Generator

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Name Advantx VAMP VAMP Velara CFD Polydoros Open Polydoros ISOpen XTP-8100G

    Nominal output (kW) 100 64 100 100 100 100

    Generator type Multipulse High frequency High frequency High frequency High frequency High frequency

    kV range:RadiographicFluoroscopic

    40 to 15060 to 120

    40 to 12560 to 120

    40 to 12540 to 125 Maximum 125

    50 to 12550 to 125

    50 to 12550 to 125

    Maximum tube current(mA) 1250 1250 1250 1000 1000 1250

    Fluoro pulse:frequency (pps)

    pulse width (ms)

    25

    Auto selected

    7.5, 15, 30

    2 to 12.5

    12.5, 25

    1 to 10

    15,and 30Optional 0.5, 1.0,2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 6.0,

    7.5,(CAREVISION)

    3.2 to 10

    15,and 30Optional 0.5, 1.0,2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 6.0,

    7.5,(CAREVISION)

    3.2 to 10

    1, 2, 3, 5,10,12,17,

    20,22,25,27,3030

    1 to 13

    Fluoroscopy kV and mAcontrol

    Automatic/manual Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic

    Automatic/manual

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 11

    Table E: Generator (continued)

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    High contrast fluoroscopymode max mA and cut offtime

    High level controlmode up to 52

    cGymin-1

    High level controlmode up to 8.76

    cGymin-1Cont. 30 mA

    Pulsed 260 mA StandardUp to 170 mA and

    9 cGymin-1

    137 mA skin doseup to

    18 mR/min

    (200mA with LMBtube)

    Patient dose reductionfeatures

    Cardiac techniqueprediction,automatic

    brightness controlcircuitry,

    diamentor dosemonitoring and

    dose detailalternatives

    Added additionalcopper filtration,

    low doseselection,

    removable anti-scatter grid

    Automatic wedgefilter, doublewedge filters,

    Dynamicfluorograb

    Grid switched X-ray tube

    Spectrabeamfiltration

    CAREMATIC(Auto acquisition

    parameters basedon fluoroscopy)CAREWATCHCAREFILTER

    Optional: CAREPROFILE

    CAREPOSITIONSTORE FLUORO

    CAREMATIC(Auto acquisition

    parameters basedon fluoroscopy) CAREWATCHCAREFILTER

    Optional: CAREPROFILE

    CAREPOSITIONSTORE FLUORO

    Ta filter, multiplefluoroscopy

    modes, automaticfilter positioning,automatic setting

    of fluoroscopyconditions, area

    dose display

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 12

    Table F: X-ray tube assembly

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Insert type Maxiray TM 150TH.13Maxiray 150

    version 5 MRC GS 05 08

    MEGALIX Cat125/35/80-121GW or

    MEGALIX Cat125/15/40/80 -

    121GW

    MEGALIX Cat125/35/80-

    121GWDRX-T7445GFS

    Focal spot sizes (mm) 0.3/0.6/1.2 0.6/1.2 0.5/0.8 0.4/0.8 or0.3/0.6/1.0 0.4/0.8 0.3/0.5/0.8

    Nominal anode input power(kW) 16/47/115 47/115 44/85 35/80 35/80 20/49/98

    Max heat content for completetube assembly (MHU) 1.95 3.1 5.4 2 2 1.8

    Max continuous heat dissipationfor complete tube assembly(kHU.s-1)

    2.3 2.3 11 6.8 6.75 5.7

    Type of collimators/ wedges Linear and irisdiaphragm

    Linear collimatorsand contour

    wedge

    Linear and irisdiaphragms,

    automatic wedgefilter

    Rotating squareblade collimation

    and wedge-shaped

    diaphragm plateplus iris blades

    with 33 or 40 cmII

    Square pluswedge diaphragm

    Linear and irisdiaphragms,

    compensat-ionfilters

    Operation of collimatorauto/manual

    Automatic to fieldsize and then

    manual

    Automatic to fieldsize and then

    manual

    Iris: automatic,collimator: manual

    Automatic withrotation over-ride

    via remote

    Automatic withrotation over-ride

    via remote

    Automatic to fieldsize and then

    manual

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 13

    Table F: X-ray tube assembly (continued)

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Virtual collimation No No Yes Optional Optional Yes

    Total beam filtration(mm Al) 2.5 >2.5 >2.5 >2.5 >2.5 3.6

    Additional added filtrationfitted to tube (mm) 0, 1 Al + 0.1 Cu 0.1, 0.2 Cu 0, 0.2, 0.5, 1 Cu

    0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.6or 0.9 Cu

    0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.6or 0.9 Cu

    0.03 Ta, 0.06 Ta,1.5 Al

    Dose area product (DAP)meter or equivalent Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 14

    Table G (a): Detector: IIGE Advantx LC+ Siemens Axiom Artis FC Toshiba Infinix CCi

    Name HX Artis RTP9211J-G11

    Detector technology CsI II CsI II CsI II

    Nominal diameter of fieldsizes (cm) 22/16/11

    23/17/13, optional 8.5 or

    33/22/17/13, optional 8.5 or

    40/28/20/14, optional 10

    23/17/12

    Nominal peak DQE (%) 65 65 70

    Expected lifetime of detector >5 year 8 to 10 years > 10 years

    Conversion factor for eachfield size(cd.m-2).(s.mGy-1)

    25/15/8/5 (for 40cm II)

    20.5 or

    26 or

    29

    28.6

    Contrast ratio >30:1

    25:1 or

    25:1 or

    38:1

    34:1

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 15

    Table G (b) Detector: flat panel detector

    GE Innova 2000 Philips Integris Allura FlatDetector F Siemens Axiom Artis dFCToshiba

    (Works In Progress)

    Name Revolution Dynamic flat detector Artis dFC DynaDirect 3000

    Detector technology a-Si photodiode / TFT array CsI on Si a-Si photodiode / TFT array a-Se

    Nominal field sizes (size ofsquare) (cm) 20/17.3/14.7/12.2

    18.5/13/11(25/20/15 DIAGONAL)

    18/14/11(25/20/16 DIAGONAL) 23

    Array size (pixel) 1024 (20cm fov) to 608(12.2cm fov) 1024 1024 1024 1024 1536 x 1536 x 14-bit

    Nominal peak DQE (%) 70 75 75 85

    Expected lifetime of detector 10 years 5 to 6 + years 10 years 10+ years

    Pixel pitch (m) 200 184 184 150

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 16

    Table H: Monitors

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    TV monitor name Ultrabright Ultrabright ExtraBright CRTOptional LCD

    TFT HighContrast Flat

    Display

    TFT HighContrast Flat

    DisplaySMM21103L

    Screen size of monitors (cm) 51 51 51 46 46 53

    Mounting options Wall, floor orceilingWall, floor or

    ceiling Ceiling Ceiling Ceiling Ceiling

    Number of monitors suppliedas standard

    2 (+ 1 in controlarea)

    2 (+ 1 in controlarea)

    2 CRTs (+ 1 TFTLCD in control

    area)

    2 (+ 1 in controlarea)

    2 (+ 1 in controlarea) 2

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 17

    Table I (a): Imaging system image intensifierGE Advantx LC+ Siemens Axiom Artis FC Toshiba Infinix CCi

    TV system name MS 90 Artis MTV-800C

    TV camera type Plumbicon CCD CCD

    Acquisition rate (fps) 6.3, 8.3, 12.5, 25 15, 30 0.33 to 60

    Detector input exposure rateon each field size (nGys-1)

    Information not supplied 100/210/370 3.6 to 9.67 (Average)

    Sensing area of ABC Central portion of image field 9 9 cm (23 cm field)10 10 cm (33 cm field)

    Central 40% of image field

    LIH Yes Yes Yes

    Line and frame standard ofvideo output 1249 or 625 line scan rate

    1060 lines76 Hz 1049 line interlaced

    Nominal resolution onmonitor for each field size(lp.mm-1)

    1.7/2.4 /~3.2 1.6/2.0/2.4 1.8/2.2/2.8

    Number of programmabletechniques 240 58 128

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 18

    Table I (b): Imaging system flat panel detector

    GE Innova 2000 Philips Integris Allura FlatDetector F Siemens Axiom Artis dFCToshiba

    (Works In Progress)

    Acquisition rate (fps) 7.5, 15, 30 12.5, 25 15, 30 0.33 to 60

    Detector input exposure rateon each field size (nGys-1)

    10.5/11.4/14.0/15.8nGy/frame for fluoroscopy

    Detector dose: 90 R/sec[30 or 60]

    Patient dose: 5, 10 and 20R/min [10,20]

    15.7/24.7/48.1 nGy/pulse:fluoroscopy

    91.8/145/282 nGy/pulse:acquisition (Coro ND)

    3.6 to 9.67 (Average)

    Sensing area of ABC Central 500 500 pixels Programmeable 40 or 60 %Approx circular and centredto field and of approx 10 cm

    diameterVariable

    LIH Yes Standard Yes Yes

    Line and frame standard ofvideo output 625 lines, 72 Hz frame rate

    1280 x 1024 lines, 76 Hzframe rate 1060 lines, 76 Hz frame rate Not available

    Nominal resolution onmonitor for each field size(lp.mm-1)

    2.5 for all field sizes 2.7 for all field sizes 2.7 for all field sizes 2.3/2.8/3.1

    Number of programmabletechniques 240

    Fluoroscopy: 3

    Acquisition 3250 128

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 19

    Table J: Image acquisition

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Name DLX Innova Digital DL Information notsupplied Artis Artis DFP 8000D

    Noise reduction Yes Yes Yes (Xres) Yes Yes Yes

    Edge enhancement Yes Yes Yes (Spirit) Yes Yes Yes

    Run length selection No Yes n/a Yes Yes Yes

    Image reversal Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Image rotation Yes Yes No Yes (Automaticcompensation)Yes (Automaticcompensation) Yes

    Fluoroscopic programmingof radiographic factors Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Rotational angiography Yes Option OptionalDYNAVISION

    option with DSApackage

    DYNAVISION DRoption availablefrom December

    2003

    Yes

    Road-mapping Yes Option Yes

    Included in DSAoption

    Overlay fadeoption

    With Full DSA inDecember 2003

    Overlay fadestandard

    Yes

    Text overlay Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Contour and contrastenhancement Yes Yes

    Yes (Xres +Spirit

    processing)Yes Yes Yes

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 20

    Table J: Image acquisition (continued)

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Greyscale optimisation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Zoom and roam Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Electronic zoom Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Windowing Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Electronic collimation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Subtraction Yes Option Option Option Optionc Yes

    Re-masking Yes Option Option Option Optionc Yes

    Measurements Yes Yes Option Yes Yes Yes

    Fluoro grab Yes Yes Yes (10 sec) Store fluorooptionStore fluoro

    option Yes

    Fluoro replay Yes No Yes Store fluorooptionStore fluoro

    option Yes

    Cardiac quantificationanalysis

    Coronary andvessel analysis,Sheehan wall

    motion

    Stenosis cathetercalibration, vesselsizing, ventricularanalysis, centreline wall motion,global ejection

    fraction

    Coronaryquantification,ventricular

    quantification

    Optional LVanalysis, vascular

    analysis withstenosis

    quantification andscientific coronary

    analysis

    Optional LVanalysis, vascular

    analysis withstenosis

    quantification andscientific coronary

    analysis

    Stenosis andejection fraction

    Max number of highresolutions storable in harddrive

    32 000 (1024 x 1024)

    72 000 (1024 x 1024)

    120,000 imagesat 10242

    6 250. Options of12 500, 25 000 or

    50 000

    25 000 or optional50 000

    32 500(1024 x 1024 x 12

    bit)

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 21

    Table J: Image acquisition (continued)

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Removable storage CD writer CD writer CD writer CD recorder CD recorder CD writer

    DICOM conformance Yes Yes Yes d Yes Yes Yes

    Notes:c. Cardiac Subtraction option from July 2003. Full DSA option from December 2003d. Two way DICOM image interface, two way RIS DICOM interface

  • Specifications summary

    KCARE Report: Comparative Specifications of Cardiovascular Imaging Systems 22

    Table K: Environmental conditions and room size

    GE Advantx LC+ GE Innova 2000Philips Integris

    Allura FlatDetector F

    Siemens AxiomArtis FC

    Siemens AxiomArtis dFC

    Toshiba InfinixCCi

    Operating temperaturerange (C) 10 to 32 10 to 32 10 to 35 10 to 35 15 to 30 15 to 35

    Relative humidity range (%) 20 to 70 20 to 70 20 to 80 20 to 75 20 to 75 35 to 70

    Air conditioning required No No Yes No No Recommended

    Room sizeW x L x H (m) 7.3 9.1 3.0 7.3 9.1 3.0 4.5 6.0 2.9

    e 5.9 6.5 2.5 5.9 6.5 2.5 5.2 6.2 x 2.8

    Notes:e. Equipment room 3.4 x 1.5 m containing 3 x 40E cabinets